The first tool for a triangle with no right angle. Covers the Law of Sines and its proof by dropping an altitude, the two configurations it handles unambiguously, and the Angle-Side-Side case where the same data may describe no triangle, exactly one, or two genuinely different ones — decided by comparing the given opposite side against the altitude c sine alpha. Closes with the area formula in terms of two sides and their included angle.
Subject: Trigonometry · 69 slides · symbolic lesson
Open the interactive version of this deck
Title
Trigonometry · Section 11.2
Measuring a triangle that has no right angle in it
Objectives
Chapter 10 solved right triangles. Every technique there leaned on the right angle: the Pythagorean Theorem needs it, and so does every ratio in the definition of sine, cosine and tangent. This lesson is the first tool that works without one.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, pp. 896-904 — learning goals for the section
Everything you did with triangles in Chapter 10 depended on a right angle being present. The Pythagorean Theorem needs one. So does every single ratio in the definitions of sine, cosine and tangent, because the words opposite, adjacent and hypotenuse have no meaning in a triangle without a right angle. The moment a problem hands you a triangle with three slanted sides, that whole toolkit goes quiet.
This section fixes that with one construction: drop a perpendicular from a vertex to the side across from it. That perpendicular is a leg of two right triangles at once, and writing its length twice produces a relationship between an angle and the side facing it. That relationship, the Law of Sines, is the first thing in this course that works on any triangle at all.
The last three objectives are where the real interest lies. One pattern of given data does not determine a triangle, and the same three numbers can describe two different triangles, or none. Learning to spot that before you start computing is the skill this section is really about.
Warm-up
A triangle has an angle of 40 degrees with the side across from it measuring 5, and a second angle of 60 degrees.
Discussion prompt
Try to find the side opposite the 60 degree angle using only Chapter 10 tools. Write down where you get stuck, in one sentence.
Write something down before reading on. It does not need to be a full attempt, just an honest note of where you run out of road.
What you should find is that there is nowhere to start. You can label the 40 degree angle, and you can label the side of length 5 across from it, but the words opposite and adjacent do not apply until there is a right angle to measure them against. Nothing you know yet converts an angle into a length here.
The way out is to build a right angle yourself. Drop a perpendicular from one vertex onto the opposite side and suddenly there are two right triangles, each of which obeys everything you learned in Chapter 10. That construction is the engine of this whole section, and the rest of Part 1 is just working out what it gives you.
Section
Part 1
Worked example
A right triangle has a hypotenuse of 7 units and one leg of 4 units. Find the third side and both acute angles, to the nearest hundredth of a degree.
Figure (svg): A right triangle drawn to scale with the right angle at the lower right, a horizontal leg of length the square root of 33, a vertical leg of length 4, and a hypotenuse of length 7 from the lower left to the top right.
Name the parts the book's way
Why: The right angle sits opposite the hypotenuse, so the hypotenuse is c; call the given leg b and the unknown leg a.
\[ b = 4, \quad c = 7, \quad a = \;? \]
Apply the Pythagorean Theorem
Why: The two legs and the hypotenuse.
\[ a^2 + 4^2 = 7^2 \]
Solve for the missing leg
Why: Subtract and take the positive root.
\[ a^2 = 49 - 16 = 33, \quad a = \sqrt{33} \]
Relate the two GIVEN lengths to alpha
Why: Side b is adjacent to alpha and c is the hypotenuse, so cosine is the ratio that uses only given data.
\[ \cos(\alpha) = \frac{4}{7} \;\Longrightarrow\; \alpha = \arccos\!\left(\frac47\right) \approx 55.15^\circ \]
Relate the same two lengths to beta
Why: From the other corner side b is opposite, so the same two numbers give a sine.
\[ \sin(\beta) = \frac{4}{7} \;\Longrightarrow\; \beta = \arcsin\!\left(\frac47\right) \approx 34.85^\circ \]
Check that the angles close the triangle
Why: The two acute angles of a right triangle must be complementary, and these add to exactly 90 degrees.
\[ 55.15^\circ + 34.85^\circ = 90^\circ \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 896 — Example 11.2.1
Start with what you can already do, so that the contrast with the rest of the lesson is sharp. There is nothing new in this solution, but two habits in it are worth copying for the next hundred problems.
The first habit is the labelling. A lower-case Greek letter names an angle, and the matching English letter names the side across from it. That convention is what makes the Law of Sines readable, so it is worth adopting now rather than when the notation gets heavier.
The second habit is subtler. After finding the missing leg, you could get the angle at the left corner several ways: from the two legs with a tangent, from the leg and the hypotenuse with a cosine. The book deliberately chooses the two lengths that were given in the problem, 4 and 7, rather than the square root of 33 that was just computed. The computed value is only as good as its rounding; the given values are exact. Feed rounded numbers into later steps and the error grows at every stage.
Notice the check at the end. Two acute angles of a right triangle must add to 90 degrees, and they do. A check that costs one addition is a check worth doing every time.
Concept
Figure (svg): A scalene triangle with vertices A at the lower left, B at the top and C at the lower right. The angle at A and the side opposite it are drawn in one colour, the angle at B and its opposite side in a second colour, and the angle at C and its opposite side in a third.
angle-side opposite pair — An angle of a triangle together with the side across from it. Lower-case Greek names the angle, the matching lower-case English letter names the side.
\[ (\alpha, a), \qquad (\beta, b), \qquad (\gamma, c) \]
Two habits from the book travel with this notation. Work from the data you were given rather than from a value you computed, so that a rounding error is never fed into the next line. And work in degrees for now, because the surveying and navigation problems that need these theorems are stated in degrees.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, pp. 896-897 — the labelling convention
Take a moment with the picture, because everything after this depends on reading it fluently. Each angle is drawn in the same colour as the side it faces, and the side it faces is always the one it does not touch. The angle at the left corner touches two sides and faces the third; that third side is its partner.
The phrase angle-side opposite pair will appear in every theorem in this section, and the reason is simple. The Law of Sines relates such pairs to each other, and it says nothing whatever about an angle and a side that touch. Almost every setup error you can make here comes from pairing an angle with a side that touches it.
The two working habits mentioned on the slide are worth internalising. Prefer given data to computed data, so rounding never compounds. And work in degrees for now, because the problems these theorems exist for, surveying, navigation, road building, are stated in degrees. Radians will return in the next chapter.
Concept
Figure (svg): An acute triangle A B C with A at the lower left, B at the top and C at the lower right. A dashed perpendicular drops from B to the point Q on side A C, splitting the triangle into two right triangles, and is labelled h.
Drop a perpendicular from the top vertex to the side across from it. It is a leg of the left right triangle and a leg of the right one at the same time, so its length can be written twice, using a different angle each time.
\[ \sin(\alpha) = \frac{h}{c} \quad\text{and}\quad \sin(\gamma) = \frac{h}{a} \]
Two names for one length, so the two names are equal. That equation, rearranged, is the Law of Sines.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 897 — the acute case of the proof
This is the picture the whole section rests on, so do not move past it quickly. The dashed segment drops from the top vertex straight down to the base, meeting it at a right angle, and in doing so it cuts the original triangle into two right triangles.
Now look at what the dashed segment is in each of them. In the left triangle it is the side opposite the angle at A, and the side c is the hypotenuse, so the sine of that angle is the dashed length divided by c. In the right triangle the same dashed segment is opposite the angle at C, with a as the hypotenuse.
The crucial point is that there is only one dashed segment. Two different expressions describe one length, so they are equal to each other, and that single equation is the Law of Sines waiting to be tidied up. If you can rebuild this picture from memory you never have to memorise the theorem at all.
Worked example
Prove the first equal ratio for a triangle whose angles are all acute.
\[ \text{To prove: } \frac{\sin(\alpha)}{a} = \frac{\sin(\gamma)}{c} \]
Drop the altitude from B
Why: It meets side AC at a point Q inside the segment, because both base angles are acute.
\[ h = BQ, \quad BQ \perp AC \]
Read the sine at A
Why: In triangle ABQ the side h is opposite alpha and c is the hypotenuse.
\[ \sin(\alpha) = \frac{h}{c} \;\Longrightarrow\; h = c\sin(\alpha) \]
Read the sine at C
Why: In triangle BCQ the same h is opposite gamma and a is the hypotenuse.
\[ \sin(\gamma) = \frac{h}{a} \;\Longrightarrow\; h = a\sin(\gamma) \]
Equate the two expressions
Why: Both equal the one length h.
\[ c\sin(\alpha) = a\sin(\gamma) \]
Divide both sides by the product ac
Why: Neither side length is zero, so the division is legal.
\[ \frac{\sin(\alpha)}{a} = \frac{\sin(\gamma)}{c} \]
Check on a triangle you already know
Why: In a thirty-sixty-ninety triangle with hypotenuse 2, the side opposite 30 degrees is 1 and the side opposite 90 degrees is 2; both ratios come out at one half.
\[ \frac{\sin 30^\circ}{1} = 0.5 = \frac{\sin 90^\circ}{2} \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 897 — proof of Theorem 11.2, first case
Follow the five lines and notice how little machinery is involved. Nothing here is beyond Chapter 10 except the idea of doing it twice and equating the results.
The one step worth pausing on is the division at the end. You have the product of c and the sine of alpha equal to the product of a and the sine of gamma. Dividing both sides by the product of a and c is what moves each side length underneath its own sine, and that is what produces the familiar shape of the theorem. Try the division the other way, by the product of the sines, and you get the reciprocal form, which is equally true and often more convenient.
The check is deliberately one you can verify in your head. In a thirty-sixty-ninety triangle with hypotenuse 2, the side facing 30 degrees is 1 and the side facing the right angle is 2. Both ratios come out at one half. Whenever you are unsure whether you have the law the right way up, test it on that triangle; it takes ten seconds and it has never once let anyone down.
Concept
Figure (svg): The same acute triangle, now with a dashed perpendicular from A meeting side B C at a point Q prime, labelled h prime, creating two new right triangles at B and at C.
The first altitude only ever mentions the two angles at its base. To reach the third ratio, drop a perpendicular from a different vertex and repeat the argument on the two right triangles it makes.
\[ h' = c\sin(\beta) = b\sin(\gamma) \;\Longrightarrow\; \frac{\sin(\beta)}{b} = \frac{\sin(\gamma)}{c} \]
Chain the two results through the ratio they share and all three are equal. That is the whole theorem for an acute triangle.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 897 — the second altitude
The first altitude only ever mentions the two angles at the base it lands on, which is why it produced just one of the three equalities. To reach the third you have to start again from a different corner.
In the picture the perpendicular now comes from the left vertex and lands on the side facing it. Exactly the same argument runs: the new dashed length is opposite the angle at B in one right triangle and opposite the angle at C in the other, so it can be written two ways and the two ways are equal.
Chain the two results together through the ratio they have in common and all three are equal. That completes the theorem for any triangle whose angles are all acute. What is left is the awkward case where one angle is obtuse and the altitude escapes the triangle, which is the next slide.
Worked example
One angle is now obtuse, and the altitude from the far vertex lands outside the triangle. Show the proof survives.
Figure (svg): A triangle with an obtuse angle at A. Vertex B lies up and to the left of A, and C lies to the right of A on a horizontal line. The altitude from B, drawn dashed, meets the extension of side A C at a point Q to the LEFT of A, outside the triangle, and the acute angle at A between that extension and side A B is marked as alpha prime.
Locate the foot of the altitude
Why: With the angle at A obtuse, the perpendicular from B meets the LINE through A and C on the far side of A, at a point Q outside the segment.
\[ \alpha > 90^\circ \;\Longrightarrow\; Q \text{ lies outside } \overline{AC} \]
Name the angle that is actually in the right triangle
Why: Triangle ABQ contains not alpha but the angle beside it along a straight line.
\[ \alpha' = 180^\circ - \alpha \]
Write the altitude from that right triangle
Why: The side h prime is opposite alpha prime, and c is the hypotenuse.
\[ h' = c\sin(\alpha') \]
Use the supplement identity
Why: Sine takes the same value at an angle and at its supplement, so the primed angle can be swapped out.
\[ \sin(180^\circ - \alpha) = \sin(\alpha) \;\Longrightarrow\; h' = c\sin(\alpha) \]
Read the other right triangle and equate
Why: Triangle BCQ gives the same h prime in terms of gamma, and the rest of the argument is unchanged.
\[ h' = a\sin(\gamma) = c\sin(\alpha) \;\Longrightarrow\; \frac{\sin(\alpha)}{a} = \frac{\sin(\gamma)}{c} \]
Check the identity that did the work
Why: At 150 degrees and at 30 degrees the sine is one half in both cases, exactly as the proof needed. Remember this fact: in the third part of the lesson it stops being a convenience and becomes a genuine ambiguity.
\[ \sin(150^\circ) = \tfrac12 = \sin(30^\circ) \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, pp. 897-898 — proof of Theorem 11.2, second case
Look at where the dashed line lands. With the angle at A wider than a right angle, the perpendicular from B misses the segment entirely and meets the extension of the base on the far side of A. The right triangle it forms therefore sits outside the original triangle, and the angle it contains at A is not alpha.
It is the angle beside alpha along a straight line, so the two of them total 180 degrees. One identity from Chapter 10 rescues the whole argument: the sine of an angle and the sine of its supplement are the same number. So the expression for the altitude comes out identical, and everything downstream is unchanged.
Store that identity somewhere prominent. Here it is a convenience, quietly patching a hole in a proof. In Part 3 exactly the same fact stops being a convenience and becomes a genuine fork in the road, because when you run the law backwards from a sine to an angle, you cannot tell which of the two angles you are looking at. The ambiguous case is this identity, seen from the other side.
Notation
Annotate
On: \( \frac{\sin(\alpha)}{a} = \frac{\sin(\beta)}{b} = \frac{\sin(\gamma)}{c} \)
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 897 — Theorem 11.2
Work through the annotations one at a time rather than reading the formula as a block. The first is the one that costs marks: every fraction pairs an angle with the side facing it. If you find yourself writing a side underneath the sine of an angle that touches it, stop and redraw.
The third annotation is a practical time-saver. Flipping every fraction gives sides on top and sines underneath, which is just as true. Use the sines-on-top version when you are chasing an angle and the sides-on-top version when you are chasing a side, and in each case the unknown ends up isolated after one multiplication instead of two.
The last annotation tells you when the theorem is usable at all. Any one equation in the chain names four quantities, two angles and two sides, and you can only solve for one unknown. So three of the four must already be known, which means a complete pair plus one extra. That single requirement is what the next two slides are about.
Picture it
Figure (svg): Five small copies of the same triangle. In the top row the given parts are highlighted for the Angle-Angle-Side, Angle-Side-Angle and Angle-Side-Side cases, each marked as having a complete pair. In the bottom row the Side-Angle-Side and Side-Side-Side cases are highlighted and marked as having no complete angle-side opposite pair.
Highlight the parts you were handed and look for an angle joined to the side across from it. Three of the five standard data sets contain one; two do not, and no amount of algebra will rescue them.
The bottom two cases are exactly what the Law of Cosines in the next section is built for. Recognising which case you are in, before writing anything, is half the work of solving a triangle.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 901 — the naming of the cases
Before any calculation, look at your given data and find the highlighted parts in one of these five pictures. Three of them contain an angle joined by colour to the side facing it; two do not.
The three workable ones are named after the order the parts appear around the triangle. Angle-Angle-Side means two angles and a side that touches only one of them. Angle-Side-Angle means two angles and the side running between them. Angle-Side-Side means one angle, the side facing it, and one more side. Those names come straight from the congruence conditions you met in geometry, with one important difference that Part 3 will make a great deal of.
The bottom two contain no opposite pair and never will, because there is only one angle in the data and the angle sum cannot manufacture another. Those are exactly the cases the Law of Cosines is built for in the next section. Recognising which of the five you are in, before writing anything down, is genuinely half the work.
Sorting
Sort into buckets
For each set of given data, decide whether the Law of Sines can be applied straight away.
Sort these before checking, and do it by eye rather than by calculation. For each row, ask one question: is there an angle here together with the side across from it, or can the angle sum produce one?
Three rows hand you a pair directly. Two more give you two angles and some side; there the third angle comes free from the angle sum, and once all three angles are known every side has a partner, so the law can start. That is why two angles and any side at all is always workable.
The two that fail are the three-sides row and the two-sides-with-the-angle-between-them row. In both, only one angle is ever known, or none, so the angle sum cannot rescue you. Notice that the failure is not about difficulty; it is that the equation you would want to write has two unknowns in it. That is a structural obstacle, and it needs a different theorem, not more effort.
Prediction
Figure (svg): A triangle to scale with a side of length 6 and a side of length 3 meeting at a 40 degree angle. The angle facing the side of length 6 is obtuse, about 112 degrees, and the angle facing the side of length 3 is small, about 28 degrees.
Predict first
In a triangle, side a is longer than side b. What follows about the angles across from them?
Correct: Alpha is larger than beta
Why: The equal ratios say that the sine of alpha over a equals the sine of beta over b. If a is the larger side, the sine of alpha must be the larger sine. In a triangle the largest angle faces the largest side, so a longer side always faces a wider angle. In the picture the side of length 6 faces an angle of about 112 degrees while the side of length 3 faces about 28 degrees.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 900 — the size comparison used in the two-triangle argument
Commit to one of the four options before revealing. This fact will do real work in Part 3, where it is the test that decides whether a second triangle survives.
The reasoning is short. The law says the sine of alpha divided by a equals the sine of beta divided by b. If a is the bigger denominator and the two fractions are equal, then the sine of alpha must be the bigger numerator. Turning a bigger sine into a bigger angle takes one more observation, that the biggest angle in a triangle always faces the biggest side, which you can see in the picture: the side of length 6 faces an opening of about 112 degrees while the side of length 3 faces about 28.
Use this constantly as a sanity check. After solving any triangle, list the three angles in order and the three sides in order. If the two orders do not match, something is paired wrongly and you can find it in seconds.
Section
Part 2
Concept
Give me two angles and the third is forced, because the three must total a straight angle. Three known angles fix the triangle's shape completely, leaving only its scale undecided.
\[ \gamma = 180^\circ - \alpha - \beta \]
One length then fixes the scale, and the Law of Sines converts that one length into the other two. Whether the given side sits between the two given angles or off to one side changes nothing about the count: there is exactly one triangle either way.
| case | what is given | how many triangles |
|---|---|---|
| AAS | two angles and a side touching only one of them | exactly one |
| ASA | two angles and the side joining them | exactly one |
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 901 — the remarks after Example 11.2.2
There is a clean way to see why these two cases can never surprise you. Two angles determine the third, and three angles determine the shape of a triangle completely. What they do not determine is how big to draw it, since scaling a triangle up leaves every angle untouched.
One length settles the scale, and after that everything is forced. It makes no difference whether the given side sits between the two given angles or off to one side: either way the shape is known and the size is known, so exactly one triangle exists. That is the content of the two rows in the table.
This is worth stating plainly because it is the contrast that makes Part 3 make sense. Nothing goes wrong in these cases, and nothing can. When you meet data that gives two answers, the reason will be that the shape was never pinned down in the first place.
Worked example
Solve the triangle with alpha equal to 120 degrees, a equal to 7 units, and beta equal to 45 degrees.
\[ \alpha = 120^\circ, \quad a = 7, \quad \beta = 45^\circ \]
Spot the complete pair
Why: Alpha and a are an angle-side opposite pair, so the law can start; beta has a partner waiting to be found.
\[ (\alpha, a) = (120^\circ, 7) \quad\text{known} \]
Set up the ratio for b
Why: Put the sides on top, because b is what is wanted.
\[ \frac{b}{\sin(45^\circ)} = \frac{7}{\sin(120^\circ)} \]
Solve for b
Why: Multiply both sides by the sine of 45 degrees.
\[ b = \frac{7\sin(45^\circ)}{\sin(120^\circ)} = \frac{7\sqrt6}{3} \approx 5.72 \]
Find the third angle from the angle sum
Why: This is the only value that must be derived rather than given.
\[ \gamma = 180^\circ - 120^\circ - 45^\circ = 15^\circ \]
Solve for c using the GIVEN pair
Why: Gamma is a derived value, so pair it with the original alpha and a rather than with the computed b, to keep rounding error out.
\[ c = \frac{7\sin(15^\circ)}{\sin(120^\circ)} \approx 2.09 \]
Figure (svg): A wide flat triangle drawn to scale with its longest side, of length 7, horizontal along the bottom. The angle at the left end is 45 degrees, the apex above carries the obtuse angle of 120 degrees, and the angle at the right end is 15 degrees.
Check with the size ordering
Why: The angles run 15, 45, 120 degrees and the sides opposite them run 2.09, 5.72, 7. The orders match exactly, as they must.
\[ 15^\circ < 45^\circ < 120^\circ \quad\text{and}\quad 2.09 < 5.72 < 7 \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 898 — Example 11.2.2 number 1
This is the model solution for the whole of Part 2, so read it once for the moves and once for the ordering of them.
The first move is to notice that a pair is already present: the 120 degree angle and the side of 7 facing it. Everything else is one ratio away from that pair. The second is to find the third angle from the angle sum, which is free.
The third move is the one that separates a careful solution from a lucky one. To find the last side you need the 15 degree angle, which you derived rather than were given. You cannot avoid that. But you can choose which pair to run it against, and pairing it with the original 120 degrees and 7 keeps every other number exact. Pairing it with the rounded 5.72 you just computed would fold that rounding into the answer for no reason.
The check at the end is the size ordering. Angles of 15, 45 and 120 degrees face sides of 2.09, 5.72 and 7. Both lists rise together, which is what has to happen.
Worked example
Solve the triangle with alpha equal to 85 degrees, beta equal to 30 degrees, and c equal to 5.25 units.
\[ \alpha = 85^\circ, \quad \beta = 30^\circ, \quad c = 5.25 \]
Notice there is no complete pair yet
Why: Neither given angle faces the given side, so the law cannot start until a pair is manufactured.
\[ (\alpha, a)? \;\text{no} \qquad (\beta, b)? \;\text{no} \]
Manufacture the pair from the angle sum
Why: Gamma is the angle facing the one side you know.
\[ \gamma = 180^\circ - 85^\circ - 30^\circ = 65^\circ \]
Solve for a against that new pair
Why: Now gamma and c are a complete pair; every other side is one ratio away.
\[ \frac{a}{\sin(85^\circ)} = \frac{5.25}{\sin(65^\circ)} \;\Longrightarrow\; a = \frac{5.25\sin(85^\circ)}{\sin(65^\circ)} \approx 5.77 \]
Solve for b against the same pair
Why: Reuse the pair with gamma and c, not the a you just computed.
\[ b = \frac{5.25\sin(30^\circ)}{\sin(65^\circ)} \approx 2.90 \]
Figure (svg): A triangle drawn to scale with its longest side, about 5.77, horizontal along the bottom. The angle at the left end is 30 degrees, the angle at the right end is 65 degrees, and the apex carries 85 degrees; the side between the 30 degree and 85 degree corners is the given length 5.25.
Check every ratio against every other
Why: All three sine-over-side ratios should agree to rounding; they come out at 0.1725, 0.1724 and 0.1726.
\[ \frac{\sin 85^\circ}{5.77} \approx 0.1726, \quad \frac{\sin 30^\circ}{2.90} \approx 0.1724, \quad \frac{\sin 65^\circ}{5.25} \approx 0.1726 \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, pp. 898-899 — Example 11.2.2 number 2
The interesting thing about this one is that you cannot start. The two given angles both touch the given side of 5.25 and neither faces it, so there is no complete pair to write a ratio from.
The fix costs one subtraction. The third angle, 65 degrees, is the one facing the given side, so computing it manufactures exactly the pair you were missing. Once you have it, both remaining sides come out of two independent ratios against that same pair.
Notice that the pair you use here is built from a derived angle, which is unavoidable, but that you still use it for both remaining sides rather than chaining one answer into the next. The check then tests all three ratios against each other. They should all give the same number, about 0.1725, and they do to rounding. That is the strongest single check available on a solved triangle, because it tests every part at once.
Ranking
Put in order
You are given two angles and the side between them. Put the steps of a clean solution in order.
Why: Naming the case first tells you what to expect. The angle sum is free and it is what creates the pair you need. Every later side is then computed against that same original pair, so a rounding error is never fed forward, and the size check catches a mispaired ratio immediately.
Drag the steps into order before checking, and pay particular attention to where the case identification goes.
It goes first, before anything is computed, because it tells you what to expect. Knowing you are in the Angle-Side-Angle case tells you there is exactly one answer, that the angle sum is the first move, and that no ambiguity can arise. Skipping that thought is how people end up hunting for a second triangle that was never there, or missing one that was.
The last step, checking that the longest side faces the largest angle, takes five seconds and catches the most common error in the whole section. Build it into the procedure rather than treating it as optional.
Fill the middle
A triangle has alpha equal to 40 degrees with a equal to 8, and beta equal to 65 degrees. Find b.
Fill in the blanks
\frac4011.28 = \frac______}^\circ} \;\Longrightarrow\; b = \frac______ \approx ___
Why: The known complete pair is alpha with a, so the right-hand fraction must carry the sine of 40 degrees over 8. Evaluating gives 8 times 0.9063 divided by 0.6428, which is 11.28. A common slip is to write the sine of 65 degrees underneath the 8, pairing the side with the angle that touches it instead of the angle facing it.
Fill both blanks before checking. The first is about pairing and the second is about arithmetic, and the first matters far more.
The known complete pair is the 40 degree angle with the side of 8 facing it, so that pair has to be the fraction on the right. The left fraction carries the unknown b over the sine of the angle facing b, which is 65 degrees. Getting this right is a matter of asking, for each fraction, which angle faces which side.
The classic wrong answer writes the sine of 65 degrees underneath the 8. That pairs the given side with an angle that merely touches it, and it gives about 5.67 instead of 11.28. The size check exposes it instantly: 65 degrees is the larger angle, so the side facing it must be the longer one, and 5.67 is shorter than 8.
Error analysis
Annotate
On: \( b \approx 5.72 \;\Longrightarrow\; \frac{c}{\sin(15^\circ)} = \frac{5.72}{\sin(45^\circ)} \;\Longrightarrow\; c \approx 2.0929 \)
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 896 — the remark on propagated error
Read the line and see whether you can spot the problem before revealing the annotations. Nothing in the algebra is wrong, and the answer is very nearly right, which is what makes this worth examining.
The mistake is one of habit rather than method. The value 5.72 was rounded two lines earlier, so its third decimal is already wrong, and every subsequent line inherits that. The alternative costs nothing: the original pair, 120 degrees with 7, was given exactly and could have been used instead.
Here the damage is a thousandth of a unit, which feels like fussing. Scale the same calculation up to a survey across several kilometres, or chain it through six steps of a traverse, and the error stops being invisible. The rule is simple enough to follow without thinking: solve every unknown against the data you were handed, and reach for a computed value only when there is genuinely no alternative, as with the derived third angle.
Trap
Asked for b when alpha is 40 degrees, a is 8 and beta is 65 degrees:
\[ \frac{b}{\sin 40^\circ} = \frac{8}{\sin 65^\circ} \]
\[ b \approx 5.67 \]
Wrong. The sine of 40 degrees has been placed under b.
Each fraction must hold an angle and the side facing it. Side b faces beta, and side a faces alpha.
\[ \frac{b}{\sin 65^\circ} = \frac{8}{\sin 40^\circ} \]
\[ b \approx 11.28 \]
The size check catches it at once: beta is the larger angle, so b must be the larger side.
This is the single most common error in the section, and it happens because the two given numbers, 40 degrees and 8, appear next to each other in the problem statement and feel like they belong together. They do belong together, but in the same fraction, not in opposite ones.
Read every fraction out loud as you write it: the sine of this angle, over the side facing this angle. Doing that once per fraction is enough to prevent the error permanently.
The recovery is also cheap. The wrong version gives 5.67 and the right one gives 11.28, and the size rule separates them at a glance: 65 degrees is bigger than 40, so the side facing it must be bigger than 8. Any answer smaller than 8 is wrong before you check anything else.
Matching
Match the pairs
Why: In the first, the given side faces one of the given angles, so a complete pair is already on the table. In the second, the given side runs between the two named corners and faces the angle you have not been told, so the angle sum must come first. The third hands you an angle, the side facing it and one extra side, which is the case that may have two answers. The fourth wedges the angle between the two sides, so no ratio can be written at all.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 901 — the four congruence conditions and the naming of the cases
Name each case before matching, and say out loud which side faces which angle. The whole exercise is a test of reading the data rather than of computing anything.
The first two look similar and are not. In one, the given side faces one of the given angles, so a pair is already there. In the other, the given side runs between the two named corners and faces the angle you were not told, so the angle sum has to come first. Both end with exactly one triangle, but they start differently.
The third is the case that occupies the rest of the lesson, and the fourth is the one that defeats this section entirely, because the angle is wedged between the two sides and no ratio can be written at all. If you found yourself trying to write a ratio for it, that instinct is exactly what the next section will redirect.
Section
Part 3
Intuition
In the two cases just solved, two angles were known, so the triangle's shape was settled before any arithmetic began. Replace one of those angles by a side and that guarantee disappears.
The reason sits in the proof you have already seen. An angle and its supplement have the same sine, which was a convenience when it rescued the obtuse case. Run the law backwards, from a sine to an angle, and the same fact becomes a fork: the sine you computed has two possible owners, and sometimes both of them fit.
\[ \sin(\gamma) = k \quad\text{has solutions}\quad \gamma_0 \text{ and } 180^\circ - \gamma_0 \]
So the question in this part is never just what is gamma. It is how many triangles the given data describes at all, and that question has to be settled first.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 901 — the Angle-Side-Side case
You may remember from geometry that there are four ways to prove two triangles congruent, and that Angle-Side-Side is conspicuously not one of them. This part of the lesson is where you find out why.
The mechanism is the identity that rescued the obtuse proof. Sine cannot tell an angle from its supplement. When you use the law in the forward direction, from an angle to a length, that costs nothing. When you use it backwards, computing a sine and then asking which angle produced it, the answer is genuinely two angles, and sometimes both of them fit into a triangle alongside the angle you were given.
So the question to ask in this part is never simply what is gamma. It is how many triangles the data describes at all, and you settle that before solving anything. A whole theorem exists for that count, and the picture on the next slide is where it comes from.
Concept
Figure (svg): The Angle-Side-Side construction. From vertex A a horizontal ray runs right and a second ray leaves at 30 degrees; vertex B sits on the slanted ray at distance 4. A dashed circular arc centred at B, of radius a, sweeps down toward the horizontal ray, and a dashed perpendicular from B to the horizontal ray is labelled h equals c sine alpha.
Here is the construction, exactly as the given data dictates it. The angle at A is known, so both rays leaving A are fixed. The side c is known, so B is nailed down on one of them. The side a is known, but only its length: its far end is free to rotate about B, and the third vertex must land where that free end meets the other ray.
\[ \text{given: } \alpha, \; c \;\text{(adjacent)}, \; a \;\text{(opposite } \alpha\text{)} \]
A circle and a line meet twice, once or not at all. That is the whole ambiguity, and it is a fact about circles rather than a defect in the Law of Sines.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, pp. 901-902 — the figures in the proof of Theorem 11.3
Build this picture in your head and you will never need to memorise the theorem that follows. The given angle fixes both rays leaving the left vertex. The given adjacent side fixes B on one of them. So two of the three corners are already nailed down.
The third side has a known length but a free direction: its far end can rotate about B, tracing out a circle. The third corner of the triangle has to be where that circle meets the other ray. And a circle can meet a line twice, once, or not at all.
That is the entire ambiguous case, and notice what it is not. It is not a weakness in the Law of Sines, or a rounding problem, or something you can avoid by being more careful. It is a fact about circles and lines, and the algebra you are about to do is simply reporting it.
Picture it
Figure (svg): One stage carrying four dashed arcs centred at B, of radii 1, 2, 3 and 4. The radius-1 arc stays clear of the horizontal ray; the radius-2 arc just touches it at the foot of the altitude; the radius-3 arc cuts it at two marked points; the radius-4 arc cuts it at one point far to the right and again exactly at A.
Every arc in this picture is centred at the same B, and the ray is the same ray. Only the radius changes, and it is measured against one length: the perpendicular distance from B down to the ray.
\[ h = c\sin(\alpha) = 4\sin(30^\circ) = 2 \]
Shorter than the perpendicular and the arc cannot reach the ray at all. Equal to it and the arc grazes the ray at one point. Longer than the perpendicular but shorter than c, and the arc cuts across the ray twice. As long as c or longer, and the near crossing has slipped back past A.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 901 — the definition of h in Theorem 11.3
Everything in this picture is fixed except the radius. The same angle, the same adjacent side, the same ray, four different lengths for the swinging side. Watch what changes and what does not.
There is exactly one length that matters for comparison: the perpendicular distance from B down to the ray, which the book calls h. It is the shortest possible distance from B to that ray, so anything shorter than it cannot reach at all. With the given angle at 30 degrees and the adjacent side at 4, that distance is 2, and you can see the radius-1 arc hanging above the ray with nowhere to go.
At exactly 2 the arc grazes the ray at a single point. Past 2 it cuts across, entering and leaving, giving two crossings. And once the radius reaches 4, the length of the adjacent side, the near crossing has slid all the way back to the vertex and is about to disappear behind it. Those three numbers, less than 2, between 2 and 4, and 4 or more, are the whole classification.
Worked example
Solve the triangle with alpha equal to 30 degrees, a equal to 1 unit and c equal to 4 units.
\[ \alpha = 30^\circ, \quad a = 1, \quad c = 4 \]
Write the ratio that involves the unknown angle
Why: Alpha with a is a complete pair, and gamma faces the other known side.
\[ \frac{\sin(\gamma)}{4} = \frac{\sin(30^\circ)}{1} \]
Solve for the sine of gamma
Why: Multiply both sides by 4.
\[ \sin(\gamma) = 4\sin(30^\circ) = 4\cdot\tfrac12 = 2 \]
Compare with the range of sine
Why: Sine never leaves the interval from minus one to one, so no real angle has a sine of 2.
\[ \sin(\gamma) \in [-1, 1] \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{no such } \gamma \]
Figure (svg): The stage with a short arc of radius 1 centred at B. The arc's lowest point stops well above the horizontal ray, so there is no third vertex and no triangle.
Check the geometry against the algebra
Why: The altitude from B is 4 sin 30, which is 2, and the swinging side is only 1 unit long. It cannot reach the ray, and the impossible sine is the algebra saying exactly that.
\[ a = 1 < 2 = c\sin(\alpha) = h \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{no triangle} \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 899 — Example 11.2.2 number 3
The algebra here is startling the first time you see it. You set up the ratio exactly as you have been taught, solve for the sine of the unknown angle, and get 2.
There is nothing wrong with the working. Sine simply never takes a value outside the interval from minus one to one, so no angle on earth has a sine of 2, and the correct conclusion is that no triangle exists with this data. Write that down as the answer; it is a complete answer, not a failure.
The picture explains what the algebra is reporting. The perpendicular from B to the ray is 2 units long, and the swinging side is only 1. It cannot reach the ray at any angle, so there is no third vertex to be had. Notice that the impossible sine and the impossible geometry are the same statement: the sine came out as the adjacent side times the sine of the given angle, divided by the swinging side, which is exactly h divided by a. Bigger than one means a is smaller than h.
Worked example
Same angle, same c, but now a equal to 2 units.
\[ \alpha = 30^\circ, \quad a = 2, \quad c = 4 \]
Solve for the sine of gamma as before
Why: Only the denominator has changed.
\[ \frac{\sin(\gamma)}{4} = \frac{\sin(30^\circ)}{2} \;\Longrightarrow\; \sin(\gamma) = 2\sin(30^\circ) = 1 \]
Bound gamma before choosing it
Why: Gamma shares a triangle with a 30 degree angle, so it has only 150 degrees of room.
\[ 0^\circ < \gamma < 150^\circ \]
Pick the only angle in range with that sine
Why: Sine reaches 1 exactly once in the whole interval.
\[ \gamma = 90^\circ \]
Finish the triangle
Why: Angle sum, then the Law of Sines against the given pair.
\[ \beta = 180^\circ - 30^\circ - 90^\circ = 60^\circ, \quad b = \frac{2\sin(60^\circ)}{\sin(30^\circ)} = 2\sqrt3 \approx 3.46 \]
Figure (svg): The stage with an arc of radius 2 centred at B that just touches the horizontal ray at the foot of the altitude. The triangle A B C is drawn with a right angle marked at C.
Check against the altitude
Why: The swinging side equals the altitude exactly, which is the tangency case, and a radius meeting a line at a single point is perpendicular to it. That is why gamma had to be a right angle.
\[ a = 2 = c\sin(\alpha) = h \;\Longrightarrow\; \gamma = 90^\circ \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 899 — Example 11.2.2 number 4
One number has changed and the answer changes completely. This time the sine of the unknown angle comes out at exactly 1.
Notice the step that bounds the angle before choosing it. The unknown angle shares a triangle with a 30 degree angle, so it has at most 150 degrees of room. Within that range sine reaches 1 exactly once, at 90 degrees, so there is no choice to make and no second candidate to test. The triangle is right-angled, and the rest is Chapter 10 arithmetic.
The picture shows why the right angle was inevitable. The arc touches the ray at exactly one point, which is tangency, and the radius drawn to a point of tangency always meets the line at a right angle. The swinging side has landed precisely on the altitude, so the swinging side and the altitude are the same segment. Whenever a is equal to h, expect a right angle at the far corner.
Worked example
Same angle, same c, and now a equal to 3 units.
\[ \alpha = 30^\circ, \quad a = 3, \quad c = 4 \]
Solve for the sine of gamma
Why: The same single ratio as before.
\[ \frac{\sin(\gamma)}{4} = \frac{\sin(30^\circ)}{3} \;\Longrightarrow\; \sin(\gamma) = \frac{4\sin(30^\circ)}{3} = \frac23 \]
List every angle in range with that sine
Why: Below 1 the sine is shared by an acute angle and its supplement, and both are under 150 degrees.
\[ \gamma_2 = \arcsin\!\left(\tfrac23\right) \approx 41.81^\circ, \qquad \gamma_1 = 180^\circ - 41.81^\circ \approx 138.19^\circ \]
Test both against the size rule
Why: Side c is longer than side a, so the angle facing c must be the larger of the two. Both candidates beat 30 degrees, so neither can be ruled out.
\[ c = 4 > 3 = a \;\Longrightarrow\; \gamma > \alpha; \quad 41.81^\circ > 30^\circ \text{ and } 138.19^\circ > 30^\circ \]
Finish the acute branch
Why: Angle sum, then the Law of Sines against the given pair.
\[ \beta_2 \approx 108.19^\circ, \quad b_2 = \frac{3\sin(108.19^\circ)}{\sin(30^\circ)} \approx 5.70 \]
Finish the obtuse branch
Why: Identical arithmetic with the other gamma.
\[ \beta_1 \approx 11.81^\circ, \quad b_1 = \frac{3\sin(11.81^\circ)}{\sin(30^\circ)} \approx 1.23 \]
Figure (svg): The stage with an arc of radius 3 centred at B crossing the horizontal ray at two marked points, one near x equals 1.23 and one near x equals 5.70. Both triangles are drawn from A and B to those two points, in two different colours.
Check both against the altitude test
Why: The altitude is 2 and the given side a is 3, which sits strictly between the altitude and c, so Theorem 11.3 predicts exactly two triangles, and exactly two were found.
\[ h = 2 < a = 3 < c = 4 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{two triangles} \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, pp. 899-900 — Example 11.2.2 number 5
Here is the case the section is named for, and the working has one extra step that everything turns on.
The sine comes out at two thirds, below one, so two angles have it: the acute one your calculator returns, about 41.81 degrees, and its supplement, about 138.19 degrees. Both are under the 150 degree ceiling, so both fit alongside the given angle. There is also a second test, and it is the size rule from Part 1: since the adjacent side of 4 is longer than the opposite side of 3, the angle facing the 4 must be larger than 30 degrees, and both candidates are.
With both surviving, you simply run the remaining work twice. Two angle sums, two applications of the law, two triangles. Do not be tempted to prefer the acute one because the calculator offered it; the calculator has no idea what triangle you are drawing.
The check reads the answer back through Theorem 11.3. The altitude is 2, the opposite side is 3 and the adjacent side is 4, so 3 sits strictly between them, which is precisely the two-triangle condition. The theorem predicted the count before any of the work was done.
Picture it
Figure (svg): The two Angle-Side-Side answers drawn side by side, each with all six parts labelled. On the left the acute version, with gamma about 41.81 degrees and the third side about 5.70. On the right the obtuse version, with gamma about 138.19 degrees and the third side about 1.23.
Separated, the two triangles have nothing in common to the eye, and yet the three numbers you were handed are identical in both: an angle of 30 degrees, the side facing it of length 3, and an adjacent side of length 4.
So the data is genuinely incomplete. In a real problem the situation itself usually settles the choice, by saying which side is longest, or that an angle is acute, or where a point must lie. Without such a remark, both triangles are correct answers and you must report both.
Seeing the two triangles side by side, fully labelled, is worth more than any amount of argument. One is broad and low, the other narrow and steep. Nobody would call them the same triangle.
Now look at what they have in common. The angle at the left is 30 degrees in both. The side running up to the top vertex is 4 in both. The side coming down from the top vertex is 3 in both. Those three numbers are the entire problem statement, and they are identical.
So the data is genuinely incomplete, and that is the honest conclusion. In a real application the situation almost always settles it: a surveyor knows the target is north of the road, or a physical constraint says the third side is the longest, or an angle is known to be acute. Absent such a remark, both triangles are correct and a complete answer reports both. Giving only one is not a rounding slip; it is half an answer.
Worked example
Last of the four: same angle, same c, and a equal to 4 units.
\[ \alpha = 30^\circ, \quad a = 4, \quad c = 4 \]
Solve for the sine of gamma
Why: Now the given sides are equal.
\[ \frac{\sin(\gamma)}{4} = \frac{\sin(30^\circ)}{4} \;\Longrightarrow\; \sin(\gamma) = \tfrac12 \]
List the candidates and apply the bound
Why: Two angles have a sine of one half, but gamma must be strictly less than 150 degrees.
\[ \gamma = 30^\circ \quad\text{or}\quad \gamma = 150^\circ \;\text{(rejected)} \]
Finish the one surviving triangle
Why: Angle sum, then the Law of Sines.
\[ \beta = 180^\circ - 30^\circ - 30^\circ = 120^\circ, \quad b = \frac{4\sin(120^\circ)}{\sin(30^\circ)} = 4\sqrt3 \approx 6.93 \]
Figure (svg): The stage extended to the left of A. An arc of radius 4 centred at B meets the horizontal ray far to the right and again exactly at the vertex A. A second, fainter arc of radius 5 meets the ray to the right but its other crossing falls behind A on the opposite ray, drawn in grey.
Check why the second candidate died
Why: Rejecting 150 degrees is the algebra's version of the picture: the arc's near crossing has landed exactly on A, and for any a bigger than c it lands behind A on the opposite ray, where no triangle can be built.
\[ \alpha + 150^\circ = 180^\circ \;\Longrightarrow\; \beta = 0^\circ, \text{ not a triangle} \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 900 — Example 11.2.2 number 6
The last of the four, and the one that most often gets solved wrongly, because the arithmetic offers you two candidates and only one of them is real.
The sine comes out at one half, so the candidates are 30 degrees and 150 degrees. But the unknown angle must leave room for the given 30 degrees, so it has to be strictly less than 150. The supplement fails by exactly nothing, which is the interesting part: at 150 degrees the third angle would be zero and the triangle would be flat.
The picture says the same thing geometrically. With the swinging side equal to the adjacent side, the near crossing of the arc has landed exactly on the vertex A, so the would-be second triangle has collapsed to a line. The faint arc drawn for a length of 5 shows what happens next: the near crossing goes behind A altogether, onto the opposite ray, where it cannot serve as a corner. That is why any swinging side at least as long as the adjacent side gives exactly one triangle.
Notation
Annotate
On: \( a < h \quad a = h \quad h < a < c \quad a \ge c \)
\[ h = c\sin(\alpha) \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 901 — Theorem 11.3
The theorem looks like four rules to memorise. It is really one quantity and three comparisons, so learn the quantity first.
The quantity is the altitude: the other given side times the sine of the given angle. Geometrically it is the shortest distance from B to the ray, which is why nothing shorter can reach. Get that one definition right and the four outcomes follow from the picture without any memorising.
Read the last annotation carefully, because it is the only one where the geometry and the algebra look different. Geometrically, a swinging side at least as long as the adjacent side pushes the near crossing to or behind the vertex. In angle terms, the angle facing the shorter side must be the smaller angle, which forces the unknown angle to be acute and kills the obtuse candidate. They are the same fact in two languages, and having both makes the case memorable.
Concept
Solving for an angle from its sine is not the same kind of move as solving for a side. A side comes out of a multiplication and is unique. An angle comes out of an inverse function that has been forced to choose.
\[ \arcsin: [-1, 1] \to \left[-90^\circ, 90^\circ\right] \]
The inverse sine has to return a single value, so its range was cut down to the acute angles and their negatives. That restriction is a decision made about the function, not a fact about triangles. Inside a triangle an angle may be anything up to a straight angle, and the supplement of the value your calculator returned has exactly the same sine.
\[ \sin(180^\circ - \theta) = \sin(\theta) \quad\text{for every } \theta \]
So the calculator gives you one candidate and you must supply the other. Then you test it, and there is only one test: does it leave a positive amount of room for the angle you were given?
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, pp. 899-900 — the two values of gamma in Example 11.2.2 number 5
It is worth being precise about why a second answer appears here and nowhere else in the solution. Finding a side is a multiplication, and a multiplication has one result. Finding an angle means running sine backwards, and sine is not one-to-one over the range of angles a triangle can contain.
To make an inverse function exist at all, the range of the inverse sine was cut down to the acute angles and their negatives. That was a decision made about the function so that a calculator could return a single number. It was not a statement about triangles, and a triangle happily contains angles up to a straight angle.
So when your calculator hands you an angle, treat it as one of two candidates rather than as the answer. Write the supplement beside it immediately. Then apply the only test there is: added to the given angle, does it leave a positive amount of room for the third corner? If yes, it is a real triangle and you owe the reader both.
Concept
Figure (svg): A graph of the sine of gamma against the length a, for a fixed angle alpha of 30 degrees and a fixed side c of 4. The curve is 2 over a, falling steeply; a dashed line at height 1 cuts it at a equals 2, and a dashed vertical line marks a equals 4.
Everything above can be read off one graph. With the angle and the adjacent side fixed, the sine of the unknown angle is a constant divided by the swinging side, so it falls as the side grows.
\[ \sin(\gamma) = \frac{c\sin(\alpha)}{a} = \frac{2}{a} \]
Above the height 1 there is no angle at all. Below it there are always two angles with that sine, and the only remaining question is whether both of them fit into a triangle alongside the given angle. The vertical line where the swinging side equals the adjacent side is where the answer to that changes.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, pp. 901-902 — the proof of Theorem 11.3
The whole of Theorem 11.3 is visible in this one graph, so spend a moment reading it properly. The horizontal axis is the length of the swinging side. The vertical axis is the sine of the unknown angle, which the law gives as a fixed number divided by that length.
Because the numerator is fixed at the altitude, the curve falls as the swinging side grows. Above the dashed line at height 1 there are no angles at all, and the shaded region on the left marks exactly the lengths that give no triangle. At the crossing point the sine is 1 and the angle is a right angle. Everywhere to the right of it there are always two angles with that sine.
The vertical line is the second boundary, and it is a different kind of boundary. To its left both of the two angles fit alongside the given angle; to its right only the acute one does. So the graph carries both tests at once: the horizontal line decides whether any angle exists, and the vertical line decides whether the obtuse one survives.
Tweak it
Parameter explorer
The curve plots the sine of gamma against the swinging side a, with the adjacent side fixed at 4. Slide the given angle and read off the smallest a that still gives a triangle. How does that reading relate to the given angle?
\[ \sin(\gamma) = \frac{4\sin({alpha}^\circ)}{a} \]
Start with the given angle at 30 degrees and find where the curve crosses the height of one. It should be at a swinging side of 2, matching the worked examples. Then push the angle wider and watch that crossing travel to the right.
The reason is worth saying in words. The altitude is the adjacent side times the sine of the given angle, so widening the angle raises the altitude, and a taller altitude demands a longer swinging side before the arc can reach the ray at all. At 80 degrees the altitude is nearly the whole adjacent side of 4, so almost nothing shorter than 4 will work.
Now run the angle the other way, down to 10 degrees. The crossing slides in close to the origin, meaning almost any swinging side produces a triangle, and the stretch of lengths that produce two triangles becomes very wide. Shallow given angles are where the ambiguous case bites hardest, which is exactly the situation in surveying, where sightings are often taken at small angles to a baseline.
Trap
With the sine of gamma equal to two thirds:
\[ \gamma = \arcsin\!\left(\tfrac23\right) \]
\[ \gamma \approx 41.81^\circ \]
Wrong, or at least only half right. The calculator gave one angle; the triangle may allow two.
The arcsine function returns only acute angles for positive inputs, because it has to return a single value. The triangle has no such restriction.
\[ \gamma \approx 41.81^\circ \;\text{ or }\; 138.19^\circ \]
Always write the supplement down too, then test each one: keep it if it leaves room for the given angle, discard it if the two would total 180 degrees or more.
This is the error that turns a correct method into half an answer, and it is entirely the fault of how inverse functions have to work. The arcsine can only return one number, so for a positive input it returns the acute one. That is a convention, not a fact about your triangle.
Build the habit of writing both candidates down immediately, before you have any idea whether the second one survives. It costs one subtraction. Then test each: keep it if it leaves room for the given angle, discard it if the two would total 180 degrees or more.
Notice how much cheaper this is than deciding in advance. You do not need to remember which of the four cases you are in, or compute an altitude, if you simply generate both candidates and let the angle sum eliminate the impossible one. The altitude test is faster when you want the count up front; the two-candidate habit is safer when you are already mid-solution.
Concept
Figure (svg): An obtuse angle of 117 degrees at A opening up and to the left, with the known side of length 42 running to the vertex C. A dashed arc of radius 45 centred at C crosses the horizontal ray once at about 5.9 to the right of A and once at about 44 to the left of A, behind the vertex, where a triangle cannot be formed.
Suppose the angle you are given is itself obtuse. Any second obtuse angle would already push the total past a straight angle, so the supplement candidate is dead before it is tested.
\[ \alpha > 90^\circ \text{ and } 180^\circ - \gamma_0 > 90^\circ \;\Longrightarrow\; \alpha + (180^\circ - \gamma_0) > 180^\circ \]
In the picture the same fact appears as geometry: with an obtuse angle at A, the foot of the perpendicular has already slid behind A, so one of the two crossings can never be reached. An obtuse given angle yields one triangle or none, never two.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 902 — the closing remark of the Angle-Side-Side discussion
This one falls out of the angle sum in a single line, and it is worth carrying as a shortcut. If the angle you were given is already obtuse, a second obtuse angle would push the total past a straight angle, so the supplement candidate is dead before you test it.
The picture tells the same story with geometry. When the angle at A opens past a right angle, the foot of the perpendicular from C slides behind A. One of the two crossings of the arc is therefore always on the wrong side of the vertex, out on the opposite ray, and cannot be a corner.
There is a useful corollary. An obtuse angle in any triangle must face the longest side, so if you are handed an obtuse angle whose opposite side is not the longest of the given lengths, you can stop immediately: no triangle exists. That check is faster than computing the altitude and it catches one of the most common exercise types in the set.
Sorting
In each row the given angle is alpha, the side a faces it, and c is the other given side. Compute the altitude first.
Sort into buckets
Sort each data set by the number of triangles it describes. Compute the altitude before deciding.
Sort these before checking, and do the arithmetic in the order the theorem suggests: altitude first, then two comparisons. Resist the urge to solve any of them.
Two rows need no altitude at all. The one with the 110 degree angle is obtuse, and an obtuse angle must face the longest side; here it faces 9 while 11 is also present, so nothing can be built. The row where the swinging side is 14 against an adjacent side of 12 is settled by the second comparison alone: at least as long means exactly one.
The remaining four all hinge on the altitude. For the three rows with a 25 degree angle it is about 5.07, which puts 4 below it, 8 between it and 12, and nothing else to decide. The row with a 30 degree angle and an adjacent side of 10 has an altitude of exactly 5, and the opposite side is exactly 5, so the arc is tangent and the single triangle is right-angled. The last row is the tightest: the altitude is about 19.73 and the opposite side is 20, only a quarter of a unit clear, but that is enough for two triangles.
Worked example
Exercise 8 of the section: alpha is 42 degrees, a is 17, and b is 23.5. Solve completely.
\[ \alpha = 42^\circ, \quad a = 17, \quad b = 23.5 \]
Count the triangles before solving
Why: The other given side plays the role of c in Theorem 11.3; the altitude is that side times the sine of the given angle.
\[ h = 23.5\sin(42^\circ) \approx 15.72, \quad 15.72 < 17 < 23.5 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{two} \]
Solve for the sine of beta
Why: Beta faces the other given side, so it is the angle the law reaches first.
\[ \sin(\beta) = \frac{23.5\sin(42^\circ)}{17} \approx 0.9250 \]
Write down both candidates
Why: The acute value from the calculator, and its supplement.
\[ \beta_1 \approx 67.66^\circ, \qquad \beta_2 \approx 112.34^\circ \]
Finish the first triangle
Why: Angle sum, then the law against the given pair.
\[ \gamma_1 \approx 70.34^\circ, \quad c_1 = \frac{17\sin(70.34^\circ)}{\sin(42^\circ)} \approx 23.92 \]
Finish the second triangle
Why: The same two moves with the obtuse beta.
\[ \gamma_2 \approx 25.66^\circ, \quad c_2 = \frac{17\sin(25.66^\circ)}{\sin(42^\circ)} \approx 11.00 \]
Check that both angle sets close
Why: Each triple must total a straight angle, and both do to rounding.
\[ 42 + 67.66 + 70.34 = 180, \qquad 42 + 112.34 + 25.66 = 180 \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 904 — Exercise 8
This is the ambiguous case with numbers that are not chosen to be pretty, which is what an exam question looks like. The structure is identical to the worked example, so run the same script.
Count first. The other given side times the sine of the given angle is about 15.72, and the side facing the given angle is 17, which is longer than that and shorter than 23.5. Two triangles, decided before a single unknown is found.
Then solve twice. The law reaches the angle facing the other given side first, its sine comes out at 0.925, and the two candidates are about 67.66 and 112.34 degrees. Each gives a third angle from the angle sum and a third side from one more ratio against the original pair.
The check is the cheapest one available with two answers on the page: each set of three angles must total exactly 180 degrees. If one of them does not, you have subtracted from the wrong number or copied a candidate incorrectly, and you will find it in seconds.
Worked example
Exercise 6: alpha is 117 degrees, a is 45, and b is 42.
\[ \alpha = 117^\circ, \quad a = 45, \quad b = 42 \]
Check the obtuse rule first
Why: The obtuse angle must face the longest side. Here 45 is longer than 42, so a triangle is possible, and it can only be one.
\[ a = 45 > 42 = b \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{exactly one triangle} \]
Solve for the sine of beta
Why: Beta faces the other given side.
\[ \sin(\beta) = \frac{42\sin(117^\circ)}{45} \approx 0.8316 \]
Reject the supplement
Why: The acute candidate is about 56.26 degrees; its supplement, 123.74 degrees, added to 117 already exceeds a straight angle.
\[ 117^\circ + 123.74^\circ = 240.74^\circ > 180^\circ \;\Longrightarrow\; \beta \approx 56.26^\circ \]
Finish the triangle
Why: Angle sum, then the law against the given pair.
\[ \gamma \approx 6.74^\circ, \quad c = \frac{45\sin(6.74^\circ)}{\sin(117^\circ)} \approx 5.92 \]
Check the ordering of the parts
Why: Angles of 6.74, 56.26 and 117 degrees should face sides of 5.92, 42 and 45, in that order, and they do.
\[ 6.74^\circ < 56.26^\circ < 117^\circ \quad\text{and}\quad 5.92 < 42 < 45 \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 904 — Exercise 6
Compare this with the previous slide and notice how much work the first line saves. The given angle is obtuse, so at most one triangle can exist, and the obtuse angle must face the longest side. It faces 45, and the only other given length is 42, so a triangle is possible and it is unique.
You could reach the same conclusion by computing the altitude, about 37.42, and observing that 45 exceeds the other given side of 42. Both routes work; the obtuse shortcut is faster and it is worth having.
The rest is routine, except for the explicit rejection of the supplement. Write that line down even though you knew in advance it would fail. On an exam, showing that you considered the second candidate and ruled it out is the difference between a complete answer and a lucky one, and it takes one line.
Look at how lopsided the result is: angles of about 7, 56 and 117 degrees. The check that the size orders match is doing real work on a triangle this extreme, because a mispaired ratio would show up immediately as a large side facing a tiny angle.
Fill the middle
An Angle-Side-Side problem with the given angle 30 degrees has produced a sine of two thirds for the unknown angle gamma.
Fill in the blanks
\sin(\gamma) = \tfrac23 \;\Longrightarrow\; \gamma_2 \approx 41.81^\circ \quad\text138.19\quad \gamma_1 = 180^\circ - 41.81^\circ = 11.81^\circ, \qquad \beta_1 = 180^\circ - 30^\circ - \gamma_1 \approx ___^\circ
Why: Subtracting the acute answer from 180 degrees gives the supplement, 138.19 degrees. It survives the fit test because 30 plus 138.19 is 168.19, still under a straight angle, leaving 11.81 degrees for the third corner. Had the given angle been larger than 41.81 degrees, the supplement would have been squeezed out and only one triangle would remain.
Fill both blanks before checking. The first is a subtraction, the second is the angle sum, and together they are the entire procedure for producing and testing a second candidate.
The supplement comes from subtracting the acute answer from 180 degrees, giving about 138.19. It survives because adding it to the given 30 degrees leaves 11.81 degrees for the third corner, which is a positive amount of room.
Now imagine the given angle had been larger, say 60 degrees. Then 60 plus 138.19 is already more than 180, the third angle would be negative, and the supplement would be rejected. That is the whole test, and it is the same test in every problem: does the supplement leave a positive amount of room?
Explain it to yourself
Discussion prompt
Without using the words sine or supplement, explain to someone who has not seen this section why two sides and one angle can describe two different triangles, but two angles and one side never can. Two or three sentences.
Write your answer out before revealing, and take the constraint seriously: no sines and no supplements. Forcing yourself to explain it geometrically is what makes it stick, because the geometric version is the one you can reconstruct under pressure.
The key contrast is how much gets pinned down by the given data. Two angles determine the shape completely, so the one side you are given has nothing left to decide except scale. One angle and two sides pin down only two corners and leave the third to be found as the meeting point of a circle and a line, which is a question that can have two answers.
If your explanation mentions the circle and the line, you have it. If it mentions the comparison that decides between the outcomes, the swinging side against the perpendicular distance and against the other given side, you have all of it.
Section
Part 4
Concept
Field problems rarely hand you a labelled triangle. They give a baseline you can walk along, and two angles measured from it, and the hard part is deciding which angles are actually inside the triangle.
A surveyor at a station records the angle between the shoreline ahead and the line of sight. When the target lies behind that station, the recorded angle and the triangle's interior angle at that corner are supplements, not the same number.
\[ \gamma_{\text{interior}} = 180^\circ - \text{(recorded angle)} \]
Sketch first, mark the two angles you are actually given, and only then decide which of them belongs in the triangle. Three lines of arithmetic then finish the problem.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 902 — the setup of Example 11.2.3
Everything in Parts 1 to 3 assumed a labelled triangle. Field problems do not come labelled, and the hardest part of them is almost never the trigonometry.
The recurring difficulty is the same every time. A surveyor stands at a point and records the angle between the shoreline ahead of them and their line of sight to the target. If the target lies beyond that point, the angle inside the triangle at that corner is not the recorded angle; it is its supplement, because the triangle's side runs backwards along the shore to the other station.
So make the sketch first and mark both angles on it, the recorded one outside the triangle and the interior one. Only then start writing ratios. The arithmetic in these problems is three or four lines; the sketch is where all the marks are.
Worked example
Two sightings of an island are taken from a straight shoreline, 5 miles apart. At the first point the angle between the shore and the island is 30 degrees; at the second it is 45 degrees. How far is the island from the second point?
Figure (svg): A shoreline drawn as a horizontal line with observation point P at the left and Q five miles to the right. Lines of sight run from P and from Q to an island up and to the right. The angle at P between the shore and the sight line is 30 degrees; at Q the angle measured from the shore ahead is 45 degrees, so the interior angle of the triangle at Q is 135 degrees, and the angle at the island is 15 degrees.
Find the interior angle at the second station
Why: The 45 degree reading is measured from the shore ahead, and the island lies behind that line, so the angle inside the triangle is its supplement.
\[ \gamma = 180^\circ - 45^\circ = 135^\circ \]
Find the angle at the island
Why: The three interior angles total a straight angle.
\[ \beta = 180^\circ - 30^\circ - 135^\circ = 15^\circ \]
Identify the complete pair
Why: The 5 mile baseline faces the angle at the island, so beta with 5 is the pair to use.
\[ (\beta, 5) = (15^\circ, 5) \]
Write the Law of Sines for the distance d
Why: The side d faces the 30 degree angle at the first station.
\[ \frac{d}{\sin(30^\circ)} = \frac{5}{\sin(15^\circ)} \]
Solve
Why: Multiply through by the sine of 30 degrees.
\[ d = \frac{5\sin(30^\circ)}{\sin(15^\circ)} \approx 9.66 \;\text{miles} \]
Check the answer is believable
Why: The angle at the island is only 15 degrees, much smaller than 30 degrees, so the side facing it must be much shorter than d. The baseline of 5 miles against 9.66 miles is exactly that.
\[ 15^\circ < 30^\circ \quad\text{and}\quad 5 < 9.66 \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, pp. 902-903 — Example 11.2.3, first part
Work through the picture before the algebra. The two observation points sit on the shore, 5 miles apart, with the island out in the water beyond the second one. The 30 degree and 45 degree readings are both taken from the shore ahead.
At the first station that reading is already inside the triangle, because the other station lies ahead along the shore. At the second station it is not: the triangle's side runs backwards to the first station, so the interior angle there is 180 minus 45, which is 135 degrees. That single subtraction is the entire difficulty of the problem.
After that it is one angle sum and one ratio. The 5 mile baseline faces the 15 degree angle at the island, so that is the complete pair, and the distance you want faces the 30 degree angle. The answer, about 9.66 miles, is nearly twice the baseline, which is the point of the check: the angle facing the baseline is half the angle facing the distance, so the distance should be roughly twice as long.
Worked example
Same island. Which point on the shore is nearest to it, and how far away is the island from there?
Figure (svg): A right triangle with the right angle at C on the shoreline, the 45 degree angle at Q, the hypotenuse of length about 9.66 running from Q up to the island, the vertical leg y from the island down to C, and the horizontal leg x from Q to C.
Name the nearest point
Why: The shortest distance from a point to a line is the perpendicular one, so the nearest point C is the foot of the perpendicular from the island.
\[ \overline{IC} \perp \text{shoreline} \]
Find the angle at Q in the new right triangle
Why: The sight line from Q to the island rises from the shore at the recorded 45 degrees, and C lies further along the shore.
\[ \angle IQC = 45^\circ \]
Write the sine in that right triangle
Why: The distance y from the island to the shore is opposite the 45 degree angle; the hypotenuse is the 9.66 miles just found.
\[ \sin(45^\circ) = \frac{y}{d} \]
Solve for the distance to shore
Why: Multiply by d.
\[ y = d\sin(45^\circ) \approx 9.66\left(\frac{\sqrt2}{2}\right) \approx 6.83 \;\text{miles} \]
Find how far along the shore that point sits
Why: The remaining angle in the right triangle is also 45 degrees, so the two legs are equal.
\[ 180^\circ - 90^\circ - 45^\circ = 45^\circ \;\Longrightarrow\; x = y \approx 6.83 \;\text{miles} \]
Check with the Pythagorean Theorem
Why: The two legs and the hypotenuse must agree, and 6.83 squared twice over gives 93.3, whose root is 9.66.
\[ \sqrt{6.83^2 + 6.83^2} = 6.83\sqrt2 \approx 9.66 = d \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 903 — Example 11.2.3, second part
The second half of the problem asks a different kind of question, and it is answered with Chapter 10 rather than the Law of Sines. Once you know one distance, the rest of the picture is a right triangle.
The nearest point on the shore is the foot of the perpendicular from the island, because the shortest distance from a point to a line is always the perpendicular one. That perpendicular, the sight line of 9.66 miles, and the stretch of shore between them form a right triangle, and the angle at the second station in it is the recorded 45 degrees.
From there a single sine gives the distance to shore, about 6.83 miles, and because the remaining angle is also 45 degrees the two legs are equal, so the nearest point is the same 6.83 miles along the shore. The check with the Pythagorean Theorem is worth doing because it uses a completely different relationship than the one that produced the answer.
Error analysis
Annotate
On: \( \frac{d}{\sin(30^\circ)} = \frac{5}{\sin(105^\circ)} \;\Longrightarrow\; d \approx 2.59 \)
Look at the line and try to name the error before revealing. The algebra is flawless; every step follows from the one above it. The problem is upstream, in the picture that was never drawn.
The 45 degree reading has been dropped straight into the triangle as an interior angle, which makes the angle at the island 105 degrees instead of 15. Everything downstream is then wrong, and the wrongness is large: 2.59 miles instead of 9.66.
The size test would have caught it instantly. A result of 2.59 is shorter than the 5 mile baseline, which would mean the 30 degree angle faces a shorter side than the angle at the island does, and the angle at the island was supposedly the largest of the three. Any answer that violates the size ordering is wrong, and checking that is faster than rechecking the arithmetic.
Worked example
A mountain road has a 7 percent grade. A tree stands plumb beside it. From a point 500 feet downhill, the angle of inclination from the road to the top of the tree is 6 degrees. How tall is the tree?
Figure (svg): A long shallow road rising at about four degrees from a point P on the left to the base of a tree 500 feet away. The tree stands vertically, about 53 feet tall. The sight line from P to the top of the tree makes a 6 degree angle with the road, the angle between the road and the tree at its base is 94 degrees, and the angle at the top of the tree is 80 degrees.
Turn the grade into an angle
Why: A 7 percent grade rises 7 feet for every 100 feet forward, and the angle is the inverse tangent of that ratio.
\[ \tan(\theta) = \frac{7}{100} \;\Longrightarrow\; \theta = \arctan(0.07) \approx 4.00^\circ \]
Find the angle between the road and the tree
Why: The tree is vertical, so it stands at a right angle to the horizontal, and the road slopes 4 degrees below the horizontal going downhill.
\[ 90^\circ + 4^\circ = 94^\circ \]
Find the angle at the top of the tree
Why: The three interior angles of the sighting triangle total a straight angle.
\[ 180^\circ - 6^\circ - 94^\circ = 80^\circ \]
Identify the complete pair
Why: The 500 foot stretch of road faces the 80 degree angle at the treetop.
\[ (80^\circ, 500) \]
Write the Law of Sines for the height
Why: The tree faces the 6 degree angle at the observer.
\[ \frac{\text{height}}{\sin(6^\circ)} = \frac{500}{\sin(80^\circ)} \]
Solve
Why: Multiply through by the sine of 6 degrees.
\[ \text{height} = \frac{500\sin(6^\circ)}{\sin(80^\circ)} \approx 53.07 \;\text{feet} \]
Check against a rough estimate
Why: Ignoring the slope entirely, a 6 degree rise over 500 feet gives 500 times the tangent of 6 degrees, about 52.6 feet. The grade shifts that by only half a foot, which is the right size of correction for a 4 degree slope.
\[ 500\tan(6^\circ) \approx 52.55 \approx 53.07 \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, pp. 904-905 — Exercises 22 and 24
Two ideas from different chapters meet in this one. A road grade is a ratio of rise to run given as a percentage, so turning it into an angle is an inverse tangent: 7 over 100 gives about 4 degrees.
The hint in the exercise is to show first that the tree makes a 94 degree angle with the road, and that step is the only subtle one. The tree is plumb, meaning vertical, so it stands at a right angle to the horizontal. The road slopes 4 degrees below horizontal in the downhill direction, so the angle between the downhill road and the upright tree is 90 plus 4.
After that it is one angle sum and one ratio, with the 500 foot stretch of road facing the 80 degree angle at the treetop. The answer is about 53 feet.
Look hard at the check. Pretending the road were flat and using a plain right triangle gives 52.55 feet, only half a foot less. That is a good sanity test for any small-angle correction: the correction should be small. If accounting for a 4 degree slope had changed your answer by twenty feet, something would be badly wrong.
Estimation
Two sightings 5 miles apart, at 30 degrees and 45 degrees to the shore.
Predict first
Before any arithmetic: roughly how far is the island from the second observation point?
Correct: About 10 miles
Why: The angle at the island is only 15 degrees, half the 30 degree angle at the first station, so the side facing 30 degrees must be far longer than the 5 mile baseline. Sine is close to linear for small angles, so the ratio of the sines of 30 and 15 degrees is close to 2, and the distance is close to 10 miles. The exact value is 9.66. If your answer came out smaller than the baseline, an interior angle was taken wrongly.
Guess first, and guess with reasoning rather than instinct. This is a skill worth practising because it catches setup errors that arithmetic checks never will.
The reasoning goes through the size rule. The angle at the island is 15 degrees and the angle at the first station is 30 degrees, so the side facing 30 degrees must be substantially longer than the 5 mile side facing 15 degrees. For small angles the sine is very nearly proportional to the angle, so doubling the angle roughly doubles the side, and about 10 miles is the estimate. The exact answer is 9.66.
The most valuable thing about this estimate is what it rules out. If you had taken the 45 degree reading as the interior angle, you would have got 2.59 miles, less than the baseline. An estimate you formed before computing would have rejected that immediately.
Real world
Discussion prompt
A surveyor needs the width of a river she cannot cross. She paces 80 metres along her own bank, and from the two ends she sights a tree on the far bank at 54 degrees and 71 degrees to the bank. Find the width, and then say why surveyors prefer this method to one that needs a measured distance across.
Work the river problem before revealing. It is Example 11.2.3 with different scenery, and recognising that is the point.
The second half of the question is the more important one. Angles can be measured to a fraction of a degree by an instrument that never leaves its tripod. Distances have to be physically traversed, and across a river, a canyon or a city you often cannot traverse them at all. So the professional method is to measure one baseline with great care and derive everything else from angles.
That idea scaled up is triangulation, and before satellite positioning it was how entire countries were mapped: a single carefully measured baseline, sometimes only a few kilometres long, extended across a nation by a chain of triangles in which nothing but angles was ever measured again. Every one of those triangles was solved with the theorem on this slide.
Section
Part 5
Concept
Figure (svg): A triangle with vertex C at the lower left, B at the lower right a distance 8 away, and A above, a distance 6 from C at an angle of 50 degrees. A dashed perpendicular drops from A to the base, marked as the height, equal to 6 times the sine of 50 degrees.
The old formula needs a height, and a height is a perpendicular. The same altitude that proved the Law of Sines supplies one: from the vertex A, the perpendicular to the base has length b times the sine of the angle at C.
\[ A = \tfrac12(\text{base})(\text{height}) = \tfrac12 a\,(b\sin\gamma) = \tfrac12 ab\sin(\gamma) \]
Theorem 11.4 — The area enclosed by a triangle equals one half the product of any two sides and the sine of the angle between them.
\[ A = \tfrac12 bc\sin(\alpha) = \tfrac12 ac\sin(\beta) = \tfrac12 ab\sin(\gamma) \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 903 — Theorem 11.4
The area formula you have known since primary school needs a base and a height, and the height has to be perpendicular. In a triangle with no right angle that perpendicular is not one of the sides, which is why the old formula stalls.
But you have already built that perpendicular twice in this lesson. Drop it from a vertex and its length is the side coming down to that vertex, times the sine of the angle there. Substitute it into half base times height and you have the theorem.
There are three versions because there are three vertices to drop from, and they are all the same formula read from a different corner. The pattern is easy to recall: two sides, and the sine of the angle where those two sides meet. Never an angle that faces one of them.
Concept
There are three versions of the area formula because there are three corners to drop the perpendicular from. They always give the same number, so the choice between them is not about correctness.
\[ A = \tfrac12 bc\sin(\alpha) = \tfrac12 ac\sin(\beta) = \tfrac12 ab\sin(\gamma) \]
The choice is about error. Count how many of the three ingredients each version takes straight from the problem statement and how many you had to compute, and pick the version with the most given data in it. That is the same habit as pairing a derived angle with the original side rather than with a rounded one.
| if the problem gives you | use | because |
|---|---|---|
| two sides and the angle between them | that angle and those two sides | nothing needs computing at all |
| two angles and one side | the given side, one computed side, and the angle where they meet | only one length has to be found |
| all three sides and no angle | none of these yet | an angle must come from the Law of Cosines first |
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 903 — the remark in Example 11.2.4 about minimising propagated error
All three versions give the same number, so nothing here is about getting the right answer. It is about getting the most accurate one with the least work, which is a different and more grown-up question.
The rule is to count. For each version, count how many of the three ingredients came straight off the page and how many you had to compute yourself. Pick the version with the most given data, because every computed value carries a rounding error into the product, and the errors multiply.
The table turns that into three common situations. If the problem hands you two sides and the angle wedged between them, you are already done; this is the one case where the area is easier than solving the triangle. If you are given two angles and one side, compute just one more side, choosing the one that meets the given side at a known angle. And if you are given three sides with no angle at all, none of these versions can start, which is another job for the next section.
Worked example
Find the area of the triangle from Example 11.2.2 number 1, where alpha was 120 degrees, a was 7 and beta was 45 degrees.
\[ a = 7, \quad \beta = 45^\circ, \quad c = \frac{7\sin(15^\circ)}{\sin(120^\circ)}, \quad b = \frac{7\sin(45^\circ)}{\sin(120^\circ)} \]
Choose the version that leans on given data
Why: Two of the three versions need two computed sides. The version with beta between a and c needs only one computed length, so it inherits the least rounding.
\[ A = \tfrac12 ac\sin(\beta) \]
Substitute
Why: Use the exact expression for c rather than its rounded value 2.09.
\[ A = \tfrac12(7)\left(\frac{7\sin(15^\circ)}{\sin(120^\circ)}\right)\sin(45^\circ) \]
Evaluate
Why: Sine of 15 degrees is 0.2588, sine of 120 degrees is 0.8660, sine of 45 degrees is 0.7071.
\[ A \approx \tfrac12(7)(2.0920)(0.7071) \approx 5.18 \;\text{square units} \]
Check with a different version of the formula
Why: Using the two computed sides b and c with the given angle alpha must give the same number, and it does.
\[ \tfrac12 bc\sin(\alpha) \approx \tfrac12(5.7155)(2.0920)(0.8660) \approx 5.18 \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 903 — Example 11.2.4
The mathematical content here is one substitution. What makes it worth a slide is the choice at the start, which is the same propagated-error habit as in Part 2, now applied to the area formula.
You have three versions to choose from, and they differ in how much given data they use. Two of them need both computed sides. The version built on the given side of 7 and the given angle of 45 degrees needs only one computed length, so it inherits the least rounding. Choosing it is free, and it is the version the book picks for exactly this reason.
Use the exact expression for the computed side rather than its rounded value, if your calculator will let you. The check then recomputes the area from the other two sides and the given obtuse angle; getting 5.18 both ways confirms both the area and the sides that went into it.
Worked example
Exercise 21 asks for the area of the triangle in Exercise 1: alpha is 13 degrees, beta is 17 degrees, a is 5.
\[ \alpha = 13^\circ, \quad \beta = 17^\circ, \quad a = 5 \]
Find the third angle
Why: The angle sum, as always.
\[ \gamma = 180^\circ - 13^\circ - 17^\circ = 150^\circ \]
Decide which sides the area formula will need
Why: The only given side is a, and the only given angles are alpha and beta. Beta sits between sides a and c, so that version needs just one new length.
\[ A = \tfrac12 ac\sin(\beta) \]
Find c from the given pair
Why: Alpha with a is the pair that was handed over.
\[ c = \frac{5\sin(150^\circ)}{\sin(13^\circ)} \approx 11.11 \]
Evaluate the area
Why: Sine of 17 degrees is 0.2924.
\[ A \approx \tfrac12(5)(11.11)(0.2924) \approx 8.12 \;\text{square units} \]
Check with the other two sides
Why: The third side b is 5 sin 17 over sin 13, about 6.50, and half of a times b times the sine of 150 degrees gives the same area.
\[ \tfrac12(5)(6.50)(0.5) \approx 8.12 \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, p. 904 — Exercises 1 and 21
This one asks you to combine the two halves of the lesson: solve enough of the triangle to have two sides and an included angle, then apply the area formula.
The choice of formula again decides how much work there is. Only one side is given, so one side must be computed whatever you do. The angle of 17 degrees sits between the given side and the side you are about to compute, so building the area from those two costs exactly one application of the Law of Sines.
Notice the triangle itself: an angle of 150 degrees with two tiny angles of 13 and 17 degrees. It is a long thin sliver, and its area of about 8.12 square units is small compared with a side of 11.11, which is what a sliver should look like. The check recomputes the area from the other pair of sides and the 150 degree angle, and lands on the same number.
Matching
Match the pairs
Why: Each pair of sides meets at the vertex named by the letter the third side does not use: b and c both touch A, so the angle between them is alpha. The last item is the trap. An angle and the side facing it never bound a corner, so no area formula is built from them; that combination is the one you use for the Law of Sines, not for area.
This is a notation drill rather than a calculation, and it is worth doing slowly once so that you never have to think about it again.
The rule is easy to state: each pair of sides meets at the vertex named by the letter neither of them uses. Sides b and c both touch A, so the angle between them is the one at A. A quick test on any candidate formula is that the two side letters and the angle letter should use all three letters exactly once between them.
The last item is the trap, and it is worth naming. A side and the angle facing it are the pairing you use all the time for the Law of Sines, so the combination feels natural. But they never bound a corner, so no area formula can be built from them. Same two letters, opposite purpose.
Edge cases
Parameter explorer
Two sides of a triangle are 15 and b units, and the curve shows the area as the angle between them runs from 0 to 180 degrees. Where is the area largest, and what happens at the two ends?
\[ A = \tfrac12(15)({b})\sin(\theta) \]
Move the angle slowly from one end to the other and watch where the area peaks. It is at 90 degrees, and the reason is worth stating: when the two sides are perpendicular, one of them is itself the height, so no sine is lost.
At either end the triangle degenerates. Squeeze the angle to nothing and the two sides lie on top of each other; open it to a straight angle and they lie end to end. Both collapse to a line segment with no area, which is what the curve does.
The symmetry about 90 degrees is the observation to carry away. It means an angle and its supplement enclose exactly the same area, so the area formula cannot tell them apart. That is the same blind spot that created the ambiguous case, and the next slide makes it into a counterexample.
Trap
Asked for the area given a of 8, b of 15 and gamma of 73 degrees:
\[ A = \tfrac12 ac\sin(\gamma) \]
or, worse, with sides 8 and 15 and the angle alpha:
\[ A = \tfrac12 ab\sin(\alpha) \]
Wrong. Neither angle sits between the two sides being multiplied.
The sine must belong to the corner where the two sides meet. Sides a and b meet at C, so the angle is gamma.
\[ A = \tfrac12 ab\sin(\gamma) \approx 57.38 \]
A quick test: the two side letters and the angle letter must use all three letters exactly once between them.
The area theorem is often remembered as one half, times two sides, times a sine, with the identity of the angle left vague. That vagueness is where the marks go.
The sine has to belong to the corner where the two sides actually meet. If you multiply a by b, the angle must be the one at the vertex those two sides share, which is the one named by the remaining letter.
The letter test is the fastest guard: write the formula down and check that the two side letters and the angle letter use each of the three letters once. Half a times b times the sine of gamma passes; half a times b times the sine of alpha uses a twice and never mentions c, so it fails. That check takes a second and it is reliable.
Counterexample
Figure (svg): Three triangles drawn to the same scale, each built from a side of length 8 and a side of length 15. The included angles are 30 degrees, 73 degrees and 150 degrees; the first and last are visibly different shapes but carry the same area of 30, while the middle one has the largest area, about 57.4.
Discussion prompt
Someone claims that two sides and the area determine the triangle. Use the picture to break the claim, and say which fact about sine is responsible.
Answer the challenge before revealing, and use the picture rather than algebra: it is doing the whole job.
The outer two triangles are built from the same two lengths, 8 and 15, and they enclose the same area of 30 square units, and yet one is a squat sliver and the other a splayed-out sliver pointing the other way. Two sides and an area plainly do not determine a triangle.
The culprit is the fact that has run through every part of this lesson. An angle and its supplement have the same sine. It rescued the obtuse case of the proof in Part 1. It created the ambiguous case in Part 3. Here it makes the area formula unable to distinguish 30 degrees from 150. One identity, three consequences, and it is worth carrying that connection out of the lesson.
Section
Part 6
Pattern
Figure (svg): A flow diagram. Starting from the given data, the first question is whether a complete angle-side opposite pair is present; if not, the Law of Cosines is needed. If a pair is present, the next question is whether two angles are known, which leads straight to one triangle. Otherwise the altitude is computed and compared with the given opposite side, branching to none, one right, two, or one triangle.
This is the order to work in, and it runs from the cheapest decision to the most expensive arithmetic, because a cheap decision can stop the problem early or change what the arithmetic means.
Naming the case costs nothing and tells you the answer count in advance. Two angles given always means exactly one triangle, so you can work without looking over your shoulder. One angle with two sides means you must compute the altitude and count before you solve, because how many answers you owe is part of the answer.
The last two lines are habits rather than steps. Solve everything against the pair you were handed, so no rounding compounds. Check the ordering of angles against sides at the end, because it catches the most common mistake in the section in about five seconds. And when you want an area, reach for two sides with the angle between them, never a side and the angle facing it.
Comparison
Throughout, the given angle is alpha, the side a faces it, c is the other given side, and the altitude is c times the sine of alpha.
Comparison matrix
| comparison | triangles | what the sine of gamma does | the shape you get |
|---|---|---|---|
| a is less than h | 0 | comes out bigger than 1 | the arc never reaches the ray |
| a equals h | 1 | equals exactly 1 | a right triangle |
| h is less than a, and a less than c | 2 | is below 1, and both angles fit | one acute and one obtuse version |
| a is at least c | 1 | is below 1, but the obtuse angle will not fit | one triangle, gamma acute |
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, pp. 901-902 — Theorem 11.3 and its proof
Fill the blanks from the pictures rather than from memory, and if a row is not obvious, redraw the swinging arc for it in the margin.
The three columns are three ways of saying the same thing, and seeing them line up is the point of the table. The comparison column is geometry: how long is the swinging side against the perpendicular distance and against the other given side. The sine column is algebra: what the law reports when you solve for the unknown angle. The shape column is the answer you write down.
The two middle rows are the ones people mix up. Equal to the altitude gives a right triangle, not two; between the altitude and the other side gives two, not one. If you find yourself hesitating, redraw the tangent arc: an arc that touches a line exactly once is perpendicular to it, and that is the whole of the second row.
Check
Check your understanding
On which set of given data can the Law of Sines NOT be used at all?
Answer: C
Why: Every ratio in the law pairs an angle with the side facing it. Two sides with the angle wedged between them contain no such pair, and no angle sum can create one, because only one angle is known. That is the Side-Angle-Side case, and it needs the Law of Cosines.
The question is about what the law can start on, not about which data determines a triangle. Three of these four determine exactly one triangle, and one of them still cannot be touched by this section.
Two sides with the angle between them is that case. Every ratio in the law pairs an angle with the side facing it, and here only one angle is known, so there is no pair and the angle sum cannot make one. The triangle is perfectly well determined; it simply needs the Law of Cosines.
If you picked the Angle-Side-Side option, remember that the law does apply there. The complication in that case is the number of answers, not whether the law can be used.
Check
Check your understanding
How many triangles satisfy alpha equal to 35 degrees, a equal to 6 and c equal to 9?
Answer: C
Why: The altitude is 9 times the sine of 35 degrees, about 5.16. The side facing the given angle is 6, which is longer than 5.16 and shorter than 9, so the swinging side crosses the ray twice and both crossings lie in front of the vertex. Two triangles.
Do the altitude calculation before looking at the options, then read off the answer. The point of this check is that the count is decided by one multiplication and two comparisons, with no triangle solved at all.
The other given side times the sine of the given angle is about 5.16. The side facing the given angle is 6, longer than that, so the arc reaches the ray; and 6 is shorter than 9, so both crossings lie in front of the vertex. Two triangles.
The tempting wrong answer is the last one, that you cannot tell without solving. That is exactly what Theorem 11.3 exists to refute. Knowing the count in advance also tells you how much work to expect, which is useful information under time pressure.
Check
Check your understanding
Two sides of a triangle measure 9 and 14, and the angle between them is 40 degrees. What is the area?
Answer: A
Why: Half of 9 times 14 times the sine of 40 degrees is 63 times 0.6428, which is 40.5 square units. The angle is between the two sides, so this is exactly the case the theorem covers.
Every one of the wrong options here corresponds to a specific slip, so if you picked one, find out which slip it was rather than just noting the right answer.
Doubling the correct answer means the factor of one half was dropped, and that quantity has a meaning: it is the area of the parallelogram built on the two sides, of which your triangle is exactly half. Using a cosine instead of a sine gives 48.3, and the fix is to remember that the height is the second side times the sine of the included angle, because the height is opposite that angle in the little right triangle.
The value 63 is the product of the two sides halved and doubled again, with the sine left out entirely. It would be correct only if the two sides were at right angles, which is the one case where the sine equals one.
Explain it to yourself
Discussion prompt
A classmate says the ambiguous case shows that the Law of Sines is unreliable. Answer the charge in three or four sentences, saying what the law actually promises and where the missing information really is.
Write your answer out before revealing. Being able to defend a theorem against a plausible complaint is a good test of whether you actually understand what it claims.
The core of the defence is that the law only ever claims that the three ratios are equal in any triangle, and that claim is true in every ambiguous case. When two triangles exist, the law is reporting the truth: two triangles satisfy this data. A theorem that told you there was only one would be the unreliable one.
The missing information is in the data. Two sides and a non-included angle are not enough to determine a triangle, which is precisely why Angle-Side-Side is missing from the list of congruence conditions. Where the law genuinely does hide something is in the inverse sine, which must return one value when two angles qualify, and the cure for that is the procedural habit of always writing the supplement down and testing it.
Exit ticket
\[ \alpha = 32^\circ, \quad a = 14, \quad c = 22 \]
Discussion prompt
Decide how many triangles this data describes, solve every one of them, and give the area of each. Show the altitude comparison that settles the count.
This puts the whole lesson into one problem. Count first, solve every triangle the count promises, and finish with an area for each using two sides and the angle between them.
The altitude is about 11.66, the side facing the given angle is 14, and the other given side is 22, so 14 sits strictly between them and there are two triangles. Both candidates for the unknown angle survive, and the two solutions look very different: one triangle is nearly right-angled at the third corner and the other is a narrow sliver.
Look at the two areas, about 154 and about 64. They differ by a factor of well over two, which is a good reminder of why reporting only one triangle is not a small omission. If a question like this appears with no extra remark to choose between them, both are part of the answer.
Recap
| tool | what it needs | what it gives |
|---|---|---|
| Law of Sines | one complete angle-side opposite pair | every remaining side and angle, one ratio at a time |
| angle sum | two angles | the third angle, free of charge |
| Theorem 11.3 | the given angle, its opposite side, and one more side | the number of triangles, before any of them is solved |
| supplement rule | the acute angle from an inverse sine | the second candidate, to be kept or rejected on fit |
| Theorem 11.4 | two sides and the angle between them | the area |
\[ \frac{\sin(\alpha)}{a} = \frac{\sin(\beta)}{b} = \frac{\sin(\gamma)}{c}, \qquad A = \tfrac12 ab\sin(\gamma), \qquad h = c\sin(\alpha) \]
The two cases this section cannot touch are three sides with no angle, and two sides with the angle squeezed between them. Both are handled in the next section by the Law of Cosines, which also removes the ambiguity by finding a cosine rather than a sine.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.2 The Law of Sines §11.2, pp. 896-904 — the whole section
OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §10.1 Non-right Triangles: Law of Sines §10.1 — the same material in OpenStax
One theorem, one counting rule and one area formula. The Law of Sines needs a complete angle-side opposite pair before it can start, and with one it will produce every remaining part of the triangle, one ratio at a time. The angle sum is free and often creates the pair you were missing.
Theorem 11.3 is the piece that is new in spirit rather than in technique. It tells you how many answers exist before you compute any of them, from one multiplication and two comparisons. Behind it is the fact that shaped the entire lesson: an angle and its supplement share a sine, which rescued the obtuse proof, created the ambiguity, and left the area formula unable to distinguish an angle from its supplement.
What this section cannot do is start on three sides with no angle, or two sides with the angle squeezed between them. Both go to the Law of Cosines in the next section, which has the useful side effect of removing ambiguity entirely: it produces a cosine, and cosine, unlike sine, takes a different value at an angle and at its supplement.
Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Trigonometry — $55/session, free consultation.