10.3b Right Triangle Trigonometry and Angles of Elevation

All six circular functions lifted off the unit circle: expressed as ratios of x, y and r for any point on the terminal side, and as ratios of the three sides of a right triangle of any size. Covers reconstructing a point from a single function value plus a quadrant, the angle of inclination and the classic one- and two-sighting height problems, and closes with the domains and ranges of all six functions including the extended interval notation the book uses to write them.

Subject: Trigonometry · 70 slides · symbolic lesson

Open the interactive version of this deck

What this lesson covers

The lesson, slide by slide

1. Right Triangle Trigonometry and Angles of Elevation

Title

Trigonometry · Section 10.3b

The six circular functions, lifted off the unit circle

2. What this lesson gives you

Objectives

Lesson 10.3a defined the six circular functions on the unit circle, where the radius is one. Almost nothing in the world has radius one. This lesson lifts all six off that circle and puts them to work on real triangles.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, pp. 752-760 — Theorems 10.9, 10.10 and 10.11, Examples 10.3.4 and 10.3.5

Everything so far has lived on the unit circle, where the distance from the origin is one and the coordinates of a point are the cosine and the sine themselves. That is a beautiful place to define the functions and a useless place to apply them, because almost nothing you will ever measure has a radius of one.

This lesson does the lifting. The same six functions are rewritten as ratios of the two coordinates of any point on the terminal side and its distance from the origin, and then rewritten again as ratios of the three sides of a right triangle of any size. Nothing new is defined. Every formula you meet here is one of last lesson's identities with the fractions cleared.

Two payoffs follow. The first is that a single given value plus a quadrant is enough to recover all six, which is the standard exam question. The second is that surveying problems, the height of a tower or a tree measured from the ground, become one-line applications. The lesson closes by collecting the domains and ranges of all six, which is what tells you when an equation has no solutions at all.

3. What you can already do with a point

Warm-up

Discussion prompt

The terminal side of an angle, plotted in standard position, passes through the point with coordinates 3 and negative 4. From Lesson 10.2 you can already find the cosine and the sine. Write both down, and then say what you would need in order to get the tangent and the secant as well.

Write your answer down before revealing anything. This takes thirty seconds and it tells you exactly how much of this lesson is genuinely new, which is less than you probably expect.

The radius comes from the distance formula, and then the cosine and sine are the two coordinates divided by it. That much was Theorem 10.3 in the last lesson. For the other four you do not need any new definition, because Lesson 10.3a already gave you the quotient and reciprocal identities: tangent is sine over cosine, secant is one over cosine, and so on.

What this lesson adds is the observation that those combinations simplify beautifully. When you divide sine by cosine, the radius appears on the top and the bottom and cancels, leaving one coordinate over the other. When you turn the cosine upside down, you get the radius over a coordinate. Those simplified forms are Theorem 10.9, and they save you from ever building a complex fraction again.

4. Beyond the unit circle

Section

Part 1

5. Where the four new formulas come from

Concept

Figure (svg): A coordinate plane with a dashed circle of radius r about the origin. A ray from the origin meets the circle at a point Q, and a vertical dashed line drops from Q to the horizontal axis, making a right triangle whose horizontal leg is marked x, vertical leg y and slanted side r.

Three lengths live in this picture: the two coordinates and the distance r. Every one of the six circular functions is one of them divided by another.

Lesson 10.2 already generalised the first two: for a point on the terminal side at distance r from the origin, the cosine is the first coordinate over r and the sine is the second coordinate over r. Feed that into the reciprocal identity.

\[ \sec(\theta) = \frac{1}{\cos(\theta)} = \frac{1}{\,x/r\,} = \frac{r}{x} \]

\[ \tan(\theta) = \frac{\sin(\theta)}{\cos(\theta)} = \frac{\,y/r\,}{\,x/r\,} = \frac{y}{x} \]

The radius cancels out of the tangent entirely. Doing the same for the other two gives the whole of Theorem 10.9, and every one of the six is now a ratio of two of the three lengths in the picture.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 752 — Theorem 10.9

Look at the picture first. Three lengths appear: the horizontal leg, the vertical leg, and the slanted side from the origin to the point. The horizontal leg is the first coordinate, the vertical leg is the second, and the slanted side is the radius. Everything in this lesson is one of those divided by another.

The derivation on the slide is worth doing yourself rather than reading. Write the reciprocal identity for secant, substitute the coordinate form of cosine into it, and simplify the complex fraction. One over a fraction is the fraction flipped, so one over the first coordinate over the radius is the radius over the first coordinate. The tangent is the same trick with a quotient instead of a reciprocal, and the two radii cancel.

That cancellation is the thing to notice. Tangent and cotangent involve no radius at all. It means they are unchanged by how far out along the ray you go, and it also means they can be any size whatever, because neither coordinate is forced to be the larger. Both of those facts return later in the lesson.

6. Reading Theorem 10.9 piece by piece

Notation

Annotate

On: \( \sec\theta = \tfrac{r}{x}, \;\; \csc\theta = \tfrac{r}{y}, \;\; \tan\theta = \tfrac{y}{x}, \;\; \cot\theta = \tfrac{x}{y} \)

  • The distance from the origin to the point, the positive square root of x squared plus y squared. It is a length, so it is never negative, whatever quadrant the point is in.
  • The actual coordinates, signs included. All the sign information in all six answers enters here and nowhere else.
  • Secant and tangent both divide by x, so both are undefined when the point sits on the vertical axis. Theorem 10.9 states that proviso explicitly.
  • Cosecant and cotangent divide by y, so both are undefined when the point sits on the horizontal axis.
  • Nothing here requires r to be 1. Set r equal to 1 and you get the unit-circle definitions of Lesson 10.3a back again.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 752 — Theorem 10.9 and its provisos

Step through the annotations in order and keep the picture from the previous slide in view. The single most important one is the note about the radius: it is a distance, and distances are never negative. Students lose more marks to a negative radius in this section than to anything else.

The two provisos are not fine print. Secant and tangent share a denominator, so they fail together, at every angle whose terminal side is vertical. Cosecant and cotangent share the other denominator, so they fail together, at every angle whose terminal side is horizontal. Committing that pairing to memory now will make the last part of the lesson feel like revision.

Finally, notice what happens if you set the radius equal to one. Secant becomes one over the first coordinate, cosecant one over the second, and the two quotients are unchanged. The unit-circle definitions you learned last lesson are the special case, not a different theory.

7. Any point on the ray gives the same six numbers

Intuition

Figure (svg): One ray from the origin carrying two points, a near one and a far one. Each has its own right triangle down to the horizontal axis; the far triangle is an enlargement of the near one, and the two pairs of legs are in the same proportion.

Two points on one ray give two similar triangles. Every ratio of two sides is the same in both, which is why you may choose whichever point is convenient.

Two points on one terminal side make two right triangles that are similar, because they share the angle at the origin and both have a right angle at the foot. Similar triangles have proportional sides, so every ratio of two sides is the same in both.

\[ \frac{y_1}{x_1} = \frac{y_2}{x_2}, \qquad \frac{x_1}{r_1} = \frac{x_2}{r_2}, \qquad \frac{r_1}{y_1} = \frac{r_2}{y_2} \]

That is a licence you will use constantly: when a problem gives you a ratio instead of a point, you may choose whichever point on the ray makes the arithmetic easiest.

This slide is the licence for everything in Part 2, so do not skim it. Two points on the same terminal side give two right triangles that share the angle at the origin and both have a right angle at the foot of the vertical. Two equal angles makes them similar, and similar triangles have sides in the same proportion.

In the picture the near point has legs of two and one and a bit, and the far point has legs of four and a half and just under three. Neither pair of numbers matters. What matters is that the second coordinate divided by the first is the same in both, and so is every other ratio you can form.

The practical consequence is enormous. When a problem gives you a tangent of three quarters, it has not told you where the point is, only what the ratio is. You are free to choose the point with coordinates three and four, or six and eight, or anything else on the ray, and every choice produces the same six answers. Choose the one with the smallest whole numbers and the arithmetic stays clean.

8. Example 10.3.4(1): all six from the point (3, −4)

Worked example

The terminal side of an angle, plotted in standard position, contains this point. Find the values of the six circular functions.

\[ Q(3, -4) \]

Compute the radius

Why: The radius is the distance from the origin to the point, and a distance is taken positive.

\[ r = \sqrt{x^2 + y^2} = \sqrt{3^2 + (-4)^2} = \sqrt{25} = 5 \]

Divide each coordinate by the radius

Why: That gives the two functions with r underneath.

\[ \cos(\theta) = \frac{x}{r} = \frac{3}{5}, \qquad \sin(\theta) = \frac{y}{r} = -\frac{4}{5} \]

Turn each of those upside down

Why: Secant is r over x and cosecant is r over y.

\[ \sec(\theta) = \frac{r}{x} = \frac{5}{3}, \qquad \csc(\theta) = \frac{r}{y} = -\frac{5}{4} \]

Divide the coordinates by each other

Why: Tangent is y over x, cotangent is x over y, and the radius never appears.

\[ \tan(\theta) = \frac{y}{x} = -\frac{4}{3}, \qquad \cot(\theta) = \frac{x}{y} = -\frac{3}{4} \]

Figure (svg): A coordinate plane with a dashed circle of radius 5. The point 3 comma negative 4 sits in the fourth quadrant, joined to the origin by a segment of length 5, with a horizontal leg of 3 and a vertical leg of 4 completing a right triangle below the axis.

Only cosine and secant come out positive here, because only the horizontal coordinate is positive and the radius never is negative.

Check every reciprocal pair multiplies to one

Why: The point is right of the vertical axis and below the horizontal one, so the angle is in quadrant four, where only cosine and secant are positive; that is exactly the pattern above.

\[ \frac{3}{5}\cdot\frac{5}{3} = 1, \quad \left(-\frac{4}{5}\right)\left(-\frac{5}{4}\right) = 1, \quad \left(-\frac{4}{3}\right)\left(-\frac{3}{4}\right) = 1 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 753 — Example 10.3.4, number 1

This is the model solution for the whole of Part 1, and it has a rhythm worth copying: radius first, then three divisions, then three reciprocals. Do the radius before you look at any of the six, because it is the one number every other line depends on.

Notice how little thinking the signs require. You never ask yourself which quadrant this is or which functions are positive there. You simply divide the actual coordinates, minus signs included, and the signs look after themselves. The quadrant only comes back at the end, as a check.

That check is the habit to build. Look at the picture: the point is to the right and below, so the angle is a fourth-quadrant angle, where cosine and secant should be the only positive values. They are. A second free check is that each reciprocal pair multiplies to one, which catches a flipped fraction instantly. Both checks together take about ten seconds and they catch nearly every slip you can make here.

9. Move the point further out along the same ray

Prediction

\[ (2, 3) \;\longrightarrow\; (4, 6) \]

Predict first

The point on the terminal side is replaced by one twice as far from the origin. What happens to the six values?

  • All six double
  • All six are halved
  • All six are unchanged
  • Cosine and sine are unchanged, the other four double

Correct: All six are unchanged

Why: Doubling the point doubles x, doubles y and doubles the radius as well, so every one of the six ratios has the same factor of two on the top and the bottom. This is the similar-triangle argument in numbers, and it is the reason you are free to pick a convenient point later in the lesson.

\[ \frac{2y}{2x} = \frac{y}{x}, \qquad \frac{2r}{2x} = \frac{r}{x}, \qquad \frac{2x}{2r} = \frac{x}{r} \]

Commit to one of the four options before revealing. Most people who get this wrong pick the first, because doubling something usually doubles something else.

The reason nothing changes is that all three lengths double together, not just the two coordinates. The radius is computed from the coordinates, so if both are doubled the radius is doubled too, and every one of the six ratios has a factor of two on the top and the bottom.

If you picked the last option, you were half right in spirit: you noticed that cosine and sine involve the radius and the quotients do not. But the radius scaling is what saves them. Try it with real numbers if you are not convinced: the point two and three has radius the square root of thirteen, and the point four and six has radius twice that.

10. Three lengths, three kinds of ratio

Concept

The radius is the hypotenuse of the little triangle, so it is at least as large as either coordinate in absolute value. That single fact sorts the six functions into three pairs that behave completely differently.

pairformwhat its size must be
cosine and sinecoordinate over rat most 1, because r is the largest
secant and cosecantr over a coordinateat least 1, for the same reason
tangent and cotangentcoordinate over coordinateany real number at all, since either can be the larger

\[ |x| \le r \text{ and } |y| \le r \;\Longrightarrow\; |\cos| \le 1, \;\; |\sec| \ge 1 \]

Keep that table in mind. In the last part of the lesson it turns into the official statement of the six ranges, and it is what makes some equations unsolvable.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 752 — Theorem 10.9 read against Theorem 10.3

This table is short but it does a lot of work later, so read it slowly. The radius is the hypotenuse of the little triangle, and a hypotenuse is always the longest side, so neither coordinate can be larger than the radius in absolute value.

Follow the three consequences. Put the radius underneath and the result is at most one in size, which is why cosine and sine are bounded. Put the radius on top and the result is at least one in size, which is why secant and cosecant can never be small. Leave the radius out altogether and there is no constraint at all, because either coordinate may be the larger.

Those three sentences are the ranges of all six functions, stated informally. In Part 5 they become Theorem 10.11, and the middle one is what makes some equations impossible to solve. If you understand the table now, that part of the lesson will cost you almost no new effort.

11. Tangent is the slope of the terminal side

Concept

Figure (svg): A ray from the origin rising to the right through the point 4 comma 3, with a dashed horizontal run of 4 and a dashed vertical rise of 3 drawn beneath it, and the whole line continued into the third quadrant.

Tangent is the only one of the six that uses neither the radius nor anything but the two coordinates, so it is exactly the slope of the terminal side.

The tangent is the second coordinate over the first, and that is exactly the rise over the run of the line through the origin and the point. So the tangent of an angle in standard position is the slope of its terminal side.

\[ m = \frac{\text{rise}}{\text{run}} = \frac{y - 0}{x - 0} = \frac{y}{x} = \tan(\theta) \]

This is worth holding on to for two reasons. It explains why every point on the ray gives the same tangent, and it tells you that a vertical terminal side, which has no slope, is precisely where the tangent fails to exist.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 753 — footnote 6, on the terminal side as a line

You have known this since your first algebra course without knowing it was trigonometry. The slope of a line through the origin is the second coordinate over the first, and that is precisely the tangent of the angle it makes with the positive horizontal direction.

Two things follow immediately. First, the tangent is the same for every point on the ray, because slope does not depend on which two points of a line you use. That is the similar-triangle argument arriving from a completely different direction, which is a good sign that it is true.

Second, and more useful, a vertical line has no slope, and correspondingly the tangent has no value when the terminal side is vertical. The failure of the tangent at a quarter turn is not an arbitrary exclusion; it is the same fact as the undefined slope of a vertical line. Whenever you are asked why the tangent is undefined somewhere, the slope picture gives you a one-sentence answer.

12. The quadrant decides every sign

Picture it

Figure (svg): A coordinate plane divided into its four quadrants, each labelled with the signs of the two coordinates and with the circular functions that are positive there: all six in the first, sine and cosecant in the second, tangent and cotangent in the third, cosine and secant in the fourth.

The radius is positive in every quadrant, so the sign of each of the six values is decided entirely by the signs of the two coordinates.

Because the radius is positive, each of the six values takes its sign from the coordinates alone. In the second quadrant the first coordinate is negative and the second positive, so only the pair built from the second coordinate over the radius survives with a plus sign.

Study the four corners of this picture rather than memorising a mnemonic. In every quadrant the radius is positive, so the sign of each value is decided by the two coordinates alone, and the only question is how many minus signs end up in each fraction.

In the first quadrant both coordinates are positive, so no fraction has any minus sign, and all six are positive. In the second, only the second coordinate is positive, so the only positive values are the two that pair the second coordinate with the radius, namely sine and cosecant. In the third both coordinates are negative, so the two fractions that divide one coordinate by the other have two minus signs and come out positive: tangent and cotangent. In the fourth, only the first coordinate is positive, so cosine and secant survive.

Notice that the positive pairs always come in twos, because reciprocals always share a sign. That means you only ever have to remember which one function is positive in each quadrant; its partner comes free.

13. Sort the six by sign in quadrant three

Sorting

An angle has its terminal side through a point whose two coordinates are both negative.

Sort into buckets

Which of the six circular functions are positive at such an angle, and which are negative?

Positive
tangent = y / x; cotangent = x / y
Negative
cosine = x / r; sine = y / r; secant = r / x; cosecant = r / y
pos
Tangent and cotangent divide one coordinate by the other. Two negatives divide to a positive, so these are the only two that survive in quadrant three.
neg
The other four all have the positive radius in one position and a negative coordinate in the other, so each comes out negative.

Sort all six before checking. The fastest way is not to recall a rule but to write each function as its fraction and count the minus signs, exactly as the previous slide did.

Four of the six pair a coordinate with the radius. The radius is positive and both coordinates are negative here, so each of those four fractions carries exactly one minus sign and comes out negative. The remaining two divide one negative coordinate by the other, so they carry two minus signs and come out positive.

If you find yourself hesitating on secant or cosecant, use the reciprocal shortcut. A number and its reciprocal always have the same sign, so secant must match cosine and cosecant must match sine. Once you have decided about cosine and sine, four of the six answers are already settled.

14. A terminal side along an axis: Q(0, −2)

Worked example

Theorem 10.9 attaches a proviso to four of the six formulas. Here is what those provisos are protecting against.

\[ Q(0, -2) \]

Compute the radius

Why: One coordinate is zero, so the distance is just the size of the other.

\[ r = \sqrt{0^2 + (-2)^2} = 2 \]

Divide each coordinate by the radius

Why: Cosine and sine are untroubled: the radius is never zero.

\[ \cos(\theta) = \frac{0}{2} = 0, \qquad \sin(\theta) = \frac{-2}{2} = -1 \]

Try to reciprocate the cosine

Why: Secant is r over x, and x here is zero.

\[ \sec(\theta) = \frac{2}{0} \quad \text{undefined} \]

Reciprocate the sine

Why: Cosecant is r over y, and y is not zero.

\[ \csc(\theta) = \frac{2}{-2} = -1 \]

Divide the coordinates both ways

Why: Tangent divides by x and fails; cotangent divides by y and does not.

\[ \tan(\theta) = \frac{-2}{0} \quad\text{undefined}, \qquad \cot(\theta) = \frac{0}{-2} = 0 \]

Check against the angle itself

Why: The point is straight down from the origin, so one angle with this terminal side is three quarters of a turn; the cosine there is zero, and any function with a cosine in its denominator must fail at that angle.

\[ \theta = \frac{3\pi}{2}: \quad \cos(\theta) = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \sec(\theta), \tan(\theta) \text{ undefined} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 752 — the provisos in Theorem 10.9

This is the slide that turns the provisos of Theorem 10.9 from small print into something you can picture. The point sits straight below the origin, so its first coordinate is zero, and every formula with that coordinate underneath collapses.

Work through which ones survive. Cosine and sine are fine, because the radius is never zero and it is the one underneath. Cosecant is fine, because it divides by the second coordinate, which is not zero. Cotangent is fine, and in fact equals zero, because zero divided by a nonzero number is perfectly respectable. Only secant and tangent fail, and they fail together, exactly as the pairing on the notation slide predicted.

The check at the end connects this to something you already know. The angle with this terminal side is three quarters of a turn, and you learned last lesson that the cosine there is zero. Any function with a cosine in its denominator must be undefined at that angle. This is the whole of Part 5 in miniature, arrived at from a single point.

15. Trap: letting the radius carry a sign

Trap

The trap

A point in the third quadrant, and a plausible-looking line:

\[ (-3, -4) \]

\[ r = -5 \]

\[ \cos(\theta) = \frac{-3}{-5} = \frac{3}{5} \]

Wrong. The cosine of a third-quadrant angle cannot be positive.

The fix

The radius is a distance, so it is the positive square root and nothing else. Every minus sign in the six answers has to come from a coordinate.

\[ r = \sqrt{(-3)^2+(-4)^2} = 5 \]

\[ \cos(\theta) = -\frac{3}{5} \]

The instinct to make r negative usually comes from wanting a particular answer. Compute r first, before you look at any of the six, and the temptation never arises.

This mistake almost always appears in the reconstruction problems of Part 2, where you are choosing the lengths yourself rather than reading them off a point. The temptation is to make the radius negative because you want the final answer to come out negative, and the arithmetic obliges.

Hold on to the meaning instead of the algebra. The radius is how far the point is from the origin. There is no such thing as being minus five units away from something. When you compute it as a square root, you take the positive root, always, and the plus or minus that usually accompanies a square root does not apply.

The practical defence is ordering. Compute the radius as the very first line, before you have any opinion about what the answers should look like. Then give the coordinates their signs from the quadrant. If you follow that order the temptation never arises, because by the time you care about signs the radius is already written down and positive.

16. Reconstructing a point from one value

Section

Part 2

17. Read the value as a ratio, then invent the point

Concept

Problems usually run the other way round: you are told one function value and a quadrant, and asked for the other five. Theorem 10.9 says every value is a ratio of two of x, y and r, so a given value tells you what two of those three are, up to a common factor.

\[ \cot(\theta) = -4 = \frac{-4}{1} = \frac{4}{-1} = \frac{8}{-2} = \cdots \]

Because every point on the ray gives the same six numbers, you may take the simplest of those splittings. The only real decision is which of the two parts gets the minus sign, and the quadrant makes that decision for you.

  1. Write the given value as a fraction, and name each part using Theorem 10.9.
  2. Give the coordinates the signs the quadrant demands. The radius stays positive.
  3. Compute the missing third length from the other two.
  4. Read off all six ratios, rationalising any surd in a denominator.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 753 — the method of Example 10.3.4, number 2

This is the reverse of Part 1 and it is where almost every exercise in the book lives, so the four-step list is worth learning as a routine rather than reinvented each time.

The key realisation is that a given value is a ratio, and a ratio can be split into a numerator and a denominator in infinitely many ways. Negative four is four over negative one, and also negative four over one, and also eight over negative two. The previous part showed that all points on one ray give the same six values, so any of those splittings that lands you on the right ray will do.

The word right is doing the work there. Only the quadrant tells you which of the two sign patterns you need, and it is the only genuinely error-prone step in the whole routine. Write the quadrant down before you write the coordinates, decide there and then whether each coordinate is positive or negative, and then choose the splitting that matches. The error-analysis slide that follows shows what happens when you do it the other way round.

18. Example 10.3.4(2): a cotangent of −4 in quadrant four

Worked example

Find the values of the five remaining circular functions.

\[ \cot(\theta) = -4, \qquad \theta \text{ in Quadrant IV} \]

Read the cotangent as a ratio of coordinates

Why: Theorem 10.9 says cotangent is x over y, so any point on the terminal side has that quotient.

\[ \frac{x}{y} = -4 \]

Put the minus sign where quadrant four wants it

Why: There the first coordinate is positive and the second negative, so write the four on top and the minus underneath.

\[ -4 = \frac{4}{-1} \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 4, \;\; y = -1 \]

Compute the radius

Why: Sixteen plus one is seventeen, which is not a perfect square.

\[ r = \sqrt{4^2 + (-1)^2} = \sqrt{17} \]

Divide by the radius and rationalise

Why: Multiply the top and bottom of each by the root.

\[ \cos(\theta) = \frac{4}{\sqrt{17}} = \frac{4\sqrt{17}}{17}, \qquad \sin(\theta) = \frac{-1}{\sqrt{17}} = -\frac{\sqrt{17}}{17} \]

Reciprocate for secant and cosecant

Why: Here the root ends up on top, so nothing needs rationalising.

\[ \sec(\theta) = \frac{\sqrt{17}}{4}, \qquad \csc(\theta) = -\sqrt{17} \]

Reciprocate the given cotangent

Why: Tangent and cotangent are a reciprocal pair.

\[ \tan(\theta) = \frac{y}{x} = -\frac{1}{4} \]

Figure (svg): A coordinate plane with a ray going down and to the right into the fourth quadrant, passing through the point 4 comma negative 1 and continuing to 8 comma negative 2, with the right triangle for the nearer point drawn in.

Both marked points lie on the same ray, so both give a cotangent of negative four and both give the same five remaining values.

Check with a different point on the same ray

Why: Taking eight and negative two gives the same cotangent, and after the larger radius the same cosine, exactly as the similar-triangle argument promised.

\[ r = \sqrt{68} = 2\sqrt{17}, \qquad \frac{x}{r} = \frac{8}{2\sqrt{17}} = \frac{4}{\sqrt{17}} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 753 — Example 10.3.4, number 2

Follow the logic of the second step carefully, because that is where the problem is really solved. Cotangent is the first coordinate over the second. Quadrant four means the first coordinate is positive and the second negative. So the minus sign in the given value has to belong to the denominator, and negative four must be read as four over negative one, not as negative four over one.

After that the work is mechanical. The radius comes out as the square root of seventeen, which does not simplify, so you will be rationalising. Rationalising is not optional here; the book's answers are written with no root in any denominator, and so are most answer keys you will meet.

The check is the most instructive part of the slide. Taking the point eight and negative two instead gives a radius of two root seventeen, and when you divide eight by that you get four over root seventeen again. This is the similar-triangle argument turning into arithmetic in front of you, and it is a good check to run whenever you doubt whether your choice of point was allowed.

19. Find the error: signs that contradict the quadrant

Error analysis

A student is given the same cotangent of negative four, but with the angle in quadrant two.

Annotate

On: \( \cot\theta = -4 = \tfrac{4}{-1} \;\Rightarrow\; x = 4,\; y = -1,\; \sin\theta = -\tfrac{\sqrt{17}}{17} \)

  • Quadrant two has a negative first coordinate. Taking x positive puts the point in quadrant four, which is a different angle entirely.
  • Quadrant two has a positive second coordinate. Both signs have been chosen backwards, which is why the quotient still came out right.
  • A ratio of negative four is produced by two different sign patterns. The value alone cannot tell them apart; only the quadrant can.
  • Write the value as negative four over one instead: x is minus four and y is one. Then the radius is still root seventeen, but the sine comes out positive, as every quadrant two angle demands.

\[ \text{Quadrant II}: \quad x = -4, \; y = 1, \; r = \sqrt{17}, \; \sin(\theta) = \frac{\sqrt{17}}{17} \]

Read the line and try to spot the problem before opening the annotations. The value is right, the radius is right, and the arithmetic is right, which is what makes this error so hard to catch in your own work.

What has gone wrong is that both coordinates were given the signs of quadrant four while the problem said quadrant two. Because both were wrong together, their quotient still came out as negative four, so nothing in the working looks suspicious. Only the final signs give it away: a second-quadrant angle must have a positive sine, and this one does not.

The lesson is about the order of decisions. Do not read the given value and let it suggest a splitting. Read the quadrant first, write down the two signs the coordinates must have, and only then split the value to match. And when you finish, check the sign of at least one answer against the quadrant, exactly as the worked examples do.

20. Exercise 22: a tangent of 12 over 5 in quadrant three

Worked example

\[ \tan(\theta) = \frac{12}{5}, \qquad \theta \text{ in Quadrant III} \]

Read the tangent as y over x

Why: Theorem 10.9 again, this time the other quotient.

\[ \frac{y}{x} = \frac{12}{5} \]

Make both coordinates negative, as quadrant three requires

Why: Two minus signs cancel in a quotient, so the tangent is unchanged by the choice.

\[ x = -5, \;\; y = -12 \;\Longrightarrow\; \frac{-12}{-5} = \frac{12}{5} \]

Compute the radius

Why: Twenty-five plus one hundred and forty-four is one hundred and sixty-nine.

\[ r = \sqrt{(-5)^2 + (-12)^2} = \sqrt{169} = 13 \]

Divide the coordinates by the radius

Why: Both come out negative, as quadrant three demands.

\[ \cos(\theta) = -\frac{5}{13}, \qquad \sin(\theta) = -\frac{12}{13} \]

Reciprocate all three

Why: Secant, cosecant and cotangent in one sweep.

\[ \sec(\theta) = -\frac{13}{5}, \quad \csc(\theta) = -\frac{13}{12}, \quad \cot(\theta) = \frac{5}{12} \]

Check with the Pythagorean identity

Why: The squares of the cosine and the sine must add to one, which is the Pythagorean theorem for the little triangle divided through by the radius squared.

\[ \frac{25}{169} + \frac{144}{169} = \frac{169}{169} = 1 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 759 — Exercise 22

This exercise looks easier than the last one and there is a small trap hiding in that. The given tangent is positive, so you might be tempted to take both coordinates positive and be done. But a positive tangent happens in two quadrants, the first and the third, and the problem told you which.

In quadrant three both coordinates are negative, and since two minus signs cancel in a quotient, the tangent comes out positive as required. That is why the tangent alone could never have told you which quadrant you were in. The quadrant is genuinely extra information, not a decoration on the problem.

The final check is a new one, and it is the most useful check in this whole part. Squaring the cosine and the sine and adding them must give one, by the first Pythagorean identity from Lesson 10.3a. It catches a wrong radius, a mis-copied coordinate, and an arithmetic slip, all at once, and it costs two squarings.

21. Exercise 24: fill the middle of a secant reconstruction

Fill the middle

The angle lies in quadrant four and its secant is seven. Fill in the three missing pieces of the reconstruction.

Fill in the blanks

\sec\theta = 7 \;\Rightarrow\; x = 1, \; r = 7, \; y^2 = 49-1 = 48, \; y = -4\sqrt{3}

Why: Secant is r over x, so seven over one names the radius as 7 and the first coordinate as 1. Then y squared is 49 minus 1, which is 48, and the square root of 48 is 4 root 3. Quadrant four forces the second coordinate to be negative, which is why the minus sign is already printed in front of the blank.

\[ \cos(\theta) = \frac{1}{7}, \qquad \sin(\theta) = -\frac{4\sqrt3}{7}, \qquad \tan(\theta) = -4\sqrt3 \]

\[ \sec(\theta) = 7, \qquad \csc(\theta) = -\frac{7\sqrt3}{12}, \qquad \cot(\theta) = -\frac{\sqrt3}{12} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 759 — Exercise 24

Fill all three blanks before checking any of them. The structure is deliberately the same as the two worked examples you have just seen, so if you can complete this you have the routine.

The first blank is the easiest step of the whole problem and the one people most often overthink. Secant is the radius over the first coordinate, and seven is seven over one, so the radius is seven and the first coordinate is one. Once those are down, the second coordinate comes from the circle equation rather than from the given value.

The third blank wants the square root of forty-eight in simplest form. Forty-eight is sixteen times three, so the root is four times the root of three. The minus sign is already printed for you, because quadrant four forces the second coordinate to be negative, and the last line of the slide shows what the five other values become once that coordinate is in place.

22. Exercise 25: a cosecant that has already been rationalised

Worked example

\[ \csc(\theta) = -\frac{10\sqrt{91}}{91}, \qquad \theta \text{ in Quadrant III} \]

Undo the rationalisation

Why: Ninety-one is the root of ninety-one times itself, so one factor cancels.

\[ -\frac{10\sqrt{91}}{91} = -\frac{10\sqrt{91}}{\sqrt{91}\cdot\sqrt{91}} = -\frac{10}{\sqrt{91}} \]

Read the cosecant as r over y

Why: The radius must be the positive part, so the minus sign belongs to the second coordinate.

\[ \frac{r}{y} = \frac{10}{-\sqrt{91}} \;\Longrightarrow\; r = 10, \;\; y = -\sqrt{91} \]

Recover the first coordinate from the radius

Why: Rearrange the equation of the circle.

\[ x^2 = r^2 - y^2 = 100 - 91 = 9 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = \pm 3 \]

Choose the sign from the quadrant

Why: In quadrant three the first coordinate is negative.

\[ x = -3 \]

Read off the five remaining values

Why: Each is a ratio of two of the three lengths.

\[ \cos(\theta) = -\frac{3}{10}, \qquad \sin(\theta) = -\frac{\sqrt{91}}{10}, \qquad \sec(\theta) = -\frac{10}{3} \]

Finish with the two quotients

Why: Both coordinates are negative, so both of these are positive.

\[ \tan(\theta) = \frac{-\sqrt{91}}{-3} = \frac{\sqrt{91}}{3}, \qquad \cot(\theta) = \frac{3\sqrt{91}}{91} \]

Check that the given value comes back

Why: Recomputing the cosecant from the point must return the number the problem started with.

\[ \frac{r}{y} = \frac{10}{-\sqrt{91}} = -\frac{10\sqrt{91}}{91} \approx -1.048 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 759 — Exercise 25

This is the hardest of the reconstruction exercises, and the difficulty is entirely in the first step. The given value has already been rationalised, which is how answer keys print things, but it is the wrong form for reading off lengths. Undo it before doing anything else.

The undoing uses the fact that ninety-one is the square root of ninety-one multiplied by itself. Cancel one factor from the top and the bottom and you are left with ten over the root of ninety-one, which is now in the shape the theorem wants: a radius on top and a coordinate underneath.

The rest is the standard routine, with one difference from the earlier examples. Here you are given the radius and one coordinate rather than two coordinates, so the missing length comes from rearranging the circle equation, and it comes with a plus or minus that only the quadrant can resolve. The final check, recomputing the cosecant and getting back the number you were given, is worth doing every time on a problem with this much rearranging in it.

23. Match each value and quadrant to its point

Matching

In every row the tangent has size three quarters. Only the signs and the quadrant change.

Match the pairs

  • l1. tan θ = 3/4, quadrant I
  • l2. tan θ = 3/4, quadrant III
  • l3. tan θ = −3/4, quadrant II
  • l4. tan θ = −3/4, quadrant IV
  • r1. (4, 3)
  • r2. (−4, −3)
  • r3. (−4, 3)
  • r4. (4, −3)

Why: Tangent is y over x, so a positive tangent needs the two coordinates to agree in sign and a negative tangent needs them to disagree. That still leaves two possibilities in each case, and the quadrant picks between them. Every one of these four points has radius 5, so the four angles have cosines of three fifths, minus three fifths, minus four fifths and four fifths respectively.

Make all four matches before checking. The point of the exercise is that the four rows differ only in signs, so any rule you invent has to be about signs and nothing else.

Start from the sign of the tangent. Tangent is the second coordinate over the first, so a positive tangent means the two coordinates agree in sign and a negative tangent means they disagree. That immediately splits the four points into two pairs, and then the quadrant picks one from each pair.

Notice that every one of these four points has a radius of five, so the four angles all have cosines and sines of the same sizes, three fifths and four fifths, differing only in sign. Four different angles, one triangle, four sign patterns. That is the whole content of this part of the lesson in a single picture, and it is worth sketching all four rays on one set of axes to see it.

24. Exercise 30: finish it yourself

Faded example

The angle lies in the first quadrant and its cosine is one third. The first two lengths are already named for you.

Fill in the blanks

x = 1, \; r = 3, \; y = 2\sqrt{2} \;\Longrightarrow\; \tan(\theta) = 2\sqrt{2}, \;\; \csc(\theta) = \frac{3\sqrt{2}}{4}

Why: From nine minus one the second coordinate squared is 8, so the coordinate itself is 2 root 2, positive because the angle is in quadrant one. Then the tangent is y over x, which is 2 root 2 over 1. The cosecant is r over y, which is 3 over 2 root 2; rationalising gives 3 root 2 over 4, about 1.061.

\[ \sin(\theta) = \frac{2\sqrt2}{3}, \qquad \sec(\theta) = 3, \qquad \cot(\theta) = \frac{\sqrt2}{4} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 759 — Exercise 30

Two of the three lengths are already given to you, so this one should take under a minute. Work out the third from the circle equation, then read off the two requested values as ratios.

The second coordinate squared is nine minus one, which is eight, and the square root of eight is two root two. Because the angle is in the first quadrant, you take the positive root and there is no sign decision to make at all.

The cosecant is the blank most people get wrong, and the reason is rationalising rather than trigonometry. The radius over the second coordinate is three over two root two, which has a root in the denominator. Multiply the top and the bottom by root two and you get three root two over four. Get into the habit of finishing that step automatically, because the answer keys in this book always do.

25. All six in a right triangle

Section

Part 3

26. An acute angle in a triangle is an angle in standard position

Concept

Figure (svg): A right triangle placed with its acute angle at the origin and one leg along the horizontal axis. The horizontal leg is labelled both a and x, the vertical leg both b and y, and the hypotenuse both c and r.

Slide any right triangle so that its acute angle sits at the origin and one leg lies along the axis: adjacent becomes x, opposite becomes y, hypotenuse becomes r.

Take any right triangle and slide it so that one acute angle sits at the origin with one of its sides along the positive horizontal axis. The side adjacent to the angle now runs along that axis, so its length is the first coordinate of the far corner. The side opposite is vertical, so its length is the second coordinate. The hypotenuse is the distance from the origin, which is the radius.

\[ a = x, \qquad b = y, \qquad c = r \]

Every formula in Theorem 10.9 can now be rewritten with triangle words in place of coordinate words, and because the angle is acute all three lengths are positive, so no sign ever appears.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 753 — the specialisation before Theorem 10.10

This slide is the hinge of the lesson. Up to now everything has been about angles at the origin; from here on it is about triangles you might actually measure. The picture shows that these are the same thing seen twice.

Take any right triangle, pick one of its acute angles, and slide the whole triangle so that the chosen angle sits at the origin with one of its sides running along the positive horizontal direction. The leg along the axis is now the first coordinate of the far corner, the vertical leg is the second coordinate, and the hypotenuse is the distance from the origin. Nothing was stretched or bent; the triangle was only moved.

So Theorem 10.10 is not a new result. It is Theorem 10.9 with the letters renamed: adjacent for the first coordinate, opposite for the second, hypotenuse for the radius. The one real difference is that an acute angle sits in the first quadrant, so all three lengths are positive and every sign question you worried about in Parts 1 and 2 simply disappears.

27. Reading Theorem 10.10 piece by piece

Notation

Annotate

On: \( \tan\theta = \tfrac{b}{a}, \;\; \sec\theta = \tfrac{c}{a}, \;\; \csc\theta = \tfrac{c}{b}, \;\; \cot\theta = \tfrac{a}{b} \)

  • The length of the side adjacent to the angle: the leg that, together with the hypotenuse, forms the angle. It is the x of Theorem 10.9.
  • The length of the side opposite the angle: the leg the angle looks across at. It is the y of Theorem 10.9.
  • The hypotenuse, always the longest of the three, and always the side facing the right angle. It is the r of Theorem 10.9.
  • An acute angle has all three lengths positive, so all six values are positive. The quadrant bookkeeping of Part 1 simply does not arise here.
  • Cosine is a over c and sine is b over c, from Theorem 10.3. Together with these four that is all six.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 753 — Theorem 10.10

Take the first two annotations seriously even if the words feel obvious, because the naming is what the next several slides depend on. Adjacent means the leg that helps form the angle; opposite means the leg the angle faces across the triangle. The hypotenuse is neither, because it forms the angle but is not a leg.

The fourth annotation is the reason this part of the lesson feels so much easier than the last. An acute angle has all three lengths positive, so all six values are positive, and there is no quadrant to consult and no sign to choose. If a negative number appears anywhere in a right-triangle calculation, you have made an error.

The last annotation is worth saying out loud: the theorem lists only four relations because you already have the other two. Cosine is adjacent over hypotenuse and sine is opposite over hypotenuse. Six relations, three pairs of reciprocals, and only three genuinely independent divisions to do.

28. In a right triangle every one of the six is positive

Concept

A length cannot be negative, and an acute angle puts all three of them on the same footing. So a right-triangle problem never asks you to choose a sign, and if a negative value appears in your working something has gone wrong.

\[ 0 < a < c, \qquad 0 < b < c \;\Longrightarrow\; 0 < \cos(\theta) < 1, \;\; \sec(\theta) > 1 \]

It also puts real limits on the answers. The hypotenuse is the longest side, so the cosine and the sine of an acute angle are strictly between zero and one, while the secant and the cosecant are strictly greater than one. The tangent alone is unrestricted, because either leg may be the longer.

This is a short slide but it gives you two free error checks, and free error checks are worth collecting.

The first is about signs. Every one of the six values of an acute angle is positive, because all three sides are lengths. If your calculator or your algebra hands you a negative number in the middle of a triangle problem, stop and look for the mistake rather than carrying it forward.

The second is about size. The hypotenuse is strictly the longest side, so the cosine and the sine of an acute angle lie strictly between zero and one, and the secant and the cosecant are strictly greater than one. If you compute a cosine of one and a half for an angle in a triangle, something is wrong. The tangent is the exception, and it is the exception for the reason you already know: it does not involve the hypotenuse at all, so either leg may be the larger and the value may be anything positive.

29. Adjacent and opposite are named by the angle, not by the page

Picture it

Figure (svg): The same right triangle drawn twice. On the left the acute angle at the bottom left is marked, and the bottom side is adjacent; on the right the acute angle at the top is marked instead, and now the vertical side is the adjacent one.

Nothing about the triangle changed. Adjacent and opposite are decided by which acute angle you are working from, never by where the side sits on the page.

The same triangle is drawn twice. On the left the marked angle is at the bottom left corner, so the base is the adjacent side. On the right the marked angle is the other acute one, and now the vertical side is the adjacent one and the base is opposite. Nothing about the triangle changed; only the angle you are working from did.

Spend a moment comparing the two halves of this picture, because the confusion it addresses costs more marks in this section than any other.

It is the same triangle both times. On the left the marked angle is at the bottom left corner, so the horizontal base helps form it and is therefore the adjacent side, while the vertical side is across from it and is the opposite one. On the right the other acute angle is marked, and now the roles are exactly swapped: the vertical side is adjacent and the base is opposite.

The reason this trips people up is that textbook diagrams usually draw the angle at the bottom left, so adjacent and horizontal come to feel like the same word. Exercise 68, which you will meet shortly, deliberately puts the angle at the top instead. Before you write any relation down, put a finger on the angle you are working from and say which side is across from it. Two seconds of that habit will save you a whole problem.

30. Before you compute: which relation?

Step zero

A right triangle has an acute angle of 40 degrees and the side adjacent to it is 11 units long. You want the hypotenuse.

Discussion prompt

Name the one relation from Theorem 10.10 that connects exactly those two sides, write the equation it gives, and say why you should not start from the tangent instead.

Write your answer before revealing. The instinct in these problems is to reach for the tangent because it is the relation you have used most, and this slide exists to interrupt that instinct for thirty seconds.

You know the adjacent side and you want the hypotenuse. There is exactly one relation among the six whose two names are adjacent and hypotenuse, and it is the secant. Writing it down gives the answer in a single multiplication.

Going through the tangent would work in the end, but it would take two steps: first find the opposite side, then use the Pythagorean theorem or the cosecant to get the hypotenuse. Two steps means two chances to make an arithmetic slip, and it means carrying a rounded intermediate value into the next line, which quietly degrades your answer. Choose the relation whose two letters are exactly the side you have and the side you want, every single time.

31. Exercise 66: a base of 9 and an angle of 60 degrees

Worked example

The right angle is at the bottom right. The base of 9 is adjacent to the unknown angle at the bottom left, the side marked a is opposite it, and the 60 degree angle sits at the top. Find the unknown angle, a and c.

Find the unknown angle from the angle sum

Why: The angles of a triangle add to a straight angle, and one of them is a right angle, so the two acute ones are complementary.

\[ \theta = 180^\circ - 90^\circ - 60^\circ = 30^\circ \]

Pick the relation linking the base to a

Why: The base of 9 is adjacent and a is opposite, so tangent is the one relation carrying both.

\[ \tan(\theta) = \frac{a}{9} \]

Solve for a

Why: Multiply through by 9 and use the special value of the tangent at 30 degrees.

\[ a = 9\tan(30^\circ) = 9\cdot\frac{\sqrt3}{3} = 3\sqrt3 \approx 5.196 \]

Pick the relation linking the base to the hypotenuse

Why: Secant is hypotenuse over adjacent.

\[ \sec(\theta) = \frac{c}{9} \]

Solve for c

Why: The secant of 30 degrees is the reciprocal of root three over two.

\[ c = 9\sec(30^\circ) = 9\cdot\frac{2\sqrt3}{3} = 6\sqrt3 \approx 10.392 \]

Figure (svg): A right triangle with the right angle at the bottom right, a horizontal base of 9, a vertical side marked a, and a slanted hypotenuse marked c. The angle at the top is 60 degrees and the angle at the bottom left is the unknown theta.

Drawn to scale: the side opposite the thirty degree angle really is a little over half the base, and the hypotenuse a little over the base.

Check with the Pythagorean theorem

Why: The two legs squared must add to the hypotenuse squared, and they do exactly, with no rounding involved.

\[ 9^2 + (3\sqrt3)^2 = 81 + 27 = 108 = 36\cdot 3 = (6\sqrt3)^2 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 760 — Exercise 66

This is the model right-triangle solution, and its shape is: find the missing angle, then one relation per missing side. Getting the missing angle first is useful even when you are not asked for it, because it gives you a choice of which angle to work from.

Both relations here are chosen by the rule from the previous slide. The base of nine is adjacent to the unknown angle, so for the opposite side you want the relation with opposite and adjacent in it, which is the tangent; for the hypotenuse you want the one with hypotenuse and adjacent, which is the secant.

Because the angles are thirty and sixty degrees, the values are exact and no calculator is needed. Look at the drawing, which is to scale: the vertical side really is a little over half the base, and the hypotenuse a little over the base itself. The final check is exact too, with no rounding anywhere: eighty-one plus twenty-seven is one hundred and eight, and so is thirty-six times three.

32. Trap: naming the sides before naming the angle

Trap

The trap

Working from the 47 degree angle at the top of Exercise 68, but reading the labels off the page:

\[ \tan(47^\circ) = \frac{a}{6} \]

\[ a = 6\tan(47^\circ) \approx 6.43 \]

Wrong. The answer is too big: a is the shorter leg here.

The fix

From the angle at the top, the base of 6 is opposite and the vertical side a is adjacent. The relation carrying those two the right way round is the cotangent.

\[ \cot(47^\circ) = \frac{a}{6} \]

\[ a = 6\cot(47^\circ) \approx 5.60 \]

Before writing any relation, put a finger on the angle and say out loud which side is across from it. Two seconds there saves the whole problem.

This is the error the naming picture was warning about, now in a real exercise. The 47 degree angle sits at the top of the triangle in Exercise 68, so the vertical side is the one adjacent to it and the base of six is the one opposite.

Writing the tangent as the vertical side over six treats the vertical side as the opposite one, which is the labelling you would use if the angle were at the bottom. The result is too big, and you can see that it is too big without doing any trigonometry: the angle at the top is less than forty-five degrees, so the side across from it must be the shorter of the two legs, and six is therefore the longer one.

That sanity check generalises and is worth carrying with you. In a right triangle the larger acute angle always faces the longer leg. If your computed side breaks that rule, you have named adjacent and opposite the wrong way round.

33. Known side and wanted side: pick the relation

Matching

In each row you know one side and one acute angle, and you want a second side. Choose the single relation that names both sides.

Match the pairs

  • l1. know adjacent, want opposite
  • l2. know adjacent, want hypotenuse
  • l3. know opposite, want hypotenuse
  • l4. know opposite, want adjacent
  • r1. tangent = opposite / adjacent
  • r2. secant = hypotenuse / adjacent
  • r3. cosecant = hypotenuse / opposite
  • r4. cotangent = adjacent / opposite

Why: Each relation is a fraction naming exactly two of the three sides, so the right one is the fraction whose two names are the side you have and the side you want. Notice the pattern: when the known side is the adjacent one it sits on the bottom, and when it is the opposite one it sits on the bottom too. The known side is always the denominator if you choose from these four, which is what makes the algebra a single multiplication.

Make all four matches before revealing, and try to state the rule you used in one sentence afterwards.

The rule is that each of the six relations is a fraction naming exactly two of the three sides, so the one you want is the fraction whose two names are the side you know and the side you want. There is always exactly one, and finding it is the entire difficulty of most right-triangle problems.

There is a bonus pattern in these four rows, and it is why the four functions of Theorem 10.10 are so convenient. In every one of them the known side has been put on the bottom, so the unknown side is the whole fraction times the known one, and the algebra is a single multiplication with nothing to rearrange. If you instead reach for cosine or sine, the unknown will sometimes land in a denominator and you will have an extra step. Given the choice, pick the relation that puts your unknown on top.

34. Exercise 68: a base of 6 and an angle of 47 degrees

Worked example

The right angle is at the bottom left. The 47 degree angle sits at the top of the vertical side a, so the base of 6 is opposite it. Find the unknown angle at the bottom right, a and c.

Find the unknown angle

Why: The two acute angles of a right triangle are complementary.

\[ \theta = 90^\circ - 47^\circ = 43^\circ \]

Pick the relation linking 6 to a

Why: From the 47 degree corner, a is adjacent and 6 is opposite, so cotangent is adjacent over opposite.

\[ \cot(47^\circ) = \frac{a}{6} \]

Solve for a

Why: The cotangent is one over the tangent, so this is a single calculator keystroke.

\[ a = 6\cot(47^\circ) = \frac{6}{\tan(47^\circ)} \approx 5.5951 \]

Pick the relation linking 6 to the hypotenuse

Why: Cosecant is hypotenuse over opposite.

\[ \csc(47^\circ) = \frac{c}{6} \]

Solve for c

Why: Again a reciprocal of a value the calculator has.

\[ c = 6\csc(47^\circ) = \frac{6}{\sin(47^\circ)} \approx 8.2040 \]

Figure (svg): A right triangle with the right angle at the bottom left, a vertical side marked a, a horizontal base of 6, and the hypotenuse running from the top of the vertical side down to the bottom right. The angle at the top is 47 degrees and the angle at the bottom right is the unknown theta.

Here the angle sits at the top, so the base of 6 is the side opposite it and the vertical side is the adjacent one.

Check with the Pythagorean theorem

Why: The two legs squared add to 67.305, and the hypotenuse squared is 67.305 as well, which also confirms that a came out shorter than the base, as the trap slide predicted.

\[ 6^2 + 5.5951^2 = 67.305, \qquad 8.2040^2 = 67.305 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 760 — Exercise 68

This is the exercise the trap slide was built from, so watch the naming. The angle of 47 degrees sits at the top of the vertical side, which means the vertical side is adjacent to it and the base of six is opposite it. Everything else follows from getting that right.

The two relations are the cotangent, which is adjacent over opposite, and the cosecant, which is hypotenuse over opposite. Your calculator probably has no cotangent or cosecant button, and it does not need one: compute the tangent or the sine and take the reciprocal. That is exactly what the two lines on the slide do.

Keep four decimal places through the working and round only at the end. The check shows why: the two legs squared and the hypotenuse squared agree to five significant figures, and they would not have if you had rounded to two decimal places along the way. The check also confirms the trap slide's prediction, that the vertical side comes out shorter than the base.

35. Exercise 67: a leg of 12 and an angle of 34 degrees

Worked example

The right angle is at the top left. The 34 degree angle is at the bottom, between the vertical side of length 12 and the hypotenuse c, and b runs along the top. Find the angle at the top right, b and c.

Find the angle at the top right

Why: Complementary to the 34 degree angle.

\[ \alpha = 90^\circ - 34^\circ = 56^\circ \]

Pick the relation linking 12 to b

Why: From the 34 degree corner the side of length 12 is adjacent and b is opposite.

\[ \tan(34^\circ) = \frac{b}{12} \]

Solve for b

Why: Multiply through by 12.

\[ b = 12\tan(34^\circ) \approx 8.0941 \]

Pick the relation linking 12 to c

Why: Secant is hypotenuse over adjacent.

\[ \sec(34^\circ) = \frac{c}{12} \]

Solve for c

Why: Divide 12 by the cosine.

\[ c = 12\sec(34^\circ) = \frac{12}{\cos(34^\circ)} \approx 14.4746 \]

Check the hypotenuse is the longest side

Why: It must exceed both legs, and the Pythagorean theorem agrees to four figures.

\[ 12^2 + 8.0941^2 = 209.51 = 14.4746^2 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 760 — Exercise 67

By now this should feel routine, which is the point of doing a third one. The right angle is at the top left, so the 34 degree angle at the bottom has the vertical side of twelve adjacent to it and the top side opposite it.

Notice that this is the same pair of relations as Exercise 66, the tangent and the secant, and for the same reason: in both, the known side is the adjacent one. Exercise 68 used the other pair because its known side was the opposite one. Two situations, two pairs of relations, and knowing which situation you are in is most of the work.

The final check here is one you can do almost at a glance. The hypotenuse must be the longest side of the triangle, and 14.47 is comfortably larger than both twelve and 8.09. When a hypotenuse comes out smaller than a leg, you have either used the wrong relation or divided when you should have multiplied.

36. Exercises 66 to 69 at a glance

Comparison

All four exercises are the same three steps. Fill the gaps from the pattern.

Comparison matrix

exercisegiven angleother acute anglehypotenuse c
66: leg 9 adjacent60°30°6√3 ≈ 10.392
67: leg 12 adjacent34°56°12 sec 34° ≈ 14.475
68: leg 6 opposite47°43°6 csc 47° ≈ 8.204
69: leg 2.5 adjacent50°40°2.5 sec 50° ≈ 3.889

Notice which relation the hypotenuse column uses. When the known leg is adjacent to the given angle it is a secant; when the known leg is opposite it is a cosecant.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 760 — Exercises 66 to 69

Fill the blanks from the pattern before checking, and treat the completed table as a summary of the whole of Part 3.

The middle column is the same in every row: the two acute angles of a right triangle always add to a right angle, so the missing one is ninety degrees minus the given one. There is nothing trigonometric in that column at all.

The last column is where the thinking is. Look at which relation appears in each row and why. Exercises 66, 67 and 69 all give a leg adjacent to the marked angle, so the hypotenuse comes from a secant. Exercise 68 gives a leg opposite the marked angle, so the hypotenuse comes from a cosecant. That single distinction, adjacent or opposite, is the only decision these four exercises ever ask you to make.

37. Why the size of the triangle does not matter

Explain it to yourself

Discussion prompt

Two right triangles both have an acute angle of 34 degrees, but one is drawn ten times larger than the other. Explain, in two or three sentences, why the tangent of 34 degrees computed from each of them is the same number, and connect your answer to Part 1 of this lesson.

Write your explanation out in sentences before revealing, and then compare the wording rather than just the idea. Being able to say this cleanly is what tells you that you have understood Part 3 rather than memorised it.

The algebraic half of the answer is that enlarging by a factor of ten multiplies both the numerator and the denominator of the ratio by ten, so the ratio is unchanged. The geometric half is that the two triangles are similar, and similar triangles have proportional sides by definition.

The part worth adding is the connection back to Part 1. If you slide both triangles so their 34 degree angles sit at the origin, the larger one is simply the point ten times further out along the same terminal side, and you already proved on the prediction slide that such a point gives identical values. Three arguments, one fact. When several different routes lead to the same place, you are usually looking at something structural rather than a coincidence.

38. Angles of elevation

Section

Part 4

39. The angle of inclination

Concept

Figure (svg): A horizontal base line with an observer at the left end, a dashed line of sight rising to an object drawn at the upper right, and the angle between the base line and the line of sight marked at the observer's position.

The initial side of the angle is the ground and its terminal side is the line of sight, so the whole setup is a right triangle waiting to be labelled.

angle of inclination, or angle of elevation — The angle whose initial side is a base line, usually the ground, and whose terminal side is the line of sight to an object above that base line.

The value of this idea is that it hands you a right triangle for free. The ground is one leg, a vertical drop from the object is the other, the line of sight is the hypotenuse, and the angle you are given sits between the ground and the hypotenuse.

So every elevation problem reduces to the same question you have been answering all through Part 3: which relation names the side you know and the side you want?

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, pp. 753-754 — the angle of inclination

The definition is short and the picture carries all of it. The angle has the ground as its initial side and the line of sight as its terminal side, so it is measured upward from the horizontal.

What makes this idea so productive is that it hands you a right triangle without your having to look for one. The ground is one leg, a vertical line from the object down to the ground is the other, and the line of sight is the hypotenuse. The right angle is where the object's vertical meets the ground, which is true whenever the object stands upright, and that covers towers, trees, flagpoles and cliffs.

So an elevation problem is never really a new kind of problem. It is Part 3 with the triangle hidden inside a story. Your first move in every one of them should be to draw the triangle and mark which side you know and which you want, and only then to choose the relation.

40. Example 10.3.5(1): the Armington Clocktower

Worked example

From a point on the ground 30 feet away, the angle of inclination to the top of the tower is 60 degrees. Find the height of the tower to the nearest foot.

Name the sides from the angle

Why: The 30 feet of ground is adjacent to the 60 degree angle and the height is opposite it.

\[ a = 30, \qquad b = h, \qquad \theta = 60^\circ \]

Pick the relation with the two legs

Why: Tangent is opposite over adjacent, and both of those are in play.

\[ \tan(60^\circ) = \frac{h}{30} \]

Solve for the height

Why: Multiply through by 30.

\[ h = 30\tan(60^\circ) = 30\sqrt3 \]

Evaluate and round

Why: Root three is about 1.7320508.

\[ 30\sqrt3 \approx 51.96 \;\Longrightarrow\; h \approx 52 \text{ ft} \]

Figure (svg): A right triangle drawn to scale for the clocktower problem: a horizontal base of 30 feet, a vertical tower of unknown height h on the right, and a line of sight from the observer to the top making a 60 degree angle with the ground.

To scale the tower is clearly taller than the thirty feet of ground, which is the first check on the answer: a sixty degree sight line is steeper than a forty-five degree one.

Check the answer against a reference angle

Why: A 45 degree sight line would put the height equal to the 30 feet of ground; 60 degrees is steeper, so the height must be larger, and 51.96 is.

\[ 30\tan(45^\circ) = 30 < 51.96 = 30\tan(60^\circ) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 754 — Example 10.3.5, number 1

Follow the first step, which is the one the story is hiding. The thirty feet is measured along the ground, so it is the side adjacent to the angle, and the height is vertical, so it is the side opposite. Once those two words are attached, choosing the tangent is automatic.

The arithmetic is exact because sixty degrees is a special angle. The tangent of sixty degrees is root three, so the height is thirty root three, which is about 51.96 feet, and the question asks for the nearest foot, so fifty-two.

The check is one you can run in your head on any elevation problem. At forty-five degrees the height would equal the horizontal distance exactly, because the tangent of forty-five is one. A steeper sight line must give a taller object and a shallower one a shorter object. Here sixty degrees is steeper than forty-five and the answer is bigger than thirty, so the result passes. If you ever get a height smaller than the distance from an angle above forty-five degrees, you have put the tangent upside down.

41. Double the angle, double the height?

Estimation

The observer stays 30 feet from the tower, but the angle of inclination to the top is 30 degrees rather than 60.

Predict first

The clocktower at 60 degrees came out about 52 feet tall. At 30 degrees from the same spot, roughly how tall is the object?

  • About 26 feet, half as tall
  • About 17 feet, a third as tall
  • About 37 feet
  • About 45 feet

Correct: About 17 feet, a third as tall

Why: The height is 30 times the tangent of the angle, and the tangent of 30 degrees is root three over three while the tangent of 60 degrees is root three. The second is three times the first, so halving the angle divides the height by three, not by two. The tangent is not proportional to the angle, and that is the single most useful thing to remember about these problems.

\[ 30\tan(30^\circ) = 30\cdot\frac{\sqrt3}{3} = 10\sqrt3 \approx 17.32, \qquad \frac{\tan(60^\circ)}{\tan(30^\circ)} = 3 \]

Commit to an option before revealing. Almost everyone's first instinct is that halving the angle halves the height, and it is worth feeling that instinct fail once so that you stop trusting it.

The height is the distance times the tangent of the angle, and the tangent is not proportional to the angle. At thirty degrees the tangent is root three over three, and at sixty it is root three, which is three times as large. So the same observer standing in the same place sees an object three times shorter, not twice as short.

This matters practically as well as numerically. It means small errors in measuring a steep angle produce large errors in the computed height, which is why surveyors prefer to step back and use a shallower angle when they can. The slider on the next slide lets you feel how fast the relationship steepens as the angle climbs.

42. Slide the angle of elevation

Tweak it

Parameter explorer

The curve gives the height of an object whose angle of elevation is the chosen number of degrees, seen from a horizontal distance shown along the axis. Slide the angle. What happens to the line as the angle passes 45 degrees, and what happens as it approaches 85?

\[ h = x\tan({theta}^\circ) \]

  • theta — from 5 to 85: angle of elevation (degrees)

Start with the slider at forty-five degrees. The line you see has slope exactly one, which says that at that angle the height of the object always equals your distance from it. That is the reference case to anchor everything else against.

Now move the slider down towards five degrees. The line flattens, and at five degrees an object a hundred feet away is under nine feet tall. Then move it up. The line steepens slowly at first and then very quickly: between seventy and eighty-five degrees the slope more than doubles, and at eighty-five an object a hundred feet away is over eleven hundred feet tall.

Two things to take from this. First, the graph is always a straight line through the origin, because for a fixed angle the height really is proportional to the distance. Second, the angle controls only the slope of that line, and it controls it in a wildly non-uniform way. That non-uniformity is exactly what the previous slide's prediction was about.

43. When you cannot stand at the base

Concept

Figure (svg): A tall tree at the right with two observation points on the ground to its left. The nearer point is a distance x from the tree and sights the top at 45 degrees; the farther point is 200 feet further back and sights the top at 30 degrees.

Two unknowns, the height and the near distance, so two sightings are needed; the 200 feet between them is what ties the two equations together.

The clocktower worked because the 30 feet of ground was measurable. For a tree in a forest you may not be able to reach the base at all, so the adjacent side is unknown as well as the height. One sighting then gives one equation in two unknowns, which settles nothing.

\[ \tan(\theta_1) = \frac{h}{x}: \quad \text{one equation, two unknowns} \]

The fix is a second sighting from a point a measured distance further back along the same line. That adds a second equation, and the measured distance is what links the two, because the far triangle's base is the near one's base plus that distance.

\[ \tan(\theta_2) = \frac{h}{x + d} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, pp. 754-755 — Example 10.3.5, number 2, the setup

The clocktower problem worked because someone could pace out the thirty feet from the observer to the base of the tower. Now imagine the object is a tree in dense forest, or across a river, or the tree line on the far side of a valley. You cannot measure the horizontal distance at all.

That leaves you with one equation containing two unknowns, the height and the distance, and no amount of algebra will get a number out of it. Any height at all is consistent with a single angle, provided you are willing to be the right distance away.

The fix is to take a second sighting from a point a measured distance further back along the same straight line. You now have two equations. The crucial detail, and the one the picture is drawn to make obvious, is that the far triangle's base is not a new unknown: it is the near base plus the distance you paced. That is what links the two equations and makes the system solvable.

44. Example 10.3.5(2): a California Redwood from two sightings

Worked example

Two sightings from the ground, one 200 feet directly behind the other, give angles of inclination of 45 and 30 degrees. How tall is the tree, to the nearest foot?

\[ \tan(45^\circ) = \frac{h}{x}, \qquad \tan(30^\circ) = \frac{h}{x + 200} \]

Use the near sighting to eliminate x

Why: The tangent of 45 degrees is exactly one, so the base equals the height.

\[ \frac{h}{x} = 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = h \]

Substitute into the far sighting

Why: Replace x by h and put in the special value of the tangent at 30 degrees.

\[ \frac{h}{h + 200} = \frac{\sqrt3}{3} \]

Clear the fractions

Why: Cross-multiply; both denominators are positive.

\[ 3h = (h + 200)\sqrt3 \]

Expand the right-hand side

Why: Distribute the root over the bracket.

\[ 3h = h\sqrt3 + 200\sqrt3 \]

Gather the terms in h

Why: Subtract the h term from both sides.

\[ 3h - h\sqrt3 = 200\sqrt3 \]

Factor and divide

Why: Both sides now have a single h.

\[ (3 - \sqrt3)h = 200\sqrt3 \;\Longrightarrow\; h = \frac{200\sqrt3}{3 - \sqrt3} \]

Rationalise the denominator

Why: Multiply top and bottom by three plus root three; the bottom becomes nine minus three.

\[ h = \frac{200\sqrt3(3 + \sqrt3)}{6} = \frac{600\sqrt3 + 600}{6} = 100\sqrt3 + 100 \]

Evaluate and round

Why: Root three is about 1.73205.

\[ h = 100\sqrt3 + 100 \approx 273.21 \;\Longrightarrow\; h \approx 273 \text{ ft} \]

Check the far sighting reproduces 30 degrees

Why: The near base is 273.21 as well, so the far base is 473.21, and the quotient must be the tangent of 30 degrees.

\[ \frac{273.21}{473.21} = 0.57735 = \frac{\sqrt3}{3} = \tan(30^\circ) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 755 — Example 10.3.5, number 2

This is the longest calculation in the lesson, so give the setup its due before the algebra begins. Two equations, one for each sighting, with the steeper forty-five degree angle belonging to the nearer point and the shallower thirty degree angle to the point two hundred feet further back.

The forty-five degree sighting is a gift, and you should always look for the easiest equation first. Its tangent is exactly one, so the near distance simply equals the height, and substituting that into the other equation leaves a single equation in a single unknown. From there it is ordinary algebra: cross-multiply, expand, gather the terms containing the unknown on one side, factor it out and divide.

Rationalising the answer is worth doing rather than reaching for a calculator at the earlier stage. Multiplying top and bottom by three plus root three turns a messy quotient into one hundred root three plus one hundred, which is both exact and easy to evaluate. And notice the final check: the near distance and the height turn out to be equal, so the far base is 473 feet, and dividing 273 by 473 really does give the tangent of thirty degrees. That single division confirms the whole page of algebra.

45. Find the error: the far distance with the near angle

Error analysis

A different attempt at the redwood, written down in one line before drawing the picture.

Annotate

On: \( \tan(45^\circ) = \tfrac{h}{x + 200} \;\text{ and }\; \tan(30^\circ) = \tfrac{h}{x} \)

  • The steeper sighting comes from the nearer point. Forty-five degrees is steeper than thirty, so 45 degrees belongs to the base x and 30 degrees to the base x plus 200.
  • Solving these gives a negative height, which is the arithmetic telling you the setup is impossible. A negative length is always a signal that two labels have been exchanged.
  • Move further away from a fixed object and the top appears lower, so the angle of inclination must decrease. The larger angle therefore always goes with the smaller distance.
  • Draw the picture before writing any equation, and put both observation points on the ground line. The moment they are drawn, the pairing is impossible to get wrong.

\[ \text{correct: } \tan(45^\circ) = \frac{h}{x}, \quad \tan(30^\circ) = \frac{h}{x+200} \]

Look at the pair of equations and decide what is wrong before opening the annotations. Everything about the form is right; there are two sightings and two tangents and the bases differ by two hundred.

The error is that the angles have been attached to the wrong bases. Think about what happens physically as you walk away from a tree: the top appears lower and lower, so the angle of inclination shrinks. The largest angle therefore always belongs to the smallest distance. Here forty-five degrees, the steeper of the two, has been given the larger base.

The arithmetic does warn you, if you carry it through: the height comes out negative. A negative length is always a signal that two labels have been exchanged somewhere, and it is worth treating it as information rather than as a mistake to be hidden by taking an absolute value. The real defence, though, is the picture. Draw the ground line with both observation points on it before writing any equation and this error becomes almost impossible to make.

46. An angle of depression is the same angle from above

Concept

Figure (svg): A cliff of height 90 metres on the left with an observer at the top. A dashed horizontal line runs right from the observer, and a dashed line of sight slopes down to a boat on the water. The angle between them at the top equals the angle at the boat.

The angle of depression is measured from the horizontal at the top; the equal angle inside the triangle sits at the boat, and that is the one you use.

Looking down from a height, the angle between the horizontal and the line of sight is called the angle of depression. It is not one of the angles inside the triangle, so it has to be moved before it can be used.

The horizontal at the observer and the horizontal at the water are parallel, and the line of sight crosses both, so the angle of depression at the top equals the angle of elevation at the bottom. Alternate angles, from geometry, do the whole job.

\[ \text{depression at the top} = \text{elevation at the object} = 12^\circ \]

This is a small piece of geometry rather than trigonometry, but it is the step that applied problems most often skip. The angle of depression is measured from the horizontal at the observer's eye, downward to the line of sight. It is not one of the three angles inside the triangle, so you cannot use it until you have moved it.

The move is one line of elementary geometry. The horizontal at the top of the cliff and the surface of the water are parallel, and the line of sight is a transversal cutting both. Alternate angles across a transversal are equal, so the angle of depression at the top equals the angle at the boat, and that one is inside the triangle.

In practice you may find it quicker to use the complementary angle at the top instead, the one between the cliff and the line of sight, which is ninety degrees minus the depression. Either route works. What does not work is treating the angle of depression as though it were already inside the triangle, and the picture is there to stop you doing that.

47. An angle of depression: a boat seen from a cliff

Worked example

From the top of a cliff 90 metres above the water, the angle of depression to a boat is 12 degrees. How far is the boat from the base of the cliff?

Transfer the angle into the triangle

Why: The angle of depression at the top and the angle at the boat are alternate angles between two parallel horizontals.

\[ \text{angle at the boat} = 12^\circ \]

Name the sides from that angle

Why: The 90 metre cliff is opposite the angle at the boat, and the wanted distance is adjacent to it.

\[ b = 90, \qquad a = d, \qquad \theta = 12^\circ \]

Pick the relation with the two legs

Why: Cotangent is adjacent over opposite, which is the way round that puts the unknown on top.

\[ \cot(12^\circ) = \frac{d}{90} \]

Solve for the distance

Why: Multiply through by 90.

\[ d = 90\cot(12^\circ) = \frac{90}{\tan(12^\circ)} \]

Evaluate

Why: The tangent of 12 degrees is about 0.21256.

\[ d \approx 423.4 \text{ m} \]

Figure (svg): A curve showing the horizontal distance to the boat as a function of the angle of depression, for angles from 3 to 45 degrees. The curve falls steeply from above 1700 metres at small angles and flattens towards 90 metres at 45 degrees, with the value at 12 degrees marked.

Halving the angle from twelve degrees to six more than doubles the distance, and as the sight line flattens further the distance grows without any bound at all.

Check what halving the angle does

Why: A shallower sight line should push the boat much more than twice as far out, because the cotangent grows faster than any straight line as the angle shrinks towards zero.

\[ 90\cot(6^\circ) \approx 856.3 > 2 \cdot 423.4 = 846.8 \]

The first step is the whole difficulty, and it is geometry rather than trigonometry. Once the twelve degrees has been transferred down to the boat, the ninety metre cliff is the side opposite that angle and the distance you want is the side adjacent to it.

The relation that names opposite and adjacent with the unknown on top is the cotangent, so the distance is ninety times the cotangent of twelve degrees. Your calculator has no cotangent key, so compute the tangent and divide, which is what the line on the slide does.

The check is worth understanding rather than just reading. Halving the angle from twelve degrees to six more than doubles the distance, from about 423 metres to about 856. The graph shows why: as the sight line flattens towards the horizontal, the cotangent grows without any bound at all. This is the same non-uniformity you met on the slider slide, seen from the other end, and it is why a nearly horizontal sighting is almost useless for measuring distance.

48. Roof pitch is a tangent in disguise

Real world

Discussion prompt

Builders quote a roof as 6 in 12, meaning it rises 6 units for every 12 units of horizontal run. Which circular function of the roof's angle does that fraction give directly? Then find how many units of rafter are needed per unit of horizontal run, and name the function that answers that.

Answer both parts before revealing. This is the transfer question for the whole of Parts 3 and 4, and it is a genuine piece of trade arithmetic rather than a dressed-up exercise.

The quoted fraction is rise over run, which is opposite over adjacent, which is the tangent. So a six in twelve roof has a tangent of one half and an angle of a little over twenty-six and a half degrees. Notice that builders never quote the angle itself, because the ratio is what you can actually measure with a spirit level and a tape.

The second part is the useful one. Rafter length over horizontal run is hypotenuse over adjacent, which is the secant, and for this roof it comes out at about 1.118. So every metre of horizontal run needs a little under 1.12 metres of rafter, about twelve per cent more material than a flat ceiling over the same span. Steeper roofs cost disproportionately more, and the secant is the function that says by how much.

49. Domains and ranges

Section

Part 5

50. Only two exclusion patterns among the six

Concept

Cosine and sine are defined for every real number, because a point on the unit circle always has two coordinates. The other four are quotients, so each is undefined exactly where its denominator vanishes, and there are only two possible denominators.

\[ \sec(t) = \frac{1}{\cos(t)}, \quad \tan(t) = \frac{\sin(t)}{\cos(t)} \qquad\text{fail where}\qquad \cos(t) = 0 \]

\[ \csc(t) = \frac{1}{\sin(t)}, \quad \cot(t) = \frac{\cos(t)}{\sin(t)} \qquad\text{fail where}\qquad \sin(t) = 0 \]

So there are exactly two lists of excluded numbers to learn, not four, and each list you already know from Lesson 10.2: the cosine vanishes at a quarter turn and every half turn thereafter, and the sine vanishes at every whole multiple of a half turn.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, pp. 755-757 — the discussion leading to Theorem 10.11

Before this slide, the undefined values have appeared one at a time, in provisos and in a single worked example. Here they are organised, and the organising idea is small enough to hold in your head permanently.

Cosine and sine are defined everywhere, because a point on the circle always has two coordinates. The other four are all quotients, and a quotient fails exactly where its denominator is zero. Secant and tangent both have the cosine underneath, so they fail in exactly the same places. Cosecant and cotangent both have the sine underneath, so they fail in exactly the same places as each other.

That means there are two lists to learn, not four, and you know both already from Lesson 10.2. The cosine is zero at a quarter turn and then every half turn after that, in both directions. The sine is zero at every whole multiple of a half turn. Everything in the rest of this part is bookkeeping on top of those two facts.

51. Writing the domain of secant

Worked example

Follow the book's derivation once, carefully, and the other three domains cost nothing.

\[ F(t) = \sec(t) = \frac{1}{\cos(t)} \]

Find where the definition fails

Why: A quotient is undefined exactly when its denominator is zero.

\[ \sec(t) \text{ undefined} \iff \cos(t) = 0 \]

Solve the cosine equation

Why: From Example 10.2.5, the cosine vanishes at a quarter turn and at every half turn after that, in both directions.

\[ \cos(t) = 0 \iff t = \frac{\pi}{2} + \pi k, \quad k \text{ an integer} \]

List a few of the excluded numbers

Why: Run k through zero, one and minus one and so on.

\[ t \ne \pm\frac{\pi}{2}, \;\; \pm\frac{3\pi}{2}, \;\; \pm\frac{5\pi}{2}, \;\; \ldots \]

Name the kth excluded point in one expression

Why: Take a common denominator and factor the half turn out of the numerator.

\[ x_k = \frac{\pi}{2} + \pi k = \frac{(2k+1)\pi}{2} \]

Take the interval between consecutive excluded points

Why: What survives is everything strictly between one hole and the next.

\[ (x_k, x_{k+1}) = \left(\frac{(2k+1)\pi}{2}, \;\frac{(2k+3)\pi}{2}\right) \]

Union those intervals over every integer

Why: This is what the book calls extended interval notation.

\[ \text{domain} = \bigcup_{k=-\infty}^{\infty}\left(\frac{(2k+1)\pi}{2}, \;\frac{(2k+3)\pi}{2}\right) \]

Figure (svg): A number line marked at minus five pi over two, minus three pi over two, minus pi over two, zero, pi over two, three pi over two and five pi over two. Open circles sit at every odd multiple of pi over two and thick bars cover the open intervals between them.

Each hole is one place where the cosine vanishes. The domain is everything in between, which is why it takes an infinite union to write down.

Check one value of k

Why: Putting k equal to zero should reproduce the stretch from a quarter turn to three quarters of a turn, which is exactly the second green bar to the right of the origin in the picture.

\[ k = 0: \quad \left(\frac{\pi}{2}, \;\frac{3\pi}{2}\right) \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, pp. 755-756 — the domain of secant

Work through this derivation once with a pencil, because the other three domains are the same argument with a different word, and the book expects you to produce them yourself in the exercises.

The first three steps are straightforward: the function fails where the denominator vanishes, the denominator is the cosine, and you already know where the cosine vanishes. The interesting part starts at the fourth step, where the list of excluded numbers is compressed into a single formula. Getting a common denominator and factoring turns a quarter turn plus a whole number of half turns into an odd number of quarter turns, and odd numbers are exactly what the expression two k plus one produces.

The last two steps are the notation. What survives is everything strictly between one hole and the next, and because the holes go on forever in both directions, writing down the domain requires an infinite union. Look at the picture while you read the formula: the open circles are the holes and the thick bars are the intervals, and the formula is nothing more than a compact way of saying take all the bars.

52. Reading extended interval notation

Notation

Annotate

On: \( \bigcup_{k=-\infty}^{\infty}\left(\tfrac{(2k+1)\pi}{2}, \;\tfrac{(2k+3)\pi}{2}\right) \)

  • The same symbol as a union of two sets, stretched over a list. It means: take all of these intervals and put them together into one set.
  • The limits are not values k ever takes, exactly as the upper limit of a series is never reached. They say that k runs through every integer, negative, zero and positive.
  • An odd number, whatever integer k is. So the left endpoint is always an odd multiple of a quarter turn, which is exactly where the cosine vanishes.
  • The next odd number after 2k + 1, so the right endpoint is the very next hole. Each interval reaches from one hole to the one immediately after it, with nothing skipped and nothing counted twice.
  • Both endpoints are excluded, which is the whole point: those are the numbers where the function has no value.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 756 — extended interval notation

This notation looks more forbidding than it is, and the book itself admits as much. Work through the annotations slowly and it reduces to a very short sentence: take every interval that runs from one hole to the next, and put them all together.

The comparison the book draws is with the summation notation you met in Chapter 9. There, the symbol at the top of a sum is infinity even though the index never actually equals infinity; it is a way of saying the index runs through all the natural numbers. Here it means exactly the same thing for a union, with the index running through all the integers, negative as well as positive.

The two expressions in the endpoints are worth a second look. Two k plus one is always odd, and two k plus three is the very next odd number. So each interval starts at one odd multiple of a quarter turn and stops at the next one, with nothing skipped and nothing counted twice. That is what makes the union describe the domain exactly rather than approximately.

53. A reciprocal of something small is something large

Intuition

The cosine never leaves the stretch from negative one to one. Turning a number of size at most one upside down gives a number of size at least one, and the closer the original is to zero the larger the result.

\[ 0 < |u| \le 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; \left|\frac{1}{u}\right| \ge 1 \]

That is the whole reason secant and cosecant have a gap in the middle of their ranges rather than a gap at the ends. They are not merely large sometimes; they are never small, and the values strictly between negative one and one are unreachable.

This is the idea behind the ranges of secant and cosecant, and it is worth separating from the algebra that formalises it on the next slide.

The cosine never leaves the stretch from negative one to one. Turn a number in that stretch upside down and you get a number at least as far from zero as one, because dividing one by something small gives something large. The closer the cosine is to zero, the further out the secant goes, without limit.

So the gap in the range of secant sits in the middle, not at the ends, and that is the opposite of what people expect. Bounded functions like cosine leave out everything beyond one; their reciprocals leave out everything inside one. Whenever you are asked whether some number is a possible value of a secant, the only question is whether its size is at least one.

54. Deriving the range of secant

Worked example

The cosine takes every value from negative one to one. Follow each of those through the reciprocal, splitting at zero because dividing by a negative reverses an inequality.

Split on the sign of the cosine

Why: Zero itself is already excluded from the domain.

\[ 0 < \cos(t) \le 1 \qquad\text{or}\qquad -1 \le \cos(t) < 0 \]

Divide the first case by the cosine

Why: Dividing by a positive number keeps the direction of the inequality.

\[ \cos(t) \le 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; 1 \le \frac{1}{\cos(t)} = \sec(t) \]

Divide the second case by the cosine

Why: Dividing by a negative number reverses the direction.

\[ -1 \le \cos(t) \;\Longrightarrow\; \sec(t) \le -1 \]

Describe what happens near the holes

Why: As the cosine shrinks towards zero from either side, its reciprocal runs off to infinity with the matching sign.

\[ \cos(t) \to 0^{+} \Rightarrow \sec(t) \to \infty, \qquad \cos(t) \to 0^{-} \Rightarrow \sec(t) \to -\infty \]

Collect the two pieces

Why: Every value at or beyond one in either direction is attained, and nothing in between is.

\[ \text{range} = (-\infty, -1] \cup [1, \infty) = \{u : |u| \ge 1\} \]

Figure (svg): The graph of secant over three periods, a chain of U-shaped branches opening upward above the line y equals 1 and downward below y equals negative 1, with vertical dashed asymptotes at the odd multiples of pi over two and the horizontal band between negative 1 and 1 shaded as unreachable.

The curve never enters the shaded band. Dividing one by a number of size at most one can only give a number of size at least one.

Check that both endpoints really are attained

Why: The value one occurs where the cosine is one and negative one where the cosine is negative one, so the square brackets are correct and the range is closed at both inner edges.

\[ \sec(0) = \frac{1}{1} = 1, \qquad \sec(\pi) = \frac{1}{-1} = -1 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, pp. 756-757 — the range of secant

The structure here is an inequality argument, and the reason it splits into two cases is worth being clear about: dividing an inequality by a negative number reverses it, so positive and negative cosines have to be handled separately.

Take the positive case first. The cosine is at most one and greater than zero, and dividing both sides of that by the cosine gives a secant of at least one. The negative case is the mirror image, and the reversal is what sends the conclusion the other way, giving a secant of at most negative one. Between the two cases every possible cosine has been accounted for, so the range is exactly the two outer pieces.

Look at the graph while reading this. The shaded band is the region no branch of the curve ever enters, and the vertical dashed lines are the holes you found in the domain. Near each hole the curve shoots off to infinity, which is the limiting behaviour described in the fourth step. And the check matters: the two brackets are square rather than round, because the values one and negative one really are attained, at the top and the bottom of the cosine.

55. The same argument for cosecant, tangent and cotangent

Worked example

The book leaves these to the reader. Each one is the secant derivation with a different denominator.

Find where cosecant fails

Why: Its denominator is the sine, which vanishes at every whole multiple of a half turn.

\[ \sin(t) = 0 \iff t = \pi k \quad\Longrightarrow\quad \text{dom}(\csc) = \bigcup_{k=-\infty}^{\infty}(k\pi, \;(k+1)\pi) \]

Repeat the range argument with sine in place of cosine

Why: The sine also sweeps the whole stretch from negative one to one, so its reciprocal behaves identically.

\[ \text{ran}(\csc) = (-\infty, -1] \cup [1, \infty) \]

Copy the two domains across to the quotients

Why: Tangent divides by the cosine and cotangent by the sine, so each inherits the matching list of holes.

\[ \text{dom}(\tan) = \text{dom}(\sec), \qquad \text{dom}(\cot) = \text{dom}(\csc) \]

Read the ranges of the quotients off the picture

Why: Between consecutive holes the tangent climbs from far below the axis to far above it, so it passes through every real number on the way.

\[ \text{ran}(\tan) = \text{ran}(\cot) = (-\infty, \infty) \]

Figure (svg): The graph of tangent over three periods: identical increasing branches between consecutive vertical dashed asymptotes at the odd multiples of pi over two, each branch sweeping from far below the axis to far above it.

Each branch climbs from far below to far above, so any horizontal line you draw is crossed, once on every branch. Nothing is missing from the range.

Check one value in each range

Why: A height of 3.2 is reached by the tangent on every branch, while no input whatever makes the cosecant equal to a half.

\[ \tan(1.268) \approx 3.2, \qquad \csc(t) = \tfrac12 \text{ has no solution} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 757 — Theorem 10.11

The book hands these three to you as an exercise, and they genuinely are easy once the secant case is understood, because nothing changes except which function sits underneath.

For cosecant the denominator is the sine, which vanishes at every whole multiple of a half turn, so the intervals of the domain run from one multiple to the next. The sine sweeps the same stretch from negative one to one that the cosine does, so its reciprocal has exactly the same range. Tangent shares its denominator with secant and cotangent shares its denominator with cosecant, so those two domains are simply copied across.

The ranges of the last two are different in kind, and the graph is the fastest way to see why. On each branch the tangent climbs from far below the axis to far above it without a break, so any horizontal line you care to draw is crossed, once on every branch. Nothing is left out. That is the deep difference between a reciprocal of a bounded function, which has a gap in the middle, and a quotient of two coordinates, which has no gap at all.

56. The six domains and ranges side by side

Comparison

Comparison matrix

functionexcluded inputsrange
cosinenone[−1, 1]
sinenone[−1, 1]
secantodd multiples of π/2|u| ≥ 1
cosecantmultiples of π|u| ≥ 1
tangentodd multiples of π/2all real numbers
cotangentmultiples of πall real numbers

Two exclusion lists and three ranges, arranged in reciprocal pairs. The only line worth memorising separately is that the two quotient functions leave nothing out of their range.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 757 — Theorem 10.11

Fill the three blanks before checking, and then read the table down rather than across, because the structure is in the columns.

The middle column has only three entries in it: nothing excluded, the odd multiples of a quarter turn, and the whole multiples of a half turn. Which one a function gets is decided entirely by what is in its denominator. The right column has only three entries as well: the stretch from negative one to one, everything outside it, and all real numbers.

Reciprocal pairs always share a row pattern, which halves what there is to remember. Cosine and secant have the same exclusions and opposite ranges; so do sine and cosecant. The one line that is genuinely its own fact is that tangent and cotangent leave nothing out of their range, and the reason is the one on the previous slide: they are not reciprocals of bounded functions.

57. Trap: assuming every equation has a solution

Trap

The trap

Solving an equation by reaching straight for the reciprocal:

\[ \sec(\theta) = \tfrac12 \]

\[ \cos(\theta) = 2 \]

\[ \theta = ? \]

Wrong. There is no such angle, and the second line already said so.

The fix

A half lies strictly between negative one and one, so it is not in the range of the secant. The equation has no solutions at all, and that is the complete answer.

\[ \left|\tfrac12\right| < 1 \]

Check the target against the range before you start work. It costs one glance and it saves you from hunting for an angle that does not exist.

The habit that causes this is answering equations on autopilot. Reciprocate, look up the angle, write it down. Here the reciprocating step already told you the answer and it was ignored.

A cosine of two is impossible, because the cosine never leaves the stretch from negative one to one. Equivalently, and more quickly, a half has size less than one and is therefore not in the range of the secant. Either way, the correct and complete answer is that there are no solutions, and writing that down earns full marks.

The defence is a single glance before you start. When an equation asks for a secant or a cosecant, check whether the target has size at least one. If it does not, you are finished before you begin. When you meet inverse trigonometric functions in a later chapter, this same check becomes the question of whether a number is in the domain of the inverse, so the habit pays twice.

58. Exercises 52, 53 and 61: equations with no solutions

Worked example

Three of the exercises in this set are unsolvable, and each is unsolvable for a reason you can state in one line.

Compare the first target with the range of secant

Why: The range omits everything strictly between negative one and one, and zero is in that gap.

\[ \sec(\theta) = 0: \quad 0 \notin (-\infty,-1]\cup[1,\infty) \]

Say the same thing from the definition

Why: A fraction with numerator one is never zero, however large the denominator grows.

\[ \frac{1}{\cos(\theta)} = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; 1 = 0, \text{ impossible} \]

Repeat for the cosecant equation

Why: Same argument, with the sine in the denominator.

\[ \csc(t) = 0: \quad \frac{1}{\sin(t)} = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; 1 = 0 \]

Handle a target inside the forbidden band

Why: Negative one half has size less than one, so it too is outside the range.

\[ \csc(\theta) = -\frac12: \quad \left|-\tfrac12\right| < 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{no solutions} \]

Check the contrast with a value that is allowed

Why: Exercise 56 asks for a cosecant of negative two, which lies outside the band, and that equation has infinitely many solutions.

\[ \csc(\theta) = -2 \iff \sin(\theta) = -\frac12 \iff \theta = \frac{7\pi}{6} + 2\pi k \;\text{ or }\; \frac{11\pi}{6} + 2\pi k \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 760 — Exercises 52, 53, 56 and 61

Three exercises from this set have no solutions, and the book includes them deliberately, because the commonest way to lose marks on an equation-solving question is to invent an answer for an equation that has none.

Two different explanations are given here for the same conclusion, and both are worth having. The range argument is fast: the target is not in the range, so there is nothing to find. The definitional argument is more convincing on paper: a fraction with one on top can never equal zero, because that would force one to equal zero.

The last step is the contrast that makes the others meaningful. A cosecant of negative two looks superficially like a cosecant of negative one half, but negative two has size greater than one, so it is in the range, and that equation has infinitely many solutions in two families. The size of the number, not its sign or its appearance, is what decides.

59. Which of these equations have solutions?

Sorting

Sort into buckets

Sort each equation by whether any real number satisfies it.

Has solutions
sec θ = 2; csc θ = −1; tan θ = −1000; cot θ = 0; sec θ = 1
No solutions
sec θ = 0; csc θ = −1/2; csc θ = 0.4
yes
Two and one both have size at least one, so they are in the range of secant; negative one has size one, so it is in the range of cosecant. Tangent and cotangent have every real number in their range, so minus one thousand and zero are both attainable: cotangent is zero wherever the cosine is, at the odd multiples of a quarter turn.
no
Zero, minus a half and 0.4 all lie strictly between negative one and one, and neither secant nor cosecant ever takes a value in that band. A reciprocal of a number of size at most one cannot have size less than one.

Sort all eight before checking. Each one takes about three seconds once you know what to look at, so this is a test of whether you have the criterion rather than of your arithmetic.

For secant and cosecant the criterion is size at least one. Two, one and negative one all qualify; zero, negative one half and four tenths do not, because all three lie strictly inside the forbidden band. Notice that the sign is irrelevant: negative one is fine and positive four tenths is not.

For tangent and cotangent there is no criterion at all, because their range is every real number. Minus one thousand is a perfectly ordinary tangent, reached on every branch of the curve. A cotangent of zero is reached wherever the cosine is zero, which is at the odd multiples of a quarter turn, the same numbers that are excluded from the tangent's domain. That coincidence is not an accident: cotangent is zero exactly where tangent is undefined.

60. Exercise 64: solving a secant equation for t

Worked example

\[ \sec(t) = \frac{2\sqrt3}{3} \]

Check the target lies in the range

Why: Two root three over three is about 1.1547, which has size at least one, so solutions do exist.

\[ \left|\frac{2\sqrt3}{3}\right| \approx 1.1547 \ge 1 \]

Reciprocate both sides

Why: Turn the secant equation into a cosine equation and rationalise.

\[ \cos(t) = \frac{3}{2\sqrt3} = \frac{3\sqrt3}{6} = \frac{\sqrt3}{2} \]

Find the solutions in one turn

Why: The cosine is root three over two at one twelfth of a turn on either side of the positive horizontal axis.

\[ t = \frac{\pi}{6} \qquad\text{or}\qquad t = \frac{11\pi}{6} \]

Add every whole turn

Why: Coterminal numbers give the same cosine, so each solution repeats forever in both directions.

\[ t = \frac{\pi}{6} + 2\pi k \qquad\text{or}\qquad t = \frac{11\pi}{6} + 2\pi k \]

Check one of them

Why: Evaluate the secant directly at the first solution and rationalise.

\[ \sec\left(\frac{\pi}{6}\right) = \frac{1}{\sqrt3/2} = \frac{2}{\sqrt3} = \frac{2\sqrt3}{3} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 760 — Exercise 64

This exercise puts the two halves of Part 5 together. First the range check, which costs one glance and tells you that solutions exist, and then the actual solving, which is a cosine equation in disguise.

Reciprocating is the move that turns the problem into one you have already solved. Three over two root three needs rationalising, and it simplifies to root three over two, which is one of the special values you know. From there the solutions are the two numbers in a single turn whose cosine is root three over two, one just above the start of the turn and one just below the end.

Adding a whole number of full turns is not decoration; without it the answer is incomplete. The question says solve for a real number, and every coterminal number has the same cosine, so each of the two solutions repeats forever in both directions. The check at the end is the one you should always do on an equation like this: take your answer and evaluate the original function at it.

61. Break the claim about secant and cosine

Counterexample

Discussion prompt

Someone claims: since secant is one over cosine, the secant of an angle is always larger than its cosine. Find a value of t that breaks the claim, and then say exactly which angles the claim does hold for.

Try to break the claim yourself before revealing. Looking for a counterexample is a much better use of thirty seconds than trying to decide whether a claim feels right.

The claim has a kernel of truth, which is why it is tempting. When the cosine is a small positive number, its reciprocal really is much larger, and if you only ever test angles in the first quadrant the claim survives every test.

It fails as soon as the cosine goes negative. Turning a negative number of size less than one upside down makes it more negative, not larger, so the secant drops below the cosine. And at the two angles where the cosine is one or negative one, the secant equals the cosine exactly, so even a claim of being at least as large would fail if you insisted on strictness. The moral is that a statement about reciprocals needs a sign condition and a size condition, and the habit of hunting for the boundary cases is what finds both.

62. Putting it together

Section

Part 6

63. Pattern: from one fact to all six

Pattern

Figure (svg): A flow diagram beginning with the question of what you are given. A point leads straight to computing the radius; one value and a quadrant leads to inventing a point first; a triangle with an angle leads to naming adjacent, opposite and hypotenuse. All three arrive at the same box of six ratios.

Three different kinds of question, one common destination. Only the first box differs; the last step is always the same six divisions.
  1. Given a point? Compute the radius from the two coordinates first, and keep it positive.
  2. Given one value and a quadrant? Split the value into two parts, give the coordinates the signs the quadrant demands, then compute the missing third length.
  3. Given a triangle and an acute angle? Name adjacent, opposite and hypotenuse from that angle, not from the page, and choose the one relation whose two letters are the side you know and the side you want.
  4. Then read off the six ratios, rationalising any surd left in a denominator.
  5. Always check. The sign pattern against the quadrant, the Pythagorean theorem in a triangle, or the given value recomputed from the point.
  6. Before solving an equation, compare the target with the range: nothing strictly between negative one and one is a secant or a cosecant.

This is the whole lesson as a procedure, and the picture is deliberately arranged with three different starts and one shared finish, because that is the structural point.

Whatever you are given, the goal is always the same: get hold of the three lengths. A point hands you two of them and the third is a square root away. A value with a quadrant hands you a ratio of two of them, so you invent a convenient pair with the right signs and compute the third. A triangle hands you all three under different names, with every sign positive.

The last two lines are the ones that separate a careful answer from a lucky one. Always run a check, and choose the cheapest one available: the sign pattern against the quadrant, the Pythagorean theorem in a triangle, or recomputing the value you were given. And before solving any equation in secant or cosecant, compare the target with the range, because an equation with no solutions is answered in one line or not at all.

64. Order a two-sighting problem

Ranking

Put in order

Put the steps of a two-sighting height problem into the order you should carry them out.

  1. Draw the ground line with both observation points and the object
  2. Write one tangent equation for each sighting, the steeper angle with the shorter base
  3. Use the simpler equation to express the unknown base in terms of the height
  4. Substitute into the second equation and solve the resulting linear equation for the height
  5. Rationalise, evaluate and round, then check the second sighting reproduces its angle

Why: The picture comes first because it is what stops the two angles being paired with the wrong distances, which is the commonest error in these problems. Both equations must be written before either is used, since it is the comparison that reveals which one is simpler. Eliminating the base turns two equations into one, and the check at the end costs one division and catches a sign slip anywhere earlier.

Put the five steps in order before checking. Only one of them is genuinely contentious, and it is the first.

Drawing the picture comes before writing any equation, and it is not optional politeness. The single most common error in these problems is pairing the steeper angle with the longer distance, and that error is almost impossible to make once both observation points are drawn on a ground line with the object between them in view.

The rest of the order follows from the algebra. Both equations must be written before either is used, because you need to compare them to see which is simpler to rearrange. Eliminating the unknown base turns two equations into one. And the check goes last, costs one division, and catches an error made anywhere earlier in the page.

65. Check: all six from a point

Check

Check your understanding

The terminal side of an angle contains the point with coordinates −8 and 15. What is the cosecant of that angle?

  • A. 17/15 (correct)
  • B. −17/8
  • C. 15/17
  • D. −17/15

Answer: A

Why: The radius is the square root of 64 plus 225, which is the square root of 289, namely 17. Cosecant is r over y, and y is 15, so the value is 17/15. The point is in quadrant two, where the second coordinate is positive, so the cosecant is positive as well.

Why B tempts people
That is the secant, r over x, and the minus sign is right for it, but the question asked for the cosecant.
Why C tempts people
That is the sine, y over r. Cosecant is its reciprocal, so the 17 belongs on top.
Why D tempts people
The size is right but the sign is not. Cosecant takes its sign from the second coordinate, which is positive here.

Compute the radius first. Sixty-four plus two hundred and twenty-five is two hundred and eighty-nine, which is seventeen squared, so the radius is seventeen and no surds appear anywhere.

Then read the definition rather than recalling it. Cosecant is the radius over the second coordinate, so seventeen over fifteen. Two of the distractors are the other values you could form from the same three numbers, and one is the correct size with the wrong sign, which is what happens if you decide the answer should be negative because the point is in the second quadrant. Only the first coordinate is negative there, so only the values built from it come out negative.

If you hesitated over which of the six you were being asked for, write all six down in the reciprocal pairs before you look at the options. It takes fifteen seconds from a radius of seventeen, and it makes every distractor visibly wrong rather than merely unappealing. That habit is worth carrying into the exam, because these questions are almost always written so that the wrong options are the other correct values of the same angle.

66. Check: choosing the relation in a triangle

Check

Check your understanding

In a right triangle an acute angle measures 38 degrees and the side opposite it is 7 units long. Which single equation gives the hypotenuse c directly?

  • A. c = 7 sec 38°
  • B. c = 7 csc 38° (correct)
  • C. c = 7 cot 38°
  • D. c = 7 tan 38°

Answer: B

Why: Cosecant is hypotenuse over opposite, and the known side is the opposite one, so c over 7 equals the cosecant of 38 degrees and c is 7 times that, about 11.37. The relation you want is the one whose two names are the side you have and the side you want.

Why A tempts people
Secant is hypotenuse over adjacent. That relation would be right if the known side of 7 were the adjacent one.
Why C tempts people
Cotangent is adjacent over opposite, so this gives the other leg, not the hypotenuse.
Why D tempts people
Tangent is opposite over adjacent, so this does not involve the hypotenuse at all, and it also has the known side in the wrong position.

The whole question is which relation names the two sides in play, and the two sides in play are the opposite one and the hypotenuse.

That is the cosecant, so the hypotenuse is seven times the cosecant of thirty-eight degrees, about 11.37. Two of the wrong options, the secant and the cotangent, would be right if the known side were the adjacent one or if you wanted the other leg, so they are the errors you make by naming the sides carelessly. The tangent option does not involve the hypotenuse at all, which you can spot without any calculation.

There is a size check available too, and it costs nothing. The hypotenuse must be longer than either leg, so any option coming out below seven is wrong on sight, which disposes of the tangent one at about 5.47. The other two both survive that test, at about 8.96 and 8.88, so the size check narrows the field but cannot finish the job. Name the relation properly and the answer is unambiguous.

67. Check: domains and ranges

Check

Check your understanding

Which one of these four statements is true?

  • A. The range of cotangent is all u with |u| ≥ 1
  • B. Cosecant is undefined at the odd multiples of π/2
  • C. Tangent is undefined at the odd multiples of π/2 (correct)
  • D. The range of secant is all real numbers except 0

Answer: C

Why: Tangent is sine over cosine, so it fails exactly where the cosine vanishes, which is at the odd multiples of a quarter turn. That is the same exclusion list as secant, because secant has the same denominator.

Why A tempts people
Cotangent is a quotient of two coordinates, not a reciprocal of a bounded function, so its range is every real number with nothing left out.
Why B tempts people
Cosecant is one over sine, so it fails where the sine vanishes, at the whole multiples of a half turn, not at the odd multiples of a quarter turn.
Why D tempts people
The range of secant leaves out the whole open band from negative one to one, not just the single number zero.

Go through the four statements one at a time rather than looking for the one that feels right, because all four are of the same shape and three of them are near misses.

Tangent has the cosine underneath, so it fails wherever the cosine does, at the odd multiples of a quarter turn. The cosecant option swaps the two exclusion lists, which is the commonest confusion in this part. The cotangent option gives it the range of a reciprocal of a bounded function, which it is not. And the last option describes the range of secant as everything except zero, which misses the whole band between negative one and one.

If you want one question to ask yourself on any statement of this kind, it is what sits in the denominator. That single fact decides the exclusions, and whether the function is a reciprocal or a quotient of two coordinates decides the range. Everything in Theorem 10.11 follows from those two observations, so you never need to hold six domains and six ranges in memory as separate facts.

68. Explain the three-length picture to yourself

Explain it to yourself

Discussion prompt

Without looking back, write two or three sentences explaining why one picture, a point on a ray with its right triangle, accounts for all three of the situations in this lesson: a point given by coordinates, a single value with a quadrant, and a right triangle with an acute angle. Then say what changes between the three.

Write this out in full sentences before revealing. If you can produce it from memory, you can rebuild every formula in the lesson from one drawing, which is a much lighter thing to carry than twelve formulas.

The core of the answer is that all three situations describe the same object: an angle at the origin, a point somewhere on its terminal side, and the right triangle joining that point to the axis. Three lengths live in that drawing, and all six functions are one of them divided by another. That is why the same six divisions finish every problem.

What differs is only which of the three lengths you are handed and under what name. A point gives two of them directly. A value with a quadrant gives a ratio of two of them, so you choose a convenient pair. A triangle gives all three, renamed as adjacent, opposite and hypotenuse, with every sign positive because an acute angle sits in the first quadrant. Say that last clause out loud a few times; it is the sentence that makes Part 3 feel like a restatement rather than new material.

69. Exit ticket

Exit ticket

An angle lies in the third quadrant and its secant is negative five thirds. From a point 60 feet from a flagpole, the angle of elevation to its top is 52 degrees.

Discussion prompt

Find the tangent of the angle, and separately find the height of the flagpole to the nearest foot. Then say, in one sentence, why the second problem never required you to think about signs.

Do both halves and then answer the one-sentence question, which is the part that shows whether the lesson landed.

For the first half, the secant is the radius over the first coordinate, and the radius has to be positive, so the minus sign belongs to the first coordinate. The third quadrant then forces the second coordinate to be negative as well, and the circle equation gives its size as four. The tangent is a quotient of two negatives, so it comes out positive, which is exactly what the third quadrant predicts.

The second half needs no sign reasoning at all, and that is the point of asking the two together. A flagpole problem is an acute angle in a right triangle, where all three sides are lengths and every one of the six values is positive. The difference between the two halves is not difficulty; it is whether the angle is acute and the lengths are genuine lengths.

70. Recap

Recap

you are givenfirst movewhat to check at the end
a point on the terminal sidecompute the radius, positivethe sign pattern matches the quadrant
one value and a quadrantsplit the value, sign the coordinatesrecompute the given value from your point
a right triangle and an acute anglename adjacent, opposite, hypotenusethe Pythagorean theorem, and that c is largest
one elevation and a reachable baseone tangent equationa steeper angle gives a taller answer
two elevations a measured distance aparttwo tangent equationsthe far sighting reproduces its angle

\[ \sec\theta = \tfrac{r}{x} = \tfrac{c}{a}, \;\; \csc\theta = \tfrac{r}{y} = \tfrac{c}{b}, \;\; \tan\theta = \tfrac{y}{x} = \tfrac{b}{a}, \;\; \cot\theta = \tfrac{x}{y} = \tfrac{a}{b} \]

Two functions are defined everywhere and bounded, two are never small, and two take every real value. Lesson 10.4 leaves the definitions behind and starts building identities that relate one angle to another.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, pp. 752-760 — Theorems 10.9, 10.10 and 10.11

OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §7.2 Right Triangle Trigonometry §7.2 Right Triangle Trigonometry — the same material, with the ratios named sine, cosine and tangent first

The table is organised by what you are handed, because that is how the exercises are organised. Read down the first column, decide which row you are in, and the second column tells you your first move. The third column is the part people skip, and it is where the marks are.

Underneath the table sits the one line worth memorising: each of the four new functions has two equivalent readings, one in coordinates and one in triangle sides. Those readings are not two theorems. They are one theorem seen from two positions, and sliding an acute triangle to the origin is what turns the second into the first.

Three sentences summarise the last part. Cosine and sine are defined everywhere and never leave the stretch from negative one to one. Secant and cosecant have holes wherever their denominators vanish and never take a value of size less than one. Tangent and cotangent have the same holes as their partners and take every real value. Lesson 10.4 leaves definitions behind entirely and starts relating the function of one angle to the function of another, beginning with what happens when you negate the angle.

Sources

  1. Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities — Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Version 3 Corrected Edition, July 4 2013, pp. 752-759
  2. OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §7.2 Right Triangle Trigonometry

Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Trigonometry — $55/session, free consultation.

Book on Wyzant · Text (657) 465-8108