3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change

The amount of change formula and the estimate it licenses, motion along a line with velocity, speed and acceleration and the rule for speeding up or slowing down, marginal cost, revenue and profit in economics, population growth rates, and the discipline of attaching correct units to every applied derivative.

Subject: Calculus I · 68 slides · symbolic lesson

Open the interactive version of this deck

What this lesson covers

The lesson, slide by slide

1. Derivatives as Rates of Change

Title

Calculus I · Section 3.4

What the number f′(a) is for

2. What this lesson gives you

Objectives

Section 3.3 made differentiation quick. This section is about what the answer means: every derivative is a rate, and a rate lets you predict, describe motion, and price one more item.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, pp. 230-235 — learning objectives 3.4.1 to 3.4.5

Up to now the derivative has been something you compute: a limit, a slope, a rule applied to a formula. This lesson is about what the number you get actually tells you. The short answer is that every derivative is a rate of change, measured in output units per input unit, and a rate is something you can act on.

You will use that one idea five ways. You will predict a value a short time ahead from a value now and a rate now. You will describe a moving object completely: where it is, which way it is going, when it stops, and whether it is gaining speed. You will do the same for populations, and you will price the next item a business makes or sells.

None of this needs a new differentiation rule. Everything here runs on the power rule and the rules of Section 3.3. The new skill is interpretation, and in particular the habit of attaching units and a sign to every derivative you compute.

3. Before anything new: what is f′(a)?

Warm-up

Discussion prompt

Write the definition of the derivative of f at a as a limit, and say in one sentence what the fraction inside the limit measures.

Write the definition before you reveal it. Every application in this lesson grows out of the fraction inside that limit, so it is worth having it exactly right.

The fraction is a change in output divided by a change in input, which is an average rate of change over a short interval. The derivative is what those average rates settle down to as the interval shrinks to nothing. That makes the derivative an instantaneous rate: how fast the output is changing at one input value.

Keep both readings in mind. As a slope, the derivative is the steepness of the tangent line. As a rate, it is how much the output changes per unit of input, right now. This lesson leans on the second reading, but the first is what makes the pictures work.

4. The amount of change

Section

Part 1

5. Three ways to measure change

Concept

Over an interval from a to a plus h, a function's change can be measured three ways, each built from the one before.

\[ \text{amount of change: } f(a+h) - f(a) \]

\[ \text{average rate of change: } \frac{f(a+h) - f(a)}{h} \]

\[ \text{instantaneous rate of change: } f'(a) = \lim_{h\to 0}\frac{f(a+h) - f(a)}{h} \]

The first has the units of the output. The second and third have output units per input unit: they are rates.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 231 — amount of change and average rate of change

These three quantities are easy to blur together, so look at how each one is built from the one before. The amount of change is a plain difference of two outputs. If f measures a population, it is a number of people.

Dividing that difference by the length of the interval gives the average rate of change. Now the units change: people per year rather than people. On a graph this is the slope of the secant line joining the two points.

Letting the interval shrink to zero gives the instantaneous rate, the derivative. It has the same units as the average rate, people per year, but it describes a single moment rather than a stretch of time.

A good test of understanding is to ask of any number in a word problem: is this an amount, an average rate, or an instantaneous rate? The sorting activity at the end of this part asks exactly that.

6. Solving the derivative for the new value

Concept

For a small h the limit is nearly reached, so the average rate is nearly the derivative.

\[ f'(a) \approx \frac{f(a+h) - f(a)}{h} \]

\[ f(a+h) - f(a) \approx f'(a)\,h \]

\[ f(a+h) \approx f(a) + f'(a)\,h \]

Multiply both sides by h, then add f(a). The last line is the amount of change formula: new value equals old value plus rate times step.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 231 — equation 3.10

This derivation is three lines of algebra, and it is worth being able to redo it. Start from the fact that for a small step, the average rate of change is close to the derivative. That is only saying the limit has nearly been reached.

Multiply both sides by the step h to get the amount of change on its own: change is about rate times step. Then add f of a to both sides to get the new value on its own. The result is equation 3.10 in the book.

Read the final line as a sentence: the new value is roughly the old value plus the rate times the step. You use this reasoning every day. If you are driving at sixty miles per hour and you are fifty miles from home, you expect to be about ten miles from home in forty minutes. That is the amount of change formula, with a rate you are assuming stays constant.

7. Reading equation 3.10 piece by piece

Notation

Annotate

On: \( f(a+h) \approx f(a) + f'(a)\,h \)

  • The value you want but cannot measure yet: the population next year, the position a moment from now.
  • The value you know now. Everything is built on this starting point.
  • Rate times step: the amount of change the current rate would produce if it stayed constant over the whole step.
  • Only approximately equal. The rate does not stay constant, so the formula carries an error that shrinks as h shrinks.

Step through the annotations and connect each piece to a situation. The left side is the value you want but do not have. The first term on the right is the value you do have. The second term is the change you expect, built as a rate times a step.

The approximately-equal sign is the part to take seriously. The formula pretends that the rate stays at its starting value for the whole step. Real rates drift, so the formula is only an estimate, and the error depends on two things: how long the step is, and how quickly the rate is changing.

When you use this formula in an answer, say that it is an estimate. Better still, say whether it is likely to be too high or too low. The next few slides show how to tell.

8. Walking along the tangent line

Picture it

Figure (svg): The decreasing curve y equals 1 plus 4 over x with its tangent line at x equals a. At x equals a plus h the tangent line sits well below the curve, and a red vertical segment marks the gap between the tangent-line estimate and the true value.

The estimate walks along the tangent line; the true value walks along the curve. The red gap is the error, and it grows as h grows or as the curve bends harder.

The right-hand side of the formula is the height of the tangent line at a plus h. Using it means pretending the curve is straight for one step.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 231 — Figure 3.22

Look at what the formula computes geometrically. Starting from the point at a, it moves a distance h to the right along the tangent line, not along the curve. The tangent line has slope f prime of a, so after a run of h it has risen by f prime of a times h. That height is the estimate.

The true value sits on the curve directly above or below the estimate. The red segment is the gap between them, which is the error. In this picture the curve bends upward while the tangent runs straight, so the curve pulls away above the tangent, and the estimate comes out too low.

The picture also shows why a shorter step helps. Near the point of tangency, the curve and the tangent line are almost indistinguishable. The farther you walk, the more the curve has a chance to bend away. This is the same tangent line you met as a limit of secant lines in Section 3.1; here it is being used as a stand-in for the function.

9. Example 3.33: a point and a slope

Worked example

If f(3) equals 2 and f′(3) equals 5, estimate f(3.2).

Find the step h

Why: The known point is at 3 and the target is at 3.2.

\[ h = 3.2 - 3 = 0.2 \]

Write the amount of change formula at a equal to 3

Why: Old value plus rate times step.

\[ f(3.2) = f(3 + 0.2) \approx f(3) + (0.2)f'(3) \]

Substitute the given values

Why: f(3) is 2 and the rate is 5.

\[ f(3.2) \approx 2 + 0.2(5) \]

Simplify

Why: Rate times step is 1.

\[ f(3.2) \approx 2 + 1 = 3 \]

Figure (svg): A straight line of slope 5 through the point (3, 2). A horizontal run of 0.2 from x equals 3 to 3.2 and a vertical rise of 1 lead to the estimated point (3.2, 3).

The only information given is a point and a slope, which is exactly a tangent line. The estimate is where that line is after a run of 0.2.

Check the slope of the step

Why: Rise over run from the known point to the estimate must equal the given rate, or the estimate is not on the tangent line.

\[ \frac{3 - 2}{3.2 - 3} = \frac{1}{0.2} = 5 = f'(3) \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 231 — Example 3.33

Notice how little information this problem gives: one value of f and one value of its derivative, both at 3. You do not know the formula for f at all. That is precisely the situation the amount of change formula was built for.

The work is short. Find the step, which is two tenths. Multiply it by the rate, five, to get a change of one. Add that to the starting value of two. The estimate for f at 3.2 is three.

The check confirms that the estimate lies on the tangent line. The run from 3 to 3.2 is two tenths, the rise from 2 to 3 is one, and one divided by two tenths is five, which is the given derivative. The figure shows the same right triangle drawn on that line.

What the check cannot tell you is how close three is to the true value, because the formula for f was never given. With only a point and a slope, the tangent-line estimate is the best available answer.

10. Checkpoint 3.21: a negative start

Prediction

\[ f(10) = -5, \qquad f'(10) = 6 \]

Predict first

Estimate f(10.1).

  • −4.4
  • −5.6
  • 1
  • 0.6

Correct: −4.4

Why: The step is one tenth, so the change is about six times a tenth, which is 0.6. Adding that to minus 5 gives minus 4.4. The option 0.6 is only the change, and minus 5.6 subtracts it although the rate is positive.

\[ f(10.1) \approx -5 + (0.1)(6) = -4.4 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 231 — Checkpoint 3.21

Commit to an answer before revealing. This checkpoint repeats Example 3.33 with two small traps built in: the starting value is negative, and the answer options include the change on its own.

The step is one tenth and the rate is six, so the change is six tenths. Adding six tenths to minus five gives minus 4.4. The value goes up because the rate is positive, so any option below minus five is going the wrong way.

If you picked 0.6, you computed the change correctly and forgot to add it to the starting value. That is the most common slip with this formula. Say the formula as a sentence while you use it, old value plus rate times step, and both parts will be there.

11. Why the estimate has an error

Intuition

The formula freezes the rate at its value at a. If the rate itself changes during the step, the frozen rate is wrong for most of the step.

A curve that bends upward has a rising rate, so the tangent line runs below it and the estimate comes out low. A curve that bends downward gives an estimate that is too high.

Shrinking the step helps twice over: the rate has less time to drift, and the drift is multiplied by a smaller step. That is why the error behaves like the square of h.

The amount of change formula uses one rate for the whole step: the rate at the start. If the true rate climbs during the step, the formula underestimates how much the function grows. If the true rate falls, the formula overestimates it.

Whether the rate climbs or falls is a question about how the graph bends. A graph that curves upward has slopes that increase, so its tangent line runs below it and the estimate is too low. A graph that curves downward has slopes that decrease, so the estimate is too high. You will make this precise with the second derivative in Chapter 4.

The claim that the error behaves like the square of the step deserves a reason. Over a step of length h, the rate drifts by an amount roughly proportional to h, and that drift acts over a distance h. Multiply them and you get something like h squared. The next example shows that for the squaring function the error is exactly h squared.

12. How big is the error? The squaring function

Worked example

An example of the kind in the exercises: estimate the change in the squaring function from 3 to 3.1, then measure the error exactly.

\[ f(x) = x^2, \quad a = 3, \quad h = 0.1 \]

Differentiate and evaluate at 3

Why: Power rule.

\[ f'(x) = 2x, \quad f'(3) = 6 \]

Estimate the change

Why: Rate times step.

\[ f(3.1) - f(3) \approx 6(0.1) = 0.6 \]

Compute the exact change

Why: 3.1 squared is 9.61.

\[ f(3.1) - f(3) = 9.61 - 9 = 0.61 \]

Find the error for a general step h

Why: Expand the square and subtract the estimate.

\[ (3+h)^2 - 9 - 6h = 9 + 6h + h^2 - 9 - 6h = h^2 \]

Figure (svg): Left: the parabola y equals x squared and its tangent at x equals 3; at x equals 4 the curve is at 16 and the tangent at 15, a gap of 1. Right: the error plotted against the step h, a parabola through (0.1, 0.01), (0.5, 0.25) and (1, 1).

Cut the step to a tenth and the error drops to a hundredth. Small steps make the tangent estimate very good.

Check the formula against the numbers

Why: At h equal to 0.1 the error formula gives 0.01, exactly the gap between 0.61 and 0.6; at h equal to 1 it gives 1, the gap between 16 and 15.

\[ h = 0.1: \; 0.61 - 0.6 = 0.01 = (0.1)^2, \qquad h = 1: \; 7 - 6 = 1 = 1^2 \]

This example is chosen because everything can be computed exactly, so you can see the error rather than just be told about it. The derivative at 3 is six, so a step of a tenth is predicted to raise the square by six tenths. The true rise, from 9 to 9.61, is 0.61.

The general step is the heart of it. Expand three plus h, all squared, subtract the starting value nine and the prediction six h, and everything cancels except h squared. So the error is exactly the square of the step, for every step.

The right-hand panel of the figure plots that error against h. It hugs zero for small steps and grows quickly for larger ones: a step of a tenth costs a hundredth, a step of a half costs a quarter, a full step costs one. Shrink the step tenfold and the error shrinks a hundredfold.

The check reads two points off the error formula and matches them against the actual gaps. That is a genuine test: if the algebra in the fourth step were wrong, the numbers would not agree.

13. Amount, average rate, or instantaneous rate?

Sorting

Sort into buckets

Sort each expression by which measure of change it is.

Amount of change
f(5) − f(2); R(101) − R(100)
Average rate
[f(5) − f(2)] / 3; slope of the secant from x = 2 to x = 5
Instantaneous rate
f′(2); slope of the tangent at x = 2
amt
f(5) − f(2) and R(101) − R(100) are plain differences of outputs, with output units and no division.
avg
Dividing the change by the length of the interval, 3, gives an average rate; geometrically it is a secant slope.
inst
f′(2) is the limit of those averages, and geometrically the slope of the tangent line at 2.

Sort each expression before checking. The quickest test is to ask whether there is a division by the length of an interval, and whether there is a limit.

A plain difference of outputs is an amount of change. That includes R of 101 minus R of 100, which will come back later as the exact revenue from the 101st item. A difference divided by the interval length is an average rate, and geometrically it is a secant slope. A derivative, or the slope of a tangent line, is an instantaneous rate.

The reason this matters is units. An amount has output units. Both kinds of rate have output units per input unit. When a problem asks for a rate and you report an amount, the units will expose the mistake, provided you write them down.

14. Motion along a line

Section

Part 2

15. Position, velocity, speed, acceleration

Concept

An object moves along a number line, and s(t) is its position at time t. Differentiating once gives how fast position changes; differentiating again gives how fast that changes.

\[ v(t) = s'(t), \qquad \text{speed} = |v(t)|, \qquad a(t) = v'(t) = s''(t) \]

velocity, speed, acceleration — Velocity is the rate of change of position and carries a sign: positive means moving in the positive direction. Speed is the size of the velocity, never negative. Acceleration is the rate of change of velocity.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 232 — Definition

Picture a bead sliding along a wire marked as a number line. Its position at time t is s of t. The derivative of position is velocity: how fast the position number changes. Because position can increase or decrease, velocity carries a sign, positive when the bead moves toward larger numbers and negative when it moves toward smaller ones.

Speed is the size of the velocity without its sign. A car moving backward at five metres per second has velocity minus five but speed five. The speedometer reads speed; it has no idea which way you are going.

Acceleration is the rate of change of velocity, so it is the second derivative of position. It measures how quickly the velocity is changing, not how fast the object is moving. An object can be moving very fast with zero acceleration, or be momentarily at rest with a large acceleration, like a ball at the top of its flight.

16. Reading the motion definitions

Notation

Annotate

On: \( v(t) = s'(t) \qquad |v(t)| \qquad a(t) = v'(t) = s''(t) \)

  • Position units per time unit, such as feet per second. The sign says which way the object moves.
  • Speed: what a speedometer shows. It forgets the direction, so it is never negative.
  • Acceleration: velocity units per time unit, such as feet per second per second.
  • The same acceleration seen as the second derivative of position: the rate of change of a rate of change.

Step through the annotations and pay special attention to units, because they are how you keep these three quantities apart. If position is in feet and time in seconds, velocity is in feet per second and acceleration in feet per second per second.

The absolute value bars on speed do real work. Velocity answers two questions at once: how fast and which way. Speed answers only the first. So two objects moving in opposite directions at the same rate have the same speed and opposite velocities.

The last annotation says acceleration is the second derivative of position. That is the first time you meet a second derivative doing a physical job. The same idea shows up later in this lesson for populations, where the second derivative says whether growth is speeding up or easing off.

17. Average velocity against instantaneous velocity

Concept

Average velocity is the average rate of change of position over a time interval: the displacement divided by the elapsed time.

\[ v_{\text{ave}} = \frac{s(t_2) - s(t_1)}{t_2 - t_1} \]

Instantaneous velocity is its limit as the interval shrinks to a single instant, which is the derivative.

\[ v(t) = \lim_{h\to 0}\frac{s(t+h) - s(t)}{h} = s'(t) \]

One is a secant slope, the other a tangent slope. The next example computes both for the same fall and gets different answers.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 231 — learning objective 3.4.2

These two formulas look almost the same, and that is the point: instantaneous velocity is the limit of average velocities. Average velocity uses a real interval of time, so it can be computed from two measurements. Instantaneous velocity needs the limit, or equivalently the derivative.

Think of a trip that takes two hours to cover a hundred miles. The average velocity is fifty miles per hour, even if you sat in traffic for half an hour and then drove at seventy. Your speedometer showed the instantaneous velocity at each moment; the average smooths all of that into one number.

Geometrically, average velocity is the slope of a secant line on the position graph, and instantaneous velocity is the slope of a tangent line. In the next example those two slopes differ by a factor of two, and the figure shows both lines.

18. Example 3.34: the dropped ball

Worked example

A ball is dropped from 64 feet; its height in feet after t seconds is given below. Find (a) its velocity on impact and (b) its average velocity during the fall.

\[ s(t) = -16t^2 + 64 \]

Find when it lands

Why: The ground is height zero.

\[ -16t^2 + 64 = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; t^2 = 4 \;\Longrightarrow\; t = 2 \]

Differentiate for the velocity

Why: Power rule; the constant 64 drops out.

\[ v(t) = s'(t) = -32t \]

(a) Evaluate at landing

Why: Negative, because the height is decreasing.

\[ v(2) = -32(2) = -64 \text{ ft/s} \]

(b) Divide the amount of change by the time

Why: Final height minus starting height, over 2 seconds.

\[ v_{\text{ave}} = \frac{s(2) - s(0)}{2 - 0} = \frac{0 - 64}{2} = -32 \text{ ft/s} \]

Figure (svg): The height s of t equals minus 16 t squared plus 64 falling from 64 at t equals 0 to 0 at t equals 2. A dashed secant line joins the two ends (slope minus 32) and a steeper tangent line touches the curve at t equals 2 (slope minus 64).

The average velocity is the slope of the secant over the whole fall; the impact velocity is the slope of the tangent at the last instant, twice as steep.

Check with the midpoint and the endpoints

Why: Velocity changes at a constant rate here, so the average velocity must equal the mean of the start and end velocities, and also the velocity at the halfway time.

\[ \frac{v(0) + v(2)}{2} = \frac{0 + (-64)}{2} = -32 = v(1) \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 232 — Example 3.34

Almost every motion problem starts the same way: find the time you care about. Here that is the landing time, found by setting the height to zero. The equation gives t squared equal to 4, and only the positive root, 2 seconds, makes sense.

For the impact velocity, differentiate the position to get minus 32 t and put in t equal to 2. The answer, minus 64 feet per second, is negative because the height is decreasing: the ball is moving down.

For the average velocity, you do not need the derivative at all. Divide the total change in height, minus 64 feet, by the two seconds the fall took. The result is minus 32 feet per second, exactly half the impact velocity. The figure shows why: the secant from start to finish is much less steep than the tangent at the end.

The check uses a fact about constant acceleration: velocity changes at a steady rate, so its average over an interval is the average of its two end values, which here is also the velocity halfway through. All three give minus 32.

19. Trap: a negative speed

Trap

The trap

A write-up of Example 3.34:

\[ v(2) = -64 \]

\[ \text{speed on impact} = -64 \text{ ft/s} \]

Wrong. Speed is never negative.

The fix

The minus sign belongs to the velocity and says the ball is moving down. Speed takes the absolute value and throws the direction away.

\[ |v(2)| = 64 \text{ ft/s} \]

This slip costs marks because it mixes two different quantities. The derivative gives velocity, which carries a sign. The question asked for speed, which does not.

The fix is one line: take the absolute value. The ball hits the ground at 64 feet per second, moving downward. If a question says velocity, keep the sign and say what it means. If it says speed, report a positive number. If you are unsure which is wanted, give both, clearly labelled.

20. Three graphs, one motion

Picture it

Figure (svg): Three side-by-side graphs over t from 0 to 5.5 with dashed lines at t equals 2 and 4. Position rises to 24, dips to 20, rises again. Velocity is positive, crosses zero at 2, negative until 4, then positive. Acceleration is a straight line crossing zero at t equals 3.

Where the position graph turns, the velocity graph crosses zero; where the velocity graph turns, the acceleration graph crosses zero. Each graph is the slope of the one to its left.

These are the graphs of Example 3.36. Each graph is the slope of the one to its left, so the zeros of each graph line up with the turning points of the one before it.

Look across the three panels from left to right. Each graph is the derivative of the one before it, so each shows the slope of its neighbour on the left.

The position graph climbs, turns at t equal to 2, dips, turns again at t equal to 4, and climbs. At both turns its tangent is flat, so the velocity graph crosses zero exactly there, at the dashed lines. Between them the position falls, and the velocity is below the axis.

The velocity graph itself is a parabola with its lowest point at t equal to 3. So its slope, the acceleration, crosses zero at 3: negative before, positive after. Reading these links in both directions is a skill you will use constantly in Chapter 4, where the shape of a graph is read from its derivatives.

21. At rest is not the same as turning around

Intuition

An object is at rest at an instant when its velocity is zero. It changes direction when its velocity changes sign.

\[ \text{at rest: } v(t) = 0 \qquad \text{turns: } v \text{ changes sign at } t \]

A ball at the top of its flight does both. But a velocity can touch zero and keep its sign, and then the object pauses for an instant and carries on the same way. The sign chart is what tells the two apart.

Two ideas get merged here, and the difference is subtle. At rest means the velocity is zero at that instant. Turning around means the velocity changes sign, from positive to negative or the reverse.

Most of the time the two happen together. A ball thrown upward has zero velocity at the top, and its velocity goes from positive to negative there, so it both rests and turns. But a velocity can also touch zero and bounce back without changing sign. Then the object pauses for an instant and carries on in the same direction.

The practical rule is: solve v equal to zero to find the candidate turning times, then check the sign of v on either side. Only a sign change is a turn. The counterexample slide later in this part shows the simplest position function where the two ideas come apart.

22. Example 3.36(a)-(c): when and which way

Worked example

A particle moves along a coordinate axis. Find its velocity, the times it is at rest, and when it moves right or left.

\[ s(t) = t^3 - 9t^2 + 24t + 4, \quad t \ge 0 \]

(a) Differentiate

Why: Term by term.

\[ v(t) = s'(t) = 3t^2 - 18t + 24 \]

(b) Set the velocity to zero

Why: At rest means zero velocity.

\[ 3t^2 - 18t + 24 = 0 \]

Factor out 3

Why: Every coefficient is a multiple of 3.

\[ 3(t^2 - 6t + 8) = 0 \]

Factor the quadratic

Why: Two numbers with product 8 and sum minus 6.

\[ 3(t-2)(t-4) = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; t = 2, \; t = 4 \]

(c) Read the sign between the zeros

Why: Each factor changes sign once.

\[ v > 0 \text{ on } [0,2) \cup (4,\infty), \qquad v < 0 \text{ on } (2,4) \]

Figure (svg): A sign chart with vertical dashed lines at t equals 0, 2 and 4. The factor t minus 2 is negative then positive; t minus 4 is negative until 4. Their product v is positive before 2, negative between 2 and 4, positive after 4, with arrows pointing right, left, right.

Each factor changes sign once. The product is positive, negative, positive, and the arrows read that as right, left, right.

Check with one test point in each interval

Why: Any value inside an interval must give that interval's sign.

\[ v(1) = 9 > 0, \quad v(3) = -3 < 0, \quad v(5) = 9 > 0 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 233 — Example 3.36 and Figure 3.23

The work here is the standard motion routine, and it is worth doing in exactly this order. Differentiate to get the velocity. Set the velocity to zero and solve to find the rest times. Then read the sign of the velocity between those times.

The factoring is where time is saved. Every coefficient is a multiple of 3, so take 3 out first; the quadratic that remains factors as t minus 2 times t minus 4. The particle is at rest at 2 and at 4.

The sign chart does the rest. Each factor changes sign once, at its own zero. Before 2 both factors are negative, so their product is positive. Between 2 and 4 only one is negative, so the product is negative. After 4 both are positive. The particle moves right, then left, then right.

The check picks one test value inside each interval. It is the cheapest insurance there is: three substitutions confirm the whole chart.

23. Example 3.36(d): drawing the path

Worked example

Use the rest times to sketch where the particle actually goes.

Find the starting position

Why: Put t equal to 0.

\[ s(0) = 4 \]

Find the position at the first turn

Why: At t equal to 2.

\[ s(2) = 8 - 36 + 48 + 4 = 24 \]

Find the position at the second turn

Why: At t equal to 4.

\[ s(4) = 64 - 144 + 96 + 4 = 20 \]

Figure (svg): The path of the particle drawn above a number line from minus 8 to 28: it starts at 4 when t is 0, moves right to 24 at t equals 2, turns and moves left to 20 at t equals 4, then turns again and moves right.

The particle's whole history on one line. The vertical offsets only separate the legs; the motion itself is horizontal.

Check the legs against the sign chart

Why: Each leg must move the way the sign of v says: up while v is positive, down while it is negative, and up again after 4.

\[ 4 \nearrow 24 \; (v>0), \quad 24 \searrow 20 \; (v<0), \quad s(5) = 24 > 20 \; (v>0) \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 233 — Example 3.36(d) and Figure 3.24

The sign chart tells you which way the particle goes; the positions at the key times tell you where. You need the starting position and the position at each turning time, and nothing else.

The particle starts at 4. It moves right until t equal to 2, reaching 24. It then turns and moves left until t equal to 4, stopping at 20. After that it moves right forever. The figure draws these legs one above another only so they do not overlap; the actual motion is all along the one horizontal line.

The check compares the positions with the sign chart. Position should rise on the first leg, fall on the second, and rise on the third, and it does: 4 to 24, then 24 to 20, then on to 24 at t equal to 5. If a position had gone the wrong way, one of the calculations would be wrong.

24. Displacement versus distance travelled

Worked example

Extending Example 3.36: over the first five seconds, how far does the particle end up from its start, and how far does it actually travel?

Displacement: final minus initial position

Why: s(5) is 125 minus 225 plus 120 plus 4.

\[ s(5) - s(0) = 24 - 4 = 20 \]

Split the interval at the turning times

Why: Between turns the motion is one way, so each leg's length is an absolute change.

\[ [0,2], \; [2,4], \; [4,5] \]

Measure each leg

Why: Positions 4, 24, 20, 24.

\[ |24 - 4| = 20, \quad |20 - 24| = 4, \quad |24 - 20| = 4 \]

Add the legs

Why: Distance counts every unit of ground covered.

\[ \text{distance} = 20 + 4 + 4 = 28 \]

Check with the signed legs

Why: Adding the legs with their signs, right positive and left negative, must give back the displacement.

\[ 20 - 4 + 4 = 20 = s(5) - s(0) \]

These two words sound alike and mean different things. Displacement is where you end up relative to where you started: final position minus initial position. It can be negative. Distance travelled is how much ground you covered, counting every leg as positive.

When the particle never turns, the two agree up to a sign. When it turns, they separate, because retraced ground counts toward distance but cancels in displacement. Here the particle goes right 20, back 4, and right 4 again. It ends 20 units from its start, but it has travelled 28.

The method is always the same: split the time interval at every turning time, take the absolute change in position on each piece, and add. The check adds the same legs with their signs instead, and that must give back the displacement. It does: 20, minus 4, plus 4.

25. Find the error: distance from the endpoints

Error analysis

Annotate

On: \( \text{distance on } [0,5] = |s(5) - s(0)| = |24 - 4| = 20 \)

  • This is the size of the displacement, and it is computed correctly: the particle ends 20 units right of its start.
  • The velocity changes sign at t = 2 and t = 4, so the particle doubled back: 4 units left, then 4 units right again.
  • Split at every sign change of v and add the absolute legs: 20 + 4 + 4 = 28.

Read the claimed calculation first and decide what it actually computes before revealing the notes. Nothing in the arithmetic is wrong; the mistake is in what was asked.

The absolute value of the end-to-end change is the size of the displacement. It is the right answer to how far from the start does the particle finish, and the wrong answer to how far does it travel. The two differ whenever the velocity changes sign inside the interval, and here it does so twice.

Whenever a question says distance travelled, your first move should be to find where the velocity changes sign. If it never does, the endpoint calculation is fine. If it does, split there. That one habit prevents this error entirely.

26. Checkpoint 3.22: which way at t = 3?

Prediction

\[ s(t) = t^2 - 5t + 1 \]

Predict first

At time t = 3, is the particle moving left to right or right to left?

  • Left to right
  • Right to left
  • It is at rest
  • Cannot tell without the position

Correct: Left to right

Why: Direction is the sign of the velocity, not of the position. The velocity is 2t minus 5, which is 1 at t equal to 3: positive, so the particle moves to the right. Its position there is minus 5, which is negative, and that is the trap: where it is says nothing about which way it is going.

\[ v(t) = 2t - 5, \quad v(3) = 1 > 0 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 233 — Checkpoint 3.22

Choose your answer before revealing. The trap in this checkpoint is to look at the position and let its sign decide the direction.

The position at 3 is minus 5, so the particle is to the left of the origin. That says where it is, not which way it is going. Direction is the sign of the velocity, and the velocity is 2 t minus 5, which is 1 at t equal to 3. Positive velocity means the particle is moving to the right, from left to right.

A useful picture: you can be standing west of your house and walking east toward it. Your position is negative and your velocity is positive. Neither sign tells you anything about the other.

27. Zero velocity without a turn

Counterexample

Discussion prompt

Someone claims: whenever v(t) = 0, the object changes direction. Give a position function that breaks this claim, and say what the velocity does at the bad instant.

Write a candidate before revealing. The claim sounds right because in most textbook examples every zero of the velocity is a turn. The job is to find a case where it fails.

The cube function does it. Its velocity is 3 t squared, which is zero at t equal to 0 and positive everywhere else. The particle slows to a momentary stop at the origin and then carries on in the same direction. There is a rest, but no turn.

What this proves is that solving v equal to zero only gives you candidates. To know whether the object actually turns, you have to check that the velocity changes sign there. A squared factor in the velocity is the usual sign that it does not.

28. Exercise 157: the potato gun

Worked example

A potato is fired upward at 100 ft/s from the top of an 85-foot building. Find its velocity and speed at 0.5 s and 5.75 s, its peak, and its landing.

\[ s(t) = -16t^2 + 100t + 85 \]

Differentiate

Why: Velocity, then acceleration.

\[ v(t) = -32t + 100, \qquad a(t) = -32 \text{ ft/s}^2 \]

Evaluate the velocity at the two times

Why: One on the way up, one on the way down.

\[ v(0.5) = 84 \text{ ft/s}, \qquad v(5.75) = -84 \text{ ft/s} \]

Take absolute values for speed

Why: Same speed, opposite directions.

\[ |v(0.5)| = |v(5.75)| = 84 \text{ ft/s} \]

Find the peak where v is zero

Why: Velocity changes from positive to negative there.

\[ -32t + 100 = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; t = 3.125 \text{ s}, \quad s(3.125) = 241.25 \text{ ft} \]

Find the landing with the quadratic formula

Why: Solve s(t) = 0 and keep the positive root.

\[ 16t^2 - 100t - 85 = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; t = \frac{100 + \sqrt{15440}}{32} \approx 7.008 \text{ s} \]

Velocity on landing

Why: Substitute the landing time.

\[ v(7.008) \approx -32(7.008) + 100 \approx -124.26 \text{ ft/s} \]

Figure (svg): The height of the potato, minus 16 t squared plus 100 t plus 85, from t equals 0 to about 7. Marked points: t equals 0.5 and 5.75 at the same height 131, the peak at t equals 3.125 and height 241.25, and the landing at about t equals 7.01.

At equal heights on the way up and on the way down the speed is the same; only the sign of the velocity differs.

Check the landing speed a second way

Why: For constant acceleration 32 the square of the final speed is the square of the launch speed plus twice 32 times the drop of 85 feet.

\[ \sqrt{100^2 + 2(32)(85)} = \sqrt{15440} \approx 124.26 \;\checkmark \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 236 — Exercise 157

This exercise pulls together everything in the motion part. The velocity is minus 32 t plus 100, and the acceleration is the constant minus 32, which is gravity in feet per second per second.

At half a second the velocity is 84 feet per second upward; at 5.75 seconds it is 84 feet per second downward. The speed is the same both times, and the figure shows why: the two times are at the same height, one on the way up and one on the way down, placed symmetrically about the peak.

The peak is where the velocity is zero, at 3.125 seconds, and the height there is 241.25 feet. The landing needs the quadratic formula, because the potato starts 85 feet up rather than at the ground; it lands after about 7.01 seconds, travelling down at about 124.26 feet per second.

The check computes the landing speed a completely different way, from the rule for constant acceleration that you may know from physics. Getting the same 124.26 from both methods is strong evidence that the landing time is right.

29. Slide the launch speed

Tweak it

Parameter explorer

The curve is the potato's height s(t) = −16t² + v₀t + 85. Slide the launch speed v₀. How does the time of the peak move, and what is the velocity at the peak every time?

\[ s(t) = -16t^2 + {v}t + 85 \]

  • v — from 20 to 120: launch speed v₀ (ft/s)

Start at a launch speed of 100 and watch where the peak of the curve sits, then move the slider down and up. The peak slides left as the launch gets slower and right as it gets faster, and it rises with it.

The reason is on the velocity. The velocity is minus 32 t plus the launch speed, so it hits zero at the launch speed divided by 32. Double the launch speed and you double the time to the top. Whatever the launch speed, the velocity at the peak is zero, because the peak is exactly where the motion changes from up to down.

Notice also that the starting height of 85 feet never changes, and neither does the shape of the curve's bending. Both come from terms the slider does not touch. Only the linear term, the launch speed, moves the peak.

30. Speeding up and slowing down

Section

Part 3

31. Speeding up means v and a agree

Concept

Speed is the size of v, so it rises exactly when v squared rises. Differentiate v squared with the chain rule:

\[ \frac{d}{dt}\left[v(t)^2\right] = 2v(t)\,v'(t) = 2v(t)\,a(t) \]

\[ v\,a > 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; |v| \text{ increasing (speeding up)} \]

\[ v\,a < 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; |v| \text{ decreasing (slowing down)} \]

So compare the two signs. The same sign means speeding up; opposite signs mean slowing down. Neither sign on its own decides it.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 233 — Example 3.35(b)

This is the one genuinely new idea in the section, so it is worth seeing why it is true rather than memorising it. Speed is the size of the velocity. When the velocity is not zero, the speed rises exactly when the square of the velocity rises, because squaring and taking the size both ignore the sign.

Now differentiate the square of the velocity with the chain rule. The result is 2 times the velocity times its derivative, and the derivative of velocity is acceleration. So the speed is increasing when the product of velocity and acceleration is positive, and decreasing when it is negative.

A product is positive when its factors share a sign. So the rule is: same signs, speeding up; opposite signs, slowing down. Notice what the rule does not say. It does not say negative acceleration means slowing down. It depends on both signs together.

32. Four sign combinations, two verdicts

Picture it

Figure (svg): A two-by-two grid. In each cell a dot has a velocity arrow and an acceleration arrow. When both arrows point the same way (both right, or both left) the cell says speeding up; when they point opposite ways it says slowing down.

Acceleration is a push. A push along the direction of travel speeds you up; a push against it slows you down, whichever way is positive.

Negative acceleration speeds up an object that is already moving in the negative direction. The verdict depends on whether the push and the motion point the same way.

Each cell of the grid shows a moving dot with two arrows: its velocity, the way it is going, and its acceleration, the way it is being pushed. The verdict under each cell comes from comparing the two directions.

The top-left and bottom-left cells both say speeding up, even though the bottom one has everything negative. In both, the push points along the motion. The two right-hand cells both say slowing down, because the push points against the motion.

If you remember only one cell, remember the bottom-left one. A ball dropped from a roof has negative velocity and negative acceleration, and it certainly speeds up as it falls. That single example is enough to stop you from reading a negative acceleration as braking.

33. Example 3.35: slowing down while moving left

Worked example

At time 1, is this particle moving left or right, and is it speeding up or slowing down?

\[ s(t) = t^3 - 4t + 2 \]

Differentiate twice

Why: Velocity, then acceleration.

\[ v(t) = 3t^2 - 4, \qquad a(t) = 6t \]

Evaluate at t equal to 1

Why: Two numbers are all you need.

\[ v(1) = 3 - 4 = -1, \qquad a(1) = 6 \]

Read the direction from v

Why: Negative velocity.

\[ v(1) < 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{moving right to left} \]

Compare the signs

Why: Velocity negative, acceleration positive: opposite.

\[ v(1)\,a(1) = -6 < 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{slowing down} \]

Check with the speed just before and just after

Why: If it is slowing down, the speed at 1.1 must be less than at 0.9.

\[ |v(0.9)| = 1.57, \qquad |v(1.1)| = 0.37 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, pp. 232-233 — Example 3.35

At a single instant the whole question comes down to two numbers. Differentiate once for velocity and twice for acceleration, then evaluate both at t equal to 1. The velocity is minus 1 and the acceleration is 6.

The velocity decides the direction. It is negative, so the particle is moving from right to left. The comparison decides the speed. Velocity and acceleration have opposite signs, so the particle is being pushed to the right while moving to the left, and it is slowing down.

The check looks at the speed just before and just after t equal to 1. At 0.9 seconds the speed is 1.57, and at 1.1 seconds it is 0.37. The speed is clearly falling through t equal to 1, which is what slowing down means. In fact the particle is about to stop and turn, which happens at a time a little after 1.15.

34. Trap: negative acceleration means slowing down

Trap

The trap

A common reading of a sign:

\[ a(t) < 0 \]

\[ \Longrightarrow\; \text{slowing down?} \]

Wrong whenever the velocity is also negative.

The fix

A ball falling from a roof has negative velocity and negative acceleration, and it is speeding up. The test is the product of the two signs, not either sign alone.

\[ v < 0, \; a < 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; v\,a > 0 \]

The word deceleration is used in everyday speech for slowing down, and it is easy to hear negative acceleration the same way. In calculus, the sign of the acceleration only says which way the velocity is changing, and that is not the same as whether the speed is changing.

Test the wrong rule on a falling ball. Its velocity is negative because it moves down, and its acceleration is negative because gravity pulls down. The wrong rule says it slows down, but anyone who has dropped something knows it speeds up. The product of the signs gets it right: two negatives make a positive, so the speed increases.

35. Before reading any signs

Step zero

\[ s(t) = 2t^3 - 3t^2 - 12t + 8, \quad t \ge 0 \]

Discussion prompt

Exercise 150 asks when this particle speeds up and when it slows down. Before you evaluate anything, what do you need to find, and where can the verdict change?

Write your plan before revealing. The temptation with a question like this is to start plugging in numbers, but a single time value only answers the question at that one instant, and you need whole intervals.

The verdict depends on the signs of two functions, velocity and acceleration, and a sign can only change where the function is zero. So the plan is: find both functions, find the zeros of each, and use those zeros to cut the time axis into intervals. On each interval both signs are fixed, and so is the verdict.

Here the velocity has zeros at 2 and at minus 1, and minus 1 is outside the domain because time starts at 0. The acceleration has one zero, at one half. So there will be three intervals to check.

36. Exercise 150: intervals of speeding up

Worked example

\[ s(t) = 2t^3 - 3t^2 - 12t + 8, \quad t \ge 0 \]

Factor the velocity

Why: Take out 6, then factor.

\[ v(t) = 6(t^2 - t - 2) = 6(t-2)(t+1) \]

Sign of v for t at least 0

Why: The factor t plus 1 is always positive here.

\[ v < 0 \text{ on } [0,2), \qquad v > 0 \text{ on } (2,\infty) \]

Zero and sign of a

Why: A straight line through one half.

\[ a(t) = 12t - 6 = 0 \iff t = \tfrac12; \quad a < 0 \text{ on } [0,\tfrac12) \]

Compare signs on each interval

Why: Three intervals, cut at one half and at 2.

\[ [0,\tfrac12): \; -,- \quad (\tfrac12, 2): \; -,+ \quad (2,\infty): \; +,+ \]

State the verdict

Why: Same signs speed up; opposite signs slow down.

\[ \text{up on } [0,\tfrac12) \cup (2,\infty), \quad \text{down on } (\tfrac12, 2) \]

Figure (svg): The velocity 6 t squared minus 6 t minus 12 and the acceleration 12 t minus 6 on the same axes for t from 0 to 3. Green bands mark t from 0 to 0.5 and from 2 to 3, where both have the same sign; a red band marks 0.5 to 2, where their signs differ.

Green where the two curves are on the same side of the axis, red where they are on opposite sides. The verdict changes at every zero of v or of a.

Check with the speeds

Why: Speed must rise to one half, fall to 2, then rise.

\[ |v(0)| = 12, \; |v(\tfrac12)| = 13.5, \; |v(1)| = 12, \; |v(2)| = 0, \; |v(3)| = 24 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 235 — Exercise 150

Follow the plan from the previous slide. Factoring the velocity as 6 times t minus 2 times t plus 1 shows it is negative until 2 and positive after, since t plus 1 is always positive for times that make sense. The acceleration is a straight line crossing zero at one half.

Put the two sign lists side by side. Before one half, both are negative: speeding up. Between one half and 2, velocity is negative and acceleration positive: slowing down. After 2, both are positive: speeding up again.

The figure shades those intervals. Notice that the first speeding-up stretch is short and happens while the particle is moving left: it gets faster, then the acceleration turns positive and brakes it to a stop at 2, then pushes it the other way.

The check follows the speed itself through the key times: 12 at the start, 13.5 at one half, back to 12 at 1, zero at 2, and 24 at 3. It rises, falls and rises again, just as the sign comparison said.

37. Speeding up or slowing down?

Sorting

Sort into buckets

For the particle with v(t) = 3(t − 1)(t − 3) and a(t) = 6t − 12, and two bare sign pairs, sort each case.

Speeding up
t = 1.5: v = −2.25, a = −3; t = 4: v = 9, a = 12; v = −4, a = −1
Slowing down
t = 0.5: v = 3.75, a = −9; t = 2.5: v = −2.25, a = 3; v = 5, a = −2
up
Same signs in each: t = 1.5 (both negative), t = 4 (both positive), and the pair v = −4, a = −1. The push points along the motion.
down
Opposite signs in each: t = 0.5, t = 2.5, and v = 5 with a = −2. The push points against the motion.

Sort each case before checking. For the first four you are given the time, and the velocity and acceleration values have already been computed from the formulas; for the last two you get the signs directly. Either way, compare the two signs.

Pay attention to t equal to 1.5 and 2.5. The velocity is the same, minus 2.25, at both times, so the particle is moving left at the same speed at both. But the acceleration changes sign at 2, so the particle is speeding up at 1.5 and slowing down at 2.5. The same velocity with different accelerations gives different verdicts.

Also notice that none of the cases where the particle speeds up can be spotted from one sign alone. Two of them have negative acceleration, one of them has negative velocity. Only the comparison works every time.

38. Example 3.36's particle, interval by interval

Comparison

\[ v(t) = 3(t-2)(t-4), \qquad a(t) = 6t - 18 \]

Comparison matrix

intervalsign of vsign of averdict
(0, 2)+−slowing down
(2, 3)−−speeding up
(3, 4)−+slowing down
(4, ∞)++speeding up

Fill in the blanks before checking. You already know the velocity signs from the sign chart earlier in the lesson. The acceleration is 6 t minus 18, which is zero at 3, so it is negative before 3 and positive after.

The acceleration's zero at 3 splits the middle interval in two, which is why there are four rows rather than three. Between 2 and 3 the particle moves left and is pushed left, so it speeds up. Between 3 and 4 it still moves left but is now pushed right, so it slows down, coming to rest at 4.

Read the table as a story: the particle leaves at speed, slows to a stop at 2, speeds up going backwards, slows to a stop at 4, then speeds up forwards forever. Matching that story against the path drawn earlier is a good way to make it stick.

39. Populations, sciences and units

Section

Part 4

40. The population growth rate

Concept

population growth rate — If P(t) is the number of individuals in a population at time t, its growth rate is the derivative P′(t): individuals per unit of time.

\[ P(t+h) \approx P(t) + P'(t)\,h \]

This is the amount of change formula with a population in place of f. Today's size and today's growth rate predict the size a short time ahead.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, pp. 233-234 — Definition

Nothing new is happening mathematically here, and that is the lesson. A population that changes over time is a function, and its derivative is a rate: individuals per unit of time. The book calls it the population growth rate.

The amount of change formula carries straight over. Today's population plus today's growth rate times the number of years ahead estimates the population that many years ahead. The same warning applies too: the growth rate will not stay constant, so the estimate is good for short steps and poor for long ones.

Treating a population as a smooth function is itself an approximation, since a population goes up in whole individuals. For large populations the steps are so small compared with the total that the approximation is excellent, which is why this works for cities and bacteria but would be silly for a family.

41. Example 3.37: a city that triples

Worked example

A city of 10,000 triples every 5 years. Estimate its population 2 years from now.

Set up in thousands

Why: Now is t equal to 0; tripling gives the value at 5.

\[ P(0) = 10, \qquad P(5) = 30 \]

Estimate the current growth rate

Why: The book uses the average rate over the five years.

\[ P'(0) \approx \frac{P(5) - P(0)}{5 - 0} = \frac{30 - 10}{5} = 4 \]

Apply the amount of change formula

Why: Step h equal to 2 years.

\[ P(2) \approx P(0) + 2P'(0) = 10 + 2(4) = 18 \]

Convert back from thousands

Why: The book's answer.

\[ P(2) \approx 18{,}000 \]

Figure (svg): The curve P equals 10 times 3 to the t over 5 from t equals 0 to 5.5. A dashed secant joins (0, 10) to (5, 30); following it to t equals 2 gives the estimate 18, marked above the curve, whose true height at t equals 2 is about 15.5.

The book's rate of 4 thousand per year is the slope of the dashed secant, an average over five years. The curve is much flatter at t equals 0, so the estimate overshoots.

Check against the exact tripling model

Why: Tripling every 5 years means ten thousand times three to the power t over 5. Its true rate at 0 is only about 2.2, so the book's 18,000 overshoots the model's value by about 2,500.

\[ P(t) = 10 \cdot 3^{t/5}: \quad P(2) = 10 \cdot 3^{2/5} \approx 15.52, \quad P'(0) = 2\ln 3 \approx 2.20 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 234 — Example 3.37

The book's solution is short. Work in thousands, so the population now is 10 and the population in 5 years is 30. Estimate the current growth rate as the average rate over those five years, which is 4 thousand per year. Then the amount of change formula gives 10 plus 2 times 4, which is 18 thousand in two years.

Look closely at the second step. The rate it uses is an average over the next five years, not the growth rate now. The amount of change formula wants the instantaneous rate at the start. So the example mixes the two measures of change from the start of the lesson.

The check shows the cost. If the city truly triples every five years, its population follows an exponential curve, and the figure draws it. That curve is much flatter at the start than the dashed secant, so its true rate now is about 2.2 thousand per year, not 4. The model predicts about 15,500 people in two years, not 18,000. The book's method is a rough estimate from limited data; knowing which way it errs is part of using it well.

42. Checkpoint 3.23: the mosquito colony

Fill the middle

A mosquito colony has 3,000 insects now and is growing at 100 per day. Estimate its size in 3 days.

Fill in the blanks

P(3) \approx P(0) + 3\,P'(0) = 3000 + 3(100) = 3300

Why: The step is 3 days and the rate is 100 insects per day, so the change is about 300 insects and the colony is about 3,300.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 234 — Checkpoint 3.23

Fill in the blanks before checking. This is the amount of change formula in its simplest form: the step is three days, and the growth rate is given directly as 100 mosquitoes per day.

Three days at about 100 per day adds about 300 mosquitoes, so the colony grows from 3,000 to about 3,300. Unlike the city example, the rate here is given as the rate right now, so this is the formula used exactly as intended.

Check the units as you go: days times mosquitoes per day gives mosquitoes, which is what should be added to a number of mosquitoes. That quick unit check is worth doing every time, and the units part of this lesson makes it a habit.

43. A rate of a rate

Intuition

The second derivative is the rate at which the rate itself changes. For a population it says whether growth is accelerating or easing off.

\[ P''(t) > 0: \text{ growth speeding up}, \qquad P''(t) < 0: \text{ growth easing off} \]

It is the population version of acceleration, and it answers a different question from P′: not whether the population is rising, but whether it is rising faster than before.

You met the second derivative as acceleration: the rate of change of velocity. The same idea applies to any quantity. For a population, the first derivative is the growth rate, and the second derivative is how fast that growth rate is changing.

The two carry different information. A positive first derivative says the population is rising. A positive second derivative says it is rising faster and faster, and a negative second derivative says it is still rising but more and more slowly. A news report that says growth is slowing is talking about the second derivative, not the first.

Keep the two separate in your head, because mixing them up leads to the trap coming up in two slides: reading a falling growth rate as a falling population.

44. Exercise 164: a town in Ohio

Worked example

A town's population in thousands, t years from now, is modelled below. Find and interpret the first and second derivatives at years 1, 2, 3 and 4.

\[ P(t) = -\frac{1}{3}t^3 + 64t + 3000 \]

Differentiate

Why: Power rule on each term.

\[ P'(t) = -t^2 + 64 \text{ thousand people per year} \]

Evaluate the growth rate

Why: Substitute 1, 2, 3, 4.

\[ P'(1) = 63, \; P'(2) = 60, \; P'(3) = 55, \; P'(4) = 48 \]

Differentiate again

Why: The rate of change of the growth rate.

\[ P''(t) = -2t \text{ thousand people per year per year} \]

Evaluate the second derivative

Why: Substitute 1, 2, 3, 4.

\[ P''(1) = -2, \; P''(2) = -4, \; P''(3) = -6, \; P''(4) = -8 \]

Interpret

Why: Positive P′ but negative P″: the town grows every year, by less each year.

\[ P' > 0, \; P'' < 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{growing, more slowly} \]

Figure (svg): The curve P prime of t equals 64 minus t squared for t from 0 to 8.5, falling from 64 to zero at t equals 8. Dots at t equals 1, 2, 3, 4 mark the values 63, 60, 55 and 48.

The growth rate is falling, but it is still positive: the town keeps growing, just more slowly each year, until year 8.

Check P′(1) against the actual first-year change

Why: The rate at t = 1 should estimate P(2) minus P(1), and slightly overshoot it because the rate is falling.

\[ P(2) - P(1) = 3125.33 - 3063.67 = 61.67 \approx 63 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 237 — Exercise 164

The model is a cubic, so both derivatives are quick. The growth rate is 64 minus t squared, in thousands of people per year. At years 1 through 4 it is 63, 60, 55 and 48 thousand people per year.

The second derivative is minus 2 t, in thousands of people per year per year. It is negative at every one of those times and getting more negative. So the growth rate is falling, and falling faster each year.

Put the two readings together: the town grows every year in this window, but each year it adds fewer people than the year before. The figure shows the growth rate curve sliding down toward zero, which it reaches at year 8. Only after that would the town start to shrink.

The check compares the growth rate at year 1 with the actual growth during year 2, from year 1 to year 2. The rate predicts 63 thousand; the model gives 61.67 thousand. The estimate is a little high, as it should be when the rate is falling during the step.

45. Trap: a falling growth rate means a falling population

Trap

The trap

Reading Exercise 164:

\[ P'(1) = 63, \; P'(4) = 48 \]

\[ \Longrightarrow\; \text{the town is shrinking?} \]

Wrong. The rate went down, not the population.

The fix

The population falls only when P′ itself is negative. Here P′ is positive every year until year 8, so the town gains 48 thousand people in year four; it just gains fewer than before.

\[ P' > 0: \text{ still growing} \]

This mistake comes from reading a derivative as if it were the quantity itself. The growth rate dropped from 63 to 48 thousand per year, and it is tempting to hear that as the town losing people.

The population falls only when the growth rate is below zero. A growth rate of 48 thousand per year still adds 48 thousand people in a year. The decline in the rate means the growth is slowing, not that the town is shrinking. The same confusion shows up with prices, where falling inflation still means rising prices, only more slowly, and with speed, where slowing down still means moving forward.

46. The units of a derivative

Concept

A derivative is a limit of change in output divided by change in input, so its units are the output units divided by the input units.

\[ \frac{\Delta V}{\Delta t} \;\to\; \frac{\text{litres}}{\text{minute}} \]

\[ \text{units of } f'(x) = \frac{\text{units of } f}{\text{units of } x} \]

Attaching units is also a check: if a velocity comes out in feet squared, something went wrong.

The units of a derivative come straight from the definition. The derivative is a limit of fractions whose top is a change in the output and whose bottom is a change in the input. Taking a limit does not change units, so the derivative has output units divided by input units.

In the example, V measures volume in litres and t measures time in minutes, so the derivative of V is in litres per minute. If you ever cannot remember what a derivative means in a problem, write out its units in words and read them aloud: litres per minute is a flow rate.

Units also catch errors. If you are asked for a velocity and your units come out as feet times seconds, you multiplied where you should have divided. Writing units on every answer takes a few seconds and saves a lot of lost marks.

47. Match each derivative to its units

Matching

Match the pairs

  • a. V′(t): V in litres, t in minutes
  • b. C′(x): C in dollars, x in items
  • c. F′(r): F in newtons, r in metres
  • d. a(t) = v′(t): v in ft/s, t in seconds
  • w. litres per minute
  • x. dollars per item
  • y. newtons per metre
  • z. feet per second per second

Why: Every time, output units over input units. Acceleration looks strange only because its output, velocity, already has a per in it.

Make each match before checking, by writing the output units over the input units. The first three are direct: litres per minute, dollars per item, newtons per metre.

The last one is the one that looks odd. Acceleration is the derivative of velocity, whose units are already feet per second. Dividing by seconds again gives feet per second per second, often written as feet per second squared. It reads as how many feet per second the velocity changes by in each second.

Every applied derivative you meet in this course has units built this way. Once you trust the rule, you never need to memorise the units of any particular rate.

48. Exercise 166: centripetal force

Worked example

The centripetal force on a mass m moving at speed v, at distance r from the centre, is given below. Find its rate of change with respect to r, then evaluate it for a 1000 kg mass at 13.89 m/s, 200 m from the centre.

\[ F(r) = \frac{mv^2}{r} \]

Rewrite as a power of r

Why: m and v are constants.

\[ F(r) = mv^2 r^{-1} \]

Differentiate

Why: Power rule.

\[ F'(r) = -mv^2 r^{-2} = -\frac{mv^2}{r^2} \]

Substitute the values

Why: 13.89 squared is 192.93.

\[ F'(200) = -\frac{1000(192.93)}{200^2} = -\frac{192932.1}{40000} \]

Simplify with units

Why: Newtons per metre.

\[ F'(200) \approx -4.82 \text{ N/m} \]

Check against the actual change over one metre

Why: Moving from 200 m to 201 m, the force should drop by about 4.8 newtons.

\[ F(201) - F(200) \approx 959.86 - 964.66 = -4.80 \text{ N} \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 237 — Exercise 166

The key step is recognising what is constant. The mass and the speed are fixed, and only the distance r varies, so the force is a constant times r to the minus one. The power rule gives the derivative as minus the constant times r to the minus two.

The sign tells you something physical: as the distance from the centre grows, the force needed to keep the object on its circle decreases. The units, newtons per metre, tell you the size of that decrease for each extra metre of radius.

Substituting the values gives about minus 4.82 newtons per metre. The check computes the actual forces at 200 and at 201 metres and subtracts; the drop is about 4.80 newtons, very close to the derivative's prediction. That agreement is what the derivative promises for a one-unit step when the function is not bending sharply.

49. A bacteria culture that peaks

Real world

Figure (svg): The bacteria count N of t equals 3000 times 1 plus 4t over t squared plus 100, for t from 0 to 40 hours. It climbs from 3000 to a peak of 3600 at t equals 10, then declines slowly, passing 3480 at t equals 20 and 3360 at t equals 30.

Fast growth at first, a peak at ten hours, then a slow decline that is itself slowing down.

Discussion prompt

Exercise 165: N(t) = 3000(1 + 4t/(t² + 100)) bacteria after t hours, with N′(t) = 12000(100 − t²)/(t² + 100)². Interpret N′(0) = 120, N′(10) = 0, N′(20) = −14.4 and N′(30) = −9.6.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 237 — Exercise 165

Write your interpretations before revealing. Read each derivative as a rate, with units of bacteria per hour, and pay attention to its sign.

At the start the culture is growing at 120 bacteria per hour. At 10 hours the rate is zero: the culture has reached its peak of 3,600 and is momentarily holding steady. After that the rate is negative, so the culture is shrinking.

Compare the last two values. At 20 hours it is losing about 14.4 bacteria per hour, and at 30 hours about 9.6. The decline continues but more slowly, which the figure shows as a curve flattening out on its way down. That is the second-derivative reading again: the rate is negative, but it is rising toward zero.

50. Marginal cost, revenue and profit

Section

Part 5

51. Marginal means derivative

Concept

In economics the derivative of a total has its own name.

\[ MC(x) = C'(x), \qquad MR(x) = R'(x) \]

\[ P(x) = R(x) - C(x) \;\Longrightarrow\; MP(x) = P'(x) = R'(x) - C'(x) \]

marginal cost, revenue, profit — The derivatives of the cost, revenue and profit functions with respect to the number of items x. Their units are dollars per item.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 234 — Definition

Economists have their own word for derivative: marginal. Marginal cost is the derivative of the cost function, marginal revenue is the derivative of the revenue function, and marginal profit is the derivative of the profit function.

Because profit is revenue minus cost, and derivatives respect differences, marginal profit is marginal revenue minus marginal cost. That identity is worth remembering: it lets you find marginal profit without writing the profit function at all, and it gives you a free check when you do.

All three are in dollars per item. They measure how fast the totals change as production or sales increase, and the next slide shows why that rate is a good stand-in for the cost or revenue of one more item.

52. Why a derivative prices one more item

Concept

Items come in whole numbers, so the smallest sensible step is one item. Put h equal to 1 in the difference quotient.

\[ C'(x) = \lim_{h\to 0}\frac{C(x+h) - C(x)}{h} \]

\[ C'(x) \approx \frac{C(x+1) - C(x)}{1} = C(x+1) - C(x) \]

The right side is the cost of producing item number x plus 1. So the marginal cost at x estimates the cost of the next item.

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 234 — the approximation with h = 1

The derivative is a limit as the step goes to zero, but you cannot make a fraction of a dishwasher. The smallest meaningful step in production is one item. So take the difference quotient with a step of one and drop the limit.

With a step of one, the denominator disappears and you are left with C of x plus 1 minus C of x: the exact extra cost of making item number x plus 1. So the marginal cost at x approximates the cost of the next item.

The approximation is the amount of change formula again, with a step of one. That means everything you learned about its error still holds. If the cost curve bends upward, the marginal cost underestimates the true cost of the next item; if it bends downward, it overestimates. For a business making thousands of items, one item is a tiny step and the estimate is excellent.

53. Reading the marginal cost approximation

Notation

Annotate

On: \( MC(x) = C'(x) \approx C(x+1) - C(x) \)

  • Marginal cost at a production level of x items: a rate, in dollars per item.
  • The exact extra cost of item number x + 1. Note the + 1: the rate at 100 prices the 101st item.
  • The derivative uses the tangent line; the exact difference uses the curve. They differ by the bending of C over one unit.

Step through the annotations, and focus on the plus one. The marginal cost evaluated at 100 estimates the cost of the 101st item, not the 100th. It is the rate at the start of the step from 100 items to 101.

This off-by-one confuses people for a simple reason: the question says 101st, so it feels natural to put 101 into the derivative. But putting in 101 estimates the step from 101 to 102, which is the 102nd item.

The approximately-equal sign has the same meaning as before. The derivative follows the tangent line, the exact difference follows the curve, and the gap is the bending of the curve over one unit. The examples that follow compute both sides so you can see how small that gap usually is.

54. Example 3.38: the 101st barbecue dinner

Worked example

When x barbecue dinners are sold, the price is p dollars, for x from 0 to 300, and revenue is quantity times price. Estimate the revenue from the 101st dinner and compare with the exact value.

\[ p(x) = 9 - 0.03x, \qquad R(x) = x\,p(x) \]

Build the revenue function

Why: Multiply quantity by price.

\[ R(x) = x(9 - 0.03x) = -0.03x^2 + 9x \]

Differentiate

Why: Marginal revenue.

\[ MR(x) = R'(x) = -0.06x + 9 \]

Evaluate at 100

Why: The rate at 100 prices the 101st dinner.

\[ R'(100) = -6 + 9 = 3 \]

Compute the exact revenue from the 101st dinner

Why: R(101) minus R(100).

\[ R(101) - R(100) = 602.97 - 600 = 2.97 \]

Figure (svg): The revenue parabola R of x equals minus 0.03 x squared plus 9 x from 0 to 300, peaking at 675 when x is 150. The tangent line at x equals 100, where R is 600, has slope 3.

Marginal revenue is the slope of the revenue curve. At 100 dinners it is still positive; past 150 each extra dinner, sold at the lower price it demands, brings in less total revenue.

Check the comparison

Why: The estimate 3 dollars is 3 cents above the true 2.97 dollars: the revenue curve bends down, so the tangent runs above it.

\[ 3 - 2.97 = 0.03 \text{ dollars} \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 235 — Example 3.38

The first step builds the revenue function from the price function. Revenue is the number sold times the price each one sells for, and here the price falls as more dinners are sold. Multiplying out gives a downward parabola.

Marginal revenue is its derivative, minus 0.06 x plus 9. To price the 101st dinner, evaluate at 100: the answer is 3 dollars. The exact revenue from that dinner, the revenue from 101 dinners minus the revenue from 100, is 2.97 dollars.

The figure shows the whole revenue curve. At 100 dinners it is still climbing, with slope 3. At 150 it peaks, where the marginal revenue is zero, and beyond that each extra dinner actually lowers total revenue, because the lower price hits every dinner sold.

The check compares the estimate with the exact value: 3 cents apart, and the estimate is the higher one. That is what a downward-bending revenue curve should produce, since the tangent line runs above it.

55. Checkpoint 3.24: fish-fry profit

Worked example

\[ P(x) = -0.03x^2 + 8x - 50 \]

Differentiate

Why: Marginal profit.

\[ P'(x) = -0.06x + 8 \]

Evaluate at 100 to price the 101st dinner

Why: Six less than eight.

\[ P'(100) = -6 + 8 = 2 \text{ dollars} \]

Check against the exact profit from the 101st dinner

Why: The difference should be close to 2, and slightly below it since P bends down.

\[ P(101) - P(100) = 451.97 - 450 = 1.97 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 235 — Checkpoint 3.24

This checkpoint runs the same routine on a profit function. Differentiate to get the marginal profit, minus 0.06 x plus 8, then evaluate at 100 to price the 101st dinner. The marginal profit is 2 dollars.

The check computes the exact profit from the 101st dinner, 451.97 minus 450, which is 1.97 dollars. The estimate is 3 cents high, exactly as in the revenue example, and for the same reason: the profit function has the same downward-bending quadratic term.

In fact, for any quadratic function the gap between the derivative estimate and the exact one-step change is the coefficient of the squared term. Here that coefficient is minus 0.03, which is why the gap is 3 cents.

56. How close is the marginal estimate?

Estimation

\[ C(x) = 1000 + 12x + 0.1x^2, \qquad C'(50) = 22 \]

Predict first

The marginal cost at 50 is 22 dollars. Guess the exact cost of the 51st unit, C(51) − C(50).

  • Exactly 22
  • 22.10
  • About 23
  • About 44

Correct: 22.10

Why: The exact cost is 1872.10 minus 1850, which is 22.10. The cost curve bends upward, so the tangent runs a little below it and the marginal estimate is ten cents low. For a quadratic cost the gap is always the coefficient of x squared, here 0.1.

\[ C(51) - C(50) = 1872.10 - 1850 = 22.10 \]

Guess before revealing. You know the marginal cost at 50 is 22 dollars; the question is how far the true cost of the 51st unit is from that.

The exact cost is the total for 51 units minus the total for 50, which is 22.10 dollars. So the estimate is only ten cents low. The cost curve bends upward because of the 0.1 x squared term, so the tangent runs just below it, and the estimate comes out slightly low.

The options of 23 and 44 are there because each one makes a common slip: 23 is what you might guess if you thought the error was large, and 44 would come from doubling the rate by mistake. In practice, marginal estimates for smooth cost functions are close to exact, which is why businesses use them.

57. Exercise 160: the thirteenth food processor

Worked example

\[ C(x) = 200 + \frac{7}{x} + \frac{x^2}{7} \]

Differentiate

Why: Write 7 over x as 7 times x to the minus one.

\[ MC(x) = C'(x) = -\frac{7}{x^2} + \frac{2x}{7} \]

Evaluate at 12 to estimate the 13th

Why: The rate at 12 prices item 13.

\[ C'(12) = -\frac{7}{144} + \frac{24}{7} \approx -0.0486 + 3.4286 = 3.38 \]

Find the actual cost of the 13th

Why: C(13) minus C(12).

\[ C(13) - C(12) \approx 224.6813 - 221.1548 = 3.53 \]

Figure (svg): A zoomed view of the cost curve C of x from 11.6 to 13.4. The tangent at x equals 12 rises to 224.53 at x equals 13, just below the curve's 224.68; a small red gap of about 0.15 separates them.

Over a one-unit step the tangent and the curve part company by about fifteen cents: the marginal estimate is slightly low because the cost curve bends upward.

Check the direction of the error

Why: The second derivative is positive, so the cost curve bends up and the marginal estimate must be low; it is, by about 15 cents.

\[ C''(x) = \frac{14}{x^3} + \frac{2}{7} > 0, \qquad 3.38 < 3.53 \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 236 — Exercise 160

The cost function has a term 7 over x, which is easier to differentiate if you rewrite it as 7 times x to the minus one. The power rule then gives minus 7 over x squared, and the last term gives 2 x over 7.

To estimate the cost of the thirteenth processor, evaluate the marginal cost at 12, the level just before it. The value is about 3.38 dollars. The exact cost, the total for 13 minus the total for 12, is about 3.53 dollars.

The figure zooms in on the stretch from 12 to 13 so you can see the gap: the tangent at 12 arrives just below the curve. The check explains the direction of the error using the second derivative, which is positive everywhere here, so the cost curve bends upward and the estimate must be low. It is, by about 15 cents.

58. Exercise 163: cordless drills

Worked example

Cordless drills sell at price p when x are sold, and cost C(x) to make. Find and interpret the marginal revenue and marginal profit at 1000 and at 4000 drills.

\[ p = 143 - 0.03x, \qquad C(x) = 75{,}000 + 65x \]

Marginal cost

Why: The fixed cost disappears.

\[ C'(x) = 65 \]

Revenue and marginal revenue

Why: Quantity times price.

\[ R(x) = 143x - 0.03x^2, \qquad R'(x) = 143 - 0.06x \]

Evaluate R′

Why: At 1000 and 4000.

\[ R'(1000) = 83, \qquad R'(4000) = -97 \]

Profit and marginal profit

Why: Revenue minus cost.

\[ P(x) = -0.03x^2 + 78x - 75{,}000, \qquad P'(x) = 78 - 0.06x \]

Evaluate P′

Why: At 1000 and 4000.

\[ P'(1000) = 18, \qquad P'(4000) = -162 \]

Interpret

Why: The 1001st drill adds about 18 dollars of profit; the 4001st lowers profit by about 162 dollars.

\[ \text{sell more at } 1000, \quad \text{sell fewer at } 4000 \]

Check with MP = MR − MC

Why: Each marginal profit must be the marginal revenue minus 65.

\[ 83 - 65 = 18 \;\checkmark, \qquad -97 - 65 = -162 \;\checkmark \]

OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change §3.4, p. 237 — Exercise 163

This is a longer problem, but each piece is one derivative. The cost is a fixed amount plus 65 dollars per drill, so the marginal cost is simply 65. Revenue is quantity times price; its derivative is 143 minus 0.06 x.

At 1000 drills the marginal revenue is 83 dollars: selling one more brings in about 83 dollars. At 4000 it is minus 97: selling one more actually lowers total revenue, because the price cut needed to sell it applies to all 4000.

Marginal profit follows the same pattern: plus 18 dollars at 1000 and minus 162 dollars at 4000. So at 1000 drills, making and selling more adds profit; at 4000, it destroys profit, and the firm should sell fewer.

The check uses the identity from the start of this part, marginal profit equals marginal revenue minus marginal cost. Subtracting 65 from each marginal revenue gives the two marginal profits exactly. When two independent routes agree, you can trust both.

59. Find the error: a negative marginal profit

Error analysis

Annotate

On: \( P'(4000) = -162 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{the firm loses 162 dollars at 4000 drills} \)

  • A rate, in dollars per drill: how profit changes when one more drill is sold. It is computed correctly.
  • It is not the profit itself. P(4000) is a different number: minus 243,000 dollars in this model.
  • Selling the 4001st drill lowers total profit by about 162 dollars, so this firm is selling too many.

Read the claim and decide what is wrong before revealing the notes. The number is right; the interpretation is not.

Marginal profit is a rate, in dollars per drill. It says what happens to total profit when one more drill is sold. A value of minus 162 means that selling the 4001st drill would lower total profit by about 162 dollars. It says nothing directly about the profit at 4000 drills, which is a separate calculation.

In this model the profit at 4000 drills happens to be minus 243,000 dollars, a genuine loss, but you learn that from the profit function, not its derivative. The same confusion between a value and its rate appeared with the town's population. The cure is the same too: say the units out loud. Dollars per drill is a rate, and dollars is a value.

60. Putting it together

Section

Part 6

61. Pattern: reading any derivative as a rate

Pattern

Figure (svg): A flow diagram. Position s(t) is differentiated to velocity v(t), then to acceleration a(t). From v: zeros of v give rest times, the sign of v gives direction. From v and a together: same signs mean speeding up, opposite signs slowing down.

Two derivatives, then three readings: when it stops, which way it goes, and whether it is gaining speed.
  1. Name the units first: output units per input unit.
  2. To estimate a new value, use old value plus rate times step, and say which way the error goes.
  3. For motion, differentiate twice; zeros of v give rest, the sign of v gives direction.
  4. To decide speeding up, compare the signs of v and a on each interval between their zeros.
  5. For distance, split at every sign change of v and add the absolute legs.
  6. For the (n + 1)th item, evaluate the marginal function at n.

This slide gathers the whole lesson into one routine. The flow diagram shows the motion part: differentiate position twice, then make three readings. Zeros of the velocity give rest times, the sign of the velocity gives direction, and the signs of velocity and acceleration together say whether the object is speeding up.

The list adds the rest. Always start by naming the units, because they tell you what kind of quantity the derivative is. Use the amount of change formula for estimates, and say which way the error goes. For distance, never use only the endpoints if the object turns.

The last rule, about the plus one in marginal problems, is small but costs marks often. The rate at a production level prices the next item, so the cost of item n plus 1 uses the marginal cost at n.

62. Put a motion analysis in order

Ranking

Put in order

Order the steps for finding the total distance a particle travels on an interval.

  1. Differentiate s(t) to get v(t)
  2. Solve v(t) = 0 to find candidate turning times
  3. Check the sign of v on each piece to confirm real turns
  4. Evaluate s at the endpoints and at each turning time
  5. Add the absolute changes in position over each leg

Why: Velocity first, because turns live where it changes sign. Only confirmed turns split the interval, and the distance is the sum of the absolute legs, never the single end-to-end difference.

Put the steps in order before checking. The order matters because each step uses the result of the one before.

You cannot find turning times without the velocity, and you cannot trust a candidate turning time until you have checked that the velocity changes sign there. Only then do you know how to split the interval, and only then are the positions at the split points meaningful. The final step adds the absolute legs.

If you skip the sign check, a zero of the velocity that is not a turn will split the interval unnecessarily. That does no harm to the total, but skipping the split at a real turn does, so the velocity step is the one never to skip.

63. Check: speeding up

Check

Check your understanding

At some instant a particle has v = −3 m/s and a = −2 m/s². What is happening?

  • A. Moving left and slowing down
  • B. Moving left and speeding up (correct)
  • C. Moving right and slowing down
  • D. Moving right and speeding up

Answer: B

Why: The velocity is negative, so the particle moves left. The acceleration has the same sign as the velocity, so the push points along the motion and the speed is increasing.

Why A tempts people
Negative acceleration alone does not mean slowing down; here it points the same way as the motion.
Why C tempts people
A negative velocity means moving left, not right.
Why D tempts people
The direction comes from the sign of v, which is negative, so the particle moves left.

Answer before revealing, and make two separate decisions: direction from the velocity alone, and speeding up or slowing down from the two signs together.

The velocity is negative, so the particle moves left. The acceleration is also negative, the same sign as the velocity, so the push points along the motion and the speed is increasing. The answer is moving left and speeding up.

If you chose slowing down, the negative acceleration persuaded you on its own. Go back to the falling ball: negative velocity, negative acceleration, and definitely speeding up.

64. Check: the marginal estimate

Check

Check your understanding

For C(x) = 1000 + 12x + 0.1x², which number estimates the cost of the 51st unit?

  • A. C′(51) = 22.20
  • B. C′(50) = 22 (correct)
  • C. C(51) = 1872.10
  • D. 12, the coefficient of x

Answer: B

Why: The 51st unit takes production from 50 to 51, so the rate at the start of that step, the marginal cost at 50, estimates it. The exact cost is 22.10.

Why A tempts people
The marginal cost at 51 estimates the 52nd unit, the step from 51 to 52.
Why C tempts people
That is the total cost of all 51 units, not the cost of the last one.
Why D tempts people
Twelve is the marginal cost only at x equal to 0; the 0.1x² term adds to it.

Answer before revealing. This question tests the plus-one rule: which production level does the marginal cost get evaluated at to price the 51st unit?

The 51st unit is the step from 50 units to 51, so the rate at the start of that step, the marginal cost at 50, estimates it. That is 22 dollars, and the exact cost is 22.10.

The option using 51 is the classic off-by-one; it estimates the 52nd unit. The total cost of 51 units answers a different question entirely. And 12, the coefficient of x, is the marginal cost only at zero production.

65. Check: units of a rate

Check

Check your understanding

A tank holds V(t) litres of water t minutes after a valve opens, and V′(5) = −12. Which statement is correct?

  • A. After 5 minutes the tank holds −12 litres
  • B. At 5 minutes water is leaving at about 12 litres per minute (correct)
  • C. The tank empties in 12 minutes
  • D. At 5 minutes water is leaving at about 12 minutes per litre

Answer: B

Why: The derivative is a rate in litres per minute. Its negative sign means the volume is decreasing, so water is draining at about 12 litres per minute at that instant.

Why A tempts people
That reads the rate as a value; the volume itself is not given.
Why C tempts people
One rate at one instant cannot tell you when the tank empties; the rate may change.
Why D tempts people
The units are inverted: output over input is litres per minute.

Answer before revealing, and start by writing the units of the derivative: litres over minutes, so litres per minute.

A derivative of minus 12 litres per minute means that at the 5-minute mark the volume is decreasing at 12 litres per minute. Water is draining out at that rate. It says nothing about how much water is in the tank, and a single rate at a single instant cannot tell you when the tank will be empty, because the rate may change.

If you picked the option with minutes per litre, you inverted the units. Remember the rule: output over input, and the output here is volume.

66. Explain the sign rule

Explain it to yourself

Discussion prompt

In two or three sentences, explain why comparing the signs of v and a decides whether an object is speeding up, using either the chain rule or a physical picture.

Write your explanation before revealing. Being able to justify the sign rule, rather than just state it, is what lets you apply it confidently in cases that look unusual.

There are two good explanations, and you can give either. The algebraic one: speed rises exactly when the square of the velocity rises, and the derivative of that square is 2 times the velocity times the acceleration, which is positive exactly when the two have the same sign. The physical one: acceleration is a push, and a push along your direction of travel adds speed while a push against it removes speed.

The best answers include both, because each makes the other convincing. The algebra proves the rule; the picture makes it obvious why negative acceleration can mean speeding up.

67. Exit ticket

Exit ticket

\[ s(t) = t^3 - 6t^2 + 9t, \qquad 0 \le t \le 4 \]

Discussion prompt

Find when the particle is at rest, when it moves backwards, its displacement and its total distance on [0, 4], and whether it is speeding up at t = 1.5.

This one problem uses every part of the motion material. Work it fully before revealing: velocity, rest times, direction, displacement, distance, and the speeding-up test at one instant.

The velocity factors as 3 times t minus 1 times t minus 3, so the particle is at rest at 1 and at 3 and moves backward between them. The positions at 0, 1, 3 and 4 are 0, 4, 0 and 4. So the particle ends 4 units from its start, but it travels 4 forward, 4 back and 4 forward again: 12 units in all.

At 1.5 seconds the velocity is minus 2.25 and the acceleration is minus 3. Both negative, so the particle is speeding up while moving backward. If you got every part, you have the whole of this lesson's motion toolkit.

68. Recap

Recap

ideaformularead it as
amount of changef(a + h) ≈ f(a) + f′(a)hold value plus rate times step; error shrinks like h²
motionv = s′, speed = |v|, a = v′ = s″sign of v gives direction; v = 0 with a sign change is a turn
speeding upv and a with the same signopposite signs mean slowing down
populationP(t + h) ≈ P(t) + P′(t)hindividuals per unit time
marginalC′(x) ≈ C(x + 1) − C(x)the cost of item x + 1

Every applied derivative carries output units per input unit. Next, Section 3.5 differentiates the trigonometric functions, which gives new motions to analyse.

Stewart, Calculus: Early Transcendentals 8e, §3.7 Rates of Change in the Natural and Social Sciences §3.7, pp. 224-236 — the same material in Stewart

One idea runs through the whole table: a derivative is a rate, with output units per input unit. The amount of change formula uses that rate to estimate a new value, with an error that shrinks like the square of the step.

For motion, the derivative of position is velocity, whose sign gives direction and whose size is speed, and the derivative of velocity is acceleration. Speeding up means velocity and acceleration share a sign. For populations, the same formulas predict future sizes, and the second derivative says whether growth is accelerating or easing. For business, the marginal functions estimate the cost, revenue or profit of the next item, using the rate at the level just before it.

Section 3.5 adds the derivatives of the trigonometric functions. They bring oscillating motions, such as a mass on a spring, which you will analyse with exactly the tools from this lesson.

Sources

  1. OpenStax Calculus Volume 1, §3.4 Derivatives as Rates of Change — Strang & Herman, OpenStax / Rice University, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, pp. 230-240
  2. Stewart, Calculus: Early Transcendentals 8e, §3.7 Rates of Change in the Natural and Social Sciences — James Stewart, Cengage Learning, 2016, pp. 224-236

Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Calculus I — $55/session, free consultation.

Book on Wyzant · Text (657) 465-8108