11.5b Polar Intersections and Polar Regions

Where two polar curves meet, and why solving the two equations simultaneously does not answer that question. Establishes the four-step guidelines — sketch and check the pole, solve directly, shift by a full turn, flip the sign and half-turn — through the circle-and-rose example whose eight intersection points are found four by solving and four only by the last step. Closes with a pair of equations that turn out to describe the same curve, and with describing regions of the plane by inequalities on r and theta.

Subject: Trigonometry · 66 slides · symbolic lesson

Open the interactive version of this deck

What this lesson covers

The lesson, slide by slide

1. Polar Intersections and Polar Regions

Title

Trigonometry · Section 11.5b

Where two polar curves really meet, and how to shade what lies between them

2. What this lesson gives you

Objectives

Two curves are drawn on the same axes and they visibly cross. In rectangular coordinates, finding the crossings means solving the two equations together, and that finds all of them. In polar coordinates it does not, and this lesson is about the gap.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, pp. 951-958 — the pages these objectives come from

Put your finger on the word every in the first paragraph. In every intersection problem you have done up to now, solving the two equations together was the whole job, and when the solving stopped the answer was complete. That guarantee is about to be withdrawn, and the rest of this lesson is about what replaces it.

Two things go wrong, and they are worth separating in your mind before you meet either of them. The first is the pole, which has a name for every possible direction and therefore never shows up as a shared angle. The second is a point that one curve labels with a positive distance and the other labels with a negative one; the two labels describe the same place, and an equation that has only seen one of them cannot report it.

The second half of the lesson looks easier and depends entirely on the first. To describe a region you need the angles at which its two boundary curves cross, so every region problem contains an intersection problem inside it. Learn the four guidelines properly here and the shading at the end costs almost nothing.

3. Before anything new: how many names has a point?

Warm-up

Discussion prompt

The point with rectangular coordinates one and the square root of three has polar coordinates two and pi over three. Write down three more polar coordinate pairs naming that same point, and say what rule you used.

Write your three extra names down before you reveal anything, and write the rule you used next to each one. If producing them felt slow, that is the single most useful thing you will learn about yourself today, because everything in this lesson is an application of those two rules.

The first rule adds or subtracts whole turns. It changes the label and nothing else, and it is the harmless one. The second rule negates the distance and adds a half turn: you face the opposite way and walk backwards, which lands you in exactly the same place by the other route.

Notice that the second rule is a trade, not a simplification. You have swapped a positive distance in one direction for a negative distance in the opposite direction, and an equation may happily accept one of those and flatly reject the other. That single fact is the reason an intersection problem in polar coordinates needs four steps instead of one.

4. Graphs meet where the points meet

Section

Part 1

5. A point of the plane has infinitely many names

Concept

Figure (svg): A polar grid of three concentric circles. A solid arrow of length two runs from the pole at sixty degrees to a point P; a dashed ray runs from the pole in the opposite direction, marked walk backwards.

Reach P by facing sixty degrees and walking two units forward, or by facing the opposite way and walking two units backwards. Same point, different names.

A rectangular pair names one point and one point names one pair. A polar pair still names one point, but a point answers to endlessly many pairs, and that asymmetry is where all the trouble starts.

\[ (r, \theta) \;\sim\; (r, \theta + 2\pi k) \;\sim\; (-r, \theta + (2k+1)\pi), \quad k \in \mathbb{Z} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 951 — the remark before Example 11.5.3

Look at the figure and follow both routes to the same dot. The solid arrow faces sixty degrees and walks two units forward. The dashed ray faces the opposite way, and you would walk two units backwards along it. Two completely different instructions, one destination.

The asymmetry is what matters. Going from a name to a point is a function: give me a distance and a direction and I will give you exactly one place. Going the other way is not: give me a place and I can hand you back endlessly many names for it, differing by whole turns and by that reversal.

An equation in r and the angle is a test, and a test can only be applied to a name. So when you ask whether a point is on a graph, you are really asking whether any one of its names passes the test. Hold on to that phrasing, because the next slide turns it into the definition of an intersection.

6. What it means for a point to be on both graphs

Concept

By the Fundamental Graphing Principle, a point lies on the graph of a polar equation when at least one of its names satisfies that equation. It need not be the same name for both graphs.

\[ P \text{ on } E_1 \iff \exists (r,\theta) \text{ naming } P \text{ with } E_1(r,\theta) \]

\[ P \text{ on both} \iff \exists (r,\theta), (r',\theta') \text{ naming } P, \; E_1(r,\theta), \; E_2(r',\theta') \]

Setting the two expressions for r equal asks a narrower question: is there a single name that satisfies both at once? Every point it finds is genuine, but it can miss points whose two names differ.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 951 — the paragraph introducing Example 11.5.3

Read the two displayed statements side by side and notice where the letters change. In the first, one name has to pass one test. In the second, there are two names and two tests, and nothing anywhere insists that the two names are the same name.

That is the whole difficulty in one line. When you set the two expressions for r equal to each other, you have quietly added a condition the definition never asked for: that a single name satisfies both equations at once. Every solution you get that way is genuine, so the method is sound. It is completeness you have lost.

It is worth naming the failure mode now so you recognise it later. If a point is on both graphs but the name that works for the first curve is not the name that works for the second, equating the two expressions can never see it. The three remaining guidelines exist to hand that point a second name.

7. Why rectangular coordinates never have this problem

Intuition

In rectangular coordinates a point has exactly one name. So a point lies on both curves precisely when its one and only pair of coordinates satisfies both equations, and solving the system finds every such pair. Nothing can hide.

Polar coordinates buy a great deal of convenience for circles, roses and spirals, and the price is paid here: the algebra now sees names, while the picture shows points. Every technique in this lesson is a way of closing that gap.

So the first move on any intersection problem is not algebra at all. It is a sketch, because the sketch counts the points, and the count is what tells you whether the algebra has finished.

Spend a moment appreciating why you have never had to think about any of this before. In rectangular coordinates the map from names to points runs both ways: one pair, one point, one point, one pair. A point on both curves has exactly one pair of coordinates, and that pair has no choice but to satisfy both equations.

So the completeness you have relied on since algebra was never a property of solving. It was a property of the coordinate system, borrowed without noticing. Polar coordinates give you circles and roses and spirals for almost nothing, and this is the bill.

The practical consequence is the habit this lesson is really teaching. On any polar intersection problem, your first move is to draw the two curves and count the crossings, because that count is the only thing in the whole problem that can tell you when the algebra has finished. Skip the sketch and you will stop early and never find out.

8. Three crossings, two of them solutions

Picture it

Figure (svg): A circle of radius one centred one unit above the pole, drawn through a heart-shaped cardioid that opens downward. Two green dots mark the crossings in the first and second quadrants, and a pink dot marks the pole where the two curves also meet.

Three crossings are visible. Setting the two expressions for r equal finds exactly two of them.

The circle and the cardioid cross in the first quadrant, in the second quadrant, and at the pole. The next slide equates the two expressions for r and gets two answers, not three.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 951 — Example 11.5.3, part 1, the sketch

Look carefully and count before reading on. There is a crossing up and to the right of the pole, a matching one up and to the left, and the two curves also both pass through the pole itself, which is marked in pink. Three places where the ink of one curve sits on the ink of the other.

The circle here is small: radius one, sitting one unit above the pole. The cardioid is the big heart opening downward, reaching four units below the pole at its furthest. They only have room to interact near the top, which is why the two green crossings are close together and close to the origin.

Now make a prediction and hold yourself to it. The next slide equates the two expressions for r and produces two points. Before you see it, decide which of the three you expect to be missing, and why the missing one might be special.

9. Example 11.5.3(1): the circle and the cardioid

Worked example

Find every point of intersection of the two graphs sketched above.

\[ r = 2\sin(\theta) \qquad\text{and}\qquad r = 2 - 2\sin(\theta) \]

Equate the two expressions for r

Why: This asks for a single name that satisfies both equations.

\[ 2\sin\theta = 2 - 2\sin\theta \]

Collect the sine terms

Why: Add two sine theta to both sides.

\[ 4\sin\theta = 2 \]

Solve for the sine

Why: Divide by four.

\[ \sin\theta = \tfrac12 \]

List the angles

Why: The sine takes the value one half at two angles on each turn.

\[ \theta = \tfrac{\pi}{6} + 2\pi k \quad\text{or}\quad \theta = \tfrac{5\pi}{6} + 2\pi k \]

Find r at each angle

Why: Both equations must give the same r, and they do.

\[ 2\sin\tfrac{\pi}{6} = 1 = 2 - 2\sin\tfrac{\pi}{6} \]

Check the pole on each curve separately

Why: The pole is on a curve when that curve's r is zero at some angle, whatever the angle is.

\[ 2\sin\theta = 0 \iff \theta = \pi k, \qquad 2 - 2\sin\theta = 0 \iff \theta = \tfrac{\pi}{2} + 2\pi k \]

Collect the answer

Why: Two points from the algebra, one from the pole check.

\[ \left(1, \tfrac{\pi}{6}\right), \quad \left(1, \tfrac{5\pi}{6}\right), \quad \text{and the pole} \]

Verify the first point in rectangular coordinates

Why: Convert it and compare with the sketch: it sits in the first quadrant, a little above and to the right of the pole, exactly where the two curves were seen to cross.

\[ (1)\left(\cos\tfrac{\pi}{6}, \sin\tfrac{\pi}{6}\right) = \left(\tfrac{\sqrt3}{2}, \tfrac12\right) \approx (0.866, 0.500) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 952 — Example 11.5.3, part 1

The first five steps are ordinary trigonometry and you should be able to run them without help: collect the sine terms, divide, read off the two angles where the sine is one half, then put each angle back to get the distance. Both equations return one at those angles, which is the confirmation that the names really do agree.

The step to slow down on is the pole check, and notice how differently it is phrased from everything above it. It does not ask where the two curves are at the pole together. It asks two separate questions, one per curve: is this curve ever at the pole at all? The circle answers yes, at whole multiples of half a turn. The cardioid answers yes, at a quarter turn. Neither answer mentions the other curve.

That is the entire reason the pole is a separate step. If you tried to find it by equating, you would be looking for an angle that appears in both lists, and there is not one. The book is explicit that the two curves are never at the origin simultaneously, and it does not matter in the slightest, because the origin is still a place they both visit.

10. The pole is the point whose angle is free

Concept

Figure (svg): A close-up of the pole. The circle comes in flat along the horizontal dashed line, the cardioid comes in vertically along the dashed line up the y-axis, and a pink dot marks the pole they share.

Both curves pass through the pole, each along its own ray. No single pair of coordinates can record both arrivals.

the pole — The origin. Its polar names are the pairs with r equal to zero and any angle whatever, so a curve passes through it as soon as its r hits zero once.

\[ (0, \theta) \text{ names the pole for every } \theta \]

That is why a shared pole survives no equation. The circle sits at the pole when the angle is a whole multiple of pi; the cardioid sits there when the angle is pi over two. Neither list contains a member of the other.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 952 — the discussion of the origin

The zoomed picture is the argument in one image. Look at how the two curves arrive: the circle comes into the pole flat, along the horizontal, and the cardioid comes in vertically, straight down the axis. They meet at the pole and they approach it along completely different rays.

For every other point of the plane the direction is pinned down, up to that one reversal. The pole is the exception: a distance of zero erases the direction entirely, so the pole answers to a name with any angle you like. There is nothing left for two angle lists to have in common, and nothing that needs to be.

So the test becomes wonderfully cheap. Take one curve on its own, set its r to zero, and ask only whether a solution exists. You do not care what the solution is. Do that for each curve, and if both say yes, the pole is a shared point. This is two lines of work and it is the step people most often leave out.

11. The zeros that never line up

Picture it

Figure (svg): The two r-functions plotted against theta on one set of axes. The circle's function crosses zero at nought, pi and two pi; the cardioid's touches zero only at pi over two. No zero is shared.

Equating the two functions asks for a shared height at a shared angle. The zeros happen at different angles, so this picture has nothing to report.

Here are the two right-hand sides plotted against the angle. Equating them looks for a crossing of the two curves in this picture, and there are two. Passing through the pole means touching the horizontal axis, and each curve does that, at angles the other one never uses.

This is the same fact again, drawn where the algebra lives. Both right-hand sides are plotted against the angle, so a simultaneous solution of the original system is a place where these two curves cross each other, and you can see there are exactly two of them, at a sixth and five sixths of a half turn.

Now look at the horizontal axis instead. A curve touching that axis means its r is zero, which means that curve is sitting at the pole. The circle's function crosses it three times over the full turn, at the start, the middle and the end. The cardioid's function only touches it once, at a quarter turn, where it bounces off rather than crossing.

The key observation is negative: there is no vertical line in this picture that passes through a dot of each colour. The zeros never happen at the same angle, so equating the two functions has nothing at all to say about the pole. The picture is not hiding the third intersection; the picture genuinely does not contain it.

12. Reading the pole check

Notation

Annotate

On: \( (0, \theta) \text{ is the pole for every } \theta \)

  • Only the first coordinate is pinned. Distance zero from the pole is the pole, whichever way you were facing.
  • This is what makes the pole special. Every other point has its direction fixed up to a half turn, so its names are constrained.
  • To ask whether a curve passes through the pole, solve r = 0 for that one curve alone. If it has any solution at all, the curve reaches the pole.
  • Do it twice, once per curve. If both tests succeed, the pole is an intersection point, even if the two angle lists are disjoint.

Work down the four annotations in order, because they build. The first two say what the pole is, and the last two say what to do about it.

The annotation labelled the test is the one to memorise as a sentence. Solve r equal to zero for one curve alone, and ask only whether a solution exists. Not which angle, not how many, just whether. Every time you find yourself comparing angles here you have drifted back into the habit the last three slides were trying to break.

The fourth annotation adds the only bookkeeping you need: do it twice, once per curve, and both must succeed. If only one curve reaches the pole, the pole is on one graph and not the other, and it is not an intersection. You will see exactly that happen two examples from now, with a circle centred at the pole that is never zero.

13. Trap: making the pole wait for a shared angle

Trap

The trap

A tempting write-up:

\[ 2\sin\theta = 0 \Rightarrow \theta = 0, \pi \]

\[ 2 - 2\sin\theta = 0 \Rightarrow \theta = \tfrac{\pi}{2} \]

no common angle,

so the pole is not an intersection.

The fix

Wrong. Intersection is about points, not about angles. Both curves visit the pole; nothing requires them to visit it at the same value of theta, any more than two roads crossing requires two cars to be there at the same moment.

\[ 0 \cdot (\cos 0, \sin 0) = (0,0) \]

\[ 0 \cdot \left(\cos\tfrac{\pi}{2}, \sin\tfrac{\pi}{2}\right) = (0,0) \]

Read the left column and notice how reasonable it looks. Every line of the algebra is correct. The two angle lists really are disjoint, and there really is no integer that makes them agree. The error is in the conclusion drawn from all that correct work.

The confusion is between a point and an event. The curves are sets of points, not vehicles moving through time, so there is no sense in which they have to arrive anywhere together. Two roads cross at a junction whether or not two cars reach it at the same moment, and the junction is on both roads either way.

The cost of this mistake is predictable and easy to spot in your own work. Any pair of curves that both pass through the origin will come out one point short, and it will always be the same missing point. If your count is one below the sketch, this is the first thing to check.

14. Does this curve reach the pole?

Sorting

Sort into buckets

For each equation, decide whether r is zero for at least one angle.

Reaches the pole
r = 6 sin θ; r = 1 − 2 cos θ; r = 3 − 5 cos θ
Never reaches it
r = 5; r = 3 + sin θ; r = 4 + 2 cos θ
yes
6 sin θ is zero at θ = 0; 1 − 2 cos θ is zero when cos θ = 1/2; 3 − 5 cos θ is zero when cos θ = 3/5. All three values are inside the range of the cosine, so each equation has a solution.
no
r = 5 is never zero. For 3 + sin θ the smallest value is 2, and for 4 + 2 cos θ it is 2, because the sine and cosine cannot go below −1. None of these curves comes closer to the pole than 2.

Sort all six before you reveal anything, and do it by arithmetic rather than by picturing the curves. The whole question is whether the expression on the right can be driven down to zero.

For a constant, the answer is no and there is nothing to think about. For anything of the form a constant plus a multiple of a sine or cosine, compare the two sizes: the smallest value the expression can take is the constant minus the size of the coefficient. Three plus a sine bottoms out at two, four plus twice a cosine bottoms out at two, and neither can reach the pole.

The last two are the ones that pay off. One minus twice a cosine reaches zero when the cosine is one half, and three minus five cosines reaches zero when the cosine is three fifths. Both of those values sit comfortably inside the range of the cosine, so both curves do visit the pole. Notice that three fifths is not a special angle at all, and it does not matter: you only needed to know that a solution exists.

15. Finish the pole check for the cardioid

Fill the middle

The cardioid from the worked example, tested on its own. Fill the two blanks.

Fill in the blanks

2 - 2\sin\theta = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \sin\theta = 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; \theta = \frac{\pi}{2} + 2\pi k

Why: Subtract two and divide by minus two: the sine must equal one, which happens only at a quarter turn. A solution exists, so the cardioid reaches the pole, and that is the whole test. The angle at which it happens is not compared with anything.

Fill both blanks before checking. Subtract two from each side and divide by minus two; the sine must be one, and the sine is one at exactly one angle in a turn.

Now say out loud what you have just established and what you have not. You have established that the cardioid passes through the pole, which was the entire question. You have also produced a specific angle, and that angle is a by-product with no further use here. Nothing is going to be compared with it.

This is the slide to come back to if the pole check ever feels arbitrary. It is not a weaker version of solving the system; it is a different question with a different shape of answer. Solving asks for angles. The pole check asks a yes or no.

16. The four guidelines

Section

Part 2

17. Two ways to rename a point, two extra equations

Concept

Figure (svg): A circle of radius three. A green arrow runs from the pole at sixty degrees to a marked point; a pink dashed ray runs from the pole at two hundred and forty degrees, the direction you face to reach the same point by walking backwards.

The same point carries a positive name on one ray and a negative name on the opposite ray. An equation can be satisfied by one and not the other.

A point's names come in exactly two flavours: same distance and a whole number of extra turns, or the negated distance and an odd number of half turns. So if solving misses a point, one of those two renamings is the reason.

\[ (r, \theta) \equiv (r, \theta + 2\pi k) \qquad (r, \theta) \equiv (-r, \theta + (2k+1)\pi) \]

The repair is to substitute each renaming into one of the equations and solve again. Into one only: doing it to both simply restates the original system in new letters.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, pp. 953-954 — the two cases, r equal and r negated

This slide is the bridge between the diagnosis and the cure, so make sure you see why the count is exactly two. Given a point with a nonzero distance, any other name for it either keeps the distance, in which case the direction can only differ by whole turns, or negates it, in which case the direction must differ by an odd number of half turns. There is no third possibility.

Two kinds of renaming means two extra equations to solve, and that is where guidelines three and four come from. They are not a grab bag of tricks. They are an exhaustive list, which is why running all four really does finish the problem.

The instruction to substitute into one equation only is the part people get wrong, and the reason is worth holding on to. The point of the substitution is to let the two equations look at two different names of the same place. Rename both sides and the two names move together, so you are back to the situation the direct solve already handled.

18. Reading the equivalence rule as a recipe

Notation

Annotate

On: \( (r, \theta) \;\equiv\; (r, \theta + 2\pi k) \;\equiv\; (-r, \theta + (2k+1)\pi) \)

  • The name you already have: the one that satisfies the first equation.
  • Same direction, extra whole turns. Substituting this into the other equation is step 3.
  • Opposite direction, negated distance. Substituting this is step 4, and it is the one that finds hidden points.
  • Any integer, positive or negative. In practice you simplify the trigonometric expression until k disappears, and read off what is left.
  • This rule assumes r is not zero. The pole is exactly the case it does not cover, which is why the pole gets its own step.

Take the three expressions left to right as three descriptions of one place, and match them to the three numbered steps. The left is the name you already have, the middle is what step three substitutes, and the right is what step four substitutes.

The annotation on the integer k deserves a second look, because it worries people. You are not going to solve anything for k. You substitute, simplify the trigonometry until the whole number of turns disappears inside the sine or cosine, and read off whatever equation is left. Sometimes k vanishes completely and sometimes it survives as a sign, which is the case you will meet in part four of the example.

The last annotation is the one that ties this part back to the last one. This rule assumes the distance is not zero, so it says nothing whatever about the pole. The pole is the one point the renaming machinery cannot reach, and that is precisely why it needed a step of its own.

19. The guidelines, as the book states them

Concept

Guidelines for finding points of intersection — Sketch both graphs and check whether each passes through the pole. Solve for pairs satisfying both equations. Substitute theta plus a whole number of turns into one equation and solve again. Substitute negated r and theta plus an odd number of half turns into one equation and solve again.

  1. Sketch first. The picture counts the crossings, so you know when to stop.
  2. Check the pole on each curve alone, by setting its r to zero.
  3. Solve directly. This finds every point whose two names agree.
  4. Shift the angle by a full turn in one equation, and solve again.
  5. Flip the sign of r and shift by a half turn in one equation, and solve again.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 955 — Guidelines for Finding Points of Intersection

This is the book's own list, and the thing to notice is that sketching is item one rather than advice in the margin. The sketch is load bearing. Without it you have no target count, and without a target count nothing in the remaining three steps ever tells you to stop.

Read the list as three different questions rather than four procedures. Does either curve touch the pole? Is there a name both equations accept? Is there a pair of different names, one for each equation, describing one place? The last question splits in two only because there are two ways for names to differ.

Commit the phrase but not both to memory now. It appears in the book twice, in both of the substitution steps, and it is the single instruction that most often gets dropped. The error analysis two slides from here shows exactly what you get if you drop it.

20. Example 11.5.3(2): two circles, and a pole on only one

Worked example

Find the intersections of a circle centred at the pole with a circle through the pole.

\[ r = 2 \qquad\text{and}\qquad r = 3\cos(\theta) \]

Equate the expressions for r

Why: The first equation supplies the constant.

\[ 2 = 3\cos\theta \]

Isolate the cosine

Why: Divide by three.

\[ \cos\theta = \tfrac23 \]

Solve with the arccosine

Why: Two thirds is not a special value, so the answer stays in inverse-function form.

\[ \theta = \arccos\left(\tfrac23\right) + 2\pi k \quad\text{or}\quad \theta = 2\pi - \arccos\left(\tfrac23\right) + 2\pi k \]

Name the two points

Why: One in the first quadrant, one in the fourth.

\[ \left(2, \arccos\tfrac23\right) \quad\text{and}\quad \left(2, 2\pi - \arccos\tfrac23\right) \]

Check the pole on each curve

Why: The first equation has no zero at all, so the pole is not shared.

\[ 2 = 0 \text{: impossible}, \qquad 3\cos\theta = 0 \iff \theta = \tfrac{\pi}{2} + \pi k \]

Run the sign flip on the second equation

Why: Substituting negated r and a half turn returns the very same equation, so it produces nothing new.

\[ -r = 3\cos(\theta + \pi) = -3\cos\theta \;\Longrightarrow\; r = 3\cos\theta \]

Figure (svg): Two overlapping circles: one of radius two centred at the pole, one of radius one and a half through the pole and the point three on the x-axis. Green dots mark the two crossings; a hollow red circle marks the pole, which lies on the smaller circle only.

Here the pole check fails: one curve reaches the pole and the other cannot, so the pole is not a shared point.

Verify the first point numerically

Why: The arccosine of two thirds is 0.8411 radians, about 48.19 degrees; the second circle's r there is exactly 2, and the rectangular point is 1.333 and 1.491, matching the crossing in the sketch.

\[ 3\cos(0.8411) = 2.000, \qquad 2\left(\cos 0.8411, \sin 0.8411\right) \approx (1.333, 1.491) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, pp. 952-953 — Example 11.5.3, part 2

Compare this with the last worked example and notice how much of the work is the same. Equate, isolate the trigonometric function, solve. The only difference is that two thirds is not a value the cosine takes at any special angle, so the answer has to stay in terms of the arccosine, which is perfectly respectable and not a sign that you have gone wrong.

The pole check goes the other way this time, and that is the point of including the example. The first equation says the distance is two, always, and two is never zero, so that circle simply does not pass through the origin. The other circle does. One yes and one no is a no, and the hollow marker in the figure is there to remind you that a point on one graph only is not an intersection.

The sign flip is worth watching too, because it is a genuine result rather than a wasted step. Substituting into the second equation gives you back the very same equation, and the reason is the identity you know: a cosine picks up a minus sign under a half turn, and that minus cancels against the minus on r. When the substitution reproduces the original, you are guaranteed nothing new, and you can say so in one line and move on.

21. Put the guidelines in working order

Ranking

Put in order

Order the five moves of a complete intersection argument.

  1. Sketch both curves and count the crossings
  2. Set each curve's r to zero on its own, to test the pole
  3. Equate the two expressions for r and solve
  4. Replace theta by theta plus a whole turn in one equation and solve again
  5. Replace r by its negative and theta by a half turn more, in one equation, and solve again

Why: The sketch comes first because it supplies the target count. The pole test is cheap and is the one thing no substitution will ever find. Then the direct solve, then the two renamings, which are only worth running once you know the direct solve has left something out.

Drag all five into place before checking. Two of the orderings are forced and the rest follow from them.

The sketch has to be first because everything after it is measured against its count. The pole check should come early for a different reason: it is cheap, it takes two lines, and it is the one point no amount of substituting will ever produce. Get it out of the way while it is still the easy step.

The two substitutions come last, and in that order, because the direct solve tells you whether you need them. If your four steps have already matched the count from the sketch, you can stop. If they have not, the sign flip is the one far more likely to be hiding the remainder, since the angle shift so often just reproduces the equation you started with.

22. Find the error: substituting into both equations

Error analysis

A student, asked to run the sign flip on the circle and the rose, applies it to each equation at once.

Annotate

On: \( -r = 6\cos\bigl(2(\theta+\pi)\bigr) \quad\text{and}\quad -r = 3 \)

  • Renaming both sides renames the same point twice. The system that comes out is the original system with r replaced by minus r throughout, so it has exactly the original solutions, written backwards.
  • The substitution is meant to let one equation see a DIFFERENT name of the point than the other equation sees. Applying it to both keeps the two names in step, which is the situation the direct solve already covered.
  • Apply it to one equation only. Which one is your choice: pick the one whose algebra is easier, which here is the rose, since the circle has no theta in it at all.
  • The book notes that substituting into r = 3 instead gives minus r equal to 3, that is r equal to minus 3, which coupled with the rose gives the same four new points with less work.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 954 — footnotes 13 and 15

See whether you can name the error before the annotations. Nothing here is algebraically illegal, which is what makes it hard to catch: the substitution is applied correctly, just applied twice.

The second annotation is the explanation worth internalising. The substitution exists to break the lockstep between the two equations, so that one of them can be looking at a different name of the point than the other. Applying it on both sides keeps them in step and simply relabels the whole system, which cannot produce a solution the original system did not already have.

The last annotation is a genuine time saver from the book's own footnotes, and it is the version to use in practice. Put the substitution into whichever equation has less angle in it. Here the circle is just a constant, so negating r turns it into a demand that r be minus three, and coupling that with the untouched rose gives the four missing points with far less algebra than going through the rose.

23. Before you solve anything

Step zero

\[ r = 3 \qquad\text{and}\qquad r = 6\cos(2\theta) \]

Discussion prompt

You are about to find the intersections of a circle of radius three with a four-petal rose reaching out to six. Before touching the algebra: sketch them, and say how many crossings there should be and why. Then say what the pole check gives.

Sketch the two curves on paper before you read either answer, and make the count yourself. A rose with four petals reaching out to six, and a fence at distance three all the way round.

The reasoning for the count should be about the journey, not about any equation. Each petal starts at the pole, travels out to six, and comes back, so each petal has to get past distance three on the way out and again on the way back. Two crossings a petal, four petals, eight in all. That number is now your target, and it was produced without solving anything.

The pole answer is the other half of the preparation, and it goes the opposite way from the first example. The rose visits the pole four times, but the circle of radius three never does, so the pole is not a shared point. Knowing that before you start means you will not waste time hunting for it later or wrongly add it to your list.

24. Eight points, four steps

Section

Part 3

25. Eight crossings on one circle

Picture it

Figure (svg): A four-petal rose reaching out to six, crossed by a circle of radius three. Eight crossings are marked on the circle: four green ones at thirty, one hundred and fifty, two hundred and ten and three hundred and thirty degrees, and four pink ones at sixty, one hundred and twenty, two hundred and forty and three hundred degrees.

Eight crossings, evenly spaced around the circle. The algebra, run once, produces four of them.

The eight crossings sit thirty degrees apart around the circle. Four of them are coloured green and four pink, and the next five slides are about why one colour comes out of the algebra and the other does not.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 953 — Example 11.5.3, part 3, the sketch

Take a slow look at where the eight dots sit. They are evenly spaced around the circle, thirty degrees apart, and they alternate in colour. The alternation is not decoration: it is the whole content of this part of the lesson.

The four green ones are at thirty, one hundred and fifty, two hundred and ten and three hundred and thirty degrees, and each sits on a petal. The four pink ones are at sixty, one hundred and twenty, two hundred and forty and three hundred degrees, and they also sit on petals, but on petals that the rose traces while its r is negative.

That is the distinction the next several slides unpack. A petal drawn with a negative r is drawn in the opposite direction from the angle that produced it, so the crossings on it carry names with a negative first coordinate. An equation whose left-hand side is a plain positive three has no way of returning such a name.

26. Why each petal crosses the circle twice

Intuition

Follow one petal. It leaves the pole, swings out to its tip at distance six, and returns to the pole. The circle of radius three is a fence at a fixed distance, so the petal must cross that fence once on the way out and once on the way back.

\[ 0 \to 6 \to 0 \quad\text{crosses}\quad 3 \quad\text{twice} \]

Four petals, two crossings each, eight in all. The count comes from the shape of the journey, not from any equation, and that is exactly why it can be trusted as a check on the algebra.

Notice too that the petals opposite each other are traced with a negative distance, since the cosine of twice the angle is negative there. That is the seed of the trouble the next few slides expose.

This is a counting argument and it is worth doing in your head rather than on paper. Put your finger at the pole and trace one petal: out from zero, all the way to six at the tip, and back to zero. Your finger's distance from the pole went up and came back down.

A distance that starts at zero, rises to six and returns to zero has to pass through three twice, once on each leg of the journey. Nothing about roses or cosines is needed for that; it is just the fact that a continuous quantity cannot get from zero to six without visiting everything in between.

The reason to trust this count more than the algebra is that it comes from the shape rather than from a manipulation. You cannot forget a step in it. That is why the sketch is the reference against which the algebra is judged, rather than the other way round, and it is also why the last paragraph on this slide matters: opposite petals are traced with a negative distance, and you have just counted their crossings too.

27. How much will one round of algebra find?

Estimation

Predict first

The sketch shows eight crossings. Equating the two expressions for r gives a cosine equation. How many of the eight will that equation produce?

  • All eight
  • Four of them
  • Two of them
  • None of them, the pole aside

Correct: Four of them

Why: Equating gives the cosine of twice theta equal to one half, which has four solutions on a full turn, each with r equal to three. The other four crossings are reached by the rose with r equal to minus three, and an equation that has r equal to three on the left can never report those.

Commit to an option before you reveal. It is worth being wrong here, because the gap between what you expect and what comes out is the thing this part of the lesson is about.

Work it through if you want certainty. Equating gives the cosine of twice the angle equal to one half. Twice the angle therefore lands at plus or minus a sixth of a full turn, and adding whole turns to that and halving gives four distinct angles over one turn. Four solutions, each with the distance equal to three.

Now compare with the sketch: eight drawn, four found, so half the answer is missing. The reason is structural rather than arithmetic. Every solution this equation can ever produce has r equal to three, because that is literally what the first equation says, and four of the eight crossings are recorded by the rose with r equal to minus three instead.

28. Example 11.5.3(3a): the four the algebra reports

Worked example

Run the direct solve on the circle and the rose.

\[ r = 3 \qquad\text{and}\qquad r = 6\cos(2\theta) \]

Equate the expressions for r

Why: Both equal r, so they equal each other.

\[ 6\cos(2\theta) = 3 \]

Isolate the cosine

Why: Divide by six.

\[ \cos(2\theta) = \tfrac12 \]

Solve for twice the angle

Why: The cosine is one half at plus and minus pi over three.

\[ 2\theta = \pm\tfrac{\pi}{3} + 2\pi k \]

Halve everything

Why: Dividing the whole turn by two leaves half turns.

\[ \theta = \tfrac{\pi}{6} + \pi k \quad\text{or}\quad \theta = \tfrac{5\pi}{6} + \pi k \]

List the distinct points

Why: Four of them, each at distance three from the pole.

\[ \left(3,\tfrac{\pi}{6}\right), \; \left(3,\tfrac{5\pi}{6}\right), \; \left(3,\tfrac{7\pi}{6}\right), \; \left(3,\tfrac{11\pi}{6}\right) \]

Check the count against the sketch

Why: The sketch showed eight crossings and the algebra has produced four, at thirty, one hundred and fifty, two hundred and ten and three hundred and thirty degrees. Four points are unaccounted for, so the work is not finished.

\[ 6\cos\left(2\cdot\tfrac{\pi}{6}\right) = 6\cos\tfrac{\pi}{3} = 3 \;\checkmark \qquad 4 \text{ found of } 8 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 953 — Example 11.5.3, part 3

The algebra here is short and you should be fluent in it, but watch the halving step specifically. You solve for twice the angle first, and the whole turns that come with the general solution become half turns when you divide by two. Forget that and you will report two angles instead of four.

Check the four angles against the picture as you list them: thirty, one hundred and fifty, two hundred and ten and three hundred and thirty degrees. Those are the green dots, one on each petal, and each is at distance three, which is the circle. Everything on this slide is correct as far as it goes.

The last step is the one that makes this a teaching example rather than a routine solve. It does not verify an answer; it verifies that the answer is incomplete. Four found against eight drawn is a mismatch, and the discipline being built here is to write that comparison down every time rather than stopping the moment the algebra runs out of things to do.

29. Example 11.5.3(3b): shifting the angle changes nothing

Worked example

Step 3: replace theta by theta plus a whole number of turns, in the rose equation only.

Substitute the shifted angle

Why: Only the rose has a theta in it, so only the rose can change.

\[ r = 6\cos\bigl(2(\theta + 2\pi k)\bigr) \]

Expand the argument

Why: The factor of two multiplies the shift as well.

\[ 2(\theta + 2\pi k) = 2\theta + 4\pi k \]

Reduce the cosine

Why: Four pi k is a whole number of turns, which the cosine cannot see.

\[ \cos(2\theta + 4\pi k) = \cos(2\theta) \]

Compare with the equation you started from

Why: It is the same equation, so it has the same solutions and yields no new points.

\[ r = 6\cos(2\theta) \]

Verify on a shifted angle

Why: Take the angle pi over six plus a full turn: the rose gives three again, and the point is the one already on the list.

\[ 6\cos\left(2\left(\tfrac{\pi}{6} + 2\pi\right)\right) = 6\cos\left(\tfrac{\pi}{3} + 4\pi\right) = 3 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 953 — Example 11.5.3, part 3, the first substitution

This is guideline three, and it is included precisely because it fails. Watch the factor of two: it multiplies the shift as well as the angle, so a whole turn added to the angle becomes two whole turns inside the cosine, and the cosine cannot see whole turns at all.

So the substituted equation is the original equation, character for character. That is a result and not a dead end. It tells you that no point of intersection can be hiding behind a difference of whole turns, and you can cross guideline three off with confidence rather than wondering whether you did it wrong.

Get used to this outcome, because it is the common one. Whenever the angle appears inside a sine or cosine multiplied by a whole number, adding whole turns to the angle adds whole turns inside the function, and the step is guaranteed to be empty. The step earns its keep in the rarer case where the angle is divided by something, which is exactly what happens in part four.

30. Where the other four are hiding

Concept

Figure (svg): The rose function six cosine two theta plotted against theta over a full turn, a wave between minus six and six. Four green dots sit where it equals three and four pink dots where it equals minus three.

The circle of radius three is met wherever the rose's r is three OR minus three. Only the first four survive the equation as written.

A point sits on the circle of radius three when its distance from the pole is three. On the rose, that happens whenever the value of six cosine two theta is three, and also whenever it is minus three, because a negative r of size three lands the same distance away, in the opposite direction.

\[ \text{distance } 3 \iff |6\cos(2\theta)| = 3 \iff \cos(2\theta) = \pm\tfrac12 \]

The equation the direct solve wrote down was six cosine two theta equal to three. It cannot see the lower line, and the lower line is worth four points.

This picture answers the question the last three slides have been circling. On the horizontal axis is the angle and on the vertical is the rose's r, running from minus six to six over the turn. The circle of radius three is not one line here but two, at height three and at height minus three.

The reason there are two is worth saying slowly. Being on the circle means being at distance three from the pole, and distance is the size of r, not r itself. A point whose r is minus three is three units away from the pole, just in the direction opposite the one the angle names. So both lines describe the circle.

Count the dots: four green where the wave meets the upper line and four pink where it meets the lower one, eight altogether, matching the sketch exactly. The equation you wrote in the direct solve put the number three on one side with no absolute value anywhere, so it was only ever going to find the upper line. Nothing was done wrong; the question asked was too narrow.

31. Example 11.5.3(3c): the sign flip finds the rest

Worked example

Step 4: replace r by its negative and theta by an odd number of half turns more, in the rose equation only.

Substitute both replacements

Why: Negated distance on the left, shifted angle on the right.

\[ -r = 6\cos\bigl(2(\theta + (2k+1)\pi)\bigr) \]

Expand the argument

Why: Twice an odd multiple of pi is an even multiple of pi.

\[ 2\theta + (2k+1)(2\pi) \]

Reduce the cosine

Why: Whole turns again vanish inside the cosine.

\[ \cos\bigl(2\theta + (2k+1)(2\pi)\bigr) = \cos(2\theta) \]

Rearrange into an equation for r

Why: Multiply both sides by minus one.

\[ r = -6\cos(2\theta) \]

Couple it with the circle

Why: Now the constant three meets the negated rose.

\[ -6\cos(2\theta) = 3 \]

Isolate the cosine

Why: Divide by minus six.

\[ \cos(2\theta) = -\tfrac12 \]

Solve for the angle

Why: The cosine is minus one half at two thirds of pi and its reflection.

\[ \theta = \tfrac{\pi}{3} + \pi k \quad\text{or}\quad \theta = \tfrac{2\pi}{3} + \pi k \]

List the four new points

Why: Read the r from the rose: it is minus three at each of these angles.

\[ \left(-3,\tfrac{\pi}{3}\right), \; \left(-3,\tfrac{2\pi}{3}\right), \; \left(-3,\tfrac{4\pi}{3}\right), \; \left(-3,\tfrac{5\pi}{3}\right) \]

Verify one of them lies on the circle

Why: Convert the first: the negated distance points it the opposite way, to the rectangular point minus 1.5 and minus 2.598, whose distance from the pole is exactly three, so it is on the circle as well.

\[ (-3)\left(\cos\tfrac{\pi}{3}, \sin\tfrac{\pi}{3}\right) = (-1.5, -2.598), \quad \sqrt{1.5^2 + 2.598^2} = 3.000 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 954 — Example 11.5.3, part 3, the second substitution

Work down the first four steps watching only what happens to the cosine. Twice an odd multiple of a half turn is an even multiple of a half turn, that is, a whole number of full turns, and the cosine ignores those. So the entire effect of the substitution survives on the left-hand side, as the minus in front of r.

Multiply through and you have a genuinely new equation: r equals minus six times the cosine of twice the angle. This is the first time in the problem that the algebra has been allowed to consider a negative distance, and the moment you couple it with the circle you get the cosine equal to minus one half and four new angles at sixty, one hundred and twenty, two hundred and forty and three hundred degrees.

Read the four answers carefully, because their form is unfamiliar. Each has a negative first coordinate. The last step converts one of them and measures: facing sixty degrees and walking three units backwards lands you down and to the left, at a distance of exactly three from the pole. It is on the circle, and the picture confirms it is one of the pink dots. Eight found, eight drawn, and now the problem is finished.

32. Trap: stopping when the algebra stops

Trap

The trap

A complete and correct calculation:

\[ 6\cos(2\theta) = 3 \]

\[ \theta = \tfrac{\pi}{6}, \tfrac{5\pi}{6}, \tfrac{7\pi}{6}, \tfrac{11\pi}{6} \]

Four points. Every line of it is right, and the answer is half of the answer.

The fix

Nothing in the algebra announces that it has finished. Only the sketch does. Eight crossings were drawn, four were produced, so four are missing and there is more work to do.

The habit to build: count on the picture first, and compare at the end. A mismatch is the signal to run steps three and four.

\[ 8 \text{ drawn} \ne 4 \text{ found} \]

Look at the left column and try to find a line that is wrong. There is not one. The equation is right, the solving is right, the four angles are right, and the four points really are intersections. This is what makes the error dangerous: nothing in the work itself is available to warn you.

What is missing is external. The algebra has no way of knowing how many answers there should be, and no equation ever announces that it has given you all of them. Only the picture carries that information, which is why the sketch is a step of the procedure rather than a nicety.

Build the comparison into your write-up as a physical habit. Write the expected count at the top of the page as soon as you have sketched, and write the found count next to it before you box anything. A mismatch is not a disaster; it is an instruction to go and run steps three and four.

33. Slide the radius and count the crossings

Tweak it

Parameter explorer

The curve plotted is the distance from the pole to the rose, minus the radius a. Every crossing of the horizontal axis is an angle at which the rose meets the circle of radius a. Slide a from 1 up to 7 and count the crossings on one full turn.

\[ \bigl| 6\cos(2\theta) \bigr| - {a} \]

  • a — from 1 to 7: circle radius a

The absolute value is doing the work. Distance from the pole is the size of r, so it counts the negative values of r too, which is exactly what the unmodified equation refuses to do.

Before you touch the slider, read what is plotted: the distance from the pole to the rose, with the radius subtracted. The absolute value is there deliberately, because distance is the size of r, so this curve counts the negative values of r as well. That is the difference between this picture and the equation you solved first.

Leave the radius at three and count the crossings of the horizontal axis over one turn. There should be eight, which is the number the sketch gave you and the number the plain equation refused to produce. Now push the radius up towards six and watch the crossings pair off and merge.

At exactly six there are four, and they are the petal tips, where the circle touches the rose without cutting through it. Above six there are none at all, because the circle is then entirely outside the rose. If you ever want to know how many intersections to expect before doing any algebra, this is the picture to imagine: a horizontal line sliding up through the graph of the distance.

34. When the sign flip can matter, and when it cannot

Intuition

The substitution takes an equation and returns another equation. Sometimes the new one is the old one, and then the step is guaranteed to give nothing; sometimes it is genuinely different, and then it is worth solving.

\[ r = 3\cos\theta \;\longmapsto\; -r = 3\cos(\theta+\pi) = -3\cos\theta \;\Longrightarrow\; r = 3\cos\theta \]

\[ r = 6\cos(2\theta) \;\longmapsto\; -r = 6\cos(2\theta) \;\Longrightarrow\; r = -6\cos(2\theta) \]

The circle through the pole is unchanged, so its four steps collapse to two. The rose changes sign, so its step four is a new equation and finds four new points. The difference is whether the half turn lands inside the trigonometric function as a half turn or as a whole one.

Two examples sit side by side here and the contrast is the lesson. In both, the substitution is performed identically; the difference is entirely in what the trigonometry does with the half turn.

In the first, the angle appears on its own inside the cosine, so the half turn goes in as a half turn and the cosine flips sign. That flip cancels against the minus on r and you get your original equation back. Guaranteed nothing new, and you can say so immediately.

In the second, the angle is multiplied by two, so the half turn becomes a whole turn inside the cosine and is invisible there. The minus on r has nothing to cancel against and survives. New equation, new solutions. The rule to carry away: look at what the coefficient of the angle does to a half turn before you commit to grinding through the substitution, and you will often be able to predict the outcome in a line.

35. Which step produced each point?

Sorting

Sort into buckets

Each point below is a genuine intersection. Say which move of the guidelines produces it.

The pole check
the origin, for r = 2 sin θ and r = 2 − 2 sin θ; the origin, for r = 3 cos θ and r = 1 + cos θ
Solving directly
(3, π/6) for r = 3 and r = 6 cos 2θ; (1, 5π/6) for r = 2 sin θ and r = 2 − 2 sin θ
The sign flip
(−3, π/3) for r = 3 and r = 6 cos 2θ; (1, π) for r = 1 − 2 cos θ and r = 1
pole
Both origins come from setting each curve's r to zero on its own. For the circle and cardioid the angles are multiples of pi and pi over two; for the two curves in the last pair they are pi over two and pi. No shared angle, and it does not matter.
solve
These two have names that satisfy both equations as written, so equating the two expressions for r finds them at once.
flip
In each of these the point's name on one curve has a negative first coordinate. Only the substitution that negates r and adds a half turn lets one equation see that name.

Sort all six before checking, and diagnose rather than guess. There are only three questions to ask of each item, and they come in a fixed order.

Is the point the origin? If so it came from the pole check, always, and no amount of solving would have found it. Otherwise, look at the first coordinate: is it negative? A negative first coordinate is the signature of the sign flip, because no equation with a positive expression on one side can produce such a name. Everything else came from equating the two expressions directly.

The last item is the one worth pausing on, since it has a positive first coordinate and still comes from the flip. The name given happens to be the positive one, but the limacon reaches that point with a negative r at a different angle, so the two curves label it with opposite signs. When in doubt, ask which name each curve uses, not which name you have been handed.

36. Exercise 24: the sign flip pays off again

Worked example

Exercise 24 from the section: find all the points of intersection.

\[ r = 1 - 2\cos(\theta) \qquad\text{and}\qquad r = 1 \]

Equate the expressions for r

Why: The constant on the right does the work.

\[ 1 - 2\cos\theta = 1 \]

Solve for the cosine

Why: Subtract one and divide by minus two.

\[ \cos\theta = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \theta = \tfrac{\pi}{2} + \pi k \]

Name the direct solutions

Why: Two points, at the top and the bottom of the unit circle.

\[ \left(1, \tfrac{\pi}{2}\right) \quad\text{and}\quad \left(1, \tfrac{3\pi}{2}\right) \]

Check the pole

Why: The second curve is never zero, so the pole cannot be shared.

\[ 1 = 0 \text{: impossible} \]

Apply the sign flip to the limacon

Why: Negate r and add a half turn to the angle.

\[ -r = 1 - 2\cos(\theta + \pi) = 1 + 2\cos\theta \]

Rearrange

Why: Multiply through by minus one.

\[ r = -1 - 2\cos\theta \]

Couple it with the circle

Why: Set the new expression equal to one.

\[ -1 - 2\cos\theta = 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; \cos\theta = -1 \]

Solve

Why: The cosine is minus one at half a turn.

\[ \theta = \pi \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{the point } (1, \pi) \]

Verify the extra point is on the limacon

Why: The pair one and pi names the rectangular point minus one and zero. Read that point off the limacon at angle zero: its r there is minus one, which is the same point, so it is genuinely on both curves and the direct solve had indeed missed it.

\[ 1 - 2\cos 0 = -1, \qquad (-1)(\cos 0, \sin 0) = (-1, 0) = (1)(\cos\pi, \sin\pi) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 958 — Exercise 24

This one is worth doing yourself before reading the steps, because the numbers are friendly and the shape of the argument is identical to the rose. A limacon with an inner loop, and a circle of radius one.

The direct solve is three lines and gives the top and bottom of the unit circle. The pole check fails at once, because the second curve is the constant one and one is never zero. So after two of the four guidelines you have two points, and if you had sketched first you would know there is a third.

The sign flip is where the exercise earns its place. Substituting into the limacon turns minus into plus in front of the cosine, and the resulting equation forces the cosine to be minus one, which happens at a half turn. The extra point sits one unit to the left of the pole. Trace the final check carefully: the limacon reaches that point at angle zero with an r of minus one, while the circle reaches it at a half turn with an r of plus one. Same place, opposite signs, exactly the configuration the direct solve cannot see.

37. Match each move to what only it can find

Matching

Match the pairs

  • l1. sketch and count
  • l2. check r = 0 on each curve
  • l3. equate the two expressions for r
  • l4. negate r and add a half turn
  • r1. the number the algebra has to reach
  • r2. the one point whose angle is unconstrained
  • r3. every point whose two names agree
  • r4. points seen with opposite signs by the two curves

Why: The sketch is not decoration: it supplies the target count, and without it nothing tells you the algebra has stopped early. The pole check handles the single point whose names put no constraint on the angle. Direct solving handles agreement of names, and the sign flip handles disagreement.

Make all four pairings before checking, and read the right-hand column as a list of exclusive rights. Each move finds something no other move can.

The sketch is the odd one out and the one most likely to be undervalued. It does not find a point at all; it supplies the number the algebra has to reach. Strike it out and the other three still work, but you lose every means of knowing whether they have finished.

The remaining three split the points cleanly by how the two curves name them. Unconstrained angle means the pole. Names that agree means the direct solve. Names that disagree in sign means the flip. Those three cases cover every possibility, which is the real justification for the guidelines being a complete procedure rather than a checklist of ideas.

38. Two equations, one curve

Section

Part 4

39. What if the substitution turns into the other equation?

Concept

Figure (svg): Two half-period waves over an interval of four pi: a solid sine-like curve and a dashed cosine-like curve, shifted from one another. Yellow dots mark the two places where their heights agree.

Plotted against the angle, the two are plainly different functions. That is what makes the next picture a surprise.

Here are two equations that plainly define different functions of the angle: a sine of half the angle and a cosine of half the angle, which agree at only two angles over the interval needed to draw them.

\[ r = 3\sin\left(\tfrac{\theta}{2}\right) \qquad\text{and}\qquad r = 3\cos\left(\tfrac{\theta}{2}\right), \quad 0 \le \theta \le 4\pi \]

If the sign-flip substitution turned one of these equations into the other, then every single point of one graph would automatically be on the other. That would not be four intersection points, or eight; it would be all of them.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 954 — Example 11.5.3, part 4

Look at the two functions plotted here and satisfy yourself that they are genuinely different. One is a sine of half the angle and the other is a cosine of half the angle, they are a quarter of their own period apart, and over the full interval needed to draw them they agree at only two angles. The book's footnote puts it well: viewed as functions, these are two different animals.

Now read the last paragraph on the slide as a hypothetical and take it seriously. Suppose the sign-flip substitution applied to one of these equations produced the other one exactly. Then every name satisfying the first would automatically hand you a name of the same point satisfying the second, with no exceptions and no solving.

That would not be an intersection problem with an unusually large answer. It would mean the two equations have the same graph, and the phrase points of intersection stops being the right question. Keep that possibility in mind as the algebra unfolds over the next three slides, because it is what actually happens.

40. Different equations, identical graphs

Picture it

Figure (svg): A closed looping curve drawn thick, with a thin dashed curve lying exactly on top of it everywhere. Two yellow dots on the y-axis mark the only two points the algebra reports.

The dashed curve never leaves the solid one. Every point of this curve is an intersection point, and the algebra reports two.

Both are drawn here, one thick and one dashed, and the dashed one never appears beside the thick one. Whatever the angle, the two equations sweep out the same set of points, just in a different order and with different labels.

This is the payoff picture, and the thing to look for is what is absent. The dashed curve is drawn on top of the solid one, and nowhere, at any point of the loop, does it peel away. There is no stretch of dashed curve sitting on its own anywhere in the frame.

So the two equations sweep out the same set of points. They do it differently, starting in different places and labelling each point with a different pair, but the set of places visited is identical. Compare this with the previous slide, where the two functions were plainly different, and you have the sharpest example in the whole lesson of the gap between names and points.

The two yellow dots are there as a warning. They are the answer the direct solve reports, and they are correct: those two points really are on both graphs. They are also two out of infinitely many, which is what happens when you trust a count that came out of the algebra.

41. Example 11.5.3(4a): the direct solve finds one point

Worked example

Start where you always start: with the two names agreeing.

Equate the two expressions

Why: The threes will cancel.

\[ 3\sin\left(\tfrac{\theta}{2}\right) = 3\cos\left(\tfrac{\theta}{2}\right) \]

Justify dividing by the cosine

Why: If the cosine were zero the left side would have to be zero too, and no angle has both sine and cosine zero, so the cosine is safe to divide by.

\[ \cos\left(\tfrac{\theta}{2}\right) = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \sin\left(\tfrac{\theta}{2}\right) = 0 \text{: impossible} \]

Divide

Why: A sine over a cosine is a tangent.

\[ \tan\left(\tfrac{\theta}{2}\right) = 1 \]

Solve for half the angle

Why: The tangent is one at a quarter turn, and repeats every half turn.

\[ \tfrac{\theta}{2} = \tfrac{\pi}{4} + \pi k \]

Double

Why: Multiply through by two.

\[ \theta = \tfrac{\pi}{2} + 2\pi k \]

Find r

Why: Put the angle into either equation.

\[ r = 3\sin\left(\tfrac{\pi}{4}\right) = \tfrac{3\sqrt2}{2} \approx 2.121 \]

Verify both equations give it

Why: The sine and the cosine of a quarter turn are equal, so both sides come out at 2.1213, and the point is the one on the positive y-axis in the picture.

\[ 3\sin\left(\tfrac{\pi}{4}\right) = 2.1213 = 3\cos\left(\tfrac{\pi}{4}\right) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, pp. 954-955 — Example 11.5.3, part 4, the direct solution

Most of this is familiar, but the second step is a piece of care you should copy. Dividing by a variable expression is usually forbidden, so the book stops and justifies it: if the cosine of half the angle were zero then the equation would force the sine of half the angle to be zero as well, and no angle has both. The divisor is therefore safe.

After that the work is quick. Sine over cosine is tangent, the tangent is one at an eighth of a turn, and doubling gives a quarter turn for the angle itself. Putting that back gives a distance of about 2.121, and the point sits on the vertical axis above the pole, which you can find in the figure two slides back.

One point. Hold that number lightly. You have not sketched a count for this problem, and the direct solve has no idea whether it has finished, so at this stage all you honestly know is that there is at least one intersection.

42. Example 11.5.3(4b): a whole turn finds a second

Worked example

Step 3, on the cosine equation. Half of a whole turn is a half turn, so this substitution is not vacuous here.

Substitute the shifted angle

Why: Into the cosine equation only.

\[ r = 3\cos\left(\tfrac12[\theta + 2\pi k]\right) = 3\cos\left(\tfrac{\theta}{2} + \pi k\right) \]

Expand with the sum formula for cosine

Why: Write it as a combination of the sine and cosine of half the angle.

\[ 3\cos\tfrac{\theta}{2}\cos(\pi k) - 3\sin\tfrac{\theta}{2}\sin(\pi k) \]

Put in the values at whole multiples of pi

Why: The sine is always zero there and the cosine is plus or minus one.

\[ \sin(\pi k) = 0, \qquad \cos(\pi k) = \pm 1 \]

Take k odd

Why: An even k just returns the original equation; an odd k flips the sign.

\[ r = -3\cos\left(\tfrac{\theta}{2}\right) \]

Couple it with the sine equation

Why: Same division as before, with a sign.

\[ 3\sin\tfrac{\theta}{2} = -3\cos\tfrac{\theta}{2} \;\Longrightarrow\; \tan\left(\tfrac{\theta}{2}\right) = -1 \]

Solve

Why: The tangent is minus one at minus a quarter turn.

\[ \tfrac{\theta}{2} = -\tfrac{\pi}{4} + \pi k \;\Longrightarrow\; \theta = -\tfrac{\pi}{2} + 2\pi k \]

Verify the point is a new one

Why: The distance is the same, 2.1213, but the direction is opposite: the first point is on the positive y-axis and this one is on the negative y-axis.

\[ \left(\tfrac{3\sqrt2}{2}, \tfrac{\pi}{2}\right) \to (0, 2.121), \qquad \left(\tfrac{3\sqrt2}{2}, -\tfrac{\pi}{2}\right) \to (0, -2.121) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 955 — Example 11.5.3, part 4, the second substitution

Here is the case the earlier examples never produced: a step three that is not vacuous. The reason is in the first line. The angle is divided by two inside the cosine, so a whole turn added to the angle becomes a half turn inside the function, and the cosine most certainly notices half turns.

Follow the expansion rather than accepting the result. The sum formula splits the cosine into two terms, the sine of a whole multiple of a half turn is zero so one term disappears, and the cosine of that multiple is plus or minus one depending on parity. Even multiples give you back the equation you started with; odd multiples flip its sign, and the flipped version is the new equation worth solving.

Coupling it with the sine equation gives the tangent equal to minus one and a second point, at the same distance but in the opposite direction, below the pole rather than above it. Two points now, both from the algebra, and still no reason to believe the list is complete.

43. Example 11.5.3(4c): the sign flip returns the other equation

Worked example

Step 4, on the cosine equation. Watch what the algebra produces.

Substitute the negated r and the half-turn shift

Why: Both replacements at once, into the cosine equation.

\[ -r = 3\cos\left(\tfrac12\bigl[\theta + (2k+1)\pi\bigr]\right) \]

Split the argument

Why: Half the shift is an odd multiple of a quarter turn.

\[ \tfrac12\bigl[\theta + (2k+1)\pi\bigr] = \tfrac{\theta}{2} + \tfrac{(2k+1)\pi}{2} \]

Expand with the sum formula

Why: Write A for half the angle and B for the shift.

\[ \cos(A + B) = \cos A\cos B - \sin A\sin B \]

Evaluate the shift's sine and cosine

Why: An odd multiple of a quarter turn sits on the vertical axis.

\[ \cos B = 0, \qquad \sin B = \pm 1 \]

Simplify

Why: Only the second term survives.

\[ -r = \mp 3\sin\left(\tfrac{\theta}{2}\right) \]

Take k equal to zero

Why: Then the shift's sine is plus one, and the two minus signs cancel.

\[ -r = -3\sin\left(\tfrac{\theta}{2}\right) \;\Longrightarrow\; r = 3\sin\left(\tfrac{\theta}{2}\right) \]

Read what that says

Why: The substituted cosine equation IS the sine equation, so every name satisfying the sine equation gives a name satisfying the cosine equation.

\[ (r, \theta) \text{ on the first} \;\Longrightarrow\; (-r, \theta + \pi) \text{ on the second} \]

Verify on a sample angle

Why: Take the angle 1.1 radians on the sine curve, and the angle 1.1 plus pi on the cosine curve. The distances differ in sign and the directions are opposite, so the two land on exactly the same point of the plane.

\[ \theta = 1.1: \quad r = 3\sin(0.55) = 1.567 \;\to\; (0.711, 1.398) \]

\[ \theta = 1.1 + \pi: \quad r = 3\cos(2.121) = -1.567 \;\to\; (0.711, 1.398) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 955 — Example 11.5.3, part 4, the conclusion

This is the longest piece of algebra in the lesson and it is worth following line by line, because the conclusion is unlike anything else you have seen. Halving the shift is what does the damage: an odd number of half turns, halved, becomes an odd number of quarter turns, and the cosine of a quarter turn is zero while its sine is plus or minus one.

So the sum formula kills the cosine term entirely and leaves only a sine term, with a sign. Take the shift to be a single half turn and the two minus signs cancel, and what you are left with on the page is r equals three times the sine of half the angle, which is the other equation exactly.

Read the last step as a statement about points, not about formulas. It says that whenever a name satisfies the first equation, the renamed version of that same point automatically satisfies the second. There is no solving to do and no angles to list: every point of one graph is a point of the other. The numerical check makes it concrete by taking an arbitrary angle, 1.1 radians, and showing that both curves land on the same rectangular point from opposite directions.

44. So how many intersection points are there?

Prediction

Predict first

For the sine and cosine of half the angle, how many points of intersection do the two graphs have?

  • One
  • Two
  • Four
  • Every point of the curve

Correct: Every point of the curve

Why: The substitution turned one equation into the other, so any name satisfying the first gives a name of the same point satisfying the second. The two equations describe the same set of points. The direct solve found two of them, which is a fair warning about reporting a count straight from the algebra.

Choose an option before revealing. Three of the four are numbers and one is not, and noticing that asymmetry is most of the work.

The substitution turned one equation into the other, so there is nothing left to solve. Any name on the first curve gives, by renaming, a name on the second curve for the same place. The graphs are the same set of points, and the number of shared points is the number of points on the curve.

Look back at what the direct solve reported: two. Not wrong, just radically incomplete, and nothing in those two lines of algebra hinted at it. This example is the strongest argument in the section for the first guideline. Had you sketched both curves and noticed they lay on top of each other, you would have suspected the answer before writing anything down.

45. Break the claim that different equations mean different curves

Counterexample

Discussion prompt

A classmate says: two polar equations that are not the same equation must have at least one point that lies on one graph and not the other. Give the counterexample from this section, and then give a second, much simpler one of your own.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 955 — the conclusion of Example 11.5.3

Write both counterexamples before revealing, and make the second one genuinely simpler rather than a variation on the first. The claim being refuted is the unexamined assumption you have carried in from rectangular graphing.

The example from the section is the pair you have just spent four slides on, and it is a heavy piece of machinery to wheel out. The lighter one is the distance two and the distance minus two. Both sweep the same circle, because walking two units backwards in every direction covers exactly the places you reach by walking two units forwards in every direction.

The small example is the better teaching tool precisely because it is so plain. Same picture, different equation, and the reason is the renaming rule and nothing else. Once you accept it there, the half-angle pair stops feeling like a paradox and starts looking like the same phenomenon with more trigonometry wrapped around it.

46. Regions of the plane

Section

Part 5

47. Two inequalities cut out a region

Concept

A polar equation draws a curve. A pair of inequalities, one on the angle and one on the distance, draws a region: for each angle in the allowed range, keep the points whose distance lies between the two bounds.

\[ \{(r,\theta) \mid f(\theta) \le r \le g(\theta), \; \alpha \le \theta \le \beta \} \]

Reading one is a sweep. Let the angle run from its lower limit to its upper limit; at each angle, the two bounds mark off a segment of the ray. The region is everything those segments cover.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 956 — the introduction to Example 11.5.4

The shift from curves to regions is smaller than it looks, so read the set notation slowly. An equation pins the distance to one value at each angle. A pair of inequalities allows a whole interval of distances at each angle, and that is the only change.

Read it as a physical sweep rather than as a set. Stand at the pole and turn from the first angle limit to the second. At every instant you are facing along some ray, and the two bounds mark off a segment of that ray: start here, stop there. The region is the whole family of segments, swept out as you turn.

That reading is what makes region problems quick. It tells you what to draw first, namely the two extreme rays, and then what to draw on each one. It also tells you immediately when something is wrong: if at some angle in the range the far bound is nearer than the near bound, your segment has negative length and the description is empty there.

48. Why the angle limits are almost always crossing angles

Intuition

Look at what has to happen at the end of a sweep. The region stops when one of two things happens: the outer bound falls back to the inner bound, so the segment shrinks to nothing, or the two bounds swap places, so the description would stop making sense.

Both are the same event: the two boundary curves cross. So the angle limits in a region description are usually intersection angles, which is why the whole first half of this lesson had to come first.

\[ g(\alpha) = f(\alpha) \quad\text{or}\quad g(\beta) = f(\beta) \]

The exceptions are when a bound reaches the pole, as with a petal, or when the region is deliberately cut at an axis, as in the exercises that ask for one quadrant only.

This slide explains where the numbers in a region description come from, and it saves a great deal of hunting later. Think about what can bring a sweep to an end.

The segment you are sweeping can shrink to nothing, which happens when the outer bound falls back onto the inner bound. Or the two bounds can cross over each other, after which the description asks for something impossible. Those are not two events but one: the two boundary curves meet.

So the angle limits in a region description are intersection angles, which is why the first two thirds of this lesson had to come first. Two exceptions are worth remembering: a bound that reaches the pole, as when a petal closes, and a limit imposed by the question itself, such as an exercise asking only for the part of the region in one quadrant. Everything else is a crossing angle.

49. Reading a polar region description

Notation

Annotate

On: \( \{(r,\theta) \mid f(\theta) \le r \le g(\theta), \; \alpha \le \theta \le \beta \} \)

  • Read this one FIRST. It says which rays out of the pole are in play, and it is usually chosen at the angles where the two boundary curves cross.
  • How far out along each ray the region starts. A zero here means the region starts at the pole; a curve here means the region has a hole or a near edge.
  • Where it stops. This is the curve you would name if asked what the region is inside of.
  • The left-hand bound must really be the smaller one at every angle in the range. If the expressions swap places part-way, the range has to be split there.
  • Nothing says the bounds are positive. When both are negative the segment lies on the opposite side of the pole, and the region is drawn there.

Five annotations, and the first one is an instruction about reading order. Look at the angle range before you look at anything else, because it tells you which part of the plane you are in, and the bounds only make sense once you know that.

The middle two annotations are about what each bound does. A zero on the inside means the region starts at the pole and is solid. A curve on the inside means there is something cut out of the middle, or an inner edge that follows a shape. The outer bound is the curve you would name if somebody asked what the region is inside of.

The last two are the ones that catch people. The smaller expression must be on the left at every angle in the range, not just at the angle you happened to test, and if the two expressions swap places part-way through the range then the range has to be split there. And nothing requires either bound to be positive: when both are negative the segments lie on the far side of the pole, and the region is drawn there. The third worked example is exactly that case.

50. Example 11.5.4(1): one petal of a rose

Worked example

\[ \{(r,\theta) \mid 0 \le r \le 5\sin(2\theta), \; 0 \le \theta \le \tfrac{\pi}{2} \} \]

Name the boundary curve

Why: The outer bound is a four-petal rose.

\[ r = 5\sin(2\theta) \]

Find where that curve is at the pole

Why: Twice the angle must be a multiple of pi.

\[ 5\sin(2\theta) = 0 \iff \theta = 0, \tfrac{\pi}{2} \; (\text{on } [0, \tfrac{\pi}{2}]) \]

Read the angle range

Why: It runs from one zero to the next, which is exactly one petal: the first-quadrant one.

\[ 0 \le \theta \le \tfrac{\pi}{2} \]

Find the petal's tip

Why: The sine is largest when twice the angle is a quarter turn.

\[ \theta = \tfrac{\pi}{4}: \quad r = 5\sin\left(\tfrac{\pi}{2}\right) = 5 \]

Read the distance range

Why: From the pole out to the curve, at every angle in the sweep.

\[ 0 \le r \le 5\sin(2\theta) \]

Figure (svg): A four-petal rose drawn faintly, with the first-quadrant petal traced in bold and shaded. Dashed rays along the positive x-axis and the positive y-axis mark the ends of the angle interval.

The angle limits choose the petal. The r limits fill it from the pole out to the boundary.

Check a sample ray

Why: At thirty degrees the boundary is at 4.330, so a point at distance two along that ray is inside the region and a point at distance 4.5 is outside.

\[ 5\sin\left(\tfrac{\pi}{3}\right) = \tfrac{5\sqrt3}{2} \approx 4.330 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 956 — Example 11.5.4, part 1

Notice that the first real step is a pole calculation, which may feel like the wrong tool for a region problem. It is not. For a rose the zeros of r are where the petals begin and end, so finding them tells you at once what the given angle range is picking out.

Here the zeros on the first quarter turn are at the two ends of the range itself, which is the confirmation you want: this range traces exactly one petal, from the moment it leaves the pole to the moment it returns. The tip is at an eighth of a turn, where the sine of twice the angle is at its maximum and the distance is five.

With the angle range understood, the distance bounds are almost free. Zero on the inside means each segment starts at the pole; the rose on the outside means it stops at the curve. Sweep those segments over the quarter turn and you have filled the petal in. The final check makes it concrete on one ray: at thirty degrees the boundary is at about 4.330, so a point 2 units out is inside and a point 4.5 units out is not.

51. Example 11.5.4(2): inside the rose and outside the circle

Worked example

\[ \{(r,\theta) \mid 3 \le r \le 6\cos(2\theta), \; 0 \le \theta \le \tfrac{\pi}{6} \} \]

Recognise both boundaries

Why: The circle of radius three and the rose from Example 11.5.3, part 3.

\[ r = 3 \quad\text{and}\quad r = 6\cos(2\theta) \]

Recall where they cross in the first quadrant

Why: That intersection was computed earlier in this lesson.

\[ 6\cos(2\theta) = 3 \iff \theta = \tfrac{\pi}{6} \]

Read the inner bound

Why: At least three from the pole: outside or on the circle.

\[ r \ge 3 \]

Read the outer bound

Why: At most the rose: inside or on the petal.

\[ r \le 6\cos(2\theta) \]

Check the two ends of the sweep

Why: At the start the segment runs from three out to six; at the finish the two bounds have met, so the region tapers to a single point.

\[ \theta = 0: \; 3 \le r \le 6; \qquad \theta = \tfrac{\pi}{6}: \; 3 \le r \le 3 \]

Figure (svg): The four-petal rose and the circle of radius three again, with the sliver between them shaded: the part of the right-hand petal lying outside the circle, between the angles nought and pi over six.

The lower bound is a curve too. The region is squeezed between the circle and the petal, and it pinches shut at the crossing angle.

Verify the range cannot be stretched

Why: Just past the crossing the rose is nearer the pole than the circle, so the description would ask for r at least three and at most 2.466 and would describe nothing at all.

\[ \theta = 0.5736: \quad 6\cos(2\theta) = 2.466 < 3 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 956 — Example 11.5.4, part 2

This is the first region with a curve on the inside as well as the outside, so read the inequality as two separate conditions. At least three from the pole means outside or on the circle. At most the rose means inside or on the petal. The region is the overlap.

The crossing angle was computed earlier in this lesson, and here is the payoff for having done it. At the start of the sweep the segment runs from three out to six, which is as wide as it will ever be. As the angle climbs, the rose comes in while the circle stays put, so the segment narrows, and at the crossing angle the two bounds meet and the segment vanishes. Look at the figure and watch the shading taper to a point.

The final step shows what happens if you push past that angle, and it is worth computing rather than asserting. A little beyond thirty degrees the rose is at about 2.466, which is nearer the pole than the circle, so the description would be asking for a distance of at least three and at most 2.466. That is nothing at all. The range is not merely conventional; it is the largest range for which the set is non-empty.

52. Fill in the angle that closes the region

Fill the middle

The same pair of curves, with the upper angle limit removed. Fill it in, and the bound it comes from.

Fill in the blanks

\\frac{\pi}{6}}\}, \quad \text3 6\cos(2\theta) = ___ \text___

Why: The sweep has to stop where the outer bound falls to the inner one. That is the intersection angle of the rose with the circle, thirty degrees, where both bounds equal three and the region pinches shut. Past it the rose is nearer the pole than the circle and the description would be empty.

Fill both blanks before checking, and get the second one from the first rather than the other way round.

The sweep has to stop where the outer bound falls to the inner one, and you already know that angle: it is the crossing of the rose with the circle, at thirty degrees, computed in part three of the previous example. At that angle both bounds are equal to three.

The reason this is worth practising as a reflex is that it works in reverse too. Given a region description with an angle limit in it, you can usually work out which curves are involved by asking what would have to be true at that angle. A limit that is not a crossing angle is a signal that the region has been cut deliberately, at an axis or a quadrant boundary, and that is worth noticing before you start shading.

53. Example 11.5.4(3): a region where r is negative throughout

Worked example

\[ \{(r,\theta) \mid 2 + 4\cos(\theta) \le r \le 0, \; \tfrac{2\pi}{3} \le \theta \le \tfrac{4\pi}{3} \} \]

Find where the limacon is at the pole

Why: Set its r to zero.

\[ 2 + 4\cos\theta = 0 \iff \cos\theta = -\tfrac12 \]

Solve

Why: Those two angles bound the given range exactly.

\[ \theta = \tfrac{2\pi}{3}, \; \tfrac{4\pi}{3} \]

Check the sign of r in between

Why: Halfway along, at half a turn, the cosine is minus one.

\[ \theta = \pi: \quad 2 + 4(-1) = -2 < 0 \]

Read the inequality in the right order

Why: Because the limacon's r is negative here, it is the SMALLER of the two bounds, so it belongs on the left.

\[ 2 + 4\cos\theta \le r \le 0 \]

Say what the segment does

Why: At each of these angles the segment runs backwards from the pole out to the curve.

\[ |r| \le |2 + 4\cos\theta| \]

Figure (svg): A limacon with a large outer loop reaching six on the x-axis and a small inner loop reaching two. The inner loop is shaded, and two dashed rays at one hundred and twenty and two hundred and forty degrees show the angle interval that traces it.

Over this stretch of angles the limacon's r is negative, so every point of the loop sits opposite the ray that produced it.

Verify the far end of the loop

Why: At half a turn the limacon's r is minus two; facing left and walking two units backwards lands at the rectangular point two and zero, which is the tip of the inner loop on the right of the picture.

\[ (-2)(\cos\pi, \sin\pi) = (2, 0) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 957 — Example 11.5.4, part 3

Everything you have learned about writing the smaller bound on the left is about to be tested, so go slowly. Start with the two zeros of the limacon: the cosine is minus one half at two thirds and four thirds of a turn, and those are precisely the two ends of the given range. That is your first clue that the range traces the inner loop.

The sign test in the middle is the step that decides the whole slide. Pick any angle strictly inside the range, and half a turn is the convenient one: the cosine is minus one there and the limacon's r is minus two. Negative. So the limacon is the smaller of the two bounds and zero is the larger, and the inequality has to be written with the curve on the left, which looks backwards compared with every other region in this lesson.

Now read what the segments do. At each of these angles the ray points up and to the left, or down and to the left, but the distances are negative, so the points land behind you, on the right of the pole. That is why the shaded loop opens to the right while the two dashed rays point left. The last check pins it down at one angle: facing left and walking two units backwards puts you at two units to the right, which is the tip of the inner loop.

54. Trap: writing a negative region with zero on the left

Trap

The trap

The inner loop, written the way every other region has been written:

\[ \{(r,\theta) \mid 0 \le r \le 2 + 4\cos\theta \} \]

\[ \tfrac{2\pi}{3} \le \theta \le \tfrac{4\pi}{3} \]

This is the empty set.

The fix

On that stretch of angles the limacon's r is negative, so the condition asks for a number that is at least zero and at most something negative. No number qualifies, at any angle in the range.

\[ \theta = \pi: \quad 0 \le r \le -2 \]

The bound on the left is whichever expression is smaller, not whichever one looks simpler. Test the sign at one angle inside the range before you write the inequality down.

The left column is what happens when you write the inequality from habit instead of from a sign test. Zero on the left, curve on the right, as in every other example in the section.

Test it at a single angle and it collapses. At half a turn the limacon's r is minus two, so the condition asks for a number that is at least zero and at most minus two. Nothing qualifies, and the same failure happens at every angle in the range, so the set described is empty. You have written down a perfectly well-formed description of nothing.

The defence takes five seconds. Before writing the inequality, evaluate both bounds at one angle inside the range and put the smaller one on the left. Do not decide by which expression looks more like a boundary curve, and do not assume zero is always the lower bound; on an inner loop it is always the upper one.

55. Example 11.5.4(4): two regions joined at the crossing angle

Worked example

A union: the angle keeps sweeping, and the outer boundary changes hands part-way.

\[ \{0 \le r \le 2\sin\theta, \; 0 \le \theta \le \tfrac{\pi}{6}\} \; \cup \; \{0 \le r \le 2 - 2\sin\theta, \; \tfrac{\pi}{6} \le \theta \le \tfrac{\pi}{2}\} \]

Recall the crossing angle

Why: It is the one found at the start of this lesson.

\[ 2\sin\theta = 2 - 2\sin\theta \iff \theta = \tfrac{\pi}{6} \]

Sweep the first piece

Why: From the pole out to the circle, as the angle climbs to thirty degrees.

\[ 0 \le \theta \le \tfrac{\pi}{6}: \quad 0 \le r \le 2\sin\theta \]

Sweep the second piece

Why: The angle picks up where it stopped, and the cardioid takes over as the outer bound.

\[ \tfrac{\pi}{6} \le \theta \le \tfrac{\pi}{2}: \quad 0 \le r \le 2 - 2\sin\theta \]

Check that the two pieces meet

Why: At the join both bounds equal one, so the region has no gap and no overlap.

\[ 2\sin\tfrac{\pi}{6} = 1 = 2 - 2\sin\tfrac{\pi}{6} \]

Figure (svg): A close-up of the first quadrant showing the circle and the cardioid meeting on the ray at thirty degrees. Two differently shaded wedges meet along that ray: the lower one bounded by the circle, the upper one bounded by the cardioid.

One sweep of the angle, two different outer boundaries. The join is exactly the intersection angle found earlier.

Verify the far end closes

Why: At a quarter turn the cardioid is at the pole, so the second piece shrinks to nothing and the whole region is bounded.

\[ 2 - 2\sin\left(\tfrac{\pi}{2}\right) = 0 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 957 — Example 11.5.4, part 4

A union looks more complicated than it is. Read the two pieces and notice that the angle ranges are adjacent, not overlapping: the first runs up to thirty degrees and the second picks up from there. It is one continuous sweep with a change of boundary part-way.

The change of boundary is forced, and the crossing angle is where it is forced. Below thirty degrees the circle is the nearer of the two curves, so it is the circle that limits how far out you can go. Above thirty degrees the cardioid is nearer, so it takes over. Using the wrong one on either stretch would give you points outside one of the two curves.

Two checks close the argument, and both are worth copying. At the join, both bounds equal one, so the two shaded pieces meet along that ray with no gap and no overlap. At the far end, at a quarter turn, the cardioid is at the pole, so the second piece closes itself and the whole region is bounded. Look at the figure and find both facts in it before moving on.

56. Exercise 50: inside the circle and inside the rose

Worked example

Exercise 50 asks for set-builder notation for the part of the first quadrant lying inside both the circle and the rose.

\[ r = 3 \qquad\text{and}\qquad r = 6\sin(2\theta) \]

Find the crossing angles

Why: Equate the two expressions for r.

\[ 6\sin(2\theta) = 3 \;\Longrightarrow\; \sin(2\theta) = \tfrac12 \]

Solve on the first quadrant

Why: Twice the angle runs from nought to half a turn there.

\[ 2\theta = \tfrac{\pi}{6}, \; \tfrac{5\pi}{6} \;\Longrightarrow\; \theta = \tfrac{\pi}{12}, \; \tfrac{5\pi}{12} \]

Decide which bound is smaller near the axes

Why: Close to the axes the rose is near the pole, so the rose is the binding bound.

\[ 0 \le \theta \le \tfrac{\pi}{12}: \quad 6\sin(2\theta) \le 3 \]

Decide which bound is smaller in the middle

Why: Between the crossings the rose swings out to six, so the circle binds.

\[ \tfrac{\pi}{12} \le \theta \le \tfrac{5\pi}{12}: \quad 3 \le 6\sin(2\theta) \]

Write the three pieces

Why: Union of the two rose pieces with the circular piece between them.

\[ \{0 \le r \le 6\sin(2\theta), 0 \le \theta \le \tfrac{\pi}{12}\} \cup \{0 \le r \le 3, \tfrac{\pi}{12} \le \theta \le \tfrac{5\pi}{12}\} \]

Add the last piece

Why: By symmetry about the forty-five degree line.

\[ \cup \; \{0 \le r \le 6\sin(2\theta), \; \tfrac{5\pi}{12} \le \theta \le \tfrac{\pi}{2}\} \]

Figure (svg): The first-quadrant petal of a rose reaching out to six, with a quarter circle of radius three inside it. The shaded region is bounded by the petal near the axes and by the circular arc in the middle.

Inside both curves means r is under whichever bound is lower. The crossing angles are where the lower bound changes hands.

Verify at the middle angle

Why: At forty-five degrees the rose is out at six and the circle at three, so the circle is indeed the smaller bound there, which is what the middle piece claims.

\[ 6\sin\left(\tfrac{\pi}{2}\right) = 6 > 3 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 959 — Exercise 50

Inside both is the phrase to decode first. At each angle, being inside both means the distance is under the circle and under the rose, which means it is under whichever of the two is smaller. So the outer bound of the region is not a single curve at all: it is the lower of the two, and it changes hands wherever they cross.

So the crossing angles are the structural information, and they come from the same equating you have done all lesson. On the first quadrant the sine of twice the angle is one half at fifteen and seventy-five degrees, and those two angles cut the quarter turn into three pieces.

Now decide which bound binds on each piece, and reason from the shape rather than testing blindly. Close to either axis the petal is near the pole, so the rose is the smaller bound and the region is the thin part of the petal. In the middle the petal has swung out to six while the circle sits at three, so the circle binds. The final check confirms it at forty-five degrees, where the rose is at six and the circle at three. Three pieces, and the middle one is a plain circular arc.

57. Describe each region in set-builder notation

Comparison

From Exercises 41 to 48 of the section. Fill in the missing bounds.

Comparison matrix

the region in wordsbounds on rbounds on θ
inside the circle r = 50 ≤ r ≤ 50 ≤ θ ≤ 2π
inside r = 5, in Quadrant III0 ≤ r ≤ 5π ≤ θ ≤ 3π/2
inside the left half of r = 6 sin θ0 ≤ r ≤ 6 sin θπ/2 ≤ θ ≤ π
inside r = 4 cos θ, in Quadrant IV0 ≤ r ≤ 4 cos θ−π/2 ≤ θ ≤ 0
inside the top half of r = 3 − 3 cos θ0 ≤ r ≤ 3 − 3 cos θ0 ≤ θ ≤ π
inside r = 5 but outside r = 33 ≤ r ≤ 50 ≤ θ ≤ 2π

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 959 — Exercises 41 to 48

Fill every blank before checking. Each row is one sentence of English to be turned into two inequalities, and the translation is mechanical once you have decided which part of the sentence is about distance and which is about direction.

Words like inside and outside are about the distance, so they set the bounds on r. Words like Quadrant III, left half and top half are about direction, so they set the range of the angle, and it is worth drawing the two extreme rays each time rather than guessing. The left half of a circle sitting above the pole is swept by angles from a quarter turn to a half turn, which is not the range most people write down first.

The last row is the one that breaks the pattern, and it is the one to study. Outside the smaller circle is a condition on the distance, not on the direction, so it changes the lower bound from zero to three and leaves the angle running over the whole turn. A region with a hole in it is described by lifting the inner bound off the pole, and nothing else changes.

58. Where a polar region is the useful object

Real world

Discussion prompt

A directional antenna's reach in each direction is described by a polar curve: it carries furthest straight ahead and less to the sides. A second antenna on the same mast is omnidirectional, reaching the same distance whichever way you look. Write down, in words, what region the two descriptions have to be combined into if you want the area covered by the directional antenna but not by the omnidirectional one, and say what you would have to compute first.

Answer in words before revealing, and resist the urge to invent formulas. The question is about which quantities go where in the description, which is the part that transfers to every applied problem you will meet.

The omnidirectional antenna reaches the same distance in every direction, so it is a circle centred on the mast and it supplies a constant inner bound. The directional one varies with direction, so it is a curve and it supplies the outer bound. Covered by the first but not the second means being beyond the constant and within the curve, which is the same shape of description as the rose outside the circle.

The last part is the point of the whole slide. The range of directions is not given to you: it is the set of directions in which the beam actually reaches further than the constant, and its endpoints are the crossing angles of the two curves. You cannot even write the region down until the intersection problem is solved, which is why this lesson took the order it did.

59. Putting it together

Section

Part 6

60. Pattern: finding every point of intersection

Pattern

Figure (svg): A flow diagram: sketch both curves and count the crossings, then check the pole on each curve separately, then solve the equations directly, then rerun with theta shifted by a full turn, then rerun with r negated and theta shifted by a half turn, and finally compare the count with the sketch.

Two of the five boxes are algebra you would have done anyway. The other three are what polar coordinates add.
  1. Sketch both curves and count the crossings. This number is your target; the algebra alone will never tell you it has finished.
  2. Check the pole on each curve separately. Set that curve's r to zero and ask only whether a solution exists. If both curves have one, the pole is an intersection point.
  3. Equate the two expressions for r and solve. Every point whose two names agree comes out here.
  4. Substitute theta plus a whole turn into one equation and solve again. Often this returns the same equation, which is a result, not a failure.
  5. Substitute negated r and a half-turn shift into one equation and solve again. This is the step that finds points the two curves label with opposite signs.
  6. Compare your count with the sketch. If the substituted equation turns into the other equation, the two graphs are identical and every point is shared.

Read the diagram as a route and note that it starts outside the algebra. The first box is the sketch, and the arrow that comes back along the bottom is the comparison of the count with the picture. Everything in between is bracketed by that loop.

Two of the five moves are the algebra you would have done anyway in any coordinate system: sketch and solve. The other three are what polar coordinates add, and each corresponds to a way a point can carry more than one name. The pole check handles the point with no fixed direction, the angle shift handles whole turns, and the sign flip handles the reversal.

The line at the bottom of the diagram is the one to carry into your own work: the pole is never found by solving, it is found by looking. And a mismatch between your count and your sketch is not a mystery to be puzzled over. It is a specific instruction telling you which of the last two boxes you have not yet run.

61. Check: which pair shares the pole?

Check

Check your understanding

For which pair of curves is the pole a point of intersection?

  • A. r = 2 and r = 3 cos θ
  • B. r = 3 cos θ and r = 1 + cos θ (correct)
  • C. r = 4 and r = 2 + sin θ
  • D. r = 1 − 2 sin θ and r = 2

Answer: B

Why: Set each curve's r to zero on its own. Three cosine theta is zero at a quarter turn, and one plus cosine theta is zero at half a turn. Both curves reach the pole, so the pole is a shared point, even though no angle serves both.

Why A tempts people
The constant two is never zero, so that circle never reaches the pole and cannot share it.
Why C tempts people
Neither curve reaches the pole: the constant four is never zero, and two plus the sine is never smaller than one.
Why D tempts people
The limacon does reach the pole, when the sine is one half, but the circle of radius two does not, so the pole is on one graph only.

Run the test rather than picturing the curves. For each pair, set each equation's r to zero separately and ask only whether a solution exists.

A constant on its own is never zero, which eliminates three of the four options immediately without any trigonometry at all. In the surviving pair both curves reach the pole, one at a quarter turn and one at a half turn, and the fact that those angles are different is not an objection. Notice that the last distractor is the most tempting, because one of its curves genuinely does reach the pole; one out of two is not enough.

62. Check: which move produces the point?

Check

Check your understanding

For the circle r = 3 and the rose r = 6 cos 2θ, which move of the guidelines produces the point (−3, π/3)?

  • A. equating the two expressions for r
  • B. the pole check
  • C. replacing θ by θ + 2πk in the rose equation
  • D. replacing r by −r and θ by θ + (2k + 1)π in the rose equation (correct)

Answer: D

Why: The first coordinate is negative, so this name can never satisfy the equation that sets r to three. Only the substitution that negates r produces the equation whose solutions have the cosine of twice the angle equal to minus one half, and those are the four extra points.

Why A tempts people
Equating gives the cosine of twice the angle equal to plus one half, whose solutions all have r equal to three, never minus three.
Why B tempts people
The pole check concerns only the origin, and in any case the circle of radius three never reaches it.
Why C tempts people
That substitution leaves the rose equation unchanged, because twice a whole turn is still a whole turn inside the cosine.

Look at the first coordinate before you look at anything else. It is negative, and that single feature settles the question.

The circle's equation says r is three. No substitution into the other equation changes that, so no name with a negative first coordinate can ever come out of it unless r itself has been negated somewhere. Only the fourth option does that. If you were drawn to the third, remember that doubling a whole turn gives another whole turn, which the cosine cannot detect, so that substitution reproduces the rose equation unchanged.

63. Check: reading a region

Check

Check your understanding

Which set describes the region inside the circle r = 5 but outside the circle r = 3?

  • A. {(r, θ) | 0 ≤ r ≤ 5, 0 ≤ θ ≤ 2π}
  • B. {(r, θ) | 3 ≤ r ≤ 5, 0 ≤ θ ≤ 2π} (correct)
  • C. {(r, θ) | 5 ≤ r ≤ 3, 0 ≤ θ ≤ 2π}
  • D. {(r, θ) | 3 ≤ r ≤ 5, 0 ≤ θ ≤ π}

Answer: B

Why: Outside the smaller circle makes three the lower bound on the distance, and inside the larger one makes five the upper bound. Every direction is included, so the angle runs over a full turn.

Why A tempts people
That is the whole disc of radius five, including the hole in the middle that was supposed to be removed.
Why C tempts people
The bounds are the wrong way round, so no distance satisfies both and the set is empty.
Why D tempts people
Stopping the angle at half a turn keeps only the upper half of the ring.

Translate the two halves of the sentence separately. Inside the larger circle is an upper bound on the distance; outside the smaller one is a lower bound. Neither phrase says anything about direction.

So the distance runs from three to five and the angle runs over the whole turn, which gives a ring. Two of the distractors are worth diagnosing: one forgets to lift the lower bound off the pole and keeps the hole filled in, and one writes the bounds in the wrong order, which describes the empty set rather than the ring. The fourth keeps only the top half by stopping the angle early.

64. Say why the substitution goes into one equation only

Explain it to yourself

Discussion prompt

In two or three sentences, explain to someone who has just learned the guidelines why the renaming substitution is applied to one of the two equations and never to both at the same time.

Write your answer out before revealing, and make sure at least one sentence is a reason rather than a restatement of the rule.

The reason is about names. The whole purpose of the substitution is to let the two equations look at different names of the same place, since the case where they can use the same name was already handled by solving directly. Rename on both sides and the two names stay locked together, so the system you produce is the original one in disguise and it has exactly the original solutions.

The practical corollary is worth adding to your answer: which equation you choose is entirely free, so choose the one that makes the trigonometry shorter. If one of the two has no angle in it at all, substituting into that one costs a single line, and the book itself recommends exactly that in a footnote.

65. Exit ticket

Exit ticket

\[ r = 2\cos(\theta) \qquad\text{and}\qquad r = 2\sqrt{3}\,\sin(\theta) \]

Discussion prompt

Exercise 25. Find every point of intersection of these two circles, running all the guidelines, and say which move produced each point.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 958 — Exercise 25

This is a complete intersection problem in miniature, and the point of it is that the algebra alone gets you halfway. Run all four guidelines and label each point with the move that produced it, because that labelling is the thing being assessed.

Equating gives a tangent equal to one over the square root of three, so the angle is a sixth of a half turn, and the distance there is the square root of three, about 1.732. That is one point. The pole check then succeeds on both curves, at a quarter turn on the first and at zero on the second, and the different angles are irrelevant, so the origin is the second point.

The sign flip is the step that earns its keep by producing nothing. Both of these curves have the angle appearing on its own inside a sine or a cosine, so the half turn flips the function's sign and cancels against the minus on r, returning each equation to itself. Two points in all, and only one of them came out of the algebra. If you reported one point, the pole check is the habit to work on.

66. Recap

Recap

movewhat it askswhat only it can find
sketch and counthow many crossings are there?the target number; nothing else supplies it
pole checkis each curve's r ever zero?the pole, whose angle is unconstrained
solve directlyis there one name satisfying both?every point whose two names agree
shift the angledoes a whole turn change the equation?points a periodic label hides; often nothing
flip the signdoes negating r change the equation?points the curves label with opposite signs

\[ (r,\theta) \equiv (r, \theta + 2\pi k) \equiv (-r, \theta + (2k+1)\pi), \quad r \ne 0 \]

A region is then written by choosing the angle range at the crossing angles and putting the smaller bound on the left. Section 11.6 turns these same curves into the graphs of complex numbers, where the pair of a distance and an angle becomes a single number.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, pp. 955-957 — the Guidelines and Example 11.5.4

OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §10.4 Polar Coordinates: Graphs §10.4 — the same intersection idea, briefly

Five rows, and the column that matters most is the third one. Each move has something only it can find, which is why the procedure is complete when you run all of them and unreliable when you run three.

Underneath sits the identity the whole lesson rests on, with the condition that r is not zero attached to it. That exclusion is not a technicality: it is the reason the pole needs a row of its own. Every other row is a consequence of one or other half of that identity, and if you can reconstruct the table from the identity you have understood the section rather than memorised it.

The regions at the end are the same material put to work. Choose the angle range at the crossing angles, test the sign at one interior angle, and put the smaller bound on the left. Section 11.6 takes these same curves and reads a distance and a direction as a single complex number, at which point the renaming rules you have been using all lesson turn into statements about multiplication.

Sources

  1. Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations — Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Version 3 Corrected Edition, July 4 2013, pp. 951-958
  2. OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §10.4 Polar Coordinates: Graphs

Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Trigonometry — $55/session, free consultation.

Book on Wyzant · Text (657) 465-8108