11.4a Polar Coordinates: Plotting and Multiple Names

A second address system for the plane, built from a pole and a polar axis rather than two number lines. Covers plotting from a directed distance and a rotation, what a negative first coordinate and a negative angle each mean, and the property that characterises exactly when two polar pairs name the same point — the reason a point has infinitely many polar names and only one rectangular one.

Subject: Trigonometry · 63 slides · symbolic lesson

Open the interactive version of this deck

What this lesson covers

The lesson, slide by slide

1. Polar Coordinates: Plotting and Multiple Names

Title

Trigonometry · Section 11.4

A second address system for the plane, in which every point has infinitely many addresses

2. What this lesson gives you

Objectives

Since Section 1.1 every point has been named by going across and then up. This lesson builds a second system from a fixed point and a fixed ray, in which a point is named by how far out it is and how far round.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, pp. 919-924 — learning objectives for this half of the section

You have used one address system for the plane since the very first section of the course: go across, then go up. It has served you well, and it has one property you have never had cause to notice, because you have never seen a system without it. Every point has exactly one address.

This lesson builds a second system out of a fixed point and a fixed ray. A point is named by how far out from the fixed point it is and how far round from the fixed ray. That is how a radar reports a contact, how a compass bearing works, and how anything that rotates is naturally described.

The surprise, and the whole difficulty of the section, is that the new system loses uniqueness. One point answers to infinitely many names. Most of your work here is learning to move between those names deliberately: to produce one on demand, to recognise two names for one point, and to reduce any name to a standard one when a question insists on a single answer.

3. Before anything new: coterminal angles

Warm-up

Discussion prompt

Two angles in standard position are coterminal when they share a terminal side. Write down, without looking back, the rule for generating every angle coterminal with a given one, and say how many there are.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 919 — the section assumes Chapter 10's standard-position angles

Write your answer before reading on. This is not a warm-up in the decorative sense; the fact you are recalling is the entire cause of everything strange in this lesson.

Two angles in standard position are coterminal when they finish on the same ray. Adding or subtracting any whole number of full turns leaves the terminal side exactly where it was, so every angle has infinitely many coterminal partners, one for each integer.

Now watch what happens when that fact is put inside a coordinate system. If the second entry of a pair is an angle, and an angle has infinitely many equal-looking versions, then the pair has infinitely many versions too. The polar system does not create the redundancy; it inherits it from the way angles have always worked.

4. A second address system

Section

Part 1

5. Two numbers, but not two lengths

Concept

Fix a point, called the pole, and a ray leaving it, called the polar axis. A point is then named by a pair: how far out from the pole, and how far round from the polar axis.

Figure (svg): Two panels. On the left a rectangular grid: from the origin an arrow runs three units left, then a second arrow runs four units up to the point P at minus three, four. On the right a polar grid of rings and rays: an arrow runs out from the pole along a ray, with a curved arrow showing the rotation from the polar axis to that ray.

The same plane, addressed two ways. The rectangular pair is two lengths at right angles; the polar pair is one length and one rotation.

pole and polar axis — The pole is the reference point, identified with the origin. The polar axis is the reference ray, identified with the positive part of the horizontal axis. Together they do the job the two number lines do in the rectangular system.

\[ r = \text{directed distance from the pole} \]

\[ \theta = \text{rotation from the polar axis} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 919 — the definition of the polar coordinate system

Look at the two panels together. On the left, the familiar route to the point: three units left, four units up. The two motions are perpendicular, and the point ends up at the far corner of a rectangle, which is why these are also called rectangular coordinates.

On the right, nothing is perpendicular. There is one length, drawn as the arrow out from the pole, and one rotation, drawn as the curved arrow from the polar axis to that ray. The pole plays the part of the origin and the polar axis plays the part of the positive horizontal axis, so the two pictures are laid over the same plane.

Read the pair in that order every time: distance first, angle second. The pair looks identical to a rectangular pair on the page, and a great many mistakes in this section come from reading the second entry as a height when it is a rotation.

6. How far out, and how far round

Intuition

People give directions this way all the time. Nobody says three blocks east and four blocks north when they can point and say five blocks that way. A bearing and a range is a polar pair.

The rectangular system is built for motions that are perpendicular to one another, and it describes rectangles well. The polar system is built for rotation, and it describes anything that turns or radiates well, which is most of physics and all of navigation.

The price is paid in this lesson. Rotation repeats, so the second coordinate repeats, so a point stops having a unique name. That is not a defect to be patched; it is what makes the system able to follow a moving point round and round.

It is worth being clear about why anyone bothers with a second system, because otherwise the non-uniqueness feels like a defect rather than a trade.

Rectangular coordinates are built out of two perpendicular motions, so they describe anything rectangular beautifully and anything circular awkwardly. A circle of radius three, in rectangular form, is an equation you have to square things to write. In polar form it is three words long: the distance is three.

The cost arrives immediately. Rotation comes back to where it started, so the angle repeats, so the names repeat. That is the price of a system whose second coordinate is an angle, and it buys you the ability to follow a point round and round without the description breaking. Keep that trade in mind; the last part of the lesson is about when you want to pay it and when you do not.

7. Reading the pair piece by piece

Notation

Annotate

On: \( P(r, \theta) \quad\text{with}\quad r \in \mathbb{R}, \; \theta \in \mathbb{R} \)

  • Distance first, angle second. The pair looks exactly like a rectangular pair and means something entirely different, which is why the letters r and θ are always written when there is any doubt.
  • r is a DIRECTED distance, so it may be negative. A negative r means: face along θ, then walk backwards. The actual distance from the pole is |r|.
  • A rotation from the polar axis, positive counter-clockwise and negative clockwise, measured in radians unless a degree sign says otherwise. It may exceed a full turn.
  • Neither entry is restricted. Both range over all the real numbers, and that freedom is exactly why one point answers to many pairs.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 919 — notation for the polar pair

Step through the annotations one at a time. The second one is the piece of the definition that most people skim, and it is the piece the rest of the lesson is built on.

The first coordinate is a directed distance, not a distance. Direction is built into it. A positive value means walk forwards along the ray the angle selects; a negative value means walk backwards along that same line, straight through the pole and out the other side. The actual distance from the pole is the size of the number, ignoring its sign.

The last annotation is the one to keep. Neither entry is restricted in any way. The angle may be negative, it may be larger than a full turn, and the distance may be negative. That total freedom is convenient when you are describing motion and inconvenient when you are trying to compare two answers, which is the tension the lesson ends on.

8. Two routes, one point

Concept

Given a pair, there are two ways to carry out the instruction, and the book asks you to practise both.

Figure (svg): Two polar grids. On the left the point is reached by first moving four units out along the polar axis and then swinging that mark counter-clockwise through five sixths of pi. On the right the same point is reached by first rotating to the terminal side of five sixths of pi and then moving four units out along it.

Both routes end on the same dot. The angle-first reading is the one worth keeping: the point sits on the terminal side of the angle, that far from the pole.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, pp. 919-920 — both plotting routes, worked for (4, 5π/6)

The book asks you to practise both routes, and the advice is worth taking, because each one makes a different thing obvious.

The distance-first route, on the left, makes the pair feel like an instruction: go out this far, then swing round by that much. It is the route that matches the order the entries are written in. The angle-first route, on the right, makes the answer feel like a description: the point is on the terminal side of the angle, that far from the pole.

Use the distance-first route to understand what the pair says and the angle-first route to actually plot. The second one is the one that keeps working when the entries turn negative, because it separates the two decisions cleanly: the angle chooses a line, and the sign of the distance chooses which way along it you travel.

9. Plotting a point with both coordinates positive

Worked example

The book's first plot. Both entries are positive, so nothing has to be reversed.

\[ \text{Plot } P\left(4, \tfrac{5\pi}{6}\right). \]

Read the two entries

Why: The first is a distance, the second a rotation.

\[ r = 4, \qquad \theta = \tfrac{5\pi}{6} \]

Convert the angle to degrees to see where it points

Why: Multiply by 180 over pi.

\[ \tfrac{5\pi}{6} \cdot \tfrac{180^\circ}{\pi} = 150^\circ \]

Rotate to the terminal side

Why: One hundred and fifty degrees counter-clockwise from the polar axis.

\[ \text{terminal side of } 150^\circ \]

Travel four units out along it

Why: The first coordinate is positive, so forwards.

\[ P = \text{the point } 4 \text{ units from the pole on that ray} \]

Figure (svg): A polar grid with five numbered rings. The ray at five sixths of pi is drawn solid, the rotation from the polar axis is marked as an arc labelled one hundred and fifty degrees, and a dot sits on the ray at the fourth ring, in the second quadrant.

Reading the pair off the picture: the ring says the distance, the ray says the direction. Nothing else is needed to plot a point.

Check the quadrant against the angle

Why: An angle between ninety and one hundred and eighty degrees has its terminal side in the second quadrant, and the plotted dot is in the second quadrant, on the fourth ring.

\[ 90^\circ < 150^\circ < 180^\circ \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{Quadrant II} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, pp. 919-920 — the plot of (4, 5π/6), both routes

This is the model solution for the easiest case, and every later example is this one with a sign flipped somewhere. Notice how little there is to it: identify the two entries, turn, walk.

Converting the angle to degrees is not compulsory, but it is a good habit early on, because most people have a much better feel for one hundred and fifty degrees than for five sixths of pi. Once you can see immediately that five sixths of pi is just short of a half turn, you can stop converting.

The check at the end costs nothing and catches nearly everything. An angle strictly between a quarter turn and a half turn has its terminal side in the second quadrant, so the plotted dot had better be in the second quadrant. When a sign goes wrong later in this lesson, this is the check that will tell you.

10. Which quadrant, before you plot?

Prediction

\[ P\left(6, \tfrac{5\pi}{3}\right) \]

Predict first

Both entries are positive. Which quadrant does this point lie in?

  • Quadrant I
  • Quadrant II
  • Quadrant III
  • Quadrant IV

Correct: Quadrant IV

Why: Five thirds of pi is three hundred degrees, which is between two hundred and seventy and three hundred and sixty, so its terminal side is in the fourth quadrant. With a positive first coordinate the point sits on that terminal side, six units out.

Commit to an option before revealing. Both entries here are positive, which is the case where your instinct is reliable, so this is a chance to confirm that the instinct is actually in place before the signs start changing.

Five thirds of pi is three hundred degrees. It is past three quarters of a turn and short of a full turn, so its terminal side is in the fourth quadrant, and since the distance is positive the point sits on that terminal side.

If you converted to degrees to answer, that is exactly right for now. If you answered directly from the fraction, check yourself against the conversion anyway. The fractions of pi that appear over and over in this chapter are worth knowing by sight: a sixth is thirty degrees, a quarter is forty-five, a third is sixty, a half is ninety.

11. Sort six points by quadrant

Sorting

Sort into buckets

Each first coordinate is positive, so the angle alone decides. Sort the points by quadrant.

Quadrant I
(3, π/6)
Quadrant II
(2, 3π/4); (2, 5π/6)
Quadrant III
(5, 4π/3)
Quadrant IV
(1, 7π/4); (4, −π/3)
q1
π/6 is 30°, a first-quadrant terminal side.
q2
3π/4 is 135° and 5π/6 is 150°; both terminal sides lie between 90° and 180°.
q3
4π/3 is 240°, between 180° and 270°.
q4
7π/4 is 315°; −π/3 is 60° clockwise, which is the same terminal side as 300°. Both are fourth-quadrant angles.

Every first coordinate here is positive, so the angle alone decides, and the sort is really a test of how quickly you can place an angle.

Two of the six deserve a second look. The angle in the fifth item is negative, which means the rotation is clockwise; sixty degrees clockwise reaches the same terminal side as three hundred degrees counter-clockwise, so it lands in the fourth quadrant beside the fourth item. The sixth item, five sixths of pi, is one hundred and fifty degrees, in the second quadrant with three quarters of pi.

Notice that two items landed in the same bucket by two different routes, one from a positive angle and one from a negative one. That is the first small taste of the main theme: different-looking pairs, same region of the plane.

12. What angle should the pole itself be given?

Socratic

Discussion prompt

Every point other than the pole lies on exactly one ray from the pole, so it has a well-defined direction. What pair, or pairs, should name the pole, and what does your answer say about the system as a whole?

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 923 — all polar coordinates of the form (0, θ) represent the pole

Write something down before revealing, even if it is only a shrug in words. The question looks like a technicality and it is actually the deepest thing in the section.

Every point except the pole sits on exactly one ray from the pole, so it has a direction, and an honest angle can be extracted from it. The pole has no direction, because you never left. You reach it by travelling zero units, and rotating a point that has not moved achieves nothing, so every angle whatsoever is correct for it.

Keep this in your pocket. At the end of the lesson you will meet a restriction that gives every point a unique name, and you will be able to say at once why the pole escapes it, and why no cleverer restriction could catch it either.

13. When r is negative

Section

Part 2

14. Directed distance: what the minus sign buys

Concept

The word directed in directed distance is doing real work. The angle chooses a ray; the sign of the first coordinate chooses which way along that ray you walk.

Figure (svg): A polar grid with a full line through the pole at forty-five degrees: the half in the first quadrant is solid, the half in the third quadrant is dashed. An arrow runs forward from the pole to a dot three units out in the first quadrant, and another arrow runs backward from the pole to a dot three units out in the third quadrant.

The angle chooses the ray; the sign of the first coordinate chooses which way along it you walk.

\[ r < 0: \quad \text{walk the OPPOSITE way along the ray} \]

So a pair with a negative first coordinate names a point on the terminal side of the angle plus a half turn, at a distance given by the size of that coordinate.

\[ (r, \theta) \text{ with } r<0 \;=\; \left(|r|, \theta + \pi\right) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 920 — if r is less than zero, move in the opposite direction

This is the idea that has no analogue in the system you already know, so give it a moment. In rectangular coordinates a minus sign means the other side of an axis, and that is all it can mean. Here it means something about travel.

Look at the figure. There is one straight line through the pole, and the angle picks it out. The solid half is where the angle points; the dashed half is directly behind you. A positive first coordinate walks along the solid half, a negative one along the dashed half. Same line, opposite directions.

The consequence is the formula on the slide, and it is the single most useful line in the lesson: a pair with a negative first coordinate names the same point as the pair with the size of that coordinate and the angle increased by a half turn. Whenever a negative first coordinate appears, that is the move.

15. Plotting Q: a negative first coordinate

Worked example

The book's second illustration. The angle is an ordinary first-quadrant angle; the distance is not.

\[ \text{Plot } Q\left(-3.5, \tfrac{\pi}{4}\right). \]

Rotate to the terminal side of the angle

Why: A quarter of pi is forty-five degrees, in the first quadrant.

\[ \tfrac{\pi}{4} = 45^\circ \]

Read the sign of the first coordinate

Why: It is negative, so the travel is backwards.

\[ r = -3.5 < 0 \]

Walk backwards through the pole

Why: Three and a half units the other way along the same line.

\[ \text{distance from the pole} = |-3.5| = 3.5 \]

Name the terminal side you land on

Why: Backwards along the ray at a quarter of pi is forwards along the ray a half turn later.

\[ \tfrac{\pi}{4} + \pi = \tfrac{5\pi}{4} \]

Figure (svg): A polar grid. A dashed ray points into the first quadrant at forty-five degrees with its rotation marked. A red arrow runs from the pole in the opposite direction, three and a half units into the third quadrant, ending at a dot labelled Q. A dashed arc shows the extra half turn from the dashed ray round to the dot.

The dashed ray is where the angle points. Q is on the other side of the pole, which is the terminal side of the angle plus a half turn.

Check with a positive-distance name

Why: Plotting the pair below directly, a rotation of two hundred and twenty-five degrees followed by a forward walk of three and a half units, lands on the same dot in the third quadrant.

\[ Q\left(-3.5, \tfrac{\pi}{4}\right) = Q\left(3.5, \tfrac{5\pi}{4}\right), \quad \tfrac{5\pi}{4} = 225^\circ \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 920 — the plot of Q(−3.5, π/4)

Follow the order of the steps carefully, because the temptation is to deal with the minus sign by ignoring it and fixing things later. Rotate first, then read the sign, then walk.

The rotation is an ordinary forty-five degree turn into the first quadrant, so the dashed ray in the figure points up and to the right. But the point is not there. The travel is backwards, so the point comes out down and to the left, in the third quadrant, three and a half units from the pole.

The last two steps are the ones worth copying into your own work. Name the terminal side the point actually lies on, which here is two hundred and twenty-five degrees, and then confirm by plotting the positive-distance name directly. Two independent routes to the same dot is as much certainty as you get in this section.

16. A negative angle turns the other way

Concept

A negative second coordinate means the rotation away from the polar axis is clockwise instead of counter-clockwise. That is the whole of it: the travel is unaffected.

\[ \theta < 0: \quad \text{rotate clockwise by } |\theta| \]

Two minus signs in a pair therefore do two unrelated jobs, and they are applied to different things. Keeping them apart is most of the skill in this section.

what is negativewhat it changeswhat it leaves alone
the first coordinatethe direction of travel along the raythe ray the angle selects
the second coordinatethe direction of the rotationthe direction of travel

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 920 — θ less than zero means a clockwise rotation

This rule is much simpler than the previous one, and the only real risk is contaminating it with the previous one. A negative angle changes the direction of the turn and nothing else at all.

The table is there because these two rules are constantly confused under pressure. A minus sign on the first entry reverses the walk and leaves the ray alone. A minus sign on the second entry reverses the turn, which chooses a different ray, and leaves the walk alone.

When a pair arrives with two minus signs, deal with them one at a time and in this order: angle first, to find the ray; then distance, to decide which way along it. Doing them in that order means you never have to hold two reversals in your head at once.

17. Plotting R: a negative angle

Worked example

The book's third illustration, and the last piece of the plotting rule.

\[ \text{Plot } R\left(3.5, -\tfrac{3\pi}{4}\right). \]

Read the sign of the angle

Why: Negative, so the rotation is clockwise.

\[ -\tfrac{3\pi}{4} = -135^\circ \]

Rotate clockwise to the terminal side

Why: One hundred and thirty-five degrees the other way lands in the third quadrant.

\[ \text{terminal side of } -135^\circ \]

Travel forwards along it

Why: The first coordinate is positive, so no reversal.

\[ r = 3.5 > 0 \]

Figure (svg): A polar grid with a clockwise arc sweeping from the polar axis down and round through one hundred and thirty five degrees into the third quadrant, where a solid ray is drawn. A green arrow runs forward from the pole three and a half units along that ray to a dot labelled R.

Nothing here is negative except the direction of the turn. The travel is forwards, because the first coordinate is positive.

Check with a positive angle

Why: Adding a full turn gives an angle with the same terminal side, and the standard-position name of that terminal side is two hundred and twenty-five degrees, which is where the dot is.

\[ -\tfrac{3\pi}{4} + 2\pi = \tfrac{5\pi}{4} = 225^\circ \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 920 — the plot of R(3.5, −3π/4)

Compare this with the previous example as you read it. There the distance was negative and the angle ordinary; here the angle is negative and the distance ordinary. The two examples between them cover every sign you will meet.

Turning one hundred and thirty-five degrees clockwise from the polar axis takes you down through the fourth quadrant and into the third. The walk is then forwards, because the distance is positive, so the point sits three and a half units out along that ray.

The check is the coterminal rule from the warm-up, doing real work for the first time. Adding a full turn to the negative angle gives five quarters of pi, which is two hundred and twenty-five degrees, and that names the same terminal side. If that number looks familiar from the previous slide, the next slide is for you.

18. Two different instructions, one dot

Anomaly

Figure (svg): One polar grid carrying both routes at once. A red dashed ray points into the first quadrant with a backward red arrow through the pole, and a green clockwise arc leads to a forward green arrow, and both arrows end on the very same dot in the third quadrant.

Two pairs that share no entry, and yet name one point. That is the fact the rest of the lesson has to account for.

Predict first

The pair naming Q has a negative distance and a first-quadrant angle. The pair naming R has a positive distance and a negative angle. They share no entry. What is the relationship between the two points?

  • They are the same point
  • They are a half turn apart
  • They are reflections in the polar axis
  • One is twice as far out as the other

Correct: They are the same point

Why: Walking backwards from a ray at forty-five degrees and walking forwards from a ray at minus one hundred and thirty-five degrees both end three and a half units out in the third quadrant. Nothing in the two pairs looks alike, and yet the dot is the same one, which is why the section needs a rule for deciding when two pairs agree.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 921 — the points Q and R above are, in fact, the same point

Commit to an option before revealing. The two pairs share no entry, not the distance and not the angle, and one of them has a negative distance while the other has a negative angle. Everything on the page says they should be different points.

They are the same point. The backwards walk from a forty-five degree ray and the forwards walk from a minus one hundred and thirty-five degree ray both finish three and a half units out in the third quadrant, which the figure shows by drawing both routes onto one dot.

This is the observation the rest of the lesson has to account for. Two pairs with nothing in common can name one point, so you cannot decide whether two polar answers agree by comparing them entry by entry. A rule is needed, and the next part of the lesson states it and proves it.

19. Trap: reading the pair as a horizontal and a vertical step

Trap

The trap

A pair arrives and the eye reads it as the familiar thing:

\[ (2, 3) \;\to\; \text{right } 2, \text{ up } 3? \]

Wrong. In polar form the second entry is an angle of three radians, about one hundred and seventy-two degrees.

\[ (2, 3) = \text{2 units out at } 172^\circ \]

The fix

There is no way to tell from the symbols alone, so the context has to tell you. Whenever a question mixes the two systems, write the letters into the pair as you read it, and plot before you calculate.

\[ (x, y) \ne (r, \theta) \]

A rectangular pair describes a corner of a rectangle. A polar pair describes the end of a walk along a rotated ray. They agree only at the pole.

Pin the example down numerically, because the size of the error is the surprise. Read as a polar pair, the second entry is an angle of three radians, just under a half turn, so the point lies almost directly to the left of the pole and only a little above the polar axis. Read as a rectangular pair it is two to the right and three up. Those are nowhere near each other, and the notation gives no warning at all.

There are two giveaways worth trusting. A second entry written as a fraction involving pi is almost certainly an angle, and so is one carrying a degree sign. Past that you have only the instruction or the section heading, which is why any exercise set that mixes the systems says explicitly which is which.

The habit that protects you costs nothing. Name the two entries out loud as you copy them down, then plot before you calculate. A point plotted in the wrong quadrant announces itself at once, while an arithmetic answer built on a misread pair looks perfectly respectable right to the last line.

20. Two sign flips that do different things

Picture it

Figure (svg): A polar grid with a yellow base dot three units out at thirty degrees. A red dot sits diametrically opposite it, three units out at two hundred and ten degrees, and a green dot sits three units out at minus thirty degrees, mirrored across the polar axis. A dashed loop round the base dot marks the edit that changes nothing.

Three edits that look equally small on the page. One moves the point across the plane, one mirrors it, and one does nothing at all.

Start from the yellow dot. Negating the first coordinate sends the point half a turn round the pole, to the red dot. Negating the angle reflects the point in the polar axis, to the green dot. Adding a whole turn to the angle does nothing whatsoever.

These three edits are the entire vocabulary of the rest of the lesson, and confusing the first two is the most common error in the section.

Spend a moment on this figure, because the three coloured dots are the three things you can do to a pair, and telling them apart is most of the skill in the rest of the lesson.

Negating the first coordinate sends the point straight through the pole to the diametrically opposite position: the red dot. Negating the angle mirrors the point in the polar axis: the green dot. Adding a whole turn to the angle changes absolutely nothing: the dashed loop around the yellow dot.

Notice that two of these edits move the point and one does not, and that the two that move it move it in completely different ways. The rule coming up in the next part allows exactly two kinds of edit, and neither of them is the green one. If your working ever produces a reflection, you have negated an angle when you should have shifted it.

21. Find the error: negating the angle instead of adding pi

Error analysis

Annotate

On: \( \left(-4, \tfrac{\pi}{3}\right) \;\Longrightarrow\; \left(4, -\tfrac{\pi}{3}\right) \)

  • Something did have to change when the minus sign moved off the first coordinate, so something was changed. The instinct is right.
  • Negating the angle reflects the point in the polar axis. Combined with the sign flip on r, the result is the reflection of the correct answer, not the correct answer.
  • A sign flip on r is a half turn, so it must be paid for with a half turn: add (or subtract) π. The right-hand pair is (4, π/3 + π) = (4, 4π/3).
  • π/3 is 60°, so the given pair is 4 units out at 60° + 180° = 240°. The student's answer sits at −60°, which is 300°: a different point entirely.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, pp. 920-921 — the plots of Q and R, from which both rules come

Read the line before revealing the annotations and try to say precisely what is wrong. It is worth noticing that whoever wrote it did something rather than nothing; they knew the sign flip had to be compensated. The instinct was sound and the compensation was the wrong one.

Flipping the sign of the first coordinate turns the point through a half turn. To get back to where you started you must turn a half turn the other way, which means adding or subtracting a half turn from the angle. Negating the angle does not do that; it reflects, and a reflection is a different motion entirely.

The arithmetic in the last annotation makes it concrete. The correct answer sits at two hundred and forty degrees and the wrong one sits at three hundred. Those are different points on the same ring, and no amount of later tidying will bring them together.

22. Complete the flip to a positive first coordinate

Fill the middle

The point below is to be renamed so that its first coordinate is positive. Fill in both blanks.

Fill in the blanks

\left(-5, \tfrac57\right) = \left(___, \tfrac______ + \pi\right) = \left(___, \tfrac___\pi}___\right)

Why: Flipping the sign of the first coordinate costs a half turn, so 5 replaces minus 5 and pi is added to the angle. One sixth of pi plus six sixths of pi is seven sixths of pi, an angle of 210 degrees in the third quadrant, which is where a backward walk from a 30 degree ray lands.

Fill both blanks before checking. The first blank is the easy one; the second is where the arithmetic with sixths of pi has to be done carefully.

One sixth of pi is thirty degrees, and a half turn is six sixths of pi, so the sum is seven sixths of pi, which is two hundred and ten degrees. That is in the third quadrant, exactly where a backwards walk from a thirty degree ray should put you.

Get into the habit of writing the intermediate form, with the half turn still visible as a separate term, before you combine the fractions. That way, if the final fraction comes out wrong, you can see immediately whether the mistake was in the rule or in the arithmetic.

23. Slide the first coordinate through zero

Tweak it

Parameter explorer

The curve shows how far the point is to the right of the pole as the angle turns through one revolution; the horizontal axis is the angle in radians. Slide the first coordinate from positive to negative and watch the whole curve. What single change to the angle would have produced the same curve?

\[ \text{across} = {r}\cos(\theta) \]

  • r — from -4 to 4: first coordinate r

The curve here is not the polar point itself; it is one number about it, plotted against the angle. Specifically it is how far the point lies to the right of the pole as the angle turns through one full revolution, with the first coordinate held fixed by the slider.

Start with the first coordinate positive and watch the shape. Then drag it down through zero and into the negatives. At zero the curve flattens onto the axis, which is the pole refusing to move however much you turn. Below zero the whole curve turns upside down.

Now ask what else could have produced that flipped curve. Leaving the first coordinate positive and adding a half turn to every angle does exactly the same thing, because a half turn sends the rightward measurement to its negative. That is the second clause of the equivalence property, seen as a graph rather than as a picture of the plane.

24. Infinitely many names

Section

Part 3

25. Counting the names of one point

Concept

Fix a point that is not the pole, two units from the pole on the terminal side of a third of pi. Which pairs name it?

Figure (svg): A horizontal angle line running from minus two pi to four pi with the multiples of pi ticked. Yellow dots above the line mark the angles a third of pi, a third of pi plus two pi, and a third of pi minus two pi; red dots below the line mark the same angles shifted by pi. The two rows alternate all along the line.

Every yellow dot is a name with the first coordinate positive, every red dot a name with it negative. Both rows run on for ever.

\[ (2, \tfrac{\pi}{3} + 2\pi k) \quad\text{and}\quad (-2, \tfrac{\pi}{3} + \pi + 2\pi k), \quad k \in \mathbb{Z} \]

Two infinite families, one for each sign of the first coordinate, interleaving half a turn apart. A rectangular point has one name; this point has one for every integer, twice over.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 921 — a point can be represented by infinitely many polar coordinate pairs

The figure is not a picture of the plane; it is a picture of the angles that work. The horizontal line is a line of angles, running from two full turns back to two full turns forward, and every dot on it marks an angle that names the point in question.

The yellow dots above the line are the angles that work with a positive first coordinate: the terminal side of the point, plus or minus any number of whole turns. The red dots below the line are the angles that work with a negative first coordinate, and they sit exactly half a turn away from the yellow ones.

Two things to take away. First, the names come in two families, one for each sign, and neither family is more correct than the other. Second, both families run on for ever in both directions, so the number of names is infinite and stays infinite however far out you look.

26. One point, four of its names

Picture it

Figure (svg): A polar grid with one dot two units out at sixty degrees. Four routes reach it: a short counter-clockwise arc, a long spiral of one whole turn plus sixty degrees, a backward arrow from a dashed ray at two hundred and forty degrees, and a backward arrow from a dashed ray at minus one hundred and twenty degrees.

Four pairs, no two alike, all naming the dot in the first quadrant. The first coordinate is plus two twice and minus two twice.

Four routes to one dot. Two turn to the ray the dot is on and walk forwards; two turn to the opposite ray and walk backwards. Each of the four has infinitely many relatives, obtained by adding whole turns.

Four routes, one dot. Two of them turn to the ray the dot is on and walk forwards, differing only by a whole turn. The other two turn to the opposite ray and walk backwards, and they also differ from each other by a whole turn.

The purpose of the picture is to make the two families visible at once. Notice that you cannot tell from the dot which name produced it, which is the practical meaning of non-uniqueness: a plotted point carries no memory of how you got there.

Every one of the four names has infinitely many relatives waiting behind it, obtained by adding whole turns. Four is just as many as fits legibly on a grid.

27. Reading the equivalence property

Notation

Annotate

On: \( r' = r, \; \theta' = \theta + 2\pi k \quad\text{or}\quad r' = -r, \; \theta' = \theta + (2k+1)\pi \)

  • One for a matching first coordinate, one for an opposite one. There is no third case: the distance from the pole is the same in both names, so r' is either r or −r.
  • An even number of half turns. The direction of travel is unchanged, so the first coordinate must be unchanged too.
  • An odd number of half turns. The direction of travel is reversed, which is paid for by flipping the sign of the first coordinate.
  • Negative k subtracts turns, k = 0 is allowed. This is what makes each family infinite in both directions.
  • The property assumes both first coordinates are non-zero. Every pair (0, θ) is the pole, and that case is stated separately.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 923 — Equivalent Representations of Points in Polar Coordinates

This is the central result of the lesson, and the annotations are there to stop it from looking like two unrelated facts glued together.

The reason there are exactly two clauses and not three is in the first annotation. Both names measure the distance from the same point to the same pole, so the sizes of the two first coordinates must agree, which leaves only two possibilities: the same number, or its negative.

The middle two annotations are the heart of it. An even number of half turns leaves you facing the same way, so the first coordinate is unchanged. An odd number leaves you facing backwards, which has to be paid for by flipping the sign. Read the two clauses that way and they stop being a pair of formulas to memorise.

28. Why the two clauses are really one idea

Concept

Suppose two pairs name the same point and neither first coordinate is zero. Follow what the picture forces, one step at a time.

\[ \text{distance from the pole is the same} \;\Longrightarrow\; |r'| = |r| \;\Longrightarrow\; r' = r \text{ or } r' = -r \]

If the first coordinates agree

Why: Both walks go forwards the same distance, so both angles must select the same ray.

\[ r' = r \;\Longrightarrow\; \theta' \text{ coterminal with } \theta \;\Longrightarrow\; \theta' = \theta + 2\pi k \]

If the first coordinates are opposite

Why: One walk goes forwards, the other backwards, so the two rays point opposite ways and the angles are half a turn out.

\[ r' = -r \;\Longrightarrow\; \theta' \text{ coterminal with } \theta + \pi \;\Longrightarrow\; \theta' = \theta + \pi + 2\pi k \]

\[ \theta + \pi + 2\pi k = \theta + (2k+1)\pi \]

So both clauses count half turns, and the only thing that matters is whether that count is even or odd. Even keeps the sign of the first coordinate; odd flips it.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 924 — the argument following the property

This is the book's own argument, laid out one move per line. It is worth following because it turns a rule you would otherwise memorise into something you could reconstruct from a picture in about thirty seconds.

Start from the only thing you know: two names for the same point. The distance from that point to the pole is a single number, and each name reports it as the size of its first coordinate, so those sizes agree and the first coordinates are either equal or opposite.

Then the two branches write themselves. If the first coordinates are equal, both walks go forwards, so both angles must select the same ray, which means coterminal, which means whole turns apart. If they are opposite, one walk goes forwards and the other backwards, so the two rays point opposite ways, which means the angles are half a turn apart plus whole turns. Collect the half turn and the whole turns into one expression and you have the odd multiple of pi that the property states.

29. Example 11.4.1, part 1: two more names for the point at 240 degrees

Worked example

Plot the point and give one further name with a positive first coordinate and one with a negative first coordinate.

\[ P(2, 240^\circ) \]

Plot it

Why: Two hundred and forty degrees counter-clockwise, then two units forwards.

\[ \text{Quadrant III}, \; 2 \text{ units from the pole} \]

Fix what every name must share

Why: The distance from the pole is 2, so the first coordinate is 2 or minus 2.

\[ r = \pm 2 \]

For the positive case, take a coterminal angle

Why: Subtract a full turn from 240 degrees.

\[ 240^\circ - 360^\circ = -120^\circ \;\Longrightarrow\; (2, -120^\circ) \]

For the negative case, subtract a half turn

Why: Starting two units to the left of the pole, a rotation of 60 degrees puts the backward walk on the right ray.

\[ 240^\circ - 180^\circ = 60^\circ \;\Longrightarrow\; (-2, 60^\circ) \]

Figure (svg): A polar grid with three rings. A yellow arc sweeps counter-clockwise through two hundred and forty degrees, an orange arc sweeps clockwise through one hundred and twenty degrees, and both finish on the same ray in the third quadrant where a dot sits two units out. A green dashed ray at sixty degrees carries a backward arrow through the pole to the same dot.

The same dot, reached by turning forwards, by turning backwards, and by facing the opposite way and walking backwards.

Check both against the property

Why: The first has the same first coordinate and angles differing by one whole turn, so clause one applies; the second has the opposite first coordinate and angles differing by one half turn, an odd count, so clause two applies.

\[ 240^\circ - (-120^\circ) = 360^\circ, \qquad 240^\circ - 60^\circ = 180^\circ \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 921 — Example 11.4.1, part 1

This is the first of the four parts of the book's example, and the pattern it sets is worth learning as a pattern, because the other three parts are the same four moves with different signs.

Move one is to plot and fix the distance. Every name of this point has a first coordinate of two or minus two, and no other value is possible, which cuts the search down enormously before any angle is chosen.

Move two is to pick an angle for each sign. For the positive sign the angle must be coterminal with the given one, so subtracting a full turn gives minus one hundred and twenty degrees. For the negative sign the angle must be half a turn away, so subtracting a half turn gives sixty degrees. The check at the end tests each answer against the matching clause of the property, which is the write-up an examiner wants to see.

30. Example 11.4.1, part 2: starting from a negative first coordinate

Worked example

The given name already has a negative first coordinate, so the plotting rule is applied before anything else.

\[ P\left(-4, \tfrac{7\pi}{6}\right) \]

Locate the point

Why: Face along seven sixths of pi, which is two hundred and ten degrees, then walk backwards four units.

\[ \tfrac{7\pi}{6} + \pi = \tfrac{13\pi}{6} \equiv \tfrac{\pi}{6} \]

Record what the picture gives

Why: The point is four units from the pole on the terminal side of one sixth of pi.

\[ \text{distance } 4, \quad \text{terminal side } \tfrac{\pi}{6} \]

Name it with a positive first coordinate

Why: Use the terminal side the point is actually on.

\[ \left(4, \tfrac{\pi}{6}\right) \]

Name it again with a negative first coordinate

Why: Keep minus 4 and choose an angle coterminal with the given one; subtract a whole turn.

\[ \tfrac{7\pi}{6} - 2\pi = -\tfrac{5\pi}{6} \;\Longrightarrow\; \left(-4, -\tfrac{5\pi}{6}\right) \]

Figure (svg): A polar grid with five rings. A dashed ray runs into the third quadrant at two hundred and ten degrees with its arc marked, and a red arrow runs from the pole in the opposite direction four units into the first quadrant, ending at a dot. A second, clockwise arc is drawn to minus one hundred and fifty degrees.

Neither printed angle points at the point. Both are angles whose opposite direction does, which is exactly what a negative first coordinate means.

Check the quadrants agree

Why: Seven sixths of pi points into the third quadrant and the negative first coordinate sends the point to the opposite quadrant, the first; one sixth of pi is thirty degrees, in the first quadrant, four units out. The two descriptions agree.

\[ \left(-4, \tfrac{7\pi}{6}\right) = \left(4, \tfrac{\pi}{6}\right) = \left(-4, -\tfrac{5\pi}{6}\right) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, pp. 921-922 — Example 11.4.1, part 2

Here the given name already has the awkward sign, so the very first thing to do is find out where the point actually is. Do not try to generate other names from the symbols; generate them from the point.

Seven sixths of pi is two hundred and ten degrees, pointing into the third quadrant, and the negative distance sends the point to the opposite ray, one sixth of pi, in the first quadrant. That fact, four units out on the terminal side of one sixth of pi, is the only thing you need for the rest of the question.

Then the two names come out easily. For a positive first coordinate, use the terminal side the point is actually on. For a negative one, keep the given first coordinate and move the given angle by a whole turn, which is legal by the first clause. Notice that neither printed angle points at the point: that is the situation the figure is drawing.

31. Same point, or a different one?

Discrimination

\[ \text{Compare each pair with } \left(2, \tfrac{\pi}{3}\right). \]

Sort into buckets

Use the equivalence property, not a picture, to sort these.

The same point
(2, 7π/3); (−2, 4π/3); (2, −5π/3); (−2, −2π/3)
A different point
(−2, π/3); (2, −π/3)
same
7π/3 and −5π/3 differ from π/3 by ±2π, an even number of half turns, with the first coordinate kept: clause one. 4π/3 and −2π/3 differ from π/3 by +π and −π, an odd number, with the first coordinate flipped: clause two.
diff
(−2, π/3) flips the first coordinate but changes the angle by nothing, an even count, so it lands half a turn away. (2, −π/3) keeps the first coordinate but changes the angle by −2π/3, which is not a whole turn, so it lands elsewhere on the same ring.

Do this one with the property rather than with a picture; the point of the exercise is to get fluent with counting half turns.

For each candidate, ask two questions in order. Is the first coordinate the same or the opposite? Then, how many half turns apart are the angles? Same first coordinate needs an even count; opposite first coordinate needs an odd count. Any other combination is a different point.

The two that fail are instructive. One of them flips the sign without moving the angle at all, which is an even count with an opposite first coordinate, so it lands a half turn away. The other keeps the first coordinate but moves the angle by two thirds of a turn, which is not a whole number of turns, so it lands elsewhere on the same ring. Both mistakes appear regularly in homework.

32. Example 11.4.1, part 3: an angle past a full turn

Worked example

A large distance and an angle bigger than a whole revolution, taken clockwise.

\[ P\left(117, -\tfrac{5\pi}{2}\right) \]

Reduce the rotation

Why: Five halves of pi is one whole turn plus a quarter turn, taken clockwise.

\[ -\tfrac{5\pi}{2} = -2\pi - \tfrac{\pi}{2} \]

Locate the point

Why: The terminal side is the downward vertical, and the walk is forwards.

\[ \text{terminal side } -\tfrac{\pi}{2}, \quad 117 \text{ units out} \]

Name it with a positive first coordinate

Why: Add two whole turns to the given angle to land in the standard range.

\[ -\tfrac{5\pi}{2} + 4\pi = \tfrac{3\pi}{2} \;\Longrightarrow\; \left(117, \tfrac{3\pi}{2}\right) \]

Name it with a negative first coordinate

Why: Subtract a half turn from that angle and flip the sign.

\[ \tfrac{3\pi}{2} - \pi = \tfrac{\pi}{2} \;\Longrightarrow\; \left(-117, \tfrac{\pi}{2}\right) \]

Figure (svg): A polar grid with rings labelled fifty, one hundred and one hundred and fifty. A spiral sweep winds clockwise from the polar axis through one full turn and a quarter more, ending pointing straight down, where a dot sits at a distance of one hundred and seventeen on the downward ray.

A rotation of more than a full turn is perfectly legal; it just lands on a terminal side some shorter rotation would have reached.

Check the negative name directly

Why: A quarter turn points straight up; a negative first coordinate sends the walk straight down, one hundred and seventeen units, which is where the point is.

\[ \left(-117, \tfrac{\pi}{2}\right) = \left(117, \tfrac{\pi}{2} + \pi\right) = \left(117, \tfrac{3\pi}{2}\right) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 922 — Example 11.4.1, part 3

The distance of one hundred and seventeen is there to make a point: nothing about the method depends on the size of the numbers. The interesting entry is the angle.

Five halves of pi is one whole turn plus a quarter turn, taken clockwise, which the spiral in the figure draws as a sweep that passes its own starting direction before finishing. Where it finishes is all that matters: pointing straight down.

From there the two names are routine. Adding two whole turns to the given angle brings it into the usual range as three quarters of a turn, and subtracting a half turn from that, with a sign flip, gives the quarter turn with a negative distance. The check is worth reading: a quarter turn points straight up, and the negative first coordinate sends the walk straight down, which is where the point is.

33. Example 11.4.1, part 4: both coordinates negative

Worked example

The last part of the example, with a minus sign on each entry.

\[ P\left(-3, -\tfrac{\pi}{4}\right) \]

Deal with the angle

Why: Negative, so rotate clockwise a quarter of a right angle and a half: forty-five degrees.

\[ -\tfrac{\pi}{4} = -45^\circ, \quad \text{Quadrant IV ray} \]

Deal with the distance

Why: Negative, so walk backwards from there; the point lands on the opposite ray.

\[ -\tfrac{\pi}{4} + \pi = \tfrac{3\pi}{4} \]

Name it with a positive first coordinate

Why: Use the terminal side the point is on.

\[ \left(3, \tfrac{3\pi}{4}\right) \]

Name it with a negative first coordinate

Why: Keep minus 3 and add a whole turn to the given angle.

\[ -\tfrac{\pi}{4} + 2\pi = \tfrac{7\pi}{4} \;\Longrightarrow\; \left(-3, \tfrac{7\pi}{4}\right) \]

Figure (svg): A polar grid with a clockwise arc of forty-five degrees into the fourth quadrant, where the ray is dashed. A red arrow runs from the pole in the opposite direction, three units into the second quadrant, ending at a dot; a second dashed ray marks the terminal side of three quarters of pi that the dot lies on.

Two minus signs, two different jobs: one reverses the turn, the other reverses the walk. Applied in order they land the point in the second quadrant.

Check the quadrant

Why: The angle alone points into the fourth quadrant; flipping the sign of the distance sends the point to the opposite quadrant, the second. Three quarters of pi is one hundred and thirty-five degrees, in the second quadrant, three units out.

\[ \left(-3, -\tfrac{\pi}{4}\right) = \left(3, \tfrac{3\pi}{4}\right) = \left(-3, \tfrac{7\pi}{4}\right) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 923 — Example 11.4.1, part 4

The last part of the example puts both minus signs in the same pair, which is the case people dread. Taken in order, it is no harder than the others.

Deal with the angle first: negative, so turn clockwise forty-five degrees, into the fourth quadrant. Then deal with the distance: negative, so walk backwards, which sends the point to the opposite ray, three quarters of pi, in the second quadrant.

The check names the quadrants explicitly, and that is the habit to build. The angle alone points into the fourth quadrant; one sign flip on the distance sends the point to the opposite quadrant, which is the second. If your answer had come out in the fourth quadrant, you would know at a glance that a sign had been dropped.

34. Match each edit to the pair with its effect

Matching

Match the pairs

  • l1. negate r
  • l2. negate θ
  • l3. add 2π to θ
  • l4. negate r and add π to θ
  • r1. moves the point a half turn about the pole
  • r2. reflects the point in the polar axis
  • r3. nothing moves: one whole turn, an even count of half turns
  • r4. nothing moves: the sign flip and the half turn cancel

Why: Two of the four edits leave the point exactly where it is, and they are the two clauses of the equivalence property. The other two move it, and they move it in quite different ways: one across the pole, the other across the polar axis. Negating the angle is the edit with no clause, which is why it is the one that goes wrong.

Four edits, four effects, and the exercise is really asking you to sort them into the ones the equivalence property allows and the ones it does not.

Two of the edits leave the point exactly where it is, and those two are the two clauses of the property: a whole turn with the sign kept, and a half turn with the sign flipped. The other two both move the point, and they move it in different directions, which is why confusing them produces an answer that is wrong in a way that is hard to spot.

Negating the angle is the edit with no clause of its own. It is a perfectly good geometric operation, a reflection in the polar axis, but it is not a renaming. If it shows up in your working while you are producing alternate names, something has gone wrong.

35. Trap: adding pi without flipping the sign of r

Trap

The trap

Asked for another name for a point, a student adds a half turn:

\[ \left(5, \tfrac{\pi}{6}\right) \;\to\; \left(5, \tfrac{7\pi}{6}\right)? \]

Wrong. That is a different point, diametrically opposite the first.

\[ \tfrac{\pi}{6}: \text{QI}, \quad \tfrac{7\pi}{6}: \text{QIII} \]

The fix

The equivalence property allows a half turn only when the sign of the first coordinate flips with it. Add a whole turn and keep the sign, or add a half turn and flip the sign; never one without the other.

\[ \left(5, \tfrac{\pi}{6}\right) = \left(5, \tfrac{13\pi}{6}\right) \]

\[ \left(5, \tfrac{\pi}{6}\right) = \left(-5, \tfrac{7\pi}{6}\right) \]

Both legal names keep the point in the first quadrant. Name the quadrant before and after every edit: if it changed, so did the point.

This one is tempting precisely because half of it is right. A half turn does appear in the property, so adding one feels legitimate. It is legitimate only when the sign of the first coordinate flips at the same time.

Think of it as paying a bill. A sign flip costs a half turn; a half turn costs a sign flip. Doing one without the other leaves the account unbalanced, and an unbalanced account means the point has moved to the opposite side of the pole.

The quickest defence is to name the quadrant before and after. The original point in the example is in the first quadrant and the proposed answer is in the third, and there is no reading of the rules under which renaming a point changes its quadrant.

36. How many names inside fifty turns?

Estimation

\[ \text{Names of } (2, \tfrac{\pi}{3}) \text{ whose angle lies in } [0, 100\pi) \]

Predict first

Angles are restricted to one hundred pi, which is fifty whole turns. How many different polar pairs name this one point inside that window?

  • Fifty
  • One hundred
  • Two hundred
  • Still infinitely many

Correct: One hundred

Why: With the first coordinate positive the angles are a third of pi plus whole turns, and fifty whole turns fit in the window, so there are fifty such names. With the first coordinate negative there are fifty more, half a turn out of step with the first fifty. One hundred in all, and the count is finite only because the window is.

\[ 50 \text{ (with } r = 2) + 50 \text{ (with } r = -2) = 100 \]

Guess before you check. Most people either say infinitely many, forgetting that the window is finite, or say fifty, forgetting that there are two families.

Inside a window of fifty whole turns there are exactly fifty angles of the form terminal side plus whole turns, so fifty names with a positive first coordinate. There are fifty more with a negative first coordinate, each sitting half a turn away from one of the first fifty, so one hundred in total.

The point of the count is to make the infinity concrete. The names are not scattered arbitrarily; they arrive at a perfectly regular rate of two per turn, alternating between the two signs. If you remove the window, the same regular pattern simply continues for ever in both directions.

37. Producing alternate names

Section

Part 4

38. A procedure that does not depend on the given pair

Concept

When a question asks for another name, the reliable move is to stop working with the given pair and work from the plotted point instead. A plotted point has no signs left to get wrong.

  1. Plot the point. Sign slips are invisible in symbols and obvious in a picture.
  2. Read off the distance from the pole; every name has first coordinate plus or minus that.
  3. Read off the terminal side the point is actually on; that angle serves the positive first coordinate.
  4. For a negative first coordinate, add or subtract π from any angle that served the positive one.
  5. Add whole turns to either to satisfy a range condition.

\[ \text{distance } d, \text{ terminal side } \alpha \;\Longrightarrow\; (d, \alpha + 2\pi k) \text{ or } (-d, \alpha + \pi + 2\pi k) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, pp. 921-923 — the pattern of all four parts of Example 11.4.1

Here is the whole of the naming business as one procedure, and the first line is the one that does the work. Plot the point, then forget the pair you were given.

The reason is worth understanding rather than just accepting. Any sign error you make while manipulating symbols is invisible, because the result still looks like a perfectly good pair. The same error in a picture puts a dot in the wrong quadrant, which you cannot miss. So you move the delicate part of the work into the picture, where errors announce themselves.

Once you have the two numbers from the picture, the distance and the terminal side, every name the point has is generated by the last line on the slide. Everything afterwards, including range conditions, is bookkeeping on whole turns.

39. Before you write a single name

Step zero

\[ \text{Give three names for } \left(-2.5, -\tfrac{\pi}{4}\right). \]

Discussion prompt

Before producing any name at all, what two numbers should you extract from this pair, and which of the two given entries is guaranteed NOT to be one of them?

Write your answer down before revealing. Thirty seconds spent here saves a scribbled-out page later.

The two numbers to extract are the distance from the pole and the terminal side the point actually lies on. The distance is easy: it is the size of the first entry, two and a half. The terminal side is not the given angle, because the first coordinate is negative; it is the given angle plus a half turn, which is three quarters of pi.

That is the general warning. Whenever the first coordinate is negative, the printed angle is guaranteed not to be the terminal side of the point. Working from the printed angle in that situation produces names for the diametrically opposite point, and every one of them will look plausible.

40. Exercise 2: three names to order

Worked example

The exercise set asks for three further names, each meeting a stated condition. Start from the point.

\[ \left(5, \tfrac{7\pi}{4}\right): \quad \text{(a) } r<0,\; 0 \le \theta \le 2\pi; \quad \text{(b) } r>0,\; \theta \le 0; \quad \text{(c) } r>0,\; \theta \ge 2\pi \]

Read the point off the given pair

Why: Both entries are positive, so the terminal side is the given angle: three hundred and fifteen degrees.

\[ d = 5, \qquad \alpha = \tfrac{7\pi}{4} = 315^\circ \]

Part (a): flip the sign and pay a half turn

Why: Subtracting pi keeps the angle inside the required range; adding pi would overshoot it.

\[ \tfrac{7\pi}{4} - \pi = \tfrac{3\pi}{4} \;\Longrightarrow\; \left(-5, \tfrac{3\pi}{4}\right) \]

Part (b): keep the sign and subtract a whole turn

Why: That is the only way to reach an angle at or below zero without touching the first coordinate.

\[ \tfrac{7\pi}{4} - 2\pi = -\tfrac{\pi}{4} \;\Longrightarrow\; \left(5, -\tfrac{\pi}{4}\right) \]

Part (c): keep the sign and add a whole turn

Why: Eight quarters make a turn, so seven quarters become fifteen quarters.

\[ \tfrac{7\pi}{4} + 2\pi = \tfrac{15\pi}{4} \;\Longrightarrow\; \left(5, \tfrac{15\pi}{4}\right) \]

Figure (svg): Two polar grids. On the left, a counter-clockwise arc through seven quarters of pi and a clockwise arc through a quarter of pi both end on a ray in the fourth quadrant carrying a dot five units out. On the right, the same dot with a dashed ray at three quarters of pi and a backward arrow through the pole, plus a spiral marking an angle of fifteen quarters of pi.

One dot, three requested names. The constraint on each answer decides which turn to make, not where the point is.

Check each answer against its own condition

Why: The first has a negative first coordinate and an angle between zero and two pi; the second has a positive one and a negative angle; the third has a positive one and an angle above two pi. All three match the answer key.

\[ \tfrac{3\pi}{4} \approx 2.36 \in [0, 2\pi], \quad -\tfrac{\pi}{4} \le 0, \quad \tfrac{15\pi}{4} \approx 11.78 \ge 2\pi \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 930 — Exercise 2; answer on p. 932

This exercise is where the section actually lives: not plotting, but producing names to order. The three conditions are different, so the same point needs three different treatments.

Read the conditions before you start generating. Condition (a) wants a negative first coordinate, which forces a half turn, and you choose to subtract rather than add because subtracting keeps the angle inside the required window. Conditions (b) and (c) both keep the first coordinate positive, so they are whole-turn adjustments in opposite directions.

The final step checks each answer against its own condition rather than against the point, and that is deliberate. By that stage you already know all three name the right point, because whole turns and half-turn-with-flip never move it. The only remaining way to lose the marks is to break the stated range, so that is what you check.

41. Order the moves

Ranking

Put in order

Put the steps of a complete alternate-name answer into the order that never goes wrong.

  1. Plot the point from the given pair
  2. Read off the distance from the pole
  3. Read off the terminal side the point lies on
  4. Write the name with a positive first coordinate
  5. Shift by a half turn and flip the sign for the negative name
  6. Add whole turns until each name meets its stated range

Why: Plotting comes first because everything after it is read off the picture rather than manipulated from the symbols. The range conditions come last: they are satisfied by adding whole turns, which never moves the point, so imposing them early only makes the earlier steps harder.

Drag the steps into order before checking. Two of the orderings are genuinely debatable, and the reasoning matters more than the answer.

Plotting comes first because everything after it is read off a picture rather than manipulated from symbols, which is the whole defence against sign errors. Reading the distance and the terminal side comes next, because those two numbers are what every name is built from.

The range conditions come last, and this is the step people put too early. Satisfying a range means adding whole turns, and whole turns never move the point, so the adjustment is harmless at the end and a distraction at the beginning. Fix the sign first; slide the angle afterwards.

42. Exercise 15: a distance that is a square root

Worked example

The same three conditions, on a pair with both entries negative and an irrational distance.

\[ \left(-\sqrt{5}, -\tfrac{4\pi}{3}\right) \]

Find the terminal side the point is on

Why: The first coordinate is negative, so add a half turn to the given angle.

\[ -\tfrac{4\pi}{3} + \pi = -\tfrac{\pi}{3} \]

Record the distance

Why: The size of the first entry, a little over two.

\[ d = \sqrt{5} \approx 2.236 \]

Part (a): a negative first coordinate, angle between zero and two pi

Why: Keep the given first coordinate and add a whole turn to the given angle.

\[ -\tfrac{4\pi}{3} + 2\pi = \tfrac{2\pi}{3} \;\Longrightarrow\; \left(-\sqrt{5}, \tfrac{2\pi}{3}\right) \]

Part (b): a positive first coordinate, angle at most zero

Why: The terminal side itself is already negative.

\[ \left(\sqrt{5}, -\tfrac{\pi}{3}\right) \]

Part (c): a positive first coordinate, angle at least two pi

Why: Add two whole turns to that angle.

\[ -\tfrac{\pi}{3} + 4\pi = \tfrac{11\pi}{3} \;\Longrightarrow\; \left(\sqrt{5}, \tfrac{11\pi}{3}\right) \]

Figure (svg): A polar grid with three rings. A clockwise arc sweeps through four thirds of pi into the second quadrant, where the ray is dashed; a red arrow runs the opposite way from the pole, about two and a quarter units into the fourth quadrant, ending at a dot just past the second ring.

An irrational distance changes nothing about the procedure: the ring it lands between is the only thing that looks different.

Check the three against the point

Why: All three name a point about 2.24 units from the pole on the terminal side of minus sixty degrees, in the fourth quadrant, and all three match the printed answers.

\[ -\tfrac{\pi}{3} \equiv \tfrac{5\pi}{3} = 300^\circ, \quad \text{Quadrant IV} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 930 — Exercise 15; answer on p. 935

An irrational distance looks intimidating and changes nothing at all. The only visible difference is that the dot lands between two rings rather than on one.

Both entries are negative, so work in the usual order. The angle is a clockwise rotation of four thirds of pi, which is two hundred and forty degrees the wrong way round and lands in the second quadrant; the negative distance then sends the point to the opposite ray, minus a third of pi, in the fourth quadrant.

Watch how each of the three conditions is met by a different single move. Condition (a) keeps the given first coordinate and adds a whole turn to the given angle. Conditions (b) and (c) start from the terminal side instead, which is already negative, so (b) is free and (c) needs two whole turns. Choosing the smallest adjustment that satisfies the condition is how you keep the fractions manageable.

43. Which candidate meets the stated condition?

Elimination

\[ \text{A name for } \left(-4, \tfrac{5\pi}{4}\right) \text{ with } r < 0 \text{ and } 0 \le \theta \le 2\pi \]

Eliminate the wrong options

All four candidates name the right point. Only one meets the condition as stated. Which survives?

  • A. (−4, 5π/4)
  • B. (−4, 13π/4)
  • C. (4, π/4)
  • D. (4, 9π/4)

Survives elimination: A

Why: The given pair already satisfies the condition, which is what makes the exercise a trap: there is nothing to do. The textbook's answer key prints the pair whose angle is thirteen quarters of pi instead, a correct name for the point but one whose angle sits outside the range the question asked for.

Work through the four candidates before revealing. All four name the correct point, so the usual check is no help; the question is entirely about the stated condition.

The surviving candidate is the pair you were given. That is what makes the exercise a trap: it already has a negative first coordinate and an angle inside one turn, so there is nothing to do, and the instinct to change something anyway is what the other three options are built on.

The second option deserves a note, because it is the answer printed in the back of the textbook for this exercise. It names the right point, and its angle is a little over three turns, which is outside the range the question asks for. Use it as a reminder that an answer key is a useful check and not an authority: hold both the key and your own answer up against the stated condition.

44. Exercise 16: pi as a distance and as an angle

Worked example

The last exercise in the set uses the same symbol for both entries, which is a useful shock.

\[ (-\pi, -\pi) \]

Read the second entry as a rotation

Why: A half turn, taken clockwise, which lands on the ray pointing away from the polar axis.

\[ \theta = -\pi = -180^\circ \]

Read the first entry as a distance

Why: About 3.14 units, travelled backwards because it is negative.

\[ d = \left|-\pi\right| = \pi \approx 3.14 \]

Combine them

Why: Backwards along the ray at minus a half turn is forwards along the polar axis itself.

\[ -\pi + \pi = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{terminal side } 0 \]

Produce the three required names

Why: Add a whole turn for (a), then use the terminal side with a positive distance for (b) and (c).

\[ \text{(a) } (-\pi, \pi), \quad \text{(b) } (\pi, -2\pi), \quad \text{(c) } (\pi, 2\pi) \]

Figure (svg): A polar grid with four rings. A clockwise arc sweeps a half turn from the polar axis round to the negative horizontal direction, drawn dashed. A red arrow runs the opposite way, out along the polar axis, ending at a dot a little past the third ring, on the polar axis itself.

The same symbol does two unrelated jobs in one pair: a length of about 3.14, and a rotation of a half turn.

Check that all four pairs name one point

Why: Every one of them puts the point about 3.14 units from the pole on the polar axis: the two with a negative first coordinate face backwards along the horizontal, the two with a positive one face forwards, and all four angles are whole multiples of pi.

\[ (-\pi, -\pi) = (-\pi, \pi) = (\pi, -2\pi) = (\pi, 2\pi) = (\pi, 0) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 930 — Exercise 16; answer on p. 935

The same symbol appears twice in this pair and means two completely unrelated things: a rotation of a half turn, and a length of about three point one four. If that feels like a deliberate provocation by the authors, it is.

Take it in the usual order. The angle is a clockwise half turn, so the ray points away from the polar axis, to the left. The distance is negative, so the walk is backwards, straight back through the pole and out along the polar axis itself. The point ends up on the polar axis, a little over three units out.

The three required names then come almost for free, because the terminal side is zero and adding or subtracting whole turns to zero gives the tidiest numbers in the whole exercise set. The check is the important line: all four pairs describe a point on the polar axis at the same distance, which you can confirm by eye on the figure.

45. Break the claim

Counterexample

Discussion prompt

A classmate proposes a shortcut: two polar pairs name the same point exactly when they have the same first coordinate and coterminal angles. Give a counterexample, and then say what the shortcut is actually a correct statement about.

Write a counterexample before revealing. The proposed shortcut is not stupid; it is exactly half of the correct rule, and it is the half most people remember.

Any point with two names of opposite sign breaks it, and the cheapest one to write is the pair from earlier in the lesson with a positive first coordinate against its partner with the negative one. Their first coordinates differ and their angles are not coterminal, and yet they are one point.

The second half of the question is the more valuable one. A counterexample does more than refute a claim; it tells you what kind of rule could possibly be true. Here it tells you that coterminality alone can never be the whole story, because reversing the direction of travel is a genuinely second way to arrive at the same place, and any complete rule has to have a clause for it.

46. Finish the reduction to a positive first coordinate

Faded example

The pair below is to be given the name it would be reported with: first coordinate positive, angle between zero and a whole turn. Fill in the blanks.

Fill in the blanks

\left(-2, \tfrac25\right) = \left(___, \tfrac______ - \pi\right) = \left(___, \tfrac___\pi}___\right)

Why: Flipping the sign of the first coordinate costs an odd number of half turns, and here subtracting pi is the choice that lands inside the range; adding pi would give seventeen sixths of pi, which is above two pi. Eleven sixths minus six sixths is five sixths of pi, an angle of 150 degrees.

Fill both blanks before checking, and pay attention to why the half turn is subtracted rather than added.

Flipping the sign of the first coordinate requires an odd number of half turns, and both adding and subtracting one are legal. Adding gives seventeen sixths of pi, which is more than a full turn and so fails the range. Subtracting gives five sixths of pi, which is one hundred and fifty degrees and sits comfortably inside.

That choice, between adding and subtracting the half turn, is the small decision that separates a tidy answer from a correct answer that needs another line of work. Look at where the given angle sits in the turn before you decide: if it is in the second half, subtract.

47. Uniqueness, and what it costs

Section

Part 5

48. Restricting the range to force one answer

Concept

Infinitely many names make answers impossible to compare, so problems usually impose a restriction: the first coordinate at least zero, and the angle in a half-open interval one whole turn long.

\[ r \ge 0, \qquad 0 \le \theta < 2\pi \]

Figure (svg): A rectangle representing every standard address, with the angle running along the bottom from zero to two pi and the distance running up the side. The bottom edge, where the distance is zero, is drawn thick and red and labelled as a single point, the pole. The right-hand edge at two pi is dashed to show it is excluded.

Inside the shaded strip every point of the plane has exactly one address — except the red edge, where the whole edge collapses to the pole.

Inside that strip every point of the plane has exactly one address, with one exception, and the exception is drawn in red along the bottom edge.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 924 — the restriction problems impose when they want a single answer

Infinitely many names are a problem for anyone who has to mark your work, or compare two answers, or store a location in a computer. So problems usually impose a restriction, and the one on this slide is the standard choice.

The picture is not the plane; it is the set of allowed addresses. The horizontal direction is the angle, running across exactly one turn, and the vertical direction is the distance, running upward from zero. Every point of the plane corresponds to exactly one spot in that strip, which is what uniqueness means.

Except for the red edge. Along the bottom of the strip the distance is zero, and every one of those addresses names the pole, so the whole edge collapses to a single point. That is the exception you predicted several slides ago, drawn.

49. Reading the standard restriction

Notation

Annotate

On: \( r \ge 0 \quad\text{and}\quad 0 \le \theta < 2\pi \)

  • Kills one of the two families at a stroke: no name with a negative first coordinate survives, so the distance is an ordinary distance again.
  • The angle 0 is allowed and 2π is not. If both were allowed, every point on the polar axis would keep two names, which is exactly what the restriction is for.
  • The interval is one whole turn long, so it contains exactly one angle from each coterminal family. Any interval of that length would do; this one is the convention.
  • Every point except the pole gets exactly one name. The pole gets θ = 0 by convention, but nothing in the restriction forces that choice.

Two conditions, and each one kills a specific kind of duplication. The first kills a whole family at once: with the first coordinate required to be non-negative, no name with a negative distance survives, and the directed distance becomes an ordinary distance again.

The second condition handles the angle, and the half-open interval is doing careful work. One endpoint is included and the other is not, because the two endpoints are coterminal and admitting both would hand every point on the polar axis two names, which is exactly what the restriction is for.

Note the last annotation. The restriction works for every point except the pole, and for the pole a convention is simply adopted. It is worth knowing that this is a convention rather than a consequence, because it is the kind of detail that decides whether a piece of software has a bug.

50. Reducing an arbitrary name to standard form

Worked example

A name arrives with the wrong sign and an angle more than a turn too large. Reduce it.

\[ \text{Put } \left(-6, \tfrac{17\pi}{4}\right) \text{ in standard form.} \]

Flip the sign of the first coordinate and pay a half turn

Why: Add pi, which is four quarters.

\[ \left(-6, \tfrac{17\pi}{4}\right) = \left(6, \tfrac{17\pi}{4} + \tfrac{4\pi}{4}\right) = \left(6, \tfrac{21\pi}{4}\right) \]

Subtract a whole turn

Why: Two pi is eight quarters.

\[ \tfrac{21\pi}{4} - \tfrac{8\pi}{4} = \tfrac{13\pi}{4} \]

Subtract another whole turn

Why: Thirteen quarters is still above eight quarters.

\[ \tfrac{13\pi}{4} - \tfrac{8\pi}{4} = \tfrac{5\pi}{4} \]

State the standard name

Why: Six is at least zero and five quarters of pi is below two pi.

\[ \left(6, \tfrac{5\pi}{4}\right) \]

Check by quadrant

Why: Seventeen quarters of pi is two whole turns plus a quarter of pi, so the given angle points into the first quadrant; the negative first coordinate sends the point to the opposite quadrant, the third. Five quarters of pi is two hundred and twenty-five degrees, in the third quadrant, six units out.

\[ \tfrac{17\pi}{4} - 4\pi = \tfrac{\pi}{4}, \qquad \tfrac{\pi}{4} + \pi = \tfrac{5\pi}{4} = 225^\circ \]

This is the standard exam question of the section, and the order of operations is what makes it painless. Fix the sign first, then fix the angle.

Fixing the sign costs a half turn, which here pushes the angle above five full turns. That is fine; whole turns come off freely afterwards, and each subtraction is eight quarters. Two subtractions bring it into range, and you can see at each stage whether another is needed.

The check at the end is the one to imitate. Reduce the original angle by whole turns to see which quadrant it points into, then apply one half turn for the sign flip and see which quadrant that gives. If the quadrant of your final answer disagrees, a sign has gone astray somewhere in the middle.

51. The one point no restriction can fix

Edge cases

Discussion prompt

The restriction gives every point a unique name except one. Say which point, explain why no other restriction could fix it either, and say what is usually done in practice.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, p. 923 — all polar coordinates of the form (0, θ) represent the pole

Answer in writing before revealing. You met this question in the first part of the lesson; this is the moment to see that your answer there has a consequence here.

Uniqueness comes from two things being forced: the distance, by requiring it to be non-negative, and the angle, by confining it to one turn. At the pole the distance is zero and the angle is never forced at all, because rotation does nothing to a point that has not moved from the centre of the rotation.

That is a fact about the geometry, not about the interval you chose, so no other interval can repair it. In practice the pole is reported with an angle of zero, and any procedure that converts points into polar form has to check for the pole separately. You will see exactly that happen in the next lesson.

52. What a closed interval would cost

Prediction

\[ 0 \le \theta \le 2\pi \quad\text{instead of}\quad 0 \le \theta < 2\pi \]

Predict first

Suppose the angle were allowed to reach a whole turn as well as zero. What goes wrong?

  • Nothing; both intervals work equally well
  • Points on the polar axis get two names
  • Negative first coordinates become necessary again
  • The pole loses its name entirely

Correct: Points on the polar axis get two names

Why: Zero and a whole turn are coterminal, so a point on the polar axis would satisfy the restriction twice over, once with each. The half-open interval exists exactly to break that tie, and it is why the right-hand edge of the strip was drawn dashed.

Commit to an option before revealing. The change looks like pedantry, and the cost of it is small but real.

Zero and a whole turn are coterminal, so if both were allowed, every point on the polar axis would have two standard names instead of one. Uniqueness would fail on an entire ray rather than at a single point, which is far worse than the pole.

This is why the right-hand edge of the address strip was drawn dashed. Half-open intervals turn up all over mathematics for this same reason, and the reason is always the same: the two ends of a period represent the same thing, so exactly one of them must be admitted.

53. Rectangular against polar

Comparison

Comparison matrix

RectangularPolar
reference objectstwo perpendicular number linesa pole and a polar axis
what the entries aretwo directed lengthsa directed length and a rotation
names per pointexactly oneinfinitely many
same-point testboth entries agreecoterminal, or opposite r and an odd number of half turns
the awkward pointnonethe pole

The two systems agree on how many numbers a point needs and disagree on nearly everything else. The disagreement in the third row is what almost every question in this section is really testing.

Fill the blanks from memory before checking, and take particular care over the third and fourth rows, which are the ones the section is actually about.

The two systems agree on the count of numbers and on almost nothing else. The row that matters is the same-point test. In rectangular coordinates it is as simple as a test can be: both entries agree, and that is that. In polar coordinates it takes two clauses and a parity argument.

The last row is worth a moment too. Rectangular coordinates have no awkward point at all; the origin behaves exactly like every other point. The pole does not, and it is the only place where polar coordinates are genuinely, irreparably ambiguous.

54. When you should not restrict

Intuition

The restriction is a convention for reporting a location, not a rule about the plane. As soon as something moves, the restriction gets in the way.

A point travelling round the pole passes through angles beyond one turn, and a curve traced by such a point is described far more naturally by letting the angle run on. Some curves are described more naturally still by letting the first coordinate go negative for part of the trip, which is how a single formula can produce petals on opposite sides of the pole.

So the rule of thumb is: restrict when you are reporting where something is, and do not restrict when you are describing how something moves. The next sections of the chapter, on graphs of polar equations, live entirely on the unrestricted side.

Having spent several slides imposing uniqueness, it is worth saying clearly that the restriction is a reporting convention and nothing more. Nobody is obliged to use it, and for a large part of this chapter nobody does.

The reason is motion. A point travelling round the pole passes through angles beyond a single turn, and cutting the angle off at one turn would cut the journey short. Some curves are described most simply by letting the distance go negative for part of the trip, which is how one short formula can produce petals on opposite sides of the pole.

So the rule of thumb is: restrict when you are reporting where something is, and do not restrict when you are describing how something moves. The sections on graphs of polar equations, which come next in the chapter, live entirely on the unrestricted side of that line.

55. A radar screen is a polar plane

Real world

Figure (svg): A radar screen drawn as a polar grid with range rings labelled five, ten, fifteen and twenty miles and compass letters at the four edges. A bright wedge trails behind the sweep line, which points up and to the right, and three contacts are marked as dots with their ranges beside them.

The rings are the first coordinate and the sweep is the second. The machine measures a polar pair directly; a rectangular pair would have to be computed from it.

Discussion prompt

A radar reports a contact as a range and a bearing, which is a polar pair. On three consecutive sweeps the tracking software receives bearings of 40, 400 and 760 degrees at the same range. Explain, using this lesson, why that is one contact and not three, and say what the software must do before comparing two reports.

This is not an analogy. A radar genuinely measures a distance and a bearing, and the rings and the sweep line printed on the screen are a polar grid. Converting to a rectangular pair would be extra work that nobody has any reason to do.

The question is about what happens when the bearing keeps accumulating instead of resetting. Three reports at bearings differing by whole turns are three names for the same direction, so with equal ranges they are three names for one contact. The first clause of the equivalence property says so exactly.

The practical consequence is the one worth carrying away. Before any two polar reports can be compared, each has to be reduced to a standard form, with the angle brought into one fixed turn and the range made non-negative. Comparing the raw pairs entry by entry would invent a new contact on every sweep, which is precisely the bug the restriction exists to prevent.

56. Putting it together

Section

Part 6

57. Pattern: any question about a polar point

Pattern

Figure (svg): A flow diagram. A first box says read the pair as distance and rotation. An arrow leads to a box that asks whether the angle is negative, branching to turn clockwise or counter-clockwise. Both branches meet a box that asks the sign of the first coordinate, branching to walk forwards or backwards through the pole, and both of those lead to the final box: the point, and the terminal side it lies on.

Two questions, asked in this order, plot any polar pair. Every other question in the section is about naming the dot once it is there.
  1. Plot first. Turn to the terminal side, clockwise if the angle is negative; then walk, backwards through the pole if the first coordinate is negative.
  2. Record two numbers from the picture: the distance from the pole, and the terminal side the point is on.
  3. For another name, add a whole turn and keep the sign, or add a half turn and flip the sign.
  4. For a range condition, satisfy the sign first, then add whole turns until the angle is where it must be.
  5. Never add a half turn without flipping the sign, and never flip the sign without moving the angle.

Everything in this lesson collapses into two questions asked in order, and the diagram asks them: what is the sign of the angle, and what is the sign of the distance. The first decides which way to turn, the second decides which way to walk.

Once the dot is on the page, the naming half of the lesson is bookkeeping. Add whole turns and keep the sign, or add a half turn and flip the sign; those are the only two legal moves, and every alternate name is a combination of them.

The last line is the one most often broken under pressure. A half turn and a sign flip travel together, always. If you find yourself doing one of them alone, stop and name the quadrant before and after, because the point has just moved.

58. Check: where a negative first coordinate lands

Check

Check your understanding

In which quadrant does the point (−4, 2π/3) lie?

  • A. Quadrant I
  • B. Quadrant II
  • C. Quadrant III
  • D. Quadrant IV (correct)

Answer: D

Why: Two thirds of pi is 120°, whose terminal side is in Quadrant II. The negative first coordinate sends the point a half turn round, to the terminal side of 120° + 180° = 300°, which is in Quadrant IV.

Why A tempts people
This would be the answer if the angle were reflected rather than shifted by a half turn; reflection is what negating the ANGLE does.
Why B tempts people
Quadrant II is where the angle points. The point is on the opposite ray, because the first coordinate is negative.
Why C tempts people
Quadrant III would need a terminal side between 180° and 270°; 300° is past that.

The angle and the answer are in different quadrants, which is the whole content of the question. Two thirds of pi points into the second quadrant, and the negative first coordinate sends the point to the opposite ray.

Opposite means a half turn, not a reflection. One hundred and twenty degrees plus a half turn is three hundred degrees, which is in the fourth quadrant. If you answered with the first quadrant, you reflected instead of shifting, which is the error the whole second part of this lesson was about.

59. Check: which pair names the same point

Check

Check your understanding

Which pair names the same point as (5, π/6)?

  • A. (−5, π/6)
  • B. (−5, 7π/6) (correct)
  • C. (5, 7π/6)
  • D. (−5, −π/6)

Answer: B

Why: The first coordinate flips sign, which is an odd number of half turns, and the angle moves by exactly π. That is clause two of the equivalence property, so the pairs agree.

Why A tempts people
The sign flipped but the angle did not move, an even count, so this is the point a half turn away.
Why C tempts people
The angle moved by a half turn but the sign did not flip, so this too is the diametrically opposite point.
Why D tempts people
The sign flipped and the angle moved by −π/3, which is neither a whole turn nor a half turn, so this pair is somewhere else on the ring.

Test each option against the two clauses rather than plotting. Ask whether the first coordinate is the same or the opposite, then count the half turns between the angles.

The correct option flips the sign and moves the angle by exactly one half turn: opposite first coordinate, odd count, clause two satisfied. Two of the wrong options do exactly one of those two things, which puts them at the diametrically opposite point, and the third moves the angle by an amount that is neither a whole turn nor a half turn.

60. Check: the standard name

Check

Check your understanding

What is the standard name of (−3, 5π/3), with the first coordinate at least 0 and the angle in a half-open turn from 0?

  • A. (3, 2π/3) (correct)
  • B. (3, 5π/3)
  • C. (3, π/3)
  • D. (3, 8π/3)

Answer: A

Why: Flipping the sign costs a half turn: 5π/3 + π = 8π/3, which is above 2π, so subtract a whole turn to get 2π/3. The point is 3 units out at 120°, in Quadrant II.

Why B tempts people
The minus sign was simply deleted. A sign flip always has to be paid for with a half turn.
Why C tempts people
This is what subtracting 2π from 5π/3 twice would give; the sign flip was never paid for at all.
Why D tempts people
The half turn was added correctly but the angle was never brought back inside one turn: 8π/3 is larger than 2π.

Two operations are needed here and the order is free, but the arithmetic is easier if you flip the sign first and then bring the angle back into range.

Flipping the sign costs a half turn, which pushes the angle past a full turn, so one whole turn comes back off. The result is two thirds of pi, one hundred and twenty degrees, in the second quadrant, three units out.

The most tempting wrong option simply deletes the minus sign from the first coordinate. It is worth naming that temptation, because the deleted sign leaves no trace in the answer: the pair still looks perfectly reasonable, and only the quadrant gives it away.

61. Say why the pole is the difficult point

Explain it to yourself

Discussion prompt

In two or three sentences, explain to someone who has just met polar coordinates why every point except the pole can be given exactly one name, and why the pole cannot. Use the words distance and rotation.

Write your two or three sentences before revealing. Being able to say this cleanly is a good test of whether the lesson has landed, because it requires you to say what makes a name unique in the first place.

The argument has two halves. For any other point, both entries are forced: the distance is the one positive number that measures how far out it is, and the rotation is the one angle within a turn that reaches its ray. For the pole, the distance is forced to be zero and the rotation is forced by nothing, because rotating about a point you are standing on leaves you where you are.

If your sentences mention a convention, that is a bonus. The pole is usually reported with an angle of zero, and that choice is made by agreement rather than by the geometry, which is a distinction worth being able to make.

62. Exit ticket

Exit ticket

\[ Q\left(-6, -\tfrac{5\pi}{3}\right) \]

Discussion prompt

Name the quadrant this point is in, give its standard name, and give one further name with a negative first coordinate and an angle above a whole turn.

This puts the whole lesson into one problem: read a pair with two negative entries, name the quadrant, produce the standard name, and then produce a name to a specified pattern.

Take the entries in order. The angle is a clockwise rotation of five thirds of pi, which reaches the terminal side of a third of pi in the first quadrant; the negative first coordinate then sends the point a half turn away, into the third quadrant. Six units out at two hundred and forty degrees is the standard name.

For the last part, notice that you do not have to replot anything. Adding whole turns to the given pair never moves the point, so two whole turns added to the given angle, with the given negative first coordinate kept, satisfies the condition immediately. Recognising when no work is needed is as much a skill as doing the work.

63. Recap

Recap

if the question saysyour first move is
plot this polar pairturn to the terminal side, then walk, backwards if the first coordinate is negative
the first coordinate is negativeadd π to the angle and take the size of the coordinate
give another nameadd a whole turn, or flip the sign and add a half turn
do these name the same point?test both clauses of the equivalence property
report it in standard formfix the sign first, then add whole turns into the range

\[ (r, \theta) = (r', \theta') \iff \begin{cases} r' = r \text{ and } \theta' = \theta + 2\pi k \\ r' = -r \text{ and } \theta' = \theta + (2k+1)\pi \end{cases} \]

So far the two coordinate systems have been described side by side without being connected. The next lesson supplies the theorem that moves a point, and then an equation, freely between them.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates §11.4, pp. 919-924 — everything on these slides traces back here

OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §10.3 Polar Coordinates §10.3 — the same material, more briefly, in OpenStax

Two rules for plotting and one rule for naming. Turn clockwise when the angle is negative; walk backwards through the pole when the distance is negative; and remember that a backwards walk lands you on the terminal side of the angle plus a half turn.

The naming rule is the one to carry forward. Two pairs name the same point exactly when their first coordinates agree and their angles are a whole number of turns apart, or when their first coordinates are opposite and their angles are an odd number of half turns apart. Everything in the section, including every alternate-name exercise, is that one statement applied.

So far the two coordinate systems have sat side by side without being connected: you can plot in either, and you can name a point in either, but nothing yet turns one pair into the other. The next lesson supplies exactly that, and the first thing it will need is the fact you have just spent an hour on, that a point has many polar names and only one of them will drop out of a calculation.

Sources

  1. Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.4 Polar Coordinates — Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Version 3 Corrected Edition, July 4 2013, pp. 919-924
  2. OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §10.3 Polar Coordinates

Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Trigonometry — $55/session, free consultation.

Book on Wyzant · Text (657) 465-8108