4.10 Antiderivatives

Reversing differentiation: the general antiderivative and why the constant is essential, indefinite integral notation, the reversed power rule and the basic formulas, initial-value problems, and the family of vertically shifted curves sharing one derivative.

Subject: Calculus I · 68 slides · symbolic lesson

Open the interactive version of this deck

What this lesson covers

The lesson, slide by slide

1. Antiderivatives

Title

Calculus I · Section 4.10

Running differentiation backwards, and the constant that comes with it

2. What this lesson gives you

Objectives

Chapter 3 answered one question over and over: given a function, what is its derivative? This section asks the reverse, and the answer turns out to be a whole family of functions rather than one.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, pp. 419-430 — learning objectives 4.10.1 to 4.10.4

Everything in Chapter 3 was a machine that ran in one direction: put a function in, get its derivative out. This section runs the machine backwards. You are handed a derivative and asked what function it came from.

Two surprises are waiting. The first is that the answer is never a single function: there is always a whole family of them, and you will see exactly why and exactly how big that family is. The second is that, although finding an antiderivative can be hard, checking one is always easy, because checking just means differentiating, which you already know how to do.

By the end you will be able to reverse every derivative formula you know, integrate sums term by term, and use a single known point to pick out one function from the family. That last skill is how position is recovered from acceleration, which is the application the section is built around.

3. Before anything new: three derivatives

Warm-up

Discussion prompt

Without looking anything up, write the derivatives of x cubed, of sin x, and of ln x. Then answer: which function has derivative 3x²? Is there only one?

Write your three derivatives before revealing. These are the formulas this lesson will read backwards, so they need to be instant. If any of them took you more than a couple of seconds, it is worth a quick review of Sections 3.3, 3.5 and 3.9 before going on.

The second question is the whole lesson in miniature. You probably said x cubed, because the power rule turns x cubed into three x squared. But x cubed plus seven also works, and so does x cubed minus a million. Adding a constant never changes a derivative, because the derivative of a constant is zero.

So the honest answer to which function is: infinitely many, all differing by constants. Hold on to that, because the first part of the lesson proves there are no others.

4. Differentiation run backwards

Section

Part 1

5. Given the acceleration, find the position

Picture it

Figure (svg): Three boxes in a row: position s of t, velocity v of t, acceleration a of t. Arrows along the top point right, labelled differentiate. Arrows along the bottom point left, labelled antidifferentiate, and under them the extra facts needed: the starting velocity and the starting position.

Going forward is automatic. Going back is not: each backward step loses a constant, and a starting value has to put it back.

\[ v(t) = s'(t), \qquad a(t) = v'(t) = s''(t) \]

A phone's accelerometer measures acceleration, not position. To get velocity you need a function whose derivative is the acceleration; to get position, a function whose derivative is the velocity. Both are questions about reversing a derivative.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, pp. 419-420 — the rectilinear-motion motivation

Look at the diagram from left to right first. That is Chapter 3: differentiate position to get velocity, differentiate velocity to get acceleration. Each arrow is automatic, a rule applied.

Now read the bottom row, right to left. If an accelerometer tells you the acceleration at every moment, getting back to velocity means finding a function whose derivative is that acceleration. Getting from velocity to position is the same question again.

Notice the green notes under the bottom arrows. Going backwards loses something. Many different motions share the same acceleration: a car that started at rest and one that started at sixty miles per hour can brake identically. So each backward step will need one extra fact, a starting value. Part 5 of the lesson does exactly this calculation for a braking car.

6. The definition of an antiderivative

Concept

antiderivative — A function F is an antiderivative of f if the derivative of F equals f at every x in the domain of f.

\[ F'(x) = f(x) \quad \text{for all } x \text{ in the domain of } f \]

The definition gives you a way to test any claim: differentiate the candidate and compare. It gives you no way to find one. Finding comes from knowing your derivatives well enough to recognise them in reverse.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 420 — Definition

The definition is short, and it is worth noticing what kind of definition it is. It tells you how to recognise an antiderivative, not how to produce one. Given a candidate F, you differentiate it; if you get f back everywhere f is defined, F qualifies.

This asymmetry runs through the whole subject. Differentiation is mechanical: there are rules, and any function built from the usual pieces can be differentiated by applying them. Antidifferentiation has no such complete set of rules. For now you will find antiderivatives mostly by recognition, asking yourself which derivative you already know produces this function.

The good news is the flip side of that asymmetry: because checking is differentiation, you can always verify an answer, completely, in a line or two.

7. One antiderivative of 2x, then infinitely many

Concept

The power rule says x squared differentiates to 2x, so x squared is an antiderivative of 2x.

\[ \frac{d}{dx}\left(x^2\right) = 2x \]

But the derivative of a constant is zero, so adding a constant changes nothing:

\[ \frac{d}{dx}\left(x^2 + 5\right) = 2x, \qquad \frac{d}{dx}\left(x^2 - \sqrt2\right) = 2x \]

\[ \frac{d}{dx}\left(x^2 + C\right) = 2x + 0 = 2x \quad\text{for every constant } C \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 420 — the discussion after the definition

Start with the easy recognition. You know the power rule sends x squared to 2x, so x squared is an antiderivative of 2x. That is one.

Then ask whether there are more. Adding any constant to x squared leaves the derivative untouched, since the constant's derivative is zero. So x squared plus 5 works, and so does x squared minus the square root of 2, which is the book's own slightly odd choice, picked to make the point that the constant can be any real number at all, not just a whole number.

The last line packages all of these into one expression with a letter C standing for an arbitrary constant. The question the next two slides settle is whether this list is complete, or whether some antiderivative of 2x could look completely different.

8. A family of parallel parabolas

Picture it

Figure (svg): Five parabolas y equals x squared plus C, for C from minus 2 to 2, stacked vertically. At x equals 1 each has a short tangent segment, and all five segments are parallel with slope 2.

Every member has the same slope at every x, so every one is an antiderivative of 2x. Only the height differs, and the derivative cannot see height.

Every curve is the same parabola moved up or down. At any chosen x all of them have the same slope, which is why they all share the derivative 2x. The derivative measures slope and knows nothing about height.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 422 — Figure 4.85

This is Figure 4.85 of the book, with one addition: the yellow segments. Each is the tangent line at x equal to 1 on one member of the family. They are all parallel, all with slope 2, which is what 2x equals at x equal to 1.

Pick any other vertical line and the same thing happens: at every x, all five curves have the same slope. That is precisely what it means for them all to have the same derivative. A derivative measures steepness, and moving a curve straight up or down does not change its steepness anywhere.

So the derivative has thrown away one piece of information, the height. When you run the process backwards, that missing height shows up as the constant C. Keep this picture in mind whenever you are tempted to leave the constant off.

9. Why there are no others: Corollary 2 of the MVT

Concept

Could some antiderivative of 2x fail to be x squared plus a constant? Suppose G is any antiderivative of the same f as F on an interval.

\[ (G - F)'(x) = G'(x) - F'(x) = f(x) - f(x) = 0 \]

Section 4.4 proved, from the Mean Value Theorem, that a function whose derivative is zero on an interval is constant.

\[ G(x) - F(x) = C \;\Longrightarrow\; G(x) = F(x) + C \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 420 — Corollary 2 of the Mean Value Theorem

The family of vertical shifts is certainly made of antiderivatives. The real question is whether it contains all of them. Could there be some strange function, not a shifted parabola, whose derivative is also 2x?

The argument is two lines. Take any two antiderivatives of the same function. Their difference has derivative zero, because the two derivatives are equal and cancel. And Section 4.4 proved, using the Mean Value Theorem, that a function whose derivative is zero on an interval must be constant.

So any second antiderivative is the first one plus a constant. There is no strange function hiding anywhere. This is why the plus C is a complete answer rather than a vague gesture: it provably describes every antiderivative there is, as long as you are working on an interval.

10. Reading Theorem 4.14 piece by piece

Notation

Annotate

On: \( F' = f \text{ on } I \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{every antiderivative of } f \text{ on } I \text{ is } F(x) + C \)

  • You need just one antiderivative, found by any means: a guess, a table, a formula. The theorem does the rest.
  • An interval. The Mean Value Theorem needs an unbroken stretch of x; on a domain with a gap, each piece may get its own constant.
  • Part (ii): nothing is missed. No antiderivative exists outside the family.
  • Part (i): each constant gives a genuine antiderivative. The family is the most general antiderivative.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 420 — Theorem 4.14, general form of an antiderivative

Work through the annotations one at a time. The first says you only ever need to find one antiderivative. However you find it, by guessing, from a table, or by a clever rewrite, the theorem then hands you all the rest for free.

The words on an interval are easy to skip and they matter. The Mean Value Theorem needs an unbroken stretch of the number line. If the domain has a gap, as the domain of one over x does at zero, the argument cannot cross the gap, and each piece can carry its own constant. A later slide builds exactly such an example.

The last two annotations are the two halves of the theorem. Part one says every function of the form F plus C is an antiderivative. Part two says every antiderivative is of that form. Together they say the family is exactly right: nothing extra, nothing missing.

11. Is it an antiderivative of 2x?

Sorting

Sort into buckets

Differentiate each candidate. Which are antiderivatives of 2x, and which are not?

Yes: derivative is 2x
x² + 7; (x − 1)(x + 1); x² − π
No
(x + 1)²; 2x²; x² + x
yes
x² + 7 and x² − π differ from x² by a constant, and (x − 1)(x + 1) expands to x² − 1, another member of the family. All three differentiate to 2x.
no
(x + 1)² = x² + 2x + 1 differentiates to 2x + 2; 2x² gives 4x; x² + x gives 2x + 1. Each differs from x² by something that is not a constant.

Differentiate each candidate rather than judging by appearance. Some of these are built to look wrong while being right, and some to look right while being wrong.

The product of x minus 1 and x plus 1 does not look like x squared plus a constant until you multiply it out: then it is x squared minus 1, a member of the family. The square of x plus 1 looks just as innocent, but expanding it gives x squared plus 2x plus 1, and that middle term is not a constant. Its derivative is 2x plus 2.

The general lesson is that belonging to the family means differing from x squared by a constant, and nothing else. Differing by x, as in x squared plus x, or by a factor, as in 2x squared, puts a function outside it.

12. Example 4.50(a): all antiderivatives of 3x squared

Worked example

\[ f(x) = 3x^2 \]

Ask which power differentiates to a square

Why: The power rule lowers the exponent by one, so start from the cube.

\[ \frac{d}{dx}\left(x^3\right) = 3x^2 \]

Name one antiderivative

Why: The coefficient 3 came out automatically, so nothing needs adjusting.

\[ F(x) = x^3 \]

Apply Theorem 4.14

Why: Every antiderivative is this one plus a constant, and every such function is one.

\[ \text{all antiderivatives: } x^3 + C \]

Check by differentiating

Why: Try a specific member, say C equal to minus 4.

\[ \frac{d}{dx}\left(x^3 - 4\right) = 3x^2 - 0 = 3x^2 \;\checkmark \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, pp. 420-421 — Example 4.50a

The method here is recognition. You want a function whose derivative has a square in it, and the power rule lowers exponents by one, so the natural guess is a cube. Differentiating x cubed gives exactly three x squared, coefficient and all, so no adjustment is needed.

Then Theorem 4.14 does the rest. One antiderivative gives the whole family by adding C. The final step checks a specific member, with C equal to minus 4, to make the point that the constant really does disappear under differentiation, whatever it is.

When the coefficient does not come out right on the first guess, you fix it by multiplying by a constant. For instance, if the function had been x squared, the cube would give three times too much, so you would divide by three. Part 3 turns that adjustment into the power rule for integrals.

13. Example 4.50(b): one over x needs an absolute value

Worked example

\[ f(x) = \frac1x, \quad x \ne 0 \]

Try the natural log

Why: It differentiates to one over x, but it only exists for positive x.

\[ x > 0: \quad \frac{d}{dx}(\ln x) = \frac1x \]

Handle negative x with ln of minus x

Why: Chain rule: the inside, minus x, has derivative minus 1.

\[ x < 0: \quad \frac{d}{dx}\ln(-x) = \frac{1}{-x}\cdot(-1) \]

Simplify

Why: The two minus signs cancel.

\[ \frac{1}{-x}\cdot(-1) = \frac1x \]

Combine the two cases

Why: The absolute value is x on the right and minus x on the left.

\[ \frac{d}{dx}\ln|x| = \frac1x \quad \text{for all } x \ne 0 \]

Figure (svg): The graph of y equals ln of the absolute value of x: two mirror-image branches, one for positive x and one for negative x, both undefined at 0. Tangent segments at x equals 2 and x equals minus 2 have slopes one half and minus one half.

The left branch is the mirror image of the right, so its slopes are the negatives of the right branch's slopes, exactly matching one over x, which is negative there.

Check with slopes

Why: At x equal to minus 2 the curve should fall with slope minus one half; the difference quotient agrees.

\[ \frac{\ln 2.01 - \ln 1.99}{-2.01 - (-1.99)} = \frac{0.0100}{-0.02} \approx -0.5 = \frac{1}{-2} \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 421 — Example 4.50b

The natural logarithm differentiates to one over x, so it is the obvious candidate. The catch is the domain: one over x is defined for negative numbers too, and the logarithm of a negative number is not. An antiderivative must work on the whole domain of the function, so you need something that also handles negative x.

Try the logarithm of minus x, which is defined exactly when x is negative. The chain rule multiplies by the derivative of the inside, minus one, and the two minus signs cancel, giving one over x again. The absolute value neatly combines both cases into a single formula.

The graph shows why this works. The left branch is the mirror image of the right branch. Mirroring flips the sign of every slope, so where the right branch has slope one half at 2, the left branch has slope minus one half at minus 2, which is exactly one over minus 2. The numerical check confirms that slope with a difference quotient.

14. Example 4.50(c) and (d): cosine and the exponential

Worked example

\[ \text{(c) } f(x) = \cos x \qquad \text{(d) } f(x) = e^x \]

Recall which function differentiates to cosine

Why: Sine does.

\[ \frac{d}{dx}(\sin x) = \cos x \]

State the family for (c)

Why: Theorem 4.14 again.

\[ \text{all antiderivatives of } \cos x: \quad \sin x + C \]

Recall the exponential's derivative

Why: It is its own derivative.

\[ \frac{d}{dx}\left(e^x\right) = e^x \]

State the family for (d)

Why: The antiderivative is again the exponential.

\[ \text{all antiderivatives of } e^x: \quad e^x + C \]

Figure (svg): The curves y equals sine x and y equals cosine x from 0 to 2 pi. Dashed vertical lines at pi over 2 and 3 pi over 2 show that sine peaks and bottoms out exactly where cosine crosses zero.

Where sine is flat, its derivative cosine is zero; where sine climbs fastest, at 0 and 2 pi, cosine is at its largest. Sine is the antiderivative that cosine is the slope of.

Check (c) against the picture

Why: Sine is flat where cosine is zero, at pi over 2, and rises fastest at 0, where cosine equals 1.

\[ \cos\tfrac{\pi}{2} = 0, \qquad \cos 0 = 1 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 421 — Example 4.50c and d

Both parts are pure recognition from the Chapter 3 derivative table. Sine differentiates to cosine, so sine is an antiderivative of cosine. The exponential is its own derivative, so it is its own antiderivative. Then add C to each.

The picture is worth a moment because it lets you see the relationship rather than just recite it. The solid curve is sine; the dashed curve is cosine, its slope. Where sine reaches its peak and its trough, it is momentarily flat, and exactly there cosine crosses zero. Where sine rises most steeply, at 0 and at 2 pi, cosine reaches its maximum value of one.

Reading a graph like this, where one curve is the slope of the other, is a skill you will use constantly in Chapter 5. The antiderivative climbs where the function is positive and falls where it is negative.

15. Checkpoint 4.49: all antiderivatives of sin x

Prediction

\[ f(x) = \sin x \]

Predict first

Which family is the set of all antiderivatives of sin x?

  • cos x + C
  • −cos x + C
  • −sin x + C
  • sin²x / 2 + C

Correct: −cos x + C

Why: The derivative of cos x is minus sin x, one sign short. So the derivative of minus cos x is plus sin x. The guess cos x is the natural first move, and the sign is exactly what the check by differentiating catches.

\[ \frac{d}{dx}(-\cos x) = -(-\sin x) = \sin x \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 421 — Checkpoint 4.49

Commit to an option before revealing. This checkpoint is placed right after the cosine example on purpose, because the pattern from that example, swap sine and cosine, is exactly what leads people astray here.

The derivative of cosine is minus sine, not sine. So cosine is off by a sign. To fix the sign, put a minus in front: the derivative of minus cosine is minus minus sine, which is sine.

If you picked cos x plus C, the check by differentiating would have caught it in one line. That is the habit this lesson is trying to build: every time you write an antiderivative, differentiate it back, and especially whenever trigonometric functions are involved, since that is where the signs hide.

16. When the domain has a gap

Counterexample

Discussion prompt

Theorem 4.14 needs an interval. The domain of one over x is two intervals. Build an antiderivative of one over x that is NOT of the form ln|x| + C for a single constant C.

This slide tests whether you really understood the words on an interval in Theorem 4.14. Try to build the example yourself before revealing.

The domain of one over x is all real numbers except zero, which is two separate intervals. On the positive side, every antiderivative is ln x plus some constant. On the negative side, every antiderivative is the log of minus x plus some constant. But nothing forces those two constants to be the same, because the Mean Value Theorem argument cannot reach across the missing point at zero.

So the function that adds 1 on the right and subtracts 3 on the left is a perfectly good antiderivative, and it is not ln of the absolute value plus a single C. In practice this almost never matters, because an initial-value problem only ever works on one interval at a time. But it is a good reminder that hypotheses in theorems are there for a reason.

17. Trap: an antiderivative is not the antiderivative

Trap

The trap

Asked for all antiderivatives of 2x, a common answer is:

\[ x^2 \]

Incomplete. That is one member of an infinite family.

The fix

Theorem 4.14 says the general antiderivative is one antiderivative plus an arbitrary constant. Dropping the constant loses real information: in Part 4 the constant is the one thing an initial condition gets to adjust.

\[ \text{all antiderivatives of } 2x: \; x^2 + C \]

Leaving off the constant is the single most common error in this topic, and it is tempting because x squared really is an antiderivative of 2x. The problem is the question asked for all of them, and x squared is only one.

The cost is not just a lost mark. In an initial-value problem, the constant is the only thing you can adjust to make the curve pass through a given point. If you drop it at the start, you have nothing to adjust later, and the point simply cannot be fitted. Treat the plus C as part of the answer, not as decoration.

18. The indefinite integral

Section

Part 2

19. A symbol for the whole family

Concept

Writing all antiderivatives of f every time is clumsy, so there is a symbol for it.

indefinite integral — The most general antiderivative of f: if F is one antiderivative, the indefinite integral of f is F plus an arbitrary constant.

\[ \int f(x)\,dx = F(x) + C \]

\[ \int 2x\,dx = x^2 + C \]

Finding an indefinite integral is called integrating f. The collection of all the F plus C is the family of antiderivatives.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, pp. 421-422 — Definition of the indefinite integral

Writing the phrase all antiderivatives of every time would get tiresome, so mathematics has a symbol for it. The tall, stretched S is the integral sign, and the whole expression, integral sign, function, and dx, is called the indefinite integral.

The word indefinite is there to distinguish it from the definite integral you will meet in Chapter 5. That one has numbers at the top and bottom of the integral sign and produces a single number. This one has no limits and produces a whole family of functions.

The shape of the S is not an accident. It stands for sum, and the reason a symbol for antiderivatives should be a sum is the deepest idea in the course, the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus. For now, read it simply as: the family of antiderivatives of whatever follows.

20. Reading the indefinite integral piece by piece

Notation

Annotate

On: \( \int f(x)\,dx = F(x) + C \)

  • The integral sign. It says: give me every function whose derivative is what follows.
  • The integrand, the function being antidifferentiated.
  • Names the variable of integration. Every other letter in the integrand is treated as a constant.
  • The answer is a family of functions, not a number. Chapter 5's definite integral will be the one that gives a number.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 422 — integrand and variable of integration

Step through the four parts. The integral sign asks the question, the integrand is the function you are antidifferentiating, and the answer on the right is a family, one antiderivative plus C.

The dx is the part people are tempted to treat as decoration, and it is not. It names the variable. In an integrand containing only x it looks redundant, but as soon as there is another letter in the expression, the dx is the only thing telling you which letter varies and which letters are constants. The next slide makes that concrete.

It also marks where the integrand ends. Without it, an expression like integral of x plus 1 would be ambiguous about whether the 1 is inside. And in Chapter 5 and beyond, the dx will carry real meaning of its own, as the width of a thin slice.

21. The differential names the variable

Fill the middle

\[ \int 4t^3\,dt = t^4 + C \]

Fill in the blanks

\int 4t^3\,dx = 4t^3x + C

Why: The differential is dx, so x is the variable and 4t³ is just a constant coefficient. The antiderivative of a constant k with respect to x is kx, so the answer is 4t³x + C. Check: differentiating 4t³x with respect to x gives 4t³.

The first line integrates four t cubed with respect to t, which is the power rule, giving t to the fourth. Now the same integrand, but the differential is dx. Try the blank before checking.

With dx, the variable is x, and there is no x in the integrand at all. So four t cubed is just a constant, like the number 7. The antiderivative of a constant with respect to x is that constant times x.

The two answers look nothing alike and both are right, because they answer different questions. That is the clearest possible demonstration that the differential is part of the question, not a formality to be copied without thinking.

22. An antiderivative can always be checked

Concept

The definition makes every answer checkable in one line, because it runs Chapter 3 forwards.

\[ \int f(x)\,dx = F(x) + C \quad\iff\quad F'(x) = f(x) \]

Finding an antiderivative can be hard. Checking one never is: differentiate your answer and see whether the integrand comes back. From now on every antiderivative in this deck ends with that check.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, pp. 423-424 — the remark before Example 4.51

This slide states, in one line, the most useful fact in the whole section. The integral of f equals F plus C exactly when F differentiates to f. The left side is a claim about antiderivatives; the right side is a claim about derivatives, and you know how to test those.

This means that no matter how an answer was obtained, from a table, a friend, a computer algebra system, or a lucky guess, you can confirm it or refute it with Chapter 3 alone. Very few problems in mathematics come with a built-in check like this.

So take the habit seriously. Every antiderivative on the remaining slides ends with a check step, and on any test you should do the same, at least mentally. It catches sign errors, forgotten coefficients, and wrong exponents almost every time.

23. Example 4.51: verifying two claimed integrals

Worked example

\[ \text{(a) } \int\left(x + e^x\right)dx = \frac{x^2}{2} + e^x + C \qquad \text{(b) } \int x e^x\,dx = x e^x - e^x + C \]

Differentiate the answer to (a)

Why: Term by term; the constant vanishes.

\[ \frac{d}{dx}\left(\frac{x^2}{2} + e^x + C\right) = x + e^x \]

Compare with the integrand

Why: It matches, so (a) is correct. Note the answer is the sum of the two separate antiderivatives.

\[ x + e^x = x + e^x \;\checkmark \]

Differentiate the answer to (b)

Why: The first term needs the product rule.

\[ \frac{d}{dx}\left(x e^x - e^x + C\right) = \left(e^x + x e^x\right) - e^x \]

Simplify

Why: The two single exponentials cancel.

\[ e^x + x e^x - e^x = x e^x \;\checkmark \]

Figure (svg): Two curves for x from minus 4 to 1: f of x equals x e to the x, and F of x equals x e to the x minus e to the x. F has its lowest point at x equals 0, the same place where f crosses from negative to positive.

F falls while f is negative and rises once f is positive, and bottoms out exactly where f is zero. That is what it means for f to be F's derivative.

Check that the product of antiderivatives would fail

Why: Multiplying the antiderivatives of x and of the exponential gives the wrong derivative.

\[ \frac{d}{dx}\left(\frac{x^2 e^x}{2}\right) = x e^x + \frac{x^2 e^x}{2} \ne x e^x \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 424 — Example 4.51

In both parts you are not asked to find anything, only to check. That is the point: you can verify an integral you could not yet have found yourself.

Part (a) is a sum, and differentiating the claimed answer term by term gives the integrand straight back. Notice the structure: the answer is the antiderivative of x plus the antiderivative of the exponential. Sums behave nicely, as Part 3 will make official.

Part (b) is a product, and it needs the product rule to differentiate. The single exponential terms cancel and x times the exponential remains, so the claim is correct. The graph shows it visually: the solid curve F reaches its lowest point exactly where the dashed curve, its derivative, crosses zero. The last step shows the tempting shortcut, multiplying the two separate antiderivatives, gives a different derivative, so products do not integrate factor by factor.

24. Checkpoint 4.50: verify an integral of x cos x

Socratic

\[ \int x\cos x\,dx = x\sin x + \cos x + C \]

Discussion prompt

You do not need to know how to find this integral to decide whether it is right. How do you decide, and is it right?

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 424 — Checkpoint 4.50

Answer the first question before the second: how do you decide? The only reliable way is to differentiate the claimed antiderivative and compare with the integrand.

The product rule on x sin x gives sin x plus x cos x. The derivative of cos x is minus sin x, which cancels the sin x. What remains is x cos x, exactly the integrand, so the claim is correct.

Notice that you have just confirmed an integral you have no method to find yet. Finding it requires integration by parts, a technique from Calculus II. Checking it needed nothing more than the product rule. That gap between finding and checking is why the check is such a powerful habit.

25. Find the error: a product integrated factor by factor

Error analysis

Annotate

On: \( \int x\cos x\,dx = \left(\int x\,dx\right)\left(\int \cos x\,dx\right) = \frac{x^2}{2}\sin x + C \)

  • There is no product rule that lets an integral of a product split into a product of integrals. Sums split; products do not.
  • Differentiate the answer: the product rule gives x sin x plus (x²/2) cos x, which is not x cos x.
  • The true answer, x sin x + cos x + C, was verified on the previous slide. Methods for products come in Calculus II (integration by parts).

Look at the argument and find the illegal step before revealing the notes. The integrals of x and of cos x are each computed correctly, so the error is not in the arithmetic.

The error is the very first equals sign. Integrals split over sums because derivatives split over sums. Derivatives do not split over products; the product rule has two terms, not one. So there is no reason for integrals to split over products, and they do not.

The check exposes it immediately. Differentiating the claimed answer with the product rule gives two terms, and neither of them is x cos x on its own. Whenever you are unsure whether a manipulation of an integral is legal, differentiate the result and see.

26. Exercise 482: two answers that disagree, both right

Worked example

\[ \int \sin x\cos x\,dx \]

First route: spot sine times its own derivative

Why: The chain rule says the derivative of sine squared over two is sine times cosine.

\[ \frac{d}{dx}\left(\tfrac12\sin^2 x\right) = \sin x\cos x \]

Second route: use the double-angle identity

Why: Sine times cosine is half of sine of 2x.

\[ \sin x\cos x = \tfrac12\sin 2x \]

Antidifferentiate that

Why: The derivative of cos 2x is minus 2 sin 2x, so divide by minus 4.

\[ \frac{d}{dx}\left(-\tfrac14\cos 2x\right) = \tfrac12\sin 2x \]

Compare the two answers

Why: Write cos 2x as 1 minus 2 sine squared.

\[ -\tfrac14\cos 2x = -\tfrac14\left(1 - 2\sin^2 x\right) = \tfrac12\sin^2 x - \tfrac14 \]

Figure (svg): Two curves from 0 to 2 pi: one half sine squared x, oscillating between 0 and one half, and minus one quarter cosine 2x, oscillating between minus one quarter and one quarter. Vertical arrows at pi over 2 and at pi show the gap between them is one quarter both times.

The two answers never agree in value, but the gap between them is the same everywhere. They are two members of one family, exactly as Theorem 4.14 predicts.

Check the constant gap numerically

Why: At x equal to 0.7 and 2.1 the difference is one quarter both times, as Theorem 4.14 demands.

\[ \tfrac12\sin^2 x - \left(-\tfrac14\cos 2x\right) = 0.25 \text{ at } x = 0.7 \text{ and } x = 2.1 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 429 — Exercise 482

This exercise shows something that confuses many students when they compare answers with a classmate or a computer: two correct antiderivatives can look completely different.

The first route notices that cos x is the derivative of sin x, so the integrand is a sine times its own derivative, which is what the chain rule produces from one half sine squared. The second route uses the double-angle identity first and gets minus one quarter cos 2x. Both check out when differentiated.

Theorem 4.14 says they must then differ by a constant, and rewriting cos 2x with the identity shows the constant is one quarter. The graph makes it visible: the two curves have identical shapes, one sitting exactly one quarter above the other everywhere. If your answer and the back of the book disagree, test whether they differ by a constant before assuming you are wrong.

27. The power rule and the table

Section

Part 3

28. Reversing the power rule

Concept

Differentiating lowers the exponent by one and multiplies by the old exponent. Reversing it must raise the exponent by one and divide by the new exponent.

\[ \frac{d}{dx}\left(\frac{x^{n+1}}{n+1}\right) = (n+1)\frac{x^{n}}{n+1} \]

\[ (n+1)\frac{x^{n}}{n+1} = x^n \]

Power rule for integrals (Theorem 4.15) — For every exponent n except minus one, the integral of x to the n is x to the n plus 1, divided by n plus 1, plus C.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, pp. 422-423 — Theorem 4.15

The derivative power rule does two things to x to the n plus 1: it brings the exponent down as a factor and lowers the exponent by one. To undo it, you raise the exponent by one and divide by the new exponent, so that when the derivative brings the new exponent down, it cancels the division.

The two lines of maths are the check that this works: differentiate x to the n plus 1 over n plus 1, and the factor n plus 1 cancels, leaving x to the n. That is the entire proof of Theorem 4.15.

The one restriction is visible in the formula itself. When n is minus one, the new exponent is zero, and the formula asks you to divide by zero. The next slides deal with that case separately.

29. Reading Theorem 4.15 piece by piece

Notation

Annotate

On: \( \int x^n\,dx = \frac{x^{n+1}}{n+1} + C, \quad n \ne -1 \)

  • Raise the exponent by one: the reverse of the power rule's lowering it.
  • Divide by the NEW exponent, so that differentiating brings the factor n + 1 down and cancels it.
  • Works for negative and fractional exponents too: roots and reciprocals must first be written as powers.
  • At n = −1 the new exponent is 0 and the formula divides by zero. That case is ln|x| + C.

Go through the notes in order. The first two are the recipe: raise the exponent by one, then divide by the new exponent, not the old one. Dividing by the old exponent is a common slip, and the check by differentiating catches it at once.

The third note is where most of the work actually lies. The power rule applies to any real exponent, including negative ones and fractions, but only if you first write the function as a power. One over x cubed must become x to the minus three; the square root of x must become x to the one half. Most errors with this rule are errors of rewriting, not of applying it.

The last note flags the exception at minus one, which you already know how to handle from Example 4.50(b): the answer is the natural log of the absolute value.

30. The one exponent the rule cannot handle

Intuition

\[ n = -1: \quad \frac{x^{0}}{0} \quad \text{is meaningless} \]

Something must fill the gap, because one over x certainly has antiderivatives: ln|x| is one. Choose each power antiderivative to pass through the point one comma zero and watch what happens as n closes in on minus one.

Figure (svg): Curves of x to the n plus 1, minus 1, over n plus 1 for n equal to minus one half, minus 0.8, minus 1.2 and minus 1.5, all passing through the point 1 comma 0. The curve ln x runs between them, and the curves for n closer to minus 1 hug it.

As n closes in on minus one from either side, the power-rule antiderivatives squeeze onto ln x. The logarithm is the missing member of the power family.

\[ \frac{x^{n+1} - 1}{n+1} \;\longrightarrow\; \ln x \quad \text{as } n \to -1 \]

It is natural to wonder why the power family should suddenly break down at exactly one exponent. The picture answers that it does not really break: the logarithm is where the power family was heading all along.

Each curve is a power-rule antiderivative, shifted by a constant so that it passes through the point where x is one and y is zero. That shift is allowed, because any member of the family is an antiderivative. The curve for n equal to minus one half lies above the logarithm on the right; the curve for n equal to minus one and a half lies below; the dashed ones, closer to minus one, squeeze in tighter.

In the limit they close onto ln x from both sides. So the formula fails at minus one only because the expression written for it becomes zero over zero, not because the antiderivatives misbehave. The slider on the next slide lets you watch the squeeze happen continuously.

31. Slide n toward minus one

Tweak it

Parameter explorer

The curve is the power-rule antiderivative of x to the n, shifted to pass through (1, 0). Slide n toward −1 from either side. What curve does it approach, and what happens exactly at n = −1?

\[ F(x) = \frac{x^{n+1} - 1}{n+1}, \quad n = {n} \]

  • n — from -2.5 to 1: exponent n

Start with n at zero, where the curve is the straight line x minus 1, the antiderivative of 1 shifted through the point one comma zero. Then slide n down slowly toward minus one and watch the curve bend.

As n gets close to minus one, the curve settles onto a shape that no longer changes much: that is the natural logarithm, and at exactly minus one the slider draws it. Keep going past minus one, to minus 1.5 and minus 2, and the curves move away on the other side.

The point to take away is that the logarithm is not a strange exception bolted onto the power rule. It is the member of the power family at the one exponent where the formula's algebra fails. That is why the answer at minus one looks so different from the others, even though the functions themselves change smoothly.

32. Table 4.13: derivative formulas read right to left

Concept

derivative (Chapter 3)indefinite integral
d/dx (kx) = k∫ k dx = kx + C
d/dx (ln|x|) = 1/x∫ 1/x dx = ln|x| + C
d/dx (eˣ) = eˣ∫ eˣ dx = eˣ + C
d/dx (sin x) = cos x∫ cos x dx = sin x + C
d/dx (cos x) = −sin x∫ sin x dx = −cos x + C
d/dx (tan x) = sec²x∫ sec²x dx = tan x + C
d/dx (sec x) = sec x tan x∫ sec x tan x dx = sec x + C
d/dx (csc x) = −csc x cot x∫ csc x cot x dx = −csc x + C
d/dx (cot x) = −csc²x∫ csc²x dx = −cot x + C
d/dx (sin⁻¹x) = 1/√(1 − x²)∫ 1/√(1 − x²) dx = sin⁻¹x + C
d/dx (tan⁻¹x) = 1/(1 + x²)∫ 1/(1 + x²) dx = tan⁻¹x + C

Nothing here is new. Every row is a derivative you already know, read from right to left. The minus signs move across with the functions: that is where most errors live.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 423 — Table 4.13

Nothing in this table needs to be memorised as new. Each row is a Chapter 3 derivative, written first in its familiar form and then turned around. If you can differentiate sine, tangent, secant and the inverse functions, you can already integrate their derivatives.

What does need care is the minus signs. The derivatives of cosine, cosecant and cotangent all carry minus signs, so their reverses do too. The integral of sine is minus cosine, the integral of cosecant times cotangent is minus cosecant, and the integral of cosecant squared is minus cotangent.

A good strategy when you blank on a row is to reconstruct it: think which function differentiates to this one, differentiate your guess, and fix the sign or constant. That is faster and more reliable than trying to recall the table cold.

33. Match each integrand to its antiderivative

Matching

Match the pairs

  • a. sec²x
  • b. sec x tan x
  • c. 1/(1 + x²)
  • d. csc x cot x
  • e. 1/√(1 − x²)
  • p. tan x + C
  • q. sec x + C
  • r. tan⁻¹x + C
  • s. −csc x + C
  • t. sin⁻¹x + C

Why: Each pair is a Chapter 3 derivative read backwards. The only sign to watch is csc x cot x: the derivative of csc x is MINUS csc x cot x, so the antiderivative carries a minus sign.

Make each match by asking which function has this derivative, then confirm by differentiating mentally. Most of these are direct reversals of rows you have just seen.

The one designed to catch you is cosecant times cotangent. The derivative of cosecant is minus cosecant cotangent, so to get plus cosecant cotangent you need minus cosecant. If you matched it to plus cosecant, the check fails on the sign.

The two inverse functions are worth separating carefully: one over one plus x squared goes with the inverse tangent, and one over the square root of one minus x squared goes with the inverse sine. The square root is the tell.

34. Trap: the sign on the integral of sine

Trap

The trap

Remembering that sine and cosine swap:

\[ \int \sin x\,dx = \cos x + C \]

Wrong sign.

The fix

Differentiate the answer: the derivative of cos x is minus sin x, not sin x. The correct antiderivative carries the minus sign.

\[ \int \sin x\,dx = -\cos x + C \]

\[ \frac{d}{dx}(-\cos x) = \sin x \;\checkmark \]

This error comes from remembering that sine and cosine are paired and forgetting which direction carries the minus sign. It appears on almost every first test on antiderivatives.

The cure is not to memorise harder but to check. Differentiate cos x and you get minus sin x, which is the negative of what you wanted. So put a minus sign in front and differentiate again: minus cos x gives sin x. One line, and the sign is settled for good.

35. Sums, differences and constant multiples

Concept

Differentiation respects sums and constant multiples, so antidifferentiation does too. If F and G are antiderivatives of f and g:

\[ \frac{d}{dx}\big(F(x) \pm G(x)\big) = f(x) \pm g(x) \]

\[ \frac{d}{dx}\big(kF(x)\big) = kf(x) \]

Theorem 4.16 — The integral of a sum or difference is the sum or difference of the integrals, and a constant factor can be moved in front of the integral sign.

\[ \int\big(f \pm g\big)dx = F \pm G + C, \qquad \int kf\,dx = kF + C \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, pp. 424-425 — Theorem 4.16

The reason integrals split over sums is simply that derivatives do. If F and G are antiderivatives of f and g, then F plus G differentiates to f plus g, so F plus G is an antiderivative of the sum. The same argument works for differences and for constant multiples.

In practice this is what makes integration of polynomials and similar expressions routine. You split the integrand into pieces, pull the constant coefficients out in front, integrate each piece with the power rule or the table, and put it back together.

One practical detail: you only need one constant at the end. Each separate integral technically contributes its own constant, but a sum of arbitrary constants is just another arbitrary constant, so writing C one plus C two plus C three adds nothing.

36. Exercises 521-524: which rules survive?

Sorting

Sort into buckets

Suppose f is an antiderivative of v. Which statements are true, and which are false?

True
2f(x) is an antiderivative of 2v(x)
False
f(2x) is an antiderivative of v(2x); f(x) + 1 is an antiderivative of v(x) + 1; (f(x))² is an antiderivative of (v(x))²
t
Constant multiples pass straight through: the derivative of 2f is 2f′ = 2v.
f
By the chain rule f(2x) has derivative 2v(2x). The derivative of f + 1 is v, not v + 1. And (f)² has derivative 2f·v, not v². Test f = x, v = 1: (x)² = x² has derivative 2x, not 1.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 430 — Exercises 521-524

These four statements look equally plausible, which is exactly what makes them good practice. Test each by differentiating the proposed antiderivative and seeing whether you get the claimed function.

Only the constant multiple survives: the derivative of twice f is twice v. Composing with 2x brings in the chain rule, so the derivative of f of 2x is twice v of 2x, not v of 2x. Adding 1 to f adds nothing to the derivative, so f plus 1 is an antiderivative of v, not of v plus 1. And squaring f gives, by the chain rule, twice f times v.

When a general claim feels uncertain, try the simplest possible example. With v equal to 1 and f equal to x, the last claim would say x squared differentiates to 1, which is plainly false.

37. Example 4.52(a): a polynomial, term by term

Worked example

\[ \int\left(5x^3 - 7x^2 + 3x + 4\right)dx \]

Split the integral

Why: Theorem 4.16: a sum integrates term by term.

\[ \int 5x^3\,dx - \int 7x^2\,dx + \int 3x\,dx + \int 4\,dx \]

Pull out the constants

Why: The constant-multiple rule.

\[ 5\int x^3\,dx - 7\int x^2\,dx + 3\int x\,dx + 4\int 1\,dx \]

Apply the power rule to each

Why: Raise each exponent by one and divide by the new exponent; one C for the whole thing.

\[ = 5\cdot\frac{x^4}{4} - 7\cdot\frac{x^3}{3} + 3\cdot\frac{x^2}{2} + 4x + C \]

Tidy the coefficients

Why: Nothing cancels, so write each as a single fraction.

\[ = \frac54 x^4 - \frac73 x^3 + \frac32 x^2 + 4x + C \]

Check by differentiating

Why: Each power rule brings its exponent down and cancels the denominator.

\[ \frac{d}{dx}\left(\tfrac54 x^4 - \tfrac73 x^3 + \tfrac32 x^2 + 4x\right) = 5x^3 - 7x^2 + 3x + 4 \;\checkmark \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, pp. 425-426 — Example 4.52a

This is the template for integrating any polynomial. Split it into its four terms, pull each coefficient out in front, and apply the power rule to each power of x. The constant 4 is 4 times x to the zero, which integrates to 4x.

Watch the division in each term: each exponent goes up by one, and each term is divided by its new exponent. So five x cubed becomes five quarters x to the fourth, and so on.

The check differentiates the whole answer. Each power rule brings its exponent down, which cancels the fraction you just created, and the original polynomial returns. Once this is familiar you will do all of it in one line, but on a first pass it is worth writing out every move.

38. Before integrating a quotient

Step zero

\[ \int \frac{x^2 + 4\sqrt[3]{x}}{x}\,dx \]

Discussion prompt

There is no quotient rule for integrals. What must you do to this integrand BEFORE any formula applies?

Write your answer before revealing. This slide exists to stop the reflex of looking for a formula before the integrand is in a shape any formula fits.

There is no quotient rule for integrals, so a fraction must be broken up first. Dividing each term of the numerator by the single-term denominator is always allowed. Then every term needs to become a power of x: the cube root is x to the one third, and dividing that by x subtracts one from the exponent, giving minus two thirds.

After the rewrite, the integrand is a sum of powers, and the power rule does the rest. Rewriting is often most of the work in this section.

39. Example 4.52(b): a cube root over x

Worked example

\[ \int \frac{x^2 + 4\sqrt[3]{x}}{x}\,dx \]

Rewrite as powers

Why: Divide each term of the numerator by x; the cube root is the one-third power.

\[ \frac{x^2 + 4x^{1/3}}{x} = x + 4x^{-2/3} \]

Integrate each term

Why: Power rule; for the second term the new exponent is minus two thirds plus one, which is one third.

\[ \int x\,dx + 4\int x^{-2/3}\,dx = \frac{x^2}{2} + 4\cdot\frac{x^{1/3}}{1/3} + C \]

Simplify

Why: Dividing by one third is multiplying by 3.

\[ = \frac12 x^2 + 12x^{1/3} + C \]

Check at x equal to 8

Why: The derivative of the answer is x plus 4 times x to the minus two thirds; at 8 both sides give 9.

\[ 8 + 4\cdot 8^{-2/3} = 8 + 1 = 9 = \frac{64 + 4\cdot 2}{8} \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 426 — Example 4.52b

The rewrite from the previous slide turns the problem into two power-rule integrals. The first, x, integrates to x squared over two. The second needs care with fractions: minus two thirds plus one is one third, so you divide by one third, which is the same as multiplying by three. With the 4 in front, that gives 12.

The check here uses a single convenient value rather than differentiating symbolically. At x equal to 8, the cube root is 2, which keeps the arithmetic clean. The derivative of the answer, x plus four x to the minus two thirds, gives 8 plus 1, which is 9, and the original integrand gives 64 plus 8, over 8, also 9.

A numerical check at one point is not a proof, but it catches nearly every slip in exponents and coefficients, and it takes seconds.

40. Example 4.52(c): an inverse tangent

Worked example

\[ \int \frac{4}{1 + x^2}\,dx \]

Move the constant out

Why: Constant-multiple rule.

\[ 4\int \frac{1}{1 + x^2}\,dx \]

Recognise a table entry

Why: One over one plus x squared is the derivative of the inverse tangent.

\[ \frac{d}{dx}\left(\tan^{-1}x\right) = \frac{1}{1 + x^2} \]

Write the answer

Why: One constant, outside.

\[ \int \frac{4}{1 + x^2}\,dx = 4\tan^{-1}x + C \]

Figure (svg): The bell-shaped curve 4 over 1 plus x squared, peaking at 4 when x is 0, and the S-shaped curve 4 arctan x, rising from about minus 6.28 to about 6.28, steepest at the origin where its slope is 4.

The antiderivative climbs fastest where the integrand is tallest, at x equals 0, and flattens toward plus and minus 2 pi as the integrand dies away.

Check the slope at the origin

Why: The answer's derivative at 0 should equal the integrand at 0.

\[ \frac{d}{dx}\left(4\tan^{-1}x\right)\Big|_{x=0} = \frac{4}{1 + 0} = 4 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 426 — Example 4.52c

No rewriting is needed here, only recognition. After the constant 4 is moved outside, the remaining integrand is exactly the derivative of the inverse tangent from Table 4.13.

The picture shows the relationship in both directions. The dashed bell-shaped curve is the integrand. The solid S-shaped curve is its antiderivative, four times the inverse tangent. The antiderivative climbs most steeply at the origin, where the integrand is tallest, and levels off toward plus and minus two pi at the edges, where the integrand is almost zero.

The check compares one slope: the antiderivative's slope at zero should be the integrand's value at zero, which is 4. The yellow segment on the graph has that slope. Recognising derivatives of inverse functions will matter a great deal in Calculus II.

41. Example 4.52(d): simplify first, then integrate

Worked example

\[ \int \tan x\cos x\,dx \]

Write tangent as sine over cosine

Why: The integrand is a product, so simplify it before reaching for the table.

\[ \tan x\cos x = \frac{\sin x}{\cos x}\cos x \]

Cancel

Why: Valid wherever cos x is not zero, which is everywhere tan x is defined.

\[ \frac{\sin x}{\cos x}\cos x = \sin x \]

Integrate the table entry

Why: Remember the minus sign.

\[ \int \tan x\cos x\,dx = \int \sin x\,dx = -\cos x + C \]

Check by differentiating

Why: Then undo the simplification.

\[ \frac{d}{dx}(-\cos x) = \sin x = \tan x\cos x \;\checkmark \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 426 — Example 4.52d

Tangent times cosine is a product, and products cannot be integrated factor by factor. But this product collapses: tangent is sine over cosine, and the cosine cancels, leaving plain sine.

The cancellation is legal wherever cosine is not zero, which is exactly where tangent is defined in the first place, so nothing is lost. Then the integral is a table entry, with its familiar minus sign.

In the book's solution the final line is printed without the dx inside the integrals. That is only a typesetting slip; the dx belongs there, as written on this slide. The lesson of the example is that simplifying the integrand is often the whole trick, so always look for an identity before reaching for anything harder.

42. Checkpoint 4.51: a cubic with four terms

Worked example

\[ \int\left(4x^3 - 5x^2 + x - 7\right)dx \]

Split and pull out constants

Why: Theorem 4.16.

\[ 4\int x^3\,dx - 5\int x^2\,dx + \int x\,dx - 7\int 1\,dx \]

Apply the power rule

Why: One C at the end.

\[ = 4\cdot\frac{x^4}{4} - 5\cdot\frac{x^3}{3} + \frac{x^2}{2} - 7x + C \]

Simplify

Why: The 4s cancel in the first term.

\[ = x^4 - \frac53 x^3 + \frac12 x^2 - 7x + C \]

Check at x equal to 1.7

Why: A central difference of the answer matches the integrand to three decimals.

\[ F'(1.7) \approx -0.098, \qquad 4(1.7)^3 - 5(1.7)^2 + 1.7 - 7 = -0.098 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 426 — Checkpoint 4.51

This is the same procedure as Example 4.52(a), and it is worth doing it on your own before looking at each step. Split, pull out the constants, raise each exponent by one, divide by the new exponent, and write a single C.

The first term simplifies nicely: four x cubed becomes four times x to the fourth over four, which is just x to the fourth. The other terms keep their fractions.

The check this time is numerical, at x equal to 1.7, using a central difference, the average slope over a tiny interval on either side. It agrees with the integrand to three decimal places. A numerical check like this is exactly what you can do on a calculator if you are unsure of an answer during a test.

43. Exercise 493: split the fraction

Fill the middle

\[ \int \frac{3x^2 + 2}{x^2}\,dx = \int\left(3 + 2x^{-2}\right)dx \]

Fill in the blanks

\int\left(3 + 2x^-2\right)dx = 3x + ___x^___ + C

Why: The power rule sends x to the minus 2 to x to the minus 1 divided by minus 1, so 2x⁻² integrates to −2x⁻¹, that is, −2/x. Check: the derivative of −2x⁻¹ is 2x⁻², and the derivative of 3x is 3.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 429 — Exercise 493

The fraction has already been split for you: three x squared over x squared is 3, and two over x squared is two times x to the minus two. Fill in the coefficient of x to the minus one.

The power rule on x to the minus two raises the exponent to minus one and divides by minus one. So the two becomes minus two. Many people drop that minus sign, because dividing by a negative exponent feels unusual. The check restores it: differentiating minus two x to the minus one gives plus two x to the minus two.

44. Complete the antiderivative table

Comparison

Comparison matrix

integrandrewrite asantiderivative (+ C)
√xx^(1/2)(2/3)x^(3/2)
1/x³x^(−3)−1/(2x²)
1/xx^(−1)ln|x|
sec²x + 1sec²x + 1tan x + x
(√x)³x^(3/2)(2/5)x^(5/2)

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 429 — Exercises 476, 477 and 481

Fill in each blank, working left to right across the row. The middle column is the rewrite, and it is where the work lies: roots become fractional powers and reciprocals become negative powers.

Two rows need a second look. The reciprocal of x is the exception to the power rule and goes to the natural log of the absolute value. And the square root of x, cubed, is x to the three halves, which then integrates to two fifths x to the five halves.

The secant squared row is a reminder that the table and the power rule combine freely: tangent comes from the table, and x comes from integrating the constant 1.

45. Trap: integrating a quotient as a quotient

Trap

The trap

Treating the top and bottom separately:

\[ \int \frac{x^2 + 1}{x}\,dx = \frac{x^3/3 + x}{x^2/2} + C \]

Wrong. There is no quotient rule for integrals.

The fix

Divide first, so every term is a table form, then integrate term by term.

\[ \frac{x^2 + 1}{x} = x + \frac1x \]

\[ \int\left(x + \frac1x\right)dx = \frac{x^2}{2} + \ln|x| + C \]

This mistake integrates the numerator and the denominator separately and divides the results. It feels symmetric with the way sums work, but there is no quotient rule for integrals, just as there is no product rule.

The fix is always the same: rewrite the quotient as a sum of simpler terms before integrating. Here, dividing each term by x gives x plus one over x, and those two terms are a power-rule integral and the logarithm case. If you are ever unsure, differentiate the proposed answer; the quotient-of-integrals version gives something that looks nothing like the original.

46. Initial-value problems

Section

Part 4

47. Differential equations: an equation for a function

Concept

differential equation — An equation relating an unknown function and one or more of its derivatives. Solving it means finding the function.

\[ \frac{dy}{dx} = f(x) \qquad (4.9) \]

The simplest kind just names the derivative. Its solutions are exactly the antiderivatives of f.

\[ \frac{dy}{dx} = 6x^2 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = \int 6x^2\,dx = 2x^3 + C \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, pp. 426-427 — equation 4.9

A differential equation is an equation whose unknown is a function rather than a number. It relates the function to its derivatives. Most of the important laws of physics, biology and economics are stated this way, because they describe how quantities change.

The simplest kind, equation 4.9, just says what the derivative is. Solving it is antidifferentiating, so its solutions are the family of antiderivatives. For a derivative of six x squared, that is two x cubed plus C.

Notice the solution of a differential equation is not a single function but a family. That is the same plus C you have been carrying since Part 1. The next slide shows how one extra fact picks out a single member.

48. An initial condition picks one curve

Concept

\[ \frac{dy}{dx} = f(x), \qquad y(x_0) = y_0 \]

An initial-value problem adds one known point. For the derivative 6x squared with y equal to 5 when x is 1, substitute the point into the family:

\[ y(1) = 2(1)^3 + C = 5 \;\Longrightarrow\; C = 3 \]

Figure (svg): Four curves y equals 2x cubed plus C for C equal to minus 3, 0, 3 and 6. The curve with C equal to 3 is highlighted and passes through the marked point 1 comma 5.

The differential equation alone allows every curve in the family. The initial condition keeps only the one through the point: C equals 3.

\[ y = 2x^3 + 3 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 427 — equations 4.10 and 4.11, and Figure 4.86

An initial-value problem pairs a differential equation with a single known point on the solution curve, called the initial condition. The word initial comes from motion problems, where the known point is usually the state at time zero.

The method is to substitute. The family says y is two x cubed plus C. The point says that when x is 1, y is 5. Put those numbers in and one equation in C remains, which gives C equal to 3.

The graph, the book's Figure 4.86, shows why exactly one member works. The curves are vertical shifts of one another, so they never cross, and through any point exactly one of them passes. That is why the initial condition gives a unique answer rather than several.

49. Slide C until the curve hits the point

Tweak it

Parameter explorer

Every curve y = 2x³ + C solves dy/dx = 6x². Slide C until the curve passes through (1, 5). Which C works, and could two different values both work?

\[ y = 2x^3 + {C} \]

  • C — from -6 to 10: constant C

Move the slider and watch the whole curve rise and fall rigidly. Its shape never changes, because every value of C gives a curve with the same derivative six x squared.

Aim for the point one comma five. You should find it at C equal to 3 and nowhere else. At x equal to 1 the curve's height is 2 plus C, and that has to equal 5.

The second question in the prompt is the important one. Two different values of C cannot both work, because the curves are vertical shifts and so never share a point. That uniqueness is what makes initial-value problems worth solving: the answer is a single, definite function.

50. Example 4.53: slope sin x, starting at height 5

Worked example

\[ \frac{dy}{dx} = \sin x, \qquad y(0) = 5 \]

Solve the differential equation

Why: Antidifferentiate, with the minus sign.

\[ y = \int \sin x\,dx = -\cos x + C \]

Substitute the initial condition

Why: Put x equal to 0 and y equal to 5.

\[ -\cos 0 + C = 5 \]

Solve for C

Why: Cosine of 0 is 1.

\[ C = 5 + \cos 0 = 6 \]

Write the particular solution

Why: One member of the family.

\[ y = -\cos x + 6 \]

Figure (svg): Three curves y equals minus cosine x plus C for C equal to 2, 4 and 6, drawn from minus 1 to 7. The curve with C equal to 6 is highlighted; it passes through the point 0 comma 5.

At x equals 0, minus cosine is minus 1, so each curve starts one unit below its C. To start at height 5, C must be 6.

Check both conditions

Why: The derivative is right, and so is the starting height.

\[ y' = \sin x \;\checkmark, \qquad y(0) = -1 + 6 = 5 \;\checkmark \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, pp. 427-428 — Example 4.53

Every initial-value problem in this section has the same two stages. First solve the differential equation, which here means antidifferentiating sine, remembering its minus sign. Then use the condition to find C.

Substituting x equal to 0 is the step to be careful with. Cosine of 0 is 1, so the family's value at 0 is minus 1 plus C, and setting that equal to 5 gives C equal to 6. A common slip is to assume the value at zero is just C, which is true for polynomials but not here.

The graph shows three members of the family, each starting one unit below its own C because of that minus cosine. The highlighted one starts at 5. The final check confirms both the derivative and the starting height, which is the complete check for any initial-value problem.

51. Checkpoint 4.52: slope 3 over x squared

Worked example

\[ \frac{dy}{dx} = 3x^{-2}, \qquad y(1) = 2 \]

Antidifferentiate

Why: Power rule: the new exponent is minus 1.

\[ y = 3\cdot\frac{x^{-1}}{-1} + C = -\frac{3}{x} + C \]

Substitute the initial condition

Why: Put x equal to 1.

\[ -\frac31 + C = 2 \]

Solve for C

Why: Add 3 to both sides.

\[ C = 5 \]

Write the solution

Why: The initial point has x positive, so the solution lives on the interval of positive x.

\[ y = 5 - \frac3x, \quad x > 0 \]

Figure (svg): Three curves y equals C minus 3 over x for x from 0.3 to 6, with C equal to 3, 5 and 7. Each rises from far below and levels off toward the height C. The curve with C equal to 5 is highlighted and passes through the point 1 comma 2.

Each solution approaches its own C as x grows, because 3 over x dies away. The initial condition picks the one that is at height 2 when x is 1.

Check the derivative and the point

Why: Differentiate minus 3 over x, then evaluate at 1.

\[ y' = 3x^{-2} \;\checkmark, \qquad y(1) = 5 - 3 = 2 \;\checkmark \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 428 — Checkpoint 4.52

Rewrite three over x squared as three x to the minus two, and the power rule gives three times x to the minus one over minus one, which is minus three over x.

The initial condition at x equal to 1 gives minus 3 plus C equal to 2, so C is 5. The answer is five minus three over x.

There is one subtlety worth noticing. The function three over x squared is not defined at zero, so its antiderivatives live on two separate intervals, and the initial point, with x equal to 1, lies on the positive one. So the solution is stated for positive x. Each curve in the graph levels off toward its own value of C as x grows, because three over x shrinks to nothing.

52. Exercise 501: a trig initial-value problem

Fill the middle

\[ f'(x) = \cos x + \sec^2 x, \qquad f\left(\tfrac{\pi}{4}\right) = 2 + \tfrac{\sqrt2}{2} \]

\[ f(x) = \sin x + \tan x + C, \qquad f\left(\tfrac{\pi}{4}\right) = \tfrac{\sqrt2}{2} + 1 + C \]

Fill in the blanks

\tfrac1___ + 1 + C = 2 + \tfrac______ \;\Longrightarrow\; C = ___

Why: Subtract √2/2 from both sides and then 1: C = 1. So f(x) = sin x + tan x + 1. Check: at π/4 this gives √2/2 + 1 + 1 = 2 + √2/2, and its derivative is cos x + sec²x.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 430 — Exercise 501

The antiderivative has been found for you: cosine integrates to sine, and secant squared to tangent. At pi over four, sine is root two over two and tangent is 1. Fill in the constant.

The equation is set up so that the root two over two terms appear on both sides and cancel, leaving 1 plus C equal to 2. So C is 1 and the function is sin x plus tan x plus 1.

Initial conditions at angles like pi over four are common because the trigonometric values are exact there. Knowing the standard values at pi over six, pi over four and pi over three saves a lot of time in problems like this.

53. Exercise 504: two antidifferentiations, two constants

Worked example

Find two possible functions f with the given second derivative.

\[ f''(x) = x^2 + 2 \]

Antidifferentiate once

Why: This recovers the first derivative, with a first constant.

\[ f'(x) = \frac{x^3}{3} + 2x + C_1 \]

Antidifferentiate again

Why: The constant C one integrates to C one times x, and a second constant appears.

\[ f(x) = \frac{x^4}{12} + x^2 + C_1 x + C_2 \]

Choose two members

Why: Any values of the two constants will do; here C one is 0 and then 1, with C two equal to 0.

\[ f(x) = \frac{x^4}{12} + x^2 \quad\text{or}\quad f(x) = \frac{x^4}{12} + x^2 + x \]

Figure (svg): Two curves: x to the fourth over 12 plus x squared, symmetric with its lowest point at the origin, and the same plus x, tilted, with its lowest point to the left of the origin. The gap between them is the line y equals x, not a constant.

Both curves have second derivative x squared plus 2, yet they are not shifted copies of each other. Two antidifferentiations leave a whole line, C one x plus C two, undetermined.

Check by differentiating twice

Why: The x term dies after two derivatives, which is why both survive.

\[ \frac{d^2}{dx^2}\left(\frac{x^4}{12} + x^2 + x\right) = \frac{d}{dx}\left(\frac{x^3}{3} + 2x + 1\right) = x^2 + 2 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 430 — Exercise 504

Here you are given the second derivative, so you must antidifferentiate twice. The first antidifferentiation recovers the first derivative and introduces a constant, C one. The second recovers f itself, and the constant C one becomes C one times x, while a new constant C two appears.

So the general answer has two arbitrary constants, and the family is much bigger than before. The graph shows two members that are not vertical shifts of one another: they differ by the line y equals x. Both still have the same second derivative, because a straight line vanishes after two differentiations.

The exercise asks for two possible functions, so any two choices of the constants will do. To pin down a single f you would need two conditions, for example a value of f and a value of its derivative. That is exactly the situation in the motion problems of the next part.

54. From acceleration to position

Section

Part 5

55. Two antidifferentiations, two starting values

Concept

Motion runs the chain from Part 1 backwards. Each step is an initial-value problem, and each needs its own starting value.

\[ v'(t) = a(t), \quad v(0) = v_0 \;\Longrightarrow\; v(t) \]

\[ s'(t) = v(t), \quad s(0) = s_0 \;\Longrightarrow\; s(t) \]

For constant acceleration the result is the familiar formula from physics, now derived rather than memorised:

\[ s(t) = \tfrac12 a t^2 + v_0 t + s_0 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 428 — the discussion before Example 4.54

This is Exercise 504's lesson applied to motion. Acceleration is the second derivative of position, so recovering position takes two antidifferentiations, and each introduces a constant.

Physics supplies the two conditions naturally: the starting velocity and the starting position. The first initial-value problem uses the starting velocity to get the velocity function; the second uses the starting position to get the position function.

When the acceleration is constant, carrying this out once gives the formula you may have memorised in a physics class: one half a t squared plus v nought t plus s nought. You now know where it comes from, and more importantly, you can handle accelerations that are not constant, where that formula does not apply.

56. Example 4.54(a): how long until the car stops?

Worked example

A car travelling at 88 feet per second, which is 60 miles per hour, brakes with a constant deceleration of 15 feet per second squared.

Set up the initial-value problem

Why: Decelerating means the acceleration is negative.

\[ v'(t) = -15, \qquad v(0) = 88 \]

Antidifferentiate

Why: The antiderivative of a constant is that constant times t.

\[ v(t) = -15t + C \]

Use the initial velocity

Why: At t equal to 0 the velocity is C itself.

\[ v(0) = C = 88 \;\Longrightarrow\; v(t) = 88 - 15t \]

Stopped means velocity zero

Why: Solve for t.

\[ 88 - 15t = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; t = \frac{88}{15} \approx 5.87 \text{ s} \]

Figure (svg): The velocity v of t equals 88 minus 15 t, a straight line falling from 88 feet per second at t equals 0 to zero at t equals 88 over 15, about 5.87 seconds. The triangle under it is shaded.

The line reaches zero at 88 over 15 seconds. Keep an eye on the shaded triangle: its area will turn out to equal the stopping distance.

Check the stopping time

Why: The speed falls 15 feet per second each second, so it takes 88 over 15 seconds to lose all 88.

\[ 88 - 15\cdot\frac{88}{15} = 0 \;\checkmark \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 428 — Example 4.54a

Begin by naming things: t is the time since the brakes went on, and the acceleration is minus 15 feet per second squared, negative because the car is slowing down. The initial velocity is 88 feet per second.

Antidifferentiating a constant gives that constant times t, plus C. At time zero, the velocity equals C, so C is 88, and the velocity decreases in a straight line. The car stops when the velocity reaches zero, which happens at 88 over 15 seconds, just under six seconds.

The graph shows the velocity line and the triangle under it. The shaded area is labelled with a number that you will compute on the next slide by a completely different route. Keep it in mind.

57. Example 4.54(b): how far does it travel?

Worked example

Set up the second initial-value problem

Why: Measure position from where the brakes were applied.

\[ s'(t) = 88 - 15t, \qquad s(0) = 0 \]

Antidifferentiate

Why: Power rule on each term.

\[ s(t) = 88t - \frac{15}{2}t^2 + C \]

Use the initial position

Why: At t equal to 0 every other term vanishes.

\[ s(0) = C = 0 \]

Evaluate at the stopping time

Why: Put t equal to 88 over 15.

\[ s\left(\tfrac{88}{15}\right) = 88\cdot\frac{88}{15} - \frac{15}{2}\cdot\frac{88^2}{15^2} \]

Simplify

Why: Both terms have 88 squared over 15; the second is half the first.

\[ = \frac{88^2}{15} - \frac{88^2}{30} = \frac{88^2}{30} = \frac{7744}{30} \approx 258.13 \text{ ft} \]

Figure (svg): The position s of t equals minus 7.5 t squared plus 88 t for t from 0 to 88 over 15: a curve rising steeply at first and flattening to a horizontal tangent at 258.13 feet when the car stops.

The position curve starts with slope 88, the initial velocity, and flattens to slope zero exactly when the velocity reaches zero.

Check with the velocity graph

Why: The shaded triangle under the velocity line has the same area: half of base times height. Chapter 5 explains why that is no coincidence.

\[ \tfrac12 \cdot \frac{88}{15} \cdot 88 = \frac{7744}{30} \approx 258.13 \;\checkmark \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, pp. 428-429 — Example 4.54b

The second initial-value problem uses the velocity as the derivative of position. Measuring position from the point where braking starts makes the initial position zero, which makes the constant zero too.

Evaluating at the stopping time is careful fraction arithmetic. Both terms have 88 squared over 15 in them, and the second is half the first, so the result is 88 squared over 30, about 258 feet. The position graph starts with slope 88, the initial speed, and flattens to a horizontal tangent exactly when the car stops.

The check computes the area of the triangle under the velocity graph and gets the same 258 feet. That is not a coincidence: distance travelled equals area under the velocity curve, and the reason is the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus in Chapter 5. You have just seen it happen before it has been proved.

58. Checkpoint 4.53: half the speed, how far?

Estimation

\[ v(0) = 44 \text{ ft/s}, \qquad a = -15 \text{ ft/s}^2 \]

Predict first

The same car brakes the same way from 44 ft/s, half the speed. Roughly how far does it travel before stopping, compared with the 258 ft from 88 ft/s?

  • about 258 ft, the same
  • about 129 ft, half
  • about 65 ft, a quarter
  • about 32 ft, an eighth

Correct: about 65 ft, a quarter

Why: It stops in half the time, 44/15 ≈ 2.93 s, AND travels at half the average speed, so the distance falls by a factor of four: s = 44²/30 ≈ 64.53 ft. Stopping distance grows with the square of the speed.

Figure (svg): The stopping distance v squared over 30 plotted against the initial speed v from 0 to 100 feet per second at a deceleration of 15 feet per second squared: a parabola. Dots mark 44 feet per second with 64.5 feet, and 88 feet per second with 258.1 feet.

The distance grows with the square of the speed: halve the speed and the stopping distance drops to a quarter.

\[ t = \frac{44}{15} \approx 2.93 \text{ s}, \qquad s = \frac{44^2}{30} \approx 64.53 \text{ ft} \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 429 — Checkpoint 4.53

Make a guess before revealing. Most people's intuition says half the speed means half the distance, and the point of this checkpoint is that intuition is wrong.

At half the speed, the car stops in half the time. But it is also travelling at half the average speed during that shorter time. Half the time at half the speed covers a quarter of the distance: 88 squared over 30 becomes 44 squared over 30, which is about 64.5 feet.

The graph plots stopping distance against initial speed, and the curve is a parabola because the distance is the speed squared over 30. This is the real reason speed limits near schools are so low: a modest reduction in speed buys a much larger reduction in stopping distance.

59. Exercise 514: designing the brakes

Real world

Discussion prompt

A car company wants its new model to stop in less than 450 ft from 60 mph (88 ft/s). Assuming constant deceleration, how strong must the braking be? Use what you derived: with deceleration d, the stopping distance is v₀² over 2d.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives §4.10, p. 430 — Exercise 514

This exercise runs the braking calculation backwards: instead of knowing the deceleration and finding the distance, you know the distance allowed and must find the deceleration needed. Work it through before revealing.

With an unknown deceleration d, the velocity is 88 minus d t, the car stops at 88 over d seconds, and the same antidifferentiation as before gives a stopping distance of 88 squared over twice d. Requiring that to be under 450 feet gives d greater than about 8.6 feet per second squared.

The car in Example 4.54 decelerated at 15, comfortably more than this. Specifications like this in real vehicle testing come from exactly this chain: an acceleration, two antidifferentiations, and two initial conditions.

60. Putting it together

Section

Part 6

61. Pattern: antidifferentiate, check, then pin the constant

Pattern

Figure (svg): A flow diagram of five boxes: rewrite the integrand as a sum of table forms; antidifferentiate term by term and add one C; differentiate back to check; if there is an initial condition, substitute it; solve for C and write the particular solution.

Every problem in this section runs along this track; the bottom row only runs when a point on the curve is given.
  1. Rewrite first. Split fractions, turn roots into powers, simplify products like tan x cos x.
  2. Integrate term by term with the power rule and Table 4.13; write one + C.
  3. Differentiate back. The integrand must return exactly.
  4. If a point is given, substitute it and solve for C; each extra antidifferentiation needs one more condition.
  5. Never integrate a product or quotient factor by factor.

This is the whole lesson as a procedure. The top row happens in every problem; the bottom row only runs when you are given a point that the answer must pass through.

Rewriting comes first because formulas only fit integrands in the right shape: sums of powers and table entries. Then integrate term by term with a single C. Then differentiate back before doing anything else, because if the family is wrong, any constant you compute from it will be wrong too.

If there is an initial condition, substitute it and solve for C, and check that the final function passes through the point. With a second derivative, expect two constants and two conditions.

62. Put the initial-value procedure in order

Ranking

Put in order

Order the steps for solving dy/dx = f(x) with y(x₀) = y₀.

  1. Rewrite f as a sum of table forms
  2. Antidifferentiate term by term and add one C
  3. Differentiate the family back to check it
  4. Substitute x₀ and y₀ into the family
  5. Solve for C and write the particular solution

Why: The constant can only be found once the family exists, and the family should be checked before a condition is spent on it: an error in the antiderivative would otherwise produce a confident, wrong C.

Arrange the steps before checking. The only step whose position might be debated is the check by differentiating, and there is a good argument for doing it before using the initial condition.

If you find C first and then discover the antiderivative was wrong, all the work with the condition is wasted. Checking the family first means the condition is spent on a family you already trust.

63. Check: a general antiderivative

Check

Check your understanding

What is the general antiderivative of f(x) = 6x² − 4 cos x?

  • A. 2x³ − 4 sin x + C (correct)
  • B. 2x³ + 4 sin x + C
  • C. 12x + 4 sin x + C
  • D. 2x³ − 4 sin x

Answer: A

Why: Integrate term by term: six x squared gives two x cubed, and minus four cosine gives minus four sine, since sine differentiates to cosine. Differentiating the answer returns the integrand, and the constant makes it the whole family.

Why B tempts people
The integral of cosine is plus sine, so minus four cosine integrates to minus four sine. The sign flip belongs to the integral of sine, not cosine.
Why C tempts people
This differentiated the first term instead of antidifferentiating it.
Why D tempts people
Correct antiderivative, but only one of them: without the + C this is not the general antiderivative.

Integrate each term separately and then differentiate your answer to make sure. The first term is a power-rule integral; the second is a table entry with a constant multiple.

Two distractors test the two signs and directions: one flips the sign of the sine term, one differentiates instead of antidifferentiating. The last distractor is correct except for the missing constant, and that omission matters, because the question asked for the general antiderivative.

64. Check: an initial-value problem

Check

Check your understanding

Solve dy/dx = 2x + 1 with y(1) = 3.

  • A. y = x² + x + 3
  • B. y = x² + x + 1 (correct)
  • C. y = x² + 1
  • D. y = x² + x

Answer: B

Why: The family is x squared plus x plus C. At x equal to 1 it gives 2 plus C, which must equal 3, so C is 1. Check: the derivative is 2x plus 1, and y(1) is 1 plus 1 plus 1, which is 3.

Why A tempts people
This sets C equal to the y-value 3. But at x = 1 the family is 2 + C, so y(1) would be 5.
Why C tempts people
The constant term 1 integrates to x, which is missing here; the derivative of this answer is only 2x.
Why D tempts people
Correct family member for C = 0, but y(1) = 2, not 3: the initial condition was never used.

Find the family first, then substitute the point. At x equal to 1, the family x squared plus x plus C gives 2 plus C, and that must equal 3.

The tempting wrong answer sets C equal to the given y value, 3. That is only right when the rest of the family happens to be zero at the given x, which is not the case here. Always substitute the full expression.

65. Check: which rule is real?

Check

Check your understanding

Which statement about indefinite integrals is true for all continuous f and g?

  • A. ∫ f(x)g(x) dx = (∫ f(x) dx)(∫ g(x) dx)
  • B. ∫ k f(x) dx = k ∫ f(x) dx for any constant k (correct)
  • C. ∫ x⁻¹ dx = x⁰/0 + C
  • D. Two antiderivatives of f on an interval can differ by x

Answer: B

Why: Constant multiples pass through the integral sign because they pass through derivatives: the derivative of k times F is k times f. That is the second half of Theorem 4.16.

Why A tempts people
Products do not split. Example 4.51(b) showed the product of antiderivatives of x and eˣ is not an antiderivative of x eˣ.
Why C tempts people
The power rule excludes n = −1; the answer is ln|x| + C.
Why D tempts people
On an interval, Theorem 4.14 forces the difference to be a constant; a difference of x would change the derivative by 1.

Each option is a rule someone might wish were true. Test each against what you know about derivatives, since every property of integrals comes from a property of derivatives.

Constant multiples pass through derivatives, so they pass through integrals. Products do not, as Example 4.51(b) showed. The power rule excludes the exponent minus one, where the logarithm takes over. And on an interval, two antiderivatives can only differ by a constant, never by a function like x.

66. Explain why plus C is the complete answer

Explain it to yourself

Discussion prompt

In two or three sentences: why does writing F(x) + C describe EVERY antiderivative of f on an interval, and not just some of them?

Write your explanation before revealing. The aim is to reproduce the Mean Value Theorem argument in your own words, because it is the reason the entire lesson hangs together.

A good answer has three ingredients: take any second antiderivative, notice the difference of the two has derivative zero, and invoke the fact that zero derivative on an interval forces a constant. If your explanation mentioned the interval, give yourself extra credit; that is the condition most people forget.

67. Exit ticket

Exit ticket

A ball is thrown straight up at 20 metres per second from a height of 2 metres. Gravity gives a constant acceleration of minus 9.8 metres per second squared.

Discussion prompt

Find the height function s(t), the time the ball reaches its highest point, and that height.

This combines both halves of the lesson: two antidifferentiations and two initial conditions, then an optimisation-style question using the velocity.

The acceleration is minus 9.8, so the velocity is minus 9.8 t plus 20, using the launch speed as the first constant. The position is minus 4.9 t squared plus 20 t plus 2, using the launch height as the second.

The ball is highest when its velocity is zero, at 20 over 9.8, about 2.04 seconds, and the height there is about 22.41 metres. Check that the numbers make sense: a ball thrown upward at 20 metres per second should rise about twenty metres, and it does.

68. Recap

Recap

ideastatementwhy it holds
antiderivativeF′ = fthe definition; check by differentiating
general formevery antiderivative is F + CMean Value Theorem, on an interval
power rule∫ xⁿ dx = xⁿ⁺¹/(n + 1) + C, n ≠ −1the derivative power rule reversed
n = −1∫ 1/x dx = ln|x| + Cboth branches of ln|x| have slope 1/x
linearitysums split, constants come outdifferentiation does the same
initial-value problema point fixes Cthe family's curves never cross

\[ \int f(x)\,dx = F(x) + C \quad\iff\quad F'(x) = f(x) \]

Next, Chapter 5 connects this family to area: the definite integral, and the Fundamental Theorem that says why the triangle under the car's velocity graph measured its stopping distance.

Stewart, Calculus: Early Transcendentals 8e, §4.9 Antiderivatives §4.9, pp. 350-357 — the same material in Stewart

An antiderivative undoes a derivative, and there is never just one. On an interval, every antiderivative is one particular one plus a constant, and the Mean Value Theorem guarantees nothing else exists. The indefinite integral is the notation for that whole family.

To compute one, rewrite the integrand into powers and table forms, integrate term by term using linearity, and always differentiate back to check. The power rule covers every exponent except minus one, which gives the logarithm of the absolute value.

An initial condition picks a single member of the family; a second derivative needs two conditions. That is how position comes back from acceleration. In Chapter 5 the same antiderivatives will compute areas, and you will see why the triangle under the velocity graph gave the stopping distance.

Sources

  1. OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §4.10 Antiderivatives — Strang & Herman, OpenStax / Rice University, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, pp. 419-430
  2. Stewart, Calculus: Early Transcendentals 8e, §4.9 Antiderivatives — James Stewart, Cengage Learning, 2016, pp. 350-357

Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Calculus I — $55/session, free consultation.

Book on Wyzant · Text (657) 465-8108