6.1 Areas between Curves

The area between two curves as the integral of top minus bottom, why the axis is irrelevant, splitting where the curves cross, integrating with respect to y using horizontal strips, and choosing the variable that avoids splitting.

Subject: Calculus I · 64 slides · symbolic lesson

Open the interactive version of this deck

What this lesson covers

The lesson, slide by slide

1. Areas between Curves

Title

Calculus I · Section 6.1

Top minus bottom, one strip at a time

2. What this lesson gives you

Objectives

Chapter 5 found the area between one curve and the x-axis. Most regions worth measuring are squeezed between two curves instead, and this lesson turns every such region into one or two definite integrals.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, pp. 540-550 — learning objectives 6.1.1 to 6.1.3

Everything you did with areas in Chapter 5 measured the gap between a curve and the x-axis. That was a special case, and a slightly odd one: the axis is not usually part of the problem, it just happens to be drawn on the page. This lesson removes it and lets both edges of the region be curves.

The formula you are heading towards is almost disappointingly simple. Subtract the lower curve from the upper one and integrate the result. Nearly all of the work in this section is in the two questions that come before you write the integral: where does the region start and stop, and which curve is on top there.

Two things will bite if you are not warned. The first is that curves sometimes swap places inside the interval, and a single integral then quietly cancels part of the area away. The second is that a region's boundary can change formula even when the curves never cross, which is what forces some problems into two integrals and makes the alternative in Part 4 worth learning.

Read the objective list as a promise about what you should be able to set up by the end, not just recognise. Setting up is the skill being taught here.

3. Before anything new: area under one curve

Warm-up

Discussion prompt

From Chapter 5: write the area of the region under y = x + 4 and above the x-axis, from x = 1 to x = 4, as a definite integral, and evaluate it. What would change if the curve dipped below the axis?

Answer this on paper before you reveal it, because the whole lesson is built on top of it and any rust will show up later as confusion rather than as a wrong answer.

The integral you just wrote is already a top-minus-bottom integral in disguise. The top is the line and the bottom is the x-axis, whose height is zero, so subtracting it changes nothing and you never noticed you were subtracting. Everything new in this lesson comes from replacing that zero with a second function.

Pay attention to the second half of the question, about a curve that dips below the axis. That habit of splitting at the crossings and flipping signs is correct in Chapter 5 and it is the single biggest source of unnecessary work in Chapter 6. Part 1 will show you exactly when it is no longer needed, and if you carry it in unexamined you will split regions that never needed splitting.

4. The strip and the difference

Section

Part 1

5. Area between two curves is a difference of two areas

Concept

Figure (svg): Three panels over the interval from 1 to 4. Left: the area under the line y equals x plus 4, shaded. Middle: the area under the line y equals 3 minus x over 2, shaded. Right: only the band between the two lines, shaded.

Take the area under the top curve and remove the area under the bottom curve: what is left is exactly the band between them.

When one curve sits above the other on the whole interval, the region between them is what remains of the area under the top curve after the area under the bottom curve is removed.

\[ \int_1^4 (x+4)\,dx - \int_1^4 \left(3 - \frac{x}{2}\right)dx = 19.5 - 5.25 = 14.25 \]

Linearity lets you merge the two integrals into one, whose integrand is the gap between the curves.

\[ \int_a^b f(x)\,dx - \int_a^b g(x)\,dx = \int_a^b \left[f(x) - g(x)\right]dx \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 540 — Figure 6.2

Read the three panels from left to right as a subtraction you can see. The left panel is the area under the upper line, the middle panel is the area under the lower line, and the right panel is what is left over when you take the second away from the first. Nothing about that argument depends on the curves being straight.

The numbers are worth checking against the picture. Nineteen and a half, minus five and a quarter, leaves fourteen and a quarter, and the right-hand shaded band does look like roughly three quarters of the left-hand one. Getting into the habit of glancing at a figure and asking whether the number is the right size will save you many marks.

The last line is the move that makes the whole section practical. Two separate integrals over the same interval can be merged into one whose integrand is the difference of the two functions, because integration is linear. From here on you never compute two areas and subtract; you compute one integral whose integrand is a gap.

That merge is also what frees you from the axis. Once the integrand is a gap, the axis has dropped out of the calculation entirely, which is the point of the next few slides.

6. Slice the region into vertical strips

Concept

Figure (svg): The band between y equals x plus 4 and y equals 3 minus x over 2 from x equals 1 to 4, cut into six vertical rectangles whose heights are taken at their left edges. One rectangle is highlighted with an arrow marking its height, f minus g, and a label for its width, delta x.

Each rectangle stands on the lower curve and reaches the upper curve, so its height is a difference. Six of them give 13.125; the band's true area is 14.25.

Cut the interval into n pieces of equal width and stand one rectangle on each piece, reaching from the lower curve to the upper curve at a chosen point of that piece.

\[ \Delta x = \frac{b-a}{n}, \qquad \text{height}_i = f(x_i^*) - g(x_i^*) \]

\[ \Delta A_i = \left[f(x_i^*) - g(x_i^*)\right]\Delta x \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 540 — Figure 6.3

Find the highlighted rectangle in the figure and look only at that. It stands on the lower curve and its top edge touches the upper curve, so its height is a difference of two function values taken at the same place. The double arrow drawn on it is measuring exactly that.

This is the one genuinely new object in the section, and it is worth naming carefully. In Chapter 5 a rectangle stood on the axis and its height was one function value. Here it stands on a curve and its height is a subtraction. Every formula in the lesson is a consequence of that one change.

The width is the same for every rectangle, and it is the interval length divided by the number of pieces. The starred point is just an honest admission that the strip has to take its height from somewhere; the left edge, the right edge or the middle all work, and in the limit the choice stops mattering.

Notice how badly six rectangles do here. They give thirteen and an eighth against a true area of fourteen and a quarter, and the picture shows why: each rectangle's top edge is level while the real roof is sloping, so every strip loses a thin triangle. Thinner strips lose thinner triangles.

7. Add the strips, then take the limit

Concept

Adding the rectangles gives an approximation; it is a Riemann sum for the function f minus g.

\[ A \approx \sum_{i=1}^{n} \left[f(x_i^*) - g(x_i^*)\right]\Delta x \]

As the strips get thinner the approximation becomes exact, and the limit of a Riemann sum is a definite integral.

\[ A = \lim_{n\to\infty}\sum_{i=1}^{n} \left[f(x_i^*) - g(x_i^*)\right]\Delta x = \int_a^b \left[f(x) - g(x)\right]dx \]

strips nleft-endpoint sumerror
613.1251.125
6014.13750.1125
limit14.250

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 541 — the Riemann sum before Theorem 6.1

There is no new theory on this slide, and that is the point worth taking from it. Once you know the height of one strip, adding the strips gives a Riemann sum, and a Riemann sum for the difference of the two functions is exactly what the definite integral of that difference means. You already proved this in Chapter 5; you are only feeding it a different integrand.

Look at the table before you accept the limit on faith. Six strips undershoot by a little over one, sixty strips undershoot by about a tenth, and the error has fallen by the same factor as the strip width. That tenfold pattern is what convergence looks like in practice, and it is reassuring in a way that the word limit on its own is not.

One thing to be careful about: the error here is one-sided. Every left-endpoint rectangle sits under a rising gap, so every one of them is too short and the sum is always too small. When you use a rough sum as a sanity check later, knowing whether it is biased high or low is often as useful as the number itself.

8. Reading Theorem 6.1 piece by piece

Notation

Annotate

On: \( f(x) \ge g(x) \text{ on } [a,b] \;\Longrightarrow\; A = \int_a^b \left[f(x) - g(x)\right]dx \)

  • The hypothesis: f is the top curve on the WHOLE interval. If the curves cross inside [a, b], this formula does not apply as written.
  • The left and right edges of the region: given in the problem, or found where the curves meet.
  • The height of one vertical strip at position x. It is never negative, because f is on top.
  • The width of a strip. Vertical strips are stacked along the x-axis, so the variable is x.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 541 — Theorem 6.1, equation 6.1

Open the annotations in order and treat the first one as the important one. The hypothesis is that the upper function stays upper across the whole interval, and the word whole is doing real work. If the curves swap anywhere inside, this formula is not slightly inaccurate, it is measuring something else, and Part 3 exists to deal with that case.

The second annotation is about where the limits come from, and there are only two possibilities. Either the problem hands them to you, as this one does, or the curves themselves supply them by meeting. Knowing which situation you are in is the first decision of every problem in this section.

The third annotation is the one to say out loud: the integrand is the height of one strip. Not a curve, not an area, a height. If you can look at your own integrand and point to the strip it measures, your setup is almost certainly right, and if you cannot, stop and sketch.

The last annotation is a bookkeeping rule that pays off in Part 4. Vertical strips are stacked along the x-axis, so the differential is in x and everything in the integral must be written in x. When you turn the strips sideways, every one of those words changes.

9. Example 6.1: between two lines on [1, 4]

Worked example

The region lies above one line, below another, and between the vertical lines at 1 and 4.

\[ f(x) = x + 4, \quad g(x) = 3 - \frac{x}{2}, \quad [1, 4] \]

Confirm which line is on top

Why: The lines meet only once, and that meeting point lies outside the interval, so the order cannot change inside it.

\[ x + 4 = 3 - \frac{x}{2} \iff x = -\frac23 \notin [1,4] \]

Write top minus bottom, keeping the brackets

Why: The whole of g is subtracted.

\[ f(x) - g(x) = (x+4) - \left(3 - \frac{x}{2}\right) \]

Simplify

Why: Distribute the minus sign: the minus x over 2 becomes plus.

\[ = x + 4 - 3 + \frac{x}{2} = \frac{3x}{2} + 1 \]

Antidifferentiate

Why: Power rule on each term.

\[ \int_1^4 \left(\frac{3x}{2} + 1\right)dx = \left[\frac{3x^2}{4} + x\right]_1^4 \]

Evaluate at both ends

Why: Upper limit first, then subtract the lower.

\[ = (12 + 4) - \left(\frac34 + 1\right) = 16 - \frac74 \]

Combine

Why: Sixteen is sixty-four quarters.

\[ A = \frac{57}{4} = 14.25 \]

Figure (svg): The region between y equals x plus 4 above and y equals 3 minus x over 2 below, shaded from x equals 1 to x equals 4; at x equals 1 the gap is 2.5 and at x equals 4 it is 7.

Both edges are straight lines, so the region is a trapezoid with parallel vertical sides 2.5 and 7.

Check with geometry

Why: Both edges are straight, so the region is a trapezoid whose parallel sides are the gaps at 1 and at 4, and whose width is 3.

\[ f(1) - g(1) = 2.5, \quad f(4) - g(4) = 7, \quad \frac{2.5 + 7}{2}\cdot 3 = 14.25 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, pp. 541-542 — Example 6.1

Notice what the first step actually does. It does not assume which line is on top; it finds the only place the two lines could possibly swap, sees that the place lies outside the interval, and concludes that whatever order holds at one point holds everywhere on the interval. That is a complete argument, and it takes one line.

The second and third steps are deliberately separate, and you should keep them separate in your own work. Write the subtraction with the lower function inside brackets, and only then distribute the minus sign. Combining those two moves into one is how the trap two slides later happens, and it happens to almost everybody at least once.

From there it is Chapter 5 arithmetic. Antidifferentiate, evaluate at the top, subtract the value at the bottom. If you are still making sign slips at that last stage, write the two bracketed values down before you combine them rather than doing it in your head.

The check is the part to copy as a habit. Both edges of this region are straight, so the region really is a trapezoid, and the trapezoid rule from school gives the same fourteen and a quarter. Whenever a region happens to be a shape you knew before calculus, use that as an independent test of your integration.

10. Checkpoint 6.1: fill in the middle

Fill the middle

Checkpoint 6.1 asks for the area between the lines below on the interval from 1 to 5. Fill in the simplified height and the area.

\[ f(x) = \frac{x}{2} + 5, \quad g(x) = x + \frac12, \quad [1, 5] \]

Fill in the blanks

\int_1^5 \left[\left(\frac\frac9212+5\right) - \left(x+\frac12\right)\right]dx = \int_1^5 \left(___ - \frac______\right)dx = ___

Why: Five minus one half is nine halves, and x over 2 minus x is minus x over 2. The antiderivative is 9x/2 − x²/4; from 1 to 5 it gives 65/4 − 17/4 = 12. Check: the gaps at the ends are 4 and 2, and a trapezoid 4 wide with those sides has area (4 + 2)/2 · 4 = 12.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 542 — Checkpoint 6.1

Work the two blanks out on paper before you type anything, because the first one is exactly where careless subtraction shows up. You are subtracting a whole binomial, so both of its terms change sign: the one half becomes a minus one half against the five, and the x becomes a minus x against the x over two.

That second cancellation is worth pausing on. The coefficient of x in the gap is negative, which means the two lines are converging: the region is wider at its left edge than at its right. Look at the numbers if you want proof. The gap is four at the left end and two at the right.

Once the integrand is right the rest is a straight power-rule integration, and the answer comes out to a whole number, which is a mild sign that you have not slipped.

The explanation offers a trapezoid check, and it is the same check as in Example 6.1. Two parallel vertical sides of four and two, across a width of four, average out to a rectangle three tall and four wide. Twelve. Getting the same answer from geometry and from calculus is about as convincing as a check gets.

11. The x-axis plays no part

Intuition

In Chapter 5 you split an integral wherever the curve crossed the x-axis. Here the axis never appears in the integrand: only the gap between the two curves does.

\[ \big(f(x) - c\big) - \big(g(x) - c\big) = f(x) - g(x) \]

Slide both curves up or down by any amount c and every strip keeps its height. So a region between two curves may sit above the axis, below it or across it, and the formula does not change.

This is the most important idea in Part 1, and it is one line of algebra. Shift both curves by the same amount and the shifts cancel when you subtract, so every strip in the region keeps exactly the height it had. The region has moved, but nothing you integrate has changed.

The consequence is a rule you can use immediately: a region between two curves never needs splitting at the x-axis. It may lie above the axis, below it, or straddle it, and the top-minus-bottom integral is the same either way. Half the unnecessary work students do in this section comes from not believing that.

It is worth being precise about why Chapter 5 was different rather than just noting that it was. There the lower boundary of the region was the axis itself, so where the curve dropped below the axis the roles of upper and lower genuinely swapped, and a swap does force a split. The axis was never special; it was just playing the part of the lower curve.

So the question to ask is never whether the axis is crossed. It is whether the two boundaries swap. Keep that distinction and the rest of the lesson gets much simpler.

12. Sliding the region down changes nothing

Picture it

Figure (svg): Two panels. Left: the Example 6.1 region, entirely above the x-axis. Right: the same region moved down 5 units, so part of it lies below the x-axis; the vertical gaps are unchanged.

Every strip keeps its height when both curves move together. The x-axis now cuts through the region, and it makes no difference.

On the right, both lines of Example 6.1 have been moved down 5 units. The x-axis now cuts through the region, yet the gap at every x is the same simplified expression, three x over two plus one, so the area is still fifty-seven quarters.

Compare the two panels at a single x-value rather than as whole pictures. Pick the middle of the interval, measure the vertical gap on the left, and measure it again on the right. It is the same gap. Both curves fell five units, so the distance between them could not have changed.

The two captions underneath are the same expression in disguise, and expanding them is the fastest way to convince yourself. On the left the gap simplifies to three x over two plus one, and on the right, once you have distributed the minus sign through the negative constant and the negative x over two, you get three x over two plus one again.

Now look at what did change. On the right the x-axis cuts straight through the shaded region, and about a third of the region lies below it. In Chapter 5 that would have meant two integrals and a sign flip. Here it means nothing at all, because the axis is not one of the boundaries.

If you ever find yourself uneasy about a region below the axis, redraw it shifted upwards. The area is unchanged and your nerves will be steadier.

13. Does the axis crossing cost you a split?

Prediction

\[ y = x - 1 \quad\text{and}\quad y = -2 - \frac{x}{2} \quad \text{on } [1, 4] \]

Predict first

This is Example 6.1 moved down 5. Part of the region is now below the x-axis. What is its area?

  • 57/4, unchanged
  • Less than 57/4, because the part below the axis counts negatively
  • More than 57/4
  • It cannot be found without splitting at the x-axis

Correct: 57/4, unchanged

Why: The integrand is the gap (x − 1) − (−2 − x/2) = 3x/2 + 1, the same as before, so the integral is the same 57/4. The axis never enters a top-minus-bottom integral; negative heights only arose in Chapter 5 because the bottom curve there was the axis itself.

Commit to one of the four options before reading on, and notice which option tempts you. The second one, that the part below the axis counts negatively, is the answer that the whole of Chapter 5 trained you to give, which is exactly why this slide is here.

The reasoning is short once you see it. These two lines are the Example 6.1 lines with five subtracted from each, so their difference is unchanged, so the integral is unchanged, so the area is the same fifty-seven quarters. You do not have to recompute anything; you only have to notice the shift.

Negative heights arose in Chapter 5 for one reason: the lower boundary was the axis, and when the curve fell below the axis the upper and lower boundaries traded places. Nothing trades places here. The line that was above is still above, by exactly the same distance, at every point of the interval.

The fourth option, that you cannot find the area without splitting, is the expensive mistake. You can spend ten minutes finding where each line crosses the axis, splitting into three pieces and flipping signs, and arrive at the answer a one-line integral would have given you.

14. Trap: losing the brackets around g

Trap

The trap

A common line in Example 6.1:

\[ (x + 4) - 3 - \frac{x}{2} = \frac{x}{2} + 1 \]

\[ \int_1^4 \left(\frac{x}{2}+1\right)dx = \frac{27}{4} \]

Wrong. Only the first term of g was subtracted.

The fix

The minus sign applies to all of g, so its minus x over 2 becomes plus x over 2. Write g inside brackets every time, then distribute.

\[ (x+4) - \left(3 - \frac{x}{2}\right) = \frac{3x}{2} + 1 \]

\[ \int_1^4 \left(\frac{3x}{2}+1\right)dx = \frac{57}{4} \]

Look at the left-hand column before the correction and try to spot the exact character that is wrong. Everything about the setup is right: the correct region, the correct interval, the correct curve on top. The only fault is that the minus sign reached the three and then stopped.

What makes this dangerous is that the wrong integrand is perfectly plausible. It is positive, it is increasing, and it integrates cleanly to twenty-seven quarters. There is nothing in the algebra that looks broken, and if you did not know the answer you would have no reason to suspect it.

The defence is mechanical, and it is the reason Example 6.1 kept the brackets as a separate step. Write the lower function inside brackets, then distribute on the next line. A subtracted expression has every one of its signs reversed, so the minus x over two becomes a plus x over two and the gap grows rather than shrinks.

There is also a quick sanity test. The gap at the left end of this region is two and a half and at the right end it is seven, so the average height is around five and the width is three, giving something near fifteen. Twenty-seven quarters is under seven, which is far too small for a region you can see.

15. Slide k: the height function of a lens

Tweak it

Parameter explorer

The line y = kx and the parabola y = x² enclose a lens from x = 0 to x = k. The curve drawn is the strip height kx − x², and the area under its hump is the lens's area. Slide k: how does the area change when k doubles?

\[ A = \int_0^{{k}}\left({k}x - x^2\right)dx = \frac{{k}^3}{6} \]

  • k — from 0.5 to 4: slope k

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 548 — Exercise 2 and the problem seeds: y = 2x and y = x²

Be clear about what the slider is plotting before you touch it. It is not the two curves; it is the gap between them. The hump you see is the strip height as a function of position, and the area under that hump is the area of the lens-shaped region caught between the line and the parabola.

That is a useful way to look at every problem in this section. Once you have written top minus bottom, you have a single ordinary Chapter 5 problem, and the region whose area you are finding is the one under the graph of the gap. The two-curve picture is how the problem is posed; the one-curve picture is how it is solved.

Now move the slider and watch two things at once: the hump gets wider and it gets taller. It ends at the point where the line meets the parabola, so it widens in proportion to the slope, and its peak grows like the square of the slope. Width times height suggests growth like a cube, and the readout confirms it.

So doubling the slope multiplies the area by eight, not by two. Predictions like that are cheap and they catch gross errors instantly, which is worth more than it sounds.

16. Where the curves meet

Section

Part 2

17. When no interval is given, the curves supply it

Concept

Often the region is simply enclosed by the two curves. Its left and right edges are then the x-values where the curves meet, found by setting them equal.

\[ f(x) = g(x) \quad\Longrightarrow\quad x = a, \; x = b \]

Solving tells you where the edges are, but not which curve is on top between them. For that, evaluate both at any point strictly between the crossings.

\[ a < x_0 < b: \quad f(x_0) > g(x_0) \;\Longrightarrow\; f \text{ is on top} \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 542 — text before Example 6.2

This is a small shift in how you read a problem, and it trips people up mostly because nothing announces it. When a problem says the region enclosed by two curves, or the region bounded by them, there are no vertical edges: the region ends where the curves meet, and finding those meeting points is your first job.

Setting the two functions equal gives an equation whose solutions are the x-coordinates of the meeting points. They are the limits of your integral. Be careful not to carry the y-coordinates along by accident; a horizontal coordinate has no business being a limit in an integral taken along the x-axis.

Solving tells you where, but it says nothing about which curve is on top, and you need that too. The remedy is one line: pick any convenient point strictly between two consecutive meeting points and evaluate both functions there. Whichever is larger is the roof for that whole stretch, because the curves cannot cross again without meeting again.

That last sentence is the reason a single test point suffices, and it is worth keeping in mind. Between consecutive crossings the difference of the two functions never changes sign, so one sample settles the whole piece.

18. A shortcut for parabola-and-line regions

Intuition

When the gap between the curves is a quadratic, with leading coefficient a and zeros at alpha and beta, the gap factors and the integral has a closed form.

\[ f(x) - g(x) = a(x - \alpha)(\beta - x) \]

\[ \int_{\alpha}^{\beta} a(x-\alpha)(\beta - x)\,dx = \frac{a(\beta - \alpha)^3}{6} \]

You will not use this to answer questions, but it is an excellent way to check the answers you get by integrating, and it shows why the lens on the slider grew like a cube.

Stewart, Calculus: Early Transcendentals 8e, §6.1 Areas Between Curves §6.1, pp. 428-437 — compare Stewart's parabola-and-line examples

This slide is not asking you to memorise anything you will be graded on. It is giving you a cheap second opinion, and second opinions are what stop a sign slip from becoming a wrong answer.

The reason it works is that these regions all have the same integrand in disguise. When the gap between the curves is a quadratic, it factors into a leading coefficient times the distance past the left crossing times the distance short of the right crossing. Integrating that product over the whole span always gives the same shape of answer, and the span appears cubed.

Notice the sensitivity that cube implies. Move the crossings ten per cent further apart and the area grows by about a third. If you ever find two crossings and are unsure whether you solved the quadratic correctly, this tells you how much a small error in the roots would cost.

It also explains the slider on the previous slide without any extra work. The lens there was a parabola-and-line region whose crossings were zero and the slope, so its span was the slope itself, and the cube in this formula is the cube you watched in the readout.

19. Example 6.2: a parabola over a line

Worked example

Find the area of the region below the parabola and above the line.

\[ f(x) = 9 - \left(\frac{x}{2}\right)^2, \quad g(x) = 6 - x \]

Set the curves equal

Why: The edges of the region are where they meet.

\[ 9 - \frac{x^2}{4} = 6 - x \]

Clear the fraction

Why: Multiply every term by 4.

\[ 36 - x^2 = 24 - 4x \]

Collect on one side

Why: Move everything to the right.

\[ x^2 - 4x - 12 = 0 \]

Factor

Why: Two numbers with product minus twelve and sum minus four.

\[ (x - 6)(x + 2) = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = -2, \; x = 6 \]

Test a point between

Why: At x equal to 0 the parabola is higher.

\[ f(0) = 9 > 6 = g(0) \]

Write top minus bottom

Why: Subtract the whole line.

\[ f(x) - g(x) = 9 - \frac{x^2}{4} - 6 + x = 3 + x - \frac{x^2}{4} \]

Antidifferentiate

Why: Term by term.

\[ A = \left[3x + \frac{x^2}{2} - \frac{x^3}{12}\right]_{-2}^{6} \]

Evaluate at each end

Why: At 6: eighteen plus eighteen minus eighteen. At minus 2: minus six plus two plus two thirds.

\[ A = 18 - \left(-\frac{10}{3}\right) = \frac{64}{3} \approx 21.33 \]

Figure (svg): The downward parabola y equals 9 minus x squared over 4 and the line y equals 6 minus x, crossing at (−2, 8) and (6, 0); the lens-shaped region between them is shaded.

No interval was given: the two crossing points are the left and right ends of the region.

Check with the parabola-and-line shortcut

Why: The gap has leading coefficient one quarter and zeros eight apart.

\[ \frac{a(\beta-\alpha)^3}{6} = \frac{\tfrac14 \cdot 8^3}{6} = \frac{128}{6} = \frac{64}{3} \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, pp. 542-543 — Example 6.2

Nothing in this problem gives you an interval, so the first five steps are about manufacturing one. That is the shape of most problems in this section: a short piece of algebra to find the edges, a one-line test to find the roof, and then an integration you could have done a month ago.

Watch the fraction-clearing step. Multiplying every term by four turns a problem with quarters in it into a clean quadratic, and clean quadratics factor. Fractions are not hard, but they are where arithmetic slips cluster, so it is worth a line to get rid of them before solving.

The test point is zero, which is chosen because it is easy rather than because it is special, and it lies between minus two and six as required. The parabola is at nine there and the line at six, so the parabola is the roof across the whole region. Look at the figure and confirm it: the shaded lens really does hang below the curve.

The check uses the shortcut from two slides back. The gap has leading coefficient one quarter and its zeros are eight apart, and eight cubed is a large number, which is why a region with an unremarkable-looking lens shape has area over twenty-one.

20. Before integrating: which is on top?

Step zero

\[ y = x \quad\text{and}\quad y = x^4 \]

Discussion prompt

Checkpoint 6.2 asks for the area of the region between these curves. Before you integrate anything, what are the edges of the region, and which curve is the roof? Give a reason for each, not a guess.

Write both answers down before revealing, and insist on a reason rather than an impression. Guessing which curve is on top is the single most common way to get a completely wrong answer while doing all the integration perfectly.

The edges come from factoring out an x, which leaves a cubic equal to one. Do not lose the solution at zero to a careless division; dividing both sides by x is the classic way to throw away a crossing, and here it would cost you the entire left edge of the region.

For the roof, one test point settles it, and the numbers are worth looking at rather than just accepting. At one half the line is at one half and the quartic is at one sixteenth, so the line is well clear. The underlying reason is that between zero and one, multiplying a number by itself makes it smaller, and the fourth power is three such multiplications.

That reason generalises usefully. On the interval from zero to one, a higher power is always the lower curve, and past one the order reverses. Knowing that, you can predict the roof for a whole family of problems without testing anything.

21. Checkpoint 6.2: a line over a quartic

Worked example

\[ f(x) = x, \quad g(x) = x^4 \]

Record the edges and the roof

Why: From the previous slide.

\[ [0, 1], \quad x \ge x^4 \text{ there} \]

Set up top minus bottom

Why: Theorem 6.1.

\[ A = \int_0^1 \left(x - x^4\right)dx \]

Antidifferentiate

Why: Power rule twice.

\[ = \left[\frac{x^2}{2} - \frac{x^5}{5}\right]_0^1 \]

Evaluate

Why: The lower limit contributes nothing.

\[ = \frac12 - \frac15 = \frac{3}{10} \]

Figure (svg): The line y equals x and the curve y equals x to the fourth from x equals 0 to 1.25; they meet at the origin and at (1, 1), and the thin region between them is shaded.

The quartic hugs the axis until about x equals one half, so most of the triangle under y equals x belongs to the region.

Check with a midpoint sum

Why: Four strips at 0.125, 0.375, 0.625 and 0.875 already land close.

\[ M_4 = 0.25\sum_{i=1}^{4}\left(x_i - x_i^4\right) \approx 0.3103 \approx 0.3 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 543 — Checkpoint 6.2

This one is deliberately quick, because you did the hard part on the previous slide. The whole point of separating them is that the setup and the integration are different skills, and it is the setup that decides whether your answer is right.

Notice how little the quartic contributes. Its antiderivative brings in a fifth, against the line's one half, so the region has about three fifths of the area of the triangle under the line. Look at the figure and that is exactly what you see: the quartic hugs the axis for most of the interval and only rears up near the right-hand end.

The check is a four-strip midpoint sum, and the number it gives is worth thinking about. It comes out about three per cent high, which is what you should expect: the gap here is a hump, and midpoint rectangles under a hump slightly overshoot near the peak.

A rough sum like that will never confirm a fifth decimal place, and it is not meant to. What it confirms is that you have not lost a factor, dropped a term or mixed up the curves, and those are the errors that actually happen.

22. Exercise 1: a region mostly below the axis

Worked example

Find the area between the parabola and the horizontal line.

\[ y = x^2 - 3 \quad\text{and}\quad y = 1 \]

Set the curves equal

Why: The parabola reaches height 1 twice.

\[ x^2 - 3 = 1 \iff x^2 = 4 \iff x = \pm 2 \]

Find the roof

Why: At x equal to 0 the line is at 1 and the parabola at minus 3.

\[ 1 > -3 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = 1 \text{ is on top} \]

Write top minus bottom

Why: Brackets around the parabola.

\[ 1 - \left(x^2 - 3\right) = 4 - x^2 \]

Antidifferentiate

Why: Power rule.

\[ A = \int_{-2}^{2}\left(4 - x^2\right)dx = \left[4x - \frac{x^3}{3}\right]_{-2}^{2} \]

Evaluate

Why: The antiderivative is odd, so the lower value is minus the upper.

\[ = \left(8 - \frac83\right) - \left(-8 + \frac83\right) = \frac{32}{3} \]

Figure (svg): The parabola y equals x squared minus 3 and the horizontal line y equals 1, meeting at x equals minus 2 and 2; the region between them is shaded and most of it lies below the x-axis.

Three quarters of the region is below the x-axis, and still no splitting is needed: the tallest strip, at x equal to 0, has height 1 minus (−3), which is 4.

Check with the shortcut

Why: Leading coefficient 1, zeros four apart. No splitting at the x-axis was needed, and none was done.

\[ \frac{1 \cdot 4^3}{6} = \frac{64}{6} = \frac{32}{3} \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 548 — Exercise 1

This is the slide to come back to when you are tempted to split a region at the x-axis. Look at the figure: three quarters of the shaded region sits below the axis, and the solution never mentions the axis once.

Follow what happens to the minus three when the parabola is subtracted. It becomes a plus three against the one, and the gap comes out as four minus x squared, a perfectly ordinary positive hump. The negative function values have vanished into the subtraction, which is exactly what the shifting argument from Part 1 promised.

The tallest strip is the one in the middle, and its height is worth computing by hand: the line is at one and the parabola at minus three, so the distance between them is four. That number four is a distance, not a difference of two positive heights, and treating heights as distances is what keeps you out of trouble when a curve goes negative.

The evaluation step uses a shortcut worth having. The antiderivative here is an odd function and the interval is symmetric about zero, so the value at the lower limit is the negative of the value at the upper one, and subtracting it doubles rather than cancels.

23. Estimate before integrating: a line over a parabola

Estimation

Figure (svg): The parabola y equals x squared and the line y equals 3x plus 4, meeting at x equals minus 1 and 4; the region between is shaded and its tallest vertical strip, at x equals 1.5, has height 6.25.

The region is 5 wide and at most 6.25 tall, so it sits inside a 5 by 6.25 box of area 31.25.

Predict first

Exercise 2: the region between y = x² and y = 3x + 4. Before integrating, which is the best estimate of its area?

  • About 5
  • About 21
  • About 31
  • About 63

Correct: About 21

Why: The region fits in a box 5 wide and 6.25 tall, area 31.25, and a parabolic hump fills two thirds of its box, so about 21. Integrating confirms it: the curves meet at −1 and 4, and the integral of 3x + 4 − x² from −1 to 4 is 125/6 ≈ 20.83. 31 is the whole box, 5 is just the width.

\[ \int_{-1}^{4}\left(3x + 4 - x^2\right)dx = \frac{56}{3} - \left(-\frac{13}{6}\right) = \frac{125}{6} \approx 20.83 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 548 — Exercise 2

Pick an option before you compute anything. The habit being built here is not estimation for its own sake; it is knowing roughly what a correct answer looks like so that a wrong one cannot slip past you.

The bounding box is the easiest estimate available and you should learn to write it down in one line. The region runs from minus one to four, so it is five wide, and the drawn segment shows the tallest strip is a little over six, so the region fits inside a box of about thirty-one. That is an upper bound you can trust.

Then refine it. The gap here is a parabolic hump, and a hump fills about two thirds of the box around it, which lands you near twenty-one. The exact answer is a shade under twenty-one, so the estimate was good to a few per cent for about fifteen seconds of work.

Look at the two distractors and what each represents. Thirty-one is the whole box, which is what you get if you forget that the region is curved, and five is just the width, which is what you get if you confuse a length with an area. Both are mistakes that an estimate catches and an integration does not.

24. Curves that cross

Section

Part 3

25. When the curves cross, the roof changes

Concept

Figure (svg): The curves y equals sine x and y equals cosine x from 0 to pi, crossing at pi over 4. Left of the crossing, the small region R1 has cosine on top; right of it, the larger region R2 has sine on top.

The roof changes owner at the crossing. On R₁ the cosine is on top; on R₂ the sine is.

If the curves cross inside the interval, neither one is on top throughout. The height of a strip is still the distance between the curves, which is the absolute value of their difference.

\[ \text{height at } x = \left|f(x) - g(x)\right| \]

Summing those heights gives Theorem 6.2. It needs no assumption about which curve is higher.

\[ A = \int_a^b \left|f(x) - g(x)\right|dx \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, pp. 543-544 — Theorem 6.2 and Figure 6.6

Look at the figure and note the single crossing point. To its left the cosine curve is higher; to its right the sine curve is. There is no function that is on top throughout this interval, so the hypothesis of Theorem 6.1 genuinely fails, and you need something more careful.

The fix is to stop thinking about which curve is which and think about distance instead. The height of a strip is how far apart the curves are, and a distance is never negative, which is what the absolute value bars are recording. Theorem 6.2 says nothing more than that: the area is the integral of the distance between the curves.

That is a clean statement, but it is not directly computable, because you cannot antidifferentiate an absolute value as it stands. In practice the theorem is a licence to split: find the crossings, decide which curve is on top on each piece, and write an ordinary top-minus-bottom integral for each piece.

So Theorem 6.2 does not replace Theorem 6.1, it organises repeated use of it. Every piece you end up with is a Theorem 6.1 problem, and the new work is entirely in locating the pieces.

26. Reading Theorem 6.2 piece by piece

Notation

Annotate

On: \( A = \int_a^b \left|f(x) - g(x)\right|dx = \int_a^c (g - f)\,dx + \int_c^b (f - g)\,dx \)

  • Distance between the curves: positive whichever one is higher. No hypothesis f ≥ g is needed.
  • A crossing inside [a, b], found by solving f(x) = g(x). The absolute value changes formula there.
  • On this piece g is the roof, so the distance is g minus f.
  • On this piece f is the roof. Each piece is an ordinary Theorem 6.1 integral.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 543 — Theorem 6.2

Read this annotation set as a translation from a statement you cannot compute into two integrals you can. The left-hand side is the honest definition; the right-hand side is what you actually write down.

The first annotation is the reason the absolute value is there at all. It converts a difference, which has a sign, into a distance, which does not, and that is what lets one formula cover both sides of a crossing without any hypothesis about which curve is higher.

The second annotation is where all the work is. Finding the crossing inside the interval is what turns the theorem into two integrals, and if you miss one, you get a confidently wrong number rather than an error message. Solve for every crossing and then check which of them lie strictly inside your interval.

The last two annotations show the two pieces with their curves the right way round, and notice that they are in opposite orders. That is the whole content of the split: each piece subtracts its own lower curve. If you write the same order on both pieces, one of them comes out negative and the total is too small.

27. Why one integral of the difference falls short

Concept

Figure (svg): The height function sine x minus cosine x from 0 to pi, negative from 0 to pi over 4 (shaded red, area about 0.414) and positive from pi over 4 to pi (shaded green, area about 2.414).

One integral of the difference adds the green and subtracts the red: 2.414 minus 0.414 is 2, not the area 2.828.

Integrating the signed difference across a crossing counts the piece where the curves are the wrong way round as negative, and subtracts it.

\[ \int_0^{\pi}(\sin x - \cos x)\,dx = 2.414 - 0.414 = 2 \]

\[ \int_0^{\pi}\left|\sin x - \cos x\right|dx = 2.414 + 0.414 = 2.828 \]

This is Chapter 5's net area against total area again, with the difference of two curves playing the part of one curve.

The figure here is not the two curves; it is their signed difference, and that change of viewpoint is what makes the problem obvious. The difference dips below zero on the short stretch before the crossing and rises above it afterwards, and a definite integral treats those two regions with opposite signs.

Put the two numbers side by side. The positive part is about two and four tenths and the negative part about four tenths. A single integral gives their difference, close to two. The area you were asked for is their sum, about two and eight tenths. The gap between those answers is twice the small piece, and it is not a rounding error.

This is the same distinction as net area against total area from Chapter 5, and it may help to say so explicitly. There, one curve and the axis; here, two curves. The mechanism is identical: wherever the integrand changes sign, an integral cancels rather than accumulates.

The practical warning is that nothing goes wrong visibly. The wrong integral is easy, clean and gives a tidy answer of exactly two. Only knowing to look for the crossing protects you.

28. Example 6.3: sine and cosine on [0, pi]

Worked example

Find the area of the region between the two curves over the interval from 0 to pi.

\[ f(x) = \sin x, \quad g(x) = \cos x, \quad [0, \pi] \]

Find the crossing

Why: Divide by cosine, which is not zero where the two are equal.

\[ \sin x = \cos x \iff \tan x = 1 \iff x = \frac{\pi}{4} \]

Find the roof on the left piece

Why: At 0, cosine is 1 and sine is 0.

\[ x \in \left[0, \tfrac{\pi}{4}\right]: \quad \cos x \ge \sin x \]

Find the roof on the right piece

Why: At pi over 2, sine is 1 and cosine is 0.

\[ x \in \left[\tfrac{\pi}{4}, \pi\right]: \quad \sin x \ge \cos x \]

Split the absolute value

Why: Each piece gets its own top minus bottom.

\[ A = \int_0^{\pi/4}(\cos x - \sin x)\,dx + \int_{\pi/4}^{\pi}(\sin x - \cos x)\,dx \]

Evaluate the first piece

Why: Antiderivative sine plus cosine.

\[ \left[\sin x + \cos x\right]_0^{\pi/4} = \sqrt2 - 1 \]

Evaluate the second piece

Why: Antiderivative minus cosine minus sine; at pi it is 1, at pi over 4 it is minus root 2.

\[ \left[-\cos x - \sin x\right]_{\pi/4}^{\pi} = 1 + \sqrt2 \]

Add the pieces

Why: Both are positive, as areas must be.

\[ A = (\sqrt2 - 1) + (1 + \sqrt2) = 2\sqrt2 \approx 2.828 \]

Check against the unsplit integral

Why: The single integral of sine minus cosine is 2: the area minus twice the small piece, exactly as the cancellation predicts.

\[ \int_0^{\pi}(\sin x - \cos x)\,dx = 2 = 2\sqrt2 - 2(\sqrt2 - 1) \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, pp. 543-544 — Example 6.3

The first step is the one to learn. Rather than guessing where these two curves meet, divide through by the cosine and turn the equation into one about the tangent, which you can solve exactly. Dividing is safe here because the cosine cannot be zero at a point where the two functions are equal, since the sine is not zero there.

The next two steps find the roof on each piece, and they cost almost nothing: evaluate both functions at a convenient point in each piece. At zero the cosine is one and the sine is zero; at a quarter turn the sine is one and the cosine is zero. Two test points, two roofs, done.

Then the split, and notice that the two integrals have their curves in opposite orders. That is not bookkeeping fussiness, it is the whole reason for splitting. Each piece must subtract whichever curve is underneath on that piece.

Both pieces come out positive, as areas must, and they are wildly different sizes: the left one is about four tenths, the right one about two and four tenths. The check is the nicest part. Take the area and subtract twice the small piece, and you get exactly the two that the unsplit integral gave, which confirms both answers at once.

29. Checkpoint 6.3: sine and cosine on [pi/2, 2pi]

Worked example

\[ f(x) = \sin x, \quad g(x) = \cos x, \quad \left[\tfrac{\pi}{2}, 2\pi\right] \]

Find the crossing inside the interval

Why: Tangent equals 1 at pi over 4 and 5 pi over 4; only the second is inside.

\[ \tan x = 1, \; x \in \left[\tfrac{\pi}{2}, 2\pi\right] \;\Longrightarrow\; x = \frac{5\pi}{4} \]

Find each roof

Why: At pi, sine is 0 and cosine is minus 1; at 3 pi over 2, cosine is 0 and sine is minus 1.

\[ \sin x \ge \cos x \text{ on } \left[\tfrac{\pi}{2}, \tfrac{5\pi}{4}\right], \quad \cos x \ge \sin x \text{ on } \left[\tfrac{5\pi}{4}, 2\pi\right] \]

First piece

Why: Minus cosine minus sine is root 2 at 5 pi over 4 and minus 1 at pi over 2.

\[ \int_{\pi/2}^{5\pi/4}(\sin x - \cos x)\,dx = \sqrt2 - (-1) = 1 + \sqrt2 \]

Second piece

Why: Sine plus cosine is 1 at 2 pi and minus root 2 at 5 pi over 4.

\[ \int_{5\pi/4}^{2\pi}(\cos x - \sin x)\,dx = 1 - (-\sqrt2) = 1 + \sqrt2 \]

Add

Why: Two equal pieces.

\[ A = 2 + 2\sqrt2 \approx 4.828 \]

Figure (svg): The curves y equals sine x and y equals cosine x from pi over 2 to 2 pi, crossing at 5 pi over 4. Left of the crossing the sine is on top; right of it the cosine is. Both pieces are shaded.

Two pieces of exactly equal area on opposite sides of the crossing. In a single integral of sine minus cosine they cancel to zero.

Check numerically

Why: A midpoint sum of the absolute difference with 1000 strips gives 4.8284, matching to four decimals.

\[ M_{1000} \approx 4.8284 \approx 2 + 2\sqrt2 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 544 — Checkpoint 6.3

Try this one before reading it, and be especially careful with the first step. The tangent equals one at infinitely many places, and only one of them lies in this interval. Writing down the general solution and then filtering it is safer than trying to spot the right one.

The second step needs test points that lie in the correct pieces, and both of the ones chosen give negative values for the functions. That is fine and it is worth getting comfortable with. The question is never whether a function is positive, only which of the two is larger, and minus one is larger than minus the square root of two.

Now look at the figure and the two labels on it. The two pieces have exactly the same area, which you can see from the symmetry of the picture about the crossing. That symmetry is also the trap: in a single unsplit integral these two equal pieces cancel perfectly and give zero.

The check is a fine-grained numerical sum, and matching to four decimal places is strong evidence. Note that this check integrates the distance, not the difference, which is precisely what makes it an independent test of the split rather than a repeat of it.

30. Trap: the absolute value outside the integral

Trap

The trap

For Checkpoint 6.3, taking the absolute value of the answer rather than of the integrand:

\[ A = \left|\int_{\pi/2}^{2\pi}(\sin x - \cos x)\,dx\right| \]

\[ = |0| = 0 \]

Wrong. A region you can see has area zero.

The fix

The absolute value belongs on the height of each strip, before anything is added. Taking it at the end only fixes the sign of a total in which the pieces have already cancelled.

\[ \int_a^b \left|f - g\right|dx \]

\[ \ne \left|\int_a^b (f - g)\,dx\right| \]

\[ A = (1 + \sqrt2) + (1 + \sqrt2) \]

\[ = 2 + 2\sqrt2 \]

Read the left-hand column and ask yourself why anybody would write it. The answer is that it looks like an entirely reasonable instinct: areas are positive, so take the absolute value at the end and the sign problem goes away. On many problems that even gives the right number, which is what makes the habit so durable.

Here it fails spectacularly, and the failure is instructive. The two pieces are exactly equal in size and opposite in sign, so they cancel completely and the integral is zero. Taking the absolute value of zero gives zero, and you have just claimed that a region you can see on the screen has no area.

The point is one of timing. The absolute value belongs on the height of each strip, before any adding happens, so that no strip can ever be counted as negative. Applied at the end, it can only correct the sign of a total in which the damage was already done.

The two expressions in the correction column are genuinely different objects, and the inequality between them is worth remembering as a fact in its own right. The integral of a distance is never smaller than the size of the integral of the difference, and they are equal only when no crossing occurs inside the interval.

31. One integral, or a split?

Sorting

Sort into buckets

Integrating in x, does each region need to be split into more than one integral?

One integral
y = 2x and y = x², between where they meet; y = x² − 3 and y = 1 (mostly below the axis); y = x + 4 and y = 3 − x/2 on [1, 4]
Must split
y = x and y = x³ on [−1, 1]; y = sin x and y = cos x on [0, π]; under y = x² and y = 2 − x, above the x-axis (Example 6.4)
one
The same curve is the roof and the same curve is the floor all the way across. Crossing the x-axis, as the fourth region does, never forces a split; meeting at the endpoints is how the edges are found.
split
Somewhere strictly inside the interval the roof or the floor changes formula: x and x³ swap at 0, sine and cosine swap at π/4, and in Example 6.4 the roof changes from x² to 2 − x at x = 1.

Sort these by asking one question about each: does either end of a vertical strip move onto a different curve somewhere strictly inside the interval. That is the only thing that forces a split, and the question is answerable from a sketch in a few seconds.

The fourth region is the one designed to catch you. It lies mostly below the x-axis, which every instinct from Chapter 5 says should mean splitting, and it needs a single integral. The line is the roof and the parabola is the floor from one end to the other, and the axis is not a boundary at all.

The second and third need splitting because the curves genuinely swap. The line and the cubic trade places at the origin, and the sine and cosine trade places a quarter of the way along. In both cases the roof changes owner, so one formula cannot describe both pieces.

The fifth is the subtle one, and it is the case Part 4 is built around. The two curves do not cross inside the region at all; instead the region's own upper boundary switches from the parabola to the line at their meeting point. A split can be forced by the shape of the region, not only by a crossing.

32. A sign chart of the difference finds the pieces

Concept

To split correctly you need every crossing inside the interval and the roof on each piece. Both come from one object: the difference of the two functions, and where it changes sign.

\[ d(x) = f(x) - g(x): \quad d > 0 \Rightarrow f \text{ on top}, \quad d < 0 \Rightarrow g \text{ on top} \]

Figure (svg): A sign chart on the interval from minus 1 to 1 with a mark at 0. Row one, the factor x: negative then positive. Row two, the factor x squared minus x plus 2: positive throughout. Row three, the difference d of x: negative then positive, so the parabola is on top on the left and the cubic on the right.

The difference changes sign only at 0, because the quadratic factor is never zero. One interior crossing means exactly two pieces.

Factor the difference, mark its zeros on a number line, and test one point in each piece. Each piece then contributes an ordinary top-minus-bottom integral, and the area is their sum.

\[ A = \sum_{\text{pieces}} \int_{c_{k-1}}^{c_k} \left|d(x)\right|dx \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 543 — Theorem 6.2 in practice

This slide turns the split into a routine, and the routine is worth adopting because it finds the crossings and the roofs in one pass rather than two. Build a single function, the difference of the two, and study where it changes sign.

The chart in the middle is read a row at a time. Factor the difference, give each factor a row, mark the sign of that factor on each side of its zero, and multiply down the column. The bottom row is the sign of the difference itself, and wherever it is positive the first curve is the roof.

Look at the second row, which is positive everywhere. That factor has no real zeros, so it can never change sign, and it therefore cannot create a crossing. Recognising a factor that is never zero saves you from splitting at a place where nothing happens, and it also tells you how many pieces to expect before you do any integrating.

The two test values printed underneath are the confirmation step, and you should always do it. A sign chart built from factors is easy to get right, but a single numerical check on each piece costs almost nothing and catches a reversed sign immediately.

33. Exercise 17: a cubic and a parabola that swap once

Worked example

\[ y = x^3 \quad\text{and}\quad y = x^2 - 2x \quad \text{on } [-1, 1] \]

Set the curves equal

Why: Collect everything on one side.

\[ x^3 - x^2 + 2x = 0 \iff x\left(x^2 - x + 2\right) = 0 \]

Solve

Why: The quadratic factor has discriminant 1 minus 8, which is negative, so its roots are not real.

\[ x = 0 \text{ is the only crossing} \]

Find the roof on each side

Why: Test minus one half and one half.

\[ x = -\tfrac12: \; -0.125 < 1.25, \qquad x = \tfrac12: \; 0.125 > -0.75 \]

Left piece: parabola on top

Why: Antiderivative, then evaluate from minus 1 to 0.

\[ \int_{-1}^{0}\left(x^2 - 2x - x^3\right)dx = \left[\frac{x^3}{3} - x^2 - \frac{x^4}{4}\right]_{-1}^{0} = \frac{19}{12} \]

Right piece: cubic on top

Why: The same move on the other side.

\[ \int_{0}^{1}\left(x^3 - x^2 + 2x\right)dx = \frac14 - \frac13 + 1 = \frac{11}{12} \]

Add

Why: Thirty twelfths.

\[ A = \frac{19}{12} + \frac{11}{12} = \frac{5}{2} \]

Figure (svg): The cubic y equals x cubed and the parabola y equals x squared minus 2x from x equals minus 1 to 1, crossing only at the origin. Left of the origin the parabola is on top; right of it the cubic is.

One crossing inside the interval, so two integrals. The left piece is the larger one.

Check against the signed integral

Why: Without the split, the pieces subtract; a midpoint sum of the absolute gap with 1000 strips gives 2.5000.

\[ \int_{-1}^{1}\left(x^3 - x^2 + 2x\right)dx = \frac{11}{12} - \frac{19}{12} = -\frac23, \qquad M_{1000} \approx 2.5000 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 549 — Exercise 17

This is the first problem where finding the crossings takes real thought, so work slowly through the first two steps. Collecting everything on one side and factoring out an x leaves a quadratic, and the important observation is that the quadratic has no real roots.

Check the discriminant yourself rather than taking it on trust: one minus eight is negative, so that factor never vanishes. This is what the middle row of the sign chart on the previous slide was recording, and it means the origin is the only crossing in sight, let alone the only one inside the interval.

So there are exactly two pieces, and the two test points tell you which curve is the roof on each. On the left the parabola is well above the cubic; on the right the cubic has just overtaken it. Look at the figure to see how uneven the two pieces are: the left one is almost half again as large as the right one.

The check is the most valuable part of this example. The unsplit integral gives minus two thirds, which is not the area and is not even positive, and a fine numerical sum of the distance gives exactly two and a half. Seeing the wrong answer next to the right one is what makes the lesson stick.

34. Find the error: an area of zero

Error analysis

Figure (svg): The line y equals x and the cubic y equals x cubed from minus 1 to 1, crossing at minus 1, 0 and 1; two congruent regions are shaded, one on each side of the origin.

Two visible pieces of area one quarter each. Any calculation that reports zero has let them cancel.

Annotate

On: \( A = \int_{-1}^{1}\left(x - x^3\right)dx = \left[\frac{x^2}{2} - \frac{x^4}{4}\right]_{-1}^{1} = 0 \)

  • Correct: the integrand is odd and the interval is symmetric, so the integral really is 0.
  • The error. The line is on top only on [0, 1]; on [−1, 0] the cubic is higher, and this integrand is negative there.
  • The warning sign. A region that is visibly there cannot have area 0; the two quarter-unit pieces cancelled.
  • Split at 0: ∫ from −1 to 0 of (x³ − x) plus ∫ from 0 to 1 of (x − x³) = 1/4 + 1/4 = 1/2.

Look at the line of working before you open any annotation, and try to say which step is wrong. It is genuinely hard, because there is no arithmetic mistake anywhere in it. The antiderivative is right and the evaluation is right.

The fault is in the integrand, and it was fixed before the integration began. The line is the higher curve only on the right half of the interval; on the left half the cubic is higher, so on that half the expression being integrated is the negative of the strip height.

The figure tells you the price. There are two visible pieces of a quarter each, so the area is a half, and the calculation returned zero because the two pieces were counted with opposite signs. Symmetry, which usually helps, is what makes the cancellation exact here.

Take the warning sign seriously as a general rule. An area of zero for a region you can see is impossible, and so is a negative area. Whenever a top-minus-bottom integral returns zero or a negative number, the first thing to suspect is an unnoticed crossing, and the fix is always to split and add the pieces.

35. Break the endpoint test

Counterexample

Figure (svg): The parabola y equals x squared and the line y equals 1 from minus 2 to 2. At both endpoints the parabola is higher (4 against 1), yet between minus 1 and 1 the line is on top; the three pieces are shaded in two colours.

Testing only the endpoints misses the middle piece. The crossings at minus 1 and 1 are found by solving, not by looking at the ends.

Discussion prompt

Claim: if f(a) ≥ g(a) and f(b) ≥ g(b), then f is on top on all of [a, b], so one integral of f − g gives the area. Find a counterexample, and say what it costs you to believe the claim.

Try to build the counterexample yourself before revealing, because the claim is exactly the shortcut you will be tempted to take under time pressure. Checking the two endpoints feels like checking the region, and it is much quicker than solving an equation.

The example given is about as simple as it gets. A parabola and a horizontal line: at both ends of the interval the parabola is four and the line is one, so the endpoint test says the parabola is on top. In the middle of the interval the parabola is at zero and the line at one, so the test is simply wrong.

Look at the figure and count the pieces. There are three, the outer two with the parabola on top and the middle one with the line on top, and each has the same area. Believing the claim gives four thirds; the true area is four, so the error is a factor of three. That is not a near miss.

The lesson is narrow and worth stating precisely. Crossings are found by solving the equation that sets the two functions equal, and by nothing else. Endpoints tell you nothing about the interior, and a sketch is a good warning system but not a proof.

36. A region whose roof changes at a corner

Picture it

Figure (svg): The region under y equals x squared from 0 to 1 and under y equals 2 minus x from 1 to 2, above the x-axis. A dashed line at x equals 1 splits it; a strip on the left reaches the parabola, a strip on the right reaches the line.

A vertical strip left of x equal to 1 is capped by the parabola; right of it, by the line. Two roofs, two integrals.

Here the curves do not cross inside the region; instead the region's roof is made of two different curves, the parabola up to x equal to 1 and the line after it, with the x-axis as the floor throughout. A single top-minus-bottom formula cannot describe both halves.

Spend a moment on why this figure is different from every region so far, because it is easy to file it under curves that cross and miss the point. These two curves do cross, at the dashed line, but the crossing is not inside the region; it is a corner of the region.

Follow the two highlighted strips. The left one stands on the x-axis and reaches up to the parabola. The right one stands on the same axis and reaches up to the line. The floor never changes, but the roof hands over from one curve to the other, and no single formula describes both strips.

So a split is forced, and it is forced by the shape of the region rather than by any cancellation of signs. There is nothing negative anywhere in this problem and nothing would come out wrong in sign; you simply cannot write the height of a general strip with one expression.

This is the case that motivates all of Part 4. If you turn the picture on its side, the left boundary is one curve all the way up and the right boundary is one curve all the way up, and the split disappears. Keep that in mind as you work through the two integrals.

37. Example 6.4: two roofs, one floor

Worked example

Find the area of the region bounded by the parabola, the line and the x-axis in Figure 6.7.

\[ y = x^2, \quad y = 2 - x, \quad y = 0 \]

Find where the roof changes

Why: Set the parabola equal to the line.

\[ x^2 = 2 - x \iff x^2 + x - 2 = 0 \iff (x+2)(x-1) = 0 \]

Keep the root that belongs to the region

Why: The region is in the first quadrant, so minus 2 is discarded; the line meets the axis at 2.

\[ x = 1, \qquad 2 - x = 0 \iff x = 2 \]

First piece: parabola over the axis

Why: From 0 to 1.

\[ A_1 = \int_0^1 x^2\,dx = \left[\frac{x^3}{3}\right]_0^1 = \frac13 \]

Second piece: line over the axis

Why: From 1 to 2.

\[ A_2 = \int_1^2 (2 - x)\,dx = \left[2x - \frac{x^2}{2}\right]_1^2 = 2 - \frac32 = \frac12 \]

Add

Why: Common denominator six.

\[ A = \frac13 + \frac12 = \frac56 \]

Check the second piece as a triangle

Why: It is a right triangle with legs 1 and 1, so its area must be one half, and it is.

\[ \tfrac12 \cdot 1 \cdot 1 = \tfrac12 = A_2 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, pp. 544-545 — Example 6.4

Start by identifying what the three given equations do. Two of them are the roofs and the third, the x-axis, is the floor for the whole region. Three boundary curves and a corner is the signature of a problem that needs splitting.

The first two steps look for x-values and find three candidates, of which one is discarded. Be clear about why. Setting the parabola equal to the line gives two solutions, but only one of them is a corner of this region; the other is off to the left where the region does not reach. Always check a solved root against your sketch before using it as a limit.

Then two ordinary Chapter 5 integrals, because with the axis as the floor the strip heights are just function values. Notice how small both pieces are, a third and a half, and how the second is larger despite the line being lower: it is twice as wide.

The check is almost free and you should always take it when it is available. The second piece is a right triangle with legs of one, so its area must be a half, and it is. Any part of a region bounded only by straight lines can be checked this way.

38. Checkpoint 6.4: a root curve meets a line

Worked example

The region lies above the x-axis, under the square root curve up to where it meets the line, then under the line.

\[ f(x) = \sqrt{x}, \quad g(x) = \frac32 - \frac{x}{2} \]

Find where the roof changes

Why: Multiply by 2, then set s equal to the square root of x.

\[ 2\sqrt{x} = 3 - x \iff s^2 + 2s - 3 = 0 \iff (s+3)(s-1) = 0 \]

Keep the valid root

Why: A square root is not negative, so s is 1 and x is 1; the line meets the axis at 3.

\[ s = 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 1, \qquad g(3) = 0 \]

First piece: root curve over the axis

Why: Power rule with exponent one half.

\[ A_1 = \int_0^1 x^{1/2}\,dx = \left[\frac23 x^{3/2}\right]_0^1 = \frac23 \]

Second piece: line over the axis

Why: From 1 to 3.

\[ A_2 = \int_1^3 \left(\frac32 - \frac{x}{2}\right)dx = \left[\frac{3x}{2} - \frac{x^2}{4}\right]_1^3 = \frac94 - \frac54 = 1 \]

Add

Why: Two thirds plus one.

\[ A = \frac23 + 1 = \frac53 \]

Figure (svg): The region above the x-axis bounded by y equals square root of x from 0 to 1 and by the line y equals 3 over 2 minus x over 2 from 1 to 3; the curves meet at (1, 1).

The same shape of problem as Example 6.4: a curved roof that hands over to a straight one at x equal to 1.

Check the second piece as a triangle

Why: Base from 1 to 3, height 1 at x equal to 1.

\[ \tfrac12 \cdot 2 \cdot 1 = 1 = A_2 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 545 — Checkpoint 6.4

This is Example 6.4 with a square root in place of the parabola, so try it before reading. The structure is identical: a curved roof, then a straight roof, with the x-axis as floor throughout.

The first step has a genuine technique in it. An equation with a square root and a plain x is not a quadratic, but it becomes one the moment you name the square root as a new variable. Then it factors, and the two roots are easy.

Discarding the negative root is not optional bookkeeping. A square root is never negative, so that root corresponds to no point at all, and if you carried it forward you would be integrating over an interval that does not exist. Getting into the habit of checking substituted roots against the meaning of the substitution will serve you in every later chapter.

The second piece is again a triangle, with base two and height one, which confirms the value of one exactly. Add the two pieces and the answer is five thirds. Hold on to that number, because Checkpoint 6.5 will get it from a single integral and the agreement is the point of the comparison.

39. Integrating with respect to y

Section

Part 4

40. Read the boundaries as functions of y

Concept

Example 6.4 needed two integrals because its roof changed formula. Turn the picture on its side: each boundary curve can be solved for x instead.

\[ y = x^2, \; x \ge 0 \quad\Longrightarrow\quad x = \sqrt{y} \]

\[ y = 2 - x \quad\Longrightarrow\quad x = 2 - y \]

Now the region has a single left edge, the root curve, and a single right edge, the line, for every height y from 0 up to the meeting point at height 1. The negative root is discarded because the region lies to the right of the y-axis.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 545 — Regions Defined with Respect to y

This is the pivot of the lesson, so read the slide slowly. The observation is that a curve does not care which variable you solve it for. The same parabola can be described as a height in terms of a horizontal position, or as a horizontal position in terms of a height, and the second description is sometimes far more convenient.

Do the two algebraic rearrangements yourself. Taking a square root and rearranging a linear equation are both routine, and the only subtlety is the choice of sign. The full solution of the first one has a plus-or-minus in front of the root, and you keep the positive branch because the region lies to the right of the vertical axis.

Now look at what the rearrangement bought. In the new description the region has exactly one left boundary and one right boundary, valid from the bottom of the region to the top. The corner that forced Example 6.4 into two integrals has stopped being a corner, because it is now a corner of the top edge rather than a change of roof.

The lesson generalises: a split is a property of the direction you slice in, not of the region itself. Change the direction and the split can vanish.

41. Horizontal strips: right minus left

Concept

Figure (svg): The Example 6.4 region cut into five horizontal rectangles, each running from the parabola x equals square root of y on the left to the line x equals 2 minus y on the right, for y from 0 to 1.

Every horizontal strip has the same two ends: the parabola on the left, the line on the right. One formula, one integral.

Partition the y-interval from c to d and lay each rectangle sideways, from the left curve to the right curve. Its length is right minus left and its thickness is the change in y.

\[ \Delta A_i = \left[u(y_i^*) - v(y_i^*)\right]\Delta y \]

\[ A = \lim_{n\to\infty}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\left[u(y_i^*) - v(y_i^*)\right]\Delta y = \int_c^d \left[u(y) - v(y)\right]dy \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 546 — Figures 6.8 and 6.9

Look at the figure and check one strip carefully before reading the formulas. Each rectangle lies on its side, starting on the curve on the left and ending on the line on the right, and every one of them has the same pair of boundaries. That is what a region with no split looks like.

The derivation on this slide is the Part 1 derivation with the words exchanged, and you should notice that rather than re-learn it. Height becomes length, top minus bottom becomes right minus left, width becomes thickness, and the sum is again a Riemann sum whose limit is a definite integral.

The one thing that genuinely changes is the variable. Sideways strips are stacked up the vertical axis, so the thickness is a change in height and every expression in the integral must be written in terms of height. Mixing the two variables in one integral is the most common failure here, and it is always visible: an integral with a horizontal variable inside and a vertical differential at the end cannot be right.

So there is no new theory in Part 4 at all, only a new orientation. If you understood Part 1, you already understand this, provided you are disciplined about the variable.

42. Reading Theorem 6.3 piece by piece

Notation

Annotate

On: \( u(y) \ge v(y) \text{ on } [c,d] \;\Longrightarrow\; A = \int_c^d \left[u(y) - v(y)\right]dy \)

  • The RIGHT boundary, written as x = u(y). Right plays the part that top played in Theorem 6.1.
  • The LEFT boundary, x = v(y). The length of a horizontal strip is right minus left.
  • Heights, not x-values: the bottom and top of the region, read off the y-axis or from the meeting points' y-coordinates.
  • Strips are stacked up the y-axis, so everything in the integral is written in y.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, pp. 546-547 — Theorem 6.3, equation 6.2

Work through these annotations and deliberately map each one onto its Theorem 6.1 counterpart. The right boundary plays the part the top boundary played, the left boundary plays the part the bottom one played, and the length of a strip is the difference of the two, exactly as its height was before.

The naming convention here catches people out, so fix it now. The letter that comes first alphabetically is the right boundary and the second is the left, which is the opposite of the way you might guess. What matters is not the letters but the subtraction: the farther-right boundary minus the farther-left one.

The limits deserve their own sentence. They are heights, and they come from the bottom and the top of the region. If a problem gives you the meeting points as coordinate pairs, you want the second number in each pair, and taking the first is by far the most frequent error in this part of the lesson.

The differential is the reminder that ties it together. Once you have committed to sideways strips, everything in the integral, the two boundary expressions and the two limits, has to be in terms of height. One stray horizontal coordinate makes the whole integral meaningless.

43. Example 6.5: Example 6.4 in one integral

Worked example

Find the area of the Example 6.4 region by integrating with respect to y.

Write both boundaries as functions of y

Why: The root curve is on the left, the line on the right.

\[ v(y) = \sqrt{y}, \qquad u(y) = 2 - y \]

Find the limits in y

Why: The floor is the x-axis, height 0; the curves meet at the point (1, 1), height 1.

\[ [c, d] = [0, 1] \]

Write right minus left

Why: Theorem 6.3.

\[ A = \int_0^1 \left[(2 - y) - \sqrt{y}\right]dy \]

Antidifferentiate

Why: The root is y to the one half.

\[ = \left[2y - \frac{y^2}{2} - \frac23 y^{3/2}\right]_0^1 \]

Evaluate

Why: Every term vanishes at 0.

\[ = 2 - \frac12 - \frac23 = \frac56 \]

Check against Example 6.4

Why: Same region, same area, one integral instead of two.

\[ \frac56 = \frac13 + \frac12 = A_1 + A_2 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 547 — Example 6.5 and Figure 6.10

This is the payoff for all of Part 4, and it is worth appreciating how little work it takes. The same region that needed two integrals now needs one, and nothing about the region changed; only the direction of slicing did.

The first step is the rearrangement, and it is where the thinking is. The curve on the left is the parabola, so its description in terms of height is a square root, and the curve on the right is the line, whose description is a simple subtraction. Once those are written down, the integral writes itself.

The limits are the step to be careful with. The bottom of the region is the x-axis at height zero and the top is the point where the two curves meet, which sits at height one. Notice that the horizontal coordinate of that meeting point is also one, which is a coincidence of these particular numbers and is exactly the sort of coincidence that hides an error. Ask where the number came from, not just what it is.

The check is the comparison with Example 6.4. Five sixths either way, from two integrals or from one, which confirms the new theorem and the old arithmetic simultaneously.

44. Checkpoint 6.5: Checkpoint 6.4 sideways

Worked example

Find the area of the Checkpoint 6.4 region by integrating with respect to y.

Solve the root curve for x

Why: Square both sides; x is not negative in the region.

\[ y = \sqrt{x} \;\Longrightarrow\; x = y^2 = v(y) \]

Solve the line for x

Why: Multiply by 2 and rearrange.

\[ y = \frac32 - \frac{x}{2} \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 3 - 2y = u(y) \]

Find the limits in y

Why: From the axis up to the meeting point (1, 1).

\[ [c, d] = [0, 1] \]

Integrate right minus left

Why: Power rule term by term.

\[ A = \int_0^1 \left(3 - 2y - y^2\right)dy = \left[3y - y^2 - \frac{y^3}{3}\right]_0^1 \]

Evaluate

Why: Three minus one minus one third.

\[ A = \frac53 \]

Figure (svg): The Checkpoint 6.4 region with one horizontal strip drawn at height y, running from the curve x equals y squared on the left to the line x equals 3 minus 2y on the right; y runs from 0 to 1.

Turned sideways, the region has one left edge and one right edge all the way from y equal to 0 up to y equal to 1.

Check against Checkpoint 6.4

Why: The x-integration gave two thirds plus one.

\[ \frac53 = \frac23 + 1 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 547 — Checkpoint 6.5

Try this before reading it; you have now seen the pattern twice and this is the chance to own it. Two rearrangements, two limits in terms of height, one integral.

The first rearrangement is the interesting one, because squaring both sides of an equation can create solutions that were not there. Here it does not cause trouble, because the region lies where both coordinates are positive, but notice that the square root curve and its sideways parabola are the same set of points only on that half of the plane.

Look at the figure and find the drawn strip with its label. Its length is the line's horizontal position minus the parabola's, and that expression is valid for every height from the bottom of the region to the top. Compare that with Checkpoint 6.4, where the roof changed partway across and no single expression worked.

The check is the comparison with the earlier answer: five thirds, reached before as two thirds plus one. Whenever you have solved a problem both ways, the agreement is worth more than either calculation on its own, because the two routes share almost no arithmetic.

45. Exercise 5: a sideways parabola and a vertical line

Worked example

Find the area between the curves by integrating over the y-axis.

\[ x = y^2 \quad\text{and}\quad x = 9 \]

Find where they meet

Why: Set the two x-values equal.

\[ y^2 = 9 \iff y = \pm 3 \]

Identify right and left

Why: At y equal to 0 the line is at 9 and the parabola at 0.

\[ u(y) = 9, \qquad v(y) = y^2 \]

Integrate right minus left

Why: Theorem 6.3 from minus 3 to 3.

\[ A = \int_{-3}^{3}\left(9 - y^2\right)dy = \left[9y - \frac{y^3}{3}\right]_{-3}^{3} \]

Evaluate

Why: Eighteen at the top, minus eighteen at the bottom.

\[ A = 18 - (-18) = 36 \]

Figure (svg): The sideways parabola x equals y squared opening to the right and the vertical line x equals 9, meeting at (9, 3) and (9, −3); the region between them is shaded with one horizontal strip highlighted.

Right edge always the line, left edge always the parabola: a horizontal strip at height y has length 9 minus y squared.

Check by integrating in x

Why: Vertical strips run from minus root x to root x, a height of two root x.

\[ \int_0^9 2\sqrt{x}\,dx = \left[\frac43 x^{3/2}\right]_0^9 = \frac43 \cdot 27 = 36 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 548 — Exercise 5

Read the two given equations carefully before doing anything. Both of them give a horizontal position in terms of something else, which is the strongest possible hint about how to slice. A boundary presented in that form is asking for sideways strips.

The first step sets the two horizontal positions equal, which gives two heights rather than two horizontal positions. That is the right kind of answer, and it is the point of the exercise. In this part of the lesson the limits of your integral are always heights.

Identifying right and left takes one test value, and zero is the convenient one. The line is at nine there and the parabola at zero, so the line is the right-hand boundary throughout, and the strip drawn in the figure confirms it: the shaded rectangle runs from the curve rightwards to the line.

The check integrates the same region the other way, and it is worth doing because it shows what you saved. Sliced vertically, each strip runs from the lower half of the parabola to the upper half, a length of twice a square root, so you get a fractional power instead of a polynomial. Same answer, slightly more awkward integrand, and one lucky escape from a split.

46. Trap: x-limits in a dy integral

Trap

The trap

Exercise 23's region, between the sideways parabola and the line, has corners at these two points. A tempting setup:

\[ x = y^2, \; x = y + 2 \]

\[ (1, -1), \; (4, 2) \]

\[ \int_1^4 \left(y + 2 - y^2\right)dy \]

Wrong. Those are the meeting points' x-coordinates.

The fix

In a dy integral every limit is a height. Read the y-coordinates of the meeting points, or solve the two x-expressions equal for y.

\[ y^2 = y + 2 \iff y = -1, \; y = 2 \]

\[ A = \int_{-1}^{2}\left(y + 2 - y^2\right)dy \]

Look at the left-hand column and notice how nearly right it is. The region is right, the boundaries are right, the integrand is right, and the differential is right. Only the two numbers on the integral sign are wrong.

They are wrong because they are horizontal coordinates. The meeting points have been found correctly as coordinate pairs, and then the first number of each pair has been carried into the integral, which is the natural thing to do after a whole chapter of slicing vertically. In a sideways integral you want the second number of each pair.

This error is hard to spot afterwards because the result is a perfectly ordinary-looking number. There is no sign problem, no absolute value, nothing negative, and if you did not already know the answer you would have no reason to be suspicious. That is exactly why the rule has to be applied at the moment of writing rather than checked at the end.

The correction shows the reliable route: set the two horizontal expressions equal and solve for height, so that the limits are produced in the right variable from the start. Then there is no pair of coordinates lying around to pick the wrong number from.

47. Choosing the variable

Section

Part 5

48. Count the formulas each strip meets

Concept

Before integrating, draw one vertical strip and one horizontal strip anywhere in the region, then slide each across. Every time an end of the strip moves onto a different curve, that direction needs another integral.

regionvertical strips (dx)horizontal strips (dy)
Example 6.4: x², 2 − x, axisroof changes at x = 1: 2 integralsalways √y to 2 − y: 1 integral
Example 6.2: parabola over linealways parabola over line: 1left edge changes at y = 8: 2

Pick the direction with fewer pieces, provided both boundaries can be solved for that variable.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 545 — the motivation for integrating with respect to y

This slide gives you a procedure for a decision you have so far been making by feel, and it is worth practising until it takes ten seconds. Draw one strip of each orientation anywhere in the region, then imagine sliding each one across the region from one side to the other.

What you are watching for is a moment when one end of the strip leaves one curve and lands on another. Every such moment is a split. Count them in each direction, add one, and you have the number of integrals that direction will cost you.

Read the table as two worked examples of exactly that count. The Example 6.4 region costs two integrals vertically and one sideways, which is why Part 4 existed. The Example 6.2 region is the other way round: one vertically, but two sideways, because above the parabola's vertex the left boundary switches from the line to the other branch of the parabola.

The final sentence carries the important caveat. Fewer pieces is only better if you can actually solve both boundaries for the variable you have chosen, and there are curves you cannot solve. Count the pieces, then check that the algebra is available, and only then commit.

49. One region, sliced two ways

Picture it

Figure (svg): Two copies of the region between the sideways parabola x equals y squared and the line x equals y plus 2. Left: vertical strips; a strip left of x equals 1 runs between the two halves of the parabola, a strip right of it runs from the line up to the parabola. Right: horizontal strips, every one running from the parabola to the line.

The same region, two ways to slice it. Vertical strips meet two different lower edges; horizontal strips always run parabola to line.

The region between the sideways parabola and the line x equal to y plus 2. Vertical strips hit the lower half of the parabola until x equal to 1 and the line after that. Horizontal strips always run from the parabola to the line.

Compare the two panels one strip at a time rather than as whole pictures. On the left, the two highlighted strips are in different parts of the region and they have genuinely different descriptions: the one on the far left runs from the bottom half of the parabola to the top half, while the one further right runs from the line up to the parabola.

That is a change of floor, not a change of roof, and it is easy to miss when you sketch quickly. The parabola opens sideways, so its lower branch is the floor for a while and then the line takes over at the point where the line crosses the parabola's lower branch.

Now look at the right-hand panel. Every sideways strip starts on the parabola and ends on the line, with no exceptions anywhere in the region, so one expression covers all of them and one integral finishes the problem.

The two captions summarise the trade in a sentence each, and the next two slides do both calculations in full so you can see the cost in arithmetic rather than just in the number of integrals. Keep in mind that both are correct; one is simply shorter.

50. Exercise 23 in y: one integral

Worked example

\[ y^2 = x \quad\text{and}\quad x = y + 2 \]

Find the meeting heights

Why: Set the two x-values equal.

\[ y^2 = y + 2 \iff (y-2)(y+1) = 0 \iff y = -1, \; y = 2 \]

Identify right and left

Why: At y equal to 0 the line is at 2 and the parabola at 0.

\[ u(y) = y + 2, \qquad v(y) = y^2 \]

Integrate right minus left

Why: Theorem 6.3.

\[ A = \int_{-1}^{2}\left(y + 2 - y^2\right)dy = \left[\frac{y^2}{2} + 2y - \frac{y^3}{3}\right]_{-1}^{2} \]

Evaluate

Why: Ten thirds at the top, minus seven sixths at the bottom.

\[ A = \frac{10}{3} - \left(-\frac{7}{6}\right) = \frac{27}{6} = \frac92 \]

Check with the shortcut

Why: Leading coefficient 1 in y, zeros three apart.

\[ \frac{1 \cdot 3^3}{6} = \frac{27}{6} = \frac92 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 549 — Exercise 23

This is the easy direction, and the first step is what makes it easy. Setting the two horizontal expressions equal produces a quadratic in height directly, so the limits arrive already in the variable you need and there is no chance of importing the wrong coordinate.

Identifying right and left takes one test value at height zero, where the line is at two and the parabola at zero. Notice that the parabola's vertex is at the origin, so the parabola is the left boundary from the bottom of the region to the top, without exception.

The integration is a plain polynomial in three terms, and the only place to be careful is the lower limit, where the odd powers change sign and the even one does not. Write out the value at each limit separately before subtracting; doing it in your head is how the seven sixths turns into a minus seven sixths.

The check uses the parabola-and-line shortcut from Part 2, and it is legitimate here even though the roles of the variables are swapped, because the gap is still a quadratic with a leading coefficient of one and two known zeros. Three cubed over six is nine halves, which is a pleasant confirmation for almost no work.

51. Exercise 23 in x: the same area in two pieces

Worked example

Now integrate the same region with respect to x, to see what the choice of variable saves.

Solve both boundaries for y

Why: The parabola has two halves.

\[ y = \pm\sqrt{x}, \qquad y = x - 2 \]

Left piece: between the halves of the parabola

Why: For x from 0 to 1, the strip runs from minus root x to root x.

\[ A_1 = \int_0^1 2\sqrt{x}\,dx = \frac43 \]

Right piece: from the line up to the parabola

Why: For x from 1 to 4.

\[ A_2 = \int_1^4 \left(\sqrt{x} - x + 2\right)dx = \left[\frac23 x^{3/2} - \frac{x^2}{2} + 2x\right]_1^4 \]

Evaluate the right piece

Why: Sixteen thirds at 4, thirteen sixths at 1.

\[ A_2 = \frac{16}{3} - \frac{13}{6} = \frac{19}{6} \]

Add

Why: Eight sixths plus nineteen sixths.

\[ A = \frac{8}{6} + \frac{19}{6} = \frac{27}{6} = \frac92 \]

Check against the y-integration

Why: The same number, as it must be, from two integrals and a square root instead of one polynomial.

\[ A_1 + A_2 = \frac92 = \int_{-1}^{2}\left(y + 2 - y^2\right)dy \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 549 — Exercise 23

This slide exists to make the cost concrete, so compare it line by line with the previous one rather than reading it on its own. Same region, same answer, and roughly twice the work.

The first step already shows where the trouble comes from. Solving the sideways parabola for height needs a plus-or-minus, which is to say it is not a function at all: each horizontal position between zero and one has two heights on the curve. That is why the left piece runs from one branch to the other and has a strip height of twice a square root.

The second piece has a different floor, the line, and a fractional-power integrand, and the evaluation involves sixths against thirds. None of it is hard, but there are about twice as many chances to slip, and the whole of that extra exposure was avoidable.

The check is that the two pieces add to the same nine halves the single sideways integral gave. When two genuinely different routes agree, you can stop worrying about arithmetic and start thinking about which route you should have taken. Here the answer is obvious, and the point of doing both is so that it will be obvious next time before you start.

52. How many integrals each way?

Comparison

Comparison matrix

regionintegrals in dxintegrals in dy
under x² and 2 − x, above the axis21
x = y² and x = y + 221
y = 9 − (x/2)² over y = 6 − x12
x + 4 over 3 − x/2 on [1, 4]13
x = y² and x = 911

Fill in every blank before checking, and fill them in by counting rather than by remembering. For each region, picture a strip of the given orientation sliding across, and count the places where an end of it changes curve.

The last row is the one worth studying, because three is a surprising answer for a region that takes a single integral the other way. It is the trapezoid from Example 6.1. Sliced sideways, a low strip runs from the falling line across to the right edge, a middle strip runs from the left edge across to the right edge, and a high strip runs from the rising line across to the right edge. Three descriptions, three integrals.

Notice what caused that. The left and right edges of the region are vertical lines, and a vertical line is a perfectly good left or right boundary for sideways strips but a terrible top or bottom. Given vertical boundary lines, slice vertically.

The row with a one in both columns is the useful counterexample to any rule of thumb. Sometimes neither direction needs splitting, and then you choose on the strength of the integrand instead: a polynomial beats a square root.

53. Exercise 55: a parabola opening sideways

Worked example

Find the area between the curves. Solved for y the parabola needs two branches, so integrate in y.

\[ x = y^2 - 2 \quad\text{and}\quad x = 2y \]

Find the meeting heights

Why: Quadratic formula.

\[ y^2 - 2 = 2y \iff y^2 - 2y - 2 = 0 \iff y = 1 \pm \sqrt3 \]

Identify right and left

Why: At y equal to 1 the line is at 2 and the parabola at minus 1.

\[ u(y) = 2y, \qquad v(y) = y^2 - 2 \]

Complete the square in right minus left

Why: This centres the integrand on y equal to 1.

\[ 2y - (y^2 - 2) = 3 - (y - 1)^2 \]

Shift the variable

Why: Let w equal y minus 1; the limits become minus root 3 and root 3.

\[ A = \int_{-\sqrt3}^{\sqrt3}\left(3 - w^2\right)dw \]

Integrate over the symmetric interval

Why: Twice the integral from 0.

\[ A = 2\left[3w - \frac{w^3}{3}\right]_0^{\sqrt3} = 2\left(3\sqrt3 - \sqrt3\right) = 4\sqrt3 \]

Figure (svg): The sideways parabola x equals y squared minus 2 with vertex at (−2, 0) and the line x equals 2y, meeting where y equals 1 minus root 3 and 1 plus root 3; the region between them is shaded.

Solved for x, both boundaries are simple in y. Solved for y, the parabola needs a plus-or-minus root and the bottom edge changes formula.

Check with the shortcut and numerically

Why: Zeros two root 3 apart, leading coefficient 1; both give 6.928.

\[ \frac{(2\sqrt3)^3}{6} = \frac{24\sqrt3}{6} = 4\sqrt3 \approx 6.928 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 550 — Exercise 55

Read the opening sentence as the decision it is. The parabola opens sideways, so solving it for height would need two branches, and that alone settles the direction of slicing before any algebra happens.

The meeting heights come from a quadratic that does not factor, so the quadratic formula is the tool and the answers are irrational. Do not be put off by that: irrational limits are no harder to substitute than whole numbers, and here they are about to become much more pleasant.

The completing-the-square step is the elegant part of this example and it is worth learning as a general move. The integrand is a downward parabola in the height, and completing the square recentres it on its peak. Shifting the variable then makes the limits symmetric about zero, so you can integrate half the region and double, and the awkward roots do most of their cancelling automatically.

The check is two checks in one. The parabola-and-line shortcut gives four times the square root of three from the leading coefficient and the distance between the roots, and the decimal value confirms it numerically. Notice how far apart those roots are, about three and a half, which is why an unassuming-looking region has an area near seven.

54. Match each region to its best setup

Matching

Match the pairs

  • a. y = x² and y = x + 2
  • b. x = y² and x = y + 2
  • c. y = sin x and y = cos x on [0, π]
  • d. x = y² − 2 and x = 2y
  • w. dx, one integral: (x + 2) − x² from −1 to 2
  • x. dy, one integral: (y + 2) − y² from −1 to 2
  • y. dx, split at the crossing x = π/4
  • z. dy, one integral: 2y − (y² − 2) from 1 − √3 to 1 + √3

Why: The first two look alike and are mirror images: in the first, x is the free variable and vertical strips need one formula; in the second, y is. Sine and cosine cannot be solved for x in any useful way, so x it is, with a split. The sideways parabola wants dy for the same reason as the second.

Do the matching from the shape of each pair of equations rather than by working the problems, because that is the skill this slide is testing. The form a boundary is written in tells you a great deal about which variable to use.

The first two are mirror images of each other and they are placed together deliberately. In one, the parabola gives a height in terms of a horizontal position, so vertical strips need one formula. In the other, the roles are exchanged and sideways strips need one formula. The algebra is identical and only the orientation differs.

The third is the case where you have no choice. Neither the sine nor the cosine can usefully be solved for the horizontal position over this interval, so you slice vertically whether you like it or not and pay for it with a split at the crossing. Sometimes a split is not a failure of planning; it is the only route available.

The fourth is the previous slide's exercise, and it is here so that you can recognise the signature. Both boundaries given as horizontal positions, one of them a parabola opening sideways, limits that are heights. Once you can spot that pattern, the setup takes seconds.

55. Profit as an area between curves

Real world

Figure (svg): Marginal revenue, a falling line from 429 dollars, and marginal cost, a parabola starting at 229 dollars and dipping to 4 dollars before rising, for 0 to 260 phones; they meet at 200 phones, and the region between them from 0 to 200 is shaded.

While revenue per phone exceeds cost per phone, each extra phone adds profit. The shaded area is the profit accumulated up to the 200th phone.

Discussion prompt

Exercise 49: a factory's marginal cost is C(x) = 0.01x² − 3x + 229 dollars and its marginal revenue is R(x) = 429 − 2x dollars, for the xth phone. Find the area between the curves from x = 0 to where they meet, and say what it represents.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves §6.1, p. 550 — Exercise 49

Work this out before revealing, and treat it as an ordinary area problem, because that is all it is. Two curves, no interval given, so find where they meet and integrate the gap.

What is worth thinking about is the meaning of the gap. Each curve gives an amount of money per extra unit made, so the difference is the extra profit from one more unit, and a thin strip is that profit times a small number of units. Adding the strips accumulates the profit, which is why an area has units of money here rather than units of squared length.

The meeting point at two hundred is the economically interesting number, and the figure shows why. To its left the revenue curve is above the cost curve and every extra unit adds something; past it the cost curve is above and every extra unit loses money. Producing beyond that point reduces the total, which is a genuine conclusion rather than a formality.

Notice also what the answer does not include. The area gives the profit above fixed costs, because marginal cost is about the next unit only and says nothing about the cost of opening the factory. An area between curves gives you an accumulated change, never an absolute level.

56. Setting up reliably

Section

Part 6

57. Pattern: finding an area between curves

Pattern

Figure (svg): A flow diagram: sketch the region; solve the curves equal to find the crossings; choose vertical or horizontal strips; write top minus bottom or right minus left; split wherever a boundary formula changes; integrate each piece and add.

Seven moves, and only one of them is integration.
  1. Sketch the region and shade it; mark where each curve bounds it.
  2. Solve the curves equal to find every meeting point, including any inside the interval.
  3. Choose strips. Vertical strips mean dx and top minus bottom; horizontal strips mean dy and right minus left.
  4. Split wherever an end of the strip moves onto a different curve.
  5. Integrate each piece, add, and check: positive, plausible against a box, and equal both ways if you have time.

This is the order to work in, and the caption under the diagram is the honest summary: the integration is the easy part, and almost every lost mark is lost in the first four boxes.

The sketch comes first and it is not optional. It tells you how many meeting points to expect, which curve should be on top, whether the region has vertical edges, and whether any boundary changes formula. All four of those are hard to recover from algebra alone and obvious from a picture.

The two decisions in the middle are the ones worth slowing down for. Solve for every meeting point, then check which of them lie strictly inside your interval, because those are the ones that force splits. Then choose the direction of slicing by counting how many pieces each direction costs, and check that you can solve both boundaries for the variable you have chosen.

The last box is the one people skip, and it is cheap. Is the answer positive. Does it fit inside a box you can draw around the region. Does it agree with a triangle, a trapezoid, the parabola-and-line shortcut or a four-strip numerical sum. Every worked example in this lesson ended with one of those, and you should end yours the same way.

58. Put the setup in order

Ranking

Put in order

Order the steps for finding the area enclosed by y = x² and y = x + 2.

  1. Sketch the parabola and the line and shade the region
  2. Solve x² = x + 2 to get x = −1 and x = 2
  3. Test x = 0 to see that the line is on top
  4. Write the integral of (x + 2 − x²) from −1 to 2
  5. Evaluate to get 9/2 and compare with a bounding box

Why: The sketch comes first because it shows how many meeting points to expect and which curve should be on top; solving then pins down the edges, a test point confirms the roof, and only then is the integral written. The answer 9/2 sits well inside the 3 by 2.25 box around the region.

Drag the steps into order before checking, and pay attention to where you were tempted to put the test point. That is the step people move, usually to the end as an afterthought, and it belongs before the integral is written.

The reason the sketch has to be first is that it decides what the later steps are even looking for. Without it you do not know whether to expect two meeting points or four, whether the region has straight edges, or whether the answer should be a small number or a large one.

Solving and testing are two separate steps for a reason worth restating. Solving tells you where the edges are; testing tells you which curve is the roof between them. Neither answers the other's question, and a problem worked with one of them missing is exactly the kind that produces a clean, plausible, wrong answer.

The final step pairs the evaluation with a bounding-box check, and that pairing is the habit to leave this lesson with. An answer without a check is just the last thing you wrote down.

59. Check: setting up top minus bottom

Check

Check your understanding

Which integral gives the area of the region enclosed by y = 2x and y = x²?

  • A. ∫ from 0 to 2 of (2x − x²) dx (correct)
  • B. ∫ from 0 to 2 of (x² − 2x) dx
  • C. ∫ from 0 to 4 of (2x − x²) dx
  • D. ∫ from −2 to 2 of (2x − x²) dx

Answer: A

Why: The curves meet where 2x = x², at x = 0 and x = 2. At x = 1 the line is at 2 and the parabola at 1, so the line is on top: the area is the integral of 2x − x² from 0 to 2, which is 4/3.

Why B tempts people
Bottom minus top: this gives −4/3, the negative of the area.
Why C tempts people
4 is the y-coordinate of the second meeting point, (2, 4). In a dx integral the limits are x-values.
Why D tempts people
The curves do not meet at x = −2; between −2 and 0 the parabola is above the line, and this integral mixes a region that is not enclosed.

Work this out before looking at the options, because three of the four are there to catch a specific habit and you will learn more from noticing which one attracted you.

The curves meet at zero and at two, and at the midpoint the line is at two while the parabola is at one, so the line is the roof. That gives the line minus the parabola, integrated between those two horizontal positions, and the answer is four thirds.

The second option has the subtraction the wrong way round, which is the error that produces a negative answer. If you ever finish a top-minus-bottom integral and get a negative number, you have either reversed the curves or missed a crossing, and both are quick to check.

The third option uses four as the upper limit, and four is the height of the second meeting point rather than its horizontal position. That confusion is the single most common error in this whole lesson, and it is the mirror image of the trap slide in Part 4. The fourth option invents a meeting point that does not exist, which a sketch would have ruled out in a moment.

60. Check: curves that cross

Check

Check your understanding

What is the area between y = sin x and y = cos x on [π/2, 2π]?

  • A. 0
  • B. 2 + 2√2 (correct)
  • C. 1 + √2
  • D. 2√2

Answer: B

Why: The curves cross at 5π/4. Sine is on top before it and cosine after it, and each piece has area 1 + √2, so the total is 2 + 2√2 ≈ 4.83.

Why A tempts people
That is the signed integral of sin x − cos x over the whole interval: the two equal pieces cancel. Areas are added, not cancelled.
Why C tempts people
That is only one of the two pieces.
Why D tempts people
That is the area on [0, π] from Example 6.3, a different interval.

This is Checkpoint 6.3 again, so if you worked it earlier you should recognise the numbers. If you did not, the safe route is to find the crossing first and only then think about areas.

The crossing sits five eighths of the way round, with the sine curve above before it and the cosine curve above after it, and the two pieces happen to be the same size. Adding them gives the answer, which is a little under five.

The first option is the one to think hardest about. It is the value of the single unsplit integral, and it is zero precisely because the two equal pieces cancel. Anyone who set the problem up without looking for the crossing would get it, which is why it is the most instructive wrong answer on the slide.

The other two are size errors rather than method errors. One is a single piece, which you get by forgetting that there are two, and the other is the answer to Example 6.3 over a different interval, which you get by recalling instead of computing. Both are worth a moment: half an answer and somebody else's answer are the two ways a memorised number goes wrong.

61. Check: integrating in y

Check

Check your understanding

Which integral gives the area of the region between x = y² and x = 4?

  • A. ∫ from −2 to 2 of (4 − y²) dy (correct)
  • B. ∫ from 0 to 4 of (4 − y²) dy
  • C. ∫ from −2 to 2 of (y² − 4) dy
  • D. ∫ from 0 to 4 of √x dx

Answer: A

Why: The curves meet where y² = 4, at heights −2 and 2. The line x = 4 is on the right, so the strip length is 4 − y², and the area is 32/3.

Why B tempts people
0 and 4 are x-values. The limits of a dy integral are heights, here −2 and 2.
Why C tempts people
Left minus right: this gives −32/3.
Why D tempts people
This counts only the half of the region above the x-axis, 16/3.

Read the two given equations and let their form make the first decision for you. Both describe a horizontal position, so the strips are sideways, the differential is a change in height, and the limits must be heights.

That observation alone eliminates two options, which is worth noticing as a technique. You can often narrow a multiple-choice question to two candidates without computing anything, just by checking that the variable, the differential and the limits are consistent with one another.

The curves meet where the square of the height is four, so at heights of minus two and two, and at height zero the line is at four while the parabola is at zero. So the line is the right boundary and the strip length is four minus the square of the height.

The last option is the interesting distractor because it is not nonsense: it is a correct integral for the upper half of the region. If you chose it, you probably sketched only the part above the axis. This region is symmetric about the axis and both halves count, which is a reminder that a sideways parabola reaches both upwards and downwards.

62. Explain when a split is needed

Explain it to yourself

Discussion prompt

In Chapter 5 you split an integral wherever the curve crossed the x-axis. In this lesson, Exercise 1's region crossed the x-axis and needed no split, while Example 6.4's region needed one although no curves crossed. In two or three sentences, say what actually forces a split.

Write your two or three sentences down before revealing, and resist the temptation to write a rule about the x-axis. Being able to state this in your own words is worth more than any formula on the recap slide, because it is what tells you which formula to reach for.

The two examples in the prompt are chosen to break the obvious answers. Exercise 1's region sits mostly below the axis and takes one integral; Example 6.4's region sits entirely above the axis, has no crossing inside it, and takes two. So neither the axis nor a crossing is the real criterion.

The real criterion is about the strip. A split is needed exactly where one end of a sliding strip moves from one curve onto another. Crossings do that, because the roof and the floor trade places. A change of boundary does it too, as the roof did at the corner in Example 6.4. Nothing else does.

The axis fits that rule as an ordinary case rather than an exception. When the axis is one of the two boundaries, as it was throughout Chapter 5, a curve dipping below it swaps the roles and forces a split. When the axis is merely drawn on the page, it has no effect at all.

63. Exit ticket

Exit ticket

\[ y = x^2 - 2x \quad\text{and}\quad y = x \]

Discussion prompt

Find the area of the region enclosed by these curves. Part of the region lies below the x-axis: does that change your setup?

Work this end to end before revealing, and start by sketching. The parabola dips below the axis between zero and two and the line passes through the origin, so a good sketch takes about fifteen seconds and settles most of the problem.

The crossings come from a quadratic that factors after everything is collected on one side, giving zero and three. Then one test point, at a horizontal position of one, where the line is at one and the parabola at minus one. The line is the roof across the whole region, with no crossing inside, so one integral suffices.

Watch the subtraction when you form the gap. Subtracting the parabola turns its minus two x into a plus two x, so the gap is three x minus x squared and not negative x squared. That is the bracket trap from Part 1 in its final appearance, and it is worth checking your own line against it.

The second half of the question is the real assessment. Part of the region does lie below the axis and it changes nothing, because the axis is not a boundary here. If you split at zero and two, you did more work than the problem asked for and probably got the same answer, which is the best possible way to discover that you did not need to.

64. Recap

Recap

situationstripintegral
f on top of g on [a, b]vertical, height f − g∫ from a to b of (f − g) dx
no interval givenverticallimits where f(x) = g(x)
curves cross at c inside [a, b]height |f − g|split at c; each piece top minus bottom
u right of v for c ≤ y ≤ dhorizontal, length u − v∫ from c to d of (u − v) dy

\[ A = \int_a^b \left|f(x) - g(x)\right|dx \qquad A = \int_c^d \left[u(y) - v(y)\right]dy \]

Next, Section 6.2 slices solids the same way: a strip becomes a disc or a washer, and top minus bottom becomes the difference of two squared radii.

Stewart, Calculus: Early Transcendentals 8e, §6.1 Areas Between Curves §6.1, pp. 428-437 — the same material in Stewart

Read the table as four situations rather than four formulas, because the formula is always the same: integrate the distance between the two boundaries, in the direction perpendicular to your strips.

The first two rows are about where the limits come from, and there are only two answers. Either the problem hands them to you, or the curves meet and their meeting points supply them. Getting the limits from the wrong place, especially taking a coordinate from the wrong axis, is the most frequent single error in this material.

The third row is the one that costs the most marks when it is missed, because it fails silently. A crossing inside the interval means a single signed integral counts part of the area as negative, and the result can be too small, zero or negative without anything looking wrong. Solve for every crossing, split there, and add positive pieces.

The fourth row is the freedom you gained in Part 4. Slicing sideways is not a different theory, only a different orientation, and it can turn two integrals into one. Choose the direction by counting pieces, then check that you can solve both boundaries for the variable you picked.

Section 6.2 reuses all of this with one change. A strip becomes a slice of a solid, and the height of the strip becomes the area of that slice, so top minus bottom turns into a difference of two squared radii.

Sources

  1. OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §6.1 Areas between Curves — Strang & Herman, OpenStax / Rice University, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, pp. 540-550
  2. Stewart, Calculus: Early Transcendentals 8e, §6.1 Areas Between Curves — James Stewart, Cengage Learning, 2016, pp. 428-437

Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Calculus I — $55/session, free consultation.

Book on Wyzant · Text (657) 465-8108