Gravitation and Orbits

Newton's law of universal gravitation with superposition, g at altitude and inside a planet via the shell theorem, the tunnel through the Earth as simple harmonic motion, U = -GMm/r derived by integration with mgh as its limit, circular orbits and Kepler's third law, orbital energy and escape speed, elliptical orbits from angular momentum plus energy, and the Hohmann transfer.

Subject: AP Physics C: Mechanics · 73 slides · diagram-first lesson

Open the interactive version of this deck

What this lesson covers

The lesson, slide by slide

1. Gravitation and Orbits

Title

AP Physics C: Mechanics — Gravitation

One inverse-square law, and everything it says about planets, satellites, tunnels and escape

2. What this deck buys you

Objectives

For seven decks gravity has been a constant downward pull of mg. That was always an approximation, valid within a few kilometres of the ground. This deck replaces it with the real law and follows it as far as it goes.

The organising idea: orbits are problems in the two conservation laws you already own. Energy and angular momentum, applied to an inverse-square force, answer almost every question this unit can ask.

Every deck so far has treated gravity as a constant downward force of mg. That was never wrong for the problems it was used on, but it was always an approximation — a good one only within a few kilometres of the ground.

This deck replaces it with the law Newton actually wrote down, and the payoff is large. The same law that makes an apple fall holds the Moon in its orbit, sets the length of a year, decides whether a rocket comes back, and explains why astronauts float.

You will meet very little new machinery. Orbits turn out to be problems in the second law and in the two conservation laws you already own — energy and angular momentum — applied to a force that weakens as one over r squared.

So the deck doubles as a review of the whole course. If something here feels hard, it is usually because one of those older tools is rusty, and the fix is to go back to it rather than to learn something new.

3. The Law of Universal Gravitation

Section

Section 1

4. Every mass attracts every other mass

Concept

\[ F_g = \frac{G m_1 m_2}{r^2} \qquad G = 6.67\times 10^{-11}\,\text{N m}^2/\text{kg}^2 \]

Figure (svg): Two spheres of different size with equal and opposite gravitational force arrows pointing toward each other along the line joining their centres, and the separation r marked between centres.

The gravitational pair: equal and opposite, always attractive, along the line joining the centres.

Four facts are packed into that one line. The force is always attractive. It acts along the line joining the centres. It is proportional to each mass. And it falls off as the inverse square of the distance.

The r is measured centre to centre, not surface to surface. For a satellite that means the Earth's radius plus the altitude — the most common slip in this unit.

\[ \vec{F}_{12} = -\frac{Gm_1m_2}{r^2}\,\hat{r}_{12} \]

In vector form the minus sign says the force on object 2 points back toward object 1, opposite the unit vector that runs from 1 to 2. Attractive means pointing back along r.

The law is short, and each piece of it carries a separate claim. Read it slowly the first time.

The force is proportional to each mass, which means it is proportional to their product. Double either mass and the force doubles. It falls as the inverse square of the distance between centres: double the distance and the force drops to a quarter.

It is always attractive. There is no negative mass, so there is no gravitational repulsion — which is why gravity, the weakest force in nature, ends up dominating on the scale of planets and galaxies. Nothing ever cancels it.

The distance r is measured from centre to centre. For a satellite, that means the Earth's radius plus the altitude. Forgetting to add the radius is the single most common mistake in this unit, and it makes answers wrong by factors of hundreds.

Notice too that the figure shows two arrows of equal length. The formula contains the product of the masses, so it gives the same number for the force on each body. That is Newton's third law, built into the law of gravitation.

5. Reading the law of gravitation

Notation

Annotate

On: \( F_g = \frac{G\,m_1\,m_2}{r^2} \)

  • A universal constant, the same everywhere in the universe and absurdly small: 6.67 times ten to the minus eleven in SI units. It is why you need a planet's worth of mass to notice gravity at all.
  • The PRODUCT of the masses. Double either one and the force doubles. That symmetry is the third law built into the formula — the same expression gives the force on each body.
  • The inverse square. Double the distance and the force falls to a quarter; triple it and it falls to a ninth. r is centre to centre, not surface to surface.
  • This is the magnitude only. The direction is always toward the other mass — gravity never repels — and you add the direction by hand from a diagram.

Compare it with mg. The near-surface weight hides G, the Earth's mass and the Earth's radius inside a single number, 9.8. This law unpacks that number and lets it vary.

Go through the annotations one at a time and connect each to something physical.

G is the conversion factor between mass and gravitational force, and its tininess — six point six seven times ten to the minus eleven — is the reason you never feel the pull of a building or another person. It takes a planet's worth of mass to make gravity noticeable.

The product of the masses is the third-law symmetry. Swap which body you call one and which you call two and nothing changes, so the force on each is the same size.

The inverse square is geometry. Anything spreading out from a point into three-dimensional space is spread over an area that grows as r squared, so it thins as one over r squared. You will see that idea in a figure shortly.

Finally, the formula gives only a magnitude. You supply the direction yourself, and the direction is always toward the other body. Draw the arrow first, then attach the number to it.

6. G is tiny, which is why you never notice it

Concept

Estimate the pull between two 70 kg people standing 1.0 m apart.

Why: Treat each as a point mass at their centre — crude, but fine for an order of magnitude.

\[ F = \frac{(6.67\times 10^{-11})(70)(70)}{(1.0)^2} = 3.3\times 10^{-7}\,\text{N} \]

That is the weight of a dust speck of about thirty micrograms. Friction with the floor is millions of times larger, so the attraction is real and completely invisible.

Now replace one person with the Earth.

Why: The 70 kg person on the surface, 6.37 times ten to the six metres from the Earth's centre.

\[ F = \frac{(6.67\times 10^{-11})(5.97\times 10^{24})(70)}{(6.37\times 10^{6})^2} = 687\,\text{N} = (70)(9.81) \]

Same law, same G, and out comes exactly your weight. The difference between invisible and inescapable is entirely the 10 to the 24 kilograms of planet on the other side of the equation.

Gravity is the weakest of the fundamental forces by an enormous margin, yet it runs the solar system — because it only ever adds. Mass has no negative version, so nothing cancels it.

Do this calculation once, because it gives you a feel for the scale of G.

Two people a metre apart attract each other with about three times ten to the minus seven newtons. That is real, and in careful laboratory experiments with lead spheres it is measurable — that is exactly how Henry Cavendish first measured G in 1798. But it is millions of times smaller than the friction holding you in place.

Swap one person for the Earth and the same law, with the same G, gives six hundred and eighty-seven newtons for a seventy kilogram person: exactly their weight. The only thing that changed was ten to the twenty-four kilograms of planet.

So mg is not a separate law. It is this law, evaluated at the Earth's surface, with everything except your mass packed into the single number nine point eight one. A few slides from now you will unpack that number and let it vary.

7. The force between the Earth and the Moon

Worked example

The Moon (7.35 x 10^22 kg) orbits 3.84 x 10^8 m from the Earth's centre. Find the gravitational force between them, and the acceleration it gives each body.

Use GM for the Earth to save a multiplication.

Why: GM_E = (6.67e-11)(5.97e24) = 3.98e14 m^3/s^2. This product appears in every Earth-orbit problem, so it is worth computing once.

\[ F = \frac{GM_E m_M}{r^2} = \frac{(3.98\times 10^{14})(7.35\times 10^{22})}{(3.84\times 10^{8})^2} = 1.98\times 10^{20}\,\text{N} \]

Divide by each mass for the accelerations.

Why: The same force acts on both bodies, so the lighter one accelerates more.

\[ a_{\text{Moon}} = \frac{1.98\times 10^{20}}{7.35\times 10^{22}} = 2.70\times 10^{-3}\,\text{m/s}^2 \qquad a_{\text{Earth}} = \frac{1.98\times 10^{20}}{5.97\times 10^{24}} = 3.3\times 10^{-5}\,\text{m/s}^2 \]

Check the Moon's value against its orbit.

Why: A circular orbit with r = 3.84e8 m and period 27.3 days (2.36e6 s) needs a centripetal acceleration of 4 pi^2 r / T^2 = 2.72e-3 m/s^2. The law of gravitation predicts the orbit to within one percent.

That last check is Newton's own Moon test — the calculation that convinced him the force pulling an apple down is the same force holding the Moon in its orbit.

This worked example is worth more than its arithmetic, because the last step is a piece of history.

First, the habit. Rather than multiplying G by the Earth's mass every time, compute GM once — three point nine eight times ten to the fourteen — and reuse it. Every Earth-orbit problem in this deck uses that number.

The force comes out near two times ten to the twenty newtons. Dividing by each mass gives very different accelerations for the two bodies, which is the subject of the next slide.

Now the check. The Moon's acceleration according to the law of gravitation is two point seven times ten to the minus three metres per second squared. The acceleration a circular orbit of the Moon's size and period actually requires is two point seven two times ten to the minus three. They agree to within a percent.

That comparison is Newton's Moon test. He made it in the 1660s and it convinced him that the force pulling an apple to the ground and the force bending the Moon's path are the same force, diluted by the inverse square of the distance. It is one of the great unifications in physics, and you have just repeated it.

8. The Earth pulls harder on the Moon than the Moon pulls on the Earth

Trap

The trap

The Earth is 81 times more massive than the Moon. Surely the bigger body exerts the bigger pull.

And the Moon visibly circles the Earth, not the other way round, which seems to confirm it.

The fix

The two forces are exactly equal in magnitude: 1.98 x 10^20 N each.

Look at the formula. It contains the product of the two masses, so swapping which body you call 1 and which you call 2 changes nothing. The law is symmetric, and that symmetry is Newton's third law.

What differs is the acceleration. The same force divided by masses 81 times apart gives accelerations 81 times apart: 2.7 x 10^-3 m/s^2 for the Moon, 3.3 x 10^-5 m/s^2 for the Earth.

And the Earth does move. Both bodies orbit their common centre of mass, which sits about 4700 km from the Earth's centre — inside the Earth, but well off-centre. The Earth wobbles around that point once a month.

Same structure as the lorry and the car in the momentum deck: equal forces, unequal masses, unequal accelerations.

The intuition is strong — the Earth is huge, the Moon is small, the Moon goes round the Earth — and the formula flatly contradicts it.

Look at the formula again. The two masses appear as a product, so the expression is the same whichever body you calculate the force on. The Earth pulls the Moon and the Moon pulls the Earth with exactly the same one point nine eight times ten to the twenty newtons.

What the intuition is really tracking is the response, not the force. Divide the same force by two masses eighty-one times apart and you get accelerations eighty-one times apart. The Moon swings around dramatically; the Earth barely wobbles.

But it does wobble. Both bodies orbit their common centre of mass, which sits about four thousand seven hundred kilometres from the Earth's centre. The Earth traces a small circle around that point every month, and that wobble is detectable — the same technique, applied to stars, is how many planets around other stars have been discovered.

9. Double the distance

Prediction

Predict first

A satellite is moved from a distance r to a distance 2r from the Earth's centre. By what factor does the gravitational force on it change?

  • It halves
  • It falls to one quarter
  • It falls to one eighth
  • It is unchanged, since the masses did not change

Correct: It falls to one quarter

Why: The force goes as one over r squared. Doubling r multiplies r squared by four, so the force falls to a quarter. Halving is the answer for a one-over-r law, which is how the POTENTIAL energy behaves, not the force.

Figure (svg): Lines spreading from a point source: at distance r they pass through one square of area, at distance 2r the same lines spread over four squares.

In three dimensions, area grows as r squared — so anything spreading out from a point thins as one over r squared.

The geometric reason is in the figure. Area grows as the square of distance in three-dimensional space, so any influence spreading from a point is diluted by r squared.

This is the most common one-line question about the law, and the trap in it is a quiet one.

The force goes as one over r squared, so doubling r divides the force by four. Tripling r divides it by nine. Moving to ten times the distance divides it by a hundred.

The tempting wrong answer is a half, and it comes from confusing the force with the potential energy, which goes as one over r. Both laws appear in this deck, so it is worth keeping them apart from the start: the force is inverse-square, the energy is inverse-first-power.

The figure shows why it is a square. Picture the gravitational influence as lines spreading out from the mass. At twice the distance the same lines cover four times the area, so each patch of area receives a quarter as much. That is the geometry of three-dimensional space, and it is the same reason light from a bulb gets dimmer with distance.

10. Superposition: gravity from several bodies adds as vectors

Concept

\[ \vec{F}_{\text{net}} = \vec{F}_1 + \vec{F}_2 + \cdots \qquad \text{each } \vec{F}_i \text{ computed as if the others were absent} \]

Each body pulls on the test mass independently, through the same law, and the net force is the vector sum. The presence of a third body does not alter the force between the first two.

Figure (svg): The Earth on the left and the Moon on the right with a spacecraft between them. Two gravity arrows point from the spacecraft toward each body, and they are equal at the balance point nine tenths of the way to the Moon.

Between the Earth and the Moon there is one point where the two pulls cancel.

The usual exam use: find where two pulls cancel, or find the net force on a mass at the corner of a triangle of masses. Both reduce to computing each force separately, drawing the arrows, and adding components.

When several bodies pull on one object, you calculate each pull as if the others were not there, then add them as vectors. That is all superposition means.

It sounds obvious, but it is a genuine physical fact about gravity, not a mathematical convenience. The Sun's pull on the Earth is exactly the same whether or not the Moon is present.

The figure shows the classic one-dimensional case: a spacecraft between the Earth and the Moon. Near the Earth, the Earth's pull wins. Near the Moon, the Moon's wins. Somewhere between, they are equal and opposite and the net force is zero.

In two dimensions the procedure is the same as for any vector problem in the forces deck. Draw each force from the object toward the body pulling it, resolve into components, add the components. The only thing specific to gravity is the formula for each magnitude.

11. Where the Earth and Moon pull equally

Worked example

Find the point on the line between the Earth and the Moon (d = 3.84 x 10^8 m apart) where a spacecraft feels no net gravitational force. The Earth is 81.2 times the Moon's mass.

Let x be the distance from the Earth's centre and set the two magnitudes equal.

Why: The spacecraft's own mass cancels, as it always does in gravitation.

\[ \frac{GM_E m}{x^2} = \frac{GM_M m}{(d-x)^2} \]

Take the square root of both sides instead of expanding.

Why: Expanding gives a quadratic; the square root gives a linear equation directly. Take the positive root, since the point lies between the bodies.

\[ \frac{x}{d - x} = \sqrt{\frac{M_E}{M_M}} = \sqrt{81.2} = 9.01 \]

Solve for x.

Why: Collect the x terms.

\[ x = \frac{9.01}{10.01}\,d = 0.900\,d = 3.46\times 10^{8}\,\text{m} \]

Check it is closer to the Moon.

Why: It must be: the weaker body has to be approached more closely before its pull can match the stronger one. 90 percent of the way across is right.

The square-root trick is the habit to keep. Whenever two inverse-square terms are set equal, root both sides before doing anything else.

The setup is a single equation — Earth's pull equals Moon's pull — and the technique worth learning is in the second step.

If you cross-multiply, you get a quadratic in x. You can solve it, but it is slow and it produces two roots you then have to interpret. Taking the square root of both sides first turns it into a linear equation in one move.

The positive root gives the point between the two bodies, which is the one asked for. The negative root corresponds to a point beyond the Moon where the pulls are equal in size but point the same way, so they add rather than cancel — not a balance point at all.

The answer, ninety percent of the way to the Moon, passes the sanity check. The weaker body has to be approached much more closely before its pull can match the stronger one.

This is the point the Apollo crews passed on the way out, after which the Moon's gravity began to win and their spacecraft started speeding up again.

12. The gravitation recipe

Pattern

  1. Measure r from centre to centre. For anything above a planet that is the planet's radius plus the altitude.
  2. Use GM, not G and M separately. For the Earth, GM = 3.98 x 10^14 m^3/s^2, or equivalently g R^2.
  3. Decide: force or energy? Forces and accelerations need F = GMm/r^2. Speeds between two distances need energy with U = -GMm/r.
  4. For orbits, set gravity equal to the centripetal requirement, and expect the orbiting mass to cancel.
  5. For ellipses, add angular momentum — it is conserved because gravity points at the centre.
  6. Check against a known orbit: low Earth orbit takes about 90 minutes at about 7.7 km/s.

\[ GM_E = gR_E^2 \approx 3.98\times 10^{14}\,\text{m}^3/\text{s}^2 \]

The identity GM = gR^2 is worth having: it lets you work entirely in g and R if a problem gives those instead of G and M — the AP exam often does.

These six habits cover nearly every problem in the deck. The first two are about avoiding arithmetic errors; the rest are about choosing the right tool.

Centre to centre, always. Write r equals R plus h as your first line in any altitude problem, before anything else.

Using GM rather than G and M separately saves a multiplication and a source of error in every problem. And the identity GM equals g R squared means you can work entirely with g and R when that is what you are given, which the AP exam often does.

The third habit is the big decision. If the question is about a force or an acceleration at one place, use the inverse-square law. If it is about speeds at two different distances, use energy with U equals minus GMm over r. Mixing these up is how a five-minute problem becomes a twenty-minute one.

The last habit is a cheap check worth memorising: a low Earth orbit takes about ninety minutes at about seven point seven kilometres per second. Any answer for a nearby satellite that is far from those numbers has an error in it.

13. g Is Not a Constant

Section

Section 2

14. Where g = 9.8 comes from

Concept

Set your weight equal to the gravitational force from the Earth.

Why: Your mass appears on both sides and cancels — this is why every object falls with the same acceleration.

\[ mg = \frac{GM_Em}{R_E^2} \;\Rightarrow\; g = \frac{GM_E}{R_E^2} \]

\[ g = \frac{3.98\times 10^{14}}{(6.37\times 10^{6})^2} = 9.81\,\text{m/s}^2 \]

So 9.8 is not a fundamental constant. It is G times the Earth's mass divided by the square of the Earth's radius — a fact about this planet.

\[ g(r) = \frac{GM_E}{r^2} = g_0\left(\frac{R_E}{r}\right)^2 \qquad (r \ge R_E) \]

At any distance r from the centre the local gravitational acceleration is the same expression with r in place of R. The second form is the practical one: no G needed, just the ratio of distances.

This slide takes apart the most familiar number in the course.

Set your weight, mg, equal to the gravitational force from the Earth. Your mass cancels from both sides, and what remains is g equals GM over R squared. Plug in the Earth's mass and radius and out comes nine point eight one.

The cancellation of your mass is worth pausing on. It is the reason all objects fall at the same rate — Galileo's observation — and it falls straight out of the law. Heavier objects feel a bigger force in exact proportion to the extra mass they have to accelerate.

The important consequence is that g is not a constant of nature. It is a fact about this planet at this radius. On the Moon it is about one point six; at the top of Everest it is about zero point three percent less than at sea level; at the space station it is eight point seven.

The second form — g naught times R over r, squared — is the one to use in practice. It needs no G and no M, only the ratio of distances, and it makes the scaling obvious.

15. Sweep the distance from the Earth's centre

Tweak it

Parameter explorer

Move from the surface (1 Earth radius) outward to the Moon's distance (60 Earth radii). How fast does g fall off, and what is it at the Moon's orbit?

\[ \frac{g}{g_0} = \frac{1}{({x})^2} \]

  • x — from 1 to 61

The steepness near the planet is the inverse square at work: the first Earth radius of climbing takes away three quarters of g.

Move the slider slowly from one Earth radius outward and watch how fast g drops.

The first few Earth radii do most of the work. At two Earth radii — one radius above the surface — g is already a quarter of its surface value. By geostationary orbit it is about two percent.

Notice the space station's entry. It is only six percent further from the centre than you are, so g there is still eighty-nine percent of surface gravity. That number matters for the next two slides.

Finally, look at the bottom row. At the Moon's distance, sixty Earth radii, g is two point seven times ten to the minus three metres per second squared — the same number you found for the Moon's centripetal acceleration two worked examples ago. The slider is replaying Newton's Moon test.

16. g at the altitude of the space station

Worked example

The International Space Station orbits 400 km above the surface. Find g there.

Convert the altitude to a centre-to-centre distance.

Why: Add the Earth's radius. Using 400 km directly is the classic error and gives an answer two thousand times too large.

\[ r = R_E + h = 6.37\times 10^6 + 0.40\times 10^6 = 6.77\times 10^{6}\,\text{m} \]

Scale the surface value by the square of the radius ratio.

Why: This avoids G and M entirely.

\[ g = 9.81\left(\frac{6.37}{6.77}\right)^2 = 9.81(0.885) = 8.68\,\text{m/s}^2 \]

Interpret.

Why: Gravity at the station is 89 percent of what it is on the ground. An astronaut there weighs, in the sense of gravitational force, almost exactly what they weigh at home.

Which raises the obvious question: why do they float? The next slide answers it, and the answer is not that gravity is weak.

The calculation is short; the important step is the first one.

Four hundred kilometres is an altitude, measured from the surface. The law needs a distance from the centre. So r is six point three seven plus zero point four zero, giving six point seven seven million metres. If you put four hundred kilometres straight into the formula, you get a g about two hundred and fifty times surface gravity, which should immediately look wrong.

Then use the ratio form. The radius is larger by a factor of six point seven seven over six point three seven, so g is smaller by the square of that, which is a factor of zero point eight eight five. Eight point six eight metres per second squared.

The answer is surprisingly large. Space is not far away; four hundred kilometres is about the distance from London to Paris. On the scale of the planet, the station is skimming the surface — which makes the floating astronauts a genuine puzzle, and the next slide resolves it.

17. Astronauts float because there is no gravity up there

Trap

The trap

Astronauts drift around the cabin, water forms floating spheres, and the word everyone uses is zero gravity.

So the station must be far enough away that the Earth's pull has faded out.

The fix

Gravity at the station is 8.7 m/s^2, 89 percent of surface gravity. The astronauts are falling.

Figure (svg): The Earth drawn to scale with the space station's orbit as a circle barely outside the surface, showing how close 400 km is on the scale of the planet.

On the scale of the Earth the station is skimming the surface; gravity there is nearly full strength.

The station and everyone in it are in free fall — accelerating toward the Earth at 8.7 m/s^2 together. Because the floor falls exactly as fast as the astronaut, the floor exerts no normal force, and the normal force is what your body registers as weight.

They never hit the ground because they are also moving sideways at 7.7 km/s. They fall around the curve of the Earth, continuously, and miss it.

Correct words: the astronauts are apparently weightless, or in free fall. Their true weight — the gravitational force on them — is almost unchanged. A lift whose cable snapped would produce exactly the same floating, at ground level.

This is probably the most widespread misconception in all of physics, so it is worth being completely clear about.

Gravity at the station is eighty-nine percent of its surface value. If you could build a tower four hundred kilometres tall and stand on top of it, you would feel almost your normal weight.

The astronauts float because they are in free fall. The station, and everything in it, is accelerating toward the Earth at eight point seven metres per second squared, all together. Nothing pushes up on the astronaut because the floor is falling away just as fast as they are.

And what you feel as weight is not gravity itself. It is the normal force from the floor, or the tension in your bones holding your body up against it. Remove that support — in a falling lift, on a roller coaster's drop, in orbit — and you feel weightless while gravity acts exactly as before.

So why do they never hit the ground? Because they are also moving sideways at seven point seven kilometres per second. They fall continuously, and the Earth's surface curves away beneath them just as fast. The precise words are apparent weightlessness, or free fall. Zero gravity is simply wrong.

18. The shell theorem

Concept

Newton needed a result before he could treat the Earth as a point: does a big sphere really pull as though all its mass were at its centre? He proved that it does, and found something stranger alongside it.

a uniform spherical shell of mass Mgravitational force on a mass m
m outside the shell, distance r from the centreGMm / r^2 — exactly as if all of M were at the centre
m anywhere inside the shellexactly zero

A solid sphere is a nest of shells, so the first row means any spherically symmetric body acts on outside objects as a point mass at its centre. That is what has quietly justified every r = R + h so far.

The second row is the surprise. Inside a hollow shell there is no gravitational force at all — not just at the centre, where symmetry would make it obvious, but at every point inside, however close to the wall.

The AP exam expects you to use both rows, not to prove them by integration. The next slide gives the geometric argument for the second row, which is worth understanding.

Newton had a real problem before he could publish. His law is for point masses, but the Earth is a huge sphere and you are standing on its surface, very much not far from most of it. Why should the whole planet act as if its mass were at its centre?

He proved — it took him years, and it is said to be one reason he delayed publishing — that for a spherically symmetric shell, it does exactly that for anything outside. Since a solid sphere is just a set of nested shells, the whole Earth acts on you as a point mass at its centre.

The second result came with it and is stranger. Anywhere inside a hollow uniform shell, the net gravitational force is exactly zero. Not just at the centre, where symmetry makes it obvious, but right up against the inside wall.

You are not expected to prove either result by integration on the AP exam. You are expected to use them both — the first every time you write r equals R plus h, and the second whenever a question takes you inside a planet.

19. Why the inside of a shell feels nothing

Picture it

Figure (svg): A circular shell with a point mass off-centre inside it. A narrow double cone through the point meets the shell on the near side in a small patch and on the far side in a larger patch.

Each pair of opposite patches pulls equally in opposite directions, so the whole shell's pull cancels.

Draw a thin double cone through the point. It cuts the shell in two patches, one near and one far.

The far patch is bigger: its area — and so its mass — grows as the square of its distance. But its pull per kilogram falls as the inverse square of that same distance. The two factors cancel exactly, so the near and far patches pull with equal strength in opposite directions.

Every cone through the point pairs up the whole shell this way, so the total is zero. Notice that the argument works only because the force is inverse-square. With any other power law the cancellation would fail — which is one reason the inverse square is so special.

Here is the geometric argument for the second result, and it is genuinely satisfying.

Put the mass off-centre, closer to the right-hand wall, and draw a thin double cone through it. On the near side, the cone cuts out a small patch of shell. On the far side, it cuts out a large one.

The far patch has more mass, because its area grows as the square of its distance. But its pull per kilogram is weaker by the inverse square of that same distance. The two factors cancel exactly, so the small near patch and the big far patch pull with equal strength in opposite directions.

Every possible cone pairs up the shell this way, so the whole shell's pull cancels. The point does not even need to be on the axis of symmetry.

Notice the argument works only because the force is an inverse square. With any other power, the area factor and the force factor would not cancel. That exact cancellation is one of the things that makes the inverse-square law special — and the same argument, applied to electric charge in electrodynamics, is the heart of Gauss's law.

20. Inside a uniform sphere, g grows linearly with r

Concept

At radius r inside a uniform planet, split it into the part inside r and the shells outside r.

Why: The outer shells contribute nothing (shell theorem, row two). The inner ball acts as a point at the centre (row one).

Find the mass inside r from the uniform density.

Why: Mass scales with volume, so with the cube of the radius.

\[ M_{\text{enc}} = M\,\frac{r^3}{R^3} \]

Apply the law of gravitation to just that enclosed mass.

Why: Two powers of r cancel against the r squared in the denominator.

\[ g(r) = \frac{GM_{\text{enc}}}{r^2} = \frac{GM}{R^3}\,r \qquad (r \le R) \]

Figure (svg): A graph of g against r: a straight line rising from zero at the centre to its maximum at the surface r equals R, then an inverse-square curve falling away outside.

g is largest at the surface: linear inside a uniform planet, inverse-square outside.

So g rises linearly from zero at the centre to its maximum at the surface, then falls as one over r squared. At the centre you would be weightless — every direction pulls equally.

This is the payoff of the shell theorem, and the derivation is three lines once you see how to split the planet.

At a radius r inside, divide the planet into the ball inside r and the shells outside r. The outer shells pull with zero net force, so forget them. The inner ball acts as a point mass at the centre.

For a uniform planet the enclosed mass scales with volume, so as r cubed over R cubed. Put that into the inverse-square law and two powers of r cancel the r squared in the denominator, leaving g proportional to r.

So the graph has a striking shape. g rises in a straight line from zero at the centre to its maximum at the surface, then falls off as one over r squared outside. The surface is the strongest place to be.

The real Earth is not uniform — its iron core is much denser than its rocky mantle — so actual g increases slightly as you go down through the mantle before falling toward the centre. But the uniform model is what the AP exam uses, and it captures the essential point: at the centre, you would be weightless.

21. A tunnel through the Earth

Worked example

Drill a straight frictionless tunnel through the Earth's centre and drop a ball in. Treat the Earth as uniform. Describe the motion and find how long the trip to the far side takes.

Figure (svg): An animated cross-section of the Earth with a straight tunnel through the centre and a ball oscillating from one end to the other.

The ball oscillates through the centre of the Earth in simple harmonic motion.

Write the force at distance r from the centre, using the linear interior result.

Why: The force is toward the centre, so it carries a minus sign along the tunnel.

\[ F = -m\,g(r) = -\frac{GMm}{R^3}\,r = -\frac{mg_0}{R}\,r \]

Recognise the form.

Why: Force proportional to displacement and directed back toward equilibrium is exactly Hooke's law, with an effective spring constant k = m g0 / R. So the motion is simple harmonic.

\[ \omega = \sqrt{\frac{k}{m}} = \sqrt{\frac{g_0}{R}} \qquad T = 2\pi\sqrt{\frac{R}{g_0}} = 2\pi\sqrt{\frac{6.37\times 10^6}{9.81}} = 5063\,\text{s} \]

Answer the question asked.

Why: The trip to the far side is half a period.

\[ \tfrac{1}{2}T = 2530\,\text{s} \approx 42\,\text{min} \]

Find the top speed, at the centre.

Why: For simple harmonic motion the maximum speed is the amplitude times omega.

\[ v_{\max} = \omega R = \sqrt{g_0 R} = 7.9\,\text{km/s} \]

Remarkably, 84 minutes and 7.9 km/s are exactly the period and speed of a satellite skimming the surface. That is not a coincidence: the satellite's shadow on any diameter executes the very same simple harmonic motion.

This is a classic problem because it connects gravitation to simple harmonic motion with almost no effort.

Inside the uniform Earth, the force on the ball is toward the centre and proportional to its distance from the centre. Force proportional to displacement and pointing back toward equilibrium is exactly a spring force. So the ball oscillates in simple harmonic motion, with an effective spring constant m g naught over R.

From there the period is pure recall: two pi root m over k, which becomes two pi root R over g. That works out at about eighty-four minutes for a full round trip, so a one-way trip to the far side takes about forty-two minutes, wherever you start.

The top speed, at the centre, is about seven point nine kilometres per second, and here is the surprising part. Eighty-four minutes and seven point nine kilometres per second are exactly the period and speed of a satellite in a circular orbit just skimming the surface.

That is no coincidence. Uniform circular motion, viewed edge-on, is simple harmonic motion. The ball in the tunnel moves exactly like the shadow of the skimming satellite projected onto the tunnel's line.

22. A tunnel that misses the centre

Anomaly

Now drill a straight frictionless tunnel between two cities that are not opposite each other — say London and New York. The tunnel is a chord, much shorter than the diameter.

Figure (svg): A circular Earth with a horizontal chord tunnel above the centre. At a point on the chord, the gravity arrow points at the centre; its component along the tunnel is drawn separately and points toward the chord's midpoint.

Only the component of gravity along the tunnel accelerates the ball, and it grows linearly with distance from the midpoint.

Predict first

Compared with the 42-minute trip straight through the centre, how long does the trip along the shorter chord take?

  • Less, in proportion to the shorter length
  • More, because the slope is gentler
  • Exactly the same: about 42 minutes
  • It depends on the latitude of the cities

Correct: Exactly the same: about 42 minutes

Why: Gravity inside points at the centre with strength proportional to r. Its component along the chord is (g0 / R) times r times the cosine of the angle, and r cos(angle) is just the distance x from the chord's midpoint. So the force along the tunnel is -(m g0 / R) x — the same spring constant as before — and every chord has the same 84-minute period. The shorter path is exactly compensated by the gentler pull.

Every straight frictionless tunnel through a uniform planet, between any two points, takes the same 42 minutes. The anomaly dissolves once you look at the component rather than the whole force.

Make your prediction honestly before reading the explanation — almost everyone gets this one wrong the first time.

The intuition says a shorter tunnel should be quicker. But a chord is less steep than a diameter, so the push along it is weaker, and the two effects compete.

The figure shows how to settle it. Gravity points at the centre with strength proportional to r. Only the component along the tunnel matters, because the walls take care of the rest. That component is the full force times the cosine of the angle, and r times that cosine is just the distance x from the midpoint of the chord.

So the force along the tunnel is minus m g naught over R times x — exactly the same spring constant as for the tunnel through the centre. Same spring constant, same mass, same period. Every straight frictionless tunnel through a uniform planet takes forty-two minutes, end to end.

This is the kind of result that tells you a model is doing real work. Nobody would guess it; the mathematics forces it.

23. g at half the Earth's radius

Check

Treat the Earth as a uniform sphere with surface gravity 9.8 m/s^2.

Check your understanding

What is g at a point halfway from the Earth's centre to its surface?

  • A. 39 m/s^2
  • B. 9.8 m/s^2
  • C. 4.9 m/s^2 (correct)
  • D. 2.45 m/s^2

Answer: C

Why: Inside a uniform sphere g = (GM/R^3) r, which is linear in r. Halfway in, g is half its surface value: 4.9 m/s^2. Only the mass inside r = R/2 pulls — one eighth of the planet — and it is four times closer than the surface is to the full mass, giving one eighth times four, which is one half.

Why A tempts people
This applies GM/r^2 with the FULL mass of the Earth at r = R/2, giving four times surface gravity. The outer shells contribute nothing, so you may only use the mass enclosed.
Why B tempts people
g is not constant below the surface. Treating it as constant ignores the shell theorem entirely.
Why D tempts people
One quarter would come from an inverse-square law running the wrong way. The interior law is linear, so halving r halves g.

24. Gravitational Potential Energy

Section

Section 3

25. Why mgh cannot be the whole story

Concept

U = mgh assumes the force is the same constant mg at every height. Once g depends on r, that assumption fails — and you can see it fail with a single limit.

By mgh, lifting a satellite to infinity would cost infinite energy. But g falls off so fast that the total work needed to escape is finite. Rockets do escape the Earth; mgh says they cannot.

So you need the general form, and you get it the way every potential energy is built: integrate the force.

\[ U(r) - U(\infty) = -\int_{\infty}^{r} \vec{F}\cdot d\vec{r} \]

The reference point is placed at infinity, not at the ground. Far from every planet the force vanishes, so that is the one location every problem in the universe can agree to call zero.

mgh was built on one assumption: the force is the same constant mg everywhere. Now that you know the force weakens with distance, the assumption is plainly false over large heights. The question is how badly it fails.

The cleanest way to see the failure is the limit. By mgh, lifting something to infinite height costs infinite energy, so nothing could ever escape the Earth. But rockets do escape. The true force falls off so quickly that the total work needed to reach infinity is finite.

So you need the general formula, and you build it the way every potential energy is built: integrate the force along a path and attach a minus sign. You did this for springs in the energy deck; the only new feature here is the inverse square.

The reference point moves to infinity. Far from every mass the force vanishes, so infinity is the one place every problem in the universe can agree to call zero. The ground is a perfectly good reference for a ball thrown in a park; it is a poor one for a planet.

26. Deriving U = -GMm/r by integration

Worked example

Write the force with its direction.

Why: Gravity on m points toward the centre, opposite the outward unit vector.

\[ F_r = -\frac{GMm}{r^2} \]

Apply the definition of potential energy, with U = 0 at infinity.

Why: The potential energy at r is minus the work gravity does as m comes in from infinity to r.

\[ U(r) = -\int_{\infty}^{r} \left(-\frac{GMm}{r'^2}\right)dr' = GMm\int_{\infty}^{r}\frac{dr'}{r'^2} \]

Integrate.

Why: The antiderivative of r to the minus two is minus r to the minus one.

\[ U(r) = GMm\left[-\frac{1}{r'}\right]_{\infty}^{r} = GMm\left(-\frac{1}{r} + 0\right) \]

\[ \boxed{U(r) = -\frac{GMm}{r}} \]

Check the sign makes physical sense.

Why: Coming in from infinity, gravity does positive work, so the potential energy must fall below its value at infinity — that is, below zero. A negative U is exactly right.

Check the derivative recovers the force.

Why: F = -dU/dr = -d/dr(-GMm/r) = -GMm/r^2. Toward the centre, inverse square. Consistent.

Follow the signs carefully here, because the derivation has two minus signs that both matter.

The force on m points inward, toward the centre, so its radial component is negative: minus GMm over r squared. The definition of potential energy adds another minus sign in front of the integral. Two minuses make the integrand positive.

Integrating one over r squared gives minus one over r. Evaluating from infinity to r, the infinity term is zero, and what is left is minus GMm over r.

Now the two checks, both worth doing every time you derive a potential energy. First, the sign: coming in from infinity, gravity does positive work, so potential energy must fall below its starting value of zero — a negative U is exactly what physics demands. Second, the derivative: minus dU by dr gives back minus GMm over r squared, the inward inverse-square force you started with.

If either check failed, the derivation would have an error in it. Since both pass, the result is right.

27. Reading the minus sign in U = -GMm/r

Notation

Annotate

On: \( U(r) = -\frac{G M m}{r} \)

  • Not an error and not optional. Zero is at infinity, and every bound position is BELOW that, so U is negative everywhere at finite r. The deeper you are in the well, the more negative.
  • Not one over r squared. The force is the derivative of U, which costs one power of r. Doubling the distance halves U; it quarters F.
  • Centre to centre, as always. On the surface, r = R and U = -GMm/R, a large negative number — what matters in any problem is only the CHANGE in U.
  • A choice, but the only sensible one. It makes U the energy needed to escape, with the sign flipped: you need +GMm/r to climb out from r.

A potential well is the right picture: the function rises toward zero as r grows, steeply near the planet and ever more gently far out. A body with total energy below zero is trapped in that well.

Students often treat this minus sign as a nuisance to be dropped. It is the most informative part of the formula.

Zero is at infinity. Every position at a finite distance from the planet is lower than infinity — you would have to do work to climb out — so U is negative everywhere you will ever actually be. Deeper in the well means more negative.

The one over r, not one over r squared, matters too. The force is the derivative of the energy, which costs one power of r. So doubling the distance halves the potential energy but quarters the force.

The most useful way to read the formula is as an escape cost. At distance r, you sit GMm over r below the top of the well. That is exactly how much energy you would have to add to climb out completely — which is where escape speed comes from later in the deck.

And since only changes in U ever enter a calculation, the large negative number at the surface is not a problem. What matters is how much it changes between the two places in your question.

28. U = mgh is the near-surface limit

Concept

Take the change in U when you climb from the surface to height h.

Why: Use the exact formula at both ends.

\[ \Delta U = -\frac{GMm}{R+h} + \frac{GMm}{R} = GMm\,\frac{h}{R(R+h)} \]

If h is small compared with R, replace R + h by R in the denominator.

Why: For a 100 m cliff the error in doing so is about one part in sixty thousand.

\[ \Delta U \approx \frac{GMm}{R^2}\,h = mgh \]

Figure (svg): A graph of U against r: a curve rising from a large negative value at the surface toward zero at large r, with a straight dashed tangent line at the surface labelled mgh.

Near the surface the curve is almost straight, and its slope is mg — that straight-line approximation is mgh.

Geometrically, mgh is the tangent line to the true curve at the surface. Close in it is indistinguishable from the curve; far out it overshoots without limit, which is the infinite-escape-energy problem from two slides back.

This slide reconciles the old formula with the new one, and shows exactly when the old one is safe.

Take the change in the exact potential energy from the surface to a height h. After combining the fractions it is GMm h over R times R plus h. If h is small compared with R, the R plus h is essentially R, and the whole thing collapses to GMm over R squared times h. GM over R squared is g, so this is mgh.

The figure shows the same thing geometrically. The true curve, minus GMm over r, is curved. mgh is its tangent line at the surface. Close to the surface the two are indistinguishable — for a hundred-metre cliff they differ by one part in sixty thousand.

Far from the surface the tangent line keeps rising forever, while the true curve flattens out toward zero. That divergence is precisely the infinite-escape-energy problem from two slides ago: mgh is a straight line, and a straight line never levels off.

So mgh was never wrong. It was the first term in an approximation, valid as long as h is a small fraction of R.

29. Gravitational potential energy is positive and zero at the ground

Trap

The trap

Every problem so far set U = 0 at the floor and called higher places positive. So a satellite, being very high, must have a large positive potential energy.

The fix

With the universal formula, U is negative everywhere and zero only at infinity. A satellite has a large negative U — less negative than on the ground, which is all that "higher" means.

locationU for a 1000 kg mass
Earth's surface, r = 6.37 x 10^6 m-6.25 x 10^10 J
space station orbit, r = 6.77 x 10^6 m-5.88 x 10^10 J
geostationary orbit, r = 4.21 x 10^7 m-9.4 x 10^9 J
infinitely far away0

Read the table as a ladder: climbing raises U toward zero. The station sits 3.7 x 10^9 J higher than the ground, exactly as the climb requires.

Both conventions are legitimate — only changes in U are physical. But you must not mix them. Write mgh with a ground reference and -GMm/r with an infinity reference in the same equation and the answer is meaningless.

Rule of thumb: if a problem involves more than a few kilometres of altitude, or the words orbit, escape or infinity, use -GMm/r throughout.

This trap catches people precisely because the old habit was correct for its own problems.

With the universal formula, U is negative at every finite distance. A satellite has a large negative potential energy — less negative than yours on the ground, which is all that higher means. The table shows the ladder: climbing raises U toward zero but never past it.

Both conventions are legitimate, because only differences in U are physical. You could keep zero at the ground and add a constant to everything. Nothing about the physics would change.

The danger is mixing them. If one term in your energy equation uses mgh with zero at the ground and another uses minus GMm over r with zero at infinity, the two zeros are in different places and the equation is meaningless. Pick one convention per problem and stick to it.

The practical rule on the slide is the one to keep. Any mention of orbits, escape, infinity, or altitudes beyond a few kilometres means the universal formula, everywhere in the problem.

30. How high does a 5.0 km/s launch go?

Worked example

A probe is launched straight up from the Earth's surface at 5.0 km/s. Ignoring air resistance and the Earth's rotation, how high does it rise?

Conserve energy between launch and the top, where v = 0.

Why: Use the exact potential energy. The probe's mass cancels.

\[ \tfrac{1}{2}v_0^2 - \frac{GM}{R} = -\frac{GM}{r_{\max}} \]

Evaluate the known terms per kilogram.

Why: GM/R = 3.98e14 / 6.37e6 = 6.25e7 J/kg, and half v squared = 1.25e7 J/kg.

\[ -\frac{GM}{r_{\max}} = 1.25\times 10^7 - 6.25\times 10^7 = -5.00\times 10^{7}\,\text{J/kg} \]

Solve for the top radius, then subtract the Earth's radius.

Why: The question asks for height above the surface.

\[ r_{\max} = \frac{3.98\times 10^{14}}{5.00\times 10^{7}} = 7.96\times 10^{6}\,\text{m} \;\Rightarrow\; h = 1.59\times 10^{6}\,\text{m} = 1590\,\text{km} \]

Compare with the constant-g estimate.

Why: v^2 / 2g gives 1280 km. The real probe goes 25 percent higher, because gravity weakens as it climbs and stops it less effectively.

The gap grows rapidly with speed. At 11.2 km/s the constant-g estimate gives 6400 km, while the true answer is infinity.

This is the cleanest example of when the universal potential energy is essential.

Energy conservation between launch and the top of the flight, with kinetic energy zero at the top. Divide through by the probe's mass, which cancels as always, and work per kilogram. GM over R is six point two five times ten to the seven joules per kilogram; half v squared is one point two five times ten to the seven.

The total energy per kilogram is negative — minus five times ten to the seven — so the probe is bound and will come back. The top of the flight is where the potential energy alone equals that total. Solve and the top is at seven point nine six million metres from the centre: about sixteen hundred kilometres up.

Now compare. The constant-g formula, v squared over 2g, gives twelve hundred and eighty kilometres. The real probe goes twenty-five percent higher, because gravity weakens as it climbs and therefore slows it less than the constant-g model assumes.

The comparison in the last line is worth remembering. At escape speed, the constant-g formula gives sixty-four hundred kilometres. The true answer is infinity. The approximation does not degrade gracefully; it fails completely.

31. Find the mistake in this launch-height calculation

Error analysis

A student answers the previous problem with the kinematics they learned in the first deck.

Annotate

On: \( v_0^2 = 2gh \;\Rightarrow\; h = \frac{(5000)^2}{2(9.8)} = 1.28\times 10^{6}\,\text{m} \)

  • v squared = 2gh comes from CONSTANT acceleration. Over this climb g falls from 9.8 m/s^2 at the ground to about 6.3 m/s^2 at the real top, so the assumption is badly violated.
  • Weaker gravity higher up decelerates the probe less, so it climbs further than the formula says. The estimate is too LOW — 1280 km against the true 1590 km.
  • Compare h with R. Here h is a fifth of the Earth's radius, far too large for any constant-g formula. As a working threshold, beyond about one percent of R start using -GMm/r.

The arithmetic is flawless and the answer is still wrong. That is the signature of a model applied outside its range, and the fix is never more careful arithmetic — it is the right model.

There is no arithmetic error here. Every number is computed correctly, and the answer is still wrong by three hundred kilometres. That is what it looks like when a formula is used outside the conditions it was derived under.

v squared equals 2gh is a constant-acceleration result. It came from the kinematics deck, where gravity really was constant over the heights involved. Here the probe climbs a fifth of an Earth radius, and gravity at the top is only about two thirds of its surface value.

Think about which way the error goes. Weaker gravity higher up means the probe is slowed less than the formula assumes, so it climbs further. The estimate is an underestimate, which matches what you found.

The lesson generalises. Before using any formula, ask what it assumed. For any constant-g result, that assumption is that the height is tiny compared with the planet's radius. Here the ratio is about one fifth, which is nowhere near tiny.

32. Circular Orbits

Section

Section 4

33. Newton's cannon

Intuition

Figure (svg): An animated drawing of a cannon on a tall mountain on a small Earth. Slow shots curve down and hit the ground at increasing distances; the fastest shot curves all the way around in a circular orbit, with a satellite moving along it.

Fire fast enough and the projectile falls around the Earth forever.

Newton's own thought experiment. A cannon on an impossibly tall mountain fires horizontally. A slow shot falls nearby; a faster one lands further off; faster still and the Earth's surface curves away beneath it.

At one particular speed the shot falls toward the Earth exactly as fast as the surface curves away. It never lands. That is an orbit: free fall with enough sideways speed to keep missing.

Nothing new is required to describe it — just gravity providing the centripetal force you met in the forces deck.

This is Newton's own picture, from his writings on the system of the world, and it is still the best way to understand what an orbit is.

Imagine a mountain so tall that air resistance is irrelevant, with a cannon firing horizontally from the top. A slow shot curves down and lands nearby. A faster shot lands further away, and because the Earth is round, the ground beneath it has curved away a little, so it travels further still before landing.

Keep increasing the speed. At one particular speed, the shot falls toward the Earth at exactly the rate the surface curves away beneath it. It never lands. It comes back round to the mountain and keeps going.

That is all an orbit is: free fall with enough sideways speed to keep missing the ground. The Moon is falling toward the Earth right now, and has been for four billion years.

Notice there is no new physics in the picture. The cannonball is a projectile, the same as in the kinematics deck. The only change is that the ground is curved and gravity points at the centre rather than straight down.

34. Gravity supplies the centripetal force

Concept

Figure (svg): A satellite on a circular orbit around a planet, with the gravitational force and the acceleration both pointing to the centre and the velocity tangent to the orbit.

In a circular orbit, gravity alone provides exactly the centripetal force the circle needs.

\[ \frac{GMm}{r^2} = \frac{mv^2}{r} \;\Rightarrow\; v = \sqrt{\frac{GM}{r}} \]

Three consequences follow immediately. The satellite's own mass cancels, so every object at a given radius orbits at the same speed. Speed decreases with radius, as one over root r. And the period follows from the circumference.

\[ T = \frac{2\pi r}{v} = 2\pi\sqrt{\frac{r^3}{GM}} \]

The yellow acceleration arrow points at the centre, and the cyan velocity is perpendicular to it — the same picture as any uniform circular motion. Gravity changes the direction of the velocity and never its size.

In uniform circular motion, something has to supply a net inward force of m v squared over r. For an orbit, gravity is the only force acting, so gravity must be that force. Set them equal.

The satellite's mass appears on both sides and cancels. That is the first consequence and it is a big one: every object at a given radius orbits at the same speed, whether it is a space station or a spanner an astronaut has let go of.

The second consequence is that speed decreases with radius. v is root GM over r, so further out means slower. That surprises people, because higher orbits sound more energetic — the energy section will untangle that.

The figure uses the course's colour grammar. The pink gravitational force and the yellow acceleration both point at the centre; the cyan velocity is tangent to the circle. Gravity is always perpendicular to the motion in a circular orbit, so it does no work: it changes the direction of the velocity, never its size.

35. Speed and period of the space station

Worked example

Find the orbital speed and period of the space station, orbiting at r = 6.77 x 10^6 m.

Speed from the orbit condition.

Why: Gravity equals the centripetal requirement, and the station's mass cancels.

\[ v = \sqrt{\frac{GM}{r}} = \sqrt{\frac{3.98\times 10^{14}}{6.77\times 10^{6}}} = 7.67\times 10^{3}\,\text{m/s} \]

Period from the circumference.

Why: One orbit is 2 pi r of path at constant speed.

\[ T = \frac{2\pi(6.77\times 10^{6})}{7.67\times 10^{3}} = 5.55\times 10^{3}\,\text{s} = 92.5\,\text{min} \]

Check against reality.

Why: The station circles the Earth about every 92 minutes — roughly sixteen sunrises a day. The calculation agrees.

Notice the speed in more familiar units.

Why: 7.67 km/s is about 27,600 km/h, or Los Angeles to New York in under ten minutes. That sideways speed is what being in orbit costs, and it is why reaching orbit is so much harder than reaching space.

Reaching 400 km altitude takes about 3.7 MJ per kilogram; reaching the speed to stay there takes about 29 MJ per kilogram. Orbit is mostly about going sideways.

Two lines of calculation, and they reproduce one of the most familiar facts about spaceflight.

The speed is root GM over r, about seven point six seven kilometres per second. The period is the circumference divided by that speed, about fifty-five hundred seconds, or ninety-two and a half minutes. The real station circles the Earth in about ninety-two minutes, so the model is right.

Put the speed in everyday units and it becomes vivid: twenty-seven thousand kilometres per hour. The crew see a sunrise or sunset roughly every forty-five minutes.

The last line contains an important insight about spaceflight. Lifting a kilogram to four hundred kilometres takes about three point seven megajoules. Giving it the speed to stay there takes about twenty-nine megajoules — eight times as much. Getting to space is easy; staying there is the expensive part, because staying means going sideways very fast.

36. Deriving Kepler's third law

Worked example

Kepler found from decades of data that the square of a planet's period is proportional to the cube of its orbital radius. Derive it, and find the constant.

Start from the period of a circular orbit.

Why: It came from v = sqrt(GM/r) and T = 2 pi r / v.

\[ T = 2\pi\sqrt{\frac{r^3}{GM}} \]

Square both sides.

Why: The radius appears cubed and the period squared, exactly as Kepler found.

\[ T^2 = \left(\frac{4\pi^2}{GM}\right)r^3 \]

Read the constant.

Why: The ratio T^2/r^3 depends only on the mass of the CENTRAL body. Every planet of the Sun shares one value; every satellite of the Earth shares another.

Use it as a ratio — no constants needed.

Why: Mars orbits at 1.52 times the Earth's distance from the Sun, so its year is 1.52 to the power 3/2 Earth years.

\[ T_{\text{Mars}} = (1.52)^{3/2}\,\text{yr} = 1.87\,\text{yr} \]

Run the logic backwards and it becomes the most important use of the law: measure T and r for any orbiting body, and you have weighed the thing it orbits. That is how the masses of the Sun, of Jupiter, and of the black hole at the centre of the galaxy are known.

Kepler discovered this law from Tycho Brahe's planetary observations in 1619, with no idea why it should be true. You can now derive it in two lines.

Start from the period of a circular orbit, two pi root r cubed over GM. Square both sides and you have T squared proportional to r cubed, with the constant of proportionality four pi squared over GM.

The key observation is what the constant depends on: only the mass of the central body. Every planet orbiting the Sun has the same value of T squared over r cubed. Every satellite of the Earth shares a different value. The orbiting body's own mass never appears.

That makes the law easy to use as a ratio. Mars is one point five two times further from the Sun than the Earth is, so its year is one point five two to the power three halves Earth years — one point eight seven years. No constants needed.

And it makes the law a weighing machine. Measure the period and size of any orbit and you can compute GM for the thing at the centre. That is the only way anyone has ever weighed the Sun, the planets, or the black hole at the centre of our galaxy.

37. Sweep the orbital radius out to the Moon

Tweak it

Parameter explorer

Kepler's third law says T grows as r to the 3/2. Starting from a satellite skimming the surface (84 minutes), slide the radius out in Earth radii. Where does the period reach one day, and where does it reach a month?

\[ T = 1.41\,\text{h}\times({x})^{3/2} \]

  • x — from 1 to 61

The 3/2 power is gentler than it looks at first: to multiply the period by 8 you only need to multiply the radius by 4.

Slide from the surface outward and watch the period grow. The three-halves power means it grows faster than the radius but slower than its square.

Look for the two landmarks. At about six point six Earth radii the period reaches twenty-four hours. That is geostationary orbit, where a satellite keeps pace with the rotating Earth and stays over one spot — which is why satellite dishes can point at a fixed place in the sky.

At about sixty Earth radii the period reaches a month. That is where the Moon is. One law, with no adjustment at all, connects a satellite skimming the surface to the Moon.

The note below the slider is a good mental shortcut. To multiply a period by eight, multiply the radius by four, since four to the three halves is eight. Questions about ratios of periods almost always come out in clean numbers like that.

38. Geostationary orbit

Worked example

A geostationary satellite orbits above the equator with a period equal to one rotation of the Earth (a sidereal day, 86 164 s), so it hangs over one spot. Find its orbital radius, altitude and speed.

Solve Kepler's third law for r.

Why: Everything else is known.

\[ r = \left(\frac{GM T^2}{4\pi^2}\right)^{1/3} = \left(\frac{(3.98\times 10^{14})(86164)^2}{4\pi^2}\right)^{1/3} \]

\[ r = (7.48\times 10^{22})^{1/3} = 4.21\times 10^{7}\,\text{m} \]

Subtract the Earth's radius for the altitude.

Why: Geostationary satellites are not in low orbit at all.

\[ h = 4.21\times 10^7 - 0.637\times 10^7 = 3.58\times 10^{7}\,\text{m} \approx 35\,800\,\text{km} \]

Find the speed.

Why: Circumference over period, or root GM over r — they must agree.

\[ v = \sqrt{\frac{GM}{r}} = \sqrt{\frac{3.98\times 10^{14}}{4.21\times 10^{7}}} = 3.07\times 10^{3}\,\text{m/s} \]

Why the sidereal day and not 24 hours: the satellite must keep up with the Earth's rotation relative to the stars. The 24-hour solar day is four minutes longer because the Earth also moves along its own orbit during that time. The difference changes r by about 0.2 percent.

This is a direct application of Kepler's third law, solved for the radius.

Put the period of one rotation into T squared equals four pi squared r cubed over GM, rearrange for r, and take a cube root. The radius comes out at four point two one times ten to the seven metres — about six point six Earth radii, matching the slider.

Subtract the Earth's radius and the altitude is about thirty-five thousand eight hundred kilometres. That is roughly ninety times higher than the space station. Communication satellites are not in low orbit at all; they are a tenth of the way to the Moon.

The speed, three point zero seven kilometres per second, is less than half the station's. Higher orbits are slower, as the speed formula said.

The detail about the sidereal day is worth understanding even if you never need it on an exam. The Earth turns once relative to the stars every twenty-three hours fifty-six minutes. The twenty-four hour day is a little longer because the Earth also moves along its orbit around the Sun, so it has to turn slightly more than once to bring the Sun back to the same place. A satellite has to keep pace with the stars' version.

39. A heavier satellite in the same orbit

Prediction

Predict first

Two satellites orbit the Earth in circular orbits of the same radius. One has ten times the mass of the other. How do their orbital speeds compare?

  • The heavier one is faster
  • The heavier one is slower
  • They have exactly the same speed
  • The heavier one is faster by a factor of root ten

Correct: They have exactly the same speed

Why: Orbital speed is v = sqrt(GM/r), where M is the Earth's mass. The satellite's own mass appears on both sides of GMm/r^2 = mv^2/r and cancels. The heavier satellite does feel ten times the gravitational force — and needs ten times the centripetal force, so the two scale together.

This is Galileo's falling-objects result in orbital form. A hammer and a feather dropped together fall together; a hammer and a feather released together in orbit orbit together. Astronauts on a spacewalk drift beside their station for exactly this reason.

This prediction tests whether you believe the cancellation in the orbit equation.

The heavier satellite really does feel ten times the gravitational force. But to move on the same circle at the same speed, it also needs ten times the centripetal force. The two scale together exactly, so the required speed is the same.

It is Galileo's result about falling bodies, transplanted to orbit. In a vacuum, a hammer and a feather fall together. In orbit, a hammer and a feather released side by side stay side by side.

This has a practical side. An astronaut on a spacewalk, a dropped tool, and the station itself all orbit together because they all have the same orbital speed at the same radius. Tethers are there for safety against small pushes, not to stop the astronaut falling behind.

40. Which orbit is faster?

Check

Satellite A orbits the Earth in a circle of radius r. Satellite B orbits in a circle of radius 4r.

Check your understanding

How does B's orbital speed compare with A's?

  • A. One sixteenth
  • B. One quarter
  • C. One half (correct)
  • D. Twice as fast

Answer: C

Why: v = sqrt(GM/r), so four times the radius gives one over root four, which is one half the speed. The period, by contrast, grows by four to the 3/2, which is eight: B travels a circle four times as long at half the speed.

Why A tempts people
This applies the inverse square to the speed. It is the FORCE (and acceleration) that falls by 16; the speed depends on the square root of GM/r.
Why B tempts people
This is a one-over-r dependence. The speed goes as one over the square root of r.
Why D tempts people
Higher orbits are slower, not faster. Gravity is weaker further out, so less speed is needed to keep the satellite on its circle.

41. Orbital Energy

Section

Section 5

42. The energy of a circular orbit

Concept

Kinetic energy, from the orbital speed.

Why: Substitute v squared = GM/r.

\[ K = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2 = \frac{GMm}{2r} \]

Potential energy, from the universal formula.

Why: With zero at infinity.

\[ U = -\frac{GMm}{r} \]

Add them.

Why: The kinetic energy is exactly half the size of the potential energy, so the total is negative.

\[ E = K + U = -\frac{GMm}{2r} \qquad K = -E \qquad U = 2E \]

Those three relations are the whole of orbital energy. In a circular orbit the kinetic energy is the magnitude of the total energy, and the potential energy is twice the total.

The total is negative, and that is the definition of a bound orbit. To get the satellite to infinity — where E would be zero at best — you must add energy. The negative sign is how much.

This slide gives you three short relations that answer almost every orbital energy question.

The kinetic energy comes from the orbit speed: half m v squared with v squared equal to GM over r gives GMm over 2r. The potential energy is minus GMm over r. Add them and the total is minus GMm over 2r.

Now compare the three. The kinetic energy has exactly the same size as the total but the opposite sign: K equals minus E. The potential energy is exactly twice the total: U equals 2E. Those relations hold for every circular orbit around every body.

The negative total is the signature of a bound orbit. A satellite with negative total energy cannot reach infinity, because at infinity its potential energy would be zero and its kinetic energy would have to be negative. The size of the negative number tells you how much energy you would have to add to free it.

Keep K equals minus E especially close at hand. It is the relation that explains every orbital paradox in the next three slides.

43. The energy ladder of circular orbits

Picture it

Figure (svg): A graph of energy against orbital radius. The kinetic energy curve is positive and falling; the potential energy curve is negative and rising; the total energy curve lies between, negative and rising toward zero.

As the orbit grows, total and potential energy rise toward zero while kinetic energy falls.

Read the ladder left to right as climbing to a higher orbit. E rises — you must supply energy. U rises twice as much. And K falls by the difference: the higher satellite moves more slowly.

That is the source of every orbital paradox in the next few slides. Raising an orbit adds energy and lowers the speed. Lowering it removes energy and raises the speed. Speed and total energy move in opposite directions.

Read the graph from left to right, as if you were climbing to higher and higher orbits.

The orange total energy curve rises toward zero. So moving to a higher orbit requires adding energy, which is what your intuition expects.

The pink potential energy curve rises too, and twice as steeply. And the cyan kinetic energy curve falls. Every joule you add to the total raises the potential energy by two joules and lowers the kinetic energy by one.

That last fact is the counter-intuitive one. A higher orbit has more total energy and a lower speed. A lower orbit has less total energy and a higher speed. In orbital mechanics, speed and total energy move in opposite directions.

Hold that sentence in mind. It is the whole explanation of the drag paradox, the Hohmann transfer and the rendezvous problem, all of which are coming up.

44. Energy to raise a satellite to geostationary orbit

Worked example

A 1000 kg satellite is moved from the space station's orbit (r1 = 6.77 x 10^6 m) to geostationary orbit (r2 = 4.21 x 10^7 m). Find the energy required and what happens to its kinetic energy.

The required energy is the change in total orbital energy.

Why: Both orbits are circular, so E = -GMm/2r applies to each.

\[ \Delta E = \frac{GMm}{2}\left(\frac{1}{r_1} - \frac{1}{r_2}\right) \]

Substitute.

Why: GMm/2 = (3.98e14)(1000)/2 = 1.99e17 J m.

\[ \Delta E = (1.99\times 10^{17})(1.477\times 10^{-7} - 0.237\times 10^{-7}) = 2.47\times 10^{10}\,\text{J} \]

Split the change into kinetic and potential.

Why: Use K = -E and U = 2E for each orbit.

\[ \Delta K = -2.47\times 10^{10}\,\text{J} \qquad \Delta U = +4.94\times 10^{10}\,\text{J} \]

Interpret.

Why: The engines supply 2.5 x 10^10 J. The potential energy rises by twice that, and the satellite's own kinetic energy pays the other half — it ends up moving at 3.1 km/s instead of 7.7 km/s.

Twenty-five gigajoules is roughly the chemical energy in 570 kg of kerosene — but the rocket needed to deliver it weighs far more, for the rocket-equation reasons from the momentum deck.

The calculation is one subtraction, and the interpretation is where the learning is.

Both orbits are circular, so each has total energy minus GMm over 2r. The energy required is the difference: GMm over 2, times one over r one minus one over r two. That comes to about two point five times ten to the ten joules.

Now split it, using K equals minus E and U equals 2E. The potential energy rises by twice the energy supplied, about four point nine times ten to the ten joules. The kinetic energy falls by the same amount the engines supplied. The satellite ends up moving at three point one kilometres per second instead of seven point seven.

So the engines paid for half the climb, and the satellite's own kinetic energy paid for the other half. That is the energy ladder made concrete.

The comparison with kerosene is a reminder that energy is not the hard part of spaceflight. Twenty-five gigajoules is about the energy in a few hundred kilograms of fuel. The hard part is that the rocket has to carry that fuel, and the fuel needed to lift the fuel, which is what the rocket equation from the momentum deck is about.

45. Adding energy to a satellite makes it go faster

Trap

The trap

Energy and speed go together in everything you have studied so far: more kinetic energy means more speed. Fire the engine forward and the satellite must end up faster.

The fix

Adding energy to a satellite in a circular orbit ends with it moving more slowly.

The engine does speed it up — for a moment. But the faster satellite now has more speed than its circle requires, so it rises. As it climbs, gravity does negative work and takes back more kinetic energy than the engine gave.

low orbithigh orbit
total energy Emore negativeless negative (higher)
potential energy U = 2Emore negativehigher, by twice as much
kinetic energy K = -Elargersmaller
speedfasterslower

The bookkeeping is exact: every joule you add as total energy raises U by two joules and lowers K by one. The net effect of adding energy is to slow the satellite down.

Keep the two meanings of "speed it up" apart. The engine burn is an instant increase in speed; the new circular orbit has a lower speed. Exam questions often turn on which one is being asked about.

Everything in your experience says that more energy means more speed. For a satellite changing orbit, that experience misleads you.

The engine burn itself does increase the speed, for a moment. But a satellite moving faster than its circle requires does not stay on the circle. It climbs. And as it climbs, gravity does negative work on it, taking kinetic energy away and converting it into potential energy.

The table shows the end result once it settles onto a new circular orbit. Higher total energy, much higher potential energy, lower kinetic energy, lower speed. Adding energy ended with the satellite moving more slowly.

The two meanings of speed up are the source of the confusion. Immediately after a burn, the satellite is faster. On its new circular orbit, it is slower. Exam questions frequently hinge on which of those two moments they are asking about, so read the wording carefully.

46. Air drag speeds a satellite up

Anomaly

Low satellites skim the top of the atmosphere and feel a tiny drag force, opposite to their motion. Drag takes energy away.

Figure (svg): A slowly tightening spiral path of a satellite decaying toward the Earth, with velocity arrows that get longer as the path moves inward.

A satellite losing energy to drag spirals inward and speeds up.

Predict first

As drag slowly removes energy from a satellite in a nearly circular low orbit, what happens to its speed?

  • It decreases, since drag opposes the motion
  • It increases
  • It stays the same while the orbit shrinks
  • It decreases until the satellite stops and falls straight down

Correct: It increases

Why: Losing energy makes E more negative, so the orbit shrinks. For circular orbits K = -E, so a more negative E means a LARGER kinetic energy. The satellite spirals inward and speeds up: gravity does positive work on the way down that is twice the energy drag removes, so the speed rises despite the drag.

This is the satellite drag paradox, and it is observed: decaying satellites speed up until they re-enter. The resolution is the same ladder — K and E move in opposite directions.

Commit to a prediction first. Drag opposes motion, so it ought to slow the satellite. That is the trap.

Drag does remove energy, so the total energy becomes more negative. A more negative total energy means a smaller orbit. And for circular orbits, K equals minus E, so a more negative E means a larger kinetic energy.

Put differently: as the satellite sinks, gravity does positive work on it. That work is twice the energy drag removes, so even after paying for the drag the satellite gains kinetic energy. It spirals inward and speeds up.

This is observed. Satellites in decaying low orbits are measured to speed up as they lose altitude, until they enter the dense atmosphere and burn up. It is called the satellite drag paradox, and the energy ladder dissolves it completely.

47. Escape Speed

Section

Section 6

48. Escape: reaching infinity with nothing to spare

Concept

To escape, a body must reach infinity — where U = 0 — with a kinetic energy that is zero or more. So the total energy must be zero or positive.

\[ E = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2 - \frac{GMm}{R} \ge 0 \]

Find the minimum launch speed by setting E exactly to zero.

Why: The mass cancels, as always.

\[ v_{\text{esc}} = \sqrt{\frac{2GM}{R}} = \sqrt{2}\,v_{\text{circ}} \]

Escape speed is root two times the circular orbit speed at the same radius. A satellite in low orbit is already 71 percent of the way to escape speed — it needs about 41 percent more speed, not a fresh start.

total energywhat the orbit does
E below zerobound: a circle or an ellipse, returns forever
E exactly zeroa parabola: just escapes, arriving at infinity at rest
E above zeroa hyperbola: escapes with speed to spare

Escape is an energy question, and the condition is simple once the potential energy is zero at infinity.

To reach infinity, the body must arrive there with kinetic energy of zero or more. Since U is zero at infinity, that means the total energy must be zero or positive. The minimum escape speed is the one that makes the total exactly zero.

Setting half m v squared equal to GMm over R gives v equals root 2GM over R. Compare it with the circular orbit speed, root GM over R, and the ratio is root two. Escape speed is about forty-one percent faster than orbital speed at the same radius.

The table connects energy to the shape of the path. Negative total energy gives a closed orbit, a circle or ellipse. Exactly zero gives a parabola that just barely escapes. Positive gives a hyperbola that escapes with speed to spare. One number decides the fate of the body.

49. Escape speed from Earth

Worked example

Find the escape speed from the Earth's surface, and from the space station's orbit.

At the surface, r = R_E.

Why: Use the GM/R value already computed: 6.25 x 10^7 J/kg.

\[ v_{\text{esc}} = \sqrt{2(6.25\times 10^{7})} = 1.12\times 10^{4}\,\text{m/s} = 11.2\,\text{km/s} \]

From the station's orbit, r = 6.77 x 10^6 m.

Why: Escape speed depends on where you start: further out, less is needed.

\[ v_{\text{esc}} = \sqrt{2}\,(7.67\,\text{km/s}) = 10.8\,\text{km/s} \]

Compare with the speed the station already has.

Why: It is moving at 7.67 km/s, so an extra 3.2 km/s, in the right direction, sends it out of the Earth's grip.

Check the energy route gives the same answer.

Why: E = 0 at escape. From orbit, E per kilogram is -GM/2r = -2.94e7 J/kg; reaching zero means adding 2.94e7 J/kg of kinetic energy. Half of 10.84 km/s squared minus half of 7.67 km/s squared is 5.88e7 - 2.94e7 = 2.94e7 J/kg — exactly the same.

Note what 11.2 km/s does not mean: it is not a speed you must maintain. It is the speed you need at the surface once, with no further thrust. A rocket burning continuously can leave the Earth at any speed at all.

The surface result, eleven point two kilometres per second, is one of the standard numbers worth knowing.

From orbit, the escape speed is lower, because you start part of the way up the well. From the station's altitude it is ten point eight kilometres per second, and the station is already moving at seven point six seven, so the extra needed is only about three kilometres per second.

The check on the slide is worth following. The energy route says you need to add exactly the magnitude of the orbital energy, GM over 2r per kilogram. The speed route gives the same number. Two different arguments, one answer.

The last paragraph corrects a widespread misunderstanding. Escape speed is not a speed you must keep up. It is the speed you need once, at the start, if you get no further push. A rocket that keeps firing its engine can leave the Earth at walking pace, in principle — it just keeps paying for the climb as it goes.

50. Does the launch direction matter for escape?

Prediction

Predict first

Ignoring air and the Earth's rotation, a ball is launched from the surface at exactly escape speed. In one trial it goes straight up; in another it goes off at 30 degrees above the horizontal. Which trial escapes?

  • Only the vertical one
  • Only the angled one, since it gains orbital help
  • Both escape
  • Neither — escape requires continuous thrust

Correct: Both escape

Why: Escape is decided by the total energy, and energy is a scalar: half m v squared does not care which way v points. At escape speed E = 0 in both trials, so both reach infinity. The paths differ — one is a straight line, the other a parabola — but as long as the path does not intersect the planet, only the speed matters.

Direction matters only through the ground: a launch aimed downward would hit the planet first. And in practice rockets launch eastward to borrow the Earth's rotation, about 0.46 km/s at the equator — a real saving, but in the frame of the stars, not a change to the escape condition.

The answer follows directly from the fact that energy is a scalar.

Kinetic energy is half m v squared. The squared speed has no direction in it. So two launches at the same speed from the same place have the same total energy, regardless of where they point. If that energy is zero or more, both escape.

The paths are different, of course. One goes straight up; the other curves away. But the question of whether the body reaches infinity is decided by energy alone.

The only way direction can matter is by aiming into the planet. A launch pointed downward hits the ground before it gets anywhere.

The remark about launching eastward is a real effect but a different one. The Earth's rotation gives everything at the equator a free four hundred and sixty metres per second relative to the stars. Launch east and that speed adds to yours. The escape condition is unchanged; you are simply starting with part of it already paid.

51. Bound or escaping?

Sorting

Each situation describes a body near the Earth. Sort by whether it escapes to infinity or remains bound.

Sort into buckets

Bound (E < 0)
launched straight up from the surface at 10 km/s; a satellite in a circular orbit, E = -GMm/2r; a probe at the space station's altitude moving at 10 km/s; an object whose kinetic energy is exactly half the magnitude of its potential energy
Escapes (E >= 0)
launched horizontally from the surface at 12 km/s; launched at 11.2 km/s, 45 degrees above the horizontal; a comet passing with total energy +3 x 10^12 J
bound
These have negative total energy. 10 km/s at the surface is below 11.2 km/s; 10 km/s at the station's altitude is below the 10.8 km/s needed there; a circular orbit has E = -GMm/2r by construction; and K = |U|/2 is exactly the circular-orbit relation, so E = -K, negative.
free
These have zero or positive total energy. Anything at or above 11.2 km/s at the surface escapes regardless of direction (provided it misses the ground), and a positive total energy is the definition of an unbound, hyperbolic path.

Item f is the one to recheck. 10 km/s sounds close to escape, and from the surface it is short of 11.2 — but from orbit the target drops to 10.8 km/s, still not reached. Always compute escape speed at the actual radius.

The sorting rule is the sign of the total energy, and the technique is to compute escape speed at the actual position before comparing.

Ten kilometres per second at the surface falls short of eleven point two, so that body comes back. Twelve kilometres per second at the surface exceeds it, so that one escapes — in any direction that misses the ground.

Eleven point two at forty-five degrees is the direction question again. Energy is a scalar, so the angle is irrelevant, and the body escapes.

The last item rewards recognising a relation rather than computing. Kinetic energy equal to half the magnitude of the potential energy is exactly the circular-orbit relation, K equals GMm over 2r. That body is in a circular orbit, with negative total energy, so it is bound.

Item f is where people slip. Ten kilometres per second sounds close to escape. But at the station's radius the threshold is ten point eight, so ten is still short.

52. One launch point, four orbits

Picture it

Figure (svg): Four paths leaving the same point above a planet, all launched horizontally at increasing speed: a circle, an ellipse, an open parabola and a wider hyperbola, each labelled with the sign of its total energy.

Same point, same direction, rising launch speed: circle, ellipse, parabola, hyperbola.

All four leave the dot horizontally; only the speed differs. Below escape speed the path closes on itself — a circle at exactly v_circ, an ellipse above it. At exactly escape speed it opens into a parabola. Faster still, a hyperbola.

These are the conic sections, and Newton proved that an inverse-square force produces only conic sections. The sign of E sorts them: negative closes, zero just opens, positive opens wide.

This figure summarises the whole of orbital mechanics in one picture.

All four paths start at the same point moving in the same direction. The only difference is the launch speed. At exactly the circular speed, the path is a circle. A little faster and it becomes an ellipse with the launch point as its closest approach.

At exactly escape speed the ellipse breaks open into a parabola: the body leaves and arrives at infinity with nothing to spare. Faster still and the path becomes a hyperbola, leaving with speed in hand.

Circles, ellipses, parabolas and hyperbolas are the conic sections, studied by the ancient Greeks as slices through a cone. Newton proved that an inverse-square force produces exactly these curves and nothing else. That an abstract piece of Greek geometry turned out to describe the motion of the planets is one of the remarkable facts of science.

53. Push the launch speed toward escape

Edge cases

Parameter explorer

A probe is launched straight up at a fraction f of escape speed. Energy conservation gives the maximum distance from the centre as r_max / R = 1 / (1 - f^2). Push f toward 1. What happens to the height, and what happens at f = 1?

\[ \frac{r_{\max}}{R} = \frac{1}{1 - ({f})^2} \]

  • f — from 0.1 to 0.99

The derivation is one line: half v squared minus GM/R equals minus GM/r_max, with v = f times root(2GM/R). The constant-g formula would give a finite height for every f, which is exactly where it fails.

Drag the slider slowly toward one and watch the maximum distance diverge.

At half escape speed, the probe reaches a third of an Earth radius above the surface. At ninety percent, over four Earth radii. At ninety-nine percent, about fifty Earth radii — most of the way to the Moon. The last one percent of speed buys more height than everything before it.

That divergence is the potential well flattening out. Far from the planet gravity is so weak that a small amount of leftover kinetic energy carries the probe an enormous distance.

At exactly one the formula divides by zero, which is the mathematics telling you the probe never stops. Beyond one it gives a negative distance — no turning point exists, and the probe escapes.

Contrast this with the constant-g formula, which would give a finite height for any launch speed. That is the clearest possible demonstration of why the universal potential energy is needed.

54. Why the Moon has no atmosphere

Real world

The Moon's escape speed is only 2.38 km/s. Earth's is 11.2 km/s.

Discussion prompt

Gas molecules move at a range of speeds set by temperature — at the Moon's daytime temperature of about 400 K, nitrogen molecules average about 0.6 km/s. That is well below 2.38 km/s, yet the Moon has lost any atmosphere it once had. Explain how, and why the Earth kept its nitrogen but lost its hydrogen.

This is a good example of a physics answer that needs one more idea than the obvious one.

The obvious comparison fails. Nitrogen molecules at the Moon's daytime temperature average about zero point six kilometres per second, well below the Moon's escape speed. So why did it lose them?

The missing idea is that molecular speeds have a distribution. The average is modest, but at any instant a small fraction of molecules are moving several times faster. Those at the top of the atmosphere, heading outward, escape. Collisions keep regenerating the fast tail, so the leak continues for as long as there is gas.

Over billions of years, even a slow leak empties an atmosphere. The rule of thumb from planetary science — lose a gas if its typical speed exceeds about one sixth of escape speed — captures that. Apply it and the Moon loses nitrogen, while the Earth keeps it comfortably.

Hydrogen and helium are light enough to move fast even on Earth, especially in the hot upper atmosphere, and the Earth has lost almost all its free hydrogen and helium for exactly this reason.

55. How small would the Sun have to be to trap light?

Estimation

Predict first

If the Sun (GM = 1.33 x 10^20 m^3/s^2) were squeezed until its escape speed equalled the speed of light, 3.0 x 10^8 m/s, roughly what would its radius be? (Today it is 7 x 10^8 m.)

  • About 3 metres
  • About 3 kilometres
  • About 3000 kilometres
  • About the size of the Earth

Correct: About 3 kilometres

Why: Set sqrt(2GM/R) = c and solve: R = 2GM/c^2 = 2(1.33e20)/(9.0e16) = 2950 m, about 3 km. The whole mass of the Sun would have to fit inside a sphere the size of a small town. This Newtonian estimate happens to give exactly the Schwarzschild radius of general relativity.

The coincidence is genuine, and lucky: the Newtonian argument is not valid for light, yet the factor of 2 comes out right. The idea of a "dark star" whose escape speed exceeds c was proposed this way by John Michell in 1783.

This is an estimation question: set up the escape condition, plug in light speed, and see what radius comes out.

R equals 2GM over c squared. For the Sun that is about three kilometres. The entire mass of the Sun would have to fit inside a sphere the size of a small town before light could not escape it.

The Newtonian argument is not really valid for light, which does not slow down as it climbs the way a ball does. General relativity is needed to describe black holes properly.

But the answer happens to be exactly right. The Schwarzschild radius of general relativity is also 2GM over c squared, factor of two and all. John Michell reached this idea of a dark star in 1783, using exactly the calculation on this slide, more than a century before Einstein.

56. Elliptical Orbits and Kepler's Second Law

Section

Section 7

57. Angular momentum about the Sun is conserved

Concept

Gravity on a planet points straight at the Sun. A force along the line to the pivot has no lever arm, so it exerts no torque about the Sun.

\[ \vec{\tau} = \vec{r}\times\vec{F} = 0 \quad \text{since } \vec{F} \parallel \vec{r} \qquad \Rightarrow \qquad \vec{L} = \text{constant} \]

Any force pointing at a fixed centre — a central force — conserves angular momentum about that centre. It does not matter that the force changes in size around the orbit; only its direction matters.

Figure (svg): An elliptical orbit with the Sun at one focus. At the near point, the closest approach, the velocity arrow is long; at the far point it is short. The distances from the Sun to each point are marked.

Close in the planet moves fast; far out it moves slowly — in exactly inverse proportion to distance.

At the two ends of the long axis — closest approach and farthest point — the velocity is perpendicular to r, so L = m r v exactly. Conservation then gives the key working relation:

\[ m r_p v_p = m r_a v_a \qquad \Rightarrow \qquad \frac{v_p}{v_a} = \frac{r_a}{r_p} \]

This slide brings in the second conservation law you need for orbits, and it comes almost for free.

Gravity on a planet points straight at the Sun. Torque is r cross F, and when F lies along r the cross product is zero. So gravity exerts no torque about the Sun, and the planet's angular momentum about the Sun stays constant.

This works for any force aimed at a fixed point — a central force. It does not matter that gravity is stronger at perihelion than at aphelion; only its direction matters for the torque.

At the two ends of the long axis, the velocity is perpendicular to the radius, so angular momentum is simply m r v. Conservation then says r times v is the same at both ends. Close to the Sun the planet moves fast; far from it, slowly, in exact inverse proportion to the distance.

The figure exaggerates the shape to make the effect visible. The Earth's orbit is so nearly circular that its speed varies by only about three percent, but comets on long ellipses change speed by factors of hundreds.

58. Kepler's second law: equal areas in equal times

Picture it

Figure (svg): An elliptical orbit with the Sun at a focus. A short, wide shaded wedge near the Sun and a long, thin shaded wedge far from the Sun have equal areas, each swept out in the same time.

The line from the Sun to the planet sweeps equal areas in equal times.

In a short time dt, the planet moves through angle d-theta and the Sun-planet line sweeps a thin triangle.

Why: Its area is half the base r times the height r d-theta.

\[ dA = \tfrac{1}{2}r^2\,d\theta \;\Rightarrow\; \frac{dA}{dt} = \tfrac{1}{2}r^2\omega = \frac{L}{2m} \]

Since L is constant, the rate of sweeping area is constant. Kepler's second law is conservation of angular momentum — the same law, discovered from Tycho Brahe's data seventy years before anyone knew why it held.

Kepler stated this law in 1609 purely from Tycho Brahe's observations of Mars. Here is why it is true.

In a short time dt, the line from the Sun to the planet sweeps out a thin triangle. Its area is a half times r times r d-theta. Divide by dt and the rate is a half r squared omega. And r squared omega is exactly angular momentum divided by mass.

So the rate of sweeping area equals L over 2m. Since L is conserved, the rate is constant. Equal areas in equal times is conservation of angular momentum, stated geometrically.

The figure shows what that looks like. Near the Sun, the planet moves fast and the wedge is short and wide. Far from the Sun, it moves slowly and the wedge is long and thin. The areas match.

It is worth appreciating the history. Kepler had the law seventy years before Newton explained it, and nearly three centuries before anyone thought of it as a conservation law. Conservation laws are often discovered as patterns long before they are understood.

59. Elliptical orbits: two conservation laws, two unknowns

Concept

An elliptical orbit has two speeds of interest — at the near and far points — and you have two conservation laws to find them.

\[ \text{angular momentum:} \quad r_p v_p = r_a v_a \]

\[ \text{energy:} \quad \tfrac{1}{2}v_p^2 - \frac{GM}{r_p} = \tfrac{1}{2}v_a^2 - \frac{GM}{r_a} \]

Solve them together and the total energy turns out to depend only on the length of the orbit, not its shape:

\[ E = -\frac{GMm}{2a} \qquad a = \frac{r_p + r_a}{2} \;\text{ (the semi-major axis)} \]

That is the circular-orbit formula with r replaced by a. A circle is the ellipse with r_p = r_a = a, so the two results agree. Kepler's third law extends the same way: T^2 = (4 pi^2 / GM) a^3 for any ellipse.

Here is the general strategy for elliptical orbits, and it is the same strategy as for elastic collisions: two unknowns, two conservation laws.

Angular momentum gives a simple ratio between the speeds at the two ends. Energy gives a second, quadratic equation linking the same two speeds to the two distances. Together they pin both speeds down.

Solving them in general reveals something elegant. The total energy depends only on the semi-major axis, a, half the length of the ellipse — not on how elongated it is. E equals minus GMm over 2a, which is the circular-orbit formula with r replaced by a.

Kepler's third law extends in the same way. For any ellipse, T squared is four pi squared over GM times a cubed. Two orbits with the same long axis have the same period and the same energy, however different their shapes.

60. Perigee and apogee speeds of a transfer orbit

Worked example

A satellite moves on an ellipse with perigee (closest point) at r_p = 6.77 x 10^6 m and apogee at r_a = 4.21 x 10^7 m. Find its speed at each.

Use angular momentum to express v_a in terms of v_p.

Why: At both points the velocity is perpendicular to r, so L = m r v.

\[ v_a = v_p\frac{r_p}{r_a} \]

Substitute into the energy equation and solve for v_p.

Why: After collecting terms, the result is a single compact formula.

\[ v_p = \sqrt{\frac{2GM\,r_a}{r_p(r_p + r_a)}} = \sqrt{\frac{2(3.98\times 10^{14})(4.21\times 10^{7})}{(6.77\times 10^{6})(4.89\times 10^{7})}} = 1.01\times 10^{4}\,\text{m/s} \]

Then v_a from angular momentum.

Why: The ratio of distances is about 6.2, so the far speed is 6.2 times smaller.

\[ v_a = (1.01\times 10^{4})\frac{6.77}{42.1} = 1.62\times 10^{3}\,\text{m/s} \]

Check with E = -GMm/2a.

Why: Per kilogram: -GM/(r_p + r_a) = -3.98e14 / 4.89e7 = -8.14e6 J/kg. At perigee: half of (1.01e4)^2 minus GM/r_p = 5.07e7 - 5.88e7 = -8.1e6 J/kg. They agree.

Compare with the circular orbits at each end: 7.67 km/s at the inner radius and 3.07 km/s at the outer. The ellipse is faster than the inner circle at perigee and slower than the outer circle at apogee — that mismatch is what the next section exploits.

This is the standard elliptical-orbit problem. The method is the one from the previous slide; the arithmetic is the part to take slowly.

Angular momentum gives v a in terms of v p, a simple ratio of distances. Substitute that into the energy equation, and after collecting terms you get a single formula for v p. It comes out at about ten point one kilometres per second.

Then v a follows from the ratio: the far point is about six point two times further out, so the speed there is about six point two times smaller, one point six two kilometres per second.

Always finish with the check through E equals minus GMm over 2a. It uses a completely different route to the same total energy, so agreement is strong evidence that both speeds are right.

The last paragraph sets up the next section. This ellipse is faster than the inner circle at its near point, and slower than the outer circle at its far point. To join the two circles via this ellipse, you would need a speed change at each end — and that is exactly how spacecraft change orbits.

61. r v is the same at every point of the orbit

Trap

The trap

Angular momentum is conserved and L = m r v, so r times v must be the same all the way round the ellipse.

The fix

L = m r v only where the velocity is perpendicular to r — at perigee and apogee. Everywhere else you need the angle.

Figure (svg): A point on an ellipse partway between the near and far points, with the radius vector from the Sun and the velocity tangent to the orbit making an angle that is not 90 degrees.

Away from the ends of the major axis, the velocity is not perpendicular to the radius.

\[ L = m r v\sin\phi \]

Here phi is the angle between r and v. It equals 90 degrees only at the two extreme points; between them the orbit cuts across the radial direction at a slant, and r v by itself overstates L.

This is why problems almost always ask about perigee and apogee. If one asks about some other point, use r v sin phi — or, often easier, use energy, which needs no angle at all.

This trap catches people who learn r p v p equals r a v a as a formula without remembering where it came from.

Angular momentum is m r v sine phi, where phi is the angle between the radius and the velocity. At perigee and apogee the velocity is exactly perpendicular to the radius, so sine phi is one and the formula reduces to m r v.

Everywhere else on an ellipse, the orbit crosses the radial direction at a slant. The figure shows such a point: the velocity is visibly not perpendicular to the radius. There, r times v overstates the angular momentum, and using r v alone gives wrong speeds.

The practical advice is on the slide. If a question asks about a point that is not perigee or apogee, either include the sine of the angle or, usually more easily, use energy, which depends only on the distance and needs no angle at all.

62. Match each tool to the question it answers

Matching

Match the pairs

  • a. the speed at apogee, given the speed at perigee and both distances
  • b. the speed at any distance r, given the total energy
  • c. the period of an orbit of known size
  • d. the gravitational acceleration at the orbit
  • e. whether a body will ever come back
  • 1. angular momentum: r_p v_p = r_a v_a
  • 2. energy: half v^2 - GM/r = E/m
  • 3. Kepler's third law
  • 4. Newton's law of gravitation, GM/r^2
  • 5. the sign of the total energy

Why: Angular momentum links speeds at the two ends of the major axis with a simple ratio. Energy gives the speed at any radius once the total is known, with no angle needed. Kepler's third law gives the period from the size. The law of gravitation gives the force and acceleration at a point. And the sign of the total energy alone decides whether the orbit closes.

Most orbit problems use two of these. Perigee-apogee problems use the first two together; the third and fourth handle circles; the fifth answers yes-or-no questions about escape before any calculation.

This matching exercise is really about recognising which conservation law a question is reaching for.

Speeds at the two ends of an ellipse, with both distances known: angular momentum, as a simple ratio. Speed at an arbitrary distance with the energy known: the energy equation, which needs no angle. Period from size: Kepler's third law. Acceleration at a point: the law of gravitation itself.

The fifth match is the quickest win in the whole deck. Whether a body ever comes back is decided by the sign of its total energy, and you can often answer that question without finding a single speed.

In practice most problems need two of these at once. The perigee-apogee problem uses angular momentum and energy together. Circular orbit problems use the law of gravitation and the centripetal condition. Seeing which pair a problem needs is most of the work.

63. A comet's speed at aphelion

Check

A comet passes perihelion at 0.50 AU from the Sun moving at 50 km/s. Its aphelion is at 10 AU.

Check your understanding

What is its speed at aphelion?

  • A. 1000 km/s
  • B. 11 km/s
  • C. 2.5 km/s (correct)
  • D. 0.125 km/s

Answer: C

Why: Angular momentum is conserved and the velocity is perpendicular to r at both ends, so r_p v_p = r_a v_a. Then v_a = 50 (0.50 / 10) = 2.5 km/s. The comet is 20 times further away and moves 20 times more slowly.

Why A tempts people
This multiplies by the distance ratio instead of dividing. A body far from the Sun moves SLOWER, not faster.
Why B tempts people
This divides by the square root of 20, as though speed went as one over root r — that is true for comparing CIRCULAR orbits of different sizes, not for two points on the same ellipse.
Why D tempts people
This divides by 20 squared. Angular momentum gives a simple inverse proportion between speed and distance at the two ends, not an inverse square.

64. Changing Orbits

Section

Section 8

65. The Hohmann transfer

Concept

To move from a low circular orbit to a high one, the most fuel-efficient route between two coplanar circles uses two short engine burns and a half-ellipse between them.

Figure (svg): Two concentric circular orbits around a planet. A half-ellipse runs from the inner circle on the right to the outer circle on the left, with a forward burn marked at each end.

A Hohmann transfer: speed up onto an ellipse, coast half an orbit, speed up again to circularise.
  1. Burn 1, at the inner orbit: speed up. The extra speed is more than the inner circle needs, so the craft rises onto an ellipse whose perigee is the inner orbit.
  2. Coast for half an orbit. The craft climbs, slowing as gravity takes back kinetic energy — exactly as angular momentum requires.
  3. Burn 2, at apogee: speed up again. At apogee the craft is moving too slowly for the outer circle, so a second forward burn circularises it there.

Both burns are forward. Yet the craft ends in a higher orbit moving more slowly than where it began — the energy ladder at work.

Walter Hohmann worked this out in 1925, decades before any spacecraft existed, and it is still how many missions change orbit.

The idea is to use an ellipse that just touches both circles. Its near point lies on the inner circle; its far point lies on the outer circle. The spacecraft only has to switch from circle to ellipse at one end, and from ellipse to circle at the other.

At the inner circle, the ellipse is faster than the circle, so the first burn speeds the craft up. It then coasts for half an orbit, climbing and slowing as gravity takes back its kinetic energy.

At the outer circle, the ellipse is slower than the circle, so the second burn speeds the craft up again. Both burns point forward.

And yet the craft ends up in the higher orbit moving more slowly than it started. Every one of the energy-ladder ideas is at work in this one manoeuvre.

66. The two burns of a Hohmann transfer

Worked example

Find the two speed changes needed to move from the space station's orbit (7.67 km/s) to geostationary orbit (3.07 km/s), using the transfer ellipse from the previous worked example, and the time the transfer takes.

Burn 1: from the inner circle to the ellipse's perigee speed.

Why: The ellipse's perigee speed was 10.1 km/s.

\[ \Delta v_1 = 10.07 - 7.67 = 2.40\,\text{km/s} \]

Burn 2: from the ellipse's apogee speed to the outer circle.

Why: The ellipse arrives at apogee at 1.62 km/s; the geostationary circle needs 3.07 km/s.

\[ \Delta v_2 = 3.07 - 1.62 = 1.46\,\text{km/s} \]

Total.

Why: This is the propellant budget, through the rocket equation.

\[ \Delta v_{\text{total}} = 3.86\,\text{km/s} \]

Transfer time: half the period of the ellipse.

Why: Kepler's third law with the semi-major axis a = (r_p + r_a)/2 = 2.45 x 10^7 m.

\[ \tfrac{1}{2}T = \pi\sqrt{\frac{a^3}{GM}} = \pi\sqrt{\frac{(2.45\times 10^{7})^3}{3.98\times 10^{14}}} = 1.90\times 10^{4}\,\text{s} \approx 5.3\,\text{h} \]

The craft added 3.86 km/s of speed in two burns and ended up 4.6 km/s slower than it started. Nothing is lost: the speed went into climbing the potential well.

This uses the ellipse you already solved, so all the hard work is done.

The first burn takes the craft from the station's seven point six seven kilometres per second to the ellipse's perigee speed of ten point zero seven: a change of two point four. The second burn takes it from the ellipse's apogee speed of one point six two to the geostationary circle's three point zero seven: a change of one point four six.

The total, three point eight six kilometres per second, is what mission planners call the delta-v budget. Through the rocket equation from the momentum deck, it decides how much propellant the craft must carry.

The transfer time is half the period of the ellipse, using Kepler's third law with the semi-major axis. About five and a quarter hours.

And the final line is the punchline. Two forward burns adding almost four kilometres per second, and the craft ends up four point six kilometres per second slower than where it started. The speed was not lost; it was converted into height.

67. To catch a spacecraft ahead of you, should you speed up?

Socratic

Discussion prompt

You are in a circular orbit, and a space station is in the same orbit 100 km ahead of you. Your instinct is to fire your engine forward to catch up. What actually happens if you do, and what should you do instead?

Think this through with the energy ladder before reading the answer, because it is exactly the kind of question where intuition and physics disagree.

Firing forward adds energy and puts you on a larger orbit. Larger orbits have longer periods. So although you are briefly faster, each lap now takes longer, and you drift further and further behind the station you were chasing.

The right move is the opposite. Fire backward, drop onto a smaller orbit with a shorter period, and gain on the station each lap. When you have caught up, fire forward to raise your orbit back to the original circle, arriving beside the target.

The general rule is worth carrying away. A burn changes the orbit half a revolution later, on the far side. A forward burn raises the far side; a backward burn lowers it. Thinking about where the burn will take you half an orbit from now is the habit that makes orbital manoeuvres make sense.

68. Why do both burns speed you up, yet you end slower?

Explain it to yourself

Discussion prompt

In the Hohmann transfer both engine burns increase the craft's speed, yet its final speed is lower than its initial speed. Explain where the speed went, using both conservation laws.

Write your own explanation first. This is a good test of whether the two conservation laws feel like tools yet, or still like formulas.

During the coast between the burns, nothing does any work except gravity, so the total energy is constant. As the craft climbs, potential energy rises, and kinetic energy must fall to compensate. It loses about eight and a half kilometres per second of speed on the climb.

Angular momentum tells you exactly how much. With r v constant at the two ends, climbing by a factor of six point two forces a drop in speed by the same factor.

The total energy did increase, because each burn added energy. But for a circular orbit kinetic energy is minus the total energy, so the higher, more energetic orbit is the slower one.

So the burns paid for the climb, and gravity converted more than all of the added kinetic energy into potential energy along the way. Nothing paradoxical remains once you track where every joule went.

69. Putting It Together

Section

Section 9

70. Near-surface gravity versus universal gravity

Comparison

Comparison matrix

quantitynear the surfaceanywhere
forcemg, constantGMm / r^2
acceleration9.8 m/s^2 downwardGM / r^2 toward the centre
potential energymgh-GMm / r
zero of potential energywherever you choose, often the groundinfinity
energy to escapeinfinite (the model breaks)GMm / R
shape of a free-fall patha parabolaa conic: ellipse, parabola or hyperbola

The left column is the tangent-line approximation to the right column. It is excellent within a few kilometres of the surface and fails without warning beyond that.

The last row has a pleasing twist: the near-surface parabola of projectile motion is really a tiny arc of a very elongated ellipse with the Earth's centre at its focus. Over a few hundred metres the two are indistinguishable.

Fill in the blanks before revealing them; each one tests whether you can state the near-surface version and the universal version side by side.

Read the left column as the approximation and the right column as the truth. The near-surface version is what you get from the universal one by assuming the height is tiny compared with the planet's radius. It is excellent for a ball in a park and useless for a satellite.

The energy-to-escape row is where the approximation fails outright. With constant g, escape costs infinite energy; with the real law, it costs GMm over R, a finite number.

The last row is a lovely piece of unification. The parabola of projectile motion is really a tiny piece of an extremely elongated ellipse with the centre of the Earth at its far focus. Over a few hundred metres you cannot tell the difference. The kinematics deck and this deck were describing the same motion all along.

71. Choosing the orbit tool

Pattern

  1. Circular orbit? Set GMm/r^2 = mv^2/r. Speed, period and Kepler's third law follow.
  2. Two points on an ellipse, at the ends of the long axis? Angular momentum (r_p v_p = r_a v_a) plus energy.
  3. Speed at one radius from speed at another, no angle given? Energy alone, with U = -GMm/r.
  4. Will it come back? Compute E. Negative is bound; zero or positive escapes.
  5. Inside a planet? Only the enclosed mass counts; for a uniform sphere g grows linearly with r.
  6. Changing orbits? A forward burn raises the far side of the orbit; a backward burn lowers it.

Point three is the most under-used. Energy needs no direction and no angle, so it often answers a question in one line that angular momentum would need a diagram for.

This is the decision list to run through at the start of any gravitation problem.

Circular orbit: set gravity equal to the centripetal requirement and everything follows — speed, period, Kepler's third law, and orbital energy.

Ellipse with perigee and apogee: angular momentum plus energy, solved together.

Speed at one distance from speed at another, with no angle given: energy alone. This is the most under-used tool in the list. Because energy needs no direction, it often gives a one-line answer where a force or angular-momentum approach would need a diagram.

Will it come back: just compute the sign of the total energy. Inside a planet: only the enclosed mass counts. Changing orbit: a forward burn raises the far side, a backward burn lowers it.

72. Four questions before you close the deck

Exit ticket

Discussion prompt

From memory: (1) Why do astronauts in the space station float? (2) What is g at the centre of a uniform planet, and why? (3) A satellite in a circular orbit loses energy to drag. Does it speed up or slow down? (4) Escape speed from a radius r is how many times the circular orbit speed there?

Answer all four from memory before looking. Each targets a misconception rather than a calculation.

The first is about free fall. The astronauts are not without gravity; they are without support. Gravity at the station is nearly full strength.

The second is about the shell theorem. At the centre of a uniform planet, all the mass is outside you, and outer shells pull with zero net force. g is zero there.

The third is the drag paradox. Losing energy shrinks the orbit, and smaller orbits are faster. K equals minus E settles it in one line.

The fourth is the escape relation. Root two times the circular speed at the same radius. If any of the four made you hesitate, the slide that answers it is the one to revisit.

73. What you can do now

Recap

the ideathe one-line version
F = GMm / r^2always attractive, centre to centre, inverse square
g(r) = GM / r^2 outside, (GM/R^3) r insidelargest at the surface, zero at the centre
U = -GMm / rzero at infinity, negative everywhere else
v = sqrt(GM/r), T^2 = (4 pi^2 / GM) r^3higher orbits are slower and longer
E = -GMm / 2rK = -E, U = 2E: adding energy slows you down
v_esc = sqrt(2GM/R) = sqrt(2) v_circE = 0 is the threshold of escape
r_p v_p = r_a v_aangular momentum: central forces exert no torque

That completes the course. Every idea in it was one of two things: Newton's second law, or a conservation law obtained by integrating it. Gravitation used them all at once — force for the orbit condition, energy for escape, angular momentum for ellipses — which is why it makes a good place to finish.

This deck replaced the one approximation that every earlier deck relied on — constant gravity — with the real law, and followed that law from falling apples to escaping rockets.

Very little of it was new machinery. The orbit condition was the second law with a centripetal acceleration. Escape and orbital energy were energy conservation with a new potential energy. Elliptical orbits and Kepler's second law were angular momentum conservation for a central force.

The ideas with the longest reach are the energy relations for circular orbits. K equals minus E and U equals 2E explain why higher orbits are slower, why drag speeds satellites up, and why two forward burns can leave a spacecraft moving more slowly.

And that is the whole course. Forces, energy, momentum, rotation, oscillation and gravitation all come back to Newton's second law and the conservation laws you get by integrating it. Gravitation is a good place to finish because it uses every one of those tools at once.

Sources

  1. AP Physics C: Mechanics Course and Exam Description (gravitation, orbits, and angular momentum of orbiting bodies) — College Board, 2024
  2. AP Physics C Table of Information and Equation Tables (universal gravitation, gravitational potential energy) — College Board, 2024

Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors AP Physics C: Mechanics — $55/session, free consultation.

Book on Wyzant · Text (657) 465-8108