Lifting the coordinate definition off the unit circle by similar triangles: on a circle of radius r the point at angle theta has coordinates r cosine theta and r sine theta, and conversely the cosine and sine can be read off any point on the terminal side as x over r and y over r. Includes the equations of circular motion as explicit functions of time, right triangle trigonometry recovered as the first-quadrant special case, and the domain and range of cosine and sine once they are read as functions of a real number.
Subject: Trigonometry · 69 slides · symbolic lesson
Open the interactive version of this deck
Title
Trigonometry · Section 10.2
One terminal side, every circle it crosses
Objectives
Every value so far has come from a circle of radius one, and almost nothing in the world has radius one. This lesson lifts the definition off the unit circle, and in doing so it finally answers the question Section 10.1 opened with: where is a rotating object at time t?
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, pp. 730-736 — the objectives of subsection 10.2.1
Two lessons ago the cosine and the sine were defined as the coordinates of a point on a circle of radius one. That was the right place to start, because a radius of one makes the definition as clean as possible. It is also the reason the definition looks useless: you will almost never be handed a circle of radius one.
This lesson removes that restriction, and it does so with a single idea you already own from geometry, namely similar triangles. Once the restriction is gone, three things fall out in quick succession. You can find the values from any point at all, without knowing the angle. You can write down where a spinning object is at any moment, which is the question Section 10.1 raised and could not answer. And the right triangle trigonometry you may have met in school appears as nothing more than the first-quadrant case.
The lesson closes by changing how you read the input. Once an angle in radians is just a real number, the cosine and the sine become genuine functions of a real variable, with a domain and a range, and you can start asking the questions you asked about every other function in this book.
Warm-up
Before anything new, recall the one value you will scale up in a moment.
Discussion prompt
Write down the cosine and sine of sixty degrees from the unit circle. Then answer this: a point sits on a circle of radius 5 at that same angle. What do you think its coordinates are, and what makes you think so?
Commit to an answer in writing before you reveal anything. Guessing here is cheap and it primes you to notice whether the theorem matches your instinct.
Most people guess that both coordinates simply multiply by five, and they are right. It is worth noticing that the guess is not obvious, though. Plenty of quantities do not scale that politely: the area inside a sector multiplies by twenty-five, not five, and the angle does not change at all. So the fact that both coordinates scale by exactly the same factor as the radius is a real claim, and it needs the argument on the next few slides.
If your guess was different, do not cross it out. Keep it visible and compare it with the theorem when it arrives; a corrected guess sticks far better than a blank page that was filled in later.
Section
Part 1
Concept
Draw an acute angle in standard position and follow its terminal side outward. It crosses the unit circle once, at a point the previous lessons called the cosine and sine. Keep going and it crosses the circle of radius r as well.
Figure (svg): A unit circle inside a larger circle of radius r, both centred at the origin. One terminal side leaves the origin and crosses the unit circle at a point P with coordinates x-prime and y-prime, then crosses the larger circle at Q with coordinates x and y.
\[ P(x', y') \text{ on } x^2 + y^2 = 1, \qquad Q(x, y) \text{ on } x^2 + y^2 = r^2 \]
The question of this part is how the far point's coordinates are related to the near point's. Both points sit on the same ray, so the relationship had better be simple.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 730 — the opening of subsection 10.2.1
Look at the picture and be clear about what is fixed and what is free. The angle is fixed: one ray, drawn once. The two circles are different, so the ray crosses them at two different points, and the outer point is just the inner one pushed straight out along the ray.
Both points therefore carry information about the same angle, and the whole question of this part is how to translate between them. Before reading on, notice that the answer cannot be complicated: the two points lie on a straight line through the origin, and there are not many ways for two such points to relate.
Notice also what the picture does not contain. There is no requirement that the angle be special, no requirement that the radius be a whole number, and no calculation anywhere yet. Everything on the next slide comes out of geometry alone.
Concept
Figure (svg): Two nested right triangles sharing the angle at the origin: the small one has hypotenuse 1 reaching P, the large one has hypotenuse r reaching Q, and both have a vertical side dropped to the horizontal axis.
Drop a perpendicular from each point to the horizontal axis. That builds two right triangles, and they share the angle at the origin, so their third angles agree too.
\[ \triangle OPA \sim \triangle OQB \]
\[ \frac{x}{x'} = \frac{r}{1} = r \qquad\Longrightarrow\qquad x = r\,x' \]
\[ \frac{y}{y'} = \frac{r}{1} = r \qquad\Longrightarrow\qquad y = r\,y' \]
The argument as written covers an acute angle. Reflecting the picture through the axes and through the origin carries it to every other non-quadrantal angle, and the four quadrantal angles can be checked by hand in a moment.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 730 — the similar-triangle derivation
Take a moment over why the two triangles are similar, because this is the one step of the lesson where a reason is genuinely required. They share the angle at the origin, since they are built on the same ray. Each has a right angle at the foot of its perpendicular. Two pairs of equal angles force the third pair to be equal too, so the triangles are similar.
Similar triangles have proportional sides, and the proportion is easy to read off here because the small triangle's hypotenuse is the radius of the unit circle, which is 1. So the ratio of hypotenuses is r to 1, which is just r, and every other pair of matching sides is in that same ratio. The horizontal legs give the first line, and the vertical legs give the second.
The book proves this for an acute angle only, because that is the only case the picture shows. Reflecting the whole diagram across the horizontal axis, the vertical axis and the origin carries the argument to the other three quadrants, and the four quadrantal angles you can check directly in a few seconds.
Concept
Now replace the near point's coordinates by their names. By definition they are the cosine and the sine of the angle.
\[ x' = \cos(\theta), \quad y' = \sin(\theta) \;\Longrightarrow\; x = r\cos(\theta), \; y = r\sin(\theta) \]
Theorem 10.3 — If the point with coordinates x and y lies on the terminal side of an angle and on the circle of radius r about the origin, then x is r times the cosine of the angle and y is r times the sine. Turned around, the cosine is x over r and the sine is y over r, where r is the distance from the point to the origin.
\[ \cos(\theta) = \frac{x}{r} = \frac{x}{\sqrt{x^2+y^2}}, \qquad \sin(\theta) = \frac{y}{r} = \frac{y}{\sqrt{x^2+y^2}} \]
Put the radius equal to one and the second reading collapses back to the definition you started with, which is the sign of a theorem that genuinely extends rather than replaces.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 730 — Theorem 10.3
The theorem is a translation rather than a discovery. Everything was already proved on the previous slide; all that happens here is that the two unit-circle coordinates get their proper names, cosine and sine.
Read the two forms separately, because they answer different questions. The first form takes an angle and a radius and hands you a position, which is what you want when you are placing a point or tracking an object. The second form takes a position and hands you the two values, which is what you want in nearly every exercise, and it never requires you to know the angle.
Check the special case before you move on. Put the radius equal to one and the first form says the coordinates are the cosine and the sine, while the second form says the cosine and the sine are the coordinates. Both collapse to the original definition, which is exactly what a good generalisation should do.
Intuition
On the unit circle the coordinate and the value happen to be the same number, and that coincidence hides what the cosine really is. It is not a length. It is a length divided by another length.
\[ \cos(\theta) = \frac{\text{horizontal displacement}}{\text{distance from the origin}} \]
A ratio of two lengths has no units and no size of its own: measure the same picture in inches or in miles and the ratio does not move. That is exactly why the cosine can be a function of the angle alone, with the circle nowhere in its input.
It also explains the bound you will meet at the end of the lesson. The numerator is one leg of a right triangle and the denominator is its hypotenuse, and a leg can never beat the hypotenuse.
On the unit circle the coordinate and the value are the same number, and that coincidence quietly teaches the wrong lesson. It makes the cosine feel like a length. It is not. It is one length divided by another, and that division is the whole reason the cosine can depend on the angle alone.
Think about what a ratio ignores. Measure the same diagram in centimetres or in miles, and both the numerator and the denominator change by the same factor, so the quotient does not move. Enlarge the drawing on a photocopier and the same thing happens. A ratio simply cannot see the scale of the picture it was measured in.
This also explains, in advance, the bound you will meet in the last part of the lesson. The numerator is one leg of a right triangle and the denominator is that triangle's hypotenuse, and a leg can never be longer than the hypotenuse. So the cosine can never exceed one in size, no matter what circle you use.
Notation
Annotate
On: \( \cos(\theta) = \frac{x}{r} = \frac{x}{\sqrt{x^2+y^2}} \)
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 730 — Theorem 10.3, second form
Work through the annotations one at a time and connect each to the picture from two slides ago. The two most important ones are the numerator and the denominator, because between them they settle every sign question you will ever have in this lesson.
The numerator carries a sign; the denominator never does. A point out to the left has a negative first coordinate, and dividing a negative number by a positive distance leaves it negative, so the cosine comes out negative. You do not have to remember any sign rules for this. The arithmetic does it for you, provided you do not accidentally make the radius negative.
The last annotation is quietly important. Any angle whose terminal side passes through the point gives the same answer, and coterminal angles all share a terminal side. So the theorem is well defined: it cannot be asked to produce two different cosines for one point.
Picture it
Figure (svg): Three quarter-circle arcs of radius 1, 2 and 3 about the origin, cut by a single ray at sixty degrees. The three crossing points are labelled with coordinates one half and root three over two, then 1 and root three, then three halves and three root three over two.
One ray at sixty degrees, three circles. Both coordinates double from the first circle to the second and triple from the first to the third, exactly as the theorem says. The angle does not budge, and neither does either coordinate divided by the radius.
\[ \frac{1/2}{1} = \frac{1}{2} = \frac{3/2}{3} = \frac12 \]
Read the three labelled points from the inside out. The first coordinate goes one half, then one, then three halves: exactly the radius times one half each time. The second coordinate does the same with root three over two. Both coordinates have grown, and they have grown by the same factor.
Now do the division shown under the picture. One half over one, one over two, three halves over three: all of them one half. The stretching cancels, every time, because it was applied to both parts of the fraction.
The ray itself is worth a second look. It has been drawn once and it serves all three circles, which is the visual form of the claim that the angle is an input rather than something the circle decides. Changing circles moves the crossing point along the ray; it never moves the ray.
Prediction
\[ \text{unit circle at } 60^\circ: \quad \left(\tfrac12, \tfrac{\sqrt3}{2}\right) \]
Predict first
Which point does the same terminal side hit on the circle of radius 5?
Correct: (5/2, 5√3/2)
Why: Theorem 10.3 multiplies BOTH coordinates by the radius, so one half becomes five halves and root three over two becomes five root three over two. Check it on the circle: twenty-five quarters plus seventy-five quarters is one hundred quarters, which is twenty-five, the radius squared.
Choose an option before revealing. Three of the four are wrong in ways that are worth recognising on sight.
The correct answer multiplies both coordinates by five. The second option forgot to scale at all, which would put the point on the unit circle rather than on the circle of radius five. The third scaled the sine but then also cleared the fraction in the cosine, which is a different kind of error, and the fourth scaled only one of the two coordinates, which is the commonest slip of all.
Whatever you chose, run the check in the explanation. Square both coordinates of your answer and add them; if the total is not twenty-five, the point is not on the right circle. That test takes ten seconds and it catches all three wrong answers.
Worked example
Theorem 10.3 used in the direction it is stated: angle and radius in, coordinates out.
\[ \text{Find the point at } \theta = \frac{5\pi}{6} \text{ on } x^2 + y^2 = 36. \]
Read the radius off the circle's equation
Why: The right-hand side is the radius squared, and a radius is positive.
\[ r^2 = 36 \;\Longrightarrow\; r = 6 \]
Find the unit-circle values first
Why: Five pi over six lies in quadrant two with reference angle pi over six, so the cosine is negative and the sine is positive.
\[ \cos\!\left(\tfrac{5\pi}{6}\right) = -\frac{\sqrt3}{2}, \qquad \sin\!\left(\tfrac{5\pi}{6}\right) = \frac12 \]
Multiply each by the radius
Why: Theorem 10.3 scales both coordinates by r.
\[ x = 6\!\left(-\frac{\sqrt3}{2}\right), \qquad y = 6\!\left(\frac12\right) \]
Simplify both
Why: Six halves is three, and six times root three over two is three root three.
\[ x = -3\sqrt3, \qquad y = 3 \]
Figure (svg): A circle of radius 6 about the origin with the terminal side of an angle of five pi over six drawn into the second quadrant, meeting the circle at the point minus three root three comma three, with dashed lines to both axes.
Check the point lies on the circle
Why: Twenty-seven plus nine is thirty-six, which is the radius squared; and the point is left of the vertical axis and above the horizontal one, which is quadrant two as required.
\[ (-3\sqrt3)^2 + 3^2 = 27 + 9 = 36 = r^2 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 730 — Theorem 10.3, first form
This is the theorem used forwards, and the shape of the solution is worth copying because it separates the two kinds of work. The first half is pure recall from the previous lesson: the reference angle is pi over six, the quadrant is the second, so the cosine is minus root three over two and the sine is one half. The second half is one multiplication each.
Do not skip the step where the radius is read off the equation of the circle. The equation gives thirty-six, which is the radius squared, and a student in a hurry will happily multiply by thirty-six instead of six. Write the line out.
The check is the one you should perform on every problem of this type. Square the two coordinates and add them; if the result is not the radius squared, something has gone wrong, and it is nearly always the radius. Then glance at the picture: the point should be up and to the left, and it is.
Sorting
Sort into buckets
An angle is fixed and the circle grows from radius 1 to radius r. Sort each quantity by whether it grows with the circle.
Sort each item by asking one question: does it have the radius as a factor once, or does the radius cancel out of it?
The two coordinates each pick up exactly one factor of the radius, straight from the theorem. The arc length does too, from the radian definition of Section 10.1: arc length is the radius times the radian measure. Those three grow together.
The other three do not move. The angle is the input, so nothing about the circle can touch it. The cosine and the quotient of the second coordinate by the radius each have a factor of the radius upstairs and downstairs, so the factors cancel. If you found this sort easy, you have the main idea of the whole part: coordinates scale, ratios do not.
Socratic
Figure (svg): One ray from the origin with three marked points at distances 2, 3.5 and 5, each with a dashed line dropped to the horizontal axis, and the quotient of first coordinate over distance written beside each: all three quotients equal 0.8.
Discussion prompt
Two students pick different points on the same terminal side. One uses the point at distance 2, the other the point at distance 5. Explain why they cannot get different answers for the cosine.
Write your explanation before revealing, and try to make the word similar carry the argument rather than the word obviously.
The reason is the same similar-triangles argument as before, now used in the other direction. The two students have built two right triangles on one ray. Same angle at the origin, same right angle at the foot, so the triangles are similar, so the first coordinate over the distance is the same fraction in both. The picture shows three points and one answer, 0.8, three times over.
The practical consequence is worth banking. When a problem tells you a point on the terminal side, you are free to use it as given or to walk along the ray to a friendlier one. If the point is minus one and a half comma two, doubling both coordinates gives minus three comma four and a distance of five, and the arithmetic becomes trivial.
Tweak it
Parameter explorer
The horizontal axis is the angle in radians, from zero to one full turn; the curve is the FIRST COORDINATE of the moving point, which is r times the cosine. Slide r. What changes about the curve, and what refuses to change?
\[ x(\theta) = {r}\cos(\theta) \]
A parametric idea plotted one coordinate at a time: the horizontal axis here is the angle, not a position in the plane.
Set the radius to one first and look at the curve. That is the plain cosine: it starts at one, falls through zero a quarter of the way along, reaches minus one halfway, and comes back. Now drag the radius upward.
Everything stretches vertically and nothing at all moves horizontally. The places where the coordinate is zero, largest and smallest stay pinned to the same angles, because the radius multiplies the whole curve by a constant and a constant cannot move a zero. Only the height of the wave responds.
Be clear about what this plot is. The horizontal axis is the angle, not a horizontal position in the plane, so you are not looking at the circle from above; you are looking at one coordinate of the moving point graphed against the angle. That is the standard way to see a parametric idea one piece at a time, and it is exactly the picture Section 10.5 will spend a whole lesson on.
Section
Part 2
Concept
The first reading of Theorem 10.3 answers a question you rarely have. The second reading answers the one you usually do have: here is a point, what are the values?
\[ \cos(\theta) = \frac{x}{r}, \qquad \sin(\theta) = \frac{y}{r}, \qquad r = \sqrt{x^2+y^2} \]
Notice what is missing. The angle never appears on the right-hand side, so you produce both values exactly without ever finding, naming or approximating the angle. That is the only way to get exact values for an angle that is not one of the sixteen special ones.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, pp. 730-731 — Theorem 10.3, second form
This is the form you will use in nearly every problem, so read the right-hand sides carefully. Neither of them contains the angle. That is not an oversight; it is the point. You can produce both values exactly from a point, with no calculator and no inverse function.
Think about how strong that is. For an angle that is not one of the sixteen special ones, there is no other way to get an exact value. You cannot find the angle exactly, so you cannot look its cosine up. But if you know one point on its terminal side with nice coordinates, both values come out as exact fractions in one line each.
The four numbered steps are the whole procedure. The one most often skipped is the last: check the size and the signs. Both cost a glance, and between them they catch the two commonest errors, an upside-down fraction and a lost minus sign.
Concept
This is the single most common place the sign goes wrong, so it is worth stating on its own.
\[ r = \sqrt{x^2 + y^2} \; > 0 \quad\text{for every point except the origin} \]
The square root symbol means the non-negative root, and a distance could hardly be anything else. So every negative sign in an answer has to come from the numerator, which is where the quadrant lives.
\[ \text{Quadrant III}: \; x < 0, \; y < 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \cos(\theta) < 0, \; \sin(\theta) < 0 \]
Put positively: you do not need the sign rules of the previous lesson here at all. Carry the coordinates' signs through the division and the quadrant takes care of itself.
This slide exists because a negative radius is the single most common way this lesson goes wrong, and the error is invisible: the arithmetic all works, the answer just has the wrong sign.
The square root symbol means the non-negative root, by convention and by common sense, since it is standing for a distance. So the denominator is positive for every point except the origin, which is excluded because it lies on no terminal side in any meaningful way.
Turn that into a working habit. Every minus sign in your final answer should be traceable to a coordinate, never to the radius. In quadrant three both coordinates are negative, so both values come out negative, and you get that for free without recalling any sign rule at all. If you find yourself writing a negative radius, you have confused the distance to a point with the position of the point.
Step zero
\[ \text{The terminal side of } \theta \text{ contains } (-7, 24). \]
Discussion prompt
Do not compute the cosine yet. Write down, in order, the two things you must settle before any division happens, and say what each will be for this point.
Write both answers down before revealing. Thirty seconds spent here saves the two most expensive mistakes in the part.
The distance has to come first for a purely practical reason: it is the denominator of both answers, so nothing can be divided until it exists. Here the numbers are friendly, seven and twenty-four and twenty-five, one of the standard Pythagorean triples. Recognising those triples on sight is worth doing, because textbook points are built from them.
The quadrant is the second thing, and it is not part of the calculation; it is your independent check on the calculation. A negative first coordinate with a positive second one is quadrant two, so you should expect a negative cosine and a positive sine before you compute anything. When the division confirms your expectation, you can move on with confidence. When it contradicts it, you have found an error for free.
Worked example
The book's own example. Watch the rationalising at the end, which is where most of the marks are lost.
\[ Q(4, -2) \text{ lies on the terminal side of } \theta. \text{ Find } \cos(\theta) \text{ and } \sin(\theta). \]
Find the distance to the origin
Why: Sixteen plus four is twenty, and twenty is four times five.
\[ r = \sqrt{4^2 + (-2)^2} = \sqrt{20} = 2\sqrt5 \]
Divide the first coordinate by that distance
Why: This is the cosine, by the second form of Theorem 10.3.
\[ \cos(\theta) = \frac{x}{r} = \frac{4}{2\sqrt5} = \frac{2}{\sqrt5} \]
Rationalise the denominator
Why: Multiply above and below by root five.
\[ \frac{2}{\sqrt5}\cdot\frac{\sqrt5}{\sqrt5} = \frac{2\sqrt5}{5} \]
Divide the second coordinate the same way
Why: The minus sign rides along untouched.
\[ \sin(\theta) = \frac{-2}{2\sqrt5} = -\frac{1}{\sqrt5} = -\frac{\sqrt5}{5} \]
Figure (svg): The point Q at four comma minus two in the fourth quadrant, joined to the origin, with the horizontal leg of length 4 and the vertical leg of length 2 drawn, and the circle of radius two root five through the point.
Check with the Pythagorean identity and the quadrant
Why: Twenty twenty-fifths plus five twenty-fifths is one; and a positive cosine beside a negative sine is quadrant four, which is where the point sits.
\[ \left(\frac{2\sqrt5}{5}\right)^2 + \left(-\frac{\sqrt5}{5}\right)^2 = \frac{20}{25} + \frac{5}{25} = 1 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 731 — Example 10.2.6, number 1
This is the book's own example, and the only part with any subtlety is the last move in each line, the rationalising. The distance is the square root of twenty, which simplifies to two root five, and that simplification is worth doing at once because it makes both divisions easier.
Watch the cosine line. Four over two root five reduces to two over root five, and then multiplying above and below by root five gives two root five over five. Many people stop at two over root five; it is the same number, but leaving a root in a denominator is a convention your marker will expect you to follow, and it also makes two answers easier to compare.
The sine keeps the minus sign all the way through, untouched by anything. And the check does two jobs at once: the identity confirms the sizes, and the sign pattern, positive cosine with negative sine, confirms quadrant four, which is where the picture shows the point.
Trap
The terminal side passes through the point 6 comma 8, so:
\[ \cos(\theta) = 6 \]
\[ \sin(\theta) = 8 \]
Wrong. Both are impossible.
Those are coordinates, not values. Divide by the distance to the origin first.
\[ r = \sqrt{36+64} = 10 \]
\[ \cos(\theta) = \tfrac{6}{10} = \tfrac35 \]
\[ \sin(\theta) = \tfrac{8}{10} = \tfrac45 \]
Coordinates equal values only on the unit circle, where the distance is one and dividing by it changes nothing. Off that circle the division is the whole content of the theorem.
This mistake is so natural that it deserves naming. On the unit circle, and only there, the coordinates and the values are the same numbers, and the first two lessons drilled that identification hard. Then the circle changes and the identification silently breaks.
Your safety net is the bound. Neither the cosine nor the sine can ever exceed one in size, so any answer bigger than one is wrong before you check anything else. A claimed cosine of six is not slightly off; it is impossible. Build the habit of glancing at the size of every value you write, and this error cannot survive.
The repair is one division. Find the distance to the origin and divide both coordinates by it, and the numbers drop into the interval where they belong.
Worked example
Same machinery, a point chosen so the radius comes out whole.
\[ \text{The terminal side of } \theta \text{ contains } (-9, 12). \]
Find the distance to the origin
Why: Eighty-one plus one hundred forty-four is two hundred twenty-five.
\[ r = \sqrt{(-9)^2 + 12^2} = \sqrt{225} = 15 \]
Divide both coordinates by fifteen
Why: No surd this time, so no rationalising.
\[ \cos(\theta) = \frac{-9}{15} = -\frac35, \qquad \sin(\theta) = \frac{12}{15} = \frac45 \]
Read the quadrant off the signs
Why: A negative first coordinate with a positive second is quadrant two, and the two values inherit exactly those signs.
\[ x < 0, \; y > 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{Quadrant II} \]
Figure (svg): The point minus nine comma twelve in the second quadrant joined to the origin, with a horizontal leg of length 9 and a vertical leg of length 12 forming a right triangle, and a dashed circle of radius 15 through the point.
Check with the Pythagorean identity
Why: Nine twenty-fifths plus sixteen twenty-fifths is twenty-five twenty-fifths.
\[ \left(-\tfrac35\right)^2 + \left(\tfrac45\right)^2 = \tfrac{9}{25} + \tfrac{16}{25} = 1 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, pp. 730-731 — Theorem 10.3, in the pattern of Example 10.2.6
Numbers like these are chosen, not lucky. Nine, twelve, fifteen is three times the three, four, five triple, so the distance comes out whole and no rationalising is needed. When you meet a point whose distance is whole, expect the rest of the problem to be short.
Notice how little quadrant reasoning is required. You do not decide that the cosine is negative because the angle is in quadrant two; you simply carry the minus sign of the first coordinate through the division, and the negative appears on its own. The quadrant then serves as a check rather than as a step.
The identity check at the end works out to nine twenty-fifths plus sixteen twenty-fifths. That will always happen, for any point at all, because the identity is just the distance formula rearranged. If it ever fails for you, the arithmetic in the distance is where to look first.
Fill the middle
One point, three blanks. Work left to right, since the first answer is the denominator of the other two.
Fill in the blanks
r = \sqrt13 = -5/13, \qquad \cos(\theta) = 12/13, \qquad \sin(\theta) = ___
Why: Twenty-five plus one hundred forty-four is one hundred sixty-nine, whose root is 13. Then each coordinate is divided by 13, keeping its own sign: the first coordinate is negative, so the cosine is negative, and the point is in quadrant two.
Fill the blanks left to right, because the first one is the denominator of the other two. Five, twelve, thirteen is another standard triple, and spotting it saves you from computing a root at all.
The two remaining blanks are just the coordinates divided by thirteen, each keeping its own sign. If you typed a positive value for the cosine, look again at the first coordinate: it is negative, and dividing a negative number by a positive distance cannot produce a positive result.
As a final check, square the two answers and add them. Twenty-five over one hundred sixty-nine plus one hundred forty-four over one hundred sixty-nine is one hundred sixty-nine over one hundred sixty-nine, which is one, exactly as the Pythagorean identity requires.
Worked example
A point whose distance is not a whole number, so the answer carries a root all the way through.
\[ \text{The terminal side of } \theta \text{ contains } (2, -3). \text{ Find both values exactly.} \]
Find the distance to the origin
Why: Four plus nine is thirteen, which is prime, so the root does not simplify.
\[ r = \sqrt{2^2 + (-3)^2} = \sqrt{13} \]
Write both quotients
Why: Leave the root where it is for one line.
\[ \cos(\theta) = \frac{2}{\sqrt{13}}, \qquad \sin(\theta) = \frac{-3}{\sqrt{13}} \]
Rationalise both denominators
Why: Multiply above and below by root thirteen in each.
\[ \cos(\theta) = \frac{2\sqrt{13}}{13}, \qquad \sin(\theta) = -\frac{3\sqrt{13}}{13} \]
Check the size of each value
Why: Neither may exceed one, since each is a leg over a hypotenuse.
\[ \frac{2\sqrt{13}}{13} \approx 0.5547, \qquad -\frac{3\sqrt{13}}{13} \approx -0.8321 \]
Check with the Pythagorean identity
Why: Four thirteenths plus nine thirteenths is one, and a positive cosine with a negative sine is quadrant four, where the point is.
\[ \frac{4\cdot 13}{169} + \frac{9\cdot 13}{169} = \frac{4}{13} + \frac{9}{13} = 1 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 730 — Theorem 10.3; the exercises on p. 736 use the same pattern
Four plus nine is thirteen, which is prime, so the root will not simplify and it is going to be with you to the end of the problem. That is normal; most points do not sit on a nice triple.
The rationalising step is the one to be careful with. Multiplying above and below by root thirteen turns two over root thirteen into two root thirteen over thirteen. A common slip is to multiply only the denominator, which changes the value of the fraction rather than its appearance.
Two checks are run at the end, and both are worth keeping. First the size: each value must lie between minus one and one, and the decimals 0.55 and minus 0.83 clearly do. Then the identity: four thirteenths plus nine thirteenths is one. Between them they catch an upside-down fraction and a botched rationalisation, which is most of what can go wrong here.
Error analysis
A student is given the point minus five comma minus twelve, in quadrant three, and writes this.
Annotate
On: \( r = -13, \quad \cos(\theta) = \frac{-5}{-13} = \frac{5}{13} \)
Read the two lines above before revealing the annotations and try to name the error yourself. The arithmetic in them is flawless, which is exactly what makes the mistake dangerous.
The error is the first symbol: a radius of minus thirteen. The radius is the distance from the point to the origin, and the square root sign means the non-negative root, so it is thirteen. Because the numerator was also negative, the two minus signs cancelled and the answer came out positive.
The damage shows up as a contradiction that a quick check would expose. The point is in quadrant three, where both values must be negative, and the working above has produced a positive cosine. Naming the quadrant before dividing turns this from an invisible error into an obvious one, which is why that habit is worth the ten seconds it costs.
Matching
All four points are the same distance from the origin, so only the signs and the order change.
Match the pairs
Why: Every one of these points is 5 units from the origin, so each value is a coordinate over 5. The first coordinate always becomes the cosine and the second always becomes the sine, each keeping its own sign, so the quadrant is readable straight off the pair.
All four points are five units from the origin, so the denominator is the same every time and only the numerators and their signs change. That is deliberate: it isolates the one skill being practised, which is keeping track of which coordinate becomes which value and what sign it carries.
Work by sign pattern rather than by arithmetic. A pair of positives is quadrant one, negative then positive is quadrant two, two negatives is quadrant three, and positive then negative is quadrant four. Match the pattern first and the fractions will follow.
If you mismatched the second and fourth items, the likely cause is swapping the roles of the coordinates. The first coordinate always makes the cosine and the second always makes the sine, in that order, no matter which quadrant the point is in.
Counterexample
Discussion prompt
A classmate says: the cosine measures how far right the point is, so a point on a circle of radius 100 must have a bigger cosine than a point at the same angle on the unit circle. Give a specific pair of numbers that kills the claim, then say in one sentence what the claim confuses.
Write a specific counterexample, with numbers, before you reveal. A general argument is fine too, but numbers are harder to fool yourself with.
The claim has a true part hidden inside it, which is why it tempts people. The coordinate really does grow when the circle grows, a hundredfold in the example here. What the claim misses is that the denominator grows by exactly the same factor, so the quotient stays put. The classmate is describing the coordinate and calling it the cosine.
There is also a knock-out blow that needs no arithmetic at all. The cosine can never exceed one, so if enlarging the circle really did increase it, you could pick a circle large enough to push the cosine past one, which is impossible. Arguments of that shape, where a claim would violate a known bound, are often the fastest way to kill a wrong idea.
Section
Part 3
Concept
Section 10.1 defined the angular velocity as the angle swept per unit time, and then stopped, because there was no way yet to turn an angle into a position. Theorem 10.3 is that missing piece.
\[ \omega = \frac{\theta}{t} \qquad\Longrightarrow\qquad \theta = \omega t \]
Read the second equation as a promise: at any time t you know the angle, and knowing the angle plus the radius is exactly what Theorem 10.3 needs. Two substitutions and the position is a formula in t.
\[ x = r\cos(\theta) = r\cos(\omega t), \qquad y = r\sin(\theta) = r\sin(\omega t) \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 732 — the derivation before Equation 10.3
Section 10.1 got as far as the rate and then stopped, because a rate of turning tells you how much angle has been swept but nothing about where the object is. The missing link was a way to turn an angle into a position, and that is precisely what Theorem 10.3 supplies.
The rewriting is trivial algebra: rate equals angle over time, so angle equals rate times time. What makes it powerful is that the right-hand side contains only known constants and the clock, so the angle is now a formula in the time.
Substitute that formula wherever the angle appeared in Theorem 10.3 and both coordinates become functions of the time. Two substitutions, and a question that could not even be phrased two sections ago is answered completely. It is worth pausing on how little machinery this took.
Concept
Figure (svg): A circle of radius 2960 miles about the origin with eight dots marking the position of a point every three hours through one day, labelled at zero, six, twelve and eighteen hours, and a curved arrow showing the counter-clockwise direction.
Equation 10.3 — An object travelling on a circle of radius r about the origin with constant angular velocity, starting at the point r comma 0 when the clock reads zero, has coordinates r times the cosine of omega t and r times the sine of omega t. A positive angular velocity turns it counter-clockwise and a negative one turns it clockwise.
\[ x = r\cos(\omega t), \qquad y = r\sin(\omega t) \]
Two conditions are quietly built in. The object starts on the positive horizontal axis, and the rate never changes. Both can be relaxed later, and Section 11.1 will do so, but everything in this lesson assumes them.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 732 — Equation 10.3
The picture shows one full day sampled every three hours. The dots are evenly spaced around the circle because equal time steps sweep equal angles, which is exactly what constant angular velocity means.
Two assumptions are built into Equation 10.3 and you should be able to state them. The object starts at the point on the positive horizontal axis when the clock reads zero, and the rate never changes. If an object starts somewhere else, the equations need a shift inside the cosine and sine, which is the phase shift of Section 11.1; if the rate changes, this lesson does not apply at all.
The sign of the rate carries the direction: positive turns counter-clockwise, negative turns clockwise. Nothing else in the formula changes, which is a pleasantly cheap way to encode a direction.
Notation
Annotate
On: \( x = r\cos(\omega t), \qquad y = r\sin(\omega t) \)
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 732 — Equation 10.3
Step through the four annotations and notice how differently the two constants behave. The radius multiplies both coordinates from outside, so it controls only the size of the motion. The rate sits inside the cosine and the sine, so it controls only how quickly the motion repeats. They never interfere.
The third annotation is the one that costs marks in an exam. A rate in radians per hour multiplied by a time in hours leaves radians, so the thing inside the cosine is already an angle in radians and your calculator must be in radian mode. There is no degree symbol anywhere in Equation 10.3, and that is not an accident.
The fourth annotation is a habit rather than a fact. Before you evaluate anything, sort the symbols into constants of this particular wheel and the one variable, the time. Everything except the time is fixed before the clock starts.
Worked example
Back in Section 10.1 the radius of the Earth at the latitude of Lakeland Community College was simply asserted to be about 2960 miles. Here is where that number comes from.
\[ \text{equatorial radius } = 3960 \text{ miles}, \qquad \text{latitude } 41.628^\circ \text{ north} \]
Slice the Earth through the poles
Why: The cross-section is a circle whose radius is the equatorial radius, with the Equator lying along the horizontal axis.
\[ x^2 + y^2 = 3960^2 \]
Say what is actually being asked for
Why: As the Earth turns, the point traces a circle whose radius is its distance from the polar axis, and that distance is the first coordinate.
\[ \text{want: } x \text{ at } \theta = 41.628^\circ \]
Apply Theorem 10.3
Why: The first coordinate is the radius times the cosine of the angle.
\[ x = 3960\cos(41.628^\circ) \]
Evaluate with the calculator in degree mode
Why: This angle is not one of the special ones, so the value is a decimal.
\[ 3960\cos(41.628^\circ) = 2959.995\ldots \approx 2960 \]
Figure (svg): A cross-section of the Earth through the poles drawn as a circle of radius 3960 miles, with a radius drawn to a point at 41.628 degrees north and a dashed horizontal segment from the polar axis out to that point marked 2960 miles.
Check the two extreme latitudes
Why: At the Equator the cosine is one and the latitude circle is the whole Equator; at the pole the cosine is zero and the circle shrinks to a point. The answer must lie between, and 2960 does lie between 0 and 3960.
\[ 3960\cos(0^\circ) = 3960, \qquad 3960\cos(90^\circ) = 0 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 731 — Example 10.2.6, number 2
This example closes a loop. Back in Section 10.1 you used a radius of 2960 miles for Lakeland Community College and the book simply promised to justify it later. This is later.
The step worth dwelling on is the second one, deciding what is actually being asked for. As the Earth turns, a point at that latitude traces a circle, and the radius of that circle is its distance from the axis of rotation, which in the cross-section picture is a horizontal distance from the vertical axis. A horizontal distance from the vertical axis is the first coordinate. Once you see that, Theorem 10.3 finishes the problem in one line.
The check uses the two extreme latitudes and it is a good habit generally. At the Equator the cosine is one, so the latitude circle is the Equator itself, 3960 miles. At the pole the cosine is zero, so the circle shrinks to a point. Your answer must lie between, and 2960 does. Notice also how precise the textbook value turns out to be: the calculator gives 2959.995.
Worked example
With the radius known, the position of a fixed point on the Earth becomes an explicit function of the time of day.
\[ r = 2960 \text{ miles}, \qquad \text{one revolution every } 24 \text{ hours} \]
Convert the rate into radians per hour
Why: One revolution is two pi radians, and it takes twenty-four hours.
\[ \omega = \frac{2\pi \text{ rad}}{24 \text{ hr}} = \frac{\pi}{12} \text{ rad/hr} \]
Turn the angle into a function of time
Why: Angle swept equals rate times elapsed time.
\[ \theta = \omega t = \frac{\pi}{12}t \]
Substitute into Theorem 10.3
Why: Each coordinate is the radius times a circular function of that angle.
\[ x = r\cos(\omega t), \qquad y = r\sin(\omega t) \]
Put the numbers in
Why: Miles for the coordinates, hours for the time.
\[ x = 2960\cos\!\left(\frac{\pi}{12}t\right), \qquad y = 2960\sin\!\left(\frac{\pi}{12}t\right) \]
Check at the start and at half a day
Why: At time zero the point is at the assumed starting position on the positive horizontal axis; twelve hours later it is diametrically opposite, which is exactly half a revolution.
\[ t = 0 \to (2960, 0), \qquad t = 12 \to (2960\cos\pi, 2960\sin\pi) = (-2960, 0) \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 732 — Example 10.2.7
Every piece of this was assembled earlier; the example just puts them in one place. The radius came from the previous slide, and the rate came from Section 10.1: one revolution, which is two pi radians, in twenty-four hours.
Write the general form before substituting the numbers. It keeps the structure visible and it means that if you misremember a number you have only one line to repair rather than the whole solution.
The check exercises both ends of half a revolution. At time zero the point is at the assumed start, which confirms you have not accidentally shifted anything. At twelve hours the angle is pi, and the point is diametrically opposite, which is exactly right for half a day. If either of those had come out wrong, the rate would be the first thing to re-examine.
Picture it
Figure (svg): Two curves on the same axes over twenty-four hours: the first coordinate starts at 2960, falls to minus 2960 at twelve hours and returns; the second coordinate starts at zero, peaks at 2960 at six hours and bottoms at eighteen hours.
The same motion, replotted with time along the horizontal axis. Each coordinate swings between the radius and its negative, and the second coordinate runs a quarter of a revolution behind the first.
Nothing here is new: every height on these two curves is one coordinate of one dot on the previous figure. Section 10.5 will study these two waves for their own sake.
This is the same motion as the circle picture, drawn differently. There, time was hidden in which dot you were looking at. Here, time runs along the horizontal axis and each curve shows one coordinate.
Read a few values off and match them to the circle. At six hours the first coordinate is zero and the second is at its maximum, because the point is at the top. At twelve hours the first coordinate is at its most negative and the second is zero, because the point is diametrically opposite the start. Every height on these curves is one coordinate of one dot on the earlier picture.
The two curves are the same shape, one running a quarter of a revolution behind the other. That quarter-turn offset between the cosine and the sine is a fact you will meet again and again, and Section 10.5 studies these two waves for their own sake. For now it is enough to see where they come from.
Worked example
The equations of motion earn their keep by being evaluated.
\[ x = 2960\cos\!\left(\tfrac{\pi}{12}t\right), \quad y = 2960\sin\!\left(\tfrac{\pi}{12}t\right), \quad t = 8 \]
Find the angle swept in eight hours
Why: Rate times time, and the twelve cancels into the eight.
\[ \theta = \frac{\pi}{12}(8) = \frac{2\pi}{3} \]
Read the special values
Why: Two pi over three is in quadrant two with reference angle pi over three.
\[ \cos\!\left(\tfrac{2\pi}{3}\right) = -\tfrac12, \qquad \sin\!\left(\tfrac{2\pi}{3}\right) = \tfrac{\sqrt3}{2} \]
Multiply both by the radius
Why: Theorem 10.3 again, with r equal to 2960.
\[ x = 2960\!\left(-\tfrac12\right) = -1480, \qquad y = 2960\!\left(\tfrac{\sqrt3}{2}\right) = 1480\sqrt3 \]
Give the second coordinate as a decimal
Why: Root three is about 1.7321.
\[ y = 1480\sqrt3 \approx 2563.4 \text{ miles} \]
Check the distance from the axis of rotation
Why: It must still be 2960 miles, because the point cannot leave its own latitude circle.
\[ \sqrt{(-1480)^2 + (1480\sqrt3)^2} = 1480\sqrt{1+3} = 2(1480) = 2960 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 732 — Equation 10.3, evaluated
The equations of motion are only worth writing if you can evaluate them, so make this routine. Find the angle, look up its two values, multiply both by the radius.
Eight hours is a third of a day, so the angle should be a third of a revolution, and two pi over three is exactly that. If your angle does not match a rough mental fraction of a turn, stop and recheck the rate before going further.
The check is one you can run on every answer of this type, and it costs almost nothing: square both coordinates, add them, and you must get the radius back. Here the algebra is pretty, since 1480 factors out and leaves the root of one plus three, which is two. The point has moved but its distance from the axis has not, which is the one thing a point on a latitude circle can never do.
Trap
A wheel of radius 5 turns at two radians per second. Where is the marked point after three seconds?
\[ \theta = 2(3) = 6 \]
\[ x = 5\cos(6^\circ) \approx 4.97 \]
Wrong. Six radians, not six degrees.
Angular velocity is radians per unit time, so the product of the rate and the time is already an angle in radians. Keep the calculator in radian mode.
\[ x = 5\cos(6) \approx 4.80 \]
\[ y = 5\sin(6) \approx -1.40 \]
One radian is about 57 degrees, so the same number read in the wrong unit is out by a factor of nearly sixty. This is never a rounding-sized mistake.
Angular velocity is defined in radians per unit time, so the moment you multiply it by a time you have an angle in radians. There is no conversion left to do, and a degree symbol on that line means something has gone wrong upstream.
The two answers are not close. Six degrees is barely past the start, so the first coordinate stays near the radius. Six radians is almost a whole turn, ending just below the horizontal axis, so the second coordinate should be negative and the wrong version does not even get its sign right. Sign disagreements like that are the cheapest way to catch a mode error.
Practically: set the calculator to radian mode at the start of any circular-motion problem and leave it there. The only places degrees belong in this lesson are the right-triangle problems, where the angle is given with a degree symbol attached.
Worked example
A rate given in revolutions has to be converted before Equation 10.3 will accept it.
\[ r = 0.4 \text{ m}, \qquad 2 \text{ revolutions per second, starting at } (0.4, 0) \]
Convert revolutions into radians
Why: Each revolution is two pi radians, and there are two of them every second.
\[ \omega = 2\,\frac{\text{rev}}{\text{s}} \cdot 2\pi\,\frac{\text{rad}}{\text{rev}} = 4\pi \text{ rad/s} \]
Write the equations of motion
Why: Radius 0.4 metres, angular velocity four pi.
\[ x = 0.4\cos(4\pi t), \qquad y = 0.4\sin(4\pi t) \]
Find the period from the rate
Why: One full revolution is two pi radians at four pi radians per second.
\[ T = \frac{2\pi}{\omega} = \frac{2\pi}{4\pi} = \frac12 \text{ s} \]
Check with a quarter turn
Why: An eighth of a second is a quarter of the period, so the mark should be at the top of the wheel, and it is.
\[ t = \tfrac18: \; 4\pi\!\left(\tfrac18\right) = \tfrac{\pi}{2}, \quad (x, y) = (0, 0.4) \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 732 — Equation 10.3, with the rate converted
Rates in the wild almost never arrive in radians per second. They come as revolutions per minute on a motor plate, as hertz on a specification sheet, or as a period in seconds. Equation 10.3 accepts only radians per unit time, so converting is step one, always.
The conversion here is one multiplication: two revolutions per second, two pi radians in each revolution, so four pi radians per second. Writing the units in the line, as the solution does, makes it obvious that revolutions cancel and radians survive.
The period is the reciprocal idea and it is worth computing even when the question does not ask for it, because it gives you a check. Half a second per revolution matches two revolutions per second, and then the quarter-turn test at an eighth of a second lands the mark exactly at the top of the wheel, where it should be.
Intuition
Whatever numbers you put in for the radius, the rate and the time, the point always lands on the intended circle. That is not luck; one identity does it.
\[ x^2 + y^2 = r^2\cos^2(\omega t) + r^2\sin^2(\omega t) \]
\[ x^2 + y^2 = r^2\left[\cos^2(\omega t) + \sin^2(\omega t)\right] = r^2(1) = r^2 \]
The Pythagorean identity of the previous lesson is doing the work, and it holds for every angle whatsoever, so it holds at every instant. The equations of motion are built so that the constraint can never be violated.
This is also a free check on any answer you produce: square the two coordinates, add them, and you should get the radius squared back.
This is the reassurance that the equations of motion are not merely a plausible guess. No matter what numbers go in for the radius, the rate and the time, the point comes out on the intended circle, and one identity guarantees it.
Follow the two lines. Squaring each coordinate produces a factor of the radius squared, and factoring that out leaves the sum of a squared cosine and a squared sine, which is one for every angle whatsoever. So the sum of the squared coordinates is the radius squared at every instant, which is the equation of the circle.
The Pythagorean identity you met last lesson is doing all the work, and this is a good illustration of what identities are for: they hold for every input, so they can be used to prove that a constraint is never violated. It also gives you a free check on any position you compute, which the last two worked examples both used.
Edge cases
Parameter explorer
Time in hours runs along the horizontal axis, and the curve is the first coordinate divided by the radius, so it is just the cosine of omega t. Slide omega from very slow to fast. What does omega change, and what is it powerless to change?
\[ \frac{x(t)}{r} = \cos({w}\,t) \]
The rate decides how often the motion repeats; the radius decides how big it is. The two settings never interfere with each other.
Start with the slider near 0.26, which is pi over twelve, the Earth's rate in radians per hour. You should see exactly one full wave across the twenty-four hours, which is one revolution per day.
Now push it up. The wave squeezes horizontally: more revolutions fit into the same day. Pull it down and the wave stretches out, and at the slowest settings you do not even see a full turn in a day. What never changes is the height of the wave, because the plot shows the coordinate divided by the radius, and the rate has no way to touch that.
The separation is worth stating in words. The radius sets how big the motion is; the rate sets how often it repeats. Two independent dials, which is why the equations of motion have exactly two constants in them.
Real world
Every device that spins at a steady rate is described by the same two equations, and every position report in the plane can be turned back into an angle's worth of information.
Discussion prompt
A receiver reports your position as 120 metres east and 50 metres south of a marker. Find your distance from the marker, and find the cosine and the sine of the bearing angle measured counter-clockwise from due east. Which of those two calculations needs this lesson, and which needs an inverse function you have not met yet?
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, pp. 730-731 — Theorem 10.3 in applied form
Answer both halves of the question before revealing, especially the last part about which calculation needs a tool you have not met.
The distance is the same square root as always, and the numbers are chosen so it comes out whole: 120, 50, 130 is ten times a 12, 5, 13 triangle. The two values are then quotients, and the negative second coordinate makes the sine negative, which is right for a position south of the marker.
The final part matters more than the arithmetic. Going from a point to the cosine and sine is easy and exact, and that is this lesson. Going from the cosine back to the angle is genuinely harder, because a great many angles share one cosine, so the inverse has to be tamed by restricting the domain first. That is Lesson 10.6a, and noticing now why it is difficult will make it much less mysterious then.
Section
Part 4
Concept
Figure (svg): Two panels. On the left a right triangle with the acute angle theta at the lower left, adjacent side a along the bottom, opposite side b up the right, and hypotenuse c. On the right the same triangle placed with theta at the origin and a along the horizontal axis, its far corner P at the point a comma b on a circle of radius c.
Take any right triangle with an acute angle marked, and slide it onto the axes so that the marked angle sits at the origin and its neighbouring leg lies along the positive horizontal axis. Nothing about the triangle changes; it has only been moved.
\[ a^2 + b^2 = c^2 \;\Longrightarrow\; P(a, b) \text{ lies on } x^2 + y^2 = c^2 \]
So the far corner is a point on the terminal side, on the circle of radius c, and Theorem 10.3 applies to it word for word with r equal to c.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, pp. 732-733 — the development before Theorem 10.4
The move here is physical, not algebraic: pick the triangle up and put it on the axes, with the marked angle at the origin and its adjacent leg along the positive horizontal axis. Nothing about the triangle has changed, because sliding and turning do not alter lengths or angles.
Now look at what the triangle has become. Its far corner is a point whose coordinates are the two legs, and by the Pythagorean theorem that point is exactly the hypotenuse away from the origin. So it sits on a circle whose radius is the hypotenuse, and Theorem 10.3 applies to it with no adjustment at all.
That is why right triangle trigonometry is not a separate subject with its own rules. It is the circle definition looked at in the first quadrant, where all the coordinates are positive and can be read as plain lengths.
Concept
adjacent, opposite, hypotenuse — For an acute angle inside a right triangle: the adjacent side is the leg that touches the angle, the opposite side is the leg across from it, and the hypotenuse is the side across from the right angle. Only the two legs swap roles when you change which acute angle you are looking at.
\[ \cos(\theta) = \frac{a}{c} = \frac{\text{adjacent}}{\text{hypotenuse}}, \qquad \sin(\theta) = \frac{b}{c} = \frac{\text{opposite}}{\text{hypotenuse}} \]
This is Theorem 10.3 with the coordinates renamed: the first coordinate of the corner is the adjacent leg, the second is the opposite leg, and the distance to the origin is the hypotenuse. No new mathematics has happened.
| you want | you know | the relation to write |
|---|---|---|
| the hypotenuse | the adjacent leg and the angle | cosine of the angle equals adjacent over hypotenuse |
| the hypotenuse | the opposite leg and the angle | sine of the angle equals opposite over hypotenuse |
| the adjacent leg | the hypotenuse and the angle | adjacent equals hypotenuse times cosine |
| the opposite leg | the hypotenuse and the angle | opposite equals hypotenuse times sine |
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 733 — Theorem 10.4
The theorem contains no new mathematics; it renames the parts of Theorem 10.3 in triangle language. The first coordinate becomes the adjacent leg, the second becomes the opposite leg, and the distance to the origin becomes the hypotenuse.
The words adjacent and opposite are relative to a chosen angle, and this is where most errors in this part begin. The same leg is adjacent to one acute angle and opposite the other, so the first thing to do in any triangle problem is decide which angle you are working from. The hypotenuse is the only side whose name never changes.
The table is a lookup for the four situations you actually meet. Read it as a sentence: the relation to write is the one that contains the side you know and the side you want, and nothing else. Choosing that relation well means you never have to rearrange more than one equation.
Worked example
Find the missing angle and both missing sides. This is the book's own worked triangle.
\[ \text{right triangle}, \quad \theta = 30^\circ, \quad \text{adjacent leg } = 7 \]
Find the third angle first
Why: It is the cheapest unknown: the three angles add to 180 degrees and one of them is the right angle.
\[ 180^\circ - 90^\circ - 30^\circ = 60^\circ \]
Write the cosine relation
Why: The 7 touches the 30 degree angle, so it is the adjacent leg.
\[ \cos(30^\circ) = \frac{7}{c} \]
Solve for the hypotenuse
Why: Multiply by c, divide by the cosine, and substitute the exact value.
\[ c = \frac{7}{\cos(30^\circ)} = \frac{7}{\frac{\sqrt3}{2}} = \frac{14}{\sqrt3} \]
Rationalise
Why: Multiply above and below by root three.
\[ c = \frac{14\sqrt3}{3} \approx 8.083 \]
Use the sine for the remaining leg
Why: The opposite leg is the hypotenuse times the sine of the angle.
\[ b = c\sin(30^\circ) = \frac{14\sqrt3}{3}\cdot\frac12 = \frac{7\sqrt3}{3} \approx 4.041 \]
Figure (svg): A right triangle drawn to scale with a thirty degree angle at the left, an adjacent side of length 7 along the bottom, an opposite side of about 4.04 and a hypotenuse of about 8.08, and the remaining angle marked sixty degrees.
Check with the Pythagorean theorem
Why: Forty-nine plus forty-nine thirds is one hundred ninety-six thirds, and squaring the hypotenuse gives one hundred ninety-six over nine times three, the same number.
\[ 7^2 + \left(\frac{7\sqrt3}{3}\right)^2 = 49 + \frac{49}{3} = \frac{196}{3} = \left(\frac{14\sqrt3}{3}\right)^2 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, pp. 733-734 — Example 10.2.8
Take the free unknown first. The three angles add to 180 degrees and one of them is 90, so the missing angle costs one subtraction and cannot go wrong. Getting it out of the way also means that from here on you may work from either acute angle, whichever makes the relation simpler.
The hypotenuse comes from the cosine because the 7 touches the 30 degree angle, making it the adjacent leg. Solving gives seven over root three halves, which is fourteen over root three, and then rationalising gives fourteen root three over three. That fraction gymnastics is the fiddliest part of the problem, so write every line.
For the last side there were two routes: the Pythagorean theorem, or the sine. The solution takes the sine because it is one multiplication, and then keeps the Pythagorean theorem in reserve as the check. That is the right division of labour, since a check computed by an independent route is worth far more than one that repeats the same steps.
Ranking
Put in order
Order the steps of a complete solution of a right triangle, given one acute angle and one side.
Why: Naming the sides comes first, because until you know which leg is adjacent you cannot tell whether the cosine or the sine is the relation you need. The third angle is next because it costs one subtraction and can never go wrong. Only then is there any algebra, and the Pythagorean check comes last, when all three sides exist.
Drag the steps into order before revealing, and pay particular attention to the first two.
Naming the sides has to come first, because until you know which leg is adjacent to the angle you are working from, you cannot tell whether the cosine or the sine is the relation you need. Guessing here is how the adjacent and opposite mix-up happens.
The third angle is second because it is free: one subtraction, no possibility of error, and it may open up an easier relation. The algebra comes third, and the Pythagorean check comes last, when all three sides exist to be checked. If you put the check earlier you have nothing to check it against.
Worked example
The angle is the same as in Example 10.2.8 but the given side is 1, so every answer should shrink by the same factor.
\[ \text{right triangle}, \quad 30^\circ \text{ given}, \quad \text{adjacent leg } = 1 \]
Find the missing angle
Why: The same subtraction as before.
\[ \theta = 180^\circ - 90^\circ - 30^\circ = 60^\circ \]
Use the cosine of the thirty degree angle
Why: Its adjacent leg is the given side of length 1.
\[ \cos(30^\circ) = \frac{1}{c} \;\Longrightarrow\; c = \frac{1}{\cos(30^\circ)} = \frac{2}{\sqrt3} \]
Rationalise the hypotenuse
Why: Multiply above and below by root three.
\[ c = \frac{2\sqrt3}{3} \approx 1.155 \]
Find the remaining leg with the sine
Why: The leg opposite the thirty degree angle is the hypotenuse times the sine of thirty degrees.
\[ b = c\sin(30^\circ) = \frac{2\sqrt3}{3}\cdot\frac12 = \frac{\sqrt3}{3} \approx 0.577 \]
Figure (svg): A right triangle with a thirty degree angle at the left, adjacent side of length 1, opposite side of about 0.577 and hypotenuse of about 1.155, with the remaining angle marked sixty degrees.
Check against Example 10.2.8
Why: Every length here is one seventh of the matching length there, which is exactly what similarity predicts when the adjacent leg drops from 7 to 1.
\[ \frac{\sqrt3/3}{7\sqrt3/3} = \frac17, \qquad \frac{2\sqrt3/3}{14\sqrt3/3} = \frac17 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 737 — Exercise 55
The angles here are identical to Example 10.2.8, so before computing anything you already know the shape of the answer: this is the same triangle at a different size, and every length should be one seventh of the corresponding length there.
The method is unchanged. The cosine gives the hypotenuse, since the given side of length 1 touches the 30 degree angle; the sine then gives the remaining leg. Rationalise as you go so the final answers are in standard form.
The check is the interesting part of this exercise. Dividing each answer by the matching answer from Example 10.2.8 gives one seventh both times, which is the similarity of the two triangles showing up in the arithmetic. A triangle's angles do not care how big it is, so shrinking the adjacent leg from 7 to 1 shrinks everything else in exactly the same proportion.
Worked example
This time the given side is across from the named angle, so the sine is the relation to reach for first.
\[ \text{right triangle}, \quad 45^\circ \text{ given}, \quad \text{the leg opposite it } = 3 \]
Find the missing angle
Why: One angle is the right angle and one is 45 degrees.
\[ \theta = 180^\circ - 90^\circ - 45^\circ = 45^\circ \]
Use the sine of the given angle
Why: The given side is opposite it, and sine is opposite over hypotenuse.
\[ \sin(45^\circ) = \frac{3}{c} \;\Longrightarrow\; c = \frac{3}{\frac{\sqrt2}{2}} = \frac{6}{\sqrt2} = 3\sqrt2 \approx 4.243 \]
Find the last side with the cosine
Why: The remaining leg touches the 45 degree angle, so it is the hypotenuse times the cosine.
\[ a = c\cos(45^\circ) = 3\sqrt2\cdot\frac{\sqrt2}{2} = \frac{3\cdot 2}{2} = 3 \]
Figure (svg): A right triangle with the right angle at the lower left, a forty-five degree angle at the top, a vertical side a, a horizontal side of length 3 along the bottom and a hypotenuse of about 4.243, with the remaining angle also forty-five degrees.
Check that the triangle came out isosceles
Why: Two equal angles force two equal legs, and the two legs did come out equal; Pythagoras agrees with the hypotenuse.
\[ 3^2 + 3^2 = 18 = (3\sqrt2)^2 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 737 — Exercise 56
Notice the difference from the previous two exercises: the given side is across from the named angle, not touching it. That single fact decides everything, because it means the relation containing the given side and the hypotenuse is the sine, not the cosine.
Once the hypotenuse is three root two, the last leg comes from the cosine, and the root twos cancel to leave a clean 3. Watch that cancellation: three root two times root two over two is three times two over two, which is 3.
The check is structural rather than numerical, which makes it especially satisfying. Both acute angles are 45 degrees, so the triangle is isosceles and the two legs must be equal, and they are. You could have predicted the answer before doing any algebra, and being able to do that is a sign you understand the shape rather than just the procedure.
Error analysis
A right triangle has an acute angle of 25 degrees and hypotenuse 14. A student wants the leg b across from that angle and writes this first line.
Annotate
On: \( \cos(25^\circ) = \frac{b}{14} \;\Longrightarrow\; b \approx 12.69 \)
Read the line above and try to spot the problem before revealing the annotations. The arithmetic is correct; the relation is not.
The cosine takes the adjacent leg over the hypotenuse, and the line above has fed it the opposite leg. The number that came out, about 12.69, is a real length in this triangle, just not the one that was asked for: it is the adjacent leg. That is what makes this error so easy to miss, since the answer looks entirely reasonable.
The last annotation is the defence worth adopting. Twenty-five degrees is a narrow wedge, so the side across from it has to be the short one. An answer of 12.69 against a hypotenuse of 14 is almost the whole hypotenuse, which is clearly wrong for a thin angle. Sanity-checking a side against the size of its angle takes one second and catches this every time.
Worked example
The angle is not special, so this one ends in decimals. The method does not change.
\[ \theta = 25^\circ, \qquad c = 14 \]
Find the adjacent leg
Why: Adjacent equals hypotenuse times cosine.
\[ a = 14\cos(25^\circ) = 14(0.90631) \approx 12.688 \]
Find the opposite leg
Why: Opposite equals hypotenuse times sine.
\[ b = 14\sin(25^\circ) = 14(0.42262) \approx 5.917 \]
Find the third angle
Why: Subtract the two known angles from 180 degrees.
\[ 180^\circ - 90^\circ - 25^\circ = 65^\circ \]
Check with the Pythagorean theorem
Why: The two legs squared should rebuild the hypotenuse squared, which is 196; rounding accounts for the last digit.
\[ 12.688^2 + 5.917^2 = 160.99 + 35.01 = 196.0 = 14^2 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 733 — Theorem 10.4, with a non-special angle
Nothing changes when the angle is not special except that the answers are decimals. Keep the exact expression on one line and the decimal on the next, so the structure of the solution stays readable.
Both legs come straight from Theorem 10.4 rearranged: each leg is the hypotenuse times the appropriate value. No division and no rearranging is needed at all when the hypotenuse is the side you were given, which is why this is the easiest of the four triangle situations.
The Pythagorean check will not land exactly on 196 because the values were rounded, and that is expected rather than worrying. What you are looking for is agreement to the number of decimal places you kept. If it came out as 210 or 180, the error would be a swapped relation, not rounding.
Estimation
Figure (svg): A very shallow right triangle: a horizontal run of thirty metres, a ramp surface rising at eight degrees from the left end, and a short vertical rise of about 4.2 metres at the right end.
Predict first
A ramp climbs at 8 degrees over a horizontal run of 30 metres. Before computing: roughly how high is its far end?
Correct: about 4 metres
Why: The hypotenuse is the run divided by the cosine of 8 degrees, about 30.29 metres, and the rise is that times the sine of 8 degrees, about 4.22 metres. A useful rule of thumb for small angles: the rise is roughly the run times the angle in radians, and 8 degrees is about 0.14 radians, so about 4.2 metres. Eight metres would be a 15 degree ramp, far steeper than anything wheelchairs use.
\[ c = \frac{30}{\cos(8^\circ)} \approx 30.295, \qquad \text{rise} = c\sin(8^\circ) \approx 4.216 \text{ m} \]
Commit to an option before revealing, and notice that the picture is drawn to scale. Eight degrees really is that shallow, which is why estimating from the drawing alone is difficult.
There is a genuinely useful shortcut hidden in the answer. For small angles the rise is roughly the run times the angle measured in radians. Eight degrees is about 0.14 radians, and 30 times 0.14 is about 4.2, which is within a hundredth of the exact answer. Rules of thumb like this are worth collecting, because they let you check an exact calculation without repeating it.
For scale: accessibility standards generally cap a ramp at about 5 degrees, so 8 degrees is already steep for a wheelchair, and the 15 degree option would be a steep driveway. If you chose 8 metres, you may have been thinking of the hypotenuse rather than the rise, or applied the sine to the wrong side.
Section
Part 5
Concept
Figure (svg): The unit circle with a thick highlighted arc running counter-clockwise from the point one comma zero through about 2.2 units of arc, ending at the point with coordinates cosine t and sine t, with dashed lines from that point to both axes.
Radian measure already identified a real number with an angle: the number is the length of arc that angle cuts off on the unit circle. So a bare real number can be fed to the cosine with no conversion at all.
\[ t \in \mathbb{R} \;\longleftrightarrow\; \theta = t \text{ radians}, \qquad \cos(t) = \cos(\theta), \; \sin(t) = \sin(\theta) \]
Concretely: start at the point 1 comma 0, walk t units counter-clockwise along the unit circle, and the coordinates where you stop are named the cosine and the sine of t. Walk backwards for a negative t.
\[ P(\cos(t), \sin(t)) \text{ is the endpoint of an arc of length } t \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 734 — the identification of real numbers with angles
Everything on this slide was quietly set up in Section 10.1, when radian measure defined the measure of an angle as the arc it cuts off on the unit circle. Once an angle and an arc length are the same number, feeding a plain real number to the cosine requires no conversion whatsoever.
Follow the picture as a procedure. Start at the point one comma zero, walk t units counter-clockwise along the circle, and stop. The two coordinates where you stopped are the cosine and the sine of t. For a negative t, walk the same distance clockwise instead.
This is not a new definition competing with the old one; it is the old one with the word angle deleted. The practical upshot is that expressions such as the cosine of 2 or the sine of e are perfectly ordinary numbers, and you can now graph these functions against a real variable, which is what Section 10.5 will do.
Concept
That identification is what promotes the cosine and the sine from operations on angles to functions of a real variable, which is how the rest of the book will treat them.
\[ f(t) = \cos(t), \qquad g(t) = \sin(t) \]
The first question about any new function is the same as it was for polynomials, rationals, exponentials and logarithms: what may go in, and what can come out.
What may go in is everything. There is no largest angle and no shortest arc: you can wind any distance in either direction around the circle, so every real number is a legal input. No division, no even root and no logarithm appears anywhere in the construction to forbid anything.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 734 — the paragraph before Theorem 10.5
This slide is the promotion. Up to now the cosine has been an operation you performed on an angle. Naming it f and giving it a real variable makes it a function like any other in this book, which means the standard first questions apply.
The domain argument is worth being able to give in one sentence. There is no largest angle and no longest arc, since you may keep winding around the circle in either direction forever, so every real number is a legal input. It also helps to notice what is absent from the construction: no division, no even root and no logarithm, so there is nothing that could exclude a value.
The range is the harder of the two questions, and the next two slides answer it. Before reading them, try to predict the answer from the picture on the previous slide: the outputs are coordinates of a point on a circle of radius one, so how large can they get?
Notation
Annotate
On: \( \text{dom} = (-\infty, \infty), \qquad \text{ran} = [-1, 1] \)
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 735 — Theorem 10.5
The theorem says the same two things twice, once for the cosine and once for the sine, because the two coordinates play completely symmetric roles on the circle. Learning one gets you the other free.
Keep the reasons attached to the facts, since the facts alone are easy to swap. The domain is everything because there is no limit on how far you may wind. The range stops at one because the outputs are coordinates of a point on a circle of radius one, and a coordinate cannot be longer than the radius.
The square brackets are not decorative. They say the interval is closed, so minus one and one are genuinely attained, which happens at the four quadrantal angles. That matters for solving equations: the sine really can equal one, so that equation has solutions, whereas the sine equalling 1.0001 has none.
Picture it
Figure (svg): The unit circle with three horizontal lines across it: one at height one half cutting the circle twice, one at height one touching it at a single point, and one at height 1.4 passing above the circle without touching it at all.
Asking which numbers the sine can produce is asking which horizontal lines meet the unit circle. Inside the shaded band a line cuts the circle twice; at the very top or bottom it touches once; outside the band it misses entirely.
So a value strictly between minus one and one comes from infinitely many inputs, the values minus one and one come from one family each, and nothing outside the band comes from anything.
This picture turns an algebraic fact into a geometric one. Asking which values the sine can take is asking which horizontal lines meet the unit circle, because the sine is the height of a point on that circle.
Three cases, and only three. A line inside the shaded band cuts the circle in two points, so the equation has two families of solutions, one per crossing. A line at the very top or very bottom touches at a single point, so there is one family. A line outside the band misses entirely, so there are no solutions at all.
Keep this image when you meet an equation later in the course. Before solving anything, ask where the horizontal line sits. If it is outside the band, you can write no solution immediately and move on, and you will have spent no effort at all.
Worked example
Exactly the solution of the previous lesson with the variable renamed. Nothing about the method changes when the input is called a real number.
\[ \sin(t) = -\frac12 \]
Find the reference number
Why: One half is the sine of pi over six, so pi over six is the size of the arc measured from the horizontal axis.
\[ \sin\!\left(\frac{\pi}{6}\right) = \frac12 \]
Locate the right quadrants
Why: The sine is the second coordinate, and it is negative in quadrants three and four.
\[ \text{Quadrant III and Quadrant IV} \]
Write one solution in each quadrant
Why: Add the reference number to pi, and subtract it from two pi.
\[ t = \pi + \frac{\pi}{6} = \frac{7\pi}{6}, \qquad t = 2\pi - \frac{\pi}{6} = \frac{11\pi}{6} \]
Add every whole revolution
Why: Winding around again returns to the same point on the circle, so the same value comes back.
\[ t = \frac{7\pi}{6} + 2\pi k \quad\text{or}\quad t = \frac{11\pi}{6} + 2\pi k, \quad k \in \mathbb{Z} \]
Check one member of each family
Why: Take k equal to zero in the first, and k equal to minus one in the second, which gives the negative arc of pi over six.
\[ \sin\!\left(\frac{7\pi}{6}\right) = -\frac12, \qquad \sin\!\left(\frac{11\pi}{6} - 2\pi\right) = \sin\!\left(-\frac{\pi}{6}\right) = -\frac12 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 735 — the comments following Theorem 10.5; Exercise 43
The only thing new here is the name of the variable. The book is explicit about it: you solve this exactly as you solved the same equation for an angle in the previous lesson, because a real number and an angle in radians are the same object seen two ways.
The method is worth rehearsing anyway. The size of the value gives the reference number, pi over six. The sign of the value gives the quadrants, third and fourth, since the sine is the second coordinate. One solution in each quadrant comes from adding the reference number to pi and subtracting it from two pi.
Then every whole revolution is added, which is what the integer parameter does, and the two families are the complete answer. The check at the end tests one member of each family, and the second test also shows something useful: taking the parameter as minus one turns the second family into the negative arc of pi over six, which is the same list of numbers written differently.
Discrimination
Sort into buckets
Decide each one from the range alone, before attempting to solve anything.
Note the trap in the fourth item: minus two is outside the interval, so it does belong in the empty bucket. Check your own sort against that one.
Sort all six from the range alone, without solving anything. That is the skill: recognising in one glance that an equation is hopeless, or that it is worth the work.
Four of the six ask for values inside the interval from minus one to one, so each has infinitely many solutions. Two of them ask for something impossible: three is above the top of the range, and minus 1.001 is just below the bottom. Note how little the margin matters, since 1.001 is as impossible as a thousand.
The item most people get wrong is the sine equal to minus two. The minus sign makes it feel different from the cosine equal to three, but minus two is below minus one, so it is outside the interval from the other end and equally unsolvable. Check that one against your own sort.
Worked example
Some equations are settled without any trigonometry at all, purely by the range.
\[ \cos(t) = 3 \]
Compare the right-hand side with the range
Why: Theorem 10.5 says every output of the cosine lies in the closed interval from minus one to one.
\[ \text{ran}(\cos) = [-1, 1] \]
Test whether three is in that interval
Why: It is not; three is above the upper end.
\[ 3 > 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; 3 \notin [-1, 1] \]
State the conclusion
Why: No real number has cosine three, so the solution set is empty.
\[ \text{no solution} \]
Say what goes wrong geometrically
Why: The cosine is the first coordinate of a point on the unit circle. Forcing that coordinate to be three demands a negative square.
\[ x^2 + y^2 = 1, \; x = 3 \;\Longrightarrow\; 9 + y^2 = 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; y^2 = -8 \]
Check the companion exercise
Why: Exercise 45 asks for the sine equal to minus two, and the same argument disposes of it from the other end of the interval.
\[ \sin(t) = -2: \quad -2 < -1 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{no solution} \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 737 — Exercises 42 and 45
A four-line solution, and none of the lines involve any trigonometry. The whole argument is that the demanded value is not in the range, so no input can produce it.
Write the reason down rather than just the conclusion. On an exam, no solution on its own earns very little; no solution because the range of the cosine is the interval from minus one to one and 3 lies outside it earns the mark.
The geometric step is the one that makes it stick. The cosine is the first coordinate of a point on the unit circle, so demanding a cosine of three demands a point three units to the right of the origin on a circle of radius one. The algebra spits out a negative square, which is the arithmetic way of saying the same thing. The companion exercise with the sine equal to minus two fails at the other end for the same reason.
Trap
The cosine only ever produces numbers between minus one and one, so:
\[ \text{dom}(\cos) = [-1, 1] \]
Wrong. That is the range, written twice.
The input is an angle, or equally an arc length, and there is no largest angle. You may keep turning in either direction for as long as you like.
\[ \text{dom}(\cos) = (-\infty, \infty) \]
\[ \text{ran}(\cos) = [-1, 1] \]
The outputs are penned in because they are coordinates on a circle of radius one. The inputs are not penned in by anything at all, which is why expressions such as the cosine of one thousand are perfectly ordinary numbers.
This confusion comes from a real observation, which is why it is so easy to fall into. The cosine genuinely is trapped between minus one and one, so it feels as if something about it must be bounded. The error is attaching that bound to the wrong side of the function.
Separate the two by asking what each one is. The inputs are angles or arc lengths, and nothing stops you turning as far as you like in either direction, so the domain is every real number. The outputs are coordinates on a circle of radius one, and a coordinate cannot beat the radius, so the range is the closed interval from minus one to one.
A concrete test settles it. Is the cosine of one thousand a real number? Yes, entirely ordinary: one thousand radians is about 159 revolutions, and you land somewhere perfectly definite on the circle. If the domain were bounded, that expression would be meaningless, and it plainly is not.
Two truths and a lie
Sort into buckets
Sort the four claims. Exactly two are true.
Sort all four before revealing, and try to give yourself a one-line reason for each, not just a verdict.
The two true claims are the domain statement and Theorem 10.3 itself. Both are central facts of the lesson, and if either felt uncertain, go back to the slides that established them rather than memorising the verdict.
The two false ones are the lesson's two signature errors. Growing the circle multiplies the coordinate and the radius by the same factor, so the ratio does not move, which is the counterexample slide in one sentence. And the radius is a distance, so it is never negative; all the sign information in quadrant three sits in the two coordinates, where it belongs.
Comparison
Comparison matrix
| unit circle | circle of radius r | |
|---|---|---|
| equation of the circle | x² + y² = 1 | x² + y² = r² |
| the point at angle θ | (cos θ, sin θ) | (r cos θ, r sin θ) |
| the cosine, read off the point | x | x / r |
| distance from the origin | 1 | r |
| range of the first coordinate | −1 to 1 | −r to r |
Reading down the last column: the coordinates stretch, the ratios do not, and that single distinction is the whole lesson.
Fill every blank before checking. The middle column is the material of Lesson 10.2a, so this doubles as a test of whether that lesson is still solid.
Read the completed table down the last column and one pattern emerges. Every row that describes a length, the coordinates, the point, the distance, the reach of the first coordinate, picks up a factor of the radius. The one row that describes a ratio, the cosine read off the point, picks up a division by the radius instead, which is what stops it changing.
That contrast is the whole lesson compressed into a table. Lengths scale, ratios do not, and the cosine and the sine are ratios.
Section
Part 6
Pattern
Figure (svg): A decision diagram: from a box asking what you already know, four arrows lead to four relations, and all four feed into a final box of checks.
This is the triage diagram for every problem in the lesson. One question, what are you given, and each answer points at exactly one relation.
The four routes are genuinely different tasks, so it is worth being able to recognise them from a problem's first sentence. An angle and a radius means you want a position, so multiply. A point means you want the values, so divide by the distance. A rate and a time means the angle is not given at all and has to be built from the rate first. A triangle means the same division, with the sides renamed by their position.
The three checks at the end apply to all four routes. No value may exceed one in size, the signs must match the quadrant, and the two coordinates must satisfy the Pythagorean relation. Run them every time. They cost seconds and they catch almost every error this lesson can produce.
Check
Check your understanding
The terminal side of an angle contains the point with coordinates −8 and −6. What is the cosine of that angle?
Answer: A
Why: The distance to the origin is the square root of 64 plus 36, which is 10. The cosine is the first coordinate over that distance, so it is minus eight tenths, which is minus four fifths. The point is in quadrant three, where the cosine is negative, so the sign is right.
The point is in quadrant three, so before any arithmetic you should expect both values to come out negative. That expectation alone eliminates two of the four options.
The distance is 10, from the six, eight, ten triangle, so the cosine is minus eight tenths, which reduces to minus four fifths. The most tempting wrong option is the sine, minus three fifths, which is the right idea applied to the wrong coordinate: the first coordinate always makes the cosine.
The last option is upside down and is caught by the bound rather than by any calculation. A value of minus five quarters exceeds one in size, which no cosine can do.
Check
Check your understanding
An object moves on a circle of radius 3 about the origin at 5 radians per second, starting at the point 3 comma 0. Where is it after pi over ten seconds?
Answer: A
Why: The angle swept is the rate times the time, which is 5 times pi over ten, or pi over two. The cosine of pi over two is 0 and the sine is 1, and each is multiplied by the radius 3, giving the point 0 comma 3, a quarter turn counter-clockwise from the start.
Work out the angle first and the rest follows. Five radians per second for pi over ten seconds gives pi over two, a quarter of a revolution counter-clockwise from the start.
Then apply Equation 10.3 rather than stopping at the unit circle. The unit-circle point at a quarter turn is zero comma one, and both coordinates must be multiplied by the radius 3, which gives zero comma three. The option zero comma one is there precisely for anyone who forgets that multiplication.
The other two wrong options correspond to angles rather than to arithmetic slips: three comma zero is a whole number of revolutions and minus three comma zero is half a revolution. If you picked one of those, recheck the angle calculation rather than the substitution.
Check
Check your understanding
Which of these equations has no solution?
Answer: C
Why: Dividing by 5 turns the third equation into cosine of t equals 1.2, and 1.2 lies outside the interval from minus one to one, so no real number satisfies it. The other three all ask for values inside the range, so each has infinitely many solutions.
Three of these four are solvable, and the quickest route is to compare each demanded value with the interval from minus one to one.
The third option hides its demand behind a coefficient. Divide both sides by 5 and it asks for a cosine of 1.2, which is outside the range, so there is no solution. Whenever an equation has a number in front of the cosine or sine, isolate the function before judging solvability.
The two boundary cases are worth noticing. Both minus one for the cosine and minus one for the sine are attained, at pi and at three pi over two respectively, so both equations are solvable; they are the special case with one family of solutions rather than two, which is the middle line of the circle picture from earlier.
Explain it to yourself
Discussion prompt
In two or three sentences, explain to someone who has only seen the unit circle why the cosine of an angle can be computed from a point on a circle of radius 100 just as well as from a point on the unit circle. Use the word similar somewhere.
Write your sentences out before revealing. Being able to explain this is a much better test of understanding than being able to compute with it, because the computation can be done by pattern-matching and the explanation cannot.
A complete answer has two parts. First the geometry: both points lie on the same terminal side, so the right triangles dropped from them are similar, and similar triangles have proportional sides. Second the consequence: the first coordinate divided by the distance is therefore the same fraction in both triangles, even though the coordinate and the distance are each a hundred times bigger in one than in the other.
If you can add the one-line version, that the cosine is a ratio rather than a length and enlarging a picture cannot change a ratio inside it, you have the idea in a form you will still have next year.
Exit ticket
\[ \text{A wheel of radius } 20 \text{ cm turns at } 3 \text{ rad/s, starting at } (20, 0). \]
Discussion prompt
Write the equations of motion. Then find where the mark is after pi over six seconds. Then say whether the mark could ever be at the point 25 comma 0, and why.
Three parts, and they cover the three things the lesson asked you to be able to do: write the equations, evaluate them, and reason about what is possible.
For the second part, the angle comes out as pi over two, a quarter turn, so the mark is at the top of the wheel, at zero comma twenty. If you got a different point, check whether you multiplied both coordinates by the radius of 20.
The third part can be answered twice over, and it is worth giving both reasons. Physically, the mark is fixed to the rim, so it is always exactly 20 centimetres from the centre and can never be 25 away. Algebraically, the first coordinate is 20 times a cosine and a cosine never exceeds one, so that coordinate never exceeds 20. The second reason is the range of the cosine doing useful work, which is exactly what the last part of the lesson was for.
Recap
| what you have | what you write | what to check |
|---|---|---|
| angle and radius | x is r times the cosine, y is r times the sine | the point satisfies the circle's equation |
| a point on the terminal side | cosine is x over r, sine is y over r, with r the distance | signs match the quadrant, neither value exceeds 1 |
| radius and angular velocity | x is r cos of omega t, y is r sin of omega t | the angle is in radians, not degrees |
| a right triangle | adjacent over hypotenuse, opposite over hypotenuse | the three sides satisfy Pythagoras |
| cosine or sine of a real number | domain all reals, range minus one to one | a demanded value outside the range means no solution |
\[ \cos(\theta) = \frac{x}{\sqrt{x^2+y^2}}, \qquad \sin(\theta) = \frac{y}{\sqrt{x^2+y^2}} \]
Section 10.3 takes the same point and forms the other four quotients its coordinates allow, which gives the tangent, secant, cosecant and cotangent; every one of them will be defined from this same picture.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, pp. 730-736 — Theorems 10.3, 10.4 and 10.5 and Equation 10.3
OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §7.2 Right Triangle Trigonometry §7.2 — the right triangle ratios, reached from the triangle rather than from the circle
Four situations and one theorem underneath all of them. If you are given an angle and a radius, multiply; if you are given a point, divide by its distance from the origin; if you are given a rate, build the angle from it first; if you are given a right triangle, rename the sides and divide. Theorem 10.4 is not an extra result to memorise, it is Theorem 10.3 with the coordinates called adjacent and opposite.
The checks are worth as much as the methods. No value may exceed one in size, every sign must match the quadrant, and the coordinates must always satisfy the Pythagorean relation. Those three between them catch the negative radius, the swapped coordinates, the upside-down fraction and the degree-mode slip, which is nearly everything that goes wrong here.
Next, Section 10.3 keeps the same point on the same terminal side and forms the other four quotients its coordinates allow. The tangent is the second coordinate over the first, and the secant, cosecant and cotangent are the reciprocals of the three you will then have. Every one of them is defined from this same picture, so the work you have done here carries directly across.
Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Trigonometry — $55/session, free consultation.