Theorem 11.7 and what it does and does not settle. Converts points in both directions, showing why the arctangent alone cannot determine the angle and why every conversion into polar form starts with a sketch. Then converts equations both ways, contrasting the mechanical rectangular-to-polar substitution with the awkward reverse, and examining what multiplying by r and squaring both sides do to a solution set.
Subject: Trigonometry · 68 slides · symbolic lesson
Open the interactive version of this deck
Title
Trigonometry · Section 11.4
One point, two addresses, and the dictionary between them
Objectives
The previous lesson built the polar system beside the rectangular one and never connected them. Theorem 11.7 connects them, and almost every mark lost on this material is lost in one of the two directions it opens.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, pp. 924-929 — the pages these objectives are drawn from
The last lesson gave you a second way to name a point and left the two systems sitting side by side, unconnected. This lesson builds the bridge. Once it is built you can move any point, and any equation, from one system to the other.
The bridge is not symmetric, and that asymmetry is the whole plot of the lesson. One direction is a substitution you could do half asleep: two formulas, two answers, no decisions. The other direction hands you two constraints that narrow the answer without ever finishing it, and something outside the algebra has to choose. That something is a sketch.
The second half does the same thing for equations rather than points, and adds a new worry: an algebraic move can quietly change which points an equation describes. You will learn which moves are risky, what each one adds or loses, and the one feature of polar coordinates that usually rescues you.
Warm-up
Discussion prompt
An angle is in standard position and a point sits on its terminal side, a distance r from the origin. Write down the two formulas from Section 10.2 that give the cosine and the sine of that angle in terms of the point's coordinates. Then rearrange them to isolate x and y.
Write your answer down before revealing. If the two formulas come back instantly, this lesson is going to feel short; if they do not, go back to Section 10.2 for five minutes, because everything here is built on them.
Those definitions were stated for a point on the terminal side of an angle in standard position, at a distance from the origin. That is exactly the situation a polar pair describes: the angle is the rotation and the distance is how far out you walk. So the definition is already the conversion; it just needs rearranging and then extending to the cases the definition did not cover.
Notice which way the definitions point. They give you a cosine and a sine from a point. What you usually want is the reverse: a point from a cosine and a sine. Multiplying through by the distance turns one into the other.
Section
Part 1
Concept
Identify the pole with the origin and the polar axis with the positive horizontal axis. Now every point of the plane carries both kinds of address at once, and the question is how to translate.
Figure (svg): Two square coordinate planes side by side, each showing the same point. On the left the point is reached by moving 2 to the right and 2 root 3 up along a rectangular grid. On the right the same point is reached by turning through a third of pi from the polar axis and walking out 4 units along concentric circles.
On the left the instructions are two perpendicular walks. On the right they are one turn and one walk. Both end at the same place, so there must be a formula carrying either pair to the other.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 924 — identifying the pole with the origin
Look at the two panels and read them as two sets of directions to the same house. On the left: go two blocks east, then a little over three and a half blocks north. On the right: face a third of a turn from due east, then walk four blocks. Both work, and a driver who only understands one set needs a translator.
The translation only exists because of a decision made in the first sentence: the pole is the origin and the polar axis is the positive horizontal axis. If a problem ever puts the pole somewhere else, none of the formulas in this lesson apply until you shift the picture back.
Keep the right-hand panel in mind when polar equations start looking strange. The concentric circles are the lines of constant distance and the rays are the lines of constant direction; a polar equation is a curve drawn on that grid, and it will look natural or awkward depending on whether the curve respects that grid.
Picture it
Figure (svg): A coordinate plane with a ray from the origin out to a point in the first quadrant. A vertical dashed drop from the point to the horizontal axis makes a right triangle whose hypotenuse is r, whose horizontal leg is labelled r cosine theta and whose vertical leg is labelled r sine theta, with the angle theta marked at the origin.
Drop a perpendicular from the point to the horizontal axis. The hypotenuse is the directed distance, the angle at the origin is the rotation, and the two legs are the coordinates you want.
This single triangle generates all four relations, and it is worth being able to draw it from memory in about three seconds. The point is at the far corner, the origin is at the near corner, and the perpendicular dropped to the horizontal axis makes the right angle.
The hypotenuse is the directed distance. The horizontal leg is the adjacent side of the angle, so the cosine of the angle is that leg over the hypotenuse, which rearranges to the first coordinate being the distance times the cosine. The vertical leg is the opposite side, so the same argument gives the second coordinate.
The two constraint relations come from the same triangle read differently: the Pythagorean theorem on the legs gives the sum of squares, and the opposite over the adjacent gives the tangent. If you ever forget a formula in this lesson, draw the triangle rather than trying to recall the symbols.
Concept
Theorem 11.7 — Suppose a point is written in rectangular coordinates as x and y and in polar coordinates as a directed distance and an angle. Then the first coordinate is the distance times the cosine of the angle, the second is the distance times the sine, the sum of the squares of the coordinates is the square of the distance, and the tangent of the angle is the second coordinate over the first, provided the first is not zero.
\[ x = r\cos(\theta), \qquad y = r\sin(\theta) \]
\[ x^2 + y^2 = r^2, \qquad \tan(\theta) = \frac{y}{x} \quad (x \ne 0) \]
Read the first line as a recipe and the second line as a constraint. A recipe hands you an answer; a constraint only narrows the field of candidates.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 924 — Theorem 11.7
Read the two lines as different kinds of statement. The first line is a recipe: feed in a distance and an angle and it hands you two numbers, with no choices and no conditions. The second line is a constraint: it is a true statement about any point, but it does not hand you anything, it only rules candidates out.
That distinction is the single most useful idea in this lesson. Nearly every lost mark in this material comes from asking the second line to do the first line's job, that is, treating the tangent relation as though it produced an angle rather than filtering one.
Note the proviso attached to the tangent relation and the absence of any proviso on the first line. The recipes are unconditional, including when the distance is negative and at the pole itself. You will prove those two cases on the next slides, because a theorem that quietly assumed a positive distance would undo the flexibility the previous lesson spent all its time building.
Notation
Annotate
On: \( x = r\cos(\theta) \qquad\text{and}\qquad y = r\sin(\theta) \)
Step through the annotations and notice how little is being asked of you. There is no case analysis, no absolute value and no sign rule. You substitute a distance and an angle and you get two numbers.
The second annotation explains why you can be relaxed about which name for the point you were handed. Two coterminal angles have the same cosine and the same sine, so they produce the same rectangular pair. Since a point has infinitely many polar names and only one rectangular one, a formula going this way must be insensitive to the choice of name, and it is.
The first annotation is the one that earns the proof on the next-but-one slide. It is easy to believe these formulas when the distance is positive and the angle is acute, because then the triangle picture is right there. Believing them when the distance is negative takes an argument.
Concept
Square the two recipes and add. The Pythagorean identity collapses the right-hand side and the first constraint falls out.
\[ x^2 + y^2 = r^2\cos^2(\theta) + r^2\sin^2(\theta) = r^2\left(\cos^2(\theta)+\sin^2(\theta)\right) = r^2 \]
Divide the second recipe by the first instead, and the quotient identity gives the other constraint.
\[ \frac{y}{x} = \frac{r\sin(\theta)}{r\cos(\theta)} = \tan(\theta) \quad (x \ne 0) \]
Notice what was lost on the way. Squaring throws away the sign of the distance, and dividing cancels the distance completely and throws away half of the direction. The second pair can never return more than it was given.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 924 — the quotient identity behind Theorem 11.7
Both constraints are derived here rather than stated, and the derivations are short enough that you should be able to reproduce them. Square and add, and the Pythagorean identity does the work. Divide, and the quotient identity does the work.
Now watch what each derivation destroys. Squaring makes the sign of the distance invisible, so the sum of squares can only ever tell you the distance in size, never its sign. Dividing cancels the distance completely, so the quotient knows nothing about how far out the point is, and it also cannot distinguish a direction from the exactly opposite direction, since flipping both coordinates leaves the quotient alone.
This is why the second pair is where the work is. Each relation gives you a number that two different answers share, so each one leaves you with a decision. The rest of Part 3 is about making that decision reliably, and the answer turns out to be embarrassingly simple: draw the point.
Worked example
The theorem is proved for a positive distance by Theorem 10.3. Here is the case that needs work.
\[ \text{Show } x = r\cos(\theta) \text{ still holds when } r < 0. \]
Rewrite the pair with a positive first coordinate
Why: The equivalent-representations rule flips the sign of the distance and adds a half turn.
\[ (r, \theta) \;\text{ names the same point as }\; (-r, \theta + \pi), \quad -r > 0 \]
Apply the already-proved case to the new pair
Why: Its first coordinate is positive, so Theorem 10.3 applies to it.
\[ x = (-r)\cos(\theta + \pi) \]
Substitute the half-turn identity
Why: Adding pi reflects the point through the origin, so the cosine changes sign.
\[ \cos(\theta + \pi) = -\cos(\theta) \]
Simplify the two sign changes
Why: A negative times a negative.
\[ x = (-r)\bigl(-\cos(\theta)\bigr) = r\cos(\theta) \]
Figure (svg): A coordinate plane with a dashed ray drawn in the direction of a third of pi and a solid arrow drawn from the origin in exactly the opposite direction, reaching a point in the third quadrant three and a half units from the origin. A dashed circle of that radius passes through both the forward and the backward position.
Check on a case with a negative distance
Why: The pair with distance minus three and angle a third of pi should land three units out in the opposite direction, at x equal to minus one point five. The formula gives minus three times one half, which is minus one point five, and the picture agrees.
\[ x = (-3)\cos\left(\tfrac{\pi}{3}\right) = (-3)\left(\tfrac12\right) = -1.5 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 924 — the proof of Theorem 11.7 for r negative
The reason this case needs its own proof is that the circular-function definition from Chapter 10 was stated for a point on the terminal side of the angle, and when the distance is negative the point is on the opposite side. The definition simply does not reach it.
The repair uses the equivalence rule from the previous lesson. Any pair with a negative first coordinate names the same point as the pair with the sign flipped and a half turn added, and that second pair does have a positive first coordinate, so the already-proved case applies to it. Then the half-turn identity for cosine contributes a minus sign that exactly cancels the one you introduced.
Look at the figure while you read the argument. The dashed arrow is where a positive distance would have sent you, the solid arrow is where the negative distance actually sends you, and the two are a half turn apart on the same circle. The cancellation of the two minus signs is that half turn, written in algebra.
Intuition
The remaining case is the pole itself, where the distance is zero. Both recipes return zero whatever the angle, which is the right answer: the pole is the origin.
\[ r = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 0\cdot\cos(\theta) = 0, \quad y = 0\cdot\sin(\theta) = 0 \]
The constraint pair says nothing useful there. The sum of squares is zero, which is honest, but the tangent relation is undefined, because the first coordinate is zero. The pole is the one point whose angle is pure convention.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 924 — the case r equals zero
The pole is the last case and the easiest, but it is worth a moment because it is the one point where the polar system genuinely misbehaves. The recipes return zero and zero whatever angle you feed them, which is correct, since every pair with a zero first coordinate names the pole.
The constraint pair is less happy. The sum of squares is zero, which is true and useless. The tangent relation does not apply at all, because the first coordinate is zero. So if you are ever converting the origin into polar form, do not compute: just say that the distance is zero and the angle is anything you like.
Exercise 97 of this section asks you to name the origin in four different ways, and the point of the exercise is precisely this. No restriction on the range of the angle can ever make the pole's name unique, because the angle plays no part in locating it.
Prediction
A point is known only by its polar first coordinate, which is seven. Nothing is known about its angle.
Predict first
What can you say about the sum of the squares of its rectangular coordinates?
Correct: It equals 49
Why: The theorem says the sum of the squares of the coordinates is the square of the directed distance, and that holds for every angle. Seven squared is forty-nine. The angle decides where on the circle the point sits, never how far out it is.
Commit to an option before revealing. The trap here is to read the question as being about the point, which is unknown, rather than about the sum of squares, which is not.
The constraint relation says that the sum of the squares of the rectangular coordinates equals the square of the directed distance, and there is no angle anywhere in that statement. So knowing the distance fixes the sum of squares exactly, and knowing nothing about the angle costs you nothing here.
Geometrically, all you have been told is that the point lies on a circle of radius seven about the origin. The angle decides where on that circle, never how far out. Notice also that the answer would be the same if the distance were minus seven, which is another way of seeing that the sum of squares cannot recover the sign.
Socratic
Discussion prompt
Theorem 11.7 states the tangent relation only when the first coordinate is not zero. Say what breaks when it is zero, and how such points are handled instead.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 924 — the proviso on the tangent relation
Answer in writing before revealing. This looks like a technicality and it is not: it is the first place where the constraint pair visibly runs out.
When the first coordinate is zero the quotient is undefined, and so is the tangent of the angle you are looking for, which is a quarter turn or three quarters of a turn. The two sides break together, which is at least consistent, but consistency does not help you solve for anything. An undefined equals undefined is not an equation you can use.
The practical response is the one the book takes in Example 11.4.2, part 3: read the angle off the picture. A point on an axis has an obvious direction, and insisting on the algebra there is a way of making an easy problem hard. Keep this case in mind, because it is the cleanest demonstration that the sketch is part of the method, not a substitute for it.
Section
Part 2
Concept
Going from polar to rectangular form, both answers come from the recipe pair. There is no quadrant to decide, no sign to choose and nothing to check afterwards except your arithmetic.
\[ (r, \theta) \;\longmapsto\; \bigl(r\cos(\theta),\; r\sin(\theta)\bigr) \]
Every point has exactly one rectangular address, so this direction cannot be ambiguous. Whatever polar name you were handed, coterminal or with a negative distance, the formulas return the same pair.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, pp. 924-925 — applying Theorem 11.7 forwards
This part of the lesson is the part you should find easy, and if it is not easy the problem is almost always the evaluation of the cosine and the sine rather than the conversion itself.
The reason there is nothing to decide is worth stating plainly. A point has exactly one rectangular address. A procedure that produces an address is therefore producing the only possible answer, so no ambiguity can arise, no quadrant needs choosing, and no sign needs fixing.
One consequence to notice: you may be handed a very strange-looking polar name, with a negative distance or an angle several turns round, and it makes no difference at all. Substitute exactly what you were given. The formulas absorb the strangeness and return the same pair the tidy name would have returned.
Worked example
\[ \text{Convert } \left(5, \tfrac{7\pi}{4}\right) \text{ to rectangular coordinates.} \]
Locate the direction first
Why: Seven quarters of pi is a quarter turn short of a full turn, so the ray points into quadrant four: expect a positive first coordinate and a negative second.
\[ \tfrac{7\pi}{4} = 2\pi - \tfrac{\pi}{4} \]
Evaluate the cosine and the sine
Why: The reference angle is a quarter of pi, and in quadrant four the cosine is positive and the sine negative.
\[ \cos\left(\tfrac{7\pi}{4}\right) = \frac{\sqrt2}{2}, \qquad \sin\left(\tfrac{7\pi}{4}\right) = -\frac{\sqrt2}{2} \]
Multiply each by the distance
Why: Substitute into the recipe pair.
\[ x = 5\cdot\frac{\sqrt2}{2} = \frac{5\sqrt2}{2}, \qquad y = 5\cdot\left(-\frac{\sqrt2}{2}\right) = -\frac{5\sqrt2}{2} \]
Figure (svg): A coordinate plane with an arc sweeping counterclockwise from the polar axis through seven quarters of pi, ending on a ray into the fourth quadrant. The point five units out along that ray is marked, with its horizontal leg and vertical leg drawn as a right triangle.
Check with the distance constraint
Why: The squares must add to twenty-five, and each coordinate is about 3.5355, whose square is 12.5. Two of those make 25, and the signs match the quadrant the sketch predicted.
\[ \left(\frac{5\sqrt2}{2}\right)^2 + \left(-\frac{5\sqrt2}{2}\right)^2 = \frac{50}{4}+\frac{50}{4} = 25 = 5^2 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 930 — Exercise 17
The habit to build here is the first step: name the quadrant before you compute anything. It costs two seconds and it means that if your arithmetic later produces a negative first coordinate you will notice immediately.
Seven quarters of pi is one of the common angles, a quarter of a turn short of the whole turn, with reference angle a quarter of pi. In quadrant four the cosine is positive and the sine is negative, which is where the one minus sign in the answer comes from.
The check is the sum of squares, and it is a good habit because it catches exactly the errors that are hardest to spot: a wrong reference angle or a dropped factor. If the squares do not add up to the square of the distance, something upstream is wrong, and you know it before you hand the answer in.
Worked example
\[ \text{Convert } \left(-4, \tfrac{5\pi}{6}\right) \text{ to rectangular coordinates.} \]
Predict the quadrant before computing
Why: Five sixths of pi aims into quadrant two, and a negative distance sends the point to the opposite quadrant, which is quadrant four.
\[ \tfrac{5\pi}{6} + \pi = \tfrac{11\pi}{6} \quad\text{: quadrant IV} \]
Evaluate the two circular functions
Why: Reference angle a sixth of pi, in quadrant two.
\[ \cos\left(\tfrac{5\pi}{6}\right) = -\frac{\sqrt3}{2}, \qquad \sin\left(\tfrac{5\pi}{6}\right) = \frac12 \]
Multiply by the negative distance
Why: Two minus signs in the first coordinate, one in the second.
\[ x = (-4)\left(-\frac{\sqrt3}{2}\right) = 2\sqrt3, \qquad y = (-4)\left(\frac12\right) = -2 \]
Figure (svg): A coordinate plane with a dashed ray drawn into the second quadrant at five sixths of pi and a hollow marker four units along it. A solid arrow runs from the origin in the opposite direction into the fourth quadrant, ending at the actual point, with its legs drawn.
Check the quadrant and the distance
Why: The answer has a positive first coordinate, about 3.4641, and a negative second, which is quadrant four as predicted, and twelve plus four is sixteen, the square of the distance.
\[ \left(2\sqrt3\right)^2 + (-2)^2 = 12 + 4 = 16 = (-4)^2 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 930 — Exercise 22
Here is the first place the sketch pays for itself. The angle points into quadrant two and the answer comes out in quadrant four, and if you had not predicted that in advance you would probably assume you had made a sign error.
The mechanics are unchanged: substitute exactly what you were given, minus four included. The first coordinate picks up two minus signs, one from the distance and one from the second-quadrant cosine, so it comes out positive. The second coordinate picks up only one, from the distance, so it comes out negative.
Read the figure carefully. The hollow marker is where the point would be if the distance were positive four, and the solid marker is where it actually is. They are a half turn apart, on opposite ends of the same diameter, which is precisely what a negative directed distance means.
Fill the middle
Both recipes are set up; only the two circular values are missing.
Fill in the blanks
x = 6\cos\left(\tfrac-\tfrac12\tfrac{\sqrt3}{2}\right) = 6\left(___\right) = -3, \qquad y = 6\sin\left(\tfrac______\right) = 6\left(___\right) = 3\sqrt3
Why: Two thirds of pi lies in quadrant two with reference angle a third of pi, so the cosine is negative one half and the sine is positive root three over two. The point comes out three to the left and about 5.196 up, which is quadrant two, exactly where the angle pointed.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 925 — the same substitution as Example 11.4.2's check steps
Fill both blanks before checking. The arithmetic around them has been done for you on purpose, so that the only thing being tested is whether you can produce the cosine and the sine of a common second-quadrant angle.
Two thirds of pi has reference angle a third of pi and lies in quadrant two, so the cosine is negative and the sine is positive. Those two signs are the whole exercise; the sizes, one half and root three over two, you already know.
Check the answer against the quadrant. The point comes out about three to the left and about five point two up, which is quadrant two, matching the direction the angle pointed. Since the distance is positive, no flip was involved, so anything else would have been a mistake.
Worked example
\[ \text{Convert } \bigl(6, \arctan(2)\bigr) \text{ to rectangular coordinates.} \]
Draw the triangle the arctangent names
Why: The angle whose tangent is two has opposite side two and adjacent side one, in quadrant one.
\[ \text{legs } 1 \text{ and } 2 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{hypotenuse } \sqrt{1^2+2^2} = \sqrt5 \]
Read the cosine and the sine off that triangle
Why: Adjacent over hypotenuse, and opposite over hypotenuse.
\[ \cos\bigl(\arctan 2\bigr) = \frac{1}{\sqrt5}, \qquad \sin\bigl(\arctan 2\bigr) = \frac{2}{\sqrt5} \]
Multiply each by the distance and rationalise
Why: Six over root five, with the root cleared from the denominator.
\[ x = \frac{6}{\sqrt5} = \frac{6\sqrt5}{5}, \qquad y = \frac{12}{\sqrt5} = \frac{12\sqrt5}{5} \]
Figure (svg): A coordinate plane with a small triangle from the origin to the point one across and two up, and a larger similar triangle along the same ray out to a point about 2.68 across and 5.37 up. The small triangle's legs are labelled 1 and 2 with hypotenuse root 5.
Check the distance and the slope
Why: The coordinates are about 2.6833 and 5.3666, whose squares add to 36, and the second divided by the first is exactly two, which is the tangent we started from.
\[ \frac{36}{5} + \frac{144}{5} = \frac{180}{5} = 36 = 6^2, \qquad \frac{y}{x} = 2 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 930 — Exercise 27
An arctangent in the data looks intimidating and is not. It is a name for an angle, and the fastest way to work with it is to draw the triangle it names rather than to reach for a calculator.
The angle whose tangent is two is the angle in a right triangle with opposite side two and adjacent side one. The Pythagorean theorem gives the hypotenuse as root five, and then the cosine and the sine are just sides over hypotenuse. No decimals are needed anywhere.
The figure shows the small triangle and the actual point on the same ray, because they are similar triangles. Scaling the small one until its hypotenuse is six is exactly what multiplying by the distance does. That is why the answer keeps the same shape and only changes size, and why the quotient of the final coordinates comes back out as two.
Faded example
Exercise 30 uses the same triangle idea, but the arctangent is negative, so the angle sits below the polar axis in quadrant four.
Fill in the blanks
\cos\left(\arctan\left(-\tfrac43\right)\right) = \tfrac35, \quad \sin\left(\arctan\left(-\tfrac43\right)\right) = -\tfrac45 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 5\left(\tfrac35\right) = 3, \quad y = 5\left(-\tfrac45\right) = -4
Why: The arctangent of minus four thirds is a fourth-quadrant angle with reference triangle 3, 4, 5, so the cosine is three fifths and the sine is minus four fifths. Multiplying by five undoes the fifths and returns the point three across and four down, whose distance from the origin is indeed five.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 930 — Exercise 30
Fill the two blanks before checking. This is the same triangle idea as the previous slide, with one extra thing to get right.
The arctangent of a negative number is a negative angle, so it lies below the polar axis in quadrant four. Its reference triangle has legs three and four and hypotenuse five, so the cosine is three fifths, positive because quadrant four has a positive first coordinate, and the sine is minus four fifths.
Notice how tidily the fifths cancel against the distance of five. Problems in this exercise set are built that way on purpose: the distance is chosen to be the hypotenuse of the triangle the arctangent names, so that the answer comes out in whole numbers. If yours does not, check the triangle first.
Sorting
Sort into buckets
Sort each polar pair by the quadrant of the point it names. Decide by looking at the direction, then at the sign of the distance.
Sort all six before checking. For each one, ask two questions in order: where does the angle point, and does the sign of the distance flip it?
Three of these have a positive distance, and for those the answer is simply where the angle points. Two thirds of pi is quadrant two, seven sixths is quadrant three, and minus a quarter of pi is quadrant four because a negative angle turns clockwise.
The other three have a negative distance, so each lands in the quadrant diagonally opposite its angle. Quadrant two flips to four, quadrant three flips to one, and quadrant one flips to three. If you sorted by the angle alone you will have three items in the wrong place, and the pattern in the errors will be obvious: every one of them is diagonally opposite where it belongs.
Trap
A frequent wrong line when the first coordinate is negative:
\[ \left(-4, \tfrac{5\pi}{6}\right) \;\to\; x = 4\cos\left(-\tfrac{5\pi}{6}\right) \]
Wrong. The minus sign was moved from the distance onto the angle.
A negative distance reflects the point through the pole; a negative angle reflects it across the polar axis. Those are different points, and only in special cases do they agree. Substitute the numbers exactly as given.
\[ x = (-4)\cos\left(\tfrac{5\pi}{6}\right) = 2\sqrt3 \]
\[ 4\cos\left(-\tfrac{5\pi}{6}\right) = -2\sqrt3 \]
This error is tempting because both a negative distance and a negative angle feel like the same kind of reversal, and because moving a minus sign around feels harmless when you are used to ordinary algebra.
They are not the same reversal. A negative distance reflects the point through the pole, a half turn away. A negative angle reflects it across the polar axis, which is a mirror image rather than a rotation. The two only agree for points on the vertical axis, which is a coincidence rather than a rule.
The defence is mechanical and reliable: substitute exactly the numbers you were given, minus signs and all, and let the arithmetic sort it out. The recipes were proved for negative distances precisely so that you would never need to move the sign anywhere.
Section
Part 3
Concept
Coming the other way there is no recipe, only the two constraints. The first gives the distance up to a sign; the second gives the angle only up to a half turn.
\[ r = \pm\sqrt{x^2+y^2}, \qquad \theta = \arctan\left(\frac{y}{x}\right) + \pi k \]
Figure (svg): A coordinate plane with the line through the origin of slope four thirds drawn across both the first and third quadrants. The point 3 across and 4 up and the point 3 to the left and 4 down are both marked, with their reference triangles drawn.
The figure shows the difficulty in one picture. Both marked points have the same quotient, so the tangent relation cannot tell them apart, yet they are diagonally opposite each other.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 926 — solving the constraint relations for r and theta
This is the slide the rest of Part 3 is built on, so slow down here. Going this way you have no recipe, only two constraints, and each constraint leaves two candidates standing.
The sum of squares gives the distance up to a sign, because both signs square to the same thing. The quotient gives the direction up to a half turn, because flipping the signs of both coordinates leaves the quotient unchanged. The figure shows two points that are diagonally opposite each other and share the same quotient exactly.
So the algebra hands you four combinations and asks you to pick one. The problem statement usually eliminates two of them by demanding a non-negative distance and an angle in a stated range, and the sketch eliminates the rest. That is the method, and it is not a shortcut around the algebra; it is the part of the work the algebra cannot do.
Picture it
Figure (svg): A coordinate plane fanned with rays. The rays pointing into the right half plane, covering quadrants one and four, are drawn in green and labelled as the directions the arctangent can return. The rays into the left half plane, quadrants two and three, are drawn in red and labelled as directions it never returns.
The arctangent is a function, so it returns exactly one angle for each input, and those outputs fill only a half turn. Anything in the left half of the plane is outside its range, and it will confidently hand back the diagonally opposite direction instead.
The arctangent was built to be a function, which means one output per input, which means its range had to be cut down to a half turn. That cut is invisible while you work in quadrant one and it bites the first time you work in quadrant two.
The green rays are the directions it can return, filling quadrants one and four; the red dashed rays are the directions it never returns. If your point is in the left half of the plane, the arctangent will hand you the direction diagonally opposite it, confidently and with no warning.
This is why the habit worth building is to compute the reference angle from the size of the quotient, ignoring signs entirely, and then to place it in the quadrant your sketch showed. That way the arctangent is only ever asked a question it can answer, and the quadrant decision is made where it belongs.
Concept
Stitz and Zeager open their worked example by saying that although the problem does not ask for it, plotting the point first avoids many common mistakes. That is not a beginner's crutch; it is the step that supplies the information the algebra cannot.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 925 — Example 11.4.2, opening remark
Stitz and Zeager are not telling you to sketch because sketching is wholesome. They are telling you because the sketch supplies information the algebra provably cannot supply, and it supplies it in seconds.
Notice the order of the four steps, and in particular that the reference angle is computed from the size of the quotient. Working with the size means the signs never get a chance to mislead you, and it means the arctangent is only asked about first-quadrant angles, which is the one region it is reliable in.
The last step is where the problem's stated range does its work. A half-open turn starting at zero, which is what most of these exercises ask for, has exactly one angle in each direction, so once the quadrant is settled the answer is forced.
Worked example
Convert to polar form with a non-negative distance and an angle in one full turn from zero.
\[ P\left(2, -2\sqrt3\right) \]
Plot it and name the quadrant
Why: The first coordinate is positive and the second negative, so the point is in quadrant four.
\[ x = 2 > 0, \quad y = -2\sqrt3 < 0 \]
Compute the square of the distance
Why: Square both coordinates and add.
\[ r^2 = (2)^2 + \left(-2\sqrt3\right)^2 = 4 + 12 = 16 \]
Take the non-negative root
Why: Both signs solve the equation; the problem asks for the non-negative one.
\[ r = \pm 4 \;\Longrightarrow\; r = 4 \]
Find the reference angle from the quotient
Why: Minus root three is the tangent of a third of pi in size.
\[ \tan(\theta) = \frac{-2\sqrt3}{2} = -\sqrt3 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{reference angle } \tfrac{\pi}{3} \]
Place it in quadrant four
Why: Subtract the reference angle from a full turn to stay inside the required range.
\[ \theta = 2\pi - \tfrac{\pi}{3} = \tfrac{5\pi}{3} \]
Figure (svg): A coordinate plane with the point 2 across and 2 root 3 down marked in the fourth quadrant, its reference triangle drawn, an arc sweeping counterclockwise from the polar axis through five thirds of pi to the ray, and the reference angle marked between the ray and the positive horizontal axis.
Check by converting back
Why: Four times the cosine of five thirds of pi is four times one half, which is two; four times the sine is four times minus root three over two, which is minus two root three. Both coordinates come back.
\[ 4\cos\left(\tfrac{5\pi}{3}\right) = 4\left(\tfrac12\right) = 2, \quad 4\sin\left(\tfrac{5\pi}{3}\right) = 4\left(-\tfrac{\sqrt3}{2}\right) = -2\sqrt3 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 925 — Example 11.4.2, part 1
This is the model solution for the whole of Part 3, so read every line with the words covered and check that the maths alone runs from the point to the answer.
The reference angle comes out as a third of pi because the size of the quotient is root three, and root three is the tangent of a third of pi. Placing that in quadrant four inside a half-open turn starting at zero means measuring the long way round, so the answer is a full turn minus a third of pi.
The check is the important habit. Converting back runs the easy direction, which has no ambiguity in it, so if the original coordinates come back you know the answer is right. This is much stronger than re-reading your own work, because it uses a different route.
Worked example
\[ Q(-3, -3) \]
Plot it and name the quadrant
Why: Both coordinates negative puts the point in quadrant three.
\[ x = -3 < 0, \quad y = -3 < 0 \]
Compute the distance
Why: Nine and nine make eighteen, and eighteen is nine times two.
\[ r^2 = (-3)^2 + (-3)^2 = 18 \;\Longrightarrow\; r = \pm\sqrt{18} = \pm 3\sqrt2 \]
Choose the non-negative value
Why: The problem asks for a non-negative distance.
\[ r = 3\sqrt2 \approx 4.2426 \]
Find the reference angle
Why: Equal legs make the quotient one, whose reference angle is a quarter of pi.
\[ \tan(\theta) = \frac{-3}{-3} = 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{reference angle } \tfrac{\pi}{4} \]
Place it in quadrant three
Why: Add the reference angle to a half turn.
\[ \theta = \pi + \tfrac{\pi}{4} = \tfrac{5\pi}{4} \]
Figure (svg): A coordinate plane with the point 3 to the left and 3 down marked in the third quadrant, its reference triangle drawn as an isosceles right triangle, and an arc from the polar axis counterclockwise through five quarters of pi to the ray.
Check by converting back
Why: Three root two times the cosine of five quarters of pi is three root two times minus root two over two, which is minus three, and the sine gives the same. Both coordinates return.
\[ 3\sqrt2\cos\left(\tfrac{5\pi}{4}\right) = 3\sqrt2\left(-\tfrac{\sqrt2}{2}\right) = -3 = 3\sqrt2\sin\left(\tfrac{5\pi}{4}\right) \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 925 — Example 11.4.2, part 2
Equal coordinates always make the reference angle a quarter of pi, because the reference triangle is isosceles. You can see that from the picture without computing anything, which is a small saving here and a large one under exam pressure.
The distance is the square root of eighteen, and you should simplify it to three root two rather than leaving a decimal. Radicals in these answers are almost always meant to be simplified, and the check step is much cleaner in exact form.
Placing the reference angle in quadrant three means adding it to a half turn, which is the opposite adjustment from quadrant four in the previous example. Rather than memorising four rules, look at the sketch each time and ask how far round the ray is; the adjustment will be obvious.
Worked example
\[ R(0, -3) \]
Notice that the quotient is unavailable
Why: The first coordinate is zero, so the tangent relation does not apply and no reference triangle exists.
\[ \frac{y}{x} = \frac{-3}{0} \quad\text{undefined} \]
Read the distance straight off the definition
Why: The point sits three units from the pole, so the distance is three in size.
\[ r = \pm 3 \;\Longrightarrow\; r = 3 \]
Read the angle off the picture
Why: The point lies on the downward vertical axis, and the angle in the required range whose terminal side points straight down is three halves of pi.
\[ \theta = \tfrac{3\pi}{2} \]
Figure (svg): A coordinate plane with the point three units straight down the negative vertical axis marked. No reference triangle can be drawn because the horizontal leg has length zero. An arc runs counterclockwise from the polar axis through three halves of pi to the downward ray.
Check by converting back
Why: Three times the cosine of three halves of pi is three times zero, which is zero, and three times the sine is three times minus one, which is minus three. The point returns exactly.
\[ 3\cos\left(\tfrac{3\pi}{2}\right) = 0, \qquad 3\sin\left(\tfrac{3\pi}{2}\right) = -3 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, pp. 925-926 — Example 11.4.2, part 3
This is the case the tangent relation refuses, and the book's response is instructive: it stops calculating and starts looking. The footnote in the text says explicitly that since the first coordinate is zero, the angle would have to be determined geometrically anyway.
So read both answers off the definition. The point is three units from the pole, so the distance is three in size and three exactly once you are told to keep it non-negative. Its ray points straight down, and the angle in the required range with that terminal side is three quarters of a turn.
Do not treat this as an exception to be feared. Axis points are the easiest conversions in the whole lesson, provided you stop trying to force the algebra through. The formula is unavailable; the picture is unmistakable.
Worked example
\[ S(-3, 4) \]
Plot it and name the quadrant
Why: A negative first coordinate with a positive second is quadrant two.
\[ x = -3 < 0, \quad y = 4 > 0 \]
Compute the distance
Why: Nine and sixteen make twenty-five.
\[ r^2 = (-3)^2 + 4^2 = 25 \;\Longrightarrow\; r = 5 \]
Compute the quotient
Why: Minus four thirds is not the tangent of any common angle, so the arctangent has to be named rather than evaluated.
\[ \tan(\theta) = \frac{4}{-3} = -\frac43 \]
Name the reference angle and place it
Why: The reference angle is the arctangent of four thirds, and quadrant two is a half turn minus that.
\[ \theta = \pi - \arctan\left(\tfrac43\right) \approx 2.2143 \]
Figure (svg): A coordinate plane with the point 3 to the left and 4 up marked in the second quadrant and its 3 4 5 reference triangle drawn. The reference angle is marked between the ray and the negative horizontal axis, and the full angle is marked as an arc from the polar axis.
Check by converting back
Why: The cosine of pi minus that arctangent is minus three fifths and the sine is four fifths, so five times them returns minus three and four. The book leaves this simplification to the reader; it is the difference identity for cosine applied to a half turn.
\[ 5\left(-\tfrac35\right) = -3, \qquad 5\left(\tfrac45\right) = 4 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 926 — Example 11.4.2, part 4
Two things make this part harder than the first three. The quotient is not the tangent of any common angle, so the answer has to be left as an arctangent, and the point is in quadrant two, which is exactly where the arctangent is unreliable.
The reference angle is the arctangent of four thirds, computed from the size of the quotient with the signs discarded. Quadrant two is a half turn minus the reference angle, so the answer is pi minus that arctangent, about 2.21 radians. Writing the exact form first and the decimal second is the right order.
The check is the one the book leaves to you, and it is worth doing once. The cosine of a half turn minus an angle is the negative of the cosine, and the sine is unchanged, so the cosine here is minus three fifths and the sine is four fifths. Multiplying by five returns the original coordinates exactly.
Error analysis
Annotate
On: \( S(-3,4): \quad \tan\theta = -\tfrac43 \;\Longrightarrow\; \theta = \arctan\left(-\tfrac43\right) \approx -0.9273 \)
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 926 — why part 4 needs pi minus the arctangent
Read the three lines before opening the annotations and try to name the exact line that fails. Most people can feel that something is wrong and point at the wrong place.
The first line is fine: the quotient really is minus four thirds. The failure is in the arrow on the second line, where one solution of the tangent equation is treated as the solution. Every angle a half turn away has the same tangent, so the equation has infinitely many solutions and the arctangent returns only the one inside its own restricted range.
The value it returns, about minus 0.93, is the direction of the point three across and four down, which is diagonally opposite the point you were given. Adding a half turn repairs it, and the only reason you know to add it is the sketch. This is the single most common error in the whole section, so it is worth being able to describe out loud.
Comparison
Comparison matrix
| point | quadrant | distance r |
|---|---|---|
| (6, 8) | I | 10 |
| (−3, 4) | II | 5 |
| (−5, −12) | III | 13 |
| (24, −7) | IV | 25 |
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 931 — Exercises 47, 51 and 53, with Example 11.4.2 part 4
Fill the blanks before checking. Each row is a point from the section's exercise set, and the distances are all whole numbers, which is a hint that the coordinates form familiar right triangles.
The quadrants come straight from the signs: positive and positive is one, negative and positive is two, both negative is three, positive and negative is four. The distances come from the sum of squares, and three of these are the classic triples, six eight ten, three four five and five twelve thirteen.
Notice how much of a conversion this table already is. Once the quadrant and the distance are known, all that remains is the reference angle, and for a point like twenty-four across and seven down you would leave that as an arctangent rather than trying to name it.
Ranking
Put in order
Order the steps of a complete conversion into polar form, with a stated range on the distance and the angle.
Why: The plot comes first because it supplies the one thing the algebra cannot, and it is free. The reference angle is computed from the size of the quotient so the sign never gets a chance to mislead you, and the quadrant is applied afterwards. The check runs the easy direction, which has no ambiguity in it.
Drag the steps into order before checking. Only one ordering is really contested, and it is where the sketch goes.
The sketch goes first, because it costs nothing and because every later step is safer once the quadrant is known. Putting it last, as a check, wastes it: by then you have already made the decision it was supposed to inform.
The other ordering worth noticing is that the reference angle is computed before the quadrant is applied, not after. If you try to compute the final angle in one move you are back to asking the arctangent a question it cannot answer. Two small steps beat one unreliable one.
Trap
A common line in an answer that asks for a negative distance:
\[ r^2 = 18 \;\Longrightarrow\; r = 3\sqrt2 \]
Incomplete. The equation has two solutions and the problem chose one of them.
Write both, then say which one the problem asked for. If a question wants a negative distance instead, the angle must move by a half turn as well, and an answer that changes only the sign of the distance names a different point.
\[ r = \pm 3\sqrt2 \]
\[ \left(3\sqrt2, \tfrac{5\pi}{4}\right) = \left(-3\sqrt2, \tfrac{\pi}{4}\right) \]
This one does not usually cost marks on a standard question, because the standard question asks for a non-negative distance and the positive root is what you wanted anyway. It costs marks the moment a question asks for something else.
The habit that protects you is to write both roots on one line and then state which one the problem asked for. It takes four extra characters and it makes the choice visible, which means you will notice when a question asks for the other one.
And when a question does ask for a negative distance, remember that changing the sign of the distance alone changes the point. The angle has to move a half turn at the same time. The second line on the right shows the two names of the same point in Example 11.4.2, part 2.
Section
Part 4
Concept
An equation in the two rectangular variables describes a set of points. To describe the same set in polar variables, replace each variable by its recipe and simplify.
\[ x \;\longrightarrow\; r\cos(\theta), \qquad y \;\longrightarrow\; r\sin(\theta) \]
The Pythagorean identity does most of the simplifying, because squares of the two recipes keep appearing together. After that the usual algebra applies: expand, gather, factor.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 927 — the substitution strategy
Converting an equation is really converting a set of points, and it helps to keep saying that to yourself. The equation is just a description; the thing you must preserve is which points satisfy it.
Going this way the technique is mechanical: wherever you see the first variable write the distance times the cosine, wherever you see the second write the distance times the sine, then simplify. Almost every simplification you will need is the Pythagorean identity, because the two substituted expressions squared and added collapse to the square of the distance.
There is one book misprint to be aware of on this page: in the text of part 1a the substitution is written as the second variable equalling just the sine, with the distance dropped. It is a typing slip, and the work immediately below it uses the distance correctly.
Concept
Conversion is not only algebra. Each move either preserves the set of points described, or quietly enlarges it, or loses part of it, and the final answer is only correct if the set survived.
| move | what it can do to the set of points |
|---|---|
| substituting the recipes | nothing: the two descriptions are the same points |
| factoring, then discarding a factor | loses points, unless the discarded factor's points are already in the other factor |
| dividing by an expression | loses points wherever that expression is zero |
| multiplying by the distance | adds the pole, which is usually already there |
| squaring both sides | adds the points of the negated equation |
Stitz and Zeager check this every time, and then say that in practice most books do it without a second thought. Knowing which move is risky is what lets you skip the check safely.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 929 — the closing remark on pedantic verification
This table is the part of the lesson that most courses skip, and it is the part that makes the rest safe. Every line of algebra you write is also a claim that the same points still satisfy the equation, and some moves break that claim.
Learn the table by the reason rather than by rote. Dividing loses the places where the divisor is zero. Multiplying by the distance adds the pole, since a distance of zero then satisfies anything. Squaring makes the equation blind to a sign, so it admits the negated version too.
The authors check every one of these and then tell you, at the end of the section, that most books do not bother. That is not a licence to stop thinking. It is a licence to skip the written check once you can see at a glance that the move was safe, which is a different skill and the one this table is training.
Worked example
\[ (x-3)^2 + y^2 = 9 \]
Substitute both recipes
Why: Replace each variable by its polar expression.
\[ \bigl(r\cos(\theta) - 3\bigr)^2 + \bigl(r\sin(\theta)\bigr)^2 = 9 \]
Expand the square
Why: The first bracket is a difference squared.
\[ r^2\cos^2(\theta) - 6r\cos(\theta) + 9 + r^2\sin^2(\theta) = 9 \]
Subtract nine and group the squared terms
Why: The nines cancel, and the two squared terms share a factor.
\[ r^2\bigl(\cos^2(\theta)+\sin^2(\theta)\bigr) - 6r\cos(\theta) = 0 \]
Apply the Pythagorean identity
Why: The bracket is one.
\[ r^2 - 6r\cos(\theta) = 0 \]
Factor
Why: Both terms carry a factor of the distance.
\[ r\bigl(r - 6\cos(\theta)\bigr) = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; r = 0 \;\text{ or }\; r = 6\cos(\theta) \]
Figure (svg): A circle of radius 3 centred three units along the horizontal axis, so that it passes through the origin. A ray from the origin at a quarter of pi cuts the circle at the point 3 across and 3 up, and the segment from the origin to that crossing is marked as r equals 6 cosine theta.
Check that discarding the first factor loses nothing
Why: The first factor is only the pole. Putting a quarter turn into the second equation gives six times zero, which is zero, so the pole is already on the circle described by the second equation, and the answer is the second alone. At a direction of zero the second gives six, and the point six along the axis is indeed on the circle.
\[ \theta = \tfrac{\pi}{2}: \; r = 6\cos\left(\tfrac{\pi}{2}\right) = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{the pole is already included} \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 927 — Example 11.4.3, part 1a
Work through the substitution and watch for the moment the Pythagorean identity appears. It always appears when a rectangular equation contains both variables squared, which for circles is always.
The factoring at the end is where the thinking is. You get two equations, and one of them describes nothing but the pole. Before discarding it you have to be sure the other equation already reaches the pole, and it does: a quarter turn makes the cosine zero, which makes the distance zero.
Look at the picture and notice what the polar equation is telling you geometrically. The circle passes through the pole, so a ray from the pole cuts it at one point, and the distance out to that point is six times the cosine of the direction. A shape that needs a squared binomial in rectangular form needs one cosine in polar form.
Worked example
\[ y = -x \]
Substitute both recipes
Why: The distance appears on both sides.
\[ r\sin(\theta) = -r\cos(\theta) \]
Gather everything on one side and factor
Why: Add the right-hand side to both sides.
\[ r\bigl(\cos(\theta) + \sin(\theta)\bigr) = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; r = 0 \;\text{ or }\; \cos(\theta)+\sin(\theta) = 0 \]
Solve the second factor for the angle
Why: Divide by the cosine, which is never zero at a solution here, and read off the tangent.
\[ \tan(\theta) = -1 \;\Longrightarrow\; \theta = -\tfrac{\pi}{4} + \pi k \]
Think geometrically about what to keep
Why: With the angle fixed at minus a quarter of pi, the distance is free and may be negative or zero, so that one equation already traces the whole line, pole included.
\[ \theta = -\tfrac{\pi}{4} \]
Figure (svg): A coordinate plane with the line of slope minus one drawn through the origin. A solid arrow points into the fourth quadrant along the direction minus a quarter of pi, and a dashed arrow points the opposite way into the second quadrant, labelled as the half the line picks up from negative values of r.
Check the two halves and the pole
Why: Distance two root two gives the point two across and two down, which satisfies the original line, and distance minus two root two gives two to the left and two up, which also satisfies it. Distance zero gives the pole, which is on the line.
\[ \left(2\sqrt2, -\tfrac{\pi}{4}\right) \to (2,-2), \qquad \left(-2\sqrt2, -\tfrac{\pi}{4}\right) \to (-2, 2) \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 927 — Example 11.4.3, part 1b
The algebra here is short and the geometry is where the interest lies. After factoring you get the pole again, plus an equation in the angle alone, whose solutions are one direction and every direction a half turn from it.
The move that surprises people is choosing a single angle as the final answer. It works because in the equation that fixes the angle, the distance is a free variable: it can be any value at all, positive, negative or zero. Letting it run over all values sweeps out the whole line, including the half in the opposite direction, and including the pole.
Compare this with the previous slide. There the answer was a distance as a function of the angle; here the answer is an angle with the distance free. Polar equations come in both shapes, and recognising which one you are producing is half of reading them.
Trap
Halfway through the parabola conversion:
\[ r\cos^2(\theta) = \sin(\theta) \]
\[ \Longrightarrow\; r = \frac{\sin(\theta)}{\cos^2(\theta)} \]
Not yet. The divisor could be zero, and dividing by zero loses solutions.
Justify the division before you make it. If the cosine were zero, the left side would be zero, so the sine would have to be zero too, and no angle has both equal to zero. The divisor is never zero at a solution, so nothing is lost and the division is legal.
\[ \cos(\theta)=0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \sin(\theta)=0 \]
\[ \cos^2+\sin^2 = 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{impossible} \]
The general rule is worth memorising in the book's own words: never divide through by a quantity that may be zero. Almost every lost solution in algebra comes from breaking it.
But a rule you cannot ever satisfy is useless, so learn the discharge as well. Here you argue that if the divisor were zero, the equation would force the sine to be zero too, and no angle has both its cosine and its sine equal to zero, because they satisfy the Pythagorean identity. So the divisor is never zero at a solution and the division is safe.
Notice the shape of that argument, because you will reuse it constantly. You are not claiming the divisor is never zero anywhere; you are claiming it is never zero at a point that satisfies the equation, which is all you need.
Worked example
\[ y = x^2 \]
Substitute both recipes
Why: The right-hand side is a square, so the distance is squared with it.
\[ r\sin(\theta) = \bigl(r\cos(\theta)\bigr)^2 = r^2\cos^2(\theta) \]
Gather and factor
Why: Move everything to one side; both terms carry the distance.
\[ r\bigl(r\cos^2(\theta) - \sin(\theta)\bigr) = 0 \]
Divide the second factor by the squared cosine
Why: Justified on the previous slide: the divisor is never zero at a solution.
\[ r = \frac{\sin(\theta)}{\cos^2(\theta)} \]
Rewrite as a product of two named functions
Why: One reciprocal cosine makes a secant; the remaining sine over cosine is a tangent.
\[ r = \frac{1}{\cos(\theta)}\cdot\frac{\sin(\theta)}{\cos(\theta)} = \sec(\theta)\tan(\theta) \]
Figure (svg): The parabola y equals x squared drawn on a coordinate plane, with a ray from the origin at a quarter of pi meeting it at the point one across and one up. The distance along that ray is marked as root two, matching secant times tangent at a quarter of pi.
Check one direction, and check the pole
Why: At a quarter of pi the secant is root two and the tangent is one, so the distance is root two, and root two in that direction is the point one across and one up, which satisfies the original equation. At a direction of zero the formula gives zero, so the discarded factor is recovered.
\[ \theta=\tfrac{\pi}{4}: \; r = \sqrt2 \to (1,1), \quad 1 = 1^2 \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 928 — Example 11.4.3, part 1c
This example is the reason the section ends with a warning. The rectangular equation is about as short as an equation can be, and the polar version needs a product of two reciprocal functions.
The work itself is routine once the division has been justified: substitute, factor out the distance, divide, and then recognise the resulting fraction as a secant times a tangent. Writing it in that named form rather than as a fraction is worth doing, because the next section graphs polar equations and those names are the ones you will recognise.
The check is short but it earns its place, because it tests the answer at an actual angle and lands on an actual point of the parabola. The final remark, that a direction of zero gives a distance of zero, also confirms that the discarded factor was recovered, so nothing was lost.
Worked example
The same technique on a circle the book does not do, from the section's exercise set.
\[ x^2 + y^2 - 2y = 0 \]
Substitute the recipes and use the sum of squares
Why: The first two terms are the square of the distance by the identity, so only the last term needs the recipe.
\[ r^2 - 2r\sin(\theta) = 0 \]
Factor out the distance
Why: Both terms carry it.
\[ r\bigl(r - 2\sin(\theta)\bigr) = 0 \]
Discard the pole factor
Why: A direction of zero puts the pole back into the second equation, so nothing is lost.
\[ r = 2\sin(\theta) \]
Figure (svg): A circle of radius one centred one unit up the vertical axis, passing through the origin, with a ray from the origin at a third of pi meeting it and the distance out to the crossing marked as two sine theta.
Check with a direction
Why: At a third of pi the distance is two times root three over two, which is root three, and that point is about 0.866 across and 1.5 up. Its squares add to about three, and twice its second coordinate is three, so the original equation holds.
\[ r=\sqrt3 \to (0.866, 1.5): \; 0.75+2.25 = 3 = 2(1.5) \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 931 — Exercise 70
This one is from the exercise set rather than the worked examples, and it is quicker than it looks because the first two terms are already the square of the distance. You do not need to substitute into them at all.
After factoring you again get the pole plus a useful equation, and again the pole is recovered by the useful equation, this time at a direction of zero. That pattern is not an accident: any circle passing through the pole converts into a single circular function of the direction, and the pole is always the point where that function is zero.
Compare the answer with the one from part 1a. A circle through the pole centred on the horizontal axis gives a cosine; one centred on the vertical axis gives a sine. That pair of facts is worth carrying into Section 11.5, where you will graph both.
Matching
Match the pairs
Why: A vertical line fixes the first coordinate, so the distance times the cosine is constant and the distance is a multiple of the secant; a horizontal line does the same with the sine and the cosecant. A circle about the pole is the shortest polar equation there is. A line through the pole fixes the direction and leaves the distance free, so it is an angle equation, not a distance equation.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 931 — Exercises 57, 59, 63 and 64
Match all four before checking. Two of them are lines, one is a circle, and one is a line through the origin, and the last of those behaves quite differently from the other two.
A vertical line fixes the first coordinate, and the first coordinate is the distance times the cosine, so the distance must be the constant over the cosine, which is the constant times the secant. A horizontal line does the same with the sine, giving a cosecant. Notice that neither of these passes through the pole, and neither polar form is defined for the direction along the line.
The circle about the origin gives the shortest polar equation in the lesson, and the line through the origin gives an angle equation with the distance free, exactly like the line in part 1b. Whenever a rectangular equation has no constant term, expect the polar form to fix an angle rather than a distance.
Section
Part 5
Concept
There is no clean pair of recipes going this way. Solving the constraints for the polar variables gives expressions with a plus-or-minus and an arctangent in them, and substituting those into an equation produces something nobody wants to look at.
\[ r = \pm\sqrt{x^2+y^2}, \qquad \theta = \arctan\left(\frac{y}{x}\right) + \pi k \]
So the strategy changes. Instead of substituting into the equation, rearrange the equation until one of four familiar expressions appears, and replace that.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 928 — the second strategy
Here is where the asymmetry becomes unavoidable. You could in principle solve the two constraints for the polar variables and substitute, and the top line of the slide shows what you would be substituting: an expression with a plus-or-minus in it and an expression with an arctangent and an unknown integer in it.
Nobody does that, and the book says so plainly. Instead you leave the equation in polar variables and manipulate it until one of four recognisable combinations appears, then swap that combination for its rectangular meaning in a single step.
So the skill in this direction is pattern recognition rather than substitution. You are looking at an equation and asking what would have to happen for a squared distance, or a distance beside a cosine, to appear, and then making that happen. The next slide lists the four things you are hunting for.
Notation
Annotate
On: \( r^2 = x^2+y^2, \quad r\cos(\theta) = x, \quad r\sin(\theta) = y, \quad \tan(\theta)=\tfrac{y}{x} \)
Commit these four to memory, because the whole of this direction consists of trying to manufacture one of them. They are not new; they are the four relations of Theorem 11.7 rearranged so that the polar side is what you would actually see in an equation.
The first is the one you chase most often. An equation with a lone distance in it is not convertible, so you multiply through or square until every distance is either squared or sitting beside a cosine or a sine.
The last one is the odd member of the family, and it is for equations that mention only the angle. Those cannot be reached by any relation involving the distance, so the tangent is the only door in. Notice that using it also costs you information, since the tangent is blind to a half turn, and the free distance is what quietly pays the bill.
Worked example
\[ r = -3 \]
Square both sides
Why: A bare distance is not convertible; a squared one is.
\[ r^2 = (-3)^2 = 9 \]
Substitute the sum of squares
Why: This is the one relation that takes a squared distance directly.
\[ x^2 + y^2 = 9 \]
Ask what the squaring did
Why: The squared equation is satisfied by the distance plus three as well as minus three, so on the face of it the set of points grew.
\[ r^2 = 9 \iff r = \pm 3 \]
Repair the worry with the equivalence rule
Why: Every point named by a distance of plus three also has a name with distance minus three and the angle moved a half turn, so no new points entered the plane.
\[ (3, \theta) = (-3, \theta + \pi) \]
Figure (svg): A circle of radius three about the origin, with a dashed ray drawn at a third of pi and a solid arrow drawn the opposite way to the point three units out on the far side, showing that the pair with directed distance minus three lands on the circle.
Check one point both ways
Why: The pair with distance minus three and angle a third of pi converts to about minus 1.5 across and minus 2.598 up, and 2.25 plus 6.75 is 9, so the point lies on the circle the rectangular equation describes.
\[ (-1.5)^2 + \left(-\tfrac{3\sqrt3}{2}\right)^2 = 2.25 + 6.75 = 9 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 928 — Example 11.4.3, part 2a
This example is short but it carries the most important idea in the second half of the lesson, so do not skim it.
The move is forced: the equation has no angle in it, so there is nothing to pair the distance with, and squaring is the only way to reach a convertible expression. The result is the circle of radius three about the origin, which is clearly the right curve.
The worry, and its resolution, are what matter. Squaring seems to admit a distance of plus three as well as minus three, so the set of ordered pairs really has grown. But every point named with a distance of plus three also has a name with distance minus three and the angle moved a half turn, so the set of points in the plane has not changed at all. That rescue is available because polar names are not unique, and it will rescue you again on the cardioid.
Worked example
\[ \theta = \tfrac{4\pi}{3} \]
Take the tangent of both sides
Why: The tangent is the one relation that reaches an angle equation.
\[ \tan(\theta) = \tan\left(\tfrac{4\pi}{3}\right) = \sqrt3 \]
Substitute the quotient
Why: The tangent of the angle is the quotient of the coordinates.
\[ \frac{y}{x} = \sqrt3 \]
Clear the denominator
Why: Multiply both sides by the first coordinate.
\[ y = x\sqrt3 \]
Ask what the two moves did
Why: Taking the tangent kept every angle a half turn away, and clearing the denominator allowed a zero first coordinate, which the quotient form forbade.
\[ \tan(\theta)=\sqrt3 \iff \theta = \tfrac{\pi}{3} + \pi k \]
Figure (svg): A coordinate plane with the line of slope root three through the origin. A solid arrow runs from the origin into the third quadrant along the direction four thirds of pi, and a dashed arrow runs the opposite way into the first quadrant, which the equation only reaches through negative values of the directed distance.
Check that the extra half is already there
Why: The original equation lets the distance be negative, and a negative distance in the direction four thirds of pi lands in quadrant one, which is exactly the half the tangent step seemed to add. Distance minus three gives the point 1.5 across and about 2.598 up, and root three times 1.5 is 2.598, so it is on the line.
\[ (-3, \tfrac{4\pi}{3}) \to (1.5, 2.598), \quad \sqrt3(1.5) = 2.598 \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 928 — Example 11.4.3, part 2b
Taking the tangent of both sides is the only available move, because the equation mentions no distance at all. The tangent of four thirds of pi is root three, and the quotient relation converts that immediately.
Two separate things happened that could have changed the curve, and the book flags both. Taking the tangent kept every angle a half turn away, so the equation now describes a whole line rather than a single ray. Clearing the denominator allowed a zero first coordinate, which the quotient form had excluded.
Both turn out to be harmless for the same reason as in part 1b: in the original equation the distance is free, so negative values already traced the opposite ray, and a distance of zero already gave the pole. The figure shows those two halves, and the check lands on a specific point in the half that looked like it had been added.
Intuition
Multiplying both sides by the distance is the workhorse move of this direction, because it turns a bare distance into a squared one and turns a lone cosine into a first coordinate.
\[ r = f(\theta) \;\longrightarrow\; r^2 = r\,f(\theta) \]
The one thing it can do to the set of points is add the pole, because a distance of zero satisfies the new equation whatever the angle. So after multiplying, ask a single question: was the pole already on the original curve? Almost always it was, and then the move costs nothing.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 929 — the discussion of multiplying by r
Of the four moves in this direction, this is the one you will reach for most often, because a great many polar equations have exactly the shape shown: a lone distance on one side and a function of the angle on the other.
Multiplying turns the left into a squared distance, which converts on sight, and turns the right into the distance times a circular function, which also converts on sight. Two conversions for the price of one multiplication.
The only cost is that a distance of zero now satisfies the new equation for every angle, so the pole has been added. The check is one line: does the original equation have a solution with a zero distance? For anything of the form distance equals a cosine or a sine, it does, because those functions are zero somewhere. So the move is almost always free, and you should still say so.
Worked example
\[ r = 4\cos(\theta) \]
Multiply both sides by the distance
Why: The left becomes a square, and the right becomes a distance times a cosine.
\[ r^2 = 4r\cos(\theta) \]
Substitute both standard expressions
Why: The left is the sum of squares; the right carries the first coordinate.
\[ x^2 + y^2 = 4x \]
Complete the square in the first variable
Why: Move the term across and add four to both sides.
\[ x^2 - 4x + 4 + y^2 = 4 \]
Write it as a circle
Why: The first three terms are a square.
\[ (x-2)^2 + y^2 = 4 \]
Figure (svg): A circle of radius two centred two units along the horizontal axis, drawn from its polar equation r equals four cosine theta, with the centre and the rightmost point marked and the rectangular equation printed beside it.
Check the pole and one other point
Why: A direction of a quarter turn gives a distance of zero, so the pole is on the original curve and multiplying added nothing; and at a direction of zero the distance is four, giving the point four along the axis, where two squared plus zero is four.
\[ (4-2)^2 + 0^2 = 4 \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 931 — Exercise 84
This is the standard use of the multiplying move, and it is worth doing enough times that it becomes automatic. Multiply, convert both sides, then complete the square to recognise the shape.
Completing the square is a Chapter 7 skill being reused, and it is what turns an unrecognisable rectangular equation into a circle with a visible centre and radius. Without it you would have the right equation and no idea what it described.
Compare the two forms in the figure. In polar form the curve is four times a cosine, which is about as simple as a curve gets; in rectangular form it is a circle centred two units along the axis. Both are fine descriptions, and they are short in different ways, which is the theme of the last part of this lesson.
Fill the middle
Exercise 88. One multiplication turns the secant into something the theorem recognises.
Fill in the blanks
r = 7\sec(\theta) \;\Longrightarrow\; r = \frac7x \;\Longrightarrow\; r\cos(\theta) = ___ \;\Longrightarrow\; ___ = 7
Why: A secant is one over a cosine, so multiplying both sides by the cosine puts the distance and the cosine together, and that product is the first rectangular coordinate. The curve is the vertical line seven units to the right of the origin. Nothing was added or lost, because the cosine is never zero on the original curve.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 931 — Exercise 88
Fill both blanks before checking. The chain has been laid out for you so that the only decision is recognising which rectangular expression appears at the end.
A secant is one over a cosine, so writing it that way and then multiplying both sides by the cosine puts the distance and the cosine next to each other. That product is the first rectangular coordinate, and the equation collapses to a constant first coordinate, which is a vertical line.
Nothing was added or lost on the way, because the cosine is never zero at a point of the original curve; if it were, the right-hand side would be undefined. This is a case where the safety check takes one sentence, which is exactly the situation the book means when it says the pedantic verification is usually left unsaid.
Worked example
\[ r = 1 - \cos(\theta) \]
Multiply by the distance to create a square
Why: Squaring alone would do nothing useful to the right-hand side.
\[ r^2 = r - r\cos(\theta) \]
Move the leftover distance to the other side
Why: Now one side is a lone distance and the other is convertible.
\[ r = r^2 + r\cos(\theta) \]
Square both sides
Why: This clears the lone distance on the left.
\[ r^2 = \bigl(r^2 + r\cos(\theta)\bigr)^2 \]
Substitute the two standard expressions
Why: The square of the distance and the product with the cosine both appear.
\[ x^2 + y^2 = \bigl(x^2 + y^2 + x\bigr)^2 \]
Figure (svg): The cardioid traced by r equals one minus cosine theta, a heart-shaped curve with its dimple at the origin opening toward the left, drawn on a coordinate plane with its two equations printed beside it.
Check a point on the curve
Why: At a direction of pi the distance is two, giving the point two to the left. The left side is four, and the right side is four minus two, squared, which is four. The two sides agree, and the fourth-degree result is the honest cost of insisting on rectangular coordinates here.
\[ (-2)^2 + 0^2 = 4, \qquad \bigl(4 + 0 + (-2)\bigr)^2 = 2^2 = 4 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, pp. 928-929 — Example 11.4.3, part 2c
This is the hardest conversion in the section and the most instructive. Read the steps in order and notice that each one is chosen to remove the obstruction the previous one left.
Squaring first would do nothing, because the right-hand side squared is no easier. So multiply by the distance instead, which produces a squared distance and a convertible product but leaves one lone distance behind. Move that to the other side, square to clear it, and now every occurrence is convertible.
Look at what you end up with: a fourth-degree implicit relation, against a nine-character polar equation for the same curve. The book's point, and the reason the next section exists, is that insisting on rectangular coordinates here costs you far more than it buys. The check at the end is short but real, and it lands on the leftmost point of the heart.
Error analysis
Annotate
On: \( r = 1-\cos(\theta) \;\Longrightarrow\; r^2 = \bigl(r^2+r\cos\theta\bigr)^2 \;\Longrightarrow\; r = \pm\bigl(r^2 + r\cos\theta\bigr) \)
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 929 — the verification in Example 11.4.3, part 2c
Open the annotations one at a time and keep asking the same question: has the set of points changed, or only the set of ordered pairs?
The squaring step is the one under suspicion, and the suspicion is justified: the squared equation is satisfied by both the plus and the minus versions, and the minus version is a relation the original never contained. If this were a rectangular equation the conversion would be broken.
It is not broken, and the reason is the same rescue as in part 2a. Take a point satisfying the minus branch and rename it with the distance negated and the angle moved a half turn; that name satisfies the plus branch, and it is the same point in the plane. Polar coordinates are forgiving about squaring in a way that rectangular coordinates never are, and knowing exactly why is what lets you use the shortcut safely.
Sorting
Sort into buckets
Sort each polar equation by the first move that makes a standard expression appear.
Sort all six before checking. For each one, look at what is stopping you: is there a lone distance, no angle at all, a reciprocal function, or no distance at all?
Two of them have a lone distance equal to a lone circular function, and those are the multiply-by-the-distance cases: one multiplication produces two convertible expressions at once. Two of them hide a reciprocal, and clearing it does the same job in one step, handing you a coordinate directly.
The remaining two are the extremes. One has no angle in it, so nothing can be paired with the distance and squaring is the only route. One has no distance in it, so no distance relation can reach it and the tangent is the only route. Deciding which of these four situations you are in is most of the work in this direction.
Counterexample
Discussion prompt
A classmate says squaring both sides of a polar equation never matters, because the distance appears squared in the theorem anyway. Name the equation in this lesson where squaring genuinely changed the relation, say what it added, and explain the one feature of polar coordinates that rescues the conversion.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 928 — the footnote on equivalent representations
Write your answer before revealing, and make sure it has all three parts: the equation, what squaring added, and the feature that saves the day.
The equation is the constant negative distance from part 2a. Squaring admitted every point named with a distance of plus three, which as a set of ordered pairs is genuinely larger. The rescue is that polar names are not unique: each of those pairs names a point that also has a name with distance minus three, and that name satisfies the original equation.
The last part is the one worth carrying away. The rescue depends on a feature of the polar system, not on anything about this particular equation. In rectangular coordinates each point has exactly one name, so there is no second name to fall back on and a squaring step really can add points. That is why you check it there and can usually wave it through here.
Section
Part 6
Concept
The lesson's examples cut both ways. A circle centred on the pole has a two-character polar equation and a three-term rectangular one; a straight line missing the pole has a two-term rectangular equation and a polar one with a fraction in it.
| shape | rectangular | polar |
|---|---|---|
| circle about the origin | x² + y² = 9 | r = 3 |
| line through the origin | y = x√3 | θ = π/3 |
| circle through the origin | (x − 3)² + y² = 9 | r = 6 cos θ |
| parabola | y = x² | r = sec θ tan θ |
| cardioid | x² + y² = (x² + y² + x)² | r = 1 − cos θ |
Read the table in both directions. The last two rows are the reason the next section graphs polar equations without converting them at all.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 929 — the closing remark on which system to use
Read the table in both directions and resist the urge to decide that one system is better. Two rows favour polar, two favour rectangular, and one is a rout.
The pattern behind the table is that a coordinate system is short for the shapes built out of the quantities it measures. Polar coordinates measure distance from a point and direction from a ray, so anything defined by those two is short in polar form. Rectangular coordinates measure displacement along two fixed perpendicular directions, so anything built out of constant rates is short there.
The last two rows are the argument for the next section. If converting a cardioid to rectangular form produces a fourth-degree relation, then graphing it by converting is hopeless, and Section 11.5 will graph polar equations directly instead.
Picture it
Figure (svg): Two panels. On the left a circle centred at the origin, labelled with its very short polar equation and its longer rectangular one. On the right a straight line of slope two, labelled with its very short rectangular equation and its longer polar one.
A shape built out of distance from one centre is short in polar form. A shape built out of a constant rate of change is short in rectangular form. Choose the system whose basic quantity the shape is already made of.
The two panels are deliberately chosen to be equally simple curves with wildly unequal equations. A circle about the origin is two characters in polar form. A straight line that misses the origin is a fraction in polar form.
Ask yourself what each curve is made of. The circle is made of one distance, held constant, which is precisely one of the two quantities polar coordinates measure. The line is made of a constant rate of change and an offset, which is precisely what rectangular coordinates measure.
So the choice of system is not a matter of taste or habit. Look at the definition of the shape, see which two quantities it is built from, and use the system that measures those. When a problem hands you a system you did not choose, this lesson is how you get out of it.
Intuition
Polar coordinates measure distance from one chosen point and direction from one chosen ray. A curve whose definition mentions those same two quantities will have a short polar equation almost automatically.
\[ r = 3 \quad\text{is}\quad \text{all points at distance } 3 \]
Rectangular coordinates measure displacement along two fixed perpendicular directions, so they are short for anything built out of constant rates and straight offsets. Neither system is better; each is fluent in a different language.
This slide is the short version of the previous two, and it is the one to remember if you remember nothing else about choosing a system.
A polar equation is a statement about distance from the pole and direction from the polar axis. If the shape you care about is defined by those quantities, the equation will be short, often just one of them held constant. A circle about the pole is the extreme case: the whole equation is one number.
The converse is just as useful. If a shape is defined without reference to any special point, like a line of constant slope, then forcing it into polar form means expressing a property it does not have in terms of quantities it does not care about, and the equation gets long. Nothing has gone wrong; you have simply asked the wrong system.
Real world
Discussion prompt
A radar dish measures how long a pulse takes to return and which way it was pointing. Say which coordinate system that gives you directly, and what a collision-avoidance system must do before it can decide whether two aircraft are converging.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 931 — Exercise 98, the polar distance formula
Answer before revealing, and try to say why the conversion is necessary rather than merely convenient.
Anything that rotates and measures range reports a polar pair, because that is physically what it measures: a time of flight, which gives a distance, and a pointing direction, which gives an angle. Radar, sonar, lidar and a surveyor's theodolite all work this way.
The reason the software converts is that relative position is a subtraction, and polar pairs do not subtract. Subtracting two distances and two angles gives you nothing meaningful, whereas subtracting two rectangular pairs gives the displacement between the aircraft directly, and its rate of change tells you whether they are converging. So the tracker converts on the way in, does all its arithmetic in rectangular coordinates, and converts back only to draw the sweep on the screen.
Tweak it
Parameter explorer
The horizontal axis is the angle, over one full turn, and the curve is the first rectangular coordinate of the point. Slide the directed distance. Where does the curve cross zero, and what is true about the point at those angles?
\[ x = {r}\cos(\theta) \]
Start with the distance at four and move it slowly down through zero to minus five. The curve is the first rectangular coordinate of the point, plotted against the direction as the direction runs through one full turn.
The crossings do not move. Whatever the distance, the curve is zero at a quarter turn and at three quarters of a turn, because at those directions the cosine is zero. Those are the two directions along the vertical axis, and they are exactly the points where the first coordinate vanishes and the tangent relation is unavailable.
Now make the distance negative and watch the whole curve flip. That reflection is the half turn: every point moves to the diametrically opposite position, so every coordinate changes sign. Seeing it as a flip of one graph, rather than as a special case in a formula, is the clearest way to hold on to what a negative directed distance means.
Pattern
Figure (svg): A flow diagram with two branches. Going one way, a point or equation in polar form is converted by direct substitution of r cosine theta and r sine theta. Going the other way, a rectangular object is converted by first sketching or by rearranging until r squared, r cosine theta, r sine theta or the quotient appears.
Four routes, and the diagram is arranged so that the easy ones are on top. Before you start any conversion, decide which of the four you are on, because the technique is completely different in each case.
The two routes into rectangular form differ more than you might expect. For a point it is a substitution with no decisions. For an equation it is a search: manufacture one of the four expressions and swap it.
The two routes into polar form also differ. For a point, the constraints leave a choice and the sketch makes it. For an equation, the substitution is mechanical but the simplification usually produces a discarded factor you must account for. The last line of the list is the one that applies everywhere: after any move that multiplies, squares or divides, say out loud what happened to the set of points.
Check
Check your understanding
For a point with polar coordinates (r, θ) and rectangular coordinates (x, y), which statement is true for every point of the plane, with no extra condition?
Answer: A
Why: The recipe pair is stated for every point, including the pole and every pair with a negative directed distance; the proof handles those cases separately and they come out right. Each of the other three fails somewhere.
This question is about the shape of the theorem rather than about any calculation, and three of the four options are true in restricted circumstances, which is what makes them tempting.
The recipe pair is the only one stated with no conditions at all, and the proof spent two cases making sure of it: a negative distance, and the pole. The tangent relation carries an explicit proviso. The arctangent version is not in the theorem at all and is wrong for half the plane. The positive square root is right only when the distance has been required to be non-negative.
Check
Check your understanding
Convert (−2, 2√3) to polar form with r at least zero and θ at least zero but below one full turn. Which angle is correct?
Answer: B
Why: The distance is the square root of 4 plus 12, which is 4. The size of the quotient is root three, so the reference angle is a third of pi, and the point is in quadrant two, so the angle is a half turn minus a third of pi, which is two thirds of pi.
Work it out before choosing, and sketch the point first, because three of the four options are angles you can reach by a plausible slip.
The point is two to the left and about three and a half up, so it is in quadrant two. The distance is four and the size of the quotient is root three, giving a reference angle of a third of pi. Quadrant two means a half turn minus the reference angle.
Each wrong option corresponds to a specific mistake: the reference angle used unadjusted, the reference angle added to a half turn instead of subtracted, and the raw arctangent value. If you picked one of them, name the slip before moving on.
Check
Check your understanding
Converting r = 6 sin θ into rectangular form, which first move makes the standard expressions appear?
Answer: A
Why: Multiplying by the distance turns the left side into the square of the distance and the right side into six times the distance times the sine, and both of those convert on sight, giving the sum of squares equal to six times the second coordinate.
The equation has a lone distance on one side and a lone sine on the other, which is the most common shape in the exercise set, so the move you choose here you will choose many more times.
Multiplying by the distance converts both sides at once: the left becomes the sum of squares and the right becomes six times the second coordinate. The result is a circle, and completing the square in the second variable shows it is centred three units up with radius three.
Squaring is the wrong tool because it leaves a squared sine, which is not one of the four convertible expressions. Dividing by the sine is worse, since it risks dividing by zero and moves you further from a coordinate. The tangent is for equations that mention no distance at all.
Explain it to yourself
Discussion prompt
In two or three sentences, explain why converting a point into rectangular form needs no decisions, while converting one into polar form always ends with a choice. Base your answer on how many names a point has in each system.
Write your two or three sentences before revealing, and make sure the word unique appears somewhere in them.
The whole asymmetry comes from counting names. Rectangular names are unique, so a procedure producing one is producing the only answer and cannot face a choice. Polar names are infinitely many, so any procedure producing one must select, and the constraint relations are not strong enough to select for you.
It is worth noticing that this is not a flaw in the algebra that a cleverer formula could fix. The information genuinely is not there: the sum of squares cannot know the sign of the distance and the quotient cannot know a half turn. Something outside the two relations has to supply it, and a sketch is the cheapest something available.
Exit ticket
\[ \text{(a) Convert } \left(-2\sqrt3,\, 2\right) \text{ to polar form, with } r \ge 0 \text{ and } 0 \le \theta < 2\pi. \]
\[ \text{(b) Convert } r = -4\sin(\theta) \text{ to rectangular form.} \]
Discussion prompt
Do both, and for part (b) name the one move you made that could have changed the set of points, and say why it did not.
Do both parts on paper before revealing, and for part (a) sketch the point first, as you have been doing all lesson.
In part (a) the point is about three and a half to the left and two up, so quadrant two. The distance is four and the size of the quotient is one over root three, whose reference angle is a sixth of pi, so the answer is a half turn minus a sixth of pi.
In part (b) the shape of the equation tells you the move immediately: a lone distance and a lone sine, so multiply by the distance. The result is a circle centred two units below the origin with radius two. The risky move was the multiplication, which adds the pole, and the pole was already on the curve because a direction of zero gives a distance of zero. Saying that sentence is part of the answer, not an optional extra.
Recap
| what you have | what you want | the move |
|---|---|---|
| a polar pair | rectangular | substitute into the recipe pair; no decisions |
| a rectangular pair | polar | sketch, sum of squares, reference angle, quadrant |
| a rectangular equation | polar | substitute both recipes, simplify, watch the discarded factor |
| a polar equation | rectangular | engineer r², r cos θ, r sin θ or tan θ, then substitute |
\[ x = r\cos(\theta), \; y = r\sin(\theta), \; x^2+y^2 = r^2, \; \tan(\theta) = \tfrac{y}{x} \]
Two of these are recipes and two are constraints, and every difficulty in the lesson came from asking a constraint to do a recipe's job. Next, Section 11.5 graphs polar equations directly, without converting them at all, which is exactly what the cardioid argued for.
OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §10.3 Polar Coordinates §10.3 — the same material in OpenStax
Four routes and four relations, and the table is worth copying onto one card. The two recipes are unconditional and do all the work going into rectangular form. The two constraints are filters, and every difficulty in the lesson came from asking a filter to hand you an answer.
For points, the direction into rectangular form has no decisions and the direction into polar form always ends in one, because a point has one rectangular name and infinitely many polar ones. For equations, the direction into polar form is a substitution and the direction into rectangular form is a search for one of four expressions, with a mandatory question afterwards about what the move did to the set of points.
Section 11.5 takes the hint the cardioid gave. Rather than converting polar equations and graphing the result, it graphs them directly on the polar grid, which is the only sensible thing to do once you have seen a nine-character equation turn into a fourth-degree relation.
Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Trigonometry — $55/session, free consultation.