3.1 Terminology

Count probabilities from pictures of equally likely outcomes, read probability as a long-run relative frequency, combine events with OR, AND and complements, and shrink the sample space to find conditional probabilities.

Subject: Statistics · 65 slides · applied lesson

Open the interactive version of this deck

What this lesson covers

The lesson, slide by slide

1. Probability Terminology

Title

Statistics · §3.1

Outcomes, events, OR, AND and news, each counted from a picture

2. You will leave able to do these five things

Objectives

  1. List a sample space and an event
  2. Find a chance by counting equal outcomes
  3. Read probability as a long-run share
  4. Combine events with OR, AND and not
  5. Find a chance once some news arrives

3. Eight rules from earlier courses carry every step

Concept

\[ \frac{u}{v} = \frac{u \div w}{v \div w} \]

Scale

Why: same value, cut into new parts

\[ \frac{u}{w} + \frac{v}{w} = \frac{u + v}{w} \]

Like fractions

Why: parts of one size add up

\[ \frac{w}{w} = 1 \]

Whole

Why: w equal parts make one

\[ \frac{u / w}{v / w} = \frac{u}{v} \]

Shared bottoms

Why: the common w cancels

\[ u \times v \text{ cells} \]

Grid count

Why: rows times columns, each pair once

\[ \text{count} \div \text{total} \]

Relative frequency

Why: a value's data share

\[ u\% = u \div 100 \]

Percent

Why: parts per hundred

\[ 2 \div 3 \approx 0.67 \]

Round

Why: ≈ marks a cut-off decimal

4. A friend peeks at two tossed coins and reports one fact

Prediction

Predict first

A friend peeks at a tossed dime and nickel: 'at least one is heads.'

Is both heads now a 50-50?

  • No: less than one half
  • Yes: exactly one half
  • No: more than one half

Correct: No: less than one half

Why: Calling 'the other coin' a 50-50 pretends we know which coin showed heads, and the friend never said. The deck builds a way to count chances with news, then comes back for the exact answer.

5. Two tossed coins can land in four different ways

Worked example

Figure (svg): A 2 by 2 grid of the two coins' outcomes: rows are the dime's H and T, columns the nickel's H and T, cells still empty

H: heads, T: tails. HT: dime H, nickel T.

\[ \text{dime: } H,\ T \]

List the dime's faces

Why: they label the grid's rows

\[ \text{nickel: } H,\ T \]

List the nickel's faces

Why: columns, each pairing with both

\[ 2 \times 2 = 4 \]

Count rows times columns

Why: each dime face meets each nickel

Figure (svg): A 2 by 2 grid of the two coins' outcomes: rows are the dime's H and T, columns the nickel's H and T, cells HH, HT, TH, TT

\[ HH,\ HT,\ TH,\ TT \]

Check: read every cell aloud

Why: four pairings, none repeated or missing

6. Count outcomes: sample spaces and events

Section

Idea 1 of 4

7. A board game moves you ahead on a roll of 5 or 6

Concept

Figure (svg): The six faces of one fair die as plain cells 1 to 6

Roll one fair die: a 5 or a 6 moves you ahead.

Discussion prompt

What single number could say how likely a move ahead is, before you roll?

Answer:

List every face the die can show, then weigh the winning faces against all of them.

8. Counting 2 winning faces cannot tell a six-sided die from a ten-sided one

Worked example

Figure (svg): Two dice as cell strips: a six-sided die 1 to 6 with 5 and 6 shaded blue; the ten-sided die's strip not drawn yet

\[ \text{six-sided: } \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5, 6} \to \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2} \text{ wins} \]

Count the six-sided die's wins

Why: the obvious measure of chance

\[ \text{ten-sided: } \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{9, 10} \to \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2} \text{ wins} \]

Count a ten-sided die's top two

Why: can counts compare two dice?

Figure (svg): Two dice as cell strips: a six-sided die 1 to 6 with 5 and 6 shaded blue; a ten-sided die 1 to 10 with 9 and 10 shaded blue

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2} \]

Compare the two win counts

Why: the test counts must pass

\[ 6 - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2} = 4,\ \ 10 - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2} = 8 \]

Check: count each die's losers

Why: same wins, spread over more faces

9. The die's outcomes form a sample space S, and the wins form an event E

Worked example

Figure (svg): The six faces of one fair die as plain cells 1 to 6

Experiment: one roll. Outcome: the face that shows.

\[ S = \{1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6\} \]

Collect every outcome as S

Why: a sample space misses no result

\[ E = \{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5}, \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6}\} \]

Collect the winning outcomes as E

Why: an event: any set of outcomes

Figure (svg): The six faces of one fair die as cells 1 to 6, with 5 and 6 shaded blue as the event E

\[ 6 \text{ in } S,\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2} \text{ in } E \]

Count both sets

Why: weighing needs whole and part

\[ \{1, 2, 3, 4\}\colon\ 4 + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2} = 6 \]

Check: add the losers to E

Why: no face is missed or doubled

10. Sharing a certain chance of 1 among six equal faces gives E two sixths

Worked example

Figure (svg): The six faces of one fair die as cells 1 to 6, with 5 and 6 shaded blue as the event E

\[ P(S) = 1 \]

Score S's chance, P(S), as 1

Why: some face must show

\[ 1 \div 6 = \frac{1}{6} \]

Share 1 among the 6 faces

Why: fair: equally likely faces, equal shares

Figure (svg): The six faces of one fair die, each labelled with its share 1/6

\[ P(E) = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{\frac{1}{6} + \frac{1}{6}} \]

Collect face 5's and 6's shares

Why: an event gathers its outcomes' chances

Figure (svg): The six faces of one fair die, each labelled with its share 1/6, with 5 and 6 shaded blue

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{\frac{1}{6} + \frac{1}{6}} = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2}}{6} \]

Add like fractions

Why: the win needs one single number

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2}}{6} + \frac{4}{6} = 1 \]

Check: add the four losing shares

Why: E and the losers rebuild certainty

11. With equally likely outcomes, a chance is the event's count over S's count

Worked example

Figure (svg): The six faces of one fair die as cells 1 to 6, with 5 and 6 shaded blue as the event E

\( {P(S) = 1}\;\;\Rightarrow\;\;\allowbreak {\dfrac{1}{6} \text{ per face}}\;\;\Rightarrow\;\;\allowbreak {P(E) = \dfrac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2}}{6}} \)

\[ P(E) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2 \text{ in } E}}{6 \text{ in } S} \]

Read 2 and 6 as counts

Why: each E face brings one sixth

Figure (svg): The six faces of one fair die with 5 and 6 shaded blue; below: 2 blue cells in E, 6 cells in S

\[ P(A) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{\text{outcomes in } A}}{\text{outcomes in } S} \]

Replace E by any event A

Why: any S whose outcomes share equally

Equally likely: every outcome has the same chance.

\[ A = S\colon\ \frac{6}{6} = 1 \]

Check: let A be all of S

Why: a certain event must score 1

12. Every probability lies between 0 for never and 1 for always

Worked example

Figure (svg): The die strip with 5 and 6 shaded blue above an empty chance scale marked 0 and 1

\[ \text{face } 7\colon\ 0 \text{ outcomes} \]

Count the faces showing 7

Why: an event no roll can give

\[ \frac{0}{6} = \textcolor{#6b7280}{0} \]

Divide 0 by 6

Why: an impossible event scores 0

Figure (svg): The die strip above a chance scale from 0 to 1, with a grey dot at 0 labelled never

\[ \text{faces 1 to 6: } \frac{6}{6} = \textcolor{#6b7280}{1} \]

Divide all 6 faces by 6

Why: a certain event scores 1

Figure (svg): The chance scale with grey dots at 0, never, and 1, always

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{0} \le P(A) \le \textcolor{#6b7280}{1} \]

Place every event between

Why: counts run from none to all

Figure (svg): The chance scale with the whole stretch from 0 to 1 shaded grey between never and always

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{0} \le \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2}}{6} \le \textcolor{#6b7280}{1} \]

Check the win chance sits inside

Why: a real event must land inside

Figure (svg): The shaded chance scale with a blue dot at 2/6, a third of the way from 0 to 1

13. Exactly one head on a dime and a nickel has chance 2/4 = 0.5

Worked example

Figure (svg): A 2 by 2 grid of the two coins' outcomes: rows are the dime's H and T, columns the nickel's H and T, cells HH, HT, TH, TT

\[ S = \{HH, HT, TH, TT\} \]

Read S off the grid

Why: fair coins, four equal cells

\[ A = \{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{HT}, \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{TH}\} \]

Shade the one-head cells

Why: marks the cells to count

Figure (svg): A 2 by 2 grid of the two coins' outcomes: rows are the dime's H and T, columns the nickel's H and T, cells HH, HT, TH, TT

\[ P(A) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2}}{4} \]

Divide A's count by 4

Why: fair coins: equal cells

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2}}{4} = 0.5 \]

Divide 2 by 4

Why: 0.5 reads as even odds

\[ HH,\ TT\colon\ 2 \text{ unshaded of } 4 \]

Check: count cells outside A

Why: 0.5 must mean half the cells

14. Head counts are not equally likely, so 1/3 is wrong

Trap

The trap

\[ \{0 \text{ H},\ 1 \text{ H},\ 2 \text{ H}\} \]

List head counts as outcomes

Why: a tempting shorter list

\[ P(1 \text{ H}) = \frac{1}{3} \]

Give each head count 1/3

Why: treats them as equally likely

\[ \frac{1}{3} \ne \frac{2}{4} \]

Compare with the grid

Why: fails: one head fills two cells

The fix

Figure (svg): The four coin cells HH, HT, TH, TT in a row, with HT and TH shaded blue

\[ P(1 \text{ H}) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2}}{4} \]

Count one-head cells over 4

Why: only cells are equally likely

\[ \frac{1}{4} + \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2}}{4} + \frac{1}{4} = 1 \]

Check: shares of 2, 1, 0 heads

Why: the grid's cells, each counted once

15. Tomorrow can only bring rain or no rain

Prediction

Predict first

Tomorrow it either rains or stays dry: two outcomes.

Does that make the chance of rain one half?

  • No: the two outcomes need not be equally likely
  • Yes: rain is one of two outcomes
  • Yes, but only when no forecast exists

Correct: No: the two outcomes need not be equally likely

Why: The counting rule shares 1 equally only among equally likely outcomes. Rain and dry are two outcomes, but nothing makes them equal: a spinner with one rain slice and three dry slices also has just two outcomes.

16. One rain slice of four gives rain 1/4, not 1/2

Worked example

Figure (svg): A spinner cut into two halves labelled rain and dry: the naive two-outcome view

Spinner model: 4 equal slices, 1 rain.

\[ S = \{\text{rain},\ \text{dry}\} \]

List the two outcomes

Why: lists need no equal chances

\[ \text{rain: } \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1} \text{ slice},\ \text{dry: } 3 \text{ slices} \]

Sort the 4 slices

Why: slices are the equal units

Figure (svg): A spinner cut into four equal slices: one rain slice shaded blue and three dry slices

\[ P(\text{rain}) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{4} \]

Divide rain slices by 4

Why: equal units license counting

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{4} + \frac{3}{4} = 1 \]

Check: add the dry share

Why: every slice is rain or dry

17. Try It 3.2's number from 1 to 10 leaves the event and its chance to you

Faded example

Figure (svg): The numbers 1 to 10 as plain cells

Try It 3.2: pick a number from 1 to 10 at random.

Fill in the blanks

A = more than 6 holds 7, 8, 9, 10; P(A) = 4/10

Why: S has the 10 numbers. More than 6 means 7, 8, 9 and 10, four outcomes, so P(A) = 4/10 = 0.4.

18. Four of the ten numbers exceed 6, so P(A) = 4/10

Worked example

Figure (svg): The numbers 1 to 10 as plain cells

\[ S = \{1, 2, \ldots, 10\} \]

Take the ten numbers as S

Why: each pick equally likely

\[ A = \{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7, 8, 9, 10}\} \]

Shade the numbers above 6

Why: 'more than' excludes 6

Figure (svg): The numbers 1 to 10 as cells with 7, 8, 9 and 10 shaded blue

\[ P(A) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4}}{10} \]

Divide A's count by 10

Why: fair picks license counting

\[ 6 + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} = 10 \]

Check: add the 6 unshaded cells

Why: A and the rest fill S

19. Repeat it: relative frequency in the long run

Section

Idea 2 of 4

20. A Belgian one-euro coin landed heads in 56% of 250 trials

Concept

Figure (svg): A bar of the Belgian euro's 250 trials split into 56% heads (blue) and 44% tails

Book: statistics students tested the coin 250 times.

Discussion prompt

Does 56% heads in 250 trials prove the coin is not fair?

Answer:

First see how far a coin we know is fair strays in runs of different lengths.

21. Ten flips of a fair coin gave 7 heads, far from half

Worked example

Figure (svg): The first 10 simulated flips of a fair coin as cells: T H H H H H H H T T, with the 7 heads shaded blue

A computer flipped a fair coin: P(H) = 0.5.

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} \text{ H in } 10 \]

Count heads in 10 flips

Why: a quick fairness test

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7}}{10} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.7} \]

Divide heads by 10 flips

Why: shares face P(H) directly

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.7} - \textcolor{#6b7280}{0.5} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.2} \]

Subtract the true chance

Why: fair coins' misses set the bar

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7}}{10} - \frac{5}{10} = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2}}{10} \]

Check: redo it in tenths

Why: 2 tenths is the same 0.2

22. This fair coin strayed less on longer runs

Worked example

Figure (svg): Running share of heads against flips on a ten-fold axis with the first point 0.7 at 10 flips and a grey line at P(H) 0.5

Simulated heads: 43 in 100, 509 in 1000, 5023 in 10000.

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{43}}{100} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.43} \]

Divide 43 by 100 flips

Why: shares compare any run lengths

Figure (svg): Running share of heads against flips on a ten-fold axis, drawn to 100 flips, with 0.7 at 10 and 0.43 at 100, and a grey line at P(H) 0.5

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{509}}{1000} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.509} \]

Divide 509 by 1000

Why: was the dip a trend?

Figure (svg): The running share drawn to 1000 flips, with points 0.7, 0.43 and 0.509

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5023}}{10000} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.5023} \]

Divide 5023 by 10000

Why: does the settling continue?

Figure (svg): The running share drawn to 10000 flips, with points 0.7, 0.43, 0.509 and 0.5023 hugging the grey line at 0.5

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.509} \times 1000 = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{509},\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.5023} \times 10000 = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5023} \]

Check: undo the two longest divisions

Why: recovers the simulated head counts

23. The miss tends to shrink: the law of large numbers

Worked example

Figure (svg): The running share of heads drawn to 10000 flips, with points 0.7, 0.43, 0.509 and 0.5023, a grey line at P(H) 0.5, and a blue miss bar from 0.7 down to 0.5

\( {\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.2} \text{ miss}},\ \allowbreak \allowbreak {\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.43}},\ \allowbreak \allowbreak {\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.509}},\ \allowbreak \allowbreak {\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.5023}} \)

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{0.5} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.43} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.07} \]

Find the 100-flip miss

Why: larger minus smaller: no negatives

Figure (svg): The running share with blue miss bars from 0.7 and from 0.43 to the grey line at 0.5

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.509} - \textcolor{#6b7280}{0.5} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.009} \]

Find the 1000-flip miss

Why: did 10× the flips help?

Figure (svg): The running share with miss bars at 10, 100 and a short bar at 1000 flips

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.5023} - \textcolor{#6b7280}{0.5} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.0023} \]

Find the 10000-flip miss

Why: did another 10× help?

Figure (svg): The running share with miss bars at all four runs, the 10000-flip bar barely visible

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.2} > \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.07} > \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.009} > \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.0023} \]

Check: order the misses

Why: shrinking misses are the law's claim

24. The euro's 140 heads in 250 trials hint at bias but cannot settle it

Worked example

Figure (svg): A bar of the Belgian euro's 250 trials split into 56% heads (blue) and 44% tails

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{56\%} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.56} \]

Write 56% as a decimal

Why: a decimal can scale 250

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.56} \times 250 = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{140} \]

Take 0.56 of 250 trials

Why: counts show the lopsidedness

Figure (svg): A bar of the euro's 250 trials split into 140 heads (blue) and 110 tails

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.56} - \textcolor{#6b7280}{0.5} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.06} \]

Subtract the fair chance

Why: a miss compares with fair coins

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.06} \text{ vs } \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.07} \text{ at } 100 \]

Set it beside our fair coin's miss

Why: but 250 trials should miss less

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{140} \div 250 = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.56} \]

Check: divide heads by 250

Why: undoes the count

25. Tails never need to catch up after 7 heads

Trap

The trap

\[ P(\text{T next}) > 0.5 \]

Expect tails after 7 H, 3 T

Why: assumes the coin remembers

\[ P(\text{T next}) = 0.5 \]

Compare with a fair coin

Why: fails: no memory, every flip 50-50

The fix

\[ \text{expect } 990 \div 2 = 495 \]

Expect about half of 990 new flips

Why: each new flip is still fair

\[ \text{expect } \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} + 495 = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{502} \]

Add the early 7 heads

Why: kept, just outnumbered

\[ 10 + 990 = 1000 \]

Total the flips

Why: early ones count too

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{502} \div 1000 = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.502} \]

Check: expected share after 1000

Why: near 0.5, with no catch-up

26. Two hospitals count days on which over 60% of births are boys

Prediction

Predict first

Hospitals with 15 and 45 births a day; about half are boys.

Which records more days with over 60% boys?

  • The small hospital
  • The large hospital
  • About the same: 60% is 60% anywhere

Correct: The small hospital

Why: By the law of large numbers, a day's share of boys stays nearer one half when there are more births. The small hospital's days stray further from half, so they cross 60% more often.

27. A birth shifts a small day's share 3× as far

Worked example

Figure (svg): Two rows of birth cells: 15 for the small hospital and 45, in three rows of 15, for the large one

\[ 0.6 \times 15 = \textcolor{#6b7280}{9} \]

Find 60% of 15 births

Why: more boys than this pass 60%

Figure (svg): Two rows of birth cells, 15 for the small hospital and 45 for the large one, with a grey line after the 9th cell of the small row

\[ 0.6 \times 45 = \textcolor{#6b7280}{27} \]

Find 60% of 45 births

Why: large days need the same bar

Figure (svg): The birth rows with grey cut-off lines after cell 9 of 15 and cell 27 of 45, labelled 60%: 9 and 60%: 27

\[ \text{one birth: } \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{15},\ \ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{45} \]

Share one birth in each day

Why: step size sets the straying

Figure (svg): The birth rows with both cut-off lines, and the first cell of each hospital's row shaded blue as one birth

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{45} + \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{45} + \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{45} = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3}}{45} \]

Add three large-day steps

Why: tests the 3× claim against 1/15

Figure (svg): The birth rows with cut-off lines, one small-day cell and three large-day cells shaded blue

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3} \div 3}{45 \div 3} = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{15} \]

Check: reduce 3/45 by 3

Why: three large steps make one small

28. 600 rolls of a fair die leave the long-run count to you

Faded example

Figure (svg): The six faces of one fair die as cells 1 to 6, with 5 and 6 shaded blue as the event E

E: rolling 5 or 6, with P(E) = 2/6.

Fill in the blanks

Rolls in E to expect ≈ 200; a run with 230 such rolls has relative frequency ≈ 0.383

Why: 600 ÷ 6 = 100 rolls per face, and E has 2 faces: about 200. A run with 230 gives 230 ÷ 600 ≈ 0.383, a little above the long-run share.

29. A run of 230 of 600 rolls gives 0.383

Worked example

Figure (svg): The six faces of one fair die as cells 1 to 6, with 5 and 6 shaded blue as the event E

\[ 600 \div 6 = 100 \]

Split 600 rolls among 6 faces

Why: equal faces, equal rolls

Figure (svg): A bar of 600 rolls cut into six equal parts, each labelled 100

\[ 2 \times 100 = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{200} \]

Take the two faces in E

Why: 5 and 6 expect 100 each

Figure (svg): The 600-roll bar with its last two parts merged and shaded blue, labelled E: 200

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{230} \div 600 \approx \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.383} \]

Divide the run's count by 600

Why: puts the run on P's scale

Figure (svg): Two bars over 600 rolls: expected, with E: 200 shaded blue at the right end; one run, with E: 230 shaded blue

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{2} \div \textcolor{#6b7280}{6} \approx \textcolor{#6b7280}{0.333} \]

Write P(E) as a decimal

Why: a decimal to set beside 0.383

Figure (svg): The two 600-roll bars, with a grey dashed line on the run's bar where the expected E: 200 begins, labelled expected E starts, so the run's E: 230 reaches past it

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.383} \times 600 \approx \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{230},\ \ \textcolor{#6b7280}{0.333} \times 600 \approx \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{200} \]

Check: scale both shares by 600

Why: undoes both divisions

30. Combine events: OR, AND and not

Section

Idea 3 of 4

31. A raffle pays tickets that are even or above 13

Concept

Figure (svg): The raffle's tickets 1 to 19 as plain cells in two rows

Example 3.1, as a raffle: one ticket from 1 to 19.

Discussion prompt

A prize goes to every ticket that is even or above 13. How many of the 19 tickets win?

Answer:

Mark the even tickets and the tickets above 13, then count each winning ticket once.

32. Adding 9 even tickets and 6 high tickets counts three tickets twice

Worked example

Figure (svg): Tickets 1 to 19 in two blocks of numbered columns, no rows marked yet

A: even tickets. B: tickets above 13.

\[ A = \{2, 4, \ldots, 18\}\colon\ 9 \]

Count the even tickets

Why: plan: tally each group

Figure (svg): Tickets 1 to 19 in two blocks with row A marking the even tickets 2 to 18 by dots

\[ B = \{14, 15, \ldots, 19\}\colon\ 6 \]

Count the tickets above 13

Why: adding needs both tallies

Figure (svg): The ticket blocks with row A marking even tickets and row B marking tickets 14 to 19

\[ 9 + 6 = 15 \]

Add the two counts

Why: seems to count winners

\[ 14, 16, 18\colon\ \text{marked twice} \]

Check: look for double marks

Why: 15 counted these three twice

Figure (svg): The ticket blocks with rows A and B and the columns 14, 16 and 18, marked in both rows, boxed

33. OR keeps a ticket marked in either row; AND needs both

Worked example

Figure (svg): Tickets 1 to 19 in two blocks with row A marking even tickets and row B marking tickets 14 to 19

\[ A \text{ AND } B = \{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{14, 16, 18}\} \]

Keep columns marked twice

Why: AND needs both conditions

Figure (svg): The ticket blocks with rows A and B and a blue AND row shading tickets 14, 16 and 18

\[ A \text{ OR } B\colon\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{12} \text{ tickets} \]

Keep columns with any mark

Why: OR accepts either, or both

Figure (svg): The ticket blocks with rows A and B and a blue OR row shading tickets 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12 and 14 to 19

Book symbols: A ∪ B is A OR B; A ∩ B is A AND B.

\[ 15 - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{12} \]

Check: remove the double count

Why: the attempt counted 3 twice

34. The raffle's AND and OR events have chances 3/19 and 12/19

Worked example

Figure (svg): Tickets 1 to 19 in two blocks with rows A and B marked

\[ P(A) = \frac{9}{19},\ \ P(B) = \frac{6}{19} \]

Divide both row counts by 19

Why: fair draws make tickets equally likely

\[ P(A \text{ AND } B) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3}}{19} \]

Divide the AND count by 19

Why: each overlap ticket carries one nineteenth

Figure (svg): The ticket blocks with a blue AND row shading 14, 16 and 18

\[ P(A \text{ OR } B) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{12}}{19} \]

Divide the OR count by 19

Why: counting covers combined events too

Figure (svg): The ticket blocks with a blue OR row shading the 12 winning tickets

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3}}{19} \le \frac{9}{19} \le \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{12}}{19} \]

Check: order AND, A, OR

Why: AND inside A, A inside OR

35. A second stall pays on every ticket that is not even

Concept

Figure (svg): The raffle's tickets 1 to 19 with the 9 even tickets shaded blue

A: the 9 even tickets. A′ (A prime): every ticket not in A.

Discussion prompt

How could A's count of 9 give P(A′) without listing A′?

Answer:

Every ticket is even or not, never both: the rest of the 19 are exactly A′.

36. A′ holds the 10 tickets that A leaves out

Worked example

Figure (svg): Tickets 1 to 19 in blocks of seven with row A marking the 9 even tickets by dots; the A′ row not drawn yet

\[ 19 - 9 = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{10} \text{ in } A' \]

Take A's 9 from 19

Why: each ticket is even or not

Figure (svg): Tickets 1 to 19 in blocks of seven: row A marks the 9 even tickets with dots, and a blue row A′ shades the 10 odd tickets

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{P(A')} = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{10}}{19} \]

Divide A′'s count by 19

Why: equally likely tickets license counting

Figure (svg): The A and A′ rows with the note A prime: 10 of 19 tickets

\[ A' = \{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1, 3, 5, \ldots, 19}\}\colon\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{10} \]

Check: list the odd tickets

Why: a count made without subtracting

37. A and A′ split S, so their chances add to 1

Worked example

Figure (svg): Tickets 1 to 19 in blocks of seven: row A marks the 9 even tickets with dots, and a blue row A′ shades the 10 odd tickets

\( {P(A) = \dfrac{9}{19}},\quad\allowbreak \allowbreak {\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{P(A')} = \dfrac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{10}}{19}} \)

\[ \frac{9}{19} + \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{10}}{19} = \frac{19}{19} \]

Add the two chances

Why: like fractions add their tops

Figure (svg): The A and A′ rows with the note 9 dots plus 10 blue make 19

\[ \frac{19}{19} = 1 \]

Use the whole rule

Why: all 19 tickets are certain

\[ P(A) + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{P(A')} = 1 \]

Name each chance

Why: each outcome sits in exactly one

\[ \text{each of 19 columns: one mark} \]

Check: count the marks per column

Why: no ticket twice, none missing

Figure (svg): The A and A′ rows with every ticket's column boxed, each holding exactly one mark

38. P(A′) = 1 − P(A) still holds when an event is certain

Worked example

Figure (svg): The raffle's tickets 1 to 19 with the 10 odd tickets, the event A prime, shaded blue

\( {P(A) + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{P(A')} = 1} \)

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{P(A')} = 1 - P(A) \]

Subtract P(A) from both sides

Why: gives A′ from A alone

\[ C = S,\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{P(C)} = 1 \]

Let C be every ticket

Why: an edge: nothing left outside

Figure (svg): All 19 raffle tickets shaded blue as event C, with the note outside C: none

\[ P(C') = 1 - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1} \]

Put in P(C) = 1

Why: any event must obey it

\[ 1 - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1} = 0 \]

Subtract

Why: gives a value counting can test

\[ C' = \{\,\}\colon\ \frac{0}{19} = 0 \]

Check: count tickets in C′

Why: counting agrees: none of 19

39. Reading OR as 'just one' drops the shared face

Trap

The trap

\[ A = \{2, 4, 6\},\ B = \{1, 2, 3\} \]

List the even and under-4 faces

Why: their overlap tests OR

\[ \text{just one: } \{1, 3, 4, 6\} \]

Keep faces in one event only

Why: reads OR as either, not both

\[ P(\text{just one}) = \frac{4}{6} \]

Divide 4 faces by 6

Why: fails: OR keeps shared face 2

The fix

\[ A \text{ OR } B = \{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1, 2, 3, 4, 6}\} \]

Keep faces in A, B or both

Why: overlap included, counted once

\[ P(A \text{ OR } B) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5}}{6} \]

Divide the 5 faces by 6

Why: fair faces make counting valid

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5}}{6} + \frac{1}{6} = 1 \]

Check: add face 5, in neither

Why: OR and its complement fill S

40. A second event B is joined to event A with OR

Prediction

Predict first

A and B are two events of the same experiment.

Can P(A OR B) ever be smaller than P(A)?

  • No: A OR B contains every outcome of A
  • Yes: when B is very unlikely
  • Yes: when A and B overlap

Correct: No: A OR B contains every outcome of A

Why: Every outcome in A is also in A OR B, so A OR B holds at least A's outcomes. An unlikely B or an overlap can leave the chance unchanged, never cut it.

41. Even when B adds nothing new, A OR B keeps all of A

Worked example

Figure (svg): Faces 1 to 6 with row A marking 2, 4, 6 and row B marking only 6

\[ A = \{2, 4, 6\},\ B = \{6\} \]

Pick B inside A

Why: B then adds the least possible

\[ A \text{ OR } B = \{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2, 4, 6}\} \]

Keep faces in either event

Why: nothing in A can drop out

Figure (svg): Faces 1 to 6 with row A marking 2, 4, 6 and row B marking only 6, and a blue OR row shading 2, 4 and 6

\[ P(A \text{ OR } B) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3}}{6} \]

Divide the 3 faces by 6

Why: can OR fall below P(A)?

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2, 4, 6}\colon\ \text{each in the OR row} \]

Check: find A's faces in the OR row

Why: none of A's outcomes was lost

42. Example 3.2's A OR B′ leaves the listing to you

Faded example

Figure (svg): The six faces of one fair die as plain cells 1 to 6

Example 3.2: A = even face, B = face under 4.

Fill in the blanks

B′ holds faces 4, 5, 6; A OR B′ holds faces 2, 4, 5, 6; P(A OR B′) = 4/6

Why: B′ is the faces not under 4: 4, 5, 6. A OR B′ keeps faces in A (2, 4, 6) or B′ (4, 5, 6) or both: 2, 4, 5, 6. That is 4 of the 6 faces.

43. B′ adds face 5 to A, so P(A OR B′) = 4/6

Worked example

Figure (svg): Faces 1 to 6 with row A marking 2, 4, 6; the B′ row not drawn yet

\[ B' = \{4, 5, 6\} \]

Take the faces not under 4

Why: B′ is everything B leaves out

Figure (svg): Faces 1 to 6 with row A marking 2, 4, 6 and row B′ marking 4, 5, 6

\[ A \text{ OR } B' = \{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2, 4, 5, 6}\} \]

Keep faces in either row

Why: shared faces 4, 6 count once

Figure (svg): Faces 1 to 6 with row A marking 2, 4, 6 and row B′ marking 4, 5, 6, and a blue OR row shading 2, 4, 5 and 6

\[ P(A \text{ OR } B') = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4}}{6} \]

Divide the 4 faces by 6

Why: fair faces share 1 equally

\[ \{1, 3\}\colon\ 2 \text{ faces in neither} \]

Count the unmarked faces

Why: the leftovers let us check

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4}}{6} + \frac{2}{6} = 1 \]

Check: add the neither share

Why: event and rest must fill S

44. Use the news: conditional probability

Section

Idea 4 of 4

45. A friend rolls a die and says only that it came up even

Concept

Figure (svg): The six faces of one fair die with 2 and 3 shaded blue as event A

Book example: A = the face is 2 or 3.

Discussion prompt

A had 2 faces of 6. Once you hear 'even', how likely is A now?

Answer:

The news rules out the odd faces; count A's faces among those that remain.

46. Keeping all six faces ignores the news and still counts face 3

Worked example

Figure (svg): The six faces of one fair die with 2 and 3 shaded blue as event A

\[ P(A) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2}}{6} \]

Count A's faces over all 6

Why: a baseline to judge the news

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{1, 3, 5} \text{ cannot show} \]

Apply the news: the roll is even

Why: odd faces are now impossible

Figure (svg): The six faces with odd faces 1, 3 and 5 greyed and dashed as ruled out; face 2 shaded blue

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{3} \text{ is odd} \]

Recheck A's two faces

Why: 2/6 still counts a ruled-out face

\[ \{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2}, \textcolor{#6b7280}{3}\} \text{ vs } \{2, 4, 6\}\colon\ \text{only } \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2} \]

Check: which of A's faces survive

Why: counting 3 overstates A's chance

47. Given an even roll, one of the three even faces is in A

Worked example

Figure (svg): The six faces with odd faces greyed out as ruled out and face 2 shaded blue

B: an even roll. P(A | B): A's chance given B.

\[ B = \{2, 4, 6\} \]

Make B the new sample space

Why: only these faces can have shown

Figure (svg): The six faces with 2, 4 and 6 heavily outlined as B and odd faces greyed out

\[ A \text{ AND } B = \{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2}\} \]

Keep A's faces inside B

Why: A's outcomes still in play

Figure (svg): The six faces with 2, 4 and 6 heavily outlined as the new sample space B, face 2 also shaded blue, and odd faces greyed out

\[ P(A \mid B) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{3} \]

Divide by B's 3 faces, not 6

Why: even faces stay equally likely

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{3} + \frac{2}{3} = 1 \]

Check: add faces 4 and 6

Why: B's faces make the new whole

48. Dividing top and bottom by 6 rewrites 1/3 as two chances

Worked example

Figure (svg): The six faces with 2, 4 and 6 heavily outlined as the new sample space B, face 2 also shaded blue, and odd faces greyed out

\( {P(A \mid B) = \dfrac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{3}} \)

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{3} = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1} \div 6}{3 \div 6} \]

Divide top and bottom by 6

Why: brings back S's six faces

Figure (svg): All six faces back in plain ink as S, with 2, 4 and 6 still heavily outlined as B and face 2 shaded blue

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1} \div 6 = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{P(A \text{ AND } B)} \]

Read the top as a chance

Why: count over 6 is a chance

Figure (svg): All six faces back in plain ink as S, with 2, 4 and 6 still heavily outlined as B and face 2 shaded blue

\[ 3 \div 6 = P(B) \]

Read the bottom as a chance

Why: the bottom needs a chance too

Figure (svg): All six faces back in plain ink as S, with 2, 4 and 6 still heavily outlined as B and face 2 shaded blue

\[ \frac{1/6}{3/6} = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{3} \]

Check with the shared-6 rule

Why: matches the shrunk-space count

49. With equally likely outcomes, P(A | B) is P(A AND B) over P(B)

Worked example

Figure (svg): All six faces back in plain ink as S, with 2, 4 and 6 still heavily outlined as B and face 2 shaded blue

\( {\dfrac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{3} = \dfrac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1} \div 6}{3 \div 6}}\;\;\Rightarrow\;\;\allowbreak {\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1} \div 6 = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{P(A \text{ AND } B)}}\;\;\Rightarrow\;\;\allowbreak {3 \div 6 = P(B)} \)

\[ P(A \mid B) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{P(A \text{ AND } B)}}{P(B)} \]

Put both chances in place

Why: holds for any equally likely S

Figure (svg): All six faces back in plain ink as S, with 2, 4 and 6 still heavily outlined as B and face 2 shaded blue

The bottom cannot be 0: the rule needs P(B) > 0.

\[ \{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4, 6}\}\colon\ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2/6}}{3/6} = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2}}{3} \]

Check: try the event {4, 6} instead

Why: rule and picture must agree

Figure (svg): All six faces as S, with 2, 4 and 6 outlined as B and faces 4 and 6 shaded blue as the test event

50. All of S as news leaves the chance alone

Worked example

Figure (svg): The six faces of one fair die with 2 and 3 shaded blue as event A

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{A} \text{ AND } S = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{A} \]

Keep A's faces inside S

Why: S holds every face

Figure (svg): The six faces all heavily outlined as the news S, with faces 2 and 3 also shaded blue as A

\[ P(\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{A} \mid S) = P(\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{A} \text{ AND } S) \div P(S) \]

Make S the news in the rule

Why: the rule takes any news

\[ P(\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{A} \mid S) = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2/6} \div 6/6 \]

Substitute both chances

Why: the top overlap is A itself

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2/6} \div 6/6 = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2}}{6} \]

Cancel the shared 6

Why: compare with the old chance

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2} \text{ of } 6 \text{ outlined faces} \]

Check: count blue among outlined

Why: no face ruled out

51. Given a ticket above 13, the raffle's chance of an even ticket is 3/6

Worked example

Figure (svg): Tickets 1 to 19 in blocks of seven with rows A and B marked and a blue AND row shading 14, 16 and 18

\( {P(A \text{ AND } B) = \dfrac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3}}{19}},\quad\allowbreak \allowbreak {P(B) = \dfrac{6}{19}} \)

\[ P(A \mid B) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3/19}}{6/19} \]

Put in the raffle's chances

Why: the news sits in the bottom

Figure (svg): The ticket blocks with a blue AND row at 14, 16, 18 and the columns of B, tickets 14 to 19, boxed

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3/19}}{6/19} = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3}}{6} \]

Cancel the shared 19

Why: leaves counts inside B's six tickets

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3} \text{ of } 6 \text{ boxed} \]

Check: count blue in the boxes

Why: counting inside B must agree

52. Swapping the news gives P(B | A) = 3/9, not 3/6

Worked example

Figure (svg): The ticket blocks with a blue AND row at 14, 16, 18 and the columns of B, tickets 14 to 19, boxed

\( {P(A \text{ AND } B) = \dfrac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3}}{19}},\quad\allowbreak \allowbreak {P(A) = \dfrac{9}{19}} \)

\[ P(B \mid A) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3/19}}{9/19} \]

Make A the news instead

Why: tests whether swapping the news matters

Figure (svg): The ticket blocks with a blue AND row at 14, 16, 18 and the columns of A, the even tickets, boxed

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3/19}}{9/19} = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3}}{9} \]

Cancel the 19 again

Why: leaves counts inside A's nine tickets

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3} \text{ of } 9 \text{ boxed} \]

Check: tally blue among boxed columns

Why: picture must match the fraction

53. Dividing by the wrong event swaps the question

Trap

The trap

Try It 3.2: above 6, given odd?

\[ \text{above 6 and odd: } \{7, 9\} \]

Find the numbers in both

Why: the rule's top count

\[ 2 \div 4 = 0.5 \]

Divide by the 4 above 6

Why: treats 'above 6' as news

\[ 0.5 = P(\text{odd} \mid \text{above } 6) \]

Name what 0.5 measures

Why: fails: the news was 'odd'

The fix

Figure (svg): Numbers 1 to 10 with the odd numbers heavily outlined as the news, 7 and 9 also shaded blue, and even numbers greyed out

\[ P(\text{above } 6 \mid \text{odd}) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2}}{5} \]

Divide by the 5 odd numbers

Why: the given event fills the bottom

\[ 1, 3, 5, 7, 9\colon\ 5;\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7, 9}\colon\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2} \]

Check: recount the outlined cells

Why: a recount, not the same division

54. A friend reports that a die roll came up under 4

Prediction

Predict first

Example 3.2: A = even face. News B: the face is under 4.

Is A now more likely, less likely, or unchanged?

  • Less likely
  • More likely: news always sharpens a chance
  • Unchanged: the die ignores what you learn

Correct: Less likely

Why: Among faces 1, 2 and 3 only 2 is even: one face of three. Before the news, three faces of six were even, which is more. News can raise, lower or leave a chance.

55. Under 4 leaves one even face of three, below the old three sixths

Worked example

Figure (svg): The six faces of one fair die as plain cells 1 to 6

\[ P(A) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3}}{6} \]

Count even faces over all 6

Why: the old chance, for comparing

Figure (svg): The six faces with the even faces 2, 4 and 6 shaded blue

\[ A \text{ AND } B = \{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2}\} \]

Keep even faces under 4

Why: only face 2 passes both tests

Figure (svg): The six faces with 1, 2 and 3 heavily outlined as B, face 2 also blue, and 4, 5, 6 greyed out

\[ P(A \mid B) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{3} \]

Divide by B's 3 faces

Why: news shrinks the space

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{3} = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2}}{6} \]

Write 1/3 in sixths

Why: compares directly with 3/6

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2}}{6} < \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3}}{6} \]

Check: fewer sixths than before

Why: the news lowered A's chance

56. Try It 3.1's ordered pairs leave the conditional chance to you

Faded example

Figure (svg): Try It 3.1's 12 ordered pairs as a 3 by 4 grid: rows are the first number 1 to 3, columns the second number 1 to 4

A: the sum is even. B: first number prime (2 or 3).

Fill in the blanks

pairs in B = 8; pairs in A AND B = 4; P(A | B) = 4/8

Why: B is rows 2 and 3: 2 × 4 = 8 pairs. Even sums there: (2,2), (2,4), (3,1), (3,3), four pairs. So P(A | B) = 4/8 = 0.5.

57. Given B, 4 of the 8 pairs have an even sum

Worked example

Figure (svg): Try It 3.1's 12 ordered pairs as a 3 by 4 grid: rows are the first number 1 to 3, columns the second number 1 to 4

\[ 2 \times 4 = 8 \text{ pairs in } B \]

Count rows 2 and 3

Why: B's pairs: the new sample space

Figure (svg): The pairs grid with rows 2 and 3 heavily outlined as B and row 1 greyed out

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{(2,2),\ (2,4),\ (3,1),\ (3,3)} \]

Find even sums inside B

Why: both events hold for these

Figure (svg): The pairs grid with B outlined, and (2,2), (2,4), (3,1), (3,3) shaded blue

\[ P(A \mid B) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4}}{8} \]

Divide by B's 8 pairs

Why: the shrunk space goes below

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4}}{8} + \frac{4}{8} = 1 \]

Check: add B's 4 odd-sum pairs

Why: B's 8 pairs fill the whole

58. Five counting moves answer every question in this section

Pattern

  1. List S; mark the event's outcomes
  2. Equally likely: event count ÷ S count
  3. OR: either; AND: both; A′: not A
  4. Given B: count inside B, divide by B's count
  5. Long run: relative frequency nears the probability

\[ P(A) = \frac{\text{in } A}{\text{in } S},\quad P(A') = 1 - P(A),\quad P(A \mid B) = \frac{P(A \text{ AND } B)}{P(B)} \]

59. A table of 100 people asks for a left-handed chance among females

Check

Figure (svg): Example 3.3's table: males 43 right-handed, 9 left-handed; females 44 right-handed, 4 left-handed

Example 3.3: F = female, L = left-handed.

Check your understanding

One of these 100 people is picked at random. Find P(L | F).

  • A. 4/48 (correct)
  • B. 4/13
  • C. 4/100
  • D. 48/100

Answer: A

Why: Given F, only the female row counts: 44 + 4 = 48 people, and 4 of them are left-handed. So P(L | F) = 4/48, about 0.083.

Why B tempts people
4/13 divides by the left-handed column: that is P(F | L), the news swapped.
Why C tempts people
4/100 divides by everyone: that is P(F AND L), which ignores the news.
Why D tempts people
48/100 is P(F), the share of females, with nothing about handedness.

60. Four of the 48 females are left-handed

Worked example

Figure (svg): Example 3.3's table: males 43 right-handed, 9 left-handed; females 44 right-handed, 4 left-handed

\[ 44 + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} = 48 \]

Total the female row

Why: the news makes it the space

Figure (svg): Example 3.3's table with a total column (52, 48) and the female row heavily outlined

\[ P(L \mid F) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4}}{48} \]

Put the 4 left-handers over 48

Why: only the outlined row counts

Figure (svg): The table with the female row outlined and the cell 4 (female, left) shaded blue

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} \div 48 \approx 0.083 \]

Divide 4 by 48

Why: a decimal ranks against other chances

\[ 9 + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} = 13 \]

Total the left-handed column

Why: explains the rival answer 4/13

\[ \frac{44}{48} + \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4}}{48} = 1 \]

Check: add the right-handed share

Why: the row fills the whole

61. A classmate says the news 'face card' cannot change the chance of a king

Check

A standard deck: 13 ranks in each of 4 suits.

Check your understanding

The drawn card is a jack, queen or king. A classmate says P(king) stays 4/52. Which reply is right?

  • A. Wrong: given a face card, 4 of 12 cards are kings (correct)
  • B. Right: learning something cannot change a card
  • C. Wrong: the queens and jacks make a king less likely
  • D. Right: 4/52 and 4/12 are the same share

Answer: A

Why: The news shrinks the space to the 12 face cards (3 ranks in 4 suits), and 4 of them are kings: 4/12 = 1/3, far above 4/52 = 1/13.

Why B tempts people
The card is fixed, but our space of possibilities shrank: 40 cards were ruled out.
Why C tempts people
The news removed 40 non-kings, so the kings' share rose, not fell.
Why D tempts people
4/12 reduces to 1/3 and 4/52 to 1/13: different shares.

62. Given a face card, a king has chance 4/12, not 4/52

Worked example

Figure (svg): The 12 face cards as a grid: rows are the suits spades, hearts, diamonds, clubs; columns are jack, queen, king

\[ 4 \times 3 = 12 \]

Count suits times face ranks

Why: the news leaves 12 cards

Figure (svg): The face-card grid with all 12 cells heavily outlined as the news

\[ P(\text{king} \mid \text{face}) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4}}{12} \]

Divide the 4 kings by 12

Why: the 12 cards stay equally likely

Figure (svg): The face-card grid outlined, with the king column shaded blue

\[ P(\text{king}) = \frac{4}{52} \]

Count kings in the whole deck

Why: the classmate's chance without news

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} \div 4}{12 \div 4} = \frac{1}{3},\ \ \frac{4 \div 4}{52 \div 4} = \frac{1}{13} \]

Check: reduce both shares

Why: exposes the gap between shares

63. At least one head leaves both heads at 1/3

Worked example

Figure (svg): A 2 by 2 grid of the two coins' outcomes: rows are the dime's H and T, columns the nickel's H and T, cells HH, HT, TH, TT

\[ B = \{HH, HT, TH\} \]

Keep cells with a head

Why: the peek rules out TT

Figure (svg): The coin grid with HH, HT, TH heavily outlined as B and TT greyed out

\[ \text{both heads: } \{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{HH}\} \]

Find HH inside B

Why: the count's top: HH AND B

Figure (svg): The coin grid with B outlined, HH shaded blue and TT greyed out

\[ P(HH \mid B) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{3} \]

Divide by B's 3 cells

Why: they stay equally likely

\[ P(HH \text{ AND } B) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{4},\ \ P(B) = \frac{3}{4} \]

Divide both counts by 4

Why: readies the chance rule

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1/4}}{3/4} = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{3} \]

Check: cancel the shared 4

Why: the rule matches counting

64. Naming the coin that shows heads would make the answer 1/2

Worked example

Figure (svg): A 2 by 2 grid of the two coins' outcomes: rows are the dime's H and T, columns the nickel's H and T, cells HH, HT, TH, TT

\( {B = \{HH, HT, TH\}},\quad\allowbreak \allowbreak {P(HH \mid B) = \dfrac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{3}} \)

\[ D = \{HH, HT\} \]

Keep cells with the dime heads

Why: tests 'the other coin'

Figure (svg): The coin grid with the dime-heads row HH, HT outlined and row TH, TT greyed out

\[ P(HH \mid D) = \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{2} \]

Divide by D's 2 cells

Why: the 50-50 the intuition wanted

Figure (svg): The coin grid with the dime-heads row outlined and HH shaded blue

\[ \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{3} < \frac{\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1}}{2} \]

Compare the two kinds of news

Why: which news keeps more cells?

\[ TH\colon\ \text{in } B,\ \text{not in } D \]

Check: find the cell that differs

Why: TH alone explains the gap

65. You can now count chances, with or without news

Recap

OpenStax Introductory Statistics 2e, §3.1 Terminology §3.1, pp. 168-171 — Examples 3.1–3.3 and Try Its 3.1–3.2 trace back here

Sources

  1. OpenStax Introductory Statistics 2e, §3.1 Terminology — Illowsky & Dean, OpenStax / Rice University, CC BY 4.0, pp. 168-171
  2. OpenStax Introductory Business Statistics 2e, §3.1 Terminology — Illowsky & Dean, OpenStax / Rice University, CC BY 4.0

Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Statistics — $55/session, free consultation.

Book on Wyzant · Text (657) 465-8108