The Reference Angle Theorem and what it buys: the acute angle a terminal side makes with the x-axis determines the size of both coordinates, and the quadrant supplies the two signs, so five memorised values generate all sixteen special points on the unit circle. Covers the four subtraction rules, the denominator shortcut in radian measure, angles built symmetrically from a given one, and the first trigonometric equations — where a single value produces two families of infinitely many solutions.
Subject: Trigonometry · 68 slides · symbolic lesson
Open the interactive version of this deck
Title
Trigonometry · Section 10.2b
Five memorised values, and the symmetry that turns them into sixteen
Objectives
Lesson 10.2a gave you the cosine and sine of three acute angles and of the four quadrantal angles. That is seven points on the unit circle, all in the first quadrant or on an axis. This lesson gets the rest of the circle for free, using nothing but the symmetry it already has.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, pp. 721-730 — the pages this lesson covers
In the last lesson you built seven points on the unit circle: the four where an axis crosses it, and three in the first quadrant that came out of the two special right triangles. That is a small stock of facts, and the circle has a lot more points on it than seven.
This lesson does not add any facts. It adds one observation: the circle is symmetric about both axes and about the origin, so every point you know is secretly three more points. Reflecting a known point into another quadrant changes the signs of its coordinates and nothing else. Follow that through and the seven facts become the whole sixteen-point circle that every later chapter assumes you have at your fingertips.
The last part of the lesson turns the question around. Instead of starting with an angle and finding a coordinate, you will start with a coordinate and find the angles, which is your first trigonometric equation. The surprise there is that the answer is never a single number.
Warm-up
Discussion prompt
Without looking anything up, write down the cosine and sine of each of these seven angles: zero, pi over six, pi over four, pi over three, pi over two, pi, and three pi over two. Then say which of the seven took no work at all.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 722 — the table of essential values
Write your seven rows before revealing the table. Doing it from memory now, rather than reading it, tells you which of the seven you actually have and which you are about to need.
If you hesitated on the three acute rows, go back to the special triangles for a minute: the forty-five degree triangle is isosceles, so its two legs are equal and both coordinates come out the same; the thirty-sixty triangle has its short leg exactly half the hypotenuse, which is where the one half comes from. Rebuilding them beats memorising them, because a rebuilt value cannot be half-remembered.
One more thing to notice about the table. The largest cosine and the largest sine are both one, and no entry is bigger. That is not a coincidence of the special angles, and by the end of the lesson it will be the reason a certain equation has no solutions at all.
Section
Part 1
Concept
Take the angle five pi over six. Its terminal side is in quadrant two, and nothing you have so far applies to it. But look at how far it sits from the horizontal.
Figure (svg): Two unit circles. On the left a ray at pi over six with its point root three over two comma one half. On the right the same point reflected across the y-axis to give the point for five pi over six, minus root three over two comma one half, with the reference angle pi over six marked against the negative x-axis.
\[ \frac{5\pi}{6} = \pi - \frac{\pi}{6} \]
The terminal side of five pi over six makes an angle of pi over six with the negative x-axis, exactly as the terminal side of pi over six makes with the positive one. Reflecting the known point across the vertical axis lands on it.
\[ \cos\left(\frac{5\pi}{6}\right) = -\frac{\sqrt3}{2}, \qquad \sin\left(\frac{5\pi}{6}\right) = \frac12 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 721 — the opening reflection argument
Look at the two pictures side by side before reading any formula. On the left the terminal side leans thirty degrees above the positive horizontal direction. On the right it leans thirty degrees above the negative horizontal direction. Those are mirror images in the vertical axis.
A mirror in the vertical axis sends a point to the point with the same height and the opposite horizontal position. So the height, which is the sine, is unchanged at one half, and the horizontal position, which is the cosine, flips from root three over two to its negative. You did not compute anything; you reflected.
The phrase to hold on to is the one the book uses next: the angle pi over six is the reference angle for five pi over six. It is the acute angle the terminal side makes with the horizontal axis, and it is the part of the picture that survives the reflection.
Concept
reference angle — For a non-quadrantal angle in standard position, the acute angle its terminal side makes with the x-axis. It is measured to the positive x-axis in quadrants one and four, and to the negative x-axis in quadrants two and three.
Figure (svg): Four small unit circles side by side, one per quadrant. In each the terminal side of an angle is drawn with a shaded wedge between it and the x-axis: to the positive x-axis in quadrants one and four, to the negative x-axis in quadrants two and three. Every wedge is acute.
Two things are worth stressing. The reference angle is measured to the x-axis and never to the y-axis, and it always comes out acute. If yours is obtuse, you measured to the wrong axis.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, pp. 721-722 — the definition of the reference angle
The definition has two halves, and the second half is the one that gets misremembered. First, the reference angle is acute, always. Second, it is measured to the x-axis, always, and never to whichever axis happens to be closer.
Work through the four small circles and check that in each one the shaded wedge runs from the terminal side to the nearer half of the horizontal axis. In quadrants one and four that is the positive half; in quadrants two and three it is the negative half. In all four the wedge is smaller than a quarter turn, which is what acute means.
There is one case the definition quietly excludes: a non-quadrantal angle. If the terminal side lies along an axis there is no acute wedge to measure, and none is needed, because you can read the point off the axis directly. Later in the lesson that exclusion will matter when you solve an equation whose answers are quadrantal.
Notation
Annotate
On: \( \cos(\theta) = \pm\cos(\alpha), \qquad \sin(\theta) = \pm\sin(\alpha) \)
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 722 — Theorem 10.2, the Reference Angle Theorem
Step through the four annotations and notice how little the theorem claims. It says the two coordinates of your angle are the two coordinates of an acute angle, possibly with signs changed. It does not say which signs, and it is not being coy: the reference angle genuinely does not carry that information, because four different angles, one in each quadrant, share it.
The third annotation is the one that saves marks. There are two plus-or-minus symbols and they are chosen separately. In quadrant two the first is a minus and the second is a plus; in quadrant four it is the other way round. A student who decides on one sign and stamps it on both coordinates will be right in quadrants one and three and wrong in quadrants two and four, which is a coin-flip dressed up as a method.
So treat the theorem as half of a two-step procedure. Step one, the size, comes from the reference angle. Step two, the signs, comes from the quadrant. Keeping the steps apart is the whole discipline of this lesson.
Intuition
The theorem looks like a computation rule, and it is not. Its proof is four pictures: the unit circle is symmetric about the x-axis, about the y-axis and about the origin, so the point for any angle is the mirror image of the point for its reference angle.
A mirror can flip a sign, but it cannot change a distance. That is the whole content: reflecting moves a point to a new quadrant while leaving its distance from each axis untouched.
So the two coordinates of any special angle are the two coordinates of an acute angle, wearing signs. Nothing is recomputed and nothing new is memorised.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, pp. 721-722 — the symmetry argument preceding Theorem 10.2
It is worth being clear about what kind of statement the Reference Angle Theorem is, because it looks like a calculation rule and it is really a geometric one. Its proof is not algebra. Its proof is that the unit circle has three symmetries, and each of them carries a first-quadrant point to a point in another quadrant while preserving both distances from the axes.
That is why the theorem is stated with plus-or-minus and no further detail. A reflection can only ever flip signs. It cannot make a coordinate bigger or smaller, so the sizes are forced to be the reference angle's sizes.
If you find yourself trying to remember the theorem, draw the circle and one reflection instead. Thirty seconds of drawing reconstructs the whole statement, and you will never draw a reflection that changes a length.
Concept
Each quadrant needs its own subtraction, because the wedge is measured to a different half of the x-axis. All four answer the same question, so there is no need to memorise them as separate facts.
| quadrant of θ | reference angle α | measured to | in degrees |
|---|---|---|---|
| I | α = θ | the positive x-axis | α = θ |
| II | α = π − θ | the negative x-axis | α = 180° − θ |
| III | α = θ − π | the negative x-axis | α = θ − 180° |
| IV | α = 2π − θ | the positive x-axis | α = 360° − θ |
Every row subtracts the angle from, or takes it away from, the nearest horizontal direction. Reading the second column as four formulas to recall is exactly the habit this lesson is trying to replace.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, pp. 721-722 — the four cases of the definition
Four rules look like four things to memorise, and they are not. Cover the middle column and ask the question the column answers: how far is this terminal side from the horizontal? In quadrant two you have gone past the horizontal, so you subtract your angle from half a turn. In quadrant three you have gone past it the other way, so you subtract half a turn from your angle. Both are the same question with the subtraction written the way round that gives a positive answer.
There is a useful self-check built into the table. If your answer comes out negative, or bigger than a quarter turn, you used the wrong row. A reference angle that is not acute is a signal, not a nuisance.
The degree column is there so you can work in either measure. Nothing conceptual changes: half a turn is one hundred eighty degrees and a full turn is three hundred sixty, and the four rules read the same.
Worked example
Find the cosine and the sine of two hundred twenty-five degrees.
\[ \theta = 225^{\circ} \]
Place the terminal side
Why: One hundred eighty degrees lands on the negative x-axis, and the angle overshoots it, so the terminal side is in quadrant three.
\[ 180^{\circ} < 225^{\circ} < 270^{\circ} \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{quadrant III} \]
Subtract to reach the negative x-axis
Why: Quadrant three measures the wedge back to the negative x-axis.
\[ \alpha = 225^{\circ} - 180^{\circ} = 45^{\circ} \]
Take both sizes from the table
Why: At forty-five degrees the two coordinates are equal.
\[ \cos(45^{\circ}) = \frac{\sqrt2}{2}, \qquad \sin(45^{\circ}) = \frac{\sqrt2}{2} \]
Figure (svg): A unit circle with the terminal side of 225 degrees in quadrant three, the sweep from the positive x-axis marked, a 45 degree wedge between the terminal side and the negative x-axis, and the point minus root two over two comma minus root two over two with dashed drop lines to both axes.
Attach the quadrant three signs
Why: The point is left of centre and below it, so both coordinates are negative.
\[ \cos(225^{\circ}) = -\frac{\sqrt2}{2}, \qquad \sin(225^{\circ}) = -\frac{\sqrt2}{2} \]
Check with the Pythagorean identity
Why: A legitimate pair of coordinates must land on the circle, and one half plus one half is one.
\[ \left(-\frac{\sqrt2}{2}\right)^2 + \left(-\frac{\sqrt2}{2}\right)^2 = \frac12 + \frac12 = 1 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, pp. 722-723 — Example 10.2.3, part 1
This is the model solution for the whole lesson, so watch the order of the steps rather than the arithmetic. Place the angle first. Find the reference angle second. Look up the two sizes third. Attach the signs last, and only then write anything down as an answer.
Two hundred twenty-five degrees is a pleasant case because it is diagonal: the reference angle is forty-five degrees, so the two coordinates have the same size and you only have to think about signs. Quadrant three is left of centre and below it, so both are negative.
Notice the check at the end. It is not decoration. Squaring both coordinates and adding must give one, because every point you produce is supposed to be on the unit circle. That one line catches a surprising number of slips, including the most common one of all, using root three over two where root two over two belongs.
Trap
For five pi over six, the nearest axis is the vertical one, and the wedge to it is small:
\[ \frac{5\pi}{6} \text{ to } \frac{\pi}{2}: \; \frac{5\pi}{6} - \frac{\pi}{2} = \frac{\pi}{3} \]
\[ \cos\left(\frac{5\pi}{6}\right) = -\cos\left(\frac{\pi}{3}\right) = -\frac12\,? \]
Wrong. The true value is minus root three over two.
The reference angle is measured to the x-axis, never to whichever axis happens to be closer. Measured correctly the wedge is pi over six, and the first coordinate has size root three over two.
\[ \alpha = \pi - \frac{5\pi}{6} = \frac{\pi}{6} \]
The two wrong answers, one half and root three over two, are the coordinates swapped. Measuring to the wrong axis reliably produces the other coordinate.
This error feels reasonable, which is why it is worth naming. Five pi over six is much closer to the vertical axis than to the horizontal one, and measuring to the nearer axis seems like the natural thing to do. The definition does not permit it.
The reason the definition insists on the horizontal axis is symmetry of a particular kind. Reflecting in the vertical axis preserves the height and flips the horizontal position, which is exactly the behaviour the theorem describes. Measuring to the vertical axis would give you the complement of the reference angle, and the complement swaps the roles of the two coordinates.
That is why the wrong answer here is one half rather than nonsense. It is not a random error; it is the other coordinate. If you ever find that your cosine and sine have been swapped, check which axis you measured to first.
Matching
Match the pairs
Why: 180 minus 150 is 30, in quadrant two. 210 minus 180 is 30, in quadrant three. 360 minus 315 is 45, in quadrant four. And a clockwise turn of 60 degrees also stops in quadrant four, where the wedge to the positive x-axis is 60 degrees. Two angles can share a reference angle and still have different coordinates, which is exactly why the quadrant is named in every answer here.
Make all four matches before checking. The reference angles here are only thirty, forty-five and sixty degrees, so the real work is deciding the quadrant.
Look at what each right-hand option carries: an angle and a quadrant. That pairing is deliberate. Two of the four angles have the same reference angle of thirty degrees but land in different quadrants, so they have the same pair of sizes and different signs. A reference angle on its own never identifies a point.
The negative angle is the one worth pausing on. Turning sixty degrees clockwise ends in quadrant four, and the wedge to the positive horizontal direction is sixty degrees. The angle is negative; the wedge is not. Reference angles are always positive and always acute.
Step zero
\[ \theta = \frac{11\pi}{6} \]
Discussion prompt
Do not compute anything yet. Decide which quadrant this terminal side lands in, and say which of the four subtractions you are therefore going to use. Name the landmark angle you compared it with.
Write your answer down before revealing this one. The instinct is to start subtracting immediately, and the point of the slide is to slow that instinct by about twenty seconds.
The move that makes the comparison instant is rewriting the landmarks with the same denominator. A quarter turn is three pi over six, half a turn is six pi over six, three quarters is nine pi over six, and a full turn is twelve pi over six. Against that ruler, eleven pi over six is obviously in the last quarter of the circle.
This habit pays off for the rest of the chapter. Almost every wrong reference angle you will produce comes from a correctly performed subtraction applied in the wrong quadrant, and deciding the quadrant first makes that mistake almost impossible.
Worked example
Find the cosine and the sine of eleven pi over six.
\[ \theta = \frac{11\pi}{6} \]
Locate the terminal side
Why: Eleven pi over six is just short of two pi, so it lies in quadrant four.
\[ \frac{9\pi}{6} < \frac{11\pi}{6} < \frac{12\pi}{6} \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{quadrant IV} \]
Take the angle away from a full turn
Why: Quadrant four measures the wedge forward to the positive x-axis.
\[ \alpha = 2\pi - \frac{11\pi}{6} = \frac{12\pi}{6} - \frac{11\pi}{6} = \frac{\pi}{6} \]
Read the two sizes at pi over six
Why: From the memorised table.
\[ \cos\left(\frac{\pi}{6}\right) = \frac{\sqrt3}{2}, \qquad \sin\left(\frac{\pi}{6}\right) = \frac12 \]
Figure (svg): A unit circle with the terminal side of eleven pi over six just below the positive x-axis in quadrant four, the small wedge of pi over six between the terminal side and the positive x-axis, and the point root three over two comma minus one half.
Attach the quadrant four signs
Why: Right of centre and below it: the first coordinate positive, the second negative.
\[ \cos\left(\frac{11\pi}{6}\right) = \frac{\sqrt3}{2}, \qquad \sin\left(\frac{11\pi}{6}\right) = -\frac12 \]
Check the sizes against the picture
Why: Root three over two is about zero point eight seven and one half is zero point five, so the point is far right and only slightly down, which is exactly where the terminal side stops.
\[ \frac{\sqrt3}{2} \approx 0.87, \qquad -\frac12 = -0.5 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 723 — Example 10.2.3, part 2
Here the two sizes are different, so the signs have real work to do. The reference angle is pi over six, whose cosine is the large value and whose sine is the small one, and quadrant four makes the cosine positive and the sine negative.
Use the picture as a sanity check rather than as a source. The terminal side stops just short of the positive horizontal direction, so the point must be far to the right and only slightly below the axis. A large positive first coordinate and a small negative second one is exactly that. If your answer had been one half for the cosine you would see immediately that the point was too close to the vertical axis.
The final check compares the exact values with their decimals for the same reason. Getting into the habit of translating root three over two into about zero point eight seven costs nothing and makes every answer visually checkable.
Concept
Neither the four subtractions nor the table says anything about a negative angle or an angle past a full turn. Nothing has to be added to handle them: add or subtract whole revolutions until the angle lands between zero and one full turn, then proceed as usual.
\[ \theta \text{ and } \theta + 2\pi k \text{ are coterminal for every integer } k \]
Figure (svg): The reference angle plotted against the angle, from minus two pi to four pi. The graph is a triangular wave that rises to pi over two and falls back to zero every pi radians, touching zero at every multiple of pi.
The graph plots the reference angle against the angle. It repeats every half turn and drops to zero at every multiple of pi, which is precisely where there is no reference angle to find.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 723 — the reductions in Example 10.2.3, parts 3 and 4
Nothing new is needed for a negative angle or an angle bigger than a full turn, and that is the point of this slide. Whole revolutions do not move the terminal side, so they cannot change either coordinate. Add or subtract as many as you like until the angle is somewhere comfortable.
The graph makes the point twice over. It plots the reference angle against the angle, and it repeats itself every half turn, so two angles a whole number of turns apart sit at the same height: they have the same reference angle, as the three marked points show. It also drops to zero at every multiple of pi, and zero is not an acute angle, which is the graph's way of saying that quadrantal angles have no reference angle.
One caution. Reducing by whole turns changes the angle you are working with but not the answer. If a question asks for the angle itself, rather than its cosine and sine, you must remember which reduction you performed.
Worked example
Find the cosine and the sine of minus five pi over four.
\[ \theta = -\frac{5\pi}{4} \]
Turn clockwise and see where you stop
Why: A negative angle sweeps clockwise. Five pi over four is five eighths of a turn, which passes the negative y-axis and stops in quadrant two.
\[ -\frac{5\pi}{4}: \quad -\pi > -\frac{5\pi}{4} > -\frac{3\pi}{2} \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{quadrant II} \]
Measure the wedge to the negative x-axis
Why: The book takes it directly from the clockwise picture: after half a turn clockwise there is a quarter of a pi left over.
\[ \alpha = \frac{5\pi}{4} - \pi = \frac{\pi}{4} \]
Figure (svg): A unit circle with a clockwise sweep of five pi over four from the positive x-axis, ending in quadrant two, and the wedge of pi over four between that terminal side and the negative x-axis. The point is minus root two over two comma root two over two.
Read the two sizes at pi over four
Why: Both coordinates are equal at the diagonal.
\[ \cos\left(\frac{\pi}{4}\right) = \frac{\sqrt2}{2}, \qquad \sin\left(\frac{\pi}{4}\right) = \frac{\sqrt2}{2} \]
Attach the quadrant two signs
Why: Left of centre and above it: the first coordinate negative, the second positive.
\[ \cos\left(-\frac{5\pi}{4}\right) = -\frac{\sqrt2}{2}, \qquad \sin\left(-\frac{5\pi}{4}\right) = \frac{\sqrt2}{2} \]
Check by adding a whole turn instead
Why: Adding two pi gives three pi over four, a quadrant two angle with the same reference angle and the same point, so the two routes agree.
\[ -\frac{5\pi}{4} + 2\pi = \frac{3\pi}{4}, \quad \alpha = \pi - \frac{3\pi}{4} = \frac{\pi}{4} \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 723 — Example 10.2.3, part 3
A negative angle unsettles people more than it should. All it means is that the sweep runs clockwise. Where the sweep stops is the only thing either coordinate depends on.
Follow the clockwise arc in the picture: past the negative vertical direction at a quarter turn, past the negative horizontal at a half turn, and stopping an eighth of a turn beyond that, which puts the terminal side up and to the left. Quadrant two. The wedge to the negative horizontal axis is pi over four.
The check at the end is the one to copy. Rather than trusting the clockwise reasoning, add a whole turn to get three pi over four, a familiar quadrant two angle, and run the standard rule on that instead. Two independent routes to the same point is how you build confidence with negative angles, and after a dozen of them you will not need the second route.
Worked example
Find the cosine and the sine of seven pi over three.
\[ \theta = \frac{7\pi}{3} \]
Compare the angle with one full revolution
Why: Write a full turn with the same denominator.
\[ 2\pi = \frac{6\pi}{3} < \frac{7\pi}{3} \]
Remove one revolution
Why: A whole turn returns the terminal side to where it started, so it changes neither coordinate.
\[ \frac{7\pi}{3} - \frac{6\pi}{3} = \frac{\pi}{3} \]
Recognise what is left
Why: Pi over three is acute, so it is in quadrant one and is its own reference angle.
\[ \alpha = \frac{\pi}{3}, \qquad \text{quadrant I} \]
Figure (svg): A unit circle with a dashed complete revolution drawn inside it and then a solid extra wedge of pi over three, so the terminal side of seven pi over three lies in quadrant one on top of the terminal side of pi over three. The point is one half comma root three over two.
Read the values with quadrant one signs
Why: Both coordinates are positive in quadrant one, so nothing changes sign.
\[ \cos\left(\frac{7\pi}{3}\right) = \frac12, \qquad \sin\left(\frac{7\pi}{3}\right) = \frac{\sqrt3}{2} \]
Check that coterminal angles must agree
Why: Seven pi over three and pi over three differ by exactly one turn, so they share a terminal side and therefore share a point. Quoting the pi over three values is forced, not merely convenient.
\[ \frac{7\pi}{3} - \frac{\pi}{3} = 2\pi \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{same point} \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 723 — Example 10.2.3, part 4
The first move is the only one that is specific to this example: compare the angle with a full turn, written with the same denominator so the comparison is immediate. Six pi over three is one revolution, and you have seven, so there is one turn to peel off.
What is left is pi over three, which is acute, so it is in quadrant one and it is its own reference angle. Quadrant one changes no signs, so the answer is simply the memorised pair.
Read the final check carefully, because it explains why the peeling was legitimate rather than merely convenient. Two angles differing by a whole turn have literally the same terminal side, so they meet the circle at literally the same point, so they have literally the same cosine and sine. Nothing is being approximated or discarded.
Sorting
Sort into buckets
Reduce into one revolution where you need to, then sort each angle by the quadrant its terminal side lands in.
Sort all six before checking. Two of them need reducing first, and one needs a clockwise sweep, so the sorting is really six small decisions rather than one.
Use the denominator ruler again. With denominator six, the landmarks are three, six, nine and twelve; with denominator four they are two, four, six and eight; with denominator three they are one and a half, three, four and a half and six. Once you know the landmarks, placing an angle is instant.
Notice that no bucket here is empty and quadrants one and three each take two angles, from quite different starting points. Two angles in the same quadrant share their pair of signs but need not share their sizes, which is the distinction the next part of the lesson turns into a procedure.
Section
Part 2
Concept
The Reference Angle Theorem hands you two sizes and two unresolved signs. Resolving them is not a harder version of the same question; it is a different question with a different source of information.
Figure (svg): A unit circle with one sample point drawn in each quadrant and dashed drop lines to the axes, labelled with the sign of each coordinate: right and up in quadrant one, left and up in quadrant two, left and down in quadrant three, right and down in quadrant four.
The first coordinate is negative exactly when the point is left of the vertical axis, and the second is negative exactly when the point is below the horizontal one. There is a well-known mnemonic for this, and it is worth resisting: picturing the point is faster and it cannot be misremembered.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 722 — the sign discussion following Theorem 10.2
This slide is the second half of the method, and the sentence to take from it is that the second half is not harder than the first. It is just different. The size of each coordinate comes from a reference angle; the sign of each comes from a quadrant. Two questions, two sources.
Read the four labels off the picture rather than memorising them. A point in quadrant two is to the left of the vertical axis, so its horizontal position is negative and its cosine is negative. It is above the horizontal axis, so its height is positive and its sine is positive. That is the entire derivation, and it works in whichever quadrant you happen to be in.
You may have met a mnemonic for this, some phrase whose initials record which functions are positive where. Resist it. A mnemonic can be misremembered and gives no warning when it has been; a picture of a point either is or is not left of centre.
Intuition
Run along the quadrants in order and watch each column. The first coordinate is positive, negative, negative, positive: the two negatives are the two left-hand quadrants, sitting next to each other.
The second coordinate is positive, positive, negative, negative: its two negatives are the two lower quadrants, also next to each other. Each sign changes exactly twice around the circle, which is the same as saying each coordinate crosses zero twice per revolution.
Keep that in mind for Lesson 10.5a. Two sign changes per revolution is what makes the graphs of cosine and sine cross the horizontal axis twice per period.
Run your eye down each column and notice that the pattern is not random. The cosine column reads positive, negative, negative, positive, and the two negatives are adjacent because the two left-hand quadrants are adjacent. The sine column reads positive, positive, negative, negative, for the same reason about the two lower quadrants.
Each column therefore changes sign exactly twice per revolution. Say that in terms of the coordinates and it means each coordinate passes through zero twice per revolution: the cosine as the point crosses the vertical axis, the sine as it crosses the horizontal one.
Hold on to that count. When you meet the graphs of cosine and sine in Lesson 10.5a, each of them will cross the horizontal axis twice per period, and this is why. The graphs are not new information about cosine and sine; they are this circle unrolled.
Comparison
Comparison matrix
| quadrant | cos θ | sin θ |
|---|---|---|
| I | positive | positive |
| II | negative | positive |
| III | negative | negative |
| IV | positive | negative |
Fill each blank by picturing a point in that quadrant and asking whether it is left of centre and whether it is below centre. If you filled them from a memorised phrase instead, do it again from the picture and check that the two agree.
Fill in the four blanks before revealing, and then do something slightly unusual: fill them in a second time from the picture, and check that the two attempts agree. If you filled them from a remembered phrase the first time, this is where you find out whether the phrase is intact.
The blank that catches people is the quadrant four row, because it is the only row in the table where the cosine is positive and the sine is negative. Quadrant two is its mirror image, with the signs the other way round. Those two rows are where a single carelessly copied sign does real damage.
When the table is complete, read it once as geometry rather than as a table. The cosine is negative in the left half of the plane; the sine is negative in the bottom half. Two half-planes, four intersections, four rows.
Error analysis
Annotate
On: \( \cos\left(\frac{3\pi}{4}\right) = -\frac{\sqrt2}{2}, \qquad \sin\left(\frac{3\pi}{4}\right) = -\frac{\sqrt2}{2} \)
\[ \sin\left(\frac{3\pi}{4}\right) = +\frac{\sqrt2}{2} \]
Read the two lines and look for the error before revealing the annotations. Everything about the sizes is right, so the mistake is not in the reference angle or in the table.
The error is that one sign decision was made and then used twice. Three pi over four is in quadrant two, where the point is left of centre and above it, so the first coordinate is negative and the second is positive. The writer decided on negative and applied it to both.
This is the single most common error in the lesson, and it is invisible in half of all cases: in quadrants one and three both signs really are the same, so the bad habit passes unnoticed until it meets quadrant two or four. The defence is the discipline from a few slides ago: ask left-or-right, then ask up-or-down, as two separate questions.
Concept
Count what is actually stored. Three acute pairs, from the two special triangles, and four points on the axes. Everything else is one of those seven reflected into another quadrant.
\[ 3 \text{ acute pairs} \times 4 \text{ quadrants} + 4 \text{ axis points} = 16 \text{ points} \]
So the famous sixteen-point circle is not sixteen facts. It is seven facts and one idea.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 724 — the figure the authors say should be committed to memory
Before you look at the famous sixteen-point figure, count what you would actually have to store. Three pairs of numbers from the acute angles, and four points on the axes that need no storing at all because you read them off. That is the whole inventory.
The multiplication on the slide is the accounting. Each acute angle has a partner in each of the four quadrants, sharing its two sizes and differing in its signs, which is twelve points, and the four axis points bring it to sixteen.
Why insist on this? Because a student who has memorised sixteen points as sixteen facts has sixteen chances to misremember, and no way to check. A student who has three pairs and a symmetry has three chances to misremember, and a picture that catches every error. The second student is faster too, after about a week.
Picture it
Figure (svg): The unit circle with all sixteen special angles drawn as spokes. Each spoke carries the angle in radians inside the circle and the exact coordinates of its point outside, from one comma zero at the right round to root three over two comma minus one half.
Every spoke of this figure was generated by the last two parts of the lesson. The four highlighted spokes are the quadrantal ones; the twelve others come in threes, one per quadrant, sharing their sizes with the acute angle at the front of that trio.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 724 — Important Points on the Unit Circle
Spend a minute on this figure, and then spend a better minute drawing it yourself from scratch. The book says this one should be committed to memory, and the honest version of that instruction is that you should be able to regenerate it in under a minute, not that you should photograph it.
Here is how the regeneration goes. Draw the circle and the four axis points. Mark the three first-quadrant special angles and write their pairs. Then go round the other three quadrants, copying the sizes in the same order and changing the signs according to the quadrant. Everything you need is in the first quadrant and in the sign table.
Look at the highlighted spokes, the four along the axes. Those are the only points with a zero in them, and they are the reason a few later formulas have to treat quadrantal angles separately. Everything else on the circle has two nonzero coordinates.
Worked example
From the section's exercise set: find the exact cosine and sine of twenty-three pi over six.
\[ \theta = \frac{23\pi}{6} \]
Compare with one revolution
Why: A full turn is twelve pi over six, and the angle is nearly twice that.
\[ 2\pi = \frac{12\pi}{6} < \frac{23\pi}{6} < \frac{24\pi}{6} = 4\pi \]
Remove exactly one revolution
Why: One turn is enough to land inside the first revolution.
\[ \frac{23\pi}{6} - \frac{12\pi}{6} = \frac{11\pi}{6} \]
Figure (svg): A unit circle with a spiral sweeping counter-clockwise from the positive x-axis through one complete revolution and on to eleven pi over six, where the spiral meets the terminal side in quadrant four. The point is root three over two comma minus one half.
Find the reference angle
Why: Eleven pi over six is a quadrant four angle, so take it away from a full turn.
\[ \alpha = \frac{12\pi}{6} - \frac{11\pi}{6} = \frac{\pi}{6} \]
Size from the reference angle, signs from quadrant four
Why: First coordinate positive, second negative.
\[ \cos\left(\frac{23\pi}{6}\right) = \frac{\sqrt3}{2}, \qquad \sin\left(\frac{23\pi}{6}\right) = -\frac12 \]
Check against the sixteen-point figure
Why: Eleven pi over six is one of the sixteen spokes, and its listed point is root three over two comma minus one half, which is what the reduction produced.
\[ \frac{23\pi}{6} \text{ and } \frac{11\pi}{6} \text{ share a point} \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 736 — Exercise 14
This one is from the section's own exercise set, and it is here because the reduction is slightly less obvious: twenty-three pi over six is more than one turn but less than two, so exactly one revolution comes off.
The spiral in the picture is a way of seeing the whole sweep at once. It records how far you turned, which is nearly two full revolutions, but only the direction it ends in has any effect on the coordinates. That is the point of drawing it: the long journey and the short one arrive at the same place.
The check is worth adopting as a general habit. Once you have reduced to one of the sixteen special angles, find that angle on the memorised figure and compare. If the figure and your calculation disagree, one of them is wrong and you have found out cheaply.
Fill the middle
This angle needs four whole turns added before it lands inside one revolution. Supply the reduced angle and then the first coordinate.
Fill in the blanks
-\frac\frac{5\pi}{6}-\frac{\sqrt3}{2} + 8\pi = ___, \qquad \cos\left(-\frac______\right) = ___
Why: Eight pi is forty-eight pi over six, and forty-eight minus forty-three is five, so the reduced angle is five pi over six. That is a quadrant two angle with reference angle pi over six, so the first coordinate has size root three over two and is negative.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 736 — Exercise 16
Fill both blanks before revealing. The first is arithmetic with whole turns; the second is the whole method compressed into one value.
For the first blank, work out how many turns you need. One turn is twelve pi over six, and you need enough to get past forty-three, so four turns, which is forty-eight pi over six. Forty-eight less forty-three leaves five pi over six.
For the second blank, five pi over six is where the lesson started: quadrant two, reference angle pi over six, so the first coordinate has size root three over two and is negative because the point is on the left. If you wrote the positive value, you found the size and stopped; go back and ask the left-or-right question explicitly.
Prediction
\[ \frac{7\pi}{6} \quad\text{and}\quad \frac{11\pi}{6}: \quad \alpha = \frac{\pi}{6} \text{ for both} \]
Predict first
Both of these have reference angle pi over six. What must be true of their cosines and their sines?
Correct: Each coordinate agrees in size, but either one may differ in sign
Why: The reference angle fixes both sizes, so root three over two and one half appear in both answers. The quadrants differ, so the signs may differ: here the first coordinates are opposite in sign, minus root three over two against root three over two, while the second coordinates happen to agree, both minus one half. Neither sign is forced to differ, and neither is forced to agree.
Commit to one option before revealing. The wrong options here are all things that are true of some pairs of angles, which is what makes them tempting.
The correct statement is deliberately cautious: the sizes must agree, and either sign may or may not differ. For these two particular angles the cosines are opposites and the sines happen to be equal, both negative one half, because quadrants three and four are on the same side of the horizontal axis. A different pair of quadrants would give a different pattern.
If you chose the option saying both values are opposite, you were thinking of a pair of angles related by a half turn, which does flip both. Sharing a reference angle is a weaker relationship than that, and it constrains the sizes only.
Trap
The angle is negative, so the answers are negative:
\[ \theta = -\frac{\pi}{6} \]
\[ \cos\left(-\frac{\pi}{6}\right) = -\frac{\sqrt3}{2}\,? \]
Wrong. That cosine is positive.
The sign of the angle says which way you turned. The sign of a coordinate says which side of centre the point ended up on. A clockwise eighth-turn stops in quadrant four, to the right of centre, so the first coordinate is positive.
\[ \cos\left(-\frac{\pi}{6}\right) = \frac{\sqrt3}{2} \]
\[ \sin\left(-\frac{\pi}{6}\right) = -\frac12 \]
Only the second coordinate is negative, and it is negative because the point is below the axis, not because the angle was.
The words negative angle and negative cosine use the same adjective for two unrelated things, and that is the whole source of this mistake. A negative angle describes the direction you turned. A negative cosine describes where the point ended up.
Test the confusion on the example. Turning clockwise by pi over six is a small clockwise nudge, and it leaves the terminal side almost along the positive horizontal direction, only just below it. The point is therefore far to the right, so the cosine is a large positive number, and only slightly down, so the sine is a small negative one.
A useful reflex: whenever a minus sign appears in the angle, deal with it by finding the terminal side, and then forget it entirely. From that moment the quadrant is the only thing that speaks about signs.
Section
Part 3
Intuition
Write a special angle as a reduced fraction times pi. Then the denominator names the reference angle outright, with no subtraction at all.
Figure (svg): Three unit circles. The first carries the four angles whose reduced form has denominator six, all making a pi over six wedge with the x-axis. The second carries the four with denominator four, all making pi over four. The third carries the four with denominator three, all making pi over three.
| reduced denominator | reference angle | the four angles |
|---|---|---|
| 6 | π/6 | π/6, 5π/6, 7π/6, 11π/6 |
| 4 | π/4 | π/4, 3π/4, 5π/4, 7π/4 |
| 3 | π/3 | π/3, 2π/3, 4π/3, 5π/3 |
The numerator still has a job: it decides the quadrant, and therefore the two signs. The denominator has already decided both sizes.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 724 — the remark on radian measure and reference angles
This is the one genuinely convenient thing about radian measure, and the book says so in a slightly grudging footnote. If a special angle is written as a reduced fraction times pi, the denominator names the reference angle: six means pi over six, four means pi over four, three means pi over three.
Look at the three circles to see why. The angles with denominator six are pi over six, five pi over six, seven pi over six and eleven pi over six, one in each quadrant, and every one of them makes the same acute wedge with the horizontal axis. The numerators are what spread them around the circle.
The word reduced is doing real work. Four pi over six is not a denominator-six angle, because it reduces to two pi over three, and its reference angle is pi over three. Always reduce the fraction before reading anything off it.
Worked example
Find the exact cosine and sine of ten pi over three, using the shortcut rather than the four rules.
\[ \theta = \frac{10\pi}{3} \]
Reduce by one revolution
Why: A full turn is six pi over three.
\[ \frac{10\pi}{3} - \frac{6\pi}{3} = \frac{4\pi}{3} \]
Read the reference angle off the denominator
Why: Four thirds is already in lowest terms, and the denominator is three.
\[ \alpha = \frac{\pi}{3} \]
Find the quadrant from the numerator
Why: Four thirds of pi is past pi and short of three pi over two.
\[ \pi = \frac{3\pi}{3} < \frac{4\pi}{3} < \frac{4.5\pi}{3} = \frac{3\pi}{2} \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{quadrant III} \]
Figure (svg): A unit circle with the terminal side of four pi over three in quadrant three, a dashed full revolution showing the turn removed from ten pi over three, and the wedge of pi over three against the negative x-axis. The point is minus one half comma minus root three over two.
Attach the quadrant three signs
Why: Both coordinates negative, with sizes taken at pi over three.
\[ \cos\left(\frac{10\pi}{3}\right) = -\frac12, \qquad \sin\left(\frac{10\pi}{3}\right) = -\frac{\sqrt3}{2} \]
Check against the four subtraction rules
Why: Quadrant three subtracts pi, and four pi over three minus three pi over three is pi over three: the shortcut and the rule agree.
\[ \alpha = \frac{4\pi}{3} - \pi = \frac{\pi}{3} \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 736 — Exercise 19
Watch how short this gets once the shortcut is available. Peel off one turn, read the reference angle off the denominator without any subtraction, decide the quadrant from the numerator, and attach the signs.
Deciding the quadrant is now the only thinking step, so make the comparison efficient: with denominator three, half a turn is three pi over three and three quarters of a turn is four and a half pi over three, so four pi over three sits between them, in quadrant three.
The final step checks the shortcut against the rule it replaced, and that is worth doing the first few times you use any shortcut. Quadrant three subtracts half a turn, four pi over three less three pi over three is pi over three, and the two methods agree. Once you have seen them agree three or four times, use the shortcut and stop checking.
Discrimination
Sort into buckets
Sort each angle by whether the shortcut applies: is its reference angle one of pi over six, pi over four and pi over three?
Sort all six before checking. The only test you need is the reduced denominator: six, four and three are the special ones, and nothing else is.
The half of the sort that teaches something is the not-special half. Two pi over five is a perfectly respectable angle, its terminal side meets the circle at a perfectly respectable point, and that point has a perfectly respectable cosine and sine. What it does not have is an expression in terms of the square roots in your table, so a decimal from a calculator is the only form available.
Thirteen pi over six is the trap in the special half, because its denominator is six but it is bigger than a full turn. Reduce first, always, and then read the denominator.
Worked example
Find the exact cosine and sine of one hundred seventeen pi. The denominator shortcut does not apply, because this is a whole multiple of pi.
\[ \theta = 117\pi \]
Remove as many whole turns as possible
Why: Each revolution is two pi, so remove fifty-eight of them.
\[ 117\pi - 58(2\pi) = 117\pi - 116\pi = \pi \]
Identify what is left
Why: Pi is a quadrantal angle, so there is no reference angle and nothing to subtract.
\[ \theta \text{ is coterminal with } \pi \]
Figure (svg): A number line of the multiples of pi from zero to six pi. Above each even multiple sits the point one comma zero and below each odd multiple sits the point minus one comma zero, so the two alternate along the line.
Read the point straight off the axis
Why: The terminal side of pi is the negative half of the horizontal axis, where it meets the circle at minus one comma zero.
\[ \cos(117\pi) = -1, \qquad \sin(117\pi) = 0 \]
Check with the parity of the multiplier
Why: An even multiple of pi is a whole number of turns and lands at one comma zero; an odd multiple lands at minus one comma zero. One hundred seventeen is odd.
\[ 117 = 2(58) + 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{odd multiple} \;\Longrightarrow\; (-1, 0) \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 736 — Exercise 20
An angle like this looks designed to be tedious and is designed to be instant. The shortcut does not apply, because a whole multiple of pi is quadrantal and has no reference angle, and that is precisely what makes it easy.
You could divide one hundred seventeen by two and work with the remainder, and the picture shows the shortcut that results: every extra half turn flips the point between the two ends of the horizontal axis. Even multiples of pi land at the right-hand end; odd multiples land at the left-hand end. One hundred seventeen is odd.
Take the general lesson from this rather than the specific answer. Before hunting for a reference angle, always ask whether the terminal side is on an axis. If it is, there is no reference angle, no table lookup and no sign to choose: just a point with a zero in it.
Ranking
Put in order
Put these four cosines in order, smallest first. Do not compute decimals: use the reference angle for the size and the quadrant for the sign.
Why: Three of the four are in quadrant two, so they are negative, and among negatives the largest size is the smallest number: root three over two, then root two over two, then one half. That orders them as 5π/6, then 3π/4, then 2π/3. The last, 7π/4, is in quadrant four, so its cosine is positive and it is the largest of the four.
Sorting signed quantities by size is where sign errors surface. A bigger size makes a negative number smaller, and reversing that is the commonest slip on this kind of question.
Order all four before checking, and do it without decimals. The exercise is about coordinating two pieces of information, the size and the sign, not about arithmetic.
Start with the signs, because they split the list. Three of these angles are in quadrant two, where the cosine is negative, and one is in quadrant four, where it is positive. So the quadrant four angle is the largest, whatever the sizes say.
Among the three negatives, the ordering reverses: the biggest size is the smallest number. Root three over two is the biggest size, so five pi over six has the smallest cosine, then root two over two, then one half. If you ordered the negatives by size instead of by value, that reversal is the thing to fix, and it will come up again whenever you compare negative quantities.
Section
Part 4
Concept
So far every angle arrived as a number. Often it arrives as a description instead: half a turn more than some acute angle, or a quarter turn more, or a full turn less. The angle itself is never named.
\[ \theta = \pi + \alpha, \quad \theta = 2\pi - \alpha, \quad \theta = 3\pi - \alpha, \quad \theta = \frac{\pi}{2} + \alpha \]
Nothing changes about the method. Plot the description as a sequence of rotations, see which quadrant you land in, and find the acute wedge to the horizontal axis. What changes is that the answer comes out in terms of the cosine and sine of the given angle rather than as a surd.
Three of the four descriptions above have the given angle itself as their reference angle. One of them does not, and that one is the most instructive case in the section.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 725 — Example 10.2.4, the setup
Up to now every angle has arrived as a number you could locate on the circle. In this part the angle arrives as a recipe: half a turn more than some acute angle, a full turn less than it, a quarter turn more. The acute angle is never named as a number, and it never needs to be.
The method does not change at all. Plot the recipe as a sequence of rotations, see which quadrant you finish in, and find the acute wedge to the horizontal axis. What changes is only the form of the answer: instead of a surd you get the cosine and sine of the given angle, possibly with new signs.
Read the last sentence of the slide as a warning shot. Three of the four recipes have the given angle as their reference angle, and one does not. Spotting which one, and understanding why, is the real content of this part.
Worked example
Suppose the acute angle alpha has cosine five thirteenths. Find its sine and plot it in standard position.
\[ \cos(\alpha) = \frac{5}{13}, \quad \alpha \text{ acute} \]
Substitute into the Pythagorean identity
Why: The identity is the equation of the unit circle from Lesson 10.2a.
\[ \left(\frac{5}{13}\right)^2 + \sin^2(\alpha) = 1 \]
Isolate the square of the sine
Why: Twenty-five over one hundred sixty-nine taken from one.
\[ \sin^2(\alpha) = 1 - \frac{25}{169} = \frac{144}{169} \]
Take the square root, keeping both signs for now
Why: A square root leaves a choice of sign, and the algebra cannot resolve it.
\[ \sin(\alpha) = \pm\frac{12}{13} \]
Resolve the sign from the quadrant
Why: An acute angle is a quadrant one angle, where the second coordinate is positive.
\[ \sin(\alpha) = \frac{12}{13} \]
Figure (svg): A unit circle with an acute angle alpha whose terminal side passes through the point five thirteenths comma twelve thirteenths, drawn with its reference triangle: a horizontal leg of five thirteenths, a vertical leg of twelve thirteenths and a hypotenuse of one.
Check that the point lies on the circle
Why: Twenty-five plus one hundred forty-four is one hundred sixty-nine, so the point is exactly one unit from the origin.
\[ \frac{25}{169} + \frac{144}{169} = \frac{169}{169} = 1 \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 725 — Example 10.2.4, part 1
This is the Lesson 10.2a skill, used once so that the rest of the example has something concrete to work with. The identity gives the size of the missing coordinate and the quadrant gives its sign, in that order.
Look closely at the step where the square root is taken. The algebra genuinely cannot decide the sign, and writing plus-or-minus there is not hedging, it is honest: both values satisfy the identity. What rules one of them out is external information, namely that an acute angle is in the first quadrant, where the height is positive.
By the way, five, twelve and thirteen is a Pythagorean triple, which is why this example comes out in whole-number fractions. The angle itself is about sixty-seven degrees, and it is worth noting that you never need that number. Everything that follows uses the point, not the angle.
Worked example
Find the cosine and sine of half a turn more than alpha.
\[ \theta = \pi + \alpha \]
Plot it as two rotations
Why: Turn half a revolution, then alpha further. Half a turn lands on the negative x-axis, and alpha more takes you below it.
\[ \pi \text{ then } \alpha \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{quadrant III} \]
Figure (svg): Two unit circles. On the left a rotation of pi followed by a further rotation of alpha, ending in quadrant three. On the right the same terminal side with the wedge alpha drawn against the negative x-axis, showing that alpha is its reference angle, and the point minus five thirteenths comma minus twelve thirteenths.
Identify the reference angle
Why: The second rotation started from the negative x-axis, so the wedge back to that axis is exactly alpha.
\[ \alpha \text{ is the reference angle for } \theta \]
Write both sizes with the theorem
Why: The sizes are the cosine and sine of alpha, signs still open.
\[ \cos(\theta) = \pm\frac{5}{13}, \qquad \sin(\theta) = \pm\frac{12}{13} \]
Attach the quadrant three signs
Why: Both coordinates are negative there.
\[ \cos(\pi + \alpha) = -\frac{5}{13}, \qquad \sin(\pi + \alpha) = -\frac{12}{13} \]
Check with the diametrically opposite point
Why: Half a turn carries every point to the point directly opposite through the centre, and the opposite of a point is its negative in both coordinates, which is what came out.
\[ (x, y) \;\xrightarrow{+\pi}\; (-x, -y) \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, pp. 725-726 — Example 10.2.4, part 2a
Draw this one as two rotations before you write anything: half a turn, which lands on the negative horizontal axis, and then the acute angle beyond it, which drops you below that axis into quadrant three.
Because the second rotation started from the horizontal axis, what is left over between the terminal side and that axis is exactly the acute angle you turned. So the given angle is its own reference angle here, and the Reference Angle Theorem applies with no adjustment.
The check is the nicest part. Adding half a turn to any angle sends its point to the point directly opposite through the centre, and the opposite of a point has both coordinates negated. So for this recipe you could have written the answer down immediately, and the reference angle argument agreed with the geometry.
Worked example
Find the cosine and sine of a full turn less alpha.
\[ \theta = 2\pi - \alpha = 2\pi + (-\alpha) \]
Rewrite the subtraction as a rotation
Why: One complete counter-clockwise revolution, then back up by alpha.
\[ \text{one full turn, then } -\alpha \]
See where backing up lands you
Why: Backing up from the positive x-axis drops below it, into quadrant four.
\[ 2\pi - \alpha \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{quadrant IV} \]
Figure (svg): Two unit circles. On the left a complete counter-clockwise revolution followed by backing up alpha radians clockwise, landing in quadrant four. On the right the same terminal side with alpha as the wedge against the positive x-axis, and the point five thirteenths comma minus twelve thirteenths.
Identify the reference angle
Why: The wedge from the terminal side up to the positive x-axis is the amount you backed up, namely alpha.
\[ \alpha \text{ is the reference angle for } \theta \]
Attach the quadrant four signs
Why: First coordinate positive, second negative.
\[ \cos(2\pi - \alpha) = \frac{5}{13}, \qquad \sin(2\pi - \alpha) = -\frac{12}{13} \]
Check with the reflection in the x-axis
Why: Backing up alpha from a whole turn is the mirror image of turning alpha forward, and a mirror in the horizontal axis changes only the second coordinate, exactly as happened.
\[ (x, y) \;\xrightarrow{\text{mirror in } x} \; (x, -y) \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 726 — Example 10.2.4, part 2b
The rewriting in the first step is the move to copy: a subtraction becomes a rotation forward followed by a rotation backward. That turns a formula into something you can draw.
One full turn brings you back to the positive horizontal axis, and backing up the acute angle from there drops you just below it, into quadrant four. As in the previous part, the rotation you backed up is measured from the horizontal axis, so it is the reference angle.
The check names the underlying symmetry. Backing up an acute angle from a full turn is the same as reflecting the acute angle's point in the horizontal axis, and such a reflection changes only the height. One coordinate keeps its sign and one flips, which is what quadrant four says too. Two arguments, same answer.
Matching
Match the pairs
Why: With alpha acute, adding it to half a turn overshoots the negative x-axis downwards, giving quadrant three. Backing it off a full turn drops below the positive x-axis, giving quadrant four. Backing it off half a turn stays above the negative x-axis, giving quadrant two, and three pi points the same way as pi, so backing it off three pi lands in quadrant two as well.
Two of these descriptions land in the same quadrant, which is the point of listing them together: three pi and pi have the same terminal side, so anything built from them behaves identically.
Make all four matches before checking, and draw each recipe rather than trying to remember it. A quick sketch of two rotations takes five seconds and is never wrong.
The pair worth studying is the third and fourth. Half a turn less the acute angle and three halves of a turn less the acute angle both land in quadrant two, because three pi and pi have the same terminal side. Any recipe built on three pi behaves exactly as the same recipe built on pi.
That observation generalises. Only the reduced amount of turning matters, so when a recipe involves a large multiple of pi, reduce the multiple first and the recipe becomes one you have already seen.
Worked example
Find the cosine and sine of three pi less alpha.
\[ \theta = 3\pi - \alpha = 3\pi + (-\alpha) \]
Count the revolutions in three pi
Why: Three pi is one and a half turns, which finishes on the negative x-axis.
\[ 3\pi = 2\pi + \pi \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{same terminal side as } \pi \]
Back up alpha from there
Why: Backing up from the negative x-axis lifts the terminal side above it, into quadrant two.
\[ 3\pi - \alpha \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{quadrant II} \]
Figure (svg): Two unit circles. On the left one and a half revolutions, ending along the negative x-axis, followed by backing up alpha radians, which lands in quadrant two. On the right the same terminal side with alpha as the wedge against the negative x-axis and the point minus five thirteenths comma twelve thirteenths.
Identify the reference angle
Why: The wedge between the terminal side and the negative x-axis is the amount you backed up.
\[ \alpha \text{ is the reference angle for } \theta \]
Attach the quadrant two signs
Why: First coordinate negative, second positive.
\[ \cos(3\pi - \alpha) = -\frac{5}{13}, \qquad \sin(3\pi - \alpha) = \frac{12}{13} \]
Check against pi minus alpha
Why: Three pi minus alpha and pi minus alpha differ by exactly one revolution, so they must share a point, and both give the quadrant two answer.
\[ (3\pi - \alpha) - (\pi - \alpha) = 2\pi \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, pp. 726-727 — Example 10.2.4, part 2c
The only new thing here is counting the revolutions in three pi, and the safest way is to write it as a full turn plus a half turn. So three pi finishes on the negative horizontal axis, in the same direction as a plain half turn.
Backing up the acute angle from the negative horizontal axis lifts the terminal side above that axis, into quadrant two, and leaves the acute angle as the wedge to it. So again the given angle is the reference angle, and only the signs are new.
The check compares this recipe with the simpler one, half a turn less the acute angle. The two differ by exactly one revolution, so they must land on the same point. If you ever meet a recipe with a big multiple of pi, this is how to handle it: reduce the multiple and check that the two versions agree.
Concept
One construction in this example has a reference angle that is not alpha, and the Reference Angle Theorem cannot be used on it directly. What replaces the theorem is an older fact from geometry.
Figure (svg): A circle with two equal central angles drawn from different starting radii, each closed off by a straight chord. The two chords are drawn as dashed segments of visibly equal length, with tick marks showing the equality.
Equal central angles cut off chords of equal length, wherever on the circle they sit. So if a point is a certain rotation away from one comma zero, and a second point is the same rotation away from zero comma one, the two points sit at matching distances from their respective starting points.
That is enough to pin down the second point's coordinates without knowing the angle, and the next slide does exactly that.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 728 — the chord argument in Example 10.2.4, part 2d
This slide exists because the next one cannot use the Reference Angle Theorem, and something has to take its place. What takes its place is a fact from plane geometry that predates all of trigonometry.
The fact is in the picture: two central angles of the same size cut off chords of the same length, no matter where on the circle they sit. Nothing about position matters, only the opening of the wedge. You can check it with a compass, and it is the reason a circle can be divided into equal arcs at all.
Here is how the next slide will use it. If one point is a certain rotation away from the point at the right of the circle, and a second point is the same rotation away from the point at the top, then the two points are the same distance from their respective starting points. That is enough to identify the second point's coordinates without ever naming the angle.
Worked example
Find the cosine and sine of a quarter turn more than alpha. This is the case where the theorem does not apply.
\[ \theta = \frac{\pi}{2} + \alpha \]
Plot the two rotations
Why: A quarter turn to the positive y-axis, then alpha further, which lands in quadrant two.
\[ \frac{\pi}{2} \text{ then } \alpha \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{quadrant II} \]
Measure the wedge to the x-axis and compare it with alpha
Why: The second rotation started from the vertical axis, not a horizontal one, so what is left over to the negative x-axis is the rest of the quarter turn.
\[ \alpha_{\text{ref}} = \pi - \left(\frac{\pi}{2} + \alpha\right) = \frac{\pi}{2} - \alpha \ne \alpha \]
Figure (svg): Two unit circles. On the left a quarter turn followed by alpha, landing in quadrant two, with the wedge between that terminal side and the negative x-axis marked as pi over two minus alpha, not alpha. On the right the alpha point and the new point, with equal dashed chords from the vertical axis showing that the coordinates have swapped roles.
Use equal chords instead
Why: The point Q is alpha of a turn away from zero comma one, just as P is alpha of a turn away from one comma zero, so the two chords are equal and the coordinates trade places.
\[ P\left(\frac{5}{13}, \frac{12}{13}\right) \;\longrightarrow\; Q\left(-\frac{12}{13}, \frac{5}{13}\right) \]
Read off the two values
Why: Quadrant two, with the sizes swapped from alpha's.
\[ \cos\left(\frac{\pi}{2} + \alpha\right) = -\frac{12}{13}, \qquad \sin\left(\frac{\pi}{2} + \alpha\right) = \frac{5}{13} \]
Check with the identity and the quadrant
Why: The squares still add to one, and quadrant two demands a negative first coordinate and a positive second one, which is what these are.
\[ \frac{144}{169} + \frac{25}{169} = 1, \quad -\frac{12}{13} < 0 < \frac{5}{13} \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, pp. 727-728 — Example 10.2.4, part 2d
This is the most instructive part of the section, and the book asks you to pause before reading on. Do pause. Plot the two rotations, look at the acute wedge between the terminal side and the horizontal axis, and ask whether it is the angle you turned.
It is not. The second rotation started from the vertical axis, so the wedge left over to the horizontal axis is what remains of the quarter turn, namely the complement of your acute angle. The Reference Angle Theorem is perfectly true here, but its reference angle is that complement, and you do not know the complement's cosine and sine.
So the chord argument steps in. The new point is the same rotation away from the top of the circle as the original point is from the right of the circle, so the two points are related by the quarter turn that carries the horizontal axis onto the vertical one. Under that rotation the two coordinates swap roles, and the quadrant supplies the signs. Notice what the answer looks like: the twelve and the five have traded places, which no other recipe in this example did.
Notation
Annotate
On: \( \cos\left(\frac{\pi}{2} + \alpha\right) = -\sin(\alpha) \)
\[ \sin\left(\frac{\pi}{2} + \alpha\right) = \cos(\alpha) \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 728 — the result of Example 10.2.4, part 2d
Look at the left side and the right side of the line and notice what changed. On the left there is a cosine; on the right there is a sine. None of the other three recipes changed the function, and this one did.
The reason is in the second annotation. A quarter turn carries the horizontal axis onto the vertical one, so it carries first coordinates onto second coordinates. Anything that swaps the axes swaps the two functions, and the minus sign is then supplied by the quadrant in the usual way.
Do not memorise either line yet. In Lesson 10.4a you will prove a whole family of relations like these, called the cofunction identities, from the sum formulas, and they will cover every combination of a quarter turn with an angle. For now these two lines are a conclusion you drew from one picture, and drawing the picture again is always available to you.
Socratic
Discussion prompt
Half a turn, a full turn and three half-turns all leave alpha as the reference angle. A quarter turn does not. Explain what those three have in common that the quarter turn lacks, in one sentence, before reading on.
Write your sentence before revealing. The question has a one-line answer, and finding it yourself is worth much more than reading it.
The answer is about which axis the rotation finished on. Half a turn, a full turn and three half-turns all finish on the horizontal axis, and the reference angle is measured to the horizontal axis, so whatever acute amount you turn beyond them is already measured from the right line. A quarter turn finishes on the vertical axis, so the acute amount you turn beyond it is measured from the wrong line, and what remains to the horizontal axis is its complement.
This is a good example of a general habit: when one case in a list misbehaves, find the property the others share. Here the property is the axis, and once you see it you can predict the behaviour of any new recipe without computing anything. Three halves of a turn plus an acute angle, for instance, finishes on the horizontal axis, so it will behave like the well-behaved ones.
Fill the middle
Same alpha as before, with cosine five thirteenths and sine twelve thirteenths. A quarter turn less alpha is still acute, so it stays in quadrant one and no sign is negative.
Fill in the blanks
\cos\left(\frac\frac{12}{13}\frac{5}{13} - \alpha\right) = ___, \qquad \sin\left(\frac______ - \alpha\right) = ___
Why: A quarter turn less alpha is the complement of alpha, so its reference angle is that same complement and its terminal side is in quadrant one. Reflecting alpha's point in the diagonal line through the origin swaps the two coordinates and changes no sign, so the cosine is twelve thirteenths and the sine is five thirteenths.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 728 — the same chord argument, one quadrant earlier
Fill both blanks before revealing. This is the mirror image of the previous example: a quarter turn less the acute angle instead of a quarter turn more.
Because the acute angle is smaller than a quarter turn, the result is still acute and still in quadrant one, so both values are positive and no sign has to be chosen. All that happens is the swap: the horizontal position of the new point is the height of the old one and the other way round.
If you want to see the swap geometrically, reflect the original point in the diagonal line through the origin at forty-five degrees. That reflection exchanges the two coordinates and changes no sign, and the angles it relates are exactly an angle and its complement.
Comparison
Comparison matrix
| θ | quadrant | cos θ | sin θ |
|---|---|---|---|
| π + α | III | −5/13 | −12/13 |
| 2π − α | IV | 5/13 | −12/13 |
| 3π − α | II | −5/13 | 12/13 |
| π/2 + α | II | −12/13 | 5/13 |
Read down the last two columns. The first three rows use only the numbers five thirteenths and twelve thirteenths in their original roles. The last row has them swapped, and that swap is the whole difference the quarter turn makes.
Fill the blanks from the pictures you have already drawn, not by pattern-matching against the other rows. Each row is a different rotation and deserves its own thirty seconds.
When the table is complete, read the last two columns downwards. The first three rows use the two numbers in their original roles, five thirteenths for the cosine and twelve thirteenths for the sine, and differ only in signs. The last row has them swapped.
That is the summary of this whole part. A recipe that finishes on the horizontal axis changes signs only; a recipe that finishes on the vertical axis swaps the two coordinates as well. When you meet the sum and difference identities in Lesson 10.4a, these four rows are the special cases you should test them against.
Section
Part 5
Concept
Every question so far started with an angle and produced a coordinate. Turn that around: start with a coordinate and ask which angles produce it.
\[ \cos(\theta) = \frac12 \]
Figure (svg): A unit circle crossed by a vertical line at one half. The line meets the circle at two points, one in quadrant one at pi over three and one in quadrant four at five pi over three, each shown with its terminal side and a pi over three wedge against the positive x-axis.
Asking for the first coordinate to equal one half means asking where the terminal side meets the circle at a fixed horizontal position. That fixed position is a vertical line, and a vertical line strictly inside the circle cuts it in two places.
So the question has two answers before coterminal angles are even considered. Both crossings are the same distance from the horizontal axis, so both have the same reference angle.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 728 — Example 10.2.5, the setup
Every question so far has run in one direction: from an angle to a pair of coordinates. This part runs the other way, from a coordinate to the angles that produce it, and that is what a trigonometric equation is.
The geometry is simpler than the algebra makes it sound. Asking for a cosine of one half is asking for a point on the circle whose horizontal position is one half. Those points lie on a vertical line, and a vertical line that passes strictly inside the circle cuts it exactly twice.
So the answer has two parts before coterminal angles are even mentioned, and the picture says something else too: the two crossings are reflections of each other in the horizontal axis, so they have the same reference angle. That is why a single table lookup will serve for both.
Notation
Annotate
On: \( \theta = \frac{\pi}{3} + 2\pi k, \quad k \text{ an integer} \)
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 728 — coterminal solutions, and Section 10.1 for the coterminal criterion
This notation is new, so read all four annotations before using it. The first symbol is one solution, found in the usual way. The two pi times an integer is the machine that turns one solution into infinitely many.
The third annotation is easy to skip and matters. The integer may be negative, so this family runs backwards as well as forwards. That is why the same family can often be written with a different representative, which you will see happen in the next example.
The fourth annotation is the one that costs marks on tests. One family covers one of the two crossings. A complete answer to one of these equations has two families in it, unless something special has happened, and the lesson will show you the one case where something special does happen.
Worked example
Find every angle whose cosine is one half. With no context given, the book answers in radians.
\[ \cos(\theta) = \frac12 \]
Turn the equation into a position
Why: The cosine is the first coordinate, so the terminal side must meet the circle where that coordinate is one half.
\[ x = \frac12 \text{ on the unit circle} \]
Name the two quadrants
Why: A positive first coordinate puts the point on the right of the vertical axis, which is quadrant one or quadrant four.
\[ \text{QI or QIV} \]
Find the reference angle
Why: One half is the cosine of pi over three in the table.
\[ \cos\left(\frac{\pi}{3}\right) = \frac12 \;\Longrightarrow\; \alpha = \frac{\pi}{3} \]
Figure (svg): A unit circle with two sweeps drawn from the positive x-axis: a short counter-clockwise sweep of pi over three to the quadrant one crossing, and a long counter-clockwise sweep of five pi over three all the way round to the quadrant four crossing. Both terminal sides meet the vertical line at one half.
Write the quadrant one solutions
Why: Pi over three itself, plus any number of whole turns.
\[ \theta = \frac{\pi}{3} + 2\pi k \]
Write the quadrant four solutions
Why: The quadrant four angle with reference angle pi over three is a full turn less pi over three.
\[ \theta = 2\pi - \frac{\pi}{3} + 2\pi k = \frac{5\pi}{3} + 2\pi k \]
Check one member of each family
Why: Pi over three and five pi over three both have reference angle pi over three and both lie on the right of the circle, so both cosines are one half, as required.
\[ \cos\left(\frac{\pi}{3}\right) = \frac12, \qquad \cos\left(\frac{5\pi}{3}\right) = \frac12 \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 728 — Example 10.2.5, part 1
Watch the order here, because it is the reverse of the evaluation procedure and that is exactly the point. The sign of the value tells you which two quadrants. The size of the value tells you the reference angle. Then each quadrant gives you a representative, and each representative gives you a family.
The picture shows the two sweeps that answer the question, and they are worth looking at because they are so different in length. One is a sixth of a revolution and the other is nearly a whole one. They are not negatives of each other and not supplements of each other; they are simply the two places the vertical line cuts the circle.
The check at the end evaluates both representatives forwards, using the procedure from the first half of the lesson. Solving and evaluating are inverse operations, so every solving problem comes with a free check, and you should take it every time until the two directions feel like one skill.
Intuition
An equation in algebra usually has finitely many solutions, and it is tempting to stop at the first angle you find. The reason that fails here is built into the definition of cosine and sine: they are functions of a terminal side, and infinitely many angles share one terminal side.
So every solution of one of these equations drags a whole family of coterminal angles along with it. Writing down one member and calling it the answer is like answering a question about a direction by naming one trip that ends facing that way.
It is also why an inverse cosine will need care in Lesson 10.6a. You cannot undo a function that sends infinitely many inputs to the same output without first restricting which inputs you allow.
If your instinct was to stop at the first angle you found, that instinct comes from algebra, where equations usually have finitely many solutions. Here the instinct is wrong for a structural reason, not a technical one.
Cosine and sine are functions of a terminal side, and infinitely many angles share one terminal side. So the moment one angle solves the equation, every angle coterminal with it solves it too. There is no way to have finitely many solutions unless the value lies outside the possible range, in which case there are none at all.
Keep this in view for Lesson 10.6a. Defining an inverse cosine means choosing one solution out of infinitely many, which is why that lesson has to restrict the domain before it can define anything. The awkwardness you are meeting here is the reason for the awkwardness there.
Worked example
Find every angle whose sine is negative one half.
\[ \sin(\theta) = -\frac12 \]
Turn the equation into a position
Why: The sine is the second coordinate, so this fixes a height rather than a horizontal position.
\[ y = -\frac12 \text{ on the unit circle} \]
Name the two quadrants
Why: A negative second coordinate puts the point below the horizontal axis: quadrant three or quadrant four.
\[ \text{QIII or QIV} \]
Find the reference angle from the size
Why: Ignore the sign and look up one half as a sine.
\[ \sin\left(\frac{\pi}{6}\right) = \frac12 \;\Longrightarrow\; \alpha = \frac{\pi}{6} \]
Figure (svg): A unit circle crossed by a horizontal line at minus one half, meeting it at seven pi over six in quadrant three and eleven pi over six in quadrant four. Beside it a number line of angles marks the two families of solutions, each spaced two pi apart.
Write the quadrant three family
Why: The quadrant three angle with reference angle pi over six is half a turn plus pi over six.
\[ \theta = \pi + \frac{\pi}{6} + 2\pi k = \frac{7\pi}{6} + 2\pi k \]
Write the quadrant four family
Why: The quadrant four angle with the same reference angle is a full turn less pi over six.
\[ \theta = 2\pi - \frac{\pi}{6} + 2\pi k = \frac{11\pi}{6} + 2\pi k \]
Check that the second family can be written differently
Why: Taking k to be minus one in the second family gives minus pi over six, so the book's remark that the quadrant four answers can equally be written as minus pi over six plus whole turns describes the same list of angles.
\[ \frac{11\pi}{6} - 2\pi = -\frac{\pi}{6} \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, pp. 728-730 — Example 10.2.5, part 2, and the remark that follows
Same procedure, with one extra thing to notice: the value is negative, so the sign now selects the two lower quadrants rather than the two right-hand ones. Fixing a height is a horizontal line rather than a vertical one.
When you look up the reference angle, ignore the sign entirely. Reference angles are acute and their values are positive, so you look up one half as a sine, get pi over six, and let the quadrants deal with the minus.
The check is doing something more interesting than checking. Taking the integer to be minus one in the second family produces the clockwise angle minus pi over six, which is the book's remark at the end of the example: the quadrant four answers can be written either way, and the two descriptions list exactly the same angles. When your answer looks different from the back of the book, test whether the two families coincide before assuming you are wrong.
Trap
Asked for every angle with sine negative one half, a common answer is:
\[ \theta = \frac{7\pi}{6} + 2\pi k \]
Incomplete. Every angle listed is a solution, but a whole second family is missing.
A horizontal line strictly between the top and the bottom of the circle cuts it twice, so there are two crossings and therefore two families. Finding one reference angle is half the work.
\[ \theta = \frac{7\pi}{6} + 2\pi k \]
\[ \text{or}\quad \theta = \frac{11\pi}{6} + 2\pi k \]
Ask yourself which two quadrants the sign allows, and check that your answer has a family in each of them.
This is the most common incomplete answer in the section, and the word incomplete matters: every angle in the given family really does solve the equation. Nothing written is false. A whole second family is simply absent.
The defence is to make the two-quadrant question explicit. Before finding any reference angle, write down which two quadrants the sign of the value allows. Then you have a checklist, and an answer with only one family visibly fails it.
Both traps in this lesson have the same shape, incidentally. One sign decision applied to two coordinates, and one family offered for two crossings. In both cases the fix is to notice that there were two questions rather than one.
Worked example
Find every angle whose cosine is zero. This is the one case where the two families merge.
\[ \cos(\theta) = 0 \]
Turn the equation into a position
Why: A first coordinate of zero puts the point on the vertical axis itself.
\[ x = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{the terminal side lies along the } y\text{-axis} \]
Note that these are quadrantal angles
Why: A quadrantal angle has no reference angle, so the theorem is not used; the two points are read off the axis.
\[ (0, 1) \text{ and } (0, -1) \]
Figure (svg): A unit circle whose crossings with the vertical axis are marked at pi over two and three pi over two, with a number line below showing that those two families interleave into one family spaced pi apart.
Write the two families
Why: The two terminal directions are a quarter turn and three quarters of a turn.
\[ \theta = \frac{\pi}{2} + 2\pi k \quad\text{or}\quad \theta = \frac{3\pi}{2} + 2\pi k \]
Merge them into one family
Why: The two representatives differ by half a turn, not a whole one, so stepping by half turns from either one produces the whole list.
\[ \theta = \frac{\pi}{2} + \pi k \]
Check the merged form generates both
Why: Taking k to be zero gives a quarter turn and taking k to be one gives three quarters of a turn, and the even and odd values of k reproduce the two original families exactly.
\[ k = 0: \frac{\pi}{2}; \quad k = 1: \frac{3\pi}{2}; \quad k = 2: \frac{5\pi}{2} \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 730 — Example 10.2.5, part 3
This is the exception the lesson has been promising. A cosine of zero means a horizontal position of zero, which puts the point on the vertical axis itself, so the answers are quadrantal angles and there is no reference angle anywhere in the problem.
Start as usual with the two families, a quarter turn and three quarters of a turn, each with whole turns added. Then look at the two representatives: they differ by a half turn, not a whole one. That is what allows the merge, because stepping by half turns from either representative produces both lists at once.
Be careful about when this is allowed. It works because the two crossings happen to be diametrically opposite, which happens for cosine equals zero and sine equals zero and for nothing else. If you try it on the previous example, stepping by half turns from seven pi over six would produce pi over six, whose sine is positive one half. The merge is a special case, not a shortcut.
Tweak it
Parameter explorer
The curve plots the cosine of an angle minus the value c, over two full revolutions. Each crossing of the horizontal axis is one solution of cosine of theta equals c. Slide c from minus one and a half up to one and a half and count the crossings.
\[ \cos(\theta) - {c} \]
The curve here is the cosine of the angle with the value subtracted, so a crossing of the horizontal axis is a solution of the equation. Two full revolutions are shown, so expect twice as many crossings as there are per revolution.
Start with the value at one half and count four crossings, which is two per revolution: the two families. Now slide the value slowly up towards one. The two crossings in each revolution move towards each other, and at exactly one they merge into a single crossing. That is the case where the vertical line is tangent to the circle, and the two families become one.
Push past one and the curve lifts clear of the axis: no crossings, no solutions. The same thing happens below minus one. So the whole story is in the picture: two families strictly inside the range, one family at either end of it, and nothing outside.
Worked example
From the exercise set: find all of the angles satisfying this equation.
\[ \cos(\theta) = -\frac{\sqrt3}{2} \]
Read the sign as a pair of quadrants
Why: A negative first coordinate puts the point to the left of the vertical axis.
\[ \text{QII or QIII} \]
Read the size as a reference angle
Why: Root three over two is the cosine of pi over six.
\[ \alpha = \frac{\pi}{6} \]
Figure (svg): A unit circle crossed by a vertical line at minus root three over two, meeting it at five pi over six in quadrant two and seven pi over six in quadrant three. Both reference triangles are drawn against the negative x-axis and are mirror images of each other.
Build the quadrant two representative
Why: Half a turn less the reference angle.
\[ \theta = \pi - \frac{\pi}{6} = \frac{5\pi}{6} \]
Build the quadrant three representative
Why: Half a turn plus the reference angle.
\[ \theta = \pi + \frac{\pi}{6} = \frac{7\pi}{6} \]
Add the whole turns
Why: Each representative carries its own family.
\[ \theta = \frac{5\pi}{6} + 2\pi k \quad\text{or}\quad \theta = \frac{7\pi}{6} + 2\pi k \]
Check the two representatives numerically
Why: Root three over two is about zero point eight six six, and both cosines come out as its negative, about minus zero point eight six six.
\[ \cos\left(\frac{5\pi}{6}\right) = \cos\left(\frac{7\pi}{6}\right) \approx -0.866 \;\checkmark \]
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 737 — Exercise 32
This is an exercise from the section, and it is worth doing with the checklist rather than by recognition. Sign first: the value is negative, so the point is left of the vertical axis, which allows quadrants two and three.
Size second: root three over two is the cosine of pi over six, so that is the reference angle for both crossings. Then build one representative in each quadrant, half a turn less the reference angle and half a turn plus it, and add whole turns to each.
Look at the picture and notice the symmetry the two answers have. The two crossings of a vertical line are always reflections of each other in the horizontal axis, so they always share a reference angle and always differ only in the sign of the height. That is worth knowing in advance: for a cosine equation, the two representatives are always a plus-and-minus pair around the nearer horizontal direction.
Counterexample
\[ \cos(\theta) = -1.001 \]
Discussion prompt
Exercise 39 asks for all angles satisfying this. Say how many there are and why, using the circle rather than any algebra.
Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 737 — Exercise 39
Write your answer before revealing, and answer with the picture rather than with algebra. The question is not a trick; it is a check that you know what a cosine is.
A cosine is the horizontal position of a point on the unit circle, and the entire circle lies between the vertical lines at minus one and at one. So a cosine can never be smaller than minus one. The line the equation asks for misses the circle completely, and there is nothing to find.
The habit to build is checking the range before starting work. If you had gone hunting for a reference angle whose cosine is one and one thousandth, you would have spent several minutes discovering that the table has no such entry, and you might have concluded that you had misread the table rather than the question.
Real world
Figure (svg): A wheel of radius one on a tower, with the ground drawn below and a dashed horizontal line marking a fixed height. The line cuts the wheel at two points, one on the way up and one on the way down, with arrows showing the direction of travel at each.
Discussion prompt
A wheel of radius one turns steadily, and a rider's height above the centre is the sine of the angle turned. The rider passes a height of three fifths of the radius. Explain why there are two positions per revolution at that height, and say what distinguishes them physically.
Write your explanation before revealing. The point of the slide is that the two families you have been producing all along are not an artefact of the notation; they are a fact about turning things.
A fixed height is a horizontal line, and it cuts the wheel in two places. One of them is on the rising side and the other on the falling side, so the two solutions differ in something physical: the direction the rider is travelling. Height alone genuinely cannot tell you which one you are at, which is why a single answer would be wrong rather than merely incomplete.
The whole-turns part of each family is the wheel going round again. If someone asks when the rider is at that height, they are asking for a list of times, and the list is infinite and periodic for the same reason your answers are.
Section
Part 6
Pattern
Figure (svg): A flow diagram: reduce the angle into one revolution, decide whether it is quadrantal, and if not find the reference angle from the denominator or by subtraction, take the two sizes from the memorised table, then attach the signs from the quadrant.
This is the order to work in, and the order is chosen so the cheap decisions come first. Reducing by whole turns costs one subtraction. Asking whether the angle is quadrantal costs one glance, and a yes ends the problem immediately with no table lookup and no signs.
Only then do you look for a reference angle, by the denominator if you are in radians and by the subtraction for the quadrant otherwise. The two sizes come from the three memorised pairs, and the signs come last and separately.
The final line is the one that makes this lesson pay off twice. Solving an equation is the same diagram traversed backwards: the sign of the value gives you two quadrants, the size gives you the reference angle, and each quadrant contributes a family. If you can run the diagram in both directions you have everything Section 10.2 asks for.
Check
Check your understanding
An angle has reference angle pi over six and its terminal side lies in quadrant three. What are its cosine and its sine?
Answer: A
Why: The reference angle pi over six supplies the two sizes, root three over two for the cosine and one half for the sine. Quadrant three makes both coordinates negative, so both signs are minus.
This question separates the two jobs deliberately: the reference angle is handed to you, so only the lookup and the signs are being tested.
The reference angle pi over six gives the large size for the cosine and the small one for the sine. Quadrant three is left of centre and below it, so both are negative. One of the wrong options swaps the two sizes, which is the error you make by measuring to the vertical axis, and another gives quadrant four's signs.
If you hesitated over which size goes with which function, go back to the thirty-sixty-ninety triangle for a moment. At thirty degrees the side across from the angle is the short one, and that side is the height, so the sine is the small value.
Check
Check your understanding
Which of these angles does NOT have reference angle pi over four?
Answer: C
Why: Written in lowest terms, 2π/3 has denominator three, so its reference angle is pi over three. The other three all reduce to a denominator of four and so share the reference angle pi over four.
Reduce each fraction before doing anything else, then read its denominator. That is the entire question.
Three of the four have denominator four in lowest terms, so all three have reference angle pi over four, even though they are in three different quadrants. The odd one out has denominator three, so its reference angle is pi over three instead.
Notice how little the quadrant mattered here. Reference angle and quadrant are independent pieces of information, and a question can ask about either one without touching the other.
Check
Check your understanding
Which is the complete set of angles whose sine is root three over two?
Answer: B
Why: A positive sine puts the point above the horizontal axis, in quadrant one or two, and the size root three over two gives reference angle pi over three. The two representatives are pi over three and half a turn less pi over three, which is two pi over three, each with whole turns added.
Run the checklist: sign first, then size, then one representative per quadrant, then whole turns. A positive sine puts the point above the horizontal axis, which allows quadrants one and two.
The reference angle is pi over three, so the representatives are pi over three and half a turn less pi over three. One wrong option offers a single family, and another offers a quadrant three angle, where the sine is negative and therefore solves the equation with the wrong sign.
The last wrong option is the interesting one, because it tries the merge from the cosine equals zero example. Stepping by half turns here would sweep in angles whose sines are negative. The merge is only legal when the two crossings are diametrically opposite, and two crossings of a horizontal line at a nonzero height never are.
Explain it to yourself
Discussion prompt
In two sentences, explain why the Reference Angle Theorem writes plus-or-minus instead of resolving the signs, and name what does resolve them. Then say what goes wrong if you try to do both jobs at once.
Write both sentences out before revealing. Being able to say why the theorem is stated with plus-or-minus is a good test of whether you have the idea or only the procedure.
The short version: an acute angle carries no information about direction, because four angles, one per quadrant, share it, so the only thing it can determine is the size of each coordinate. The quadrant determines both signs, and it determines them independently of each other.
The second half of the question is the practical payoff. The two errors this lesson keeps warning you about are exactly the two ways of merging the jobs: measuring the wedge to the wrong axis corrupts the sizes, and choosing one sign for both coordinates corrupts the signs in the two quadrants where they differ. Keeping the jobs apart eliminates both at once.
Exit ticket
\[ \text{(a) evaluate } \cos\left(-\frac{5\pi}{6}\right) \text{ and } \sin\left(-\frac{5\pi}{6}\right); \quad \text{(b) solve } \cos(\theta) = -\frac12 \]
Discussion prompt
Do both parts, and for part (b) give every solution, not one. Say in one line which quadrants each part used and why.
Do both parts before revealing, and notice that they are the same knowledge used in opposite directions.
In part (a) add a whole turn to get seven pi over six, which is in quadrant three with reference angle pi over six, so both values are negative: the large size for the cosine and the small one for the sine. In part (b) the value is negative, so the point is on the left, allowing quadrants two and three; the size one half belongs to pi over three; and the two representatives are two pi over three and four pi over three, each with whole turns added.
The one-line explanation at the end is the part worth getting right. Evaluating uses one quadrant because one angle has one terminal side. Solving uses two because a single coordinate is consistent with two positions on the circle, and no amount of algebra can choose between them.
Recap
| what you are given | what you do | what you get |
|---|---|---|
| an angle, any size or sign | reduce by whole turns, then find the reference angle | the two sizes, from three memorised pairs |
| its quadrant | ask left-or-right, then up-or-down | the two signs, chosen separately |
| a terminal side on an axis | read the point off the axis | a quadrantal value, no reference angle needed |
| a value of cosine or sine | the sign gives two quadrants, the size gives the reference angle | two families of solutions, whole turns apart |
\[ \cos(\theta) = \pm\cos(\alpha), \quad \sin(\theta) = \pm\sin(\alpha), \quad \theta = \theta_0 + 2\pi k \]
Next, Lesson 10.2c lifts all of this off the unit circle: on a circle of any radius the coordinates become the radius times these same two values, which is what turns the circle into a model of circular motion and recovers right triangle trigonometry as a special case.
OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §7.3 Unit Circle §7.3 Unit Circle — the same material in OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry
Everything in this lesson comes from one idea and one distinction. The idea is that the unit circle is symmetric, so every point is a reflection of a first-quadrant point. The distinction is that the size of a coordinate and its sign come from different places: the reference angle gives the size, the quadrant gives the sign.
Run the table's four rows as a self-test. Given any angle, however large or negative, you should be able to reduce it, decide whether it is quadrantal, find its reference angle and attach two signs. Given any value of cosine or sine, you should be able to name two quadrants, find one reference angle and write two families of solutions.
Lesson 10.2c lifts all of it off the unit circle. On a circle of radius r the point at a given angle is simply r times the point you now know, which turns this circle into a model of circular motion and recovers the right triangle trigonometry you may have met in school as the first-quadrant special case.
Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Trigonometry — $55/session, free consultation.