Solving when one side is already a perfect square, the number that completes x squared plus bx, solving any quadratic equation by completing the square with any leading coefficient, an area model, and rewriting a function in vertex form to read off its maximum.
Subject: Algebra 2 · 69 slides · symbolic lesson
Open the interactive version of this deck
Title
Algebra 2 · Lesson 4.7
What to do when a quadratic refuses to factor: build the square that is missing
Objectives
Lessons 4.3 and 4.4 taught you to factor, and factoring is fast when it works. It works only when the roots happen to be nice numbers, which most quadratics in the world are not. This lesson gives you a method that never fails.
The idea is in the name and it is completely literal. An expression that is nearly a square gets the missing piece added on, and once it really is a square you finish it the way Lesson 4.5 finished things: take a square root.
Two mistakes account for almost every lost mark here, and both get a slide of their own. One is adding the missing piece to one side of an equation and not the other. The other is mishandling a leading coefficient that is not 1.
There is a bigger prize at the end. Complete the square on a quadratic with letters instead of numbers and out falls the quadratic formula, which is the whole of Lesson 4.8. This lesson is where that formula is actually built.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 284 — Before, Now, Why and the Key Vocabulary
Warm-up
Everything in this lesson is those two skills joined together, so check that both are still sharp before you go on. Write both answers down before you read the ones provided.
\[ x^{2} = 49 \qquad \text{and} \qquad x^{2} + 10x + 25 \]
Discussion prompt
Solve the first, and factor the second. Then say what the two have in common.
Look at the second one again and notice the relationship the pattern hides. Half of ten is five, and five squared is twenty-five, which is exactly the number sitting at the end. That is not a coincidence about this trinomial; it is the only way a trinomial can be a square.
Now join the two skills. If a quadratic equation had a perfect square on the left and a number on the right, you could factor the left and take roots, and the equation would be finished in two lines.
The rest of the lesson is about what to do when the left side is not quite a perfect square. The answer is to make it one, on purpose, and that is a manufacturing job rather than a search.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 284 — the link back to Lesson 4.5
Section
Part 1
Concept
In Lesson 4.5 you solved equations shaped like a square equals a number. The variable sat alone inside the square, so a square root finished the job in a line.
\[ x^{2} = k \;\Longrightarrow\; x = \pm\sqrt{k} \]
Nothing in that move cares that the thing being squared is a bare x. If the whole of a bracket is squared and the other side is a number, the same move works, and it delivers two equations instead of one.
\[ (x - 4)^{2} = 25 \;\Longrightarrow\; x - 4 = \pm 5 \]
That is the entire content of the first part of this lesson. When one side of an equation is a perfect square trinomial, write it as a binomial squared and you are back in Lesson 4.5.
Keep the plus-or-minus sign in view. A positive number has two square roots, so dropping the minus one throws away half the answer, and the half you throw away is the one an examiner checks for.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 284 — the opening paragraph and Example 1
Notation
Before using this equation, take it apart. Each piece does a different job, and knowing which is which is what stops you from taking a root of the wrong thing.
Annotate
On: \( (x - 4)^{2} = 25 \)
The last note is the one people skip. Getting to x minus 4 equals plus or minus 5 feels like arriving, and it is one full move short of an answer.
Notice also what the bracket is telling you before you solve anything. Whatever x turns out to be, it sits 5 away from 4, so the two answers must be 4 less 5 and 4 plus 5. The bracket names the centre and the root names the reach.
That reading is worth keeping, because every answer in this lesson comes out in that form, and in Lesson 4.8 the quadratic formula will turn out to be exactly a centre with a reach either side of it.
Worked example
The left side is one of the perfect square trinomials from Lesson 4.4, so no manufacturing is needed yet. Spot the pattern, then use it.
\[ x^{2} - 8x + 16 = 25 \]
Write the left side as a binomial squared
Why: the first term is x times x and the last is 4 times 4, and the middle term is twice 4 times x with a minus sign, so the bracket is x minus 4.
\[ (x - 4)^{2} = 25 \]
Check that pattern in your head rather than trusting it. Half of the middle coefficient, negative 8, is negative 4, and negative 4 squared is 16. The last number agrees, so the trinomial really is a square.
Take square roots of each side
Why: a positive number has two square roots, so both signs are kept.
\[ x - 4 = \pm 5 \]
Solve for x
Why: add 4 to each side to free x from the bracket.
\[ x = 4 \pm 5 \]
Figure (svg): A number line from minus three to eleven with a hollow point at four and solid points at minus one and nine, and two arrows of length five running from four out to each of them.
The picture is the answer read as a sentence: start at 4 and go 5 in each direction. Splitting the plus-or-minus into its two cases gives 9 and negative 1.
\[ x = 4 + 5 = 9 \qquad \text{or} \qquad x = 4 - 5 = -1 \]
Check both answers in the original equation
Why: substitute 9 first, then negative 1: 81 − 72 + 16 = 25 and 1 + 8 + 16 = 25.
\[ 9^{2} - 8(9) + 16 = 25 \qquad (-1)^{2} - 8(-1) + 16 = 25 \]
The book notes a second route: write the equation as x squared minus 8x minus 9 equals 0 and factor it. Both routes reach 9 and negative 1, and the factoring route only exists because this one happens to be factorable.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 284 — Example 1
Picture it
An equation with a squared bracket on one side and a number on the other is asking where two graphs meet. Seeing that once makes the plus-or-minus sign obvious rather than a rule to remember.
Figure (svg): The parabola y equals the square of x minus four, crossed by the horizontal line y equals twenty-five, with the two crossing points at x equal to minus one and x equal to nine marked.
The parabola is the left side and the flat line is the right side. They cross twice, once on each arm, and those two crossings are the two answers you found.
The lowest point of the parabola sits at 4 on the horizontal axis, and the two crossings sit the same distance either side of it. That symmetry is why the answers came out as a centre plus or minus a reach.
Ask yourself what would change if the right side were 0 instead of 25. The line would drop onto the vertex, the two crossings would slide together, and the equation would have one answer instead of two. Lesson 4.8 gives that situation a name.
Fill the middle
Both of these have a perfect square trinomial sitting on the left, so both are two-line problems. Work them before filling anything in.
\[ x^{2} + 6x + 9 = 36 \qquad \text{and} \qquad x^{2} - 10x + 25 = 1 \]
Fill in the blanks
(x + 3)^3 = 36 \;\Rightarrow\; x = -9 \text6 4 \qquad (x - 5)^___ = 1 \;\Rightarrow\; x = ___ \text___ ___
Why: Nine is three squared and the middle term is positive, so the first bracket is x plus 3, giving x equal to negative 3 plus or minus 6, which is 3 or negative 9. Twenty-five is five squared with a negative middle term, so the second bracket is x minus 5, giving 5 plus or minus 1, which is 6 or 4.
The sign inside the bracket comes from the middle term, never from the last one. Both trinomials here end in a positive number, and one bracket is a plus and the other a minus.
Notice how differently the two answers are spread. The first pair are 12 apart because the square root of 36 is 6; the second pair are only 2 apart because the square root of 1 is 1. The number on the right controls the spread and nothing else.
Check one of them the slow way if you are not yet convinced. Putting negative 9 into the first equation gives 81 minus 54 plus 9, which is 36, so that root is genuine.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 285 — Guided Practice 1 and 2
Worked example
This one looks heavier only because the numbers are larger. The structure is exactly Example 1, and recognising that is most of the work.
\[ x^{2} - 24x + 144 = 100 \]
Check that the left side really is a square
Why: half of negative 24 is negative 12, and negative 12 squared is 144, which is the constant on the left, so the pattern holds.
\[ \left(\tfrac{-24}{2}\right)^{2} = (-12)^{2} = 144 \]
Running that check first costs one line and protects you from the commonest failure in this part, which is assuming a trinomial is a square because it looks like one.
Write the left side as a binomial squared
Why: the bracket is x minus 12 because the middle term is negative.
\[ (x - 12)^{2} = 100 \]
Take square roots of each side
Why: keeping both signs, since 100 has two square roots.
\[ x - 12 = \pm 10 \]
Solve for x
Why: add 12 to each side.
\[ x = 12 \pm 10 = 22 \; \text{or} \; 2 \]
Read the answer as a centre and a reach again: centred on 12, reaching 10 either way. The two roots are far apart because 100 is a large number to take the root of.
Notice how little the size of the numbers mattered. Nothing in the method scaled with 144 or 100; the work was finding half of the middle coefficient, and that was one division whatever the rest of the equation looked like.
Check the smaller answer in the original equation
Why: 4 minus 48 plus 144 is 100, which is the right-hand side.
\[ 2^{2} - 24(2) + 144 = 4 - 48 + 144 = 100 \]
Checking the answer nearer zero is usually the faster of the two, and one clean check is normally enough to catch a slip in the bracket.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 285 — Guided Practice 3
Trap
Solving the equation from Guided Practice 3, here is a very common last line:
\[ (x - 12)^{2} = 100 \]
\[ x - 12 = 10 \]
\[ x = 22 \]
Every line is arithmetically correct, and the answer given is a genuine solution. It is simply not the whole answer.
A square hides a sign. Both 10 and negative 10 square to 100, so both must be carried forward.
\[ x - 12 = \pm 10 \]
\[ x = 22 \; \text{or} \; 2 \]
The graph says the same thing. A parabola that rises above a horizontal line does so on both arms, so there are two crossings whenever there is one.
Build the habit now. Write the plus-or-minus sign at the same moment you write the square root, not afterwards when you remember it.
The lost root is often the more interesting one. Here it is 2, a small positive number, while the one that survived is 22; in a modelling problem the discarded root is frequently the only one that the situation can actually use.
Prediction
Exercise 12 changes one number and asks the same question. Before answering, think about what a squared bracket is allowed to equal when x is a real number.
\[ x^{2} - 4x + 4 = -1 \]
Predict first
The left side is a perfect square trinomial. What are the solutions of this equation?
Correct: 2 + i and 2 - i
Why: The left side is the square of x minus 2, so the equation says that a square equals negative 1. No real number squares to a negative, but Lesson 4.6 gave you the imaginary unit for exactly this. The square roots of negative 1 are i and negative i, so x minus 2 is plus or minus i, and x is 2 plus or minus i.
\[ (x - 2)^{2} = -1 \;\Longrightarrow\; x - 2 = \pm i \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 2 \pm i \]
Nothing about the method changed. The bracket still gave the centre, 2, and the square root still gave the reach; the reach simply turned out to be imaginary.
Graphically this is the case where the horizontal line sits below the vertex, so the parabola never reaches it. There are no crossings, and the two answers are complex rather than real.
Check the answer the way you would check any other. Two plus i, minus 2, is i, and i squared is negative 1, which is exactly the right-hand side.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 288 — Exercise 12
Section
Part 2
Picture it
Everything so far needed a perfect square to be handed to you. From here you make one yourself, and the picture below is what makes the rule obvious rather than something to memorise.
Figure (svg): A cyan square of side x beside an orange rectangle of height x and width b, with the two widths marked along the top and the combined area named underneath.
Read the drawing as area. The cyan square has side x, so its area is x squared. The orange strip is x tall and b wide, so its area is b times x. Together they hold exactly the expression you want to work with.
Now look at the shape rather than the area. It is a rectangle, not a square, because one side is x and the other is x plus b. Something is missing, and the question of this lesson is what.
Keep asking that as a shape question rather than an algebra question for the next two slides. The algebra will follow the picture without any effort once the picture is settled.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 283 — the Investigating Algebra activity with algebra tiles
Picture it
You cannot make a square by piling the strip on one side, because the strip would make that side too long. The trick is to share it equally between two sides.
Figure (svg): The same square and strip, with the strip divided down the middle into two equal halves, and an arrow showing one half sliding round to sit underneath the square.
Cut the orange strip down the middle. Each half is x tall and b over 2 wide, so each holds half the area of the original strip and the two together still hold all of it.
Leave one half where it is, on the right of the square, and slide the other half round to sit underneath. Nothing has been added and nothing thrown away; the same area is simply arranged differently.
Look at the shape now. Both the width and the height have grown by b over 2, so the outline is very nearly a square, and the only thing stopping it is one empty corner.
This is the move the whole method is named after, and it is why the rule halves b. If you did not halve it, one side would grow by b and the other not at all, and you would still have a rectangle.
Concept
Look at the hole in the corner and ask what size it is. Its width is set by the half-strip on the right and its height by the half-strip underneath, and both of those are b over 2.
Figure (svg): The square with a half-strip along its right edge and another along its bottom edge, leaving an empty square corner marked as b over two, squared, and the whole side marked x plus b over two.
A hole whose width and height are both b over 2 is a square of area b over 2, all squared. That is the number you add, and the picture leaves you no room to add anything else.
\[ x^{2} + bx + \left(\dfrac{b}{2}\right)^{2} = \left(x + \dfrac{b}{2}\right)^{2} \]
The right-hand side is just the outside of the finished picture: each side has length x plus b over 2, and a square's area is its side times itself.
completing the square — Adding the constant that turns x squared plus bx into a perfect square trinomial. That constant is always half the coefficient of x, squared.
Students who learn only the words halve it and square it can do the exercises and cannot say why. Students who carry the picture can rebuild the rule from scratch whenever they doubt it, and can also see instantly why adding b squared instead would be four times too much.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 284 — the Key Concept box and its two diagrams
Notation
Here is the rule on its own, with the picture underneath each piece of it. Read it as a set of instructions on b, since b is the only input the rule ever has.
Annotate
On: \( x^{2} + bx + \left(\tfrac{b}{2}\right)^{2} \)
The sign note is worth dwelling on. Completing the square on x squared minus 10x uses b equal to negative 10, so half of b is negative 5 and the number added is 25, while the bracket in the answer is x minus 5.
So the sign of b never reaches the number you add, and always reaches the bracket. Losing track of that is how a correct 25 ends up paired with a bracket of x plus 5.
One more habit: say what you are halving out loud. Half the coefficient of x, not half the expression and not half the constant. Naming it properly is a surprisingly effective guard.
Worked example
The book asks for the value of c that makes this trinomial a perfect square, and then for the trinomial written as a binomial squared. Three short steps do it.
\[ x^{2} + 16x + c \]
Find half the coefficient of x
Why: the coefficient of x is 16, and half of 16 is 8. In the picture, 8 is the width of each half-strip.
\[ \dfrac{16}{2} = 8 \]
Square the result
Why: the corner is 8 wide and 8 tall, so its area is 64.
\[ 8^{2} = 64 \]
Replace c with that result
Why: and the trinomial is now a perfect square.
\[ x^{2} + 16x + 64 \]
Figure (svg): The completed area model for x squared plus sixteen x: a square of side x, two strips of width eight, and a solid corner of area sixty-four, with the whole side marked x plus eight.
The drawing accounts for every term. One cyan square of area x squared, two orange strips of 8x each making the 16x, and one gold corner of 64. Nothing is left over and nothing is missing.
Write it as a binomial squared
Why: the side of the big square is x plus 8, so the area is that side times itself.
\[ x^{2} + 16x + 64 = (x + 8)(x + 8) = (x + 8)^{2} \]
The question asked for two things, and it is worth separating them. The value of c is 64, and the binomial squared is x plus 8, all squared. The 8 and the 64 are different objects: one is a length on the diagram and the other is an area, and answering with the wrong one is a common way to lose a mark that was earned.
Check by expanding the bracket
Why: x times x is x squared, the two cross products give 8x each, and 8 times 8 is 64, returning the trinomial exactly.
\[ (x + 8)^{2} = x^{2} + 8x + 8x + 64 = x^{2} + 16x + 64 \]
Expanding back is the only check worth making here, and it takes one line. If the middle term does not come back as 16x, the number you added was wrong.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 285 — Example 2
Trap
Completing the square on x squared plus 16x, a very tempting first attempt:
\[ x^{2} + 16x + 256 \]
\[ \text{because } 16^{2} = 256 \]
The reasoning behind it sounds fine. The middle number is 16, squares are what make perfect square trinomials, so square the 16.
Expand the bracket it would need and the middle term comes back wrong.
\[ (x + 16)^{2} = x^{2} + 32x + 256 \]
That is 32x, twice what you started with, because the 16 gets counted once on each side of the square.
Figure (svg): The same corner drawn twice: the correct eight by eight square of area sixty-four, and over it a red sixteen by sixteen square of area two hundred and fifty-six that is four times as large.
The picture shows the size of the error exactly. The red square is b by b, and the dashed lines cut it into four corners of the right size, so b squared is four times too much.
If you can see why the strip had to be halved, you will never make this mistake. The corner is square because both of its sides were cut from the same strip, and each of those cuts was half of b.
Fill the middle
Same rule twice, and both middle coefficients are even, so both answers are whole numbers. Do them in your head before you fill anything in.
\[ x^{2} + 14x + c \qquad \text{and} \qquad x^{2} + 22x + c \]
Fill in the blanks
x^49 + 14x + 7 = (x + 121)^11 \qquad x^___ + 22x + ___ = (x + ___)^___
Why: Half of 14 is 7 and 7 squared is 49, so the bracket is x plus 7. Half of 22 is 11 and 11 squared is 121, so the bracket is x plus 11. Notice that the number inside the bracket is the halved value, and the number added to the trinomial is that same value squared.
The pairing is the thing to fix in your memory. Whatever number you halve b down to goes inside the bracket; that same number squared goes into the trinomial.
Check either one by expanding. The square of x plus 11 gives 11x twice over, which is the 22x you wanted, and 121 at the end.
If you found yourself computing 14 over 2 on paper, that is fine for now. The speed comes from repetition, and there are eight of these in the exercise set for exactly that reason.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 285 — Guided Practice 4 and 5
Worked example
Every middle coefficient so far has been even, which made the halving invisible. Here is an odd one, and it is the case people assume must be wrong.
\[ x^{2} - 9x + c \]
Find half the coefficient of x
Why: the coefficient is negative 9, and half of that is negative 9 over 2. A fraction here is normal, not a symptom of an error.
\[ \dfrac{-9}{2} = -\dfrac{9}{2} \]
Square the result
Why: squaring kills the minus sign, and squaring a fraction squares top and bottom separately.
\[ \left(-\dfrac{9}{2}\right)^{2} = \dfrac{81}{4} \]
Replace c with that value
Why: so the trinomial is complete.
\[ x^{2} - 9x + \dfrac{81}{4} \]
The bracket keeps the sign that the squaring discarded. Half of b was negative, so the binomial is x minus nine halves. That pairing is the whole of the sign rule: the constant added is always positive, and the bracket always copies the sign of the middle term.
Write it as a binomial squared
Why: the side of the square is x minus nine halves.
\[ x^{2} - 9x + \dfrac{81}{4} = \left(x - \dfrac{9}{2}\right)^{2} \]
Do not be tempted to round 81 over 4 to 20 for tidiness. The trinomial is a perfect square for exactly one value of c and for no other, so an approximation here is simply a wrong answer wearing friendly clothes.
Check by expanding the bracket
Why: the two cross products are each negative nine halves times x, which add to negative 9x, and nine halves squared is 81 over 4.
\[ \left(x - \tfrac{9}{2}\right)^{2} = x^{2} - \tfrac{9}{2}x - \tfrac{9}{2}x + \tfrac{81}{4} = x^{2} - 9x + \tfrac{81}{4} \]
If a decimal is easier to trust, 81 over 4 is 20.25, and twice 4.5 is 9, so the middle term is right either way.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 285 — Guided Practice 6
Picture it
If a fractional answer still feels suspicious, draw it. The picture does not know or care whether b is even.
Figure (svg): The area model for x squared plus seven x: two narrow strips of width three point five and a corner of area twelve point two five, with the whole side marked x plus three point five.
Here b is 7, so each half-strip is 3.5 wide, and the corner is a 3.5 by 3.5 square of area 12.25. Written as a fraction that is 49 over 4, which is what Exercise 19 asks for.
Nothing in the construction required the halves to be whole. The strip is cut down the middle wherever the middle happens to be, and for an odd width that lands between two whole numbers.
There is a practical reason to prefer the fraction to the decimal. Fractions stay exact through the rest of a solution, while a decimal like 12.25 is fine here but becomes a rounding problem the moment the numbers are less friendly.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 288 — Exercise 19
Tweak it
Here is a second way of seeing the same number, which Exercise 59 asks you to discover for yourself. Graph x squared plus bx and watch where the lowest point sits as b changes.
Parameter explorer
Set b to 6 and read the lowest point off the curve. Then set b to 4 and to 10. What is the connection between b and how far the lowest point sits below the horizontal axis?
\[ y = x^{2} + bx, \quad b = {b} \]
So the number you add is not an arbitrary repair. It is the exact depth of the dip, and adding it lifts the curve until its lowest point rests on the axis.
Try a negative value of b as well. The dip moves to the right of the axis instead of the left, and the depth is unchanged, because squaring half of a negative b gives the same positive number.
This also explains something you will need in Part 5. Completing the square on a function is how you find its lowest point, and that is the whole of vertex form.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 289 — Exercise 59
Matching
Four expressions from the exercise set, four constants. Halve and square each coefficient in your head; the aim is speed now rather than working.
Match the pairs
Why: Half of 6 is 3 and 3 squared is 9. Half of negative 24 is negative 12 and that squared is 144, with a minus sign inside the bracket. Half of 7 is seven halves, giving 49 over 4. The last one has an invisible coefficient of negative 1, so half of it is negative one half and the constant is one quarter.
The last pair is the one that catches people. A lone minus x has a coefficient of negative 1, not 0, and forgetting that leaves you looking for half of nothing.
Notice that the sign inside each bracket always copies the sign of the middle term, while every constant added is positive. Those two facts together settle every matching of this kind.
Try covering the right-hand column and generating the four constants yourself. Being able to produce them rather than recognise them is what the next part will demand.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 288 — Exercises 13, 15, 19 and 21
Section
Part 3
Concept
Lesson 4.3 asked you to find two numbers with a given sum and product. When such numbers exist and are whole, factoring is the fastest method there is. When they are not, the search simply fails and leaves you with nothing.
\[ x^{2} - 12x + 4 = 0 \]
Try it on this one. You need two numbers multiplying to 4 and adding to negative 12, and the only whole-number pairs for 4 are 1 with 4 and 2 with 2. Neither adds to negative 12, so the search is over.
Completing the square does not search. It builds the perfect square it needs, which means it works on every quadratic equation without exception, and that is why it is worth learning even though it is slower.
\[ x^{2} + bx + \left(\dfrac{b}{2}\right)^{2} = \left(x + \dfrac{b}{2}\right)^{2} \]
One new rule joins it as soon as an equation is involved. When you add the missing corner to the left side, you must add the same number to the right side, because an equation is a statement that two amounts are equal.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 285 — the Solving Equations paragraph
Step zero
Do not start writing yet. Look at this equation and decide what has to happen before the completing-the-square rule can be applied at all.
\[ x^{2} - 12x + 4 = 0 \]
Discussion prompt
Name the first move and say why it is needed. Then say what number you will add, and to which sides.
This is the step most often skipped, and skipping it produces an expression with two constants on the left, which is no longer anything the rule describes.
Think of it as clearing the workbench. The rule needs a square and a strip and nothing else; the constant is a third object that must be put on the other side of the equation first.
Notice also that the right side is allowed to be anything at all, including a negative number. It is the left side that must have the exact shape the rule expects.
Worked example
This is the equation that defeated factoring two slides ago. Completing the square solves it in six lines and produces an exact answer with a square root in it.
\[ x^{2} - 12x + 4 = 0 \]
Subtract 4 from each side
Why: to leave the left side in the form x squared plus bx, which is what the rule needs.
\[ x^{2} - 12x = -4 \]
Add half of negative 12, squared, to each side
Why: half of negative 12 is negative 6, and negative 6 squared is 36. Both sides get it, or the equation stops being true.
\[ x^{2} - 12x + 36 = -4 + 36 \]
The right side is now a number you can simplify, and the left side is a perfect square by construction. That is the whole engine of the method.
Write the left side as a binomial squared
Why: the bracket is x minus 6 because half of b was negative 6.
\[ (x - 6)^{2} = 32 \]
Take square roots of each side
Why: keeping both signs.
\[ x - 6 = \pm\sqrt{32} \]
Solve for x
Why: add 6 to each side.
\[ x = 6 \pm\sqrt{32} \]
Simplify the radical
Why: 32 is 16 times 2, and the square root of 16 is 4, so the root of 32 is 4 root 2.
\[ \sqrt{32} = \sqrt{16}\cdot\sqrt{2} = 4\sqrt{2} \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 6 \pm 4\sqrt{2} \]
Leave the answer in that exact form. Six plus four root two is about 11.66 and six minus four root two is about 0.34, but the surd form is the one that is exactly right.
Six lines, and not one of them involved a guess. Compare that with the factoring search, which asked you to imagine pairs of numbers until one of them worked; here the number you needed at every stage was calculated rather than found.
Check the larger answer in the original equation
Why: squaring 6 plus 4 root 2 gives 36 plus 48 root 2 plus 32, and subtracting 12 times the same number removes 72 plus 48 root 2, leaving 68 − 72 + 4, which is 0.
\[ (6 + 4\sqrt2)^{2} - 12(6 + 4\sqrt2) + 4 = 68 + 48\sqrt2 - 72 - 48\sqrt2 + 4 = 0 \]
Watch how the root-2 parts cancel exactly. That cancellation is the signature of a correct surd answer, and it is worth looking for whenever you check one.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 285 — Example 3
Picture it
The book suggests a second check for Example 3: graph the function and read its crossings. It is worth doing once, because it turns an unfamiliar surd answer into two points you can see.
Figure (svg): The parabola y equals x squared minus twelve x plus four, with its two x-intercepts near nought point three four and eleven point six six marked and its vertex at six, minus thirty-two.
The two marked crossings sit at about 0.34 and about 11.66, which are the decimal values of six minus four root two and six plus four root two. Algebra and picture agree.
Look also at how far apart they are. The gap is eight root two, a little over 11, and the vertex sits exactly halfway between them at 6, which is the centre the bracket named.
A graph will never prove an exact answer, since it can only ever be read to a few decimal places. What it does do is catch a blunder: a sign error would put your answers somewhere the curve does not cross.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 285 — the Check note after Example 3
Ranking
The method is five moves, and they only work in one order. Sort them before you meet an equation that punishes the wrong order.
Put in order
Order these moves for solving a quadratic equation by completing the square, starting with the first.
Why: Dividing comes first because the rule for the missing corner is written for a leading coefficient of 1, and dividing later would change the number you have already added. Moving the constant comes next so that the left side has the exact shape the rule expects. Only then can the corner be added, the bracket written and the roots taken.
The first two are the ones that get swapped. Moving the constant first and then dividing is not fatal, but it means dividing a number you have already moved, and that is one more place to drop a sign.
The last two are never in doubt, because a square root can only be taken once there is a square to take it of. If you find yourself wanting to take a root earlier, the left side is not finished.
Say the list to yourself as you start any of the exercises. Five moves, always the same five, and the only thing that varies between problems is how much arithmetic each one costs.
Worked example
A first one to run the five moves on. The leading coefficient is already 1, so the method starts at move two.
\[ x^{2} + 6x + 4 = 0 \]
Subtract 4 from each side
Why: clearing the constant off the left.
\[ x^{2} + 6x = -4 \]
Add half of 6, squared, to each side
Why: half of 6 is 3, and 3 squared is 9.
\[ x^{2} + 6x + 9 = -4 + 9 \]
This is the picture from Part 2 with real numbers in it: a square of side x, two strips of 3x, and a gold corner of 9 added to both sides at once.
Write the left side as a binomial squared and simplify the right
Why: the bracket is x plus 3, and negative 4 plus 9 is 5.
\[ (x + 3)^{2} = 5 \]
Take square roots of each side
Why: 5 is not a perfect square, so the root stays as a surd.
\[ x + 3 = \pm\sqrt5 \]
Solve for x
Why: subtract 3 from each side.
\[ x = -3 \pm\sqrt5 \]
Read it as a centre and a reach once more. The roots sit either side of negative 3, about 2.24 away, so they are roughly negative 0.76 and negative 5.24.
It is worth noticing why this equation could not be factored. The roots are irrational, so no pair of whole numbers multiplies to 4 and adds to 6, and the search of Lesson 4.3 would have gone on for ever without finding anything.
Check the answer by expanding it back
Why: the square of negative 3 plus root 5 is 14 minus 6 root 5, and adding 6 times negative 3 plus root 5 removes 18 and returns the 6 root 5, leaving negative 4, which the plus 4 cancels.
\[ (-3 + \sqrt5)^{2} + 6(-3 + \sqrt5) + 4 = 14 - 6\sqrt5 - 18 + 6\sqrt5 + 4 = 0 \]
Again the surd parts cancel. If yours do not, the arithmetic slipped somewhere, and the place to look first is the sign on the centre.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 286 — Guided Practice 7
Trap
Solving x squared plus 6x equals 20, a line that ruins everything after it:
\[ x^{2} + 6x = 20 \]
\[ x^{2} + 6x + 9 = 20 \]
\[ (x + 3)^{2} = 20 \]
The left side is now a genuine perfect square, so the work looks right. It is a different equation from the one asked.
Adding 9 to one side changes what the equation claims. The 9 has to go on both.
\[ x^{2} + 6x + 9 = 20 + 9 \]
\[ (x + 3)^{2} = 29 \]
Figure (svg): A balance beam resting level on a fulcrum, with a block for x squared plus six x and a gold block of nine stacked on the left pan, and a block for twenty with a matching gold nine on the right.
The balance shows the size of the damage: two answers about 5.39 either side of negative 3 rather than 4.47, wrong in the first decimal place.
The reason it is so easy to miss is that the left side looks finished either way. A perfect square appears, the bracket comes out clean, and nothing on the page complains. Only the right-hand number carries the evidence, which is why you should write the addition on both sides in the same movement of the pen.
Worked example
Every equation so far has started with a bare x squared. This one starts with two of them, and the rule for the missing corner has no idea what to do with that.
\[ 2x^{2} + 8x + 14 = 0 \]
Divide each side by the coefficient of x squared
Why: dividing by 2 makes the leading coefficient 1, which is the only shape the rule is written for. Every term must be divided, including the 14.
\[ x^{2} + 4x + 7 = 0 \]
Dividing is safe here because the right side is 0, and 0 divided by 2 is still 0. That is a small mercy of equations set equal to zero, and it does not apply when the right side is anything else.
Subtract 7 from each side
Why: clearing the constant off the left.
\[ x^{2} + 4x = -7 \]
Add half of 4, squared, to each side
Why: half of 4 is 2, and 2 squared is 4.
\[ x^{2} + 4x + 4 = -7 + 4 \]
Write the left side as a binomial squared and simplify
Why: the bracket is x plus 2, and negative 7 plus 4 is negative 3.
\[ (x + 2)^{2} = -3 \]
A square equal to a negative number is the case from Part 1 again. Lesson 4.6 gave you the imaginary unit for it, so the method carries straight on rather than stopping.
Take square roots of each side
Why: the square root of negative 3 is i times the square root of 3.
\[ x + 2 = \pm\sqrt{-3} = \pm i\sqrt3 \]
Solve for x
Why: subtract 2 from each side.
\[ x = -2 \pm i\sqrt3 \]
Check the first solution in the divided equation
Why: squaring negative 2 plus i root 3 gives 4 minus 4i root 3 plus 3 times i squared, which is 1 minus 4i root 3; adding 4 times the same number and then 7 cancels everything.
\[ (-2 + i\sqrt3)^{2} + 4(-2 + i\sqrt3) + 7 = 1 - 4i\sqrt3 - 8 + 4i\sqrt3 + 7 = 0 \]
Notice that the imaginary parts cancel exactly, just as the surd parts did in Example 3. A complex root always arrives with a partner that undoes it.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 286 — Example 4
Error analysis
This is the book's own error-analysis exercise, and the mistake in it is the single most expensive one in the lesson. Read the third line carefully before reading the notes.
Annotate
On: \( 4(x^{2} + 6x + 9) = 11 + 9 \)
The safest habit is the one Example 4 used: divide every term by the leading coefficient first, so that you never have a bracket sitting between what you add and the equation.
If you do prefer to factor the coefficient out, keep asking what the left side actually gained. Whatever you write inside the bracket gets multiplied by the number outside it before it counts.
Check the corrected answer to be sure it is right. Four times 0.4278 squared is about 0.732, plus 24 times 0.4278 is about 10.27, less 11 is zero to three decimal places.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 289 — Exercise 51
Worked example
A leading coefficient of 3 this time, and it divides into every other term exactly, which makes the first move painless.
\[ 3x^{2} + 12x - 18 = 0 \]
Divide each side by 3
Why: every term goes: 3 into 3 is 1, 3 into 12 is 4, and 3 into negative 18 is negative 6.
\[ x^{2} + 4x - 6 = 0 \]
Check that division term by term rather than in one glance. Leaving the constant undivided is the classic slip, and it produces an answer that looks perfectly reasonable and is wrong.
Add 6 to each side
Why: clearing the constant off the left.
\[ x^{2} + 4x = 6 \]
Add half of 4, squared, to each side
Why: half of 4 is 2, and 2 squared is 4.
\[ x^{2} + 4x + 4 = 6 + 4 \]
Write the left side as a binomial squared and simplify
Why: the bracket is x plus 2, and 6 plus 4 is 10.
\[ (x + 2)^{2} = 10 \]
Take square roots and solve
Why: 10 is not a perfect square, so the answer keeps its surd.
\[ x = -2 \pm\sqrt{10} \]
The two roots are about 1.16 and about negative 5.16. A quick sanity check: they sit either side of negative 2, which is where this parabola has its lowest point.
Dividing by 3 at the start rather than factoring it out was a deliberate choice. Because the right-hand side was zero, the division cost nothing at all, and it removed any chance of the Exercise 51 error appearing later on.
Check the positive root in the original equation
Why: 1.1623 squared is 1.3509, three times that is 4.0527, twelve times 1.1623 is 13.947, and 4.0527 plus 13.947 less 18 is 0.
\[ 3(1.1623)^{2} + 12(1.1623) - 18 \approx 4.053 + 13.947 - 18 = 0 \]
A decimal check like this one cannot prove an exact answer, but it will always expose a dropped division, which is what this example was chosen to test.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 286 — Guided Practice 10
Error analysis
The book's other error analysis. Every line of this solution is right until the very last one, which is the hardest kind of mistake to spot in your own work.
Annotate
On: \( x = -5 \pm \sqrt{12} = -5 \pm 4\sqrt{3} \)
The rule being misused is simple enough: only a perfect square factor comes out of a radical, and it comes out as its own square root. Four comes out as 2, not as 4.
A numerical check kills this error in seconds. Squaring 4 root 3 gives 48, not 12, so the simplification cannot be right.
This is also why Exercise 34 offers both negative 5 plus or minus 2 root 3 and negative 5 plus or minus 4 root 3 among its choices. The book is testing this exact slip on purpose.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 289 — Exercise 50
Worked example
This one does not look like a quadratic at all to begin with. It is a product on one side and a number on the other, so the first job is to make it look like the equations you know.
\[ 6x(x + 8) = 12 \]
Expand the left side
Why: multiply 6x by each term inside the bracket.
\[ 6x^{2} + 48x = 12 \]
Divide each side by 6
Why: 6 goes into every term exactly: into 6 once, into 48 eight times, and into 12 twice.
\[ x^{2} + 8x = 2 \]
The constant is already on the right, so there is nothing to move. That happens often once an equation has been rearranged, and skipping an unnecessary step is not the same as forgetting it.
Add half of 8, squared, to each side
Why: half of 8 is 4, and 4 squared is 16.
\[ x^{2} + 8x + 16 = 2 + 16 \]
Write the left side as a binomial squared and simplify
Why: the bracket is x plus 4, and 2 plus 16 is 18.
\[ (x + 4)^{2} = 18 \]
Take square roots and simplify the radical
Why: 18 is 9 times 2, so its square root is 3 root 2.
\[ x + 4 = \pm 3\sqrt2 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = -4 \pm 3\sqrt2 \]
Both roots survive here, because nothing in the question describes a length or a time. When an equation is presented on its own, with no situation attached, every solution it has is a solution you keep.
Check the larger root in the original equation
Why: negative 4 plus 3 root 2 is about 0.2426, and 6 times 0.2426 times 8.2426 is 12 to four decimal places.
\[ 6(0.2426)(0.2426 + 8) \approx 12 \]
Checking in the original rather than in a rearranged line is the point here, because the expanding and the dividing are both places an error could have crept in.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 286 — Guided Practice 11
Fill the middle
Same shape as Example 4 but with a real pair of answers at the end. Work it fully before filling in the blanks, dividing by 2 first.
\[ 2n^{2} - 4n - 14 = 0 \]
Fill in the blanks
n^8 - 2n - 7 = 0 \;\Rightarrow\; (n - 1)^2 = ___ \;\Rightarrow\; n = 1 \pm ___\sqrt___
Why: Dividing by 2 gives n squared minus 2n minus 7 equals 0. Moving the 7 gives n squared minus 2n equals 7, and half of negative 2 squared is 1, so both sides gain 1 and the right side becomes 8. The square root of 8 is 2 root 2, so the roots are 1 plus or minus 2 root 2, about 3.83 and about negative 1.83.
The bracket is n minus 1 because half of negative 2 is negative 1. Whenever the middle coefficient is 2, the number you add is just 1, which makes these the quickest problems in the set.
Simplifying root 8 is where Exercise 50's error would strike again. Eight is 4 times 2, the 4 comes out as a 2, and the answer is 2 root 2, not 4 root 2.
Check the larger root roughly: 3.828 squared is 14.65, twice that is 29.3, less 4 times 3.828 which is 15.3, less 14, gives about zero. The answer stands.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 286 — Guided Practice 9
Discrimination
Completing the square always works, but it is not always the quickest route. Look at each equation and decide what you would actually do, given everything Chapter 4 has taught you.
Sort into buckets
Sort each equation by the method you would reach for first.
The decision is quick to make. Glance for a square already present, then try the factoring search briefly, and complete the square when neither offers itself.
Do not feel obliged to abandon completing the square on the factorable ones. It will give you the right answer on every equation here, and the only cost is a longer piece of working.
The one that most people misfile is the equation with no real roots. Nothing about its appearance warns you, which is exactly why Lesson 4.8 introduces a number that tells you in advance.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 288 — Exercises 24, 27, 52 and the factoring set from Lesson 4.3
Elimination
The book's multiple-choice exercise, and every wrong option here is a specific mistake from this lesson. Work the equation first, then strike the impostors out.
\[ x^{2} + 10x + 8 = -5 \]
Eliminate the wrong options
Solve the equation, then eliminate every answer that a known slip would produce.
Survives elimination: c
Why: Moving the 8 across gives x squared plus 10x equal to negative 13, and half of 10 squared is 25, so both sides gain 25 and the right side becomes 12. The bracket is x plus 5, so x is negative 5 plus or minus root 12, and root 12 is 2 root 3. The answer is negative 5 plus or minus 2 root 3, about negative 1.54 and about negative 8.46.
Notice how the two wrong ideas combine. One option gets the centre wrong, one gets the surd wrong, and one manages both, which is how a well-built multiple-choice question is put together.
The sign of the centre is easy to settle without solving. The middle term is plus 10x, so half of b is plus 5, so the bracket is x plus 5, so the centre is negative 5. The centre always carries the opposite sign to the bracket.
Confirm the survivor numerically before you commit. Negative 1.536 squared is 2.36, plus 10 times negative 1.536 is negative 15.36, plus 8 gives negative 5, which is the right-hand side.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 288 — Exercise 34
Section
Part 4
Concept
Real questions do not arrive as quadratic equations. They arrive as a sentence about a shape or a situation, and turning that sentence into an equation is a separate skill from solving it.
That last line is the one this part exists for. An equation is happy with a negative answer; a rectangle is not. Every model here produces two roots, and in each case one of them describes something impossible.
\[ 7x(x + 6) = 112 \]
Here is the equation from Example 5, written straight from the sentence: a rectangle of length 7x and width x plus 6 has area 112. Nothing has been solved yet, and nothing needs to be until the sentence has been captured.
It is worth checking whether it factors before reaching for the longer method. Dividing by 7 gives x squared plus 6x equal to 16, and 16 has no whole-number pair adding to 6, so the search fails and the square gets built.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 286 — Example 5
Worked example
A rectangle has sides 7x and x plus 6, and an area of 112 square units. The book asks for x, and offers negative 8, 2, 10.6, and both negative 8 and 2 as choices.
\[ 7x(x + 6) = 112 \]
Use the area formula to set up
Why: length times width equals area, which is the relationship the picture claims.
\[ \text{length} \times \text{width} = \text{area} \]
Apply the distributive property
Why: multiply 7x by each term in the bracket.
\[ 7x^{2} + 42x = 112 \]
Divide each side by the coefficient of x squared
Why: 7 divides every term exactly: into 7 once, into 42 six times, into 112 sixteen times.
\[ x^{2} + 6x = 16 \]
Add half of 6, squared, to each side
Why: half of 6 is 3, and 3 squared is 9.
\[ x^{2} + 6x + 9 = 16 + 9 \]
Write the left side as a binomial squared and take roots
Why: the bracket is x plus 3, and 25 has square roots 5 and negative 5.
\[ (x + 3)^{2} = 25 \;\Longrightarrow\; x + 3 = \pm 5 \]
Solve for x
Why: subtract 3 from each side and split the two cases.
\[ x = -3 \pm 5 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 2 \; \text{or} \; x = -8 \]
Figure (svg): A rectangle fourteen units long and eight units tall drawn to scale, labelled seven x along the top and x plus six up the side, with its area of one hundred and twelve marked inside.
Now test both against the rectangle. With x equal to 2 the sides are 14 and 8, which is a genuine rectangle. With x equal to negative 8 the sides would be negative 56 and negative 2, and a side length cannot be negative, so that root is rejected.
Notice that the rejection happens after the solving and not during it. The algebra is allowed to run to the end and produce everything it can; only then do you ask which of its answers the rectangle is able to be.
Check the surviving answer in the original equation
Why: 7 times 2 is 14, 2 plus 6 is 8, and 14 times 8 is 112, the area you were given.
\[ 7(2)(2 + 6) = 14 \cdot 8 = 112 \]
The book's own hint points the same way: the choices offering negative 8 can be eliminated on sight, because they describe a rectangle with negative sides.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 286 — Example 5
Counterexample
Rejecting a root feels uncomfortable the first few times, because the algebra offered it and the algebra has not been wrong so far. Work out precisely what is going on.
\[ 7x(x + 6) = 112 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 2 \; \text{or} \; x = -8 \]
Discussion prompt
Substitute negative 8 into the equation and say whether it satisfies it. Then say what is actually being rejected, and why the algebra cannot see the problem by itself.
So there are two questions on every modelling problem, and they have to be asked separately. Which numbers solve the equation, and which of those describe the situation.
Get into the habit of writing the restriction down as soon as you name the unknown. Writing that x must be positive at the start makes the rejection a formality rather than an afterthought.
The restriction is not always positivity, either. Exercise 67 rejects a root because it would need a wall longer than the school has, which is a perfectly positive number that still cannot happen.
Fill the middle
A rectangle has sides x and x plus 10, and an area of 50. Set it up and solve it before filling anything in; the leading coefficient is already 1 this time.
\[ x(x + 10) = 50 \]
Fill in the blanks
x^75 + 10x = 50 \;\Rightarrow\; (x + 5)^5 = ___ \;\Rightarrow\; x = -5 + ___\sqrt___
Why: Half of 10 is 5 and 5 squared is 25, so both sides gain 25 and the right side becomes 75. The square root of 75 is 5 root 3, so x is negative 5 plus or minus 5 root 3. Only the plus root survives, giving x about 3.66, and the sides are then about 3.66 and about 13.66.
Simplifying root 75 is the step to take slowly. Seventy-five is 25 times 3, and the 25 comes out as 5, giving 5 root 3 rather than anything else.
Reject the other root on sight. Negative 5 minus 5 root 3 is about negative 13.66, which would make a side of the rectangle negative, so the situation forbids it.
Check the survivor in the original: 3.66 times 13.66 is 50 to two decimal places, so the answer is right even though it is not a whole number.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 288 — Exercise 35
Worked example
A trapezoid has parallel sides 3x minus 1 and x plus 9, a height of x, and an area of 20. This one needs the trapezoid area formula from Lesson 1.4 before any of this lesson applies.
\[ A = \tfrac12 (b_1 + b_2)h \]
Figure (svg): A trapezoid drawn to scale with its shorter parallel side marked three x minus one, its longer parallel side marked x plus nine, a dashed height marked x, and an area of twenty inside.
Substitute the three expressions
Why: the two parallel sides are the bases and x is the perpendicular height.
\[ \tfrac12\big((3x - 1) + (x + 9)\big)x = 20 \]
Combine the two bases first
Why: 3x plus x is 4x, and negative 1 plus 9 is 8, so the bracket becomes 4x plus 8.
\[ \tfrac12(4x + 8)x = 20 \]
Multiply out and halve
Why: half of 4x plus 8 is 2x plus 4, and multiplying by x gives two terms.
\[ 2x^{2} + 4x = 20 \]
Divide each side by 2
Why: 2 divides all three numbers exactly.
\[ x^{2} + 2x = 10 \]
Add half of 2, squared, to each side
Why: half of 2 is 1, and 1 squared is 1.
\[ x^{2} + 2x + 1 = 10 + 1 \]
Write as a binomial squared and take roots
Why: the bracket is x plus 1, and 11 is not a perfect square.
\[ (x + 1)^{2} = 11 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = -1 \pm\sqrt{11} \]
Only the positive root can be a height, so x is negative 1 plus root 11, about 2.32. The other root is about negative 4.32 and would give a trapezoid with negative dimensions.
Look back at how quickly the letters collapsed. Two bases and a height, three different expressions in x, became a single quadratic the moment the bases were added and the half was cleared. Most geometry problems in this exercise set behave the same way, so do the combining before you start worrying about the method.
Check the surviving answer in the area formula
Why: the two bases are about 5.95 and about 11.32, their sum is about 17.27, and half of that times the height 2.32 is 20.
\[ \tfrac12(5.95 + 11.32)(2.317) \approx 20 \]
Notice how much of this problem was Lesson 1.4 rather than Lesson 4.7. Setting a model up correctly is usually the longer half of the work.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 288 — Exercise 38
Real world
Your school is adding a rectangular eating section along part of a 70 foot wall. Three sides will be fenced with the 120 feet of fencing available, and the section must cover 1500 square feet.
Figure (svg): A seventy foot school wall drawn as a thick line, with a rectangular eating section against part of it, its two depths marked x and its open side marked one hundred and twenty minus two x.
Read the diagram before writing anything. Two sides of length x run away from the wall, and the third fenced side runs parallel to it, so it uses whatever fencing the two depths have left over.
\[ x(120 - 2x) = 1500 \]
Discussion prompt
Solve this equation by completing the square, then explain which root must be rejected and why, and give the dimensions of the eating section.
This is the sharpest version of the rejection idea in the whole lesson. Nothing about the discarded root is mathematically wrong, and nothing about it is negative; it is simply a design the site cannot hold.
Notice how the equation was written, too. The 120 feet of fencing had to be split before any algebra happened, and getting that split wrong is a far commoner error here than anything in the solving.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 290 — Exercise 67
Estimation
A parallelogram has base x plus 6 and height x, and an area of 48. Before solving, estimate, because an estimate is what tells you afterwards whether your exact answer is plausible.
\[ x(x + 6) = 48 \]
Predict first
Estimate x by trying whole numbers. Which value is closest?
Correct: about 4.5
Why: Trying x equal to 4 gives 4 times 10, which is 40, and x equal to 5 gives 5 times 11, which is 55. The target 48 sits between them and slightly nearer 55, so x is a little over 4.5. Completing the square confirms it: the bracket x plus 3 squared equals 57, so x is root 57 minus 3, which is about 4.55.
\[ (x + 3)^{2} = 57 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = -3 + \sqrt{57} \approx 4.55 \]
Estimating first is cheap and catches large errors. If your exact working had produced 7 or 2, you would know at a glance that something had gone wrong.
It also tells you in advance that the answer will not be a whole number, which is a signal to reach for completing the square rather than spending time on a factoring search that cannot succeed.
Note that the area grows faster than you expect as x rises, because both the base and the height grow together. That is why the answer sits nearer 4.5 than the halfway point between 4 and 5.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 288 — Exercise 36
Section
Part 5
Concept
Lesson 4.2 gave you three ways of writing the same quadratic function, and said that each one hands you a different feature for free. Vertex form is the one that hands you the turning point.
\[ y = a(x - h)^{2} + k, \qquad \text{vertex } (h, k) \]
At the time you were handed functions already written that way. The obvious question was left hanging: what do you do when a function arrives in standard form and you want its vertex?
\[ y = x^{2} - 10x + 22 \]
Completing the square is the answer. It is the only general method for turning standard form into vertex form, which makes this lesson the missing half of Lesson 4.2.
One difference from Part 3 matters. There you were solving an equation and both sides were changed together. Here you are rewriting a function, so the y side must be kept honest as the x side is reshaped.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 287 — the Vertex Form paragraph
Worked example
The book's way of laying this out keeps the equation balanced at every line by adding the same amount to the y side as to the x side. Follow the pattern of the question marks.
\[ y = x^{2} - 10x + 22 \]
Prepare to complete the square
Why: leave a gap on each side for the number about to be added, and gather the x terms into a bracket.
\[ y + \;? \;= (x^{2} - 10x + \;?\;) + 22 \]
Add half of negative 10, squared, to each side
Why: half of negative 10 is negative 5, and negative 5 squared is 25, so both gaps become 25.
\[ y + 25 = (x^{2} - 10x + 25) + 22 \]
The 25 on the left is what keeps the statement true. Adding 25 inside the bracket on the right changes that side by 25, so the left side must gain the same amount.
Write the bracket as a binomial squared
Why: the bracket is x minus 5, because half of b was negative 5.
\[ y + 25 = (x - 5)^{2} + 22 \]
Solve for y
Why: subtract 25 from each side, and 22 minus 25 is negative 3.
\[ y = (x - 5)^{2} - 3 \]
Figure (svg): The parabola y equals x squared minus ten x plus twenty-two with its vertex at five, minus three marked, its axis of symmetry drawn, and its y-intercept at twenty-two marked.
Read the vertex straight off: h is 5 and k is negative 3, so the turning point is at 5, negative 3, which is exactly where the graph bottoms out.
Check by putting a value into both forms
Why: at x equal to 0 standard form gives 22, and vertex form gives negative 5 squared, which is 25, minus 3, which is also 22.
\[ (0)^{2} - 10(0) + 22 = 22 \qquad (0 - 5)^{2} - 3 = 25 - 3 = 22 \]
One agreeing value is not a proof, but combined with the fact that both are quadratics with the same leading coefficient it is a very good check, and it takes one line.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 287 — Example 6
Concept
There is a second layout for the same job, and you will meet both. Instead of adding 25 to the y side, add 25 and take it away again on the x side, which changes nothing at all.
\[ y = (x^{2} - 10x + 25) - 25 + 22 \]
The bracket is now a perfect square and the two loose numbers combine, so the finish is identical.
\[ y = (x - 5)^{2} - 3 \]
Both layouts are honest and both are common. Choose one and stay with it, because mixing them halfway through a solution is where the bookkeeping collapses.
Whichever you use, the question to keep asking is the same. What did I just do to this side, and what have I done to keep the statement true?
Notice the difference from Part 3 one more time. When you solve an equation you may change both sides; when you rewrite a function you are producing an identity, so the total change must be zero.
Fill the middle
Two functions in standard form. Complete the square on each and read the vertex; the arithmetic is small enough to do without paper.
\[ y = x^{2} - 8x + 17 \qquad \text{and} \qquad y = x^{2} + 6x + 3 \]
Fill in the blanks
y = (x - 4)^1 + 3 \qquad \text6 \qquad y = (x + ___)^___ - ___
Why: For the first, half of negative 8 is negative 4 and 16 completes it, and 17 minus 16 leaves 1, so the vertex is at 4 and 1. For the second, half of 6 is 3 and 9 completes it, and 3 minus 9 is negative 6, so the vertex is at negative 3 and negative 6.
Watch the sign relationship. The bracket for the first function is x minus 4 and its vertex is at positive 4, because vertex form subtracts h inside the bracket.
A quick check on each: put x equal to 0 into the vertex form and you should get the constant from the standard form. Sixteen plus 1 is 17, and 9 minus 6 is 3, so both are right.
The number left outside, k, is the lowest value the function ever reaches, since a square can never be negative. That is the fact Part 5 is really about.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 287 — Guided Practice 13 and 14
Worked example
This one is written with function notation and has a negative constant, so the arithmetic at the end goes further below zero than the others.
\[ f(x) = x^{2} - 4x - 4 \]
Gather the x terms and leave a gap
Why: the constant stays outside the bracket where it cannot interfere.
\[ f(x) = (x^{2} - 4x + \;?\;) - 4 \]
Add half of negative 4, squared, inside the bracket
Why: half of negative 4 is negative 2, and negative 2 squared is 4. Adding 4 inside means subtracting 4 outside so that nothing changes overall.
\[ f(x) = (x^{2} - 4x + 4) - 4 - 4 \]
That double bookkeeping is the whole of the add-and-subtract layout. The bracket gains 4 so that it can become a square, and the outside loses 4 so that the function is still the same function.
Write the bracket as a binomial squared and combine the constants
Why: the bracket is x minus 2, and negative 4 minus 4 is negative 8.
\[ f(x) = (x - 2)^{2} - 8 \]
So the vertex is at 2 and negative 8, and since the leading coefficient is positive the parabola opens upward and negative 8 is the least value this function ever takes.
Function notation changes nothing about the method. Whether the left side is called y or f of x, the moves happen on the right and the answer is read off the finished form in exactly the same way.
Check by putting x equal to 2 into the original
Why: 4 minus 8 minus 4 is negative 8, which is the k the vertex form claims.
\[ f(2) = 2^{2} - 4(2) - 4 = 4 - 8 - 4 = -8 \]
Substituting the h you found is the most efficient possible check on a vertex form, because it tests both numbers at once.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 287 — Guided Practice 15
Trap
Rewriting y equals negative 16t squared plus 96t plus 3, a step that looks reasonable:
\[ y = -16(t^{2} - 6t) + 3 \]
\[ y + 9 = -16(t - 3)^{2} + 3 \]
Nine was added inside the bracket, so nine was added on the left. That is the move that worked in Example 6, where there was no coefficient in the way.
The bracket is multiplied by negative 16, so adding 9 inside it changes that side by negative 144, not by 9.
\[ (-16)(9) = -144 \]
\[ y - 144 = -16(t - 3)^{2} + 3 \]
\[ y = -16(t - 3)^{2} + 147 \]
The book's own Avoid Errors note says exactly this: add negative 144 to each side, not just 9.
The test to run every time you factor a coefficient out is a simple one. Ask what the whole side changed by, not what you wrote inside the bracket, and multiply by the number standing outside before you touch the other side.
The wrong version claims the ball peaks at 12 feet rather than 147, which is barely above the batter's head. A wrong answer this large is worth noticing.
Worked example
The height y in feet of a baseball t seconds after it is hit is given by this function. The question asks for the greatest height it reaches.
\[ y = -16t^{2} + 96t + 3 \]
The greatest height is the y-coordinate of the vertex, because the leading coefficient is negative and the parabola therefore opens downward. So the whole problem is a vertex-form problem.
Factor negative 16 from the first two terms
Why: the rule for the missing corner needs a coefficient of 1 on t squared, and the constant 3 stays outside.
\[ y = -16(t^{2} - 6t) + 3 \]
Prepare to complete the square
Why: leave a gap inside the bracket and a matching gap on the left, remembering that whatever goes inside is multiplied by negative 16.
\[ y + (-16)(?) = -16(t^{2} - 6t + \;?\;) + 3 \]
Add negative 16 times 9 to each side
Why: half of negative 6 is negative 3, and negative 3 squared is 9; inside the bracket that 9 is worth negative 144.
\[ y + (-16)(9) = -16(t^{2} - 6t + 9) + 3 \]
Write the bracket as a binomial squared
Why: the bracket is t minus 3.
\[ y - 144 = -16(t - 3)^{2} + 3 \]
Solve for y
Why: add 144 to each side, and 3 plus 144 is 147.
\[ y = -16(t - 3)^{2} + 147 \]
Figure (svg): The height of a baseball against time, a downward parabola starting at three feet, rising to one hundred and forty-seven feet at three seconds and falling back to the ground just after six seconds.
The vertex is at 3 and 147, so the ball reaches its greatest height of 147 feet three seconds after it is hit. The squared term can only ever take height away, never add it, which is why 147 is the maximum.
Check by evaluating the original function at t equal to 3
Why: negative 16 times 9 is negative 144, plus 96 times 3 which is 288, plus 3, giving 147.
\[ -16(3)^{2} + 96(3) + 3 = -144 + 288 + 3 = 147 \]
Test a neighbouring time too if you want to be sure it is a maximum rather than just a point: at t equal to 2.5 the height is 143, and at 3.5 it is also 143, so 3 really is the peak.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 287 — Example 7
Faded example
Same ball, same gravity, a weaker swing. The 96 becomes 80 and the starting height becomes 2, and everything else about the method is unchanged.
\[ y = -16t^{2} + 80t + 2 \]
Work it through yourself: factor negative 16 out of the first two terms, halve the resulting middle coefficient, square it, and remember that whatever you add inside the bracket counts as negative 16 times that much.
Fill in the blanks
y = -16\left(t - 2.5\right)^102 + ___
Why: Factoring gives negative 16 times the bracket t squared minus 5t, plus 2. Half of negative 5 is negative 2.5, and 2.5 squared is 6.25, which inside the bracket is worth negative 100. So the left side gains negative 100, the bracket becomes t minus 2.5 squared, and 2 plus 100 is 102. The ball reaches 102 feet after 2.5 seconds.
Compare the two hits. Cutting the upward speed from 96 to 80, a drop of about a sixth, cut the maximum height from 147 feet to 102 feet, a drop of nearly a third. Height depends on speed much more sharply than you might guess.
Check it directly: negative 16 times 6.25 is negative 100, plus 80 times 2.5 which is 200, plus 2, giving 102 feet. The vertex form and the original agree.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 287 — Guided Practice 16
Real world
A skateboard shop sells about 50 boards a week at its current price. For each dollar it takes off the price, it sells about one more board. The revenue model is a product of two brackets.
\[ y = (70 - x)(50 + x) \]
Figure (svg): Weekly revenue against the number of dollars cut from the price, a downward parabola peaking at three thousand six hundred dollars when the cut is ten dollars.
Read the model before touching it. The first bracket is the price after a cut of x dollars, and the second is the number of boards sold at that price, so their product is the money taken in.
Discussion prompt
Multiply the brackets out, write the result in vertex form by completing the square, and say what price maximises the weekly revenue and how much that revenue is.
Notice why there is a best answer at all. Each dollar off wins one more sale but costs a little on every sale already being made, and those two effects balance exactly at a cut of 10 dollars.
The curve is worth reading beyond its peak too. Cutting 30 dollars off gives 40 times 80, which is only 3200, so an aggressive discount earns the shop less than doing nothing.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 290 — Exercise 64
Comparison
Both forms describe the same parabola, and neither is better in general. What differs is which feature you can read without doing any work, so fill the table in and see what each buys you.
Comparison matrix
| y = x² − 10x + 22 | standard form | vertex form |
|---|---|---|
| written out | x² − 10x + 22 | (x − 5)² − 3 |
| value at x = 0 | 22, read off at once | 25 − 3, one calculation |
| vertex | hidden | (5, -3) |
| least value reached | hidden | -3 |
| opens | upward, since the first coefficient is positive | upward, same coefficient |
Standard form gives the height at the vertical axis for free, because setting x to zero wipes out the other two terms. Vertex form gives the turning point for free, because a square is smallest when it is zero.
Completing the square is the bridge between the two columns, and it only runs one way in this lesson. Going back the other way is just expanding the bracket, which Lesson 4.2 already showed you.
When a question asks for a maximum, a minimum, a turning point or a best price, it is asking for vertex form whether or not it says so. Recognising that is worth more than any single technique here.
OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §2.5 Quadratic Equations §5.1 — the same two forms, called general form and standard form
Picture it
Exercise 59 asks what completing the square does to a graph. Compare the curve you start with against the perfect square you turn it into, and the answer is very clean.
Figure (svg): Two parabolas of the same shape: y equals x squared plus six x sitting with its vertex nine units below the axis, and y equals the square of x plus three with its vertex resting on the axis.
The two curves have the same shape and the same axis of symmetry at negative 3. The only difference is height: adding 9 has lifted the whole curve by 9, putting its lowest point exactly on the horizontal axis.
That 9 is the number that completes the square for x squared plus 6x, and the lift is the same number, which is not a coincidence. The depth of the dip is always half of b, squared.
It also explains the shape of every answer in Part 3. Lifting the curve onto the axis is what makes the left side a square; putting the constant back on the right side is what tells you how far up the line sits.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 289 — Exercise 59
Section
Part 6
Pattern
Everything in this lesson is the same five moves, with one extra decision at the front and one extra check at the back. Learn the route rather than the individual problems.
The two most expensive errors both live at step four. One is adding to only one side, the other is forgetting that a factored-out coefficient multiplies whatever you put inside the bracket.
| what you are doing | what stays balanced | what you end with |
|---|---|---|
| solving an equation | add the same number to both sides | two values of x |
| rewriting a function | add and subtract, so nothing changes overall | vertex form and a turning point |
| modelling a situation | both of the above, plus the situation's own limits | the one answer that can happen |
That table is the real summary of the lesson. The algebra is identical in all three rows, and what changes is what balance means and which answers survive at the end.
Notice what is missing from the route: any step that could fail. Factoring has a search in it that sometimes comes up empty, and every other method in Chapter 4 works only on equations of a particular shape. This one never stops halfway, which is why it is the method a formula can be built out of.
Worked example
This is the book's challenge exercise, and it is the door into Lesson 4.8. Run the same five moves on a general quadratic, keeping the letters, and see what falls out.
\[ x^{2} + bx + c = 0 \]
Subtract c from each side
Why: clearing the constant off the left, exactly as with numbers.
\[ x^{2} + bx = -c \]
Add half of b, squared, to each side
Why: the rule does not need to know what b is.
\[ x^{2} + bx + \left(\dfrac{b}{2}\right)^{2} = -c + \dfrac{b^{2}}{4} \]
Write the left side as a binomial squared
Why: the bracket is x plus b over 2.
\[ \left(x + \dfrac{b}{2}\right)^{2} = \dfrac{b^{2}}{4} - c \]
Take square roots of each side
Why: keeping both signs, as always.
\[ x + \dfrac{b}{2} = \pm\sqrt{\dfrac{b^{2}}{4} - c} \]
Solve for x and put the right side over one denominator
Why: four c over four is c, so the numerator under the root becomes b squared minus 4c, and the root of 4 in the denominator is 2.
\[ x = \dfrac{-b \pm \sqrt{b^{2} - 4c}}{2} \]
Read the shape of that answer. Negative b over 2 is the centre, the square root is the reach, and the number under the root decides whether the reach is real, zero or imaginary. Every answer in this lesson had that form.
Nothing in that derivation was new. It is the five moves from the pattern slide, run once, with letters where the numbers usually sit; the only extra work was tidying the right-hand side onto a single denominator at the end.
Check it against Example 3
Why: there b was negative 12 and c was 4, so the formula gives 12 plus or minus the root of 144 minus 16, all over 2, which is 6 plus or minus 4 root 2.
\[ x = \dfrac{12 \pm \sqrt{144 - 16}}{2} = \dfrac{12 \pm 8\sqrt2}{2} = 6 \pm 4\sqrt2 \]
Do the same with a leading coefficient a in place of the 1 and you get the quadratic formula itself, which is where Lesson 4.8 begins. You have just built it.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 289 — Exercise 61
Check
Straight from Part 2. Halve the coefficient of x, square it, and do not be put off because the answer is a fraction.
Check your understanding
Which value of c makes x² − 13x + c a perfect square trinomial?
Answer: A
Why: Half of negative 13 is negative thirteen halves, and squaring that squares the top and the bottom separately, giving 169 over 4. The trinomial is then the square of x minus thirteen halves, and 169 over 4 is 42.25.
Every wrong value here is a real slip rather than a random number: one forgets to square the denominator, one forgets to halve, and one forgets to square at all.
The safest order is always the same. Halve first, and only then square, because squaring first and halving afterwards gives a completely different number.
Confirm it by expanding. The square of x minus thirteen halves gives two cross terms of negative thirteen halves x, which add to negative 13x, and 169 over 4 at the end.
Odd middle coefficients turn up constantly once you start solving equations rather than filling in blanks, because nothing forces the coefficient of x to be even. Being comfortable with a fractional corner is worth more here than any amount of speed on the even ones.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 288 — Exercise 20
Check
Part 3, with the division at the front. Divide every term, then run the five moves, and keep an eye on the sign of the right-hand side.
Check your understanding
Solve 2k² + 16k = −12 by completing the square.
Answer: A
Why: Dividing every term by 2 gives k squared plus 8k equal to negative 6. Half of 8 is 4 and 4 squared is 16, so both sides gain 16 and the right side becomes 10. The bracket is k plus 4, so k is negative 4 plus or minus root 10, about negative 0.84 and about negative 7.16.
The wrong answers here are the three standard failures of this part: dividing incompletely, not dividing at all, and reading the centre with the sign of the bracket instead of the opposite one.
Settle the sign without solving. The middle term is positive, so half of b is positive, so the bracket is k plus something and the centre is negative.
Check the winner numerically. Negative 0.8377 squared is 0.7017, twice that is 1.4034, and 16 times negative 0.8377 is negative 13.4034, and those add to negative 12 exactly.
If you found yourself hesitating over whether to divide, look at where the equation would have taken you otherwise. Half of 16 is 8 and 8 squared is 64, and the 2 sitting in front of the k squared would have made that 64 worth 128 on the left, which is the Exercise 51 trap all over again.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 288 — Exercise 28
Check
Part 5, in a real setting. The coefficient of t squared is negative, so the parabola opens downward and the vertex is a maximum.
Check your understanding
A drum major tosses a baton, and its height in feet after t seconds is h = −16t² + 32t + 6. What is its maximum height?
Answer: A
Why: Factoring negative 16 from the first two terms gives negative 16 times the bracket t squared minus 2t, plus 6. Half of negative 2 is negative 1, and 1 inside the bracket is worth negative 16, so the vertex form is negative 16 times t minus 1 squared, plus 22. The baton peaks at 22 feet after 1 second.
Notice that one of the wrong answers is a perfectly real number from the problem, the starting height. A question about a maximum is never asking for the value at zero unless the curve opens downward from there.
The quickest confirmation is to evaluate the original at the vertex time: negative 16 plus 32 plus 6 is 22 feet, which matches.
Check that it really is a peak by trying a neighbour. At half a second the height is 18 feet and at one and a half seconds it is also 18 feet, so one second is the top of the flight.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 290 — Exercise 62
Explain it to yourself
The transfer question at the end of this lesson asks for the picture, not the rule. Write your answer out before reading the one below, because producing it is the test.
Discussion prompt
Using the area diagram, explain why the number added to complete the square is half of b, squared, rather than b squared. Then say what would go wrong geometrically if you added b squared instead.
If your explanation used the words halve it and square it without mentioning the picture, write it again. The rule is what you are meant to be explaining, so it cannot also be the explanation.
A good test of whether you have it: could you rebuild the rule from scratch on a blank page, with nothing but a square and a strip to work from? If yes, you will never misremember it.
The same picture answers a question Lesson 4.4 left open, too. It is why a perfect square trinomial always ends in the square of half its middle coefficient, which is what made those trinomials recognisable in the first place.
Exit ticket
One equation using everything: a constant to move, a square to build, a radical to simplify, and a check to make.
\[ x^{2} + 6x - 3 = 0 \]
Discussion prompt
Solve by completing the square, simplify the radical fully, and check one of your two answers in the original equation.
The place to be careful is root 12. Twelve is 4 times 3, the 4 comes out as a 2, and the answer is 2 root 3, which is the exact error the book set as Exercise 50.
If you reached negative 3 plus or minus root 12 and stopped, you have solved the equation but not finished the answer. Simplifying a radical fully is part of the answer, not decoration on it.
One last look at the shape of what you wrote. A centre of negative 3, a reach of 2 root 3, and two answers either side of it: that is the form every solution in this lesson took, and the form the quadratic formula will take next lesson.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.7 Complete the Square §4.7, p. 288 — Exercise 24
Recap
Factoring is a search that sometimes fails. Completing the square is a construction that never does, and the picture behind it is one square, one strip cut in half, and the corner that is left over.
\[ x^{2} + bx + \left(\dfrac{b}{2}\right)^{2} = \left(x + \dfrac{b}{2}\right)^{2} \]
| the job | the extra move | example from this lesson |
|---|---|---|
| one side is already a square | none: take roots, keep both signs | x² − 8x + 16 = 25 gives 9 and −1 |
| solve an equation | add the corner to both sides | x² − 12x + 4 = 0 gives 6 ± 4√2 |
| the leading coefficient is not 1 | divide every term first | 2x² + 8x + 14 = 0 gives −2 ± i√3 |
| model a situation | reject the root the situation forbids | 7x(x + 6) = 112 gives x = 2 only |
| rewrite a function | add and subtract, so nothing changes | y = x² − 10x + 22 gives vertex (5, −3) |
Every row is the same five moves. What changes is what balance means: an equation may gain the same amount on both sides, while a function must gain and lose the same amount on one.
Two errors are worth carrying a warning about into the homework. Adding the corner to one side only, and forgetting that a factored-out coefficient multiplies whatever you write inside its bracket.
Lesson 4.8 does this once more with letters, on a general quadratic with a leading coefficient a, and gives the result a name. You already did the harder half of that derivation on the Exercise 61 slide, so the formula will arrive as a summary rather than a surprise.
OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §2.5 Quadratic Equations §2.5 — the same method, called solving by completing the square
Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Algebra 2 — $55/session, free consultation.