6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing

Volume as the integral of a cross-sectional area, solids with known cross-sections, the disk method for a region touching the axis, the washer method for one separated from it, revolving about lines other than the coordinate axes, and why the axis decides the variable.

Subject: Calculus I · 67 slides · symbolic lesson

Open the interactive version of this deck

What this lesson covers

The lesson, slide by slide

1. Determining Volumes by Slicing

Title

Calculus I · Section 6.2

A volume is the integral of a cross-sectional area

2. What this lesson gives you

Objectives

Section 6.1 added up thin strips to get an area. This lesson adds up thin slabs to get a volume, and then specialises to solids made by spinning a region about a line.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, p. 551 — learning objectives 6.2.1 to 6.2.3

Section 6.1 asked for an area and you answered it by adding thin strips. This lesson asks for a volume, and the answer comes the same way: cut the solid into thin slabs, work out the volume of one slab, and integrate. A slab is a face times a thickness, so the integrand is an area rather than a length.

Most of the lesson is about one family of solids: the ones you get by spinning a flat region about a line. Those are worth singling out because their slices are always circles or rings, so the area of a slice is known before you start and only the radius has to be found.

Keep an eye on two questions as you go, because between them they decide every problem in the section. First, which direction do you slice, which is settled entirely by the axis. Second, does the region touch that axis, which decides whether a slice is a full disk or a ring with a hole.

3. Before anything new: an area as a sum of strips

Warm-up

Discussion prompt

In Section 6.1 you found the area between y = f(x) above and y = g(x) below on the interval from a to b. What does one thin vertical strip contribute, and what integral adds up all the strips?

Write your answer down before revealing it. If the formula does not come back straight away, sketch two curves and one thin vertical strip between them; the picture almost always recovers the formula.

The point of starting here is the shape of the reasoning, not the formula. You approximated a region by pieces whose size you could compute, wrote the total as a Riemann sum, and took a limit. Everything in this lesson is the same three moves with one extra dimension.

One change matters. A strip contributed a height times a width, and the height was a difference of two function values. A slab contributes an area times a thickness, and that area is usually not a difference of two function values. Very often it is a difference of two squares instead, and confusing those two things is the single most common error in the section.

4. Slicing and known cross-sections

Section

Part 1

5. A cylinder: base area times height

Concept

Figure (svg): A solid drawn in perspective: a rounded three-lobed base region on the floor and an identical copy directly above it, joined by vertical sides. The top face is labelled A and a vertical arrow at the right is labelled h.

Slide the base straight up a distance h and every horizontal cross-section is a copy of it, so the volume is just the base area times the height.

In mathematics a cylinder is any solid made by sliding a flat region straight along a line perpendicular to it. Every cross-section perpendicular to that line is a copy of the base.

\[ V = A \cdot h \]

For a soup can the base is a disk of radius r, and the formula becomes the familiar one.

\[ V = \pi r^2 h \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, p. 551 — cross-sections and cylinders

The word cylinder is being used more generally than usual here. It means any solid you get by taking a flat region and sliding it straight along a line perpendicular to it. A soup can, a hexagonal pencil and the blob in the picture are all cylinders in this sense.

What makes the volume easy is that every cross-section is identical. Nothing changes as you move along the solid, so there is nothing to integrate: the volume is the one cross-sectional area times the distance you slid it.

This is the building block for the whole lesson. When a solid's cross-sections are not all the same, you cut it into slabs so thin that each one is very nearly a cylinder, and apply this formula to each of them. So keep the formula in the front of your mind: area of the face, times the thickness.

6. Cut a solid into slabs

Picture it

Figure (svg): Left: a solid lying along the x-axis cut into four slabs S1 to S4 of width 1, each drawn as a short cylinder with an elliptical face. Right: the graph of the cross-sectional area A(x) with four rectangles whose heights are the slabs' face areas.

Each slab's volume is its face area times its thickness, exactly like a rectangle's area under the graph of A. Adding slabs is a Riemann sum for A.

When the cross-section changes along the solid, no single base area works. So cut the solid into thin slabs. Each slab is nearly a cylinder, whose volume you already know.

Look at the two panels together, because they show the same four numbers twice. On the left the solid has been cut into four slabs; each slab is drawn as a short cylinder whose face is the cut taken somewhere inside it. On the right, those same four face areas appear as the heights of four rectangles under the graph of the area function.

That is the whole idea of the method. Once you know the area of the cut at each position, the volume of the solid is nothing more than the area under the graph of that area function. A volume question has been turned into an ordinary Chapter 5 integral.

Notice how crude four slabs are: near the waist of the solid the slab is too fat, near the bulge it is too thin. As the slabs get thinner those errors shrink, exactly as they did for rectangles under a curve, and the limit is the integral.

7. From a sum of slabs to an integral

Concept

Partition the interval from a to b into n pieces of width delta x and pick a point in each. The slab over the i-th piece is almost a cylinder with base area A at that point.

\[ V(S_i) \approx A(x_i^*)\,\Delta x \]

\[ V(S) \approx \sum_{i=1}^{n} A(x_i^*)\,\Delta x \]

That is a Riemann sum for the function A. Let the number of slabs grow without bound:

\[ V(S) = \lim_{n\to\infty}\sum_{i=1}^{n} A(x_i^*)\,\Delta x = \int_a^b A(x)\,dx \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, pp. 552-553 — Figures 6.12 and 6.13

Follow the three lines in order and notice that no new theory appears. The first line is the cylinder formula applied to one slab. The second adds the slabs up. The third recognises the sum as a Riemann sum and takes the limit, which is the definition of the definite integral from Section 5.2.

The only thing you have to supply in any particular problem is the area function. Where the cut is a square, that is a side squared; where it is a disk, it is pi times a radius squared. Everything after that is integration you can already do.

It is worth noticing what is not being assumed. The solid does not have to be round, symmetric or made by spinning anything, and the cuts do not all have to be the same shape. If you can write down the area of the cut at each position, you can find the volume.

8. Reading the slicing formula

Notation

Annotate

On: \( V = \int_a^b A(x)\,dx \)

  • The area of the cut made perpendicular to the x-axis at position x. It must be an AREA: square units.
  • The thickness of one slab. Area times thickness is volume, so the units come out cubic.
  • Where the solid begins and ends along the x-axis. Outside them the cross-section is empty.
  • The formula does not care what the cut looks like: square, triangle, disk or ring. Only its area enters.

Work through the annotations one at a time and make the units argument your own, because it is the fastest way to catch a wrong setup. The thing being integrated has to be an area, and the differential supplies a length, so the product is a volume. If your integrand is a length, you are computing an area, not a volume.

The second thing to hold on to is that the limits live on the axis you are slicing along. They are positions, not heights or radii: the place where the solid starts and the place where it ends.

The last annotation is the reason this one formula carries the whole lesson. Disks and washers are not new methods; they are this formula with a particular area substituted in. If you ever meet a solid whose cuts are hexagons or ellipses, you already know what to do.

9. Three steps, and the first is geometry

Intuition

  1. Look at a cross-section and decide its shape. Draw one if no picture is given.
  2. Write its area as a function of position.
  3. Integrate that area over the interval the solid occupies.

Steps one and two are geometry: similar triangles, the width of a region, the radius of a circle. Once the area function is written down, step three is the integration you already know from Chapter 5.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, p. 553 — Problem-Solving Strategy: Finding Volumes by the Slicing Method

Read these three steps as a division of labour. The first two are geometry and they are where the thinking is; the third is calculus and it is usually routine. Students who find these problems hard almost always find the geometry hard, not the integration.

So when you are stuck, do not reach for a formula. Draw the solid, draw one cut, and label it. Ask what shape the cut is, and what single length determines it, then write the area in terms of that length and finally express the length in terms of the position along the axis.

The habit of drawing a picture even when one is provided pays off later in the lesson, when the axis of revolution moves away from the coordinate axes and the radii stop being plain function values.

10. Example 6.6: the volume of a pyramid

Worked example

Derive the geometry formula for a pyramid with a square base of side a and height h. Put the apex at the origin with the x-axis through the centre of the base.

\[ \text{Goal: } V = \tfrac13 a^2 h \]

Name the cross-section

Why: Cut perpendicular to the x-axis. The base is a square, so every cut is a square; call its side s.

\[ \text{cut at } x: \text{ a square of side } s \]

Relate s to x with similar triangles

Why: In the side view, the cut and the base sit in similar triangles with the apex.

\[ \frac{s}{a} = \frac{x}{h} \]

Solve for s

Why: Multiply both sides by a.

\[ s = \frac{ax}{h} \]

Square it to get the area

Why: The cut is a square.

\[ A(x) = s^2 = \frac{a^2x^2}{h^2} \]

Integrate from the apex to the base

Why: The factor in front is a constant.

\[ V = \int_0^h \frac{a^2}{h^2}x^2\,dx = \frac{a^2}{h^2}\int_0^h x^2\,dx \]

Apply the power rule

Why: The antiderivative of x squared is x cubed over 3.

\[ = \frac{a^2}{h^2}\left[\frac{x^3}{3}\right]_0^h \]

Evaluate

Why: At the apex the bracket is zero.

\[ = \frac{a^2}{h^2}\cdot\frac{h^3}{3} \]

Simplify

Why: Two powers of h cancel.

\[ = \frac13 a^2 h \]

Figure (svg): Left: a square-based pyramid in perspective, apex at the left and base of side a at the right, with a square cross-section of side s shaded partway along. Right: the side view, a triangle with apex at the origin, a vertical segment s at distance x and the base a at distance h.

From the side, the cut of side s and the base of side a sit in two similar triangles, so s is to a as x is to h.

Check with Exercise 63

Why: A pyramid of height 6 with base side 2: slicing and the formula must agree.

\[ \int_0^6 \left(\frac{2x}{6}\right)^2dx = \frac19\cdot\frac{6^3}{3} = 8 = \tfrac13(2^2)(6) \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, pp. 553-554 — Example 6.6

This example derives a formula you have known since school, and that is exactly why it is a good first example: you can check the answer at the end. Set the apex at the origin so the cut has side zero there, which keeps the algebra clean.

The one piece of real work is the similar triangles step. In the side view, the triangle from the apex out to the cut and the triangle from the apex out to the base have the same shape, so their corresponding sides are in the same ratio. That gives the side of the cut as a fraction of the base side.

After that, everything is mechanical. Square the side to get a square's area, pull the constants out, and integrate x squared. The three in the denominator of the famous one third comes from the power rule, nothing more mysterious than that.

The check is worth copying as a habit. Put in the specific numbers of Exercise 63, a pyramid of height 6 and base side 2, and watch slicing and the geometry formula agree on 8.

11. Stretch the pyramid

Tweak it

Parameter explorer

The curve is the slice area A(x) = (ax/h)² of a pyramid, and the area under it is the volume. Double the height h: does the volume double? Double the base side a: what happens then?

\[ V = \tfrac13({a})^2({h}) \]

  • a — from 1 to 3: base side a
  • h — from 2 to 8: height h

Move the height slider first and watch what happens to the curve. The shape of the area function does not change; it just stretches out to the new height and still ends at the same top value, the area of the base. Twice the length, same height, so twice the area underneath, which means twice the volume.

Now move the base slider. This time the curve keeps the same width but its top value goes up as the square of the base side, because a square's area grows like the square of its side. Doubling the base side therefore multiplies the volume by four, not by two.

This kind of scaling reasoning is worth having. It tells you, without any integration, that a pyramid twice as big in every direction has eight times the volume, and it gives you a fast way to sanity check an answer whose numbers you have just changed.

12. Checkpoint 6.6: the volume of a cone

Worked example

Use slicing to derive the formula for a right circular cone of radius r and height h. Lay it on its side with the apex at the origin.

Name the cross-section

Why: Every cut perpendicular to the axis is a disk; call its radius rho.

\[ \text{cut at } x: \text{ a disk of radius } \rho \]

Similar triangles

Why: The same proportion as in the pyramid.

\[ \frac{\rho}{r} = \frac{x}{h} \]

Solve for the radius

Why: Multiply by r.

\[ \rho = \frac{rx}{h} \]

Write the area of the disk

Why: Pi times the radius squared.

\[ A(x) = \pi\rho^2 = \frac{\pi r^2}{h^2}x^2 \]

Integrate from apex to base

Why: Constants come out.

\[ V = \frac{\pi r^2}{h^2}\int_0^h x^2\,dx \]

Apply the power rule

Why: Evaluate from 0 to h.

\[ = \frac{\pi r^2}{h^2}\cdot\frac{h^3}{3} \]

Simplify

Why: Two powers of h cancel, leaving one third of the base area times the height.

\[ = \frac13\pi r^2 h \]

Figure (svg): A cone lying on its side, apex at the origin, drawn as the triangle under the line y equals r x over h and its mirror image. A highlighted disk at x = 3 has radius rho; the base at x = h has radius r.

Revolving a line through the origin makes a cone. The slice at distance x is a disk whose radius grows in proportion to x.

Check against the pyramid

Why: Both solids have cuts that scale like x squared, so each is one third of base area times height; only the base area differs.

\[ V_{\text{pyramid}} = \tfrac13(a^2)h, \qquad V_{\text{cone}} = \tfrac13(\pi r^2)h \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, p. 554 — Checkpoint 6.6

Try this one on paper before reading the solution. Every step has a twin in the pyramid derivation, so if you can reproduce that, you can do this.

The only difference is in step two: the cut is a disk rather than a square, so its area is pi times the radius squared instead of a side squared. The similar triangles are identical, and so the radius grows in proportion to the distance from the apex.

The check draws out something worth remembering. Both solids have cuts whose area grows like the square of the position, so both integrate to one third of base area times height. That is not a coincidence about cones and pyramids; it is true of every solid that tapers linearly to a point, whatever the shape of its base.

13. Same slices, same volume

Intuition

The slicing formula only ever sees the areas of the cuts. So two solids whose cuts have equal areas at every height have equal volumes, however differently they are shaped. This is Cavalieri's principle.

\[ A_1(x) = A_2(x) \text{ for every } x \;\Longrightarrow\; \int_a^b A_1(x)\,dx = \int_a^b A_2(x)\,dx \]

A straight stack of coins and the same stack pushed into a leaning tower hold the same volume. A slanted pyramid with its apex off to one side has the same volume as the upright one.

This slide is a pause for an idea rather than a technique, but it explains something you might otherwise find suspicious. The integral only ever sees the areas of the cuts, so any two solids whose cuts have matching areas must have the same volume, even if they look nothing alike.

The everyday image is a stack of coins. Push the stack over into a leaning tower and no coin changes size, so the volume is unchanged, although the solid is now slanted. The same argument says an oblique pyramid, with its apex hanging out over the edge of its base, has exactly the volume of the upright one.

Cavalieri knew this before calculus existed, and it is really a statement that the integral of a function does not care how the graph is shifted around. When you meet a solid that looks awkwardly tilted, check whether its cuts match those of something simpler.

14. Exercise 68: squares standing on a circle

Worked example

A solid has a disk of radius a as its base. Every cut perpendicular to the base and to the x-axis is a square. Find the volume.

\[ \text{base: } x^2 + y^2 \le a^2 \]

Find the base's width at x

Why: The cut runs from the lower semicircle to the upper one.

\[ s(x) = \sqrt{a^2-x^2} - \left(-\sqrt{a^2-x^2}\right) \]

Simplify the width

Why: This width is the side of the square.

\[ s(x) = 2\sqrt{a^2-x^2} \]

Square it

Why: The area of the square cut.

\[ A(x) = 4\left(a^2-x^2\right) \]

Integrate across the base

Why: The solid runs from minus a to a.

\[ V = \int_{-a}^{a}4\left(a^2-x^2\right)dx \]

Find an antiderivative

Why: Integrate the constant term and the square term separately.

\[ = 4\left[a^2x - \frac{x^3}{3}\right]_{-a}^{a} \]

Evaluate at both ends

Why: The bracket is odd, so the lower value is the negative of the upper one.

\[ = 4\left[\frac{2a^3}{3} - \left(-\frac{2a^3}{3}\right)\right] \]

Simplify

Why: Four times four thirds of a cubed.

\[ = \frac{16}{3}a^3 \]

Figure (svg): In perspective, a disk of radius 2 lies flat on the floor with the x-axis running across it. Several squares stand upright on chords of the disk, each perpendicular to the x-axis; the one at x = 0.7 is highlighted. The squares are tallest in the middle and shrink to nothing at the edges.

The side of each square is the width of the disk where the cut is made: full width in the middle, zero at the rim.

Check with Simpson's rule

Why: Simpson's rule is exact for quadratics, and A is quadratic. One panel from minus a to a uses the end values 0 and the middle value 4a squared.

\[ \frac{2a}{6}\left[0 + 4\cdot 4a^2 + 0\right] = \frac{16}{3}a^3 \quad (a = 2: \; V = \tfrac{128}{3}) \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, p. 566 — Exercise 68

Take a moment with the picture before the algebra, because this is the first solid in the lesson that is not made by spinning anything. The base is a flat disk, and on each chord perpendicular to the x-axis a square stands upright. Nothing is round except the base.

The whole problem is the width of the disk at position x. The circle gives two values of y at each x, one positive and one negative, and their difference is the width. Then the square's side is that width and its area is the width squared, which is where the factor of four comes from.

Notice that the answer, sixteen thirds of a cubed, involves no pi at all, which makes sense: only the base was circular and it was squared away immediately.

The check uses Simpson's rule, which is exact for quadratic integrands, and the area function here is quadratic. So one Simpson panel across the whole base gives the answer exactly, which is a genuine independent confirmation rather than a rough estimate.

15. Match each cut to its area

Matching

Match the pairs

  • a. square of side s
  • b. semicircle of diameter s
  • c. equilateral triangle of side s
  • d. right isosceles triangle with legs s
  • w. s²
  • x. πs²/8
  • y. (√3/4)s²
  • z. s²/2

Why: A semicircle of diameter s has radius s/2, so its area is half of pi times s squared over 4, which is pi s squared over 8. An equilateral triangle of side s has height (√3/2)s. A right isosceles triangle is half of a square. Every one is a constant times s squared, so the geometry only ever changes the constant.

Do these from the picture rather than from memory. In each case one length, the side or the diameter, determines the whole shape, so the area has to be a constant times that length squared.

The semicircle is the one people get wrong. Its diameter is s, so its radius is half of s, and the area of the full circle is pi times s squared over four; halving that gives pi times s squared over eight. If you write pi s squared over two you have used the diameter as if it were the radius.

The general lesson is that every one of these constants can be rebuilt in a few seconds from a sketch, which is much safer than trying to remember four separate formulas under exam pressure.

16. Exercise 73: semicircles on the region between two curves

Fill the middle

Figure (svg): In perspective, the thin region between y = x and y = x squared for x from 0 to 1 lies on the floor. Semicircles stand upright on chords of the region, perpendicular to the x-axis; the one at x = 0.5 is highlighted. Their diameters are the gaps between the two curves.

Each semicircle's diameter is the vertical gap between the two curves, largest near the middle and zero where the curves meet at 0 and 1.

The base is the region between y = x and y = x squared for x from 0 to 1, and every cut perpendicular to the x-axis is a semicircle. Fill in its diameter.

Fill in the blanks

A(x) = \fracx - x^2___\left(___\right)^2

Why: On the interval from 0 to 1 the line y = x lies above the parabola, so the diameter is x minus x squared. Then V is pi over 8 times the integral from 0 to 1 of (x − x²)², which is pi over 8 times 1/30, or pi over 240.

\[ V = \frac{\pi}{8}\int_0^1\left(x-x^2\right)^2dx = \frac{\pi}{8}\cdot\frac{1}{30} = \frac{\pi}{240} \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, p. 566 — Exercise 73

Look at where the semicircles are widest. Near x equal to zero and x equal to one the two curves meet, so the gap between them closes and the semicircles shrink to nothing. In between, the gap opens and the semicircles are at their fattest.

Filling in the blank means answering one question: what is the diameter of the semicircle at position x. It is the vertical gap between the two curves, and on this interval the line lies above the parabola, so the gap is x minus x squared.

The rest is routine. Square the gap, multiply by pi over eight and integrate from zero to one. The answer, pi over two hundred and forty, is tiny, and the picture tells you why: the whole solid is a thin ridge only a quarter of a unit tall at its highest point.

17. Trap: integrating the side instead of the area

Trap

The trap

For the squares standing on a disk of radius 2:

\[ V = \int_{-2}^{2} 2\sqrt{4-x^2}\,dx \]

\[ = 4\pi \]

Wrong. That is the area of the base disk.

The fix

The integrand must be an area. Side times dx is square units; only area times dx is cubic. Square the side first.

\[ V = \int_{-2}^{2} 4\left(4-x^2\right)dx \]

\[ = \frac{128}{3} \]

This mistake usually happens when you have carefully worked out the width of the base and are so pleased with it that you integrate it straight away. Watch what you actually get: the integral of the width across the base is the area of the base, in this case four pi, the area of a disk of radius two.

The defence is a units check, and it takes two seconds. The integrand times the differential must come out in cubic units. Length times length is an area, so an integrand that is a length can never produce a volume.

A second defence is to ask what shape the number describes. If your answer has no trace of the square cross-sections in it, you have thrown away the very thing that made the solid three dimensional.

18. Solids of revolution: the disk method

Section

Part 2

19. Solids of revolution

Concept

solid of revolution — The solid swept out when a flat region is revolved once about a line in its own plane, called the axis of revolution.

Figure (svg): Two panels. Left: the region under a wavy curve from x = 0 to x = 4, shaded. Right: the same region together with its mirror image below the x-axis and elliptical end faces, showing the vase-shaped solid it sweeps out when revolved about the x-axis.

Every point of the region travels in a circle about the axis. A cut perpendicular to the axis is therefore a disk, whatever the curve looks like.

A lathe makes exactly these shapes: table legs, chess pieces, vases, axles. Because every point of the region travels in a circle about the axis, a cut perpendicular to the axis is a disk.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, pp. 554-555 — Figure 6.15

This is the family of solids the rest of the lesson is about, and it is worth naming what makes them special. Every point of the region sweeps out a circle centred on the axis, so a cut perpendicular to the axis is always round: a full disk if the region reaches the axis, a ring if it does not.

That means the geometry step, which was the hard part in the slicing problems, is already done for you. You never have to ask what shape the cut is. You only have to find its radius, which is a distance from the axis to a boundary of the region.

Look at the two panels. On the left is a flat region, the only thing you ever draw. On the right is the vase it sweeps out. In practice you work entirely with the left-hand picture and imagine the right-hand one, which is why being fluent with distances in the plane matters so much here.

20. Example 6.7: slicing a solid of revolution

Worked example

The region under the curve below, from x = 1 to 4, is revolved about the x-axis. Find the volume by slicing.

\[ f(x) = x^2 - 4x + 5, \qquad 1 \le x \le 4 \]

Name the cross-section

Why: A cut perpendicular to the x-axis is a disk; its radius is the height of the curve.

\[ r = f(x) = x^2-4x+5 \]

Write the area

Why: Pi times the radius squared.

\[ A(x) = \pi\left(x^2-4x+5\right)^2 \]

Expand the square

Why: Square the trinomial term by term.

\[ \left(x^2-4x+5\right)^2 = x^4-8x^3+26x^2-40x+25 \]

Set up the integral

Why: Pi comes out in front.

\[ V = \pi\int_1^4 \left(x^4-8x^3+26x^2-40x+25\right)dx \]

Integrate term by term

Why: Power rule on each term.

\[ = \pi\left[\frac{x^5}{5}-2x^4+\frac{26x^3}{3}-20x^2+25x\right]_1^4 \]

Evaluate at 4 and at 1

Why: The bracket is 412 over 15 at 4 and 178 over 15 at 1.

\[ = \pi\left(\frac{412}{15} - \frac{178}{15}\right) \]

Subtract

Why: Take the difference of the two bracket values.

\[ = \frac{234}{15}\pi \]

Reduce

Why: Divide top and bottom by 3.

\[ = \frac{78}{5}\pi \approx 49.0 \]

Figure (svg): The parabola y = x squared minus 4x plus 5 from x = 1 to 4, the region under it shaded, its mirror image below the x-axis dashed, and elliptical faces at x = 1, at x = 4 and at a highlighted slice at x = 2.5.

The solid is waisted where the parabola dips to its minimum height 1 at x = 2, and flares to radius 5 at x = 4.

Check by differentiating the antiderivative

Why: Its derivative must give back the expanded integrand. As a size check, the radius stays between 1 and 5 over a length of 3, so the volume lies between 3 pi and 75 pi.

\[ \frac{d}{dx}\left[\frac{x^5}{5}-2x^4+\frac{26x^3}{3}-20x^2+25x\right] = x^4-8x^3+26x^2-40x+25 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, pp. 556-557 — Example 6.7

The book does this one with the general slicing formula before naming the disk method, to make the point that nothing new is needed. The cut is a circle whose radius is the height of the curve, so the area is pi times that height squared, and you integrate it.

The algebra is the only demanding part. Squaring the trinomial gives a fourth-degree polynomial, and it is easy to drop a term; multiply it out carefully and check one value, for instance at x equal to two, where both forms should give one.

The check at the end is the professional habit: differentiate the antiderivative and see the integrand come back. There is also a quick size check worth doing in your head. Over this interval the radius never drops below one and never exceeds five, so the volume must sit between the thin cylinder of radius one and the fat one of radius five, that is between about nine and two hundred and thirty six. Forty nine fits comfortably.

21. From a thin rectangle to a disk

Picture it

Figure (svg): Two panels. Left: the parabola y = (x − 1) squared plus 1 with one thin rectangle under it at x = 2. Right: the same rectangle revolved about the x-axis, drawn as a thin disk whose radius is the rectangle's height.

The rectangle's height becomes the disk's radius and its width becomes the disk's thickness.

Spin one Riemann rectangle about the x-axis and it sweeps out a thin disk. The whole solid is a stack of such disks, so its volume is the sum of their volumes.

This picture is the bridge between Section 6.1 and this one, so spend a moment on it. On the left is exactly the object you used to approximate an area: a thin rectangle standing on the x-axis with its top on the curve.

Spin it about the axis and it sweeps out a coin: a disk whose radius is the rectangle's height and whose thickness is the rectangle's width. Its volume is pi times height squared times width.

So the sum of rectangle areas that gave you the area of the region becomes a sum of disk volumes that gives the volume of the solid. The step from one to the other is exactly the step from height to pi times height squared, which is why every disk formula has a square in it.

22. The disk method

Concept

For a solid of revolution the cross-section is always a disk, so the area function is known in advance: pi times the radius squared, and the radius is the height of the curve.

disk method — If f is continuous and nonnegative on the interval from a to b, the region under f revolved about the x-axis has volume equal to the integral of pi times f squared.

\[ V = \int_a^b \pi\left[f(x)\right]^2dx \]

This is the slicing formula with the area already filled in.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, pp. 558-559 — Rule: The Disk Method, equation 6.3

Read this as a shortcut rather than a new theorem. It is the slicing formula from Part 1 with the area of the cut written in ahead of time, because for a solid of revolution you always know the shape of the cut.

The two conditions on f are there to keep the picture honest. Continuity means the solid has no sudden jumps in radius, and requiring f to be at least zero means the curve is above the axis, so its height really is the distance from the axis.

If a curve dips below the axis, all is not lost: the distance from the axis is then the absolute value of f, and since the formula squares it anyway the same integral works. That is worth knowing, because a sign slip cannot hurt you here, while a missing square always will.

23. Reading the disk formula

Notation

Annotate

On: \( V = \int_a^b \pi\left[f(x)\right]^2dx \)

  • The radius of the disk at x: the distance from the axis (the x-axis) up to the curve.
  • The radius squared. Forgetting to square is the most common slip in this section.
  • The area of the disk, A(x). Everything in front of dx is one slice's area.
  • Slices are perpendicular to the x-axis, so they are stacked along x and have thickness dx.

Read the annotations in order and pay particular attention to the second one. Every single term of a volume integral must be an area, and the square is what makes it one. Losing that square is the most frequent error in this section, and it produces an answer with the wrong units that is usually far too small.

The third annotation is a habit worth adopting: think of the whole expression in front of the differential as one object, the area of a slice, rather than as a formula with a pi bolted on. Then when the cut becomes a ring, you simply write a different area in the same place.

The last annotation is a preview of Part 3. The differential and the limits belong to the axis, not to the curve, so as soon as the axis turns vertical, every one of them changes.

24. The book's first disk: a parabola from minus 1 to 3

Worked example

Revolve the region under the parabola below about the x-axis for x from minus 1 to 3.

\[ f(x) = (x-1)^2 + 1, \qquad -1 \le x \le 3 \]

Set up the disk integral

Why: The radius is f.

\[ V = \pi\int_{-1}^{3}\left[(x-1)^2+1\right]^2dx \]

Expand, keeping x minus 1 as a block

Why: That keeps the antiderivative simple.

\[ \left[(x-1)^2+1\right]^2 = (x-1)^4 + 2(x-1)^2 + 1 \]

Integrate

Why: Each power of x minus 1 integrates like a power of x.

\[ V = \pi\left[\frac{(x-1)^5}{5} + \frac{2(x-1)^3}{3} + x\right]_{-1}^{3} \]

Evaluate at 3

Why: Here x minus 1 is 2.

\[ \frac{32}{5}+\frac{16}{3}+3 = \frac{221}{15} \]

Evaluate at minus 1

Why: Here x minus 1 is minus 2.

\[ -\frac{32}{5}-\frac{16}{3}-1 = -\frac{191}{15} \]

Subtract

Why: The lower value is negative, so the two contributions add.

\[ V = \pi\left(\frac{221}{15}+\frac{191}{15}\right) = \frac{412\pi}{15} \approx 86.3 \]

Figure (svg): The solid made by revolving the region under y = (x − 1) squared plus 1 from x = −1 to 3 about the x-axis: a spool shape, radius 5 at both ends and 1 in the middle, with a highlighted slice at x = 2.

The spool is symmetric about x = 1, where the parabola has its vertex. That symmetry gives a free check on the answer.

Check with the symmetry

Why: The solid is symmetric about x = 1, so double the half from 1 to 3, writing u for x minus 1.

\[ 2\pi\int_0^2\left(u^4+2u^2+1\right)du = 2\pi\left(\frac{32}{5}+\frac{16}{3}+2\right) = 2\pi\cdot\frac{206}{15} = \frac{412\pi}{15} \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, pp. 557-559 — Figure 6.18 and the computation after equation 6.3

The tempting move here is to expand the whole thing into a fourth-degree polynomial in x. Resist it. Because the function is written in terms of x minus one, you can keep that block intact all the way through, and each power of it integrates just like a power of x.

Evaluating at the two ends is then quick, since x minus one is two at the top and minus two at the bottom. Notice how the odd powers change sign and the even ones do not, which is what makes the two contributions add rather than cancel.

The check exploits the symmetry of the picture. The parabola has its vertex at x equal to one, and the interval runs from one unit to the left of that to two units to the right, which is not symmetric. Look again: it runs from minus one to three, that is two units on each side of one, so the solid really is symmetric and you can integrate half of it and double. Getting the same four hundred and twelve pi over fifteen from a different calculation is strong evidence the answer is right.

25. Example 6.8: revolving the square root

Worked example

Revolve the region under the square root curve for x from 1 to 4 about the x-axis.

\[ f(x) = \sqrt x, \qquad 1 \le x \le 4 \]

Set up the disk integral

Why: The radius is the square root of x.

\[ V = \int_1^4 \pi\left[\sqrt x\right]^2dx \]

Square the radius

Why: Squaring undoes the root, which is why these problems are often easy.

\[ = \pi\int_1^4 x\,dx \]

Integrate

Why: The antiderivative of x is one half of x squared.

\[ = \frac{\pi}{2}x^2\Big|_1^4 \]

Evaluate

Why: Put in the upper limit and then the lower one.

\[ = \frac{\pi}{2}(16-1) \]

Simplify

Why: Fifteen halves of pi, a little under 24.

\[ = \frac{15\pi}{2} \approx 23.6 \]

Figure (svg): The curve y = root x from 0 to 4.6, the region under it from x = 1 to 4 shaded, its mirror image dashed, and elliptical faces at x = 1, 2.5 and 4: a solid like the end of a bullet with the tip cut off.

The radius grows from 1 to 2, so the end faces have areas pi and 4 pi.

Check with the end areas

Why: Here A(x) is pi times x, a straight line, so the average of the two end areas times the length is exact.

\[ \frac{A(1)+A(4)}{2}\cdot 3 = \frac{\pi + 4\pi}{2}\cdot 3 = \frac{15\pi}{2} \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, p. 559 — Example 6.8

This is the example to remember when you are tempted to think revolution problems are harder than area problems. Squaring the radius cancels the square root completely and leaves a linear integrand, which is easier than the area problem for the same region.

That is a general phenomenon and it is worth exploiting. Square roots, cube roots and other awkward powers often simplify once they are squared, so it can pay to write the area of the slice before deciding that a problem is nasty.

The check is one you can use whenever the area function turns out to be linear. If the area of the slice grows in a straight line, the average of the two end areas times the length gives the volume exactly, in the same way that a trapezoid's area is the average of its parallel sides times its width.

26. Find the error: a radius that was never squared

Error analysis

Annotate

On: \( V = \pi\int_1^4 \sqrt{x}\,dx = \pi\left[\tfrac23 x^{3/2}\right]_1^4 = \frac{14\pi}{3} \)

  • The radius is right: the distance from the x-axis to the curve y = √x.
  • But a disk's area is π times the radius SQUARED. π√x is not an area, so the integral is not a volume.
  • The solid contains a cylinder of radius 1 and length 3 (volume 3π ≈ 9.4) and sits inside one of radius 2 (volume 12π ≈ 37.7). The faulty 14π/3 ≈ 14.7 hugs the lower bound, although the radius reaches 2.
  • Square first: π∫(√x)² dx = π∫x dx = 15π/2 ≈ 23.6, as in Example 6.8.

Look at the line before you open the annotations and try to name the error yourself. Everything about the setup is right: the correct region, the correct limits, and the radius really is the square root of x.

The mistake is that the radius was never squared, so the integrand is not the area of anything. This is the single most common slip in the section, and it is dangerous precisely because the rest of the work looks so tidy.

Two defences. First, check units: an integrand must be an area for the answer to be a volume. Second, ask whether the number is plausible. The solid here contains a cylinder of radius one and length three, of volume about nine and a half, and it is contained in a cylinder of radius two and the same length, about thirty eight. The correct answer, just under twenty four, sits between them; the faulty answer of about fifteen is suspiciously close to the lower bound for a solid whose radius reaches two.

27. Checkpoint 6.7: slicing under one over x

Worked example

Revolve the region under y = 1/x for x from 1 to 2 about the x-axis.

Set up the disk integral

Why: The radius is one over x.

\[ V = \pi\int_1^2 \left(\frac1x\right)^2dx \]

Write the square as a power

Why: One over x squared is x to the minus two.

\[ = \pi\int_1^2 x^{-2}\,dx \]

Integrate

Why: The antiderivative of x to the minus 2 is minus one over x.

\[ = \pi\left[-\frac1x\right]_1^2 \]

Evaluate

Why: Put in 2 and then 1, in that order.

\[ = \pi\left(-\frac12 + 1\right) \]

Simplify

Why: A positive number, as every volume must be.

\[ = \frac{\pi}{2} \approx 1.571 \]

Figure (svg): The hyperbola y = 1/x with the region under it from x = 1 to 2 shaded and revolved about the x-axis: a short solid that narrows from radius 1 to radius one half, with a slice at x = 1.5.

A short, trumpet-mouth solid: every radius lies between one half and one.

Check with two cylinders

Why: The radius lies between one half and 1 over a length of 1, so the solid sits between a cylinder of radius one half and one of radius 1.

\[ \pi\left(\tfrac12\right)^2(1) = 0.785 \;<\; 1.571 \;<\; 3.142 = \pi(1)^2(1) \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, p. 557 — Checkpoint 6.7

Try this before reading it. The one thing to be careful about is squaring the radius: one over x squared, not one over x, and that is a power you integrate to minus one over x.

The negative sign is where slips happen. Evaluate the bracket at two and then at one, subtract in that order, and you get one half. If you get minus one half you have subtracted the wrong way round; a volume is never negative, so that is an easy error to catch.

The check bounds the solid between two cylinders. The radius drops from one down to one half over a length of one, so the volume must sit between the cylinder of radius one half, about zero point eight, and the cylinder of radius one, about three point one. One point five seven sits neatly between them, and this kind of bracketing works on almost every problem in this lesson.

28. Checkpoint 6.8: a paraboloid from the square root of 4 minus x

Worked example

Revolve the region under the curve below, for x from 0 to 4, about the x-axis.

\[ f(x) = \sqrt{4-x}, \qquad 0 \le x \le 4 \]

Set up and square the radius

Why: Squaring the radius undoes the square root and leaves a linear integrand.

\[ V = \pi\int_0^4 (4-x)\,dx \]

Integrate

Why: Term by term with the power rule.

\[ = \pi\left[4x - \frac{x^2}{2}\right]_0^4 \]

Evaluate

Why: Put in the limits 4 and 0.

\[ = \pi(16 - 8) \]

Simplify

Why: Eight pi, about 25 cubic units.

\[ = 8\pi \approx 25.1 \]

Figure (svg): The curve y = root of 4 minus x from 0 to 4, revolved about the x-axis into a paraboloid with its round face of radius 2 at x = 0 and its tip at x = 4, drawn inside a dashed cylinder of radius 2 and length 4.

The paraboloid fills exactly half of the cylinder around it, a fact Archimedes knew. The integral will confirm it.

Check with the cylinder

Why: A(x) is linear again, falling from 4 pi to 0, so the average end area times the length is exact; the result is half of the cylinder of radius 2 and length 4.

\[ \frac{4\pi + 0}{2}\cdot 4 = 8\pi = \tfrac12\left(\pi\cdot 2^2\cdot 4\right) \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, p. 559 — Checkpoint 6.8

Once again squaring the radius destroys the square root and leaves something linear. The whole problem takes three lines, and all of the interest is in the answer.

Look at the dashed cylinder in the picture. It has radius two and length four, so its volume is sixteen pi, and the solid inside it comes out at eight pi, exactly half. That is not an accident of these numbers: whenever the radius squared falls linearly to zero, the solid fills precisely half of the cylinder around it.

Archimedes proved that fact about the paraboloid long before calculus, and it is a good thing to carry around. If a problem's radius squared is linear in the position, you can predict the answer before you integrate and use the integral as a check.

29. Estimate first: a cone from x + y = 8

Estimation

\[ \text{Revolve the triangle under } y = 8 - x, \; 0 \le x \le 8, \text{ about the } x\text{-axis.} \]

Predict first

Before integrating, roughly what is the volume?

  • About 180
  • About 540
  • About 1600
  • About 3200

Correct: About 540

Why: The solid is a cone of radius 8 and height 8, so one third of pi times 64 times 8, which is 512 pi over 3, about 536. The cylinder around it would be about 1608: a cone is exactly a third of its cylinder.

\[ V = \pi\int_0^8 (8-x)^2dx = \pi\left[-\frac{(8-x)^3}{3}\right]_0^8 = \frac{512\pi}{3} \approx 536 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, p. 566 — Exercise 74

Commit to one of the four options before you compute anything. The point of estimating first is to build the habit of knowing roughly what a volume should be, so that an answer off by a factor of pi or a factor of three cannot slip past you.

The reasoning is short. The line falls from eight to zero across an interval of length eight, so the solid is a cone of radius eight and height eight. A cone is one third of the cylinder that contains it, and that cylinder has volume pi times sixty four times eight, about sixteen hundred. So expect something near five hundred and forty.

When you do the integral, notice the shortcut in the antiderivative: because the integrand is a function of eight minus x, you can integrate it directly, with a minus sign from the chain rule, rather than expanding the square.

30. The axis decides the variable

Section

Part 3

31. Revolving about the y-axis: horizontal disks

Concept

Revolve a region about the y-axis and the slices perpendicular to the axis are horizontal. Each is a disk stacked along y, with thickness dy, and its radius is the distance from the y-axis to the curve: an x-value written as a function of y.

\[ V = \int_c^d \pi\left[g(y)\right]^2dy \]

The rule is the disk method with the roles of x and y exchanged. The region is bounded on the right by x = g(y), on the left by the y-axis, and by the horizontal lines y = c and y = d.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, p. 560 — Rule: The Disk Method for Solids of Revolution around the y-axis, equation 6.4

Nothing conceptual changes here, but every symbol does, so read the formula slowly. The slices are horizontal, stacked up the y-axis, so they have thickness dy and the limits are heights, not x-values.

The radius is the distance from the y-axis out to the curve, which is an x-value. So the boundary of the region has to be described as x in terms of y, and that usually means solving the equation of the curve for x.

This is the step most people skip. If a problem gives you y as a function of x and the axis is vertical, your first move is to invert it. If you cannot, the disk method is not going to work, and there is a slide later in this part on exactly that situation.

32. Example 6.9: horizontal disks under the square root of 4 minus y

Worked example

Revolve the region between the curve below and the y-axis, for y from 0 to 4, about the y-axis.

\[ g(y) = \sqrt{4-y}, \qquad 0 \le y \le 4 \]

Slice perpendicular to the axis

Why: The axis is vertical, so the slices are horizontal disks of thickness dy and radius g(y).

\[ V = \int_0^4 \pi\left[\sqrt{4-y}\right]^2dy \]

Square the radius

Why: Squaring undoes the square root.

\[ = \pi\int_0^4 (4-y)\,dy \]

Integrate

Why: Term by term in y.

\[ = \pi\left[4y - \frac{y^2}{2}\right]_0^4 \]

Evaluate

Why: Put in the limits 4 and 0.

\[ = \pi(16 - 8) \]

Simplify

Why: The same number as Checkpoint 6.8, which is no accident.

\[ = 8\pi \]

Figure (svg): The curve x = root of 4 minus y for y from 0 to 4, with the region between it and the y-axis shaded and revolved about the y-axis: a dome of radius 2 and height 4, with horizontal elliptical slices at y = 0, 1.5 and 4.

Revolving about the y-axis makes horizontal slices. Each one is a disk whose radius is the curve's distance from the y-axis at that height.

Check against Checkpoint 6.8

Why: Swap the names of x and y and this is the paraboloid of Checkpoint 6.8 stood on its end: radius squared is 4 minus the position in both. Same solid, same volume.

\[ \pi\int_0^4 (4-y)\,dy = \pi\int_0^4 (4-x)\,dx = 8\pi \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, pp. 560-561 — Example 6.9

Notice that the book hands you the curve already solved for x, as a function of y. That is the form you need when the axis is vertical, and part of the skill in this section is recognising which form a problem is in before you start.

The integral itself is the same three lines as Checkpoint 6.8, with y in place of x, and that is the point of the check. The two solids are the same dome, one lying on its side and the other standing up, so they must have the same volume, and they do.

Look at the picture and identify the slice at height one and a half: a horizontal disk, drawn as an ellipse because you are seeing it edge on. The radius of that disk is measured sideways from the y-axis to the curve, which is the geometric meaning of the number you are squaring.

33. Checkpoint 6.9: a cone stood on its point

Worked example

Revolve the region between x = y and the y-axis, for y from 1 to 4, about the y-axis.

Set up horizontal disks

Why: The radius at height y is g(y) = y.

\[ V = \pi\int_1^4 y^2\,dy \]

Integrate

Why: The antiderivative of y squared is y cubed over 3.

\[ = \pi\left[\frac{y^3}{3}\right]_1^4 \]

Evaluate

Why: Put in 4 and then 1.

\[ = \pi\left(\frac{64}{3} - \frac13\right) \]

Simplify

Why: Sixty three thirds is twenty one.

\[ = 21\pi \approx 66.0 \]

Figure (svg): The line x = y for y from 1 to 4 and the region between it and the y-axis, revolved about the y-axis: an upside-down cone with its tip cut off, radius 1 at the bottom and 4 at the top, with a slice at y = 2.5.

A cone standing on its point with the bottom trimmed off at height 1.

Check as a cone minus a cone

Why: The solid is the cone of radius 4 and height 4 with the cone of radius 1 and height 1 removed from its tip.

\[ \tfrac13\pi(4^2)(4) - \tfrac13\pi(1^2)(1) = \frac{64\pi - \pi}{3} = 21\pi \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, p. 561 — Checkpoint 6.9

This one is quick, so do it yourself first. At height y the region runs from the y-axis out to the line, so the radius is simply y, and squaring it gives y squared.

The limits are heights, one and four, not x-values. If you catch yourself integrating from zero you have drawn the wrong region: the region starts at height one, which is why the solid has a flat bottom rather than a point.

The check treats the solid as a big cone with a small cone removed from its tip, which is what a frustum is. The big cone has radius four and height four, the missing tip radius one and height one, and the difference is twenty one pi. Building a solid out of pieces whose volumes you know from geometry is often the fastest check available.

34. Before integrating: which variable?

Step zero

\[ \text{Revolve the region bounded by } y = 3x^2, \; x = 0, \; y = 3 \text{ about the } y\text{-axis.} \]

Discussion prompt

Before you write an integral: which variable do you integrate in, what is the radius of a slice as a function of that variable, and what are the limits?

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, p. 566 — Exercise 84

Write your three answers down before revealing, and be strict with yourself about the second one. Most wrong solutions in this part of the lesson are wrong because a radius was written in the wrong variable, and that decision is made in the first thirty seconds.

Here the axis is vertical, so slices are horizontal and the variable is y. That immediately tells you the curve must be rearranged: three x squared equals y gives x as the square root of y over three.

Then the limits. They are heights, from zero up to three, and nothing in the problem about x equal to zero changes that; the line x equal to zero is just telling you which side of the curve the region lies on.

Finally the integral is easy, because squaring the radius undoes the square root again and leaves y over three.

35. The axis decides the variable

Concept

In Section 6.1 you could choose to slice an area vertically or horizontally, whichever was easier. Here there is no choice: only slices perpendicular to the axis of revolution are disks.

\[ \text{axis horizontal} \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{vertical slices, } dx \]

\[ \text{axis vertical} \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{horizontal slices, } dy \]

So the axis tells you the variable, and every radius must then be written in that variable, even if the curve was given the other way round.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, p. 552 — the choice of slicing direction

This is the sentence to take away from Part 3. In Section 6.1 the choice of strips was yours, and you picked whichever made the algebra pleasanter. Here the choice is made for you by the axis, because only a slice perpendicular to the axis is a disk at all. A slice taken the other way is a curved shell, which is the subject of the next section.

So the routine begins with a look at the axis, not at the curves. Horizontal axis: vertical slices, thickness dx, everything written in x. Vertical axis: horizontal slices, thickness dy, everything written in y.

That loss of freedom has a cost, and the next slide shows it. Sometimes the variable you are forced into is one in which the boundary simply cannot be written down, and then this method fails and you need a different one.

36. Complete the slicing table

Comparison

Comparison matrix

axis of revolutionslices areintegrate inradius to the curve
the x-axisverticaldxf(x)
the y-axishorizontaldyg(y)
the line y = −2verticaldxf(x) + 2
the line x = 4horizontaldy4 − g(y)

Fill in every blank before checking. The two columns you are completing follow from one another: once you know whether the slices are horizontal or vertical, the differential is decided, and vice versa.

The last two rows are the ones to study, because they are where Part 5 is going. For the horizontal line, the radius is measured from that line up to the curve, so it is the curve's height plus two. For the vertical line at four, the radius is measured leftwards from the line to the curve, so it is four minus the curve's x-value.

Notice that in both of those rows the radius is a difference: the coordinate of the boundary and the coordinate of the axis, larger minus smaller. That single rule covers every axis in the section, including the coordinate axes, where the axis coordinate is zero and the difference is just the function value.

37. When the forced variable is impossible

Concept

Figure (svg): The curve y = x cubed plus x for x from −1 to 1.5, with the region between it, the y-axis and the line y = 2 shaded. A horizontal segment at height 1.5 runs from the y-axis to the curve and is labelled x = ?.

A horizontal slice needs the radius as a function of y: the x that solves x cubed plus x equals y. That x exists, but no tidy formula gives it.

Revolve the region between y = x cubed plus x, the y-axis and the line y = 2 about the y-axis. The slices must be horizontal, so each radius is the x that sits on the curve at height y.

\[ x^3 + x = y \;\Longrightarrow\; x = \; ? \]

A cubic formula exists, but squaring and integrating its answer is hopeless. The disk method stalls here. Section 6.3 fixes it by slicing parallel to the axis instead, with cylindrical shells.

This slide is here to show you the limit of the method while you still trust it, rather than to teach a technique. The axis is vertical, so you have no choice: the radius must be the x-value on the curve at height y.

For this curve that means solving a cubic equation for x in terms of y. There is a formula, discovered in the sixteenth century, but it produces nested cube roots, and squaring that and integrating it is not something anyone would attempt.

Notice that the difficulty has nothing to do with the solid being complicated. The solid is perfectly ordinary; it is the algebra of the inverse that fails. Section 6.3 gets around it by slicing parallel to the axis instead, which gives thin cylindrical shells and lets you keep x as the variable. Keep this example in mind, because recognising when the disk method cannot work is the main reason for learning shells.

38. Trap: squaring the wrong variable

Trap

The trap

Revolve the region bounded by y = x squared, y = 4 and the y-axis about the y-axis:

\[ V = \pi\int_0^2 \left(x^2\right)^2dx \]

\[ = \frac{32\pi}{5} \]

Wrong. Those are vertical slices, not disks about the y-axis.

The fix

The axis is vertical, so slice horizontally. The radius is the x on the curve at height y, which is the square root of y, and y runs from 0 to 4.

\[ V = \pi\int_0^4 \left(\sqrt{y}\right)^2dy \]

\[ = \pi\int_0^4 y\,dy = 8\pi \]

This is the error the whole of Part 3 is written to prevent, and it is seductive because the integral on the left is a perfectly good volume: it is the volume you get by revolving that region about the x-axis instead. Nothing in the computation looks wrong; the wrong question has been answered.

The tell is the mismatch between the differential and the axis. If the axis is vertical, and your integral ends in dx, something is wrong before you compute anything.

The correction is mechanical once the direction is right: solve the curve for x, so the radius at height y is the square root of y, square it, and integrate from zero to four. Whenever you finish a revolution problem, take one second to check that the differential matches the axis.

39. The washer method

Section

Part 4

40. What does a slice look like now?

Prediction

\[ \text{Region between } y=\sqrt x \text{ and } y = 1, \; 1 \le x \le 4, \text{ revolved about the } x\text{-axis} \]

Predict first

A cut perpendicular to the x-axis through this solid is…

  • A solid disk of radius √x
  • A washer: a disk with a hole
  • A cylindrical shell
  • A square of side √x − 1

Correct: A washer: a disk with a hole

Why: The region stops at the line y = 1 and never reaches the axis. The strip of empty space between the axis and y = 1 sweeps out a hole of radius 1, so each cut is a ring with outer radius √x and inner radius 1.

Commit to an option before reading on. Look at the picture in your head rather than at any formula: the region floats above the axis, separated from it by the strip between the axis and the line at height one.

When you spin the region, that empty strip spins too, and it sweeps out a cylindrical tunnel through the middle of the solid. The cut is therefore a ring, or washer, not a full disk.

This is the test you should apply from now on in every revolution problem, before you write anything: does the region touch the axis. Touching means disks, not touching means washers, and the question takes only as long as it takes to look at your sketch.

41. A washer is a disk with a hole

Concept

Figure (svg): The region between y = root x and y = 1 from x = 1 to 4, revolved about the x-axis. Its mirror image is dashed, and a highlighted slice at x = 3 is a ring: an outer ellipse of radius root 3 with a dark hole of radius 1 in the middle.

The region does not reach the axis, so every slice has a hole: the gap between the axis and the lower curve sweeps out an empty tube.

The cut is the outer disk with the inner disk removed, so its area is a difference of two disk areas.

\[ A = \pi R^2 - \pi r^2 = \pi\left(R^2 - r^2\right) \]

R is the distance from the axis to the far boundary, r the distance to the near boundary.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, pp. 561-562 — Figure 6.22

The formula on this slide is just subtraction of areas, but say the words to yourself as you read it: the area of the big disk minus the area of the hole. The next few slides exist mainly to stop that subtraction happening in the wrong place.

Naming the radii carefully is what keeps you out of trouble. The outer radius reaches from the axis to whichever boundary is farther away, and the inner radius reaches from the axis to the nearer one. On the picture, the outer boundary is the curve and the inner one is the horizontal line.

Notice that both radii are measured from the same place, the axis. That is why moving the axis, as you will in Part 5, changes both of them at once and by the same amount.

42. The book's first washer: between the square root and 1

Worked example

Revolve the region between the square root curve above and the horizontal line at height one below, for x from 1 to 4, about the x-axis.

\[ f(x) = \sqrt x, \quad g(x) = 1, \qquad 1 \le x \le 4 \]

Write the washer's area

Why: Outer radius root x, inner radius 1.

\[ A(x) = \pi\left(\sqrt x\right)^2 - \pi(1)^2 \]

Simplify

Why: Squaring the root gives x, and squaring one gives one.

\[ A(x) = \pi(x-1) \]

Integrate the area

Why: Integrate the area of a slice along the axis.

\[ V = \pi\int_1^4 (x-1)\,dx \]

Find an antiderivative

Why: Power rule on each term.

\[ = \pi\left[\frac{x^2}{2} - x\right]_1^4 \]

Evaluate

Why: Put in 4 and then 1.

\[ = \pi\left[(8-4) - \left(\tfrac12 - 1\right)\right] \]

Simplify

Why: Nine halves of pi, about 14 cubic units.

\[ = \frac{9\pi}{2} \approx 14.1 \]

Check as a solid minus its hole

Why: The full solid under the square root is Example 6.8's 15 pi over 2; the hole is a cylinder of radius 1 and length 3.

\[ \frac{15\pi}{2} - \pi(1)^2(3) = \frac{15\pi - 6\pi}{2} = \frac{9\pi}{2} \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, p. 562 — the computation after Figure 6.22

Work down the left-hand column and notice how ordinary the calculation is once the area of the slice has been written correctly. Squaring the square root gives x, squaring one gives one, and the difference is a linear integrand.

The place to be careful is the very first line. Two separate squarings happen there, and they happen before any subtraction. Write the two pi terms separately, as the book does, if that helps you resist combining them too early.

The check is one you can do on any washer problem. The solid is the full solid of revolution, computed in Example 6.8 as fifteen pi over two, with a cylindrical hole of radius one and length three drilled out, which removes three pi. That view also explains why the formula is a difference: you are removing a solid, not shortening a radius.

43. The washer method

Concept

washer method — If f and g are continuous with f at least g at least 0 on the interval from a to b, the region between them revolved about the x-axis has volume equal to the integral of pi times the difference of their squares.

\[ V = \int_a^b \pi\left[\left(f(x)\right)^2 - \left(g(x)\right)^2\right]dx \]

Square each radius, then subtract. The disk method is the special case where the inner radius is zero.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, pp. 562-563 — Rule: The Washer Method, equation 6.5

This is the last of the three rules, and it contains the other two. Set the inner radius to zero and you have the disk method; write the area of the slice as a general area function and you have the slicing formula.

The condition that one function stays above the other on the whole interval matters more than it looks. If the curves cross inside the interval, the roles of outer and inner swap at the crossing, and you must split the integral there or you will be subtracting the wrong way round on part of the region.

Notice also that both functions must be at least zero for this form to be correct as written, because otherwise a curve below the axis is not at the distance its value suggests. When a region straddles the axis of revolution, the sensible move is to work with distances explicitly, as Part 5 does.

44. Reading the washer formula

Notation

Annotate

On: \( V = \int_a^b \pi\left[\left(f(x)\right)^2 - \left(g(x)\right)^2\right]dx \)

  • The OUTER radius R: distance from the axis to the boundary farther away.
  • The INNER radius r: distance from the axis to the nearer boundary. The hole.
  • Two disk areas, subtracted. Never subtract the radii first.
  • Which curve is outer can change where curves cross; check a test point in each piece.

The third annotation is the one worth learning by heart, because there is a whole trap slide about it in a moment: square each radius first, and only then subtract. The area of a ring is a difference of two areas, never the area of some single shape whose size is the gap.

The first two annotations are about naming. Decide which curve is outer by testing a point, not by which one was mentioned first in the problem. On a sketch this is obvious; without one it is a coin toss.

The last annotation is a warning for later problems. Curves often cross, and when they do the outer and inner roles swap. Test a point in each piece of the interval and integrate the pieces separately.

45. Example 6.10: a line over a hyperbola

Worked example

Revolve the region between f(x) = x above and g(x) = 1/x below, for x from 1 to 4, about the x-axis.

Decide which curve is outer

Why: At a test point such as x = 2 the line is at 2 and the hyperbola at one half, and they only meet at x = 1.

\[ x \ge \frac1x \quad \text{for } 1 \le x \le 4 \]

Set up washers

Why: Outer radius x, inner radius one over x.

\[ V = \pi\int_1^4\left[x^2 - \left(\frac1x\right)^2\right]dx \]

Write the square as a power

Why: One over x squared is x to the minus two.

\[ = \pi\int_1^4\left(x^2 - x^{-2}\right)dx \]

Integrate

Why: Minus x to the minus 2 integrates to plus one over x.

\[ = \pi\left[\frac{x^3}{3} + \frac1x\right]_1^4 \]

Evaluate

Why: Put in 4 and then 1.

\[ = \pi\left[\left(\frac{64}{3}+\frac14\right) - \left(\frac13+1\right)\right] \]

Collect the thirds and the rest

Why: Sixty four thirds minus one third is exactly twenty one.

\[ = \pi\left(21 - \frac34\right) \]

Simplify

Why: Eighty one quarters of pi, about 64 cubic units.

\[ = \frac{81\pi}{4} \approx 63.6 \]

Figure (svg): The line y = x and the hyperbola y = 1/x from x = 1 to 4, with the region between them shaded and revolved about the x-axis: a cone-like shell with a narrow trumpet-shaped hole, and a highlighted ring at x = 2.5.

Outer radius x, inner radius one over x. The hole narrows as the outer wall widens.

Check by differentiating the antiderivative

Why: It must return the washer area over pi.

\[ \frac{d}{dx}\left[\frac{x^3}{3} + \frac1x\right] = x^2 - \frac{1}{x^2} \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, p. 563 — Example 6.10

Notice that the solution starts by deciding which curve is outer, before any integral is written. At x equal to two the line is at two and the hyperbola at one half, so the line is the outer boundary, and since the two only meet at x equal to one, that stays true across the whole interval.

The integration has a small trap in it. The inner radius squared is x to the minus two, and its antiderivative is minus one over x, so subtracting it adds one over x. A sign slip there is the most common way to get this problem wrong.

When you evaluate, group the thirds together: sixty four thirds minus one third is exactly twenty one, which leaves only the quarter and the one to deal with. Getting used to collecting like fractions before reaching for a calculator keeps the arithmetic exact.

The check differentiates the antiderivative and recovers the integrand, which catches exactly the sign slip mentioned above.

46. Checkpoint 6.10: the square root over a hyperbola

Worked example

Revolve the region between the square root curve and the hyperbola, for x from 1 to 3, about the x-axis.

\[ f(x) = \sqrt x, \quad g(x) = \frac1x, \qquad 1 \le x \le 3 \]

Decide which curve is outer

Why: Root x is at least 1 and one over x at most 1 when x is at least 1.

\[ \sqrt x \ge 1 \ge \frac1x \quad \text{for } x \ge 1 \]

Square each radius

Why: Do the squaring before any subtracting.

\[ R^2 = \left(\sqrt x\right)^2 = x, \qquad r^2 = \left(\frac1x\right)^2 = \frac{1}{x^2} \]

Set up washers

Why: Subtract the two squared radii inside the integral.

\[ V = \pi\int_1^3\left[x - \frac{1}{x^2}\right]dx \]

Integrate

Why: Power rule on each piece; the second integrates to plus one over x.

\[ = \pi\left[\frac{x^2}{2} + \frac1x\right]_1^3 \]

Evaluate

Why: Put in 3 and then 1.

\[ = \pi\left[\left(\frac92+\frac13\right) - \left(\frac12+1\right)\right] \]

Collect over sixths

Why: Put both brackets over a common denominator of six.

\[ = \pi\left(\frac{29}{6} - \frac96\right) \]

Simplify

Why: Twenty sixths reduces to ten thirds.

\[ = \frac{10\pi}{3} \approx 10.5 \]

Check by differentiating the antiderivative

Why: The derivative must return the washer's area divided by pi.

\[ \frac{d}{dx}\left[\frac{x^2}{2} + \frac1x\right] = x - \frac{1}{x^2} \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, p. 563 — Checkpoint 6.10

This is the previous example with a gentler outer curve, so try it before reading. The one thing to establish first is which curve is outer, and the argument is neat: for x at least one, the square root is at least one and one over x is at most one, so they cannot cross after x equal to one.

Squaring both radii turns the integrand into x minus one over x squared, which is the same pair of pieces as before. Again, watch the sign when you integrate the second piece.

The arithmetic is smoothest over sixths: nine halves plus one third is twenty nine sixths, and one half plus one is nine sixths. The difference is twenty sixths, which reduces to ten thirds.

47. Break the shortcut: subtract the radii first?

Counterexample

Discussion prompt

Someone writes the area of a washer as pi times (R − r)². Find a washer where this is plainly wrong, and say what shape pi times (R − r)² actually measures.

Answer this before revealing, and answer it with numbers rather than with words, because a counterexample settles the question in a way that an argument does not.

With an outer radius of three and an inner radius of two, the ring's area is five pi, while the shortcut gives pi. The shortcut is not a little bit wrong; it is wrong by a factor of five, and the error grows as the ring gets thinner relative to its radius.

The picture in the revealed answer shows what the shortcut actually computes: a small disk whose radius is the width of the ring. The algebra says the same thing. Expanding the square of the difference produces a cross term, and there is no cross term in a difference of squares. A thin ring around a large circle has much more area than a small blob of the same width, which is exactly why the two expressions disagree so badly.

48. Trap: squaring the difference of the radii

Trap

The trap

Region between y = x and y = x squared, about the x-axis:

\[ V = \pi\int_0^1 \left(x - x^2\right)^2dx \]

\[ = \frac{\pi}{30} \]

Wrong: a quarter of the true volume.

The fix

Square each radius, then subtract.

\[ V = \pi\int_0^1 \left(x^2 - x^4\right)dx \]

\[ = \pi\left(\tfrac13 - \tfrac15\right) = \frac{2\pi}{15} \]

The wrong integrand keeps a cross term the true one does not have.

\[ (x-x^2)^2 = x^2 - 2x^3 + x^4 \]

This is the counterexample from the previous slide dressed up as a real problem, and it is the most common error in the washer method. The wrong integral is not even close: it gives a quarter of the correct volume here.

The wrong version also fails a quick sanity test. The solid it describes would be the one you get by spinning the vertical gap between the curves around an axis through the gap itself, which is not the solid in the problem at all.

The correction is a discipline, not an insight: write the two squares first and subtract second, every time. If you catch yourself simplifying the difference of the curves before squaring, stop.

49. Washers about the y-axis

Concept

Revolve a region between two curves about the y-axis and the slices are horizontal rings. Both boundaries are written as x in terms of y: u(y) on the right, the outer radius, and v(y) on the left, the inner one.

\[ V = \int_c^d \pi\left[\left(u(y)\right)^2 - \left(v(y)\right)^2\right]dy \]

Nothing new, only the exchange of x and y that the axis forces.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, p. 563 — Rule: The Washer Method for Solids of Revolution around the y-axis

By now this should feel like a formality: it is the washer method with x and y exchanged, forced on you by a vertical axis, exactly as the disk method was in Part 3.

The naming can catch you out, though. The outer radius is the boundary farther from the y-axis, which is the one on the right, and the inner radius is the boundary nearer to it, which is the one on the left. Both must be written as x in terms of y.

As always, the limits are heights: the lowest and highest y in the region. A useful habit is to write the limits down immediately after deciding the direction of slicing, before you work out the radii, so that the whole setup is anchored in the right variable.

50. Exercise 98: washers stacked up the y-axis

Worked example

Revolve the region bounded by the square root curve, the vertical line at 4 and the x-axis about the y-axis.

\[ y = \sqrt x, \quad x = 4, \quad y = 0 \]

Slice horizontally

Why: The axis is vertical. At height y the region runs from the curve out to the line x = 4, and y runs from 0 to 2.

\[ 0 \le y \le 2 \]

Solve the curve for x

Why: The inner radius must be a function of y.

\[ y = \sqrt x \iff x = y^2 \]

Name the radii

Why: The line is farther from the axis than the curve.

\[ R = 4, \qquad r = y^2 \]

Set up washers

Why: Square both radii: sixteen for the line, y to the fourth for the curve.

\[ V = \pi\int_0^2\left(16 - y^4\right)dy \]

Integrate

Why: Power rule in y.

\[ = \pi\left[16y - \frac{y^5}{5}\right]_0^2 \]

Evaluate

Why: Put in 2; both terms vanish at 0.

\[ = \pi\left(32 - \frac{32}{5}\right) \]

Simplify

Why: About eighty, a little under the thirty two pi of the cylinder around it.

\[ = \frac{128\pi}{5} \approx 80.4 \]

Figure (svg): The region between the curve x = y squared (that is, y = root x), the line x = 4 and the x-axis, revolved about the y-axis: a cylinder of radius 4 and height 2 with a bowl-shaped hole, and a highlighted horizontal ring at y = 1.2.

Outer radius 4 at every height; inner radius y squared, the distance from the y-axis to the parabola.

Check with four washers

Why: A midpoint sum with four washers of thickness one half, at heights 0.25, 0.75, 1.25 and 1.75, should land close.

\[ \pi\sum_{i=1}^{4}\left(16 - y_i^4\right)(0.5) = \pi(25.93) \approx 81.5 \quad \text{vs } 80.4 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, p. 566 — Exercise 98

The region here is described with a curve, a vertical line and the x-axis, so sketch it before doing anything: it is the piece under the square root curve and to the left of x equal to four, and its heights run from zero to two.

At height y the slice runs from the parabola out to the line, so the outer radius is the constant four and the inner radius is y squared. Turning the curve from y equal to the square root of x into x equal to y squared is the key move, and it is forced by the vertical axis.

The check is a numerical one. Four washers of thickness one half, with radii taken at the midpoints of each band, give about eighty one and a half, against the exact eighty point four. The estimate is high by just over one per cent, which is what you expect from a coarse midpoint sum on a gently curving area function, and it is more than close enough to confirm the exact value.

51. Disk or washer?

Sorting

Sort into buckets

For each region and axis, will the slices be solid disks or washers?

Disks: the region touches the axis
under y = x² on [0, 2], about the x-axis; between x = y² and x = 4, about x = 4; under y = √x on [1, 4], about the x-axis
Washers: a gap between region and axis
between y = x and y = x², about the x-axis; under y = 4 − x on [0, 4], about y = −2; under y = √x on [0, 4], about the y-axis
disk
Each of these regions has an edge lying along the axis itself (the x-axis, or the line x = 4), so every slice reaches the axis and has no hole.
washer
Each of these leaves a gap: y = x² below y = x, the x-axis two units above y = −2, and, about the y-axis, the empty strip between the y-axis and the curve x = y².

Sort these by asking one question about each: does the region have an edge lying along the axis of revolution. If it does, every slice reaches the axis and there is no hole.

Two of these are worth a second look. The region under the line, revolved about the line two units below it, has a gap of two units everywhere, so it is a washer even though the region is a simple triangle. The region between the parabola and the vertical line, revolved about that same vertical line, touches the axis along its whole right-hand edge, so it is a disk even though it looks complicated.

The last one catches people. Revolving the region under the square root curve about the y-axis leaves the strip between the y-axis and the curve empty, so the solid is hollow along its axis. Always check the side of the region that faces the axis, not the side you happen to have drawn first.

52. Revolving about other lines

Section

Part 5

53. Every radius is a distance to the axis

Concept

A radius is not a height or an x-value. It is the distance from the axis to a boundary, and that is always the larger coordinate minus the smaller.

\[ \text{axis } y = c \text{ below the region: } \quad R = f(x) - c, \quad r = g(x) - c \]

\[ \text{axis } y = c \text{ above the region: } \quad R = c - g(x), \quad r = c - f(x) \]

For the x-axis c is zero and these reduce to f and g. The same holds for a vertical axis x = k, with the roles of x and y exchanged.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, p. 564 — the discussion before Example 6.11

This slide replaces three or four half-remembered rules with one. A radius is a distance, and a distance between two horizontal lines is the upper coordinate minus the lower one. Nothing else is needed.

Work through the two lines of algebra with a sketch. When the axis sits below the region, subtracting a negative number makes both radii larger, which matches the picture: moving the axis down moves everything farther from it. When the axis sits above the region, the subtraction goes the other way, because now the axis has the larger coordinate.

One consequence is worth pointing out. Moving the axis changes the outer and inner radii by the same amount, but it does not change their difference. Since the volume depends on the difference of their squares, not the difference of the radii, the volume does change, and usually grows.

54. Moving the axis opens a hole

Picture it

Figure (svg): Two panels of the same triangle under y = 4 − x from x = 0 to 4. Left: revolved about the x-axis it makes a solid cone with no hole. Right: revolved about the line y = −2 it makes a solid with a cylindrical hole of radius 2 through its middle.

Move the axis two units away from the region and the gap between them sweeps out a hole. Both radii grow by exactly that gap.

The same triangle, revolved about two different lines. About the x-axis it touches the axis and gives a solid cone. About the line two units below the x-axis, that two-unit gap becomes a tunnel, and every slice is a washer.

Compare the two panels carefully; they show the same flat triangle revolved about two different lines. On the left the axis passes along the bottom edge of the region, so the solid is a plain cone.

On the right the axis has moved down two units. The region has not changed, but the two-unit strip between the region and the axis now spins into a cylindrical tunnel, and the solid is a cone-shaped shell with a hole bored along its length.

This is why a problem that mentions a line such as y equal to minus two is not a harder version of the same problem, but a different one: the answer must account for the hole. Sketching the axis, and not just the region, is what makes this impossible to miss.

55. Example 6.11: revolving a triangle about y = -2

Worked example

Revolve the region under the slanted line and above the x-axis, for x from 0 to 4, about the horizontal line two units below the x-axis.

\[ f(x) = 4-x, \quad 0 \le x \le 4, \qquad \text{axis } y = -2 \]

Outer radius: axis to the line

Why: The line is the far boundary, above the axis.

\[ R(x) = (4-x) - (-2) \]

Simplify

Why: Subtracting a negative two adds two.

\[ R(x) = 6 - x \]

Inner radius: axis to the x-axis

Why: The x-axis is the near boundary.

\[ r(x) = 0 - (-2) = 2 \]

Set up washers

Why: Square each radius before subtracting.

\[ V = \pi\int_0^4\left[(6-x)^2 - 2^2\right]dx \]

Expand the integrand

Why: Expand the square and subtract the four.

\[ (6-x)^2 - 4 = x^2 - 12x + 32 \]

Integrate

Why: Power rule term by term.

\[ V = \pi\left[\frac{x^3}{3} - 6x^2 + 32x\right]_0^4 \]

Evaluate

Why: Put in 4; every term vanishes at 0.

\[ = \pi\left(\frac{64}{3} - 96 + 128\right) \]

Simplify

Why: Sixty four thirds plus thirty two is one hundred and sixty thirds.

\[ = \frac{160\pi}{3} \approx 167.6 \]

Check with geometry

Why: The outer surface is a frustum of a cone with radii 6 and 2 and length 4; the hole is a cylinder of radius 2 and length 4.

\[ \tfrac13\pi(4)\left(6^2 + 6\cdot2 + 2^2\right) - \pi(2^2)(4) = \frac{208\pi}{3} - \frac{48\pi}{3} = \frac{160\pi}{3} \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, p. 564 — Example 6.11

The book says it cannot apply the formula directly because the axis is not a coordinate axis, and that is the right instinct, but nothing new is actually needed: just measure both radii from the new axis.

The outer boundary is the slanted line, two units above the axis plus its own height, which gives six minus x. The inner boundary is the x-axis itself, a constant two units from the axis, so the hole has the same radius all the way along and is a genuine cylinder.

When you expand, notice that the constant four from the inner radius simply lowers the constant term from thirty six to thirty two. Many problems of this type differ from the plain ones only in such a constant.

The check builds the solid out of shapes you know from geometry: the outside is a frustum with radii six and two, and the hole is a cylinder of radius two. Subtracting gives the same one hundred and sixty pi over three, which is a genuinely independent confirmation.

56. Checkpoint 6.11: fill in the radii

Fill the middle

Revolve the region under the line and above the x-axis, for x from 0 to 3, about the horizontal line one unit below the x-axis. Fill in the outer and inner radii.

\[ f(x) = x+2, \quad 0 \le x \le 3, \qquad \text{axis } y = -1 \]

Fill in the blanks

V = \pi\int_0^3\left[\left(x+3\right)^2 - \left(1\right)^2\right]dx

Why: The outer radius is (x + 2) − (−1) = x + 3 and the inner radius is 0 − (−1) = 1. The integrand is (x + 3)² − 1 = x² + 6x + 8, and π times its integral from 0 to 3 is π(9 + 27 + 24) = 60π.

\[ V = \pi\int_0^3\left(x^2 + 6x + 8\right)dx = \pi(9 + 27 + 24) = 60\pi \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, p. 564 — Checkpoint 6.11

Fill in both blanks before checking. This is the same geometry as Example 6.11, with the axis one unit below the x-axis instead of two, so if you can do that example you can do this.

The outer radius is the line's height plus one, that is x plus three, and the inner radius is the constant one, the distance from the axis up to the x-axis. Writing minus a negative one explicitly, rather than just adding one from memory, is the habit that keeps you right when the axis is above the region instead of below.

Once the radii are in, expanding gives x squared plus six x plus eight, whose integral from zero to three is sixty. Notice again how the hole contributes only a shift in the constant term.

57. A parabola revolved about the line x = 4

Worked example

Revolve the region between x = y squared and x = 4 about the line x = 4.

Slice horizontally

Why: The axis is vertical. The curve meets the line where y squared is 4.

\[ y^2 = 4 \iff y = \pm 2 \]

Radius: axis to the curve

Why: The axis is to the right of the curve, so subtract the curve from 4. The region touches the axis, so there is no hole.

\[ r(y) = 4 - y^2 \]

Set up disks

Why: Pi times the radius squared, integrated in y.

\[ V = \pi\int_{-2}^{2}\left(4-y^2\right)^2dy \]

Use symmetry and expand

Why: The integrand is even.

\[ = 2\pi\int_0^2\left(16 - 8y^2 + y^4\right)dy \]

Integrate

Why: Power rule term by term.

\[ = 2\pi\left[16y - \frac{8y^3}{3} + \frac{y^5}{5}\right]_0^2 \]

Evaluate

Why: Put in 2; every term vanishes at 0.

\[ = 2\pi\left(32 - \frac{64}{3} + \frac{32}{5}\right) \]

Combine over 15

Why: Put the three numbers over a common denominator of fifteen.

\[ = 2\pi\cdot\frac{256}{15} \]

Simplify

Why: About one hundred and seven cubic units.

\[ = \frac{512\pi}{15} \approx 107.2 \]

Figure (svg): The parabola x = y squared from y = −2 to 2 and the vertical line x = 4, with the region between them shaded and revolved about the line x = 4: a solid shaped like a lens or a spinning top lying on its side, with a highlighted horizontal slice at y = 1.

The region touches the axis along x = 4, so there is no hole. Each horizontal slice is a disk whose radius is four minus y squared.

Check with Simpson's rule

Why: Four panels of width 1 at y = −2, −1, 0, 1, 2, where the slice areas are 0, 9 pi, 16 pi, 9 pi, 0.

\[ \frac13\left[0 + 4(9\pi) + 2(16\pi) + 4(9\pi) + 0\right] = \frac{104\pi}{3} \approx 108.9 \quad \text{vs } 107.2 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, pp. 564-566 — the method of Example 6.11 about a vertical line

Everything in this problem is decided by the first line: the axis is vertical, so the slices are horizontal and the variable is y. The curve is already given as x in terms of y, which is a gift.

The radius is measured leftwards from the axis to the parabola, so it is four minus y squared. Notice that this vanishes at y equal to plus and minus two, where the curve meets the line: the solid comes to a point at both ends, which is what makes it lens shaped.

The region touches the axis along the segment of the line between those two points, so there is no hole and these are disks, not washers. This is the case people most often get wrong in the sorting exercise.

The check uses Simpson's rule with four panels. It gives about one hundred and eight point nine against the exact one hundred and seven point two, an overestimate of one and a half per cent, which is the right size of error for a quartic integrand on such a coarse grid.

58. A football as a solid of revolution

Real world

Figure (svg): The upper half of an ellipse with half-length 5.5 and half-height 3.4, revolved about the x-axis into an egg-shaped solid, with a highlighted slice at x = 2.

Revolving half an ellipse gives a prolate spheroid, a first model of a football. The real ball has pointed ends, so this model is a little too fat.

Discussion prompt

Exercise 104: revolve the ellipse x²/a² + y²/b² = 1 about the x-axis. Find the volume in terms of a and b, then evaluate it for a ball about 11 inches long and 6.8 inches thick, so a = 5.5 and b = 3.4.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing §6.2, pp. 567-568 — Exercises 104 and 106

Try the general calculation before putting numbers in, because it is short and the result is one worth knowing. Solve the ellipse for y squared, which is what the disk formula needs, and you get a constant minus a multiple of x squared: a familiar integrand.

The answer, four thirds pi times a times b squared, generalises the sphere. Set a and b both equal to the radius and you recover four thirds pi r cubed, which is a good check on the algebra and worth doing.

For the numbers, an American football is about eleven inches long and about six point eight inches across, giving roughly two hundred and sixty six cubic inches. A real ball tapers to a point at each end, while the ellipsoid stays rounded, so this model is a little generous; Exercise 106 uses a sine curve instead and gives a smaller, pointier solid.

59. Putting it together

Section

Part 6

60. Pattern: setting up any volume of revolution

Pattern

Figure (svg): A flow diagram: sketch the region and the axis; slices perpendicular to the axis fix dx or dy; if the region touches the axis use disks, otherwise washers; write each radius as a distance to the axis; then integrate pi times R squared minus r squared.

Two decisions do all the work: which variable, fixed by the axis, and whether there is a hole, fixed by whether the region touches the axis.
  1. Sketch the region and the axis. Mark any gap between them.
  2. Slice perpendicular to the axis. A horizontal axis means dx; a vertical axis means dy. Write every boundary in that variable.
  3. Disk or washer? If the region touches the axis, disks; otherwise washers.
  4. Radii are distances to the axis: larger coordinate minus smaller.
  5. Square each radius, then subtract, multiply by pi, integrate between the limits.

This is the order to work in, and the first two steps are the ones that decide whether the rest goes smoothly. Sketch the region and the axis on the same picture: the gap, or the lack of one, is then visible rather than remembered.

The direction of slicing comes next and is never a matter of taste. Perpendicular to the axis, always. Fix the variable there and write every boundary in it before you go any further, even if that means solving a curve for the other variable.

Then the two radii, each as a distance from the axis, and only then the area of the slice, with each radius squared before anything is subtracted. If you find yourself writing an integral before you have named both radii, you are going too fast.

One last rule that is not on the diagram: check your answer against something you already know, a cylinder that contains the solid, a cone it resembles, or a coarse numerical sum. Every worked example in this lesson ended that way.

61. Put the washer method in order

Ranking

Put in order

Order the steps of a complete washer-method solution.

  1. Sketch the region and the axis of revolution
  2. Choose dx or dy from the direction of the axis
  3. Write the outer and inner radii as distances to the axis
  4. Write the area π(R² − r²) of one slice
  5. Integrate the area between the limits of the region

Why: The sketch shows the gap and the orientation. The axis fixes the variable before any radius is written, because the radii must be in that variable. Only then is the slice's area formed and integrated.

Drag the steps into order before checking. The only one that is genuinely contested is where the choice of variable belongs, and the answer is early, immediately after the sketch, because the radii cannot be written until the variable is known.

Notice that forming the area of one slice is a separate step from integrating it. Keeping them separate is what stops the squaring and the subtracting from getting muddled, and it is also what makes the method look the same whether the slice is a disk, a washer or a square.

62. Check: washers between two curves

Check

Check your understanding

Which integral gives the volume when the region between y = x and y = x² is revolved about the x-axis?

  • A. π ∫₀¹ (x − x²)² dx
  • B. π ∫₀¹ (x² − x⁴) dx (correct)
  • C. π ∫₀¹ (x⁴ − x²) dx
  • D. π ∫₀¹ (x − x²) dx

Answer: B

Why: On the interval from 0 to 1 the line y = x is outer and y = x² is inner, so the washer area is π(x² − x⁴). The integral is π(1/3 − 1/5) = 2π/15.

Why A tempts people
This squares the difference of the radii, which leaves a cross term and gives π/30, a quarter of the true volume.
Why C tempts people
The radii are reversed: on the interval from 0 to 1, x² is smaller than x, so this integrand is negative.
Why D tempts people
Neither radius is squared, so the integrand is not an area and the result is not a volume.

The two curves meet at zero and at one, and between them the line lies above the parabola, so the line gives the outer radius and the parabola the inner one.

Three of the four options are the classic errors, and it is worth naming each: squaring the difference instead of differencing the squares, reversing the two radii, and forgetting to square at all. If you picked one of them, decide which of those three descriptions fits, and you will know which habit to watch.

63. Check: horizontal slices

Check

Check your understanding

The region bounded by y = x², y = 4 and the y-axis (x ≥ 0) is revolved about the y-axis. Which integral gives the volume?

  • A. π ∫₀² x⁴ dx
  • B. π ∫₀⁴ √y dy
  • C. π ∫₀⁴ y dy (correct)
  • D. π ∫₀⁴ y² dy

Answer: C

Why: The axis is vertical, so slices are horizontal disks of thickness dy. At height y the radius is x = √y, and squaring it gives y. The volume is π times 8, or 8π.

Why A tempts people
This uses vertical slices and the height x² as a radius, which describes revolving about the x-axis, not the y-axis.
Why B tempts people
The radius √y is right, but it was never squared, so the integrand is not a disk's area.
Why D tempts people
This squares y instead of the radius √y; y is the height of the slice, not its distance from the axis.

The axis is vertical, so before anything else the answer must be an integral in dy, which removes one option immediately.

Among the rest, the radius at height y is the distance from the y-axis to the curve, which is the square root of y, and squaring it gives y. Choosing the integrand y squared means you squared the height rather than the radius, and choosing the square root means you never squared anything at all.

64. Check: an axis below the region

Check

Check your understanding

The region under y = x² for x from 0 to 2 is revolved about the line y = −1. Which integral gives the volume?

  • A. π ∫₀² (x² + 1)² dx
  • B. π ∫₀² [(x² + 1)² − 1] dx (correct)
  • C. π ∫₀² [(x²)² − 1] dx
  • D. π ∫₀² (x² − 1)² dx

Answer: B

Why: The outer radius is x² − (−1) = x² + 1 and the inner radius, from the axis up to the x-axis, is 1. The volume is π(32/5 + 16/3) = 176π/15.

Why A tempts people
This forgets the hole: the region stops at the x-axis, one unit above the axis, so each slice has an inner radius of 1.
Why C tempts people
The outer radius was measured from the x-axis instead of from the axis y = −1.
Why D tempts people
This squares a difference and uses the wrong outer radius; distances to y = −1 add 1, they do not subtract it.

Start by drawing the axis one unit below the x-axis, then the region above it. The gap is what tells you the slices are washers, so the integrand must be a difference.

Measuring from the axis, the outer radius is the curve's height plus one and the inner radius is one. The tempting wrong answer is the one that gets the outer radius right and forgets the hole; it overcounts by the volume of a cylinder of radius one and length two, which is two pi.

65. Explain why the axis picks the variable

Explain it to yourself

Discussion prompt

In Section 6.1 you could slice an area either way. Explain in two sentences why a volume of revolution forces the direction of slicing, and what goes wrong for y = x³ + x revolved about the y-axis.

Write your two sentences before revealing. Being able to say this in your own words is worth more than remembering which formula has dy in it, because the explanation regenerates the formula whenever you need it.

The heart of it is that only a cut perpendicular to the axis is a circle. Cut a solid of revolution the other way and you get a curved shell, whose area is not pi times anything simple, so the disk and washer formulas do not apply.

The second half of the question is the price of that rule. When the perpendicular direction forces you to describe the boundary in a variable you cannot solve for, as with the cubic, the method stops. That is not a failure of your algebra; it is the reason the next section exists.

66. Exit ticket

Exit ticket

\[ \text{Revolve the region under } y = \sqrt x, \; 0 \le x \le 4, \text{ about the line } y = 2. \]

Discussion prompt

Disk or washer? Write both radii, set up the integral, and find the volume.

Work this one end to end before revealing, and start with a sketch, because the axis here is unusual: it lies above the region and touches it only at the single point where the curve reaches height two.

So the far boundary from the axis is the x-axis, at a constant distance of two, and the near boundary is the curve, at distance two minus the square root of x. There is a hole everywhere except at the right-hand end, so these are washers with the constant as the outer radius, which is the reverse of the usual arrangement.

Expanding the square is the only real work: four minus the square of two minus the square root of x leaves four times the square root of x minus x. Integrating from zero to four gives forty pi over three, about forty two.

If you got the two radii the other way round, look again at which boundary is farther from the line y equal to two. That single question decides the whole problem.

67. Recap

Recap

methodwhenvolume
slicingany solid whose cut has a known area∫ A(x) dx
disksregion touches the axis∫ π R² dx (or dy)
washersa gap between region and axis∫ π (R² − r²) dx (or dy)
other axesaxis y = c or x = kradii are distances to the axis

\[ V = \int_a^b A(x)\,dx \]

The axis fixes the variable. When that variable is impossible, Section 6.3 slices the other way, into cylindrical shells.

Stewart, Calculus: Early Transcendentals 8e, §6.2 Volumes §6.2, pp. 438-448 — the same material in Stewart

One formula, three faces. The volume of any solid is the integral of the area of its cuts; for a solid of revolution that area is a disk or a ring, so all that is left to find is a radius or two.

Two questions set up every problem in this section. The axis decides the direction of slicing and therefore the variable, and whether the region touches the axis decides disk or washer. Answer those two before you write an integral and you will rarely set one up wrongly.

Two errors account for most lost marks: forgetting to square a radius, and squaring the difference of the radii instead of subtracting their squares. Both are caught by asking whether your integrand is really the area of the slice you drew.

Section 6.3 takes on the case this method cannot handle, where the forced variable is one you cannot solve for, by slicing parallel to the axis into cylindrical shells.

Sources

  1. OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.2 Determining Volumes by Slicing — Strang & Herman, OpenStax / Rice University, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, pp. 551-568
  2. Stewart, Calculus: Early Transcendentals 8e, §6.2 Volumes — James Stewart, Cengage Learning, 2016, pp. 438-448

Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Calculus I — $55/session, free consultation.

Book on Wyzant · Text (657) 465-8108