2.6 Skewness and the Mean, Median, and Mode

Fold a dot plot to test it for symmetry, watch the three centres split when the fold fails, measure how far one value moves the mean and why it leaves the median alone, and read a data set's stretch back out of its mean and median.

Subject: Statistics · 68 slides · applied lesson

Open the interactive version of this deck

What this lesson covers

The lesson, slide by slide

1. Skewness and the Mean, Median, and Mode

Title

Statistics · §2.6

Read the shape first: it decides where each centre lands

2. You will leave able to do these things with real data

Objectives

  1. Test a dot plot for a mirror line
  2. Name which side the data stretches out
  3. Measure how far one value moves the mean
  4. Read a shape from the mean and median
  5. Choose which centre a report should use

3. Nine earlier rules carry every step

Concept

\[ \bar{x} = {\textstyle\sum} x \div n \]

Mean

Why: total Σx shared among n values

\[ \text{place} = (1 + n) \div 2 \]

Median place

Why: counts along the sorted list

\[ M = (u + v) \div 2 \]

Even count

Why: M: halfway between two middles

\[ \text{mode} = \text{commonest value} \]

Mode

Why: answers what happens most often

\[ (u + v) \div 2 \]

Halfway

Why: equal steps from both ends

\[ 3 \times u = u + u + u \]

Multiply

Why: copies of one number

\[ \frac{u + v}{w} = \frac{u}{w} + \frac{v}{w} \]

Share a sum

Why: each part keeps its portion

\[ u - v < 0 \text{ if } u < v \]

Signs

Why: below gives a negative

\[ u \div v = w \Rightarrow w \times v = u \]

Divide back

Why: checks every share

4. Three groups sat one quiz and all three peak at 7

Prediction

Figure (svg): Three dot plots on one scale from 4 to 10, each with a grey dashed line at 7: Group A with 16 marks spread evenly either side, Group B with 10 marks reaching down to 4 and stopping at 8, Group C with 10 marks starting at 6 and reaching up to 10

§2.6's three data sets, read as quiz marks.

Predict first

Every group's commonest mark is 7.

Which group's mean mark is smallest?

  • Group B
  • Group A
  • Group C
  • All three are equal

Correct: Group B

Why: Group B reaches down to 4 and stops at 8, so its marks sit lower than the other two. A mean adds every mark, so the group whose marks lean low pools the least. This deck measures all three and says how far apart they end up.

5. Counting each side of 7 separates them

Worked example

Figure (svg): Three dot plots on one scale from 4 to 10, each with a grey dashed line at 7: Group A with 16 marks spread evenly either side, Group B with 10 marks reaching down to 4 and stopping at 8, Group C with 10 marks starting at 6 and reaching up to 10

\[ \text{A}:\ 5 \text{ below } \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7},\ \ 5 \text{ above} \]

Count A each side of 7

Why: shape before arithmetic

Figure (svg): Three dot plots on one scale from 4 to 10, each with a grey dashed line at 7: Group A with 16 marks spread evenly either side, Group B with 10 marks reaching down to 4 and stopping at 8, Group C with 10 marks starting at 6 and reaching up to 10, with Group A's counts printed beside its name

\[ \text{B}:\ 5 \text{ below } \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7},\ \ 1 \text{ above} \]

Count B the same way

Why: a second group to weigh

Figure (svg): Three dot plots on one scale from 4 to 10, each with a grey dashed line at 7: Group A with 16 marks spread evenly either side, Group B with 10 marks reaching down to 4 and stopping at 8, Group C with 10 marks starting at 6 and reaching up to 10, with Groups A and B's counts printed beside their names

\[ \text{C}:\ 1 \text{ below } \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7},\ \ 5 \text{ above} \]

Count C the same way

Why: one shape still unweighed

Figure (svg): Three dot plots on one scale from 4 to 10, each with a grey dashed line at 7: Group A with 16 marks spread evenly either side, Group B with 10 marks reaching down to 4 and stopping at 8, Group C with 10 marks starting at 6 and reaching up to 10, with all three groups' counts printed beside their names

\[ 5 = 5,\ \ 5 > 1,\ \ 1 < 5 \]

Compare the six counts

Why: only A answers itself

\[ 16 - 5 - 5 = 6 \]

Check: take A's 10 off 16

Why: the rest all hold 7

6. Fold it: the mirror line

Section

Idea 1 of 4

7. Group A's 16 marks run from 4 up to 10

Concept

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10

Sixteen marks out of 10, one dot each.

Discussion prompt

Which single mark would you report as Group A's typical result?

Answer:

All three §2.5 rules answer 7 here. Why do they agree?

8. The tallest stack alone leaves 10 of the 16 marks unheard

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10

f: how many marks share one value.

\[ f = 6 \text{ at } \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} \]

Count the tallest stack

Why: commonest mark, quickest guess

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, with the six-dot stack at 7 boxed and labelled mode 7

\[ 16 - 6 = 10 \]

Take the 7s off 16

Why: how many the guess ignores

\[ 10 > 6 \]

Compare the two counts

Why: most students sit outside

\[ 6 + 10 = 16 \]

Check: add both counts

Why: nobody was placed twice

9. Group A's 16 marks pool to 112, an equal share of 7

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10

\[ 3 \times \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{18} \]

Total the three 6s

Why: counting beats writing copies

\[ 6 \times \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{42} \]

Total the six 7s

Why: the tallest stack weighs most

\[ 3 \times \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{8} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{24} \]

Total the three 8s

Why: no repeated mark left out

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4 + 5 + 18 + 42 + 24 + 9 + 10} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{112} \]

Add the seven part totals

Why: Σx must hold all 16

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{112} \div 16 = \textcolor{#6b7280}{7} \]

Share the pool among 16

Why: one mark if all were level

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, with a grey dashed line at the mean 7

\[ 16 \times \textcolor{#6b7280}{7} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{112} \]

Check: rebuild the pool

Why: sixteen shares return Σx

10. Group A's median is 7, as its mean was

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, with a grey dashed line at the mean 7

\[ 1 + 16 = 17 \]

Add the outer places

Why: a median needs ends

\[ 17 \div 2 = 8.5 \]

Halve 17

Why: even n, no single middle

\[ \text{8th} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7},\ \ \text{9th} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} \]

Read places 8 and 9

Why: these two decide M

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, with a grey dashed line at the mean 7 and a grey dotted line at the median 7

\[ M = \textcolor{#6b7280}{7} \]

Take halfway of two 7s

Why: equal middles need nothing

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{\bar{x}} = \textcolor{#6b7280}{7},\ \ M = \textcolor{#6b7280}{7},\ \ \text{mode} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} \]

Set the centres out

Why: three rules, one answer

\[ 5 + 6 = 11 \ge 9 \]

Check: count to place 9

Why: the six 7s reach past

11. Every mark of Group A has a mirror partner

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, with a grey dashed fold line at 7

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3},\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{10} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3} \]

Measure 4 and 10

Why: equal gaps make a mirror

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, with a grey fold line at 7 and 1 row of blue double arrows below the axis measuring equal gaps from 7

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2},\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{9} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2} \]

Measure 5 and 9

Why: a second pair confirms

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, with a grey fold line at 7 and 2 rows of blue double arrows below the axis measuring equal gaps from 7

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1},\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{8} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1} \]

Measure 6 and 8

Why: three answered by three

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, with a grey fold line at 7 and 3 rows of blue double arrows below the axis measuring equal gaps from 7

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0} \]

Measure the six 7s

Why: on the line, reaching nowhere

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, with a grey fold line at 7 and 4 rows of blue double arrows below the axis measuring equal gaps from 7

Mirror images each side: the data is symmetrical.

\[ 5 + 6 + 5 = 16 \]

Check: add the three counts

Why: none lacks a partner

12. Each mirror pair totals 14, twice the fold

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, with a grey dashed fold line at 7

\( {7 - 4 = 3}\;\;\Rightarrow\;\;\allowbreak {7 - 5 = 2}\;\;\Rightarrow\;\;\allowbreak {7 - 6 = 1}\;\;\Rightarrow\;\;\allowbreak {7 - 7 = 0} \)

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4 + 10} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{14},\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5 + 9} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{14} \]

Add the outer pairs

Why: the fold sets a total

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, with a grey fold line at 7 and 2 rows of blue double arrows below the axis measuring equal gaps from 7

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6 + 8} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{14},\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7 + 7} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{14} \]

Add two more pairs

Why: tests the pattern nearer 7

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, with a grey fold line at 7 and 4 rows of blue double arrows below the axis measuring equal gaps from 7

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{14} \div 2 = \textcolor{#6b7280}{7} \]

Halve one pair's total

Why: each averages the fold

\[ 8 \times \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{14} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{112} \]

Check: rebuild Σx

Why: the stacks pooled 112 too

13. A pair at gap d each side of fold m averages m

Worked example

Figure (svg): A scale from 8 to 16 with a grey fold line at m, a blue dot one gap below it and a blue dot the same gap above it, both gaps arrowed and labelled 2

\[ (\textcolor{#6b7280}{m} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{d}) + (\textcolor{#6b7280}{m} + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{d}) = \textcolor{#6b7280}{m} + \textcolor{#6b7280}{m} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{d} + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{d} \]

Remove the brackets

Why: gaps can now meet

\[ -\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{d} + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{d} = 0 \]

Add the two gaps

Why: they cancel out

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{m} + \textcolor{#6b7280}{m} = \textcolor{#6b7280}{2m} \]

Add the two folds

Why: the gaps left nothing behind

\[ {\textstyle{\textstyle\sum}} x = k \times \textcolor{#6b7280}{2m} \]

Total k pairs

Why: the pool is just its pairs

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, with a grey fold line at 7 and 4 rows of blue double arrows below the axis measuring equal gaps from 7

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{2}k\textcolor{#6b7280}{m} \div 2k = \textcolor{#6b7280}{m} \]

Share among 2k marks

Why: k pairs hold all

\[ k = 8,\ \textcolor{#6b7280}{m} = \textcolor{#6b7280}{7}:\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{112} \div 16 = \textcolor{#6b7280}{7} \]

Check on Group A

Why: the fold returns

14. Equal counts each side put M on the fold

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, with a grey dashed fold line at 7

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6} \to 5 \]

Count the marks under 7

Why: a middle needs side counts

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, with the counts 5 below 7 and 5 above printed under the axis

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{8},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{8},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{8},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{9},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{10} \to 5 \]

Count the marks over 7

Why: each partner lies opposite

\[ 5 = 5 \]

Compare the two side counts

Why: pairing forces them to match

\[ \text{places } 6 \text{ to } 11 = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} \]

Name the places the 7s fill

Why: 5 marks sit either side

\[ M = \textcolor{#6b7280}{7} \]

Read places 8 and 9

Why: both middles lie inside

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, with a grey dotted median line at 7 and the counts 5 and 5 under the axis

\[ (1 + 16) \div 2 = 8.5 \]

Check: work out the middle place

Why: 8.5 falls inside that block

15. Symmetrical data can carry two modes

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of the made-up marks 4, 4, 5, 6, 6 on a scale from 3 to 7: two dots at 4, one at 5, two at 6

Made-up marks 4, 4, 5, 6, 6 — five students.

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4 + 4 + 5 + 6 + 6} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{25} \]

Add the five made-up marks

Why: a fresh set to test

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{25} \div 5 = \textcolor{#6b7280}{5} \]

Share among 5

Why: the mirror rule predicted this

Figure (svg): Dot plot of the made-up marks 4, 4, 5, 6, 6 on a scale from 3 to 7: two dots at 4, one at 5, two at 6, with a grey dashed line at the mean 5

\[ \text{modes} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6} \]

Find the two tallest stacks

Why: a tie empties the centre

Figure (svg): Dot plot of the made-up marks 4, 4, 5, 6, 6 on a scale from 3 to 7: two dots at 4, one at 5, two at 6, with a grey mean line at 5 and the two-dot stacks at 4 and 6 boxed as modes

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} \ne \textcolor{#6b7280}{5},\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6} \ne \textcolor{#6b7280}{5} \]

Compare both modes with 5

Why: neither peak marks the balance

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{5} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1},\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6} - \textcolor{#6b7280}{5} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1} \]

Check the fold at 5

Why: the mirror holds, modes differ

16. Maris folds at 5 but for two loose 3s

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Maris' ten letter counts from 0 to 10: one dot at 2, two at 3, three at 4, three at 6, one at 8

Example 2.31: Maris' ten letter counts.

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3},\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{8} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3} \]

Measure 2 and 8

Why: the ends decide fastest

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Maris' ten letter counts from 0 to 10: one dot at 2, two at 3, three at 4, three at 6, one at 8, with a grey fold line at 5 and blue arrows of 3 to the counts 2 and 8

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1},\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1} \]

Measure 4 and 6

Why: three counts answer three

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Maris' ten letter counts from 0 to 10: one dot at 2, two at 3, three at 4, three at 6, one at 8, with arrows of 3 and of 1 drawn under the axis

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2},\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7}: \text{none} \]

Seek partners for the 3s

Why: a fold demands 7s

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Maris' ten letter counts from 0 to 10: one dot at 2, two at 3, three at 4, three at 6, one at 8, with a third row of arrows showing a gap of 2 below 5 and the word none above 7

\[ 2 \ne 0 \]

Compare the two tallies

Why: no mirror, no fold

\[ 8 + 2 = 10 \]

Check: add both tallies

Why: all ten counts placed

17. A mean equal to M does not prove a fold

Trap

The trap

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1 + 2 + 6 + 9 + 12} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{30} \]

Add the values

Why: a pool to share

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{30} \div 5 = \textcolor{#6b7280}{6} \]

Share among 5

Why: this list's mean

\[ \text{3rd} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6} \]

Read place 3

Why: odd n, one middle

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{\bar{x}} = M \Rightarrow \text{folds} \]

Claim a mirror

Why: no gap measured

The fix

Figure (svg): The same made-up dot plot with a grey dashed fold line at 6, the dots reaching 5 below it and 6 above

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5},\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{12} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6} \]

Measure both ends

Why: gaps must match

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5} \ne \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6} \]

Compare the gaps

Why: low end nearer

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} \ne \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{9} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6} \]

Check inner pair

Why: no mirror here

18. Made-up marks 10, 11, 12, 13, 14 fold at 12

Prediction

Figure (svg): Dot plot of the made-up marks 10, 11, 12, 13, 14 on a scale from 9 to 15, with a grey dashed fold line at 12

Predict first

A sixth mark joins the made-up set 10, 11, 12, 13, 14.

Which new mark keeps the fold at 12?

  • Another 12
  • Another 10
  • A 15
  • A 9

Correct: Another 12

Why: A mark on the fold has a gap of 0, so it needs no partner. Each of the other three arrives with a gap that nothing answers: a second 10 would leave two marks at gap 2 below and only one above, and 15 or 9 would need a partner at 9 or 15 that the set does not have.

19. A sixth mark of 12 has gap 0, so the mean stays 12

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of the made-up marks 10, 11, 12, 13, 14 on a scale from 9 to 15, with a grey dashed fold line at 12

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{12} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{10} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2},\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{14} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{12} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2} \]

Measure the ends from 12

Why: the set folds already

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{12} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{11} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1},\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{13} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{12} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1} \]

Measure the inner pair

Why: both gaps already have partners

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{12} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{12} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0} \]

Measure the newcomer

Why: a gap of nothing asks for none

Figure (svg): Dot plot of the made-up marks 10, 11, 12, 12, 13, 14 on a scale from 9 to 15, with a grey dashed fold line at 12, and two dots stacked at 12

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{10 + 11 + 12 + 12 + 13 + 14} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{72} \]

Total the six marks

Why: a number to test the rule

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{72} \div 6 = \textcolor{#6b7280}{12} \]

Check: share the new pool

Why: the mean stays on the fold

20. When the fold fails: a long thin side

Section

Idea 2 of 4

21. Group B reaches down to 4 but stops at 8

Concept

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group B's 10 marks from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, four at 7, one at 8, nothing above 8

Ten marks out of 10, one dot each.

Discussion prompt

Group B has a mark at 4 and none at 10. What should that do to its three centres?

Answer:

The fold fails and the centres split. The next slides measure the split.

22. Group B's fold at 7 leaves two unpartnered

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group B's 10 marks from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, four at 7, one at 8, nothing above 8, with a grey dashed fold line at 7

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6}:\ 3,\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{8}:\ 1 \]

Count at 6 and at 8

Why: a mirror needs equal stacks

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group B's 10 marks from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, four at 7, one at 8, nothing above 8, with a grey fold line at 7 and blue arrows of 1 to the marks at 6 and 8

\[ 3 \ne 1 \]

Compare the two stacks

Why: one cannot answer three

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5} \to \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{9}?,\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} \to \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{10}? \]

Seek partners for 5 and 4

Why: the fold needs marks up there

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group B's 10 marks from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, four at 7, one at 8, nothing above 8, with a grey fold line at 7 and three rows of arrows, the lower two labelled none on the high side

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{9},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{10}:\ \text{no marks} \]

Read the empty high end

Why: two low marks stay unanswered

\[ 5 \text{ below } \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7},\ \ 1 \text{ above} \]

Check: count each side of 7

Why: sides this uneven cannot mirror

23. Group B's 10 marks pool to 63, an equal share of 6.3

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group B's 10 marks from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, four at 7, one at 8, nothing above 8

\[ 3 \times \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{18} \]

Total the three 6s

Why: counting shortens the line

\[ 4 \times \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{28} \]

Total the four 7s

Why: the tallest stack dominates

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4 + 5 + 18 + 28 + 8} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{63} \]

Add the five part totals

Why: Σx must hold all 10

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{63} \div 10 = \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.3} \]

Share the pool among 10

Why: an equal cut for a lopsided class

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group B's 10 marks from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, four at 7, one at 8, nothing above 8, with a grey dashed line at the mean 6.3

\[ 10 \times \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.3} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{63} \]

Check: rebuild the pool

Why: ten shares return Σx

24. Group B's median, 6.5, is a mark nobody scored

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group B's 10 marks from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, four at 7, one at 8, nothing above 8, with a grey dashed line at the mean 6.3

\[ 1 + 10 = 11 \]

Add the outer places

Why: the middle needs both ends

\[ 11 \div 2 = 5.5 \]

Halve 11

Why: no mark sits there

\[ \text{5th} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6},\ \ \text{6th} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} \]

Read places 5 and 6

Why: the middles differ here

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6} + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{13} \]

Add the middle pair

Why: halfway needs their sum

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{13} \div 2 = \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.5} \]

Halve 13

Why: M lands between two marks

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group B's 10 marks from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, four at 7, one at 8, nothing above 8, with a grey dashed mean line at 6.3 and a grey dotted median line at 6.5

\[ 5 \text{ marks} \le \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6},\ \ 5 \ge \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} \]

Check: count each side of 6.5

Why: five places either side

25. Group B's centres run mean, median, mode

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group B's 10 marks from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, four at 7, one at 8, nothing above 8, with a grey dashed mean line at 6.3 and a grey dotted median line at 6.5

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7}:\ 4 \text{ marks} \]

Count the tallest stack

Why: the mode is commonest

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group B's 10 marks from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, four at 7, one at 8, nothing above 8, with mean and median lines and the four-dot stack at 7 boxed as the mode

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6}:\ 3,\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{8}:\ 1 \]

Count the rest

Why: only taller wins

\[ \text{mode} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} \]

Take the mark with four

Why: a mark, not a count

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.3} < \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.5} < \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} \]

Order the three centres

Why: each rule stopped elsewhere

Marks stretching down: skewed left.

Tail: the long thin side.

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} - \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.3} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.7},\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} - \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.5} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.5} \]

Check from the mode

Why: the mean fell further

26. Group C's 10 marks pool to 77, an equal share of 7.7

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group C's 10 marks from 4 to 10: one dot at 6, four at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, nothing below 6

\[ 4 \times \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{28} \]

Total the four 7s

Why: the tallest stack carries most

\[ 3 \times \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{8} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{24} \]

Total the three 8s

Why: the second repeat owes its share

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6 + 28 + 24 + 9 + 10} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{77} \]

Add the five part totals

Why: Σx counts all 10 marks

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{77} \div 10 = \textcolor{#6b7280}{7.7} \]

Share the pool among 10

Why: an equal cut for a class leaning high

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group C's 10 marks from 4 to 10: one dot at 6, four at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, nothing below 6, with a grey dashed line at the mean 7.7

\[ 10 \times \textcolor{#6b7280}{7.7} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{77} \]

Check: rebuild the pool

Why: ten equal cuts rebuild 77

27. Group C's median is left to you

Faded example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group C's 10 marks from 4 to 10: one dot at 6, four at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, nothing below 6, with a grey dashed line at the mean 7.7

Group C's ten marks, already in order.

Fill in the blanks

5th mark = 7; 6th mark = 8; M = 7.5

Why: 1 + 10 = 11 and 11 ÷ 2 = 5.5, so places 5 and 6 decide M. Place 5 holds 7 and place 6 holds 8, and (7 + 8) ÷ 2 = 7.5, a value no student actually scored.

28. Group C's median, 7.5, sits below its mean

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group C's 10 marks from 4 to 10: one dot at 6, four at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, nothing below 6, with a grey dashed line at the mean 7.7

\[ 1 + 10 = 11 \]

Add the outer places

Why: ten marks, so both ends again

\[ 11 \div 2 = 5.5 \]

Halve 11

Why: places 5 and 6 decide

\[ \text{5th} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7},\ \ \text{6th} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{8} \]

Read places 5 and 6

Why: the middles disagree here

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{8} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{15} \]

Add the pair

Why: the halving starts here

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{15} \div 2 = \textcolor{#6b7280}{7.5} \]

Halve 15

Why: M falls between marks

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group C's 10 marks from 4 to 10: one dot at 6, four at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, nothing below 6, with a grey dashed mean line at 7.7 and a grey dotted median line at 7.5

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{7.5} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.5},\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{8} - \textcolor{#6b7280}{7.5} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.5} \]

Check: step to each middle mark

Why: equal steps confirm halfway

29. Each mean sits on its own tail's side

Worked example

Figure (svg): Two dot plots on one scale from 4 to 10: Group B with a grey dashed mean line at 6.3 and a grey dotted median line at 6.5, and Group C with a mean line at 7.7 and a median line at 7.5

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7}:\ 4 \text{ marks} \]

Count Group C's tallest stack

Why: its mode, for the ordering

Figure (svg): Two dot plots on one scale from 4 to 10: Group B with a grey dashed mean line at 6.3 and a grey dotted median line at 6.5, and Group C with a mean line at 7.7 and a median line at 7.5, and Group C's four-dot stack at 7 boxed as its mode

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} < \textcolor{#6b7280}{7.5} < \textcolor{#6b7280}{7.7} \]

Order Group C's centres

Why: Group B ran the other way

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.3} - \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.5} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{-0.2} \]

Take B's mean less its median

Why: the sign names the pulled side

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{7.7} - \textcolor{#6b7280}{7.5} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{+0.2} \]

Take C's mean less its median

Why: same size, the other side

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.5} + (\textcolor{#1f5fbf}{-0.2}) = \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.3},\ \ \textcolor{#6b7280}{7.5} + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{+0.2} = \textcolor{#6b7280}{7.7} \]

Check: add each gap to its median

Why: both land back on their means

30. The tall stack's side does not name it

Trap

The trap

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group B's 10 marks from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, four at 7, one at 8, nothing above 8, with the four-dot stack at 7 boxed as the mode

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7}:\ 4 \text{ marks} \]

Find the tall stack

Why: eyes go there

\[ \text{peak high} \Rightarrow \text{right} \]

Judge by the peak

Why: thin side rules

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.3} < \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.5} \]

Compare the centres

Why: 6.3 is lower

The fix

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group B's 10 marks from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, four at 7, one at 8, nothing above 8, with a grey dashed line at the mean 6.3 sitting left of the median 6.5

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5}:\ 1;\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{9},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{10}:\ \text{none} \]

Read both ends

Why: one thin, one empty

\[ \text{skewed left} \]

Name the side

Why: the tail decides

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.3} < \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.5} < \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} \]

Check the order

Why: the mean is lowest

31. Nine made-up waits: 2, 2, 3, 3, 3, 4, 4, 5 and 18 minutes

Prediction

Figure (svg): Dot plot of nine made-up waiting times on a scale from 0 to 20 minutes: two dots at 2, three at 3, two at 4, one at 5 and one far out at 18

Predict first

Made-up waiting times in minutes: 2, 2, 3, 3, 3, 4, 4, 5, 18.

Which way do these times stretch?

  • To the high side, towards 18
  • To the low side, towards 2
  • Neither: they are symmetrical
  • It cannot be told without the mean

Correct: To the high side, towards 18

Why: Eight of the nine waits sit between 2 and 5, and the ninth is 18, far above them, with nothing below 2 to answer it. The long thin side is the high side. The mean is not needed for this: the shape is visible in the plot, and the mean only measures how far the stretch reaches.

32. One wait of 18 lifts the mean above seven waits

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of nine made-up waiting times on a scale from 0 to 20 minutes: two dots at 2, three at 3, two at 4, one at 5 and one far out at 18

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3} \]

Measure the eight-wait pack

Why: they crowd three minutes

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{18} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{13} \]

Measure the reach up

Why: thin side, far longer

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2 + 2 + 3 + 3 + 3 + 4 + 4 + 5 + 18} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{44} \]

Total all nine waits

Why: a mean sizes the stretch

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{44} \div 9 \approx \textcolor{#6b7280}{4.9} \]

Share among 9

Why: one wait lifts the cut

Figure (svg): Dot plot of nine made-up waiting times on a scale from 0 to 20 minutes: two dots at 2, three at 3, two at 4, one at 5 and one far out at 18, with a grey dashed line at the mean 4.9

\[ \text{5th of 9} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3} \]

Read the middle wait

Why: odd n gives one

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{4.9} > \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3} \]

Check: mean against median

Why: the mean climbed the tail

33. Measure the pull: one mark, one move

Section

Idea 3 of 4

34. Group A's top mark of 10 is re-marked 14

Concept

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, redrawn on a scale from 4 to 14 with the top mark still at 10

Idea 1 found Group A: Σx = 112, x̄ = 7, M = 7.

Discussion prompt

Which of Group A's three centres move when its 10 becomes 14?

Answer:

Only the mean moves, and by far less than 4.

35. Adding the whole move claims 64 extra marks

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, on a scale from 4 to 14

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{14} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{10} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} \]

Measure how far it travels

Why: only this value changed

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{7} + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} = \textcolor{#6b7280}{11} \]

Add the whole move

Why: the quickest guess, worth testing

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, on a scale from 4 to 14 with the top mark moved out to 14 and a grey dashed line at 11, right of every other mark

\[ 16 \times \textcolor{#6b7280}{11} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{176} \]

Rebuild the pool from 11

Why: a mean must give Σx back

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{176} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{112} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{64} \]

Subtract the old pool

Why: the guess invented marks

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{64} \ne \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} \]

Compare with the real move

Why: sixteen times too much

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{112} + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{116} \ne \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{176} \]

Check: pool the re-marked data

Why: the true total is 60 short

36. The re-marked Group A has mean 7.25, a move of only 0.25

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, on a scale from 4 to 14

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{112} + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{116} \]

Add the move to the pool

Why: no other mark changed

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, on a scale from 4 to 14 with the top mark moved from 10 out to 14, a hollow ring left at 10 and a blue arrow labelled moves 4

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{116} \div 16 = \textcolor{#6b7280}{7.25} \]

Share the new pool

Why: the mean rule is unchanged

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, on a scale from 4 to 14 with the top mark at 14 and a grey dashed line at the mean 7.25

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{7.25} - \textcolor{#6b7280}{7} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.25} \]

Subtract the old mean

Why: how far the balance travelled

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} \div 16 = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.25} \]

Share the move itself

Why: the same number, shorter road

\[ 16 \times \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.25} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} \]

Check: rebuild the move

Why: sixteen shares make 4

37. One value out by c shifts the mean c ÷ n

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, on a scale from 4 to 14 with the top mark moved out to 14, a hollow ring at 10 and a grey line at the mean 7.25

c: one value's move · n: how many values

\[ {\textstyle{\textstyle\sum}} x + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{c} \]

Add the move

Why: no other value moved

\[ ({\textstyle{\textstyle\sum}} x + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{c}) \div n \]

Share the new pool

Why: the rule fits any list

\[ {\textstyle{\textstyle\sum}} x \div n + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{c} \div n \]

Split the share

Why: each part keeps its own

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{\bar{x}} + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{c} \div n \]

Name the first part

Why: it is the old mean

\[ \text{shift} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{c} \div n \]

Subtract the old mean

Why: the rest is its travel

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, on a scale from 4 to 14 with the top mark at 14, a grey dashed line at the new mean 7.25 and a grey dotted line at the old mean 7

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{c} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4},\ n = 16:\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} \div 16 = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.25} \]

Check on Group A

Why: it matches the long road

38. Pulling the top mark out leaves places alone

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, on a scale from 4 to 14 with the top mark moved out to 14 and a grey dashed mean line at 7.25

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{14} > \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{10} > \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{9} \]

Compare the moved mark

Why: it was largest and still is

\[ 1 + 16 = 17 \]

Add the outer places

Why: the count has not changed

\[ 17 \div 2 = 8.5 \]

Halve 17

Why: places 8 and 9 decide M

\[ \text{8th} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7},\ \ \text{9th} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} \]

Read places 8 and 9

Why: both sit far from the move

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, on a scale from 4 to 14 with the top mark at 14, a grey dashed mean line at 7.25 and a grey dotted median line at 7

\[ M = \textcolor{#6b7280}{7} \]

Take halfway between two 7s

Why: the median has not stirred

\[ 5 \text{ below } \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7},\ \ 5 \text{ above} \]

Check: count each side again

Why: the split at 7 survived

39. The shift grows with c and shrinks with n

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, on a scale from 4 to 14 with a grey dashed line at the mean 7

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{8} \div 16 = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.5} \]

Move the mark twice as far

Why: tests what distance controls

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group A's 16 marks on a scale from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, six at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, on a scale from 4 to 14 with grey lines at 7.25 and 7.5 labelled with their shifts

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} \div 32 = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.125} \]

Share the same move among 32

Why: tests what class size controls

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0} \div 16 = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0} \]

Leave the mark alone

Why: a rule must hold at its edge

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.5} > \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.25} > \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.125} \]

Rank the three shifts

Why: long moves in small classes count

The mean always travels towards the moved mark.

\[ 16 \times \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.5} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{8} \]

Check: rebuild the longest move

Why: sixteen shares add to 8

40. Group C's 10 re-marked as 20 lifts its mean to 8.7

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group C's 10 marks from 4 to 10: one dot at 6, four at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, nothing below 6, on a scale from 6 to 20

Group C pooled to 77, mean 7.7.

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{20} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{10} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{10} \]

Measure the mark's move

Why: the rule needs a distance

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{10} \div 10 = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1} \]

Share the move among 10

Why: n is the group size

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group C's 10 marks from 4 to 10: one dot at 6, four at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, nothing below 6, on a scale from 6 to 20 with the top mark moved from 10 out to 20, a hollow ring at 10 and a blue arrow labelled moves 10

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{7.7} + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1} = \textcolor{#6b7280}{8.7} \]

Add the shift on

Why: the rule's predicted balance

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group C's 10 marks from 4 to 10: one dot at 6, four at 7, three at 8, one at 9, one at 10, nothing below 6, on a scale from 6 to 20 with the top mark at 20 and a grey dashed line at the mean 8.7

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{77} + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{10} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{87} \]

Pool the re-marked data

Why: an independent road there

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{87} \div 10 = \textcolor{#6b7280}{8.7} \]

Check: share the pool

Why: the long road agrees

41. A mark crossing the middle does move M

Trap

The trap

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group B's 10 marks from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, four at 7, one at 8, nothing above 8, with a grey dotted median line at 6.5

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} \to \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{9} \]

Re-mark B's 4 as 9

Why: nine marks hold

\[ M = \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.5} \]

Keep the old median

Why: a mark crossed

\[ \text{5th} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7},\ \ \text{6th} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} \]

Read both middles

Why: they are new

The fix

Figure (svg): Dot plot of the re-marked Group B, 5, 6, 6, 6, 7, 7, 7, 7, 8, 9, on a scale from 4 to 10, with a grey dotted median line at 7

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{8},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{9} \]

Sort the new ten

Why: order rules M

\[ M = \textcolor{#6b7280}{7} \]

Halve two 7s

Why: the new middles agree

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{7} - \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.5} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.5} \]

Check M's move

Why: crossings shift it

42. A club of 50 members has mean age 34 and median age 31

Prediction

Figure (svg): A bar of the club's 50 ordered places with a grey dashed line at place 25.5 and a blue arrow leaving the top place labelled 60 to 80

Predict first

One member's age is corrected from 60 to 80 years.

What happens to the club's two centres?

  • The mean rises 0.4; the median stays 31
  • Both rise by 20
  • The mean rises 20; the median stays 31
  • Neither changes

Correct: The mean rises 0.4; the median stays 31

Why: The correction moves one age by 80 − 60 = 20, and the shift rule shares that among all 50 members: 20 ÷ 50 = 0.4, so the mean becomes 34.4. Both 60 and 80 sit above the middle of the ordered ages, so the members at places 25 and 26 keep their ages and the median stays 31.

43. The club's mean rises 0.4, its median holds

Worked example

Figure (svg): A bar of the club's 50 ordered places with a grey dashed line at place 25.5 and a blue arrow leaving the top place labelled 60 to 80

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{80} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{60} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{20} \]

Measure the correction

Why: a distance drives the rule

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{20} \div 50 = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.4} \]

Share it among 50

Why: everyone holds part

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{34} + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.4} = \textcolor{#6b7280}{34.4} \]

Add the shift on

Why: the club's new balance

\[ 1 + 50 = 51 \]

Add the outer places

Why: the median rule wants ends

\[ 51 \div 2 = 25.5 \]

Halve 51

Why: places 25 and 26 decide

Figure (svg): A bar of the club's 50 ordered places split at place 25.5, with a grey line there and a blue arrow at the top place labelled 60 to 80

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{60} > \textcolor{#6b7280}{31},\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{80} > \textcolor{#6b7280}{31} \]

Check: both ages exceed 31

Why: no middle place changed hands

44. Twenty-five made-up test scores average 62 until one rises

Faded example

Figure (svg): A bar of 25 ordered places with a grey dashed line at place 13 and a blue arrow at the top place labelled up 5

Made up: 25 scores, mean 62. One score rises 5.

Fill in the blanks

shift = 5 ÷ 25 = 0.2; new mean = 62.2

Why: The shift rule shares the 5-point rise among all 25 scores: 5 ÷ 25 = 0.2, so the mean climbs from 62 to 62.2. The median only moves if that score crossed the middle place, which is place 13.

45. The 5-point rise lifts the made-up mean to 62.2

Worked example

Figure (svg): A bar of 25 ordered places with a grey dashed line at place 13 and a blue arrow at the top place labelled up 5

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5} \div 25 = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.2} \]

Share the rise among 25

Why: the rule divides by n

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{62} + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.2} = \textcolor{#6b7280}{62.2} \]

Add the shift to the mean

Why: the new equal cut

\[ 25 \times \textcolor{#6b7280}{62} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1550} \]

Rebuild the old pool

Why: the long way, as a cross-check

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1550} + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1555} \]

Add the rise to that pool

Why: only one score changed

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1555} \div 25 = \textcolor{#6b7280}{62.2} \]

Check: share the new pool

Why: the long road lands too

46. Read it backwards: shape from two centres

Section

Idea 4 of 4

47. Terry and Davis each wrote ten words of different lengths

Concept

Figure (svg): Two dot plots on one scale from 0 to 10: Terry's counts with a tall stack at 3 and single counts out at 7 and 9, and Davis' counts with a tall stack at 3 and nothing above 4

Example 2.31: ten letter counts each, one dot per word.

Discussion prompt

Whose counts stretch to the high side, Terry's or Davis'?

Answer:

Terry's: 7 and 9 hang far above the rest. Can numbers alone say so?

48. Terry's mean, 3.7, sits above his tallest stack

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Terry's ten letter counts from 0 to 10: one dot at 1, two at 2, four at 3, one at 4, one at 7, one at 9

\[ 4 \times \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{12} \]

Total Terry's four 3s

Why: counting shortens the pool

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1 + 2 + 2 + 12 + 4 + 7 + 9} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{37} \]

Add the seven part totals

Why: Σx must hold ten counts

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{37} \div 10 = \textcolor{#6b7280}{3.7} \]

Share the pool among 10

Why: Terry's mean, for comparison

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Terry's ten letter counts from 0 to 10: one dot at 1, two at 2, four at 3, one at 4, one at 7, one at 9, with a grey dashed line at the mean 3.7

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3}:\ 4 \text{ counts} \]

Find Terry's tallest stack

Why: a peak is the obvious reference

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Terry's ten letter counts from 0 to 10: one dot at 1, two at 2, four at 3, one at 4, one at 7, one at 9, with a grey mean line at 3.7 and the four-dot stack at 3 boxed as the mode

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{3.7} > \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3} \]

Compare the mean with it

Why: the mean settled above the crowd

\[ 10 \times \textcolor{#6b7280}{3.7} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{37} \]

Check: rebuild Terry's pool

Why: ten cuts give the pool back

49. A median exists where a peak may not

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Terry's ten letter counts from 0 to 10: one dot at 1, two at 2, four at 3, one at 4, one at 7, one at 9, with a grey dashed line at the mean 3.7

\[ 1 + 10 = 11 \]

Add the outer places

Why: a place before a value

\[ 11 \div 2 = 5.5 \]

Halve 11

Why: 5.5 sits between two counts

\[ \text{5th} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3},\ \ \text{6th} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3} \]

Read the two middles

Why: both land in the 3s

\[ M = \textcolor{#6b7280}{3} \]

Take halfway of two 3s

Why: no averaging needed

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{3.7} > \textcolor{#6b7280}{3} \]

Compare the two

Why: the mean drifted high

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Terry's ten letter counts from 0 to 10: one dot at 1, two at 2, four at 3, one at 4, one at 7, one at 9, with a grey dashed mean line at 3.7 and a grey dotted median line at 3

\[ \text{places } 1\text{–}5 \le \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3},\ \ 6\text{–}10 \ge \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3} \]

Check: read the places

Why: five each side

50. Davis' mean, 2.7, comes out a whole point below Terry's

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Davis' ten letter counts from 0 to 10: two dots at 1, one at 2, five at 3, two at 4

\[ 2 \times \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2} \]

Total Davis' two 1s

Why: his shortest words repeat

\[ 5 \times \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{15} \]

Total his five 3s

Why: the tallest stack weighs most

\[ 2 \times \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{8} \]

Total his two 4s

Why: no repeat left out

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2 + 2 + 15 + 8} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{27} \]

Add the four part totals

Why: Σx must hold ten counts

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{27} \div 10 = \textcolor{#6b7280}{2.7} \]

Share the pool among 10

Why: Davis' mean, beside Terry's

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Davis' ten letter counts from 0 to 10: two dots at 1, one at 2, five at 3, two at 4, with a grey dashed line at the mean 2.7

\[ 10 \times \textcolor{#6b7280}{2.7} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{27} \]

Check: rebuild Davis' pool

Why: the cut times ten is Σx

51. Davis' median is 3, so his mean has drifted the other way

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Davis' ten letter counts from 0 to 10: two dots at 1, one at 2, five at 3, two at 4, with a grey dashed line at the mean 2.7

Ten counts again: middle place 5.5.

\[ \text{5th} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3},\ \ \text{6th} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3} \]

Read Davis' middles

Why: the same place as Terry

\[ M = \textcolor{#6b7280}{3} \]

Take halfway between two 3s

Why: his median is a count

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{2.7} < \textcolor{#6b7280}{3} \]

Compare his mean with it

Why: this mean drifted low

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Davis' ten letter counts from 0 to 10: two dots at 1, one at 2, five at 3, two at 4, with a grey dashed mean line at 2.7 and a grey dotted median line at 3

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{3} - \textcolor{#6b7280}{2.7} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.3},\ \ \textcolor{#6b7280}{3.7} - \textcolor{#6b7280}{3} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.7} \]

Measure both from 3

Why: Terry's strayed further

\[ \text{places } 4 \text{ to } 8 = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3} \]

Check: name the 3s' places

Why: 5 and 6 sit inside

52. A signed gap points at the stretched side

Worked example

Figure (svg): Two dot plots on one scale from 0 to 10: Terry's counts with a tall stack at 3 and single counts out at 7 and 9, and Davis' counts with a tall stack at 3 and nothing above 4, each with a grey dashed mean line and a grey dotted median line

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{3.7} - \textcolor{#6b7280}{3} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{+0.7} \]

Subtract Terry's median

Why: a signed gap carries direction

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{2.7} - \textcolor{#6b7280}{3} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{-0.3} \]

Subtract Davis' median

Why: his sign comes out reversed

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{+0.7}:\ \text{high side} \]

Read Terry's sign

Why: his 7 and 9 stretch upward

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{-0.3}:\ \text{low side} \]

Read Davis' sign

Why: his two 1s stretch downward

In both samples the mean fell on the stretched side.

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{3} + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.7} = \textcolor{#6b7280}{3.7},\ \ \textcolor{#6b7280}{3} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.3} = \textcolor{#6b7280}{2.7} \]

Check: step from 3 by each gap

Why: both steps land on their means

53. Maris' gap points high, his loose counts low

Trap

The trap

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{4.6} - \textcolor{#6b7280}{4} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{+0.6} \]

Subtract the median

Why: the sign names the pulled side

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{+0.6} \Rightarrow \text{stretches high} \]

Read the sign

Why: the plot disagrees

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{8} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2},\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2} \]

Measure both ends

Why: the reaches agree

The fix

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Maris' ten letter counts from 0 to 10: one dot at 2, two at 3, three at 4, three at 6, one at 8, with a grey dashed fold line at 5 and two counts at 3 facing an empty 7

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3},\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{8} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3} \]

Measure the ends

Why: test the fold

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3}:\ 2 \text{ counts},\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7}:\ \text{none} \]

Count 3 against 7

Why: weight lies low

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{4.6} > \textcolor{#6b7280}{4} \]

Check the centres

Why: a tendency only

54. Pushing B's top mark out moves only the mean

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group B's 10 marks from 4 to 10: one dot at 4, one at 5, three at 6, four at 7, one at 8, nothing above 8, with a grey dashed mean line at 6.3 and a grey dotted median line at 6.5

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{20} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{8} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{12} \]

Push the top mark to 20

Why: tests which centre notices

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{12} \div 10 = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1.2} \]

Share the push among 10

Why: the shift rule gives the travel

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.3} + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1.2} = \textcolor{#6b7280}{7.5} \]

Add the shift to the mean

Why: one mark carried it past 7

Figure (svg): Dot plot of Group B with its top mark pushed out to 20, on a scale from 4 to 20, with a grey dashed mean line at 7.5 and a grey dotted median line at 6.5

\[ M = \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.5} \]

Read the median again

Why: no mark changed places

Report the median when data stretches one way.

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{7.5} - \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.3} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1.2} \]

Check: measure the mean's travel

Why: it matches the shared push

55. A shop: mode 1 item, median 2, mean 5.4

Prediction

Figure (svg): A bar of 200 ordered places split in half at place 100.5, the lower half labelled 2 items or fewer and the upper half 2 items or more

Predict first

A shop reports three centres for 200 orders: mode 1 item, median 2 items, mean 5.4 items.

Which statement do those three numbers support?

  • At least 100 orders are below the mean
  • Half the orders are above 5.4 items
  • 5.4 items is the commonest order
  • The orders are spread evenly about 5.4

Correct: At least 100 orders are below the mean

Why: A median of 2 means at least 100 of the 200 orders are 2 items or fewer, and 2 is below 5.4. It is the median, not the mean, that splits the count in half; the commonest order is the mode, 1 item; and a mean sitting far above the median is the mark of a one-sided stretch, not an even spread.

56. The shop's median puts 100 orders below its mean

Worked example

Figure (svg): A bar of the shop's 200 orders, in size order, not yet divided

\[ 1 + 200 = 201 \]

Add the outer places

Why: 200 orders have a middle too

\[ 201 \div 2 = 100.5 \]

Halve 201

Why: places 100 and 101 decide

\[ \text{places } 1\text{–}100 \le \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2} \]

Read the places below

Why: a median of 2 caps them

Figure (svg): A bar of 200 ordered places split at place 100.5, the lower half labelled 2 items or fewer, with a grey line at the middle place

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2} < \textcolor{#6b7280}{5.4} \]

Compare the cap with 5.4

Why: all 100 sit under it too

\[ 200 - 100 = 100 \]

Check: count what is left

Why: at most 100 beat the mean

57. Twenty presidents' ages at death, as a stem plot

Faded example

Figure (svg): A stem-and-leaf plot of the presidents' ages: stem 4 with leaves 6 and 9, stem 5 with leaves 3, 6, 7, 7, 7 and 8, stem 6 with twelve leaves 0, 0, 3, 3, 4, 4, 5, 6, 7, 7, 7 and 8

Try It 2.31: stem = tens, leaf = ones, 20 ages.

Fill in the blanks

middle places = 10 and 11; M = 61.5 years

Why: 1 + 20 = 21 and 21 ÷ 2 = 10.5, so places 10 and 11 decide M. The first two stems hold 8 ages, so place 9 is the first leaf of stem 6; place 10 is 60 and place 11 is 63, and (60 + 63) ÷ 2 = 61.5.

58. Places 10 and 11 hold 60 and 63, so the median is 61.5

Worked example

Figure (svg): A stem-and-leaf plot of the presidents' ages: stem 4 with leaves 6 and 9, stem 5 with leaves 3, 6, 7, 7, 7 and 8, stem 6 with twelve leaves 0, 0, 3, 3, 4, 4, 5, 6, 7, 7, 7 and 8

\[ 1 + 20 = 21 \]

Add the outer places

Why: the stem plot is sorted

\[ 21 \div 2 = 10.5 \]

Halve 21

Why: places 10 and 11 decide

\[ 2 + 6 = 8 \]

Add the stems' leaves

Why: tells where sixties begin

\[ \text{10th} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{60},\ \ \text{11th} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{63} \]

Read places 10 and 11

Why: the sixties open here

Figure (svg): A stem-and-leaf plot of the presidents' ages: stem 4 with leaves 6 and 9, stem 5 with leaves 3, 6, 7, 7, 7 and 8, stem 6 with twelve leaves 0, 0, 3, 3, 4, 4, 5, 6, 7, 7, 7 and 8; the leaves at places 10 and 11 boxed

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{60} + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{63} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{123} \]

Add the pair

Why: a sum comes before halving

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{123} \div 2 = \textcolor{#6b7280}{61.5} \]

Check: halve that total

Why: 61.5 sits 1.5 either way

59. The first two stem rows pool to 433

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of 20 presidents' ages at death on a scale from 45 to 70: single dots at 46, 49, 53, 56 and 58, three at 57, two at 60, two at 63, two at 64, one each at 65, 66 and 68, three at 67

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{46 + 49} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{95} \]

Total the forties row

Why: one stem at a time

\[ 3 \times \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{57} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{171} \]

Total the three 57s

Why: three equal ages multiply once

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{53 + 56 + 58} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{167} \]

Add the single fifties

Why: three ages appear once

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{171} + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{167} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{338} \]

Add the fifties parts

Why: that stem's own pool

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{95} + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{338} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{433} \]

Check: add the two stems

Why: eight ages, each counted once

60. The sixties row alone pools to 774

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of 20 presidents' ages at death on a scale from 45 to 70: single dots at 46, 49, 53, 56 and 58, three at 57, two at 60, two at 63, two at 64, one each at 65, 66 and 68, three at 67

\( {95 + 338 = 433} \)

\[ 2 \times \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{60},\ 2 \times \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{63},\ 2 \times \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{64} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{120},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{126},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{128} \]

Total the three pairs

Why: counting each repeat

\[ 3 \times \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{67} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{201} \]

Total the three 67s

Why: the commonest age weighs most

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{65 + 66 + 68} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{199} \]

Add the single sixties

Why: no repeat here to shorten

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{120 + 126 + 128 + 201 + 199} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{774} \]

Add the five parts

Why: this stem's pool

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{433} + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{774} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1207} \]

Check: add both stems

Why: all 20 ages once

61. The presidents' mean sits below their median

Worked example

Figure (svg): Dot plot of 20 presidents' ages at death on a scale from 45 to 70: single dots at 46, 49, 53, 56 and 58, three at 57, two at 60, two at 63, two at 64, one each at 65, 66 and 68, three at 67

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1207} \div 20 = \textcolor{#6b7280}{60.35} \]

Share the pool among 20

Why: one age if all were level

Figure (svg): Dot plot of 20 presidents' ages at death on a scale from 45 to 70: single dots at 46, 49, 53, 56 and 58, three at 57, two at 60, two at 63, two at 64, one each at 65, 66 and 68, three at 67, with a grey dashed line at the mean 60.35

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{60.35} - \textcolor{#6b7280}{61.5} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{-1.15} \]

Subtract the median

Why: the sign names a side

Figure (svg): Dot plot of 20 presidents' ages at death on a scale from 45 to 70: single dots at 46, 49, 53, 56 and 58, three at 57, two at 60, two at 63, two at 64, one each at 65, 66 and 68, three at 67, with a grey dashed mean line at 60.35 and a grey dotted median line at 61.5

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{-1.15}:\ \text{low side} \]

Read the sign

Why: the stretch runs towards 46

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{57} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{46} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{11},\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{68} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{57} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{11} \]

Measure each end from 57

Why: equal reach, unequal filling

\[ 2 \text{ ages below } \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{53},\ \ 6 \text{ above } \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{64} \]

Check: count both thin ends

Why: two ages hold the low one

62. Five moves read a shape and choose a centre

Pattern

  1. Fold the plot: equal gaps both sides means symmetrical
  2. No fold: name the side the thin tail lies on
  3. Left stretch: mean below median; right: above
  4. One value out by c moves the mean c ÷ n
  5. Stretched data: report the median, mean beside it

\[ \text{shift} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{c} \div n,\qquad \textcolor{#6b7280}{\bar{x}} - M \text{ names the stretched side} \]

63. A class of 20 wants its mean score lifted from 5 to 5.4

Check

Figure (svg): A bar of 20 ordered places with a grey line at place 10.5 and a blue arrow leaving the top place labelled up c

Check your understanding

One student's score in a class of 20 is re-marked upward. How far must it rise to lift the class mean from 5 to 5.4?

  • A. 8 marks (correct)
  • B. 0.4 marks
  • C. 4 marks
  • D. 20 marks

Answer: A

Why: The shift rule says the mean travels c ÷ n. Here the travel is 5.4 − 5 = 0.4 and n = 20, so c ÷ 20 = 0.4 and c = 0.4 × 20 = 8 marks.

Why B tempts people
0.4 is how far the MEAN travels; the score itself must move 20 times as far.
Why C tempts people
4 would be right for a class of 10; this class holds 20, so each mark of the rise is shared twice as thinly.
Why D tempts people
20 is the class size, the divisor in the shift rule, not a distance any score moves.

64. The score must rise 8 marks to move the mean 0.4

Worked example

Figure (svg): A bar of 20 ordered places with a grey line at place 10.5 and a blue arrow at the top place labelled up 8

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{5.4} - \textcolor{#6b7280}{5} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.4} \]

Measure the mean's required travel

Why: the shift rule's known side

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.4} \times 20 = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{8} \]

Undo the sharing by 20

Why: multiplying back gives the move

\[ 20 \times \textcolor{#6b7280}{5} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{100} \]

Rebuild the old pool

Why: a second route to the answer

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{100} + \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{8} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{108} \]

Add the 8-mark rise

Why: only one score changed

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{108} \div 20 = \textcolor{#6b7280}{5.4} \]

Check: share the new pool

Why: the mean lands on target

65. Four made-up lists of five values each

Check

Figure (svg): Four dot plots on one scale from 1 to 10, one per made-up list: 1, 6, 7, 8, 9; 1, 2, 3, 4, 10; 3, 4, 5, 6, 7; and 2, 5, 5, 5, 8

Check your understanding

Which of these made-up lists of five values has its mean below its median?

  • A. 1, 6, 7, 8, 9 (correct)
  • B. 1, 2, 3, 4, 10
  • C. 3, 4, 5, 6, 7
  • D. 2, 5, 5, 5, 8

Answer: A

Why: Its total is 31, so the mean is 6.2, while its third value is 7. The lone 1 stretches the low side and drags the mean under the median.

Why B tempts people
Its total is 20, so the mean is 4 and the third value is 3: the mean sits ABOVE the median, because the 10 stretches the high side.
Why C tempts people
Its total is 25, mean 5, third value 5: the set folds at 5, so the two centres agree.
Why D tempts people
Its total is 25 as well, mean 5, third value 5: it also folds at 5, with 2 and 8 mirroring each other.

66. Only list 1 has its mean below its median

Worked example

Figure (svg): Four dot plots on one scale from 1 to 10, one per made-up list: 1, 6, 7, 8, 9; 1, 2, 3, 4, 10; 3, 4, 5, 6, 7; and 2, 5, 5, 5, 8, each with a grey dashed mean line at 6.2, 4, 5 and 5

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{31},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{20},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{25},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{25} \]

Total each list in turn

Why: a mean starts from its pool

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{31} \div 5,\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{20} \div 5,\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{25} \div 5 = \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.2},\ \textcolor{#6b7280}{4},\ \textcolor{#6b7280}{5} \]

Share each pool among 5

Why: three shares cover four

\[ \text{3rd values} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5},\ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5} \]

Read place 3 of each

Why: odd n puts M there

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.2} < \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7};\ \ \textcolor{#6b7280}{4} > \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{3};\ \ \textcolor{#6b7280}{5} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{5} \]

Compare each with its M

Why: only the first falls short

\[ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{9} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{2},\ \ \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{7} - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{1} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6} \]

Check: measure each side

Why: the low reach is longer

67. Group B's mean is smallest; C mirrors it

Worked example

Figure (svg): Three dot plots on one scale from 4 to 10, each with a grey dashed line at 7: Group A with 16 marks spread evenly either side, Group B with 10 marks reaching down to 4 and stopping at 8, Group C with 10 marks starting at 6 and reaching up to 10

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.3} < \textcolor{#6b7280}{7} < \textcolor{#6b7280}{7.7} \]

Order the three means

Why: the opening question

Figure (svg): Three dot plots on one scale from 4 to 10, each with a grey dashed line at 7: Group A with 16 marks spread evenly either side, Group B with 10 marks reaching down to 4 and stopping at 8, Group C with 10 marks starting at 6 and reaching up to 10, each labelled with its mean: 7, 6.3 and 7.7

\[ \textcolor{#6b7280}{7} - \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.3} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.7},\ \ \textcolor{#6b7280}{7.7} - \textcolor{#6b7280}{7} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{0.7} \]

Measure both from A

Why: equal misses from the fold

\[ 14 - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{4} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{10},\ \ 14 - \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{8} = \textcolor{#1f5fbf}{6} \]

Reflect B's ends through 7

Why: they land on C's

\[ \text{B stretches down, C up} \]

Name what that shows

Why: one set mirrors the other

\[ 14 - \textcolor{#6b7280}{6.3} = \textcolor{#6b7280}{7.7} \]

Check: reflect B's mean

Why: Group C's value returns

68. You can now read a shape and pick the centre that fits it

Recap

OpenStax Introductory Statistics 2e, §2.6 Skewness and the Mean, Median, and Mode §2.6, pp. 104-106 — Figures 2.16-2.21, Example 2.31 and Try It 2.31 trace back here

Sources

  1. OpenStax Introductory Statistics 2e, §2.6 Skewness and the Mean, Median, and Mode — Illowsky & Dean, OpenStax / Rice University, CC BY 4.0, pp. 104-106
  2. OpenStax Introductory Business Statistics 2e, §2.6 Skewness and the Mean, Median, and Mode — Illowsky & Dean, OpenStax / Rice University, CC BY 4.0

Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Statistics — $55/session, free consultation.

Book on Wyzant · Text (657) 465-8108