4.6 The Imaginary Unit and Complex Arithmetic

The imaginary unit i and the square root of a negative number, standard form and the families of complex numbers, adding and subtracting, multiplying with FOIL, dividing by a complex conjugate, and plotting in the complex plane with absolute value.

Subject: Algebra 2 · 74 slides · symbolic lesson

Open the interactive version of this deck

What this lesson covers

The lesson, slide by slide

1. The Imaginary Unit and Complex Arithmetic

Title

Algebra 2 · Lesson 4.6

Inventing the one number that makes every quadratic solvable

2. What this lesson gives you

Objectives

Lesson 4.5 taught you to finish an equation by taking square roots of both sides. It worked every time the number you had to take the root of was positive or zero, and it stopped dead the moment that number was negative. This lesson is about that dead end.

What happens next is unusual in school mathematics, and worth naming honestly at the start. Nobody discovered a hidden real number whose square is negative, because there is not one. Mathematicians decided to invent a new number and give it a name, then checked that the old rules of arithmetic still worked around it.

The pay-off arrives in Lesson 4.8. There the quadratic formula produces a negative number under its square root whenever a parabola misses the horizontal axis, and without this lesson you would have to write no solution and stop. With it you can finish, and the answer you write down turns out to be genuinely useful in electronics and in the study of fractals.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 275 — Before, Now, Why and the Key Vocabulary

3. First, the case that already works

Warm-up

Start where Lesson 4.5 left you. Solve each of these by isolating the square and taking roots of both sides, and write down what the very last move needs in order to be legal.

\[ x^2 = 16 \qquad\qquad 3x^2 - 7 = 41 \]

Discussion prompt

Solve both equations, then say in one sentence what has to be true of the number on the right before you are allowed to take square roots of both sides.

Hold on to that last sentence, because the whole lesson hangs off it. Nothing is wrong with the method; the method simply runs out of numbers to hand you.

Now change one digit and watch the method break. The equation x squared equals negative sixteen is solved by exactly the same moves, and at the final step there is no real number to write. Try it and you will feel the gap this lesson fills.

One more thing worth noticing before you go on. The solutions above came in a pair, positive four and negative four, because squaring loses the sign. Every answer in this lesson will come in a pair too, for exactly the same reason.

4. A number that has to be invented

Section

Part 1

5. Squaring folds the number line in half

Concept

Before inventing anything, be sure the gap is real. Squaring takes any number on the line and sends it somewhere on the non-negative half, because a positive times a positive is positive and a negative times a negative is also positive.

\[ 3^2 = 9 \qquad (-3)^2 = 9 \qquad 1^2 = 1 \qquad (-1)^2 = 1 \]

Figure (svg): Two number lines. The upper one runs from minus five to five and the lower one from minus six to twenty-six. Two arrows run from minus three and from three on the upper line down to the same point, nine, on the lower line. The part of the lower line left of zero is shaded red and marked as never reached by any square.

Two different starting numbers land on the same square, and nothing at all lands in the red stretch to the left of zero. That empty stretch is the whole problem this lesson solves.

Look at what the picture is really saying. The two arrows from three and negative three arrive at the same place, which is why square roots come in pairs. More importantly, the red stretch on the lower line is never the destination of any arrow at all.

So the sentence x squared equals negative one is not a hard equation. It is an equation with no answer among the numbers you have, in the same way that the sentence a rectangle with three sides has no answer among rectangles.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 275 — the opening paragraph

6. The parabola and the line it never reaches

Picture it

The same fact looks different on a graph, and the graph is the version to keep. A solution of x squared equals a number is a place where the curve and the horizontal line meet.

Figure (svg): The parabola y equals x squared drawn with a green horizontal line at height four crossing it twice and a red horizontal line at height minus one that the parabola never reaches.

Solutions of an equation are crossings. Raise the line and you get two; drop it below the axis and there is nothing left to cross, which is what no real solution looks like.

With the line at height four there are two meetings, at negative two and at two, and those are the two solutions. Slide the line down to height negative one and there is nothing to meet, because the curve never goes below the horizontal axis.

That is a picture worth remembering for Lesson 4.8, where a whole parabola sits above the axis and the quadratic formula still produces two answers. The answers are real in the everyday sense of being genuine; they are just not real numbers.

Notice also how close the two cases are. Nothing about the method changed between the green line and the red one, only the number you were asked to take a root of.

7. Slide the constant and watch the crossings vanish

Tweak it

Here is the same experiment under your own hand. The curve drawn is the parabola shifted up or down by a constant, and the solutions of the matching equation are wherever it meets the horizontal axis.

Parameter explorer

Slide the constant. For which values are there two crossings, exactly one crossing, and none at all? When there are none, say what has gone wrong at the last step of taking square roots.

\[ y = x^2 + c, \quad c = {c} \]

  • c — from -6 to 6: the constant c

The moment the constant becomes positive, every crossing is gone and the algebra reaches the same wall from the other direction. The equation becomes x squared equals a negative number.

Watch the two crossings approach each other as the constant rises towards zero, touch, and then disappear. Nothing violent happens to the curve at that moment, which is a hint that nothing violent should happen to the answers either.

That hint is exactly right, and it is what the rest of this lesson delivers. The two answers do not vanish when the curve lifts off the axis; they move somewhere the number line cannot show them.

8. A new number, defined on purpose

Concept

Since no existing number squares to negative one, mathematicians defined one that does and gave it a name. This is an invention, made deliberately, and not a trick that was hiding in the old rules.

the imaginary unit i — The number defined by the rule that i is the square root of negative one. Equivalently, and more usefully, i squared equals negative one.

\[ i = \sqrt{-1} \qquad\text{and so}\qquad i^2 = -1 \]

The name imaginary is an old insult that stuck, and it is a poor description. The number i is no more imaginary than negative seven, which also had to be invented once because nobody could hold a bag containing minus seven apples.

The second line is the one you will actually use. Almost every calculation in this lesson is ordinary algebra followed by one substitution, and the substitution is always i squared for negative one.

It is fair to ask whether you are allowed to just make something up. The honest answer is yes, provided the new object obeys the old rules, and that is what gets checked over the next few slides: adding, subtracting and multiplying all behave exactly as they did before.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 275 — the definition of the imaginary unit

9. Reading the definition of i piece by piece

Notation

Two lines, and each one says something different. Take them apart before using them, because most of the errors later in this lesson come from remembering only one of the two.

Annotate

On: \( i = \sqrt{-1}, \qquad i^2 = -1 \)

  • A single number with a name, exactly like pi. It is not a variable, so you never solve for it and it never stands for anything else.
  • Read the first line as a definition, not as a calculation you could carry out. There is no decimal expansion of i hiding somewhere; the line is what i means.
  • The second line is the working rule. Whenever i squared appears in a calculation, you replace it by negative one and the imaginary part of the expression shrinks.
  • This is the whole point of the invention. One number in the system now squares to something negative, which is precisely what no real number could do.

The order matters when you use them. Going forwards you write a negative root in terms of i; going backwards you clear an i squared out of an answer. Both directions appear in almost every worked example ahead.

A word about how to say it. Read the second line aloud as i squared equals negative one, not as i squared is minus one thing, and you will be much less likely to lose the sign when it turns up in the middle of a long product.

If the first line still feels uncomfortable, try thinking of it as a label rather than a claim. You are naming the solution of the equation x squared equals negative one, in the same spirit in which the symbol for the square root of two names the solution of x squared equals two.

10. The square root of any negative number

Concept

One new number is enough to handle every negative radicand at once, because every negative number is a positive number times negative one. Pull the negative one out and it becomes an i.

\[ \sqrt{-r} = \sqrt{(-1)r} = \sqrt{-1}\,\sqrt{r} = i\sqrt{r} \qquad (r > 0) \]

The condition beside it is doing real work. The splitting move in the middle is the product rule for radicals, and that rule was proved for non-negative numbers, so it is applied here to negative one and r only in the direction that defines the new symbol.

Now check the result behaves. Square the answer and you should get the number you started under the root, negative r, back again.

\[ \left(i\sqrt{r}\right)^2 = i^2 \cdot r = (-1)r = -r \]

Two concrete cases to fix the pattern. The square root of negative three is i times the square root of three, and the square root of negative four is two i, because the square root of four is an ordinary two.

\[ \sqrt{-3} = i\sqrt{3} \qquad\qquad \sqrt{-4} = i\sqrt{4} = 2i \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 275 — Key Concept: the square root of a negative number

11. Example 1: two x squared plus eleven equals negative thirty-seven

Worked example

Solve this the way Lesson 4.5 taught you. Isolate the square, take roots of both sides, and only then deal with the fact that the number you are rooting is negative.

\[ 2x^2 + 11 = -37 \]

Subtract 11 from each side

Why: because eleven is added to the term carrying the square, and subtracting undoes adding.

\[ 2x^2 = -48 \]

Divide each side by 2

Why: so that x squared stands alone, which is what the square-root move needs.

\[ x^2 = -24 \]

Stop and look at that line, because in Lesson 4.5 it would have been the end of the road. Twenty-four negative units of area is not something a real square can have.

Take square roots of each side

Why: remembering the two signs, since squaring loses the sign of the answer.

\[ x = \pm\sqrt{-24} \]

Write the root in terms of i

Why: using the rule that the root of negative r is i times the root of r.

\[ x = \pm i\sqrt{24} \]

Simplify the radical

Why: because twenty-four is four times six, and the root of four is two. This is the same simplifying you did in Lesson 4.5, untouched by the i in front.

\[ x = \pm 2i\sqrt{6} \]

The answer is a pair, as promised, and each member of the pair is a real multiple of i. Numbers of this shape have their own name, pure imaginary, which arrives in Part 2.

Check by squaring the answer back

Why: square the solution, double it and add eleven, and the negative thirty-seven you were given comes back.

\[ 2\left(2i\sqrt{6}\right)^2 + 11 = 2\left(4i^2\cdot 6\right) + 11 = 2(-24) + 11 = -37 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 275 — Example 1

12. Guided Practice 3: fill in the two missing numbers

Fill the middle

This is Example 1 with fewer steps. Isolate the square first, then turn the negative root into an i, then simplify the radical exactly as you would have done last lesson.

Fill in the blanks

x^2 + 11 = 3 \;\Longrightarrow\; x^2 = -8 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = \pm 2i\sqrt___

Why: Subtracting eleven from three leaves negative eight, and taking roots gives i times the root of eight. Since eight is four times two, the root of four comes out as an ordinary two and the simplified answer is plus or minus two i times the root of two. The number in front of the i is a real number, so it obeys every rule you already know.

Checkpoints one and two in the book are shorter still. The equation with negative thirteen on the right gives plus or minus i times the root of thirteen, and the one with negative thirty-eight gives plus or minus i times the root of thirty-eight, because neither of those numbers has a perfect square factor to pull out.

Checkpoint four is worth doing as well. Taking eight away from negative thirty-six leaves x squared equal to negative twenty-eight, and twenty-eight is four times seven, so the answer is plus or minus two i times the root of seven.

Notice that the simplifying happens exactly as it always did. The i sits in front and takes no part in the search for perfect square factors, so nothing you learned in Lesson 4.5 has been wasted.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 275 — Guided Practice 1 to 4

13. Guided Practice 5: three x squared minus seven equals negative thirty-one

Worked example

Three moves to isolate the square, then the new step. Say each move out loud before you write it, because the arithmetic with negative numbers is where this one goes wrong.

\[ 3x^2 - 7 = -31 \]

Add 7 to each side

Why: because seven is subtracted from the term carrying the square.

\[ 3x^2 = -24 \]

Divide each side by 3

Why: leaving the square alone on the left.

\[ x^2 = -8 \]

Negative twenty-four divided by three is negative eight, not eight. Dividing a negative by a positive keeps the sign negative, and losing that is the single most common slip on this page.

Take square roots and write the root in terms of i

Why: the root of negative eight is i times the root of eight.

\[ x = \pm i\sqrt{8} \]

Simplify the radical

Why: eight is four times two, and the root of four is two.

\[ x = \pm 2i\sqrt{2} \]

Compare this answer with Example 1's. Both are pure imaginary and both carry a simplified radical, which is what almost every answer in this part of the lesson looks like.

Check by squaring the answer back

Why: three times the square of the solution, minus seven, has to return negative thirty-one.

\[ 3\left(2i\sqrt{2}\right)^2 - 7 = 3\left(4i^2\cdot 2\right) - 7 = 3(-8) - 7 = -31 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 275 — Guided Practice 5

14. Exercise 11: a squared bracket with a negative on the other side

Worked example

Lesson 4.5 ended with equations whose square was a bracket rather than a single letter. Nothing about that changes here; the imaginary part only appears at the very last move.

\[ -5(n - 3)^2 = 10 \]

Divide each side by negative 5

Why: because negative five multiplies the whole squared bracket, and dividing undoes multiplying.

\[ (n - 3)^2 = -2 \]

There is the negative, and it arrived because the number in front of the bracket was negative while the right-hand side was positive. A square equal to a negative number is impossible for real n, so this equation has no real solutions.

Take square roots of each side

Why: the bracket itself is what gets rooted, and the root of negative two is i times the root of two.

\[ n - 3 = \pm i\sqrt{2} \]

Add 3 to each side

Why: to free n, exactly as you would if the right-hand side were an ordinary number.

\[ n = 3 \pm i\sqrt{2} \]

This answer is the first in the lesson with a real part and an imaginary part in the same number. That shape, a real number plus a real multiple of i, is what Part 2 calls standard form.

Check the first solution in the original equation

Why: subtract three, square, and multiply by negative five; the squared bracket gives i squared times two, which is negative two, and negative five times negative two is ten.

\[ -5\left(3 + i\sqrt{2} - 3\right)^2 = -5\left(i\sqrt{2}\right)^2 = -5(-2) = 10 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 280 — Exercise 11

15. Trap: multiplying two negative square roots

Trap

The trap

The product rule for radicals from Lesson 4.5 looks as though it should apply here:

\[ \sqrt{-4}\cdot\sqrt{-9} \]

\[ = \sqrt{(-4)(-9)} = \sqrt{36} = 6 \]

Every line looks like the rule you have used all year, and the answer is a tidy positive number.

The fix

Write each root in terms of i first, which is what the definition tells you to do, and the answer changes sign.

\[ (2i)(3i) = 6i^2 = -6 \]

Figure (svg): A narrow two-part diagram. The upper part applies the product rule for radicals to the square roots of minus four and minus nine and reaches six, marked as the tempting route. The lower part writes each root in terms of i first and reaches minus six, marked as the honest route.

Both routes start from the same product and end at numbers that are not even the same sign. Only the lower one respects what the radical rule actually requires.

The rule you quoted was proved for non-negative radicands and is simply false when both are negative. Exercise 74 makes you meet this head on with the roots of negative four and negative twenty-five, where the wrong route gives ten and the right one gives negative ten.

The habit that protects you costs nothing: turn every negative root into an i before you multiply anything. Once the i is out in front you are multiplying ordinary positive radicals, and the old rule is legal again.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 282 — Exercise 74

16. Which equations have real solutions?

Sorting

Sort these before solving any of them. In each case, isolate the square in your head and ask only one question: is the number left on the other side negative?

Sort into buckets

Sort each equation by whether its solutions are real numbers or not.

Real solutions
x² = 28; 3x² − 7 = 41
No real solutions
x² = −28; z² + 8 = 4; 2x² + 31 = 9; −5(n − 3)² = 10
real
Isolating the square leaves a positive number in each of these, twenty-eight in one case and sixteen in the other, so ordinary square roots finish the job.
imag
Each of these leaves a negative number once the square is alone: negative twenty-eight, negative four, negative eleven and negative two. Every one of them needs the imaginary unit.

The ones that catch people are those with a constant still sitting beside the square. Move the constant across first and then judge the sign, rather than reading the sign of whatever number happens to be visible.

Three of these are worth working through to their answers. The one whose square equals negative twenty-eight gives plus or minus two i times the root of seven; the one with z squared plus eight gives plus or minus two i; and the one with thirty-one added to two x squared gives plus or minus i times the root of eleven.

It is worth being clear about what the right-hand bucket means. Those equations are not unsolvable; they simply have no solution on the number line, and finding the solutions they do have is the whole business of this lesson.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 279 — Exercises 3 to 11

17. Standard form and the three families

Section

Part 2

18. Standard form: a real part and an imaginary part

Concept

Every answer so far has had at most two pieces, a plain number and a multiple of i. That is not an accident, and the book gives the shape a name.

complex number in standard form — A number written as a plus b i, where a and b are real numbers. The number a is the real part and the number b i is the imaginary part.

\[ a + bi \qquad\text{with } a, b \text{ real} \]

Read the two letters carefully. Both a and b are ordinary real numbers, so the only new symbol in the whole expression is the single i. Everything you know about arithmetic applies to a and to b.

The phrase imaginary part has a trap in it. Some books mean the whole term b i and some mean just the coefficient b; McDougal means the term b i, and the answer to a question like name the imaginary part of three minus four i is negative four i.

Almost every answer in the rest of this lesson finishes with the instruction write in standard form. That instruction means put the real piece first, the imaginary piece second, and combine everything so that only one of each appears.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 276 — the definition of standard form

19. The family tree of complex numbers

Picture it

Once a and b are allowed to be any real numbers at all, some familiar numbers turn out to be complex numbers in disguise. The diagram sorts the whole system out.

Figure (svg): Nested boxes. The outer box is labelled complex numbers a plus b i. Inside it sit a box of real numbers and a box of imaginary numbers, and inside the imaginary box sits a smaller box of pure imaginary numbers.

Every box sits inside the outer one, so every real number is already a complex number. Only the two inner boxes need a nonzero imaginary part.

The outer box is everything. Inside it, a number with b equal to zero has no imaginary piece left, so it is an ordinary real number, which is why every real number you have ever met already lives in the complex system.

A number with b not zero is called imaginary, and if its a is also zero, so that nothing but the i term survives, it is called pure imaginary. The answers to Example 1 were pure imaginary and the answer to Exercise 11 was imaginary but not pure.

So the answer to Exercise 2 in the book, is every complex number an imaginary number, is no. Seven is a complex number, because it is seven plus zero i, and it is not imaginary, because its b is zero.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 276 — the diagram of complex number types

20. Sort eight numbers into the three families

Discrimination

Use the diagram rather than your instincts. For each number, decide first whether b is zero, and only then whether a is zero as well.

Sort into buckets

Sort each number into the smallest family it belongs to.

Real
−1; π; √2; 3 + 0i
Imaginary, not pure
2 + 3i; 5 − 5i
Pure imaginary
−4i; 6i
re
In each of these the coefficient of i is zero, whether it is written out or not, so nothing imaginary survives and the number sits on the real number line you already know.
im
Both parts are present and neither is zero, so these are imaginary but not pure. They are the numbers that need a whole plane rather than a line.
pu
The real part is zero and only a multiple of i is left, which is exactly what pure imaginary means. The solutions of Example 1 were of this kind.

The last one on the list is the interesting case, because it is written with an i visible and still belongs on the real side. Writing plus zero i changes nothing about the number, so do not be fooled by the notation.

The same point runs the other way. A number like negative four i could have been written zero minus four i, which shows why pure imaginary is a special case of imaginary rather than a separate idea.

Get into the habit of asking about b first. If b is zero you never have to look at a at all, and if b is not zero then a decides between the two remaining boxes.

21. Two complex numbers are equal only if both parts match

Concept

An equation between complex numbers is secretly two equations, because the real parts must agree and the imaginary parts must agree separately. Nothing lets a real number make up for a missing imaginary one.

\[ a + bi = c + di \iff a = c \;\text{ and }\; b = d \]

That is why an equation with an unknown in each part can be read off without any algebra. Match the plain numbers to the plain numbers and the i terms to the i terms.

\[ x + yi = 5 - 3i \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 5, \quad y = -3 \]

The reason is the same one that lets you match like terms in an ordinary polynomial. A multiple of i can never equal a plain number unless both are zero, so the two parts are kept apart for the whole calculation and only combined at the end.

This also tells you when an answer is finished. Standard form has exactly one real piece and one imaginary piece, so an answer with two of either is still mid-calculation.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 276 — the condition for two complex numbers to be equal

22. Two imaginary numbers whose sum is real

Counterexample

New objects are best tested by asking what they cannot do. Here is a claim that sounds safe and is false, and Exercise 60 makes you find the counterexample yourself.

The claim is that adding two imaginary numbers always gives an imaginary number, in the way that adding two even numbers always gives an even number.

Discussion prompt

Find two imaginary numbers whose sum is a real number, then say in one sentence how the two numbers must be related for that to happen.

So the imaginary numbers are not a closed system: you can start inside them and land outside. The complex numbers as a whole are closed, which is one reason the outer box in the diagram is the one mathematicians actually work with.

Keep this example in mind for Part 6. Numbers that differ only in the sign of their imaginary part are exactly the conjugate pairs, and their good behaviour under addition is a preview of their even better behaviour under multiplication.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 280 — Exercise 60

23. The complex plane

Section

Part 3

24. Every complex number is a point

Concept

A real number needs one coordinate, so the real numbers fill a line. A complex number carries two real numbers with it, a and b, so it needs two coordinates and fills a plane.

\[ a + bi \;\longleftrightarrow\; (a, b) \]

The horizontal axis is called the real axis and carries the numbers with no imaginary part, so the ordinary number line you have used since primary school is sitting inside this picture as one horizontal line.

The vertical axis is called the imaginary axis, and its marks are labelled i, two i, three i and so on rather than one, two, three. The unit you step by going up is i itself.

This picture is the real content of the lesson. It turns a strange piece of notation into a place, and once complex numbers have positions, adding and multiplying them become movements you can watch rather than rules you have to trust.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 278 — the definition of the complex plane

25. Example 6: plotting four complex numbers

Worked example

Plot each number by reading its real part as a horizontal step and its imaginary part as a vertical one, exactly as you would plot a coordinate pair.

\[ 3 - 2i, \qquad -2 + 4i, \qquad 3i, \qquad -4 - 3i \]

Plot three minus two i

Why: start at the origin, go three units right because the real part is three, then two units down because the imaginary part is negative two.

\[ 3 - 2i \;\longleftrightarrow\; (3, -2) \]

Plot negative two plus four i

Why: two units left and then four units up.

\[ -2 + 4i \;\longleftrightarrow\; (-2, 4) \]

Plot three i

Why: its real part is zero, so there is no horizontal step at all and the point lands on the imaginary axis three units up.

\[ 3i = 0 + 3i \;\longleftrightarrow\; (0, 3) \]

Plot negative four minus three i

Why: four units left and three units down, into the corner where both parts are negative.

\[ -4 - 3i \;\longleftrightarrow\; (-4, -3) \]

Figure (svg): A complex plane with four points marked: three minus two i, minus two plus four i, three i on the vertical axis, and minus four minus three i.

Two numbers are needed to reach each point, and the number written a plus b i supplies exactly two. That is the whole reason the plane works.

Look at where the third point landed. Anything pure imaginary sits on the vertical axis, and by the same reasoning anything real sits on the horizontal axis, which is the picture of the family diagram from Part 2.

Check by reading the points back off the plane

Why: each point gives back the number it came from: three right and two down reads as three minus two i, and four left and three down reads as negative four minus three i.

\[ (3, -2) \;\longrightarrow\; 3 - 2i \qquad (-4, -3) \;\longrightarrow\; -4 - 3i \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 278 — Example 6

26. Absolute value is the distance to the origin

Picture it

For a real number, absolute value means distance from zero on the line. The definition for a complex number keeps that meaning exactly and measures distance from the origin in the plane instead.

Figure (svg): The point minus four plus three i in the complex plane, joined to the origin by an arrow, with dashed legs of length four along the real axis and three parallel to the imaginary axis forming a right triangle.

The two parts of the number are the two legs of a right triangle, so the distance to the origin is Pythagoras and nothing more.

The two dashed legs are the real part and the imaginary part, and they meet at a right angle because the two axes do. The arrow across is the distance you want, so Pythagoras finishes the job in one line.

\[ |z| = \sqrt{a^2 + b^2} \]

The result is always a real number and never negative, because it is a length. That matters: absolute value is the tool that turns a complex number into something you can compare, rank and set a bound on, which is exactly what the Mandelbrot investigation later in this deck needs.

Check the definition against the old one. A real number a is a plus zero i, so its absolute value is the root of a squared, which is the size of a with the sign thrown away. Nothing has been broken.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 279 — Key Concept: absolute value of a complex number

27. Reading the absolute value formula piece by piece

Notation

Four small pieces, and three of the four are places where marks get lost. Take the formula apart once, carefully, and the two worked examples that follow will feel routine.

Annotate

On: \( |z| = \sqrt{a^2 + b^2} \)

  • The same bars you have used for absolute value all year. They still mean distance from zero; only the place you are measuring in has changed from a line to a plane.
  • The real part, squared. Squaring destroys its sign, which is right, because a point three to the left is as far away as a point three to the right.
  • The coefficient of i, not the term b i. The i itself never enters the formula, so there is no i in the answer either.
  • A sum, never a difference. Both squares are non-negative, so what is under the root is non-negative and the answer is always a real length.

The note about b is the one to hold on to. When you compute the absolute value of negative three i you are using b equal to negative three, and the i has already done its work by telling you which axis to measure along.

The note about the sum is the one the book turns into an error-analysis exercise. Writing a minus sign under the root because the number had a minus sign in it is the most popular mistake on this page, and a slide later in this part makes you correct it.

One last point about the bars. Because the answer is a distance, comparisons like this number is bigger than that one only make sense between absolute values, never between complex numbers themselves. There is no sensible way to say that two plus three i is larger than four minus i.

28. Example 7: the absolute values of negative four plus three i and negative three i

Worked example

Two applications of the same formula, chosen because the second one hides its real part. Read off a and b before you write anything.

\[ |-4 + 3i| \qquad\text{and}\qquad |-3i| \]

Read off a and b for the first number

Why: the real part is negative four and the coefficient of i is three.

\[ a = -4, \quad b = 3 \]

Substitute into the formula

Why: square each part and add, keeping the bracket round the negative four so its sign is squared away properly.

\[ |-4 + 3i| = \sqrt{(-4)^2 + 3^2} = \sqrt{16 + 9} = \sqrt{25} = 5 \]

The answer came out a whole number because sixteen and nine happen to add to a perfect square. That is the three, four, five triangle, and it is the reason this example was chosen.

Write the second number in standard form first

Why: negative three i is zero minus three i, so its real part is zero and the coefficient of i is negative three.

\[ -3i = 0 + (-3)i \]

Substitute again

Why: zero squared contributes nothing, so only the imaginary part is left under the root.

\[ |-3i| = \sqrt{0^2 + (-3)^2} = \sqrt{9} = 3 \]

Check both answers against the plane

Why: the first point is four left and three up from the origin, and the three, four, five triangle gives a distance of five; the second sits on the imaginary axis three units below the origin, so its distance is plainly three.

\[ \sqrt{(-4)^2 + 3^2} = 5 \qquad \sqrt{0^2 + (-3)^2} = 3 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 279 — Example 7

29. Guided Practice 15 to 18: four distances

Fill the middle

Four numbers, one formula. Work them out before filling the blanks, and notice how often the answer refuses to be a whole number.

Fill in the blanks

|4 - i| = \sqrt5 \quad |-3 - 4i| = 4 \quad |2 + 5i| = \sqrt___ \quad |-4i| = ___

Why: Nine plus sixteen is twenty-five, whose root is five, and the three, four, five triangle has turned up again with both legs pointing the negative way. The last one is pure imaginary, so its real part contributes nothing and its distance is just the size of its coefficient, four. The other two leave seventeen and twenty-nine under the root, and neither simplifies.

Plot all four in one plane if you have paper to hand, as the checkpoint asks. Two of them sit in the corner where both parts are negative, one sits above and to the right, and one sits on the imaginary axis below the origin.

Compare the second and the last of these. Both have a negative imaginary part, but only one of them has any horizontal displacement at all, which is why one distance is five and the other is four.

Answers with a radical left in them are normal here and should not be turned into decimals unless a question asks. The root of seventeen is exact; one point one two three and so on is not.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 279 — Guided Practice 15 to 18

30. Exercise 58: a minus sign that crept under the root

Error analysis

Here is a student's work on an absolute value, exactly as the book prints it. Find the first line that is wrong before reading the notes.

Annotate

On: \( |2 - 3i| = \sqrt{2^2 - 3^2} = \sqrt{-5} = i\sqrt{5} \)

  • This is where it goes wrong. The formula adds the two squares; the minus sign in the number tells you that b is negative three, and squaring negative three gives positive nine.
  • Once a minus has been let under the root, the rest of the work is honest but doomed. Four take away nine really is negative five, so the error is already locked in.
  • An absolute value is a distance, so an answer carrying an i is impossible on its face. Noticing that would have caught the mistake even without redoing the work.
  • Four plus nine is thirteen, so the absolute value is the square root of thirteen, about three point six.

\[ |2 - 3i| = \sqrt{2^2 + (-3)^2} = \sqrt{4 + 9} = \sqrt{13} \]

The habit that prevents this is mechanical and worth adopting. Write the bracket round the negative number before you square it, every single time, and the sign has nowhere to hide.

The last note is the more valuable one, though. Learning to recognise an answer that cannot possibly be right, because of what kind of thing it is, will save you far more marks than learning any single formula.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 280 — Exercise 58

31. Slide the imaginary part and watch the distance

Edge cases

The curve here shows how far a complex number sits from the origin as its real part slides left and right. The slider controls the imaginary part, which is held fixed while the curve is drawn.

Parameter explorer

Slide the imaginary part. Read the lowest point of the curve each time and say what it always equals. Then read off the distance when the real part is three and the imaginary part is four.

\[ \left|x + bi\right| = \sqrt{x^2 + b^2}, \quad b = {b} \]

  • b — from 0 to 6: the imaginary part b

Two features are worth naming. The curve is symmetric about the vertical axis, because squaring the real part destroys its sign, so a number and its mirror image are equally far from the origin.

Far out to either side the curve straightens into a pair of slanted lines. Once the real part is much bigger than the imaginary part, the distance is almost the size of the real part alone, which is why a number like one thousand plus two i is barely different in size from one thousand.

Set the slider to zero and the curve becomes a sharp V through the origin. That is the ordinary absolute value of a real number, drawn as a graph, so the old idea really is a special case of the new one.

32. Adding and subtracting

Section

Part 4

33. Treat i as a letter and collect like terms

Concept

You have added expressions like this since Lesson 1.2, in a different costume. Three x plus five x is eight x, and the x never had to be a particular number for that to work.

\[ 3x + 5x = 8x \qquad\qquad 3i + 5i = 8i \]

Nothing about the left-hand calculation used the value of x, so the right-hand one is not a new rule at all. The unit i is being collected exactly as any letter would be.

That gives the rule for whole complex numbers immediately. Real parts combine with real parts, i terms combine with i terms, and the two never mix, because a plain number and a multiple of i are unlike terms.

\[ (a + bi) + (c + di) = (a + c) + (b + d)i \]

\[ (a + bi) - (c + di) = (a - c) + (b - d)i \]

Read the two lines as one instruction with a choice of sign: do to the real parts whatever you are doing to the imaginary parts. If you can add two-term expressions, you can already do this.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 276 — Key Concept: sums and differences of complex numbers

34. Example 2, parts a and b: a sum and a difference

Worked example

Two short ones from the book. In each case, group the real parts, group the imaginary parts, and write the result in standard form.

\[ (8 - i) + (5 + 4i) \qquad\qquad (7 - 6i) - (3 - 6i) \]

Group the parts of the first expression

Why: eight and five are the real parts; negative one and four are the coefficients of i. Notice that the lone minus i counts as negative one i.

\[ (8 - i) + (5 + 4i) = (8 + 5) + (-1 + 4)i \]

Simplify each group

Why: thirteen in the real slot and three in the imaginary slot.

\[ = 13 + 3i \]

The invisible one in front of that first i is worth saying out loud. A term written simply as minus i carries a coefficient of negative one, and treating it as zero is a common way to lose a mark here.

Group the parts of the second expression

Why: subtracting means subtracting each part separately: seven take away three, and negative six take away negative six.

\[ (7 - 6i) - (3 - 6i) = (7 - 3) + (-6 + 6)i \]

Simplify and write in standard form

Why: the imaginary parts have cancelled completely, leaving four plus zero i, which is written simply as four.

\[ = 4 + 0i = 4 \]

So a difference of two imaginary numbers has come out real, which is the counterexample from Part 2 turning up in the book's own worked example.

Check both by undoing them

Why: add five plus four i back to the first answer and the original first number returns; add three minus six i to the second answer and the original returns too.

\[ (13 + 3i) - (5 + 4i) = 8 - i \qquad 4 + (3 - 6i) = 7 - 6i \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 276 — Example 2, parts a and b

35. Example 2, part c: a subtraction and an addition in one line

Worked example

Three terms this time, with a bracket in the middle that is being subtracted. The order of operations is the only thing that can go wrong.

\[ 10 - (6 + 7i) + 4i \]

Deal with the subtracted bracket first

Why: the minus sign in front applies to both parts inside, so ten take away six is four and nothing take away seven i is negative seven i.

\[ 10 - (6 + 7i) + 4i = \left[(10 - 6) - 7i\right] + 4i \]

Simplify inside the square bracket

Why: the real work is done and the expression is now a difference of two complex numbers.

\[ = (4 - 7i) + 4i \]

Note that ten was really ten plus zero i, so its imaginary part was zero all along. Writing the missing zero part in is a habit worth keeping while these are still new.

Add the remaining imaginary term

Why: four i has nothing real to contribute, so only the coefficient of i changes: negative seven plus four.

\[ = 4 + (-7 + 4)i \]

Write in standard form

Why: negative seven plus four is negative three.

\[ = 4 - 3i \]

Check by reassembling the original

Why: take the answer, add back the bracket that was subtracted and remove the four i that was added, and ten should come out.

\[ (4 - 3i) + (6 + 7i) - 4i = 10 + 0i = 10 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 276 — Example 2, part c

36. Guided Practice 7 and 8: fill in the missing parts

Fill the middle

Both of these are one line of work. Add or subtract the real parts, do the same to the coefficients of i, and put the result in standard form.

Fill in the blanks

(9 - i) + (-6 + 7i) = 3 + 6i \qquad\qquad (3 + 7i) - (8 - 2i) = -5 + 9i

Why: In the first, nine take away six leaves three and negative one plus seven leaves six. In the second, the subtraction reaches both parts of the bracket: three take away eight is negative five, and seven take away negative two is seven plus two, which is nine. A minus in front of a bracket changes the sign of everything inside it, including a term that was already negative.

Checkpoint nine in the book stacks two subtractions together. Starting from negative four and taking away one plus i and then five plus nine i gives negative ten minus ten i, and the safest route is to deal with one bracket at a time.

If you found the second blank harder than the first, the reason is almost certainly the double negative. Seven minus negative two is a place where a written-out bracket earns its keep.

Check any of these instantly by adding your answer back to the number that was subtracted. If the original number reappears, the arithmetic was right, and the check takes one line.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 276 — Guided Practice 7 to 9

37. Adding complex numbers is adding arrows

Picture it

In the plane, addition stops being a rule about like terms and becomes a movement. Draw each number as an arrow from the origin to its point, and the sum is what you get by walking one and then the other.

Figure (svg): A complex plane with an arrow from the origin to four plus i, a second arrow from the origin to two plus five i, the second arrow redrawn starting at the tip of the first, and a long arrow from the origin to six plus six i completing the parallelogram.

The dashed copy of the orange arrow starts where the blue one ends, and its tip is the sum. Real parts add along the page, imaginary parts add up it.

Start at the origin and walk four right and one up, which is the blue arrow. From wherever you have landed, walk two right and five up, which is the dashed copy of the orange arrow. You finish at six right and six up.

\[ (4 + i) + (2 + 5i) = 6 + 6i \]

The two solid arrows and the two dashed ones make a parallelogram, and the sum is the corner opposite the origin. That is exactly the picture used for adding vectors in physics, and it is the same operation wearing a different name.

Look at why the like-terms rule is really this picture. The horizontal displacements add because they point along the same axis, and the vertical displacements add for the same reason, while a horizontal step can never contribute to a vertical one.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 281 — Exercise 68, the visual-thinking graph

38. Exercise 68 part a: adding by drawing

Worked example

The book asks you to find this sum by drawing a graph rather than by algebra. Do the drawing first and then confirm it, so the picture is the thing you trust.

\[ (5 + i) + (1 + 4i) \]

Draw the first number as an arrow from the origin

Why: five units right along the real axis and one unit up.

\[ 5 + i \;\longleftrightarrow\; (5, 1) \]

Start the second arrow at the tip of the first

Why: from the point five right and one up, move a further one right and four up.

\[ (5, 1) + (1, 4) = (6, 5) \]

Figure (svg): A complex plane showing an arrow from the origin to five plus i, a second arrow starting at that tip and ending at six plus five i, and a single arrow from the origin straight to six plus five i.

Walk five right and one up, then one right and four up. You land where a single walk of six right and five up would have taken you.

Read the sum off the plane

Why: the finishing point is six right and five up, which is the number six plus five i.

\[ (5 + i) + (1 + 4i) = 6 + 5i \]

Now confirm it with the like-terms rule and the two answers should agree, because the picture and the algebra are descriptions of the same thing.

Check with the algebra

Why: five plus one is six for the real parts, and one plus four is five for the coefficients of i, which is the point the drawing reached.

\[ (5 + 1) + (1 + 4)i = 6 + 5i \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 281 — Exercise 68, part a

39. Trap: a minus sign that only reaches the first part

Trap

The trap

Simplifying a difference, with the bracket dropped too early:

\[ (-1 + i) - (7 - 5i) \]

\[ = -1 + i - 7 - 5i \]

\[ = -8 - 4i \]

The minus in front of the bracket was applied to the seven and then quietly forgotten before the five i.

The fix

Subtracting a bracket changes the sign of everything inside it, so the negative five i becomes a positive five i.

\[ = -1 + i - 7 + 5i \]

\[ = -8 + 6i \]

The safest habit is to rewrite the subtraction as an addition before you combine anything. Adding negative seven plus five i is the same instruction with no sign left to lose.

Check the answer by adding the number you subtracted back on. Negative eight plus six i, plus seven minus five i, gives negative one plus i, which is the number you started with.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 279 — Exercise 15

40. Example 3: the impedance of a series circuit

Real world

Complex numbers are the standard language of alternating-current electronics, and this is the reason why. Resistors, inductors and capacitors all oppose the flow of current, but they do it in ways that do not simply add up as plain numbers.

The book's table records how each component contributes. A resistor of R ohms contributes R, an inductor of L ohms contributes L times i, and a capacitor of C ohms contributes negative C times i. The total opposition of a series circuit, called its impedance, is the sum of the contributions.

Figure (svg): A series circuit drawn as a rectangular loop with an alternating current source on the left side and, along the top, a resistor of five ohms, an inductor of three ohms and a capacitor of four ohms, each labelled with its impedance.

Three components in a row, three impedances added. The inductor contributes an upward imaginary part and the capacitor a downward one, so they partly cancel.

Read the circuit left to right. The resistor of five ohms contributes five, the inductor of three ohms contributes three i, and the capacitor of four ohms contributes negative four i, so the sum is five plus three i minus four i.

\[ 5 + 3i + (-4i) = 5 - i \]

Discussion prompt

Guided Practice 10 replaces that capacitor with one of seven ohms and changes nothing else. Find the new impedance, and say what the sign of the imaginary part is telling you about which component is now winning.

The reason this matters is that the inductor and the capacitor push against each other, and an imaginary part is exactly the right bookkeeping for that. When the two happen to cancel, the impedance becomes a plain real number and the circuit behaves as if it were only a resistor.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 277 — Example 3 and Guided Practice 10

41. Which of these sums lands on the real axis?

Prediction

A sum is real exactly when its imaginary parts cancel. Decide by looking only at the coefficients of i, without working out a single real part.

Predict first

Which sum is a real number?

  • (6 − 3i) + (5 + 4i)
  • (9 + 8i) + (8 − 9i)
  • (14 + 3i) + (7 + 6i)
  • (−2 − 6i) + (4 − 6i)

Correct: (9 + 8i) + (8 − 9i)

Why: Only one of these has coefficients of i that are opposites, eight and negative eight, so only it cancels to zero and leaves seventeen. The others leave one, nine and negative twelve in the imaginary slot. You never had to touch the real parts to decide.

In the plane the winning sum is the case where one arrow goes up by as much as the other goes down, so the walk finishes at the same height it started. The result therefore lands on the real axis.

The other three all finish above or below the real axis, and the size of the leftover coefficient of i tells you how far. That is worth checking on paper for at least one of them.

Notice the pattern hiding in the winner. Its two numbers have the same digits with the roles of the parts swapped, which is a coincidence of the exercise rather than the reason it works; what matters is only that the coefficients of i are opposites.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 279 — Exercises 12 to 20

42. Multiplying: treat i as a letter, then substitute

Section

Part 5

43. Multiply as usual, then replace i squared

Concept

Multiplication needs no new rule either. Use the distributive property or FOIL exactly as you would on two binomials in x, and then do one extra thing at the end.

That extra thing is the whole lesson in one move. Wherever i squared appears in the expanded answer, replace it by negative one. The imaginary term becomes real, and the answer collapses into standard form.

\[ (a + bi)(c + di) = ac + adi + bci + bd\,i^2 \]

\[ = ac + adi + bci - bd = (ac - bd) + (ad + bc)i \]

You do not have to memorise that second line, and you should not. What you memorise is the two-step habit: expand as though i were a letter, then substitute negative one for i squared and tidy up.

Every worked example in this part follows that habit visibly, and the substitution is written on its own line every time, because that line is where the mistakes happen.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 277 — the paragraph on multiplying complex numbers

44. Example 4 part a: four i times the bracket negative six plus i

Worked example

A single term multiplying a bracket, so this is the distributive property and nothing more until the very last stage.

\[ 4i(-6 + i) \]

Distribute the four i across the bracket

Why: multiply four i by negative six, then four i by i, keeping the i symbols untouched for now.

\[ 4i(-6 + i) = -24i + 4i^2 \]

Notice that four i times i gave four i squared, not four i. Multiplying two i symbols together produces a square, exactly as multiplying two x symbols would.

Replace i squared by negative one

Why: this is the substitution, and it is the only step that is not ordinary algebra.

\[ = -24i + 4(-1) \]

Simplify

Why: four times negative one is negative four.

\[ = -24i - 4 \]

Write in standard form

Why: the real part goes first, so the two terms swap places.

\[ = -4 - 24i \]

The result is worth pausing on. Multiplying a pure imaginary number by another complex number has produced something with a real part, which is not what addition ever did.

Check by expanding the answer back

Why: divide the answer by four i, or more simply multiply the bracket out again and confirm the same two terms appear: negative twenty-four i from the first product and negative four from the second.

\[ 4i(-6) = -24i, \quad 4i(i) = 4i^2 = -4 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 277 — Example 4, part a

45. Example 4 part b: FOIL with two complex factors

Worked example

Two brackets this time, so all four products are needed. Take them in the FOIL order and write every sign out.

\[ (9 - 2i)(-4 + 7i) \]

Multiply the first terms and the outer terms

Why: nine times negative four is negative thirty-six, and nine times seven i is sixty-three i.

\[ 9(-4) = -36, \qquad 9(7i) = 63i \]

Multiply the inner terms and the last terms

Why: negative two i times negative four is positive eight i, and negative two i times seven i is negative fourteen i squared.

\[ (-2i)(-4) = 8i, \qquad (-2i)(7i) = -14i^2 \]

Collect the four products

Why: the two middle terms are like terms, so sixty-three i and eight i combine to seventy-one i.

\[ (9 - 2i)(-4 + 7i) = -36 + 71i - 14i^2 \]

Everything so far would be identical if the letter were x. The next line is the only one that uses what i actually is.

Replace i squared by negative one

Why: negative fourteen times negative one is positive fourteen, so a term that looked imaginary has turned real and positive.

\[ = -36 + 71i - 14(-1) = -36 + 71i + 14 \]

Write in standard form

Why: negative thirty-six plus fourteen is negative twenty-two.

\[ = -22 + 71i \]

Check the real part by recomputing it on its own

Why: the real part comes from the first product and the last one: negative thirty-six, plus negative fourteen times negative one, which is negative thirty-six plus fourteen, or negative twenty-two.

\[ -36 + 14 = -22 \quad\text{and}\quad 63 + 8 = 71 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 277 — Example 4, part b

46. Guided Practice 12: the bracket three plus i times five minus i

Worked example

Same method, smaller numbers, and a chance to see how the signs behave when only one bracket carries a minus.

\[ (3 + i)(5 - i) \]

Expand with FOIL

Why: fifteen from the first terms, negative three i from the outer, five i from the inner, and negative i squared from the last.

\[ (3 + i)(5 - i) = 15 - 3i + 5i - i^2 \]

Combine the two middle terms

Why: negative three i plus five i is two i.

\[ = 15 + 2i - i^2 \]

The last term is negative one times i squared, and it is easy to lose that minus. Write it as minus i squared rather than as i squared with a sign floating somewhere nearby.

Replace i squared by negative one

Why: minus one times negative one is plus one, so the last term becomes an ordinary plus one.

\[ = 15 + 2i - (-1) = 15 + 2i + 1 \]

Write in standard form

Why: fifteen plus one is sixteen.

\[ = 16 + 2i \]

Check with the general formula

Why: for the numbers three, one, five and negative one the real part is three times five minus one times negative one, which is fifteen plus one, and the imaginary coefficient is three times negative one plus one times five, which is two.

\[ (3)(5) - (1)(-1) = 16, \qquad (3)(-1) + (1)(5) = 2 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 278 — Guided Practice 12

47. Exercise 57: an answer left with i squared still in it

Error analysis

Here is a student's work on a product, exactly as the book prints it. Every line of expansion is correct, and the answer is still wrong.

Annotate

On: \( (1 + 2i)(4 - i) = 4 - i + 8i - 2i^2 = -2i^2 + 7i + 4 \)

  • Correct. All four products are right and the two middle terms have been collected properly into seven i.
  • Also legal, and this is where the work stopped. Reordering the terms is not the same as finishing them.
  • The term with i squared in it was never converted. Leaving i squared in an answer is like leaving a fraction unsimplified: the value is right but the form is not standard, and the real part has not been found.
  • Negative two times i squared is negative two times negative one, which is positive two. Adding that to the four gives six, so the answer in standard form is six plus seven i.

\[ (1 + 2i)(4 - i) = 4 + 7i - 2(-1) = 6 + 7i \]

The book prints an Avoid Errors note beside Example 4 saying exactly this: when simplifying an expression that involves complex numbers, be sure to simplify i squared to negative one. It is there because this is the most frequent error in the whole lesson.

Build the check into your routine. Before you write a final answer, scan it for the symbol i squared, and if one is there you are not finished. A finished answer contains at most one i, never a power of one.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 280 — Exercise 57 and the Avoid Errors note on p. 277

48. Multiplying by i is a quarter turn

Picture it

Addition turned out to be a movement in the plane, and multiplication is one too. The simplest case is multiplying by i itself, and the effect is startlingly clean.

Figure (svg): A complex plane with the point three plus two i and the point minus two plus three i, each joined to the origin by an arrow, a dashed circle through both of them, and a dashed arc from the first to the second marking a quarter turn.

Both arrows have the same length, so multiplying by i has moved the point without stretching it. The only thing that changed is the direction, by exactly a right angle.

The blue arrow points at three plus two i. Multiply that number by i and you land at negative two plus three i, which is the orange arrow. The dashed circle shows that both points are the same distance from the origin.

\[ i(3 + 2i) = 3i + 2i^2 = -2 + 3i \]

So multiplying by i has not made the number bigger or smaller at all. It has rotated it a quarter turn anticlockwise about the origin, and nothing else has happened.

This is the sentence that makes i feel like a genuine number rather than a piece of notation. Negative one turns a number through half a turn, and i is the number that does half of that job, which is precisely why its square is negative one.

49. Why the turn happens

Concept

The picture on the previous slide was one example. Do the same multiplication with letters and the quarter turn falls out for every complex number at once.

\[ i(a + bi) = ai + bi^2 = -b + ai \]

Read the two ends of that line as points. The number a plus b i sits at the pair a and b, and the answer sits at the pair negative b and a. Going from one to the other is exactly the recipe for turning a point a quarter turn anticlockwise about the origin.

Check that the length has not changed, which is what a turn promises. The absolute value of the answer uses the same two numbers as before, just in the other order and with a sign that gets squared away.

\[ |-b + ai| = \sqrt{(-b)^2 + a^2} = \sqrt{a^2 + b^2} = |a + bi| \]

Now do it twice. Turning a quarter and then another quarter is a half turn, which sends every point to its opposite, and that is the same as multiplying by negative one. So two multiplications by i must equal one multiplication by negative one.

\[ i \cdot i = i^2 = -1 \]

That is the definition arriving from the other direction. It was chosen to make the algebra work, and it turns out to describe the most natural geometric operation there is.

50. The powers of i cycle every four steps

Concept

Ordinary powers grow: two to the fifth is thirty-two and two to the tenth is over a thousand. The powers of i do nothing of the kind, and the quarter-turn picture says why immediately.

Figure (svg): A unit circle in the complex plane with four marked points at one, i, minus one and minus i, joined by four arrows each labelled times i, forming a square that cycles round the circle.

Four multiplications by i bring you back to where you started, which is why the powers repeat with period four instead of growing.

Each multiplication by i moves you one quarter turn round the circle, so four of them bring you back to the start. Work the first four out and the pattern is plain.

\[ i^1 = i, \quad i^2 = -1, \quad i^3 = i^2\cdot i = -i, \quad i^4 = i^2\cdot i^2 = (-1)(-1) = 1 \]

Because the fourth power is one, multiplying by i to the fourth changes nothing, and the list of values repeats for ever with period four: i, negative one, negative i, one, and round again.

The practical consequence is that any power of i can be worked out by dividing the exponent by four and keeping the remainder. Exercise 69 asks you to build that table and describe the pattern, which is exactly what the next two slides do.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 281 — Exercise 69

51. Complete the table of powers of i

Comparison

Fill in the blanks from the cycle rather than by multiplying from scratch each time. The third column says where each entry comes from, which is the part worth reading.

Comparison matrix

power of isimplified formwhere it comes from
i to the 1ithe definition
i to the 2-1the defining rule i² = −1
i to the 3−ii² · i = (−1)i
i to the 41i² · i² = (−1)(−1)
i to the 5ii⁴ · i = 1 · i
i to the 6−1i⁴ · i² = 1 · (−1)
i to the 7-ii⁴ · i³ = 1 · (−i)
i to the 81four steps on from i⁴

Reading down the middle column gives the four values repeating twice over, which is the pattern Exercise 69 asks you to describe. The fifth row is the same as the first, the sixth as the second, and so on for ever.

The third column is doing the teaching. Every entry is the fourth power, which is one, multiplied by whichever of the first four powers matches the remainder, so no power of i ever needs more than one small multiplication.

Notice that exactly half the entries are real and half are imaginary, alternating. An even power of i is always plus or minus one and an odd power is always plus or minus i, which is a useful quick check on any answer.

52. A large power: i to the fiftieth, without a calculator

Worked example

This is the pay-off from the cycle. Nobody multiplies fifty copies of i together; you find where fifty lands in the four-step pattern and read the answer off.

\[ i^{50} \]

Divide the exponent by four and keep the remainder

Why: fifty is four times twelve with two left over, so fifty steps round the circle is twelve complete laps plus two more steps.

\[ 50 = 4(12) + 2 \]

Split the power using that division

Why: the law of exponents lets you write the power as a product, which is legal for i exactly as for any number.

\[ i^{50} = i^{4(12)}\cdot i^{2} = \left(i^4\right)^{12}\cdot i^2 \]

Replace i to the fourth by one

Why: the twelve complete laps change nothing, because one raised to any power is one.

\[ = 1^{12}\cdot i^2 = i^2 \]

Replace i squared by negative one

Why: two steps past the start is the point negative one on the circle.

\[ = -1 \]

The whole method is one division. Remainder one gives i, remainder two gives negative one, remainder three gives negative i, and remainder zero gives one.

Check with a smaller power you can count

Why: i to the sixth is the same remainder of two, and multiplying out i squared times i squared times i squared gives negative one times negative one times negative one, which is negative one as well.

\[ i^6 = \left(i^2\right)^3 = (-1)^3 = -1 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 281 — Exercise 69, the continuation

53. Trap: expecting the powers of i to grow

Trap

The trap

Asked for i to the twenty-third, it is tempting to reason by size:

\[ i^{23} \]

The powers of two grow, so the powers of i must grow as well, and twenty-three is a large exponent.

That line of thought ends either in some enormous imaginary number or in giving up, because no calculator seems willing to do it.

The fix

Powers of i do not grow, because i has absolute value one. Every multiplication by i is a turn, never a stretch, so the answer stays on the unit circle for ever.

\[ 23 = 4(5) + 3 \]

\[ i^{23} = i^3 = -i \]

A remainder of three lands three quarter turns round from the start, which is the point negative i. The answer is one of only four possible values, however large the exponent is.

The same reasoning gives a useful sanity check. If your answer to a powers-of-i question is anything other than one, negative one, i or negative i, something has gone wrong.

54. Conjugates and dividing

Section

Part 6

55. Conjugates: the same number with the sign of i flipped

Concept

Division is the one operation left, and it needs a tool. The tool is a partner number that turns any complex number into a real one when the two are multiplied together.

complex conjugates — The two numbers a plus b i and a minus b i. They have the same real part and opposite imaginary parts.

Multiply a conjugate pair together and watch what happens to the middle terms. This is the difference-of-squares pattern from Lesson 4.4, and it is the reason the whole method works.

\[ (a + bi)(a - bi) = a^2 - abi + abi - b^2i^2 \]

The two middle terms cancel

Why: they are opposites, so they add to zero and the answer has no imaginary part left at all.

\[ = a^2 - b^2i^2 \]

Replace i squared by negative one

Why: minus b squared times negative one is plus b squared.

\[ = a^2 + b^2 \]

So the product of a conjugate pair is always the sum of two squares, which is a real number and, unless both parts are zero, a positive one. The book's own example is two plus four i times two minus four i, which comes to four plus sixteen, or twenty.

You have seen that expression before. The sum of the squares of the two parts is exactly what sits under the root in the absolute value formula, so the product of a conjugate pair is the square of its absolute value.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 278 — the definition of complex conjugates

56. A conjugate pair is a mirror image in the real axis

Picture it

In the plane, taking the conjugate is as simple as taking a quarter turn was. Flipping the sign of the imaginary part sends a point straight up or down across the real axis.

Figure (svg): A complex plane showing three plus four i above the real axis and three minus four i below it, each joined to the origin by an arrow, with a dashed vertical line joining the two points through the real axis.

Flipping the sign of the imaginary part reflects the point in the real axis. The distance to the origin is untouched, which is why a number and its conjugate have the same absolute value.

Both points are three units to the right and four units away from the real axis, one above and one below, so they are the same distance from the origin. That is why a number and its conjugate always have equal absolute values.

\[ |3 + 4i| = |3 - 4i| = \sqrt{9 + 16} = 5 \]

The picture also explains why the product comes out real. Adding the two numbers cancels the vertical parts, and multiplying them cancels them in a subtler way, but in both cases the pairing up and down against each other is what does it.

Look ahead to Lesson 4.8 with this in view. Whenever the quadratic formula gives imaginary answers, the plus-or-minus sign produces exactly a conjugate pair, so the two solutions are always a mirror image of each other in the real axis.

57. Before dividing anything, what do you multiply by?

Step zero

Division by a complex number has one obstacle: the denominator contains an i and there is no way to simplify it away directly. Think about the fix before you see it worked out.

\[ \dfrac{7 + 5i}{1 - 4i} \]

Discussion prompt

You already know how to remove a radical from a denominator by multiplying the top and bottom by a conjugate. Say what you would multiply this fraction by, why that particular choice, and why multiplying by it does not change the value of the fraction.

This is precisely the rationalising move from Lesson 4.5, transplanted. There the nuisance in the denominator was a square root and the conjugate flipped the sign in front of it; here the nuisance is an i and the conjugate flips the sign in front of that.

Why is a real denominator what you want? Because dividing by a real number is easy: you can split the fraction into its real part and its imaginary part and finish in standard form. A denominator with an i in it blocks that final step entirely.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 278 — the Rewrite Quotients note beside Example 5

58. Example 5: seven plus five i, over one minus four i

Worked example

The book's own division, with every line shown. The denominator is one minus four i, so the conjugate you need is one plus four i.

\[ \dfrac{7 + 5i}{1 - 4i} \]

Multiply top and bottom by the conjugate of the denominator

Why: which is one plus four i; the fraction being multiplied in is equal to one, so the value is unchanged.

\[ = \dfrac{7 + 5i}{1 - 4i}\cdot\dfrac{1 + 4i}{1 + 4i} \]

Expand the numerator with FOIL

Why: seven, twenty-eight i, five i and twenty i squared.

\[ = \dfrac{7 + 28i + 5i + 20i^2}{1 + 4i - 4i - 16i^2} \]

Look at the denominator before going on. Its two middle terms are four i and negative four i, which cancel, and that cancelling is the entire reason the conjugate was chosen.

Replace i squared by negative one everywhere

Why: twenty i squared becomes twenty times negative one, and negative sixteen i squared becomes negative sixteen times negative one. The printed book writes this step's label as i squared equals one, dropping a minus sign; the working on the same line uses negative one, which is correct.

\[ = \dfrac{7 + 33i + 20(-1)}{1 - 16(-1)} \]

Simplify the top and the bottom

Why: seven take away twenty is negative thirteen, and one plus sixteen is seventeen.

\[ = \dfrac{-13 + 33i}{17} \]

Split into standard form

Why: a real denominator can be shared out over both parts of the numerator.

\[ = -\dfrac{13}{17} + \dfrac{33}{17}i \]

Check by multiplying the answer by the denominator

Why: multiplying negative thirteen over seventeen plus thirty-three over seventeen i by one minus four i gives back seven plus five i, as a division always must.

\[ \left(\dfrac{-13 + 33i}{17}\right)(1 - 4i) = \dfrac{-13 + 33i + 52i - 132i^2}{17} = \dfrac{119 + 85i}{17} = 7 + 5i \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 278 — Example 5

59. Guided Practice 13: five over one plus i

Worked example

A real numerator this time, which makes the arithmetic short and lets you watch the method rather than the numbers.

\[ \dfrac{5}{1 + i} \]

Multiply top and bottom by the conjugate one minus i

Why: the denominator is one plus i, so flip the sign of its imaginary part.

\[ = \dfrac{5}{1 + i}\cdot\dfrac{1 - i}{1 - i} \]

Expand both parts

Why: the top is a single distribution; the bottom is a conjugate pair, whose middle terms cancel.

\[ = \dfrac{5 - 5i}{1 - i^2} \]

The denominator is the sum of the squares of one and one, which you could have written down as two without expanding anything. That shortcut is worth using once you trust it.

Replace i squared by negative one

Why: one take away negative one is two.

\[ = \dfrac{5 - 5i}{2} \]

Split into standard form

Why: share the two out over both terms of the numerator.

\[ = \dfrac{5}{2} - \dfrac{5}{2}i \]

Check by multiplying back

Why: five halves minus five halves i, times one plus i, gives five halves plus five halves i minus five halves i minus five halves times i squared, which is five halves plus five halves, or five.

\[ \left(\dfrac{5}{2} - \dfrac{5}{2}i\right)(1 + i) = \dfrac{5}{2} + \dfrac{5}{2} = 5 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 278 — Guided Practice 13

60. Guided Practice 14: five plus two i, over three minus two i

Worked example

Both parts present in both numbers, so all four products appear on the top. This is the general case and the one to be able to do without hesitating.

\[ \dfrac{5 + 2i}{3 - 2i} \]

Multiply top and bottom by the conjugate three plus two i

Why: flipping the sign of the denominator's imaginary part.

\[ = \dfrac{5 + 2i}{3 - 2i}\cdot\dfrac{3 + 2i}{3 + 2i} \]

Expand the numerator with FOIL

Why: fifteen, ten i, six i and four i squared.

\[ = \dfrac{15 + 10i + 6i + 4i^2}{9 + 4} \]

The denominator was written down directly as nine plus four, using the rule that a conjugate pair multiplies to the sum of the two squares. Three squared is nine and two squared is four.

Collect the middle terms and substitute

Why: ten i plus six i is sixteen i, and four i squared is negative four.

\[ = \dfrac{15 + 16i - 4}{13} \]

Simplify the numerator and split

Why: fifteen take away four is eleven.

\[ = \dfrac{11 + 16i}{13} = \dfrac{11}{13} + \dfrac{16}{13}i \]

Check by multiplying the answer by three minus two i

Why: eleven over thirteen plus sixteen over thirteen i, times three minus two i, gives thirty-three plus thirty-two over thirteen for the real part and negative twenty-two plus forty-eight over thirteen for the imaginary one, which is five plus two i.

\[ \dfrac{33 + 32}{13} = 5, \qquad \dfrac{-22 + 48}{13} = 2 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 278 — Guided Practice 14

61. Exercise 29: six i over three minus i

Fill the middle

One of the book's worked-out-solution exercises. The numerator is pure imaginary, so the expansion on top is short, but the denominator still needs its conjugate.

Fill in the blanks

\dfrac109/5\cdot\dfrac______ = \dfrac______} = \dfrac______ = -\dfrac______ + ___i

Why: The denominator is a conjugate pair, so it is the sum of the squares of three and one, which is nine plus one, or ten. On the top, six i squared is negative six, giving negative six plus eighteen i over ten. Dividing both parts by ten and reducing gives negative three fifths and nine fifths, since eighteen over ten reduces to nine over five.

Reducing the fractions at the end is part of writing in standard form, and it is easy to forget after the interesting work is over. Eighteen over ten and negative six over ten both reduce by a factor of two.

Exercise 30 in the same set is worth a look because its denominator is pure imaginary. Dividing negative two minus five i by three i needs the conjugate negative three i, and the answer comes out negative five thirds plus two thirds i.

Check any division the same way every time: multiply your answer by the original denominator and the original numerator should reappear. Here, negative three fifths plus nine fifths i, times three minus i, gives six i.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 280 — Exercises 29 and 30

62. Trap: multiplying only the bottom by the conjugate

Trap

The trap

Clearing the i out of a denominator, in one move too few:

\[ \dfrac{5}{1 + i} \]

\[ = \dfrac{5}{(1 + i)(1 - i)} = \dfrac{5}{2} \]

The denominator is real now, which was the goal, and the answer looks clean.

The fix

The value has been changed. Multiplying only the bottom by one minus i divides the whole fraction by that factor, so the answer is no longer the number you started with.

\[ \dfrac{5}{1 + i}\cdot\dfrac{1 - i}{1 - i} = \dfrac{5}{2} - \dfrac{5}{2}i \]

Multiplying by one minus i over one minus i is multiplying by one, which is always safe. Multiplying by one minus i alone is not.

Test the wrong answer and it fails at once: five halves times one plus i is five halves plus five halves i, not five. The correct answer passes the same test, which is why that check is worth one line of your time.

63. Put the four steps of a division in order

Ranking

Divisions go wrong through order as often as through arithmetic. Decide the sequence before touching the next exercise you meet.

\[ \dfrac{7 + 4i}{2 - 3i} \]

Put in order

Put the steps in the order that writes this quotient in standard form.

  1. Multiply the numerator and the denominator by 2 + 3i
  2. Expand both products with FOIL
  3. Replace every i² by −1 and collect like terms
  4. Divide both parts of the numerator by the real denominator

Why: Choosing the conjugate has to come first, because everything else depends on it. Expanding comes next, then the substitution that turns the squared terms real, and only when the denominator is a single real number can you split the fraction into a real part and an imaginary part. Doing that split before the denominator is real is the step that cannot work.

Work this one through and you should reach two thirteenths plus twenty-nine thirteenths i. The denominator is the sum of the squares of two and three, which is thirteen.

The last step is the one people attempt too early. A fraction with an i in its denominator cannot be split into a real part and an imaginary part, because neither piece would be a real number divided by a real number.

One reassurance about the first step. It never matters whether the denominator's imaginary part started positive or negative; you flip whatever sign is there, and the product is the sum of the squares either way.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 280 — Exercise 32

64. Putting it together

Section

Part 7

65. Where Lesson 4.8 is heading

Concept

This lesson exists to make one case of the quadratic formula meaningful, and it is worth seeing that case now so the point of the last hour is clear.

\[ x^2 + 6x + 13 = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = \dfrac{-6 \pm\sqrt{36 - 52}}{2} = \dfrac{-6 \pm\sqrt{-16}}{2} \]

The number under the root is negative sixteen, and before today that would have ended the question. Now it does not: the root of negative sixteen is four i, and the calculation finishes.

\[ x = \dfrac{-6 \pm 4i}{2} = -3 \pm 2i \]

Figure (svg): Two panels. On the left the parabola y equals x squared plus six x plus thirteen sits entirely above the horizontal axis with its vertex at minus three, four. On the right a complex plane shows the two points minus three plus two i and minus three minus two i.

The graph on the left is telling the truth: there is no real solution. The plane on the right shows the pair of solutions that were there all along, one above the real axis and one below.

The left panel shows why there was no real answer. The parabola sits entirely above the horizontal axis, with its lowest point four units up at x equal to negative three, so it never crosses and there is nothing to read off the number line.

The right panel shows where the two answers actually live. They are a conjugate pair, one above the real axis and one below, both sitting directly above and below the vertex's own position at negative three. A graph that misses the axis has not lost its solutions; it has only lost the ability to show them.

OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §2.4 Complex Numbers §2.4 — the same imaginary unit, with the quadratic connection made in §2.5

66. The Mandelbrot set: does one plus i escape?

Real world

The pictures of the Mandelbrot set that you have seen on posters are drawn using nothing beyond this lesson: squaring a complex number, adding one, and measuring an absolute value.

The rule is a loop. Start at zero, square what you have, add the fixed number c, and repeat for ever. If the absolute values stay below some bound the number c belongs to the set, and if they run away it does not.

\[ z_0 = 0, \quad z_{n+1} = z_n^2 + c \]

Figure (svg): A stem plot of the absolute values of the first five numbers in the orbit of c equal to one plus i, rising from zero through about one point four, three point two and nine point nine to ninety-seven, with a dashed line marking a chosen bound.

The first three steps look tame and the fourth is not. Whatever bound you had in mind, this orbit has already passed it, so the starting value is outside the Mandelbrot set.

Take c equal to one plus i and follow the orbit. Zero squared plus c is one plus i. Squaring that gives two i, and adding c again gives one plus three i, whose absolute value is already over three.

\[ z_2 = (1 + i)^2 + (1 + i) = 2i + 1 + i = 1 + 3i \]

\[ z_3 = (1 + 3i)^2 + (1 + i) = -8 + 6i + 1 + i = -7 + 7i \]

One more step takes the orbit to one minus ninety-seven i, whose absolute value is about ninety-seven, and the growth is accelerating. So one plus i does not belong to the Mandelbrot set, and on the poster its pixel is left uncoloured.

Discussion prompt

Exercise 70 asks the same question for c equal to i. Work out the first four numbers of that orbit and their absolute values, then say whether i belongs to the Mandelbrot set and why you can be sure without going any further.

That is the difference the poster is drawing. Each pixel is a value of c, and its colour records whether the orbit stayed put like this one or ran away like one plus i.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 281 — the Mandelbrot investigation and Exercises 70 to 73

67. Match each expression to the move it needs

Matching

Four expressions, four different first moves. Decide by looking at the shape of each one, without doing any arithmetic at all.

Match the pairs

  • a. √(−50)
  • b. (8 − 5i) − (−11 + 4i)
  • c. (−2 + 5i)(−1 + 4i)
  • d. (4 + 9i) / (12i)
  • w. write it as i times a root, then simplify the radical
  • x. change the sign of both parts of the bracket, then collect like terms
  • y. expand with FOIL, then replace i squared by negative one
  • z. multiply top and bottom by the conjugate of the bottom

Why: A lone negative under a root always becomes i times the root of the positive number. A subtraction needs the minus sign carried into both parts of the bracket before anything is collected. A product of two brackets needs the full expansion and then the substitution. A quotient needs the conjugate of its denominator, and nothing else will clear the i out of the bottom.

The one with a pure imaginary denominator is worth a second look, because its conjugate is negative twelve i rather than something with two parts. The rule is the same: flip the sign of the imaginary part, whatever the real part happens to be.

If you can sort expressions this quickly, the arithmetic that follows is routine. Most marks lost on this topic are lost in the first line, by starting down the wrong route rather than by miscounting a sign.

Notice that two of the four moves finish with the same instruction, replace i squared by negative one. That substitution is the single step this whole lesson is built around.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 279 — Exercises 12 to 33

68. One habit behind all four operations

Pattern

Everything in this lesson is ordinary algebra with one substitution bolted on, and the table says where the substitution shows up in each case.

what you are doingthe movewhere i squared appears
a negative under a rootwrite √(−r) as i√r, then simplify the radicalonly when you square the answer to check
adding or subtractingcollect real with real, i terms with i termsnever: no two i terms are multiplied
multiplyingdistribute or FOIL as if i were a letterin the last product; replace it with −1
dividingmultiply top and bottom by the conjugate of the bottomin both the top and the bottom; replace both
  1. Turn every negative root into an i first. The product rule for radicals is false for two negative radicands.
  2. Carry a subtracted bracket's minus sign into both parts.
  3. After expanding, hunt for i squared. An answer containing a power of i is not finished.
  4. Finish in standard form: one real piece, then one imaginary piece, with fractions reduced.
  5. Check by reversing the operation, and remember that an absolute value can never come out negative or imaginary.

The middle row of the table is the reason addition felt so easy. Nothing gets multiplied, so the new rule never fires, and the whole operation is collecting like terms.

The bottom row is the reason division felt hardest. The substitution has to be made in two places at once, and there is a conjugate to choose before any of it starts.

69. Check: finishing a quadratic with no real solutions

Check

Isolate the square first, then turn the negative into an i, then simplify the radical. All three steps are needed here.

Check your understanding

Solve 2x² + 31 = 9.

  • A. x = ± i√11 (correct)
  • B. x = ± √11
  • C. x = ± i√20
  • D. x = ± 11i

Answer: A

Why: Subtracting thirty-one from nine leaves negative twenty-two, and dividing by two gives negative eleven. Taking roots of a negative eleven gives i times the root of eleven, with a plus or minus in front. Eleven has no perfect square factor, so the radical does not simplify any further.

Why B tempts people
The minus sign under the root was dropped. Negative eleven is not eleven, and only one of the two has a real square root.
Why C tempts people
The division by two was skipped, so the number under the root is twice as large as it should be.
Why D tempts people
The eleven was taken out from under the root as though the radical had disappeared. It did not: the answer is i times the root of eleven, not eleven times i.

Every wrong option here is a real slip rather than a random number, and each one is worth recognising. Two of them lose a step, and one loses a sign.

The quickest way to settle it is to square each candidate. Squaring i times the root of eleven gives negative eleven, which is what the isolated square had to equal, and none of the others do.

Notice that the answer is pure imaginary, with no real part at all. That always happens when the equation has no x term, because the two solutions are then opposites of each other.

If you found yourself hesitating between the winning answer and the one with twenty under the root, redo the division step slowly. Negative twenty-two divided by two is negative eleven, and the sign travels with the number.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 279 — Exercise 7

70. Check: a product of two complex numbers

Check

Expand fully, then hunt for the i squared. Watch the signs: both brackets here carry a minus.

Check your understanding

Write the product of 5 − 7i and −4 − 3i as a complex number in standard form.

  • A. −41 + 13i (correct)
  • B. 1 + 13i
  • C. −41 − 43i
  • D. −20 + 13i

Answer: A

Why: The four products are negative twenty, negative fifteen i, twenty-eight i and twenty-one i squared. The middle two collect to thirteen i, and twenty-one i squared is negative twenty-one, so the real part is negative twenty take away twenty-one, which is negative forty-one.

Why B tempts people
The last term was treated as plus twenty-one instead of negative twenty-one, so the real part came out twenty-one too high.
Why C tempts people
The two middle terms were subtracted instead of added. Negative fifteen i plus twenty-eight i is thirteen i, not negative forty-three i.
Why D tempts people
The i squared term was left unconverted, so it never joined the real part and the real part stopped at negative twenty.

The most valuable of these wrong answers is the one whose real part is negative twenty, because it is the error from Exercise 57 appearing again. Any answer that ignores the last product is missing part of its real part.

A quick partial check is available without redoing the whole thing. The imaginary coefficient is five times negative three, plus negative seven times negative four, which is negative fifteen plus twenty-eight, or thirteen. That alone eliminates one of the choices.

Do the real part separately as well. It is five times negative four, minus negative seven times negative three, which is negative twenty minus twenty-one. Splitting a product into its two parts like this is faster than rechecking four terms.

If the sign of the last product is what gave you trouble, write it out in full: negative seven i times negative three i is positive twenty-one i squared, and only then does the substitution make it negative.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 280 — Exercise 24

71. Check: dividing by a complex number

Check

Choose the conjugate, expand, substitute, then split. The numerator here is pure imaginary, which shortens the work but changes nothing about the method.

Check your understanding

Write 7i divided by 8 + i in standard form.

  • A. 7/65 + (56/65)i (correct)
  • B. (56/65) + (7/65)i
  • C. −7/65 + (56/65)i
  • D. 7i/65

Answer: A

Why: Multiplying top and bottom by eight minus i gives fifty-six i minus seven i squared on the top, which is seven plus fifty-six i, and sixty-four plus one on the bottom, which is sixty-five. Splitting that over sixty-five gives seven sixty-fifths for the real part and fifty-six sixty-fifths for the imaginary one.

Why B tempts people
The two parts have been swapped. The real part comes from the i squared term, which is seven, and the imaginary part from seven times eight, which is fifty-six.
Why C tempts people
The sign of the real part is wrong. Negative seven times i squared is negative seven times negative one, which is positive seven.
Why D tempts people
The i squared term was dropped entirely, so the real part never appeared and the answer is still not in standard form.

The conjugate of eight plus i is eight minus i, and its product with the original is sixty-four plus one. Writing that denominator down directly, as the sum of two squares, saves expanding four terms.

Check the winner by multiplying back. Seven sixty-fifths plus fifty-six sixty-fifths i, times eight plus i, gives fifty-six sixty-fifths plus four hundred and forty-eight sixty-fifths i, plus seven sixty-fifths i, plus fifty-six sixty-fifths times i squared, and the real parts cancel to leave seven i exactly.

The option that keeps the i in the numerator without a real part is the one to understand rather than just reject. It is what you get if you forget that multiplying by the conjugate creates a real term on the top as well as on the bottom.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers §4.6, p. 280 — Exercise 28

72. Say why the new number had to be invented

Explain it to yourself

One idea has carried the whole lesson, and putting it in your own sentences is what makes it stay. Write your answer before reading the one offered.

Discussion prompt

In three or four sentences, explain why no real number can satisfy the equation x squared equals negative one, what mathematicians did about it, and why inventing a number is a legitimate thing to do rather than a cheat. Mention one thing the invention lets you do that you could not do before.

If your explanation leaned on the word imaginary, try writing it again without that word. The name is historical and slightly misleading, and an explanation that does not depend on it is usually the clearer one.

A good test of your own understanding is whether you could tell the same story about negative numbers. They too were invented to fill a gap, they too were distrusted for centuries, and they too turned out to be indispensable.

Try the last part on a concrete case as well. Before today the equation x squared plus one equals zero had no answer you could write; now it has two, and they are i and negative i.

73. Exit ticket

Exit ticket

One question that uses the three habits of this lesson: pick the conjugate, substitute for i squared, and finish in standard form before measuring anything.

\[ \dfrac{3 + 2i}{1 - i} \]

Discussion prompt

Write this quotient in standard form, then find the absolute value of your answer, and say where both the original numerator and your answer sit relative to the real axis.

The denominator is worth writing straight down. One plus i times one minus i is the sum of the squares of one and one, which is two, so there is no need to expand it.

Check the quotient by multiplying back, as every division in this lesson has been checked. A half plus five halves i, times one minus i, gives three plus two i, which is where you started.

If the final absolute value came out as a whole number, look again: twenty-six is not a perfect square, so the exact answer keeps its radical and only a decimal approximation looks tidy.

One last connection to make before you leave. The number you divided by, one minus i, sits below the real axis, and its conjugate one plus i sits above it. Choosing the conjugate is always choosing the mirror image.

74. What you can do now

Recap

One invented number, defined so that its square is negative one, and every operation you already knew carried over unchanged with a single substitution attached.

situationwhat you doexample from this lesson
a negative under a square rootwrite it as i times the root of the positive number√(−24) = 2i√6
classifying a numberlook at b first, then a−4i is pure imaginary; 3 + 0i is real
adding or subtractingcollect real with real, i terms with i terms(8 − i) + (5 + 4i) = 13 + 3i
multiplyingFOIL, then replace i² by −1(9 − 2i)(−4 + 7i) = −22 + 71i
dividingmultiply top and bottom by the conjugate(7 + 5i)/(1 − 4i) = −13/17 + (33/17)i
measuring a numberthe root of the sum of the squares of its parts|−4 + 3i| = 5

The plane is the picture that ties the rows together. Adding is walking one arrow after another, multiplying by i is a quarter turn, taking a conjugate is a reflection in the real axis, and the absolute value is a distance from the origin.

\[ |a + bi| = \sqrt{a^2 + b^2} \qquad (a + bi)(a - bi) = a^2 + b^2 \]

Those two formulas are the same expression twice, which is not a coincidence. A number multiplied by its conjugate gives the square of its distance from the origin, and that is exactly why conjugates clear a denominator.

Lesson 4.8 uses all of this immediately. When the quadratic formula produces a negative number under its root, you now finish rather than stop, and the two answers come out as a conjugate pair sitting above and below the real axis, one for each sign of the plus or minus.

OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §2.4 Complex Numbers §2.4 — the same definitions and operations, with more practice on conjugates

Sources

  1. McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.6 Perform Operations with Complex Numbers — Larson, Boswell, Kanold & Stiff, McDougal Littell / Houghton Mifflin, 2007, pp. 275-281
  2. OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §2.4 Complex Numbers

Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Algebra 2 — $55/session, free consultation.

Book on Wyzant · Text (657) 465-8108