6.5 Physical Applications

Mass from a varying density, work as the integral of a varying force, Hooke's law and springs, the work of pumping a tank, and hydrostatic force on a vertical plate — all from the same representative-piece discipline.

Subject: Calculus I · 67 slides · symbolic lesson

Open the interactive version of this deck

What this lesson covers

The lesson, slide by slide

1. Mass, Work and Hydrostatic Force

Title

Calculus I · Section 6.5

Every formula in this section is an elementary product turned into an integral

2. What this lesson gives you

Objectives

Physics hands you two products: mass is density times length, and work is force times distance. Both assume nothing varies. In the real world the density changes along the rod, the force changes as the spring stretches, and the pressure changes with depth. Integration repairs all three the same way.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 594 — learning objectives 6.5.1 to 6.5.5

Chapter 6 has so far pointed integration at geometry: areas, volumes, arc length, surface area. This section points exactly the same machinery at physics, and it is worth noticing early that nothing new is being asked of you mathematically. Every formula here comes from a product you already trust, applied to a piece small enough that the product is honest.

The four applications are mass from a density, work from a variable force, the work of emptying a tank, and the force water exerts on a vertical surface. They look different because they come with different pictures, and that is the real difficulty of the section: the setup is the work, and the integration is usually a power rule.

So read every example twice. The first time for the answer, the second time for the three decisions that produced it: which piece, which coordinate, which elementary product. Those three decisions are what the exam questions are actually testing.

3. Two products from physics, and where they break

Warm-up

Discussion prompt

Write down the formulas you already know for the mass of a uniform rod and for the work done by a constant force. Then say, in one sentence each, exactly which word in those formulas fails when the density varies along the rod, or the force varies along the path.

Write your two formulas down before you look at the answer. If you cannot produce them from memory, that is worth knowing now, because everything in this lesson is built on them.

The point of the question is the second half. Density times length only makes sense if there is one density, and force times distance only makes sense if there is one force. As soon as either factor depends on position, the multiplication has nothing to multiply.

The repair is the same one you used for volumes in Section 6.2 and for shells in Section 6.3. Cut the object into pieces so small that the varying factor is as good as constant on each, use the elementary formula there, and let an integral add the pieces up. If you can say that sentence without the slides, the rest of this lesson is bookkeeping.

4. Mass from a varying density

Section

Part 1

5. One piece small enough to use the old formula

Concept

Figure (svg): A thin rod drawn as a long rectangle from a to b, cut into sixteen slices that are shaded progressively darker towards the right, with one slice highlighted and labelled delta x, and an axis beneath marking a and b.

Cut the rod short enough and the density across one piece is as good as constant, so that piece's mass is an ordinary product.

Lay the rod along the axis from a to b and cut it into n pieces. On the piece from one cut to the next, the density is nearly the value it takes at a point of that piece, so the piece's mass is nearly a product.

\[ m_i \approx \rho(x_i^{*})\,\Delta x \]

\[ m \approx \sum_{i=1}^{n} \rho(x_i^{*})\,\Delta x \]

That is a Riemann sum, and letting the number of pieces grow turns it into the integral.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 595 — Figures 6.48 and 6.49

Look at the picture rather than the algebra first. The rod is shaded darker towards the right because it is denser there, and the highlighted slice is narrow enough that the shading across it barely changes. That is the whole idea, drawn.

The starred point inside the slice is there for honesty. You do not know the exact density everywhere on the slice, so you pick one point of it and use the density there. The error you make by doing that shrinks faster than the number of slices grows, which is why the limit exists.

Once you recognise the sum as a Riemann sum, the limit is automatic, and you never have to build one again in this lesson. From here on you may write the elementary product straight down with a dx attached to it, which is what every worked example will do.

6. Density times length, added up

Concept

linear density — Mass per unit length at a point of a thin rod, written as a function of position along the rod.

\[ m = \lim_{n\to\infty}\sum_{i=1}^{n} \rho(x_i^{*})\,\Delta x = \int_a^b \rho(x)\,dx \]

Theorem 6.7 states exactly this. Notice that a constant density gives the old formula back: the integral of a constant over an interval of length L is that constant times L.

\[ \rho(x) = \rho_0 \;\Longrightarrow\; m = \rho_0 (b-a) \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 595 — Theorem 6.7, equation 6.10

Theorem 6.7 is the formal version of the previous slide, and it is short enough to memorise, but do not memorise it as a fact about rods. Memorise it as the statement that when a rate per unit length varies, you integrate the rate over the length.

The last line is the sanity check that keeps the theorem attached to the physics. Put in a constant density and the integral gives density times length, which is the formula you started with. Every integral formula in this lesson should collapse like that when its varying factor is made constant, and if yours does not, you have set something up wrongly.

Notice also what the theorem does not require: the density does not have to be increasing, smooth, or positive-looking in any particular way. It only has to be integrable, which in this course means essentially any formula you will be handed.

7. Reading the mass formula piece by piece

Notation

Annotate

On: \( m = \int_a^b \rho(x)\,dx \)

  • A density, not a mass: its units are mass per unit length. It is the height of the graph on the next slide.
  • The length of the thin piece. Multiplying it by the density gives that piece a mass, which is why the integral comes out in mass units.
  • The ends of the rod, in whatever coordinate the density was written in. Get these from the sentence, not from the formula.
  • A sum of the pieces' masses, taken in the limit. Nothing about it is geometric; the same symbol adds areas, volumes and masses depending on what is inside.

Work through the annotations in order, and pay closest attention to the first two. The most common conceptual slip in this whole section is treating the integrand as the quantity you want rather than as a rate. The density is not a mass; it becomes one only when multiplied by a length.

The third annotation is worth a habit. The limits come from the sentence describing the object, not from the formula for the density, and a formula for the density is perfectly happy to be evaluated outside the rod where it means nothing. Read the interval off the words.

The last annotation is the one that makes Chapter 6 a single chapter rather than five. The integral sign never knows what it is adding up. You decide that when you choose what to put inside it.

8. Units decide what the integral means

Intuition

An integral is only ever a sum of products. What each product means is fixed by the units of the integrand and of the differential, and that is the fastest way to check a setup before you evaluate anything.

integrand's unitstimes dxthe integral is
length (a height)lengthan area
area (a cross-section)lengtha volume
mass per lengthlengtha mass
forcelengthwork
force per area, times lengthlengtha force

If the units of your integrand times the units of the differential do not come out as the thing you were asked for, the setup is wrong and no amount of clean integration will save it.

This table is the cheapest error check you will ever run, and it takes about five seconds. Multiply the units of your integrand by the units of your differential; if the result is not the units of the answer, stop and re-read your setup.

It also works in reverse, which is more useful. When you are unsure what belongs inside the integral, ask what the answer must be measured in, then ask what you would have to multiply a small length by to get that. For a mass in kilograms over a rod in metres, the integrand must be kilograms per metre.

The last row looks strange until you meet it in Part 4: a pressure is a force per unit area, and multiplying it by a width and a small height gives a force. Come back to this table once you have seen the hydrostatic integral, and that row will read naturally.

9. Mass is the area under the density curve

Picture it

Figure (svg): The curve of the sine function drawn from pi over two to pi, with the region between it and the axis shaded and labelled area equals mass equals 1.

The integrand is a mass per unit length, so the shaded area is a mass, not an area. Units decide what an integral means.

The rod of Example 6.23 runs from a quarter turn to a half turn, and its density is the sine of the position. The shaded region's area is the number you want, but the number is a mass, because the height of the curve is a density.

There is nothing metaphorical about the shaded region here; it is the same region you would shade to compute an area in Section 6.1. What has changed is only the meaning attached to the height of the curve, and with it the meaning of the number.

The curve starts at a height of one at the left end and falls to zero at the right end, so this rod is heaviest at its left end and vanishingly light at its right end. Before computing anything you can therefore say that the mass is less than the length of the rod, which is about 1.57.

Keep an eye on that prediction while you do the next slide. Getting a mass of 1 is consistent with it; getting 3 would have told you immediately that something had gone wrong.

10. Example 6.23: a rod whose density is a sine

Worked example

A thin rod lies on the axis over the interval from one quarter turn to a half turn, with density equal to the sine of the position. Find its mass.

\[ \rho(x) = \sin x, \qquad a = \frac{\pi}{2}, \quad b = \pi \]

Write the mass integral

Why: Theorem 6.7 with these limits and this density.

\[ m = \int_{\pi/2}^{\pi} \sin x\,dx \]

Antidifferentiate

Why: The antiderivative of the sine is minus the cosine.

\[ \int \sin x\,dx = -\cos x \]

Evaluate at both ends

Why: The cosine of a half turn is minus one; the cosine of a quarter turn is zero.

\[ m = \Big[-\cos x\Big]_{\pi/2}^{\pi} = -(-1) - (0) = 1 \]

Check against an average density

Why: The average value of the sine over this interval is two over pi, about 0.6366, and the rod is a quarter turn long, about 1.5708. Their product is the mass, as it must be for any density.

\[ \frac{2}{\pi}\cdot\frac{\pi}{2} = 1 \;\checkmark \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 596 — Example 6.23

This is the model solution for the simplest case, so imitate its shape rather than its numbers. Name the density, name the endpoints, write the integral, integrate, evaluate.

The only place to stumble is the sign. The antiderivative of the sine is minus the cosine, and the cosine at a half turn is minus one, so the subtraction produces two negatives that cancel into a positive one. If your answer is negative for a positive density, a sign has been lost, because a mass cannot be negative.

The check is one you can use on any density at all. The mass equals the average density times the length, so if you can estimate the average height of the density curve by eye, you can estimate the mass. Here the average height is about 0.64 and the rod is about 1.57 long, and the product is exactly the answer.

11. Checkpoint 6.23: a rod from one to three

Worked example

Same theorem, a polynomial density.

\[ \rho(x) = 2x^2 + 3 \text{ on } [1, 3] \]

Write the integral

Why: Density in, limits from the interval.

\[ m = \int_1^{3}\left(2x^2+3\right)dx \]

Antidifferentiate term by term

Why: Power rule on the first term, constant on the second.

\[ \int\left(2x^2+3\right)dx = \frac{2x^3}{3} + 3x \]

Evaluate at the ends

Why: At three the bracket is eighteen plus nine; at one it is two thirds plus three.

\[ m = \left(18 + 9\right) - \left(\frac{2}{3} + 3\right) = \frac{70}{3} \approx 23.33 \]

Check with bounds

Why: The density runs from 5 at the left end to 21 at the right, over a rod of length 2, so the mass must lie between 10 and 42; the density at the midpoint is 11, giving the rough estimate 22. The answer sits just above it, as it should for a density that curves upward.

\[ 10 < \frac{70}{3} < 42, \qquad \frac{70}{3} > 22 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 596 — Checkpoint 6.23

Try this one before reading the solution; it is the same theorem with a polynomial in place of a sine, and it should take you about a minute.

The integration is a term-by-term power rule, and the only real risk is arithmetic in the final subtraction, where the lower limit contributes a fraction. Keep the exact value of seventy thirds rather than rounding early, because the check compares it with two nearby whole numbers.

Look closely at what the check does. The density is between 5 and 21 on this rod, so the mass is trapped between 10 and 42 immediately, before any integration at all. That kind of bound costs nothing and catches almost every arithmetic slip. The midpoint estimate of 22 undershoots slightly, which is what you should expect from a density that curves upward.

12. From a rod to a disk: rings, not slices

Concept

Figure (svg): A circle of radius 4 with several thinner circles inside it, one ring highlighted as a thick band, a radius drawn from the centre to the rim, and labels for the ring's radius x and its width delta x.

Density here depends only on distance from the centre, so the piece on which it is constant is a ring, not a square.

Now take a thin disk of radius r whose density depends only on the distance from the centre. A piece on which that density is constant is not a little square: it is a whole ring, because every point of a ring is the same distance out.

\[ m_i \approx \rho(x_i^{*})\cdot A_i, \qquad A_i = \pi x_i^2 - \pi x_{i-1}^2 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, pp. 596-597 — Figure 6.50 and the washer argument

Everything changes here in one respect only: the shape of the piece on which the varying quantity is constant. The density depends on distance from the centre, so all the points that share a density form a circle, and the piece is the thin ring between two nearby circles.

This should feel familiar from the shell method in Section 6.3, where the same ring appeared for the same reason. If you were comfortable there, you already know where the factor on the next slide comes from.

Notice that the partition is taken along the radius, not around the disk. The variable runs from the centre to the rim, and the integral will have those as its limits, even though the object being described is two-dimensional.

13. Write the area of a thin ring

Fill the middle

Figure (svg): On the left a circle with one ring highlighted and a cut mark at the top; an arrow labelled cut and straighten points to the right, where the ring has become a long thin rectangle of length two pi x and height delta x.

A ring is a rectangle in disguise: its area is circumference times width, which is where the factor of two pi x in Theorem 6.8 comes from.

Fill in the blanks

dA = 2\pi\,x\,dx

Why: Cut the ring and straighten it: it becomes a rectangle whose length is the circumference at radius x and whose width is dx. Its area is therefore the circumference times the width. The same factor appeared in the shell method of Section 6.3, and dropping it is the most common error in these problems.

Fill in the blank before revealing, and justify your answer with the picture rather than with a remembered formula. The ring has been cut and straightened into a long thin rectangle, and you can read its dimensions straight off the drawing.

The length of that rectangle is the distance around the circle at radius x, and its height is the thickness of the ring. That is why the area carries a factor of two pi x. If you subtract the two circle areas exactly and simplify, you get the sum of the two radii times pi times the width, which for a thin ring is the same thing.

Leaving this factor out is the single most common error in radial density problems, and it is invisible in the algebra: the integral still evaluates to a number. Only a units check or a sanity estimate will catch it, which is the point of the trap slide coming up.

14. Example 6.24: a disk whose density is a square root

Worked example

The radial density of a disk of radius four is the square root of the distance from the centre. Find its mass.

\[ \rho(x) = \sqrt{x}, \qquad r = 4 \]

Write the mass integral

Why: Theorem 6.8: density times the ring's area.

\[ m = \int_0^{4} 2\pi x\,\rho(x)\,dx = \int_0^{4} 2\pi x\sqrt{x}\,dx \]

Collect the powers of x

Why: One power of x from the ring, one half from the density.

\[ x\sqrt{x} = x^{3/2} \]

Integrate with the power rule

Why: Add one to the exponent and divide by the new exponent.

\[ \int_0^{4} x^{3/2}dx = \left[\frac{2}{5}x^{5/2}\right]_0^{4} = \frac{2}{5}(32) = \frac{64}{5} \]

Multiply by the constant

Why: The two pi rides along.

\[ m = 2\pi\cdot\frac{64}{5} = \frac{128\pi}{5} \approx 80.42 \]

Check against a uniform disk

Why: The disk's area is sixteen pi, about 50.27, so this mass is the same as a uniform disk of density 1.6. Since the density is the square root of the radius, 1.6 is the density at radius 2.56, further out than the halfway radius 2, which is right: the outer rings carry more area.

\[ \frac{128\pi/5}{16\pi} = \frac{8}{5} = 1.6, \qquad \sqrt{2.56} = 1.6 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 597 — Theorem 6.8, equation 6.11, Example 6.24

The setup is the whole lesson here. Once you have written the integrand as two pi x times the density, the rest is one power rule, so spend your care on the first line.

Watch how the two powers of x combine. One comes from the ring's circumference and one half comes from the density, so the integrand is x to the three halves. Students who lose the ring factor integrate x to the one half instead and get an answer about a fifth of the size.

The check is worth stealing for your own work. Divide the mass by the area of the disk and you get the constant density that would give the same mass, here exactly 1.6. Since the density is the square root of the radius, that value belongs to radius 2.56, further out than the halfway radius of 2, and it should be, because the rings out near the rim contain far more area than the ones near the centre.

15. Checkpoint 6.24: a disk with a linear density

Prediction

\[ \rho(x) = 3x + 2, \qquad r = 2 \]

Predict first

What is the mass of this disk?

  • 24π
  • 12π
  • 10π
  • 16π

Correct: 24π

Why: The integral is 2π times the integral from 0 to 2 of x(3x + 2), that is 2π times the integral of 3x² + 2x, which is 2π evaluated at the bracket x³ + x², giving 2π(8 + 4) = 24π, about 75.4. The tempting wrong answer 10π is what you get by integrating the density alone and forgetting the ring's circumference.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 597 — Checkpoint 6.24

Commit to an option before revealing. You can do this one without writing much: multiply the density by two pi x, integrate a quadratic over an interval of length two, and read off the answer.

The distractor worth studying is the one that is ten pi. That is what you get by integrating the density alone from the centre to the rim, with no ring factor, and it is exactly the error the next slide is about. It is not a silly mistake; it is what the one-dimensional formula would tell you to do if you forgot that the object is a disk.

If you picked it, go back to the straightened ring picture and ask what you would be adding up. Densities multiplied by radii, which is not a mass at all.

16. Trap: integrating the density alone over the radius

Trap

The trap

A disk of radius 2 with density three x plus two:

\[ m = \int_0^{2}(3x+2)\,dx \]

\[ = 6 + 4 = 10 \]

Wrong. The pieces are rings, not unit squares.

The fix

The ring at radius x has area equal to its circumference times its width, so the integrand must carry a factor of two pi x. Without it you are adding densities over a length, which is not even a mass.

\[ m = \int_0^{2} 2\pi x(3x+2)\,dx = 24\pi \]

A units check catches it instantly: mass per unit area times a length is not a mass.

This is the same error the checkpoint's distractor was built on, written out in full so you can see how reasonable it looks. Nothing in the algebra complains; the answer is a clean number, and it is wrong by a factor of two pi times an average radius.

The defence that always works is the units check. A radial density is measured in mass per unit area, and multiplying it by a length gives mass per length, not mass. The moment you write a units line under your integrand, this error becomes impossible to commit silently.

The second defence is the picture. Ask yourself which physical piece your integrand describes, and if the answer is a piece of the radius rather than a ring of the disk, you are integrating the wrong thing.

17. Work and Hooke's law

Section

Part 2

18. Work when the force is constant

Concept

work — The energy it takes to move an object against a force. For a constant force acting along the direction of motion it is the force times the distance moved.

\[ W = F \cdot d \]

systemforcedistancework
metricnewton (N)metre (m)newton-metre, called the joule (J)
Englishpound (lb)foot (ft)foot-pound (ft-lb)

One newton is the force that accelerates one kilogram at one metre per second per second, so a joule is a kilogram times a metre squared per second squared. Lifting a one kilogram book one metre takes about 9.8 joules, since you must beat gravity.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 597 — work and its units

Work is one of those words that means something looser in ordinary speech than in physics. Here it is a number, with units, defined as force times distance moved along the direction of the force, and holding a heavy box still does no work at all in this sense.

Learn the two unit systems as pairs. Newtons with metres give joules; pounds with feet give foot-pounds. Mixing them, most often by leaving a length in inches, is the most common source of wrong answers in this part of the section, and the error analysis slide later is devoted to it.

The example in the last paragraph is worth keeping as a reference point. Lifting a book of one kilogram by one metre costs about ten joules, so when a spring problem comes out at six joules you know you are in a sensible range, and when a tank comes out at twenty million you know it is a lot of water.

19. Work when the force varies

Concept

Figure (svg): The curve of twelve over x squared from x equals 1 to 2, with the region under it shaded and four rectangles of equal width drawn at the midpoints, each nearly matching the curve's height across its own strip.

Across a narrow strip the force barely changes, so that strip's work is force times distance. The integral adds the strips.

If the force changes as the object moves, partition the path instead. Over a short piece the force is nearly constant, so that piece of work is a product, and the pieces add.

\[ W_i \approx F(x_i^{*})\,\Delta x, \qquad W \approx \sum_{i=1}^{n} F(x_i^{*})\,\Delta x \]

\[ W = \int_a^b F(x)\,dx \]

A constant force makes the integral the force times the length of the interval, which is the elementary formula again.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 598 — the definition of work, equation 6.12

The argument is word for word the argument for mass, with force in place of density and distance in place of length. Partition the path, treat the force as constant on each piece, multiply, add, take the limit.

In the picture, the four rectangles are drawn with the force taken at the midpoint of each strip, and you can see how little they differ from the region under the curve even at this coarse resolution. That is the approximation getting good quickly as the pieces get small.

The final sentence matters more than it looks. When the force is constant the integral collapses back to force times distance, so this definition does not replace the elementary formula; it contains it. Every good generalisation in mathematics behaves this way, and checking that it does is a fast way to confirm you have written it correctly.

20. Reading the work integral piece by piece

Notation

Annotate

On: \( W = \int_a^b F(x)\,dx \)

  • The force needed at position x, not the force at the end of the trip. Reading off the final force and multiplying is the classic error.
  • The distance the object moves while that force acts. Force times distance is work, so the integrand's units are already energy.
  • Start and finish positions in the coordinate you chose. Choosing the coordinate is a real decision, and springs and tanks each have a natural one.
  • Taking the force in the direction of motion as positive makes work positive. A negative answer means the object moved the way the force was already pushing.

The first annotation is the one to take to heart before the spring examples. The integrand is the force required at position x, which is a function, not the single number you measure at the end of the journey.

The third annotation is easy to skim past and expensive to ignore. Choosing the coordinate is a genuine decision, and the rest of the problem is easy or awkward depending on it. For a spring, zero at the natural length makes Hooke's law come out as a constant times the variable; for a tank, zero at the rim makes the lift come out as the variable itself.

The remark about sign is mostly for reassurance. In this section every force is opposed to the motion and every answer comes out positive. If you ever get a negative work, check whether you have integrated from the far end to the near end.

21. Work is the area under the force graph

Intuition

Plot the force against position and the work becomes an area. That picture is worth keeping, because it turns every work question into a question about a region you can see.

A constant force gives a rectangle. A force that grows from zero along a straight line gives a triangle, which is why a spring's work will come out as half of the final force times the distance. A force that dies away gives a region with a long thin tail, and the tail can still have a finite area.

It also explains why work depends on where you start and stop, not just on how far you travel: the same width of region sits under a different part of the graph.

This slide has no formula in it on purpose. It is the mental picture that makes the spring results obvious rather than memorised, and it will carry you through problems where the algebra looks unfamiliar.

Test the picture on the example you just did. The force there fell away like one over the square, so the region under it has a tall left edge and a long thin tail, and most of the six joules came from the first quarter of the journey. That is a statement you can see before you integrate.

The last sentence is the practical consequence. Two stretches of the same length cost different amounts of work if they start at different places, because the same width of region sits under a different height of curve. The Exercise 235 slide is exactly that observation with numbers on it.

22. Exercise 222: a force that dies off like one over the square

Worked example

Compute the work done by the force below, in newtons, as the object moves from one metre to two metres.

\[ F(x) = \frac{12}{x^2}, \qquad x: 1 \to 2 \]

Write the work integral

Why: Definition 6.12 with these endpoints.

\[ W = \int_1^{2}\frac{12}{x^2}\,dx \]

Rewrite as a power

Why: Move the x squared upstairs with a negative exponent.

\[ \frac{12}{x^2} = 12x^{-2} \]

Integrate

Why: Power rule: the exponent becomes minus one, and dividing by minus one flips the sign.

\[ \int 12x^{-2}dx = -\frac{12}{x} \]

Evaluate at both ends

Why: Minus twelve halves at the top end, minus twelve at the bottom end.

\[ W = \left[-\frac{12}{x}\right]_1^{2} = -6 + 12 = 6 \text{ J} \]

Check against the extreme forces

Why: The force falls from 12 newtons to 3 newtons across a one metre trip, so the work must lie between 3 and 12 joules; the midpoint force is 5.33 newtons, giving a rough estimate of 5.33 joules, just under the true 6.

\[ 3 < 6 < 12, \qquad F(1.5)\cdot 1 = 5.33 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 608 — Exercise 222

This is deliberately placed before the springs, because it keeps the physics simple and lets you concentrate on the pattern: write the integral, rewrite the integrand as a power, integrate, evaluate.

The rewriting step is worth doing explicitly every time. Almost every integration error in this section happens when a fraction is integrated by inspection instead of being turned into a negative power first.

The check is the bracketing trick again. The force is never more than 12 newtons nor less than 3 across a one metre journey, so the work is between 3 and 12 joules whatever the details. The midpoint estimate of 5.33 is slightly low because the curve bends upward, and knowing which way an estimate errs is often as useful as the estimate itself.

23. Hooke's law: the force a spring answers with

Concept

Figure (svg): The straight line F equals 50x from 0 to 0.6, with the triangle under it from 0 to 0.5 shaded green and labelled 6.25 joules, inside a dashed rectangle of height 25 labelled 12.5 joules, too big.

The spring fights back harder the further it is stretched, so the work is the triangle under the force line, exactly half of the final force times the distance.

Hooke's law — The force needed to hold a spring at displacement x from its natural length is proportional to x. The constant of proportionality is the spring constant, always positive.

\[ F(x) = kx \]

The force is zero at the natural length and grows in a straight line, so the work is the area of a triangle rather than of a rectangle. Stretching and compressing by the same amount cost the same, because the graph is symmetric about the origin.

\[ W = \int_0^{b} kx\,dx = \frac{1}{2}kb^2 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 599 — Hooke's law

Hooke's law is an experimental fact about springs, not a theorem, and it holds only while the spring is not stretched so far that it deforms. Inside that range the graph is a straight line through the origin, and the spring constant is its slope.

Look at the two shaded shapes in the figure. The green triangle is the work you actually do; the dashed rectangle around it is what you would get by multiplying the final force by the distance. The rectangle is exactly twice the triangle, which is where the famous factor of one half in the spring formula comes from.

The symmetry remark is easy to check and worth remembering: compressing by a given amount costs the same as stretching by that amount, because the force graph is a straight line through the origin and the two triangles are congruent.

24. Example 6.25: from a compression to a stretch

Worked example

It takes a force of 10 newtons, in the negative direction, to compress a spring 0.2 metres from equilibrium. How much work stretches the same spring 0.5 metres from equilibrium?

Put the compression into Hooke's law

Why: Compression means a negative displacement, and the force is negative too.

\[ -10 = k(-0.2) \]

Solve for the spring constant

Why: Two negatives make the constant positive, as it must be.

\[ k = \frac{-10}{-0.2} = 50 \text{ N/m} \]

Write the work integral for the stretch

Why: From the natural length out to 0.5 metres.

\[ W = \int_0^{0.5} 50x\,dx \]

Integrate and evaluate

Why: The antiderivative is twenty-five x squared.

\[ W = \Big[25x^2\Big]_0^{0.5} = 25(0.25) = 6.25 \text{ J} \]

Check with the average force

Why: The force rises in a straight line from 0 to 25 newtons, so its average over the stretch is 12.5 newtons; average force times distance gives the same 6.25 joules.

\[ \frac{0+25}{2}\cdot 0.5 = 6.25 \;\checkmark \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 599 — Example 6.25

Read the question carefully before setting up, because it mixes two different displacements. The information given is about a compression of 0.2 metres, and the question is about a stretch of 0.5 metres. The bridge between them is the spring constant, which belongs to the spring and not to any particular displacement.

The two minus signs in the first step are the book's way of being careful with direction: a compression is a negative displacement and the force needed points the negative way too. They cancel, and the spring constant comes out positive, as it always must.

Then the work integral runs from the natural length out to 0.5 metres, because the spring starts at rest. The check with the average force is the fastest way to confirm an answer for any spring, since the force graph is a straight line and the average of a straight line is the average of its two end values.

25. Trap: work equals the final force times the distance

Trap

The trap

The spring of Example 6.25 ends up pulling with 25 newtons after a 0.5 metre stretch, so:

\[ W = 25 \cdot 0.5 = 12.5 \text{ J} \]

Wrong, by exactly a factor of two.

The fix

The force was 25 newtons only at the last instant. For most of the stretch it was smaller, and the work is the triangle under the force line, not the rectangle around it.

\[ W = \frac{1}{2}kb^2 = \frac{1}{2}(50)(0.25) = 6.25 \]

Whenever a force grows in a straight line from zero, the honest shortcut is the average force, which is half of the final one.

This is the single most common wrong answer in spring problems, and it is always wrong by exactly a factor of two, which makes it easy to recognise in your own work. If your answer is twice the book's, this is almost certainly why.

The reason it is tempting is that the number 25 newtons is a real number in the problem and it is sitting right there at the end of the stretch. But the spring only pulled that hard at the very last instant; at the halfway point it was pulling with half as much.

The honest shortcut is the average force, and for a spring the average force is half the final one because the graph is a straight line from zero. Use that as a check, not as your main method, so that you keep the habit of writing the integral.

26. Checkpoint 6.25: a spring measured in pounds and inches

Worked example

A force of 8 pounds stretches a spring 6 inches from equilibrium. How much work stretches it 1 foot from equilibrium?

Convert to one system of units

Why: The answer is wanted in foot-pounds, so measure the displacement in feet: six inches is half a foot.

\[ F = 8 \text{ lb at } x = 0.5 \text{ ft} \]

Find the spring constant

Why: Divide the force by the displacement.

\[ k = \frac{8}{0.5} = 16 \text{ lb/ft} \]

Set up the work integral

Why: From the natural length out to one foot.

\[ W = \int_0^{1} 16x\,dx \]

Integrate and evaluate

Why: The antiderivative is eight x squared.

\[ W = \Big[8x^2\Big]_0^{1} = 8 \text{ ft-lb} \]

Check with the average force

Why: At one foot the spring pulls with 16 pounds, so the average force over the stretch is 8 pounds, and 8 pounds over 1 foot is 8 foot-pounds.

\[ \frac{0+16}{2}\cdot 1 = 8 \;\checkmark \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 599 — Checkpoint 6.25

This is the same question as Example 6.25 wearing English units, and the first step is the one that decides whether you get it right. Everything must be in one system before Hooke's law is used, and since the answer is wanted in foot-pounds, that system is feet and pounds.

Six inches becomes half a foot, so the spring constant is 16 pounds per foot. If you had left the six in inches you would have got a spring constant of about 1.33, in pounds per inch, and then mixing it with a displacement in feet would produce an answer twelve times too small.

The average-force check works here exactly as before, and it is even easier because the numbers are whole: the force rises from nothing to 16 pounds, so its average is 8 pounds, and 8 pounds over 1 foot is 8 foot-pounds.

27. Exercise 235: the second five centimetres cost more

Worked example

Figure (svg): The line F equals 1600x with two shaded strips of equal width: the strip from 0 to 0.05 labelled 2 joules and the strip from 0.05 to 0.10 labelled 6 joules.

Two stretches of five centimetres each. The second one costs three times as much, because the spring is already pulling back with a larger force throughout it.

A spring has a natural length of 10 centimetres. It takes 2 joules to stretch it to 15 centimetres. How much work stretches it from 15 centimetres to 20 centimetres?

Measure displacement from the natural length

Why: Fifteen centimetres long means five centimetres of stretch, that is 0.05 metres.

\[ W(0 \to 0.05) = 2 \text{ J} \]

Use the work formula to find k

Why: Half k b squared equals the known work.

\[ \frac{1}{2}k(0.05)^2 = 2 \]

Solve for the spring constant

Why: Multiply by two and divide by the square.

\[ k = \frac{4}{0.0025} = 1600 \text{ N/m} \]

Integrate over the second stretch

Why: From 0.05 to 0.10 metres, not from zero.

\[ W = \int_{0.05}^{0.10} 1600x\,dx = \Big[800x^2\Big]_{0.05}^{0.10} \]

Evaluate

Why: Eight joules at the far end, two joules at the near end.

\[ W = 8 - 2 = 6 \text{ J} \]

Check the two strips against each other

Why: The total work out to 0.10 metres is 8 joules and the first strip took 2, so the second strip takes 6: three times as much for the same five centimetres, because the force is three times larger on average there.

\[ \frac{6}{2} = 3 = \frac{\text{average force } 120}{\text{average force } 40} \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 609 — Exercise 235

The new feature here is that the work is given and the spring constant is not, so you run the formula backwards. Half the spring constant times the square of the stretch equals the known work; solve for the constant.

Watch the displacements. A spring of natural length 10 centimetres stretched to 15 is displaced 5 centimetres, that is 0.05 metres, not 0.15. Working from the total length instead of the displacement is the classic error in this problem type, and it is worth saying out loud what zero means before you write anything.

Then look at the picture. Two strips of equal width sit under the same straight line, and the second one contains three times the area of the first. That is the whole message of the slide: work depends on where in the stretch you are, not only on how far you stretch.

28. Slide the spring constant

Tweak it

Parameter explorer

The curve is the work needed to stretch a spring a distance b from its natural length. Slide the spring constant and watch the shape: is the work ever proportional to the stretch?

\[ W(b) = \tfrac12 ({k}) b^2 \]

  • k — from 20 to 200: spring constant k (N/m)

Move the slider slowly from one end to the other. The curve rises and falls in height, but its shape never changes: it is always a parabola through the origin, because the work is always half the spring constant times the square of the stretch.

Now read the curve for a fixed spring constant. Doubling the stretch multiplies the work by four, and tripling it multiplies the work by nine. There is no setting of the slider at which the work is proportional to the stretch, which is the quantitative form of the trap two slides ago.

This is also why the last centimetre of a stretch is always the expensive one, and why real springs in machines are specified by how far they will be compressed rather than by how much force they will feel.

29. Complete the spring table

Comparison

Comparison matrix

what was measuredspring constant kwork
10 N holds it at 0.2 m50 N/m6.25 J over the first 0.5 m
8 lb holds it at 0.5 ft16 lb/ft8 ft-lb
2 J stretches it 0.05 m1600 N/m6 J from 0.05 m to 0.10 m
75 lb holds it at 0.25 ft300 lb/ft9.375 ft-lb over the first 0.25 ft

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 609 — Exercises 234 and 235

Fill every blank before checking. Each row is a complete spring problem in miniature, and the skill being drilled is moving between three quantities: a measured force at a measured displacement, the spring constant, and the work over some interval.

The second row is the unit trap in compressed form: half a foot, not six inches. The third row runs the relation backwards from a known work. The fourth is worth doing carefully, since a large spring constant and a small displacement still give a modest work, because the work depends on the square of the displacement.

When you finish, notice that no row can be completed by multiplying the force in the first column by the distance in the last. Every one of them needs either the triangle or the integral.

30. Find the error: inches left in the answer

Error analysis

Annotate

On: \( k = \frac{8}{6} \;\Longrightarrow\; W = \int_0^{12} \frac{8}{6}x\,dx = 96 \)

  • The 6 is a number of inches while the 8 is a number of pounds, so this spring constant is in pounds per inch, not pounds per foot. Mixing the two is the whole mistake.
  • Someone noticed the units clash and converted the one foot into twelve inches, which is consistent, so the integral itself is not wrong.
  • The number is right in inch-pounds. Divide by twelve inches per foot and you get the 8 foot-pounds of Checkpoint 6.25; reported as it stands, it is twelve times too large.
  • Convert everything to one system before the first line of algebra, and write the units on the spring constant. An answer with no units cannot be checked by anyone, including you.

Read the argument before revealing the annotations, and try to say in one sentence what is wrong with it. The integration is flawless, which is what makes this worth studying: a correct calculation can still produce a wrong answer.

The trouble starts in the very first fraction, where a force in pounds is divided by a length in inches, producing a spring constant in pounds per inch. Since the limits of integration were also put in inches, the calculation is internally consistent, and the answer 96 is correct in inch-pounds.

So the mistake is only in what is reported, which is exactly why writing units on every quantity is not a formality. Divide 96 inch-pounds by twelve inches per foot and you recover the 8 foot-pounds from the checkpoint. Any answer that arrives with no units cannot be checked by you or by anyone marking it.

31. Pumping a tank

Section

Part 3

32. Why pumping needs an integral

Concept

Figure (svg): A cylindrical tank of radius 4 and height 10 drawn in perspective, filled with water to a depth of 8, with one thin horizontal layer highlighted, and a downward axis to the right marking x equals 0 at the top of the tank, x equals 2 at the water surface and x equals 10 at the bottom.

With the origin at the top and x measured downward, the layer at depth x has to be lifted exactly x metres. That is the whole reason for choosing this frame.

Water at the bottom of a tank has further to travel than water at the top, so different parts of the same tankful cost different amounts of work. The pieces on which the lift is nearly constant are thin horizontal layers.

Put the origin at the top of the tank and let the position variable measure depth downward. Then the layer at depth x must be lifted exactly x units to clear the rim, which is why this frame of reference is worth the trouble of setting up.

\[ W_i \approx \underbrace{\rho_{w} V_i}_{\text{weight}} \cdot \underbrace{x_i^{*}}_{\text{lift}} \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, pp. 599-600 — Figures 6.52 and 6.53

Stay with the picture for a moment before the algebra. The water at the bottom of this tank has to travel ten metres to clear the rim; the water at the surface has to travel two. There is no single distance to multiply a weight by, and that is the only reason this problem is harder than lifting a box.

The pieces on which the lift is nearly constant are thin horizontal layers, so the partition runs down the tank. Everything else follows: a layer's volume comes from the tank's shape, its weight comes from the weight-density, and its work is weight times lift.

Do not skip the sentence about the frame of reference. Putting the origin at the top and measuring downward makes the lift equal to the variable itself, which is the cleanest possible arrangement. Any other choice works too, but then the lift is some expression like ten minus the variable, and you must remember to use it.

33. The weight-density of water

Intuition

Pumping problems need the weight of a layer, not its mass, because the force to be beaten is the weight. The book gives the weight-density of water in both systems, and which one you use is decided by the units in the question.

systemweight-density of watera layer's weight
metric9800 newtons per cubic metre9800 times the layer's volume, in newtons
English62.4 pounds per cubic foot62.4 times the layer's volume, in pounds

In the metric line the factor for gravity is already inside the number: a cubic metre of water has a mass of about 1000 kilograms and a weight of about 9800 newtons. In the English line a pound is already a weight, so nothing extra is needed.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 600 — the weight-density of water

The word to notice in this slide is weight. The force the pump has to overcome is the weight of the water, not its mass, so the constant you want is a weight per unit volume.

In the metric row, gravity has already been folded into the number: a cubic metre of water has a mass near a thousand kilograms, and multiplying by the acceleration due to gravity gives roughly nine thousand eight hundred newtons. If a problem hands you a mass density in kilograms per cubic metre instead, you must supply that factor yourself.

In the English row nothing extra is needed, because a pound is already a force. This is the one situation in which the English system is the simpler of the two, which is why most textbook tank problems are still set in feet and pounds.

34. The cylindrical tank, layer by layer

Worked example

A cylindrical tank of radius 4 metres and height 10 metres is filled to a depth of 8 metres. Find the work to pump all of the water over the top edge.

Choose the frame of reference

Why: Origin at the top of the tank, depth measured downward. The water then occupies the depths from 2 to 10.

\[ x = 0 \text{ at the rim}, \qquad \text{water: } 2 \le x \le 10 \]

Find the volume of a layer

Why: A disk of radius 4 and thickness dx.

\[ V = \pi(4)^2\,\Delta x = 16\pi\,\Delta x \]

Turn the volume into a force

Why: Multiply by the weight-density of water.

\[ F = 9800 \cdot 16\pi\,\Delta x = 156{,}800\pi\,\Delta x \]

Multiply by the lift

Why: The layer at depth x rises x metres to clear the rim.

\[ W_i \approx 156{,}800\pi\,x_i^{*}\,\Delta x \]

Integrate over the water

Why: The Riemann sum becomes an integral over the depths that hold water.

\[ W = \int_2^{10} 156{,}800\pi x\,dx = 156{,}800\pi\left[\frac{x^2}{2}\right]_2^{10} \]

Evaluate

Why: Fifty minus two inside the bracket.

\[ W = 156{,}800\pi(48) = 7{,}526{,}400\pi \approx 23{,}644{,}883 \text{ J} \]

Check with the centre of mass

Why: The water weighs 9800 times its volume of 128 pi cubic metres, and its middle sits at depth 6, halfway between 2 and 10. Total weight times that single lift gives the same answer, which works here only because every layer of a cylinder is identical.

\[ 9800(128\pi)(6) = 7{,}526{,}400\pi \;\checkmark \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, pp. 600-601 — the cylindrical tank

This is the reference solution for every pumping problem you will ever set up, so learn its skeleton: frame, volume, weight, lift, integrate, check. The cylinder is the easy case because the radius never changes, so all the geometry is in one line.

The limits deserve a second look. The tank is ten metres tall but the water only occupies depths from two to ten, so the integral runs from two, not from zero. Integrating over the empty top of the tank would add work for water that is not there.

The check is the one to remember. For a cylinder, every layer has the same weight, so the whole job is the same as lifting the entire tankful from the depth of its middle. That collapses the integral to a single product and it agrees exactly. Do not expect that shortcut to work for a cone, where the layers have very different weights, unless you know where the centre of mass is.

35. The seven steps for a pumping problem

Concept

  1. Sketch the tank and choose a frame of reference.
  2. Find the volume of a representative layer.
  3. Multiply by the weight-density to get the layer's weight, which is the force.
  4. Find the distance that layer has to be lifted.
  5. Multiply force by distance for the layer's work.
  6. Sum the layers: a Riemann sum.
  7. Take the limit and evaluate the integral.

Steps two and four are where the tank's shape enters, and they are the only steps that change from one tank to another. Step four is where a careless frame of reference costs you the problem.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 601 — Problem-Solving Strategy: Solving Pumping Problems

This is the book's own strategy, and it is worth following literally the first several times, including writing out the Riemann sum, because the habit of naming a representative layer is what keeps you out of trouble on odd-shaped tanks.

Steps two and four are the only ones where the tank's shape enters. Step two asks how wide the tank is at depth x, which is nearly always a similar triangles question, and step four asks how far that layer must travel, which is a question about your frame of reference and about where the water is being pumped to.

A detail the list hides: the limits of integration are set by the water that actually leaves, not by the tank and not by the water that stays. Reading those two levels carefully out of the problem statement is where most marks are lost.

36. Before you integrate: choose the origin

Step zero

\[ \text{a cone, point down, 12 ft deep, pumped over the rim} \]

Discussion prompt

Two students set up the same cone. One measures x downward from the rim; the other measures x upward from the point. Write the lift distance for the layer at position x in each case, and say which setup you would rather integrate.

Write both answers down before revealing. This takes thirty seconds and it will save you a whole problem at some point.

Both frames are legitimate and both give the same work, because the physical situation has not changed. What changes is which expression is simple: measuring downward from the rim makes the lift equal to the variable, while measuring upward from the point makes the radius simple instead and the lift an expression.

The fatal move is mixing them, and it is more tempting than it sounds. You draw the picture with the point at the bottom, write the radius by looking at the picture, then write the lift by looking at the same picture from the other direction. Fix the origin in words before you write a single formula, and keep every quantity in that frame.

37. Example 6.26: an inverted cone, pumped down to four feet

Worked example

Figure (svg): An inverted cone twelve feet deep with a four foot radius at the top, shown full of water, with a thin disk highlighted partway down, the radius of that disk marked, and a downward axis marking x equals 0 at the rim, x equals 8 where pumping stops and x equals 12 at the point.

Similar triangles turn the disk's radius into a function of depth. Everything else is the cylinder argument again.

A tank is an inverted cone, 12 feet deep with a base radius of 4 feet at the top. It starts full, and water is pumped over the rim until 4 feet of water remain. Find the work.

Choose the frame and the limits

Why: Depth downward from the rim. The water removed lies between the rim and the level 8 feet down.

\[ 0 \le x \le 8 \]

Find the layer's radius by similar triangles

Why: The radius shrinks from 4 at the rim to 0 at the point, 12 feet down.

\[ \frac{r}{12-x} = \frac{4}{12} = \frac13 \;\Longrightarrow\; r = 4 - \frac{x}{3} \]

Write the layer's volume

Why: A disk of that radius and thickness dx.

\[ V = \pi\left(4-\frac{x}{3}\right)^2\Delta x \]

Turn it into a force and then into work

Why: Weight-density 62.4, and the lift is x.

\[ W_i \approx 62.4\pi x\left(4-\frac{x}{3}\right)^2\Delta x \]

Expand the square

Why: Multiply out before integrating.

\[ x\left(16 - \frac{8x}{3} + \frac{x^2}{9}\right) = 16x - \frac{8x^2}{3} + \frac{x^3}{9} \]

Integrate term by term

Why: Power rule three times.

\[ \int_0^{8}\left(16x - \frac{8x^2}{3} + \frac{x^3}{9}\right)dx = \left[8x^2 - \frac{8x^3}{9} + \frac{x^4}{36}\right]_0^{8} \]

Evaluate the bracket

Why: Five hundred and twelve, minus 455.11, plus 113.78.

\[ 512 - \frac{4096}{9} + \frac{4096}{36} = \frac{512}{3} \approx 170.67 \]

Multiply by the constant

Why: The 62.4 pi rides along.

\[ W = 62.4\pi\cdot\frac{512}{3} = 10{,}649.6\pi \approx 33{,}457 \text{ ft-lb} \]

Check with the weight of the water removed

Why: The removed water has volume 193.6 cubic feet and so weighs 12,082 pounds; dividing the work by that weight says its centre was lifted 2.77 feet. That is a short lift out of a possible 8, which is right, because most of the removed water sits near the wide top.

\[ \frac{33{,}457}{12{,}082} = 2.77 \text{ ft} \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, pp. 601-603 — Example 6.26, Figures 6.54 and 6.55

This is the same skeleton as the cylinder with one extra line, the similar triangles that give the radius. Read that line off the figure: the radius is four at the rim and zero twelve feet down, so it falls by one third of a foot for every foot of depth.

The limits are the second thing to get right. The tank is twelve feet deep and starts full, but pumping stops when four feet of water remain, so the water that leaves occupies depths from zero to eight. The water below eight never moves and must not appear in the integral.

The final check is worth studying, because it is the general version of the cylinder's centre-of-mass check. Divide the work by the weight of the water removed and you get the average lift, 2.77 feet. That number has to lie between zero and eight, and it should be near the shallow end because a cone holds most of its water near the top. Both tests pass, so the answer is trustworthy.

38. What each layer costs

Picture it

Figure (svg): A bar chart of the work needed to lift each one-metre-thick layer of the tank, rising steadily from 1.23 million joules for the layer just below the surface to 4.68 million joules for the deepest layer.

Same amount of water in every bar; only the lift differs. The deepest metre of this tank costs nearly four times what the shallowest one costs.

Back to the cylinder, with the work split up by depth. Every bar contains the same volume of water and the same weight, so the only thing making the bars grow is the lift. The total work is the total area of the bars, which is what the integral computes.

Every bar in this chart holds the same amount of water, because the tank is a cylinder. The only thing that changes from bar to bar is how far that water has to travel, and the bars grow in a straight line for exactly that reason.

The total work is the total area of the bars, which is what the integral computed. Seeing it split up like this makes the answer's size believable: about two and a half million joules per metre of depth on average, over eight metres.

It also explains the prediction on the next slide. If the cost per layer grows steadily with depth, then the deep half of any tank must cost far more than the shallow half, and it is worth knowing in advance roughly how much more.

39. Does the top half cost half the work?

Prediction

\[ \text{a full cylinder, 10 m tall, pumped over the rim} \]

Predict first

You pump out only the top half of a full cylindrical tank. What fraction of the total work is that?

  • one quarter
  • one third
  • one half
  • three quarters

Correct: one quarter

Why: The work is proportional to the integral of x, so the top half contributes the integral from 0 to 5, which is 12.5, while the whole tank contributes the integral from 0 to 10, which is 50. That is one quarter. Half the water is moved, but each drop of it travels much less far, so the second half of the job costs three times as much as the first.

Commit to an option first. Most people say one half, because half the water is being moved, and the answer is one quarter.

The reason is in the integral. The work is proportional to the integral of the depth, which is proportional to the square of the depth, so the top half contributes twenty-five units out of a hundred rather than fifty. Half the water, but each drop of it travels on average half as far.

There is a practical lesson here about emptying tanks and about pumping in general. The last of the water is always the expensive part, and a pump sized for the average load will struggle at the end of the job.

40. Checkpoint 6.26: a wider cone, partly full

Worked example

An inverted cone is 10 feet deep with a base radius of 6 feet. It is filled to a depth of 8 feet, and water is pumped over the rim until 3 feet remain. Find the work.

Set the limits from the two water levels

Why: Depth downward from the rim: 8 feet of water means the surface is 2 feet down, and 3 feet left means pumping stops 7 feet down.

\[ 2 \le x \le 7 \]

Find the radius by similar triangles

Why: Six at the rim, zero 10 feet down.

\[ \frac{r}{10-x} = \frac{6}{10} \;\Longrightarrow\; r = \frac{3}{5}(10-x) \]

Build the layer's work

Why: Volume, then weight, then lift.

\[ W_i \approx 62.4\pi x\cdot\frac{9}{25}(10-x)^2\,\Delta x \]

Integrate over the water removed

Why: Constants out in front.

\[ W = 22.464\pi\int_2^{7} x(10-x)^2dx \]

Evaluate the integral

Why: Expand and use the power rule: the bracket comes out as 7355 over 12.

\[ \int_2^{7}\left(100x - 20x^2 + x^3\right)dx = \frac{7355}{12} \approx 612.92 \]

Multiply through

Why: Constant times the integral.

\[ W = 22.464\pi(612.92) = 13{,}768.6\pi \approx 43{,}255 \text{ ft-lb} \]

Check the implied lift

Why: The water removed has volume 182.8 cubic feet and weight 11,409 pounds, so the work says its centre rose 3.79 feet, comfortably between the 2 and 7 feet that bound every layer's lift.

\[ 2 < \frac{43{,}255}{11{,}409} = 3.79 < 7 \;\checkmark \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 603 — Checkpoint 6.26

Try this before reading it. It is Example 6.26 with two complications: the tank does not start full, and the numbers are not as friendly.

Both complications live in the limits. The water starts eight feet deep in a ten foot cone, so its surface is two feet below the rim, and pumping stops with three feet remaining, which is seven feet below the rim. The integral runs from two to seven, and a frequent wrong answer comes from using zero to eight, the depths of the water rather than the depths below the rim.

The check is the average lift again. Every layer that leaves is lifted between two and seven feet, so the work divided by the weight of the water removed must land in that range, and 3.79 is comfortably inside it and nearer the top, as it should be for a cone.

41. Put a pumping solution in order

Ranking

Put in order

Order the steps of a complete pumping solution.

  1. Sketch the tank and put the origin at the top, with x measuring depth
  2. Write the radius or width of the layer at depth x, using similar triangles if needed
  3. Multiply by the thickness to get the layer's volume
  4. Multiply by the weight-density to get the layer's weight
  5. Multiply by the lift distance to get the layer's work
  6. Integrate over the depths that actually get pumped, and state the units

Why: The frame of reference comes first, because both the radius and the lift are written in terms of it. Geometry then gives the volume, the weight-density gives the force, and only then does the lift enter. The limits are the depths of the water that leaves, which is rarely the whole tank.

Drag the steps before checking. The order is not arbitrary: each step needs the one before it, and the first step is the one students most often skip.

The frame of reference comes first because both the width and the lift are expressed in it. Choosing it after writing the geometry is how you end up with a radius measured from one end and a lift measured from the other.

Notice that the limits come last, attached to the integration step. They describe the water that actually leaves the tank, which is a separate question from the tank's dimensions and from where the water started.

42. Trap: the lift distance is not the tank's height

Trap

The trap

The cone of Example 6.26 is 12 feet deep, so:

\[ W = \int_0^{8} 62.4\pi(12)\left(4-\tfrac{x}{3}\right)^2dx \]

Wrong. Only the deepest water is lifted anything like 12 feet.

The fix

Each layer is lifted its own distance, and in this frame that distance is the variable x. A constant lift would mean the whole tankful travelled the same way, which is exactly what makes pumping harder than lifting a box.

\[ W = \int_0^{8} 62.4\pi\,x\left(4-\tfrac{x}{3}\right)^2dx \]

The wrong version is also easy to spot afterwards: it gives an answer bigger than the work of lifting every drop from the very bottom.

This one is seductive because the number twelve is genuinely in the problem: the cone really is twelve feet deep. It is just not the distance any particular layer travels.

The corrected version differs by a single symbol, the x in place of the twelve, and that symbol is the entire idea of the section. Each layer pays for its own journey.

The same slip has a milder cousin worth naming: using the depth of the water surface, or the depth of the remaining water, as a fixed lift for everything. Any constant in that slot is wrong unless the problem really does lift every layer the same way, which happens only when the water is raised to a fixed pipe well above the tank.

43. Exercises 240 and 241: winding up a hanging cable

Worked example

Figure (svg): A winch at the top with a hundred foot cable hanging from it, a short piece of the cable highlighted partway down, and an arrow showing that this piece must be lifted x feet to reach the winch.

Nothing is pumped here, but the reasoning is identical: each piece of cable has its own weight and its own lift.

A cable 100 feet long hangs from a winch and weighs 5 pounds per foot. Find the work to wind it all up, and then the work to lift it only 50 feet.

Choose the frame and the piece

Why: Measure x downward from the winch. The piece at depth x has weight 5 dx and must rise x feet.

\[ dW = 5x\,dx \]

Integrate over the whole cable

Why: From the top to 100 feet down.

\[ W = \int_0^{100} 5x\,dx = \Big[\tfrac52 x^2\Big]_0^{100} = 25{,}000 \text{ ft-lb} \]

Split the second question in two

Why: If the whole cable is raised 50 feet, the piece at depth x rises 50 feet when x is at least 50, and x feet when it is nearer the top.

\[ W = \int_0^{50} 5x\,dx + \int_{50}^{100} 5(50)\,dx \]

Evaluate both parts

Why: A triangle of work above, a constant lift below.

\[ W = 6250 + 12{,}500 = 18{,}750 \text{ ft-lb} \]

Check the first answer with the centre of mass

Why: The cable weighs 500 pounds in total and its middle is 50 feet down, so winding it all up is the same as lifting 500 pounds by 50 feet, which is 25,000 foot-pounds.

\[ 500 \cdot 50 = 25{,}000 \;\checkmark \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 609 — Exercises 240 and 241

No tank appears here, which is precisely why it is worth doing. The pieces are pieces of cable rather than layers of water, but the structure is identical: each piece has its own weight and its own lift.

The second question is the interesting one, and it catches people out. When the whole cable is lifted only fifty feet, the lower half of it travels the full fifty feet, while a piece near the top travels only as far as it started from the winch. So the work splits into two integrals, one of which has a constant integrand.

The check on the first answer is the centre of mass again, and here it is exact for the same reason as in the cylinder: the cable is uniform, so lifting it all is the same as lifting its total weight from its midpoint. Notice that this shortcut does not work for the second question, because the pieces travel different distances from each other.

44. Hydrostatic force

Section

Part 4

45. Pressure grows with depth, in every direction

Concept

hydrostatic pressure — Force per unit area exerted by a liquid at rest. At depth s it equals the weight-density of the liquid times s, and by Pascal's principle it acts equally in all directions.

\[ F = \rho A s, \qquad p = \frac{F}{A} = \rho s \]

For a plate lying flat at depth s the argument is easy: the plate holds up the column of water above it, whose weight is the weight-density times the volume. Dividing by the area gives a pressure that depends only on the depth.

Pascal's principle is what lets that number be used on a vertical surface too. At 530 feet down, the pressure is the weight-density times 530, which is 33,072 pounds per square foot, about 230 pounds per square inch, whichever way the surface faces.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, pp. 603-604 — Figure 6.56 and Pascal's principle

The horizontal plate is the easy case and it is where the formula comes from: the plate holds up a column of water, the column's weight is the weight-density times its volume, and dividing by the plate's area leaves a pressure that depends only on the depth.

Pascal's principle is what makes the rest of Part 4 possible. It says the pressure at a given depth acts equally in all directions, so a surface facing sideways at 530 feet down feels the same 33,072 pounds per square foot as one facing up. Without that, nothing could be said about a dam.

Convert that figure to pounds per square inch and it is about 230, roughly seven times the pressure in a car tyre. The plumbing at the bottom of the Hoover Dam has to be built for exactly that.

46. A vertical plate: strips at a common depth

Concept

Figure (svg): The triangular end of a water trough, point down, eight feet across at the surface and three feet deep, sliced into horizontal strips, with the strip at depth one and a half feet highlighted and its width marked four feet.

Every point of one thin strip sits at nearly the same depth, so the pressure on it is nearly constant and the elementary product works again.

On a vertical plate the depth changes from top to bottom, so there is no single pressure to multiply by. Cut the plate into thin horizontal strips instead: every point of one strip is at nearly the same depth.

\[ F_i \approx \rho\,s(x_i^{*})\cdot w(x_i^{*})\,\Delta x \]

\[ F = \int_a^b \rho\,w(x)\,s(x)\,dx \]

Here the depth function gives the depth at position x and the width function gives the plate's width there. The limits are the positions of the top and bottom edges of the wetted part of the plate.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, pp. 604-605 — Figure 6.57 and equation 6.13

Stewart, Calculus: Early Transcendentals 8e, §8.3 Applications to Physics and Engineering §8.3, pp. 558-568 — the same development in Stewart

The obstacle is stated in the first sentence: a vertical plate spans many depths, so there is no single pressure to multiply its area by. That should now prompt the same reflex as every other slide in this lesson, which is to look for the piece on which the varying quantity is constant.

Here the piece is a thin horizontal strip. Every point of it is at nearly the same depth, so the pressure on it is nearly constant, and its force is pressure times area, with the area being the plate's width there times the strip's thickness.

The two functions in the integral do different jobs and come from different places. The depth function comes from your frame of reference, and the width function comes from the plate's geometry, nearly always through similar triangles. Keeping them separate in your notes is the best way to avoid confusing them later, when the origin is not at the water surface.

47. Reading the hydrostatic force integral

Notation

Annotate

On: \( F = \int_a^b \rho\,w(x)\,s(x)\,dx \)

  • The weight-density of the liquid: 62.4 pounds per cubic foot for water, or 9800 newtons per cubic metre. It is a constant and comes straight out in front.
  • The depth of the strip at position x. It is x itself only when you put the origin at the water surface; on the dam it will be x minus 10.
  • The width of the plate at position x, found from the plate's shape, almost always by similar triangles.
  • Top and bottom of the wetted strip, in your coordinate. Water that is not touching the plate contributes nothing, so a drought changes the lower limit.

Three ingredients, and the annotations say where each one comes from. The weight-density is a constant you look up, the depth function comes from your frame of reference, and the width function comes from the shape of the plate.

The second annotation is a warning about the dam problem later. It is tempting to write the depth function as the variable every time, because that is what it was for the trough, but it is only true when the origin sits at the water surface.

The last annotation is worth a sentence of its own. Only the wetted part of the plate contributes, so when a drought lowers the water, the upper limit of integration moves and the depth function changes, while the width function stays exactly as it was.

48. Example 6.27: the end of a water trough

Worked example

A water trough 15 feet long has ends shaped like inverted isosceles triangles with base 8 feet and height 3 feet. Find the force on one end when the trough is full.

Choose the frame of reference

Why: The surface of the water is the top of the trough; measure x downward from there, so the depth function is x itself.

\[ s(x) = x, \qquad 0 \le x \le 3 \]

Find the width function by similar triangles

Why: The width is 8 at the surface and 0 at the point, three feet down.

\[ w(x) = 8 - \frac{8}{3}x \]

Write the force integral

Why: Weight-density times width times depth.

\[ F = \int_0^{3} 62.4\left(8 - \frac83 x\right)x\,dx \]

Expand the integrand

Why: Distribute the x before integrating.

\[ F = 62.4\int_0^{3}\left(8x - \frac{8}{3}x^2\right)dx \]

Integrate and evaluate

Why: The bracket is 36 minus 24 at the top end and zero at the bottom end.

\[ F = 62.4\Big[4x^2 - \tfrac89 x^3\Big]_0^{3} = 62.4(12) = 748.8 \text{ lb} \]

Check with the area and the centroid

Why: The triangle's area is 12 square feet and, with the base at the surface and the point down, its centroid sits 1 foot deep. Weight-density times area times the centroid's depth gives the same number, and that shortcut is the subject of Section 6.6.

\[ 62.4(12)(1) = 748.8 \;\checkmark \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, pp. 605-606 — Example 6.27, Figure 6.58

Notice what the problem gives you that you do not use: the trough is fifteen feet long, and that number never appears. The force is on one end, and the end is a triangle three feet deep and eight feet across.

The width function is the only piece of geometry here. At the surface the triangle is eight feet wide, and three feet down it has shrunk to a point, so the width falls by eight thirds of a foot for every foot of depth. If similar triangles feel shaky, draw the small triangle at depth x and the big one and write the ratio of their bases to their heights.

The check at the end previews Section 6.6. The force equals the weight-density times the area times the depth of the centroid, and for a triangle with its base at the surface the centroid is one third of the way down, so one foot. That reproduces 748.8 exactly, and it will reappear on the counterexample slide as a shortcut with a sharp edge.

49. Where the force on the trough end comes from

Picture it

Figure (svg): A curve showing the force contributed per foot of depth on the triangular trough end: zero at the surface, rising to a peak of 374.4 pounds per foot at a depth of one and a half feet, then falling back to zero at the point.

Pressure grows with depth while the triangle narrows, and the total force is the area under their product.

The curve is the integrand: the force contributed by each foot of depth. It vanishes at both ends for opposite reasons, at the top because there is no pressure and at the point because there is no width, and the total force is the area underneath it.

This curve is the integrand of the last slide, plotted. Its height at any depth is the force contributed by each foot of depth there, and the total force is the area underneath it.

The shape is the interesting part. It vanishes at the surface because the pressure is zero there, and it vanishes at the point because the triangle has no width left. In between it peaks, at a depth of one and a half feet with a value of 374.4 pounds per foot.

The picture explains something the algebra hides: most of the force on this plate comes from the middle band of it, not from the deepest water. That is why the middle-depth shortcut on a later slide gets the answer wrong in the direction it does.

50. Checkpoint 6.27: the same trough in metric units

Prediction

\[ \text{12 m long, ends 6 m across and 4 m deep, full} \]

Predict first

Using a weight-density of 9800 newtons per cubic metre, what is the force on one end?

  • about 156,800 N
  • about 78,400 N
  • about 313,600 N
  • about 39,200 N

Correct: about 156,800 N

Why: The width function is 6 minus 1.5x and the depth function is x, so the force is 9800 times the integral from 0 to 4 of 6x minus 1.5x squared, which is 9800 times the bracket 3x² minus 0.5x³, giving 9800 times 16, that is 156,800 newtons. The centroid check agrees: area 12 square metres, centroid depth 4 over 3 metres, and 9800 times 12 times 4 over 3 is 156,800.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 606 — Checkpoint 6.27

Pick an option before revealing. The structure is identical to Example 6.27, so the only real work is writing the right width function and using the metric weight-density.

The end is six metres across and four metres deep, so the width falls by one and a half metres for every metre of depth. Put that together with a depth function equal to the variable and the integral is a quadratic over an interval of length four.

The centroid check is quick and worth doing: the triangle has an area of twelve square metres and its centroid is one third of four metres down, so the force is the weight-density times twelve times four thirds. That it agrees with the integral is a good sign you have the width function right.

51. A puzzle: standing the plate up changes nothing

Anomaly

\[ \text{a plate 4 ft wide and 2 ft tall, its centre 5 ft down} \]

Predict first

Compared with the same plate lying flat at a depth of 5 feet, the force on the upright plate is:

  • exactly the same
  • larger, because the bottom is deeper
  • smaller, because the top is shallower
  • impossible to say without the shape

Correct: exactly the same

Why: For a plate of constant width the integral of the depth from 4 to 6 is the average depth, 5, times the height, 2. So the force is the weight-density times the area times the depth of the centre. The extra pressure on the lower half exactly pays for the missing pressure on the upper half, because pressure grows linearly with depth.

\[ \rho w\int_4^{6} x\,dx = \rho w\cdot\frac{6^2-4^2}{2} = \rho\,(2w)\,(5) \]

Predict before revealing. Most people expect the upright plate to feel more force, because its bottom edge is deeper than the flat plate and pressure grows with depth.

The algebra on the slide shows why the answer is exactly the same. Pressure grows linearly with depth, so the extra pressure on the lower half of the plate is precisely balanced by the shortfall on the upper half, and the total is the pressure at the centre times the area.

That is a genuinely useful shortcut, and it is safe whenever the width of the plate does not change with depth. The very next slide shows what happens when it does, so do not file this away as a general rule.

52. Does the middle depth ever work?

Counterexample

Discussion prompt

The shortcut just found says: force equals weight-density times area times the depth of the middle. Test it on the trough end of Example 6.27, whose triangle runs from depth 0 to depth 3, and say what the correct version of the shortcut is.

Work it out before revealing. You have all three numbers: the area of the triangle, the depth of its middle, and the correct force from Example 6.27.

The shortcut gives 1123.2 pounds against the true 748.8, an overestimate of fifty per cent. The reason is that halfway down in depth is not halfway down in area. This triangle is widest at the surface, so most of its area sits where the pressure is small, and weighting every part of the plate by the middle depth counts the shallow water as if it were deep.

The correct statement replaces the middle depth by the depth of the centroid, the balance point of the plate's area. For a rectangle those coincide, which is why the previous slide's shortcut worked. For any other shape you either know the centroid, which is Section 6.6, or you integrate.

53. Moving the origin off the water surface

Concept

Nothing forces the origin to sit at the water surface. On a dam it is far more convenient to put it at the top of the structure, which does not move, and then write the depth function to match the water level of the day.

origindepth functionlimits
at the water surfaces(x) = x0 down to the bottom of the wet part
at the top of the dam, water 10 ft lowers(x) = x − 1010 down to 540
at the top of the dam, water 135 ft lowers(x) = x − 135135 down to 540

The width function is written once, in the fixed coordinate, and then it never changes. Only the depth function and the upper limit move when the reservoir does, which is exactly what makes the second part of the next example cheap.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, pp. 606-607 — Figure 6.60, the frame of reference for the dam

Everything so far has put the origin at the water surface, which makes the depth function equal to the variable. That is convenient, and it is also fragile: if the water level moves, so does your whole coordinate system, and the width function has to be rewritten.

For a dam the sensible choice is to fix the origin to the structure, at the top of the dam, which never moves. The width function is then written once and for all. The price is that the depth function is no longer the variable itself: it is the variable minus however far below the top the water happens to be.

Read the table as a preview of the next two slides. Part (a) of Example 6.28 and part (b) differ in exactly two entries of that table, the depth function and the lower limit, and nothing else about the setup changes at all.

54. Example 6.28(a): the Hoover Dam, reservoir full

Worked example

Figure (svg): The face of the Hoover Dam drawn as an isosceles trapezoid, 1250 feet across the top, 750 across the bottom and 750 tall, with the full reservoir shaded to 540 feet below the top of the dam and a dashed red line marking the drought surface 135 feet below the top.

The origin is at the top of the dam, not at the water surface, so the depth of the water at x is x minus 10 when the reservoir is full.

Model the face of the dam as an isosceles trapezoid with lower base 750 feet, upper base 1250 feet and height 750 feet. When the reservoir is full the water surface is 10 feet below the top of the dam, and the water is 530 feet deep.

Choose the frame of reference

Why: Origin at the top of the dam, x downward, so the water surface is at 10 and its floor is at 540.

\[ s(x) = x - 10, \qquad 10 \le x \le 540 \]

Find the width by similar triangles

Why: Each side sets back 250 feet over the full 750 feet of height, so the half-overhang at depth x is 250 minus one third of x.

\[ r = 250 - \frac{x}{3}, \qquad w(x) = 750 + 2r \]

Simplify the width function

Why: Twice the half-overhang plus the lower base.

\[ w(x) = 1250 - \frac{2}{3}x \]

Write the force integral

Why: Weight-density times width times depth, over the wet part.

\[ F = \int_{10}^{540} 62.4\left(1250 - \frac23 x\right)(x-10)\,dx \]

Factor the integrand

Why: Take out minus two thirds to leave a plain quadratic.

\[ \left(1250-\frac23 x\right)(x-10) = -\frac23\left(x^2 - 1885x + 18{,}750\right) \]

Integrate

Why: Power rule, term by term.

\[ \int\left(x^2-1885x+18{,}750\right)dx = \frac{x^3}{3} - \frac{1885x^2}{2} + 18{,}750x \]

Put the constants together

Why: Weight-density times two thirds is 41.6, and the minus sign stays in front.

\[ F = -41.6\left[\frac{x^3}{3} - \frac{1885x^2}{2} + 18{,}750x\right]_{10}^{540} \]

Evaluate at the two limits

Why: The bracket is negative, so the force comes out positive.

\[ F = -41.6\left(-212{,}220{,}000 - 93{,}583\right) \approx 8{,}832{,}245{,}000 \text{ lb} \]

Convert to tons

Why: Two thousand pounds to the ton.

\[ \frac{8{,}832{,}245{,}000}{2000} \approx 4{,}416{,}123 \text{ tons} \]

Check with the area and an average pressure

Why: The wetted face has area 565,333 square feet, so the answer amounts to an average pressure of 15,623 pounds per square foot, the pressure at a depth of 250 feet. The water is 530 feet deep, so its middle is at 265 feet; the effective depth is shallower than that because the dam is wider near the top, which is exactly right.

\[ \frac{8{,}832{,}245{,}000}{62.4\cdot 565{,}333} = 250.4 \text{ ft} \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, pp. 606-607 — Example 6.28a, Figures 6.59 and 6.61

This is the longest setup in the lesson, so take it in two halves. The first half is geometry with no water in it: where the origin is, and how wide the dam is at depth x. The second half is the same three-factor integral you have now written twice.

The similar triangles deserve a careful look. Each sloping side moves in by 250 feet over the full 750 feet of the dam's height, so at depth x it has moved in by one third of x. The width is the lower base plus twice whatever overhang remains, which simplifies to 1250 minus two thirds of x.

The limits are 10 and 540, not 0 and 750. Above 10 there is no water, and below 540 there is no reservoir. And do the check: dividing the force by the weight-density and by the wetted area gives an effective depth of 250 feet, a little shallower than the middle of the 530 feet of water, which is exactly what you expect for a face that is wider near the top.

55. Example 6.28(b): the same dam after a drought

Worked example

Drought drops the surface of Lake Mead 125 feet below its full level. Find the force on the face of the dam now.

Update the depth function

Why: The surface is now 135 feet below the top of the dam, so depth at position x is x minus 135.

\[ s(x) = x - 135 \]

Update the limits

Why: The water now starts at 135; the floor of the reservoir has not moved.

\[ 135 \le x \le 540 \]

Keep the same width function

Why: The dam did not change shape, so this line is copied unchanged.

\[ w(x) = 1250 - \frac23 x \]

Write the new integral

Why: Same structure, two numbers different.

\[ F = \int_{135}^{540} 62.4\left(1250-\frac23 x\right)(x-135)\,dx \]

Factor the integrand

Why: The quadratic changes because the root at the surface moved.

\[ \left(1250-\frac23 x\right)(x-135) = -\frac23\left(x^2 - 2010x + 253{,}125\right) \]

Antidifferentiate and put the constants together

Why: Same power rule, same 41.6 out in front.

\[ F = -41.6\left[\frac{x^3}{3} - 1005x^2 + 253{,}125x\right]_{135}^{540} \]

Evaluate at the two limits

Why: Then divide by two thousand pounds to the ton.

\[ F = -41.6(-120{,}558{,}375) \approx 5{,}015{,}228{,}000 \text{ lb} = 2{,}507{,}614 \text{ tons} \]

Check against the full reservoir

Why: The water is now 405 feet deep instead of 530. Pressure scales with depth and the wetted area grows with depth as well, so the force should fall roughly like the square of the depth: the ratio of squares is 0.58 and the true ratio is 0.57. A quarter less water depth costs the dam over forty per cent of its load.

\[ \left(\frac{405}{530}\right)^2 = 0.58, \qquad \frac{5{,}015{,}228{,}000}{8{,}832{,}245{,}000} = 0.57 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 608 — Example 6.28b

Compare this solution with the previous one line by line. Only two things changed: the depth function, because the surface moved down, and the lower limit, for the same reason. The width function is copied over unchanged, which is the payoff for fixing the origin to the dam.

That is the general lesson about frames of reference in this section. Choose the origin so that the parts of the problem that do not move are the parts that are hard to write down.

The check is a scaling argument worth carrying with you. When the water gets shallower, both the pressure and the wetted area shrink together, so the force falls roughly like the square of the water depth. Here a 24 per cent drop in depth removed 43 per cent of the load, and a rough square-law estimate would have predicted 42 per cent.

56. Checkpoint 6.28: fifty feet lower

Estimation

\[ \text{surface 50 ft below full: } s(x) = x-60, \quad 60 \le x \le 540 \]

Predict first

At its average level the lake's surface is 50 feet below full. Before computing: where will the force land?

  • between 3 and 4 million tons
  • above 4.4 million tons
  • between 2.5 and 3 million tons
  • below 2.5 million tons

Correct: between 3 and 4 million tons

Why: The water is 480 feet deep instead of 530, so the square-law estimate predicts about 0.82 of the full load, roughly 3.6 million tons. The integral of 62.4 times the width times x minus 60, from 60 to 540, gives 7,164,518,400 pounds, that is 3,582,259 tons: right where the estimate said. A 50 foot drop in the lake removes almost a million tons of load.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 608 — Checkpoint 6.28

Estimate before computing. You now have two data points, 4.4 million tons when the lake is full and 2.5 million after a 125 foot drop, and a scaling rule that says the force falls roughly like the square of the water depth.

A 50 foot drop leaves 480 feet of water instead of 530, so the square-law estimate is about 82 per cent of the full load, or roughly 3.6 million tons. The integral confirms it at 3,582,259 tons.

Look at the size of the change: fifty feet of lake level, which is a few per cent of the depth, moves the load on the dam by nearly a million tons. That is the kind of sensitivity engineers have to design for, and it comes directly from the fact that two things, pressure and wetted area, grow together.

57. What changes the force on the trough end?

Sorting

Sort into buckets

The trough of Example 6.27 exerts 748.8 lb on one end. Which of these changes that number?

changes the force
fill it with a liquid of twice the weight-density; double both the base and the height of the triangular end; turn the triangle point-up, same base and height, still full; fill the trough only to half its depth
leaves it unchanged
make the trough 30 ft long instead of 15 ft, still full; attach the trough to a huge reservoir at the same depth
yes
The weight-density is a factor out front, so doubling it doubles the force. Doubling both dimensions of the triangle multiplies the width by 2 and the depths by 2, so the force goes up eightfold. Turning the triangle point-up moves its area into deeper water and doubles the force to 1497.6 lb. Filling only to half the depth leaves a smaller triangle in shallower water and cuts the force to one eighth.
no
Length along the trough never enters the integral: the force is computed on one end, strip by strip, and each strip's depth and width are unaffected. For the same reason, what lies behind the plate does not matter; by Pascal's principle only the depth decides the pressure.

Sort all six before checking. Every one of them can be settled by looking at the integral rather than by intuition, which is the skill being practised.

The two that leave the force alone are the ones that never enter the formula. The length of the trough does not appear anywhere, because the force was computed on one end; and by Pascal's principle it makes no difference what lies behind the plate, only how deep it is.

The other four all move a factor in the integral. Doubling the weight-density doubles the force outright. Doubling both dimensions of the triangle doubles the width and the depths at once, so the force goes up by a factor of eight. Turning the triangle point-up puts its area into deeper water and exactly doubles the force. And filling to half depth leaves a triangle of half the linear size in the shallower water, which cuts the force to an eighth.

58. Setting up reliably

Section

Part 5

59. Pattern: the representative piece, every time

Pattern

Figure (svg): A flow diagram: cut a thin piece, write its elementary product, integrate over the object, get the total; underneath, the four instances from this lesson with the product each one uses.

One discipline, five formulas. The only thing that changes from row to row is which elementary product goes inside the integral.
  1. Name the piece on which every varying quantity is nearly constant: a slice of rod, a ring, a short stretch of path, a horizontal layer, a horizontal strip.
  2. Choose the coordinate before anything else, and say in words where its origin is and which way it grows.
  3. Write the elementary product for that one piece, with its differential attached.
  4. Check the units of the product: they must be the units of the answer.
  5. Integrate over the object, with limits that describe exactly the part that counts, and state the units.
  6. Check with a crude estimate: an average density, an average force, a total weight times one lift.

This is the whole section on one slide, and it is deliberately written without any of the five formulas, because the formulas are consequences of it. If you can run this list, you can rebuild every result in the lesson.

Two of the six steps are the ones people skip under time pressure, and they are the ones worth slowing down for. Saying in words where the origin is stops the mixed-frame error from the cone; checking the units of the elementary product stops the missing ring factor from Part 1.

The last step is a habit rather than a rule. An average density, an average force, a total weight times a single lift, or the depth of a centroid: each of these gives a crude answer in one line, and a crude answer that agrees with your integral is worth a great deal of confidence.

60. Match each quantity to its elementary product

Matching

Match the pairs

  • a. mass of a rod of varying density
  • b. mass of a disk of radial density
  • c. work done by a variable force
  • d. work of pumping one layer
  • e. hydrostatic force on one strip
  • p. ρ(x) dx
  • q. 2πx ρ(x) dx
  • r. F(x) dx
  • s. (weight-density)(volume of the layer)(lift x)
  • t. (weight-density)(depth)(width dx)

Why: Every row is the same sentence: something per unit of something, times that unit. The ring carries an extra circumference because its area is not simply its width; the pumping layer carries an extra lift because the work is not finished when the water has weight.

Match all five before checking, and say the reason out loud for each. The reasons are more valuable than the matches, because the matches are the things you would look up.

Two rows carry an extra factor beyond the obvious product. The disk carries a circumference, because a ring's area is not just its width. The pumping layer carries a lift, because the weight of the water is only half the story when the water has to travel.

Once the table is complete, read down the right-hand column and notice how similar the entries are. Every one of them is a rate multiplied by the little bit of the variable it is a rate with respect to. That sentence is the whole of Chapter 6.

61. Lifting a rocket out of a gravity well

Real world

\[ F(x) = \frac{GMm}{x^2}, \quad G = 6.67\times 10^{-11}, \quad M = 6\times 10^{24} \]

Discussion prompt

A rocket of mass 1000 kilograms sits on the Earth's surface, 6400 kilometres from the centre. Find the work to lift it to 6500 kilometres from the centre, and then the work to lift it away entirely. Both to three significant figures.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications §6.5, p. 609 — Exercises 245 and 246

Try this before revealing; the integral itself is the same one over the square you did back in Exercise 222, only with astronomical constants attached.

The second part is the striking one. Lifting the rocket the first hundred kilometres costs about 962 million joules, and lifting it away from the Earth entirely costs only about sixty-five times as much, even though the distance is infinite. The improper integral converges because gravity dies off like one over the square of the distance, and this number is exactly what escape velocity is about.

The check is the one to remember from this lesson. Near the ground the weight of the rocket is about 9770 newtons, and that constant force over 100 kilometres would be 977 million joules. The true answer is slightly less, because gravity weakens on the way up, and a variable force problem whose answer comes out just under the constant-force estimate is behaving exactly as it should.

62. Check: mass from a density

Check

Check your understanding

A wire 2 feet long, starting at the origin, has density x squared plus 2x pounds per foot. What is its mass?

  • A. 20/3 lb (correct)
  • B. 8/3 lb
  • C. 12 lb
  • D. 8 lb

Answer: A

Why: The mass is the integral from 0 to 2 of x² + 2x, which is x³/3 + x² evaluated at 2, that is 8/3 + 4 = 20/3, about 6.67 pounds. The density runs from 0 to 8 pounds per foot over a 2 foot wire, so an answer between 0 and 16 is expected.

Why B tempts people
That is only the first term of the antiderivative; the 2x part of the density was dropped.
Why C tempts people
That is the value of the antiderivative at 2 multiplied by the length, which double-counts the interval.
Why D tempts people
That is the density at the far end times the length, which treats a varying density as constant.

Answer before revealing. The setup is one line and the integration is a term-by-term power rule, so the question is really testing whether you integrate the density or do something else with it.

Two of the distractors are worth diagnosing. One of them multiplies the density at the far end by the length, which is what you would do if the density were constant. Another drops half the density. Both would be caught by the same bound as always: with a density running from zero to eight over a two foot wire, the mass has to be somewhere between zero and sixteen pounds.

63. Check: a spring constant

Check

Check your understanding

A spring with a natural length of 12 inches is stretched to 15 inches by a force of 75 pounds. What is its spring constant in pounds per foot?

  • A. 5 lb/ft
  • B. 25 lb/ft
  • C. 300 lb/ft (correct)
  • D. 900 lb/ft

Answer: C

Why: The displacement is 3 inches, which is 0.25 feet, and Hooke's law gives k as the force divided by the displacement: 75 divided by 0.25 is 300 pounds per foot. Working in inches instead would give 25 pounds per inch, the same spring in different units.

Why A tempts people
That divides by the stretched length of 15 inches rather than by the displacement from equilibrium.
Why B tempts people
That is the correct constant in pounds per inch; the question asked for pounds per foot, which is twelve times larger.
Why D tempts people
That multiplies by twelve on the wrong side; converting inches to feet makes the displacement smaller, and dividing by a smaller number was already done once.

This question is about units, not about springs. Get the displacement into feet before dividing and the rest is one division.

The tempting wrong answer is the one that divides by the stretched length rather than by the displacement from the natural length. Hooke's law measures from equilibrium, always, and the natural length of the spring is the zero of that measurement.

The other near-miss is the correct constant in the wrong units. Twenty-five pounds per inch and three hundred pounds per foot describe the same spring, and only the wording of the question decides which one is wanted, which is why you should write units on every answer.

64. Check: the force on a plate

Check

Check your understanding

A vertical rectangular plate 3 metres wide hangs in water with its top edge 2 metres down and its bottom edge 5 metres down. Using 9800 newtons per cubic metre, what is the force on it?

  • A. about 309,000 N (correct)
  • B. about 206,000 N
  • C. about 441,000 N
  • D. about 88,200 N

Answer: A

Why: The width is constant, so the force is 9800 times 3 times the integral of x from 2 to 5, which is 29,400 times (25 − 4)/2 = 29,400 times 10.5 = 308,700 newtons. The shortcut agrees: area 9 square metres times the centre depth 3.5 metres times 9800.

Why B tempts people
That uses the depth of the top edge for the whole plate, which underestimates every strip below it.
Why C tempts people
That uses the depth of the bottom edge for the whole plate, the same error in the other direction.
Why D tempts people
That is the weight-density times the area alone, with no depth in it at all; the units are wrong.

This is the one plate shape where you can avoid the integral if you want to, since the width is constant. Either integrate the depth from two to five and multiply by the weight-density and the width, or use the area times the depth of the centre.

The two large distractors are the plate evaluated at a single depth, once at the top edge and once at the bottom. They bracket the right answer, which is a useful thing to notice: any correct answer must sit between those two, because the real pressure is between the pressure at the top and the pressure at the bottom.

The smallest distractor has the wrong units altogether, weight-density times area with no depth in it. A units check kills it in a second, without any arithmetic.

65. Explain the two different lengths

Explain it to yourself

Discussion prompt

In the pumping integral, the variable x appears twice: once inside the radius of the layer and once as the lift. In two sentences, say what each occurrence means physically, and what would go wrong if you used the same reasoning for a tank being filled from above rather than emptied.

Write your two sentences before revealing, because being able to say this in words is the difference between reproducing a template and understanding a setup.

The two roles of the variable really are independent of each other. One of them is about the tank, telling you how much water is at that level, and would still be there if the water were simply poured away. The other is about the journey, telling you how far that water has to go, and would change if you pumped the water to a roof instead of over the rim.

The second half of the question is a good test of whether you have the idea rather than the formula. Filling reverses the direction of travel but not the accounting, and gravity supplies the energy instead of the pump.

66. Exit ticket

Exit ticket

\[ \text{a cylinder of radius 2 m and height 5 m, full, pumped over the rim} \]

Discussion prompt

Set up and evaluate the work, then check your answer a second way.

Do the whole thing on paper before revealing: frame, layer, weight, lift, integral, check. This is the cylinder case, so there are no similar triangles to worry about and every layer has the same radius.

The tank is full, so the limits run from the rim right down to the bottom, from zero to five. The constant in front is the weight-density times the area of the disk, and the only variable part of the integrand is the lift.

Then run the centre-of-mass check, which is exact for a cylinder: the whole tankful weighs the weight-density times its volume, and its middle is halfway down. If your two answers do not agree, the fault is almost always in the limits or in a dropped factor of the area.

67. Recap

Recap

quantitythe piecethe integral
mass of a roda short lengthintegral of the linear density along the rod
mass of a diska thin ringintegral of 2πx times the radial density, from 0 to r
work of a variable forcea short moveintegral of the force over the path
work on a springa short stretchintegral of kx, which is half k times the stretch squared
work of pumpinga horizontal layerintegral of (weight of the layer) times (its lift)
hydrostatic forcea horizontal stripintegral of the weight-density times depth times width

The same three decisions run through every one of them: what the piece is, what coordinate measures it, and what elementary product its contribution is. The integration itself is the easy part, and it is never where these problems are lost.

Section 6.6 takes the last of these ideas further: the centroid check used twice in this lesson becomes a method for locating centres of mass, which then does the work of the depth integral in one product.

Stewart, Calculus: Early Transcendentals 8e, §6.4 Work §6.4, pp. 455-460 — the same material on work in Stewart

Six quantities, one method. Read the table across rather than down: each row names a piece, and the integral is nothing more than that piece's elementary product with the little length attached. If you can regenerate the middle column, the right-hand column follows.

The three decisions in the second paragraph are what to rehearse before an exam. Which piece makes the varying factor constant, which coordinate measures that piece, and what product gives its contribution. The integration that follows is Chapter 3 material and rarely harder than a power rule.

Two checks have earned their place in your routine after this lesson. The units check on the integrand, which catches a missing ring or a missing depth; and the crude single-product estimate, whether that is an average density, an average force, or a total weight lifted from a centre of mass. Section 6.6 turns that last check into a method of its own.

Sources

  1. OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.5 Physical Applications — Strang & Herman, OpenStax / Rice University, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, pp. 594-609
  2. Stewart, Calculus: Early Transcendentals 8e, §6.4 Work — James Stewart, Cengage Learning, 2016, pp. 455-460
  3. Stewart, Calculus: Early Transcendentals 8e, §8.3 Applications to Physics and Engineering — James Stewart, Cengage Learning, 2016, pp. 558-568

Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Calculus I — $55/session, free consultation.

Book on Wyzant · Text (657) 465-8108