The four remaining circular functions defined from the same two coordinates: secant and cosecant as the reciprocals of cosine and sine, tangent and cotangent as their quotients, each with the restriction its denominator forces. Covers the geometric origin of the names tangent and secant, the reciprocal and quotient identities, the Generalized Reference Angle Theorem extending the reference-angle method to all six, the two further Pythagorean identities obtained by dividing the first through by a square, and the techniques for verifying an identity including Pythagorean conjugates.
Subject: Trigonometry · 68 slides · symbolic lesson
Open the interactive version of this deck
Title
Trigonometry · Section 10.3, first half
Four more functions from the same two coordinates
Objectives
Section 10.2 read two numbers off the unit circle and called them the cosine and the sine. This lesson takes those same two numbers, forms their reciprocals and their quotients, and gets four more functions for free. Nothing new is measured; what is new is the bookkeeping, because a quotient can fail.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, pp. 744-752 — the pages this lesson is built from
You spent Section 10.2 learning to find one point. Given an angle in standard position, you can say where its terminal side crosses the unit circle, and you call the two coordinates of that point the cosine and the sine. That is the whole machine, and this lesson adds no new machinery to it at all.
What it adds is four more names. Take one over the first coordinate and you have the secant; one over the second and you have the cosecant; the second over the first is the tangent and the first over the second is the cotangent. Every value you will meet in this lesson is one of those four arithmetic operations applied to numbers you already know how to find.
The genuine new difficulty is that a fraction can fail. Cosine and sine exist at every angle, but the moment you put a coordinate underneath a fraction bar you inherit the angles where that coordinate is zero, and there the function simply has no value. Half the care in this lesson is bookkeeping about exactly which angles those are.
The second half of the lesson turns the same definitions into identities and then into a technique. Dividing the Pythagorean identity by a square twice gives two more identities for free, and with those you can verify statements about these functions rather than merely evaluate them.
Warm-up
Discussion prompt
An angle in standard position has its terminal side meeting the unit circle at the point with coordinates negative one half and root three over two. Write down the cosine and the sine of that angle, and say what the angle could be. Do it before reading on.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.2 — the definition this lesson extends
Commit to an answer before you reveal this one. Nothing that follows will make sense if reading a point off the unit circle still takes effort, because every single value in this lesson starts with exactly that step.
The cosine is the first coordinate and the sine is the second. That is not a rule to be applied, it is the definition, so there is nothing to compute here at all. If you found yourself reaching for a triangle or a calculator, go back to Lesson 10.2 and rebuild the picture first.
For the angle itself, a first coordinate of negative one half and a second of root three over two puts the point up and to the left, in quadrant two, with a reference angle of a sixth of a half turn. Adding any whole number of full turns lands on the same point, which is why the answer is a family and not a single number.
Section
Part 1
Concept
Take the point where the terminal side of the angle crosses the unit circle. Call its coordinates x and y. You already know the first two functions.
\[ \cos(\theta) = x, \qquad \sin(\theta) = y \]
Figure (svg): A unit circle with an angle of about 125 degrees drawn in standard position. The point where the terminal side meets the circle is marked, with a dashed vertical line down to the horizontal axis and a dashed horizontal line across to the vertical axis, marking its two coordinates.
The other four are the two reciprocals and the two quotients you can build from the very same pair.
\[ \sec(\theta) = \frac1x, \quad \csc(\theta) = \frac1y, \quad \tan(\theta) = \frac{y}{x}, \quad \cot(\theta) = \frac{x}{y} \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 744 — Definition 10.2
Look at the figure and resist the urge to see anything complicated. There is one angle, one point, and two dashed lines that measure the point. Everything on this slide and in the rest of the lesson is arithmetic performed on those two measurements.
The angle drawn is deliberately in quadrant two so that the first coordinate is negative. That matters, because a negative coordinate underneath a fraction bar produces a negative reciprocal and a negative quotient, and the signs are where most early mistakes live.
Read the four new definitions slowly and notice the pattern. Two of them are reciprocals, one of each coordinate. Two of them are quotients, one each way round. There is nothing else you could build from two numbers with a single operation, which is why there are exactly four new functions and not five.
Notation
Annotate
On: \( \sec(\theta) = \frac1x, \;\; \csc(\theta) = \frac1y, \;\; \tan(\theta) = \frac{y}{x}, \;\; \cot(\theta) = \frac{x}{y} \)
Work through the annotations one at a time. The first two are the ones worth rehearsing out loud, because the names are actively misleading: secant sounds as though it should partner sine, and it does not. Say to yourself, secant goes over the first coordinate, cosecant over the second.
A trick that sticks better than the names: the co-functions, cosecant and cotangent, are the ones with the second coordinate underneath. Cosine, awkwardly, is the exception, because it is a coordinate rather than a fraction. Whatever mnemonic you choose, test it against the definition rather than trusting it.
The final annotation is the one that costs marks later. When a denominator is zero the function does not become large, and it does not become zero. There is no value there at all, and writing anything other than undefined is wrong.
Concept
Cosine and sine are defined for every angle: every terminal side meets the circle somewhere. The other four are fractions, and a fraction needs a nonzero denominator.
\[ \cos(\theta) = 0 \iff \theta = \frac{\pi}{2} + \pi k, \qquad \sin(\theta) = 0 \iff \theta = \pi k \]
So the exclusions come in pairs, because the functions come in pairs that share a denominator.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 744 — the provisos in Definition 10.2
This is the single most useful organising idea in the lesson, so learn it as a question rather than a list. Faced with any of the four new functions, ask which coordinate is underneath. That one question tells you where the function fails, and it tells you which other function fails at the same places.
The first coordinate is zero exactly at the top and the bottom of the circle, which is a quarter turn and three quarters of a turn and everything coterminal with them. The second coordinate is zero exactly at the right and the left, which is zero and a half turn and everything coterminal.
Notice that the two exclusion sets are written with a step of a half turn, not a full turn. That is because each set contains two points on opposite sides of the circle, and one formula with a step of a half turn reaches both. You will meet exactly the same compression when you solve tangent equations later in the lesson.
Picture it
Figure (svg): A unit circle with the four quadrantal points marked: one comma zero and negative one comma zero on the horizontal axis, and zero comma one and zero comma negative one on the vertical axis. The two points where the first coordinate is zero are flagged for secant and tangent; the two where the second coordinate is zero are flagged for cosecant and cotangent.
On the whole circle only four points cause trouble, and at each of them exactly two of the six functions have no value. The other four are perfectly well behaved there.
Take a moment to see how little is actually broken. There are infinitely many angles, and only four points on the circle where anything goes wrong at all. Away from those four points every one of the six functions is perfectly well defined.
At the top and bottom of the circle, marked in red, the first coordinate is zero, so the secant and the tangent have no value. The cosecant and the cotangent are completely happy there, because their denominator is the second coordinate, which is one or negative one.
At the left and right, marked in orange, the roles swap exactly. This symmetry is worth remembering as a pair of failures rather than four separate facts, because it halves what there is to recall and it also tells you what is still available when one function drops out.
Sorting
Sort into buckets
Sort each function by which angles it has to exclude.
Sort these before checking. Do not try to recall a list; run the question from the previous slides on each one. Which coordinate is underneath, and where is that coordinate zero?
Cosine and sine take no work: they are the coordinates, so there is no denominator and nothing can fail. If you hesitated over those two, the definitions have not quite settled yet.
The other four split into the two pairs you have just drawn. Secant and tangent both sit over the first coordinate, so both disappear on the vertical axis. Cosecant and cotangent both sit over the second, so both disappear on the horizontal axis. Getting this sort right quickly is a good sign that the rest of the lesson will go smoothly.
Picture it
Figure (svg): An acute angle in standard position on the unit circle. Its terminal side is extended until it meets the vertical line x equals 1 at a point Q. The segment from the origin out to Q is labelled secant of theta; the piece of the line x equals 1 between the horizontal axis and Q is labelled tangent of theta. Perpendiculars are dropped from the circle point P and from Q, making two similar right triangles.
Take an acute angle and follow its terminal side outwards until it meets the vertical line one unit to the right of the origin. That line touches the circle at exactly one point, and the Latin for touch gives the word tangent. The terminal side itself cuts straight through the circle, and the Latin for cut gives the word secant.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, pp. 744-745 — the diagram naming tangent and secant
These names are not arbitrary and they are not modern. They describe two lengths in the picture in front of you, and knowing that gives you a way of rebuilding the meanings when your memory of the formulas fails.
Follow the terminal side outwards past the circle until it hits the vertical line one unit to the right of the origin. That line touches the circle at exactly one point and never crosses it, and the Latin word for touching gives the name tangent. The height at which the terminal side cuts that line is the tangent of the angle.
The terminal side itself, extended in both directions, passes straight through the circle at two points, and the Latin word for cutting gives the name secant. The length of the piece from the origin out to the tangent line is the secant of the angle. Both readings hold only for acute angles, but that is where the names came from.
Worked example
Prove that in the picture the height of Q really is the tangent, and the length of the segment out to Q really is the secant.
Name the two triangles
Why: Drop a perpendicular from the circle point P to the horizontal axis, and another from Q. Triangle OPA and triangle OQB share the angle at O and both have a right angle.
\[ \triangle OPA \sim \triangle OQB \]
Write the ratio of the vertical legs to the horizontal legs
Why: Similar triangles have equal ratios of corresponding sides. The point P is at height y over a base x; the point Q is at height y prime over a base 1.
\[ \frac{y'}{1} = \frac{y}{x} \]
Read off the height of Q
Why: The right-hand side is the definition of the tangent.
\[ y' = \frac{y}{x} = \tan(\theta) \]
Now compare the hypotenuses
Why: Triangle OPA has hypotenuse 1, because P is on the unit circle. Let h be the hypotenuse of the larger triangle, that is the length from the origin out to Q.
\[ \frac{h}{1} = \frac{1}{x} \]
Read off that length
Why: Again the right-hand side is a definition.
\[ h = \frac1x = \sec(\theta) \]
Check the claim with a number
Why: At fifty degrees the cosine is 0.64279, so the secant is 1.55572, and the tangent is 1.19175. The big triangle has legs 1 and 1.19175, so Pythagoras gives a hypotenuse of the square root of 2.42028, which is 1.55572, exactly the secant.
\[ \sqrt{1^2 + \tan^2(50^\circ)} = \sqrt{2.42028} = 1.55572 = \sec(50^\circ) \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 745 — the similar-triangle argument
This is a short proof and it is worth being able to reproduce, because it is the first time in the course that a definition gets justified by geometry rather than simply announced.
The two triangles share the angle at the origin and both have a right angle where a vertical meets the horizontal axis, so they are similar. Similar triangles have equal ratios of corresponding sides, and reading off two different pairs of corresponding sides gives you the two results.
Compare the vertical legs to the horizontal legs and you get the height of the far point. Compare the hypotenuses instead and you get the length out to it. The small triangle has hypotenuse one, because its far corner is on the unit circle, and that is what makes both ratios come out so cleanly.
The numerical check at the end is not decoration. The big triangle has legs one and the tangent, so Pythagoras must give the secant as its hypotenuse. The fact that it does is really the second Pythagorean identity in disguise, which you will derive algebraically later in this lesson.
Prediction
\[ \cos(\theta) = \frac15 \]
Predict first
What is the secant of that angle?
Correct: It is 5
Why: Secant is one divided by the cosine, so it is one divided by one fifth, which is five. The general rule worth carrying: a cosine close to zero produces an enormous secant, and a cosine of size one produces a secant of size one. A reciprocal never lands strictly between negative one and one.
Choose an answer before revealing. The wrong options here are each a real mistake someone makes: copying the number across, subtracting from one, and declaring the value undefined because the cosine is small.
Secant is one over the cosine, so a cosine of one fifth gives a secant of five. Nothing is undefined, because one fifth is not zero; the value is just large.
The general lesson is more valuable than the arithmetic. As the cosine shrinks towards zero the secant grows without bound, and as the cosine grows towards one the secant comes down towards one. The secant is never smaller than one in size, and you will prove that properly later in this part.
Section
Part 2
Concept
Definition 10.2 is written in x and y. Replace x by the cosine and y by the sine and the definitions become identities you can use anywhere.
\[ \sec(\theta) = \frac{1}{\cos(\theta)}, \qquad \csc(\theta) = \frac{1}{\sin(\theta)} \]
\[ \tan(\theta) = \frac{\sin(\theta)}{\cos(\theta)}, \qquad \cot(\theta) = \frac{\cos(\theta)}{\sin(\theta)} \]
Theorem 10.6 — Each of the four new circular functions written in terms of cosine and sine, valid at every angle where the denominator in question is not zero, and undefined where it is.
The practical consequence is large: any expression in the six functions can be rewritten in only two of them. That is the one strategy that always works, even when it is not the shortest.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 745 — Theorem 10.6
This theorem contains no new information whatsoever. It is Definition 10.2 with the letter x replaced by the cosine and the letter y replaced by the sine, which is allowed because those replacements are exactly what the definition of cosine and sine say.
Why bother writing it down, then? Because in practice you almost never know the coordinates as letters; you know them as cosine and sine values. Having the four statements in this form means you can work with any expression containing all six functions by rewriting it in only two.
Keep the strategy in mind for the rest of the lesson. Converting everything to cosine and sine is the move that always works. It is often not the shortest route, and for tangent and cotangent equations it is usually the wrong one, but when you are stuck it will get you moving.
Notation
Annotate
On: \( \tan(\theta) = \frac{\sin(\theta)}{\cos(\theta)}, \quad \cos(\theta) \ne 0 \)
The annotation worth dwelling on is the third one. Rise over run is a slope, so the tangent of an angle is the slope of its terminal side. Once that picture is in place, several later facts stop needing to be memorised.
For instance, it explains immediately why the tangent is undefined at a quarter turn: a vertical line has no slope. It explains why the tangent repeats every half turn rather than every full turn: the opposite end of the same line has the same slope. And it explains why the tangent takes every real value, since a line through the origin can be as steep or as shallow as you like.
The last annotation is a genuine contrast with secant and cosecant. Those are reciprocals of a bounded quantity and are therefore themselves bounded away from zero. The tangent is a ratio of two bounded quantities, and a ratio is not bounded at all.
Worked example
Find each value, or say that it does not exist.
\[ \text{(1) } \sec(60^\circ) \qquad \text{(2) } \csc\left(\frac{7\pi}{4}\right) \]
Write the secant as one over the cosine
Why: Theorem 10.6. Find the cosine first, then reciprocate; never try to reciprocate the angle.
\[ \sec(60^\circ) = \frac{1}{\cos(60^\circ)} = \frac{1}{1/2} \]
Simplify the compound fraction
Why: Dividing by one half is multiplying by two.
\[ \sec(60^\circ) = 2 \]
Find the sine of the second angle
Why: Seven pi over four sits in quadrant four with reference angle pi over four, so the sine is negative.
\[ \sin\left(\frac{7\pi}{4}\right) = -\frac{\sqrt2}{2} \]
Reciprocate and rationalise
Why: One over negative root two over two is negative two over root two; multiply top and bottom by root two.
\[ \csc\left(\frac{7\pi}{4}\right) = -\frac{2}{\sqrt2} = -\frac{2\sqrt2}{2} = -\sqrt2 \]
Check both against the size rule
Why: A cosine of one half is half-sized, so its reciprocal must be double-sized, and 2 is. A sine of about negative 0.7071 gives a reciprocal of about negative 1.4142, which is negative root two, and it lies outside the forbidden band between negative one and one.
\[ \frac{1}{0.5} = 2, \qquad \frac{1}{-0.7071} = -1.4142 = -\sqrt2 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 746 — Example 10.3.1, parts 1 and 2
The shape of both solutions is identical, and it is the shape of nearly every evaluation you will do: find the cosine or the sine of the angle first, then perform the one arithmetic step. Trying to go directly to a secant value is how people end up guessing.
In part two the angle is in quadrant four, so the sine is negative, and the sign travels through the reciprocal unchanged. The rationalising step at the end is optional mathematically but expected in an answer: two over root two is the same number as root two, and the second form is the one to write.
The check at the end is a habit worth building. A cosine of one half should give a secant of size two, because halving and doubling are inverse. Any reciprocal answer whose size sits strictly between zero and one is wrong before you look at anything else.
Worked example
Two angles that are not on the special list, for opposite reasons.
\[ \text{(3) } \cot(3) \qquad \text{(4) } \tan(\theta), \; \theta \text{ coterminal with } \tfrac{3\pi}{2} \]
Rewrite the cotangent as a quotient
Why: Three radians is not a common angle, so the calculator has to do it — in radian mode.
\[ \cot(3) = \frac{\cos(3)}{\sin(3)} \]
Evaluate
Why: The cosine of 3 is about negative 0.98999 and the sine of 3 is about 0.14112; the quotient is large and negative because the angle is just short of a half turn.
\[ \cot(3) \approx \frac{-0.98999}{0.14112} \approx -7.015 \]
Find the coordinates for the fourth part
Why: Coterminal angles share a terminal side, so they share the point, and at three quarters of a turn that point is the bottom of the circle.
\[ \cos(\theta) = 0, \qquad \sin(\theta) = -1 \]
Attempt the quotient
Why: The denominator is zero, so there is nothing to compute.
\[ \tan(\theta) = \frac{-1}{0} \;\text{: undefined} \]
Check the two answers differently
Why: For the cotangent: three radians is about 171.9 degrees, reference angle about 8.1 degrees, and the cotangent of 8.1 degrees is about 7.015, negative in quadrant two. For the tangent: secant shares the same denominator, so it is undefined too, while cosecant is one over negative one and cotangent is zero over negative one, both of which exist.
\[ \csc(\theta) = \frac{1}{-1} = -1, \qquad \cot(\theta) = \frac{0}{-1} = 0 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 746 — Example 10.3.1, parts 3 and 4
These two parts look similar on the page and are completely different in kind. In the first the answer is a number that you cannot find by hand; in the second there is no answer at all.
For the cotangent of three radians, everything hinges on being in radian mode. Three radians is just short of a half turn, so the point is only a little way below the negative end of the horizontal axis: the first coordinate is close to negative one and the second is small and positive. A large negative quotient is exactly what that geometry predicts, which is why the check recomputes it from the reference angle.
For the tangent at three quarters of a turn, the important discipline is to write undefined and stop. Not infinity, not a very large number, not zero. The check also shows you what is still available at that angle: the cosecant and the cotangent both exist there, because their denominator is the second coordinate, which is negative one.
Worked example
\[ \csc(\theta) = -\sqrt5, \quad \theta \text{ in Quadrant IV}. \;\text{ Find } \cos(\theta). \]
Turn the cosecant into a sine
Why: Cosecant is one over the sine, so the sine is one over the cosecant.
\[ \sin(\theta) = \frac{1}{-\sqrt5} = -\frac{1}{\sqrt5} \]
Rationalise the denominator
Why: Multiply top and bottom by root five.
\[ \sin(\theta) = -\frac{\sqrt5}{5} \]
Put it into the Pythagorean identity
Why: Squaring removes the sign, and one fifth is what is left.
\[ \cos^2(\theta) + \frac{5}{25} = 1 \]
Solve for the square of the cosine
Why: Subtract one fifth from one.
\[ \cos^2(\theta) = \frac45 \]
Take the square root, both signs
Why: The root of four fifths is two over root five, rationalised.
\[ \cos(\theta) = \pm\frac{2\sqrt5}{5} \]
Let the quadrant pick the sign
Why: In quadrant four the first coordinate is positive, so the cosine is positive.
\[ \cos(\theta) = \frac{2\sqrt5}{5} \]
Check the pair on the circle
Why: The cosine is about 0.8944 and the sine about negative 0.4472; squaring and adding gives 0.8 plus 0.2, which is 1, so the point really is on the unit circle. The signs, positive then negative, are quadrant four, as required.
\[ (0.8944)^2 + (-0.4472)^2 = 0.8 + 0.2 = 1 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 746 — Example 10.3.1, part 5
This is the standard three-move problem of the section, and you should be able to recognise it instantly: you are given one function value plus a quadrant, and asked for another. The three moves are convert to cosine or sine, use the Pythagorean identity, then let the quadrant choose the sign.
Notice the order. Taking a square root always produces two candidates, and there is no way to choose between them from the algebra alone. The quadrant information in the question is not decoration; it is the only thing that settles the sign, and an answer that gives both signs has not finished.
Quadrant four means the first coordinate is positive and the second is negative. The cosecant being negative already told you the sine was negative, which is consistent, so the extra information the quadrant supplies is precisely the sign of the cosine.
Worked example
\[ \tan(\theta) = 3, \quad \pi < \theta < \frac{3\pi}{2}. \;\text{ Find } \sin(\theta). \]
Write the tangent as a quotient and clear it
Why: A tangent of 3 says the sine is three times the cosine. It does NOT say the sine is 3 and the cosine is 1.
\[ \frac{\sin(\theta)}{\cos(\theta)} = 3 \;\Longrightarrow\; \sin(\theta) = 3\cos(\theta) \]
Express the cosine through the sine
Why: Divide both sides by three, so that only one unknown is left to substitute.
\[ \cos(\theta) = \tfrac13 \sin(\theta) \]
Substitute into the Pythagorean identity
Why: Now the identity contains the sine only.
\[ \sin^2(\theta) + \left(\tfrac13\sin(\theta)\right)^2 = 1 \]
Collect the terms
Why: One plus one ninth is ten ninths.
\[ \tfrac{10}{9}\sin^2(\theta) = 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; \sin^2(\theta) = \tfrac{9}{10} \]
Take the root and rationalise
Why: The root of nine tenths is three over root ten.
\[ \sin(\theta) = \pm\frac{3\sqrt{10}}{10} \]
Let the quadrant pick the sign
Why: Between a half turn and three quarters of a turn the angle is in quadrant three, where the second coordinate is negative.
\[ \sin(\theta) = -\frac{3\sqrt{10}}{10} \]
Check by rebuilding the tangent
Why: The sine is about negative 0.94868 and the cosine is one third of that, about negative 0.31623; their quotient is 3, and both being negative is quadrant three.
\[ \frac{-0.94868}{-0.31623} = 3 \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 746 — Example 10.3.1, part 6
The first step is the one that separates a correct solution from a lucky one. A tangent of three is a statement about the ratio of the two coordinates, so clearing the fraction gives you a relation between them, not their values.
Substituting that relation into the Pythagorean identity leaves a single unknown. Watch the algebra in the collecting step: one plus one ninth is ten ninths, so the square of the sine is nine tenths, not one tenth. Getting that upside down is the most common slip here.
Then the interval in the question does the same job the quadrant did last time. Between a half turn and three quarters of a turn you are in quadrant three, where both coordinates are negative, so the sine is negative. The check rebuilds the tangent from the two coordinates and gets three back, which is exactly the verification you should do every time.
Trap
The tempting shortcut:
\[ \tan(\theta) = 3 = \frac{3}{1} \]
\[ \Longrightarrow\; \sin(\theta) = 3, \; \cos(\theta) = 1 ? \]
Wrong. A sine of 3 is impossible.
The sine is a coordinate on the unit circle, so it can never exceed one in size. A quotient of 3 tells you the ratio of the two coordinates, not the coordinates themselves.
\[ \sin(\theta) = 3\cos(\theta) \]
Substitute that ratio into the Pythagorean identity and let it find the actual sizes, as the worked example did.
This mistake is very tempting because the notation invites it. A tangent is written as a single fraction, three over one looks like a perfectly good fraction, and the numerator of the quotient identity is the sine.
The defence is instant and costs nothing: a sine is a coordinate on a circle of radius one, so it can never exceed one in size. Any line of working that produces a sine of three has gone wrong earlier, and you can stop and look for the error rather than carrying on.
What a tangent of three really tells you is that the point sits three times as high as it is far to the right. Feed that ratio into the Pythagorean identity, as the worked example did, and the identity finds the actual sizes for you.
Concept
Converting to cosine and sine always works, but for the tangent and cotangent it is usually slower than knowing the values outright. These five are worth memorising.
| angle in degrees | angle in radians | tangent | cotangent |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 0 | 0 | undefined |
| 30 | pi over 6 | root 3 over 3 | root 3 |
| 45 | pi over 4 | 1 | 1 |
| 60 | pi over 3 | root 3 | root 3 over 3 |
| 90 | pi over 2 | undefined | 0 |
Read the two columns in opposite directions and they are the same list: the tangent climbs from zero to undefined while the cotangent falls from undefined to zero. That symmetry is a free check on your memory.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 747 — Tangent and Cotangent Values of Common Angles
You can always get these values by dividing a sine by a cosine, and for a while you probably should, so that the table means something. But once the derivation is secure, knowing the five entries outright will save you a great deal of time in the equation-solving part of this lesson and in every later chapter.
Notice that the two columns are the same five entries in opposite orders. That is not a coincidence: the cotangent of an angle is the tangent of its complement, and the five angles listed are symmetric about a half of a quarter turn. Use it as a check whenever you recall one of the values.
Pay particular attention to the two entries that say undefined. The tangent fails at a quarter turn and the cotangent fails at zero, and those two entries follow from the general rule about which coordinate sits underneath.
Picture it
Figure (svg): The unit circle with three terminal sides drawn, at pi over six, pi over four and pi over three, each extended to the vertical line x equals 1. The three heights at which they cut that line are marked, growing from about 0.58 through 1 to about 1.73.
The three common angles, each terminal side extended to the vertical line one unit out. The heights at which they cut it are the three tangent values in the table, and you can see them growing without bound as the angle approaches a quarter turn, where the terminal side becomes parallel to that line and never meets it at all.
Look at the three heights and watch how quickly they grow. From the shallowest angle to the steepest, the terminal side has turned by only a sixth of a quarter turn each time, and the height has gone from about 0.58 to 1 to about 1.73, roughly tripling.
That acceleration is the geometric reason the tangent runs away to infinity. As the terminal side approaches the vertical, it becomes more and more nearly parallel to the line it is supposed to cut, so the crossing point runs further and further up. At exactly a quarter turn the two lines are parallel and there is no crossing at all, which is the undefined entry in the table.
Try to keep this picture rather than the table. If you can see the terminal side sweeping upwards and the crossing point racing away, you will never be tempted to write a large number where undefined belongs.
Fill the middle
Express the cotangent through cosine and sine, then evaluate it at pi over three.
Fill in the blanks
\cot(\theta) = \frac\cos(\theta)}\sqrt3/2 \;\Longrightarrow\; \cot\left(\frac\sqrt3/3___\right) = \frac______} = ___
Why: Cotangent is the first coordinate over the second, which is cosine over sine. At pi over three the cosine is one half and the sine is root three over two, so the quotient is one over root three, which rationalises to root three over three. That matches the table, where pi over three has cotangent root three over three.
Fill the three blanks before checking. The first one is testing whether you have the cotangent the right way up, which is the single most common confusion of the lesson.
Cotangent is the first coordinate over the second, so it is cosine over sine, and the blank upstairs is the cosine. At a third of a half turn the point has first coordinate one half and second coordinate root three over two, so the quotient is one over root three.
One over root three is a correct answer, but the conventional form rationalises it to root three over three, and that is the entry you will see in the table and in the back of the book. Getting used to writing it that way now will save arguments with answer keys later.
Matching
Match the pairs
Why: Cosine is the first coordinate and secant is one over it; sine is the second coordinate and cosecant is one over it; tangent and cotangent are the two quotients, each the reciprocal of the other. The last pair is a reminder that y over x is a rise over a run, so the tangent of an angle is the slope of its terminal side.
Three of these four pairings are the reciprocal relationships, and the fourth is a reminder of the geometric meaning. Make the matches before revealing.
The pairing that catches people is the first two. Cosine, with the co, partners secant, with no co; sine, with no co, partners cosecant, with the co. The names are crossed, and there is no way to derive them from the words, so tie each one to its coordinate instead.
The last pairing is the one to carry forward. The second coordinate over the first is a rise over a run, which is a slope, so the tangent of an angle is the slope of its terminal side. That single sentence explains the tangent's period, its undefined points and its unbounded range.
Concept
Both coordinates on the unit circle lie between negative one and one. Reciprocating a number of size at most one gives a number of size at least one, so the secant and the cosecant skip a whole interval.
\[ |\cos(\theta)| \le 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; |\sec(\theta)| = \frac{1}{|\cos(\theta)|} \ge 1 \]
Figure (svg): Two number lines. The upper one shows the values a secant or cosecant can take: everything at or below negative one and everything at or above one, with the stretch strictly between them struck out. The lower one shows the values a tangent or cotangent can take: the entire line.
The tangent and the cotangent behave in exactly the opposite way. They are quotients of two small numbers, and a small number divided by a smaller one can be as large as you like, so every real number is a tangent of something.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 758 — the ranges, and why some equations have no solutions
This is a two-line argument and it deserves to be understood rather than accepted, because it is the reason certain equations later in the lesson have no solutions at all.
A point on the unit circle has both coordinates between negative one and one. Reciprocating a number whose size is at most one always gives a number whose size is at least one, so the secant and the cosecant are pushed out of the whole interval strictly between negative one and one. The number line in the figure shows that gap directly.
The tangent and the cotangent do the opposite, and the reason is worth saying carefully. They are quotients of two coordinates, and while both coordinates are small, their ratio is not controlled by that at all. As the terminal side turns towards the vertical, the denominator shrinks towards zero while the numerator does not, so the quotient sweeps through every value.
Picture it
Figure (svg): The graph of one over the cosine over two full turns, with vertical asymptotes wherever the cosine is zero, drawn together with the cosine itself. A horizontal band between negative one and one is shaded and the secant curve never enters it.
Where the cosine touches one or negative one the secant touches the same value, and those are the closest it ever comes to the horizontal axis. Where the cosine crosses zero the secant runs off to infinity, and the broken curve there is not a gap in the drawing but a genuine gap in the function.
Compare the two curves rather than reading either alone. Wherever the dashed cosine curve touches its highest or lowest point, the secant curve touches the same point, because one over one is one. Those touching points are the closest the secant ever comes to the horizontal axis.
Wherever the cosine crosses zero the secant flies off in both directions, and the breaks you see in the curve are genuine gaps in the function, not gaps in the drawing. The breaks land exactly at the angles you identified earlier, a quarter turn plus any number of half turns.
The shaded band is the interval that the earlier argument ruled out, and the picture confirms it: no part of the secant curve ever enters it. Keep this image beside the number-line figure from the previous slide; they say the same thing in two languages.
Tweak it
Parameter explorer
The curve is the secant of an angle with a constant c subtracted. Wherever it crosses the horizontal axis, the secant of that angle equals c. Slide c from negative three to three and watch the crossings appear and disappear.
\[ y = \sec(\theta) - {c} \]
Move the slider slowly from one end to the other and watch the crossings, because the crossings are the solutions. At any level of size two the curve meets the axis twice in each full turn, and those two crossings are the two solution families you will find algebraically in the next part.
Now bring the level in towards zero. Somewhere around one the crossings vanish entirely, and for every level strictly between negative one and one the curve floats clear of the axis. Those are exactly the equations that have no solutions, and you can now see why rather than just being told.
Watch the two crossings within one full turn as you move the level. They are reflections of each other across the vertical axis, never half a turn apart, which is the geometric reason the two secant families cannot be merged into one.
Section
Part 3
Concept
You already know that the cosine and sine of an angle match those of its reference angle up to a sign. Since the other four are built from those two, they inherit the same property.
Generalized Reference Angle Theorem — If the reference angle of theta is alpha, then each of the six circular functions of theta equals plus or minus the same function of alpha, whenever it exists. The quadrant of theta chooses the sign.
\[ \tan(\theta) = \pm\tan(\alpha), \qquad \sec(\theta) = \pm\sec(\alpha), \qquad \csc(\theta) = \pm\csc(\alpha) \]
Figure (svg): A unit circle with four terminal sides drawn, at pi over three, two pi over three, four pi over three and five pi over three. Each makes the same sixty-degree angle with the horizontal axis, and each is labelled with the value of the tangent there: plus root three in the first and third quadrants, minus root three in the second and fourth.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 747 — Theorem 10.7
This theorem earns its length by saying very little. You already knew it for cosine and sine. The other four functions are built from those two by reciprocals and quotients, and neither operation can change the size of an answer that was already determined up to a sign, so the same statement carries over.
The practical procedure it licenses has two independent halves. The reference angle gives you the size of the answer, and it is found by ignoring signs entirely. The quadrant gives you the sign, and it is found by asking about the signs of the two coordinates. Never let one half contaminate the other.
In the figure all four terminal sides make the same angle with the horizontal axis, so all four tangents have the same size. Only the sign changes, and it changes exactly when the two coordinates stop agreeing in sign.
Picture it
Figure (svg): The coordinate plane with the unit circle drawn and the four quadrants labelled. Each quadrant carries the signs of the two coordinates there and, beneath them, which of the six circular functions come out positive and which come out negative.
There are only three sign patterns, not six, because a function and its reciprocal always agree in sign. Tangent and cotangent are positive exactly where the two coordinates agree in sign, which is quadrants one and three, and that pattern belongs to neither cosine nor sine.
There are six functions but only three sign patterns, and the reason is simple: a number and its reciprocal always have the same sign, since one divided by a negative number is negative.
So the cosine and the secant agree everywhere, the sine and the cosecant agree everywhere, and the tangent and the cotangent agree with each other. That last pair follows a pattern that belongs to neither of the first two: positive where the coordinates agree in sign, which is quadrants one and three.
You may have met a mnemonic for this chart. It is fine to use one, but it is better to be able to rebuild the chart in three seconds from the signs of the coordinates, because a mnemonic can be misremembered and the coordinates cannot.
Worked example
Find every angle satisfying the equation.
\[ \sec(\theta) = 2 \]
Convert to a cosine
Why: For secant and cosecant the reliable route is always back to cosine and sine.
\[ \frac{1}{\cos(\theta)} = 2 \;\Longrightarrow\; \cos(\theta) = \frac12 \]
Find the reference angle
Why: A cosine of one half belongs to pi over three.
\[ \alpha = \frac{\pi}{3} \]
Choose the quadrants
Why: The cosine is positive where the first coordinate is positive, which is quadrants one and four.
\[ \theta = \frac{\pi}{3} + 2\pi k \quad\text{or}\quad \theta = \frac{5\pi}{3} + 2\pi k \]
Check whether the two families merge
Why: They are not half a turn apart: five pi over three minus pi over three is four pi over three, not pi. So they must stay as two families.
\[ \frac{5\pi}{3} - \frac{\pi}{3} = \frac{4\pi}{3} \ne \pi \]
Check one angle from each family
Why: The cosine of pi over three is 0.5 and so is the cosine of five pi over three; both reciprocals are 2.
\[ \sec\left(\tfrac{\pi}{3}\right) = 2, \qquad \sec\left(\tfrac{5\pi}{3}\right) = 2 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 747 — Example 10.3.2, part 1
For secant and cosecant the reliable first move is always to convert. Once the equation reads cosine equals one half, it is an equation you solved in Lesson 10.2 and nothing further is new.
Then the two halves of the procedure run separately. A cosine of one half in size belongs to a reference angle of a third of a half turn, and a positive cosine means the first coordinate is positive, which happens in quadrants one and four. Those two facts combine into two families of angles.
The fourth step is the one people skip. Before you write two families, or before you try to compress them into one, actually subtract and see how far apart they are. Here the gap is four thirds of a half turn, which is not a half turn, so the two families must stay separate.
Worked example
\[ \tan(\theta) = \sqrt3 \]
Read the reference angle off the table
Why: Do not convert this one: the table gives the tangent of pi over three directly.
\[ \tan\left(\frac{\pi}{3}\right) = \sqrt3 \;\Longrightarrow\; \alpha = \frac{\pi}{3} \]
Decide the quadrants from the sign
Why: The tangent is the second coordinate over the first, so it is positive when the two agree in sign: quadrants one and three.
\[ \tan(\theta) > 0 \text{ in QI and QIII} \]
Write the two families
Why: Quadrant one gives the reference angle itself; quadrant three gives it plus a half turn.
\[ \theta = \frac{\pi}{3} + 2\pi k \quad\text{or}\quad \theta = \frac{4\pi}{3} + 2\pi k \]
Merge them
Why: This time they ARE half a turn apart, so stepping by pi instead of by two pi visits both.
\[ \theta = \frac{\pi}{3} + \pi k \]
Figure (svg): Two unit circles side by side. On the left a single terminal side at pi over three. On the right the same line continued straight through the origin, so it also hits the circle at four pi over three, the two points being exactly half a turn apart.
Check the merged form against the picture
Why: Both terminal sides lie on one straight line through the origin, and the tangent is that line's slope, so of course they give the same value. Numerically the tangent of four pi over three is 1.7321, which is root three.
\[ \tan\left(\tfrac{4\pi}{3}\right) = 1.7321 = \sqrt3 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, pp. 747-748 — Example 10.3.2, part 2
Notice the change of strategy. For the secant you converted to a cosine; here you should not convert. The table gives the tangent values of the common angles directly, and converting would only create a fraction that you would immediately have to undo.
The sign reasoning is the part to internalise. The tangent is the second coordinate over the first, and a quotient is positive when the two agree in sign. Both positive is quadrant one; both negative is quadrant three. That is a different pair of quadrants from anything cosine or sine ever gives you.
The two families this time really are half a turn apart, so they merge into one. The picture shows why that is inevitable rather than lucky: the two terminal sides lie on a single straight line through the origin, and the tangent is that line's slope, so of course both ends give the same value.
Worked example
\[ \cot(\theta) = -1 \]
Find the reference angle from the size
Why: The table gives a cotangent of 1 at pi over four, so the reference angle is pi over four.
\[ \cot\left(\frac{\pi}{4}\right) = 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; \alpha = \frac{\pi}{4} \]
Decide the quadrants from the sign
Why: Cotangent is the first coordinate over the second, so a negative value needs the two coordinates to disagree in sign: quadrants two and four.
\[ \cot(\theta) < 0 \text{ in QII and QIV} \]
Write the two families
Why: In quadrant two the angle is a half turn minus the reference angle; in quadrant four it is a full turn minus it.
\[ \theta = \frac{3\pi}{4} + 2\pi k \quad\text{or}\quad \theta = \frac{7\pi}{4} + 2\pi k \]
Merge them
Why: Seven pi over four minus three pi over four is exactly pi, so one family with a step of pi covers both.
\[ \theta = \frac{3\pi}{4} + \pi k \]
Figure (svg): Two unit circles side by side. On the left a single terminal side at three pi over four. On the right the same line continued through the origin so it also meets the circle at seven pi over four, again half a turn apart.
Check both ends
Why: At three pi over four the point is negative root two over two, root two over two, so the quotient is negative one; at seven pi over four the signs swap and the quotient is negative one again.
\[ \cot\left(\tfrac{3\pi}{4}\right) = -1, \qquad \cot\left(\tfrac{7\pi}{4}\right) = -1 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 748 — Example 10.3.2, part 3
Same procedure, with a negative value, and the negativity only affects the sign half of the work. The size of the value, one, comes from a reference angle of a quarter of a half turn, which you read straight from the table.
A negative cotangent needs the first coordinate over the second to be negative, so the two coordinates must disagree in sign. Up and to the left is quadrant two, down and to the right is quadrant four, and those are your two families.
Again they turn out to be exactly half a turn apart and merge into one. Once you have seen this happen twice, the pattern is safe to use: tangent and cotangent always merge, because they are constant along a whole line through the origin, and the other four never do.
Trap
Having merged the tangent families, the same move gets tried on the secant ones:
\[ \theta = \tfrac{\pi}{3} + 2\pi k \]
\[ \theta = \tfrac{5\pi}{3} + 2\pi k \]
\[ \Longrightarrow\; \theta = \tfrac{\pi}{3} + \pi k ? \]
Wrong. That would add four pi over three.
Merging is allowed only when the two families are exactly a half turn apart. Test it by subtracting.
\[ \tfrac{5\pi}{3} - \tfrac{\pi}{3} = \tfrac{4\pi}{3} \]
Tangent and cotangent merge because they repeat every half turn. Cosine, sine, secant and cosecant repeat only every full turn, so their families stay separate.
Merging looks like tidying up, which is why it gets applied where it does not belong. The test takes five seconds: subtract the two starting angles and see whether you get exactly a half turn.
Here the gap is four thirds of a half turn, so stepping by a half turn from the first family would land on angles that are not solutions at all. You can see it directly on the circle: the two secant solutions are mirror images across the horizontal axis, not opposite ends of one line.
The underlying fact is about periods. Tangent and cotangent repeat every half turn; cosine, sine, secant and cosecant repeat only every full turn. Merging is legitimate exactly when the function's period is a half turn, and never otherwise.
Discrimination
Sort into buckets
Sort each equation by whether its two solution families merge into one.
Sort all six before checking, and sort them by the function rather than by the number, because the number is irrelevant to this question.
Every tangent and cotangent equation lands in the one-family bucket. Both functions take the same value at opposite ends of a line through the origin, so their two quadrant solutions are always exactly a half turn apart.
Every secant and cosecant equation lands in the two-family bucket, whatever the value and whatever its sign. Their solutions come from reflecting across an axis, which is not the same as continuing a line through the origin, so the gap between them is never a half turn. If you sorted by looking at whether the value was positive or negative, look again: the sign changes which quadrants, not how many families.
Worked example
One from the section's exercise set, worked the same way.
\[ \csc(\theta) = -2 \]
Convert to a sine
Why: Cosecant is one over the sine, so reciprocate both sides.
\[ \sin(\theta) = -\frac12 \]
Find the reference angle
Why: A sine of one half in size belongs to pi over six.
\[ \alpha = \frac{\pi}{6} \]
Choose the quadrants
Why: The sine is negative where the second coordinate is negative: quadrants three and four.
\[ \theta = \frac{7\pi}{6} + 2\pi k \quad\text{or}\quad \theta = \frac{11\pi}{6} + 2\pi k \]
Test whether they merge
Why: The gap is eleven pi over six minus seven pi over six, which is four pi over six, that is two pi over three, not a half turn.
\[ \frac{11\pi}{6} - \frac{7\pi}{6} = \frac{2\pi}{3} \ne \pi \]
Check one from each family
Why: The sine of seven pi over six is negative one half and so is the sine of eleven pi over six, so both cosecants are negative two.
\[ \csc\left(\tfrac{7\pi}{6}\right) = -2, \qquad \csc\left(\tfrac{11\pi}{6}\right) = -2 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 760 — Exercise 56
This is the same problem as the secant one with the roles of the two coordinates exchanged, so try it yourself before reading the steps. Convert, find the reference angle, choose the quadrants, then test for merging.
A sine of one half in size gives a reference angle of a sixth of a half turn, and a negative sine means the second coordinate is negative, which is quadrants three and four. Notice that these two quadrants are adjacent, sharing the bottom of the circle, which is a visual hint that the solutions will be close together and not opposite.
The merging test confirms it: the gap is two thirds of a half turn, not a half turn, so two families it is. Every cosecant equation in the exercise set will behave this way, which is worth knowing before you start the homework.
Counterexample
\[ \sec(t) = \frac12 \]
Discussion prompt
Explain in one sentence why this equation has no solutions, and then produce a cosecant equation that also has none and one that has infinitely many. Write your answer before revealing.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 758 — which equations have no solutions
Write something down before revealing, even if it is only one sentence. The point of this slide is that you can now answer a question about solutions without solving anything.
A secant of one half would require a cosine of two, and no coordinate on the unit circle reaches two. The same argument rules out every target strictly between negative one and one, for both the secant and the cosecant, and that is a whole interval of impossible equations.
The contrast with a cosecant of negative forty-two is the other half of the lesson. That is a perfectly ordinary equation: it needs a sine of about negative 0.024, a small negative number, which the circle certainly provides, once in quadrant three and once in quadrant four. Large targets are easy for these functions; small ones are impossible.
Section
Part 4
Concept
There is only one Pythagorean identity. The other two are not new facts; they are the same fact divided through by a square.
\[ \cos^2(\theta) + \sin^2(\theta) = 1 \]
Divide every term by the square of the cosine
Why: Legal wherever the cosine is not zero.
\[ \frac{\cos^2(\theta)}{\cos^2(\theta)} + \frac{\sin^2(\theta)}{\cos^2(\theta)} = \frac{1}{\cos^2(\theta)} \]
\[ 1 + \tan^2(\theta) = \sec^2(\theta) \]
The middle term became the square of a quotient, which is the square of the tangent, and the right-hand side became the square of a reciprocal, which is the square of the secant.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 748 — the derivation before Theorem 10.8
There is only one Pythagorean identity in trigonometry, and everything else with that name is it in disguise. Seeing the derivation once, rather than memorising three separate lines, is what makes them stick.
The division is legal wherever the cosine is not zero, and the proviso in the theorem comes from exactly here. Take the three terms one at a time: the first becomes a quantity over itself, which is one; the second is the square of a quotient, and the quotient is the tangent; the third is the square of a reciprocal, and the reciprocal is the secant.
Notice which two functions appeared. You divided by the cosine, and the two functions that have the cosine underneath are the tangent and the secant. That connection is the memory hook: the divisor chooses the pair of functions that show up.
Concept
Start again from the same line and divide by the other square, this time requiring the sine to be nonzero.
\[ \frac{\cos^2(\theta)}{\sin^2(\theta)} + \frac{\sin^2(\theta)}{\sin^2(\theta)} = \frac{1}{\sin^2(\theta)} \]
\[ \cot^2(\theta) + 1 = \csc^2(\theta) \]
Note where the 1 lands. In the first version it comes first, with the tangent second; here it comes second, with the cotangent first. Keeping the order straight is easier than memorising two unrelated lines, because the order records which term you divided by.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 748 — the second derivation
Start again from the same one line, not from the result of the last slide. Dividing a fresh copy by the other square gives the third identity in exactly three steps.
This time the functions with the sine underneath are the cotangent and the cosecant, and those are the two that appear, precisely as the hook predicts. The position of the 1 also moves, from the front to the middle, because it is now the second term that became a quantity over itself.
If you can rebuild both of these in under a minute, you never need to memorise them, and more importantly you will never mix up which reciprocal belongs with which. Mixing them up is the single most common error on the identities that follow, and it is exactly what the error-analysis slide later in this part is about.
Picture it
Figure (svg): Three right triangles drawn to scale side by side, each with the same forty-degree angle. The first has legs cosine and sine with hypotenuse 1. The second is the first enlarged by dividing every side by the cosine, giving legs 1 and tangent with hypotenuse secant. The third is the first divided by the sine, giving legs cotangent and 1 with hypotenuse cosecant.
Take the right triangle whose legs are the two coordinates and whose hypotenuse is the radius one. Enlarge it so that the horizontal leg becomes one, and the other two sides become the tangent and the secant. Enlarge the original instead so that the vertical leg becomes one, and the other two become the cotangent and the cosecant. The Pythagorean theorem applied to each picture gives each identity.
This picture is worth more than the algebra for most people, so spend a moment on it. On the left is the right triangle you have had since Lesson 10.2: the two coordinates as legs, the radius as hypotenuse. The Pythagorean theorem applied to it is the first identity.
Now scale that triangle up so its horizontal leg becomes one. Every side has been divided by the first coordinate, so the vertical leg becomes the tangent and the hypotenuse becomes the secant. The Pythagorean theorem applied to this new triangle is the second identity, and nothing has been assumed that was not already true of the first.
Scale the original the other way, so the vertical leg becomes one, and the horizontal leg becomes the cotangent and the hypotenuse becomes the cosecant. That is the third identity. All three are the same theorem about the same triangle, seen at three different magnifications.
One bonus from the picture: the hypotenuse is always the longest side, so the secant is always larger in size than the tangent, and the cosecant always larger than the cotangent. That is a free check on any rearrangement you write down.
Notation
Annotate
On: \( 1 + \tan^2(\theta) = \sec^2(\theta), \quad \cos(\theta) \ne 0 \)
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 749 — Theorem 10.8 and its common alternate forms
Step through the annotations and connect each to the middle triangle from the previous slide. The 1 is the scaled horizontal leg, the tangent is the vertical leg, and the secant is the hypotenuse.
The second annotation is about notation rather than mathematics, but it catches people out. Writing the exponent before the argument is a convention peculiar to trigonometry, and it means square the value of the function, never square the angle first.
The last annotation is the one you will use most. In practice you almost never need the identity in the form printed in the theorem; you need one of its two rearrangements, because what appears in a problem is a difference of two squares that you want to collapse to one term. Rehearse both rearrangements now and they will be waiting when you need them.
Comparison
Comparison matrix
| identity | solved for the square of a function | difference that equals 1 |
|---|---|---|
| cos²θ + sin²θ = 1 | sin²θ = 1 − cos²θ | cos²θ + sin²θ = 1 |
| 1 + tan²θ = sec²θ | tan²θ = sec²θ − 1 | sec²θ − tan²θ = 1 |
| cot²θ + 1 = csc²θ | cot²θ = csc²θ − 1 | csc²θ − cot²θ = 1 |
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 749 — the Common Alternate Forms
Fill the blanks before checking. Every entry is one of the three identities moved around by adding or subtracting the same thing from both sides, so there is nothing to recall beyond the three originals.
The middle column solves each identity for the square of a single function, which is the form you want when a problem hands you one square and you need another. The right column collects the differences that equal exactly one, which is the form that makes conjugate pairs collapse.
If any blank took real effort, do not just note the answer. Rebuild it from the original identity by moving one term, because the point is to be able to produce these on demand rather than to recognise them on a list.
Matching
Match the pairs
Why: Each is one of the three identities rearranged. Subtract 1 from the secant version and you are left with the tangent squared; do the same to the cosecant version and you get the cotangent squared. One minus the sine squared is the cosine squared, and the secant squared minus the tangent squared is the constant 1. Recognising these on sight is what turns a long verification into a short one.
Make all four matches before revealing. This is the recognition skill that separates a two-line verification from a twenty-line one, and it is worth drilling until it is automatic.
The first two are the subtracted forms, and they are the ones most often confused with each other. Tie each to its divisor once more: the secant version came from dividing by the cosine squared, so what is left over is the other cosine-based function, the tangent. The cosecant version leaves the cotangent.
The last one is different in kind. The secant squared minus the tangent squared is not another function; it is the constant one. That collapse is what makes the pair of secant and tangent so useful as a conjugate, and you will use it directly in one of the exercises later in this lesson.
Worked example
Simplify, given that everything in sight is defined.
\[ \frac{\tan(\theta)}{\sec^2(\theta) - 1} \]
Look at the denominator alone
Why: A secant squared minus one is one of the rearranged identities.
\[ \sec^2(\theta) - 1 = \tan^2(\theta) \]
Substitute it
Why: The whole denominator becomes a single term.
\[ \frac{\tan(\theta)}{\sec^2(\theta)-1} = \frac{\tan(\theta)}{\tan^2(\theta)} \]
Cancel one factor
Why: One power of the tangent divides out.
\[ \frac{\tan(\theta)}{\tan^2(\theta)} = \frac{1}{\tan(\theta)} \]
Name the reciprocal
Why: One over the tangent is the cotangent.
\[ \frac{1}{\tan(\theta)} = \cot(\theta) \]
Check numerically at one radian
Why: The tangent of 1 is 1.55741 and the secant of 1 is 1.85082, so the denominator is 2.42552 and the quotient is 0.64209, which is exactly the cotangent of 1.
\[ \frac{1.55741}{1.85082^2 - 1} = \frac{1.55741}{2.42552} = 0.64209 = \cot(1) \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 763 — Exercise 95
The whole problem is solved by one act of recognition, so train your eye on the denominator before you touch anything. A secant squared minus one is the second Pythagorean identity rearranged, and once it is replaced there is barely anything left to do.
Compare that to the alternative route. Converting everything to cosine and sine would work too, but it produces a compound fraction that takes several lines to clear, and you would end up at the same place. Recognising the identity is not a trick; it is the point of having learned the rearrangements.
The numerical check at one radian is a good habit for simplifications generally. If the original expression and your simplified one disagree at a randomly chosen angle, you have made an algebra error and you know it immediately.
Error analysis
Annotate
On: \( \cos^2 + \sin^2 = 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; 1 + \cot^2(\theta) = \sec^2(\theta) \)
Read the claim and try to find the problem before revealing the annotations. Everything about it looks plausible, which is exactly what makes it dangerous.
The left side shows that the division was by the square of the sine, because the first term turned into the cotangent squared and the second into one. But then the right side must be one over the sine squared, and one over the sine is the cosecant, not the secant. The two derivations were crossed halfway through.
The most useful part of this slide is the testing annotation. Testing an identity at a special angle is a good habit, but a quarter of a half turn is a bad choice, because the secant and the cosecant are equal there and the test passes for a false statement. Pick an angle where the two candidate answers differ, such as a sixth of a half turn, and the error is exposed at once.
Section
Part 5
Concept
An identity is a claim that two expressions agree at every angle where both are defined. Verifying it means transforming one side, by legal moves, until it becomes the other side. You are not solving anything, and you may not assume the claim while proving it.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 752 — Strategies for Verifying Identities
Verifying an identity is a different activity from solving an equation, and mixing them up is the commonest structural error in this topic. Solving asks which angles make a statement true. Verifying asserts that it is true at every angle where both sides are defined, and asks you to demonstrate that.
The consequence is a rule about layout. You may not start from the claim and do the same thing to both sides, because that assumes exactly what you are trying to establish. Instead you transform one side by legal moves until it turns into the other, so that every line follows from the one above it.
The strategies listed are a menu, not an algorithm. Stitz and Zeager are blunt about this: there is no complete procedure, and proficiency comes from hours of struggling with them. What the list does is stop you sitting in front of a blank page, because at any moment at least one of those six moves is available.
Worked example
Both come straight from Theorem 10.6.
\[ \text{(1) } \frac{1}{\csc(\theta)} = \sin(\theta) \qquad \text{(2) } \tan(\theta) = \sin(\theta)\sec(\theta) \]
Start with the left side of the first
Why: Replace the cosecant by its definition.
\[ \frac{1}{\csc(\theta)} = \frac{1}{\;\frac{1}{\sin(\theta)}\;} \]
Simplify the compound fraction
Why: One divided by one over something is that something.
\[ \frac{1}{\;\frac{1}{\sin(\theta)}\;} = \sin(\theta) \]
For the second, start on the right
Why: The right-hand side is the more complicated one here, so replace the secant.
\[ \sin(\theta)\sec(\theta) = \sin(\theta)\cdot\frac{1}{\cos(\theta)} \]
Read the product as a single quotient
Why: Sine over cosine is the quotient identity.
\[ \frac{\sin(\theta)}{\cos(\theta)} = \tan(\theta) \]
Check both at one radian
Why: The sine of 1 is 0.84147, so one over its reciprocal is 0.84147 again. And 0.84147 times the secant of 1, 1.85082, is 1.55741, which is the tangent of 1.
\[ 0.84147 \times 1.85082 = 1.55741 = \tan(1) \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, pp. 749-750 — Example 10.3.3, parts 1 and 2
Both of these are short, and their purpose is to show you the shape of a verification before the harder ones arrive. Read them for structure rather than content.
In the first, the left side is more complicated, so that is where you start. Replacing the cosecant produces a fraction inside a fraction, and simplifying that compound fraction finishes the job in one step.
In the second, the right side is the busier one, so you start there instead, even though it is written second. A verification does not have to be read left to right; it has to go from one whole side to the other whole side, and which direction you pick is a tactical choice you make first.
Worked example
\[ (\sec(\theta) - \tan(\theta))(\sec(\theta) + \tan(\theta)) = 1 \]
Expand the left side
Why: The same two terms with opposite signs, so the cross terms cancel and a difference of squares is left.
\[ (\sec - \tan)(\sec + \tan) = \sec^2(\theta) - \tan^2(\theta) \]
Recognise the difference
Why: This is the second Pythagorean identity in its subtracted form.
\[ \sec^2(\theta) - \tan^2(\theta) = 1 \]
State the chain
Why: Left side equals the difference of squares equals one, which is the right side.
\[ (\sec(\theta) - \tan(\theta))(\sec(\theta) + \tan(\theta)) = 1 \]
Check at one radian
Why: The secant of 1 is 1.85082 and the tangent of 1 is 1.55741; the two factors are 0.29341 and 3.40822, and their product is 1.00000.
\[ 0.29341 \times 3.40822 = 1.00000 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 750 — Example 10.3.3, part 3
This one is pure algebra from a year ago, dressed in new symbols. Two brackets with the same terms and opposite signs multiply to the difference of their squares, and here that difference is exactly the rearranged second Pythagorean identity.
Notice that no conversion to cosine and sine was needed or wanted. If you had rewritten everything in cosine and sine here, you would have created two fractions, combined them, and eventually got back to the same place after much more work.
This particular pair, the secant minus the tangent and the secant plus the tangent, appears again in the conjugate list later in the lesson, and it is the most useful of them because their product is the number one rather than another squared function.
Worked example
\[ \frac{\sec(\theta)}{1 - \tan(\theta)} = \frac{1}{\cos(\theta) - \sin(\theta)} \]
Rewrite the left side in cosine and sine
Why: It carries more identities than the right side, so it offers more moves.
\[ \frac{\sec(\theta)}{1-\tan(\theta)} = \frac{\frac{1}{\cos(\theta)}}{1 - \frac{\sin(\theta)}{\cos(\theta)}} \]
Multiply top and bottom by the cosine
Why: A cosine over a cosine is one, so nothing has changed; it just clears the small fractions.
\[ = \frac{\frac{1}{\cos(\theta)}}{1 - \frac{\sin(\theta)}{\cos(\theta)}}\cdot\frac{\cos(\theta)}{\cos(\theta)} \]
Distribute in the denominator
Why: The numerator becomes 1, and each term downstairs gets multiplied.
\[ = \frac{1}{(1)(\cos(\theta)) - \frac{\sin(\theta)}{\cos(\theta)}\cdot\cos(\theta)} \]
Cancel in the second term
Why: The two cosines divide out and the sine is left.
\[ = \frac{1}{\cos(\theta) - \sin(\theta)} \]
Check at one radian
Why: The secant of 1 is 1.85082 and the tangent is 1.55741, so the left side is 1.85082 over negative 0.55741, which is negative 3.32040. The cosine minus the sine is 0.54030 minus 0.84147, that is negative 0.30117, and one over that is negative 3.32040 as well.
\[ \frac{1.85082}{-0.55741} = -3.32040 = \frac{1}{-0.30117} \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 750 — Example 10.3.3, part 4
The choice of side is the first decision and the book is explicit about why: the left side contains two functions that can be rewritten, so it offers more to work with. The right side contains only cosine and sine already, so there is nothing to do to it.
The key move is multiplying top and bottom by the cosine. That is multiplying by one, so nothing changes in value, but it clears both of the little fractions at once. Watch carefully where the cosines cancel: in the numerator it makes the one over the cosine into a plain one, and in the second denominator term it turns the quotient back into a sine.
The reason this works so cleanly is that every small fraction in sight had the same denominator. When they do not, you will need a common denominator first, which is exactly the next example.
Worked example
\[ 6\sec(\theta)\tan(\theta) = \frac{3}{1-\sin(\theta)} - \frac{3}{1+\sin(\theta)} \]
Start on the right
Why: Two fractions to combine is more promising than a product to expand. Take the common denominator.
\[ = \frac{3(1+\sin(\theta)) - 3(1-\sin(\theta))}{(1-\sin(\theta))(1+\sin(\theta))} \]
Expand the numerator
Why: Three plus three sine minus three plus three sine.
\[ = \frac{6\sin(\theta)}{(1-\sin(\theta))(1+\sin(\theta))} \]
Expand the denominator
Why: A difference of squares.
\[ = \frac{6\sin(\theta)}{1 - \sin^2(\theta)} \]
Exchange it with a Pythagorean identity
Why: One minus the sine squared is the cosine squared, which is what puts cosines downstairs where they are needed.
\[ = \frac{6\sin(\theta)}{\cos^2(\theta)} \]
Split the single fraction into two factors
Why: One cosine goes with the 6 and the other with the sine.
\[ = 6\left(\frac{1}{\cos(\theta)}\right)\left(\frac{\sin(\theta)}{\cos(\theta)}\right) = 6\sec(\theta)\tan(\theta) \]
Check at one radian
Why: On the right, 3 over 0.15853 minus 3 over 1.84147 is 18.92398 minus 1.62913, that is 17.29485. On the left, 6 times 1.85082 times 1.55741 is 17.29485.
\[ 18.92398 - 1.62913 = 17.29485 = 6\sec(1)\tan(1) \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, pp. 750-751 — Example 10.3.3, part 5
Start on the right, even though the target is on the left. Two fractions waiting to be combined is a much clearer invitation than a product of two functions, and a verification is allowed to run in whichever direction is easier.
Once the fractions are combined, the numerator simplifies dramatically because the constant terms cancel, and the denominator is a difference of squares. At that moment you should pause and ask what you are aiming for, as the book does: the target is six times a secant times a tangent, which means cosines underneath.
That is what makes the Pythagorean step the right one. One minus the sine squared is the cosine squared, and now you have exactly the denominator you wanted. Splitting the single fraction into two factors at the end is just reading the result in the right grouping.
Worked example
\[ \frac{\sin(\theta)}{1-\cos(\theta)} = \frac{1+\cos(\theta)}{\sin(\theta)} \]
Notice the pairing
Why: The left denominator is one minus the cosine and the right numerator is one plus the cosine. That pair multiplies to a difference of squares, so aim for it.
\[ (1-\cos(\theta))(1+\cos(\theta)) = 1 - \cos^2(\theta) \]
Multiply the left side top and bottom by that conjugate
Why: Multiplying by one plus the cosine over itself changes nothing.
\[ \frac{\sin(\theta)}{1-\cos(\theta)}\cdot\frac{1+\cos(\theta)}{1+\cos(\theta)} \]
Carry out the multiplication
Why: The numerator picks up the factor; the denominator becomes the difference of squares.
\[ = \frac{\sin(\theta)(1+\cos(\theta))}{1-\cos^2(\theta)} \]
Exchange the denominator
Why: One minus the cosine squared is the sine squared.
\[ = \frac{\sin(\theta)(1+\cos(\theta))}{\sin^2(\theta)} \]
Cancel one sine
Why: A single factor of the sine divides out of top and bottom.
\[ = \frac{1+\cos(\theta)}{\sin(\theta)} \]
Check at one radian
Why: The left side is 0.84147 over 0.45970, which is 1.83049. The right side is 1.54030 over 0.84147, which is 1.83049.
\[ \frac{0.84147}{0.45970} = 1.83049 = \frac{1.54030}{0.84147} \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 751 — Example 10.3.3, part 6
Here neither side is obviously worse than the other, so the choice comes from something else: the left denominator is one minus the cosine and the right numerator is one plus the cosine. Spotting that pairing is what suggests the whole strategy.
Multiplying top and bottom by one plus the cosine is multiplying by one, so it is always legal, and it turns the two-term denominator into a difference of squares. One minus the cosine squared is the sine squared, and suddenly there is a sine to cancel against the one upstairs.
This move is worth its own name, and the book gives it one on the next slide. Whenever a stubborn two-term denominator has the form one plus or minus a function, reach for its conjugate, because the Pythagorean identity is waiting on the other side of the multiplication.
Picture it
Figure (svg): Two area pictures side by side. On the left a unit square with a smaller square of side cosine theta cut out of its corner, leaving an L-shaped region. On the right a rectangle whose width is one plus cosine theta and whose height is one minus cosine theta. The two shaded regions have the same area, and an arrow between them says the L has been cut and rearranged.
The move is the old difference of squares from algebra, dressed in trigonometric clothing. One minus something, times one plus the same something, is one minus its square, and a Pythagorean identity then turns that into a single term. That is the whole trick, and it is the reason the awkward two-term denominator disappears.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 751 — Pythagorean Conjugates
The picture is the difference of two squares as an area, which is where you first met it in algebra. A unit square with a smaller square cut out of one corner leaves an L-shaped region, and that L can be cut once and rearranged into a rectangle whose sides are the sum and the difference of the two lengths.
Read the two labels together. The area is one minus the cosine squared whichever way you look at it, and the Pythagorean identity says that is the sine squared. So multiplying by the conjugate converts a two-term expression into a single squared function, which is the only reason anyone does it.
You have seen this exact manoeuvre before with square roots, when you rationalised a denominator such as one minus root two, and with complex numbers, when you multiplied by a conjugate to make the denominator real. It is one idea wearing three costumes.
Concept
Six pairs are worth recognising on sight. In each row, multiplying the two expressions in the left column produces the single term in the right column.
| the conjugate pair | their product |
|---|---|
| 1 minus cosine, and 1 plus cosine | the square of the sine |
| 1 minus sine, and 1 plus sine | the square of the cosine |
| secant minus 1, and secant plus 1 | the square of the tangent |
| secant minus tangent, and secant plus tangent | 1 |
| cosecant minus 1, and cosecant plus 1 | the square of the cotangent |
| cosecant minus cotangent, and cosecant plus cotangent | 1 |
Every row is one of the three Pythagorean identities read as a difference of squares. If you can see that, there is nothing extra to memorise.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 751 — the list of Pythagorean Conjugates
Do not memorise this table as six facts. Look down the right-hand column and notice that every entry is one of the three Pythagorean identities read as a difference of two squares. If you know the three identities, you can generate any row in a couple of seconds.
The two rows whose product is just the number one are the most useful of the six, because they leave nothing behind at all. Those are the secant with the tangent and the cosecant with the cotangent, and both come from the subtracted forms you tabulated earlier.
In practice you will meet these from the other direction: a problem hands you a two-term denominator and you have to see which conjugate to multiply by. The answer is always the same expression with the middle sign flipped, so the real skill is noticing that the opportunity is there.
Worked example
From the section's exercise set, and it needs the fourth conjugate pair.
\[ \frac{1}{\sec(\theta)+\tan(\theta)} = \sec(\theta) - \tan(\theta) \]
Pick the conjugate of the denominator
Why: Secant plus tangent pairs with secant minus tangent, and their product is 1.
\[ (\sec(\theta)+\tan(\theta))(\sec(\theta)-\tan(\theta)) = \sec^2(\theta) - \tan^2(\theta) \]
Name that product
Why: The second Pythagorean identity, rearranged.
\[ \sec^2(\theta) - \tan^2(\theta) = 1 \]
Multiply the left side top and bottom by the conjugate
Why: Legal, since it is a quantity over itself.
\[ \frac{1}{\sec+\tan}\cdot\frac{\sec-\tan}{\sec-\tan} = \frac{\sec(\theta)-\tan(\theta)}{\sec^2(\theta)-\tan^2(\theta)} \]
Replace the denominator by 1
Why: The previous step showed it is exactly 1.
\[ = \frac{\sec(\theta)-\tan(\theta)}{1} = \sec(\theta)-\tan(\theta) \]
Check at one radian
Why: The secant of 1 is 1.85082 and the tangent of 1 is 1.55741. Their sum is 3.40822, so the left side is 0.29341, and their difference is 0.29341 as well.
\[ \frac{1}{3.40822} = 0.29341 = 1.85082 - 1.55741 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 763 — Exercise 118
Try this one before reading the steps. It is a fair test of whether the conjugate idea has landed, because there is nothing else to try: converting to cosine and sine leads into a genuinely unpleasant compound fraction.
The conjugate of the secant plus the tangent is the secant minus the tangent, and their product is the cleanest one in the table, the number one. That means the denominator after multiplying is not merely simpler; it disappears entirely.
The result is worth remembering in its own right, because it says the secant plus the tangent and the secant minus the tangent are reciprocals of each other. That fact turns up again in calculus, in the standard integral of the secant.
Trap
A popular but invalid layout for Example 10.3.3 part 6:
\[ \frac{\sin\theta}{1-\cos\theta} = \frac{1+\cos\theta}{\sin\theta} \]
\[ \sin^2\theta = 1-\cos^2\theta \]
\[ \sin^2\theta = \sin^2\theta \;\checkmark \]
Wrong as written. The first line is the thing to be proved.
Cross-multiplying uses the equation you are trying to establish. Starting from a claim and deriving something true proves nothing: you can derive a true statement from a false one.
Transform one side only, step by step, until it becomes the other side. Every line is then a consequence of the line above it, and the chain proves the claim.
\[ \frac{\sin\theta}{1-\cos\theta} = \cdots = \frac{1+\cos\theta}{\sin\theta} \]
This layout is popular because it feels efficient and it usually ends with a line that is obviously true, which feels like success. It is not, and the reason is worth stating precisely.
Starting from the claim and deriving something true proves nothing, because a false statement can also imply a true one. Assume that one equals two, multiply both sides by zero, and you have derived a true statement from a false one. The direction of the logic is wrong.
The fix costs nothing. Work down one side only, and every line is then a consequence of the line above it, so the chain from the first line to the last is a genuine proof. If cross-multiplying gave you an idea, use it as scratch work, then write the verification out in the legitimate order.
Ranking
Put in order
Put the moves of a clean verification into the order you should carry them out.
Why: Choosing the side comes first, because starting on the easy side usually leads nowhere. Rewriting creates the fractions, combining clears them, and only once everything is a single quotient does a Pythagorean identity have a sum or difference of squares to act on. The last step is not a formality: an expression that merely looks similar to the other side is not the other side.
Drag these into order before checking. The ordering is not arbitrary; each move creates the conditions the next one needs.
Choosing the side comes first, because it is the only decision you cannot undo cheaply, and starting on the simpler side usually leads nowhere. Rewriting in cosine and sine is what creates the fractions, combining is what clears them, and only once you have a single quotient does a Pythagorean identity have a sum or difference of squares to act on.
The final step is not a formality. Students regularly stop at an expression that resembles the target and call it done. Read your last line and the other side of the original claim character by character; if they are not the same expression, you are not finished.
Step zero
\[ \cos(\theta)\left(\tan(\theta) + \cot(\theta)\right) = \csc(\theta) \]
Discussion prompt
This is Exercise 111. Do not verify it yet. Say which side you would start on, name the first two moves you would make, and predict which Pythagorean identity will be needed. Write it down before revealing.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 763 — Exercise 111
Write your plan down before revealing, even though you have not been asked to do any algebra. Thirty seconds of planning routinely saves five minutes of thrashing on these problems.
The left side is the only sensible place to start, because the right side is a single symbol with nothing to expand, factor or combine. That is the general rule: work where the moves are.
Having decided, the first two moves almost pick themselves. The bracket contains a tangent and a cotangent, so rewrite both in cosine and sine, then add them over a common denominator. The numerator that appears is the sine squared plus the cosine squared, and recognising that it collapses to one is the whole problem. If you predicted the first Pythagorean identity, you had already solved it.
Real world
A road rises at an angle to the horizontal. The map distance along the ground is the horizontal run, but the distance actually driven is the sloping length, and those two differ by exactly the factor you have just been studying.
Discussion prompt
A straight mountain road climbs at 8 degrees to the horizontal. A map shows the horizontal distance from the bottom to the top as 4.0 kilometres. How far do you actually drive, and by what factor is that longer than the map distance? Use the right-triangle meaning of the secant.
This is the right-triangle reading of the secant, which the second half of this section will develop properly: the hypotenuse divided by the adjacent side. On a road, the hypotenuse is the distance you drive and the adjacent side is the distance on the map.
Work the numbers before revealing. The point is not the arithmetic but the size of the answer: a road climbing at eight degrees, which feels steep to drive and is steeper than most highways allow, costs you only about one per cent in extra distance.
That is the secant of a small angle being barely above one, which is exactly what you proved earlier in the lesson. The same calculation at forty-five degrees gives a factor of about 1.414, so the extra distance grows slowly at first and then very fast, which is the shape of the secant curve you have already seen.
Section
Part 6
Pattern
Figure (svg): A flow diagram. A single starting box asks what the expression contains. One branch leads to rewriting secant, cosecant, tangent and cotangent in terms of cosine and sine; another to spotting a sum or difference of squares and applying a Pythagorean identity; a third to multiplying by a Pythagorean conjugate. All three branches feed into a final box that says simplify to one term and compare with the other side.
This is the decision procedure for the whole lesson, and it is organised by what you are being asked to do rather than by which function appears.
The most important distinction in it is the one between secant or cosecant equations and tangent or cotangent equations. For the first pair, convert: they are reciprocals, so one step returns you to a cosine or sine equation you already know how to solve. For the second pair, do not convert: the table gives their values at the common angles directly, and converting only makes work.
The last two lines are about identities rather than numbers. When simplifying, look for a sum or difference of squares before doing anything else, because one Pythagorean identity can end the problem in a line. When verifying, stay on one side, and remember that a conjugate is the standard answer to a stubborn two-term denominator.
Check
Check your understanding
At which angle is the cotangent undefined while the tangent is perfectly fine?
Answer: B
Why: Cotangent is x/y, so it fails where the second coordinate is zero. At π the point is (−1, 0): the second coordinate is zero, so the cotangent is undefined, while the tangent is 0/(−1), which is 0.
The question is testing the organising idea of the first part, not your memory of a list. For each option, find the point on the circle and ask which coordinate is zero there.
At a half turn the point is at the far left, with second coordinate zero. The cotangent has that coordinate underneath, so it fails; the tangent has it upstairs, so it is a perfectly ordinary zero. Two of the wrong options are the mirror-image failure, where it is the tangent and the secant that drop out instead.
Check
Check your understanding
Which describes every solution of cot(θ) = √3 ?
Answer: B
Why: The table gives cot(π/6) = √3, so the reference angle is π/6. Cotangent is positive where x and y agree in sign, which is quadrants I and III, giving π/6 and 7π/6. Those are exactly π apart, so they merge into π/6 + πk.
Two separate things are being tested here, so check both in your answer: did you get the reference angle from the correct column of the table, and did you get the quadrants from the correct sign rule?
A cotangent of root three belongs to a sixth of a half turn, not a third of one; the two columns of the table run in opposite directions and reading the wrong one is the trap in the third option. A positive cotangent needs both coordinates to agree in sign, which is quadrants one and three, and those are half a turn apart, so the families merge.
Check
Check your understanding
Which single substitution turns (csc²θ − 1)·tan²θ into 1?
Answer: A
Why: The third Pythagorean identity, cot²θ + 1 = csc²θ, rearranges to csc²θ − 1 = cot²θ. The expression becomes cot²θ · tan²θ, and since cotangent is the reciprocal of tangent, that product is 1.
Work out what each substitution would give before choosing. Only one of them turns the expression into the constant one, and the others each embody a specific confusion worth naming.
The third Pythagorean identity, rearranged, says that a cosecant squared minus one is a cotangent squared. Multiplying that by the tangent squared gives a cotangent squared times a tangent squared, and since those two functions are reciprocals, the product is one. The wrong options swap the two divided identities or get the sign of the rearrangement backwards.
Explain it to yourself
Discussion prompt
In two or three sentences, explain to someone who has just met these functions why secant and cosecant can never take a value between negative one and one, while tangent and cotangent take every real value. Base your answer on the definitions, not on the graphs.
Write your explanation out before revealing, in full sentences. Being able to say why a range looks the way it does, without appealing to a graph, is a much stronger form of knowing than being able to recite it.
The key contrast is between a reciprocal and a quotient. A reciprocal of something small is large, and a reciprocal of something of size at most one is of size at least one, so the secant and the cosecant are pushed away from zero and a whole interval becomes unreachable.
A quotient of two small numbers is not controlled at all. As the terminal side turns towards the vertical the denominator of the tangent shrinks towards zero while the numerator stays near one, and the quotient passes through every value on its way out to infinity. Same bounded ingredients, opposite conclusions.
Exit ticket
\[ \sec(\theta) = -4, \quad \theta \text{ in Quadrant II} \]
Discussion prompt
Find the exact values of the other five circular functions of theta, and then verify your answer by checking one Pythagorean identity numerically.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.3 The Six Circular Functions and Fundamental Identities §10.3, p. 759 — Exercise 28
This is the standard problem of the lesson in its most compact form: one function value, one quadrant, find the rest. Work it fully before revealing, and write exact values rather than decimals.
The order matters. Convert the secant to a cosine, use the Pythagorean identity to get the size of the sine, let the quadrant fix its sign, then build the remaining three by reciprocal and quotient. Quadrant two gives a positive sine with a negative cosine, so both the tangent and the cotangent come out negative.
Then check, because the checking is half the point. One plus the tangent squared is sixteen, and the secant squared is also sixteen, so the second Pythagorean identity holds and your five values are mutually consistent. A check like that catches a dropped sign or a slipped root in seconds.
Recap
| function | from the coordinates | undefined when | range |
|---|---|---|---|
| cosine | x | never | from −1 to 1 |
| sine | y | never | from −1 to 1 |
| secant | 1 over x | x = 0 | size at least 1 |
| cosecant | 1 over y | y = 0 | size at least 1 |
| tangent | y over x | x = 0 | every real number |
| cotangent | x over y | y = 0 | every real number |
\[ 1 + \tan^2(\theta) = \sec^2(\theta), \qquad \cot^2(\theta) + 1 = \csc^2(\theta) \]
Three tools carried forward: convert to cosine and sine when in doubt; use the reference angle and the quadrant sign to solve; and verify identities on one side only, reaching for a common denominator or a Pythagorean conjugate when a two-term denominator is in the way.
Next, the second half of this section leaves the unit circle behind: the same six functions are read off a circle of any radius, and then off an ordinary right triangle, which is what turns them into a surveying instrument.
OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §7.4 The Other Trigonometric Functions §7.4 — the same six functions in OpenStax
The table is the lesson in one picture. Read across each row and you have the definition, the exclusion and the range, and every entry in it follows from the one question you have been asking all lesson: which coordinate is underneath?
Three techniques travel with you from here. Convert to cosine and sine whenever you are stuck. Solve equations by splitting the work into a reference angle for the size and a quadrant for the sign, then test whether the two families are half a turn apart. Verify identities on one side only, with a common denominator or a Pythagorean conjugate held in reserve.
The next lesson drops the assumption that the radius is one. The same six ratios are read off a circle of any size, and then off a plain right triangle, which is what lets you point these functions at a clock tower or a redwood and measure its height from the ground.
Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Trigonometry — $55/session, free consultation.