11.1b Harmonic Motion

A mass on a spring oscillates sinusoidally without going round anything. Covers Hooke's law and the equilibrium position from which all displacement is measured, the equation for free undamped harmonic motion with omega determined by the apparatus and the amplitude and phase by the initial conditions, and then the three ways the idealisation is relaxed: damped motion with a decaying envelope, resonance where forcing at the natural frequency makes the envelope grow, and beats where forcing at a different frequency produces a slow modulation that sum-to-product exposes.

Subject: Trigonometry · 65 slides · symbolic lesson

Open the interactive version of this deck

What this lesson covers

The lesson, slide by slide

1. Harmonic Motion

Title

Trigonometry · Section 11.1

A mass on a spring traces a sinusoid, and nothing is going round

2. What this lesson gives you

Objectives

Lesson 11.1a fitted sinusoids to Ferris wheels and hours of daylight, where something really was turning. A mass bouncing on a spring turns nothing at all, and its motion is a sinusoid anyway. This lesson says which sinusoid, and what happens when the idealisation is relaxed.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, pp. 885-891 — subsection 11.1.1, Harmonic Motion

The last lesson fitted sinusoids to things that were genuinely going round, or genuinely repeating on a calendar: a Ferris wheel, the hours of daylight in Fairbanks. You found the amplitude, the baseline, the angular frequency and the phase by reading them off data.

This lesson does the same job for a bouncing spring, and the difference is where the four numbers come from. Two of them, the angular frequency and the period, are decided by the apparatus alone, before anything is set moving. The other two are decided at the instant of release. Nothing has to be fitted to anything.

Then the idealisation is relaxed three times, in the order the book relaxes it: friction, which makes the swings shrink; driving at the natural rhythm, which makes them grow; and driving at a different rhythm, which makes them swell and fade. All three are the same equation with one factor changed, which is why they can be taught together in half an hour.

3. Before anything new: the three numbers of a sinusoid

Warm-up

Discussion prompt

A mass bounces on a spring. It goes 5 centimetres below its rest position and 5 centimetres above it, and one complete bounce takes 2 seconds. Without any physics at all, name the amplitude, the baseline and the angular frequency of the sinusoid that describes it.

Write your three answers down before you reveal anything. This is deliberately a question with no physics in it at all, because the point is that you already know how to describe an oscillation; what you do not yet know is how to predict one.

Half the total travel is the amplitude, which is 5 centimetres, not 10. The rest position is the baseline, and measuring displacement from it makes the baseline zero. The period is 2 seconds, and the angular frequency is two pi divided by the period.

One number is missing and cannot be recovered from the description: where in the cycle the bounce was started. That is the phase, and supplying it from physical information rather than from a graph is the single hardest thing in this lesson.

4. Equilibrium and the spring constant

Section

Part 1

5. Nothing is going round, and it is still a sinusoid

Intuition

Every sinusoid so far came from a circle: a point going round a wheel, projected onto a line. A bouncing spring has no circle anywhere in it, and yet the same three-parameter family of functions describes it exactly.

The reason is a fact from Differential Equations that this course takes on trust. A force that always pulls back toward one point, in proportion to how far you are from it, produces motion of exactly one shape. That shape is the sinusoid.

So the whole of this lesson is the previous lesson's machinery pointed at a new object. What is new is where the amplitude, the frequency and the phase come from: not from a table of data, but from the spring, the mass and the way the motion was started.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, p. 885 — the opening of subsection 11.1.1

It is reasonable to be suspicious here. Every sinusoid you have met so far was a shadow of circular motion, and a spring has no circle in it. So why should the same function turn up?

The honest answer is that the reason lives in Differential Equations, one course further on, and this course borrows the result. What you can take away now is the shape of the reason: the spring pulls back toward equilibrium, harder the further away the object is, and that particular rule of force forces the sinusoid and nothing else.

Take the borrowing seriously rather than resenting it. Theorem 11.1 is a gift from another subject, and everything you do in this lesson is trigonometry applied to it: finding an amplitude, resolving a phase from two conditions, collapsing a cosine plus a sine, finding the period of a sum.

6. Mass and weight are not the same measurement

Concept

mass — A measure of an object's resistance to straight-line motion. It does not change when the object is moved.

weight — The force gravity exerts on the object. It changes with the strength of gravity.

\[ w = mg \]

An object weighing 6 pounds on Earth weighs 1 pound on the Moon, and its mass is the same in both places. The formula for the frequency needs the mass, and a problem almost always hands you the weight instead.

systemforcemassvalue of g
Englishpounds (lb)slugs32 ft per second squared
SInewtons (N)kilograms (kg)9.8 m per second squared

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, pp. 885-886 — the Physics preliminaries

This distinction is the single most common source of wrong answers in the whole section, so it is worth a minute even though it is not trigonometry. Mass is how much stuff resists being pushed around; weight is how hard gravity is pulling on it right now.

In everyday speech the two words are interchangeable because everyone stands on the same planet. In this lesson they are not, because the formula for the angular frequency takes the mass, while the problem almost always tells you the weight. If the problem says pounds or newtons, you have been handed a force.

Learn the table. In English units, divide a weight in pounds by 32 to get a mass in slugs. In SI, divide a weight in newtons by 9.8 to get a mass in kilograms, and multiply the other way. A kilogram given directly is already a mass and needs no conversion at all, which is the trap in reverse.

7. Force or mass?

Sorting

Sort into buckets

Sort each item by whether it is a measure of force or a measure of mass.

A force
pounds; newtons; what a spring scale reads
A mass
slugs; kilograms; the quantity that is unchanged on the Moon
force
Pounds and newtons are units of force, and a spring scale works by measuring how far a spring is stretched, which is a force reading. All three would give a different answer on the Moon.
mass
Slugs and kilograms are units of mass, the quantity that does not change with location. One slug weighs 32 pounds on Earth and one kilogram weighs 9.8 newtons.

Sort all six before checking. The first four are pure vocabulary, and the last two are the ones that test whether you understand the distinction rather than just the word list.

A spring scale works by measuring how far a spring is stretched, and Hooke's law says that stretch is proportional to force. So a spring scale reads a force, and it would read differently on the Moon even though nothing about the object had changed.

That is exactly what mass is defined to be: the quantity that is unchanged when you move the object somewhere with different gravity. If you are ever unsure which of two given numbers is which, ask yourself which one would survive the trip to the Moon.

8. Equilibrium is where the two forces cancel

Concept

Figure (svg): Three drawings of the same hanging spring. On the left the spring hangs with no mass, at its natural length. In the middle a block is attached and the spring has stretched by an amount d to its equilibrium position, where the weight balances the spring force. On the right the block has been pulled further down by x below equilibrium, which is marked by a dashed line.

Equilibrium is not where the spring is unstretched; it is where the pull of gravity and the pull of the spring cancel. Every displacement in this lesson is measured from that middle picture.

Hooke's law — The force needed to stretch a spring is proportional to the stretch: F equals k times d, where k is the spring constant. A stiffer spring has a larger k.

\[ \text{at equilibrium:} \quad kd = w = mg \]

Hang the mass and the spring stretches until the spring's restoring pull exactly balances the weight. That resting place is called equilibrium, and every displacement in this lesson is measured from it, never from the spring's natural length.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, p. 886 — equilibrium and Hooke's law

Look carefully at the middle drawing. The spring is not at its natural length there; it has already been stretched by the weight of the object. Equilibrium is the place where the stretched spring pulls up exactly as hard as gravity pulls down, so the object can hang there forever without moving.

That is the origin of the coordinate. Every x in this lesson is measured from the middle drawing, not the left one. This is a convenience, not an accident: it makes the baseline of the sinusoid zero, which is why the equation of motion has no vertical shift in it.

Hooke's law is what turns a measured stretch into a number you can compute with. Hang a known weight, measure how far the spring sags, and divide: that quotient is the spring constant and it belongs to the spring, not to the object hanging on it.

9. Down is positive

Picture it

Figure (svg): The same hanging spring drawn three times, with one dashed line at the equilibrium height running across all three. In the first the block sits above that line and its displacement is marked as negative; in the second it rests on the line at zero; in the third it hangs below the line and its displacement is marked as positive. A long arrow at the left points downwards and is labelled the positive direction.

Down is positive. Getting this backwards does not change the shape of the graph, but it flips the phase and turns every answer about direction upside down.

The convention is inherited from Physics: without the spring the object would fall, so falling is the natural direction and is counted as positive. Write these four lines at the top of any spring problem before you start.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, pp. 886-887 — the sign conventions

The sign convention will feel backwards for a while, because on every graph you have ever drawn, up was positive. The book takes it from Physics: if the spring were cut, the object would fall, and the direction it would naturally go is called positive.

The consequence is that a positive displacement means below equilibrium and a positive velocity means heading downwards. So being released above equilibrium gives a negative initial displacement, and being pushed upwards gives a negative initial velocity, and a problem will often combine one of each.

Write the four lines out at the top of the page before you start any spring problem. It costs ten seconds and it protects you from an error that is completely invisible until someone asks which direction the object is travelling.

10. Example 11.1.3: the spring constant and the mass

Worked example

An object weighing 64 pounds stretches a spring 8 feet. Before any motion can be described, the apparatus has to be turned into the two numbers the theorem wants.

\[ w = 64 \text{ lb}, \qquad d = 8 \text{ ft} \]

Apply Hooke's law at equilibrium

Why: The spring force balances the weight there, so the force in Hooke's law is the weight.

\[ 64 = k \cdot 8 \]

Solve for the spring constant

Why: Divide by the stretch.

\[ k = \frac{64}{8} = 8 \;\text{lb per ft} \]

Convert the weight into a mass

Why: Weight is mass times g, and g is 32 in these units.

\[ 64 = m \cdot 32 \]

Solve for the mass

Why: Divide by 32.

\[ m = \frac{64}{32} = 2 \;\text{slugs} \]

Figure (svg): Two straight lines through the origin on axes of stretch against force. The steeper line, of slope 8, carries the point at stretch 8 feet and force 64 pounds; the shallower line, of slope 5, carries the point at stretch 2 feet and force 10 pounds.

Hooke's law is a proportionality, so its graph is a line through the origin and the spring constant is nothing but its slope. One measured stretch fixes the whole line.

Check the units by finding the period

Why: The angular frequency is the square root of 8 over 2, which is 2 per second, so one bounce takes two pi over 2, about 3.14 seconds. A heavy object on a spring that sags eight feet should indeed bounce slowly.

\[ \omega = \sqrt{\frac{8}{2}} = 2, \qquad T = \frac{2\pi}{2} = \pi \approx 3.14 \text{ s} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, p. 887 — the setup of Example 11.1.3

Nothing in this worked example is difficult, and every spring problem in the section starts with it, so make the two moves automatic. Hooke's law turns the stretch into the spring constant; the weight equation turns the weight into the mass.

Notice which number goes where. The 64 is used twice, once as the force in Hooke's law and once as the weight in the mass equation, and it means something different each time. The 8 is a length and the 32 is an acceleration, and the two are never interchangeable however similar the arithmetic looks.

The graph is Hooke's law itself, drawn. The spring constant is the slope of a line through the origin, which is why one measurement is enough to determine it, and why a stiffer spring is a steeper line. The check at the end is the habit to copy: turn your numbers into a period and ask whether that period is physically believable.

11. The same two steps in SI units

Worked example

Only the value of g changes. A 5 kilogram mass is hung from a spring and stretches it 0.2 metres.

\[ m = 5 \text{ kg}, \qquad d = 0.2 \text{ m}, \qquad g = 9.8 \]

Find the weight first

Why: Here the mass is given and the weight is not, so multiply rather than divide.

\[ w = mg = 5(9.8) = 49 \text{ N} \]

Apply Hooke's law

Why: The weight is the force that produced the measured stretch.

\[ 49 = k(0.2) \]

Solve for the spring constant

Why: Divide by 0.2.

\[ k = \frac{49}{0.2} = 245 \;\text{N per m} \]

Compute the angular frequency

Why: The square root of the spring constant over the mass.

\[ \omega = \sqrt{\frac{245}{5}} = \sqrt{49} = 7 \]

Check against the period

Why: Two pi over 7 is about 0.90 seconds, so this mass bounces a little more than once a second. A spring that sags only twenty centimetres under five kilograms is a stiff one, and a fast bounce is what a stiff spring gives.

\[ T = \frac{2\pi}{7} \approx 0.90 \text{ s} \]

The structure is identical and only the constant changes, but the direction of the first step is reversed here, and that is the point of including it. You were given a mass this time, not a weight, so you multiply by g instead of dividing.

Read the given quantities before reaching for a formula. Kilograms are a mass and need no conversion; newtons are a force and do. Pounds are a force and slugs are a mass. Getting this one decision right is most of what the unit discussion was for.

The final check is worth doing every time. A spring that sags only twenty centimetres under five kilograms is stiff, and stiff springs bounce fast, so a period of about nine tenths of a second is believable. If a calculation had given you a period of half a minute, you would want to look for the factor you dropped.

12. Trap: putting the weight where the mass belongs

Trap

The trap

With the 64 pound object of Example 11.1.3:

\[ \omega = \sqrt{\frac{k}{w}} \]

\[ = \sqrt{\frac{8}{64}} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{8}} \]

Wrong. That is about 0.354, and the period would be nearly 18 seconds.

The fix

The formula asks for the mass, and 64 pounds is a weight. Divide by g first: the mass is 2 slugs, the angular frequency is 2 and the period is about 3.14 seconds. The wrong answer is out by a factor of about 5.7, which is the square root of 32.

\[ m = \frac{w}{g} = \frac{64}{32} = 2, \quad \omega = \sqrt{\frac{8}{2}} = 2 \]

This error is so easy to make that it deserves its own slide. The weight is right there in the problem, stated in the same sentence as the stretch, and the formula has a letter under the square root that wants filling in.

The tell is the size of the answer. Dividing by a weight in pounds rather than a mass in slugs makes the denominator 32 times too big, so the angular frequency comes out about 5.7 times too small and the period about 5.7 times too long. A spring taking eighteen seconds for one bounce should stop you.

The defence is the order of operations in the pattern: convert units first, compute second. Write down the mass in slugs on its own line before you write the formula for the angular frequency, and there is nothing left to substitute wrongly.

13. The equilibrium stretch alone fixes the frequency

Concept

There is a shortcut hidden in the two steps you just did, and it is worth deriving once because it explains what the frequency really depends on.

\[ k = \frac{w}{d} = \frac{mg}{d} \]

\[ \omega = \sqrt{\frac{k}{m}} = \sqrt{\frac{mg}{d \cdot m}} = \sqrt{\frac{g}{d}} \]

Figure (svg): A falling curve showing the angular frequency as a function of the equilibrium stretch, for the English system where g is 32. Two points are marked: a stretch of 2 feet gives an angular frequency of 4, and a stretch of 8 feet gives 2.

A soft spring that sags a long way oscillates slowly; a stiff one that barely sags oscillates fast. The mass never appears, because a heavier mass stretches the spring further in exactly the compensating amount.

The mass cancels. Whatever you hang on a given spring, the angular frequency depends only on how far that object makes the spring sag. Hang something four times heavier and the sag is four times bigger, and the frequency is halved.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, p. 887 — derived from Theorem 11.1 and Hooke's law

Follow the two lines of algebra rather than just accepting the result, because the cancellation is the whole content. The spring constant is the weight over the stretch, and the weight is the mass times g, so the spring constant already contains the mass. Dividing by the mass again removes it.

The consequence is genuinely surprising the first time. Two objects of very different masses on the same spring have different periods, because they sag by different amounts. But if you tell me only the sag, I can tell you the period without knowing either the mass or the spring constant.

The graph shows how the frequency falls as the sag grows. Notice the shape: it is a square root in the denominator, so quadrupling the sag only halves the frequency. That same square root is why four times the mass gives twice the period, which is the next slide.

14. Fill the middle: from a weight and a stretch to the frequency

Fill the middle

A 10 pound object stretches a spring 2 feet. This is Exercise 6 of the section, and it will be finished in Part 2.

Fill in the blanks

k = \frac5\frac{5}{16} = 4, \quad m = \frac______ = ___, \quad \omega = \sqrt______} = ___

Why: Hooke's law gives a spring constant of 5 pounds per foot and dividing the weight by 32 gives a mass of five sixteenths of a slug. Five divided by five sixteenths is sixteen, whose square root is 4. The shortcut agrees: the square root of 32 over 2 is also 4.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, p. 891 — Exercise 6(a); answer on p. 894

Fill in all three blanks before checking. The middle one is the one people get wrong, because ten divided by thirty-two does not come out neatly and the temptation is to round it or to leave the weight in place.

Keep it as a fraction. Five sixteenths is exact, and dividing 5 by five sixteenths is multiplying by sixteen fifths, which gives exactly 16 and a square root of exactly 4. A rounded decimal would have given you something close to 4 and left you unsure whether it was supposed to be exact.

Then check with the shortcut from the previous slide: the square root of 32 over the two-foot stretch is the square root of 16, which is 4. Two independent routes to the same number is the cheapest confidence you will ever buy.

15. Four times the mass, the same spring

Prediction

Two identical springs hang side by side. One carries a 2 kilogram mass and the other an 8 kilogram mass.

Predict first

How do the two periods compare?

  • They are the same
  • The heavier one has twice the period
  • The heavier one has four times the period
  • The heavier one has half the period

Correct: The heavier one has twice the period

Why: The angular frequency is the square root of the spring constant over the mass, so multiplying the mass by four divides the angular frequency by two, and the period is two pi over the angular frequency, so the period doubles. The mass enters under a square root, which is why four times the mass is only twice the period.

Commit to one option before revealing. Most people guess that four times the mass gives four times the period, because that is what proportionality would give, and the square root is what makes it wrong.

Work it in two steps rather than one. The angular frequency has the mass underneath a square root, so four times the mass divides the angular frequency by the square root of four, which is 2. Then the period is two pi divided by the angular frequency, so halving the angular frequency doubles the period.

This is worth remembering as a feel rather than a formula: to make a spring system twice as slow you need four times the mass, or a spring four times softer. Small changes in mass barely move the period at all, which is exactly why a clock's pendulum keeps time even as dust settles on it.

16. The equation of free undamped motion

Section

Part 2

17. Theorem 11.1, and what each piece comes from

Concept

Ignore everything except gravity and the spring, and the object oscillates forever. That case is called free, because nothing outside is driving it, and undamped, because friction with the air is ignored.

Theorem 11.1 (free undamped harmonic motion) — An object of mass m hangs from a spring of constant k. If it starts at displacement x0 with velocity v0, its displacement at time t is A times the sine of omega t plus phi, with the four quantities below.

\[ x(t) = A\sin(\omega t + \phi) \]

\[ \omega = \sqrt{\frac{k}{m}}, \qquad A = \sqrt{x_0^2 + \left(\frac{v_0}{\omega}\right)^2} \]

\[ A\sin\phi = x_0, \qquad A\omega\cos\phi = v_0 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, p. 887 — Theorem 11.1

This is the theorem the rest of the lesson leans on, and it is worth reading three times: once for the shape of the answer, once for where the angular frequency comes from, and once for the two conditions at the bottom.

Notice how the inputs divide. The spring constant and the mass appear only in the angular frequency; the initial displacement and the initial velocity appear only in the amplitude and the phase. Nothing crosses over. That is why you can predict the period of a spring system before deciding how to start it.

The word free means nothing outside is driving the motion, and undamped means friction is being ignored. Both assumptions get dropped later in the lesson, and when they do, the only thing that changes is that the amplitude stops being constant.

18. Reading the equation of motion piece by piece

Notation

Annotate

On: \( x(t) = A\sin(\omega t + \phi) \)

  • Displacement from equilibrium, not from the ceiling and not from the spring's natural length. Positive means below equilibrium.
  • The amplitude: the furthest the object ever gets from equilibrium, on either side. It comes from the release, never from the spring.
  • The angular frequency, in radians per second. It comes from the spring and the mass alone: ω = √(k/m). The period is 2π/ω.
  • The phase. It records where in the cycle the motion was started, and it is the one quantity that needs BOTH initial conditions to pin down.

Two of the four are decided before anything moves, by the apparatus. The other two are decided at the instant of release. They never interfere with each other, and that is the most useful fact in the theorem.

Step through the four annotations and connect each one to the picture of the bouncing mass. The displacement is measured from equilibrium, so it is negative for half of every cycle, and that negative half is the object being above the resting place.

The distinction between the two sources is the one to hold on to. Amplitude and phase belong to the release; angular frequency belongs to the apparatus. Pull the mass further down and the swing gets bigger while the period does not move at all.

That independence is not obvious and it is not universal: it is a special feature of the restoring force being proportional to the displacement. It is also exactly what makes a pendulum clock possible, since a clock whose rate depended on how hard it had been started would be useless.

19. Where the amplitude formula comes from

Concept

The formula for the amplitude looks arbitrary until you see that it is the Pythagorean identity in disguise. Evaluate the displacement and the velocity at time zero.

\[ x(0) = A\sin\phi = x_0 \]

\[ x'(t) = A\omega\cos(\omega t + \phi) \;\Longrightarrow\; x'(0) = A\omega\cos\phi = v_0 \]

\[ \frac{v_0}{\omega} = A\cos\phi \]

\[ x_0^2 + \left(\frac{v_0}{\omega}\right)^2 = A^2\sin^2\phi + A^2\cos^2\phi = A^2 \]

So the two initial conditions are the two legs of a right triangle and the amplitude is its hypotenuse. That is why an initial push can only increase the amplitude, never reduce it: adding a positive square to another cannot make the total smaller.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, p. 887 — the formulas of Theorem 11.1

The formula for the amplitude looks like something to memorise until you see this derivation, and then it is something you could rebuild in thirty seconds. Put t equal to zero in the displacement and in its derivative, and you have two equations.

The trick is to divide the velocity equation by the angular frequency, so that both equations have the same amplitude out front. Then one of them is the amplitude times a sine and the other is the amplitude times a cosine. Square and add, and the Pythagorean identity collapses them.

Read the result geometrically. The initial displacement and the initial velocity divided by the angular frequency are the two legs of a right triangle, and the amplitude is the hypotenuse. A hypotenuse is never shorter than either leg, which is precisely why giving the object a push can only make the swing bigger.

20. Reading the two conditions on the phase

Notation

Annotate

On: \( A\sin\phi = x_0, \qquad A\omega\cos\phi = v_0 \)

  • It fixes sin φ, and therefore names two angles in one turn: one of them and its reflection across the vertical axis.
  • It fixes cos φ, and therefore names two angles as well: one of them and its reflection across the horizontal axis.
  • The two lists overlap in exactly one angle per turn. That angle is the phase; either condition alone leaves a genuine ambiguity.
  • v₀ = 0 forces cos φ = 0, so φ is a quarter turn: π/2 if x₀ is positive, −π/2 if x₀ is negative.

This is the slide to come back to whenever a phase problem goes wrong. The two conditions are not redundant, and skipping one of them is the commonest way to lose marks in this section.

Think of each condition as a line across the unit circle. The sine condition is a horizontal line and it meets the circle twice; the cosine condition is a vertical line and it also meets it twice. Between them they have one point in common per turn, and that point is the phase.

The last annotation is the shortcut worth memorising for the release-from-rest case, which is more than half the problems you will meet. No initial velocity forces the cosine to vanish, so the phase is a quarter turn one way or the other, and the sign of the initial displacement chooses which.

21. Example 11.1.3(1): released three feet below, from rest

Worked example

The apparatus from before: the spring constant is 8 and the mass is 2 slugs. The object is released 3 feet below equilibrium and let go, with no push.

\[ k = 8, \quad m = 2, \quad x_0 = 3, \quad v_0 = 0 \]

Compute the angular frequency

Why: From the apparatus alone.

\[ \omega = \sqrt{\frac{8}{2}} = 2 \]

Compute the amplitude

Why: With no initial velocity the second term under the root vanishes.

\[ A = \sqrt{3^2 + \left(\frac{0}{2}\right)^2} = \sqrt{9} = 3 \]

Use both conditions to find the phase

Why: The sine condition gives a sine of 1; the cosine condition confirms it, since 6 cos phi must be 0.

\[ 3\sin\phi = 3 \;\Longrightarrow\; \sin\phi = 1, \qquad 6\cos\phi = 0 \]

Name the phase

Why: Only a quarter turn, and angles coterminal with it, has sine 1 and cosine 0.

\[ \phi = \frac{\pi}{2} \;\Longrightarrow\; x(t) = 3\sin\left(2t + \frac{\pi}{2}\right) \]

Solve for the first equilibrium crossing

Why: Set the displacement to zero; the sine vanishes when its argument is a multiple of pi.

\[ 2t + \frac{\pi}{2} = \pi k \;\Longrightarrow\; t = -\frac{\pi}{4} + \frac{\pi}{2}k \]

Take the smallest positive time

Why: Put k equal to 1.

\[ t = \frac{\pi}{4} \approx 0.78 \text{ s} \]

Figure (svg): On the left, a hanging spring with a block pulled 3 feet below a dashed equilibrium line, and a marked track showing the 3 feet of travel it has on each side. On the right, on axes whose zero line continues that same dashed line, the graph of three sine of the quantity two t plus pi over two over one period from zero to pi, starting at three, crossing zero at pi over four and reaching minus three at pi over two.

The dashed line is the same equilibrium in both halves of the picture. The graph is that one line unrolled in time: the block's height becomes the curve's height, and the first crossing at pi over four is the block passing the dashed line on its way up.

Check the direction of travel

Why: Just after that instant the displacement is negative: at t equal to 0.795 the value is about -0.06. Negative means above equilibrium, so the object is moving upwards, which is exactly what common sense demands of something released below equilibrium.

\[ x(0.795) \approx -0.06 < 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{heading upwards} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, pp. 887-888 — Example 11.1.3, part 1

This is the model solution and every line of it earns its place. The angular frequency comes first because it is needed by the amplitude formula; the amplitude comes next; the phase comes last because it needs both of the others.

The picture is the one to keep. On the left the block hangs 3 feet below the dashed equilibrium line, and it has 3 feet of travel on each side of it. On the right the same dashed line has become the horizontal axis, and the block's height has been unrolled in time.

The check at the end is not decoration. You solved an equation and got a quarter of pi, but the equation does not know which way the object is going at that instant. Evaluating the displacement a hundredth of a second later gives a negative number, meaning above equilibrium, so it is on its way up, which is what anything released below equilibrium must be doing the first time it comes back.

22. How long is one bounce?

Estimation

Same apparatus: the 64 pound object on the spring it stretched 8 feet.

Predict first

Estimate the time for one complete bounce, down and back, before computing it.

  • About 0.3 seconds
  • About 1.6 seconds
  • About 3.1 seconds
  • About 6.3 seconds

Correct: About 3.1 seconds

Why: The angular frequency is 2 radians per second, so the period is two pi over 2, which is pi, about 3.14 seconds. A common slip is to answer 6.3 by forgetting to divide two pi by the angular frequency, and another is to answer 1.6 by taking half a period, which is one trip rather than a round trip.

\[ T = \frac{2\pi}{\omega} = \frac{2\pi}{2} = \pi \approx 3.14 \text{ s} \]

Guess before computing. The value of this slide is in noticing which of the wrong options you were drawn to, because each one corresponds to a specific slip.

If you were tempted by about six seconds, you probably wrote two pi and forgot to divide by the angular frequency. If you were tempted by about one and a half seconds, you found half a period, which is the trip down and back to equilibrium but not the whole cycle.

The period is pi seconds, a little over three. That is slow, and it should be: a 64 pound object on a spring soft enough to sag eight feet under it is about as sluggish a spring system as you are likely to meet.

23. One condition leaves two phases; two conditions leave one

Concept

Figure (svg): A unit circle with a horizontal dashed line at height three fifths cutting it at two points, one in the first quadrant and one in the second. A vertical dashed line at minus four fifths passes through the second-quadrant point only. Rays are drawn to both points; the first-quadrant one is crossed out and the second-quadrant one is marked as the phase.

The sine condition alone names two angles on the circle, a first-quadrant one and its reflection. The cosine condition is a vertical line, and it passes through only one of them.

This is the same ambiguity you met whenever an equation in a sine had to be solved. A value of the sine is a horizontal line across the unit circle, and a horizontal line meets the circle twice.

\[ \sin\phi = \tfrac35 \;\Longrightarrow\; \phi = \arcsin\tfrac35 \;\text{ or }\; \phi = \pi - \arcsin\tfrac35 \]

The cosine condition is a vertical line, and it passes through only one of those two points. Which one depends on the sign of the initial velocity, so the direction of the push is what decides the phase.

You have seen this ambiguity before, in the section on solving trigonometric equations. A single value of the sine never names a single angle; it names two per turn, symmetric about the vertical axis.

The picture makes the resolution visible. The horizontal dashed line at three fifths meets the circle in the first quadrant and again in the second. The vertical dashed line at minus four fifths passes through only the second-quadrant one, so that is the phase and the other is crossed out.

What decides which of the two you get is the sign of the initial velocity, because the cosine condition is the velocity condition. An object pushed upwards has a negative cosine of the phase; an object pushed downwards has a positive one. So the direction of the push literally chooses the quadrant.

24. Example 11.1.3(2): released with an upward velocity

Worked example

The same release point, 3 feet below equilibrium, but now the object is given a push upward at 8 feet per second. Upward is negative.

\[ \omega = 2, \quad x_0 = 3, \quad v_0 = -8 \]

Compute the amplitude

Why: The velocity contributes v0 over omega, which is minus 4, and it is squared.

\[ A = \sqrt{3^2 + (-4)^2} = \sqrt{25} = 5 \]

Use the sine condition

Why: Five times the sine of the phase is the initial displacement.

\[ 5\sin\phi = 3 \;\Longrightarrow\; \sin\phi = \tfrac35 \]

Use the cosine condition

Why: A times omega is 10, and the initial velocity is negative.

\[ 10\cos\phi = -8 \;\Longrightarrow\; \cos\phi = -\tfrac45 \]

Name the quadrant and the phase

Why: Sine positive with cosine negative is the second quadrant, and since the motion is written with a sine, express it through arcsine.

\[ \phi = \pi - \arcsin\left(\tfrac35\right) \approx 2.498 \]

Write the equation of motion

Why: Amplitude 5, angular frequency 2, that phase.

\[ x(t) = 5\sin\left(2t + \pi - \arcsin\tfrac35\right) \]

Find the highest point above equilibrium

Why: Above equilibrium is negative, so the greatest height above is where the displacement is minus the amplitude; solve for the first such time.

\[ x(t) = -5 \;\Longrightarrow\; t = \tfrac12\arcsin\tfrac35 + \tfrac{\pi}{4} \approx 1.107 \]

Figure (svg): Two sinusoids of the same period drawn over one period from zero to pi. The first, of amplitude 3, starts at its maximum of 3. The second, of amplitude 5, starts at 3 but is already falling, reaches minus 5 at about t equals 1.107, and crosses zero earlier than the first.

Both start 3 feet below equilibrium, so both curves pass through the same point at time zero. The push upward does not change the period at all; it only makes the swing reach 5 feet instead of 3.

Check both the amplitude and the time

Why: At time zero the formula gives 5 times three fifths, which is 3, the stated release point; and at t equal to 1.107 it gives -5.000, so the object is 5 feet above equilibrium there, matching the amplitude. The push added 2 feet to the swing but changed the period not at all.

\[ x(0) = 5\cdot\tfrac35 = 3, \qquad x(1.107) = -5.000 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, p. 888 — Example 11.1.3, part 2

Only one number has changed from the previous example, and it has changed by acquiring a sign. The push is upward, and upward is negative in this model, so the initial velocity is minus 8 rather than 8. Everything downstream depends on that minus sign.

Work the two conditions in order and resist the urge to reach for arcsine early. The sine of the phase is three fifths and the cosine of the phase is minus four fifths, and only after you have both should you name the angle. Because the motion is written with a sine, the book expresses the answer through arcsine, subtracting from half a turn to reach the second quadrant.

The graph shows both parts together, which is the most informative way to see what the push did. The two curves start at the same height, because the release point was the same. They have the same period, because the apparatus was the same. The only difference is that one reaches 5 and the other 3, and that the taller one is already on its way somewhere at time zero.

25. Find the error: the phase from one condition

Error analysis

A student solving part 2 stops after the sine condition.

Annotate

On: \( 5\sin\phi = 3 \;\Longrightarrow\; \phi = \arcsin\left(\tfrac35\right) \approx 0.6435 \)

  • Nothing is wrong here. Five times three fifths really is 3, and the arcsine of three fifths really is about 0.6435.
  • Arcsine only ever returns an angle between −π/2 and π/2, so it can only ever produce a FIRST or fourth quadrant answer. It cannot reach the second quadrant.
  • The cosine condition says cos φ = −4/5, which is negative. A first-quadrant angle has positive cosine, so 0.6435 contradicts it.
  • Using 0.6435 gives x(t) = 5 sin(2t + 0.6435), whose value at t = 0 is still 3, but whose initial velocity is +8: the object is sent downward instead of upward. The graph is the mirror image of the right one.

\[ x'(0) = 10\cos(0.6435) = 10\cdot\tfrac45 = +8 \ne -8 \]

Read the line and try to locate the problem before revealing the annotations. Nothing in the arithmetic is wrong, which is what makes this error so durable: every individual step checks out.

The problem is the range of arcsine. It was defined to return angles only between minus a quarter turn and a quarter turn, so it can never produce a second-quadrant answer, and the answer here needed to be in the second quadrant. The function cannot tell you that; you have to notice it.

The last annotation shows how much damage it does. The wrong phase still gives the right displacement at time zero, so a spot check would not catch it. What it gets wrong is the velocity: the object is sent downward at 8 feet per second instead of upward. The motion produced is the mirror image of the one asked for.

26. Break the claim: the amplitude is the release distance

Counterexample

Discussion prompt

A classmate says the amplitude of the motion is simply how far the object was pulled from equilibrium before being let go. Find a case in this lesson where that fails, and then say in one sentence exactly when the claim is true.

Write your counterexample before revealing, and then write the second sentence too, because naming the exact condition under which a false claim becomes true is where the understanding lives.

Example 11.1.3 part 2 is the counterexample and it is right there in this lesson: pulled 3 feet, swings 5. The claim fails whenever the object is given a push, and it fails in only one direction, since the amplitude is always at least the release distance and never less.

The reason is the square under the root. A velocity term contributes its square, which is never negative, so it can only add to the total. An upward push and a downward push of the same size give exactly the same amplitude; they differ only in the phase.

27. Exercise 6(b): a ten pound object, released from rest

Worked example

The apparatus from the cloze slide: a 10 pound object on a spring it stretches 2 feet, so the spring constant is 5, the mass is five sixteenths of a slug and the angular frequency is 4. The object is released 1 foot below equilibrium, from rest.

\[ \omega = 4, \quad x_0 = 1, \quad v_0 = 0 \]

Compute the amplitude

Why: No initial velocity, so the amplitude is the initial displacement.

\[ A = \sqrt{1^2 + 0^2} = 1 \]

Find the phase from both conditions

Why: Sine of the phase is 1 and cosine of the phase is 0.

\[ 1\cdot\sin\phi = 1, \quad 4\cos\phi = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \phi = \frac{\pi}{2} \]

Write the equation of motion

Why: Amplitude 1, angular frequency 4, quarter-turn phase.

\[ x(t) = \sin\left(4t + \frac{\pi}{2}\right) \]

Solve for the first equilibrium crossing

Why: The sine vanishes when its argument is a multiple of pi; the smallest positive time comes from the multiple 1.

\[ 4t + \frac{\pi}{2} = \pi \;\Longrightarrow\; t = \frac{\pi}{8} \approx 0.39 \text{ s} \]

Check the value and the direction

Why: At t equal to 0.4027 the displacement is about -0.04, which is above equilibrium, so the object is heading upwards as it crosses, exactly as for anything released below equilibrium and let go. The period is two pi over 4, about 1.57 seconds, and a quarter of that is 0.39 seconds, which is where the crossing landed.

\[ x(0.4027) \approx -0.04 < 0, \qquad \tfrac14 T = \tfrac14\cdot\tfrac{\pi}{2} = \tfrac{\pi}{8} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, p. 891 — Exercise 6(b); answer on p. 894

This is the first of two parts of the section's spring exercise, and it is the same shape as Example 11.1.3 part 1 with different numbers. Do it yourself before reading the steps; the point of a worked exercise is to be a check on your own attempt.

Released from rest is the easy case and it has two shortcuts. The amplitude is simply the size of the initial displacement, and the phase is a quarter turn, positive because the release was below equilibrium. If you found yourself computing an arcsine here, you did more work than the problem needed.

The final check uses a second, independent route to the answer. A sinusoid released from its maximum reaches zero after exactly a quarter of a period, and a quarter of one and a half seconds is a little under four tenths, which is where the crossing landed. Whenever a timing answer can be sanity-checked against a fraction of the period, do it.

28. Exercise 6(c): above equilibrium, pushed downward

Worked example

Same apparatus, different release: 6 inches above equilibrium with a downward velocity of 2 feet per second. Above is negative and downward is positive, so the two signs disagree.

\[ \omega = 4, \quad x_0 = -\tfrac12, \quad v_0 = 2 \]

Compute the amplitude

Why: The velocity contributes 2 over 4, which is one half, and both terms are squared.

\[ A = \sqrt{\left(-\tfrac12\right)^2 + \left(\tfrac24\right)^2} = \sqrt{\tfrac12} = \frac{\sqrt2}{2} \]

Use the sine condition

Why: The amplitude times the sine of the phase is the initial displacement, which is negative.

\[ \frac{\sqrt2}{2}\sin\phi = -\frac12 \;\Longrightarrow\; \sin\phi = -\frac{\sqrt2}{2} \]

Use the cosine condition

Why: A times omega is two root two, and the initial velocity is positive.

\[ 2\sqrt2\cos\phi = 2 \;\Longrightarrow\; \cos\phi = \frac{\sqrt2}{2} \]

Name the phase

Why: Sine negative with cosine positive is the fourth quadrant.

\[ \phi = \frac{7\pi}{4} \;\Longrightarrow\; x(t) = \frac{\sqrt2}{2}\sin\left(4t + \frac{7\pi}{4}\right) \]

Set up the downward crossings

Why: Heading downwards means the displacement is increasing, so the cosine must be positive, which forces the argument to be an even multiple of pi.

\[ 4t + \frac{7\pi}{4} = 2\pi k \;\Longrightarrow\; t = \frac{(8k-7)\pi}{16} \]

List the first three

Why: Take k equal to 1, 2 and 3.

\[ t = \frac{\pi}{16}, \; \frac{9\pi}{16}, \; \frac{17\pi}{16} \approx 3.34 \text{ s} \]

Figure (svg): Two curves of the same period, one half of pi long, drawn over a little more than two periods. The taller one, of amplitude one, starts at its maximum of one and first crosses zero at pi over eight. The shorter one, of amplitude about 0.71, starts at minus one half rising, and crosses zero going upward at pi over sixteen, at nine pi over sixteen and at seventeen pi over sixteen, the last of which is marked.

Both curves belong to the same apparatus, so they share a period of one half of pi. Only the starting height and the starting push differ, and those change nothing but the amplitude and where in the cycle the motion begins.

Check the start and the third crossing

Why: At time zero the formula gives -0.5, the stated release point, and its derivative there is 2, the stated velocity. At t equal to 3.338 the displacement is 0.000 and the derivative is positive, so the object really is passing through equilibrium heading downwards, and it is the third such crossing.

\[ x(0) = -0.5, \; x'(0) = 2, \qquad x\left(\tfrac{17\pi}{16}\right) = 0, \; x'\left(\tfrac{17\pi}{16}\right) = 2\sqrt2 > 0 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, p. 891 — Exercise 6(c); answer on p. 894

This is the hardest problem in the lesson, and the difficulty is entirely in the signs. Above equilibrium makes the initial displacement negative; a downward push makes the initial velocity positive. The two have opposite signs, which puts the phase in the fourth quadrant.

Six inches must become half a foot before it goes anywhere near a formula. Mixing feet and inches in the same calculation is a quiet way to be wrong by a factor of twelve, and nothing later in the problem would reveal it.

The last part asks for the third crossing heading downwards, and the word downwards is doing real work. Passing through equilibrium happens twice per cycle, once going each way, so you must select. Heading downwards means the displacement is increasing, which means the derivative is positive, which means the cosine is positive, which forces the argument to be an even multiple of pi. Then counting to the third one is straightforward.

29. Put the equation of motion together in order

Ranking

Put in order

Order the moves of a complete free-undamped problem.

  1. Fix the sign convention: down is positive, up is negative
  2. Turn the weight and the measured stretch into a spring constant and a mass
  3. Compute the angular frequency from the apparatus alone
  4. Combine both initial conditions into the amplitude
  5. Use both conditions together to choose the phase, then write the displacement

Why: The sign convention comes first because it decides the signs of the initial conditions, and getting it wrong afterwards is invisible. The apparatus branch must finish before the amplitude, because the amplitude formula divides the initial velocity by the angular frequency. The phase comes last because it needs the amplitude and the angular frequency as well as both initial conditions.

Drag the five moves into order before checking. Only two of them are genuinely negotiable in position, and thinking about why the other three are fixed is the exercise.

The sign convention has to be first, because it determines the signs of the two initial conditions, and once they are written down wrongly nothing later in the problem will complain. The apparatus work has to come before the amplitude, because the amplitude formula divides the initial velocity by the angular frequency.

The phase is last for a structural reason: both of its conditions involve the amplitude, and one of them involves the angular frequency as well, so it cannot be computed until everything else is known. If you ever find yourself hunting for the phase first, you have started at the wrong end.

30. Exercise 7: the pendulum in the antique clock

Worked example

A pendulum is a different apparatus with the same equation. The amplitude is the initial angular displacement, and the period is given by the formula below, with l the length of the pendulum.

\[ T = 2\pi\sqrt{\frac{l}{g}}, \qquad \theta(0) = \theta_0 \]

Turn the period into an angular frequency

Why: Angular frequency is two pi over the period, and the two pi cancels.

\[ \omega = \frac{2\pi}{T} = \frac{2\pi}{2\pi\sqrt{l/g}} = \sqrt{\frac{g}{l}} \]

Impose the initial condition

Why: The amplitude is the initial displacement and the motion starts there, so the sine must equal 1.

\[ \theta_0\sin\phi = \theta_0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \sin\phi = 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; \phi = \frac{\pi}{2} \]

Write the general answer

Why: This is part (a).

\[ \theta(t) = \theta_0\sin\left(\sqrt{\frac{g}{l}}\;t + \frac{\pi}{2}\right) \]

Put in the clock's period

Why: The clock needs a half-second period, so the angular frequency is two pi over one half.

\[ T = \tfrac12 \;\Longrightarrow\; \omega = \frac{2\pi}{1/2} = 4\pi \]

Convert the initial displacement to radians

Why: Fifteen degrees is fifteen one hundred and eightieths of pi.

\[ \theta_0 = 15^\circ = \frac{15\pi}{180} = \frac{\pi}{12} \]

Write the clock's equation

Why: This is part (b).

\[ \theta(t) = \frac{\pi}{12}\sin\left(4\pi t + \frac{\pi}{2}\right) \]

Figure (svg): On the left, a pendulum hanging from a pivot, drawn at 15 degrees to the right of a dashed vertical, with a faint copy at 15 degrees to the left and an arc marking the angle theta between the rod and the vertical. On the right, the graph of the angle against time over one half-second period, a cosine-shaped curve starting at its maximum of pi over twelve and returning there after half a second.

The apparatus has changed completely and the equation has not. The angle from the vertical plays the part the displacement from equilibrium played, and the length of the rod plays the part of the stretch.

Check by recovering the pendulum's length

Why: Solving the period formula for the length gives g times T squared over four pi squared, which is 32 times one quarter over 39.478, about 0.2026 feet, or 2.43 inches; putting that back into the square root of g over l returns 12.566, which is four pi. A two and a half inch pendulum ticking twice a second is exactly what a mantel clock has.

\[ l = \frac{gT^2}{4\pi^2} \approx 0.2026 \text{ ft}, \qquad \sqrt{\frac{32}{0.2026}} \approx 12.566 = 4\pi \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, p. 892 — Exercise 7; answer on p. 894

A pendulum is a completely different apparatus, and the equation is the same one. The angle from the vertical plays the part that displacement from equilibrium played for the spring, and the length of the rod plays the part that the equilibrium stretch played.

Part (a) is more about reading a formula than computing with one. You are given the period rather than the angular frequency, so convert; and you are told the swing starts at its extreme, which forces the sine of the phase to be 1 and hence a quarter turn, exactly as for a spring released from rest.

Part (b) needs the degrees turned into radians before anything else, and fifteen degrees is a twelfth of half a turn. The check recovers the length of the pendulum from the period: about two and a half inches, which is small, but a clock ticking twice a second needs a short pendulum. Notice that the formula for a pendulum's angular frequency is the root of g over the length, exactly the form the spring's turned out to have.

31. Damped motion

Section

Part 3

32. Promote the amplitude to a function of time

Concept

Real springs are not free and not undamped. Air resistance and internal friction bleed energy away, and the swings get smaller. The book cannot derive the resulting equation without Differential Equations, but it can analyse one, and the modification is small.

\[ x(t) = A\sin(\omega t + \phi) \;\longrightarrow\; x(t) = A(t)\sin(\omega t + \phi) \]

The constant amplitude becomes a function of time. Nothing else changes: the same sine, the same angular frequency, the same phase. Everything a damped or driven system does differently lives in that one factor.

envelope — The pair of curves given by the amplitude function and its negative. The motion is squeezed between them and touches them at every peak and trough.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, p. 889 — the introduction to Example 11.1.4

Everything from here on is the same equation with one change: the constant in front of the sine becomes a function. That is a small change to write and an enormous change in behaviour, and it covers all three of the remaining cases.

Be clear about what has not changed. The sine factor keeps the same angular frequency and the same phase, so the times at which the object passes through equilibrium are unchanged. Only how far it gets between those times is different.

The word envelope is worth having. The amplitude function and its negative are drawn as a pair of curves, and the motion is trapped between them, touching each one at every turning point. Once you can sketch the envelope you can sketch the motion, and the classification of the motion is just a description of the envelope's shape.

33. Example 11.1.4(1): collapsing a damped expression

Worked example

Write the expression below in the standard form, amplitude function times a single sine.

\[ x(t) = 5e^{-t/5}\cos t + 5e^{-t/5}\sqrt{3}\,\sin t \]

Factor out what both terms share

Why: Every factor except the cosine and the sine is common to both.

\[ x(t) = 5e^{-t/5}\left(\cos t + \sqrt3\,\sin t\right) \]

Set up the collapse of the bracket

Why: A cosine plus a sine of the same argument is one sine: the amplitude is the root of the sum of the squares, and the coefficient of the cosine is the sine of the phase.

\[ R = \sqrt{1^2 + (\sqrt3)^2} = 2, \quad \sin\psi = \tfrac12, \; \cos\psi = \tfrac{\sqrt3}{2} \]

Name the phase of the bracket

Why: Sine one half with cosine root three over two is a sixth of a turn.

\[ \cos t + \sqrt3\,\sin t = 2\sin\left(t + \frac{\pi}{6}\right) \]

Recombine

Why: The factored part multiplies the collapsed bracket.

\[ x(t) = 10e^{-t/5}\sin\left(t + \frac{\pi}{6}\right) \]

Read off the amplitude function

Why: Everything multiplying the sine, and it decays to zero.

\[ A(t) = 10e^{-t/5} \;\longrightarrow\; 0 \]

Figure (svg): An oscillation of constant period whose swings shrink steadily, drawn together with two dashed exponential curves, one above and one below, that touch every peak and every trough. The envelope starts at plus and minus ten and has shrunk to about plus and minus two by the right-hand edge.

The two dashed curves are the amplitude function and its negative. They are not part of the motion; they are the ceiling and the floor the motion is squeezed between, and they close in on zero.

Check at time zero, and against the printed answer

Why: The original at t equal to 0 is 5 times 1 plus 0, namely 5, and the collapsed form gives 10 times the sine of a sixth of a turn, which is also 5. The printed text has a third of a turn here instead of a sixth; that would give 10 times root three over two, about 8.66, so the book has a misprint and a sixth of a turn is correct.

\[ 5 = 10\sin\tfrac{\pi}{6} = 5, \qquad 10\sin\tfrac{\pi}{3} = 5\sqrt3 \approx 8.66 \ne 5 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, p. 889 — Example 11.1.4, part 1

Two moves, and the first one is the one people skip. Look at the two terms and ask what they have in common: here both carry 5 and both carry the exponential. Pull all of it out, and what remains is an ordinary cosine plus sine that you learned to collapse in Section 10.5.

The collapse itself is the sinusoid formula: the new amplitude is the root of the sum of the squares of the two coefficients, the coefficient of the cosine becomes the sine of the phase, and the coefficient of the sine becomes the cosine of the phase. Here that gives a sine of one half and a cosine of root three over two, which is a sixth of a turn.

Look closely at the check. The printed book says a third of a turn at this point, and it cannot be right: substituting zero into the original gives 5, while the book's version gives about 8.66. A sixth of a turn gives exactly 5. This is a genuine misprint in the text, and the way to catch one is exactly what was done here: put in one easy value of t and compare.

34. Reading the general form

Notation

Annotate

On: \( x(t) = A(t)\sin(\omega t + \phi) \)

  • Free undamped motion. The swings never change size, and the model runs forever.
  • Damped motion. Friction removes energy, usually giving an exponential factor, and the swings shrink toward zero.
  • Resonance. Something outside is feeding energy in at exactly the right rhythm, and the swings grow without bound.
  • Untouched in all three cases. The zeros of the motion stay evenly spaced whatever the envelope does.

This single form is the reason all three cases can be handled with the same algebra. Factor out whatever multiplies both terms, collapse what is left into one sine, and whatever you factored out is the amplitude function.

This one line is the organising idea of the second half of the lesson. Read each annotation and picture the envelope it describes: two horizontal lines, two curves closing in, two lines opening out.

The last annotation is the one that gets forgotten under pressure. The angular frequency and the phase sit inside the sine and are untouched by anything the amplitude function does, so the zeros of the motion are evenly spaced in every one of the three cases.

The practical value is that one procedure handles all of them. Factor out everything the two terms share, collapse what remains into a single sine, and then simply look at what you factored out. If it shrinks, the motion is damped; if it grows, the motion is resonant; if it is a number, the motion is free.

35. Slide the damping constant

Tweak it

Parameter explorer

The curve shows a damped oscillation. Slide the damping constant and watch two things: how fast the envelope closes in, and whether the crossings of the horizontal axis move.

\[ x(t) = 10e^{-ct}\sin(2t), \quad c = {c} \]

  • c — from 0 to 0.6: damping constant c

Start with the damping constant at zero and move it up slowly. At zero the envelope is flat and you are looking at the free undamped case from Part 2. As soon as it becomes positive the envelope starts to close in, and the larger it is the faster the motion dies.

Now watch the crossings of the horizontal axis rather than the peaks. They do not move at all, at any setting. That is the visual proof of the claim on the previous slide: the damping constant lives outside the sine and cannot touch the argument.

Try a large value and look at what happens to the shape. With heavy damping you see only one or two visible swings before the curve hugs the axis. The model still says the oscillation continues forever, but the amplitude drops below anything you could measure within a few seconds, which is what a good shock absorber is designed to do.

36. Trap: reading the shrinking as a change of speed

Trap

The trap

A student describing the damped graph:

\[ A(t) = 10e^{-t/5} \text{ shrinks} \]

so the oscillation is slowing down and the period is getting longer.

Wrong. The period is constant throughout.

The fix

Look at the sine factor: its argument is t plus a sixth of a turn, with no time-dependent stretch anywhere in it. The zeros are therefore evenly spaced forever, whatever the envelope does.

\[ x(t) = 0 \iff t + \tfrac{\pi}{6} = \pi k \]

The direct test is to measure the spacing of the crossings early and late in the graph. Small swings look slower because the curve is flatter, but flatness is amplitude, not frequency.

This is an error of perception rather than of algebra, which makes it hard to argue yourself out of. A shrinking wave really does look slower, because the curve becomes flatter and your eye reads flatness as sluggishness.

The cure is to stop looking at the peaks and look at the crossings. The argument of the sine is time plus a constant, with nothing stretching or squeezing the time, so the crossings are evenly spaced forever. Measure the spacing near the left edge and near the right edge of the graph and they will agree.

This matters beyond the picture. In real oscillating systems damping does shift the frequency very slightly, but the model in this lesson does not include that effect at all, so in anything you are asked here the frequency is exactly constant.

37. When has the swing halved?

Worked example

An ordinary question about a damped system, and an ordinary exponential equation. Use the amplitude function just found.

\[ A(t) = 10e^{-t/5}, \qquad \text{find } t \text{ with } A(t) = 5 \]

Write the equation

Why: The amplitude function equals half its starting value.

\[ 10e^{-t/5} = 5 \]

Isolate the exponential

Why: Divide both sides by 10.

\[ e^{-t/5} = \frac12 \]

Take natural logarithms

Why: The logarithm undoes the exponential, and the logarithm of one half is minus the logarithm of 2.

\[ -\frac{t}{5} = \ln\frac12 = -\ln 2 \]

Solve

Why: Multiply through by minus 5.

\[ t = 5\ln 2 \approx 3.47 \text{ s} \]

Figure (svg): The upper half of a decaying envelope, a curve falling from ten toward zero, with a horizontal dashed line at five meeting it at a marked point just after t equals three, and a second horizontal line at two and a half meeting it again just before t equals seven.

Each dashed step halves the swing, and the two marked times are 3.47 seconds apart. An exponential envelope loses the same fraction in every equal stretch of time, never the same amount.

Check that the halving repeats

Why: Starting from 5 instead of 10 and asking for 2.5 gives 10 times e to the minus t over 5 equal to 2.5, so t is 5 times the logarithm of 4, about 6.93, which is 3.47 later. The swing halves every 3.47 seconds no matter where you start counting, which is the signature of an exponential envelope.

\[ 10e^{-t/5} = 2.5 \;\Longrightarrow\; t = 5\ln 4 \approx 6.93 = 2(3.47) \]

This is an exponential equation of the kind you solved in the logarithms chapter, and the only new thing is knowing which function to set equal to what. The amplitude function is the envelope, so asking when the swing has halved is asking when the envelope has halved.

Work it in the order shown: isolate the exponential first, then take logarithms, then solve. Taking logarithms of both sides before dividing by 10 is legal but messier, because you end up with a logarithm of a product to break apart.

The check is the interesting part. Ask the same question again, starting from 5 and asking for two and a half, and the answer is another 3.47 seconds later. An exponential envelope loses the same fraction in every equal interval, never the same amount, which is why a damped oscillation has a long faint tail rather than stopping abruptly.

38. Finish the collapse

Faded example

The same two moves as Example 11.1.4 part 1, on an expression whose two coefficients are equal.

Fill in the blanks

3e^\sqrt{2}\big[\cos 2t + \sin 2t\big] = 3e^\frac{\pi}{4}\cdot ___\;\sin\left(2t + ___\right)

Why: The bracket has coefficients 1 and 1, so its amplitude is the root of one plus one, which is the square root of 2. The sine and the cosine of the phase are then both one over the square root of 2, which happens at an eighth of a turn. The whole expression is therefore three root two times e to the minus t, times the sine of the quantity two t plus an eighth of a turn, and it is damped because that factor decays.

Fill both blanks before checking. This is the same pair of moves as the worked example, on the easiest possible coefficients, so it should take under a minute.

Equal coefficients are the case worth memorising, because it comes up constantly. A cosine plus a sine with the same coefficient always collapses to the square root of two times a sine, with a phase of an eighth of a turn. If you can produce that without working it out, half of these problems become instant.

Then classify. The factor you pulled out contains a decaying exponential, so this is damped motion. It is the same classification question as always: look at what multiplies the sine and ask whether it shrinks, grows or stays put.

39. Why a car has shock absorbers

Real world

Discussion prompt

A car's suspension is a set of springs, and the shock absorbers damp them. Describe the amplitude function in each case, and explain why a car whose dampers have failed is dangerous rather than merely uncomfortable.

Write your answer before revealing, and make sure it says something about the amplitude function rather than only about comfort. The physics question is the easy half; the modelling question is the one being asked.

A car's springs and a mass on a spring are the same system. With good dampers the amplitude function decays steeply and the car settles within about one swing. With failed dampers the amplitude function is nearly constant, and the car keeps oscillating long after the bump.

The safety argument is worth getting exactly right, because it is not obvious. A bouncing wheel is not always pressing on the road with full weight, and grip is roughly proportional to the load. So for part of every bounce the tyre can deliver less braking and less steering than the driver is asking for, and that shortfall arrives without warning.

40. Forced motion and resonance

Section

Part 4

41. An envelope that grows instead of shrinking

Concept

Now imagine the whole apparatus, the ceiling the spring hangs from, is itself being shaken up and down. That is called forced motion, and what happens depends entirely on the rhythm of the shaking.

resonance — Forcing a system at exactly its own natural frequency, so that energy is added in step with the motion on every cycle and the amplitude grows without bound.

\[ x(t) = A(t)\sin(\omega t + \phi), \qquad A(t) \text{ increasing} \]

The algebra is unchanged from the damped case. The only difference in the answer is the sign of the growth in the factor you pull out, and that single difference turns an oscillation that dies into one that tears the apparatus apart.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, pp. 889-890 — the discussion after Example 11.1.4, part 2

Forced motion means something outside the system is driving it, and the case treated here is that the whole apparatus, ceiling and all, is being shaken. Whether that is harmless or catastrophic depends only on the rhythm.

Resonance is the case where the shaking matches the system's own frequency exactly. Then every push arrives at the same point of the cycle and adds to the motion instead of fighting it, and the energy accumulates. In the model nothing ever stops this, so the amplitude function grows without any ceiling.

Note how little the mathematics changes. You will factor, collapse and classify exactly as in the damped case. The whole difference between an oscillation that dies away and one that destroys the apparatus is the sign of the growth in the factor you pull out.

42. Example 11.1.4(2): collapsing a resonant expression

Worked example

Identical method: factor, collapse, recombine, then read the amplitude function.

\[ x(t) = (t+3)\sqrt2\,\cos(2t) + (t+3)\sqrt2\,\sin(2t) \]

Factor out what both terms share

Why: Both carry the quantity t plus 3, times root two.

\[ x(t) = (t+3)\sqrt2\left(\cos 2t + \sin 2t\right) \]

Set up the collapse

Why: Equal coefficients, so the amplitude of the bracket is the root of two and the sine and cosine of its phase are equal.

\[ R = \sqrt{1^2+1^2} = \sqrt2, \quad \sin\psi = \cos\psi = \frac{\sqrt2}{2} \]

Collapse the bracket

Why: Equal sine and cosine happen at an eighth of a turn.

\[ \cos 2t + \sin 2t = \sqrt2\,\sin\left(2t + \frac{\pi}{4}\right) \]

Recombine

Why: Root two times root two is 2.

\[ x(t) = 2(t+3)\sin\left(2t + \frac{\pi}{4}\right) \]

Read off the amplitude function

Why: A straight line with positive slope, which grows without bound.

\[ A(t) = 2(t+3) = 2t + 6 \;\longrightarrow\; \infty \]

Figure (svg): An oscillation of constant period whose swings grow steadily, drawn together with two dashed straight lines, one rising and one falling, that touch every peak and every trough. The envelope starts at plus and minus six and has opened to about plus and minus thirty by the right-hand edge.

Exactly the picture of damping, reflected. The envelope is now a pair of straight lines opening out, and nothing in the model ever stops them.

Check at time zero and after ten seconds

Why: The original at t equal to 0 is three root two, about 4.243, and the collapsed form gives 6 times the sine of an eighth of a turn, which is 3 root two as well. At t equal to 10 the amplitude has reached 26, more than four times its starting value, and it keeps going.

\[ 3\sqrt2 \approx 4.243 = 6\sin\tfrac{\pi}{4}, \qquad A(0) = 6, \; A(10) = 26 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, pp. 889-890 — Example 11.1.4, part 2

Do this one yourself before reading it, because it is deliberately the same shape as the damped example. Factor out what both terms share, collapse the bracket, recombine, classify.

The bracket here has equal coefficients, which is the case from the faded example: a cosine plus a sine of the same argument with equal coefficients collapses to root two times a sine with a phase of an eighth of a turn. The two root twos then multiply to give a clean 2 out front.

The amplitude function is a straight line with positive slope, so the swings grow linearly. Look at the numbers in the check: the envelope starts at 6 and reaches 26 after ten seconds, and there is nothing in the model that will ever slow that down. A real spring would have failed long before.

43. Which driving frequency?

Prediction

A structure oscillates naturally at 2 hertz. An external oscillation is applied to it.

Predict first

At which driving frequency should resonance be expected?

  • 1 hertz
  • 2 hertz
  • 4 hertz
  • Any frequency, given long enough

Correct: 2 hertz

Why: Resonance needs the driving rhythm to match the system's own rhythm, so that each push arrives at the same point of the cycle and adds to the motion rather than fighting it. A driving frequency of 1 or 4 hertz drifts out of step and produces beats, not runaway growth, and no frequency other than the natural one produces resonance however long it is applied.

Pick your answer before revealing. The temptation is to think that a faster or slower push would work too, given enough time, and it does not.

Resonance is a matching condition, not an accumulation condition. If the driving frequency equals the natural frequency, every push lands at the same point of the cycle and the effects add up. If it differs by even a little, the pushes gradually slide out of phase and start subtracting again, and the amplitude swells and fades instead of growing.

That swelling and fading is the beat phenomenon, and it is the subject of Part 5. So the two forced cases are not really separate topics: they are what happens when the driving frequency matches, and what happens when it very nearly matches.

44. Sort the amplitude functions

Discrimination

Sort into buckets

Each expression is the amplitude function of a motion. Sort it by the kind of motion it describes.

Free undamped
A(t) = 4; A(t) = 12
Damped
A(t) = 4e^(−0.2t); A(t) = 5/(t + 1)
Resonant
A(t) = 3t + 1; A(t) = 6e^(0.2t)
free
A constant amplitude, of any size, is free undamped motion: nothing adds energy and nothing removes it, so every swing is the same size as the last.
damp
Both of these fall toward zero as time grows, one exponentially and one like a reciprocal. Any amplitude function that decays describes damping; exponential decay is only the most common form of it.
res
Both of these grow without bound, one linearly and one exponentially. Growth is the signature of energy being fed in faster than it leaks out, which is what resonance means.

Sort all six before checking. The only question you have to ask about each one is what it does as time grows: settles at a number, falls to zero, or increases without bound.

Two of these are meant to catch a habit rather than a gap. Growth does not have to be exponential to count as resonant, so a straight line with positive slope belongs in the resonant bucket. And decay does not have to be exponential to count as damped, so something falling like a reciprocal belongs with the damped ones.

Notice also that the size of a constant is irrelevant. An amplitude of 12 and an amplitude of 4 are both free undamped motion; one is simply a bigger swing than the other, started differently. The classification is about the shape of the function, never about its scale.

45. Can the amplitude really grow forever?

Edge cases

Discussion prompt

The resonant model predicts swings that grow without any ceiling. That cannot be literally true of a real spring. Name two assumptions in the model that stop holding as the swings get large, and say what the unbounded prediction is actually telling an engineer.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, p. 890 — the footnote inviting the reader to investigate resonance

Answer in writing before revealing, and try to name two assumptions rather than one. Finding the point where a model stops describing reality is a skill worth practising deliberately, and this is a clean example.

Hooke's law is the first casualty. It is a good description of a spring over a limited range of stretch, and outside that range a real spring stiffens, deforms permanently or snaps. The second casualty is the assumption of no damping: friction grows with speed, so a real resonant system settles at the amplitude where the energy coming in balances the energy going out.

The engineering reading of the unbounded prediction is the important one. The model is not claiming an infinite amplitude; it is warning that nothing inside the system limits the amplitude. Whatever the eventual size turns out to be is decided by the damping and by the point of failure, which is why the design answers are to add damping or to shift the natural frequency, never to hope the shaking stays gentle.

46. Beats and the period of a sum

Section

Part 5

47. Forcing at the wrong frequency: beats

Concept

If the shaking does not match the natural frequency, the two oscillations drift in and out of step instead of reinforcing. Sometimes they push together and the swings are large; a moment later they oppose and the swings nearly vanish.

beats — The slow swelling and fading heard or seen when two oscillations of slightly different frequency are added.

\[ x(t) = 5\sin(6t) - 5\sin(8t) \]

This is a sum of two sinusoids rather than a product of an envelope and a sine, so it does not look like the previous two cases at all. Two separate questions have to be answered about it: how long before the whole pattern repeats, and what is the slow swelling that the eye and the ear actually notice.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, p. 890 — Example 11.1.4, part 3

This third case looks different from the first two, and it is: what you are handed is a sum of two sinusoids rather than an envelope multiplying one. Nothing has been factored out for you, because nothing obvious can be.

Two separate questions have to be answered about such a sum, and they have different tools. How long before the whole pattern repeats is a question about least common multiples and is answered by the ratio of the frequencies. What the slow swelling looks like is a question about identities and is answered by sum to product.

Both questions are worth asking because they measure different things. The period tells you when the picture starts over; the envelope tells you what a listener actually hears, which is a throbbing rather than either of the two tones.

48. Example 11.1.4(3): the period of the sum

Worked example

The period of a sum is the shortest interval on which both pieces complete a whole number of cycles. It is a least common multiple, not a sum and not an average.

\[ x(t) = 5\sin(6t) - 5\sin(8t) \]

Find each piece's period

Why: Two pi over the coefficient of t.

\[ T_1 = \frac{2\pi}{6} = \frac{\pi}{3}, \qquad T_2 = \frac{2\pi}{8} = \frac{\pi}{4} \]

Take the ratio of the frequencies and reduce

Why: Six to eight in lowest terms.

\[ \frac{6}{8} = \frac{3}{4} \]

Read what the ratio says

Why: For every 3 cycles the first piece completes, the second completes 4.

\[ 3 \text{ cycles of } T_1 \;\leftrightarrow\; 4 \text{ cycles of } T_2 \]

Compute the shared length

Why: Three of the first period, which must equal four of the second.

\[ 3T_1 = 3\cdot\frac{\pi}{3} = \pi, \qquad 4T_2 = 4\cdot\frac{\pi}{4} = \pi \]

Figure (svg): Two graphs stacked on the same horizontal scale from zero to pi. The upper one completes exactly three full cycles across the interval; the lower one completes exactly four. Dots mark where each returns to zero going the same way, and the two sets of dots coincide only at the two ends.

The sum repeats exactly when both pieces repeat together. Three cycles of the slower one take precisely as long as four of the faster one, and that shared length is the period.

Check by shifting the function

Why: Replacing t by t plus pi adds six pi to the first argument and eight pi to the second, both even multiples of pi, so every value repeats. Nothing shorter works, because a shorter shift would have to be a whole number of both periods and one third of pi and one quarter of pi have no smaller common multiple.

\[ x(t+\pi) = 5\sin(6t+6\pi) - 5\sin(8t+8\pi) = x(t) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, p. 890 — Example 11.1.4, part 3

The definition to hold onto is the one in the first line: the period of a sum is the shortest interval on which both pieces complete a whole number of cycles. Every step of the method is a way of finding that interval without guessing.

Taking the ratio of the frequencies and reducing it to lowest terms is the trick that makes it quick. Six to eight reduces to three to four, and that immediately tells you that three cycles of the first piece take exactly as long as four of the second. Multiply either count by its own period and you have the answer.

The picture confirms it directly. The upper curve fits three complete cycles into the interval and the lower one fits four, and the dashed lines at each end are the only two places where both are simultaneously back at the start going the same way. The check does the same thing algebraically, by shifting the function and watching every term return.

49. Fill the middle: the period of another sum

Fill the middle

The same three moves on a different pair of frequencies.

Fill in the blanks

\frac2\pi = \frac______ \;\Longrightarrow\; \text___ = ___\cdot\frac______ = ___

Why: The frequencies 4 and 6 are in the ratio two to three, so the slower piece completes 2 cycles in the time the faster completes 3. The slower piece has period two pi over 4, which is a half of pi, and twice that is pi. Checking the other way: three cycles of two pi over 6 is also pi.

Fill both blanks before checking. The arithmetic is short; the thinking is in deciding which period to multiply and by what.

The ratio four to six reduces to two to three, and the number you multiply by is the count belonging to the piece whose period you are using. Two cycles of the slower piece, whose period is half of pi, gives pi. If you had worked with the faster piece you would have used three of its cycles instead, and you would have got pi again.

That cross-check is free and you should always take it. If the two routes give different answers, you have reduced the ratio wrongly or attached a count to the wrong piece.

50. Sum to product exposes the envelope

Concept

The period tells you when the pattern repeats but not what the pattern looks like. To see the slow swelling, turn the sum into a product with the identity from Section 10.4.

\[ \sin\alpha - \sin\beta = 2\cos\left(\frac{\alpha+\beta}{2}\right)\sin\left(\frac{\alpha-\beta}{2}\right) \]

The half-sum of the two arguments is close to either one of them, so the cosine factor oscillates fast. The half-difference is small, so the sine factor oscillates slowly. A slow factor multiplying a fast one is exactly an envelope multiplying a wave.

\[ \text{fast: } \frac{\alpha+\beta}{2}, \qquad \text{slow: } \frac{\alpha-\beta}{2} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, p. 890 — the sum to product step

This identity was an exercise in trigonometric manipulation when you first met it. Here is the payoff: it is the only tool that turns a sum, which you cannot see the shape of, into a product, whose shape is obvious.

The reason it produces an envelope is worth spelling out. When the two frequencies are close, their half-sum is close to both of them, so the cosine factor oscillates about as fast as either original. Their half-difference is small, so the sine factor oscillates slowly. Fast wave, slow multiplier, and a slow multiplier on a fast wave is exactly what an envelope is.

Notice that this is the same structure as damping and resonance after all. In all three cases the motion is something times a sine. The only difference is that here the something is itself a slow sinusoid rather than an exponential or a line.

51. The beat envelope of the same motion

Worked example

Apply the identity to the motion whose period you just found.

\[ x(t) = 5\sin(6t) - 5\sin(8t) \]

Factor out the common coefficient

Why: Both terms carry a 5.

\[ x(t) = 5\left[\sin(6t) - \sin(8t)\right] \]

Apply the identity

Why: The half-sum of 6t and 8t is 7t; the half-difference is minus t.

\[ x(t) = 5\left[2\cos(7t)\sin(-t)\right] \]

Use that sine is odd

Why: The minus sign comes out of the sine.

\[ x(t) = -10\sin(t)\cos(7t) \]

Name the two factors

Why: The slow one is the envelope; the fast one is the wave inside it.

\[ A(t) = -10\sin t, \qquad \text{wave: } \cos(7t) \]

Figure (svg): A rapidly oscillating curve drawn over two full turns, whose swings swell to about ten near t equals pi over two and again near three pi over two, and shrink almost to nothing at zero, at pi and at two pi. Two dashed curves, a slow sine of amplitude ten and its negative, trace those swellings.

The two driving sinusoids drift in and out of step. Where they agree the swings add to nearly ten; where they oppose, they cancel almost exactly, and the motion nearly stops.

Check the two descriptions agree

Why: At t equal to 0.5 the sum gives 4.4896 and the product gives 4.4896 as well. The envelope's size has period pi, because the sine and its negative swap places after half a turn, and pi is exactly the period found from the ratio of the frequencies, so the two routes to the period agree.

\[ 5\sin 3 - 5\sin 4 = 4.4896 = -10\sin(0.5)\cos(3.5) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, p. 890 — Example 11.1.4, part 3, the beat phenomenon

The algebra is three short moves and none of them is difficult, but the middle one has a sign trap in it. The half-difference of 6t and 8t is minus t, not t, and forgetting the minus flips the whole answer.

Sine is an odd function, so the minus comes straight out and lands in front. The result is a slow sine of amplitude ten multiplying a fast cosine, and it is that slow factor, not the fast one, that the picture is really about.

Look at the graph and count. The envelope swells twice between zero and two turns, and the motion nearly vanishes three times. That is because loudness depends on the size of the envelope and not its sign, so the envelope's period of two turns produces a swelling pattern of period one turn, which matches the period you found from the ratio.

52. Bring the two frequencies together

Edge cases

Parameter explorer

The first piece is fixed and the second is yours to move. Slide it toward 6 and watch the envelope. What happens to the length of one swelling as the two frequencies approach each other?

\[ x(t) = 5\sin(6t) - 5\sin(ft), \quad f = {f} \]

  • f — from 6.2 to 9: second frequency

Start with the second frequency at 8 and slide it slowly down toward 6. Watch the swellings stretch out: at 8 there are several across the window, and by 6.4 there is barely one.

The reason is visible in the sum to product form. The envelope's own frequency is half the difference of the two frequencies, so as the difference shrinks the envelope slows down in exact proportion. If the two frequencies were equal the difference would be zero and the two pieces would cancel completely.

This is precisely how a tuner works. They do not try to hear whether the pitch is right; they count the beats per second, and as the string comes into tune the beats get slower and slower until they disappear. A difference of one hertz is almost impossible to hear as a pitch and completely obvious as one beat per second.

53. Trap: adding the periods of the pieces

Trap

The trap

Asked for the period of the sum:

\[ T_1 = \frac{\pi}{3}, \quad T_2 = \frac{\pi}{4} \]

\[ T = \frac{\pi}{3} + \frac{\pi}{4} = \frac{7\pi}{12} \]

Wrong. Seven twelfths of pi is not a whole number of either period.

The fix

A period has to be a whole number of cycles of both pieces at once, so it is a least common multiple, never a sum. Test any candidate by dividing: it must give a whole number both times.

\[ \frac{7\pi/12}{\pi/3} = \frac{7}{4}, \qquad \frac{\pi}{\pi/3} = 3 \]

Seven quarters is not a whole number, so seven twelfths of pi fails. Pi divided by each period gives 3 and 4, both whole, so pi is a period, and no shorter interval passes the same test.

Adding the two periods is a natural thing to reach for, because adding is what you did to the functions. But the period of a sum is not built by adding anything; it is the first moment at which both pieces happen to be back at the start together.

The test on the right is the one to carry away. Divide your candidate by each of the two periods; both quotients must be whole numbers. Seven twelfths of pi fails immediately, because dividing it by a third of pi gives seven quarters.

Then remember that being a common multiple is not enough on its own, because a period must be the shortest one. Two pi is also a common multiple here and it is not the period. Reducing the frequency ratio to lowest terms before you start is what guarantees you get the smallest.

54. Four beats a second

Estimation

A tuner sounds a 300 hertz fork against a piano string at 304 hertz.

Predict first

How many swellings of loudness are heard each second?

  • 2
  • 4
  • 302
  • 604

Correct: 4

Why: Sum to product gives a fast wave at the average of the two frequencies, 302 hertz, inside a slow envelope at the half-difference, 2 hertz. Loudness depends on the size of the envelope and not its sign, so the loudness peaks twice in each envelope cycle: 4 swellings a second, equal to the difference of the two frequencies. This is why a tuner listens for the beat rate rather than the pitch: 4 beats a second is easy to count, while a 4 hertz error inside 300 hertz is nearly impossible to hear directly.

Guess before revealing, and notice that two of the four options are numbers you can produce from 300 and 304 by an obvious operation. Only one of them is what a listener actually counts.

Sum to product gives a fast wave at the average of the two frequencies, 302 hertz, which is what you hear as the pitch. The envelope oscillates at half the difference, which is 2 hertz. But loudness follows the size of the envelope and ignores its sign, so the loudness peaks twice in every envelope cycle: 4 a second, exactly the difference of the two frequencies.

This is why tuning by ear works so well. A 4 hertz error inside a 300 hertz tone is a fifth of a semitone and very hard to hear as a pitch. As 4 throbs a second it is unmistakable, and as the string comes into tune the throbs slow down and stop, which gives the tuner an exact target rather than an approximate one.

55. Putting it together

Section

Part 6

56. Three amplitudes, one equation

Picture it

Figure (svg): Three small graphs side by side, each a fast oscillation inside a dashed envelope. In the first the envelope is a pair of horizontal lines, in the second a pair of curves closing in on zero, and in the third a pair of straight lines opening outwards.

The sine factor is identical in all three. Everything that separates free motion from friction and from resonance lives in the dashed envelope.

Cover the dashed curves and all three pictures become the same oscillation. That is the point of writing every case as an amplitude function times a single sine: the classification is entirely a question about one factor, and the factor is visible as the shape of the envelope.

Put your hand over the dashed curves in all three panels and the three pictures become much harder to tell apart, because the fast oscillation inside them is literally the same function. Take your hand away and the difference is instant.

That is the argument for writing every case in the same form. Classifying a motion is not a matter of recognising a whole graph; it is a matter of answering one question about one factor: does it stay put, shrink or grow.

It also tells you what to draw first when you sketch one of these by hand. Draw the envelope, then fill the oscillation in between the two curves, touching them at every turn. Trying to draw the wiggle first and fit an envelope around it afterwards almost never produces a usable picture.

57. The four kinds of motion

Comparison

Comparison matrix

kindamplitude functionwhat causes it
free undampedconstantno energy enters or leaves
dampeddecays to zerofriction removes energy
resonantgrows without bounddriven at the natural frequency
beatsa slow sinusoiddriven at a nearby frequency

Every row has the same sine factor and the same period for that factor. Only the middle column changes, and the right-hand column is the physical reason it changes.

Fill the three blanks from memory before checking, and then read the completed table across each row rather than down each column.

Read row by row and you get a cause and its signature: no energy exchange gives a flat envelope, friction gives a shrinking one, driving in step gives a growing one, driving nearly in step gives a slow sinusoidal one. That pairing of physical cause with envelope shape is the whole content of the second half of the lesson.

Read down the middle column and you get the diagnostic procedure instead. Given an expression, collapse it, look at the factor in front of the sine, and the row it matches tells you what is physically going on. That direction is the one an exam question will usually want.

58. The procedure, in order

Pattern

Figure (svg): A flow diagram. A weight and a measured stretch feed into two boxes, one giving the mass by dividing by g and one giving the spring constant by Hooke's law; both feed into a box computing the angular frequency. Separately the initial displacement and velocity feed into a box for the amplitude and a box for the phase. All three arrive at the equation of motion, from which a final branch classifies the amplitude as constant, decaying or growing.

The apparatus branch and the release branch never meet until the last box. That is the structure worth remembering, because it is why the period of a spring can be predicted before anything is set moving.
  1. Fix the sign convention first. Down is positive, up is negative, and a weight in pounds or newtons is not a mass.
  2. Get the apparatus numbers. Hooke's law on the measured stretch gives the spring constant; dividing the weight by g gives the mass; the square root of their quotient gives the angular frequency. The shortcut is the root of g over the stretch.
  3. Get the release numbers. The amplitude combines both initial conditions under a square root; the phase needs both conditions together, one to name two candidates and the other to choose between them.
  4. If the amplitude is not constant, factor it out, collapse the remaining cosine plus sine into one sine, and classify: decaying is damped, growing is resonant.
  5. If two different frequencies are added, the period comes from the ratio in lowest terms and the envelope comes from sum to product.

This is the order to work in for every problem in this section, and it runs from the decisions that are cheapest to get wrong invisibly to the ones that are most visible. The sign convention is first for exactly that reason.

The diagram shows the structure that makes the rest of the procedure make sense. Two chains run in parallel and never touch: the apparatus chain gives the angular frequency, and the release chain gives the amplitude and the phase. They meet only when the equation is finally written down.

The last two bullets are the second half of the lesson compressed. Any expression whose amplitude is not constant should be factored and collapsed before you say anything about it, and any sum of two different frequencies needs two separate calculations, one for the period and one for the envelope.

59. Check: the frequency from the apparatus

Check

Check your understanding

A 4 kilogram mass hangs from a spring whose constant is 36 newtons per metre. What is the angular frequency?

  • A. 9
  • B. 3 (correct)
  • C. 6
  • D. 144

Answer: B

Why: The angular frequency is the square root of the spring constant over the mass: 36 divided by 4 is 9, and the square root of 9 is 3 radians per second. The mass is already a mass here, so no division by g is needed.

Why A tempts people
That is the spring constant divided by the mass, with the square root left out.
Why C tempts people
That is the square root of 36, taken without dividing by the mass first.
Why D tempts people
That is the spring constant times the mass; the formula is a quotient, and it also needs a square root.

The quantity given here is already a mass, in kilograms, so this question is testing whether you convert out of habit rather than out of need. No division by g belongs anywhere in it.

The formula is a quotient under a square root, and each wrong option drops one of those two operations. Nine is the quotient without the root, six is the root without the quotient, and one hundred and forty-four is a product instead of a quotient.

60. Check: the amplitude from a release

Check

Check your understanding

An object with angular frequency 5 is released 12 units below equilibrium with a downward velocity of 45 units per second. What is the amplitude of the motion?

  • A. 12
  • B. 15 (correct)
  • C. 45
  • D. 57

Answer: B

Why: The velocity contributes the initial velocity divided by the angular frequency, which is 45 over 5, namely 9. Then the amplitude is the square root of 12 squared plus 9 squared, which is the square root of 225, namely 15.

Why A tempts people
That is the amplitude only if the object is released from rest; here it was given a push, which always increases the amplitude.
Why C tempts people
The initial velocity is not an amplitude, and it must be divided by the angular frequency before it can be combined with a displacement.
Why D tempts people
That adds 12 and 45 directly. The two contributions combine as the legs of a right triangle, not by addition.

Two steps, and the first is the one that is easy to skip. The initial velocity cannot be combined with a displacement directly; it must be divided by the angular frequency first, which turns 45 into 9.

After that it is a Pythagorean triple: twelve, nine, fifteen. If you answered 12 you treated the release as if it were from rest; if you answered 57 you added the two contributions instead of combining them as the legs of a right triangle.

61. Check: the period of a sum

Check

Check your understanding

What is the period of the sum of the sine of 2t and the sine of 3t?

  • A. π
  • B. 2π (correct)
  • C. 5π/3
  • D. 6π

Answer: B

Why: The frequencies are in the ratio two to three, so the slower piece completes 2 cycles while the faster completes 3. Two periods of the first piece is 2 times pi, which is two pi, and three periods of the second is 3 times two pi over 3, which is also two pi.

Why A tempts people
That is the period of the first piece alone; the second piece has not returned to its starting point going the same way after that long.
Why C tempts people
That adds the two periods, pi and two pi over three. A period of a sum is a common multiple, not a sum.
Why D tempts people
That is a common multiple, but not the smallest one: two pi already works, and a period is the shortest interval that does.

Reduce the ratio of the frequencies first: two to three is already in lowest terms, so the slower piece needs 2 cycles and the faster needs 3.

Two options here are traps of different kinds. Five thirds of pi is the sum of the two periods, which is never the right move. Six pi is a genuine common multiple and would make the function repeat, but it is three times longer than necessary, and a period is by definition the shortest interval that works.

62. Match each situation to its model

Matching

Match the pairs

  • a. a mass on a spring in a vacuum, given one pull
  • b. the same mass bouncing in air
  • c. a child pumping a swing in time with its own rhythm
  • d. two tuning forks a few hertz apart, struck together
  • w. free undamped: the amplitude function is constant
  • x. damped: the amplitude function decays toward zero
  • y. resonance: the amplitude function grows without bound
  • z. beats: a slow envelope multiplying a fast wave

Why: The four cases differ only in what is happening to the energy. In a vacuum nothing removes it, so the amplitude is constant. Air removes it, so the amplitude decays. Pumping in time adds it every cycle, so the amplitude grows. Two nearby frequencies neither add nor remove energy overall; they take turns reinforcing and cancelling, which is the slow envelope.

Match all four before checking. Each pairing is really a question about energy, so decide for each situation whether energy is being added, removed, or neither.

In a vacuum nothing removes energy, so the swings stay the same size. In air, friction removes a little on every pass, so they shrink. A child pumping in time with the swing adds energy on every cycle, which is resonance in the most familiar possible form.

The tuning forks are the odd one out, and it is worth being precise about why. No energy is being added to or taken from the system overall; the two tones simply take turns reinforcing and cancelling each other. That is why beats swell and fade rather than growing or dying, and why the envelope is itself a sinusoid.

63. Explain why the frequency never changes

Explain it to yourself

Discussion prompt

Across all four cases in this lesson the underlying frequency was the same, and only the amplitude changed. In two or three sentences, explain how you can tell that from the formula alone, and describe the one measurement you would make on a graph to test it.

Write your two or three sentences before revealing. Being able to say this out loud is a good test of whether the second half of the lesson has landed, because it is the one fact that is common to all four cases.

The structural argument is that the amplitude function is a multiplier sitting outside the sine. A multiplier can stretch a curve vertically, it can flip it, it can squash it toward the axis, but it cannot move the places where the sine itself is zero, and those places are what fix the frequency.

The experimental argument is a single measurement repeated twice. Measure the spacing between two crossings of the horizontal axis near the start of the graph, then measure it again near the end. The peaks will look completely different; the spacings will be identical.

64. Exit ticket

Exit ticket

An object weighing 24 pounds stretches a spring 2 feet. It is released 4 feet below equilibrium with a downward velocity of 12 feet per second.

Discussion prompt

Find the angular frequency, the amplitude and the phase, write the equation of motion, and give the period. State which quadrant the phase lies in and why.

This combines everything in the lesson into one problem. Work it fully before revealing: apparatus first, then amplitude, then phase, then the equation and the period.

The signs are both positive this time, which is the one combination the worked examples did not cover. Below equilibrium is positive and downward is positive, so both the sine and the cosine of the phase come out positive and the phase sits in the first quadrant, where arcsine reaches it directly and no subtraction is needed.

Finish with the check that the worked examples all used: substitute zero into your own formula and confirm you get the stated release position, then differentiate and confirm you get the stated release velocity. If both agree, the phase is right, and if either is wrong it is almost always the phase that is at fault.

65. Recap

Recap

what you are givenyour first move
a weight in pounds or newtonsdivide by g to get the mass
a spring stretches so far at equilibriumHooke's law gives the spring constant, or take the root of g over the stretch
released from restthe amplitude is the size of the initial displacement, and the phase is a quarter turn
released with a velocitycombine both conditions for the amplitude, then use both again for the phase
an amplitude that depends on timefactor it out, collapse the rest into one sine, then classify the factor
two different frequencies addedratio in lowest terms for the period, sum to product for the envelope

\[ x(t) = A(t)\sin(\omega t + \phi), \qquad \omega = \sqrt{\frac{k}{m}} = \sqrt{\frac{g}{d}} \]

Sinusoids finish here. Sections 11.2 and 11.3 leave them entirely and go back to triangles, but this time to triangles with no right angle, which neither the unit circle nor the right-triangle ratios can solve on their own.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids §11.1, pp. 885-892 — everything on these slides traces back here

OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §8.1 Graphs of the Sine and Cosine Functions §8.1 — the same amplitude, period and phase vocabulary, from a second angle

Two ideas carry the lesson. The first is that the frequency belongs to the apparatus and the amplitude and phase belong to the release, and that these two halves never interfere. The second is that every departure from the ideal, whether it is friction or driving, shows up in the amplitude and nowhere else.

The table is the one to keep beside you while doing exercises, because it is organised by what the problem tells you rather than by what you have to find. Most errors in this section happen in the first line of the solution, not the last, and the first line is what the table is about.

Take the phase seriously between now and the next assessment. It is the only part of the lesson that needs two conditions held in mind at once, and it is where the marks go missing. Everything else here is one formula applied once.

Sources

  1. Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 11 Applications of Trigonometry — §11.1 Applications of Sinusoids — Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Version 3 Corrected Edition, July 4 2013, pp. 885-891
  2. OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §8.1 Graphs of the Sine and Cosine Functions

Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Trigonometry — $55/session, free consultation.

Book on Wyzant · Text (657) 465-8108