The product and quotient properties of square roots, the two conditions for a radical expression to be simplified, rationalising denominators using conjugates, solving quadratic equations by taking square roots, and the dropped-object height model.
Subject: Algebra 2 · 76 slides · symbolic lesson
Open the interactive version of this deck
Title
Algebra 2 · Lesson 4.5
Two numbers square to the same thing, and that is why the answer has two halves
Objectives
Lessons 4.3 and 4.4 solved quadratic equations by factoring. Factoring is a wonderful method when it works, and it works only when the quadratic splits into brackets with whole numbers in them. Most quadratics do not.
This lesson takes the other road. When an equation has no plain x term, you can isolate the square and undo it directly, and the answer no longer has to be a whole number or even a fraction.
The idea that carries all five is one sentence: a positive number has two square roots, and the radical sign names only one of them. Everything that follows, including the plus-or-minus, comes out of that.
Two habits will keep you safe here. Pull the largest perfect square out of every radicand rather than the first one you spot, and finish every solved equation by squaring your answer back into the equation you started with.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 266 — Before, Now, Why and the Key Vocabulary
Warm-up
Start with the equation the book opens its third example on, and try the method you already own. Write down what you get before reading on, because the failure is the point of the slide.
\[ 3x^2 + 5 = 41 \]
Discussion prompt
Put this equation in standard form, then try to factor it. Say exactly where the attempt breaks down.
Now notice what the standard form has handed you. There is no plain x term at all, so the equation says nothing more complicated than: some number squared is twelve. That question does have an answer.
The whole of this lesson lives in the gap you just found. When a quadratic has no first-power term, you can attack the square itself instead of hunting for brackets, and the answer is allowed to be a radical.
Hold on to one more thing from the warm-up. Twelve is not a perfect square, so whatever the answer turns out to be, it will not be a whole number, and part of the work will be writing it in a tidy form.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 267 — the equation of Example 3
Section
Part 1
Concept
Start from the definition rather than from the symbol, because the symbol is where people get into trouble. A square root of a number is anything that squares to give you that number back.
square root — A number r is a square root of a number s when r squared equals s. A positive number s has two square roots, written as the root of s and the negative of the root of s. The positive one is called the principal square root.
\[ r^2 = s \;\Longleftrightarrow\; r \text{ is a square root of } s \]
Try it on nine. Three squared is nine, and negative three squared is also nine, because a negative times a negative is positive. So nine genuinely has two square roots, three and negative three, and the principal one is three.
Figure (svg): A large square-root symbol drawn over the number 45, with leader lines naming the radical sign, the radicand, and a dashed box round the whole expression labelled: this whole thing is a radical.
The three names in the picture are worth learning properly, because the book uses them constantly. The hook is the radical sign, whatever sits under it is the radicand, and the whole assembled expression is a radical.
Here is the detail that will matter on every remaining slide. The radical sign does not mean both roots. It names the positive one only, so the root of nine is three and nothing else.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 266 — square root, radical, radicand and principal square root
Concept
Why should a number have two square roots at all? Because squaring is a process that loses information, and any process that loses information is awkward to reverse.
Figure (svg): A number line from minus five to five with dots at minus three and three, two arrows leading down to a second number line from zero to twelve with a dot at nine, and a dashed arrow leading back up from nine to three only.
Follow the two solid arrows. Three and negative three are different numbers, and squaring sends both of them to the same nine. Once you are standing at nine there is nothing in the number itself that says which one you came from.
So reversing the journey is not a matter of one arrow going backwards. Two arrows arrived, so honestly reversing them means going back to both places, and that is what having two square roots means.
The dashed arrow is the radical sign, and notice that it returns to one point only. That is a convention, chosen so that the symbol names a single definite number rather than an ambiguous pair.
Those two facts sit slightly awkwardly together, and the plus-or-minus symbol is how mathematics resolves the awkwardness. It is not decoration; it is the second arrow, put back by hand.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 266 — a positive number has two square roots
Picture it
The cleanest picture of the two roots is a graph you already drew in Lesson 4.1. Put y equal to x squared on axes, then draw the horizontal line at the height you want the square to reach.
Figure (svg): The parabola y equals x squared drawn on axes through the origin, with a horizontal dashed line at y equals 9 cutting it at the two points where x is minus three and three.
The curve climbs away from the origin on both sides, so every height above the origin is reached in two places, once on the left arm and once on the right. Reaching the height nine happens at x equal to negative three and at x equal to three.
That is the geometric content of solving x squared equals nine. You are asking which x values sit on the curve at height nine, and the picture shows you that the answer is a pair, not a single point.
Read the symmetry as well. The parabola is a mirror image about the vertical axis, so the two crossings are always the same distance from zero and always opposite in sign. That is exactly the shape of a plus-or-minus answer.
Keep this picture in your head for the rest of the lesson, because it also answers two questions you have not asked yet: what happens when the line is at height zero, and what happens when it is below the axis.
Notation
This one short line is the whole lesson compressed, and every symbol in it is doing a job. Take it apart before you start using it, so that later you are moving pieces you understand.
Annotate
On: \( x = \pm\sqrt{s} \)
Say the line out loud once: x equals plus or minus the square root of s. Saying it properly is a surprisingly effective guard against dropping the first symbol, which is the most common error in this whole chapter.
Note where the plus-or-minus sits. It is outside the radical, in front of it, because it is not part of the number under the sign. It is a decision about sign applied to a number that is already positive.
One consequence to keep straight from the start. Solving an equation produces a plus-or-minus; evaluating a radical does not. The very next slide is built entirely on that difference.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 267 — the condensed form x equals plus or minus root s
Picture it
Two questions look almost identical on the page and have different numbers of answers. Separating them is the single most useful thing you can take from this part of the lesson.
Figure (svg): Two number lines side by side, each running from minus four to four. The left one, headed the value of the square root of 9, carries a single dot at 3. The right one, headed the solutions of x squared equals 9, carries dots at minus three and three.
On the left, the root of nine is being evaluated. That expression is the name of one particular number, in the same way that three plus four is the name of one particular number, and the answer is three.
On the right, an equation is being solved. The question is which values of x make the statement true, and two values do, so the answer has two parts and must be written with a plus-or-minus.
The nine is the same nine in both. What differs is the question being asked, and the number of answers follows from the question, not from the number.
A quick test whenever you are unsure. If the line you are looking at contains an equals sign and an unknown, you are solving and you need both signs. If it is just an expression to be worked out, you are evaluating and you need one.
Trap
Solving x squared equals nine, here is a very common final line:
\[ x = \sqrt{9} = 3 \]
Every symbol in it is legal, and the arithmetic is right: the root of nine really is three, and three really does satisfy the equation.
It is still only half an answer. Negative three satisfies the equation too, and this line has quietly discarded it.
Take roots of each side, then put the sign decision back in by hand, because the radical sign will not do it for you:
\[ x = \pm\sqrt{9} = \pm 3 \]
Check both. Three squared is nine, and negative three squared is also nine, so both values really do solve the equation and both belong in the answer.
The general habit: the moment you take a square root of both sides of an equation, write the plus-or-minus in the same stroke. Adding it afterwards is something people intend to do and forget.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 267 — the Avoid Errors note beside Example 3
Sorting
Test the definition on six equations rather than trusting a feeling about them. For each, ask what number the square has to equal, and then whether any real number squares to it.
Sort into buckets
Sort each equation by how many real solutions it has.
The one worth pausing on is the equation with seven on the right. Seven is not a perfect square, and some people read that as a reason to say there is no answer. There is: it is the root of seven, about 2.646, and its negative.
The zero case is the odd one out for a good reason. Zero is the only number that is its own negative, so the two mirror answers land on top of each other. On the graph, the line grazes the bottom of the parabola instead of cutting it.
Put the three buckets against the picture from two slides back and they become obvious: a line above the axis cuts the parabola twice, a line at the axis touches once, and a line below the axis misses entirely.
Prediction
Commit to an answer before you reason about it. This question separates two claims that people routinely merge, and merging them is what produces half-answers.
Predict first
How many real square roots does 9 have, and what does the radical symbol in front of it denote?
Correct: Two roots, 3 and negative 3, and the symbol denotes only the positive one
Why: Nine has two square roots because both 3 and negative 3 square to it. The radical symbol is a convention that names the principal, that is the positive, root only. Both halves matter: the first is why a solved equation has two answers, and the second is why you have to write the plus or minus in yourself.
The tempting wrong answer is the one saying the symbol denotes both. If it did, the plus-or-minus would be redundant, and you would never need to write it. Textbooks would look very different.
There is a practical reason for the convention. If the radical sign meant a pair, then every formula containing one would be ambiguous, and an expression like the root of two plus the root of three would name four different numbers.
So the symbol is deliberately made single-valued, and the cost of that choice is paid once, in the plus-or-minus you write when you solve. It is a small price for a symbol that behaves.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 266 — the principal square root
Section
Part 2
Concept
Answers in this lesson are radicals, so you need a way to tidy them. Two properties do all the work, and both hold whenever the radicands are not negative.
\[ \sqrt{ab} = \sqrt{a}\cdot\sqrt{b}, \qquad \sqrt{\dfrac{a}{b}} = \dfrac{\sqrt{a}}{\sqrt{b}} \qquad (a \ge 0, \; b > 0) \]
Read left to right and each property breaks one radical into two, which is how you pull a perfect square out of a radicand. Read right to left and each joins two radicals into one, which is how you multiply two roots together.
\[ \sqrt{18} = \sqrt{9}\cdot\sqrt{2} = 3\sqrt{2}, \qquad \sqrt{\dfrac{2}{25}} = \dfrac{\sqrt{2}}{\sqrt{25}} = \dfrac{\sqrt{2}}{5} \]
Those are the book's own two examples, and they show the two directions you will use most. In the first, nine came out as a whole three. In the second, the denominator resolved completely and the numerator did not.
One warning that will come back in Part 2's trap. There is no such property for sums. The root of a sum is not the sum of the roots, and no amount of wishing makes it one.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 266 — the Key Concept box, Properties of Square Roots
Picture it
Pulling a square factor out of a radicand can feel like symbol-shuffling. It is not: it is a statement about a shape, and the shape makes the rule obvious.
Figure (svg): A large square divided into a four by four grid of sixteen equal tiles, each labelled 5, beside a single tile of the same size labelled area 5 with side root 5; the large square is labelled area 80 with side 4 root 5.
The big square holds eighty square units, so its side is the root of eighty. The small tile holds five square units, so its side is the root of five. Sixteen tiles fill the big square exactly.
Now count along one edge. Four tiles lie along it, so the big side is four times the small side. In symbols that reads as the root of eighty equalling four times the root of five, which is the answer you get algebraically.
Notice which number came out through the radical sign and which did not. Sixteen came out as four, because sixteen is a perfect square and four is its root. Five stayed inside, because five is not.
The reason for preferring the largest square factor also shows up here. Take out four instead of sixteen and you get two tiles across a picture that still splits further, which is a job half done.
Concept
The book is precise about when a square-root expression counts as finished, and there are two conditions, not one. An answer that satisfies only the first is not yet an answer.
The first condition is handled by the product property, splitting the largest square factor off the radicand. The second is handled by rationalising, which is the whole of Part 3.
A quick way to test the first condition on a radicand you have reached: divide it by 4, then 9, then 16, then 25, and see whether any of them goes in exactly. If none does, you are done.
It is worth being clear about what simplifying is for, because it does not make the answer more correct. Two root fifty-six and four root fourteen are the same number. The convention exists so that two people solving the same problem write the same thing down and can compare.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 266 — the two conditions for a simplified square-root expression
Worked example
Two expressions, one idea. In the first there is a single radical to break up. In the second there are two radicals to join before there is anything to break up at all.
\[ \text{Simplify } \sqrt{80} \quad\text{and}\quad \sqrt{6}\cdot\sqrt{21} \]
Find the largest perfect-square factor of 80
Why: the perfect squares are 1, 4, 9, 16, 25, 36, 49, 64; of those, 4 and 16 divide 80, and 16 is the larger.
\[ 80 = 16 \cdot 5 \]
Split the radical with the product property
Why: the root of a product is the product of the roots, so the sixteen can be dealt with on its own.
\[ \sqrt{80} = \sqrt{16}\cdot\sqrt{5} \]
Take the root of the perfect square
Why: sixteen is four squared, so its root leaves the radical as a plain 4; five has no square factor, so it stays inside.
\[ \sqrt{80} = 4\sqrt{5} \]
That is the first part finished. Four root five is about 8.944, and so is the root of eighty, which is a useful thing to notice: nothing has been made smaller, only tidier.
For the second, combine the two radicals first
Why: the product property read from right to left turns two roots into one, so that there is a single radicand to examine.
\[ \sqrt{6}\cdot\sqrt{21} = \sqrt{126} \]
Split 126 at its largest square factor
Why: 126 is 9 times 14, and 14 has no square factor left, so this is as far as it goes.
\[ \sqrt{126} = \sqrt{9}\cdot\sqrt{14} = 3\sqrt{14} \]
The second part used the property in both directions, first to combine and then to split. That is the usual rhythm whenever a question hands you a product of two radicals.
Check by squaring both answers back
Why: squaring a simplified radical should rebuild the original radicand exactly, which is the only check worth running here.
\[ (4\sqrt{5})^2 = 16 \cdot 5 = 80, \qquad (3\sqrt{14})^2 = 9 \cdot 14 = 126 \]
Both rebuild the number they came from, so both are right. Squaring back is quick, exact, and catches the commonest slip of all, which is losing the whole number that came out of the radical.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 266 — Example 1, parts a and b
Worked example
Now two fractions under a radical sign. The quotient property splits each one into a fraction of two radicals, after which you treat the top and bottom separately.
\[ \text{Simplify } \sqrt{\dfrac{4}{81}} \quad\text{and}\quad \sqrt{\dfrac{7}{16}} \]
Split the first with the quotient property
Why: the root of a quotient is the quotient of the roots, so the 4 and the 81 can be rooted independently.
\[ \sqrt{\dfrac{4}{81}} = \dfrac{\sqrt{4}}{\sqrt{81}} \]
Take both roots
Why: 4 is 2 squared and 81 is 9 squared, so both radicals disappear and no radical is left anywhere.
\[ \sqrt{\dfrac{4}{81}} = \dfrac{2}{9} \]
Figure (svg): A nine by nine gridded square of area 81 with a shaded two by two square of area 4 sitting in its lower left corner; the sides 9 and 2 are marked.
The picture is the answer, drawn. The small square holds four units of area inside a big square holding eighty-one, and their sides are two and nine, which is the ratio the algebra produced.
Split the second the same way
Why: the method does not change just because one of the two numbers is not a perfect square.
\[ \sqrt{\dfrac{7}{16}} = \dfrac{\sqrt{7}}{\sqrt{16}} = \dfrac{\sqrt{7}}{4} \]
Here only the denominator resolved, and a radical survives on top. That is perfectly acceptable: the two conditions forbid a radical on the bottom, and say nothing at all about the top.
Check by squaring both answers back
Why: squaring a fraction squares the top and the bottom separately, and each should rebuild its own original number.
\[ \left(\dfrac{2}{9}\right)^2 = \dfrac{4}{81}, \qquad \left(\dfrac{\sqrt{7}}{4}\right)^2 = \dfrac{7}{16} \]
Both come back exactly. Notice that squaring the root of seven simply gives seven, which is the definition of a square root doing its job, and is the check you will use for the rest of the deck.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 266 — Example 1, parts c and d
Worked example
Three of the book's checkpoint items, worked in the order they appear. Each is one decision: which perfect square divides the radicand.
\[ \text{Simplify } \sqrt{27}, \quad \sqrt{98}, \quad \sqrt{10}\cdot\sqrt{15} \]
Split 27 at its square factor
Why: 27 is 9 times 3; 9 is a perfect square and 3 has no square factor, so one pass finishes it.
\[ \sqrt{27} = \sqrt{9}\cdot\sqrt{3} = 3\sqrt{3} \]
Ninety-eight looks unfriendly, but it is even, so halve it and keep halving: 98, 49, and there is the perfect square. Hunting for the factor by halving is faster than testing squares one at a time.
Split 98 at its square factor
Why: 98 is 49 times 2, and 49 is 7 squared, so a whole 7 comes out.
\[ \sqrt{98} = \sqrt{49}\cdot\sqrt{2} = 7\sqrt{2} \]
Combine the third pair before splitting
Why: ten and fifteen have no square factors on their own, so there is nothing to do until they are joined.
\[ \sqrt{10}\cdot\sqrt{15} = \sqrt{150} \]
Multiplying first is what makes the square factor appear. Ten contributes a 5 and fifteen contributes another, and the pair of fives is exactly the twenty-five that comes out.
Split 150 at its largest square factor
Why: 150 is 25 times 6, and 6 is 2 times 3 with no repeats, so it stays under the sign.
\[ \sqrt{150} = \sqrt{25}\cdot\sqrt{6} = 5\sqrt{6} \]
Check by squaring all three back
Why: each square should rebuild the radicand it started from, including the combined one.
\[ (3\sqrt3)^2 = 27, \quad (7\sqrt2)^2 = 98, \quad (5\sqrt6)^2 = 150 \]
All three rebuild correctly. If a check ever comes back with a number that is too small by a square factor, you have forgotten to square the whole number sitting in front of the radical.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 266 — Guided Practice 1, 2 and 3
Fill the middle
This one rewards combining first. Neither radicand has a square factor worth much on its own, and together they produce a large one.
Fill in the blanks
\sqrt4\cdot\sqrt___ = \sqrt___ = \sqrt___\cdot\sqrt___ = ___\sqrt___
Why: Eight times twenty-eight is 224, whose largest perfect-square factor is 16, and the root of 16 is 4. So the answer is 4 root 14, which is about 14.967. Check by squaring back: 4 squared is 16, times 14 is 224, which is the radicand you started from.
Watch what would happen if you split each radical before multiplying. Root eight becomes two root two and root twenty-eight becomes two root seven, giving four root fourteen straight away. Same answer, slightly more writing.
Both routes are fine, and it is worth being able to run either. Combining first is usually quicker when the numbers are small; splitting first is usually quicker when they are large and awkward to multiply.
The number to be careful with is 224 itself. Its square factors are 4 and 16, and stopping at 4 leaves two root fifty-six, which still has a square factor hiding inside it. That is the subject of the next slide.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 266 — Guided Practice 4
Error analysis
This is the book's own error-analysis exercise, and the interesting thing about it is that nothing illegal happens. Every line is true. The work is simply not finished.
Annotate
On: \( \sqrt{96} = \sqrt{4}\cdot\sqrt{24} = 2\sqrt{24} \)
\[ \sqrt{96} = \sqrt{16}\cdot\sqrt{6} = 4\sqrt{6} \]
Figure (svg): A tree from 224 splitting two ways. The left route splits it as 4 times 56, then has to split 56 again as 4 times 14. The right route splits it as 16 times 14 and finishes at once. Both routes reach 4 root 14.
The tree is for 224 rather than 96, but it is the same shape of mistake. The left-hand route takes 4 and has to come back for a second pass; the right-hand route takes 16 and is finished.
Both routes end in the same place, so this is not a matter of right and wrong. It is a matter of whether you notice that you have stopped early, and the test for that is always the same question: does the radicand still have a square factor?
A habit that avoids the whole problem: before splitting anything, check the radicand against 4, 9, 16, 25, 36, 49 and 64 from the top down and use the first one that divides it exactly.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 270 — Exercise 20
Matching
Four expressions, four answers. Do not compute all four: find the largest square factor of each radicand and the matching becomes almost instant.
Match the pairs
Why: Eighty is 16 times 5, so a 4 comes out. Twenty-seven is 9 times 3, so a 3 comes out. Ninety-eight is 49 times 2, so a 7 comes out. The product of root ten and root fifteen is the root of 150, which is 25 times 6, so a 5 comes out. In every case the whole number in front is the root of the perfect-square factor.
There is a shortcut for checking a match without doing the algebra again. Square the whole number in front, multiply by whatever is left under the radical, and you should get the original radicand back.
Try it on the pairing that gives three root three. Three squared is nine, times the three inside is twenty-seven, which is what you started with. That takes about two seconds per pair.
Notice how differently the four radicands behave. Two of them were nearly a perfect square already, one needed halving twice to find its factor, and one had no factor at all until it was multiplied by its partner.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 266 — Guided Practice 1 to 4
Worked example
Four fractions under a radical, which between them show every way the quotient property can end. Watch which of the two numbers is a perfect square in each case.
\[ \text{Simplify } \sqrt{\tfrac{9}{64}}, \quad \sqrt{\tfrac{15}{4}}, \quad \sqrt{\tfrac{11}{25}}, \quad \sqrt{\tfrac{36}{49}} \]
Split the first and take both roots
Why: 9 is 3 squared and 64 is 8 squared, so both radicals vanish and nothing is left under a sign.
\[ \sqrt{\dfrac{9}{64}} = \dfrac{\sqrt{9}}{\sqrt{64}} = \dfrac{3}{8} \]
Split the second; only the bottom resolves
Why: 15 is 3 times 5 with no square factor, so its radical survives, while 4 becomes a plain 2.
\[ \sqrt{\dfrac{15}{4}} = \dfrac{\sqrt{15}}{2} \]
Stop and check that second answer against the two conditions. Fifteen has no square factor, so the first is met, and the denominator is a plain 2, so the second is met. It is finished, radical and all.
Split the third the same way
Why: 11 is prime and 25 is 5 squared, so again only the denominator comes out.
\[ \sqrt{\dfrac{11}{25}} = \dfrac{\sqrt{11}}{5} \]
Split the fourth; both resolve again
Why: 36 is 6 squared and 49 is 7 squared, so this one lands on a plain fraction.
\[ \sqrt{\dfrac{36}{49}} = \dfrac{6}{7} \]
Two of the four came out with no radical at all and two kept one on top. That is the whole range of outcomes when the denominator is already a perfect square, which is the easy case.
Check by squaring all four back
Why: squaring a fraction squares top and bottom, and each should return the fraction you started with.
\[ \left(\tfrac38\right)^2 = \tfrac{9}{64}, \; \left(\tfrac{\sqrt{15}}{2}\right)^2 = \tfrac{15}{4}, \; \left(\tfrac{\sqrt{11}}{5}\right)^2 = \tfrac{11}{25}, \; \left(\tfrac67\right)^2 = \tfrac{36}{49} \]
All four rebuild exactly. Notice how painless these were compared with the ones coming next, and the reason is simply that every denominator here was already a perfect square.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 266 — Guided Practice 5, 6, 7 and 8
Trap
The product property is so useful that people reach for it on sums as well:
\[ \sqrt{9 + 16} = \sqrt{9} + \sqrt{16} \]
It looks like the same move, and the symbols certainly come apart just as neatly.
Work both sides out, though. The left is the root of 25, which is 5. The right is 3 plus 4, which is 7.
There is no property for sums, and there is not going to be one. The two properties are about products and quotients only.
\[ \sqrt{9 + 16} = \sqrt{25} = 5 \]
Add first, then take the root. A radical sign over a sum means the whole sum is the radicand, and the plus inside has to be done before anything leaves the sign.
The same warning covers subtraction. Whenever a radicand contains a plus or a minus, finish the arithmetic underneath before you look for square factors at all.
Sorting
Each expression below is a correct number. The question is whether it is written in finished form, so test both conditions on every one: no square factor left in a radicand, and no radical in a denominator.
Sort into buckets
Sort each expression by whether it is fully simplified.
Two root fifty-six is the instructive one among the unfinished three, because it has clearly been worked on already. Somebody split 224 using the factor 4 and stopped, which is the error from the previous slide arriving in a different disguise.
Notice that two of the six are equal to two others. The root of eighty is four root five, and root five over root two is root ten over two. Being unsimplified never means being wrong; it means being written in a form the convention does not accept.
If you found yourself computing decimal values to sort these, try again using only the two conditions. They are a checklist, and the checklist is faster and more reliable than arithmetic.
Estimation
Exercise 24 will ask you to solve x squared equals eighty-four. Before any algebra, get a feel for the size of the answer, because a rough value is how you catch a wrong one later.
Predict first
Without a calculator, which range does the square root of 84 fall in?
Correct: Between 9 and 10
Why: Nine squared is 81 and ten squared is 100, and 84 sits between them, much closer to 81. So the root is a little over 9, and in fact it is about 9.17. The range from 41 to 42 is the classic slip of halving instead of rooting, which would be the answer to a very different question.
Trapping a root between the two perfect squares on either side is worth doing every time. It costs a few seconds and it tells you immediately whether a calculator answer has a misplaced decimal point.
\[ 9^2 = 81 < 84 < 100 = 10^2 \;\Longrightarrow\; 9 < \sqrt{84} < 10 \]
Now simplify it properly. Eighty-four is 4 times 21, so the root of eighty-four is two root twenty-one, and twenty-one has no square factor, so that is the finished form.
Check the two against each other. The root of twenty-one is about 4.583, and twice that is about 9.165, which sits exactly where the estimate said it would. The exact form and the estimate agree, which is the point of doing both.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 270 — Exercise 24
Section
Part 3
Concept
The second condition for a simplified expression forbids a radical in a denominator. Meeting it is a named operation with a named tool, and the tool is a fraction equal to one.
rationalising the denominator — Rewriting a fraction so that no radical remains on the bottom, by multiplying the numerator and the denominator by the same carefully chosen expression.
The move is always legal, and for a reason worth saying out loud. Multiplying the top and the bottom by the same thing is multiplying the whole fraction by one, and multiplying by one cannot change a value.
Figure (svg): A number line from zero to two with two marked points, each carrying two labels: the point at about 0.707 is labelled one over root two above and root two over two below, and the point at about 1.581 is labelled root five over root two above and root ten over two below.
The picture makes the point better than any argument. Each pair of labels names a single point on the line, so rationalising has changed the spelling of a number and left the number alone.
Which raises a fair question: why bother? Partly convention, so that two people write the same answer, and partly practicality. Dividing by 2 is something you can do in your head; dividing by 1.414 is not.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 267 — Rationalizing the Denominator
Worked example
The book's first rationalising example. Notice that the fraction starts life under a single radical sign, so the first job is to get a denominator at all.
\[ \text{Simplify } \sqrt{\dfrac{5}{2}} \]
Split with the quotient property
Why: the root of a quotient is the quotient of the roots, which turns one radical into a fraction of two.
\[ \sqrt{\dfrac{5}{2}} = \dfrac{\sqrt{5}}{\sqrt{2}} \]
This line is correct but not finished. There is now a radical in the denominator, which the second condition forbids, so there is one more move to make.
Multiply the top and the bottom by the root of 2
Why: because the root of 2 times itself is a plain 2, which is exactly the radical-free denominator you want.
\[ \dfrac{\sqrt{5}}{\sqrt{2}} = \dfrac{\sqrt{5}}{\sqrt{2}}\cdot\dfrac{\sqrt{2}}{\sqrt{2}} \]
Multiply out the top and the bottom
Why: the top becomes the root of 10 by the product property; the bottom becomes the root of 2 squared, which is 2.
\[ = \dfrac{\sqrt{10}}{2} \]
Check the answer against both conditions before accepting it. Ten is 2 times 5, with no repeated factor, so no square divides it; and the denominator is a plain 2. Both met, so it is finished.
Check that the value did not move
Why: compare the starting expression with the answer as decimals; multiplying by a fraction equal to one must leave the number exactly where it was.
\[ \dfrac{\sqrt5}{\sqrt2} \approx 1.5811, \qquad \dfrac{\sqrt{10}}{2} \approx 1.5811 \]
They agree, as they were bound to. So the real check here is on the arithmetic, not on the legality: rationalising can never change a value, but it can easily be carried out carelessly.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 267 — Example 2, part a
Comparison
The book gives a small table for this, and it is worth filling in yourself rather than reading. In every row, ask what you would have to multiply the denominator by to leave a plain rational number.
Comparison matrix
| denominator looks like | multiply top and bottom by | the denominator becomes |
|---|---|---|
| √b | sqrt(b) | b |
| a + √b | a − √b | a^2 - b |
| a − √b | a + sqrt(b) | a² − b |
| 7 + √2 | 7 − √2 | 47 |
The first row is the easy one: a lone radical squares to its own radicand, so multiplying by itself is enough. The other two need a partner that kills the radical rather than doubling it.
Multiplying a plus a radical by itself would be a mistake worth naming now. It gives a squared, plus two a times the radical, plus b, and the middle term still carries a radical, so nothing has been cleared.
conjugates — The two expressions a plus the root of b, and a minus the root of b. They are conjugates of each other, and their product is always a rational number, namely a squared minus b.
The bottom row is the denominator from the example coming next, with the numbers already in it. Forty-nine minus two is forty-seven, and there is not a radical in sight.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 267 — the table of denominator forms and the definition of conjugates
Picture it
The conjugate trick can look like something you simply have to remember. It is not: it is the difference of two squares, which you met in Lesson 4.3, and one box diagram shows exactly where the radical goes.
Figure (svg): A two by two box model for seven plus root two, multiplied by seven minus root two. The four cells hold 49, plus seven root two, minus seven root two and minus two; the two middle cells are struck through because they cancel.
Multiply the two brackets by filling in the four cells. Seven times seven gives forty-nine. Seven times the negative root of two gives minus seven root two. The root of two times seven gives plus seven root two. And the root of two times the negative root of two gives minus two.
Now look at the two cells in the middle. They are the same size with opposite signs, so they cancel exactly, and the only reason they cancel is that the two brackets differ in exactly one sign.
What survives is forty-nine minus two, a plain forty-seven. Every radical has gone, which is the entire purpose of choosing the conjugate rather than any other multiplier.
It is worth writing the middle terms down rather than cancelling them in your head, at least for the first few. The book writes them out in full in Example 2, and so should you until the cancellation is automatic.
Worked example
Now a denominator that is a sum. Multiplying by the root of two alone will not help here, as the error-analysis slide in a moment shows, so the conjugate is the tool.
\[ \text{Simplify } \dfrac{3}{7 + \sqrt{2}} \]
Write down the conjugate of the denominator
Why: the conjugate keeps the same two terms and flips the sign between them, so it is seven minus the root of two.
\[ 7 + \sqrt{2} \;\longrightarrow\; 7 - \sqrt{2} \]
Multiply the top and the bottom by that conjugate
Why: this is multiplication by a fraction equal to one, so the value is untouched.
\[ \dfrac{3}{7 + \sqrt{2}}\cdot\dfrac{7 - \sqrt{2}}{7 - \sqrt{2}} \]
Multiply out, writing the bottom in full
Why: three lots of seven minus the root of two on top; on the bottom, all four products, so that you can see the middle pair.
\[ = \dfrac{21 - 3\sqrt{2}}{49 - 7\sqrt{2} + 7\sqrt{2} - 2} \]
Resist the urge to tidy the bottom in your head. Writing out all four terms is what makes the cancellation visible, and it is also what stops you accidentally squaring the seven and the root of two separately.
Cancel the two middle terms and subtract
Why: minus seven root two and plus seven root two are exact opposites; forty-nine minus two leaves forty-seven.
\[ = \dfrac{21 - 3\sqrt{2}}{47} \]
The numerator still contains a radical, and that is fine. Only the denominator was ever the problem, and twenty-one and three share a factor of three but forty-seven is prime, so nothing cancels further.
Check that the value did not move
Why: compare the original and the answer as decimals; they must agree, because only the spelling changed.
\[ \dfrac{3}{7+\sqrt2} \approx 0.3565, \qquad \dfrac{21-3\sqrt2}{47} \approx 0.3565 \]
They agree to four places. The second form is the one you would rather hand to somebody, because the arithmetic in it is a division by forty-seven rather than a division by an irrational number.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 267 — Example 2, part b
Fill the middle
The cancellation at the heart of Example 2 is worth doing once on its own, away from the rest of the problem. Fill in what the denominator collapses to.
Fill in the blanks
(7 + \sqrt47)(7 - \sqrt___) = 49 - 7\sqrt___ + 7\sqrt___ - 2 = ___
Why: The two middle terms are exact opposites and cancel, leaving 49 minus 2, which is 47. That cancellation is the whole reason the conjugate is the right multiplier: any other choice would leave a radical behind in the middle.
Notice that the answer, forty-seven, is a whole number rather than merely a number without radicals. That is what the difference of two squares always gives you when both a and b are whole numbers.
You can shortcut the whole line once you trust it. The product of a plus the root of b with a minus the root of b is a squared minus b, so here it is forty-nine minus two directly.
Do write the middle terms out while you are learning, though. The shortcut is only safe once you can see why the middle terms vanish, and that comes from having watched them vanish a few times.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 267 — Example 2, part b, the denominator
Error analysis
Here is the mistake the conjugate exists to prevent. A student has taken the rule that worked for a lone radical and applied it to a denominator with two terms.
Annotate
On: \( \dfrac{3}{7+\sqrt2}\cdot\dfrac{\sqrt2}{\sqrt2} = \dfrac{3\sqrt2}{7\sqrt2+2} \)
\[ \dfrac{3}{7+\sqrt{2}}\cdot\dfrac{7-\sqrt{2}}{7-\sqrt{2}} = \dfrac{21-3\sqrt{2}}{47} \]
The lesson is to read the shape of the denominator before choosing a multiplier, which is exactly what the table two slides ago was for. One term means multiply by itself; two terms mean multiply by the conjugate.
It is worth noticing that the wrong version is not false. Three root two over seven root two plus two really does equal the original fraction. It is just no more simplified than what you started with.
That makes this the same species of error as the one in Part 2: a legal move that does not finish the job. The test in both cases is to look at what you have written and ask whether either condition is still broken.
Fill the middle
Both of these start as a single radical over a fraction, so both need the quotient property first and then a rationalising step. Fill in the two answers.
Fill in the blanks
\sqrt304} = \dfrac___}___}\cdot\dfrac___}___} = \dfrac___}}}___, \qquad \sqrt______} = \dfrac______}\cdot\dfrac___}___} = \dfrac___}___}
Why: For the first, root six times root five is root thirty, and root five times root five is five, so the answer is root thirty over five, about 1.095. For the second, root nine over root eight is three over two root two; multiplying top and bottom by root two gives three root two over four, about 1.061.
The second one has a hidden extra step. The root of eight is not left as it is: eight is four times two, so the root of eight becomes two root two before any rationalising happens.
Simplifying the denominator first is worth doing every time, because it keeps the number you multiply by small. Multiplying by the root of eight instead of the root of two would work, but it would leave you cancelling an eight out of the answer afterwards.
Check both against the two conditions when you have them. Thirty is 2 times 3 times 5 with no repeats, and two has no square factor, so neither numerator can shrink further, and both denominators are whole numbers.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 268 — Guided Practice 9 and 10
Worked example
A conjugate problem where the answer can be tidied at the end. Watch for the common factor after the multiplication, because that is the step people skip.
\[ \text{Simplify } \dfrac{26}{7 - \sqrt{5}} \]
Write down the conjugate
Why: the denominator is a difference, so its conjugate is the matching sum, seven plus the root of five.
\[ 7 - \sqrt{5} \;\longrightarrow\; 7 + \sqrt{5} \]
Multiply the top and the bottom by it
Why: the numerator becomes twenty-six lots of the conjugate; leave it bracketed for now rather than expanding.
\[ \dfrac{26}{7-\sqrt{5}}\cdot\dfrac{7+\sqrt{5}}{7+\sqrt{5}} = \dfrac{26\left(7+\sqrt{5}\right)}{49 - 5} \]
Leaving the numerator as a product rather than expanding it is a deliberate choice here. It makes the common factor in the next step visible, and expanding first would hide it behind two separate terms.
Work out the denominator
Why: forty-nine minus five is forty-four, so the radical is gone from the bottom.
\[ = \dfrac{26\left(7+\sqrt{5}\right)}{44} \]
Cancel the common factor of 2
Why: twenty-six and forty-four are both even, so the fraction is not yet in lowest terms.
\[ = \dfrac{13\left(7+\sqrt{5}\right)}{22} \]
Reducing does not affect whether the expression counts as simplified in the radical sense, but it is still expected. An answer left over forty-four with a twenty-six on top looks unfinished for the same reason six over eight does.
Check that the value did not move
Why: compare the original and the answer as decimals to four places.
\[ \dfrac{26}{7-\sqrt{5}} \approx 5.4577, \qquad \dfrac{13\left(7+\sqrt{5}\right)}{22} \approx 5.4577 \]
They agree. Notice also that the answer came out larger than five, which is what you should expect: the original divides twenty-six by about 4.76, so an answer near five and a half is the right size.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 268 — Guided Practice 13
Matching
Four denominators. Do not rationalise any of them: just read the shape of each one and choose what you would multiply the top and bottom by.
Match the pairs
Why: A lone radical is multiplied by itself, because it then squares to its own radicand. A sum or a difference of a whole number and a radical is multiplied by its conjugate, which flips the middle sign so the cross terms cancel. The denominator root twelve is a lone radical too, but simplify it first: root twelve is two root three, so you only need to multiply by root three, not by root twelve.
The pairing for root twelve is the one that separates careful work from mechanical work. Multiplying by the root of twelve does clear the denominator, but it leaves a factor of twelve to cancel afterwards, which is avoidable effort.
Say the rule to yourself in two halves. One term on the bottom means multiply by that term. Two terms on the bottom mean flip the middle sign and multiply by that.
Nothing here required arithmetic, and that is the point. Choosing the multiplier is a reading task, and getting it right before you start is what keeps the calculation short.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 267 — the table of denominator forms
Prediction
A calculator handles one over the root of two just as happily as the root of two over two. So the convention needs a defence. Commit to one before reading on.
Predict first
Why is rationalising the denominator still expected, given that a calculator does not care?
Correct: It gives everyone the same written form, and it makes hand computation easier
Why: Rationalising cannot change a value, because it multiplies by a fraction equal to one, so the claim that the two expressions differ in value is false, and nothing about a denominator makes a radical undefined. What it buys you is a single agreed form, so two correct answers look alike and can be compared, and a division by a whole number instead of by an irrational one.
The hand-computation argument was overwhelming before calculators. To work out one over the root of two you would need long division by 1.41421356. To work out the root of two over two you halve 1.41421356, which anyone can do.
The comparison argument still bites today. If one student writes root five over root two and another writes root ten over two, neither is wrong, and a marker has to do work to see that they agree. The convention removes that work.
There is a third reason you will meet later in the year. Expressions with rational denominators add and compare far more easily, which matters as soon as you start combining several radicals in one calculation.
Section
Part 4
Concept
Everything in Parts 2 and 3 was preparation. Here is the method itself, and it is shorter than the tidying that follows it.
If a quadratic equation has no first-power term, then the unknown appears only inside a square. Collect the constants, divide out the coefficient, and you are left with a square equal to a number.
\[ 3x^2 + 5 = 41 \;\Longrightarrow\; 3x^2 = 36 \;\Longrightarrow\; x^2 = 12 \]
Now take square roots of both sides, writing the plus-or-minus in as you go, because the equation has two answers and the radical sign will only supply one of them.
\[ x^2 = 12 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = \pm\sqrt{12} = \pm 2\sqrt{3} \]
Compare the reach of this method with factoring. It is narrower, because it needs the equation to be a square equal to a number, and there is no hope of applying it to something with a plain x term in it.
It is also wider, in the way that matters most. Factoring can only find answers that are whole numbers or fractions; taking roots does not care, and here it hands you an irrational answer without complaint.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 267 — Solving Quadratic Equations
Worked example
The book's own example, and the one from the warm-up that factoring could not touch. Two moves to isolate the square, then the root, then the tidying.
\[ 3x^2 + 5 = 41 \]
Subtract 5 from each side
Why: the 5 is added to the term carrying the square, so it comes off first, exactly as in any linear equation.
\[ 3x^2 = 36 \]
Divide each side by 3
Why: 3 multiplies the square, so dividing leaves the square standing completely alone, which is the shape the method needs.
\[ x^2 = 12 \]
Take square roots of each side
Why: both a positive and a negative number square to 12, so the plus-or-minus is written in here, in the same stroke as the radical.
\[ x = \pm\sqrt{12} \]
This line is already a correct answer. What follows is presentation: twelve has a square factor, so the radical is not yet in the form the convention asks for.
Split the radical at its square factor
Why: twelve is 4 times 3, and 4 is a perfect square, so a 2 comes out from under the sign.
\[ x = \pm\sqrt{4}\cdot\sqrt{3} = \pm 2\sqrt{3} \]
Figure (svg): The parabola y equals x squared with a horizontal dashed line at y equals 12 cutting it at about minus 3.46 and 3.46, the two solutions of x squared equals 12.
The graph is the answer drawn. The line at height twelve cuts the parabola in two places, at about 3.46 either side of the middle, and those are the two numbers the algebra just produced.
Check both solutions by substituting them back
Why: the book runs this check itself; squaring erases the sign, so the two columns of arithmetic are identical.
\[ 3\left(2\sqrt3\right)^2 + 5 = 3(12) + 5 = 41, \qquad 3\left(-2\sqrt3\right)^2 + 5 = 3(12) + 5 = 41 \]
Both give forty-one, so both are genuine solutions. The check also shows why forgetting the negative root is so easy to get away with: the negative one satisfies the equation just as exactly, and nothing in the arithmetic complains when you leave it out.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 267 — Example 3, with the book's own check
Ranking
Before doing more equations, settle the order of the moves, because doing them in the wrong order is what turns a two-line problem into a mess.
\[ 5x^2 - 7 = 73 \]
Put in order
Put these moves in the order that solves an equation with no first-power term.
Why: Work from the outside in. The constant was added last, so it comes off first; then the coefficient of the square; only when the square stands completely alone can you take roots of both sides. Simplifying and rationalising are presentation, so they come after the mathematics is done, and the check is always last.
Run the order on the equation above and see how short it is. Add seven to get five x squared equal to eighty, divide by five to get x squared equal to sixteen, take roots to get x equal to plus or minus four.
The tempting wrong order is to take roots before the square is alone. Rooting both sides of five x squared equal to eighty gives the root of five times x on the left, which is legal and much more awkward than dividing first.
The last move looks like an afterthought and is not. For the equations in Part 5 the variable is still trapped inside a bracket after the root is taken, so there is always one more step before the answer is readable.
Notice that two of the five moves are about how the answer looks rather than what it is. That proportion is typical of this lesson: the method is short, and the tidying is where most of the writing goes.
Tweak it
The plot shows y equal to x squared minus s. Wherever that curve crosses the horizontal axis, x squared equals s, so the crossings are the solutions of the equation you are solving.
Parameter explorer
Set the number to 9 and read off the two crossings. Then bring it down to 0, and then to a negative value, and say in each case how many real solutions the equation has.
\[ y = x^2 - {s} \]
Watch the two crossings as you raise the number. They slide apart, and they always move by equal amounts in opposite directions, because the curve is a mirror image about the vertical axis.
Watch how fast they move as well. Going from one to four moves each crossing from 1 to 2, and going from four to nine moves it from 2 to 3. Quadrupling the number only doubles the answer, which is the square root at work.
The moment the number passes below zero the picture changes character entirely. The curve lifts off the axis, there is nothing to cross, and the equation has no real solution. That is the third bucket from the sorting slide in Part 1, in motion.
Trap
This is the book's other error-analysis exercise, and it is three lines long:
\[ 5x^2 = 405 \]
\[ x^2 = 81 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 9 \]
The first move is right and the arithmetic is right: eighty-one really is four hundred and five divided by five.
Eighty-one has two square roots, and only one of them was written down.
\[ x = \pm 9 \]
Test the missing one. Negative nine squared is eighty-one, and five times eighty-one is four hundred and five, so it satisfies the equation just as exactly as nine does.
This slip is common because nothing goes wrong when you make it. The answer you keep is genuinely a solution, so no arithmetic contradiction ever appears to warn you. The only guard is the habit of writing both signs as you take the root.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 270 — Exercise 21
Fill the middle
The method is done by the time you reach x squared equal to twelve. These blanks are the tidying that turns a correct line into a presentable answer.
Fill in the blanks
x^2 = 12 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = \pm\sqrt4 = \pm\sqrt2} }\cdot\sqrt___ = \pm ___\sqrt___
Why: Twelve splits as 4 times 3, and 4 is the largest perfect-square factor, so the root of 4 comes out as a 2 and the 3 stays under the sign. The answer is plus or minus two root three, about 3.46 either way. Check by squaring: 2 squared times 3 is 12, as required.
The other square factor of twelve is one, which is no help at all, so there is only one useful split here. That is what makes this an easy case: often you have to choose between two candidates.
Keep an eye on where the plus-or-minus lives through all three lines. It is written once, when the root is taken, and then carried along unchanged, because simplifying a radical never touches the sign in front of it.
Get a decimal as well, at least in your head. Root three is about 1.732, so the answers are about 3.46 and about minus 3.46, and those are the crossings you saw on the graph two slides back.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 267 — Example 3, the last two lines
Worked example
Two quick checkpoints from the book. Both land on perfect squares, so the radical disappears entirely and the answers are whole numbers.
\[ \text{Solve } 5x^2 = 80 \quad\text{and}\quad z^2 - 7 = 29 \]
Divide the first by 5
Why: the square is already alone apart from its coefficient, so a single division isolates it.
\[ x^2 = 16 \]
Take square roots of each side
Why: sixteen is a perfect square, so both roots are whole numbers, and both signs are written.
\[ x = \pm 4 \]
Notice there was nothing to simplify. That happens whenever the number the square equals turns out to be a perfect square, and it is the one case where the answer looks like something factoring would have given you.
Add 7 to each side of the second
Why: the 7 is subtracted from the squared term, so adding it undoes that and leaves the square alone.
\[ z^2 = 36 \]
Take square roots of each side
Why: thirty-six is six squared, so the two answers are six and negative six.
\[ z = \pm 6 \]
Compare the two problems for a moment. One needed a division and one needed an addition, and they needed them for the same reason: whatever was attached to the square had to be taken off before the root could be taken.
Check all four values in the original equations
Why: substitute each into the equation it came from; squaring erases the sign, so the two values in each pair give identical arithmetic.
\[ 5(\pm 4)^2 = 5(16) = 80, \qquad (\pm 6)^2 - 7 = 36 - 7 = 29 \]
Both equations are satisfied by both of their solutions. Writing the check with the plus-or-minus still in place is honest here, precisely because the squaring makes the sign irrelevant.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 268 — Guided Practice 17 and 18
Worked example
Two from the exercise set where the number the square equals is not a perfect square, so the tidying from Part 2 comes straight back into use.
\[ \text{Solve } 4p^2 = 448 \quad\text{and}\quad \dfrac{t^2}{20} + 8 = 15 \]
Divide the first by 4
Why: four multiplies the square, so dividing isolates it.
\[ p^2 = 112 \]
Take roots, then split 112 at its square factor
Why: 112 is 16 times 7, and 7 has no square factor, so a 4 comes out and the 7 stays in.
\[ p = \pm\sqrt{112} = \pm\sqrt{16}\cdot\sqrt{7} = \pm 4\sqrt{7} \]
It is worth checking that sixteen really is the largest square factor here. Four divides 112 as well, but using it would leave two root twenty-eight, and twenty-eight is still four times seven, so you would have to come back.
Subtract 8 from each side of the second
Why: the 8 is added to the term carrying the square, so it comes off first.
\[ \dfrac{t^2}{20} = 7 \]
Multiply each side by 20
Why: the square is divided by twenty, so multiplying by twenty undoes that in one move.
\[ t^2 = 140 \]
Take roots and split 140
Why: 140 is 4 times 35, and 35 is 5 times 7 with no repeats, so only a 2 comes out.
\[ t = \pm\sqrt{140} = \pm 2\sqrt{35} \]
Notice how differently the two coefficients behaved. In the first the square was multiplied, so you divided; in the second it was divided, so you multiplied. Same principle, opposite operation.
Check both answers by squaring back
Why: square each answer and rebuild the left-hand side of its own equation.
\[ 4\left(4\sqrt7\right)^2 = 4(112) = 448, \qquad \dfrac{\left(2\sqrt{35}\right)^2}{20} + 8 = \dfrac{140}{20} + 8 = 15 \]
Both rebuild their equations exactly. The second check is the more valuable one, because it exercises the division as well as the square, and a slip in the twenty would show up immediately.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 270 — Exercises 26 and 30
Prediction
Every equation so far reduced to a square equal to a positive number. Commit to what happens when it does not, before you look at the picture.
Predict first
You reduce an equation to x squared equals negative 9. What are its real solutions?
Correct: There are none, because no real number squares to a negative
Why: Squaring a positive number gives a positive, squaring a negative number also gives a positive, and squaring zero gives zero. So no real number at all produces a negative result, and the equation has no real solution. It is not an error in the working; it is a true fact about the equation.
Figure (svg): The parabola y equals x squared sitting entirely on or above the horizontal axis, with a dashed line at y equals minus 9 far below it; the two never meet.
The picture says the same thing geometrically. The parabola never goes below the horizontal axis, so a line drawn below the axis has nothing to cut, and there is no crossing to report.
Do not read this as a failure of the method. The method has done its job: it has reduced the equation as far as it goes and reported the truth, which is that no real number satisfies it.
Lesson 4.6 is where this stops being the end of the road. It builds a new kind of number whose square is negative, and with those numbers in hand, an equation like this one gets two solutions after all.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 267 — the condition that s is greater than zero
Counterexample
Reading a method backwards is the best test of whether you own it. Here you are given the number of answers and asked for an equation that produces it.
\[ \text{Write } x^2 = s \text{ with (a) two real solutions, (b) exactly one, (c) none.} \]
Discussion prompt
Give a value of s for each of the three cases, and say in one sentence what rule you used to choose it. Then check each by solving the equation you wrote.
The middle case is the one people hesitate over, because it feels like an exception to the rule that a square has two roots. It is not an exception, it is the boundary: the two roots have met in the middle, at zero.
Pair this with the picture from the previous slide. Positive s puts the line above the axis, so it cuts twice; zero puts it exactly on the axis, so it touches once; negative s puts it below, so it misses.
Being able to build an example to order is worth more than being able to solve ten equations. It means you can see the whole family at once rather than one member at a time.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 270 — Exercise 36
Section
Part 5
Concept
Nothing in the method cared that the thing being squared was a single letter. If it is a whole bracket, the same move works and there is one extra step at the end.
\[ \tfrac{1}{7}(z-2)^2 = 6 \;\Longrightarrow\; (z-2)^2 = 42 \;\Longrightarrow\; z - 2 = \pm\sqrt{42} \]
Read the last arrow carefully. Taking roots gives the whole bracket, not the letter inside it, so what you have is a linear equation to finish rather than an answer to write down.
Figure (svg): The parabola y equals the quantity x minus two, squared, with its lowest point at x equals two, a vertical dashed line at x equals two, and a horizontal dashed line at y equals about 13.33 cutting the curve at about minus 1.65 and 5.65.
The graph shows the change. The parabola has slid sideways so that its lowest point sits over two instead of over zero, and the horizontal line still cuts it in two places, symmetric about two.
That symmetry is the whole difference. In Part 4 the two answers were equally spaced about zero, so they were negatives of each other. Here they are equally spaced about two, so they are two plus and two minus the same amount.
This shape is not a curiosity: it is where Lesson 4.7 is heading. Completing the square manufactures a bracket squared out of any quadratic at all, and once you have one, this is the method you use.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 268 — Example 4
Worked example
The book sets this as a multiple-choice question, and the four options are close enough that you have to do the work properly. Clear the fraction first.
\[ \tfrac{1}{7}(z - 2)^2 = 6 \]
Multiply each side by 7
Why: the bracket squared is multiplied by one seventh, and multiplying by seven undoes that in one move.
\[ (z - 2)^2 = 42 \]
Multiplying by seven rather than dividing by one seventh is worth noticing. They are the same operation, and the multiplication is much easier to carry out without slipping.
Take square roots of each side
Why: the whole bracket is what was squared, so the whole bracket is what comes out, with a plus-or-minus in front of the radical.
\[ z - 2 = \pm\sqrt{42} \]
Check whether the radical simplifies
Why: 42 is 2 times 3 times 7, with no repeated factor, so no perfect square divides it and it stays as it is.
\[ \sqrt{42} \text{ has no square factor} \]
It is worth doing that check even when the answer is that nothing happens. Skipping it is how an unsimplified radical slips into a final answer, and the check costs one line.
Add 2 to each side
Why: this is an ordinary linear move, applied to both sides alike; the 2 joins the answer in front of the plus-or-minus, it does not go underneath the radical.
\[ z = 2 \pm \sqrt{42} \]
So the two solutions are two plus the root of forty-two, about 8.48, and two minus the root of forty-two, about minus 4.48. Both sit about 6.48 either side of two, which is the symmetry the graph showed.
Check by substituting the positive solution
Why: if z is two plus the root of forty-two, then z minus two is the root of forty-two, whose square is forty-two, and a seventh of that is six.
\[ \tfrac{1}{7}\left(2 + \sqrt{42} - 2\right)^2 = \tfrac{1}{7}\left(\sqrt{42}\right)^2 = \tfrac{42}{7} = 6 \]
The negative solution checks identically, because squaring erases the sign of the root of forty-two. That is why you only ever need to substitute one of a pair when the pair came from a plus-or-minus.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 268 — Example 4
Error analysis
Two mistakes in one short chain, and both of them look like ordinary algebra. Work out what has gone wrong before opening the notes.
Annotate
On: \( (z-2)^2 = 42 \;\Longrightarrow\; z - 2 = \sqrt{42} \;\Longrightarrow\; z = \sqrt{42} - 2 \)
\[ z = 2 \pm \sqrt{42} \]
The second error is the more interesting one, because it comes from a half-remembered rule about moving terms across. There is no such rule: there is only doing the same thing to both sides, and doing it here means adding two.
A quick guard against it: after isolating the variable, put a number in and see whether the original equation holds. That single substitution catches both mistakes at once.
Notice how the two errors interact. Dropping the plus-or-minus lost one answer, and mishandling the two corrupted the one that was left, so nothing survives. Errors in a chain do not cancel out, they accumulate.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 268 — Example 4, the last two lines
Fill the middle
The step that goes wrong most often in this part is the very last one, so practise it on its own. The root has already been taken; finish the job.
Fill in the blanks
z - 2 = \pm\sqrt2 \;\Longrightarrow\; z = ___ \pm \sqrt___
Why: The two is subtracted on the left, so adding two to each side moves it across as a plus two. The plus-or-minus stays attached to the radical and is untouched by the move. The answers are 2 plus root 42, about 8.48, and 2 minus root 42, about negative 4.48.
Read the answer aloud to be sure you have the structure right: two, plus or minus the root of forty-two. The two is the centre and the radical is the distance either side of it.
That reading is worth keeping, because it is how vertex form will be read in Lesson 4.7. The number outside the bracket tells you where the answers are centred, and the radical tells you how far apart they are.
One thing the plus-or-minus is not doing here: it is not attached to the two. Writing plus or minus two, plus or minus the root of forty-two would give four answers, and this equation has exactly two.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 268 — Example 4, the last line
Worked example
This is the example that uses everything in the deck so far. There is a coefficient to divide out, a fraction under a radical, a square factor to pull out and a denominator to rationalise.
\[ \text{Solve } 3(x - 2)^2 = 40 \]
Divide each side by 3
Why: three multiplies the bracket squared, so dividing isolates the square; the right-hand side becomes a fraction and that is fine.
\[ (x - 2)^2 = \dfrac{40}{3} \]
Take square roots of each side
Why: the whole bracket comes out, with the plus-or-minus written in as always.
\[ x - 2 = \pm\sqrt{\dfrac{40}{3}} \]
Split with the quotient property
Why: the root of a quotient is the quotient of the roots, which separates the 40 from the 3.
\[ x - 2 = \pm\dfrac{\sqrt{40}}{\sqrt{3}} \]
Now there are two separate faults to repair. The top has a square factor inside it, and the bottom is a radical. Deal with them one at a time, top first.
Simplify the top
Why: 40 is 4 times 10, and 10 has no square factor, so a 2 comes out and the 10 stays in.
\[ x - 2 = \pm\dfrac{2\sqrt{10}}{\sqrt{3}} \]
Rationalise the denominator
Why: multiply the top and the bottom by the root of 3; the bottom becomes 3, and the top becomes 2 times the root of 30.
\[ x - 2 = \pm\dfrac{2\sqrt{10}}{\sqrt{3}}\cdot\dfrac{\sqrt{3}}{\sqrt{3}} = \pm\dfrac{2\sqrt{30}}{3} \]
Add 2 to each side
Why: the ordinary linear finish, which puts the centre of the pair in front of the plus-or-minus.
\[ x = 2 \pm \dfrac{2\sqrt{30}}{3} \]
As decimals, two root thirty over three is about 3.651, so the answers are about 5.651 and about minus 1.651. They are the two crossings on the graph you saw at the start of this part.
Check by squaring the offset back
Why: x minus 2 is the fraction itself, so squaring it and multiplying by 3 must rebuild the 40.
\[ 3\left(\dfrac{2\sqrt{30}}{3}\right)^2 = 3\cdot\dfrac{4 \cdot 30}{9} = 3 \cdot \dfrac{120}{9} = 40 \]
It rebuilds exactly. The check also shows the practical value of rationalising: dividing by three is something you can do, whereas dividing by the root of three is something you would have to reach for a calculator to do.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 268 — Guided Practice 19
Faded example
Same shape, friendlier numbers. The first two moves are done for you; the rest is the routine you have just watched twice.
\[ 7(x - 4)^2 - 18 = 10 \]
Add 18 to each side
Why: the 18 is subtracted from the term carrying the square, so it comes off first.
\[ 7(x - 4)^2 = 28 \]
Divide each side by 7
Why: which leaves the bracket squared standing alone and equal to a small whole number.
\[ (x - 4)^2 = 4 \]
Stop and notice what has happened: four is a perfect square, so this is one of the rare binomial problems where the answers come out as whole numbers. Fill in the last two lines.
Fill in the blanks
(x-4)^2 = 4 \;\Longrightarrow\; x - 4 = \pm 2 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 6 \text___ x = 2
Why: The square root of 4 is 2, so the bracket is plus or minus 2. Adding 4 to each side gives 4 plus 2, which is 6, and 4 minus 2, which is 2. Check the larger one: 6 minus 4 is 2, squared is 4, times 7 is 28, minus 18 is 10, which is the right-hand side.
Check the symmetry before moving on. Six and two are each two away from four, which is where the bracket is zero, so the pair is centred exactly where the graph says it should be.
It is tempting to treat an answer of whole numbers as a sign that you should have factored instead. You could have: multiplying out gives seven x squared minus fifty-six x plus one hundred and two, which does factor. Taking roots was far quicker.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 270 — Exercise 32
Elimination
The book offers four answers to this equation. Knock out the three that cannot be right, and name the mistake behind each before you eliminate it.
\[ 3(x + 2)^2 + 4 = 13 \]
Eliminate the wrong options
Which line really gives the solutions of this equation?
Survives elimination: C
Why: Subtract 4 to get 3 times the bracket squared equal to 9, divide by 3 to get the bracket squared equal to 3, take roots to get x plus 2 equal to plus or minus the root of 3, then subtract 2. So the answers are minus 2 plus or minus the root of 3, about minus 0.27 and about minus 3.73. A number check settles it: minus 0.27 plus 2 is 1.73, squared is 3, times 3 is 9, plus 4 is 13.
The surviving line is the only one whose centre is at minus two, and the centre is the quickest thing to check. The bracket is x plus two, which is zero when x is minus two, so that is where the pair has to be balanced.
Two of the three wrong answers are centred on plus two, which is the sign slip this kind of question is built to catch. Read the bracket as it is written rather than as you expect it to be.
Both of the whole-number answers share a second fault: neither divided by the three, so both are solving the bracket squared equal to nine instead of equal to three. Whole-number answers are exactly what makes them look plausible.
When four options are this close, a number test is faster than more algebra. Pick the smaller answer from each pair, substitute it, and only one will rebuild thirteen.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 270 — Exercise 34
Worked example
The book closes its exercise set by taking the numbers away. Everything you have done in this part is here, with a, b and c standing in for the values you would normally be given.
\[ a(x + b)^2 = c \]
Divide each side by a
Why: a multiplies the bracket squared, so dividing isolates the square; a cannot be zero, or there would be no quadratic at all.
\[ (x + b)^2 = \dfrac{c}{a} \]
Take square roots of each side
Why: the whole bracket comes out, with the plus-or-minus, exactly as it did with numbers.
\[ x + b = \pm\sqrt{\dfrac{c}{a}} \]
Pause here and compare the line with Guided Practice 19. There the fraction was forty over three; here it is c over a. Nothing about the move has changed, only what the symbols are called.
Split with the quotient property
Why: the root of a quotient is the quotient of the roots, which separates c from a.
\[ x + b = \pm\dfrac{\sqrt{c}}{\sqrt{a}} \]
Rationalise the denominator
Why: multiply the top and the bottom by the root of a; the bottom becomes a, and the top becomes the root of a times c.
\[ x + b = \pm\dfrac{\sqrt{c}}{\sqrt{a}}\cdot\dfrac{\sqrt{a}}{\sqrt{a}} = \pm\dfrac{\sqrt{ac}}{a} \]
Subtract b from each side
Why: the linear finish; b was added inside the bracket, so it comes off both sides.
\[ x = -b \pm \dfrac{\sqrt{ac}}{a} \]
Read the shape of that answer. The centre is at minus b, which is where the bracket is zero, and the radical measures how far the pair sits either side of it. That is the same reading as every example in this part.
Check it against Exercise 34, where the numbers are known
Why: put a equal to 3, b equal to 2 and c equal to 9, and the general formula must reproduce the answers from two slides back.
\[ x = -2 \pm \dfrac{\sqrt{3 \cdot 9}}{3} = -2 \pm \dfrac{\sqrt{27}}{3} = -2 \pm \dfrac{3\sqrt{3}}{3} = -2 \pm \sqrt{3} \]
It reproduces them exactly. Testing a general formula on a case whose answer you already know is the cheapest possible insurance, and it is what Lesson 4.8 will do with a much more famous formula.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 270 — Exercise 37, the Challenge
Comparison
Put a Part 4 equation and a Part 5 equation side by side, step for step. Fill in the blanks, and notice where the extra work actually comes from.
Comparison matrix
| move | 3x² + 5 = 41 | 3(x − 2)² = 40 |
|---|---|---|
| isolate the square | x² = 12 | (x-2)^2 = 40/3 |
| take roots | x = ±√12 | x − 2 = ±√(40/3) |
| simplify the radical | ±2√3 | ±2√10 / √3 |
| rationalise? | no | yes, to ±2√30/3 |
| isolate the variable? | no, x is already alone | yes |
| answers | ±3.46 | 5.65 and −1.65 |
Reading down the two columns, the right-hand one costs two extra moves and introduces no new ideas at all. The rationalising came from a denominator that happened to be three, and the last step came from the bracket.
That is the honest summary of Part 5. A bracket inside the square does not make the method harder, it makes the answer longer, and the extra length is presentation rather than mathematics.
Look at the bottom row as well. The left-hand pair is centred on zero and the right-hand pair on two, which is the only structural difference between the two problems.
It is worth knowing that the right-hand column is the one you will meet most often from Lesson 4.7 onwards, because completing the square deliberately manufactures a bracket to square.
Section
Part 6
Concept
Here is where this method earns its place outside the textbook. An object dropped from rest falls according to a rule with a square in it and no plain first-power term, which is exactly the shape you have been solving all lesson.
\[ h = -16t^2 + h_0 \]
Read the letters. The height h is in feet and the time t is in seconds, and h nought is the height it was dropped from. The sixteen encodes Earth's gravity, and the minus sign says the object is going down.
Figure (svg): Height against time for an object dropped from 50 feet: a downward curve starting at 50 feet when the time is zero and reaching the ground at about 1.77 seconds.
The graph starts at the release height when the time is zero and curves downward, gently at first and then steeply, because a falling object keeps gaining speed. Only the right-hand half is drawn, since time before the drop does not exist.
Asking when it lands means asking when the height is zero, so you set h to zero and solve. There is no first-power term, so the whole question reduces to a square equal to a number.
Two assumptions are buried in that formula, and it is worth knowing them. Air resistance is being ignored, and the sixteen is an Earth number; another planet needs a different one, which is what Exercise 39 explores.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, pp. 268-269 — Modeling Dropped Objects
Notation
Before using the model, take it apart. Every piece of it is doing something physical, and knowing what means you can adapt it rather than only copy it.
Annotate
On: \( h = -16t^2 + h_0 \)
The subscript zero is a convention you will meet again and again. A letter with a nought under it means the value of that quantity at the start, and nothing is ever multiplied by a subscript.
Notice what is missing from the model as well. There is no mass anywhere in it, which is a real physical claim: in the absence of air resistance, a heavy object and a light one fall together.
Because the time is squared and the mass is absent, everything you can ask about this model is answered by the method from Part 4. That is the whole reason it appears in this lesson rather than in a physics book.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 268 — the model for a dropped object
Worked example
Students in a science competition have to build a container that protects an egg dropped from fifty feet. The question is how long the container is in the air.
\[ h = -16t^2 + h_0 \]
Substitute what the problem gives you
Why: the container lands when the height is zero, and it was dropped from fifty feet, so h nought is 50.
\[ 0 = -16t^2 + 50 \]
Subtract 50 from each side
Why: the constant is added to the term carrying the square, so it comes off first.
\[ -50 = -16t^2 \]
Divide each side by negative 16
Why: dividing a negative by a negative gives a positive, so the fraction on the left comes out positive, which it must for a square.
\[ t^2 = \dfrac{50}{16} \]
Check that sign carefully. Both sides were negative, so the division produces a positive number; if you ever reach a square equal to a negative in a falling-object problem, a sign has gone astray.
Take square roots of each side
Why: both signs, as always, even though one of them is about to be thrown away for a reason that is nothing to do with algebra.
\[ t = \pm\sqrt{\dfrac{50}{16}} = \pm\dfrac{5\sqrt{2}}{4} \approx \pm 1.77 \]
Reject the negative solution
Why: t counts seconds after the container was released, so a negative time is before the drop happened and cannot be an answer to this question.
\[ t \approx 1.77 \text{ seconds} \]
This is the first time in the lesson that a solution has been discarded, and notice the grounds. The negative value genuinely satisfies the equation; it just does not satisfy the situation the equation was built to describe.
Check by putting the time back into the model
Why: use the exact value rather than the rounded one, so that the arithmetic closes exactly.
\[ h = -16\left(\dfrac{5\sqrt2}{4}\right)^2 + 50 = -16\cdot\dfrac{50}{16} + 50 = -50 + 50 = 0 \]
The height comes out as exactly zero, which is the ground. Had you checked with 1.77 instead, you would have got about minus 0.11 feet, which is fine but only shows that the rounding is good, not that the answer is right.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 269 — Example 5
Worked example
The book's follow-up changes one number. Before computing, guess: the height has dropped by two fifths, so by how much do you expect the time to drop?
\[ \text{Repeat the drop from } h_0 = 30 \text{ feet.} \]
Substitute the new starting height
Why: the model is unchanged; only h nought moves from 50 to 30.
\[ 0 = -16t^2 + 30 \]
Isolate the square
Why: subtract 30 and divide by negative 16, both signs cancelling as before.
\[ t^2 = \dfrac{30}{16} = 1.875 \]
Take roots and simplify
Why: thirty over sixteen splits as the root of thirty over four, since sixteen is a perfect square and thirty has no square factor.
\[ t = \pm\dfrac{\sqrt{30}}{4} \approx \pm 1.37 \]
Reject the negative time
Why: the same physical reason as before: the clock starts at the release.
\[ t \approx 1.37 \text{ seconds} \]
Figure (svg): Two height-against-time curves on the same axes, one starting at 50 feet and reaching the ground at about 1.77 seconds, the other starting at 30 feet and reaching the ground at about 1.37 seconds.
Compare the two curves. The height fell by 40 percent, from fifty feet to thirty, but the time fell by only about 22 percent, from 1.77 seconds to 1.37. The two do not move together.
The reason is the square root. Time depends on the root of the height, and the root of 0.6 is about 0.775, so the new time is about 77.5 percent of the old one, which is exactly what the numbers show.
Check the ratio rather than the value
Why: the ratio of the two times should equal the square root of the ratio of the two heights, which tests both answers at once.
\[ \dfrac{1.3693}{1.7678} \approx 0.7746, \qquad \sqrt{\dfrac{30}{50}} = \sqrt{0.6} \approx 0.7746 \]
They agree to four places, so both fall times are right. A ratio check like this is more informative than a single substitution, because a mistake in either answer would break it.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 269 — Guided Practice 20
Edge cases
The plot is the model itself, with the starting height on a slider. The landing time is where the curve crosses the horizontal axis, so you can read it straight off.
Parameter explorer
Read the landing time at a starting height of 50 feet. Then find the height that gives a fall of exactly 2 seconds, and say what happens to the landing time as the starting height goes to zero.
\[ h = -16t^2 + {h0} \]
Notice how slowly the crossing moves once the height is large. Going from 50 feet to 100 does not double the fall time; it multiplies it by about 1.41, which is the root of two.
Try quadrupling instead. From 50 feet to 200 feet the fall time goes from about 1.77 seconds to about 3.54, an exact doubling, because the root of four is two.
The boundary case is worth visiting too. Slide the height all the way down to zero and the curve starts on the axis, so the fall time is zero. The object is already on the ground, and the model reports that correctly.
Worked example
A cliff diver dives off a cliff forty feet above the water. The exercise asks you to write the model first and then use it, which is the order every problem of this kind wants.
Writing the model is one substitution. The diver starts at forty feet, so h nought is 40, and everything else in the formula is fixed.
\[ h = -16t^2 + 40 \]
Set the height to zero
Why: the diver reaches the water when the height above it is zero, which is what the question is asking for.
\[ 0 = -16t^2 + 40 \]
Isolate the square
Why: subtract 40 from each side and divide by negative 16; the two negatives leave a positive on the right.
\[ t^2 = \dfrac{40}{16} = \dfrac{5}{2} \]
Take square roots of each side
Why: both signs as always, and the quotient property splits the fraction into two radicals.
\[ t = \pm\sqrt{\dfrac{5}{2}} = \pm\dfrac{\sqrt{5}}{\sqrt{2}} \]
Rationalise the denominator
Why: multiply the top and the bottom by the root of two, which is Example 2 part a arriving inside a physics problem.
\[ t = \pm\dfrac{\sqrt{5}}{\sqrt{2}}\cdot\dfrac{\sqrt{2}}{\sqrt{2}} = \pm\dfrac{\sqrt{10}}{2} \approx \pm 1.58 \]
It is worth noticing that reducing forty over sixteen to five over two first made this much tidier. Taking the root of forty over sixteen directly would have worked too, and given the same answer after more cancelling.
Reject the negative time
Why: the clock starts when the diver leaves the cliff, so only the positive value describes anything real.
\[ t \approx 1.58 \text{ seconds} \]
So the diver is in the air for a little over a second and a half. That is worth a sanity check against experience: a second and a half is about right for a forty-foot drop, and an answer of fifteen seconds would have been absurd.
Check by putting the exact time back into the model
Why: square the exact answer and rebuild the height, which must come out as zero at the water.
\[ -16\left(\dfrac{\sqrt{10}}{2}\right)^2 + 40 = -16 \cdot \dfrac{10}{4} + 40 = -40 + 40 = 0 \]
Exactly zero, so the answer is right. Compare it with the fifty-foot drop: forty feet takes about 1.58 seconds and fifty takes about 1.77, which is far closer together than the heights are.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 270 — Exercise 38
Real world
The sixteen in the model is half of Earth's gravitational acceleration, which is thirty-two feet per second squared. Replace that with the local value and the model works anywhere.
\[ h = -\dfrac{g}{2}t^2 + h_0 \]
Discussion prompt
Drop a rock from 150 feet on each of the five planets in the book's table, with g equal to 32, 12, 76, 30 and 2 feet per second squared. Find each fall time, then say what the whole set shows about how time depends on gravity.
Figure (svg): A bar chart of the time a rock takes to fall 150 feet on five planets: Earth about 3.06 seconds, Mars 5 seconds, Jupiter about 1.99 seconds, Saturn about 3.16 seconds and Pluto about 12.25 seconds.
Read the bars rather than the numbers for a moment. Jupiter and Pluto sit at the two extremes, and the ratio between their bars is about six, while the ratio between their gravities is thirty-eight. The square root has flattened the difference.
Check the model against itself on the Earth row. With g equal to thirty-two, g over two is sixteen, which is the number from Example 5, so the general model really does contain the one you have been using.
The algebra never changed across five planets. Isolate the square, take roots, reject the negative time. Only one number in the equation moved, which is the whole argument for solving a problem in letters before putting numbers in.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, p. 270 — Exercise 39
Counterexample
The model you have just used five times says nothing at all about mass. That is either an oversight or a claim about the world, and it is worth deciding which.
\[ h = -\dfrac{g}{2}t^2 + h_0 \]
Discussion prompt
A classmate says the formula must be incomplete, because a bowling ball obviously falls faster than a tennis ball. Say what the model claims, where the classmate's everyday evidence comes from, and what the model would predict for the two balls dropped on the Moon.
This is a good example of what a model is for. It is deliberately simplified, and knowing which simplification has been made tells you exactly when you may trust it and when you may not.
The trustworthy cases are dense, compact objects over short distances, which is why an egg container and a diver both work well. A sheet of paper over the same fifty feet would not.
Notice that the algebra is indifferent to all of this. The method solved the equation correctly; the judgement about whether the equation describes the situation is yours, and it always will be.
Section
Part 7
Pattern
Every equation in this lesson followed the same short routine. The only decision in it is whether the number you reach is negative, and that decision is made for you by the arithmetic.
Figure (svg): A vertical flow diagram: isolate the square, take roots and write plus or minus, simplify the radical, rationalise the denominator, isolate the variable, check by squaring back. A branch leaves the second box to a box saying no real solution if the number is negative.
Two of those five are about how the answer looks rather than what it is, which is why this lesson spends two whole parts on tidying. The mathematics is the middle line and it is one move long.
The habit that matters most is the last one. Squaring an answer back into the original equation takes a single line, and it catches a dropped coefficient, a lost sign and a botched rationalisation all at once.
OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §2.5 Quadratic Equations §2.5 — the same routine, called the square root property
Check
Combine before you split. Neither radicand has a useful square factor on its own, and the product does.
Check your understanding
Simplify the root of 8 multiplied by the root of 28.
Answer: A
Why: The product property joins the two radicals into the root of 224, and 224 is 16 times 14, so a 4 comes out and 14 stays under the sign. The answer is about 14.967, and squaring it back gives 16 times 14, which is 224.
Three of these four options are equal to one another in value, which is exactly why this is a question about the conditions rather than about arithmetic. Only one of them is written in finished form.
Run the test on the option that keeps 56 under the sign. Fifty-six is four times fourteen, so a square factor is still in there, and the answer needs one more pass.
The choice that writes fourteen root four is the only one that is actually a different number. It works out at twenty-eight, while all the others are about 14.97, so a rough decimal estimate would have eliminated it immediately.
Check
The Part 4 shape. Isolate the square first, and remember what the radical sign will and will not give you.
Check your understanding
Solve the equation 3x squared plus 5 equals 41.
Answer: A
Why: Subtracting 5 gives 3x squared equal to 36, and dividing by 3 gives x squared equal to 12. Taking roots gives plus or minus the root of 12, and 12 is 4 times 3, so the answer is plus or minus two root three, about 3.46 either way. Squaring it back gives 3 times 12 plus 5, which is 41.
Every wrong option here is a real mistake rather than a random wrong answer: one drops a sign, one divides at the wrong moment, and one stops a step early.
The option that keeps only the positive root is the one to watch for in your own work, because it is a genuine solution and nothing in the arithmetic will ever object to it.
A fast way to eliminate two of these: estimate. Twelve is a bit more than nine, so x squared equal to twelve means x is a bit more than three, which rules out anything near twelve or near two.
Check
The Part 5 shape. Take roots of both sides, then remember that a linear step is still waiting.
Check your understanding
Solve one seventh of the quantity z minus 2, squared, equals 6.
Answer: A
Why: Multiplying by 7 gives the bracket squared equal to 42, and taking roots gives z minus 2 equal to plus or minus the root of 42. Adding 2 to each side gives 2 plus or minus the root of 42, about 8.48 and about negative 4.48. Check: 8.48 minus 2 is 6.48, squared is 42, and a seventh of 42 is 6.
Three of the four options differ from the answer by exactly one slip each, and every one of those slips has appeared on a slide in this deck. That is deliberate: the options are a checklist of this lesson's traps.
The quickest discriminator is the centre. The bracket is z minus two, which is zero when z is two, so the two answers must be balanced about two, and that alone kills half the options.
Confirm the winner with the symmetry as well. The root of forty-two is about 6.48, so the answers sit about 6.48 either side of two, at about 8.48 and about minus 4.48, which is a matched pair.
Explain it to yourself
One idea has carried this whole lesson. Putting it into your own sentences is what turns it from a rule you follow into a fact you know. Write your answer before reading the one below.
Discussion prompt
In three or four sentences, explain why solving x squared equals 9 gives two answers while evaluating the root of 9 gives one. Then say what the plus-or-minus is actually doing when you write it, and why nothing else in the line supplies it.
If your explanation used the word rule more than the word because, write it again. The plus-or-minus is a consequence of two facts that you can both state, not a step somebody decided to insist on.
A good test of whether you have it: could you explain to someone a year behind you why the root of nine is not plus or minus three, without saying that is just how it is written?
Try the question the other way round as well. If the radical sign had been defined to mean both roots, what would go wrong? The answer is that every expression containing one would become ambiguous, which is worth thinking through for a minute.
Exit ticket
One equation that uses every part of the lesson: a coefficient to divide out, a bracket inside the square, a radical to simplify and a denominator to rationalise.
\[ 5(x + 1)^2 = 24 \]
Discussion prompt
Solve it completely, giving the answers in exact form and as decimals to two places. Then name the step in your working where the plus-or-minus first appears, and say why no earlier step could have produced it.
Work through it in the order the pattern slide gave you, and resist the urge to reach for a decimal before the exact form is finished. Rounding early would make the rationalising step meaningless.
The answers are centred on minus one, because the bracket is x plus one and that is where it vanishes. If your pair is centred anywhere else, look at the sign inside the bracket again.
If you found the rationalising step the hardest part, that is the ten minutes of practice to do tonight, and exercises 11 to 18 on page 269 are built for exactly it.
Recap
Five things, and the middle one is the method the other four exist to support. All of them come out of a single fact about squaring, which is that it forgets the sign of what went into it.
| if you see | then | example from this lesson |
|---|---|---|
| a radicand with a square factor | split it off with the product property | √80 = 4√5 |
| a fraction under one radical | split it with the quotient property | √(4/81) = 2/9 |
| a radical in a denominator | multiply by it, or by the conjugate | 3/(7 + √2) = (21 − 3√2)/47 |
| a square equal to a positive number | take roots of both sides, with plus or minus | x² = 12 gives x = ±2√3 |
| a bracket squared equal to a number | take roots, then isolate the variable | (z − 2)² = 42 gives z = 2 ± √42 |
| a square equal to a negative number | stop: no real solution | x² = −9 |
\[ x^2 = s \;\Longrightarrow\; x = \pm\sqrt{s} \qquad (s > 0) \]
That one line is the lesson. The plus-or-minus in it is not decoration and not a convention to memorise: it is the second square root, which the radical symbol deliberately refuses to name, put back by hand.
The dropped-object model is the same line wearing work clothes. Set the height to zero, isolate the square, take roots, and throw away the negative time on physical grounds rather than mathematical ones.
Two lessons from here this all gets much bigger. Lesson 4.7 completes the square, which manufactures a bracket squared out of any quadratic at all, and Lesson 4.8 turns that into the quadratic formula, whose plus-or-minus is the very one you have been writing all lesson.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.5 Solve Quadratic Equations by Finding Square Roots §4.5, pp. 266-269 — everything on these slides traces back here
Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Algebra 2 — $55/session, free consultation.