The quadratic formula obtained by completing the square once in general, the three kinds of solution, the discriminant as a predictor of how many and what type, the link between the discriminant and the number of x-intercepts, and the vertical-motion model with an initial velocity.
Subject: Algebra 2 · 62 slides · symbolic lesson
Open the interactive version of this deck
Title
Algebra 2 · Chapter 4 · Lesson 4.8
Build it from a picture, then let its discriminant predict the answer.
Objectives
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.8 Use the Quadratic Formula and the Discriminant §4.8, pp. 292-297 — the lesson these objectives follow
Concept
\[ (x + k)^2 = x^2 + 2kx + k^2 \]
From Lesson 4.7
Why: Squaring a sum doubles the middle term, so completing a square needs half of it.
\[ \sqrt{-1} = i \]
From Lesson 4.6
Why: Square roots of negatives are imaginary numbers, so no equation is left unsolved.
\[ h = -16t^2 + h_0 \]
From Lesson 4.5
Why: A dropped object falls 16t² feet in t seconds, so its height is its start minus that.
Prediction
Predict first
A ball leaves a hand 5 feet up, moving up at 32 feet per second. Roughly when does it land?
Correct: About 2 seconds. Section 5 finds 2.15 seconds.
Why: Gravity removes 32 feet per second of upward speed every second, so the ball stops rising after about 1 second. Falling back takes about as long again, plus a little more for the last 5 feet, so a bit over 2 seconds. Section 5 builds the equation and solves it exactly.
Section
Section 1
Estimation
Figure (svg): The garden drawn to scale: a blue x by x square beside a vermilion strip 6 feet long, with a ruler reading the width in feet
A plot is 6 feet longer than it is wide. Its area is 20 square feet.
\[ \color{#1f4e9c}{x}\,(\color{#1f4e9c}{x} + \color{#c2410c}{6}) = 20 \]
Predict first
Width 2 gives area 16. Width 3 gives area 27. Which width is closest?
Correct: 2.4 feet. The exact width is 2.385 feet.
Why: 20 is 4 above 16 and 7 below 27, so the width sits a little under halfway from 2 to 3. Width 2.4 gives 2.4 times 8.4, which is 20.16, the closest. No whole number works, so factoring cannot finish this; we need a method that always does.
Picture it
Figure (svg): The garden drawn to scale: a blue x by x square beside a vermilion strip 6 feet long, with a ruler reading the width in feet
\[ \color{#1f4e9c}{x^2} + \color{#c2410c}{6x} = 20 \]
Expand the area
Why: so each term of the area has its own piece.
\[ \color{#1f4e9c}{x^2} + \color{#c2410c}{3x} + \color{#c2410c}{3x} = 20 \]
Halve the strip
Why: so one half can sit on each side of the square.
Figure (svg): The 6-foot strip cut into two 3-foot strips, one along the right of the square and one along its bottom, leaving an empty corner
\[ \color{#1f4e9c}{x^2} + \color{#c2410c}{6x} + \color{#946b00}{9} = 20 + \color{#946b00}{9} \]
Add the 3-by-3 corner to both sides
Why: because the L-shape needs it to become a square.
Figure (svg): The empty 3 by 3 corner filled in with a dashed gold square labelled 9, completing a bigger square
Worked example
Figure (svg): The completed garden square: blue x by x, two vermilion 3 by x strips, and a gold 3 by 3 corner
\[ \color{#1f4e9c}{x^2} + \color{#c2410c}{6x} + \color{#946b00}{9} = 29 \]
\[ (x + 3)^2 = 29 \]
Write the left side as a square
Why: because its side is x plus 3.
Figure (svg): The completed square with its full side marked x plus 3
\[ x + 3 = \sqrt{29} \approx 5.39 \]
Take the positive square root
Why: because a side length cannot be negative.
Figure (svg): The completed square with its full side marked 5.39 feet
\[ \color{#1f4e9c}{x} \approx 5.39 - 3 = \color{#1f4e9c}{2.39} \]
Subtract 3 from both sides
Why: so the width stands alone.
Figure (svg): The side split into the blue width 2.39 and the vermilion 3
Check: 2.39 times 8.39 is 20.05
Why: which matches 20 up to rounding, so the width is right.
Pattern
| middle number | half of it | corner |
|---|---|---|
| 2 | 1 | 1 |
| 6 | 3 | 9 |
| 8 | 4 | 16 |
| 10 | ? | ? |
Predict first
What corner completes the square for x² + 10x?
Correct: 25.
Why: Half of 10 is 5, so each strip is 5 wide and the corner is 5 by 5, which is 25. The rule so far: halve the middle number, then square it. Squaring 10 without halving gives 100, the most common slip.
Worked example
Figure (svg): The garden drawn to scale: a blue x by x square beside a vermilion strip 6 feet long, with a ruler reading the width in feet
\[ \color{#1f4e9c}{a}x^2 + \color{#c2410c}{b}x + c = 0 \]
\[ x^2 + \color{#c2410c}{\tfrac{b}{a}}x + \tfrac{c}{a} = 0 \]
Divide every term by a
Why: so the square has side x, like the garden. We may, because a is not 0.
Figure (svg): The square and strip relabelled with letters: the strip is b over a long, with the garden's 6 in grey
\[ x^2 + \color{#c2410c}{\tfrac{b}{a}}x = -\tfrac{c}{a} \]
Subtract c over a from both sides
Why: so only the square and strip are left on the left.
Figure (svg): The same square and strip, now with their total area labelled negative c over a, the garden's 20 in grey
Check: a = 1, b = 6, c = −20 gives x² + 6x = 20
Why: which is exactly the garden, so the letters follow the numbers.
Worked example
Figure (svg): The general square with its strip halved into two strips b over 2a wide, garden value 3 in grey
\[ x^2 + \color{#c2410c}{\tfrac{b}{a}}x = -\tfrac{c}{a} \]
\[ x^2 + \color{#c2410c}{\tfrac{b}{a}}x + \color{#946b00}{\tfrac{b^2}{4a^2}} = \color{#946b00}{\tfrac{b^2}{4a^2}} - \tfrac{c}{a} \]
Add the corner to both sides
Why: because each strip is b over 2a wide, so the corner is that squared.
Figure (svg): The gold corner b over 2a squared added, garden value 9 in grey
\[ \left(x + \color{#c2410c}{\tfrac{b}{2a}}\right)^2 = \color{#946b00}{\tfrac{b^2}{4a^2}} - \tfrac{c}{a} \]
Write the left side as a square
Why: because its side is x plus b over 2a.
Figure (svg): The completed general square with its side marked x plus b over 2a
Check: b = 6, a = 1 gives a corner of 9
Why: which is the garden's corner, so the letters still match the picture.
Worked example
Figure (svg): The completed general square with its area written as b squared over 4a squared minus c over a
\[ \left(x + \color{#c2410c}{\tfrac{b}{2a}}\right)^2 = \color{#946b00}{\tfrac{b^2}{4a^2}} - \tfrac{c}{a} \]
\[ \left(x + \color{#c2410c}{\tfrac{b}{2a}}\right)^2 = \color{#946b00}{\tfrac{b^2}{4a^2}} - \tfrac{4ac}{4a^2} \]
Rewrite c over a over 4a²
Why: so both fractions share one denominator; we multiplied top and bottom by 4a.
Figure (svg): The same square with its area written as b squared over 4a squared minus 4ac over 4a squared
\[ \left(x + \color{#c2410c}{\tfrac{b}{2a}}\right)^2 = \dfrac{b^2 - 4ac}{4a^2} \]
Subtract the numerators
Why: because fractions with equal denominators combine on top.
Figure (svg): The same square with its area now written as b squared minus 4ac, over 4a squared
Check: a = 1, b = 6, c = −20 gives 116 over 4
Why: which is 29, the garden square's area.
Worked example
Figure (svg): The completed general square with area b squared minus 4ac over 4a squared
\[ \left(x + \color{#c2410c}{\tfrac{b}{2a}}\right)^2 = \dfrac{b^2 - 4ac}{4a^2} \]
\[ x + \color{#c2410c}{\tfrac{b}{2a}} = \pm\dfrac{\sqrt{b^2 - 4ac}}{2a} \]
Take both square roots
Why: because a number and its negative square to the same value.
Figure (svg): The square's side marked plus or minus the square root of b squared minus 4ac, over 2a
\[ \color{#1f4e9c}{x} = \dfrac{-\color{#c2410c}{b} \pm \sqrt{b^2 - 4ac}}{2a} \]
Subtract b over 2a from both sides
Why: so x stands alone over one denominator.
Figure (svg): The side split into the blue x and the vermilion b over 2a
Check: the garden gives (−6 ± √116) / 2
Why: which is −3 ± √29, the same answer the picture gave.
Picture it
Figure (svg): The parabola y equals x squared plus 6x minus 20, the garden equation, crossing the x-axis twice
Read the formula as a picture of the garden parabola.
\[ x = \color{#946b00}{-\tfrac{b}{2a}} \pm \color{#c2410c}{\tfrac{\sqrt{b^2-4ac}}{2a}} = \color{#946b00}{-3} \pm \color{#c2410c}{5.39} \]
Figure (svg): The parabola y equals x squared plus 6x minus 20, with a gold dashed centre line at x equals negative 3 and vermilion arrows of length 5.39 reaching both x-intercepts
The first part finds the middle. The square root part says how far each answer sits from it.
Trap
\[ 2x^2 + 8x = 10 \]
\[ x^2 + 8x = 10 \]
Divide only x² by 2
Why: because that term looked like the obstacle.
Check: x = 1 solves the original, but 1 + 8 = 9
Why: which is not 10, so this line already has different solutions.
\[ x^2 + 4x = 5 \]
Divide every term by 2
Why: because both sides must shrink by the same factor.
\[ (x + 2)^2 = 9 \]
Add the corner 4 to both sides
Why: because half of 4 is 2, and 2 squared is 4.
\[ x + 2 = \pm 3 \]
Take both square roots
Why: since 3 and −3 both square to 9.
\[ x = 1 \text{ or } x = -5 \]
Subtract 2 from both sides
Why: so x stands alone.
Check: 2(1)² + 8(1) = 10
Why: which matches, so this square was built correctly.
Two truths and a lie
Eliminate the wrong options
Two are true. Knock them out and keep the false one.
Survives elimination: C
Why: The ± appears because a number and its negative have the same square: 5 squared and negative 5 squared are both 25. Imaginary roots come later and do not create the ±; they only change what the square root evaluates to.
Explain it to yourself
Discussion prompt
In two sentences: why does the formula solve every quadratic equation, including ones that do not factor?
Hint: Which steps of the derivation needed special numbers, and which worked for any a, b and c?
Answer:
Every step of the derivation, dividing by a, adding the corner, taking square roots, works for any numbers with a not 0. So the formula is completing the square done once, in advance, for every quadratic at the same time.
Section
Section 2
Prediction
Predict first
No two integers multiply to −1 and add to 4, so x² + 4x − 1 = 0 does not factor. What will the formula give?
Correct: Two irrational numbers: −2 ± √5.
Why: Under the root the formula computes 16 plus 4, which is 20. Twenty is positive, so the roots are real, but it is not a perfect square, so √20 = 2√5 stays irrational and the answers are −2 plus or minus √5.
Worked example
Figure (svg): The curve y equals 2x squared and the line y equals 3x plus 4, crossing where x is negative 0.85 and 2.35
\[ \text{Solve } \color{#1f4e9c}{2x^2} = \color{#c2410c}{3x + 4} \]
\[ 2x^2 - 3x - 4 = 0 \]
Subtract 3x and 4 from both sides
Why: because the formula is built for an equation equal to 0.
Figure (svg): The single parabola y equals 2x squared minus 3x minus 4, crossing the x-axis at the same two x values where the curve and line met
\[ \color{#1f4e9c}{a = 2},\; \color{#c2410c}{b = -3},\; c = -4 \]
Read a, b and c
Why: so each minus sign travels with its number.
Figure (svg): The parabola with its y-intercept at negative 4 marked: c is where the graph meets the y-axis
Check: 2x² + (−3)x + (−4) rebuilds the equation
Why: so no sign was lost in the reading.
Worked example
Figure (svg): The parabola y equals 2x squared minus 3x minus 4
\[ \color{#1f4e9c}{a = 2},\; \color{#c2410c}{b = -3},\; c = -4 \]
\[ x = \dfrac{-(\color{#c2410c}{-3}) \pm \sqrt{(\color{#c2410c}{-3})^2 - 4(\color{#1f4e9c}{2})(-4)}}{2(\color{#1f4e9c}{2})} \]
Substitute with brackets
Why: so each negative is squared or multiplied as a whole.
\[ x = \dfrac{3 \pm \sqrt{9 + 32}}{4} \]
Evaluate each product
Why: because (−3)² is 9, −4(2)(−4) is +32, and 2(2) is 4.
\[ x = \dfrac{3 \pm \sqrt{41}}{4} \]
Add under the root
Why: so one number, 41, is left to take the root of.
Figure (svg): The same parabola with a gold centre line at x equals 0.75
\[ x \approx \color{#c2410c}{2.35} \text{ or } x \approx \color{#c2410c}{-0.85} \]
Split the ± into two answers
Why: since √41 is about 6.40, giving 9.40/4 and −3.40/4.
Figure (svg): The parabola with both x-intercepts marked at 2.35 and negative 0.85
Check: 2(2.35)² − 3(2.35) − 4 = −0.005
Why: which is 0 up to rounding, and the graph crosses there too.
Faded example
\[ \text{Solve } x^2 - 5x + 3 = 0 \]
\[ x = \dfrac{-(-5) \pm \sqrt{(-5)^2 - 4(1)(3)}}{2(1)} \]
Substitute with brackets
Why: so the signs of b and c survive.
Fill in the blanks
x = \dfrac13} }}4.30 \approx ___ \text___ 0.70
Why: Under the root, 25 minus 4 times 1 times 3 gives 13. The square root of 13 is about 3.61, so the larger answer is 5 plus 3.61, over 2, which is about 4.30. Check: 4.30 squared is 18.49, minus 21.5, plus 3, gives about 0.
Worked example
Figure (svg): The parabola y equals 9x squared minus 24x plus 16, touching the x-axis at one point
\[ \text{Solve } 9x^2 - 24x + 16 = 0 \]
\[ x = \dfrac{24 \pm \sqrt{576 - 576}}{18} \]
Substitute a = 9, b = −24, c = 16
Why: because (−24)² is 576 and 4 times 9 times 16 is also 576.
\[ x = \dfrac{24 \pm \color{#c2410c}{0}}{18} \]
Evaluate the root
Why: so the half-width is 0 and both answers sit at the centre.
Figure (svg): The same parabola with its single touching point marked in gold
\[ x = \color{#946b00}{\tfrac{4}{3}} \]
Reduce 24 over 18
Why: so the fraction is in lowest terms, after dividing both by 6.
Figure (svg): The parabola touching the x-axis at x equals four thirds, labelled
Check: 9(16/9) − 24(4/3) + 16 = 16 − 32 + 16
Why: which is 0, so 4/3 is the one solution.
Worked example
Figure (svg): The parabola y equals x squared plus 2x plus 5, entirely above the x-axis with its vertex at negative 1, 4
\[ \text{Solve } x^2 + 2x + 5 = 0 \]
\[ x = \dfrac{-2 \pm \sqrt{4 - 20}}{2} \]
Substitute a = 1, b = 2, c = 5
Why: because 2² is 4 and 4 times 1 times 5 is 20.
\[ x = \dfrac{-2 \pm \sqrt{\color{#c2410c}{-16}}}{2} \]
Subtract under the root
Why: so the negative sign is visible before we take the root.
Figure (svg): The same parabola with its centre line at x equals negative 1 and its lowest point, 4, marked above the axis
\[ x = \dfrac{-2 \pm \color{#c2410c}{4i}}{2} \]
Rewrite √−16 as 4i
Why: because √16 is 4 and √−1 is i.
\[ x = \color{#946b00}{-1} \pm \color{#c2410c}{2i} \]
Divide both terms by 2
Why: so the centre and half-width each get halved.
Figure (svg): The parabola with its centre line at negative 1 labelled, and a note that the imaginary half-width cannot be drawn on real axes
Check: (−1 + 2i)² + 2(−1 + 2i) + 5 = (−3 − 4i) + (−2 + 4i) + 5
Why: which is 0. What this means: the curve's centre is −1, and it misses the axis entirely.
Error analysis
A student solved x squared minus 4x plus 13 equals 0.
Annotate
On: \( x = \frac{4 \pm \sqrt{16 - 52}}{2} = \frac{4 \pm 6i}{2} = 2 \pm 6i \)
Elimination
Eliminate the wrong options
Which is the solution of x² + 8x + 11 = 0?
Survives elimination: A
Why: Under the root, 64 minus 44 is 20, and √20 = 2√5. So x = (−8 ± 2√5)/2, and dividing both terms by 2 gives −4 ± √5. Check: −4 + √5 is about −1.76, and (−1.76)² + 8(−1.76) + 11 is about 0.
Commit first
Predict first
Is there a quadratic equation that factoring solves but the formula cannot?
Correct: No, the formula solves every one.
Why: Every step of the derivation works for any a, b and c with a not 0, so the formula never fails. Factoring can be faster when it works, because it skips the arithmetic under the root, but it never finds an answer the formula misses.
Discrimination
Sort into buckets
Sort each equation by the fastest method.
Pattern
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.8 Use the Quadratic Formula and the Discriminant §4.8, p. 292 — The Quadratic Formula
Check
Check your understanding
Solve x² − 4x − 7 = 0.
Answer: A
Why: Under the root, 16 minus 4 times 1 times −7 gives 16 + 28 = 44, and √44 = 2√11. So x = (4 ± 2√11)/2, which reduces to 2 ± √11 because both terms divide by 2. Check: 2 + √11 is about 5.32, and 5.32² − 4(5.32) − 7 is about 0.
Section
Section 3
Hypothesis
Predict first
x² + 6x + 8 = 0, x² + 6x + 9 = 0 and x² + 6x + 10 = 0. Which has no real solution?
Correct: The third.
Why: Under the root the formula computes 36 minus 4 times c. For c = 8, 9 and 10 that gives 4, then 0, then −4. Only the third is negative, so only x² + 6x + 10 = 0 needs i. Raising c lifts the parabola until it clears the axis.
| c | 36 − 4c | real solutions |
|---|---|---|
| 8 | 4 | two |
| 9 | 0 | one |
| 10 | −4 | none |
Concept
Figure (svg): Three parabolas from x squared plus 6x plus 8, 9 and 10: the blue one crosses the x-axis at two marked points, the gold dashed one touches it at one, the vermilion one stays above it
\[ D = b^2 - 4ac \]
\[ \color{#1f4e9c}{D = 4 > 0}: \text{ two real} \]
\[ \color{#946b00}{D = 0}: \text{ one real} \]
\[ \color{#c2410c}{D = -4 < 0}: \text{ two imaginary} \]
Worked example
Figure (svg): The parabola y equals 3x squared minus 2x plus 5, above the x-axis
\[ \text{What kind of solutions does } 3x^2 - 2x + 5 = 0 \text{ have?} \]
\[ D = (-2)^2 - 4(3)(5) \]
Substitute with brackets
Why: so the −2 is squared as a whole.
\[ D = 4 - 60 \]
Evaluate each part
Why: because (−2)² is 4 and 4 times 3 times 5 is 60.
\[ D = \color{#c2410c}{-56} < 0 \]
Subtract
Why: so the sign is visible: negative means two imaginary solutions.
Figure (svg): The parabola above the x-axis, labelled D less than 0: no crossing
Check: at x = 1/3 the height is 1/3 − 2/3 + 5 = 4.67
Why: which is above 0, so the graph never crosses and no real roots exist.
Figure (svg): The same parabola with its lowest point, 4.67, marked above the x-axis
Sorting
Sort into buckets
Sort each equation by what the formula will give.
Worked example
Figure (svg): The parabola y equals 6x squared plus x minus 2 crossing the x-axis twice
\[ \text{Solve } 6x^2 + x - 2 = 0 \]
\[ D = 1 + 48 = \color{#946b00}{49} \]
Compute D
Why: because 1² is 1 and −4 times 6 times −2 is +48.
\[ x = \dfrac{-1 \pm \color{#946b00}{7}}{12} \]
Substitute √49 = 7
Why: so no radical is left in the answer.
Figure (svg): The parabola with its centre line at negative one twelfth and vermilion arrows of length seven twelfths reaching each side
\[ x = \color{#c2410c}{\tfrac{1}{2}} \text{ or } x = \color{#c2410c}{-\tfrac{2}{3}} \]
Split the ± into two answers
Why: since 6/12 is 1/2 and −8/12 is −2/3.
Figure (svg): The parabola with its x-intercepts marked at one half and negative two thirds
Check: (2x − 1)(3x + 2) = 6x² + 4x − 3x − 2
Why: which is 6x² + x − 2, so rational roots came from real factors.
Error analysis
A student classified 5x squared equals 3x minus 1.
Annotate
On: \( a = 5,\; b = 3,\; c = -1 \;\Rightarrow\; D = 9 + 20 = 29 \;\Rightarrow\; \text{two real} \)
Counterexample
Discussion prompt
Try to write a quadratic with real coefficients that has one real and one imaginary solution. If you cannot, explain what stops you.
Hint: Both solutions come from the same √D. What does ± do to it?
Answer:
Both solutions share the same square root of D, one with plus and one with minus. If D is negative, both contain i; if D is not negative, neither does. So the two solutions are always the same kind.
Check
Check your understanding
What is the discriminant of 2x² + 5x + 4 = 0, and what does it tell you?
Answer: A
Why: D = 5² − 4(2)(4) gives 25 − 32, which is −7. A negative D means the square root is imaginary, so there are two imaginary solutions. They still exist; only the real ones are missing.
Estimation
Predict first
7x² − 20x + 14 = 0 has D = 8. Without solving, how far apart are its two roots?
Correct: About 0.4 apart: 1.23 and 1.63.
Why: The roots sit √D/2a either side of the centre, so they are √D/a apart. √8 is about 2.83, and 2.83 divided by 7 is about 0.40. A small positive D means two real roots that sit close together.
Read the result: a small positive D means the parabola barely dips below the axis.
Section
Section 4
Prediction
Predict first
y = x² − 2x − 3 and y = x² − 2x + 2 have the same shape. How many times does each cross the x-axis?
Correct: Twice and never.
Why: Their discriminants are 4 + 12 = 16 and 4 − 8 = −4. The second is just the first lifted up 5 units, which moves its lowest point from −4 to +1, above the axis. The rest of this section shows why D and the vertex height are the same information.
Worked example
Figure (svg): The parabola y equals x squared minus 2x minus 3 on axes from negative 2 to 4
\[ y = ax^2 + \color{#c2410c}{b}x + c \]
\[ y = a\left(x^2 + \color{#c2410c}{\tfrac{b}{a}}x\right) + c \]
Factor a out of the x terms
Why: so the bracket matches the square we built in Section 1.
\[ y = a\left(x^2 + \color{#c2410c}{\tfrac{b}{a}}x + \color{#946b00}{\tfrac{b^2}{4a^2}}\right) - \color{#946b00}{\tfrac{b^2}{4a}} + c \]
Insert the corner, balanced by its opposite
Why: so y does not change: a times b²/4a² is b²/4a, taken back off.
Figure (svg): The same parabola with a gold centre line at x equals 1
Check: a = 1, b = −2, c = −3 gives y = (x² − 2x + 1) − 1 − 3
Why: which expands back to x² − 2x − 3, so nothing changed.
Worked example
Figure (svg): The parabola y equals x squared minus 2x minus 3 with its centre line at x equals 1
\[ y = a\left(x^2 + \color{#c2410c}{\tfrac{b}{a}}x + \color{#946b00}{\tfrac{b^2}{4a^2}}\right) - \color{#946b00}{\tfrac{b^2}{4a}} + c \]
\[ y = a\left(x + \color{#c2410c}{\tfrac{b}{2a}}\right)^2 - \tfrac{b^2}{4a} + c \]
Write the bracket as a square
Why: because its three terms are the completed square.
Figure (svg): The parabola with its centre line at x equals 1, where the squared bracket is zero
\[ y = a\left(x + \color{#c2410c}{\tfrac{b}{2a}}\right)^2 \color{#946b00}{- \tfrac{b^2 - 4ac}{4a}} \]
Combine the constants over 4a
Why: because c is 4ac over 4a, so the discriminant appears again.
Figure (svg): The parabola with its vertex at 1, negative 4 marked, and a gold arrow of length 4 from the axis down to it
Check: D = 4 + 12 = 16, so the height is −16/4 = −4
Why: and y at x = 1 is 1 − 2 − 3 = −4, so the two agree.
Picture it
Figure (svg): The parabola y equals x squared minus 2x minus 3 with its vertex at height negative 4
Watch what happens to D as c rises and the parabola lifts.
\[ c = -3:\; \color{#c2410c}{D = 16},\; \text{vertex } \color{#946b00}{-4} \]
Start below the axis
Why: so the curve crosses twice.
\[ c = 1:\; \color{#c2410c}{D = 0},\; \text{vertex } \color{#946b00}{0} \]
Raise c by 4
Why: because the vertex rises by 4 and D falls by 16.
Figure (svg): The parabola y equals x squared minus 2x plus 1 touching the x-axis at its vertex 1, 0
\[ c = 2:\; \color{#c2410c}{D = -4},\; \text{vertex } \color{#946b00}{1} \]
Raise c by 1 more
Why: so the vertex clears the axis and D turns negative.
Figure (svg): The parabola y equals x squared minus 2x plus 2 with its vertex at height 1, above the axis
Check
Check your understanding
A parabola opens upward and its discriminant is negative. Where is its vertex?
Answer: A
Why: The vertex height is −D over 4a. With D negative and a positive, −D/4a is positive, so the vertex is above the axis. That is also why an upward parabola with negative D never crosses: its lowest point is already above 0.
Comparison
Comparison matrix
| discriminant | upward vertex | x-intercepts |
|---|---|---|
| positive | below the axis | 2 |
| zero | on the axis | 1 |
| negative | above the axis | 0 |
Trap
\[ x^2 + 6x + 13 = 0 \]
\[ D = 36 - 52 = -16 \]
Compute D
Why: because it predicts the kind of answer.
Conclude: no solutions
Why: because the graph never touches the axis.
\[ x = \dfrac{-6 \pm 4i}{2} \]
Finish the formula with √−16 = 4i
Why: because imaginary numbers are allowed.
\[ x = -3 \pm 2i \]
Divide both terms by 2
Why: so the centre and half-width are each halved.
Check: (−3 + 2i)² + 6(−3 + 2i) + 13 = 0
Why: since (5 − 12i) + (−18 + 12i) + 13 is 0.
Explain it
Discussion prompt
A parabola opens downward with its vertex at height 3. Explain to a classmate why its discriminant must be positive.
Hint: Use the vertex height, −D over 4a, and remember a is negative.
Answer:
Opening downward means a is negative. The vertex height is 3, so negative D over 4a equals 3, which gives D equal to negative 12a. With a negative, negative 12a is positive. The picture agrees: a curve that peaks above the axis and falls both ways crosses it twice.
Section
Section 5
Prediction
Predict first
A ball thrown up at 20 feet per second would rise 20 feet in 1 second with no gravity. Gravity pulls it 16 feet back. Where is it after 1 second?
Correct: 4 feet higher.
Why: The throw carries it up 20 feet and gravity takes back 16 feet, because a falling object drops 16 feet in its first second (Lesson 4.5). So it ends 20 minus 16, which is 4 feet above where it started.
Worked example
Figure (svg): A height scale from 0 to 40 feet with a grey bar showing a start height of 5 feet
\[ \text{Start at } h_0 \text{ feet, thrown up at } v_0 \text{ feet per second} \]
\[ h = h_0 \]
Start at the release height
Why: because at t = 0 nothing has moved yet.
\[ h = h_0 + \color{#1f4e9c}{v_0 t} \]
Add the distance the throw carries it
Why: because speed times time is distance, if nothing slowed it.
Figure (svg): A blue arrow from 5 feet up to 37 feet: the throw adds 32 feet in 1 second
\[ h = \color{#c2410c}{-16t^2} + \color{#1f4e9c}{v_0 t} + h_0 \]
Subtract the distance gravity pulls it
Why: because Lesson 4.5 showed a fall of 16t² feet in t seconds.
Figure (svg): A vermilion arrow from 37 feet down 16 feet to a gold dot at 21 feet: the height after 1 second
Check: v₀ = 0 gives h = −16t² + h₀
Why: which is the dropped-object model, as it should be. Units: feet on every term.
Worked example
Figure (svg): Height h in feet against time t in seconds for the ball from slide 4: it starts at 5 feet, peaks at 21 feet at 1 second, and falls below 0 just after 2 seconds
\[ h = -16t^2 + v_0 t + h_0 \]
\[ 0 = -16t^2 + \color{#1f4e9c}{32}t + 5 \]
Substitute h = 0, v₀ = 32, h₀ = 5
Why: because landing means the height is 0 feet.
Figure (svg): The height curve with the release point at 5 feet and the peak at 21 feet marked
\[ \color{#1f4e9c}{a = -16},\; \color{#c2410c}{b = 32},\; c = 5 \]
Read a, b and c
Why: so the negative a stays attached to its sign.
Figure (svg): The height curve with c equals 5 marked at the start and a note that a negative a makes the curve open downward
Check: t = 0 gives h = 5
Why: which is the release height, so the set-up matches the story.
Worked example
Figure (svg): The height curve for the ball with its release and peak marked
\[ 0 = -16t^2 + 32t + 5 \]
\[ t = \dfrac{-32 \pm \sqrt{32^2 - 4(-16)(5)}}{2(-16)} \]
Substitute with brackets
Why: so the −16 multiplies correctly under the root.
\[ t = \dfrac{-32 \pm \sqrt{1344}}{-32} \]
Evaluate under the root
Why: because 1024 plus 320 is 1344.
Figure (svg): The height curve with a gold centre line at 1 second and vermilion arrows of 1.15 seconds reaching both zero crossings
\[ t \approx \color{#c2410c}{2.15} \text{ or } t \approx -0.15 \]
Split the ± into two answers
Why: since √1344 is about 36.66, giving −68.66/−32 and 4.66/−32.
Figure (svg): The height curve with the landing point marked at 2.15 seconds
\[ t \approx \color{#c2410c}{2.15 \text{ s}} \]
Keep only the positive time
Why: because −0.15 seconds is before the ball was thrown.
Check: t = 2.146 gives −16(4.604) + 32(2.146) + 5
Why: which is −73.66 + 68.66 + 5 = 0 feet, so the ball lands at 2.15 s.
Hypothesis
Predict first
The same ball is thrown at 64 feet per second instead of 32. How long is it in the air now?
Correct: About 4.08 s.
Why: The formula gives t = (−64 − √4416)/(−32), and √4416 is about 66.45, so t is about 4.08 s. That is a little under double because the 5-foot head start matters less on a longer flight. Checking: −16(4.08)² + 64(4.08) + 5 is about 0.
Fill the middle
A ball is thrown downward at 8 feet per second from a 40-foot ledge.
Fill in the blanks
0 = -16t^2 -8t + 40
Why: Up is positive in this model, so a downward throw gives v₀ = −8 and the middle term is −8t. Solving gives t = (8 − √2624)/(−32), which is about 1.35 seconds. Check: −16(1.35)² − 8(1.35) + 40 is about 0.
Trap
\[ 0 = -16t^2 + 6 \]
Use the dropped-object model
Why: because the ball ends up falling anyway.
\[ t = \sqrt{6/16} \approx 0.61 \text{ s} \]
Solve by square roots
Why: since there is no middle term.
Check: thrown up at 24 ft/s, it is still rising at 0.61 s
Why: so it cannot have landed yet.
\[ 0 = -16t^2 + 24t + 6 \]
Include v₀t with v₀ = 24
Why: because the throw carries it up first.
\[ t = \dfrac{-24 - \sqrt{960}}{-32} \approx 1.72 \text{ s} \]
Use the formula, keep the positive root
Why: since √960 is about 30.98.
Check: −16(1.72)² + 24(1.72) + 6 is about 0
Why: so 1.72 s is the landing time.
Check
Check your understanding
A ball leaves a hand 3 feet up, thrown up at 48 feet per second. For how long is it above 30 feet?
Answer: A
Why: Set 30 = −16t² + 48t + 3, so 16t² − 48t + 27 = 0. D = 2304 − 1728 = 576, and √576 = 24, so t = (48 ± 24)/32, which gives 0.75 s on the way up and 2.25 s on the way down. It is above 30 feet between them: 2.25 − 0.75 = 1.5 s.
Real world
Discussion prompt
A diver jumps up at 12 feet per second from a board 30 feet above the water. Write the equation for reaching the water and find the time.
Hint: Which of h₀ and v₀ is 30, and which is 12?
Answer:
\[ 0 = -16t^2 + 12t + 30 \]
\[ t = \dfrac{-12 - \sqrt{2064}}{-32} \approx 1.79 \text{ s} \]
Under the root: 144 plus 1920 is 2064. The other root, about negative 1.04, is rejected because it is before the jump.
Commit first
Predict first
For 0 = −16t² + v₀t + h₀ with h₀ above 0, can the discriminant ever be negative?
Correct: No, it is always positive.
Why: D = v₀² − 4(−16)(h₀), which is v₀² + 64h₀. Both parts are at least 0 and 64h₀ is positive, so D is always positive. That matches the picture: a ball that starts above the ground must come down through it.
Connect it up
Draw it
Draw the garden square with its corner. Beside it write the formula and colour its pieces to match. Then sketch three parabolas for D above, at and below 0, marking each vertex.
Recap
Next, Lesson 4.9 asks where a quadratic is positive or negative.
Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Algebra 2 — $55/session, free consultation.