11.8a Vectors: Components, Addition, and Scalar Multiplication

Quantities carrying both a magnitude and a direction, and the algebra they obey. Defines a vector as a directed segment, establishes that position is irrelevant, and records it as a pair of components by subtracting the tail from the head. Adds vectors tip to tail and componentwise, showing the two agree, applies the resultant to a navigation problem via the Law of Cosines, and closes with the properties of vector addition and of scalar multiplication.

Subject: Trigonometry · 66 slides · symbolic lesson

Open the interactive version of this deck

What this lesson covers

The lesson, slide by slide

1. Vectors: Components, Addition, and Scalar Multiplication

Title

Trigonometry · Section 11.8

Quantities that need a direction, and the algebra they obey

2. What this lesson gives you

Objectives

Everything measured so far in this chapter has been a single number with a unit attached. This lesson builds the object you need when the number alone is not enough, and gives it an arithmetic.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, pp. 1012-1020 — the pages this lesson covers

Every quantity you have measured so far in this course has been a single number: a length, an angle, a speed. Attach the right unit and the number says everything there is to say. This lesson is about the quantities where that is not true, the ones that also need a direction before they mean anything.

The object that carries both is a vector, and the first job is to pin down exactly what makes two vectors equal, because the answer is stranger than you expect: where the arrow sits on the page is not part of the answer. Once that is settled, a vector becomes a pair of numbers, and everything after that is arithmetic you already know done twice, once in each slot.

The payoff comes in the middle of the lesson. A plane flies one way and the wind pushes it another, and the question of where the plane actually goes turns into a triangle you can solve with the Law of Cosines from Section 11.3. Keep that example in view: it is the reason the algebra is worth building.

3. Before anything new: bearings and the Law of Cosines

Warm-up

Discussion prompt

Two things from earlier in this chapter are about to do all the heavy lifting. Without looking back: what does a bearing of N40E mean, and which triangle problem does the Law of Cosines solve that the Law of Sines cannot start?

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.3, pp. 910-911 — Theorem 11.5, and bearings from p. 905

Both tools come back hard in this lesson, so it is worth checking that they are still sharp before you need them. A bearing is always read as a rotation away from north or from south, never from east or west, and the number is how far you swing toward the east or the west named at the end.

The Law of Cosines is the one that handles a triangle when you know two sides and the angle caught between them. That is exactly the shape a wind problem makes, which is why it, and not the Pythagorean Theorem, is the tool of choice here.

If either answer came slowly, glance back at Section 11.3 before going on. Nothing in this lesson replaces them; the vectors sit on top of them.

4. What a vector is

Section

Part 1

5. A number is not always enough

Intuition

A plane's instruments read 175 miles per hour. That number is true, and it is not the speed the plane makes over the ground, because the air the plane is flying through is itself moving.

Ask what the number is missing and the answer is immediate: it never says which way. Once a second moving thing enters the picture, which way decides everything, since a tail wind and a head wind of the same strength do opposite things to the same plane.

So the quantity actually needed is a speed together with a direction. That pairing is called velocity, and the general object that carries a size together with a direction is called a vector.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1012 — the opening paragraph

Start with the question that forces the new object into existence. A plane's instruments read 175 miles per hour, and that number is true, but it is the speed through the air, not the speed over the ground. Air that is itself moving changes where the plane ends up.

Notice what the number is missing. It does not say which way. Once a second moving thing is in the picture, which way becomes the deciding factor: a tail wind and a head wind of the same strength do opposite things to the same plane.

So the quantity you actually need is a speed together with a direction, and that pairing has a name, velocity. A vector is the general version of that pairing: a size and a direction, held together as one object.

6. A vector is an arrow with a name

Concept

vector — A quantity with both a magnitude and a direction, drawn as a directed line segment: the length of the segment is the magnitude and the arrowhead gives the direction.

\[ \vec{v} = \overrightarrow{PQ}, \qquad P = \text{initial point (tail)}, \quad Q = \text{terminal point (head)} \]

Figure (svg): A coordinate grid with an arrow drawn from the point P at one comma two to the point Q at four comma six, with dashed legs along the grid showing three units across and then four units up.

The two dashed legs are the components: three across and four up. Subtracting the tail's coordinates from the head's reads them straight off the picture.

The order of the two letters is part of the name. Writing the tail first and the head second is the only thing on the page that says which way the arrow points, so the vector from P to Q is not the vector from Q to P.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1012 — the arrow notation

The picture is deliberately simple. Draw a segment, put an arrowhead on one end, and you have a vector: the length of the segment is the magnitude and the arrowhead fixes the direction. Stitz and Zeager write a small arrow over the letter, so the symbol is read as the vector v rather than the number v.

The two endpoints have names worth learning now, because the order of the letters carries meaning. The initial point is the tail, where the arrow starts; the terminal point is the head, where it ends. Writing the tail's letter first and the head's second is what tells you which way the arrow points.

Look at the figure and ask yourself the question in the text: if you were given only the two points P and Q, could you rebuild the arrow exactly? You could, which is why the two letters together are a perfectly good name for it.

7. Where you draw it does not matter

Concept

A vector is defined by two things and stops there: how long it is and which way it points. Position is not on the list, so two arrows that agree on those two things are the same vector however far apart they are drawn.

Figure (svg): Three separate arrows drawn in different parts of one coordinate plane. Every arrow is the same length and points the same way, up and to the right, because each one goes three units across and four units up from a different starting point.

Three drawings, one vector. Each arrow carries the same instruction, three across and four up, so the definition counts them as equal even though no two share an endpoint.

Every arrow in the picture carries the same instruction: go three units across and four units up. That shared instruction is the vector. Think of it as a recipe for moving rather than a place on the map.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, pp. 1012-1013 — the discussion after the first figure

This is the idea that makes vectors useful, and it is also the one students fight hardest. A vector is defined by two things only, how long and which way. Position is not on the list. So an arrow drawn in the corner of the page and an arrow drawn in the middle are the same vector, provided they agree on length and direction.

The figure shows three arrows that are all the same vector. Each one starts somewhere different and each one ends somewhere different, but every one of them goes three units to the right and four units up. That shared instruction is the vector; the three drawings are just three places it happened to be performed.

Think of a vector as a recipe for moving rather than a place on the map. Walk three east and four north, and it does not matter which street corner you started from: you performed the same displacement. That is precisely the abstraction the definition is making.

8. Reading Definition 11.5 piece by piece

Notation

Annotate

On: \( \vec{v} = \overrightarrow{PQ} = \langle x_1 - x_0,\; y_1 - y_0\rangle \)

  • Always in that order. Subtracting the other way round gives the arrow pointing back from Q to P, which is a different vector.
  • Round brackets hold a POINT, a location. Angle brackets hold a VECTOR, a displacement. The same two numbers in the two brackets mean different things.
  • The x-component: how far across the arrow travels. Positive is to the right, negative to the left.
  • Two vectors are equal exactly when the first components match and the second components match. A question about arrows has become a question about pairs of numbers.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1013 — Definition 11.5

Work through the annotations one at a time, because each one is a place people slip. The subtraction is head minus tail, always in that order, and the order is the only thing that distinguishes the arrow from the one pointing back the other way.

Watch the brackets. Round brackets hold a point, which is a location; angle brackets hold a vector, which is a displacement. The same two numbers written in the two kinds of bracket say completely different things, and the notation is the only clue on the page telling you which one is meant.

The last annotation is the one that turns geometry into algebra. Two vectors are equal exactly when their first components match and their second components match. A question about arrows on a page has just become a question about pairs of numbers, and pairs of numbers are something you can compute with.

9. Example: the vector from P(1, 2) to Q(4, 6)

Worked example

The arrow the book opens the section with.

\[ \vec{v} = \overrightarrow{PQ}, \qquad P(1, 2), \qquad Q(4, 6) \]

Name the tail and the head

Why: P is written first, so P is the initial point.

\[ \text{tail } (x_0, y_0) = (1, 2), \qquad \text{head } (x_1, y_1) = (4, 6) \]

Subtract the x-coordinates, head minus tail

Why: This is how far across the arrow travels.

\[ x_1 - x_0 = 4 - 1 = 3 \]

Subtract the y-coordinates the same way

Why: This is how far up it travels.

\[ y_1 - y_0 = 6 - 2 = 4 \]

Write the pair in angle brackets

Why: Angle brackets mark it as a vector rather than a point.

\[ \vec{v} = \langle 3, 4 \rangle \]

Check by walking the arrow

Why: Start at the tail, go three across and four up, and you should land exactly on the head. You do, so the subtraction went the right way round.

\[ (1 + 3,\; 2 + 4) = (4, 6) = Q \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1012 — the opening figure

This is the arrow the book opens the section with, so it is worth getting completely straight. The work is two subtractions, both in the same direction: coordinate of the head minus coordinate of the tail.

The three and the four are not random labels. Three is how far right you travel and four is how far up, which is exactly what the dashed legs in the figure measure. If you have ever computed a slope, you have done this before: the footnote in the book points out that the slope of this segment is four over three, the second component over the first.

The check step is the habit to build. Take the tail, add the components, and see whether you land on the head. If you do, the subtraction went the right way round. It takes five seconds and it catches the single most common error in this section.

10. Example: the same vector, drawn from a new tail

Worked example

Run the definition backwards: the components are given and so is a new place to start.

\[ \vec{v} = \langle 3, 4\rangle \text{ redrawn with initial point } P'(-2, 3) \]

Read the components as instructions

Why: Three to the right and four up, from wherever you happen to start.

\[ \text{over } 3, \qquad \text{up } 4 \]

Add the first component to the starting x-coordinate

Why: Moving right increases x.

\[ -2 + 3 = 1 \]

Add the second component to the starting y-coordinate

Why: Moving up increases y.

\[ 3 + 4 = 7 \]

Name the new head

Why: That is where the arrow finishes.

\[ Q'(1, 7) \]

Figure (svg): A coordinate grid with an arrow from the point negative two comma three to the point one comma seven, with a dashed horizontal leg of three units and a dashed vertical leg of four units marked beside it.

The same pair of numbers, performed from a different starting point. Head minus tail gives three and four again, so this arrow is the very same vector.

Check with Definition 11.5

Why: Subtract the new tail from the new head. The same pair comes back, so this really is the same vector, drawn somewhere else.

\[ \langle 1 - (-2),\; 7 - 3\rangle = \langle 3, 4\rangle \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1013 — the second figure

Now run the definition backwards. You are handed the recipe, three across and four up, and a new place to start, and you have to find where you finish. Add the first component to the starting x-coordinate and the second to the starting y-coordinate.

The result is a second arrow in a completely different part of the plane, and the whole point is that it is not a second vector. Subtract the new tail from the new head and the same pair of numbers comes back, so by Definition 11.5 it is the same vector as before.

This is why the component form is so convenient. It names the vector without naming any particular drawing of it, which means one pair of numbers stands in for infinitely many arrows at once.

11. Fill in the component form

Fill the middle

Find the component form of the vector whose tail is at the point five comma negative one and whose head is at the point two comma four.

Fill in the blanks

\langle 2 - 5,\; 4 - (-1)\rangle = \langle -3,\; 5\rangle

Why: Head minus tail in both slots. Two minus five is negative three, which is negative because the motion is to the left; four minus negative one is five, positive because the motion is upward.

Work it out on paper before typing. The tail is the first point named and the head is the second, so the subtraction runs from the second point's coordinates to the first point's.

Both signs matter here and both are meant to catch you. The motion is to the left, so the first component comes out negative; the motion is upward, so the second comes out positive. A vector with a negative component is perfectly ordinary; it simply points that way.

12. Trap: subtracting the wrong way round

Trap

The trap

For the vector from P(1, 2) to Q(4, 6), a very common first line:

\[ \langle 1 - 4,\; 2 - 6\rangle \]

\[ = \langle -3, -4\rangle \]

Wrong. That is the arrow from Q back to P.

The fix

Head minus tail, every time. The two answers differ only in sign, which is exactly why the error slips through unnoticed.

\[ \overrightarrow{PQ} = \langle 3, 4\rangle \]

\[ \overrightarrow{QP} = -\overrightarrow{PQ} \]

Catch it by adding your components to the tail and checking that you land on the head.

This is the most frequent error in the whole section, and it does not announce itself: you get a perfectly reasonable-looking pair of numbers, just the wrong one. Both components come out with their signs flipped, which means you have drawn the arrow pointing from the head back to the tail.

Two defences. First, say the rule out loud as head minus tail every single time until it is automatic. Second, use the check from the worked example: add your components to the tail and confirm you land on the head. If you land somewhere else, you subtracted backwards.

13. Vector or scalar?

Discrimination

Sort into buckets

Sort each quantity by whether a direction has to be given before the description is complete.

Vector: needs a direction
a velocity of 60 miles per hour due north; a force of 10 newtons straight down; a displacement of 5 miles north-east
Scalar: a number is enough
a speed of 60 miles per hour; a temperature of 20 degrees; a distance of 5 miles
vec
Velocity, force and displacement are all incomplete without a direction: 60 miles per hour north and 60 miles per hour south are different situations.
sca
Speed, temperature and distance are complete on their own. Notice the pairs: speed and velocity, distance and displacement, are the same measurement with and without a direction.

Sort each quantity before revealing. The test is a single question: would the quantity be incompletely described without a direction attached?

Speed, temperature and distance are complete on their own. Sixty miles per hour is a fact about how fast, and nothing is missing. Velocity, force and displacement are not complete on their own: sixty miles per hour due north and sixty miles per hour due south are different situations, and any honest description has to say which.

The pairs are deliberate. Speed and velocity, distance and displacement: each pair is the same measurement with and without a direction. Physics keeps two separate words for each pair for exactly the reason this lesson exists.

14. Predict: same length, same direction, different place

Prediction

Two arrows are drawn in opposite corners of the page. They have the same length and point the same way, and they share no endpoint.

Predict first

Are they the same vector?

  • Yes, always
  • No, their endpoints differ
  • Only if one can be slid onto the other without turning
  • Only if both start at the origin

Correct: Yes, always

Why: The definition names magnitude and direction and stops. Endpoints are not mentioned, so two arrows agreeing on those two things are one and the same vector. The third option sounds cautious but is just a restatement of the first, since sliding without turning is exactly what preserves length and direction.

Commit to an option before revealing, because the wrong answer here is the intuitive one. Every instinct you have from coordinate geometry says two objects with different endpoints are different objects.

For vectors that instinct is wrong, and deliberately so. The definition lists magnitude and direction and stops. Endpoints are not mentioned, so two arrows that agree on those two things are the same vector no matter where they are drawn.

If this still feels uncomfortable, that is a sign you are taking it seriously. Hold on to the displacement picture: the vector is the instruction, not the place where somebody carried it out.

15. Why throw the position away?

Socratic

Discussion prompt

The definition could have kept track of where an arrow sits, and deliberately does not. What is gained by discarding the position, and what is lost?

Write your answer before revealing. The question is a design question: the definition could have kept track of position, and it deliberately does not, so what was bought with that choice?

What is gained is reuse. One vector now describes every occurrence of the same displacement, everywhere in the plane, at once. That is why you can slide a wind arrow over to the tip of a plane arrow without changing what it means, which is the move the whole of the next part depends on.

What is lost is location, and when you need location you supply it separately by naming a starting point. That division of labour, a place plus a displacement, is exactly how the component form works and exactly how you will describe a line near the end of this lesson.

16. Adding vectors

Section

Part 2

17. Tip to tail: the resultant

Concept

Adding two vectors is a story about motion: perform the first displacement, then perform the second starting from wherever the first left you.

Figure (svg): Two arrows drawn tip to tail on a coordinate grid: the first runs from the origin four across and two up, the second continues from its head one to the left and three up. A third arrow runs straight from the origin to the far head.

Move along the first arrow, then along the second. The single arrow from the first tail to the last head does the job of both, and that is the sum.

resultant — The sum of two vectors, understood as the net result of moving along the first and then along the second.

The second arrow has been picked up and moved so its tail sits on the first arrow's head. That is legal only because position is not part of what a vector is.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1013 — the definition of the resultant

Here is the geometric definition of a sum, and it is a story about motion. Perform the first displacement, then perform the second starting from wherever the first one left you. The single arrow from where you began to where you ended is the sum.

Look carefully at the figure: the second arrow has been picked up and moved so that its tail sits on the first arrow's head. You are allowed to do that only because position is not part of what a vector is, which is the payoff from the previous part.

The word for the sum is resultant, and it is worth keeping because of what it suggests. The resultant is the net result: the one displacement that would have done the job of both.

18. Reading Definition 11.6 piece by piece

Notation

Annotate

On: \( \langle v_1, v_2\rangle + \langle w_1, w_2\rangle = \langle v_1 + w_1,\; v_2 + w_2\rangle \)

  • The first components add to give the first component of the sum. Nothing from the second slot takes part.
  • The second components add independently. The two slots never talk to each other.
  • This is chosen, not proved. The book picks it precisely so the arithmetic reproduces the tip-to-tail picture; the next slide shows why it does.
  • Once you accept it, adding vectors is as easy as adding numbers, and you never have to draw anything to get an answer.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1014 — Definition 11.6

The componentwise rule looks almost too easy, and the annotations are there to make sure you notice what it is claiming. First components add to give the first component of the sum; second components add to give the second. The two slots never talk to each other.

The point to take seriously is the third annotation. This rule is a definition, not a theorem. The book chose it, and chose it precisely so that the arithmetic would reproduce the tip to tail picture. The next slide shows why the choice works.

Once you accept the definition, adding vectors is no harder than adding numbers, and you can do it without drawing anything. The picture is what tells you the answer means something; the components are what let you compute it quickly.

19. Why the two additions agree

Intuition

Read each vector as a pair of instructions: go so far across, then so far up. Now perform one pair and then the other.

\[ \text{across: } v_1 \text{ then } w_1, \qquad \text{up: } v_2 \text{ then } w_2 \]

\[ \text{total across } = v_1 + w_1, \qquad \text{total up } = v_2 + w_2 \]

The two kinds of motion never interfere, because travelling sideways does not change how high you are and rising does not change how far across you are. That independence is the whole reason the components may be totalled separately.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1014 — the remark that addition is defined to match the geometry

This is the argument that joins the picture to the formula, and it is short enough to reconstruct from scratch. Read each vector as a pair of instructions: go so far across, then so far up.

Now perform them one after the other. The total distance across is the first across plus the second across, and the total distance up is the first up plus the second up. The two kinds of motion never interfere, because moving sideways does not change how high you are.

That independence is the whole reason componentwise addition works. It is also why the same trick will work for scalar multiplication later, and why it will keep working when you meet vectors in three dimensions.

20. Example 11.8.2: one sum, two ways

Worked example

Example 11.8.2. One vector arrives in component form, the other as a pair of points.

\[ \vec{v} = \langle 3, 4\rangle, \qquad \vec{w} = \overrightarrow{PQ} \text{ with } P(-3, 7), \; Q(-2, 5) \]

Put the second vector into component form first

Why: Definition 11.5 again: head minus tail, watching both negative signs.

\[ \vec{w} = \langle -2 - (-3),\; 5 - 7\rangle = \langle 1, -2\rangle \]

Add the first components

Why: Definition 11.6, first slot.

\[ 3 + 1 = 4 \]

Add the second components

Why: Second slot, independently.

\[ 4 + (-2) = 2 \]

Collect the answer

Why: Two numbers in angle brackets.

\[ \vec{v} + \vec{w} = \langle 4, 2\rangle \]

Figure (svg): A coordinate grid showing an arrow from the origin to three comma four, a second arrow from three comma four going one right and two down to four comma two, and a third arrow from the origin straight to four comma two.

The head of the sum lands at four comma two, exactly the pair the componentwise rule produced. The picture and the arithmetic were built to agree.

Check by walking the picture

Why: Draw the first vector from the origin and its head is at three comma four; from there go one right and two down and you land at four comma two, which is where the computed sum ends.

\[ (0, 0) \;\to\; (3, 4) \;\to\; (4, 2) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, pp. 1014-1015 — Example 11.8.2

The example is built to make you do two different things before you can add. One vector arrives already in component form and the other arrives as a pair of points, so the first move is always to bring them into the same language.

Converting the second vector is Definition 11.5 again: head minus tail, being careful with the two negative signs. Once both are pairs of numbers, the addition itself is two easy sums.

The check is the interesting part. Draw the first vector from the origin and its head lands at the point three comma four. Draw the second from there, one right and two down, and you land at four comma two. That is exactly where the computed sum points, so the picture and the arithmetic agree. They were designed to.

21. Subtraction is addition in disguise

Concept

There is no separate definition to learn. Subtracting a vector means adding its opposite, and the opposite is the same arrow turned round.

\[ \vec{v} - \vec{w} = \vec{v} + (-\vec{w}) = \langle v_1 - w_1,\; v_2 - w_2\rangle \]

Figure (svg): Two arrows from the origin, one to three comma four and one to one comma negative two, completed into a parallelogram with dashed sides. One diagonal runs from the origin to four comma two and the other runs from one comma negative two up to three comma four.

Both diagonals of one parallelogram. The sum runs out from the shared tail; the difference joins the two heads and points toward the vector written first.

The picture takes a moment longer to see. Draw both vectors from a shared tail: the difference is the arrow running from the head of the second to the head of the first, the other diagonal of the parallelogram whose first diagonal is the sum.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1017 — vector subtraction and its diagram

There is no separate definition of subtraction to memorise. Subtracting a vector means adding its opposite, and the opposite of a vector is the arrow of the same length pointing the other way.

Follow that through in components and the algebra collapses to something obvious: negate both components of the second vector and then add. The result is that you subtract matching components, exactly as you would hope.

The picture takes a moment longer to see. Draw both vectors from a common tail. The difference is the arrow that runs from the head of the second to the head of the first, and the book makes this exact point: it is the other diagonal of the parallelogram whose first diagonal is the sum.

22. Example: the difference of the same two vectors

Worked example

The same pair as Example 11.8.2, so the two answers can be compared directly.

\[ \vec{v} = \langle 3, 4\rangle, \qquad \vec{w} = \langle 1, -2\rangle, \qquad \text{find } \vec{v} - \vec{w} \]

Rewrite the difference as a sum

Why: That is the definition of subtraction.

\[ \vec{v} - \vec{w} = \vec{v} + (-\vec{w}) \]

Negate both components of the second vector

Why: The additive inverse negates each slot.

\[ -\vec{w} = \langle -1, 2\rangle \]

Add componentwise

Why: Definition 11.6, one slot at a time.

\[ \langle 3 + (-1),\; 4 + 2\rangle = \langle 2, 6\rangle \]

Check by adding it back

Why: If the difference is right, then moving along the second vector and then along the difference must land where the first vector lands. It does.

\[ \vec{w} + \langle 2, 6\rangle = \langle 1 + 2,\; -2 + 6\rangle = \langle 3, 4\rangle = \vec{v} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1017 — the chain of properties justifying the picture

Reuse the pair from Example 11.8.2 so you can compare the two answers directly. The sum was four comma two; the difference is two comma six. Same two vectors, very different arrows.

The verification step is worth copying as a general habit for subtraction. If the difference is correct, then adding it back to the second vector must return the first one, because that is what the book's chain of properties proves. Two quick sums confirm it.

Look at where the difference sits in the figure. It starts at the head of the vector being subtracted and ends at the head of the other one. If you ever forget the direction, rebuild it from that rule: the arrow points toward the vector you are subtracting from.

23. Find the error: the speeds were added

Error analysis

Annotate

On: \( 175 + 35 = 210 \;\text{ miles per hour} \)

  • Nothing is wrong here. The sum of 175 and 35 really is 210.
  • Adding the two lengths is correct only when the two arrows point the same way, so that the tip-to-tail picture straightens out into a single line.
  • The plane heads N40E and the wind blows toward S60E, 80 degrees apart. The picture is a genuine triangle, and a triangle's third side is shorter than the other two put together.
  • About 184 miles per hour, which is between 140 and 210. Two lengths of 175 and 35 can give any resultant from 140 up to 210, and nothing outside.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1014 — the resultant in Example 11.8.1

Read the reasoning before opening the annotations and see whether you can say precisely which step is unjustified. Nothing is wrong with the arithmetic; the sum of 175 and 35 really is 210.

What is wrong is that the two numbers being added are lengths of arrows that point in different directions. Adding lengths would be correct only if the two arrows pointed exactly the same way, so that the tip to tail picture straightened out into a single line.

The moment they point in different directions the picture becomes a genuine triangle, and the third side of a triangle is always shorter than the other two put together. That is why the true speed comes out at about 184 rather than 210, and it is the geometric content of the triangle inequality.

24. Slide the angle and watch the sum

Tweak it

Parameter explorer

The curve shows how long the sum of two vectors is as the angle between them runs from zero to 180 degrees. Slide the two lengths, and read off where the sum is longest and where it is shortest.

\[ \text{length of the sum, with lengths } {a} \text{ and } {b} \]

  • a — from 1 to 10: length of the first vector
  • b — from 1 to 10: length of the second vector

Start with both lengths where they are and move your eye along the curve from left to right. At an angle of zero the two arrows point the same way and the sum is as long as it can possibly be, the two lengths added. At 180 degrees they point exactly opposite ways and the sum is as short as it can be, the difference of the two lengths.

Everything in between is a triangle, and the curve falling steadily is the Law of Cosines doing its work. Notice that the sum is not usually anywhere near the sum of the lengths; you have to arrange the directions very carefully to get that.

Now change one of the lengths and watch the whole curve move. Two things to check: the value at the left end is always the two lengths added, and the value at the right end is always how far apart they are. Set both lengths equal and the right end drops to zero, which is the additive inverse appearing on its own.

25. Estimate the resultant

Estimation

Figure (svg): Three small panels, each combining an arrow of length five with an arrow of length three. In the first they point the same way and the total is eight; in the second they meet at a right angle and the total is about 5.83; in the third they point opposite ways and the total is two.

The same two lengths give any total from two to eight. Only the angle between them decides, which is why lengths can never simply be added.

Predict first

A swimmer is carried by two currents, each of 10 miles per hour, and nothing is said about their directions. What can be said about the resultant speed?

  • It is exactly 20
  • It is exactly 10
  • It is anything from 0 up to 20
  • It is at least 10

Correct: It is anything from 0 up to 20

Why: Pointing the same way the currents give 20; pointing exactly opposite ways they cancel to 0. Every other arrangement lands strictly between. This is the sanity check for every application in this lesson: a resultant always lies between the difference of the two lengths and their sum.

Guess before you check. Most people reach for one specific number, and the honest answer is a range, because nothing in the question says which way the two currents point.

The two extremes come from the two extreme arrangements. Pointing the same way, the resultant is twenty; pointing exactly opposite ways, it is zero. Every other arrangement gives something strictly between, so the resultant can be anything from zero up to twenty.

This is worth remembering as a sanity check in every application that follows. Whatever triangle you solve, the answer must land between the difference of the two lengths and their sum. If it does not, you have made an arithmetic slip.

26. Match the picture to the expression

Matching

Match the pairs

  • a. the diagonal running out from the shared tail
  • b. the arrow joining the head of w to the head of v
  • c. the same length as v, pointing the other way
  • d. twice as long as v, same direction
  • w. v + w
  • x. v - w
  • y. -v
  • z. 2v

Why: The two diagonals are the ones that get mixed up. The diagonal from the shared tail outward is the sum; the diagonal joining the two heads is the difference, and it points toward the head of whichever vector is written first. The last two rescale a single vector instead of combining two.

Pair each description with its expression before revealing. Three of the four are about the parallelogram that two vectors from a common tail always determine.

The two diagonals are the ones people mix up. The diagonal from the common tail outward is the sum. The diagonal joining the two heads is the difference, and it points toward the head of whichever vector is written first.

The last two are about a single vector being rescaled. Reversing the direction without changing the length is multiplication by negative one; doubling the length without changing the direction is multiplication by two. That operation gets its own part at the end of the lesson.

27. Resultants in applications

Section

Part 3

28. The vector diagram is a triangle

Concept

Everything in this part rests on one observation: two velocities added tip to tail, together with the resultant, close up into a triangle, and you have spent two sections learning to solve triangles.

  1. The two known sides are the two speeds.
  2. The angle between them comes from the two bearings, and is where nearly all the difficulty lives.
  3. The third side is the true speed, by the Law of Cosines.
  4. The angle at the tail converts back into the true bearing, by the Law of Sines.

\[ c^2 = a^2 + b^2 - 2ab\cos(\gamma), \qquad \frac{\sin(\alpha)}{a} = \frac{\sin(\gamma)}{c} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, pp. 1013-1014 — the setup of Example 11.8.1

Everything in this part rests on one observation. Two velocities added tip to tail, together with the resultant, form a closed triangle, and you have spent two sections of this chapter learning how to solve triangles.

The lengths of the two known sides are the two speeds. The angle between them comes from the two bearings, and getting that angle right is where nearly all the difficulty lives. The third side is the answer you want.

So the method is always the same three moves: draw the two arrows tip to tail, extract the angle from the bearings, then hand the triangle to the Law of Cosines. The next few slides do that three times.

29. The bearings, and the triangle they make

Picture it

Figure (svg): A compass diagram at an airport: north points up and east to the right. One arrow leaves the airport 40 degrees east of north for the plane's velocity, and a second arrow continues from its head 60 degrees east of south for the wind. A third arrow runs from the airport to the far head.

The wind arrow has been slid over so its tail sits at the plane arrow's head. That move is legal only because a vector does not care where it is drawn.

The plane leaves the airport 40 degrees east of north at 175 miles per hour, and the wind blows 60 degrees east of south at 35. Slide the wind arrow to the head of the plane arrow and the two of them, with the resultant, close into a triangle.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1014 — the vector diagram

Spend a moment on this picture, because every navigation problem in the exercises is a redrawing of it. North points up and east to the right, and both arrows leave from the compass so their bearings can be read directly.

The wind arrow has been picked up and slid over so that its tail sits at the head of the plane arrow. That move is the whole reason the first part of this lesson insisted that position is not part of a vector. Without it there is no triangle and no way to bring the Law of Cosines to bear.

Now look at what the picture hands you: two sides whose lengths you know, an angle between them you can work out from the two bearings, and a third side you want. The next three slides do exactly that, in that order.

30. Before the Law of Cosines: which angle?

Step zero

Discussion prompt

The problem gives you the numbers 40 and 60. Neither is the angle you feed into the Law of Cosines. Work out the angle inside the triangle, and say where it comes from.

Write down your answer before revealing, and resist the urge to grab the first number in the problem. The bearings given are 40 and 60, and neither of them is the angle you feed into the Law of Cosines.

Trace it round the compass. The plane's heading is 40 degrees round from north; the wind's heading is 60 degrees round from south on the same side, which is 120 degrees round from north. The two directions therefore differ by 80 degrees.

But the triangle's angle is not the angle between the two directions. When you slide the wind arrow so its tail sits on the plane arrow's head, the angle inside the triangle is the supplement of that, which is 100 degrees. Missing this supplement is the single most common way these problems go wrong.

31. Example 11.8.1(a): the true speed

Worked example

A plane leaves an airport with an airspeed of 175 miles per hour at a bearing of N40E. A 35 mile per hour wind blows at a bearing of S60E. Find the true speed.

Name the two velocities and the resultant

Why: The true velocity is the net result of the plane's motion through the air and the air's motion over the ground.

\[ \vec{v} + \vec{w} = \text{the true velocity}, \qquad c = \text{its length} \]

Read the two known sides off the problem

Why: The lengths of the two arrows are the two given speeds.

\[ 175 \text{ and } 35 \]

Use the interior angle found on the last slide

Why: The supplement of the 80 degrees between the headings.

\[ \gamma = 100^\circ \]

Apply the Law of Cosines

Why: Two sides and the angle caught between them.

\[ c^2 = 175^2 + 35^2 - 2(175)(35)\cos(100^\circ) \]

Reduce the arithmetic

Why: The squares add to 31850 and the product doubles to 12250.

\[ c^2 = 31850 - 12250\cos(100^\circ) \]

Take the square root

Why: The cosine of an obtuse angle is negative, so the subtraction makes the answer larger.

\[ c = \sqrt{31850 - 12250\cos(100^\circ)} \approx 184.33 \]

Figure (svg): A triangle with the two known sides labelled 175 and 35 meeting at an angle of 100 degrees, and the unknown third side labelled c running from the far corner back to the start. A small angle alpha is marked at the starting corner.

Two sides and the angle caught between them: the exact input the Law of Cosines takes. The angle alpha at the starting corner is what turns the answer back into a bearing.

Check against the two extreme arrangements

Why: A tail wind would give 210 and a head wind 140. The true speed must lie between them, and about 184 miles per hour does.

\[ 140 < 184 < 210 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1014 — Example 11.8.1

The setup is the whole battle; the arithmetic afterwards is routine. Two sides of 175 and 35 with 100 degrees caught between them is exactly the situation the Law of Cosines was built for.

Keep the cosine unevaluated for as long as you can and let the calculator do the rounding once at the end. The cosine of 100 degrees is negative, which is worth noticing: subtracting a negative quantity makes the answer larger than the Pythagorean value would be, and an obtuse angle should indeed spread the triangle open.

The check at the end is a habit, not a formality. The resultant must lie between the difference of the two speeds and their sum, so somewhere between 140 and 210. The answer, about 184, sits comfortably inside, and a mistake of the kind that makes an answer land outside that window would have been caught instantly.

32. Example 11.8.1(b): the true bearing

Worked example

Same triangle. The wind has pushed the plane off the heading the pilot set, and the angle it has been pushed through is the one the book calls alpha.

\[ \alpha = \text{the angle at the airport between } \vec{v} \text{ and } \vec{v} + \vec{w} \]

Write the Law of Cosines for the side opposite alpha

Why: The side opposite alpha is the wind's 35.

\[ 35^2 = 175^2 + c^2 - 2(175)c\cos(\alpha) \]

Solve for the cosine

Why: Move the two squares across and divide.

\[ \cos(\alpha) = \frac{c^2 + 30625 - 1225}{350c} = \frac{c^2 + 29400}{350c} \]

Substitute the value of c

Why: Keep the unrounded value in the calculator.

\[ \cos(\alpha) \approx \frac{(184.329)^2 + 29400}{350(184.329)} \approx 0.98236 \]

Take the inverse cosine

Why: A small angle, as the picture promised.

\[ \alpha \approx 10.8^\circ \approx 11^\circ \]

Turn the angle into a bearing

Why: The wind blows toward the east, so it can only push the plane further east of north: add, do not subtract.

\[ 40^\circ + 11^\circ = 51^\circ \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{N}51^\circ\text{E} \]

Figure (svg): A compass diagram showing the plane's heading as a dashed arrow 40 degrees east of north and the true course as a solid arrow a further 11 degrees east of it, with the total marked as a bearing of north 51 degrees east.

The wind blows toward the east, so it can only swing the course further east of north. The eleven degrees is therefore added to the forty, never subtracted.

Check with the Law of Sines

Why: Alpha is opposite the shortest side, so it is certainly acute and the Law of Sines is unambiguous here. A second route to the same angle.

\[ \sin(\alpha) = \frac{35\sin(100^\circ)}{184.329} \approx 0.18698 \;\Longrightarrow\; \alpha \approx 10.8^\circ \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1014 — Example 11.8.1, continued

Knowing how fast is only half the question. The wind has also pushed the plane off the heading the pilot set, and the angle it has been pushed through is the one the book calls alpha, sitting at the airport between the plane's own arrow and the true course.

There are two ways to get it. The book runs the Law of Cosines a second time, solving for the cosine of alpha; the check line uses the Law of Sines instead, which is safe here because alpha is opposite the shortest side and therefore certainly acute. Two independent routes to the same eleven degrees is good evidence that neither has slipped.

Then convert the angle back into a bearing, and think about the direction rather than trusting a formula. The wind blows toward the east, so it can only push the plane further east of north. That means the eleven degrees is added to the 40, giving a true bearing of N51E rather than subtracted from it.

33. Trap: the bearing angle is not the triangle angle

Trap

The trap

The bearing number is taken straight into the formula:

\[ \gamma = 40^\circ \]

\[ c^2 = 31850 - 12250\cos(\gamma) \]

\[ c \approx 149.9 \]

Wrong. Forty degrees is a compass reading, not an angle of this triangle.

The fix

A bearing measures a direction against north or south. A triangle's angle measures the opening between two of its own sides. They coincide only by accident.

\[ \gamma = 180^\circ - 80^\circ = 100^\circ \]

\[ c \approx 184.3 \]

Draw the compass at the joint of the two arrows, mark north and south through that point, and read the interior angle off the drawing.

Every number in the trap column is copied faithfully from the problem, which is exactly what makes it dangerous. It looks like careful work.

The mistake is treating a compass reading as if it were an interior angle of the triangle. A bearing measures a direction against north or south; a triangle's angle measures the opening between two of its own sides. They are different measurements and they only coincide by accident.

The reliable procedure is to draw the compass at the joint of the two arrows, mark north and south through that point, and read the interior angle off the drawing. It costs thirty seconds and it is the difference between 184 and a confidently wrong 173.

34. Exercise 53: crossing the Nessie River

Worked example

Exercise 53. A boat leaves the dock across the Nessie River at 17 miles per hour, with respect to the water, at a bearing of S68W. The river flows due east at 8 miles per hour.

Set up the sum

Why: The current carries the whole boat downstream whichever way it is pointed, so the two velocities add.

\[ \vec{b} + \vec{r} = \text{the true velocity} \]

Convert the two bearings into compass angles

Why: South and then 68 degrees toward the west is 248 degrees round from north; due east is 90.

\[ 248^\circ - 90^\circ = 158^\circ \]

Take the supplement for the interior angle

Why: The same move as in Example 11.8.1.

\[ 180^\circ - 158^\circ = 22^\circ \]

Apply the Law of Cosines

Why: Sides 17 and 8 with 22 degrees between them.

\[ c^2 = 17^2 + 8^2 - 2(17)(8)\cos(22^\circ) = 353 - 272\cos(22^\circ) \]

Evaluate

Why: The angle is small, so the two arrows nearly line up and the answer is close to their difference.

\[ c = \sqrt{353 - 272\cos(22^\circ)} \approx 10.04 \]

Find the angle between the heading and the true course

Why: The Law of Sines, with the current's 8 opposite it.

\[ \sin(\alpha) = \frac{8\sin(22^\circ)}{10.04} \approx 0.29849 \;\Longrightarrow\; \alpha \approx 17.4^\circ \]

Figure (svg): A compass diagram at a dock: an arrow leaves heading down and to the left for the boat's course across the river, a horizontal arrow continues from its head pointing east for the current, and a third arrow runs from the dock to the far head, steeper and shorter than the boat's own arrow.

The current carries the whole boat downstream whichever way it is pointed, so the two velocities add. The angle inside the triangle is 22 degrees, not 68.

Check the direction of the correction

Why: The current runs east, so it must pull the course away from west and toward south, making the angle west of south smaller than 68. It does, and the book's answer is about 10 miles per hour at S50.6W.

\[ 68^\circ - 17.4^\circ = 50.6^\circ \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{S}50.6^\circ\text{W} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1029 — Exercise 53; answer on p. 1033

This is the same method on a new story, and the story matters: the current does not care which way the boat is pointed, it simply carries the whole boat downstream. So the boat's own velocity and the river's velocity add.

Getting the angle is again the real work. The boat heads 68 degrees west of south, which is 248 degrees round the compass from north, and the river runs due east at 90 degrees. The directions differ by 158, so the angle inside the tip to tail triangle is the supplement, 22 degrees.

The final check is the one to imitate. Before you write the bearing down, ask which way the current should swing the course. It flows east, so it should pull the boat's path away from west and toward south, making the angle west of south smaller than 68. It comes out at about 50.6, which is smaller, so the sign of the correction is right.

35. Exercise 55: aiming into the current

Worked example

Exercise 55. The HMS Sasquatch must reach an island 100 miles away at a bearing of S20E in three hours. The ocean current runs at 5 miles per hour at a bearing of N60E. What speed and heading should the captain set?

Turn the requirement into a resultant

Why: One hundred miles in three hours, in the direction of the island.

\[ \vec{v} + \vec{w} = \tfrac{100}{3} \text{ mph at } \text{S}20^\circ\text{E} \approx 33.33 \text{ mph} \]

Rearrange for the unknown velocity

Why: Exactly as with numbers: subtract the current from the required resultant.

\[ \vec{v} = (\vec{v} + \vec{w}) - \vec{w} \]

Find the angle inside the subtraction triangle

Why: The required resultant is 160 degrees round from north and the current is 60, so the directions differ by 100 degrees.

\[ 160^\circ - 60^\circ = 100^\circ \]

Apply the Law of Cosines to the two known sides

Why: Sides 33.33 and 5, with 100 degrees between them, give the length of the difference.

\[ \|\vec{v}\|^2 = 33.33^2 + 5^2 - 2(33.33)(5)\cos(100^\circ) \]

Evaluate

Why: Round to the nearest mile per hour at the end.

\[ \|\vec{v}\| \approx 34.55 \approx 35 \text{ mph} \]

Find how far off the island's bearing to aim

Why: The Law of Sines, with the current's 5 opposite the angle.

\[ \sin(\theta) = \frac{5\sin(100^\circ)}{34.55} \approx 0.14251 \;\Longrightarrow\; \theta \approx 8.2^\circ \]

Figure (svg): A diagram at a port: a dashed arrow points down and slightly right to the island, marked as the resultant the captain needs. A solid arrow points down and slightly less to the right, and a short arrow for the current continues from its head up and to the right, ending exactly at the island.

The dashed arrow is fixed by the destination and the deadline. The captain's own velocity is what is left when the current is taken away from it.

Check which way to swing the heading

Why: The current pushes toward the north-east, so the captain must aim west of the island to be carried back onto it: 20 degrees east of south becomes about 11.8, matching the book's S11.8E.

\[ 20^\circ - 8.2^\circ = 11.8^\circ \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{S}11.8^\circ\text{E} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1029 — Exercise 55; answer on p. 1033

This problem runs the machinery backwards and it is the reason subtraction earns its keep. You are told what the resultant has to be, and you have to find which velocity to add to the current in order to produce it.

Start by turning the requirement into a vector. One hundred miles in three hours is a resultant of a hundred over three miles per hour, and the direction of the resultant is the direction of the island. That arrow is now known completely.

Then rearrange exactly as you would with numbers: the velocity to set is the required resultant minus the current. The figure shows why the answer is a triangle again, and why the captain has to aim upstream of the island rather than straight at it. The heading comes out about eight degrees to the west of the island's bearing, which is the correction the current will undo.

36. Where resultants turn up

Real world

Discussion prompt

Outside navigation, where else do two arrows get added tip to tail? Name two situations, and say what plays the part of the two sides and of the angle between them.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, pp. 1029-1030 — Exercises 58 to 62

Answer before revealing. The list is longer than most people expect, because anything that pushes or carries adds this way.

Forces are the classic case: two ropes pulling a load, or gravity and a cable pulling on a hanging sign. Velocities are the other big family, and the pattern is always something moving inside something else that is itself moving, such as a swimmer in a current or a person walking along a moving train.

The mathematical content is identical every time. Two arrows, tip to tail, one triangle, and the Law of Cosines. Recognising the shape is most of the work, which is why it is worth naming the pattern rather than memorising each story.

37. Properties of addition

Section

Part 4

38. The zero vector, and why it is allowed in

Concept

zero vector — The vector with both components zero, drawn as a directed segment whose head and tail are the same point. Its magnitude is zero and its direction is undefined.

\[ \vec{0} = \langle 0, 0\rangle \]

The book is honest that this is an odd object. A vector was supposed to have a direction, and this one has none that can be named.

It is admitted anyway because of what it makes possible. Without it there is no vector that leaves every other vector unchanged, and no vector can have an opposite that cancels it, so two of the four properties on the next slide would have nothing to be about. The trade is the same one made for the number zero.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1015 — the zero vector

The zero vector is an odd object and the book is honest about it. Its magnitude is zero, which is fine, but nothing sensible can be said about its direction, and a vector was supposed to have one.

It is admitted anyway because of what it makes possible. Without it there is no vector that leaves every other vector unchanged when added, and no way for a vector to have an opposite that cancels it, so two of the four properties on the next slide would have nothing to be about.

Compare it with zero itself in ordinary arithmetic. Zero is a strange number too, and it breaks division, but no one would give it up, because addition without it would be a much poorer system. The trade is the same here.

39. Theorem 11.18: the four properties of addition

Concept

propertywhat it sayswhy it holds
commutativev + w = w + vinside each slot, real addition is commutative
associative(u + v) + w = u + (v + w)inside each slot, real addition is associative
identityv + 0 = 0 + v = vadding 0 to a real number changes nothing
inversev + (-v) = 0, and -v is uniqueevery real number has exactly one negative

Every property is inherited rather than invented. Addition is defined slot by slot, and inside each slot you are adding ordinary real numbers, which obey all four.

The practical value is that ordinary algebra is now licensed: a vector expression may be rearranged and regrouped exactly as a numerical one, which is what makes the equation-solving at the end of this lesson possible.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1015 — Theorem 11.18

Read the table as a claim that vector addition behaves the way you already expect addition to behave. Order does not matter, grouping does not matter, there is a do-nothing element, and everything can be undone.

Each property is inherited rather than invented. Addition of vectors is defined slot by slot, and inside each slot you are adding ordinary real numbers, which obey all four. The next two slides prove one of them completely so you can see how short the argument is.

The practical value of the theorem is that it licenses ordinary algebra. Because these four hold, you may rearrange and regroup a vector expression exactly as you would a numerical one, which is what makes the equation-solving at the end of the lesson possible.

40. Two routes round one parallelogram

Picture it

Figure (svg): A parallelogram built from two arrows leaving the origin. One route goes along the flatter arrow first and then the steeper one; the dashed route goes along the steeper one first and then the flatter one. Both routes finish at the same far corner, where a single bold arrow from the origin also ends.

Along v then w, or along w then v: the two routes are the two sides of one parallelogram and they finish at the same corner. That is commutativity, drawn.

Go along the first arrow then the second, or along the second then the first. The two routes are the two ways round one parallelogram, and both finish at the same far corner. That is the commutative property with no algebra in it.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1016 — the parallelogram figure

Two vectors leaving a common tail always determine a parallelogram, and this figure is the reason that shape keeps coming up. The solid route travels along the flatter arrow first and then the steeper one; the dashed route takes them in the other order.

Both routes finish at the same far corner, and the bold arrow from the tail to that corner is the sum. Order of travel changes the path but not the destination, which is exactly what the commutative property asserts.

Keep this picture beside the algebra on the next slide. The proof is four lines of symbols saying nothing more than what you can see here in one glance, and having both versions is how the property becomes something you can reconstruct rather than recall.

41. Proving that order does not matter

Worked example

Theorem 11.18's first property, proved from the definition in four lines.

Start on one side and unpack the vectors

Why: Write both in component form.

\[ \vec{v} + \vec{w} = \langle v_1, v_2\rangle + \langle w_1, w_2\rangle \]

Apply Definition 11.6

Why: Add slot by slot.

\[ = \langle v_1 + w_1,\; v_2 + w_2\rangle \]

Swap the two numbers inside each slot

Why: Each slot holds ordinary real numbers, and real addition is commutative. This is the only mathematical content in the proof.

\[ = \langle w_1 + v_1,\; w_2 + v_2\rangle \]

Read Definition 11.6 backwards

Why: Repack the pair as a sum of two vectors.

\[ = \langle w_1, w_2\rangle + \langle v_1, v_2\rangle = \vec{w} + \vec{v} \]

Check on the running example

Why: Both orders give the same pair, and the parallelogram on the previous slide is the same statement drawn.

\[ \langle 3, 4\rangle + \langle 1, -2\rangle = \langle 4, 2\rangle = \langle 1, -2\rangle + \langle 3, 4\rangle \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1016 — the commutativity proof

The proof is four lines and every line is either a definition or a fact about real numbers. Start on one side, unpack the definition, do the one thing you are allowed to do, and pack the definition back up.

The only mathematical content is in the middle step, where the two numbers inside each slot change places. That is permitted because they are ordinary real numbers, and real addition is commutative. Nothing about vectors is being assumed.

The parallelogram on the previous slide is the same statement with no algebra in it. Go along the first vector then the second, or along the second then the first, and you have walked the two ways round one parallelogram. Both routes end at the same far corner, which is what the theorem says.

42. Example: finding the additive inverse

Worked example

Rather than being told what cancels a vector, derive it.

\[ \text{find } \vec{w} \text{ with } \vec{v} + \vec{w} = \vec{0}, \qquad \vec{v} = \langle v_1, v_2\rangle \]

Unpack with the definition of addition

Why: Add slot by slot and set the result equal to the zero vector.

\[ \langle v_1 + w_1,\; v_2 + w_2\rangle = \langle 0, 0\rangle \]

Split the vector equation into two number equations

Why: Two vectors are equal exactly when both components agree.

\[ v_1 + w_1 = 0 \qquad\text{and}\qquad v_2 + w_2 = 0 \]

Solve each equation

Why: One step each, and each has exactly one solution.

\[ w_1 = -v_1, \qquad w_2 = -v_2 \]

Collect the answer

Why: Existence and uniqueness in one line: the partner exists, and there is only one.

\[ -\vec{v} = \langle -v_1, -v_2\rangle \]

Figure (svg): Two arrows leaving the origin along one dashed straight line in opposite directions: one goes up and to the right to three comma four, the other goes down and to the left to negative three comma negative four. Both are the same length.

Same length, opposite directions. Going out along one and back along the other leaves you exactly where you began, which is what the zero vector records.

Check with the running example

Why: Going out along the arrow and back along its opposite leaves no net movement.

\[ \langle 3, 4\rangle + \langle -3, -4\rangle = \langle 0, 0\rangle = \vec{0} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1016 — the additive inverse

Rather than being told the answer, derive it. Write down the requirement, unpack it with the definition of addition, and see what the components are forced to be.

The key move is the third line. Two vectors are equal exactly when both components agree, so one vector equation splits into two ordinary number equations. Each is solved in a single step.

Notice what the derivation proves in passing. Each equation has exactly one solution, so the partner that cancels a given vector is not merely available, it is unique. The picture is the obvious one: the same arrow turned round, so that going out and coming back leaves you where you started.

43. Is subtraction commutative?

Counterexample

Discussion prompt

Addition of vectors does not care about order. Someone assumes subtraction inherits that. Give a specific counterexample with numbers in it, and say what goes wrong geometrically.

Write a counterexample before revealing, and make it a specific one with numbers in it. A general argument is fine once you have the example, but the example is what settles the question.

Any pair of unequal vectors will do. Swapping the order negates both components, which geometrically means the arrow points the other way along the same line. It has the same length, so it is easy to glance at a picture and think nothing has changed, but a vector with the opposite direction is a different vector.

This is worth a moment because addition is commutative and the temptation is to assume subtraction inherits it. It does not, for exactly the same reason that three minus five is not five minus three, and the vector version fails in every slot at once.

44. Which expressions are defined?

Sorting

Sort into buckets

Sort each expression by whether Section 11.8 has actually given it a meaning. Assume v and w are vectors and k is a real number.

Defined in this section
v + w; kv; v - w; the vector from the point P to the point Q
Not defined here
v + 5; vw, one vector times another
yes
Definition 11.6 gives the sum, Definition 11.7 gives a number times a vector, subtraction is addition of the inverse, and Definition 11.5 turns two points into a vector.
no
A vector plus a real number adds a pair of numbers to a single number, and there is nothing to do with the mismatch. A product of two vectors is not nonsense in general, but nothing here defines it; Section 11.9 defines one whose answer is a number, not a vector.

Sort each expression before revealing. The question is not whether you can guess what somebody meant, but whether Section 11.8 has actually given the symbol a meaning.

Adding two vectors, subtracting two vectors and multiplying a vector by a real number are all defined here. Subtracting two points to get a vector is defined too, and that is exactly Definition 11.5.

The two that fail are worth understanding rather than just remembering. A vector plus a real number is adding a pair of numbers to a single number, and there is nothing sensible to do with the mismatch. Multiplying two vectors is not nonsense in general, but nothing in this section defines it; Section 11.9 will define a product of two vectors, and its answer is a number rather than a vector.

45. Scalar multiplication

Section

Part 5

46. Definition 11.7: stretching a vector

Concept

scalar — An ordinary real number, used here to rescale a vector. The word distinguishes it from the vectors it multiplies.

\[ k\vec{v} = k\langle v_1, v_2\rangle = \langle kv_1,\; kv_2\rangle \]

The arithmetic is the easiest of the three operations: multiply the number into both components and stop. The geometry is where the interest lies.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1017 — Definition 11.7

Multiplication by a real number is the third and last operation of the section, and it is the easiest. Multiply the number into both components and you are finished.

The geometry is where the interest is. A positive multiplier rescales the arrow and leaves the direction alone: doubling makes it twice as long, halving makes it half as long. A negative multiplier rescales it and also turns it round to point the opposite way.

The next slide stacks four multiples of one vector so you can compare them side by side. Every arrow there lies along the same direction, which is the fact worth carrying away: scalar multiplication can change how long and can flip which end, but it can never tilt the arrow off its own line.

47. Four multiples of one vector

Picture it

Figure (svg): Four arrows drawn from one vertical line at a common scale. The first goes three units right and one up. Below it a second is twice as long in the same direction, a third is half as long, and a fourth is twice as long but points the opposite way, down and to the left.

Multiplying by a number changes how long the arrow is, and a negative number also turns it round. What it can never do is tilt the arrow off its own line.

The same vector scaled four ways. Doubling makes the arrow twice as long; halving makes it half as long; multiplying by negative two doubles the length and reverses it. Every one of the four lies along a single direction, which is the fact worth carrying away.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1018 — the scaling figure

Four arrows, all built from the one at the top. Doubling the number doubles the length and leaves the direction untouched. Halving it halves the length, again with no change of direction.

The fourth is the interesting one, because two things happen at once. The size of the number, two, sets the new length; the negative sign reverses which way the arrow points. Read those two effects separately and negative multipliers stop being confusing.

The arrows have been stacked rather than drawn from a common tail so that you can compare their lengths without them lying on top of one another. Slide them all back to the same tail in your head and they would sit along a single straight line, which is the property that matters.

48. Reading Theorem 11.19 piece by piece

Notation

Annotate

On: \( (k+r)\vec{v} = k\vec{v} + r\vec{v}, \qquad k(\vec{v}+\vec{w}) = k\vec{v} + k\vec{w} \)

  • Here the sum being broken open is a sum of two NUMBERS multiplying one vector. Both numbers hit the same vector.
  • Here the sum is a sum of two VECTORS multiplied by one number. The single number hits both vectors. The two statements are genuinely different, and Example 11.8.3 uses both.
  • Scalars regroup, one leaves a vector alone, and multiplying by negative one produces the additive inverse.
  • A scalar multiple equals the zero vector only when the scalar is zero or the vector is. A product cannot vanish by accident, which is what makes equation-solving safe.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1018 — Theorem 11.19

Six properties look like a lot to hold, but they divide into two families. The first three say that scalars combine with each other the way you expect; the two distributive laws say that scalars spread over a sum; and the last one says the only way to get the zero vector is to have a zero somewhere.

Take the two distributive laws slowly, because they are genuinely different statements. In the first, the sum being broken open is a sum of two numbers multiplying one vector. In the second, it is a sum of two vectors being multiplied by one number. Both are true and both get used in the next worked example.

The zero product property is the one that matters when you solve equations. It says a product cannot vanish by accident, so if a scalar multiple comes out as the zero vector, either the scalar was zero or the vector was, and there is no third possibility.

49. Proving that scalars regroup

Worked example

The associative property of scalar multiplication, in the same four moves as the earlier proof.

Start on one side and unpack the vector

Why: Write it in component form.

\[ (kr)\vec{v} = (kr)\langle v_1, v_2\rangle \]

Apply Definition 11.7

Why: The scalar reaches both components.

\[ = \langle (kr)v_1,\; (kr)v_2\rangle \]

Regroup inside each slot

Why: Multiplication of real numbers is associative. This is the only mathematical content.

\[ = \langle k(rv_1),\; k(rv_2)\rangle \]

Pull the outer scalar back out

Why: Definition 11.7 read backwards.

\[ = k\langle rv_1,\; rv_2\rangle \]

Pull the inner scalar out the same way

Why: One more application of the same definition.

\[ = k\left(r\langle v_1, v_2\rangle\right) = k(r\vec{v}) \]

Check with numbers

Why: Six times the vector, or three times it and then doubled: the same pair.

\[ (2\cdot 3)\langle 3, 4\rangle = \langle 18, 24\rangle = 2\left(3\langle 3, 4\rangle\right) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1018 — the associativity proof

This proof has the same shape as the commutativity proof earlier, and seeing that shape twice is the point. Unpack with the definition, use one fact about real numbers, pack back up.

The single fact being used is that multiplication of real numbers is associative. It is applied in each slot independently, which is possible only because the definition of scalar multiplication treats the two slots separately.

The book leaves the remaining five properties as exercises, and after following this one you should be able to write any of them out. Every proof in this part is the same four moves with a different fact about real numbers in the middle.

50. Example 11.8.3: solving for a vector

Worked example

Example 11.8.3. Every rearrangement below is licensed by a named property from the last two theorems.

\[ 5\vec{v} - 2\left(\vec{v} + \langle 1, -2\rangle\right) = \vec{0} \]

Distribute the negative two over the bracket

Why: Distributive property of scalar multiplication over vector addition.

\[ 5\vec{v} + (-2)\vec{v} + (-2)\langle 1, -2\rangle = \vec{0} \]

Multiply the constant vector by negative two

Why: Definition 11.7, one component at a time.

\[ (-2)\langle 1, -2\rangle = \langle -2, 4\rangle \]

Collect the two multiples of the unknown

Why: Distributive property of scalar multiplication over scalar addition.

\[ 5\vec{v} + (-2)\vec{v} = (5 + (-2))\vec{v} = 3\vec{v} \]

Rewrite the whole equation

Why: Two terms left, one unknown.

\[ 3\vec{v} + \langle -2, 4\rangle = \vec{0} \]

Add the inverse of the constant vector to both sides

Why: The additive inverse and the additive identity, used together.

\[ 3\vec{v} = \langle 2, -4\rangle \]

Multiply both sides by one third

Why: The scalar reaches both components.

\[ \vec{v} = \tfrac13\langle 2, -4\rangle = \left\langle \tfrac23,\; -\tfrac43 \right\rangle \]

Check by substituting back

Why: Work out the bracket first, then double it, and watch the two halves cancel exactly.

\[ \vec{v} + \langle 1, -2\rangle = \left\langle \tfrac53,\; -\tfrac{10}{3}\right\rangle \]

\[ 5\vec{v} = \left\langle \tfrac{10}{3},\; -\tfrac{20}{3}\right\rangle = 2\left\langle \tfrac53,\; -\tfrac{10}{3}\right\rangle \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1019 — Example 11.8.3

The book calls its own solution excruciatingly detailed, and the reason is to show that every rearrangement you have been making without thinking is licensed by a specific property from the last two theorems.

In practice you will not name each property out loud, but you should be able to. Distributing the negative two over the bracket uses the distributive law over vector addition; collecting the two multiples of the unknown uses the distributive law over scalar addition; moving the constant vector across uses the additive inverse and the identity together.

Once the equation reaches three times the unknown equalling a known vector, the finish is exactly what it would be with numbers: multiply both sides by one third, which reaches both components. The check substitutes the answer back and watches the two halves cancel, which is the only way to be certain.

51. Fill in the scalar combination

Fill the middle

Do both multiplications first, and only then combine.

Fill in the blanks

3\langle -1, 2\rangle - 2\langle 4, 0\rangle = \langle -11,\; 6\rangle

Why: Three times the first vector gives negative three and six; two times the second gives eight and zero. Subtracting slot by slot leaves negative eleven and six. The second component comes entirely from the first vector, since twice zero is zero.

Do both multiplications first and only then combine; mixing the two steps is how sign errors get in. Three times the first vector reaches both of its components, and two times the second reaches both of its.

The second component is the one to watch. Two times zero is zero, so subtracting it changes nothing, and the second component of the answer comes entirely from the first vector. Leaving out a zero is harmless here; misplacing it is not.

52. Exercise 1: combining two vectors

Worked example

Exercise 1 from the section's exercise set, whose second part mixes a scalar with a subtraction.

\[ \vec{v} = \langle 12, -5\rangle, \qquad \vec{w} = \langle 3, 4\rangle \]

Add componentwise for the first part

Why: Definition 11.6, slot by slot.

\[ \vec{v} + \vec{w} = \langle 12 + 3,\; -5 + 4\rangle = \langle 15, -1\rangle \]

Double the first vector

Why: The scalar attaches to that vector only, and reaches both of its components.

\[ 2\vec{v} = \langle 24, -10\rangle \]

Negate it

Why: Subtracting is adding the inverse.

\[ -2\vec{v} = \langle -24, 10\rangle \]

Add that to the second vector

Why: Slot by slot, watching the signs.

\[ \vec{w} - 2\vec{v} = \langle 3 - 24,\; 4 + 10\rangle = \langle -21, 14\rangle \]

Check the order of operations

Why: Subtracting first and doubling afterwards would multiply both vectors by two and give a completely different answer, so the scalar really does attach to one vector only.

\[ 2(\vec{w} - \vec{v}) = \langle -18, 18\rangle \ne \langle -21, 14\rangle \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1027 — Exercise 1; answers on p. 1031

The first bullet is a plain sum and needs no comment. The second is the interesting one, because it puts a scalar and a subtraction in the same expression and you have to respect the order.

The scalar attaches to one vector only. Double that vector first, then subtract the result, component by component. Doing the subtraction first and doubling afterwards multiplies both vectors by two, and the check step shows just how different the two answers are.

Writing out the doubling as its own line, then the negation as another, is slower than doing it in your head and much safer. Sign errors in this kind of expression are not rare, they are the norm, and each extra written line removes one opportunity for one.

53. Trap: multiplying two vectors slot by slot

Trap

The trap

Addition works slot by slot, so surely multiplication does too:

\[ \langle 3, 4\rangle \cdot \langle 1, -2\rangle \]

\[ = \langle 3, -8\rangle \;? \]

Wrong. Nothing in this section defines a product of two vectors.

The fix

A real number times a vector is defined. A vector times a vector is not, and no later section defines the slot-by-slot version at all.

\[ k\vec{v} = \langle kv_1, kv_2\rangle \]

\[ \langle 3, 4\rangle \cdot \langle 1, -2\rangle = -5 \]

Section 11.9 does define a product, the dot product: multiply the matching slots and then add. Its answer is a single number, not a pair.

The trap is attractive because it is the obvious pattern-match. Addition works slot by slot, so surely multiplication does too. Nothing in the section says so, and nothing later in the book defines that operation.

What does exist is different in kind. Section 11.9 defines the dot product of two vectors, and it multiplies the matching slots and then adds the two results, producing a single number rather than a vector. For these two vectors it gives negative five, which is not a pair at all.

So the rule for now is strict: a real number times a vector is defined, a vector times a vector is not. If you see two vectors side by side with no operation named, something has gone wrong in the writing.

54. Predict: what does the negative multiple look like?

Prediction

\[ \vec{v} = \langle 2, 1\rangle, \qquad \text{consider } -2\vec{v} \]

Predict first

Compared with the original arrow, what does this multiple look like?

  • Twice as long, pointing the opposite way
  • Twice as long, same direction
  • Half as long, pointing the opposite way
  • The same length, pointing the opposite way

Correct: Twice as long, pointing the opposite way

Why: Two things change, and the usual error is to notice only one. The size of the number sets the new length, so the arrow doubles; the negative sign reverses the direction. Negating both components of an arrow pointing up and to the right gives one pointing down and to the left, along the same line.

Commit to an option before revealing. Two things change when the multiplier is a negative number, and the usual error is to notice only one of them.

The size of the number sets the new length, so a multiplier of negative two makes the arrow twice as long. The sign sets the direction, and a negative sign reverses it. Both happen, and they happen independently.

Check it against the definition rather than against the picture: negating both components of an arrow pointing up and to the right gives one pointing down and to the left, along the very same line.

55. Fill the component table

Comparison

\[ \vec{v} = \langle 3, 4\rangle, \qquad \vec{w} = \langle 1, -2\rangle \]

Comparison matrix

expressionfirst componentsecond component
v + w42
v - w26
2v68
-w-12
3v - 2w716
v + (-v)00

Fill every blank before checking. The point of the table is to make the componentwise rules automatic, because in the next lesson these calculations become a sub-step inside longer problems rather than the problem itself.

The last two rows are where care is needed. The combination with two scalars needs each multiplication done first, in both slots, before the subtraction. And the row where a vector is added to its own opposite must come out as the zero vector, which is a useful pattern to be able to spot instantly.

56. Exercise 65: a line built from two vectors

Worked example

Exercise 65. A line described not by an equation in x and y, but by a place to start and a direction to travel.

\[ y = 2x - 4, \qquad \vec{v}_0 = \langle 0, -4\rangle, \qquad \vec{s} = \langle 1, 2\rangle \]

Scale the slope vector by a real number t

Why: Definition 11.7: the scalar reaches both components.

\[ t\vec{s} = \langle t,\; 2t\rangle \]

Add the intercept vector

Why: Definition 11.6, slot by slot.

\[ \vec{v}_0 + t\vec{s} = \langle 0 + t,\; -4 + 2t\rangle = \langle t,\; 2t - 4\rangle \]

Read off the terminal point in standard position

Why: A vector drawn from the origin ends at the point whose coordinates are its components.

\[ (x, y) = (t,\; 2t - 4) \]

Test that point against the equation of the line

Why: Substitute the x-coordinate and see whether the y-coordinate comes back.

\[ 2x - 4 = 2t - 4 = y \]

Figure (svg): The straight line with equation y equals two x minus four drawn on a grid. A short arrow runs from the origin down to the y-intercept, and from there a second arrow runs three across and six up along the line, with dots marking where the terminal point sits for each whole-number value of the parameter.

A place to start plus a direction to travel. Every point on the line is the intercept vector with some multiple of the slope vector added to it.

Check one value, then generalise

Why: At t equal to three the head is at three comma two, and two times three minus four is two. Replacing the two vectors by the intercept and the slope of any non-vertical line runs the same argument.

\[ \langle 0, b\rangle + t\langle 1, m\rangle = \langle t,\; mt + b\rangle \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, p. 1030 — Exercise 65

This exercise is a preview of how vectors get used once you leave this chapter, and it is worth the effort. A line is being described not by an equation in x and y but by a starting place and a direction you are free to travel along.

The two ingredients are exactly that. One vector points from the origin to the intercept; the other, with components one and the slope, is a single step along the line. Scaling that step by any real number and adding it to the intercept vector gives a point on the line, and letting the scalar run over all real numbers gives every point on it.

The verification is the satisfying part. The terminal point turns out to have coordinates t and two t minus four, and the second is exactly what the equation of the line demands of the first. The last line of the check shows the same argument works with any slope and any intercept, so every non-vertical line can be built this way.

57. Standard position

Concept

standard position — The drawing of a vector whose tail is at the origin. Every vector has one, and it is the drawing the next lesson assumes throughout.

Figure (svg): A coordinate grid with a single arrow from the origin to the point four comma three, with dashed legs down to the x-axis and across to the y-axis showing that the head's coordinates are the vector's two components.

Put the tail at the origin and the head lands at the point whose coordinates are the components. That coincidence is what the next lesson is built on.

\[ \vec{v} = \langle v_1, v_2\rangle \text{ in standard position has head } (v_1, v_2) \]

The coincidence in the picture is the reason for the name. Subtracting the origin's coordinates changes nothing, so the head lands at the point whose coordinates are the components. Convert that point to polar coordinates and the two polar quantities turn out to be how long the vector is and which way it points, which is exactly where the next lesson starts.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors §11.8, pp. 1019-1020 — standard position

There is one drawing of a vector that is more convenient than the others, and it is the one with its tail at the origin. It is called standard position, and it is worth naming because so much of the next lesson assumes it.

The reason it is convenient is the coincidence in the figure: when the tail sits at the origin, the coordinates of the head are the components of the vector. Definition 11.5 makes this obvious, since subtracting zero from each coordinate changes nothing.

That coincidence is the bridge to the next lesson. With the head sitting at a known point, you can convert that point to polar coordinates, and the two polar quantities turn out to be precisely how long the vector is and which way it points.

58. Putting it together

Section

Part 6

59. Pattern: handling any vector question in this section

Pattern

Figure (svg): A flow diagram. The first question is whether the vectors are given in components or as speeds and bearings. Components branch to componentwise arithmetic; bearings branch to drawing the tip to tail triangle, finding its interior angle, and applying the Law of Cosines and the Law of Sines. Both branches end at a checking step.

One decision at the top, then a fixed route. The checking line at the bottom belongs to both branches and is the step most often skipped.
  1. Ask which language the problem speaks. Components, or speeds and bearings.
  2. In components, do the arithmetic twice, once per slot, and never let the slots mix.
  3. In speeds and bearings, draw the two arrows tip to tail before touching a formula.
  4. Get the interior angle from the two bearings, and remember the supplement.
  5. Law of Cosines for the third side, then Law of Sines for the angle at the tail, then convert back to a bearing.
  6. Always check: walk the components back to the head, or confirm the resultant lies between the difference and the sum of the two lengths.

This is the order to work in, and it runs from cheapest to most expensive. The first question is always which language the problem is speaking, because components and arrows want different tools.

If everything is already in components, the work is arithmetic done twice and there is nothing to draw. If the problem speaks in speeds and bearings, do not rush to components: draw the tip to tail triangle, get the interior angle from the bearings, and let the Law of Cosines and the Law of Sines finish it.

The last line of the flow diagram is the one people skip. Whatever route you took, check the answer against something independent: walk the components back to the head, or confirm the resultant lies between the difference and the sum of the two lengths.

60. Put a navigation problem in order

Ranking

Put in order

Order the steps of a complete true-speed-and-bearing solution.

  1. Draw the two velocities tip to tail and close the triangle
  2. Convert both bearings into angles measured from north
  3. Take the supplement to get the angle inside the triangle
  4. Apply the Law of Cosines to find the length of the resultant
  5. Apply the Law of Sines to find the angle at the tail
  6. Convert that angle back into a compass bearing

Why: The angle work comes before the Law of Cosines, because the angle is an input to it rather than something extracted afterwards. And the final conversion back into a bearing is a separate step, the one most often forgotten: an angle inside a triangle is not yet an answer to a navigation question.

Drag the steps into order before checking. The only genuinely contested position is where the angle work goes, and the answer is early: the angle is an input to the Law of Cosines, not something you extract afterwards.

Notice that converting back into a bearing is a separate final step, and it is the one most often forgotten under time pressure. An angle inside a triangle is not an answer to a navigation question until it has been turned back into a compass reading.

61. Check: reading a component form

Check

Check your understanding

What is the component form of the vector whose tail is at (-1, 5) and whose head is at (3, -2)?

  • A. 4 and -7 (correct)
  • B. -4 and 7
  • C. 2 and 3
  • D. -3 and -10

Answer: A

Why: Head minus tail in both slots: three minus negative one is four, and negative two minus five is negative seven. The arrow travels four to the right and seven down.

Why B tempts people
Both signs are flipped, which is what you get by subtracting head from tail. That is the arrow pointing back the other way.
Why C tempts people
These are the two coordinates added rather than subtracted. Addition of the endpoints has no geometric meaning here.
Why D tempts people
The coordinates have been paired up wrongly: the x-coordinates must be subtracted from each other, and the y-coordinates from each other.

The only thing being tested is the direction of the subtraction, and three of the four options are the results of getting some part of it wrong.

Head minus tail means the second point's coordinates minus the first's. Three minus negative one is four, and negative two minus five is negative seven. If you got the pair with both signs flipped, you subtracted head from tail.

62. Check: which total force is impossible

Check

Check your understanding

Two forces of 30 pounds and 40 pounds pull on the same object. Which of these total forces is impossible, whatever the angle between them?

  • A. 10 pounds
  • B. 50 pounds
  • C. 70 pounds
  • D. 80 pounds (correct)

Answer: D

Why: The resultant of two arrows always lies between the difference of their lengths and their sum, so anything from 10 up to 70 is achievable and nothing outside is. Eighty is beyond the sum, so no arrangement of directions produces it.

Why A tempts people
Achievable, and it is one endpoint of the range: the forces pull in exactly opposite directions and 40 minus 30 is left.
Why B tempts people
Achievable, and it happens when the two forces are at right angles, since three, four, five is a right triangle.
Why C tempts people
Achievable, and it is the other endpoint: the forces pull in exactly the same direction, so their lengths add.

This question is the triangle inequality wearing a different hat. Two forces of 30 and 40 can combine to anything from their difference up to their sum, depending on the angle between them.

That gives everything from 10 up to 70 as achievable, with 10 when they oppose exactly and 70 when they align exactly. Eighty is outside that window, so no arrangement of directions produces it. The two endpoints are both achievable, which is why they are not the answer.

63. Check: a scalar combination

Check

Check your understanding

With v having components -1 and 2, and w having components 4 and 0, what is three times v minus two times w?

  • A. -11 and 6 (correct)
  • B. -5 and 6
  • C. -11 and 2
  • D. 9 and 4

Answer: A

Why: Three times the first vector gives negative three and six; two times the second gives eight and zero. Subtracting slot by slot leaves negative eleven in the first component and six in the second.

Why B tempts people
The second vector was subtracted without first being doubled. The scalar has to reach both of its components.
Why C tempts people
The first vector was not tripled in its second slot, so the six was left as a two.
Why D tempts people
The two vectors were subtracted before the scalars were applied, which changes both answers.

Do the two multiplications first and keep both slots separate the whole way through. Three times the first vector is negative three and six; two times the second is eight and zero.

Subtracting gives negative eleven in the first slot and six in the second. The tempting wrong answers come from forgetting to multiply one of the components, or from stopping after the first multiplication.

64. Explain why the arithmetic matches the picture

Explain it to yourself

Discussion prompt

In two sentences, explain why adding matching components produces exactly the same vector as laying the two arrows tip to tail. Do not use the word definition.

Write your two sentences before revealing. Being able to give this explanation is the difference between knowing the rule and understanding why anyone would choose it.

The heart of it is independence. Horizontal motion and vertical motion do not interfere: travelling sideways never changes your height and rising never changes how far across you are. So the two kinds of motion can be totalled separately, which is exactly what adding matching components does.

If you can say that clearly, you can also predict that the same argument will keep working in three dimensions, and that is in fact how vectors are defined in every course after this one.

65. Exit ticket

Exit ticket

\[ \vec{v} = \overrightarrow{PQ} \text{ with } P(2, -1), \; Q(5, 3), \qquad \vec{w} = \langle -1, 6\rangle \]

Discussion prompt

Find the component form of the first vector, then compute the second vector minus twice the first. Finally, say in one sentence why an arrow drawn in a different corner of the page can still be the same vector.

This combines the two halves of the lesson in one problem: the component arithmetic from the first half and the geometric meaning from the second.

The component work is routine if you keep the steps separate: convert the pair of points into a vector, double it, then subtract. The last part asks for a reason rather than a number, and the reason is the one this lesson has been building toward.

A vector records how far across and how far up, and nothing about where it sits. So two arrows in different corners of the page that agree on those two numbers are the same vector, and that is exactly what makes sliding one arrow to the tip of another a legal move.

66. Recap

Recap

operationthe arrowthe components
component formsubtract the tail from the headan ordered pair in angle brackets
additiontip to tail, or a diagonal of the parallelogramadd matching components
subtractionthe arrow joining the two headssubtract matching components
scalar multiplerescale, and reverse if the number is negativemultiply both components

\[ \vec{v} + \vec{w} = \langle v_1 + w_1,\; v_2 + w_2\rangle, \qquad k\vec{v} = \langle kv_1,\; kv_2\rangle \]

Theorems 11.18 and 11.19 say that all the ordinary rules of algebra survive, which is what lets you solve an equation for an unknown vector exactly as you would for an unknown number.

One quantity has been used informally throughout and never computed: how long a vector actually is. Every length so far came out of a triangle. The next lesson extracts the length and the direction straight from the components.

OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §10.8 Vectors §10.8 — the same material in OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry

Three operations and one recurring picture. A vector is a magnitude and a direction and nothing else, recorded as a pair of components by subtracting the tail from the head. Addition is tip to tail, which is the same as adding matching components. Multiplying by a real number rescales the arrow and reverses it when the number is negative.

The two theorems say that all the ordinary rules of algebra survive, which is what let you solve an equation for an unknown vector in the same way you would solve one for an unknown number.

One quantity has been used informally all through this lesson without ever being computed: how long a vector actually is. Every length so far came from the geometry of a triangle. The next lesson extracts the length and the direction straight from the components, and that is what turns a vector back into a magnitude and a bearing whenever you need one.

Sources

  1. Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.8 Vectors — Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Version 3 Corrected Edition, July 4 2013, pp. 1012-1020
  2. OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §10.8 Vectors

Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Trigonometry — $55/session, free consultation.

Book on Wyzant · Text (657) 465-8108