11.5a Graphs of Polar Equations

How to draw a polar curve without converting it to rectangular form. Establishes the Fundamental Graphing Principle for polar equations and the two shapes given by a constant coordinate, then develops the book's two-plane method: sketch r against theta on ordinary axes and read that sketch as instructions for the polar plane. Applies it to limacons, a four-petalled rose, and a lemniscate, with the negative-r intervals handled explicitly throughout.

Subject: Trigonometry · 69 slides · symbolic lesson

Open the interactive version of this deck

What this lesson covers

The lesson, slide by slide

1. Graphs of Polar Equations

Title

Trigonometry · Section 11.5

Sketch r against theta, then read that sketch as instructions

2. What this lesson gives you

Objectives

Section 11.4 gave you polar coordinates and the conversion formulas. This lesson asks a harder question: given an equation in r and theta, what curve does it describe? Converting to rectangular form almost never helps, so the book builds a method that stays in polar coordinates.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, pp. 938-951 — the pages these objectives are drawn from

Up to now every graph you have drawn has been a rectangular one: pick a value of the input, compute the output, plot the pair, join the dots. That recipe technically still works in polar coordinates, and you will see in a few slides exactly how badly it fails.

The reason it fails is that a polar pair is not a location. It is a set of instructions, and different instructions can land you in the same place. Nine rows of a table can give you four points, and worse, a table tells you nothing about what the curve is doing between the rows, which in polar coordinates can include passing through the pole and coming out on the opposite side.

So the book builds a different method, and it is the thing to take away from this lesson. You draw two pictures instead of one. The first treats r as an ordinary function of theta and lives on ordinary rectangular axes. The second is the curve you actually wanted. The first picture is the script and the second is the performance, and learning to read one into the other is the whole skill.

3. One point, many names

Warm-up

Before the new method, recall the one fact about polar coordinates that makes graphing awkward.

Discussion prompt

A point is named by r equal to minus two and theta equal to pi. Write two other names for the same point, then decide whether that point lies on the graph of the equation r equals two.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.4 — the equivalence of polar representations

Write your two names down before revealing. If you found it awkward, that is worth knowing now, because this fact is the engine of everything that follows.

There are two ways to rename a polar point. You may add or subtract any whole number of full turns, which changes nothing about where you end up. Or you may negate the first coordinate and add half a turn, which reverses the direction and then walks backwards along it, arriving at the same place by the other route.

The second move is the one that matters here. It means that the same point can have a name with a positive first coordinate and a name with a negative one, and an equation may accept one while rejecting the other. That is why the graphing principle on the next slide has to be phrased so carefully.

4. One coordinate held constant

Section

Part 1

5. The Fundamental Graphing Principle, restated

Concept

In rectangular coordinates a point is on the graph exactly when its coordinates satisfy the equation. There is only one pair to test, so nothing more needs saying.

Fundamental Graphing Principle for Polar Equations — The graph of a polar equation is the set of points that satisfy it: a point P is on the graph if and only if P has some representation whose coordinates satisfy the equation.

\[ P \in \text{graph} \iff \exists\,(r', \theta') \text{ naming } P \text{ with } r' = f(\theta') \]

The word to notice is some. A point carries infinitely many names, and the principle asks only that at least one of them work. That single word is the source of nearly every surprise in this section.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 938 — the Fundamental Graphing Principle

Read the definition twice, and put your finger on the word some. In the rectangular world you never needed it, because a point had exactly one pair of coordinates and there was nothing to quantify over.

Here the graph is a set of locations, not a set of ordered pairs. To test whether a location belongs, you are allowed to try all of its names, and a single success puts it on the graph. Failures do not count against it.

That asymmetry has a practical consequence you will meet in the very next lesson: two different-looking equations can have exactly the same graph, and two curves can cross at a point that no single pair of coordinates certifies. For now, just keep hold of the idea that the graph is made of places, and the equation is a test you are allowed to apply to any name a place has.

6. Reading the graphing principle piece by piece

Notation

Annotate

On: \( P \in G \iff \exists\,(r', \theta'): r' = f(\theta') \)

  • A point of the plane, a location. Not a pair of numbers: the same location answers to infinitely many pairs.
  • There exists. You get to hunt through all the names of P, and one success is enough. Nothing has to fail.
  • A representation of P, meaning r′ and θ′ together with the usual rules: add any whole number of turns, or negate r and add half a turn.
  • That particular pair satisfies the equation. A different name for the same point may well fail it, and that is allowed.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 938

Work through the four annotations in order. The first two are about the logic and the last two about the arithmetic, and both halves matter.

The existence symbol is doing real work. If it were replaced by a for-all, the graph of even the simplest equation would be empty, and the socratic slide a few along from here asks you to show exactly that.

The last annotation is the one that feels uncomfortable at first. You are being told that a point can be on a graph even though the obvious name for it does not satisfy the equation. Sit with that for a moment, because every strange feature of polar graphing traces back to it.

7. Example 11.5.1(1): the graph of r equals four

Worked example

Only one of the two variables appears, which makes the other one free.

\[ r = 4 \]

Name the free variable

Why: Theta is absent from the equation, so no value of it is ruled out.

\[ r = 4, \quad \theta \text{ free} \]

Describe the points that satisfy it

Why: Every point that has a name whose first coordinate is four.

\[ \{(4, \theta) : \theta \in \mathbb{R}\} \]

Turn the first coordinate into a distance

Why: The first coordinate is a directed distance from the pole, and here it is the same at every angle.

\[ \sqrt{x^2 + y^2} = |4| = 4 \]

Figure (svg): Two panels. Left: r against theta on rectangular axes, a horizontal line at height 4 across a whole turn. Right: the polar plane with a circle of radius 4 about the pole and three arrows from the pole out to it.

A constant r ignores the angle completely, so a flat line on the left becomes a full circle on the right.

Name the shape

Why: Every point four units from one fixed point, in every direction.

\[ x^2 + y^2 = 16 \]

Check by converting

Why: Squaring both sides of the polar equation and using the conversion identity from Section 11.4 gives the circle of radius four centred at the origin, which is what was drawn.

\[ r = 4 \;\Longrightarrow\; r^2 = 16 \;\Longrightarrow\; x^2 + y^2 = 16 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, pp. 938-939 — Example 11.5.1, number 1

This is the gentlest possible start, and the reason it is gentle is that theta never appears. When a variable is missing from an equation, it is free: nothing constrains it, so every value of it occurs.

So the graph is every point you can reach by pointing in some direction and walking four units. Point in all the directions and you have swept out a circle. Notice that no work was needed on the theta-r plane here, because r does not vary at all; the sketch is a flat horizontal line.

The check converts to rectangular form, which is worth doing once because it connects this to something you already trust. Squaring gives r squared, and r squared is x squared plus y squared, so the polar equation becomes the familiar circle. Do not expect converting to be this easy for the rest of the lesson; for almost every curve here it is much harder than the sketch.

8. Example 11.5.1(2): a negative constant radius

Worked example

The same situation with a minus sign in front, which changes less than you expect.

\[ r = -3\sqrt{2} \]

Name the free variable

Why: Again theta is absent, so every angle occurs.

\[ r = -3\sqrt{2} \approx -4.243, \quad \theta \text{ free} \]

Rewrite one such point with a positive radius

Why: Negating r and adding half a turn names the same point.

\[ (-3\sqrt{2},\, \theta) = (3\sqrt{2},\, \theta + \pi) \]

Read off the distance from the pole

Why: A distance is never negative; it is the size of the first coordinate.

\[ \left|-3\sqrt{2}\right| = 3\sqrt{2} \approx 4.243 \]

Figure (svg): Two panels. Left: r against theta, a horizontal line below the axis at about minus 4.24. Right: the polar plane with a circle of that radius, a pale arrow pointing at 40 degrees and a bright arrow pointing the opposite way to the plotted point.

The minus sign turns the walk around, but the distance from the pole is the same at every angle, so the graph is still a circle.

Name the shape

Why: A fixed distance in every direction once more.

\[ x^2 + y^2 = 18 \]

Check against the positive version

Why: The equation with the plus sign describes exactly the same set of points, because every point of one has a representation satisfying the other; two different equations, one graph, which is precisely what the Fundamental Graphing Principle permits.

\[ r = 3\sqrt{2} \quad\text{and}\quad r = -3\sqrt{2}: \quad \text{the same circle} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 939 — Example 11.5.1, number 2

Your instinct will be that a negative radius must mean something different, perhaps an empty graph, since a distance cannot be negative. The resolution is that the first coordinate is not a distance; it is a directed distance, and the direction it is measured along may be reversed.

Follow the second step carefully. The point with first coordinate negative three root two at some angle is the same point as the one with positive three root two at that angle plus half a turn. As theta runs over every angle, so does theta plus half a turn, so you end up sweeping out the identical circle.

The check is the interesting part. Two equations that look different have exactly the same graph, and the Fundamental Graphing Principle is what permits it. In the rectangular world that essentially never happens without the equations being algebraically equivalent. Here it happens constantly.

9. Example 11.5.1(3): a constant angle of five pi over four

Worked example

Now the other variable is the free one.

\[ \theta = \frac{5\pi}{4} \]

Name the free variable

Why: r is absent, so it runs over every real number, negative values included.

\[ \theta = \tfrac{5\pi}{4}, \quad r \text{ free} \]

Take the positive values of r

Why: They run out along the terminal side of the angle, into the third quadrant.

\[ r > 0: \quad (x, y) = \left(-\tfrac{r}{\sqrt2},\, -\tfrac{r}{\sqrt2}\right) \]

Take the negative values of r

Why: Backwards along the same line, which is the opposite ray, into the first quadrant.

\[ r < 0: \quad (x, y) = \left(\tfrac{|r|}{\sqrt2},\, \tfrac{|r|}{\sqrt2}\right) \]

Add the one value left over

Why: At r equal to zero the point is the pole itself.

\[ r = 0: \quad (x, y) = (0, 0) \]

Figure (svg): Two panels. Left: the theta-r plane with a single vertical line at five pi over four, covering every value of r. Right: the polar plane with the full line y equals x, its lower-left half marked r positive and its upper-right half marked r negative.

Fixing the angle and freeing r gives both halves of a line, not one ray: the negative values of r supply the other half.

Check by converting

Why: The tangent of the fixed angle is one, and the tangent of the polar angle is y over x, so the graph is the whole line through the pole of slope one, both halves of it.

\[ \tan\tfrac{5\pi}{4} = 1 = \frac{y}{x} \;\Longrightarrow\; y = x \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, pp. 939-940 — Example 11.5.1, number 3

Now the roles swap: theta is pinned and r is free. The temptation is to draw the terminal side of the angle and stop, and that is the most common error in this part of the section.

Take the three cases in turn, because that is how you avoid the error. Positive values of r walk forwards along the terminal side, into the third quadrant. Negative values walk backwards, which puts them on the opposite ray, in the first quadrant. And zero puts you at the pole, which joins the two rays together.

Add the three pieces and you have a complete straight line through the origin. The check confirms it by converting: the tangent of the fixed angle is one, and the tangent of the polar angle is the ratio of the rectangular coordinates, so the graph is the line of slope one through the origin.

10. Example 11.5.1(4): an angle that names the vertical axis

Worked example

A negative angle, and a graph you already know by another name.

\[ \theta = -\frac{3\pi}{2} \]

Find a friendlier coterminal angle

Why: Add one full turn; the terminal side does not move.

\[ -\tfrac{3\pi}{2} + 2\pi = \tfrac{\pi}{2} \]

Take the positive values of r

Why: Straight up from the pole.

\[ r > 0: \quad \left(r\cos\tfrac{\pi}{2},\, r\sin\tfrac{\pi}{2}\right) = (0, r) \]

Take the negative values of r

Why: The same formula, now giving a negative height: straight down.

\[ r < 0: \quad (0, r) \text{ with } r < 0 \]

Figure (svg): Two panels. Left: the theta-r plane over minus two pi to zero, with one vertical line at minus three pi over two. Right: the polar plane with the whole vertical axis drawn, its upper half marked r positive and its lower half r negative.

Minus three halves of a turn is coterminal with a quarter turn, so the terminal side is the upward axis and the graph is the whole vertical axis.

Name the shape

Why: Every point whose first rectangular coordinate is zero.

\[ x = 0 \]

Check the three pieces separately

Why: Positive r gives the upper half, negative r the lower half and zero gives the pole, and together those are every point of the vertical axis and nothing else.

\[ \{(0,y): y > 0\} \cup \{(0,0)\} \cup \{(0,y): y < 0\} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 940 — Example 11.5.1, number 4

The negative angle is the only new feature here, and the first step disposes of it. Adding a full turn does not move the terminal side, so minus three halves of a turn is the same direction as a quarter turn: straight up.

After that it is the previous example again. Positive values of r give the upward half of the vertical axis, negative values give the downward half, and zero gives the origin. Together those are every point with first rectangular coordinate zero.

Notice how unhelpful converting would have been if you had tried it first. The tangent of a quarter turn does not exist, so the ratio of the coordinates goes nowhere; you have to reason about the direction instead. The sketching method never runs into that difficulty.

11. Theorem 11.8: the two constant graphs

Concept

Theorem 11.8 — Let a and alpha be constants with a not zero. The graph of r equal to a is the circle centred at the pole of radius the absolute value of a. The graph of theta equal to alpha is the whole line containing the terminal side of alpha in standard position.

\[ r = a \;\Longrightarrow\; x^2 + y^2 = a^2, \qquad \theta = \alpha \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{a line through the pole} \]

equationfree variablegraph
r = aθcircle about the pole, radius |a|
θ = αrthe whole line, both halves

Both statements come straight from the four examples above; nothing new is being asserted. Note that the sign of a is invisible in the graph, and that the line is a line rather than a ray precisely because r is allowed to be negative.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 940 — Theorem 11.8

Nothing in this theorem is new; it just names what the four examples showed. Read it as a licence to skip the reasoning next time, not as a fact to memorise separately.

Two details are worth flagging. First, the absolute value in the radius: the sign of the constant is invisible in the picture, so two equations give one circle. Second, the word line rather than ray, which is entirely due to r being allowed to take negative values.

Whenever you meet a polar equation, the first thing to check is whether one of the two variables is missing. If it is, you are done in one line and you never need the method that takes up the rest of this lesson.

12. The two shapes polar coordinates draw for free

Intuition

These are the two curves that polar coordinates describe better than rectangular coordinates ever could, and each needs a single symbol.

A circle about the origin takes two squares and a sum in rectangular form. In polar form it is one letter equal to one number, because the polar system was built out of distance and direction, and a circle is the set of points at a fixed distance.

A line through the origin is the set of points in a fixed direction, together with the opposite direction. Fix the direction and free the distance, and that is exactly what you get. Every other curve in this lesson is a trade between the two: the distance changes as the direction turns.

It is worth pausing on why these two shapes are so cheap here when they are not cheap in rectangular coordinates. The polar system was built out of exactly two ideas, a distance and a direction, and these are the two curves you get by freezing one of them.

That is also a hint about what polar coordinates are good for. Anything organised around a centre, where the natural question is how far out and in which direction, will look simpler in polar form. Anything organised around two perpendicular rulers will not.

Everything else in this lesson is a compromise between the two extremes: the distance is no longer constant, but it depends on the direction in a controlled way. Reading that dependence is what the theta-r sketch is for.

13. Trap: drawing a ray instead of a line

Trap

The trap

A common first answer to the third example:

\[ \theta = \tfrac{5\pi}{4} \]

\[ \Longrightarrow\; \text{one ray into Quadrant III} \]

Wrong. Half the graph is missing.

The fix

Nothing in the equation restricts r, so r may be negative, and a negative r at this angle lands on the opposite ray, in Quadrant I. The graph is the whole line.

\[ r < 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \theta + \pi \]

A ray is the answer to a different question, the one with an extra condition attached.

\[ \theta = \tfrac{5\pi}{4}, \; r \ge 0 \]

This error is nearly universal on a first attempt, and it comes from a reasonable instinct. You picture an angle in standard position, you see its terminal side, and the terminal side is a ray. It is easy to forget that the equation says nothing at all about r.

The defence is a habit: whenever an equation leaves a variable free, write down explicitly what that variable is allowed to be, including the negative values and the zero. For r that gives you three pieces, and only the first of them is the terminal side.

The second formula on the right is worth remembering as the contrast. If a problem does restrict r to be non-negative, then the answer really is a ray, and being able to say precisely which condition makes the difference is what shows you understand the graph rather than having memorised a picture.

14. Circle, line, or neither?

Sorting

Sort into buckets

Theorem 11.8 covers only the equations in which one variable is missing. Sort each equation by what its graph is.

Circle about the pole
r = 7; r = −1
Line through the pole
θ = 2π/5; θ = −π/3
Something else
r = 7 cos θ; r = 2 + 2 sin θ
circ
r = 7 and r = −1 both have θ free, so the distance from the pole is constant: circles of radius 7 and 1.
line
θ = 2π/5 and θ = −π/3 both have r free, so every distance occurs in one direction and its opposite: whole lines.
other
Both of these have r depending on θ, so Theorem 11.8 says nothing. The first is a circle, but not one centred at the pole; the second is a cardioid.

Sort all six before checking. The test is purely structural: look for a missing variable, and do not attempt to imagine the curve.

The two circles are the ones in which theta never appears, and the sign of the constant makes no difference to either. The two lines are the ones in which r never appears, and both are full lines, not rays.

The last two are there to stop the rule being over-applied. In each of them r genuinely depends on theta, so Theorem 11.8 has nothing to say, and you would have to sketch. As it happens one of them is still a circle, but a circle through the pole rather than centred on it, and you will graph exactly that curve in a few slides.

15. Why the principle needs the word some

Socratic

The rectangular principle says a point is on the graph when its coordinates satisfy the equation. The polar version says when some representation does.

Discussion prompt

Take the point three units from the pole in the direction of a quarter turn, and the equation r equals three. Find a name for this point that fails the equation, and then say what would go wrong if the principle demanded that every name work.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 938

Write an answer before revealing, and try to make the second half of it precise; the first half is easy once you remember how renaming works.

The failing name is the one with a negative first coordinate. Negate three, add half a turn, and you have another perfectly good name for the same point, but it fails the equation outright.

Now push that observation as far as it goes. Every single point of the plane has names with a negative first coordinate, so demanding that all names satisfy the equation would empty every graph in this section. The quantifier is not pedantry; it is the only version of the principle that is not vacuous.

16. The two-plane method

Section

Part 2

17. Nine ordered pairs, four points

Concept

The obvious way to graph a polar equation is to tabulate it. Try that on the curve the book uses to introduce the method.

\[ r = 6\cos(\theta), \quad \theta = 0, \tfrac{\pi}{4}, \tfrac{\pi}{2}, \ldots, 2\pi \]

Figure (svg): Two panels. Left: the cosine curve of height 6 over a whole turn with nine dots on it at the eighth-turn angles. Right: the polar plane showing only four distinct plotted points, labelled with how many of the nine pairs landed on each.

Different angles keep naming the same place, so a table of values hides most of the curve instead of revealing it.
θrlands at
0, π, 2π6, −6, 6(6, 0) — three times
π/4, 5π/43√2, −3√2(3, 3) — twice
π/2, 3π/20, 0the pole — twice
3π/4, 7π/4−3√2, 3√2(3, −3) — twice

Nine ordered pairs, four distinct locations. Negative values of r keep sending the plot back to places it has already been, and no amount of extra rows fixes the real problem, which is that a table says nothing about what happens between its rows.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, pp. 940-941 — the table before the method

Count the dots on the left panel and then count the dots on the right. Nine goes in and four comes out, and the table below the figure shows which pairs collided with which.

There are two separate causes. Adding a full turn to theta gives the same point back, which accounts for the repeats at angle zero and a full turn. And the negative values of r reverse direction, which sends the second half of the table back over points the first half already visited.

The deeper problem is not the collisions, though. It is that a table is a list of isolated dots, and joining dots requires you to guess what happens in between. In polar coordinates the curve can pass through the pole and emerge on the other side while you are guessing, so the guess is often wrong. More rows will not save you.

18. Sketch r against theta, then read it as instructions

Concept

Here is the book's method. Forget for a moment that r and theta are coordinates, and treat r simply as a function of theta. Plot it on ordinary rectangular axes. That plot is called the theta-r plane.

\[ \text{step 1: } r = f(\theta) \text{ on } \theta r\text{-axes} \quad\longrightarrow\quad \text{step 2: } \text{read it onto the } xy\text{-plane} \]

Figure (svg): Two panels. Left: the first quarter of the cosine curve of height 6, with four vertical arrows drawn from the theta-axis up to the curve. Right: a quarter of a circle from the point six on the horizontal axis in to the pole, with four arrows from the pole out to it at the matching angles.

The arrow's length on the left is the arrow's length on the right; only its direction changes, and the direction is theta itself.

For each interval of theta the sketch tells you two things: whether r is growing or shrinking, and whether it is positive or negative. Those two facts are exactly what you need in order to draw the arc: how far out the curve is, and on which side of the pole.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 941 — the method introduced

Here is the whole method in one sentence: draw the boring graph first, then translate it. The boring graph is r plotted against theta on the same ordinary axes you have used since algebra, and for the curve in the picture it is just a piece of a cosine wave.

Look carefully at the two panels of the figure. Each arrow on the left is vertical, running from the theta-axis up to the curve, and its length is the value of r at that angle. Each arrow on the right has the same length but has been rotated to point along its own angle. That rotation is the entire translation.

So the question you ask of the left panel is always the same: over this stretch of angles, is the arrow getting longer or shorter, and is it pointing forwards or backwards? Longer means the curve moves away from the pole, shorter means towards it, and the sign decides which side of the pole the arc lands on.

19. Why the sketch beats the table

Intuition

A table gives you isolated dots and leaves you to guess the joins. On a polar plane those guesses are dangerous, because the curve can pass through the pole and come out somewhere unexpected, or double back on itself entirely.

The theta-r sketch gives you the whole run of values at once. It is continuous, so you can see where r is rising, where it is falling, where it crosses zero and where it changes sign, and every one of those events has a direct meaning on the polar plane.

The book is honest that the method is less precise than computing exact values. It is not trying to place points accurately; it is trying to get the shape right, and the shape is what a hand sketch is for.

It is fair to be sceptical here. The sketch looks less precise than a table of exact values, and it is. The book says so directly, and calls it a less precise but markedly faster way of generating the graph.

But precision is not what you are short of when drawing a curve by hand. What you are short of is knowledge of the shape, and the shape is decided by a handful of events: where r rises, where it falls, where it hits zero and where it changes sign. Those events are all visible at a glance on a continuous sketch and all invisible in a table.

There is a second benefit that will matter in the next lesson. The sketch shows you the angles at which the curve reaches the pole, and the lines it hugs on the way in. Those lines are what make an inner loop look right rather than looking like a wobble.

20. Reading one arrow on the theta-r plane

Notation

Annotate

On: \( \theta: 0 \to \tfrac{\pi}{2}, \quad r: 6 \to 0 \)

  • The angle the radius is pointing along. On the polar plane this is a rotation from the positive horizontal axis round to the positive vertical axis.
  • The length of that radius, read off the height of the theta-r curve. Here it shrinks from six down to nothing.
  • Shrinking r plus turning theta means the curve spirals inwards. Growing r would mean spiralling outwards.
  • Both endpoints are at or above zero, so this arc is drawn where theta actually points. Had r been negative, the arc would go opposite.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 941

Step through the annotations and connect each one to a physical movement of your hand. The theta range is a rotation; the r range is a length; the direction of change is in or out; the sign is which side.

Getting into the habit of reading all four at once is the point. Students who find polar sketching hard usually read only two of them, the angle and the size, and then guess the rest.

The last annotation is the one that separates a correct sketch from a mirror image of it. Ask about the sign every single time, even when it is obviously positive, because the moment you stop asking is the moment a limacon's inner loop ends up on the wrong side of the pole.

21. The book's walkthrough: r equals six cosine theta

Worked example

One cycle on the theta-r plane, read a quarter at a time.

\[ r = 6\cos(\theta) \]

Read the first quarter

Why: The cosine falls from one to zero, so r falls from six to zero.

\[ 0 \le \theta \le \tfrac{\pi}{2}: \quad r: 6 \to 0 \]

Transfer it

Why: Start six units out along the positive horizontal axis and pull in to the pole, arriving just as the angle reaches the vertical.

\[ (6, 0) \;\longrightarrow\; \text{the pole} \]

Read the second quarter

Why: The cosine is negative there, so r is negative and falling.

\[ \tfrac{\pi}{2} \le \theta \le \pi: \quad r: 0 \to -6 \]

Transfer it, backwards

Why: A negative r is drawn along the opposite ray, so this arc lies in Quadrant IV rather than Quadrant II.

\[ (r, \theta) = (|r|, \theta + \pi), \quad \theta + \pi \in \left[\tfrac{3\pi}{2},\, 2\pi\right] \]

Figure (svg): Two panels. Left: the cosine curve of height 6 over a half turn, its positive part in blue and its negative part in red. Right: the circle of radius 3 centred at three on the horizontal axis, with the upper half blue and the lower half red.

Half a turn of theta already closes the curve; the red arc, drawn from negative values of r, supplies the bottom half.

Find where it starts to retrace

Why: Advancing theta by half a turn negates r, and negating both coordinates gives the same point back, so the third and fourth quarters repeat the first two.

\[ r(\theta + \pi) = 6\cos(\theta + \pi) = -6\cos\theta = -r(\theta) \]

Check against the rectangular form

Why: Multiplying by r and converting gives x squared plus y squared equal to six x, and completing the square gives a circle of radius three centred at the point three comma zero, which is exactly the curve drawn and it closes after half a turn.

\[ r^2 = 6r\cos\theta \;\Longrightarrow\; x^2 + y^2 = 6x \;\Longrightarrow\; (x-3)^2 + y^2 = 9 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, pp. 941-942 — the worked development of the method

Follow this one slowly; it is the model for everything that comes after. The theta-r sketch is one cycle of a cosine wave with amplitude six, and the reading is done a quarter turn at a time.

The first quarter is easy: r falls from six to zero while the angle swings up to the vertical, so the curve spirals in from the point six units along the horizontal axis to the pole. The second quarter is where the thinking is. The cosine has gone negative, so although the angle is sweeping through the second quadrant, the arc is drawn in the fourth.

The retracing argument at the end is worth understanding rather than accepting. Adding half a turn to theta flips the sign of the cosine, and flipping the sign of r while adding half a turn is exactly the renaming rule from the start of the lesson. So the second half turn draws points that are already on the curve. The check confirms the whole thing algebraically: the curve is a circle of radius three sitting on the horizontal axis, passing through the pole.

22. The script on the left, the performance on the right

Picture it

Figure (svg): The polar plane with a pale arrow at 135 degrees, the direction theta points, and a bright arrow the opposite way at 315 degrees ending at a dot in the fourth quadrant, together with the red arc of the circle that this second quarter draws.

Face the angle, then walk backwards. The arc that the second quarter draws lies in Quadrant IV, diagonally opposite where theta was pointing.

This is the second quarter alone, the one that catches people out. The grey arrow shows where the angle is pointing, up and to the left. The yellow arrow shows where the point actually goes, down and to the right, because r is negative there.

Notice that the two arrows lie on one straight line through the pole. That is all a negative r ever does: it keeps the line and swaps the side.

This is the slide to come back to whenever a sketch of yours comes out mirrored. Just one arc is drawn, the one from the second quarter of the cosine.

The grey arrow points where theta is pointing, up and to the left at three quarters of a half turn. The yellow arrow, exactly the same length, points the other way, and the dot at its tip is where the point really goes. The faint dashed line through the pole shows that the two directions are one line.

Say the rule aloud once: face the angle, walk backwards. It sounds trivial, and it is, but it is the difference between a limacon drawn correctly and a limacon drawn inside out.

23. Exercise 1: the circle r equals six sine theta

Worked example

The same method on the sine version, from the section's exercise set.

\[ r = 6\sin(\theta) \]

Sketch r against theta

Why: One arch of a sine wave, from zero up to six and back to zero.

\[ 0 \le \theta \le \pi: \quad r: 0 \to 6 \to 0 \]

Read the first quarter

Why: r grows from nothing to six while the angle turns to the vertical.

\[ 0 \le \theta \le \tfrac{\pi}{2}: \quad r: 0 \to 6 \]

Read the second quarter

Why: r shrinks back to zero while the angle turns on to the negative horizontal; r stays positive throughout.

\[ \tfrac{\pi}{2} \le \theta \le \pi: \quad r: 6 \to 0 \]

Figure (svg): Two panels. Left: the sine curve of height 6 over a half turn, entirely above the axis. Right: the polar plane with a circle of radius 3 centred three units above the pole.

Swapping cosine for sine turns the picture a quarter turn: the same circle, now centred on the vertical axis.

Decide when to stop

Why: Over the second half turn r is negative and its size repeats the first half, so the same points come round again.

\[ r(\theta + \pi) = 6\sin(\theta + \pi) = -6\sin\theta = -r(\theta) \]

Check by converting

Why: Multiplying by r gives x squared plus y squared equal to six y, and completing the square gives the circle of radius three centred at the point zero comma three, which matches the drawing.

\[ r^2 = 6r\sin\theta \;\Longrightarrow\; x^2 + y^2 = 6y \;\Longrightarrow\; x^2 + (y-3)^2 = 9 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 958 — Exercise 1

This is the same method on a new curve, and you should try to do the reading yourself before looking at the steps. The theta-r sketch is a single arch of a sine wave, entirely above the axis over the first half turn.

Because r never goes negative on that interval, there is no reversing to do at all, which makes this one easier than the cosine version. The curve simply sweeps out from the pole to a maximum of six at a quarter turn and back in to the pole at a half turn.

So the circle sits above the pole rather than beside it. In general, cosine puts the interesting direction along the horizontal axis and sine puts it along the vertical, and that single observation will save you a great deal of time with limacons and roses too.

24. Fill the missing reading

Fill the middle

The three values that anchor the sketch of the first curve.

Fill in the blanks

r = 6\cos\theta: \quad r(0) = 6, \quad r\!\left(\tfrac0-6\right) = ___, \quad r(\pi) = ___

Why: Six, nothing, and minus six. The last one is the interesting value: it is negative, which is what sends the second half of the curve into the fourth quadrant instead of the second.

Fill all three before checking. They are the anchors of the theta-r sketch: the starting height, the crossing, and the finishing height.

The third one is the one that carries the information. It is negative, and that negative sign is what sends the whole second half of the curve into the fourth quadrant. If you wrote six there, you would draw the circle sitting in the upper half plane, which is a different curve entirely.

Getting into the habit of computing r at the quadrant angles first, before drawing anything, is worth the thirty seconds it costs.

25. Predict from the reading alone

Prediction

A reading taken from some theta-r sketch, with the curve itself hidden.

\[ \theta: \pi \to \tfrac{3\pi}{2}, \quad r: 2 \to 6 \]

Predict first

What does the polar curve do over this interval?

  • It sweeps outward, from the negative horizontal direction round to the negative vertical direction
  • It pulls inward, from the negative horizontal direction to the negative vertical direction
  • It sweeps outward, from the positive horizontal direction to the positive vertical direction
  • It stays at a constant distance and simply rotates

Correct: It sweeps outward, from the negative horizontal direction round to the negative vertical direction

Why: Two facts, read separately. The angle runs from a half turn to three quarters of a turn, which is the third quadrant, ending on the downward axis. And r grows from two to six while staying positive, so the curve moves away from the pole. Growing r means outward; the angle says where.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 943 — the third interval of Example 11.5.2, number 1

Commit to an option before revealing. The exercise is deliberately abstract: no equation, just a reading, because that is exactly what your eye takes off the theta-r sketch.

Break it into the two questions. Where is the angle going? From a half turn to three quarters of a turn, which sweeps across the third quadrant and ends pointing straight down. What is r doing? Growing, from two to six, and staying positive throughout.

Growing and positive means moving away from the pole, drawn where the angle points. So the curve sweeps outwards through the third quadrant. This is the third interval of the limacon you are about to graph, and the prediction you just made is what its picture will show.

26. Slide the amplitude and the frequency

Tweak it

Parameter explorer

This is the theta-r sketch, not the polar curve: r plotted against theta on ordinary axes. Slide the frequency and count how many times the curve crosses the horizontal axis between zero and a full turn. Each crossing is a visit to the pole.

\[ r = {a}\sin({k}\theta) \]

  • a — from 1 to 6: amplitude a
  • k — from 1 to 4: frequency k

One warning before you start: what is plotted here is the theta-r sketch, not the polar curve. This slider draws on rectangular axes, so what you see is a sine wave, not a rose. That is deliberate, because the sine wave is what you would draw first by hand.

Move the frequency and count the crossings of the horizontal axis strictly between the ends. Each crossing is a value of theta at which r is zero, which on the polar plane is a visit to the pole, which is the boundary between one petal and the next.

Now move the amplitude and watch what does not change. The crossings stay exactly where they were, because multiplying by a constant cannot move a zero. That is why the amplitude changes the size of the petals and never their number or their position.

27. Negative r, drawn correctly

Section

Part 3

28. What a negative r does to the picture

Concept

This is the single rule that makes polar sketching work, and the single place where sketches go wrong.

\[ (-r, \theta) = (r, \theta + \pi) \]

Reading the left side as an instruction: face the direction theta, then walk backwards by the distance. Reading the right side: turn to face the opposite direction, then walk forwards. They finish in the same place.

\[ (-3, \tfrac{2\pi}{3}) = \left(3, \tfrac{2\pi}{3} + \pi\right) = \left(3, \tfrac{5\pi}{3}\right) \]

So an arc of the theta-r sketch that dips below the axis is drawn in the quadrant diagonally opposite the one its angles point into. Second quadrant angles draw in the fourth; first quadrant angles draw in the third.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 942 — the footnote on plotting negative r

This slide holds the single most important line in the lesson, and it is one line long. Learn to read it in both directions.

Left to right it says: a negative radius at some angle is the same point as the positive radius at the opposite angle. Right to left it says: if you ever want to describe a point using the opposite direction, you may, at the cost of a sign.

The consequence for sketching is a quadrant rule, and it is worth saying to yourself in those terms. An arc whose angles point into the second quadrant is drawn in the fourth. An arc whose angles point into the first quadrant is drawn in the third. Always the diagonally opposite one, never the reflection across an axis.

29. Below the axis means the opposite quadrant

Picture it

Figure (svg): The polar plane with a pale arrow of length 3 at 120 degrees, a dashed arc showing a half turn, and a bright arrow of length 3 at 300 degrees ending at a labelled dot.

A negative first coordinate is an instruction to reverse: same line through the pole, opposite side of it.

The grey arrow is where two thirds of a turn points. The yellow arrow, the same length, is where a radius of minus three actually puts the point. The dashed arc between them is the half turn that connects the two readings.

Look at the two arrows and notice that they have the same length. Nothing about the size of r has changed; only its direction has been reversed.

The dashed arc between them is the half turn, and drawing it in once for yourself is a good use of thirty seconds. Many people who get this wrong are quietly reflecting the point across an axis instead of turning it through the pole, and the two operations agree often enough to hide the mistake until they suddenly do not.

One last way to say it: the negative radius keeps the line through the pole and swaps the side. Reflection keeps one axis and swaps the side. They are different operations, and only the first one is what a negative r means.

30. Reading the limacon formula piece by piece

Notation

Annotate

On: \( r = a + b\cos(\theta) \)

  • The constant offset: the average distance from the pole. On the theta-r sketch it is the height the wave oscillates about.
  • The swing either side of a. On the theta-r sketch it is the amplitude, so r runs between a minus the size of b and a plus the size of b.
  • Cosine puts the longest radius along the horizontal axis, at angle zero. Sine puts it along the vertical axis instead, at a quarter turn.
  • r is zero when the cosine equals minus a over b. That has a solution exactly when the size of a is at most the size of b, and that is the whole test for an inner loop.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, pp. 942-947 — the two limacons of Example 11.5.2

All four of the curves you are about to meet have this shape, so spending a minute decoding it now pays for itself immediately.

The first two annotations are about the theta-r sketch: the constant is the height the wave sits at, and the coefficient is how far it swings either side. Put those together and you can write down the range of r without any thought, which tells you the closest and furthest the curve ever gets from the pole.

The fourth annotation is the test you will use over and over. The curve reaches the pole exactly when the equation r equal to zero has a solution, and that happens precisely when the size of the constant is no bigger than the size of the coefficient. Bigger coefficient gives two solutions and an inner loop; equal gives one solution and a cusp; smaller coefficient gives none and the curve stays clear.

31. Example 11.5.2(1): the limacon r equals four minus two sine theta

Worked example

Divide a full turn into the four usual quarters and read each one.

\[ r = 4 - 2\sin(\theta) \]

Find the range of r

Why: The sine runs between minus one and one, so r runs between two and six and is never zero.

\[ -1 \le \sin\theta \le 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; 2 \le r \le 6 \]

Read the first quarter

Why: The sine rises from zero to one, so r falls from four to two.

\[ 0 \to \tfrac{\pi}{2}: \quad r: 4 \to 2 \]

Read the second quarter

Why: The sine falls back to zero, so r climbs back to four.

\[ \tfrac{\pi}{2} \to \pi: \quad r: 2 \to 4 \]

Read the third quarter

Why: The sine goes negative, down to minus one, so r grows to six.

\[ \pi \to \tfrac{3\pi}{2}: \quad r: 4 \to 6 \]

Read the fourth quarter

Why: The sine returns to zero and r comes back to four, closing the curve.

\[ \tfrac{3\pi}{2} \to 2\pi: \quad r: 6 \to 4 \]

Figure (svg): Two panels. Left: r against theta for four minus two sine theta, a wave staying between 2 and 6 and never touching the axis. Right: the polar plane with an egg-shaped closed curve, flattened at the top and bulging below the pole.

The whole wave sits above the axis, so the pole is never reached and the curve is one simple closed loop.

Check the two extreme points

Why: At a quarter turn r is two, giving the point zero comma two, and at three quarters of a turn r is six, giving zero comma minus six; the drawn curve is flattened at the top and bulges below, exactly as those two numbers demand.

\[ \left(2, \tfrac{\pi}{2}\right) = (0, 2), \qquad \left(6, \tfrac{3\pi}{2}\right) = (0, -6) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, pp. 942-944 — Example 11.5.2, number 1

The first step is the one to copy into your own work. Before reading any intervals, find the range of r from the range of the sine, because that immediately tells you whether the pole is in play. Here r lives between two and six, so the pole never is.

Then take the four quarters in turn. Sine rises, so r falls; sine falls, so r rises; sine goes negative, so r grows past its middle value; sine comes back, so r returns. Two shrinking stretches and two growing ones, in that order.

Transfer them and you get a closed curve that is pulled in at the top, where r is smallest, and pushed out at the bottom, where r is largest. The check confirms the two extremes numerically: two units up at a quarter turn, six units down at three quarters. Nowhere does r change sign, so nothing is drawn in a reversed direction and the shape is simply an egg.

32. Reading in and out from the shape of the sketch

Intuition

Once you have done two or three of these, the transfer becomes automatic, because only four readings are possible on any interval.

on the θr-sketchon the polar plane
r positive and risingmoving away from the pole, drawn where θ points
r positive and fallingmoving towards the pole, drawn where θ points
r negative and growing in sizemoving away from the pole, drawn opposite θ
r negative and shrinking in sizemoving towards the pole, drawn opposite θ

The size of r decides in or out; the sign of r decides which side. Keeping those two questions apart is the whole skill.

The table is the whole translation, and there are only four lines in it because there are only two questions with two answers each.

Try covering the right-hand column and reconstructing it. Size of r decides in or out; sign of r decides near or far side. If you can rebuild the table from those two sentences you will never need to memorise it.

The third row is the one people trip over, because r is negative and yet the curve is moving away from the pole. Distance from the pole is the size of r, not r, so a radius going from minus one to minus five is a curve moving outwards, drawn on the far side.

33. Does this curve ever reach the pole?

Prediction

\[ r = 4 - 2\sin(\theta) \]

Predict first

Does the graph of this equation pass through the pole?

  • Yes, once
  • Yes, twice
  • No, never
  • Yes, at every quarter turn

Correct: No, never

Why: Reaching the pole means r equal to zero for some angle. Here that would need the sine of theta to be two, which is impossible, so the curve never gets closer than two units. The smallest value of r is the constant minus the size of the coefficient, which here is four minus two.

\[ 4 - 2\sin\theta = 0 \iff \sin\theta = 2: \quad \text{no solution} \]

Commit to an answer before revealing. The question is entirely arithmetic and takes one line, and it is the line you should write first for any limacon.

Setting r to zero gives an equation for the sine of theta, and here it demands that the sine equal two, which no angle achieves. So there is no angle at which the curve reaches the pole, and the smallest distance is two, achieved at a quarter turn.

The shortcut worth carrying away: the smallest that the size of r ever gets is the constant minus the size of the coefficient. If that number is positive the curve never reaches the pole; if it is zero you get a single cusp; if it is negative you get an inner loop.

34. Example 11.5.2(2): a limacon with an inner loop

Worked example

This one crosses the theta-axis, so the first job is to find where.

\[ r = 2 + 4\cos(\theta) \]

Set r to zero

Why: A zero of r is a visit to the pole, and those angles are the important ones.

\[ 2 + 4\cos\theta = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \cos\theta = -\tfrac12 \]

Solve on one full turn

Why: The cosine is minus a half at the two angles whose reference angle is a third of a turn.

\[ \theta = \tfrac{2\pi}{3} \quad\text{and}\quad \theta = \tfrac{4\pi}{3} \]

Read the outer arc

Why: Away from those two angles the cosine is larger than minus a half, so r is positive; it reaches six at angle zero.

\[ -\tfrac{2\pi}{3} \le \theta \le \tfrac{2\pi}{3}: \quad r: 0 \to 6 \to 0 \]

Read the inner arc

Why: Between the two angles the cosine drops below minus a half, so r is negative, reaching minus two at half a turn.

\[ \tfrac{2\pi}{3} \le \theta \le \tfrac{4\pi}{3}: \quad r: 0 \to -2 \to 0 \]

Figure (svg): Two panels. Left: r against theta for two plus four cosine theta, crossing the axis at two thirds of pi and four thirds of pi and dipping to minus two. Right: the polar plane with a large loop reaching six on the horizontal axis and a small loop inside it, with the two crossing directions drawn as dashed lines.

The two angles where r is zero are exactly the two directions along which the curve enters and leaves the pole.

Transfer the inner arc

Why: Negative r means the opposite direction, so the arc drawn from angles near half a turn appears near angle zero, giving a small loop inside the big one.

\[ (-2, \pi) = (2, 0) \]

Figure (svg): A close view of the polar plane out to three units, showing only the small inner loop of the limacon, drawn in red, reaching two units along the positive horizontal axis, with the pole marked.

Every point of the inner loop comes from a negative r, so the loop lies on the far side of the pole from the angles that produced it.

Check the loop's tip

Why: At half a turn r is minus two, which is the point two comma zero, two units out along the positive horizontal axis, and that is the tip of the inner loop in the drawing; the outer loop reaches six on the same axis, so the two tips sit on the same ray.

\[ (-2, \pi) = (2, 0), \qquad (6, 0) = (6, 0) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, pp. 944-947 — Example 11.5.2, number 2

The order of the steps here is deliberate and you should copy it. Solving for the zeros of r comes first, before any reading of intervals, because those angles are the cut points that make the rest of the reading easy.

Two angles come out, at two thirds and four thirds of a turn. Between them the cosine is below minus a half and r is negative; outside them r is positive. That splits the full turn into an outer arc and an inner arc, and the inner one is the one that needs reversing.

Follow the inner arc carefully in the second picture. Its angles sweep through the second and third quadrants, but its radii are negative, so every one of its points is drawn half a turn round, on the right of the pole. The result is a small loop tucked inside the big one, its tip two units out along the positive horizontal axis, coming from the radius minus two at half a turn. The book also mentions that the curve hugs the two lines as it goes through the pole, a fact proved in calculus; those two lines are drawn in the figure.

35. Find the error: the arc drawn where the angle points

Error analysis

A student transfers the inner arc of the last curve like this.

Annotate

On: \( \left(-2, \tfrac{2\pi}{3}\right) \;\to\; \text{Quadrant II} \)

  • A negative first coordinate is not a slip to be tidied away by taking the size. It is an instruction to reverse direction.
  • Two thirds of a turn does point into Quadrant II. That is where the angle looks, not where the point goes.
  • Add half a turn: two thirds of a turn plus one half turn is five thirds of a turn, which is Quadrant IV. The point is two units out in that direction.
  • Every arc with negative r ends up in the wrong quadrant. The inner loop appears on the wrong side of the pole and the whole sketch is a reflection of the truth.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 945 — the footnote on rotating from the negative horizontal axis

See whether you can name the error before revealing the annotations. The angles are right and the radii are right; only the transfer is wrong.

What has happened is that the size of the radius was taken and the angle used exactly as given. That combination is never correct when the radius is negative, and it puts the entire inner loop in the wrong pair of quadrants.

What makes this error so hard to catch in your own work is that the resulting picture still looks like a limacon. It is a plausible curve, just not this curve: it is the mirror image. The only defence is to ask about the sign of r on every interval, before you draw.

36. Trap: an inner loop drawn as a dimple

Trap

The trap

The zeros of r are found correctly, and then:

\[ r = 2 + 4\cos\theta \]

\[ \Longrightarrow\; \text{a dent in the curve at } \theta = \pi \]

Wrong. A dent never touches the pole.

The fix

The curve reaches the pole, leaves it, comes back and crosses through. That makes a genuine loop with the pole as its crossing point, not a dent in a single closed curve.

\[ r\left(\tfrac{2\pi}{3}\right) = 0 = r\left(\tfrac{4\pi}{3}\right) \]

The test is arithmetic, not artistic: solve for the zeros of r. If there are two, there is a loop.

The two shapes are genuinely easy to confuse when sketching freehand, because both look like a curve that has been pushed in on one side. The difference is whether the curve touches the pole.

A dimple is what you get when the constant is bigger than the coefficient: r shrinks but never reaches zero, so the curve stays outside the pole all the way round. A loop is what you get when r passes through zero twice: the curve enters the pole, comes out the other side, turns round and comes back.

Do not decide this by eye. Solve the equation r equal to zero and count the solutions in one turn. Two means a loop, one means a cusp, none means a dimple or a plain oval.

37. Exercise 13: the limacon r equals one minus two cosine theta

Worked example

A limacon from the exercise set, with the coefficients the other way round.

\[ r = 1 - 2\cos(\theta) \]

Find the zeros of r

Why: Set the expression to zero and solve for the cosine.

\[ 1 - 2\cos\theta = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \cos\theta = \tfrac12 \]

Solve on one full turn

Why: The cosine is a half at a sixth of a turn and at its reflection.

\[ \theta = \tfrac{\pi}{3} \quad\text{and}\quad \theta = \tfrac{5\pi}{3} \]

Read the sign on each side

Why: Between those angles the cosine is smaller than a half, so r is positive; outside them it is negative.

\[ \tfrac{\pi}{3} < \theta < \tfrac{5\pi}{3}: \; r > 0, \qquad \text{otherwise } r < 0 \]

Find the two extreme radii

Why: The cosine is minus one at half a turn and one at zero.

\[ r(\pi) = 3, \qquad r(0) = -1 \]

Figure (svg): Two panels. Left: r against theta for one minus two cosine theta, starting at minus one, crossing zero at a third of pi and again at five thirds of pi, peaking at three. Right: the polar plane with a large loop reaching three units to the left and a small loop inside it reaching one unit to the left.

Cosine with a minus sign in front puts the long reach at half a turn, so this limacon is the mirror image of the last one.

Transfer both extremes

Why: Three at half a turn is three units to the left; minus one at angle zero is one unit to the left, since a negative radius reverses the direction.

\[ (3, \pi) = (-3, 0), \qquad (-1, 0) = (1, \pi) = (-1, 0) \]

Check against the previous limacon

Why: There the constant was two and the coefficient four and the loops opened to the right; here the constant is one, the coefficient minus two, and the loops open to the left, because the minus sign moves the longest radius from angle zero to half a turn.

\[ |{-2}| = 2 > 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{an inner loop, opening leftwards} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 958 — Exercise 13

This is the same procedure on a curve where the coefficient is negative, and the sign changes where the curve points rather than what shape it is.

Notice the difference from the previous limacon. There the constant was two and the coefficient a positive four, and the longest radius came at angle zero, so the curve reached out to the right. Here the coefficient carries a minus sign, so the longest radius comes at half a turn and the curve reaches out to the left.

The last check is the one to internalise. Compare the size of the constant with the size of the coefficient to decide whether there is a loop, and look at the sign of the coefficient and whether it is sine or cosine to decide which way the curve faces. Those are two independent questions, and keeping them separate makes limacons quick.

38. When does a limacon reach the pole?

Comparison

Comparison matrix

equationconstant against coefficientreaches the pole
r = 4 − 2 sin θ4 > 2never
r = 2 + 4 cos θ2 < 4twice: 2π/3 and 4π/3
r = 3 − 3 cos θ3 = 3once: θ = 0
r = 1 − 2 cos θ1 < 2twice: π/3 and 5π/3
r = 5 + 5 sin θ5 = 5once: θ = 3π/2

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 958 — Exercises 9 to 14

Fill in every blank before checking. Each row needs the same two lines of work: compare the two numbers, then solve the equation r equal to zero if it has a solution.

The middle column is the prediction and the right column is the verification. If the constant is larger there are no solutions and the curve stays clear. If they are equal there is exactly one solution in a turn, because the cosine or sine is being asked to take the value minus one or one, which happens at a single angle. If the coefficient is larger there are two.

The two cardioid rows are worth a second look, since they are the boundary case. Three minus three cosine theta is zero when the cosine is one, which is angle zero alone. Five plus five sine theta is zero when the sine is minus one, which is three quarters of a turn alone. One angle each, so one cusp each.

39. Loop, cusp, or clear of the pole?

Sorting

Sort into buckets

Compare the constant with the coefficient in each, and sort by what happens at the pole.

Two zeros: an inner loop
r = 1 − 2 cos θ; r = 2 + 7 sin θ
One zero: a cusp (cardioid)
r = 3 − 3 cos θ; r = 5 + 5 sin θ
No zeros: clear of the pole
r = 4 − 2 sin θ; r = 7 − 3 cos θ
loop
In 1 − 2 cos θ and 2 + 7 sin θ the coefficient is larger than the constant, so the equation r = 0 has two solutions and the curve crosses the pole twice.
cusp
In 3 − 3 cos θ and 5 + 5 sin θ the constant equals the coefficient, so r = 0 has exactly one solution in a turn: the curve touches the pole once and turns round there. These are cardioids.
clear
In 4 − 2 sin θ and 7 − 3 cos θ the constant is larger, so r never reaches zero and the curve stays a fixed distance clear of the pole.

Sort all six before checking, and do it by arithmetic rather than by imagining the curves. Two numbers per item, compared.

The cusp bucket is the narrow one: it needs the constant and the coefficient to be exactly equal, which is what makes a cardioid a special limacon rather than a generic one. The tiniest change to either number moves it into one of the other two buckets.

If you found yourself hesitating over the ones with sine rather than cosine, that hesitation is worth examining. Whether the curve faces up, down, left or right has no bearing at all on whether it reaches the pole; only the two sizes matter for that.

40. The limacon family at a glance

Picture it

Figure (svg): Four small polar plots of the curve a plus two cosine theta, for a equal to one, two, two and a half, and five: an inner loop, a heart with a sharp point at the pole, a dimpled oval and a plain convex oval.

Only the first two curves touch the pole. The constant and the coefficient decide everything about the shape.

The same coefficient throughout, with only the constant changing. As the constant grows past the coefficient the inner loop shrinks to a point, becomes a cusp, then opens out into a dent and finally smooths away altogether.

All four of these have the same coefficient, and only the constant changes. Reading them left to right is like watching a single slider being moved.

With the constant below the coefficient there is an inner loop. Push the constant up until the two are equal and the loop shrinks to nothing, leaving a sharp point at the pole: the cardioid. Push further and the point opens into a dent, and further still and the dent smooths away into a plain oval.

You are only responsible for the loop-or-not question in this lesson, since that is the one the book derives. But the picture is worth having, because it shows that all four are one family with one parameter, and it explains why the cardioid gets its own name: it is the exact boundary between two different kinds of curve.

41. Say the negative-r rule in your own words

Explain it to yourself

Discussion prompt

In two sentences, say what you do with an interval of theta on which r is negative, and why that is the right thing to do rather than a convention someone invented.

Write the two sentences out before revealing, and make the second one a reason rather than a restatement.

The first sentence is the procedure, and most people can produce it after a couple of examples. The second sentence is what tells you whether you understand it: the rule is not a drawing convention that could have been chosen differently, it is forced by what a polar pair means.

If your explanation used the word reflection anywhere, go back to the figure two slides ago. A negative radius turns the point through the pole, which is a half turn, not a reflection in an axis. The two agree for a point on an axis and disagree everywhere else.

42. Roses, and how far theta must run

Section

Part 4

43. The period of the function is not the interval you need

Concept

Every curve so far closed up after a predictable amount of turning, but the amount was not always the period of the function.

curveperiod of the functioninterval that completes the graph
r = 6 cos θ2ππ — half as much
r = 4 − 2 sin θ2π2π — the same
r = 5 sin 2θπ2π — twice as much

There is no general relation between the two. The period tells you when the function repeats its values; the graph repeats only when the values come back as the same points, and a negative r can turn a repeated value into a brand new point.

\[ r(\theta + \pi) = -r(\theta) \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{same point}, \qquad r(\theta + \pi) = r(\theta) \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{opposite point} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, pp. 950-951 — the remarks after Example 11.5.2

Look hard at the three rows of the table, because together they rule out every simple rule you might hope for. One curve needs less than a period, one needs exactly a period, one needs more.

The reason is in the line of algebra below the table. What decides whether the second half turn draws anything new is not whether the values of r repeat, but whether the points repeat. Advancing theta by half a turn reverses the direction, and a reversal of direction is cancelled by a change of sign in r.

So there are two ways for the curve to have already closed after half a turn: either the values repeat and the directions repeat, or the values flip sign at the same moment the direction reverses. When neither happens, you keep going. This is worth reading twice, because the roses later in this part are the place it bites.

44. Example 11.5.2(3): the four-petalled rose

Worked example

A fundamental cycle of this function takes half a turn, so start there and see what happens.

\[ r = 5\sin(2\theta) \]

Find the zeros of r

Why: The sine of twice the angle vanishes when twice the angle is a whole number of half turns.

\[ 5\sin(2\theta) = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \theta = 0, \tfrac{\pi}{2}, \pi, \tfrac{3\pi}{2}, 2\pi \]

Read the first quarter

Why: Twice the angle runs from zero to a half turn, so r rises to five and comes back to zero.

\[ 0 \to \tfrac{\pi}{2}: \quad r: 0 \to 5 \to 0 \]

Transfer it

Why: A whole petal, its tip at the angle where r peaks, which is an eighth of a turn.

\[ \text{tip at } \left(5, \tfrac{\pi}{4}\right): \quad \text{Quadrant I} \]

Read the second quarter

Why: Twice the angle runs through the second half turn, so r is negative, reaching minus five.

\[ \tfrac{\pi}{2} \to \pi: \quad r: 0 \to -5 \to 0 \]

Transfer it, opposite

Why: The peak is at three eighths of a turn, and a negative r sends the tip half a turn round from there.

\[ \left(-5, \tfrac{3\pi}{4}\right) = \left(5, \tfrac{7\pi}{4}\right): \quad \text{Quadrant IV} \]

Figure (svg): Two panels. Left: r against theta for five sine two theta over a whole turn, two humps above the axis and two below, each quarter in its own colour. Right: the polar plane with a four-petalled rose, each petal in the colour of the quarter that drew it.

Quarter two draws its petal in the fourth quadrant, not the second, because its r values are negative.

Carry on past half a turn

Why: The next two quarters repeat those r values, but now at angles half a turn further on, which are different points, so two more petals appear.

\[ r(\theta + \pi) = 5\sin(2\theta + 2\pi) = r(\theta) \]

Check the four tips

Why: The four peaks of the size of r occur at an eighth, three eighths, five eighths and seven eighths of a turn, and after the sign of r is taken into account the tips sit at forty-five, three hundred and fifteen, two hundred and twenty-five and one hundred and thirty-five degrees: one petal in each quadrant, as drawn.

\[ \left(5, \tfrac{\pi}{4}\right), \; \left(5, \tfrac{7\pi}{4}\right), \; \left(5, \tfrac{5\pi}{4}\right), \; \left(5, \tfrac{3\pi}{4}\right) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, pp. 947-949 — Example 11.5.2, number 3

Notice that the first step is again to find the zeros of r, and again those angles are the cut points. Here they are evenly spaced a quarter turn apart, which is already a hint that the finished curve will be symmetric.

Between two consecutive zeros, r goes out to its extreme and comes back: on the polar plane that is a petal, leaving the pole and returning to it. The first quarter gives a petal in the first quadrant, with its tip at an eighth of a turn where r peaks at five.

The second quarter is the one to watch. The sine of twice the angle is negative there, so r is negative, and although the angles are sweeping through the second quadrant the petal is drawn in the fourth. The colours in the figure are there so that you can match each quarter of the left panel to the petal it produced. Counting them, the four petals come out in the order first quadrant, fourth, third, second.

45. Two cycles, four petals

Picture it

Figure (svg): Two polar plots side by side. Left: only two petals, drawn from theta between zero and a half turn, one in the first quadrant and one in the fourth. Right: all four petals, drawn from theta over a whole turn.

The function has period pi, and yet stopping at pi leaves half the rose undrawn. The period and the interval are different questions.

On the left, theta has run for one period of the function, half a turn, and only two petals exist. The curve is not closed, and no amount of staring at the theta-r sketch will tell you that; you find it out by transferring and noticing that you are not back where you started.

On the right, theta has run a full turn and the rose is finished. The second half turn contributed the two petals in the second and third quadrants.

Compare the two pictures for a moment before reading on. They are the same curve drawn with two different amounts of turning, and the left one is simply unfinished.

The period of the sine of twice the angle is half a turn, and a great many students stop there, in good faith, having reasoned that r has taken every value it can. The left panel shows the result: two petals and a gap.

What the reasoning missed is that the second half turn takes those same values of r and pairs them with different directions. Since the values do not flip sign this time, the new points are genuinely new, diametrically opposite the old ones. You find this out by transferring and noticing that you have not returned to your starting point, which is why the method tells you to keep going until the curve retraces rather than to compute a period.

46. Break the claim: one period is enough

Counterexample

Discussion prompt

A classmate says: once theta has covered one period of the function, the polar curve must be complete, because r has taken every value it is ever going to take. Give a counterexample from this lesson, and explain in one sentence which word in the claim is doing the damage.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, pp. 950-951

Answer before revealing, and make sure you give an actual curve rather than a description of one; a counterexample has to be concrete.

The four-petalled rose is the cleanest refutation. Its function repeats after half a turn, and yet half of its graph is missing at that point. The reason is that the claim quietly substitutes values of r for points of the curve, and those are not the same thing.

The second half of the answer shows the failure runs both ways. The circle from earlier in the lesson has a function of period a full turn, and yet its graph closes after half a turn, because the values come back negated at exactly the moment the direction reverses. So the period is neither an upper bound nor a lower bound on the interval you need.

47. Exercise 5: three petals from five sine three theta

Worked example

Change the frequency from two to three and something surprising happens to the count.

\[ r = 5\sin(3\theta) \]

Find the zeros of r

Why: Three times the angle must be a whole number of half turns.

\[ 3\theta = k\pi \;\Longrightarrow\; \theta = 0, \tfrac{\pi}{3}, \tfrac{2\pi}{3}, \pi \]

Read the three thirds of a half turn

Why: The sine of three theta completes a full up-and-down on each third, alternating in sign.

\[ r: 0 \to 5 \to 0 \to -5 \to 0 \to 5 \to 0 \]

Place the first two tips

Why: The first peak is at a twelfth of a turn; the second is negative, at a quarter turn, so it is drawn half a turn round from there.

\[ \left(5, \tfrac{\pi}{6}\right), \qquad \left(-5, \tfrac{\pi}{2}\right) = \left(5, \tfrac{3\pi}{2}\right) \]

Place the third tip

Why: The last peak is positive again, at five twelfths of a turn.

\[ \left(5, \tfrac{5\pi}{6}\right) \]

Figure (svg): Two panels. Left: r against theta for five sine three theta over a half turn, one hump up, one down, one up. Right: the polar plane with a three-petalled rose whose petals point at thirty, one hundred and fifty, and two hundred and seventy degrees.

An odd number of petals needs only half a turn: the second hump, with its negative r, draws the petal pointing straight down.

Test whether half a turn is enough

Why: Advancing theta by half a turn flips the sign of r, and flipping the sign of r together with a half turn is the same point, so nothing new is drawn after half a turn.

\[ r(\theta + \pi) = 5\sin(3\theta + 3\pi) = -5\sin(3\theta) = -r(\theta) \]

Check the petal count against the tips

Why: Three tips, at thirty, one hundred and fifty and two hundred and seventy degrees, equally spaced by a third of a turn, which is what the drawing shows; the odd frequency gives three petals, not six.

\[ \tfrac{\pi}{6}, \; \tfrac{5\pi}{6}, \; \tfrac{3\pi}{2}: \quad \text{gaps of } \tfrac{2\pi}{3} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 958 — Exercise 5

Try predicting the petal count before you read the steps. Most people guess six, reasoning that a frequency of two gave four, and the fact that the guess is wrong is what makes this example worth doing.

Work through the thirds. The sine of three theta completes one full up-and-down over each third of a half turn, alternating sign, so the three petals come from three humps: up, down, up. The middle one has negative r, so its petal is drawn half a turn round from where its angles point, which puts it pointing straight down.

The test at the end settles the interval. Advancing theta by half a turn multiplies r by minus one, and a sign change together with a half turn is the same point, so nothing new appears after half a turn. Three tips, evenly spaced a third of a turn apart, and the curve is finished in half the turning that the four-petalled rose needed.

48. Why odd and even petal counts differ

Concept

The whole difference sits in one line of algebra: what happens to the formula when theta advances by half a turn.

\[ r(\theta + \pi) = a\sin\big(n\theta + n\pi\big) \]

\[ n \text{ odd}: \quad \sin(n\theta + n\pi) = -\sin(n\theta) \;\Longrightarrow\; r(\theta+\pi) = -r(\theta) \]

\[ n \text{ even}: \quad \sin(n\theta + n\pi) = \sin(n\theta) \;\Longrightarrow\; r(\theta+\pi) = r(\theta) \]

For odd n the radius flips sign as the direction reverses, and those two reversals cancel, so the point is the one already drawn. For even n the radius is unchanged while the direction reverses, so the point is a new one, diametrically opposite.

frequency npetalsinterval needed
oddnhalf a turn
even2na whole turn

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, pp. 947-951 — the rose of Example 11.5.2 and the closing remarks

Three lines of algebra explain the entire phenomenon, and they are worth being able to reproduce rather than remember.

Adding half a turn to theta adds n half turns to the argument of the sine. If n is odd that is an odd number of half turns, which flips the sign of the sine; if n is even it is a whole number of full turns, which changes nothing.

Now combine that with the renaming rule. A sign flip in r together with a half turn in theta is the same point, so for odd n the second half turn retraces. No sign flip together with a half turn in theta is the opposite point, so for even n the second half turn draws a whole new set of petals, diametrically opposite the first set. That is why odd gives n petals and even gives twice as many.

49. Why the petals come out evenly spaced

Intuition

The zeros of r are what separate one petal from the next, since a petal begins and ends at the pole. So the spacing of the petals is the spacing of the zeros.

The zeros of the sine of n times theta are evenly spaced, one every half turn divided by n, because the sine vanishes at equally spaced arguments and dividing the argument by n compresses that spacing uniformly. Evenly spaced zeros give evenly spaced petals.

The tips sit exactly halfway between consecutive zeros, where the sine reaches its extreme, which is why a rose looks so regular. None of this needs to be memorised; it can be read off the theta-r sketch in a few seconds.

This is a short slide but it removes a lot of mystery. The petals are separated by the visits to the pole, so the pattern of the petals is the pattern of the zeros of r.

The sine vanishes at evenly spaced arguments, and replacing theta by n times theta compresses that even spacing uniformly. Even spacing in, even spacing out. No further work is needed.

So when you sketch a rose by hand, the fastest route is to find the zeros, mark those directions on the paper, and then put one petal in each of the gaps with its tip in the middle. You will get a better picture in less time than any table of points could give you.

50. Match each rose to its petal count

Matching

Match the pairs

  • a. r = 2 sin 2θ
  • b. r = 5 sin 3θ
  • c. r = cos 5θ
  • d. r = 3 cos 4θ
  • w. four petals, needs a whole turn
  • x. three petals, done after half a turn
  • y. five petals, done after half a turn
  • z. eight petals, needs a whole turn

Why: Count by the frequency alone, and ignore the amplitude and the choice of sine or cosine. An odd frequency gives that many petals and finishes in half a turn; an even frequency gives twice as many and needs a full turn. So 3 and 5 give three and five petals, while 2 and 4 give four and eight.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 958 — Exercises 3 to 8

Match all four before checking, and be strict with yourself about the interval as well as the count; they come as a pair.

Only one number in each equation matters, the one multiplying theta. The amplitude scales the petals without changing anything structural, and the choice between sine and cosine rotates the whole flower without changing anything structural either.

If you slipped on the last one, the trap is that a frequency of four feels like it ought to give four petals. It gives eight, because even frequencies draw a second, opposite set on the second half turn. Odd frequencies are the ones whose petal count matches their frequency.

51. How far must theta run?

Prediction

\[ r = \sin(4\theta) \]

Predict first

How much turning does theta need to do before this curve is complete?

  • A quarter turn
  • A half turn
  • One full turn
  • Two full turns

Correct: One full turn

Why: The frequency is four, an even number, so advancing theta by half a turn leaves the radius unchanged while reversing the direction, and that produces brand new points on the opposite side. A full turn is needed, and the result is eight petals. Notice that the period of the function itself is only a quarter of a turn, four times shorter than the answer.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 958 — Exercise 7

Choose before revealing, and notice how little the equation is telling you: no amplitude to speak of and no phase, just a frequency.

The frequency is even, so half a turn leaves r completely unchanged while reversing every direction, and reversed directions with unchanged radii are brand new points. A full turn is needed.

The number to compare against is the period of the function, which is a quarter of a turn here. So the interval you need is four times the period, which is as clear a demonstration as you will get that the two quantities are unrelated.

52. When r is squared

Section

Part 5

53. Solving for r opens a gap

Concept

Everything so far had r alone on the left. When r appears squared, solving for it introduces a square root, and a square root brings two new features at once.

\[ r^2 = 16\cos(2\theta) \;\Longrightarrow\; r = \pm 4\sqrt{\cos(2\theta)} \]

\[ \cos(2\theta) < 0 \iff \tfrac{\pi}{4} < \theta < \tfrac{3\pi}{4} \;\text{ or }\; \tfrac{5\pi}{4} < \theta < \tfrac{7\pi}{4} \]

This is new. Every earlier curve had a point in every direction; this one is blank over whole wedges of the plane.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, pp. 949-950 — Example 11.5.2, number 4

Everything changes when r appears squared, and it is worth being explicit about what is new rather than treating this as another example.

Taking a square root introduces two branches, and both of them belong to the graph, because squaring either one recovers the original equation. Throwing one away loses half the curve, which is the trap a few slides along.

The second consequence is stranger and has no analogue in the earlier curves. Where the right-hand side is negative there is no real square root, so there is no point of the curve in that direction at all. Every limacon and every rose had at least one point in every direction; this curve has whole wedges of directions that are simply empty.

54. Example 11.5.2(4): the lemniscate of Bernoulli

Worked example

Sketch both branches on the theta-r plane, then transfer both.

\[ r^2 = 16\cos(2\theta) \]

Solve for r

Why: Take the square root of both sides and keep both signs.

\[ r = \pm\sqrt{16\cos(2\theta)} = \pm 4\sqrt{\cos(2\theta)} \]

Find where the square root exists

Why: The cosine of twice the angle must be at least zero.

\[ \cos(2\theta) \ge 0 \iff 0 \le \theta \le \tfrac{\pi}{4} \;\text{ or }\; \tfrac{3\pi}{4} \le \theta \le \pi \]

Find the range on those intervals

Why: The cosine runs from one down to zero, and so does its square root, so r runs between zero and plus or minus four.

\[ 0 \le \sqrt{\cos(2\theta)} \le 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; -4 \le r \le 4 \]

Transfer the plus branch

Why: It starts four units out along the positive horizontal axis, shrinks to nothing by an eighth of a turn, is absent until three eighths, then grows back to four at half a turn.

\[ (4, 0) \;\to\; \text{pole} \;\to\; (4, \pi) = (-4, 0) \]

Transfer the minus branch

Why: The same sizes, drawn in the opposite directions, which fills in the two lower halves of the loops.

\[ (-4, 0) = (4, \pi), \qquad (-4, \pi) = (4, 0) \]

Figure (svg): Two panels. Left: the theta-r plane over a half turn showing the dotted curve four cosine two theta and the two solid branches plus and minus four root cosine two theta, which vanish between a quarter of pi and three quarters of pi. Right: the polar plane with a figure-of-eight lying along the horizontal axis.

Each branch draws half of each loop, and the gap in the middle of the left panel is the empty wedge in the middle of the right one.

Identify the guide lines

Why: The angles where r is zero are an eighth and three eighths of a turn, and the curve enters and leaves the pole along those two lines.

\[ \theta = \tfrac{\pi}{4}, \qquad \theta = \tfrac{3\pi}{4} \]

Check one point on the curve

Why: At a twelfth of a turn the cosine of twice the angle is a half, so r is four times the square root of a half, about 2.828, and squaring that gives eight, which is sixteen times a half, so the point satisfies the original equation.

\[ r^2 = (2.828)^2 = 8 = 16\cos\left(\tfrac{\pi}{3}\right) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, pp. 949-950 — Example 11.5.2, number 4

Work down the steps and notice that the first three are all about the algebra of the square root, before any sketching happens. Solve, then find the domain, then find the range.

The domain is the new step. The cosine of twice the angle is non-negative on the first eighth of a turn and again from three eighths to a half, and negative in between. Those two intervals are where the curve exists over the first half turn, and the gap between them is the empty wedge.

Then transfer both branches. The plus branch starts four units out to the right, comes in to the pole at an eighth of a turn, is absent, then reappears and grows back out to four at half a turn, which is four units to the left. The minus branch does the same sizes in the opposite directions, filling in the other halves of the two loops. The check squares a value back into the original equation, which is always worth doing when a square root has been taken.

55. The angles the lemniscate forbids

Picture it

Figure (svg): The polar plane with the figure-of-eight drawn faintly and two shaded wedges, one opening upwards and one downwards between the dashed lines at a quarter of pi and three quarters of pi, marked as directions with no points.

Wherever the cosine of twice the angle is negative there is no square root, so those whole directions are empty of curve.

Two whole wedges of directions contain no points of the curve at all. Nothing like this happened with a limacon or a rose, where every direction carried at least one point.

The wedges are exactly the angles at which the cosine of twice the angle is negative, and their boundaries are the two lines along which the curve slips through the pole.

Look at the two shaded wedges and appreciate how unusual they are. For every curve earlier in this lesson, standing at the pole and turning slowly, you would see the curve in every direction you faced. Here there are whole ranges of directions with nothing in them.

The boundaries of the wedges are the two lines along which r is zero, and those are the same two lines the curve hugs as it passes through the pole. So the figure is telling you two things at once: where the curve is absent, and the direction from which it enters and leaves the origin.

If you are ever unsure whether a polar curve has gaps like this, the test is quick. Solve for r, and look for anything that can fail to be defined: a square root of a negative number, or a division by zero.

56. Where the two square roots go

Intuition

It is tempting to think of the plus branch as the top half of the figure and the minus branch as the bottom half. That is not what happens, and the coloured picture two slides back shows it.

On the first eighth of a turn the plus branch draws the upper part of the right-hand loop, because the angles point up and to the right. On the last eighth before half a turn the same plus branch draws the upper part of the left-hand loop. Each branch contributes to both loops.

The minus branch mirrors that: it fills the lower part of the left-hand loop from the first eighth, and the lower part of the right-hand loop from the last eighth. Taking the two branches together is what closes each loop.

This is a correction to the most natural wrong mental picture, and it is worth making now rather than after you have drawn a few of these.

You might expect the plus branch to be the upper half of the figure and the minus branch the lower half, by analogy with the two square roots of an ordinary rectangular equation. On the polar plane it does not work like that, because the sign of r interacts with the direction.

Go back to the coloured figure and trace one branch with your finger. The plus branch draws an upper piece on the right and an upper piece on the left; the minus branch draws the two lower pieces. Each loop is built from one piece of each branch, which is why you need both.

57. Trap: keeping only the positive square root

Trap

The trap

After solving for r, only one sign survives:

\[ r = 4\sqrt{\cos(2\theta)} \]

\[ \Longrightarrow\; \text{two half-loops, not two loops} \]

Wrong. Half the curve has been thrown away.

The fix

Both signs satisfy the original equation, since squaring destroys the sign, so both branches are part of the graph.

\[ (-4\sqrt{\cos 2\theta})^2 = 16\cos(2\theta) \]

There is one way to get the whole curve from the positive branch alone, and it is to let theta run over a full turn instead of half of one, which reaches the same points by a different route.

The habit of taking the principal square root is drilled into you for good reasons elsewhere, and it is exactly wrong here. The original equation involves r squared, and squaring destroys signs, so both roots satisfy it.

The concrete cost is that you draw two half-loops instead of two loops and end up with a curve that is not closed, which should itself be a warning sign.

The remark on the right is a genuinely useful alternative, and the book puts it in a footnote. If you let theta run over a full turn instead of half of one, the positive branch alone visits every point of the curve, because the second half turn reaches the places the negative branch was covering. Either route works; what does not work is half a turn with one branch.

58. Exercise 19: a lemniscate along the diagonal

Worked example

The same structure with sine in place of cosine, from the exercise set.

\[ r^2 = \sin(2\theta) \]

Solve for r

Why: Both signs again, and the amplitude is one this time.

\[ r = \pm\sqrt{\sin(2\theta)} \]

Find where it exists

Why: The sine of twice the angle must be at least zero, which happens on the first and third quarters of the turn.

\[ \sin(2\theta) \ge 0 \iff 0 \le \theta \le \tfrac{\pi}{2} \;\text{ or }\; \pi \le \theta \le \tfrac{3\pi}{2} \]

Find the peak

Why: The sine of twice the angle is one at an eighth of a turn, so the size of r peaks at one there.

\[ 2\theta = \tfrac{\pi}{2} \;\Longrightarrow\; \theta = \tfrac{\pi}{4}, \quad r = \pm 1 \]

Transfer the plus branch

Why: From the pole out to one unit along the diagonal of the first quadrant and back to the pole.

\[ \left(1, \tfrac{\pi}{4}\right) \]

Figure (svg): Two panels. Left: the two branches of plus and minus the square root of sine two theta over a whole turn, present on the first and third quarters and absent on the second and fourth. Right: the polar plane with a figure-of-eight lying along the diagonal line through the first and third quadrants.

Replacing cosine by sine rotates the whole figure by an eighth of a turn, and the forbidden wedges rotate with it.

Transfer the minus branch

Why: The same sizes in the opposite directions, which draws the loop in the third quadrant.

\[ \left(-1, \tfrac{\pi}{4}\right) = \left(1, \tfrac{5\pi}{4}\right) \]

Check against the previous lemniscate

Why: Replacing the cosine by the sine shifts the argument by a quarter turn, which shifts theta by an eighth of a turn, so the whole figure turns by forty-five degrees and lies along the diagonal instead of the horizontal axis, exactly as drawn.

\[ \sin(2\theta) = \cos\left(2\theta - \tfrac{\pi}{2}\right) = \cos\left(2\left(\theta - \tfrac{\pi}{4}\right)\right) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 958 — Exercise 19

Try this one on your own before reading the steps; it is the same structure as the last example with one ingredient changed.

The sine of twice the angle is non-negative on the first quarter turn and again on the third, which is a quarter turn later than where the cosine version was available. So the loops sit along the diagonal of the first and third quadrants rather than along the horizontal axis.

The final check explains why in one line. The sine of twice the angle is the cosine of twice the angle minus a quarter turn, which is the cosine of twice the quantity theta minus an eighth of a turn. Replacing theta by theta minus a constant rotates a polar curve by that constant, so this whole figure is the previous one turned through forty-five degrees.

59. Fill in the forbidden interval

Fill the middle

Where the first lemniscate has no points, written as an inequality on theta.

Fill in the blanks

r^2 = 16\cos(2\theta): \quad \text\frac{\pi}{4} \quad \frac{3\pi}{4} < \theta < ___

Why: An eighth of a turn and three eighths of a turn. Between them the cosine of twice the angle is negative, so its square root does not exist and no point of the curve lies in those directions. The same gap repeats half a turn later, between five eighths and seven eighths.

Fill both blanks before checking. The work is one inequality: where is the cosine of twice the angle negative?

The cosine of an argument is negative when that argument lies between a quarter turn and three quarters of a turn. Here the argument is twice theta, so divide those bounds by two, and you get an eighth of a turn to three eighths of a turn.

Do not forget that the same thing happens again on the far side. The cosine of twice the angle is periodic with period half a turn, so there is a second forbidden wedge exactly opposite the first, and the two together are the two gaps you can see in the picture.

60. Putting it together

Section

Part 6

61. Pattern: graphing any polar equation

Pattern

Figure (svg): A flow diagram in three rows: sketch r against theta, then solve r equals zero, then cut at those angles and the quadrant angles; from there, read each piece for size and sign; the reading branches down to two boxes, one for positive r drawn where theta points and one for negative r drawn half a turn round.

Two cheap steps before any drawing: the sketch, and the angles where r vanishes.
  1. If one variable is missing, stop and use Theorem 11.8: a circle about the pole, or a whole line through it.
  2. Otherwise sketch r against theta on ordinary rectangular axes, over one full turn to start with.
  3. Solve for the zeros of r and mark those angles; they are where the curve visits the pole, and the lines it hugs on the way.
  4. Cut at the quadrant angles and the zeros, and on each piece read off two things: is r growing or shrinking, and is it positive or negative.
  5. Transfer each piece, drawing the negative ones in the opposite direction, half a turn round from where theta points.
  6. Stop when the curve retraces, which may be sooner or later than the period of the function.

This is the order to work in, and it runs from the cheapest check to the most expensive. Read the diagram as a route rather than a list.

The first question costs nothing: is a variable missing? If so, Theorem 11.8 finishes the problem in one line. The second cheap step is to solve for the zeros of r, and that single equation tells you whether the curve reaches the pole, how many times, and along which lines.

Only then do you cut the interval and read each piece, and the reading always asks the same two questions, about size and about sign. The last step is the one most often skipped: how far theta must run is found by watching for retracing, not by computing the period of the function. That mistake is what leaves roses half drawn.

62. Put the method in order

Ranking

Put in order

Order the steps of a complete hand sketch of a polar curve.

  1. Check whether one of the two variables is missing, and if so quote Theorem 11.8
  2. Sketch r as an ordinary function of theta on rectangular axes
  3. Solve for the angles at which r is zero
  4. Cut the interval at those angles and at the quadrant angles
  5. On each piece, read whether r grows or shrinks and whether it is positive or negative
  6. Transfer each piece, drawing negative r half a turn round
  7. Extend theta until the curve retraces, then stop

Why: The cheap check goes first because it can end the problem in one line. The zeros of r have to be known before the cutting, since they are cut points; the reading has to be done before the transfer, since it is what the transfer uses; and the question of how far theta must run is answered last, by watching for retracing rather than by looking at the period.

Drag the seven steps into order before checking. Two of the orderings are genuinely forced and the rest follow from them.

The zeros of r must be found before the cutting, because they are among the cut points. And the reading of each piece must come before the transfer, because the transfer is nothing but the reading turned into a drawing.

The last step deserves its place at the end. You do not know how far theta must run until you have drawn enough to see the curve come back on itself, which is precisely why the period of the function is not the answer.

63. Where a polar graph is the natural picture

Real world

Figure (svg): Two panels. Left: the sensitivity of a microphone plotted against the angle of the sound, falling from one to zero over half a turn. Right: the same information as a polar curve, a heart shape open towards the front with a sharp point at the back.

The same numbers twice. The polar picture is the one an engineer reads, because direction is the thing being described.

Discussion prompt

A studio microphone has a cardioid pickup pattern: its gain at an angle theta from the front is one half plus one half of the cosine of theta. Find the angle at which the microphone is completely deaf, and the gain at ninety degrees to the front, then say why the polar picture is the useful one.

OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §10.4 Polar Coordinates: Graphs §10.4 — polar graphs of real quantities

Work out both numbers before revealing. The first is a one-line equation and the second is a substitution.

Setting the gain to zero forces the cosine to be minus one, which happens only directly behind the microphone. That is the single most useful fact about a cardioid microphone, and it is why you point the dead side at the thing you do not want to record. At ninety degrees the gain is exactly a half, which sound engineers quote as about six decibels down.

The two panels carry identical information, and that is the point worth taking away. The left panel is easier to read a number off; the right panel is easier to act on, because the quantity being described is a direction and the picture is drawn in directions. Whenever that is true of a problem, polar coordinates are the right choice.

64. Check: the constant graphs

Check

Check your understanding

Which of these describes the graph of the equation theta equals three pi over four?

  • A. A ray from the pole into Quadrant II
  • B. The whole line through the pole at 135° (correct)
  • C. A circle of radius 3π/4 about the pole
  • D. All of Quadrant II

Answer: B

Why: Theorem 11.8 says the graph of a constant angle is the line containing the terminal side, not the terminal side alone. Negative values of r supply the other half of the line, in Quadrant IV.

Why A tempts people
That is the terminal side by itself, which leaves out every point coming from a negative value of r.
Why C tempts people
A circle needs r to be the constant, not theta; here r is the free variable.
Why D tempts people
A region would need an inequality. The equation fixes one direction exactly.

The question is about how much of the line belongs to the graph, not about which angle is meant.

Because r is free and unrestricted, it takes negative values as well as positive ones, and those supply the opposite ray. So the graph is a complete line through the pole. The option offering only the ray is the one that would be right if the problem had added a condition making r non-negative.

65. Check: reading a negative r

Check

Check your understanding

A theta-r sketch shows that r equals minus three when theta is one sixth of a turn. Where does that point go?

  • A. 3 units from the pole in the direction 30°
  • B. 3 units from the pole in the direction 210° (correct)
  • C. 3 units below the pole, on the negative vertical axis
  • D. Nowhere: a distance cannot be negative

Answer: B

Why: A negative first coordinate reverses the direction, so add half a turn to the angle and use the size of r. One sixth of a turn is 30°, and adding 180° gives 210°, three units out in that direction.

Why A tempts people
That ignores the minus sign, which is precisely the error this lesson is built to prevent.
Why C tempts people
Reflecting in the horizontal axis is not what a negative r does; it reverses through the pole instead.
Why D tempts people
The first coordinate is a directed distance, not a distance, and it is allowed to be negative.

Run the renaming rule rather than trusting your eye. Negate the radius and add half a turn.

One sixth of a turn is thirty degrees, and adding a half turn gives two hundred and ten degrees, so the point sits three units out in the third quadrant. The tempting wrong answer simply drops the minus sign, and the other wrong answer reflects instead of reversing.

66. Check: how far theta must run

Check

Check your understanding

How much turning does theta need to do to complete the graph of r equals four cosine of twice theta?

  • A. A quarter turn
  • B. A half turn
  • C. One full turn (correct)
  • D. Two full turns

Answer: C

Why: The frequency is two, an even number, so advancing theta by half a turn leaves r unchanged while reversing the direction, which produces new points opposite the old ones. A full turn is needed and the result has four petals.

Why A tempts people
A quarter turn is the period of the function, and this lesson's whole point is that the period is not the answer.
Why B tempts people
Half a turn would be enough if the frequency were odd, because then r would flip sign and cancel the reversal of direction.
Why D tempts people
Nothing new appears after one full turn; the second turn simply redraws the first.

Look at the frequency and nothing else; the amplitude is irrelevant to this question.

Two is even, so half a turn leaves the radius alone while reversing every direction, which manufactures a second set of petals opposite the first. A whole turn is needed and the rose has four petals. Note that the period of the function is only a quarter turn, which is the trap this question is built around.

67. Explain the two planes

Explain it to yourself

Discussion prompt

A classmate asks why you bother drawing two pictures instead of just plotting points. In three sentences, explain what the first picture is, what it is not, and what job it does that a table of points cannot.

Write your three sentences out before revealing; explaining a method to someone else is the fastest way to find the part of it you do not actually understand.

The sentence people most often leave out is the middle one. The theta-r sketch is not a distorted version of the polar curve and it is not an approximation to it; it is a graph of a completely different thing, namely the relationship between two numbers. For a circle through the pole it is a cosine wave, which looks nothing like a circle.

The third sentence is the payoff. A table gives you dots and hides the behaviour between them, and in polar coordinates the behaviour between the dots includes sign changes and visits to the pole, which are exactly the events that determine the shape.

68. Exit ticket

Exit ticket

\[ r = 3 - 3\cos(\theta) \]

Discussion prompt

Say how far theta must run, find every angle at which the curve reaches the pole, give the point furthest from the pole, and name the shape.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations §11.5, p. 958 — Exercise 9

This pulls the whole lesson together on one curve, and every part of the answer comes from a step you have practised.

The constant and the coefficient are equal, so the equation r equal to zero has exactly one solution in a turn, at angle zero. One visit to the pole means a cusp rather than a loop, and a limacon with a cusp is a cardioid. The largest radius is six, at half a turn, which puts the furthest point six units along the negative horizontal axis.

For the interval, test what half a turn does: it turns the minus cosine into a plus cosine, which is neither the same function nor its negative, so half a turn is not enough and you need the full turn. If you answered half a turn out of habit from the rose, that is precisely the habit this lesson has been trying to break.

69. Recap

Recap

equationwhat to look atgraph
r = aθ is freecircle about the pole, radius |a|
θ = αr is free, and may be negativethe whole line, both halves
r = a ± b cos θ or a ± b sin θthe size of a against the size of blimacon: loop, cusp or clear of the pole
r = a sin nθ or a cos nθwhether n is odd or evenrose: n petals in half a turn, or 2n in a full turn
r² = a cos 2θ or a sin 2θwhere the right side is negativelemniscate, with two empty wedges

\[ (-r, \theta) = (r, \theta + \pi) \]

That one identity is the lesson. It is why the constant-angle graph is a line and not a ray, why a limacon has an inner loop on the far side of the pole, why an odd rose closes in half a turn and an even one does not, and why both square roots of a lemniscate are needed.

Next, Section 11.5 continues with the points at which two polar curves intersect, where the same identity causes real trouble: two curves can cross at a point without any single pair of coordinates satisfying both equations.

OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §10.4 Polar Coordinates: Graphs §10.4 — the same families, with the classification tabulated

Five rows and one identity. The five rows are the families you can now sketch by inspection, and the column in the middle tells you what to look at first in each case.

The identity underneath is the thing to carry out of the lesson, because every row depends on it. It is why a constant angle gives a line rather than a ray, why an inner loop lands on the far side of the pole, why a rose with an odd frequency closes in half a turn, and why a lemniscate needs both square roots.

The method itself is unchanged for every new curve you will ever meet: sketch r against theta, find the zeros, cut, read off size and sign, transfer, and stop when it retraces. The next lesson keeps all of this and asks a harder question on top of it, namely where two of these curves cross, and you will find that the same identity that made this lesson work is what makes that one difficult.

Sources

  1. Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.5 Graphs of Polar Equations — Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Version 3 Corrected Edition, July 4 2013, pp. 938-951
  2. OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §10.4 Polar Coordinates: Graphs

Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Trigonometry — $55/session, free consultation.

Book on Wyzant · Text (657) 465-8108