10.2a The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine

Cosine and sine defined as the two coordinates of the point where an angle's terminal side crosses the unit circle, rather than as ratios in a triangle. Covers reading the quadrantal values straight off the axes, deriving the values at pi over six, pi over four and pi over three from the two special right triangles together with the circle equation, the Pythagorean identity as the circle equation with its coordinates renamed, and recovering a missing coordinate from the identity plus quadrant information.

Subject: Trigonometry · 67 slides · symbolic lesson

Open the interactive version of this deck

What this lesson covers

The lesson, slide by slide

1. The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine

Title

Trigonometry · Section 10.2a

Two coordinates, one angle, and the identity that comes free

2. What this lesson gives you

Objectives

Section 10.1 measured angles and turned them into arc length and speed. This lesson turns an angle into a position: the point where its terminal side crosses the circle of radius one. The two coordinates of that point are given names, and almost everything else in trigonometry follows from them.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, pp. 717-722 — the definition through Example 10.2.2 and the table of common values

Everything you have done with angles so far has been about measuring them: degrees or radians, arc length, angular speed. This lesson does something different. It attaches a position to an angle, and then gives the two numbers that describe that position their own names.

The whole of the definition fits in one sentence, and once you have it, three of the five objectives above are just consequences. The quadrantal values need no work at all. The five special values need one right triangle each. The Pythagorean identity is the equation of a circle you have known since Chapter 7, written in the new names.

The last objective is the one that will appear most often on a test: you are given one of the two values and told roughly where the angle is, and you have to produce the other. That problem is really two problems, a size and a sign, and it is worth noticing from the start that the algebra can only ever give you the size.

3. Before anything new: the circle of radius one

Warm-up

Discussion prompt

Write down the equation of the circle of radius one centred at the origin. Then: if a point on that circle has first coordinate three fifths, what are the possible second coordinates, and what single extra piece of information would pin down which one it is?

OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §7.3 Unit Circle §7.3 — the unit circle in the second source

Write your answer down before you reveal anything. The equation of a circle of radius one centred at the origin is the one fact this entire lesson is built on, so it is worth knowing you have it cold.

The second half of the question is the more important one. Substituting three fifths for the first coordinate leaves a square for the second, and a square has two roots. Geometrically, a vertical line three fifths of the way along cuts the circle in two places, one above the horizontal axis and one below.

The extra fact you asked for is simply which half of the plane the point is in. Hold on to that: in about forty slides' time the same question will be dressed up as an inequality on an angle or the name of a quadrant, and the answer will be exactly as cheap as it is here.

4. Cosine and sine are coordinates

Section

Part 1

5. One angle, one point, two numbers

Concept

Put an angle in standard position: vertex at the origin, initial side along the positive horizontal axis. Its terminal side is a ray from the origin, and a ray from the origin crosses the circle of radius one exactly once. Call that crossing point P.

Figure (svg): A unit circle centred at the origin with an angle of about fifty-five degrees in standard position. Its terminal side meets the circle at a marked point P, and dashed lines drop from P to both axes; the horizontal run is labelled cosine of theta and the vertical rise sine of theta.

The angle picks the point; the point hands you two numbers. The first coordinate is named cosine, the second sine — that is the whole definition.

cosine and sine — For an angle in standard position, let P be the point where its terminal side meets the unit circle. The first coordinate of P is the cosine of the angle; the second coordinate of P is the sine of the angle.

\[ P = \big(\cos(\theta),\; \sin(\theta)\big) \quad \text{on} \quad x^2 + y^2 = 1 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 717 — the definition of cosine and sine

Read the figure from the inside out. The angle is drawn in standard position, so its vertex sits at the origin and its initial side runs along the positive horizontal axis. That agreement matters: without it, an angle would not pick out a single ray.

Now follow the terminal side out until it crosses the circle. That crossing point is called P, and it is the only thing the rest of the lesson cares about. Its first coordinate is given the name cosine, its second the name sine. Nothing is being computed here; two coordinates are being given names.

The two dashed lines in the figure are where the names come from. The horizontal run to the foot of the perpendicular is the cosine, the vertical rise from that foot to P is the sine. Because the radius is one, those two lengths are the coordinates themselves rather than fractions of something, which is the whole reason this circle in particular gets the special treatment.

6. Reading the definition piece by piece

Notation

Annotate

On: \( P\big(\cos(\theta),\, \sin(\theta)\big) \in \{(x,y) : x^2 + y^2 = 1\} \)

  • The vertex sits at the origin and the initial side runs along the positive x-axis. Without that agreement the angle would not determine a single ray, and nothing below would be well defined.
  • Cosine is the horizontal coordinate, sine the vertical one. Alphabetical order in the pair matches alphabetical order in the names, which is the only memory aid you need.
  • On a circle of radius r the crossing point would be (r cos θ, r sin θ). Radius one is what lets the coordinates BE the values rather than multiples of them; Lesson 10.2c lifts that restriction.
  • Any real angle, positive or negative, large or small, in degrees or radians. Every angle has a terminal side and every terminal side meets the circle, so both functions are defined for every input.

Work through the four annotations in order and connect each to the picture on the previous slide. The first two are the ones that get used every day: standard position is what makes the ray unique, and cosine comes first in the pair just as it comes first alphabetically.

The third annotation is worth a moment even though it is about a later lesson. On a circle of any other radius, the crossing point would have coordinates equal to the radius times these values. Radius one is what removes that factor, and it is why the circle is called the unit circle rather than just a circle.

The fourth is the annotation that makes this definition better than the one you may already have. There is no restriction on the angle at all: negative, enormous, quadrantal, it does not matter. Every angle has a terminal side and every terminal side crosses the circle exactly once, so cosine and sine are defined everywhere.

7. Why this really is a function of the angle

Concept

The book asks you to check this rather than assert it, so check it. A rule is a function when each input produces exactly one output.

  1. The input is an angle. In standard position it determines one ray, and no other.
  2. That ray meets the unit circle in exactly one point: a line through the centre of a circle crosses it twice, but a ray from the centre only once.
  3. One point has one first coordinate and one second coordinate.

So each angle has one cosine and one sine, and cosine and sine are functions. Notice what is not claimed: different angles may well share a point, and they do. That would break a function of the point, not a function of the angle.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 717 — the remark that these rules satisfy the definition of a function

The book asks you to verify this rather than just accept it, and the verification is short enough to do properly. Being a function means one input gives exactly one output, so find the input, find the output, and check there is no choice anywhere in between.

The step people skip is the second one. A whole line through the centre of a circle crosses it twice, so if the terminal side were a line rather than a ray, the definition would break immediately. It is a ray, starting at the centre and going one way only, so there is precisely one crossing.

Watch what is not being claimed. Different angles can and do land on the same point, which means neither function is one-to-one. That will matter enormously later, when you try to run the process backwards and solve an equation, because then one value will correspond to infinitely many angles.

8. Radius one is what makes the coordinates the values

Intuition

Figure (svg): The unit circle drawn inside the square whose sides are the lines x equals plus and minus one and y equals plus and minus one. The circle touches each side at exactly one point, so no point of the circle has a coordinate outside minus one to one.

Every point of the circle sits inside the dashed square, so a cosine and a sine can never leave the range from minus one to one — and each extreme is reached at exactly one point.

The circle is trapped inside the square with corners at plus and minus one, touching each side once. So neither coordinate can ever leave the interval from minus one to one, and each end is reached at exactly one point.

\[ -1 \le \cos(\theta) \le 1, \qquad -1 \le \sin(\theta) \le 1 \]

That is a fact about the definition, not a rule to learn. Any answer of two, or of minus one and a half, is not a hard problem: it is an arithmetic slip, and the picture catches it instantly.

The dashed square in the picture is the cheapest error check in trigonometry. The circle sits inside it and touches each side at one point, so no point of the circle can have a coordinate bigger than one or smaller than minus one.

That tells you both values live between minus one and one, and it also tells you something sharper: each extreme is reached exactly once. There is precisely one point on the circle whose second coordinate is one, so there is essentially one angle, up to whole revolutions, whose sine is one. You will use that fact directly in a few slides.

So if a calculation ever hands you a cosine of two, or a sine of minus one and a half, you have not discovered an exotic angle. You have made an arithmetic slip, and glancing at this picture will tell you so faster than rechecking the algebra.

9. What the coordinate definition replaces

Concept

If you have met cosine and sine before, it was probably as ratios of sides in a right triangle: adjacent over hypotenuse, opposite over hypotenuse. That definition is true, and it is about to become a special case, but on its own it cannot reach very far.

the triangle definitionthe coordinate definition
needs an acute angle, since a right triangle has two of themworks for any angle at all, of any size
says nothing about an angle of two hundred degreesthe terminal side simply lands in another quadrant
has no triangle to draw for a quadrantal anglereads the point straight off the axis
gives only positive ratios, since lengths are positivegives signed values, because coordinates are signed

Nothing you learned earlier becomes wrong. It gets extended, and the extension is what makes a cosine of an angle past a right angle mean anything at all. Lesson 10.2c shows the triangle version dropping out of this one.

If you met sine and cosine in a geometry course, it was as ratios of sides in a right triangle, and you may be wondering whether that is now wrong. It is not. It is about to become the first-quadrant special case of what you are learning here, and Lesson 10.2c will show it dropping out.

Read down the table and notice that every row is the same complaint. A right triangle has two acute angles and nothing else, so anything built only from right triangles can only ever speak about acute angles. Ask it about two hundred degrees, or about a quarter turn, and it has nothing to say.

The last row is the one that matters most in practice. Lengths of sides are positive numbers, so the triangle definition can never produce a negative cosine. Coordinates are signed, so the coordinate definition produces the signs automatically, without any extra rule to remember. Getting signs for free is the main practical gain of the change.

10. The signs are the signs of coordinates

Picture it

Figure (svg): The unit circle with the four quadrants labelled one to four and, inside each, the pair of signs that a cosine and a sine take there: both positive in quadrant one, cosine negative in quadrant two, both negative in quadrant three, sine negative in quadrant four.

Left of the vertical axis the first coordinate is negative; below the horizontal axis the second one is. There is no mnemonic to learn here, only left-right and up-down.

Because a cosine is a first coordinate, it is negative exactly when the point lies to the left of the vertical axis. Because a sine is a second coordinate, it is negative exactly when the point lies below the horizontal axis. There is nothing else to it.

Many people memorise a phrase for this table. Picturing the point and asking two yes-or-no questions is faster, and it never fails when the angle is negative or bigger than one revolution.

Nearly every course teaches a mnemonic for this diagram. You do not need one, and the mnemonic is what fails you on a negative angle or an angle bigger than a revolution, because you first have to work out which quadrant you are in anyway.

Instead, ask two questions about the point. Is it left of the vertical axis? Then the cosine is negative, because the cosine is the first coordinate. Is it below the horizontal axis? Then the sine is negative. That is the entire diagram, and it reconstructs itself in two seconds from the definition.

Notice the symmetry in the four cells: cosine changes sign as you cross the vertical axis and sine as you cross the horizontal one, so diagonally opposite quadrants disagree about both. That observation will come back on the very last part of the lesson.

11. Sort these angles by the sign of the cosine

Sorting

Sort into buckets

Cosine is the first coordinate, so this is a question about left and right. Sort each angle by the sign of its cosine.

cosine positive
π/3; 7π/4
cosine negative
2π/3; 4π/3; −π
cosine zero
π/2; 3π/2
pos
π/3 lands in quadrant I and 7π/4 in quadrant IV. Both are to the RIGHT of the vertical axis, so both first coordinates are positive.
neg
2π/3 is in quadrant II, 4π/3 in quadrant III, and −π is half a clockwise turn, landing on the negative x-axis at (−1, 0). All three are to the LEFT, so all three cosines are negative.
zero
π/2 and 3π/2 land on the vertical axis itself, at (0, 1) and (0, −1). A point on the vertical axis has first coordinate zero, so the cosine is zero — not undefined, and not small.

Work each one by placing the terminal side, not by recalling a value. The question is only whether the point ends up left of the vertical axis, right of it, or on it.

Two items deserve care. The negative angle sweeps clockwise: half a clockwise revolution lands on the negative horizontal axis, so that point is as far left as possible and the cosine is negative, in fact minus one. And the two quadrantal angles belong in the third bucket, not the first: a point on the vertical axis has first coordinate exactly zero.

If you were tempted to call a cosine of zero undefined, check the definition again. Zero is a perfectly good coordinate. There is nothing being divided by anything here, which is one of the quiet advantages of defining these by position rather than as a ratio.

12. What a cosine of negative 0.8 tells you

Prediction

\[ \cos(\theta) = -0.8 \]

Predict first

From this single fact, what can you conclude about where the terminal side of the angle lies?

  • It lies in quadrant II
  • It lies in quadrant III
  • It lies in quadrant II or quadrant III
  • It could lie in any quadrant

Correct: It lies in quadrant II or quadrant III

Why: A cosine is a first coordinate, so the point sits on the vertical line eight tenths of a unit to the left of the axis. That line cuts the unit circle twice, once above and once below the horizontal axis, giving one point in quadrant II and one in quadrant III. Nothing in the given information chooses between them, which is exactly why problems of this kind always supply a quadrant as well.

Commit to one option before revealing. The trap here is to answer with the first quadrant that fits and stop, and the correct answer is that two of them fit.

Think of the given fact as a vertical line. A cosine is a first coordinate, so knowing it equals minus eight tenths puts the point somewhere on the vertical line eight tenths of a unit to the left of the axis. That line passes through the circle twice, once above the horizontal axis in quadrant two and once below it in quadrant three.

This is why every problem later in the lesson supplies a quadrant as well as a value. One number pins the point down to a pair of candidates, never to one, and any problem that gave you only the number would not have a unique answer.

13. The quadrantal angles

Section

Part 2

14. Four angles that need no arithmetic

Concept

An angle is called quadrantal when its terminal side lies along one of the two axes. There are only four such positions, and for each one the crossing point is one of the four places where the circle meets an axis.

Figure (svg): The unit circle with its four axis crossings marked and labelled: the point one comma zero at angle zero, zero comma one at ninety degrees, minus one comma zero at one hundred eighty degrees, and zero comma minus one at two hundred seventy degrees.

Four angles, four points, no computation. Each value is a zero or a one, and which of the two it is depends only on which axis the terminal side landed on.
angleterminal sidepoint Pcosinesine
0 or 0 degreespositive horizontal axis(1, 0)10
π/2 or 90 degreespositive vertical axis(0, 1)01
π or 180 degreesnegative horizontal axis(−1, 0)−10
3π/2 or 270 degreesnegative vertical axis(0, −1)0−1

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, pp. 717-720 — Example 10.2.1 parts 1 and 2, and the table on p. 722

These four are the freebies, and they are worth being completely fluent with, because they appear inside longer problems constantly. The word quadrantal just means the terminal side lies along an axis rather than strictly inside a quadrant.

Look at the pattern in the table rather than learning four separate facts. On the horizontal axis, the point is one unit left or right and nothing up, so the sine is zero and the cosine is plus or minus one. On the vertical axis it is the other way round. Every value is a zero or a one with a sign.

The one thing to be careful of is which is which, and the fix is the same as everywhere in this lesson: sketch the ray. If it points straight up, there is no horizontal displacement at all, so the horizontal coordinate, the cosine, must be zero.

15. Example 10.2.1(1): the cosine and sine of 270 degrees

Worked example

The book's first example. It needs no computation at all, only a picture.

\[ \text{Find } \cos(270^\circ) \text{ and } \sin(270^\circ). \]

Turn the angle into a fraction of a revolution

Why: A full revolution is three hundred and sixty degrees, so divide.

\[ \frac{270^\circ}{360^\circ} = \frac34 \]

Sweep three quarters of a turn counter-clockwise

Why: From the positive horizontal axis, three quarter-turns land on the negative vertical axis.

\[ \text{terminal side} = \text{the negative } y\text{-axis} \]

Find where that ray meets the unit circle

Why: One unit straight down from the origin.

\[ P = (0, -1) \]

Read off the two coordinates

Why: First coordinate is the cosine, second is the sine.

\[ \cos(270^\circ) = 0, \qquad \sin(270^\circ) = -1 \]

Check against the equation of the circle

Why: A genuine cosine and sine pair must satisfy the circle equation, and this one does exactly.

\[ 0^2 + (-1)^2 = 1 \;\checkmark \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 717 — Example 10.2.1 part 1

This is the book's first example and there is genuinely no arithmetic in it. Converting to a fraction of a revolution is the only step that involves numbers, and it exists purely to get you to the right ray.

Three quarters of a counter-clockwise turn from the positive horizontal axis: a quarter takes you to the top, a half to the left, three quarters to the bottom. So the terminal side points straight down, and the crossing point is one unit below the origin.

Then just read the pair off in order. No horizontal displacement gives a cosine of zero; one unit down gives a sine of minus one. The check at the end costs nothing and is a habit worth forming, because a pair that fails the circle equation cannot be a cosine and a sine of the same angle.

16. Match each quadrantal angle to its point

Matching

Match the pairs

  • a. θ = 0
  • b. θ = π/2
  • c. θ = π
  • d. θ = 3π/2
  • e. θ = −π/2
  • p. (1, 0)
  • q. (0, 1)
  • r. (−1, 0)
  • s. (0, −1), reached counter-clockwise
  • t. (0, −1), reached clockwise

Why: The last two are the same point, so 3π/2 and −π/2 have the same cosine and the same sine. That is not a coincidence to be memorised: the two angles differ by a whole revolution, so they end on the same ray, and the cosine and sine only ever see the ray.

Four of these five are direct table look-ups. The fifth is the interesting one.

Three pi over two and minus pi over two end up at the same place. One sweeps three quarters of a turn counter-clockwise, the other a quarter of a turn clockwise, and both finish pointing straight down. So both have cosine zero and sine minus one.

Do not file that away as a coincidence to memorise. The two angles differ by exactly one full revolution, and the next slide shows why that guarantees identical values. Once you see the reason, you will never need to check a case like this again.

17. Coterminal angles share the point, so they share the values

Concept

Figure (svg): The unit circle with two arcs from the positive x-axis to the negative x-axis: one sweeping counter-clockwise through the upper half, the other clockwise through the lower half. Both finish on the same ray, at the single point minus one comma zero.

Two different angles, one terminal side, one point. Coterminal angles therefore have exactly the same cosine and exactly the same sine.

Two angles are coterminal when they have the same terminal side. Adding or subtracting a whole revolution never moves the terminal side, and going clockwise instead of counter-clockwise can land on it too.

\[ \theta_2 = \theta_1 + 2\pi k, \quad k \in \mathbb{Z} \;\Longrightarrow\; \cos(\theta_2) = \cos(\theta_1), \;\; \sin(\theta_2) = \sin(\theta_1) \]

This is the first real payoff of defining the values by position. The definition cannot see how you arrived, only where you stopped, so every fact about coterminal angles is automatic rather than a separate rule.

Look at the two arcs in the figure. One climbs over the top, the other dives under the bottom, and they finish on the same ray. The definition never asked how you got there; it only asked where the terminal side is.

So adding or subtracting any whole number of revolutions leaves both values completely unchanged. That is the first real dividend of defining cosine and sine by position instead of by a triangle. With the triangle definition you would have had to invent a separate rule for it.

This is also, quietly, the reason these functions repeat. Every angle has infinitely many coterminal partners, spaced one revolution apart, and all of them share a value. When Lesson 10.5 draws the graphs and calls them periodic, the period of one revolution will come from exactly this slide.

18. Example 10.2.1(2): the cosine and sine of negative pi

Worked example

A negative angle changes the direction of the sweep and nothing else.

\[ \text{Find } \cos(-\pi) \text{ and } \sin(-\pi). \]

Read the sign as a direction

Why: A negative measure means rotate clockwise, and half of a revolution in radians is pi.

\[ -\pi: \quad \tfrac12 \text{ revolution clockwise} \]

Place the terminal side

Why: Half a turn clockwise from the positive horizontal axis arrives at the negative horizontal axis.

\[ \text{terminal side} = \text{the negative } x\text{-axis} \]

Find the crossing point

Why: One unit to the left of the origin.

\[ P = (-1, 0) \]

Read off the coordinates

Why: First coordinate, then second.

\[ \cos(-\pi) = -1, \qquad \sin(-\pi) = 0 \]

Check with the coterminal angle

Why: Positive pi is half a turn the other way and lands on the same ray, so it must give the same pair, and the two angles do differ by a whole revolution.

\[ -\pi + 2\pi = \pi: \quad \cos(\pi) = -1, \; \sin(\pi) = 0 \;\checkmark \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 717 — Example 10.2.1 part 2

A minus sign in front of an angle is a direction, not a value to be subtracted from something. It says rotate clockwise instead of counter-clockwise, and that is the only thing it says.

Half a revolution in radian measure is pi, so this angle is half a turn clockwise. Going down and round from the positive horizontal axis, half a turn brings you to the negative horizontal axis. The crossing point is one unit to the left, which gives a cosine of minus one and a sine of zero.

The check is the nicest part. Positive pi is half a turn the other way and lands on the same ray, and the two angles differ by exactly one revolution, so the previous slide guarantees they agree. Two independent routes to the same pair is a much stronger check than re-reading your own work.

19. Exercises 1 and 11: the angles zero and three pi over two

Worked example

Two more quadrantal angles from the section's exercise set, done the same way.

\[ \text{(a) } \theta = 0 \qquad \text{(b) } \theta = \frac{3\pi}{2} \]

Place the zero angle

Why: No rotation at all leaves the terminal side on the initial side, the positive horizontal axis.

\[ \theta = 0: \quad P = (1, 0) \]

Read the pair

Why: The point one unit to the right of the origin.

\[ \cos(0) = 1, \qquad \sin(0) = 0 \]

Turn three pi over two into quarter-turns

Why: A quarter revolution is pi over two, so this is three of them.

\[ \frac{3\pi/2}{\pi/2} = 3 \quad \text{quarter-turns} \]

Place that terminal side and read the pair

Why: Three quarter-turns counter-clockwise reach the negative vertical axis, the same ray as two hundred and seventy degrees.

\[ \cos\left(\frac{3\pi}{2}\right) = 0, \qquad \sin\left(\frac{3\pi}{2}\right) = -1 \]

Check both pairs on the circle

Why: Each pair must satisfy the circle equation, and each does.

\[ 1^2 + 0^2 = 1, \qquad 0^2 + (-1)^2 = 1 \;\checkmark \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2.2, p. 736 — Exercises 1 and 11

Two more from the exercise set, done together because they are the same kind of problem. Take them as a speed test: with the definition in front of you, both should take about ten seconds each.

The zero angle catches people out because it feels as though nothing has happened. Nothing has: no rotation leaves the terminal side lying on the initial side, along the positive horizontal axis, and the crossing point is one unit to the right. So the cosine is one and the sine is zero.

For three pi over two, counting in quarter-turns is faster than converting to degrees. A quarter revolution is pi over two, so three pi over two is three of them, landing straight down. If you converted to two hundred and seventy degrees instead, that is fine too, and you should recognise it as the angle from the first worked example.

20. Trap: reading the coordinates in the wrong order

Trap

The trap

The point at ninety degrees, written down in a hurry:

\[ P = (0, 1) \]

\[ \cos(90^\circ) = 1? \]

\[ \sin(90^\circ) = 0? \]

Both wrong, and both wrong for one reason.

The fix

Cosine is the first coordinate. The point at ninety degrees is zero units across and one unit up, so the cosine is zero and the sine is one.

\[ \cos(90^\circ) = 0 \]

\[ \sin(90^\circ) = 1 \]

The check that catches this every time: at ninety degrees the terminal side points straight up, so there is no horizontal displacement at all. A cosine of one would mean the point was as far right as it could possibly be.

This is the most common slip in the first week of this material, and it is worth building a physical check against it rather than relying on remembering an order.

Here is the check. At ninety degrees the terminal side points straight up. Ask yourself: how far across from the vertical axis is that point? Not at all. So whichever value measures across must be zero, and the value that measures across is the cosine, because cosine is the first coordinate.

A cosine of one would mean the point sat as far to the right as the circle allows, which is where the zero angle lands, a quarter turn away from where you actually are. Saying that out loud once or twice is enough; after that the order stops being something you recall and becomes something you see.

21. The 45-45-90 triangle

Section

Part 3

22. When there is nothing to read off, drop a perpendicular

Concept

For an angle whose terminal side misses both axes there is no coordinate to read, so the coordinates have to be computed. The method is the same every time, and it is worth learning as a method rather than as five separate results.

Figure (svg): Two panels. On the left, the unit circle with the forty-five degree ray and the point P, with dashed lines making a right triangle under it. On the right, the same triangle alone, its horizontal leg labelled x, its vertical leg labelled y, its hypotenuse labelled one, and both acute angles marked forty-five degrees.

The perpendicular from P to the horizontal axis turns the coordinates into the legs of a right triangle. Equal angles force equal legs, which is the extra equation the circle alone could not give.
  1. Drop a perpendicular from P to the horizontal axis. The legs of the right triangle that appears are exactly the coordinates being sought.
  2. The geometry of that triangle supplies one equation relating the two legs.
  3. The circle supplies a second equation, the circle equation itself.
  4. Two equations, two unknowns. Solve, then let the quadrant settle the plus-or-minus.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 718 — the triangle approach introduced in Example 10.2.1 part 3

From here on the angles do not land on an axis, so there is no coordinate to read and you have to compute. What matters is that you learn this as one method used five times, not as five results.

Look at the left panel. The perpendicular from P down to the horizontal axis creates a right triangle whose horizontal leg is exactly the first coordinate and whose vertical leg is exactly the second. That is the whole trick: the numbers you want are sides of a triangle you can reason about.

You then need two equations, because there are two unknowns. The circle gives you one for free, and it is always the same one. The triangle's geometry gives you the second, and that is the only part that changes from angle to angle. At forty-five degrees the geometry says the legs are equal; at thirty and sixty it will say one leg is half the hypotenuse.

23. Example 10.2.1(3): the cosine and sine of 45 degrees

Worked example

The first non-quadrantal angle, done by the four-step method exactly as the book does it.

\[ \text{Find } \cos(45^\circ) \text{ and } \sin(45^\circ). \]

Name the coordinates

Why: Let P be the crossing point; by definition its coordinates are the two values wanted.

\[ P(x, y), \quad x = \cos(45^\circ), \; y = \sin(45^\circ) \]

Drop the perpendicular and read the angles

Why: The triangle has a right angle at the foot and forty-five degrees at the origin, so the third angle is forty-five degrees too.

\[ 180^\circ - 90^\circ - 45^\circ = 45^\circ \]

Use the geometry: equal angles, equal legs

Why: A triangle with two equal angles is isosceles, and the sides opposite them are equal.

\[ y = x \]

Substitute into the equation of the circle

Why: P lies on the unit circle, so its coordinates satisfy that equation.

\[ x^2 + x^2 = 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; 2x^2 = 1 \]

Solve for x

Why: Divide by two and take both square roots.

\[ x^2 = \frac12 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = \pm\sqrt{\frac12} = \pm\frac{\sqrt2}{2} \]

Let the quadrant choose the sign

Why: Forty-five degrees lands in quadrant I, where first coordinates are positive.

\[ x = \frac{\sqrt2}{2} \;\Longrightarrow\; \cos(45^\circ) = \sin(45^\circ) = \frac{\sqrt2}{2} \]

Check the pair on the circle

Why: Root two over two squared is one half, and two halves make one, so the point is on the unit circle; numerically the value is about 0.707107, comfortably between zero and one.

\[ \left(\frac{\sqrt2}{2}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{\sqrt2}{2}\right)^2 = \frac12 + \frac12 = 1 \;\checkmark \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 718 — Example 10.2.1 part 3

Follow the steps in order and notice how little of it is arithmetic. Naming the coordinates first is not ceremony: it is what lets you treat the two values as unknowns in an equation rather than as things to be recalled.

The geometric step is the third one. Two angles of the triangle are forty-five degrees, so it is isosceles, and the sides opposite the equal angles are equal. That gives the second coordinate equal to the first, and substituting into the circle equation collapses two unknowns into one.

Then watch the sign carefully. Solving a squared equation produces two roots, and the algebra has no idea which one you want. It is the quadrant that chooses: forty-five degrees lands in the first quadrant, where both coordinates are positive. Getting into the habit of writing the plus-or-minus line and then explicitly discarding one root is what will save you in the last part of this lesson.

24. Fill in the middle of the 45 degree derivation

Fill the middle

Fill in the blanks

y = x \;\text2x^2\; x^2 + y^2 = 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; 1/2 = 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; x^2 = sqrt2/2 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = ___

Why: Substituting y = x into the circle equation collapses two unknowns into one: x squared plus x squared is two x squared. Dividing by two gives x squared equal to one half, and the positive square root of one half is root two over two, which is also written one over root two.

The only step worth arguing about is the last one, where a square root produces two answers. Quadrant one discards the negative.

Fill all three blanks before checking any of them. The first is the substitution, the second is the division, and the third is the square root.

The first blank is where the whole derivation happens: replacing the second coordinate by the first turns the sum of two different squares into two copies of one square. Everything after that is routine.

For the last blank, root two over two and one over root two are the same number, and both are accepted. The first form is the one the book uses and the one you should write, because a rationalised denominator is easier to compare with other values at a glance.

25. Why the two values must come out equal

Intuition

Before doing any algebra you could have known that the cosine and sine of forty-five degrees are the same number, and knowing why makes the result impossible to misremember.

The line at forty-five degrees through the origin is the line where the two coordinates agree. It is the mirror line of the plane that swaps the horizontal and vertical axes, and the unit circle is unchanged by that mirror. A point sitting on the mirror line itself has to satisfy the equation of the line.

\[ y = x \;\text{ on the line }\; \Longrightarrow\; \sin(45^\circ) = \cos(45^\circ) \]

So only the size is in question, and the circle fixes that: two equal squares adding to one makes each of them one half.

There is a reason to believe this result before you compute it, and reasons are much more durable than results. The line at forty-five degrees through the origin is precisely the set of points whose two coordinates are equal.

That line is also the mirror that swaps the horizontal and vertical axes, and the unit circle is unchanged by that mirror. A point that sits on the mirror line itself cannot be moved by it, so it must satisfy the line's equation, and the line's equation says the two coordinates agree.

Once you know the two values are equal, the circle finishes the job with no triangle at all: two equal squares adding to one makes each of them one half, so each value is the positive square root of one half. Keep this way of thinking; the same mirror will explain why the thirty and sixty degree pairs are each other reversed.

26. Estimate the coordinates before you compute them

Estimation

\[ \text{the point at } 45^\circ \]

Predict first

Read the coordinates of the forty-five degree point off the picture to one decimal place, before trusting any algebra. Which estimate is closest?

  • about (0.5, 0.5)
  • about (0.7, 0.7)
  • about (0.9, 0.9)
  • about (1.0, 1.0)

Correct: about (0.7, 0.7)

Why: Root two over two is about 0.707. The pair (0.5, 0.5) is a tempting guess because forty-five is half of ninety, but halving the angle does not halve the coordinates: the point (0.5, 0.5) is well inside the circle, since a quarter plus a quarter is only one half. The pair (1.0, 1.0) is far outside it, since one plus one is two.

\[ (0.5)^2 + (0.5)^2 = 0.5 \; \text{(inside)}, \qquad (0.707)^2 + (0.707)^2 \approx 1 \; \text{(on it)} \]

Guess before you reveal, and guess from the picture rather than from anything you remember. The point at forty-five degrees sits up and to the right at equal distances, comfortably inside the corner of the dashed square.

The tempting wrong answer is one half for each, on the reasoning that forty-five is half of ninety. Angles and coordinates do not scale together like that. Check it: a quarter plus a quarter is only one half, not one, so the point with both coordinates one half lies well inside the circle, not on it.

Seven tenths each is right, and it is worth carrying that number in your head. Root two over two is about 0.707, and knowing that lets you sanity-check any answer involving a forty-five degree angle in one second, without touching a calculator.

27. The 30-60-90 triangle

Section

Part 4

28. Half of an equilateral triangle

Concept

At thirty and sixty degrees the perpendicular makes a triangle with angles of thirty, sixty and ninety degrees. The geometry fact this time is not that two legs are equal, but that one leg is exactly half the hypotenuse — and that comes from folding an equilateral triangle in half.

Figure (svg): An equilateral triangle of side one with its altitude drawn from the apex to the midpoint of the base, cutting it into two congruent right triangles. The base is split into two halves of length one half each, and the angles of the right half are marked sixty degrees at the base, thirty degrees at the apex and a right angle at the foot.

The altitude cuts the equilateral triangle into two identical halves, so the short leg is exactly half the side. That one half is where the sine of thirty degrees comes from.

An equilateral triangle of side one has all three angles equal to sixty degrees. Its altitude bisects the base and bisects the apex angle, so each half is a right triangle with angles of thirty, sixty and ninety degrees, a hypotenuse of one, and a short leg of one half.

\[ \text{short leg} = \tfrac12 \cdot \text{side} = \tfrac12 \cdot 1 = \tfrac12 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 719 — the triangle approach in Example 10.2.1 part 4

The thirty-sixty-ninety triangle needs a different geometric fact from the forty-five degree one. There are no equal legs this time, so instead you need to know how one leg compares with the hypotenuse.

The figure shows where that comparison comes from. Take an equilateral triangle with every side one and every angle sixty degrees, then drop the altitude from the apex. It bisects the base and it bisects the apex angle, leaving two identical right triangles with angles thirty, sixty and ninety.

Read off the sides of one of those halves. The hypotenuse is a full side of the original triangle, so it is one. The short leg is half the base, so it is one half. That single relation, short leg equals half the hypotenuse, is the geometric input for both of the next two worked examples, and the circle supplies the rest.

29. Where the one half comes from: the short leg

Worked example

The book leaves this as a question for the reader twice, so it is worth proving once. The claim: in a thirty-sixty-ninety triangle the leg opposite the thirty degree angle is half the hypotenuse.

Start from the right triangle and reflect it

Why: Reflect across the leg adjacent to the thirty degree angle. The two thirty degree angles join into one of sixty degrees.

\[ 30^\circ + 30^\circ = 60^\circ \]

Identify the doubled triangle

Why: All three angles of the new triangle are now sixty degrees, so it is equiangular and therefore equilateral.

\[ 60^\circ, \; 60^\circ, \; 60^\circ \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{equilateral} \]

Compare the base with the hypotenuse

Why: The base of the equilateral triangle is two copies of the short leg, and every side of an equilateral triangle equals the hypotenuse.

\[ 2 \cdot \text{short leg} = \text{hypotenuse} \]

Solve for the short leg

Why: Divide by two.

\[ \text{short leg} = \tfrac12 \cdot \text{hypotenuse} \]

Check on the unit circle

Why: With hypotenuse one the short leg is one half, and the circle equation then forces the long leg to be root three over two, whose square is three quarters.

\[ \left(\tfrac12\right)^2 + \left(\tfrac{\sqrt3}{2}\right)^2 = \tfrac14 + \tfrac34 = 1 \;\checkmark \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 719 — footnote 3, 'Again, can you show this?'

The book asks you twice, in footnotes, whether you can show this, so here it is shown once properly. It is worth doing because it is the only piece of geometry in the lesson that is not immediately visible.

The argument runs the previous slide backwards. Start with the right triangle and reflect it in the leg next to the thirty degree angle. The two thirty degree angles at the apex fuse into one of sixty, and the two right angles at the base fuse into a straight line, so you get a triangle with three sixty degree angles.

A triangle with three equal angles has three equal sides. Its base is two copies of the short leg and its other sides are the hypotenuse, so twice the short leg equals the hypotenuse. On the unit circle the hypotenuse is the radius, which is one, so the short leg is one half, and the circle equation then forces the long leg to be root three over two.

30. Example 10.2.1(4): the cosine and sine of pi over six

Worked example

Now the method, with the thirty-sixty-ninety triangle supplying the geometric equation.

\[ \text{Find } \cos\left(\frac{\pi}{6}\right) \text{ and } \sin\left(\frac{\pi}{6}\right). \]

Convert to degrees to see the triangle

Why: Multiply by one hundred and eighty over pi.

\[ \frac{\pi}{6} \cdot \frac{180^\circ}{\pi} = 30^\circ \]

Drop the perpendicular and name the angles

Why: Right angle at the foot, thirty degrees at the origin, so sixty degrees at P.

\[ 30^\circ, \; 60^\circ, \; 90^\circ \]

Use the geometry: the short leg is half the hypotenuse

Why: The leg opposite the thirty degree angle is the vertical one, and the hypotenuse is the radius, one.

\[ y = \tfrac12 \cdot 1 = \frac12 \]

Figure (svg): The unit circle with the ray at thirty degrees, the point P marked, and dashed lines forming the right triangle beneath it. The vertical leg is labelled y equals one half and the horizontal leg x equals root three over two.

The short leg of the thirty-sixty-ninety triangle is the vertical one here, so the small value one half is the sine and the large value goes to the cosine.

Substitute into the circle equation

Why: P lies on the unit circle.

\[ x^2 + \left(\frac12\right)^2 = 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; x^2 = \frac34 \]

Take the root and choose the sign

Why: Pi over six lands in quadrant I, so the first coordinate is positive.

\[ x = \pm\frac{\sqrt3}{2} \;\Longrightarrow\; x = \frac{\sqrt3}{2} \]

State the pair

Why: First coordinate is the cosine, second is the sine.

\[ \cos\left(\frac{\pi}{6}\right) = \frac{\sqrt3}{2}, \qquad \sin\left(\frac{\pi}{6}\right) = \frac12 \]

Check on the circle and against the picture

Why: Three quarters plus one quarter is one; and the point is far to the right and only slightly up, which matches a value of about 0.866 across and 0.5 up.

\[ \left(\frac{\sqrt3}{2}\right)^2 + \left(\frac12\right)^2 = \frac34 + \frac14 = 1 \;\checkmark \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 719 — Example 10.2.1 part 4

Converting to degrees first is optional but useful while the two notations still feel like different languages. Pi over six is thirty degrees, and thirty degrees is the angle in the triangle you just built.

The step to slow down on is deciding which leg is the short one. The short leg always sits opposite the thirty degree angle, and here the thirty degree angle is at the origin, so the leg opposite it is the vertical one. That makes the second coordinate one half.

After that the circle finishes it: one quarter subtracted from one leaves three quarters, and the positive square root of three quarters is root three over two. Look at the figure while you read the answer. The point is far to the right and only a little way up, which is exactly what a large cosine and a small sine look like. That visual check is what the next trap slide is about.

31. Example 10.2.1(5): the cosine and sine of 60 degrees

Worked example

The same triangle again, but standing on its other leg, so the two values trade places.

\[ \text{Find } \cos(60^\circ) \text{ and } \sin(60^\circ). \]

Drop the perpendicular and name the angles

Why: Sixty degrees at the origin and a right angle at the foot leave thirty degrees at P.

\[ 180^\circ - 90^\circ - 60^\circ = 30^\circ \]

Find which leg is the short one

Why: The short leg is opposite the thirty degree angle, and that angle now sits at P, so the short leg is the horizontal one.

\[ x = \tfrac12 \cdot 1 = \frac12 \]

Figure (svg): The unit circle with the ray at sixty degrees and the point P marked, with its right triangle drawn beneath. Now the horizontal leg is the short one, labelled x equals one half, and the vertical leg is labelled y equals root three over two.

Exactly the same triangle as at thirty degrees, stood on its other leg. The short leg has moved from the vertical to the horizontal, so the one half has moved from the sine to the cosine.

Substitute into the circle equation

Why: The same substitution as before, with the roles of the coordinates exchanged.

\[ \left(\frac12\right)^2 + y^2 = 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; y^2 = \frac34 \]

Take the root and choose the sign

Why: Sixty degrees is in quadrant I, so the second coordinate is positive.

\[ y = \frac{\sqrt3}{2} \;\Longrightarrow\; \cos(60^\circ) = \frac12, \; \sin(60^\circ) = \frac{\sqrt3}{2} \]

Check against the thirty degree answer

Why: The two pairs are each other reversed, which is what reflecting in the forty-five degree line must do, and both satisfy the circle equation.

\[ \big(\tfrac{\sqrt3}{2}, \tfrac12\big) \text{ at } 30^\circ, \quad \big(\tfrac12, \tfrac{\sqrt3}{2}\big) \text{ at } 60^\circ \;\checkmark \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 719 — Example 10.2.1 part 5

This is the same triangle as the last example, turned so that it stands on its other leg, and watching it turn is much better than computing it again from scratch.

The thirty degree angle has moved. It now sits up at P rather than down at the origin, so the leg opposite it is the horizontal one, and the short value one half has moved from the sine to the cosine. Everything else in the working is identical with the roles of the two coordinates exchanged.

The check at the end is the important line. The pair at sixty degrees is the pair at thirty degrees written backwards, and that is exactly what reflecting in the forty-five degree line does. Two slides ago you saw that this mirror swaps the coordinates, so the two answers had to be reverses of each other, and you could have written the second one down without any work.

32. Complete the table of the five essential values

Comparison

Comparison matrix

degreesradianscos θsin θ
0°010
30°π/6√3/21/2
45°π/4√2/2√2/2
60°π/31/2√3/2
90°π/201

This is the table the book says must be memorised, and it is the last piece of memorisation this chapter asks for. Every other exact value in the chapter is one of these five with a sign attached.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 722 — Cosine and Sine Values of Common Angles

Fill in every blank before checking. This is the table the book says must be memorised, and it is the only memorisation this chapter asks of you.

Rather than drilling it as ten separate facts, use the structure. The first and last rows are quadrantal, so they are zeros and ones. The middle three come from the two triangles, and forty-five degrees is the symmetric one where the two entries agree. Thirty and sixty are each other reversed.

One more pattern helps: reading down the cosine column the values fall, and reading down the sine column they rise, because the point is travelling from the right-hand side of the circle up to the top. If you ever doubt an entry, that direction of travel settles it.

33. The five points, plotted where they actually are

Picture it

Figure (svg): The first quadrant of the unit circle with five points marked on it, at zero, thirty, forty-five, sixty and ninety degrees, each labelled with its coordinate pair. The coordinates slide from one comma zero at the right to zero comma one at the top.

Watch the pattern rather than the table: the cosine slides down from one to zero while the sine climbs from zero to one, and they cross, equal, at forty-five degrees.

Seen as points rather than as a table, the five values stop being five unrelated facts. Moving counter-clockwise from the right, the first coordinate slides down from one to zero while the second climbs from zero to one, and the two cross, equal, exactly halfway.

If you can redraw this quarter-circle from memory you never need the table: the only thing to recall is that root three over two is the big one, about 0.87, and one half is the small one.

This is the same information as the table, but as geometry rather than as rows, and it is much harder to misremember. Trace the five points from the right-hand end of the quarter-circle up to the top.

As you move counter-clockwise the first coordinate shrinks from one to zero and the second grows from zero to one, and at forty-five degrees they meet. There is no way to pair a value with the wrong angle if you are reading it off this picture, because the shallow angles are obviously near the right and the steep ones obviously near the top.

Practise redrawing this quarter-circle from nothing: draw the arc, mark three rays between the axes, and label the points. If you can do that, you do not need the table, and you will still have it available in an exam where your memory of a row has gone blank.

34. Trap: pairing the values with the wrong angle

Trap

The trap

The commonest error in this whole chapter:

\[ \cos(30^\circ) = \frac12? \]

\[ \sin(30^\circ) = \frac{\sqrt3}{2}? \]

Swapped. Those are the values at sixty degrees.

The fix

Thirty degrees is a shallow angle. Its point is far to the right and barely off the axis, so the big value is the cosine and the small one is the sine.

\[ \cos(30^\circ) = \frac{\sqrt3}{2} \approx 0.87 \]

\[ \sin(30^\circ) = \frac12 \]

The picture decides it in a second, and the picture is free. Sketch the ray, ask whether the point is mostly across or mostly up, and give the big number to that coordinate.

Of all the errors in this chapter, swapping the thirty and sixty degree values is the one that costs the most marks, because it feels like knowing the answer rather than guessing.

The defence is entirely visual and takes one second. Thirty degrees is a shallow angle, only a third of the way from the horizontal axis to the vertical one, so its point is far across and barely up. Far across means a large first coordinate, so the large value, about 0.87, is the cosine.

Sixty degrees is the steep one, and everything reverses. Never try to recall which number goes where; sketch the ray and ask whether the point is mostly across or mostly up. Give the big number to that coordinate and you will be right every time, in any quadrant.

35. Order the five cosines, largest first

Ranking

Put in order

Put the cosines of the five memorised angles in order, largest first.

  1. cos 0°
  2. cos 30°
  3. cos 45°
  4. cos 60°
  5. cos 90°

Why: The values are 1, then about 0.866, then about 0.707, then 0.5, then 0. As the angle opens from zero to ninety degrees the point travels counter-clockwise from the right-hand side of the circle to the top, so its first coordinate only decreases. The order of the cosines is therefore the reverse of the order of the angles, with no computation needed at all.

Put them in order before checking, and try to do it without recalling a single numerical value.

The reasoning is pure geometry. As the angle opens from zero to ninety degrees, the point travels counter-clockwise from the right-hand side of the circle up to the top, so its first coordinate only ever decreases. The cosines therefore come out in exactly the reverse order of the angles.

If you did recall the numbers, check them against that: one, about 0.87, about 0.71, one half, zero. Decreasing throughout, as promised. The same argument run on the second coordinate says the sines increase, and between them those two sentences replace the whole table.

36. Why five values are enough for the whole chapter

Socratic

Discussion prompt

The unit circle is symmetric about the horizontal axis, about the vertical axis, and about the origin. Given only the five first-quadrant values in the table, roughly how many exact points of the circle can you now name, and what would each symmetry do to a pair of coordinates?

Write your answer before revealing. The count matters less than the mechanism, so spend your thinking on what each symmetry does to a pair of coordinates.

Reflecting a point across the vertical axis negates its first coordinate and leaves the second alone. Reflecting across the horizontal axis does the reverse. A half turn about the origin negates both. So each off-axis point in the first quadrant has three partners, one in each of the other quadrants, and their coordinates are the same numbers with different signs.

That is why a table with five rows can settle every exact value in the chapter: the size of each coordinate comes from the first-quadrant table, and only the signs depend on where you are. Lesson 10.2b makes this precise and names it the Reference Angle Theorem. For now you only need to notice that the table is short because the circle is symmetric.

37. The Pythagorean identity

Section

Part 5

38. The circle equation, with its coordinates renamed

Concept

Every worked example so far ended with the same check, because every crossing point lies on the unit circle. Writing that fact once, in the language of the new names, gives the most used identity in trigonometry.

\[ x^2 + y^2 = 1 \quad \text{for every point of the unit circle} \]

\[ x = \cos(\theta), \qquad y = \sin(\theta) \]

\[ \big(\cos(\theta)\big)^2 + \big(\sin(\theta)\big)^2 = 1 \]

Theorem 10.1, the Pythagorean Identity — For any angle: the square of the cosine plus the square of the sine equals one.

\[ \cos^2(\theta) + \sin^2(\theta) = 1 \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 720 — Theorem 10.1

Every worked example so far finished with the same check, and that repetition is a clue. The check was always the circle equation, because the crossing point is always on the circle. Writing that fact down once, in the new names, is all this theorem is.

Follow the three lines. The circle equation holds for every point of the circle. The crossing point's coordinates are the cosine and the sine. Substitute. There is no third step, which is why the theorem needs no proof beyond the substitution itself.

Do not let the importance of the result mislead you about its depth. It is not a new fact about trigonometry; it is an old fact about circles, wearing new names. That perspective is also what stops you from ever forgetting it, because you can rebuild it in one line from the picture.

39. Reading the identity, and the notation it hides

Notation

Annotate

On: \( \cos^{2}(\theta) + \sin^{2}(\theta) = 1 \)

  • A convention the book calls unfortunate and perpetuates anyway: it means (cos(θ))², the value squared. It does NOT mean cos(θ²), and it does not mean applying cosine twice.
  • The word 'identity' means it is true for every θ with no exceptions — not an equation to be solved. Quadrantal angles included: 0² + 1² is 1.
  • The one on the right is the radius squared. Lesson 10.2c will do this on a circle of radius r, where the right-hand side becomes r² instead.
  • Nothing new is being asserted. This is the equation of the unit circle with x replaced by cos(θ) and y by sin(θ), which is why it needs no proof beyond that substitution.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 720 — the squaring convention and the naming of the theorem

The first annotation is the one to read twice. The exponent sits on the whole value, not on the angle: the notation means take the cosine, then square it. The book itself calls this convention unfortunate and then uses it anyway, because everybody does.

The second annotation explains the word identity. This is not an equation waiting to be solved for the angle, it is a statement that holds for every angle at once. Test it on the quadrantal values if you like: zero squared plus one squared is one, and so is one squared plus zero squared.

The last annotation is the one that keeps the result in proportion. Nothing independent is being claimed. This is the equation of the unit circle with the coordinates renamed, which is also why the right-hand side is one: one is the radius squared. On a circle of radius r, in Lesson 10.2c, the right-hand side changes accordingly.

40. The identity is the Pythagorean theorem on the drawn triangle

Picture it

Figure (svg): A point in the second quadrant of the unit circle at about one hundred forty degrees, with the right triangle drawn from it to the horizontal axis. The horizontal leg is labelled with the absolute value of the cosine, the vertical leg with the sine, and the hypotenuse is the radius, labelled one; beside the triangle is the statement that the two legs squared add to one.

The legs of the little triangle are the sizes of the two coordinates and its hypotenuse is the radius, which is one. Squaring removes the minus signs, so the identity holds in every quadrant.

The name is not decoration. Drop the perpendicular from any non-quadrantal point and the two legs have lengths equal to the sizes of the two coordinates, while the hypotenuse is a radius, of length one. The Pythagorean theorem on that triangle is the identity.

The picture shown is in quadrant two, where the first coordinate is negative. Squaring removes the sign, so the identity is blind to the quadrant, which is exactly the property that will make it useful and also the reason it can never tell you a sign.

The name is earned, not decorative. Drop the perpendicular from any non-quadrantal point, exactly as you did for the special angles, and look at the triangle you get. Its two legs have lengths equal to the sizes of the two coordinates, and its hypotenuse is a radius, of length one.

Apply the Pythagorean theorem to that triangle and you get the identity, as the panel on the right of the figure sets out. The only subtlety is the one the figure deliberately shows: the point drawn is in the second quadrant, where the first coordinate is negative, so the leg's length is the size of the cosine rather than the cosine itself.

Squaring removes that distinction, since a number and its negative have the same square. That is why the identity is true in every quadrant with no case-by-case checking, and it is also the reason, on the next slide, that the identity can never tell you a sign.

41. Why the identity cannot tell you a sign

Intuition

Squaring is the step that costs you the information. Two numbers that differ only in sign have the same square, so the moment you square a coordinate you have thrown away which side of the axis it was on.

\[ (-0.6)^2 = (0.6)^2 = 0.36 \]

That is why every problem in the next part comes in two pieces: the identity supplies the size and the quadrant supplies the sign. An answer built from the identity alone is always two answers, and reporting only one of them without a reason is the single most common lost mark on this material.

This slide is short because the point is short, but it is the hinge of the rest of the lesson. Squaring destroys information, and it destroys exactly the information you most often need.

Six tenths and minus six tenths have the same square. So the moment you write the square of a coordinate, the identity can no longer distinguish the two sides of an axis, and any answer you extract from it comes with a plus-or-minus attached.

This is why every problem in the next part arrives in two pieces. The identity supplies the size, and the quadrant supplies the sign. If you catch yourself producing a single signed answer from the identity alone, with no sentence about a quadrant anywhere in your working, you have almost certainly lost a mark you could have kept.

42. Checking a proposed pair against the identity

Worked example

A pair of numbers can only be a cosine and sine of the same angle if it lands on the unit circle. Test three candidates.

\[ \text{(a) } \left(-\tfrac45, \tfrac35\right) \qquad \text{(b) } \left(\tfrac34, \tfrac34\right) \qquad \text{(c) } \left(\tfrac{5}{13}, \tfrac{12}{13}\right) \]

Square and add the first pair

Why: Sixteen twenty-fifths plus nine twenty-fifths.

\[ \frac{16}{25} + \frac{9}{25} = \frac{25}{25} = 1 \;\checkmark \]

Square and add the second pair

Why: Nine sixteenths twice.

\[ \frac{9}{16} + \frac{9}{16} = \frac{18}{16} = \frac98 > 1 \]

Say what that means geometrically

Why: A sum bigger than one puts the point outside the circle, so no angle has both of these values.

\[ \left(\tfrac34,\tfrac34\right) \notin \text{unit circle} \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{impossible} \]

Square and add the third pair

Why: Twenty-five plus one hundred and forty-four over one hundred and sixty-nine.

\[ \frac{25}{169} + \frac{144}{169} = \frac{169}{169} = 1 \;\checkmark \]

Verify by locating each surviving pair

Why: Pair (a) has a negative first coordinate and a positive second, so it is the quadrant II point; pair (c) is in quadrant I. Both sit on the circle, so each really is a cosine and sine pair for some angle.

\[ \left(-\tfrac45,\tfrac35\right) \in \text{II}, \qquad \left(\tfrac{5}{13},\tfrac{12}{13}\right) \in \text{I} \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 720 — Theorem 10.1 used as a test

Here the identity is used as a test rather than as a tool for finding something, and this is a useful way to meet it. Any pair of numbers claiming to be a cosine and a sine of the same angle has to land on the circle, so square them and add.

The second pair fails, and it fails in an informative way. Each entry on its own is a perfectly legal value, comfortably between minus one and one, but together they sum to nine eighths, which is more than one. The point is outside the circle, so no angle produces both.

The survivors get one extra step, and it is worth copying. Once a pair passes the test, its signs tell you which quadrant the angle is in: negative first with positive second means quadrant two. Passing the identity check and naming the quadrant together are all the information a cosine and sine pair carries.

43. Which pairs could be a cosine and a sine?

Discrimination

Sort into buckets

Square both entries and add. Sort each pair by whether some angle has that cosine and that sine.

possible
(3/5, 4/5); (0, −1); (−√2/2, √2/2); (−1/2, −√3/2)
impossible
(1/2, 1/2); (1, 0.1)
yes
Each of these squares and adds to exactly 1: 9/25 + 16/25, 0 + 1, 1/2 + 1/2, and 1/4 + 3/4. Every one is a genuine point of the unit circle, so every one belongs to some angle.
no
(1/2, 1/2) gives 1/4 + 1/4 = 1/2, which is less than one, so the point is inside the circle. (1, 0.1) gives 1 + 0.01 = 1.01, just outside it; a cosine of exactly 1 forces the sine to be 0, with no room left over.

Sort all six before checking. The work is the same every time: square both entries, add, and compare with one.

The two impossible ones fail in opposite directions. One half and one half give only one half, so that point is inside the circle, too close to the origin. The other gives slightly more than one, so it is just outside.

That second one deserves a look, because it is subtle. A cosine of exactly one is legal on its own, but it forces the point to the extreme right of the circle, which is the single point where the sine is zero. There is no room left over for a sine of a tenth. Extreme values of one coordinate leave no freedom in the other, which is the picture from the dashed square earlier in the lesson.

44. Find the error: squaring the angle instead of the value

Error analysis

Annotate

On: \( \cos^2(\theta) + \sin^2(\theta) = \cos(\theta^2) + \sin(\theta^2) = 1 \)

  • The exponent has been slid from outside the function to inside it, turning the square of a value into the value at a squared angle. These are different numbers.
  • Take θ = π. Then cos²(π) + sin²(π) = (−1)² + 0² = 1, correct. But cos(π²) + sin(π²) uses π² ≈ 9.87 radians, giving about −0.90 + (−0.43) ≈ −1.33. Not 1.
  • The notation invites it: cos²(θ) genuinely looks like an exponent attached to the angle. Read it as (cos θ)² every single time and the temptation disappears.
  • When a squared trigonometric value appears in your own working, write the brackets out in full at least once. The book warns about this convention for exactly this reason.

Look at the line and try to name the illegal move before revealing the annotations. Both sides claim to equal one, and one of them genuinely does, which is part of what makes the error hard to see.

The move is sliding the exponent from outside the function to inside it. The square of the cosine and the cosine of the squared angle are simply different numbers, and the counterexample in the second annotation shows how different: at pi the first is one and the second is about minus one and a third.

The notation is what invites the mistake, and the book warns about exactly this. Your protection is to read the squared form as the value in brackets, squared, every single time, and to write the brackets out in full in your own working whenever the expression is doing real work.

45. Slide the cosine and read the sine off the identity

Tweak it

Parameter explorer

The slider sets the cosine. The horizontal line's height is the positive option for the sine, given by the identity; the negative option is that line reflected below the axis. Slide the cosine towards plus or minus one and watch the sine collapse — and note that the quadrant, not the slider, decides which of the two signs you would report.

\[ \sin(\theta) = \pm\sqrt{1 - ({c})^{2}} \]

  • c — from -1 to 1: cosine of theta

Move the slider slowly from one end to the other and watch the height of the line. That height is the positive option for the sine; the negative option is the same line reflected below the horizontal axis, and the identity is equally happy with either.

Two things should stand out. When the cosine is at zero the line is at its highest, so the sine is at its largest size, plus or minus one. As the cosine moves towards either extreme the line drops to the axis, so the sine is squeezed to zero. The two values trade off against each other, and the total of their squares stays fixed at one.

Notice what the slider cannot do. It has no control that chooses between the line above the axis and its reflection below, because nothing in the identity makes that choice. That control is the quadrant, and it lives outside the algebra entirely.

46. Can an angle have cosine and sine both three quarters?

Counterexample

Discussion prompt

Someone claims there is an angle whose cosine and sine are both three quarters, reasoning that three quarters is between minus one and one, so it is a legal value for each. Decide whether they are right, and say precisely which condition their reasoning left out.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 720 — Theorem 10.1 as a constraint on pairs

Write your answer before revealing, and make sure you answer the second half of the question too, because that is where the learning is.

The claim fails, and the arithmetic is quick: nine sixteenths twice is nine eighths, which is more than one, so the point lies outside the circle. But the interesting part is what the faulty reasoning left out. Each value was checked against its own range, and the two ranges are both satisfied.

What was missed is that the two values are not free to be chosen independently. They are the coordinates of one point on one circle, so one constrains the other completely. The only pair with two equal positive entries is root two over two twice, at forty-five degrees, which you derived earlier in the lesson.

47. Recovering the missing value

Section

Part 6

48. The identity narrows it to two; the quadrant picks one

Concept

Figure (svg): The unit circle cut by the horizontal line at height three fifths. The line meets the circle at two points, one in the first quadrant at four fifths comma three fifths and one in the second quadrant at minus four fifths comma three fifths, with a ray drawn to each.

The identity finds both crossings at once; it has no way of telling them apart. Naming the quadrant is what discards one of the two and leaves a single answer.

This is the standard problem of the section: one of the two values is given, together with enough information to say which quadrant the terminal side is in, and the other value is wanted.

  1. Substitute the known value into the identity and solve for the square of the unknown one.
  2. Take both square roots. Write the plus-or-minus down; do not skip it.
  3. Name the quadrant and read off the sign of the coordinate you are after.
  4. Discard the other root and state the single answer.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 720 — the discussion before Example 10.2.2

This is the standard exam problem of the section, and the figure is the whole reason it works the way it does. A horizontal line at the given height cuts the circle twice, giving two candidate points.

Those two candidates are mirror images across the vertical axis. They share the same second coordinate, which is why the given sine cannot tell them apart, and their first coordinates are negatives of each other, which is exactly the plus-or-minus that the identity will hand you.

So read the four steps as two halves. The first two steps are algebra and produce a size with two possible signs. The last two are geometry and choose one. Keeping those halves separate in your written work is what makes it obvious, to you and to a marker, that you knew there was a choice to be made.

49. Example 10.2.2(1): quadrant two, sine three fifths

Worked example

\[ \theta \text{ in Quadrant II with } \sin(\theta) = \frac35. \quad \text{Find } \cos(\theta). \]

Substitute the known value into the identity

Why: The sine is given, so its square is known.

\[ \cos^2(\theta) + \left(\frac35\right)^2 = 1 \]

Isolate the square of the cosine

Why: Nine twenty-fifths taken from twenty-five twenty-fifths.

\[ \cos^2(\theta) = 1 - \frac{9}{25} = \frac{16}{25} \]

Take both square roots

Why: The square root of sixteen twenty-fifths is four fifths, with either sign.

\[ \cos(\theta) = \pm\frac45 \]

Use the quadrant to choose

Why: In quadrant two the points lie to the left of the vertical axis, so first coordinates are negative.

\[ \theta \in \text{II} \;\Longrightarrow\; \cos(\theta) < 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \cos(\theta) = -\frac45 \]

Check the pair on the circle and in the quadrant

Why: Sixteen twenty-fifths plus nine twenty-fifths is one, so the point is on the circle; and minus four fifths with plus three fifths is left of the axis and above it, which is quadrant two.

\[ \left(-\tfrac45\right)^2 + \left(\tfrac35\right)^2 = \tfrac{16}{25} + \tfrac{9}{25} = 1 \;\checkmark \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 720 — Example 10.2.2 part 1

The book's own example, and the model for every problem of this shape. Notice that the given sine is used only in its squared form, which is the first hint that its sign will not survive into the answer.

The third step is the one to write out even when you can see the answer. Sixteen twenty-fifths has two square roots, plus and minus four fifths, and the algebra has no preference between them. Writing the plus-or-minus is what forces you to go and look at the quadrant.

Quadrant two is to the left of the vertical axis, so the first coordinate is negative and the cosine is minus four fifths. The check does two jobs: it confirms the pair lies on the circle, and it confirms the pair lies in the quadrant you were given, since minus four fifths is left and plus three fifths is up. Both halves of the answer get verified.

50. Example 10.2.2(2): the quadrant given as an inequality

Worked example

This time the quadrant is not named. It is described by an inequality, and the first job is to translate it.

\[ \pi < \theta < \frac{3\pi}{2} \text{ with } \cos(\theta) = -\frac{\sqrt5}{5}. \quad \text{Find } \sin(\theta). \]

Translate the inequality into a quadrant

Why: Pi is half a revolution and three pi over two is three quarters, so the terminal side is between them.

\[ \pi < \theta < \frac{3\pi}{2} \;\Longrightarrow\; \theta \in \text{Quadrant III} \]

Figure (svg): The unit circle with the arc from pi to three pi over two shaded in, showing the third quadrant, and inside it a ray to the point whose first coordinate is about minus zero point four five and whose second is about minus zero point eight nine.

The inequality names an arc, and the whole arc lies in the third quadrant, where both coordinates are negative. That is all the sign information the problem needs.

Square the given cosine

Why: Root five over five is the same as one over root five, whose square is one fifth.

\[ \cos^2(\theta) = \left(-\frac{\sqrt5}{5}\right)^2 = \frac{5}{25} = \frac15 \]

Substitute into the identity and isolate

Why: One fifth taken from one leaves four fifths.

\[ \sin^2(\theta) = 1 - \frac15 = \frac45 \]

Take both roots and rationalise

Why: The square root of four fifths is two over root five; multiply top and bottom by root five.

\[ \sin(\theta) = \pm\frac{2}{\sqrt5} = \pm\frac{2\sqrt5}{5} \]

Use the quadrant to choose

Why: In quadrant three both coordinates are negative, so the sine is the negative root.

\[ \sin(\theta) = -\frac{2\sqrt5}{5} \]

Check numerically and on the circle

Why: One fifth plus four fifths is one; and as decimals the pair is about minus 0.447 and minus 0.894, both negative, which is quadrant three.

\[ \frac15 + \frac45 = 1, \qquad \cos(\theta) \approx -0.447, \; \sin(\theta) \approx -0.894 \;\checkmark \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 720 — Example 10.2.2 part 2

The only new thing here is the first step, and it is the step people skip. The problem does not name a quadrant, it describes an arc, and you have to translate.

Pi is half a revolution and three pi over two is three quarters of one, so the angle lies strictly between them, in the arc drawn in red in the figure. That whole arc is the third quadrant, where both coordinates are negative, and that is all the sign information you need.

The rest is the same procedure with slightly heavier arithmetic. Root five over five is one over root five, whose square is one fifth, so the sine squared is four fifths and the sine is two over root five in size. Rationalising gives two root five over five, and the quadrant makes it negative. The decimal check at the end, about minus 0.447 and minus 0.894, confirms both signs and both sizes at once.

51. Example 10.2.2(3): a sine equal to one

Worked example

The third part looks too easy to be worth writing down, and the reason it is easy is worth noticing.

\[ \sin(\theta) = 1. \quad \text{Find } \cos(\theta). \]

Substitute into the identity

Why: The sine is one, so its square is one.

\[ \cos^2(\theta) + 1^2 = 1 \]

Isolate the square of the cosine

Why: One taken from one.

\[ \cos^2(\theta) = 0 \]

Take the square root

Why: Zero has only one square root, so no quadrant information is needed at all.

\[ \cos(\theta) = 0 \]

Say why no quadrant was required

Why: A sine of one forces the point to the very top of the circle, which is a single point and not an arc, so there is nothing left to choose.

\[ \sin(\theta) = 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; P = (0, 1) \]

Check against the quadrantal table

Why: The point at the top of the circle belongs to ninety degrees, where the table already recorded a cosine of zero and a sine of one.

\[ 0^2 + 1^2 = 1, \qquad \theta = \frac{\pi}{2} + 2\pi k \;\checkmark \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 720 — Example 10.2.2 part 3

This part looks trivial, and the reason it is trivial is the point of including it. Work through it and then ask why no quadrant was needed.

The identity leaves the cosine squared equal to zero, and zero is the one number with a single square root. So there is no plus-or-minus to resolve, and the quadrant never enters the problem.

Geometrically that is the picture from early in the lesson: a sine of one forces the point to the very top of the circle, and the top of the circle is one point, not an arc. Whenever a given value is at the extreme of its range, the other value is pinned down with no extra information, because there is no second candidate to rule out.

52. Translate each condition into a quadrant

Matching

Match the pairs

  • a. π/2 < θ < π
  • b. π < θ < 3π/2
  • c. 2π < θ < 5π/2
  • d. −π/2 < θ < 0
  • e. cos θ < 0 and sin θ < 0
  • p. Quadrant I
  • q. Quadrant II
  • r. Quadrant III
  • s. Quadrant IV, reached clockwise
  • t. Quadrant III again, described by signs

Why: Two of these need care. The interval from 2π to 5π/2 is a full revolution past the interval from 0 to π/2, so it is quadrant I reached the long way round; subtracting 2π from both ends makes that obvious. And a negative angle between −π/2 and 0 sweeps clockwise into quadrant IV. The last item is the same quadrant as the second one, arrived at from the signs rather than from an interval.

Match all five before checking. Three are direct, and two are designed to catch a habit.

The interval from two pi to five pi over two is the one that catches people, because both endpoints are bigger than a revolution. Subtract a revolution from both ends and it becomes the interval from zero to pi over two, which is plainly quadrant one. Coterminal angles land in the same quadrant, so nothing is lost by shifting like that.

The negative interval is the other one to watch. Angles between minus pi over two and zero sweep clockwise from the positive horizontal axis, dropping into quadrant four. And the last item shows that a pair of sign conditions carries exactly the same information as an interval: both coordinates negative is quadrant three, however you were told it.

53. Trap: taking the positive root and moving on

Trap

The trap

Quadrant three, with a sine of minus two thirds. Find the cosine:

\[ \cos^2(\theta) = 1 - \frac49 = \frac59 \]

\[ \cos(\theta) = \frac{\sqrt5}{3}? \]

Wrong sign. The square root symbol gave one root; the equation has two.

The fix

Solving a squared equation always produces a plus-or-minus. Quadrant three is to the left of the vertical axis, so the first coordinate is negative.

\[ \cos(\theta) = \pm\frac{\sqrt5}{3} \]

\[ \cos(\theta) = -\frac{\sqrt5}{3} \]

Write the plus-or-minus line down every time, even when you are sure. It is the line that forces you to look at the quadrant, and the quadrant is the only place the sign can come from.

This is the single most expensive habit on this material, and it is expensive because the working looks complete. Every line is correct except that one root went missing.

The root symbol denotes the non-negative root of a number, but the equation you are solving is about a square, and a square equation has two solutions. Those are different statements, and conflating them is what drops the sign.

So write the plus-or-minus line down every time, even when you are confident. It is not a formality: it is the line that makes you stop and look at the quadrant, and the quadrant is the only place in the entire problem where the sign can possibly come from. Here quadrant three puts the point left of the vertical axis, so the cosine is negative.

54. Before you touch the identity

Step zero

\[ \sin(\theta) = -\frac{7}{25}, \quad \theta \text{ in Quadrant IV}. \quad \text{Find } \cos(\theta). \]

Discussion prompt

Do not solve this yet. Write down, in advance, the sign of the answer and a one-line reason, and predict roughly how big it will be. Then say what would have changed if the quadrant had been three instead.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2.2, p. 736 — Exercise 21

Answer in writing before revealing, and answer both parts. Deciding the sign in advance is a technique, not a formality: once you have committed to positive, a slip in the algebra cannot quietly talk you into a negative answer.

Quadrant four is right of the vertical axis and below the horizontal one, so the first coordinate is positive. That fixes the sign. For the size, notice that the given sine is small, only about 0.28, so the point is close to the horizontal axis and far out to the side, which means the cosine must be close to one. When the answer comes out as 0.96, it matches the prediction.

The second part of the question is the one that shows you understand the structure. Moving to quadrant three would change nothing at all in the algebra, because squaring cannot see a sign, and it would flip only the final sign. Size from the identity, sign from the picture, every time.

55. Exercise 26: a cosine of 28 over 53

Worked example

An exercise from the end of the section. The fractions look unfriendly and come out perfectly.

\[ \cos(\theta) = \frac{28}{53} \text{ with } \theta \text{ in Quadrant IV}. \quad \text{Find } \sin(\theta). \]

Square the given value

Why: Twenty-eight squared is 784 and fifty-three squared is 2809.

\[ \cos^2(\theta) = \frac{784}{2809} \]

Substitute into the identity

Why: Write the one as 2809 over 2809 so the subtraction can be done.

\[ \sin^2(\theta) = \frac{2809}{2809} - \frac{784}{2809} = \frac{2025}{2809} \]

Take both square roots

Why: Both 2025 and 2809 are perfect squares: 45 squared and 53 squared.

\[ \sin(\theta) = \pm\frac{45}{53} \]

Use the quadrant to choose

Why: Quadrant four is below the horizontal axis, so the second coordinate is negative.

\[ \sin(\theta) = -\frac{45}{53} \]

Check the pair, and notice the triple

Why: 784 plus 2025 is 2809, so the identity holds exactly; 28, 45, 53 is a Pythagorean triple, which is why the exercise came out in whole numbers.

\[ 28^2 + 45^2 = 784 + 2025 = 2809 = 53^2 \;\checkmark \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2.2, p. 736 — Exercise 26

The fractions here look intimidating and they come out perfectly, which is a hint about how the exercise was built. Push through the arithmetic and look at the numbers at the end.

The procedure is unchanged: square, subtract from one written with the same denominator, take both roots, choose with the quadrant. The only thing that needs care is remembering that the denominator gets squared too, so the common denominator is 2809 and not 53.

Then look at the check. Twenty-eight, forty-five and fifty-three form a Pythagorean triple, which is exactly why the square root came out whole. Recognising a triple in a problem like this is a genuine time-saver, and the common ones worth knowing are three-four-five, five-twelve-thirteen, eight-fifteen-seventeen and seven-twenty-four-twenty-five.

56. Exercise 22: when the answer is not a nice fraction

Worked example

Most of the time the square root does not simplify, and that is not a sign of a mistake.

\[ \cos(\theta) = \frac49 \text{ with } \theta \text{ in Quadrant I}. \quad \text{Find } \sin(\theta). \]

Square and substitute

Why: Four ninths squared is sixteen eighty-firsts.

\[ \sin^2(\theta) = 1 - \frac{16}{81} = \frac{65}{81} \]

Take both square roots

Why: Eighty-one is a perfect square; sixty-five is not, and it has no square factors, so the root stays.

\[ \sin(\theta) = \pm\frac{\sqrt{65}}{9} \]

Use the quadrant to choose

Why: Quadrant one is above the horizontal axis, so the second coordinate is positive.

\[ \sin(\theta) = \frac{\sqrt{65}}{9} \]

Check the size against the picture

Why: Root sixty-five is about 8.06, so the sine is about 0.896, bigger than the cosine of about 0.444: the point is high up and only a little to the right, which is what a first coordinate of four ninths should give.

\[ \frac{\sqrt{65}}{9} \approx 0.8958, \qquad \left(\frac49\right)^2 + \frac{65}{81} = \frac{16 + 65}{81} = 1 \;\checkmark \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2.2, p. 736 — Exercise 22

Most problems of this type do not come from a Pythagorean triple, and their answers contain a square root that will not simplify. That is normal and is not a signal that you have gone wrong.

Sixty-five factors as five times thirteen, with no repeated factor, so nothing comes out of the root. Leave it as root sixty-five over nine and resist the urge to turn it into a decimal unless the question asks you to.

The check is where the real skill is. Root sixty-five is a bit over eight, so the sine is about 0.896, while the cosine is four ninths, about 0.444. The sine is much the larger of the two, so the point is high up and only slightly to the right, which is a steep first-quadrant angle. Confirming that the shape of the answer matches the shape of the picture is worth more than re-checking the algebra.

57. Exercise 29: a decimal, and a decimal check

Worked example

The same procedure when the given value is a decimal. Nothing changes except that the check becomes approximate.

\[ \sin(\theta) = -0.42 \text{ with } \pi < \theta < \frac{3\pi}{2}. \quad \text{Find } \cos(\theta). \]

Translate the inequality

Why: Between half a revolution and three quarters of one is quadrant three.

\[ \pi < \theta < \frac{3\pi}{2} \;\Longrightarrow\; \theta \in \text{Quadrant III} \]

Square and substitute

Why: Forty-two hundredths squared is 0.1764.

\[ \cos^2(\theta) = 1 - 0.1764 = 0.8236 \]

Take both square roots

Why: The square root of 0.8236 is about 0.907524.

\[ \cos(\theta) \approx \pm 0.907524 \]

Use the quadrant to choose

Why: Both coordinates are negative in quadrant three.

\[ \cos(\theta) \approx -0.9075 \]

Check by squaring back

Why: Squaring and adding recovers one to four decimal places, and the tiny shortfall is only the rounding in the fourth decimal place, not an error.

\[ (-0.9075)^2 + (-0.42)^2 = 0.823556 + 0.1764 = 0.999956 \approx 1 \;\checkmark \]

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2.2, p. 736 — Exercise 29

Nothing about the method changes when the data is decimal, but one thing about the check does, and this example exists to make that comfortable.

Work through it as usual: translate the inequality into quadrant three, square the given sine, subtract from one, take both roots, and let the quadrant make the cosine negative. The arithmetic is calculator work, and you should keep more decimal places in the middle than you intend to report.

Now read the check. Squaring the rounded answers and adding gives 0.999956, not exactly one. That shortfall is the rounding you introduced in the fourth decimal place, and nothing else. Learning to recognise a rounding residue as harmless, rather than hunting for a mistake that is not there, is part of working with decimals.

58. Only one of these conclusions survives

Two truths and a lie

Eliminate the wrong options

An angle has sine equal to negative twelve thirteenths and lies in quadrant three. Four conclusions are offered; strike out the three that fail.

  • A. cos θ = 5/13
  • B. cos θ = −5/13
  • C. cos θ = ±5/13
  • D. cos θ = −1/13

Survives elimination: B

Why: The identity gives cosine squared equal to 1 − 144/169 = 25/169, so the size is five thirteenths. Quadrant three makes the first coordinate negative, so the cosine is minus five thirteenths. The pair (−5/13, −12/13) squares and adds to 25/169 + 144/169 = 1, and both entries are negative, as quadrant three requires.

Strike out three and keep one, and make sure you can say what is wrong with each of the three rather than just which one looks right.

Two of the wrong answers are wrong in instructive ways. The plus-or-minus option is the correct middle line of the working, and it is the thing you should have written down, but it is not an answer: the quadrant was given so that exactly one root could be discarded. The other is a sign error, correct in size and wrong in side.

The fourth option comes from subtracting the given value from one instead of subtracting its square. If you were tempted, reread the identity: everything in it is squared. The surviving answer, minus five thirteenths, squares and adds with minus twelve thirteenths to exactly one, and both entries are negative, which is what quadrant three demands.

59. Putting it together

Section

Part 7

60. Pattern: finding a cosine and a sine

Pattern

Figure (svg): A flow diagram. From the starting question, whether the terminal side lies on an axis, one branch reads the point straight off the axis and the other splits again: if one value is already known use the Pythagorean identity, otherwise drop a perpendicular and use the special triangle. Both lower branches meet at a final box that fixes the signs from the quadrant.

Two questions decide everything: is the terminal side on an axis, and do you already know one of the two values.
  1. Place the angle in standard position and find where its terminal side meets the unit circle.
  2. On an axis? Read the point off: one of the four pairs with a zero and a one in it. Stop.
  3. One value already given? Substitute it into the identity and solve for the square of the other, then take both roots.
  4. Neither? Drop a perpendicular to the horizontal axis and use the special triangle: equal legs at forty-five degrees, short leg half the hypotenuse at thirty and sixty.
  5. Fix the signs from the quadrant, never from the algebra, and check the pair on the circle.

This is the order to work in, and it runs from cheapest to dearest. Follow the diagram, not the habit of reaching for the identity first.

The first question is free: is the terminal side on an axis? If so you are done in one line, with no algebra at all. The second question is nearly free: is one of the two values already given? If so the identity turns it into the other, up to a sign.

Only if both questions fail do you drop a perpendicular and do geometry. And whichever route you took, the last step is always the same one, and always the one people forget: the size came from geometry or algebra, but the sign comes from the quadrant. Finish by checking the pair on the circle, which costs one line and catches almost every slip.

61. Where the coordinates show up: the tip of a clock hand

Real world

Figure (svg): A clock face drawn as a unit circle with twelve hour marks, and a single hand of length one pointing at the two. The hand makes an angle of thirty degrees with the positive horizontal axis, and its tip is marked at root three over two comma one half.

Hour marks sit thirty degrees apart. Measuring from the 3 rather than the 12 turns a clock reading straight into a standard-position angle, and the tip's position is then just a cosine and a sine.

Discussion prompt

A clock face has a single hand of length one, with its pivot at the origin. The hand points exactly at the 2. Find the coordinates of its tip, and then say what they would be if it pointed at the 8 instead.

Work out the angle before revealing. The trap is to measure from the 12, because that is how clocks are read, and standard position measures from the 3.

The twelve hour marks divide a revolution into twelve, so they sit thirty degrees apart. The 12 is at ninety degrees in standard position, and each hour clockwise subtracts thirty, so the 2 is at ninety minus sixty, which is thirty degrees. The tip is then at root three over two across and one half up, about 0.87 and 0.5.

The second half of the question is the interesting one. The 8 is directly opposite the 2 through the pivot, half a revolution away, so both coordinates simply change sign. You did not need to compute anything for it. That shortcut is the symmetry argument from Part 4, and Lesson 10.2b turns it into a theorem that handles all four quadrants at once.

62. Check: the definition

Check

Check your understanding

The terminal side of an angle meets the unit circle at the point with coordinates minus three fifths and four fifths. What are the cosine and the sine of the angle?

  • A. cos θ = −3/5 and sin θ = 4/5 (correct)
  • B. cos θ = 4/5 and sin θ = −3/5
  • C. cos θ = 3/5 and sin θ = 4/5
  • D. it cannot be decided without knowing the angle

Answer: A

Why: Cosine is the first coordinate of the point and sine is the second, so the values are read off in the order they are written: minus three fifths and four fifths. The point is in quadrant two, which is consistent with a negative cosine and a positive sine.

Why B tempts people
This reverses the pair. Cosine is the horizontal coordinate, which is the first one listed.
Why C tempts people
This drops the minus sign. A point three fifths of a unit to the LEFT of the vertical axis has a negative first coordinate.
Why D tempts people
The point is all the information needed; the definition never asks for the angle itself, and infinitely many coterminal angles share this point anyway.

This question tests one thing: whether you read the pair in the right order and kept the sign. The point is handed to you, so there is nothing to compute.

Cosine is the first coordinate, which here is negative three fifths, and sine is the second, four fifths. The signs are consistent with a point left of the vertical axis and above the horizontal one, which is quadrant two.

The last option is worth dismissing explicitly. You do not need the angle, and you could not find a unique one anyway, because infinitely many coterminal angles share this point. The definition only ever asks for the point.

63. Check: the special values

Check

Check your understanding

Which statement about the five memorised angles is true?

  • A. cos 60° = √3/2
  • B. sin 30° = √3/2
  • C. cos 45° = sin 45° (correct)
  • D. cos 90° = 1

Answer: C

Why: At forty-five degrees the point lies on the line where the two coordinates are equal, so the cosine and the sine are the same number, root two over two. It is the only one of the five angles for which the two values agree.

Why A tempts people
Sixty degrees is a steep angle, so its point is mostly up and only a little across: the cosine is the SMALL value, one half.
Why B tempts people
Thirty degrees is shallow, so the small value one half belongs to the sine; root three over two is its cosine.
Why D tempts people
At ninety degrees the terminal side points straight up, to the point (0, 1). The cosine is the first coordinate, which is zero.

Three of these four options are the same error in different clothes: a value paired with the wrong angle. Test each one against the picture rather than against your memory.

The true statement is the forty-five degree one, and it is true for a reason you proved earlier: the forty-five degree ray lies on the mirror line where the two coordinates are equal. It is the only one of the five angles where the cosine and sine agree.

For the others, sketch the ray. Sixty degrees is steep, so its point is mostly up, so its cosine is the small value. Thirty degrees is shallow, so its sine is the small value. And ninety degrees points straight up, so there is no horizontal displacement and its cosine is zero, not one.

64. Check: recovering the missing value

Check

Check your understanding

An angle in quadrant four has cosine equal to twelve thirteenths. What is its sine?

  • A. 5/13
  • B. −5/13 (correct)
  • C. ±5/13
  • D. 1/13

Answer: B

Why: The identity gives sine squared equal to one minus 144/169, which is 25/169, so the size of the sine is five thirteenths. Quadrant four lies below the horizontal axis, so the second coordinate is negative and the sine is minus five thirteenths.

Why A tempts people
The size is right, but quadrant four is below the horizontal axis, so the sine must be negative.
Why C tempts people
This is the correct middle line of the working, not the answer. The quadrant was supplied precisely so that one of the two roots could be thrown away.
Why D tempts people
This subtracts twelve thirteenths from one instead of subtracting its square from one. The identity involves squares.

Run the four-step procedure. Square the given value, subtract from one, take both roots, and let the quadrant choose.

One minus 144 over 169 is 25 over 169, so the size of the sine is five thirteenths. Quadrant four lies below the horizontal axis, so the second coordinate is negative, and the answer is minus five thirteenths.

The two tempting wrong answers are the ones to learn from. Five thirteenths is right in size and wrong in sign, which is the plus-or-minus trap. The plus-or-minus option is an honest middle line rather than a final answer. If you were drawn to either, the fix is the same: write the plus-or-minus, then write a sentence naming the quadrant, then write the answer.

65. Explain the plus-or-minus

Explain it to yourself

Discussion prompt

In two or three sentences, explain to someone a year behind you why the Pythagorean identity can never, on its own, finish a problem of the form 'given the sine, find the cosine', and what has to be added to finish it. Use the picture, not the algebra, in your explanation.

Write your two or three sentences before revealing, and keep to the picture as instructed. If you find yourself writing about square roots having two values, you are explaining the algebra rather than the geometry, and the geometric version is the one that will stick.

The geometric version is this: the identity is the equation of the circle, and a horizontal line at a given height meets a circle twice. The two crossing points are mirror images across the vertical axis, so they agree about the sine and disagree about the sign of the cosine. The identity is satisfied by both, equally.

What completes the problem is anything that names which crossing you want: a quadrant, an inequality on the angle, the sign of the other value, even a sketch. Being able to say this cleanly is a good sign you understand why the procedure has the shape it does, rather than just remembering the shape.

66. Exit ticket

Exit ticket

\[ \sin(\theta) = -\frac{15}{17}, \quad \frac{3\pi}{2} < \theta < 2\pi \]

Discussion prompt

Name the quadrant, find the cosine exactly, confirm your pair with the identity, and finally write down the cosine and sine of the angle that is one full revolution larger than this one.

This pulls the whole lesson into one problem, and there are four separate things to produce, so work through them in order rather than jumping to the number.

The interval runs from three quarters of a revolution to a full one, so the terminal side is in quadrant four, where the first coordinate is positive. One minus 225 over 289 is 64 over 289, so the cosine is eight seventeenths, positive. The check confirms the pair sits on the circle.

The final part is the one that shows you got the big idea rather than just the procedure. Adding a whole revolution does not move the terminal side at all, so the new angle is coterminal and its cosine and sine are identical, with no recomputation. If you recomputed instead of saying that, the lesson's central point about position is worth rereading.

67. Recap

Recap

the situationwhat to dowhat decides the sign
terminal side on an axisread the point off the axisnothing to decide: the values are 0 and ±1
one of the five special anglesuse the table, or rebuild it from the trianglequadrant I, so both values positive
one value given, plus a quadrantsubstitute into cos² + sin² = 1, take both rootsthe quadrant, read off the picture
two angles differing by a revolutionnothing: they are coterminalidentical values, same point

\[ P = \big(\cos(\theta), \sin(\theta)\big), \qquad \cos^2(\theta) + \sin^2(\theta) = 1 \]

Next, Lesson 10.2b turns the symmetry you noticed in Part 4 into the Reference Angle Theorem, so that the five values in the table generate every special point on the circle, with the quadrant supplying the signs.

Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine §10.2, p. 722 — Cosine and Sine Values of Common Angles

OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §7.3 Unit Circle §7.3 — the same definition and table in the second source

Four situations and four responses, and every one of them comes out of a single sentence: the cosine and the sine of an angle are the two coordinates of the point where its terminal side meets the circle of radius one.

The one thing to keep at your fingertips is the split between size and sign. Geometry or the identity gives you the size; only the quadrant, read off the picture, gives you the sign. That split is where nearly all the lost marks on this material live, and writing the plus-or-minus line explicitly is the habit that protects it.

Next comes the payoff for the symmetry you noticed in Part 4. Lesson 10.2b names the acute angle a terminal side makes with the horizontal axis, calls it the reference angle, and proves that its cosine and sine give the sizes of the values for the original angle. From then on the five-row table generates every exact value in the chapter.

Sources

  1. Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Ch. 10 Foundations of Trigonometry — §10.2 The Unit Circle: Cosine and Sine — Stitz & Zeager, College Trigonometry, Version 3 Corrected Edition, July 4 2013, pp. 717-722
  2. OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §7.3 Unit Circle

Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Trigonometry — $55/session, free consultation.

Book on Wyzant · Text (657) 465-8108