Unit 4 of the algebra-based course, organised around a five-step momentum attack whose key move is choosing the system before writing any equation. It defines momentum as a signed vector and contrasts it with kinetic energy, finds impulse as force times time and as the area under a force-time graph, uses the impulse-momentum theorem to explain airbags, bounces and follow-through, states exactly when momentum is conserved, classifies and solves elastic, inelastic and perfectly inelastic collisions, treats recoil as a collision run backwards, handles two-dimensional collisions component by component, uses the centre of mass velocity as a free check, and closes with the two-stage ballistic pendulum. No calculus is used anywhere.
Subject: AP Physics 1 · 71 slides · diagram-first lesson
Open the interactive version of this deck
Title
Unit 4
Impulse, conservation and collisions: solving problems where the forces are unknown
Objectives
Forces and energy already let you solve a lot. What they cannot do is handle a collision, where the forces are enormous, last a few thousandths of a second, and are never given. Momentum is the tool that answers the question anyway, and this unit is about using it as a method rather than a formula.
College Board, AP Physics 1: Algebra-Based Course and Exam Description Unit 4, Linear Momentum
Section
What a push actually changes
Concept
\[ \vec{p} = m\vec{v} \]
Momentum points the same way as the velocity and takes its sign. A cart moving left on a rightward axis has negative momentum, and that minus sign is not decoration — in a collision it does most of the work.
The unit is the kilogram metre per second. It has no special name, and the newton second you will meet in a moment turns out to be the same unit wearing a different coat.
OpenStax, College Physics 2e — chapter 8, Linear Momentum and Collisions section 8.1
Picture it
Momentum and kinetic energy both grow with mass and speed, so it is tempting to treat them as two names for one idea. They are not.
Figure (svg): A slow heavy bowling ball and a fast light soccer ball shown with equal momentum of twelve but kinetic energies of twelve and one hundred eighty joules
Momentum is proportional to speed, kinetic energy to speed squared, so the two can never carry the same information. That is exactly why a collision problem can use both: they are two independent equations about the same event.
Prediction
The two balls above roll toward you. You have to bring each one to rest with your hands.
Predict first
Which one needs the larger total push (force times time) to stop it?
Correct: They need exactly the same
Why: Stopping each ball removes all of its momentum, and both carry 12 kilogram metres per second, so the total push needed is 12 newton seconds either way. How quickly you stop it changes the force, not the product of force and time. The soccer ball will still hurt more if it hits your face, but that is about energy and contact area, not momentum.
Concept
A force that acts for a time changes an object's momentum. The product of the force and the time is called the impulse, and it equals the change in momentum exactly.
\[ \vec{J} = \vec{F}\,\Delta t = \Delta \vec{p} = m\vec{v} - m\vec{v}_0 \]
impulse — the product of a force and the time it acts for, measured in newton seconds; it is a vector in the direction of the force
This is just the second law rearranged. Force equals mass times acceleration, acceleration is change in velocity over time, and multiplying both sides by the time leaves force times time equals mass times change in velocity. Nothing new has been assumed.
OpenStax, College Physics 2e — chapter 8, Linear Momentum and Collisions section 8.2
Picture it
Real forces in a kick or a bat swing rise and fall. You do not need the formula for the curve, because the impulse is simply the area under the force-time graph.
Figure (svg): A force-time graph that rises from zero to four hundred newtons, stays flat, then falls back to zero over eighty milliseconds, with the area beneath shaded
Split the shape into triangles and rectangles and add them. Remember to convert milliseconds to seconds before you multiply, or every answer comes out a thousand times too big.
Worked example
A 0.60 kilogram ball at rest is struck by the force shown: it rises to 400 newtons over 20 milliseconds, holds for 40, then falls to zero over 20. How fast does the ball leave?
Figure (svg): The trapezoidal force-time graph with the impulse area shaded
Find the area, in seconds
Why: Two triangles, each half of 0.020 seconds times 400 newtons, and one rectangle of 0.040 seconds times 400 newtons.
\[ J = 2\times \tfrac{1}{2}(0.020)(400) + (0.040)(400) = 8 + 16 = 24 \text{ N s} \]
Set impulse equal to the change in momentum
Why: The ball starts at rest, so its initial momentum is zero.
\[ 24 = (0.60)v - 0 \;\Rightarrow\; v = 40 \text{ m/s} \]
Verify: with the average force
Why: The pulse lasts 0.080 seconds in total, so the average force is 24 divided by 0.080, which is 300 newtons. A constant 300 newtons for 0.080 seconds gives the same 24 newton seconds, and the average sits sensibly between zero and the 400 newton peak.
OpenStax, College Physics 2e — chapter 8, Linear Momentum and Collisions section 8.2
Fill the middle
A 0.058 kilogram tennis ball arrives at 30 metres per second and leaves the racket at 40 metres per second straight back. Take the outgoing direction as positive.
Fill in the blanks
\Delta p = (0.058)\big(40 - (-30)\big) = 4.06 N s
Why: The incoming velocity points the other way, so it is negative 30, and subtracting a negative adds: 40 minus negative 30 is 70. Then 0.058 times 70 is 4.06 newton seconds. Writing 40 minus 30 instead gives 0.58, an answer seven times too small, and it is the most common mistake in the unit.
Worked example
The tennis ball above is in contact with the strings for 5.0 milliseconds. Find the average force, and the peak force if the pulse is a triangle.
Figure (svg): A triangular force-time pulse over five milliseconds with a peak of 1624 newtons and a dashed line at the 812 newton average
Average force is impulse over time
Why: The change in momentum is 4.06 newton seconds from the previous slide, and 5.0 milliseconds is 0.0050 seconds.
\[ F_{\text{avg}} = \dfrac{4.06}{0.0050} = 812 \text{ N} \]
For a triangle, the area is half the base times the height
Why: So the peak must be twice the average to enclose the same area.
\[ \tfrac{1}{2}(0.0050)F_{\text{peak}} = 4.06 \;\Rightarrow\; F_{\text{peak}} = 1624 \text{ N} \]
Verify: by sizing the answer
Why: Eight hundred newtons is about the weight of an adult, delivered to a 58 gram ball. That sounds absurd until you notice it lasts five thousandths of a second — which is exactly why impulse, not force, is the useful quantity in a collision.
HyperPhysics, Mechanics — momentum, impulse and collisions impulse
Pattern
When the change in momentum is fixed by the situation, the impulse is fixed too. The only choice left is how to split it between force and time, and almost every safety device chooses a long time.
| situation | change in momentum is set by | what is changed | result |
|---|---|---|---|
| airbag in a crash | your speed before the crash | stopping time made longer | smaller force on you |
| bending your knees on landing | your speed on landing | stopping time made longer | smaller force on your legs |
| catching an egg with soft hands | the egg's speed | stopping time made longer | egg survives |
| follow-through on a swing | nothing yet, you are adding it | contact time made longer | larger impulse, faster ball |
| a karate chop on a board | the hand's speed | stopping time made very short | large force on the board |
Read the follow-through row carefully. There the force is roughly as large as you can make it, so lengthening the time increases the impulse instead of reducing the force.
OpenStax, College Physics 2e — chapter 8, Linear Momentum and Collisions section 8.2, applications
Picture it
A 70 kilogram passenger moving at 15 metres per second has to be brought to rest. That removes 1050 newton seconds of momentum no matter what they hit.
Figure (svg): Two rectangles on a force-time graph with equal area: a tall narrow one for a dashboard and a short wide one for an airbag
The airbag does not reduce the impulse at all. It stretches the same impulse over fifteen times as long, which cuts the force by a factor of fifteen.
Worked example
A 70 kilogram passenger at 15 metres per second stops in 0.010 seconds against a dashboard, or in 0.15 seconds against an airbag. Find the average force in each case.
Figure (svg): The dashboard and airbag force rectangles with equal area
The change in momentum is the same in both
Why: Final momentum zero, initial 70 times 15.
\[ \Delta p = 0 - (70)(15) = -1050 \text{ N s} \]
Divide by each stopping time
Why: The minus sign only says the force opposes the motion, so work with magnitudes.
\[ F_{\text{dash}} = \dfrac{1050}{0.010} = 105\,000 \text{ N}, \qquad F_{\text{bag}} = \dfrac{1050}{0.15} = 7000 \text{ N} \]
Verify: that the impulses match
Why: 105 000 times 0.010 is 1050, and 7000 times 0.15 is 1050. Same area, different shape. The ratio of forces, 15, is exactly the ratio of times, as it must be when the product is fixed.
OpenStax, College Physics 2e — chapter 8, Linear Momentum and Collisions section 8.2, example on stopping forces
Anomaly
Two identical 0.5 kilogram balls hit a wall at 4 metres per second. One is putty and sticks. The other is rubber and bounces straight back at 4 metres per second.
Predict first
Which ball receives the larger impulse from the wall?
Correct: The rubber ball, twice as much
Why: The putty ball goes from 4 to 0, a change of 2 kilogram metres per second. The rubber ball goes from 4 forward to 4 backward, a change of 8 metres per second in velocity and 4 in momentum. The wall has to stop it and then throw it back, so it must deliver double the impulse. This is why a bouncing bullet does more damage to a target than one that embeds.
Picture it
The same picture with the numbers written in.
Figure (svg): A ball sticking to a wall with a momentum change of two, and an identical ball bouncing back with a momentum change of four
The final velocity of the bounce is negative, and subtracting it is what doubles the answer. Every sign error in this unit is a variation on forgetting that.
Check
Solve it on paper before you click.
Check your understanding
You catch a raw egg by letting your hands move back with it. Compared with catching it on a rigid board, what has changed?
Answer: C
Why: The egg arrives at the same speed and ends at rest either way, so its change in momentum, and therefore the impulse on it, is identical. Moving your hands back stretches the stopping time, and because force times time is fixed, the force drops. The egg breaks or survives on force, not impulse.
Trap
A 0.058 kilogram tennis ball hits a racket at 30 metres per second and leaves at 40 metres per second in the opposite direction. Find the change in momentum.
Subtract the speeds
Why: 40 minus 30 is 10, times 0.058 gives 0.58 newton seconds.
Carry on to the force
Why: Every later answer — average force, peak force — is now seven times too small, and nothing in the arithmetic looks wrong.
A 0.058 kilogram tennis ball hits a racket at 30 metres per second and leaves at 40 metres per second in the opposite direction. Find the change in momentum.
Choose a positive direction first: outgoing
Why: Then the incoming velocity is negative 30, and the outgoing velocity is positive 40.
Final minus initial, with signs
Why: 40 minus negative 30 is 70, and 0.058 times 70 is 4.06 newton seconds. A reversal always makes the change bigger than either speed, never smaller.
Estimation
A 0.43 kilogram soccer ball is kicked from rest to 25 metres per second. The boot is in contact for about 8 milliseconds.
Predict first
Roughly how large is the average force on the ball?
Correct: About 1300 N
Why: The change in momentum is 0.43 times 25, about 10.8 newton seconds. Dividing by 0.008 seconds gives about 1350 newtons — roughly twice a person's weight, delivered for a blink. If your estimate came out at 13 newtons, you probably divided by 0.8 instead of 0.008, which is the milliseconds trap again.
Socratic
Coaches in every sport say follow through. The pattern table already hinted at why.
Discussion prompt
If you cannot swing any harder, why does keeping the bat or racket in contact for longer send the ball away faster?
Hint: Which of force and time can you still change?
Answer:
Because the force is already about as large as you can make it, so the only way left to increase the impulse is to increase the time.
A larger impulse means a larger change in momentum, and the ball started from the same velocity, so it leaves faster.
Notice this is the airbag argument run the other way. There the impulse was fixed and a longer time lowered the force; here the force is fixed and a longer time raises the impulse.
Section
When the total cannot change
Concept
When two objects push on each other, Newton's third law says the forces are equal and opposite. They also last exactly as long as each other, because the contact begins and ends at the same instant for both.
Equal and opposite forces for equal times give equal and opposite impulses. So whatever momentum one object gains, the other loses, and the total does not change.
\[ m_A v_A + m_B v_B = m_A v_A' + m_B v_B' \]
This is why momentum is so useful in a collision. You never need to know how large the contact forces were, only that they came in a third-law pair.
OpenStax, College Physics 2e — chapter 8, Linear Momentum and Collisions section 8.3
Picture it
Two skaters push off each other on ice. Draw a boundary around both of them before doing anything else.
Figure (svg): Two skaters inside a dashed system boundary with an equal and opposite internal push pair, and weight and normal force shown outside cancelling
Forces between things inside the boundary cancel in pairs. Only forces from outside can change the total, and here the outside forces are vertical and balanced. So the total horizontal momentum is zero before the push and zero after it.
Picture it
Write these on the inside cover of your notebook, next to the five kinematics steps from Unit 1.
Figure (svg): A five-step vertical flow from drawing before and after, through choosing the system, totalling momentum before and after, to solving and checking kinetic energy
Step two is what most students skip. If something outside the system delivers a real impulse during the event, before does not equal after and the whole method is off — so you check before you write.
Definition probe
The system is the two carts on a level, frictionless track, colliding with each other.
Sort into buckets
Is each force internal or external to that system?
Concept
Momentum of a system is conserved when the net external impulse on it is zero. In practice that happens in two ways, and problems lean on both.
The second card is why momentum works for a car crash on a real road with friction. Just before and just after the impact, the total is the same; ten seconds later, friction has removed it.
College Board, AP Physics 1: Algebra-Based Course and Exam Description Unit 4, conservation of linear momentum
Discrimination
The system is named each time. Decide before you read the rationale.
Sort into buckets
Is the momentum of the named system conserved?
Check
Solve it on paper before you click.
Check your understanding
A person standing on frictionless ice throws a ball forward. Which system has a constant total horizontal momentum during the throw?
Answer: C
Why: The throwing force is a third-law pair between the person and the ball. With both inside the boundary that pair is internal and cancels, and the ice supplies no horizontal friction. So the total stays at zero: the ball gains forward momentum and the person gains an equal backward momentum.
Section
Momentum always, kinetic energy sometimes
Concept
Every collision conserves momentum, as long as the system is chosen correctly. What varies is what happens to the kinetic energy, and that is how collisions are classified.
| type | momentum | kinetic energy | what you see |
|---|---|---|---|
| elastic | conserved | conserved | objects bounce apart cleanly |
| inelastic | conserved | some lost | objects separate, but slower than an elastic bounce |
| perfectly inelastic | conserved | the most possible lost | objects stick and move together |
The lost kinetic energy is not destroyed. It becomes thermal energy, sound and permanent deformation. Total energy is still conserved; only the kinetic part is not.
OpenStax, College Physics 2e — chapter 8, Linear Momentum and Collisions sections 8.4 and 8.5
Picture it
Two carts, three outcomes. Momentum is the same in every row.
Figure (svg): Three rows of cart collisions showing an elastic bounce, an inelastic collision where carts separate slowly, and a perfectly inelastic collision where the carts stick
The word inelastic on its own just means some kinetic energy was lost. Perfectly inelastic is the extreme case, and it is the easiest to solve, because there is only one final velocity to find.
Worked example
A 2000 kilogram truck moving at 10 metres per second rear-ends a 1000 kilogram car at rest, and the two lock together. Find their speed just after, and the kinetic energy lost.
Figure (svg): A truck hitting a stationary car with a bar chart of kinetic energy before and after
Choose the system and check it
Why: Truck plus car. The impact lasts a fraction of a second, so road friction delivers negligible impulse during it.
Momentum before equals momentum after
Why: They stick, so there is one shared final velocity.
\[ (2000)(10) + (1000)(0) = (3000)v' \;\Rightarrow\; v' = 6.67 \text{ m/s} \]
Compare kinetic energies
Why: Momentum told us the speed; kinetic energy tells us what the crash cost.
\[ K_i = \tfrac{1}{2}(2000)(10)^2 = 100\,000 \text{ J}, \qquad K_f = \tfrac{1}{2}(3000)(6.67)^2 = 66\,700 \text{ J} \]
Verify: the momentum after
Why: 3000 times 6.67 is 20 000, matching 2000 times 10. The fraction of kinetic energy lost, about one third, also equals the struck car's share of the total mass, 1000 out of 3000 — a neat result that holds whenever the target starts at rest.
OpenStax, College Physics 2e — chapter 8, Linear Momentum and Collisions section 8.5
Fill the middle
A 0.20 kilogram lump of clay moving at 6.0 metres per second hits and sticks to a 0.40 kilogram cart at rest.
Fill in the blanks
v' = \dfrac0.602.0 m/s} } = ___
Why: Momentum before is 0.20 times 6.0, which is 1.2. After the collision the clay and cart move together, so the mass that carries that momentum is the total, 0.60 kilograms, and the speed is 1.2 over 0.60, which is 2.0 metres per second. Dividing by the cart's mass alone is the usual slip.
Worked example
A 2.0 kilogram cart at 3.0 metres per second hits a 1.0 kilogram cart at rest, and the collision is elastic. Find both velocities afterwards.
Figure (svg): Before and after diagrams of an elastic collision with velocities three, then one and four metres per second
Momentum gives one equation
Why: Two unknowns, so one more equation is needed.
\[ (2.0)(3.0) = 2.0\,v_A' + 1.0\,v_B' \]
Elastic gives the second: the relative speed reverses
Why: In a one-dimensional elastic collision the objects separate as fast as they approached. This comes from the energy equation, and it is far easier to use than squaring.
\[ v_B' - v_A' = 3.0 \]
Solve the pair
Why: Substitute v_B' equals v_A' plus 3 into the momentum equation: 6 equals 3 v_A' plus 3.
\[ v_A' = 1.0 \text{ m/s}, \qquad v_B' = 4.0 \text{ m/s} \]
Verify: with kinetic energy
Why: Before: half of 2 times 9, which is 9 joules. After: half of 2 times 1 plus half of 1 times 16, which is 1 plus 8, also 9 joules. Momentum checks too: 2 plus 4 is 6. Both conserved, so the collision really was elastic.
HyperPhysics, Mechanics — momentum, impulse and collisions elastic collisions
Socratic
The shortcut in that example looks like a trick. It is not, and knowing where it comes from tells you when you are allowed to use it.
Discussion prompt
Why should two objects in an elastic collision separate at exactly the speed they approached?
Hint: Which equation do you need besides momentum, and what algebraic identity hides in it?
Answer:
Write momentum conservation and kinetic-energy conservation side by side, and move each object's terms to one side. The energy equation factors into a difference of squares.
Dividing the energy equation by the momentum equation cancels the masses and leaves the statement that the sum of each object's before and after velocities is equal. Rearranged, that is exactly the relative-speed rule.
So it is the energy equation in disguise, and it only holds when kinetic energy is conserved. Use it for an elastic collision in one dimension and never otherwise.
Two truths and a lie
A moving cart hits an identical cart at rest in a perfectly elastic head-on collision.
Eliminate the wrong options
Cross out the false statement.
Survives elimination: e3
Why: Moving off together at half speed conserves momentum, but it halves the kinetic energy — that is the perfectly inelastic outcome, not the elastic one. Half speed for double the mass gives half of the original kinetic energy, so a quarter is missing from each half. Momentum alone cannot tell the two cases apart; the kinetic energy decides.
Worked example
A 1.0 kilogram cart at 3.0 metres per second hits a 2.0 kilogram cart at rest. Afterwards the light cart moves forward at 0.50 metres per second. Find the heavy cart's velocity and decide what kind of collision it was.
Figure (svg): Before and after diagrams of a partly inelastic cart collision with velocities and kinetic energies marked
Momentum before equals momentum after
Why: One unknown this time, so momentum alone is enough.
\[ (1.0)(3.0) = (1.0)(0.50) + (2.0)v_B' \;\Rightarrow\; v_B' = 1.25 \text{ m/s} \]
Compare kinetic energies to classify it
Why: Before and after, using each cart separately.
\[ K_i = \tfrac{1}{2}(1.0)(3.0)^2 = 4.5 \text{ J}, \qquad K_f = \tfrac{1}{2}(1.0)(0.50)^2 + \tfrac{1}{2}(2.0)(1.25)^2 = 1.69 \text{ J} \]
Verify: that the outcome is physically possible
Why: Kinetic energy went down, not up, so nothing was created from nowhere. And the heavy cart in front moves faster than the light one behind, 1.25 against 0.50, so they really have separated rather than passed through each other. The carts separated but lost energy: an inelastic collision.
OpenStax, College Physics 2e — chapter 8, Linear Momentum and Collisions section 8.5
Elimination
Same carts: 1.0 kilogram at 3.0 metres per second hits 2.0 kilograms at rest. Three of these after-states cannot happen.
Eliminate the wrong options
Which outcome is possible?
Survives elimination: o1
Why: A real outcome has to pass three tests: momentum is unchanged, kinetic energy does not increase, and the objects do not pass through each other. Only the first choice passes all three. Running these three tests is a fast way to check any collision answer before you write it down.
Comparison
Fill the blank from the pattern. The two extremes of the collision spectrum, side by side.
Comparison matrix
| question | elastic | perfectly inelastic |
|---|---|---|
| is momentum conserved | yes | yes |
| is kinetic energy conserved | yes | no, the most possible is lost |
| what the objects do after | bounce apart | move together |
| relative speed after | same as before, reversed | zero |
| number of unknown velocities | two, so you need two equations | one, so momentum is enough |
Inelastic collisions sit between the columns. They need some extra information in the problem — usually one of the final velocities — because momentum alone gives one equation and there are two unknowns.
Trap
A 0.20 kilogram lump of clay at 6.0 metres per second sticks to a 0.40 kilogram cart at rest. Find the speed afterwards.
Set the kinetic energies equal
Why: Half of 0.20 times 36 equals half of 0.60 times v squared, so v squared is 12 and v is 3.46 metres per second.
Accept it because the algebra worked
Why: But momentum after would be 0.60 times 3.46, which is 2.08, against 1.2 before. The answer creates momentum, which no collision can do.
A 0.20 kilogram lump of clay at 6.0 metres per second sticks to a 0.40 kilogram cart at rest. Find the speed afterwards.
Sticking means perfectly inelastic
Why: Kinetic energy is not conserved, so it cannot be an equation. Momentum is the only law available across the collision.
Momentum: 1.2 equals 0.60 v
Why: So v is 2.0 metres per second, and the kinetic energy drops from 3.6 joules to 1.2 joules. Losing two thirds is normal for a sticky collision; gaining momentum never is.
Section
A collision run backwards
Concept
When a rifle fires, a firework bursts or two skaters push apart, the pieces start at rest together and fly apart. The forces between them are internal, so the total momentum afterwards is the same as before: zero.
\[ 0 = m_1 v_1' + m_2 v_2' \;\Rightarrow\; v_2' = -\dfrac{m_1}{m_2}v_1' \]
The kinetic energy, by contrast, goes from zero to something large. It comes from chemical energy in the powder, or from the skaters' muscles. An explosion is the mirror image of a perfectly inelastic collision: kinetic energy appears instead of disappearing, and momentum does not care either way.
OpenStax, College Physics 2e — chapter 8, Linear Momentum and Collisions section 8.6
Picture it
A 4.0 kilogram rifle fires a 10 gram bullet at 400 metres per second.
Figure (svg): A rifle recoiling at one metre per second while a bullet leaves at four hundred, with equal and opposite momenta but kinetic energies of eight hundred and two joules
The momenta are equal and opposite, as they must be. The kinetic energies are four hundred times apart, because the bullet's speed is squared and the rifle's is not. That is why the bullet is lethal and the recoil is merely a shove.
Worked example
A 4.0 kilogram rifle, initially at rest, fires a 0.010 kilogram bullet at 400 metres per second. Find the rifle's recoil velocity.
Figure (svg): The recoil diagram with momenta and kinetic energies of the rifle and the bullet
System: rifle plus bullet, starting at rest
Why: The powder pushes both ways at once, an internal pair. Total momentum before is zero.
Take the bullet's direction as positive
Why: Then the rifle's velocity should come out negative, and the sign is a check.
\[ 0 = (0.010)(400) + (4.0)v_r \;\Rightarrow\; v_r = -1.0 \text{ m/s} \]
Verify: with the kinetic energies
Why: Bullet: half of 0.010 times 160 000, which is 800 joules. Rifle: half of 4.0 times 1, which is 2 joules. Momenta of plus and minus 4.0 cancel exactly, while the energies are wildly unequal — exactly what the picture showed, so the numbers are consistent.
HyperPhysics, Mechanics — momentum, impulse and collisions recoil
Fill the middle
A 60 kilogram skater and a 40 kilogram skater stand at rest on ice and push off each other. The 40 kilogram skater moves away at 3.0 metres per second.
Fill in the blanks
The 60 kg skater moves at 2.0 m/s, in the opposite direction to the other skater.
Why: Total momentum is zero before and after. The lighter skater carries 40 times 3.0, which is 120 kilogram metres per second, so the heavier one must carry 120 the other way, and 120 over 60 is 2.0 metres per second. Heavier objects recoil more slowly, in exact proportion to the mass ratio.
Counterexample
A student argues that since the rifle and bullet get equal and opposite momentum, they must also share the kinetic energy equally.
Discussion prompt
Use the rifle numbers to refute the claim, and then say in general which piece gets more of the energy.
Hint: Write kinetic energy in terms of momentum and mass.
Answer:
The bullet gets 800 joules and the rifle 2 joules, so the claim fails by a factor of four hundred.
For equal momentum, kinetic energy is momentum squared divided by twice the mass. The momenta are equal, so the kinetic energy is inversely proportional to mass: the lighter piece always gets more.
That is why a gun is designed to be heavy compared with its bullet, and why a light gun kicks painfully.
Section
One law per direction
Concept
In two dimensions, momentum conservation is two separate statements: the total horizontal momentum is unchanged, and the total vertical momentum is unchanged. They are independent, just as the two directions of a projectile were independent in Unit 1.
\[ \sum p_x \text{ before} = \sum p_x \text{ after}, \qquad \sum p_y \text{ before} = \sum p_y \text{ after} \]
The method is the one you already have. Resolve every momentum into components with sine and cosine, conserve each direction, then reassemble the answer with Pythagoras and the inverse tangent.
OpenStax, College Physics 2e — chapter 8, Linear Momentum and Collisions section 8.6, collisions in two dimensions
Picture it
A 1500 kilogram car heading east at 20 metres per second collides with a 2500 kilogram truck heading north at 12 metres per second, and they lock together.
Figure (svg): Momentum vectors of thirty thousand east and thirty thousand north added tip to tail into a resultant at forty-five degrees
The two momenta happen to be equal, 30 000 each, so the wreck leaves at exactly 45 degrees. The truck is slower but heavier, and those two facts cancel.
Worked example
Find the speed and direction of the wreck just after the car and truck above collide and stick.
Figure (svg): The intersection momentum vector diagram with the resultant at forty-five degrees
Conserve the east-west component
Why: Only the car had any.
\[ (1500)(20) = (4000)v_x \;\Rightarrow\; v_x = 7.5 \text{ m/s} \]
Conserve the north-south component
Why: Only the truck had any.
\[ (2500)(12) = (4000)v_y \;\Rightarrow\; v_y = 7.5 \text{ m/s} \]
Reassemble the vector
Why: Pythagoras for the size, the inverse tangent for the angle.
\[ v = \sqrt{7.5^2 + 7.5^2} = 10.6 \text{ m/s}, \qquad \theta = \tan^{-1}\!\left(\tfrac{7.5}{7.5}\right) = 45^\circ \text{ north of east} \]
Verify: from the total momentum directly
Why: The total momentum is the square root of 30 000 squared plus 30 000 squared, about 42 400 kilogram metres per second. Dividing by 4000 kilograms gives 10.6 metres per second, the same answer by a different route.
OpenStax, College Physics 2e — chapter 8, Linear Momentum and Collisions section 8.6
Worked example
A 0.20 kilogram puck at 5.0 metres per second strikes an identical puck at rest. The first puck leaves at 4.33 metres per second, 30 degrees above its original line; the second leaves 60 degrees below it. Find the second puck's speed.
Figure (svg): A puck arriving along the x axis and two pucks leaving at thirty degrees above and sixty degrees below
Use the direction with the simplest before-state
Why: Before the collision there was no vertical momentum at all, so the two vertical components after must cancel. The masses are equal and cancel too.
\[ 4.33\sin 30^\circ = v_2 \sin 60^\circ \;\Rightarrow\; v_2 = \dfrac{2.165}{0.866} = 2.50 \text{ m/s} \]
Verify: with the horizontal direction
Why: Horizontal momentum after, per unit mass: 4.33 times cos 30 plus 2.50 times cos 60, which is 3.75 plus 1.25, exactly 5.0 — the incoming speed. Both components check, so the answer is right. The two pucks also leave at 90 degrees to each other, the signature of an elastic collision between equal masses.
HyperPhysics, Mechanics — momentum, impulse and collisions two-dimensional collisions
Ranking
Doing these out of order is what makes these problems feel long.
Put in order
Why: The picture and axes come first so every sign is settled. Resolving next turns vectors into numbers. Then the two conservation statements, which can be done in either order — start with whichever direction has the simpler before-state. Only at the very end do you combine, because Pythagoras and the inverse tangent need both components already known.
Section
The point that ignores collisions
Concept
The centre of mass of a system is the mass-weighted average position of its parts. Its velocity is the total momentum divided by the total mass.
\[ x_{\text{cm}} = \dfrac{m_1 x_1 + m_2 x_2}{m_1 + m_2}, \qquad v_{\text{cm}} = \dfrac{m_1 v_1 + m_2 v_2}{m_1 + m_2} = \dfrac{p_{\text{total}}}{M} \]
That second formula is the payoff. If the total momentum is conserved, the centre of mass moves at a constant velocity, no matter how violently the parts collide or explode.
College Board, AP Physics 1: Algebra-Based Course and Exam Description Unit 4, centre of mass and its velocity
Picture it
A 2 kilogram mass at 0 metres and a 1 kilogram mass at 3 metres.
Figure (svg): A number line with a two kilogram mass at zero, a one kilogram mass at three, and the centre of mass marked at one metre
Twice the mass means half the distance. The centre of mass is always closer to the heavier object, in exact proportion to the mass ratio.
Picture it
The elastic collision from Part 3 again: a 2 kilogram cart at 3 metres per second hits a 1 kilogram cart at rest.
Figure (svg): A velocity-time graph where the two carts jump to new velocities at the collision while the dashed centre-of-mass velocity stays flat at two metres per second
Before: 6 over 3 is 2 metres per second. After: 2 plus 4, over 3, is still 2. A perfectly inelastic version would leave both carts at 2 metres per second — the centre of mass velocity itself. That makes the centre of mass a free check on any one-dimensional collision answer.
Worked example
A 60 kilogram person stands at one end of a 140 kilogram boat floating at rest. They walk 4.0 metres forward along the boat. Ignoring water resistance, how far does the boat move, and how far does the person move relative to the shore?
Figure (svg): A person walking forward on a boat while the boat slides back, with the centre of mass position fixed
Choose the system: person plus boat
Why: No horizontal external force, and everything starts at rest, so the centre of mass cannot move.
Let the boat move back a distance d
Why: Then the person moves 4.0 minus d forward relative to the shore. The mass-weighted displacements must cancel.
\[ 60(4.0 - d) = 140\,d \;\Rightarrow\; 240 = 200\,d \;\Rightarrow\; d = 1.2 \text{ m} \]
\[ \text{person relative to shore: } 4.0 - 1.2 = 2.8 \text{ m} \]
Verify: that the centre of mass stayed put
Why: 60 times 2.8 is 168, and 140 times 1.2 is also 168, in opposite directions. The mass-weighted shifts cancel, so the centre of mass has not moved — and the boat moved less because it is heavier.
OpenStax, College Physics 2e — chapter 8, Linear Momentum and Collisions section 8.7
Edge cases
Every model has an edge. Worth knowing where this one ends.
Discussion prompt
A firework rises, bursts at the top of its path, and the pieces scatter. What does the centre of mass of the pieces do, and what would it take for its motion to change?
Hint: Which forces are internal to the pieces, and which are not?
Answer:
Right after the burst, the centre of mass carries on exactly as if nothing had happened, because the burst forces are internal.
Gravity is external, though, so the centre of mass keeps accelerating downward and follows the same parabola the unexploded firework would have followed — until the first piece hits the ground.
At that moment the ground pushes on one piece, an external force, and the centre of mass leaves the parabola. Only external forces can change the motion of the centre of mass; internal ones can rearrange the pieces but never move the average.
Section
Consolidation
Pattern
Everything above, compressed to what you would want on a single index card.
| situation | what is conserved | what to do first |
|---|---|---|
| a force acts for a time | nothing, momentum changes | impulse equals change in momentum |
| force-time graph given | nothing, momentum changes | find the area, in seconds |
| objects stick together | momentum only | one final velocity, momentum alone |
| elastic, one dimension | momentum and kinetic energy | momentum plus the relative-speed rule |
| explosion or recoil from rest | momentum, total zero | the pieces carry equal and opposite momentum |
| collision at an angle | each component of momentum | resolve, then conserve x and y separately |
| collision then swing or slide | momentum, then energy | split into two stages at the instant after impact |
The last row is where most exam marks are lost. Momentum carries you across the collision; energy carries you through the motion afterwards; and neither law is allowed to do the other's job.
College Board, AP Physics 1: Algebra-Based Course and Exam Description Unit 4
Worked example
A 0.010 kilogram bullet is fired into a 2.0 kilogram block hanging on strings, and embeds in it. The block swings up 0.20 metres. How fast was the bullet moving?
Figure (svg): A bullet entering a hanging block, then the block swinging up twenty centimetres, labelled as a collision stage and a swing stage
Work backwards from the swing: energy
Why: After the collision, only gravity does work on the block, so its kinetic energy at the bottom becomes potential energy at the top. The mass cancels.
\[ V = \sqrt{2gh} = \sqrt{2(9.8)(0.20)} = 1.98 \text{ m/s} \]
Then across the collision: momentum
Why: The bullet sticks, so this is perfectly inelastic, and kinetic energy is not conserved here.
\[ (0.010)v = (2.010)(1.98) \;\Rightarrow\; v = 398 \text{ m/s} \]
Verify: with the energy that disappeared
Why: The bullet arrives with half of 0.010 times 398 squared, about 792 joules. The block and bullet leave the collision with half of 2.010 times 1.98 squared, about 3.9 joules. Over 99 per cent of the kinetic energy is lost in the impact, which is exactly why energy could not be used across it.
HyperPhysics, Mechanics — momentum, impulse and collisions ballistic pendulum
Trap
Same pendulum: a 0.010 kilogram bullet embeds in a 2.0 kilogram block, which rises 0.20 metres.
Set the bullet's kinetic energy equal to the final potential energy
Why: Half of 0.010 times v squared equals 2.010 times 9.8 times 0.20, so v squared is about 788 and v is about 28 metres per second.
Accept a bullet at 28 metres per second
Why: That is the speed of a thrown baseball. The method silently assumed the collision lost no energy, when in fact it lost almost all of it.
Same pendulum: a 0.010 kilogram bullet embeds in a 2.0 kilogram block, which rises 0.20 metres.
Split at the instant just after impact
Why: Energy works for the swing; momentum works for the collision. Each law gets the stage where it holds.
Swing gives 1.98 metres per second, then momentum gives 398
Why: A speed fourteen times larger, and a plausible one for a bullet. The size check alone should have flagged 28 as wrong.
Check
Solve it on paper before you click.
Check your understanding
A 3.0 kilogram block slides off a frictionless ramp and hits a 1.0 kilogram block at rest on a frictionless floor; they stick. You know the ramp's height and are asked for their shared speed. What is the first calculation?
Answer: B
Why: This is the ballistic pendulum in reverse order: the energy stage comes first and the collision second. Going down a frictionless ramp, mechanical energy is conserved, so the height gives the speed at the bottom. Only then can momentum carry you across the sticky collision.
Error analysis
A 60 kilogram skater at rest throws a 5.0 kilogram ball forward at 6.0 metres per second. A student finds the skater's velocity.
Annotate
On: \( 0 = (5.0)(6.0) + (60)v \;\Rightarrow\; v = 0.50 \text{ m/s forward} \)
This is why step one of the attack is choosing a positive direction on the drawing. Once that arrow exists, a negative answer is information, not an inconvenience.
Explain it
Say it out loud, to a person or to an empty room. If it takes more than a minute, the idea is not settled yet.
Discussion prompt
In under a minute, explain to someone how to decide whether momentum is conserved in a problem.
Hint: System, internal pairs, external check.
Answer:
First choose the system and draw a boundary around it.
Forces between objects inside the boundary come in third-law pairs, so their impulses cancel and they cannot change the total.
Then check the forces from outside. If they cancel, or the event is so short they deliver almost no impulse, momentum is conserved; if not, widen the system or use impulse instead.
Explain it to yourself
If you can say this without notes, the collisions section has landed.
Discussion prompt
In two sentences, why does a perfectly inelastic collision lose the most kinetic energy that momentum conservation allows?
Hint: What is the one velocity that no collision can change?
Answer:
Momentum fixes the velocity of the centre of mass, and any kinetic energy tied to that motion has to survive the collision.
Only the motion of the objects relative to each other can be lost, and sticking removes all of that relative motion — so no collision can lose more.
Real world
Worth grounding, because the unit can feel like invented problems about carts.
Discussion prompt
Name three real situations that are exactly the problems in this unit, and say which idea each one uses.
Hint: One about stopping safely, one about pushing off nothing, one about a crash at an angle.
Answer:
Crumple zones and airbags are impulse: the car's change in momentum is fixed by its speed, so engineers lengthen the stopping time to shrink the force on the people inside.
A rocket in space is recoil: it throws exhaust backward and gains equal momentum forward, with nothing to push against except its own fuel.
Accident investigators work backwards through two-dimensional momentum conservation, using skid marks after a crash to find how fast each car was going before it.
Warm-up
Close the deck. This is worth several times what rereading is worth, and it tells you exactly what to revise.
Discussion prompt
From memory: the definition of momentum; what impulse equals; how to get impulse from a force-time graph; the condition for conservation; the difference between elastic and perfectly inelastic; the total momentum after an explosion from rest; how to handle a collision at an angle; and what the centre of mass does during a collision.
Hint: One definition, one equation, one area, one condition, one contrast, one zero, two components, one constant.
Answer:
Mass times velocity, a vector with the sign of the velocity.
Force times time, and also the change in momentum.
The area under the graph, with time in seconds.
Zero net external impulse on the chosen system.
Elastic keeps kinetic energy; perfectly inelastic makes the objects stick and loses the most kinetic energy possible. Both conserve momentum.
Zero. The pieces carry equal and opposite momentum.
Conserve the x and y components separately, then recombine.
Nothing. With no external force it keeps moving at constant velocity, total momentum over total mass.
Connect it up
Do this before the next session and bring it. It is the single most useful thing you can make in this unit.
Draw it
On one side, write the impulse-momentum theorem and the conservation equation, and draw a force-time graph with its area shaded. On the other side, draw three before-and-after pictures — an elastic bounce, a sticky collision and a recoil from rest — and write beside each what is conserved and what is not. Add nothing else.
If it fits on a card, you understand it. If it needs a second card, the extra material is the part to work on.
Exit ticket
Momentum is the last translational unit before rotation, so this is a good moment to choose.
Predict first
What would be most useful next time?
Correct: Whichever you pick is what I will prepare.
Why: The two-stage problems are where the exam concentrates its hardest momentum questions, because they test whether you know which law applies where. If those already feel comfortable, working through the real homework is usually the strongest next step.
Recap
One unit, one method: choose the system, check for outside impulse, set before equal to after, and then ask what happened to the kinetic energy.
| quantity | conserved in | not conserved in |
|---|---|---|
| momentum | every collision and explosion, for the right system | any system with a net external impulse |
| kinetic energy | elastic collisions only | inelastic and perfectly inelastic collisions, and explosions |
| centre of mass velocity | any system with no net external force | systems pushed from outside |
College Board, AP Physics 1: Algebra-Based Course and Exam Description Unit 4 — with OpenStax chapter 8 for extra worked practice
Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors AP Physics 1 — $55/session, free consultation.