4.3 Factoring x^2 + bx + c and the Zero Product Property

Factoring a monic trinomial by finding two numbers with the right product and sum, the difference of two squares and perfect square trinomial patterns, the zero product property that turns factors into roots, a doubling-the-area model, and the zeros of a quadratic function.

Subject: Algebra 2 · 71 slides · symbolic lesson

Open the interactive version of this deck

What this lesson covers

The lesson, slide by slide

1. Factoring x squared plus bx plus c

Title

Algebra 2 · Lesson 4.3

Two numbers that multiply to c and add to b, and the one product whose value gives its factors away

2. What this lesson gives you

Objectives

Lesson 4.2 handed you intercept form and let you read the crossings of a parabola straight off it. It never said where that form comes from. This lesson is the other half of the deal: given a quadratic written the ordinary way, you learn to rewrite it as a product.

There are two separate skills here and it is worth keeping them apart in your head. One is factoring, which is a search for two numbers. The other is the zero product property, which is what makes a factored form worth having in the first place.

Two habits will carry you the whole way. Every factorisation gets multiplied back out before you trust it, and every root gets put back into the equation it came from. Neither takes more than a line, and between them they catch nearly every mistake this topic invites.

One warning before you start. The single most common error in this lesson is a sign, not an arithmetic slip. Watch what the sign of the constant and the sign of the middle term are telling you, because together they decide the signs in your answer before you compute anything.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 252 — Before, Now, Why and the Key Vocabulary

3. First, multiply two brackets out

Warm-up

Start with the direction you already know. Multiply this product out, using FOIL or any method you like, and write the answer down before reading on. Committing to paper first is what makes the comparison worth anything.

\[ (x + 4)(x + 7) \]

Discussion prompt

Multiply the two brackets out and collect like terms. Then look at your answer and say where the 4 and the 7 each ended up.

That double appearance is the whole of the next three slides. If two numbers are hiding in the brackets, then multiplying out leaves their product sitting in one place and their sum sitting in another, and factoring is just reading those two clues backwards.

Notice also what the four products did. Two of them, seven x and four x, are like terms and collapsed into one. That collapse is why a trinomial has three terms and not four, and why recovering the original two numbers takes a little thought.

Keep your answer where you can see it. The first worked example of the lesson runs this calculation in reverse, and having the forward version beside it makes the reverse one obvious rather than mysterious.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 252 — the FOIL reminder that opens the lesson

4. The search for two numbers

Section

Part 1

5. Multiplying out shows exactly what to look for

Concept

Here is the general version of the warm-up. Write the two brackets with unknown numbers in them, multiply out, and compare the result with the trinomial you were given.

\[ x^2 + bx + c = (x + m)(x + n) = x^2 + (m + n)x + mn \]

Read the middle expression against the right-hand one, term by term. The x squared terms already agree. For the other two to agree as well, the sum of m and n must equal b and the product of m and n must equal c. That is the entire method, and it is a consequence of multiplying out rather than a rule to memorise.

Figure (svg): A rectangle of width x plus 4 and height x plus 7, cut into four tiles: a large x by x square labelled x squared, a strip labelled 7x below it, a strip labelled 4x to its right, and a small 4 by 7 rectangle labelled 28 in the corner.

The same rectangle, measured two ways. Notice that 4 and 7 are the two strip widths, so they add to the middle coefficient and multiply to the corner.

The picture is the same statement drawn. A rectangle whose sides are the two brackets splits into four tiles, and the two strips are the ones that carry 4 and 7. Their widths add to give the middle term and multiply to give the corner.

trinomial — The sum of three monomials, such as x squared plus 11x plus 28. A monomial is a number, a variable, or a product of a number and one or more variables; a binomial, such as x plus 4, is the sum of two monomials.

So a factoring problem is not a guess. It is a search with exactly two conditions, and the conditions are precise enough that the search is finite: only a handful of integer pairs multiply to any given constant, and you can test every one of them.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 252 — the derivation of the two conditions

6. Reading the two conditions piece by piece

Notation

Before using them, take the two conditions apart. Each letter here does one job, and knowing which job protects you from mixing up the sum and the product, which is the commonest way this goes wrong.

Annotate

On: \( x^2 + bx + c = (x + m)(x + n) \)

  • There is nothing in front of the x squared, so its coefficient is 1. That is why both brackets start with a plain x. Lesson 4.4 handles the case where a number sits there instead, and the search changes when it does.
  • This is the product of m and n. It comes from the last term of each bracket multiplied together, and nothing else in the expansion contributes to it.
  • This is the sum of m and n. It comes from the two middle products collapsing into one like term, which is why the sum appears rather than the two numbers separately.
  • Both brackets are written with a plus, and a negative number still fits: x plus negative 4 is the same as x minus 4. Writing it as a plus keeps the two conditions honest, so a minus in your answer means a negative value of m or n.

That last note matters more than it looks. If you write the brackets as x minus 4 and x minus 5, the two numbers are negative 4 and negative 5, and it is those negative values that must multiply to the constant and add to the middle coefficient. Forgetting the sign at that moment is how a search that was going well produces the wrong pair.

Say the two conditions aloud in the order you will use them: product first, then sum. The product comes first because it is the one that limits the search to a short list, while the sum is the test you apply to each item on that list.

One more thing to notice. Nothing here says the two numbers have to be different. If they turn out equal you get a repeated bracket, which is the perfect square case Part 2 looks at, and it is not a special exception but the ordinary rule with a coincidence in it.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 252 — Key Vocabulary and the form of the factorisation

7. The two conditions, drawn as two graphs

Concept

Here is something worth seeing once, because it makes the search feel less like rummaging. Treat the two unknown numbers as coordinates, with m across and n up. Then each of the two conditions is a curve in that plane.

\[ mn = 20 \qquad \text{and} \qquad m + n = -9 \]

Figure (svg): The curve of all pairs whose product is 20 drawn on axes labelled m and n, together with the straight line of all pairs whose sum is negative 9. The two curves meet at two points in the lower left quadrant, marked as the pair negative 4 and negative 5.

The blue curve holds every pair with product 20, the orange line every pair with sum negative 9. Both meetings sit in the quadrant where m and n are both negative, which is why both brackets get a minus sign.

Pairs with product 20 lie on the blue curve, and pairs with sum negative 9 lie on the orange line. The pair you want is where they meet, and you can see immediately that both meetings sit in the corner where m and n are both negative.

That is the sign rule, seen rather than recited. A positive product forces the two numbers into the same corner, either both positive or both negative, and the sign of the sum then says which corner. No arithmetic was needed to settle it.

The two meetings are the same answer twice, with the roles of m and n swapped. Multiplication does not care about order, so x minus 4 times x minus 5 and x minus 5 times x minus 4 are the same product, and a trinomial that factors at all factors in exactly one way.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 252 — the search conditions for Example 1(a)

8. Example 1(a): factor x squared minus 9x plus 20

Worked example

Work it as a search, not a guess. Write down the two conditions first, use the signs to shorten the list, then test the short list.

\[ x^2 - 9x + 20 \]

Name what you are looking for

Why: the constant is the product of the pair and the middle coefficient is their sum, so write both conditions down before hunting.

\[ mn = 20, \qquad m + n = -9 \]

Now read the signs before touching any arithmetic. The product 20 is positive, so the two numbers must agree in sign. The sum is negative, and two numbers that agree in sign can only add to a negative if both are negative. Both brackets will carry a minus.

List the negative factor pairs of 20 and their sums

Why: only the negative pairs are worth listing, which halves the work.

\[ \begin{array}{c|c} m, n & m + n \\ \hline -1, -20 & -21 \\ -2, -10 & -12 \\ -4, -5 & -9 \end{array} \]

Three pairs, one test each, and the third one hits. This is why the method is a search and not a gamble: the list of candidates is short, finite, and you can write the whole of it down.

Write the factorisation

Why: substitute the pair that worked into the two brackets, remembering that plus negative 4 is written minus 4.

\[ x^2 - 9x + 20 = (x - 4)(x - 5) \]

Before accepting it, multiply it back out. This takes one line and it is the only step that can catch a sign you dropped, so make it a reflex rather than a courtesy.

Check by multiplying the brackets out

Why: x times x is x squared, the two middle products are negative 5x and negative 4x which combine to negative 9x, and negative 4 times negative 5 is positive 20. That is the expression you started from, so the factorisation is exact.

\[ (x - 4)(x - 5) = x^2 - 5x - 4x + 20 = x^2 - 9x + 20 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 252 — Example 1(a)

9. The factorisation as a rectangle you can see

Picture it

Factoring is not only a number search: it is a statement about area. This picture takes the square of side x and cuts it into four tiles so that one of them is exactly the product you just found.

Figure (svg): A square of side x cut into four tiles. The bottom left tile has width x minus 4 and height x minus 5 and is the product being sought; beside it a tile of area 4 times x minus 5, above it a tile of area 5 times x minus 4, and in the corner a 4 by 5 tile of area 20.

The blue tile is the product you are hunting for. Take it out of the square and what is left over is exactly 9x minus 20, so the blue tile must be x squared minus 9x plus 20.

The blue tile has sides x minus 4 and x minus 5, so its area is the thing being factored. The other three tiles are what you have to remove from the big square to leave it, and adding them up gives 4x minus 20, plus 5x minus 20, plus 20.

\[ x^2 - \left[(4x - 20) + (5x - 20) + 20\right] = x^2 - 9x + 20 \]

Work that bracket out and you get 9x minus 20, so the blue tile is x squared minus 9x plus 20. The picture and the algebra agree, and now you can see why the 4 and the 5 appear both added, in the strips, and multiplied, in the corner.

This is the same picture you will meet again in Lesson 4.7 for completing the square, so it is worth getting comfortable with now. The only difference there is that you choose the strip widths yourself instead of finding them.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 252 — Example 1(a), drawn as an area model

10. Decide the signs before you search

Sorting

Here is the habit this part is really teaching. Look only at the sign of the constant and the sign of the middle term, and say what signs the two numbers must have. Do no arithmetic at all.

Sort into buckets

Sort each trinomial by the signs the two numbers in its brackets must have.

Both numbers negative
x² − 9x + 20; x² − 13x + 22
Both numbers positive
x² + 15x + 56
One of each sign
x² − 3x − 18; b² + 3b − 40; x² + 9x − 36
bothneg
The constant is positive, so the two numbers agree in sign, and the middle coefficient is negative, so they must both be negative. These factor as two brackets each containing a minus.
bothpos
The constant is positive and the middle coefficient is positive too, so the two numbers agree in sign and both are positive. Both brackets contain a plus.
opp
The constant is negative, so exactly one of the two numbers is negative. The sign of the middle coefficient then tells you which of the pair is the larger in size, but not the pattern of the brackets.

Two glances, and half the candidate pairs are gone before you start. On a trinomial with a positive constant you never need to test a mixed pair at all, and on one with a negative constant you never need to test a matching pair.

The third bucket is the one that stays a little open. When the constant is negative you know the brackets carry one plus and one minus, but you still have to work out which of the two numbers is the bigger. The sign of the middle coefficient decides that: the larger number in size takes the middle term's sign.

Try that on the trinomial with middle coefficient 3 and constant negative 40. One number is positive, one negative, and the positive one must be larger in size because they add to a positive 3. The pair is 8 and negative 5, and eight plus negative five is indeed three.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 252 — the Avoid Errors note on matching signs

11. Guided Practice 1: factor x squared minus 3x minus 18

Worked example

A negative constant this time, which changes the shape of the search. Expect one plus and one minus in the answer.

\[ x^2 - 3x - 18 \]

Write the two conditions

Why: the product is the constant and the sum is the middle coefficient, exactly as before.

\[ mn = -18, \qquad m + n = -3 \]

A negative product means the two numbers have opposite signs. That is a longer list than the positive case, because every factor pair of 18 now gives you two candidates depending on which member carries the minus.

List the pairs with product negative 18 and their sums

Why: six candidates, and the sums come in plus-and-minus couples because swapping which number is negative flips the sum.

\[ \begin{array}{c|c} m, n & m + n \\ \hline 1, -18 & -17 \\ -1, 18 & 17 \\ 2, -9 & -7 \\ -2, 9 & 7 \\ 3, -6 & -3 \\ -3, 6 & 3 \end{array} \]

Look down the sum column and notice the pattern: each value appears once positive and once negative. So once you have found a pair summing to positive 3 you also know the pair summing to negative 3, which is the same pair with the minus moved.

Write the factorisation

Why: the pair 3 and negative 6 has product negative 18 and sum negative 3.

\[ x^2 - 3x - 18 = (x + 3)(x - 6) \]

The sum being negative told you in advance that the negative member of the pair would be the larger one, and 6 is indeed larger than 3. That is a useful prediction to make before you start, because it cuts the list of six down to three.

Check by multiplying out

Why: the two middle products are negative 6x and positive 3x, which combine to negative 3x, and 3 times negative 6 is negative 18.

\[ (x + 3)(x - 6) = x^2 - 6x + 3x - 18 = x^2 - 3x - 18 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 253 — Guided Practice 1

12. Guided Practice 3: the same search on r squared plus 2r minus 63

Fill the middle

Now do one yourself, with the two conditions written out for you and the pair left blank. A different letter, and nothing else changes: the variable's name never affects the method.

Fill in the blanks

mn = -63, \; m + n = 2 \;\Longrightarrow\; r^2 + 2r - 63 = (r + 9)(r - 7)

Why: The constant is negative, so one number is positive and one negative, and the sum is a small positive 2, so the positive one is slightly the larger. The factor pairs of 63 are 1 and 63, 3 and 21, and 7 and 9; the closest pair is 7 and 9, and making the 9 positive gives a sum of 2. Multiplying back out: nine r minus seven r is two r, and nine times negative seven is negative 63.

Notice the reasoning that got you there quickly. The sum was small compared with the constant, which means the two numbers must be close together in size, so the factor pair nearest to each other is the one to try first. That single observation often finds the pair on the first attempt.

The opposite hint works too. A trinomial with a large middle coefficient and a small constant needs two numbers that are far apart, so start at the ends of the list instead of the middle. Choosing where to start is the difference between a search and a slog.

Always finish by expanding. Nine r minus seven r is two r, and that is the line that proves the sign choice was right. Had you put the minus on the 9 instead, the middle term would have come out as negative two r and the check would have caught it at once.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 253 — Guided Practice 3

13. Will this one factor at all?

Prediction

Guided Practice 2 asks for a trinomial that may not be factorable, and that is a legitimate answer rather than a failure. Look at the two conditions and decide before you list anything.

\[ n^2 - 3n + 9 \]

Predict first

Can this trinomial be factored over the integers?

  • Yes, into two brackets each containing a minus
  • Yes, into two brackets with one plus and one minus
  • No integer pair satisfies both conditions
  • Yes, it is a perfect square

Correct: No integer pair satisfies both conditions

Why: The product must be 9 and the sum must be negative 3. The pairs multiplying to 9 are 1 and 9, 3 and 3, negative 1 and negative 9, and negative 3 and negative 3, and their sums are 10, 6, negative 10 and negative 6. None of them is negative 3, so no integer pair works and the trinomial cannot be factored over the integers.

Four candidates, four sums, none of them the one wanted. That is a complete answer, not a shrug, because the list of integer pairs with product 9 is genuinely finite and you have just exhausted it.

\[ \begin{array}{c|c} m, n & m + n \\ \hline 1, 9 & 10 \\ 3, 3 & 6 \\ -1, -9 & -10 \\ -3, -3 & -6 \end{array} \]

Something worth noticing in that table: the smallest size the sum ever reaches is 6, at the pair 3 and 3. A product of 9 simply cannot be split into two numbers adding to anything smaller, so a middle coefficient of negative 3 was never going to happen.

Cannot be factored here means cannot be factored using integers. The equation obtained by setting this expression to zero still has solutions, and Lesson 4.8 finds them with the quadratic formula. Factoring is one tool, not the definition of solvable.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 253 — Guided Practice 2

14. Example 1(b): when the search genuinely fails

Worked example

The book's own example of a failed search. Run it properly, because saying cannot be factored is only worth marks if you have shown that the list was exhausted.

\[ x^2 + 3x - 12 \]

Write the two conditions

Why: the product must be the constant, negative 12, and the sum the middle coefficient, 3.

\[ mn = -12, \qquad m + n = 3 \]

List every integer pair with product negative 12

Why: there are six, because each factor pair of 12 can carry the minus on either member.

\[ \begin{array}{c|c} m, n & m + n \\ \hline -1, 12 & 11 \\ 1, -12 & -11 \\ -2, 6 & 4 \\ 2, -6 & -4 \\ -3, 4 & 1 \\ 3, -4 & -1 \end{array} \]

Six candidates and not one of them sums to 3. The closest are 4 and 1, so a middle coefficient of 4 or of 1 would have worked and 3 sits between them with nothing to offer it.

State the conclusion

Why: no integer pair satisfies both conditions at once, so no factorisation with integer entries exists.

\[ x^2 + 3x - 12 \text{ cannot be factored over the integers} \]

Figure (svg): The curve of all pairs whose product is negative 12, drawn with the line of all pairs whose sum is 3. They cross at two points, but neither crossing sits on a grid intersection, so neither pair is a pair of whole numbers.

The two conditions do meet, so real numbers with that product and sum exist. Neither meeting lands on a corner of the grid, which is what cannot be factored over the integers means.

The picture says something more precise, and it is worth knowing. The two conditions do meet, so numbers with that product and sum certainly exist. What they are not is whole numbers, and the crossings sit between grid corners rather than on them.

Check the claim by testing the nearest pairs

Why: the two pairs that come closest are negative 2 with 6, giving a sum of 4, and negative 3 with 4, giving a sum of 1. Since the sums jump from 1 straight to 4, nothing available sums to 3, which confirms the conclusion rather than just asserting it.

\[ -3 + 4 = 1, \qquad -2 + 6 = 4, \qquad 1 < 3 < 4 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 252 — Example 1(b)

15. Trap: a positive product with a negative sum

Trap

The trap

Factoring x squared minus 9x plus 20, here is the line students write most often:

\[ (x + 4)(x + 5) \]

The reasoning behind it is half right. Four times five is twenty, and four plus five is nine, so both numbers do look correct.

The missing half is the sign. The middle coefficient is negative 9, not 9, and nothing in that answer produces a minus.

The fix

Multiply it out and the error appears on the middle term:

\[ (x + 4)(x + 5) = x^2 + 9x + 20 \]

The pair had to multiply to a positive 20 and add to a negative 9. Both numbers negative does both jobs at once: their product is positive and their sum is negative.

\[ (x - 4)(x - 5) = x^2 - 9x + 20 \]

The habit that prevents this is to fix the signs before searching for the sizes. A positive constant with a negative middle term always means two minuses, every time, with no exceptions.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 252 — the Avoid Errors note beside Example 1

16. The two signs, and what they force

Comparison

Put the sign reasoning into a table you can carry. The left two columns are what you read off the trinomial, and the right two are what they force before you do any arithmetic.

Comparison matrix

sign of the constantsign of the middle termsigns of the two numbersexample
positivepositiveboth positivex² + 15x + 56 = (x + 7)(x + 8)
positivenegativeboth negativex² − 13x + 22 = (x − 2)(x − 11)
negativepositiveone of each, the positive one larger(x + 8)(x - 5)
negativenegativeone of each, the negative one largerx² − 4x − 12 = (x − 6)(x + 2)

The third row's blank is the factorisation of x squared plus 3x minus 40. One number is positive and one negative, the positive one is larger because the sum is positive, and the pair with product 40 that differs by 3 is 8 and 5.

Reading the table the other way round is just as useful. If your answer has two minuses in it, the trinomial you started from must have had a positive constant and a negative middle term, and if it does not, you have made a sign error somewhere.

Only the first two rows are fully determined by the signs. The bottom two leave you to find which of the pair is larger, and that is where the middle coefficient earns its keep a second time: the larger number in size always takes the middle term's sign.

17. Exercise 68: a diagram that models a factorisation

Picture it

The book's Exercise 68 asks you to draw a diagram that models a factorisation rather than just perform one. Here is the one it names, so that you can see what the tiles are doing.

\[ x^2 + 8x + 15 = (x + 5)(x + 3) \]

Figure (svg): A rectangle of width x plus 5 and height x plus 3, cut into an x by x square, a strip of area 3x below it, a strip of area 5x to the right, and a 5 by 3 corner of area 15.

The corner tile is the constant and the two strips are the middle term. Reading the side lengths off the picture is the factorisation.

The rectangle's sides are the two brackets, and its four tiles are the three terms of the trinomial, with the middle term split into the two strips it came from. Five and three appear once as strip widths, adding to 8, and once as the corner's sides, multiplying to 15.

Try building the picture for a case that does not factor and watch what goes wrong. To model x squared plus 3x minus 12 you would need a corner with area negative 12 and strip widths adding to 3, and no rectangle in the world has those measurements with whole-number sides.

The tiles also explain why the method needs the coefficient of x squared to be 1. The big tile has to be a genuine square of side x, so that both brackets begin with a single x. Lesson 4.4 puts a number in front, and then the big tile becomes several squares and the search grows.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 258 — Exercise 68(c)

18. Exercise 14: a bigger search, two steps left to you

Faded example

One more from the exercise set, with a larger constant so the list matters. Sixty-five factors in only two ways, which is the point: a big number is often an easier search than a small one.

\[ m^2 + 8m - 65 \]

The constant is negative, so one number is positive and one is negative. The sum is a positive 8, so the positive one is the larger of the two. The factor pairs of 65 are 1 with 65 and 5 with 13, and the second of those differs by 8.

Fill in the blanks

m^2 + 8m - 65 = (m + 13)(m - 5)

Why: The pair must multiply to negative 65 and add to 8. Thirteen and negative five do both: their product is negative 65 and their sum is 8. Expanding to check gives m squared minus 5m plus 13m minus 65, and the two middle terms combine to positive 8m, which is the expression you started from.

The variable here is called m, which is also the letter the lesson uses for one of the two numbers being searched for. That collision is harmless but worth noticing: the letters in a method are names, not fixed identities, and the book reuses them freely.

Notice how the size of the constant helped rather than hurt. Sixty-five is a product of two primes, so there are only two factor pairs to consider, while a constant like 24 or 36 would have offered four or five. When the number looks intimidating, count its factor pairs before you groan.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 256 — Exercise 14

19. Two patterns worth recognising

Section

Part 2

20. A difference of two squares needs no search

Concept

Some trinomials give their factors away, and it is worth spotting them because the search is then skipped entirely. Start with the shortest one, which is not even a trinomial: a square minus a square.

\[ (a + b)(a - b) = a^2 - ab + ab - b^2 = a^2 - b^2 \]

Watch the two middle products. They are equal in size and opposite in sign, so they cancel exactly and the middle term disappears. That is why the answer has only two terms instead of three.

Read that line backwards and you have a factoring rule. Anything of the form one square minus another square factors as the sum times the difference of whatever is being squared, with no candidate pairs to test.

\[ a^2 - b^2 = (a + b)(a - b) \]

It still obeys the general method, which is reassuring rather than surprising. The two numbers are b and negative b: their product is negative b squared, which is the constant, and their sum is zero, which is the missing middle term.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 253 — the Special Factoring Patterns box

21. Why a square minus a square is a rectangle

Picture it

The rule has a picture, and the picture is a single cut. Take a square of side a, remove a smaller square of side b from one corner, and ask what is left.

Figure (svg): On the left, a square of side a with a smaller square of side b removed from its top right corner, leaving an L shape cut into two rectangles. On the right, the same two rectangles pushed together to form one rectangle of width a plus b and height a minus b.

Nothing was added or thrown away between the two pictures: the L shape was cut once and slid. So a squared minus b squared and the product of a plus b with a minus b are the same area.

What is left is an L shape of area a squared minus b squared. Cut it once along the line shown and you have two rectangles, both of height a minus b, one of width a and one of width b.

Slide the second piece round to the end of the first and the L becomes a plain rectangle, a plus b wide and a minus b tall. Nothing was added and nothing thrown away, so the two areas are equal, which is the identity drawn rather than derived.

\[ a^2 - b^2 = (a + b)(a - b) \]

The picture also tells you when the rule is useless. If a equals b the rectangle has no height at all, and if the constant is a plus rather than a minus there is no corner to remove, which is exactly the sum of two squares problem a few slides from now.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 253 — Difference of Two Squares, drawn

22. Example 2(a): factor x squared minus 49

Worked example

Two terms rather than three, and both of them squares. Write each one as a square first so that the pattern is visible, then apply it.

\[ x^2 - 49 \]

Write both terms as squares

Why: 49 is 7 times 7, so the expression is one square minus another and the pattern applies.

\[ x^2 - 49 = x^2 - 7^2 \]

Naming the two things being squared is the whole of the work here. In the pattern, a is x and b is 7, and once you have said that the answer writes itself.

Apply the difference of squares pattern

Why: the sum times the difference of the two things being squared.

\[ x^2 - 7^2 = (x + 7)(x - 7) \]

You could also have found this with the ordinary search, and it is worth seeing that the two routes agree. The constant is negative 49 and the middle coefficient is 0, so the pair must multiply to negative 49 and add to zero, which forces 7 and negative 7.

The missing middle term is the clue that the pattern is available. A trinomial with no x term at all has a pair that sums to zero, and the only way two numbers sum to zero is for one to be the negative of the other, which makes their product a negative square.

Check by multiplying out

Why: the middle products are negative 7x and positive 7x, which cancel, and 7 times negative 7 is negative 49. The middle term vanishing is the whole point of the pattern.

\[ (x + 7)(x - 7) = x^2 - 7x + 7x - 49 = x^2 - 49 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 253 — Example 2(a)

23. Reading the perfect square trinomial pattern

Notation

The second pattern is a trinomial whose two numbers happen to be equal. It is worth learning to spot because the search collapses to a single candidate, but the fingerprint takes a moment to read properly.

Annotate

On: \( a^2 + 2ab + b^2 = (a + b)^2 \)

  • The first term has to be a perfect square, and a is whatever is being squared. In the book's example d squared plus 12d plus 36, a is simply d.
  • The constant has to be a perfect square too, and b is its square root. In that same example the constant is 36, so b is 6.
  • This is the test that decides it. The middle term must be exactly twice the product of a and b, no more and no less. Twice d times 6 is 12d, which matches, so the pattern holds.
  • Because both numbers in the search are the same, the two brackets are identical and you write one of them squared. That repeated bracket is what later gives a repeated root.

There is a sign version too, and it is the same pattern with b negative. If the middle term is subtracted, the bracket carries a minus and the constant is still positive, because a negative number squared is positive.

\[ a^2 - 2ab + b^2 = (a - b)^2 \]

Check the middle term before you commit. Plenty of trinomials have two square ends and a middle term that is not twice the product, and those are ordinary trinomials that happen to look tidy. The constant 36 with a middle term of 13d, for instance, is not a perfect square trinomial at all.

The pay-off for recognising the pattern is real. Instead of listing the factor pairs of 36, of which there are five, you take one square root and perform one multiplication. On a larger constant the saving is bigger still.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 253 — Perfect Square Trinomial in the Special Patterns box

24. Why the middle term is doubled

Picture it

The doubling in the pattern is the part people forget, and it stops being arbitrary the moment you draw it. Build the square whose side is d plus 6 and count the pieces.

Figure (svg): A square of side d plus 6 cut into four tiles: a d by d square, two identical 6 by d strips along its right and bottom edges, and a 6 by 6 corner square of area 36.

The middle term is twice six d because there are two strips, one along each edge. That doubling is the fingerprint of a perfect square trinomial.

There are four tiles and two of them are identical. The big square is d squared, the corner is 36, and the two strips are each 6d, one lying along the right-hand edge and one along the bottom. There is no way to have one strip without the other, because a square has two sides meeting at every corner.

\[ (d + 6)^2 = d^2 + 6d + 6d + 36 = d^2 + 12d + 36 \]

So the middle term is 12d rather than 6d for a geometric reason, not an algebraic accident. Whenever you see a middle term that is twice something and a constant that is that something squared, a completed square is what you are looking at.

Run the picture backwards to factor. Given d squared plus 12d plus 36, halve the middle coefficient to get the strip width 6, check that 6 squared is the constant, and the side of the square is d plus 6. Lesson 4.7 builds its whole method on that halving.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 253 — Example 2(b), drawn as a completed square

25. Example 2(b): factor d squared plus 12d plus 36

Worked example

Now the same expression handled in writing. Notice that the first move is a piece of recognition rather than a calculation.

\[ d^2 + 12d + 36 \]

Test the two ends for squares

Why: the first term is d squared and the constant is 6 squared, so the pattern is worth testing.

\[ d^2 + 12d + 36 = d^2 + 12d + 6^2 \]

Test the middle term against twice the product

Why: twice d times 6 is 12d, which is exactly the middle term, so this is a perfect square trinomial.

\[ 12d = 2(d)(6) \]

That second test is the one that has to be passed, not assumed. Plenty of trinomials have square ends and a middle term that is not twice the product, and they are ordinary trinomials wearing a disguise. Had the middle term been 13d instead, the pattern would have failed here and you would have gone back to the pair search.

Both tests passed, so no searching is needed. Write the expression in the pattern's own shape first, with the middle term displayed as twice the product, and the answer becomes a matter of copying.

Notice also that the same answer is available the long way. The pair with product 36 and sum 12 is 6 and 6, so the ordinary search would have found two identical numbers and given you the same repeated bracket. The pattern simply skips the listing.

Write it in the pattern's shape and read off the answer

Why: with a equal to d and b equal to 6, the pattern says the whole expression is the square of a plus b.

\[ d^2 + 2(d)(6) + 6^2 = (d + 6)^2 \]

Check by multiplying out

Why: the two middle products are both 6d and they add rather than cancel, giving 12d, and 6 times 6 is 36.

\[ (d + 6)(d + 6) = d^2 + 6d + 6d + 36 = d^2 + 12d + 36 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 253 — Example 2(b)

26. Example 2(c): factor z squared minus 26z plus 169

Worked example

The subtracted version, with a constant large enough that you would not want to list its factor pairs. This is where recognising the pattern actually saves you time.

\[ z^2 - 26z + 169 \]

Test the two ends for squares

Why: 169 is 13 times 13, so both ends are squares and the pattern is in play.

\[ z^2 - 26z + 169 = z^2 - 26z + 13^2 \]

Test the middle term against twice the product

Why: twice z times 13 is 26z, and the middle term is negative 26z, so the subtracted version of the pattern is the one that fits.

\[ -26z = -2(z)(13) \]

The minus sign lives in the bracket, not in the constant. Thirteen squared is positive whichever sign 13 carries, which is why a perfect square trinomial always ends with a positive constant even when its middle term is negative.

Write it in the pattern's shape and read off the answer

Why: with a equal to z and b equal to 13, the subtracted pattern gives the square of a minus b.

\[ z^2 - 2(z)(13) + 13^2 = (z - 13)^2 \]

Compare the labour with the alternative. Listing the negative factor pairs of 169 means knowing that 169 is 13 squared anyway, so you would have arrived at the same place by a longer road.

Knowing a few squares by heart is what makes this pattern quick, and the useful range is small: the squares up to 400 or so cover almost every textbook constant. If a constant is not on that list, the pattern is probably not what you are looking at.

Check by multiplying out

Why: both middle products are negative 13z, giving negative 26z, and negative 13 times negative 13 is positive 169.

\[ (z - 13)(z - 13) = z^2 - 13z - 13z + 169 = z^2 - 26z + 169 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 253 — Example 2(c)

27. Which pattern, if any?

Discrimination

Sorting these is the skill the patterns are really for. Look at the two end terms first: are they both perfect squares? Then look at the middle term and decide whether it is twice the product, zero, or something else entirely.

Sort into buckets

Sort each expression by the pattern it fits.

Difference of two squares
x² − 36; z² − 121
Perfect square trinomial
x² − 24x + 144; n² + 14n + 49
Neither: do the ordinary search
x² − 4x − 12; x² + 13x + 36
dots
Two terms only, both perfect squares, with a minus between them. Each factors as the sum times the difference: 6 and 6 in the first case, 11 and 11 in the second.
pst
Both end terms are perfect squares and the middle term is exactly twice the product of their roots: twice 12 is 24, and twice 7 is 14. Each is a single bracket squared.
plain
One of these has a negative constant, which no perfect square trinomial ever has, and the other has square ends but a middle term of 13 where twice the product would be 12. Both need the pair search: the answers are x minus 6 times x plus 2, and x plus 4 times x plus 9.

The last bucket contains the trap. A trinomial with square ends is not automatically a perfect square, and the one with constant 36 and middle term 13 is exactly the near miss that catches people out: twice the product would be 12, so it fails the test by one.

It does still factor, just not by pattern. The pair with product 36 and sum 13 is 4 and 9, so the answer is x plus 4 times x plus 9. Failing the pattern test costs you a shortcut, not the problem.

Notice too that a negative constant rules out a perfect square trinomial immediately. Squaring anything gives a positive result, so a constant of negative 12 cannot be b squared for any real b, and the pattern never applies.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 256 — Exercises 15 to 23

28. Guided Practice 6 and 7: both patterns, one line each

Fill the middle

Two of the book's checkpoints, handled by recognition rather than search. Halve the middle coefficient, check that the result squares to the constant, and write the bracket.

Fill in the blanks

y^2 + 16y + 64 = (y + 8)^2, \qquad w^2 - 18w + 81 = (w - 9)^2

Why: Half of 16 is 8 and 8 squared is 64, so the first is y plus 8 all squared. Half of 18 is 9 and 9 squared is 81, so the second is w minus 9 all squared, with the minus carried into the bracket because the middle term is subtracted. Expanding the second gives w squared minus 9w minus 9w plus 81, which is w squared minus 18w plus 81.

The routine is always the same three moves: halve the middle coefficient, square the result, compare it with the constant. If the comparison succeeds you have a perfect square, and the halved value is what goes in the bracket.

Get into the habit of writing the sign into the bracket rather than remembering it separately. The second answer is w minus 9, all squared, and the minus belongs to the 9, not to the squaring.

Both of these would have yielded to the ordinary search as well, with a list of the factor pairs of 64 and of 81. The pattern is worth learning because it turns three lines of list-making into one line of arithmetic, and that saving grows with the size of the constant.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 253 — Guided Practice 6 and 7

29. Order the moves that factor by pattern

Ranking

Factoring by pattern has an order, and doing the tests in the wrong order wastes the shortcut. Put the moves for the trinomial below into the sequence that works.

\[ z^2 - 26z + 169 \]

Put in order

Put the moves in the order that factors this without searching.

  1. Check that the first term and the constant are both perfect squares
  2. Take the square roots of those two terms
  3. Check that the middle term is twice the product of those roots
  4. Write the bracket, giving it the sign of the middle term

Why: The square test on the two ends comes first, because if it fails there is no pattern to use and you go back to the pair search. Only once you have the two square roots can you form twice their product, and only once that matches the middle term are you entitled to write a squared bracket. Writing the bracket first and hoping is how a trinomial with square ends but the wrong middle term gets factored wrongly.

The sequence is a filter, not a recipe. Two of the four moves are tests that can fail, and failing is useful information: it sends you back to the pair search with no time lost beyond a glance.

The last move is where the sign is decided, and it is decided by the middle term alone. A subtracted middle term gives a bracket with a minus in it, and the constant stays positive because squaring removes the sign.

Try the same sequence on the trinomial with constant 36 and middle term 13. The ends are both squares, the roots are x and 6, twice their product is 12, and 12 is not 13, so the third test fails and the pattern is abandoned. That is the sequence doing its job.

30. Is there a pattern for a sum of two squares?

Counterexample

The difference of two squares factors so neatly that it is natural to ask about the sum. Exercise 64 makes you settle the question rather than guess at it, and the answer is worth knowing permanently.

\[ x^2 + 16 \]

Discussion prompt

Suppose this sum of two squares could be factored, so that it equals x plus m times x plus n for some integers m and n. Write down the two conditions m and n would have to satisfy, then show that no integers satisfy both.

So there is no sum of squares pattern, and the asymmetry is not a gap in your notes. A difference of squares has a missing middle term because two products cancel; a sum of squares would need them to cancel and the constant to be positive at the same time, which cannot happen.

The graph says the same thing in another language. The curve for y equal to x squared plus 16 sits entirely above the horizontal axis, never touching it, so there is no value of x that makes the expression zero and therefore no bracket that could vanish.

Keep this filed next to the difference of squares rather than as an afterthought. A student who tries to factor a sum of squares has usually pattern-matched on the shape of the expression without checking the sign, and one minus sign is the whole difference between a rule and an impossibility.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 257 — Exercise 64

31. The zero product property

Section

Part 3

32. Zero is the only product that gives its factors away

Concept

Everything so far has been about rewriting an expression. Now the expression is set equal to something, and this is where factoring earns its place. First, though, notice what makes it work, because the reason is narrower than people assume.

Figure (svg): Two square panels of axes labelled A and B. On the left, the pairs whose product is 6 form two curves that never touch either axis. On the right, the pairs whose product is zero are exactly the two axes themselves, drawn thick.

Knowing a product is 6 tells you nothing about either factor, because the solutions run away along a curve. Knowing a product is zero pins one factor exactly, because the only solutions lie on the two axes.

On the left are all the pairs whose product is 6. There are infinitely many, and neither number is ever zero, so knowing the product tells you nothing at all about either factor. Two and three work, so do six and one, so do 100 and 0.06.

On the right are all the pairs whose product is zero, and they form only the two axes. Every single solution has the first number zero or the second number zero, with no exceptions anywhere on the picture.

That asymmetry is the whole engine of this lesson. A product equal to any number other than zero leaves the factors free, while a product equal to zero pins at least one of them exactly. It is why every quadratic equation gets rearranged to have a zero on one side before anything else happens.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 253 — the Zero Product Property key concept box

33. The property, in words and in letters

Notation

Here is the statement itself. It is short, and every word in it is doing work, so read it once slowly before using it twenty times.

zero product property — If the product of two expressions is zero, then one or both of the expressions equal zero. In letters: if A and B are expressions and AB equals 0, then A equals 0 or B equals 0.

Annotate

On: \( AB = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; A = 0 \text{ or } B = 0 \)

  • These stand for whole expressions, not just single letters. In this lesson they are the two brackets of a factored quadratic, so A might be x minus 4 and B might be x plus 7.
  • This is the only value that makes the property true. Replace it with 6 and the conclusion collapses, which is the trap two slides from now and the most valuable thing on this slide.
  • Read it as at least one of the two, not as one but not the other. Both brackets are allowed to be zero at once, which happens for a perfect square where the two brackets are identical.
  • It points one way, and it also happens to work backwards here: if either bracket is zero then the product certainly is. That two-way street is why the roots you find are all the roots there are.

The word or is the one that gets mistranslated. A student who reads it as and looks for a single value of x making both brackets zero at once, finds none, and concludes the equation has no solutions. The equation has two, and each one kills one bracket while leaving the other alone.

Try it on the brackets x minus 4 and x plus 7. At x equal to 4 the first bracket is zero and the second is 11, so the product is zero times 11, which is zero. The second bracket did not have to cooperate at all.

Notice also what the property does not promise. It says nothing about how big A or B is, only that one of them is zero, and that is exactly enough: an equation of the form bracket equals zero is a one-step problem.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 253 — the Zero Product Property, words and algebra

34. One quadratic becomes two linear equations

Picture it

Here is what actually happens when you apply the property. Follow the diagram from the top and notice how the difficulty falls away at the first fork.

Figure (svg): A flow diagram. The equation x minus 4 times x plus 7 equals zero sits at the top, with two arrows leading down to x minus 4 equals zero and x plus 7 equals zero, and from those to x equals 4 and x equals negative 7.

The quadratic never gets solved directly. It is traded for two one-step equations, and the word joining them is or, not and.

At the top there is a quadratic, which you have no direct method for: x appears twice, so you cannot undo operations one at a time the way Lesson 1.4 did. One line later there are two linear equations, and you have been solving those since Chapter 1.

That is the trade the whole lesson is built on. Factoring is the price, and two easy equations instead of one hard one is what you buy with it. When you cannot pay the price, which is when the trinomial does not factor, you need Lesson 4.7 or 4.8 instead.

Read the word between the two branches again: it is or. You solve both branches and collect both answers, because each one satisfies the original equation on its own. A quadratic usually has two roots, and this diagram is where they come from.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 254 — the two branches worked in Example 3

35. Trap: setting each factor equal to something other than zero

Trap

The trap

Solving a product equal to 6, here is the move that ruins the method:

\[ (x - 2)(x - 3) = 6 \]

\[ x - 2 = 6 \;\text{ or }\; x - 3 = 6 \]

It looks like the same move you have just learned, and the two answers it gives are 8 and 9.

Test the first one. Six times five is thirty, not six.

The fix

The property is about zero and nothing else. Multiply out, move the 6 across, and factor the result:

\[ x^2 - 5x + 6 = 6 \]

\[ x^2 - 5x = 0 \]

\[ x(x - 5) = 0 \]

So the roots are 0 and 5. Check the second: three times two is six, as required.

The rule to carry away: get a zero on one side before you split anything. A product equal to 6 says only that the two factors multiply to 6, which every pair on that hyperbola does.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 256 — Exercise 39, the same error on a different equation

36. Example 3: solve x squared plus 3x minus 28 equals 0

Worked example

The book's own multiple-choice example, worked in full. The equation already has a zero on the right, so the first move is the factoring.

\[ x^2 + 3x - 28 = 0 \]

Factor the left-hand side

Why: the constant is negative, so one number is positive and one negative, and the sum of 3 makes the positive one larger: the pair is 7 and negative 4.

\[ (x - 4)(x + 7) = 0 \]

Confirm that factorisation in your head before going on, because everything after it depends on it. Negative 4 plus 7 is 3, and negative 4 times 7 is negative 28. Both conditions hold.

Apply the zero product property

Why: a product of two brackets is zero exactly when one of the brackets is zero, so split into two equations joined by or.

\[ x - 4 = 0 \quad \text{or} \quad x + 7 = 0 \]

Solve each linear equation

Why: one addition and one subtraction, and that is the whole of the algebra left.

\[ x = 4 \quad \text{or} \quad x = -7 \]

The book offers four answer choices for this question, and the two negatives version and the two positives version are both on the list. Reading your own factorisation carefully is what separates them: a bracket reading x minus 4 gives the root positive 4, not negative 4.

Notice how little work the last two steps were. All the difficulty of this problem lived in the factoring, and once the two brackets existed the equation practically solved itself, which is the trade the whole of Part 3 is built on.

Check both roots in the original equation

Why: sixteen plus twelve is twenty-eight, which cancels the constant; and forty-nine minus twenty-one is twenty-eight, which cancels it too. Both roots satisfy the equation, so the pair is right.

\[ 4^2 + 3(4) - 28 = 0, \qquad (-7)^2 + 3(-7) - 28 = 0 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 254 — Example 3

37. Where those two roots sit on the graph

Picture it

The roots are not abstract. They are the two places where the parabola for this quadratic meets the horizontal axis, and seeing that once makes the whole lesson hang together.

Figure (svg): The parabola y equals x squared plus 3x minus 28 drawn on axes, crossing the horizontal axis at negative 7 and at 4, with its lowest point marked below the axis.

The two roots are the two places the curve touches down. Everything between them lies below the axis, which is where the product of the two brackets is negative.

The curve crosses at negative 7 and at 4, exactly the two values the algebra produced. That is no coincidence: the height of the curve is the value of the expression, so the curve is at height zero precisely where the expression equals zero.

Look at what happens between the two crossings. The curve dips below the axis, which means the two brackets have opposite signs there: one has gone positive while the other is still negative, so their product is negative.

Outside the two crossings both brackets agree in sign, so the product is positive and the curve is above the axis. A factored quadratic tells you not just where the curve touches down but which side of the axis it is on everywhere else.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 254 — Example 3, with the graph from Lesson 4.2's intercept form

38. Exercise 39: the book's own worked error

Error analysis

This is the error analysis exercise from the exercise set, and it is the trap from two slides ago in the book's own handwriting. Read the four lines and find the first one that is untrue.

Annotate

On: \( x^2 + 7x + 6 = 14 \;\Longrightarrow\; (x + 6)(x + 1) = 14 \)

  • This line is correct as a factoring: 6 times 1 is 6 and 6 plus 1 is 7, so x plus 6 times x plus 1 really does equal x squared plus 7x plus 6. Nothing is wrong yet.
  • Here is the problem. The right-hand side is not zero, so the zero product property does not apply, and factoring the left-hand side has bought nothing at all.
  • It set each bracket equal to 14, giving x equal to 8 or 13. Testing the first: 8 plus 6 is 14 and 8 plus 1 is 9, and 14 times 9 is 126, not 14. The answers are simply wrong.
  • Subtract 14 from both sides first, so that the equation reads x squared plus 7x minus 8 equals 0. That factors as x plus 8 times x minus 1, giving roots negative 8 and 1.

\[ x^2 + 7x - 8 = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; (x + 8)(x - 1) = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = -8 \text{ or } x = 1 \]

Check both against the equation as it was given. At x equal to negative 8, sixty-four minus fifty-six plus six is fourteen. At x equal to 1, one plus seven plus six is fourteen. Both work, and neither is 8 or 13.

The fault was never the factoring, which is what makes this error so durable. Whoever wrote those lines did the hard part correctly and then used a tool outside its stated conditions, which is a different kind of mistake from an arithmetic slip and needs a different kind of guard.

The guard is a question you ask before splitting anything: is there a zero on one side? If not, rearrange until there is. That single check costs nothing and it is the reason standard form matters.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 256 — Exercise 39

39. Exercise 33: standard form before anything else

Worked example

An equation that does not arrive with a zero on the right. The first move is not factoring, and getting the order right here is the whole point of the exercise.

\[ z^2 - 3z = 54 \]

Subtract 54 from each side to reach standard form

Why: the property needs a zero on one side, so everything moves to the left before any factoring happens.

\[ z^2 - 3z - 54 = 0 \]

Standard form means written as a quadratic expression equal to zero, with the terms in descending order of power. It is not tidiness for its own sake: it is the condition the zero product property demands.

Factor the left-hand side

Why: the product must be negative 54 and the sum negative 3, so one number is negative and the larger in size: the pair is negative 9 and 6.

\[ (z - 9)(z + 6) = 0 \]

Apply the zero product property

Why: set each bracket to zero in turn.

\[ z - 9 = 0 \quad \text{or} \quad z + 6 = 0 \]

Solve each equation

Why: one addition, one subtraction.

\[ z = 9 \quad \text{or} \quad z = -6 \]

Watch the sign flip between the brackets and the roots one more time. The bracket reading z minus 9 produces the root positive 9, and the bracket reading z plus 6 produces the root negative 6. Every bracket hands you a root with the opposite sign to the number written inside it, and reading them off unchanged is the fastest way to get all your answers wrong.

It is worth pausing on why the rearrangement had to come first. Factoring the left-hand side as it stood would have given z times z minus 3, which is perfectly true and completely useless, because the right-hand side was 54 rather than zero and neither factor is pinned down.

Check both roots in the equation as given

Why: eighty-one minus twenty-seven is fifty-four; and thirty-six plus eighteen is fifty-four. Check in the original rather than in your rearranged version, because checking your own rearrangement would happily confirm a slip you made while producing it.

\[ 9^2 - 3(9) = 54, \qquad (-6)^2 - 3(-6) = 54 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 256 — Exercise 33

40. Exercise 41: four sign patterns, one right answer

Elimination

A multiple-choice question in which every wrong option is a sign error rather than a random guess. Factor the left-hand side first, then knock out the three options that misread your own brackets.

\[ x^2 + 2x - 63 = 0 \]

Eliminate the wrong options

Which pair really are the roots of this equation?

  • A. 7 and −9
  • B. −7 and −9
  • C. −7 and 9
  • D. 7 and 9

Survives elimination: A

Why: The pair with product negative 63 and sum 2 is 9 and negative 7, so the factorisation is x plus 9 times x minus 7. Setting each bracket to zero gives x equal to negative 9 or x equal to 7, so the roots are 7 and negative 9. Substituting confirms it: forty-nine plus fourteen minus sixty-three is zero, and eighty-one minus eighteen minus sixty-three is zero.

There is a shortcut for checking a candidate pair of roots without factoring anything, and it is worth having. The two roots must multiply to the constant and add to the negative of the middle coefficient, which for this equation means a product of negative 63 and a sum of negative 2.

Test the surviving option against that: 7 times negative 9 is negative 63, and 7 plus negative 9 is negative 2. Both hold. The option with both signs flipped gives a sum of positive 2, which fails, and it is the one most people pick.

Notice how the sign of the constant alone eliminates two of the four options. A negative constant means the two roots have opposite signs, so any option offering two roots of the same sign is out before you compute anything.

The bracket to root flip is the real lesson here. A bracket reading x plus 9 is zero when x is negative 9, so every bracket hands you a root with the opposite sign to the number written in it. Say that to yourself every time.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 256 — Exercise 41

41. Guided Practice 8: solve x squared minus x minus 42 equals 0

Fill the middle

Your turn, with the structure laid out and the two brackets left blank. The middle coefficient is an invisible negative 1, which is the detail to watch.

Fill in the blanks

x^2 - x - 42 = (x - 7)(x + 6) = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 7 \text___ x = -6

Why: The pair must multiply to negative 42 and add to negative 1, so one is negative and the larger in size: negative 7 and 6. The brackets are x minus 7 and x plus 6, and setting each to zero gives 7 and negative 6. Substituting the first: forty-nine minus seven minus forty-two is zero.

A missing coefficient is a 1, and in this equation the minus in front of the lone x makes it negative 1. Treating it as zero, and therefore hunting for a pair that sums to nothing, is a real and common slip on trinomials written like this one.

Notice that the bracket and the root carry opposite signs in every case here. The bracket x minus 7 gives the root 7, and the bracket x plus 6 gives the root negative 6, which is why the answers never look like the numbers in your factorisation.

Check both roots rather than one. It is possible to factor correctly and then solve one of the two little equations wrongly, and a second substitution costs one line and catches it.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 254 — Guided Practice 8

42. Exercise 35: an equation with no constant term

Worked example

This one looks unfinished because it has no constant term at all. That is not a problem, and in fact it makes the factoring easier rather than harder.

\[ u^2 = -9u \]

Move everything to one side

Why: add 9u to each side so that the right-hand side is zero, which is what the property needs.

\[ u^2 + 9u = 0 \]

Resist the urge to divide both sides by u here. It is the shortest-looking move and it destroys a root: dividing by u assumes u is not zero, and zero turns out to be one of the two answers.

Factor out the common factor u

Why: both terms carry a u, so u times the bracket is the factored form. This is the factoring you learned in Lesson 1.4 for solving a formula.

\[ u(u + 9) = 0 \]

Apply the zero product property

Why: the two factors here are u itself and the bracket u plus 9, and either may be the zero one.

\[ u = 0 \quad \text{or} \quad u + 9 = 0 \]

Solve each

Why: the first is already solved, which is what makes zero easy to miss.

\[ u = 0 \quad \text{or} \quad u = -9 \]

The zero product property does not require both factors to be brackets. A lone u is a perfectly good factor, and the equation u equals zero is already an answer rather than something to work on, which is exactly why people read straight past it.

Equations with no constant term turn up constantly in the rest of the chapter, and they always factor this way: pull out the common factor and one of the roots is zero. If a quadratic passes through the origin, zero is a root, and the graph is the quickest way to see it coming.

Check both roots in the original equation

Why: zero squared is zero and negative nine times zero is zero, so the first works; and eighty-one equals negative nine times negative nine, so the second works too. Had you divided by u at the start you would have reported only negative 9 and lost a genuine solution.

\[ 0^2 = -9(0), \qquad (-9)^2 = -9(-9) \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 256 — Exercise 35

43. How many different roots does a squared bracket give?

Prediction

A perfect square trinomial set equal to zero is worth thinking about before solving, because the two branches of the zero product property turn out to say the same thing twice.

\[ t^2 + 10t + 25 = 0 \]

Predict first

How many different values of t satisfy this equation?

  • Two different values, as usual
  • Exactly one value, because both brackets are the same
  • No values at all
  • Infinitely many values

Correct: Exactly one value, because both brackets are the same

Why: Half of 10 is 5 and 5 squared is 25, so the left-hand side is t plus 5 all squared and the equation reads that bracket squared equals zero. The zero product property still gives two branches, but both read t plus 5 equals 0, so both produce t equal to negative 5. There is one distinct root, and it is called a repeated root or a double root.

\[ (t + 5)^2 = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; t + 5 = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; t = -5 \]

Check it: negative 5 squared is 25, and 10 times negative 5 is negative 50, and 25 minus 50 plus 25 is zero. One value, doing the job of two.

The graph shows what a repeated root looks like. Instead of cutting through the axis at two separate places the curve comes down, touches at a single point, and turns back up, so the vertex sits exactly on the axis.

Lesson 4.8 gives this case a name and a test. The discriminant is zero exactly when the two roots coincide, and a perfect square trinomial is precisely the factorable case where that happens.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 256 — Exercise 31

44. Why does the property need zero specifically?

Socratic

This is the question worth being able to answer in your own words, because a student who can answer it never falls for the product equals 6 trap again. Argue it out rather than memorising the statement.

Discussion prompt

Explain why a product being zero forces one factor to be zero, while a product being 6 forces nothing about either factor. Then say what goes wrong if someone applies the same splitting move to a product equal to 6.

The heart of it is that zero is the only number with no partners. Every other value can be reached in infinitely many ways, so knowing the product leaves both factors free, and only the value that cannot be reached at all without a zero pins anything down.

This is also why the first move on every quadratic equation is to get a zero on one side. It is not a convention: it is the only arrangement in which factoring tells you anything about the solutions.

If it helps, think of it as a gatekeeper. Factoring is the key, and the zero on the right is the lock it fits. A 6 on the right is a different lock entirely, and no amount of good factoring opens it.

45. Building the equation from a situation

Section

Part 4

46. A verbal model turns a sentence into an equation

Concept

So far the equations have been handed to you. In the rest of this part you have to write them, and the book's method for that is a verbal model: say the relationship in words first, with units, and only then replace the words with symbols.

\[ \text{new area} = \text{new length} \times \text{new width} \]

Writing that line before any algebra does two things. It forces you to decide what each quantity means, and it gives you something to check the finished equation against when the symbols start to look strange.

The situations in this lesson all share a shape: a rectangle whose length and width both change by the same unknown amount. That sharing is what makes the equation quadratic, because the unknown ends up in both factors and multiplies itself.

\[ (600 + x)(400 + x) = 480\,000 \]

Notice one more thing before the worked example. The answer to an area problem is a length, so a negative root is not an answer at all, however honestly the algebra produced it. Rejecting it is part of solving the problem, not an afterthought.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 254 — the verbal model in Example 4

47. Example 4: doubling the area of a nature preserve

Worked example

A town's nature preserve has a rectangular field 600 metres by 400 metres. The town wants to double the field's area by adding the same distance to both the length and the width. Find the new dimensions.

\[ \text{new area} = \text{new length} \times \text{new width} \]

Say what x means and write the new dimensions

Why: x is the distance added, in metres, to each of the two dimensions, so the new length is 600 plus x and the new width is 400 plus x.

\[ 2(600)(400) = (600 + x)(400 + x) \]

Double the original area is the left-hand side, and it is a plain number: two lots of 240,000 square metres, which is 480,000. Working it out now keeps the algebra tidier later.

Multiply the right-hand side out

Why: using FOIL: 600 times 400, then 600 times x, then x times 400, and finally x times x.

\[ 480\,000 = 240\,000 + 1000x + x^2 \]

Write the equation in standard form

Why: subtract 480,000 from each side so that the right-hand side is a quadratic expression and the left is zero.

\[ 0 = x^2 + 1000x - 240\,000 \]

Now the search, on numbers much larger than anything so far. The constant is negative, so one factor is positive and one negative, and the sum of 1000 tells you the positive one is larger by exactly 1000. The pair 1200 and negative 200 fits, and 1200 times 200 is 240,000.

Factor and apply the zero product property

Why: the two brackets each get set to zero in turn.

\[ 0 = (x - 200)(x + 1200) \]

Solve and reject the impossible root

Why: x equal to 200 or x equal to negative 1200; a distance added to a field cannot be negative, so only 200 survives.

\[ x = 200 \quad \text{or} \quad x = -1200 \]

Check the surviving root in the situation, not just the equation

Why: adding 200 metres gives a field 800 metres by 600 metres, whose area is 480,000 square metres, and that is exactly twice the original 240,000. The new dimensions are 800 metres by 600 metres.

\[ (800)(600) = 480\,000 = 2(600)(400) \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 254 — Example 4

48. What the added land actually looks like

Picture it

Before doing another of these, look at the shape of the thing being added. The picture explains why one unknown produces a quadratic rather than a linear equation.

Figure (svg): A rectangle 600 metres by 400 metres drawn to scale, with an added strip of width x down its right-hand side and another added strip of width x along its bottom, making a new rectangle 800 metres by 600 metres.

The added land is the orange L shape, and it has to equal the original field's area exactly. One unknown does two jobs here, which is what makes the equation quadratic.

The added land is the orange L, and it comes in three pieces: a strip down the side, a strip along the bottom, and the little square where they meet. The two strips contribute 400x and 600x, and the corner contributes x times x.

\[ (600 + x)(400 + x) = 240\,000 + 1000x + x^2 \]

That corner square is where the quadratic comes from. If only the length were extended, the added area would be 400x and the equation would be linear. It is the corner, where both extensions overlap, that produces the x squared term.

The picture is also the check. With x equal to 200, the side strip is 200 by 400, the bottom strip is 800 by 200, and those come to 80,000 and 160,000 square metres, which add to the 240,000 the town wanted.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 254 — the diagram beside Example 4

49. Guided Practice 9: the same field, different starting size

Worked example

The book's follow-up: suppose the field starts at 1000 metres by 300 metres instead, and is again to be doubled by adding the same distance to both dimensions. The method does not change at all, which is the point of practising it twice.

\[ 2(1000)(300) = (1000 + x)(300 + x) \]

Work out the target area and multiply the right-hand side out

Why: twice 300,000 is 600,000, and the product expands to the original area plus 1300x plus x squared.

\[ 600\,000 = 300\,000 + 1300x + x^2 \]

Write the equation in standard form

Why: move everything to the right so the left-hand side is zero.

\[ 0 = x^2 + 1300x - 300\,000 \]

The search again: the constant is negative, so the two numbers have opposite signs, and the sum 1300 says the positive one is larger by 1300. Try 1500 and negative 200, since 1500 times 200 is 300,000 and 1500 minus 200 is 1300.

Factor and split

Why: the pair 1500 and negative 200 gives the two brackets.

\[ 0 = (x - 200)(x + 1500) \]

Solve and reject

Why: negative 1500 metres is not a distance you can add to a field, so x is 200.

\[ x = 200 \quad \text{or} \quad x = -1500 \]

It is a genuine coincidence that x is 200 again, and a useful one: it shows that the answer depends on the shape of the field as well as its area, since the same 200 metres does very different things to a 600 by 400 field and a 1000 by 300 one.

Check the new dimensions against the requirement

Why: 1200 metres by 500 metres is 600,000 square metres, twice the original 300,000. The new field is 1200 metres by 500 metres.

\[ (1200)(500) = 600\,000 = 2(1000)(300) \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 254 — Guided Practice 9

50. Exercise 65: tripling a skate park

Real world

Same shape of problem with a different multiplier, so that the words triple the area have to be read carefully rather than assumed. A city's skate park is 100 feet long by 50 feet wide.

\[ 3(100)(50) = (100 + x)(50 + x) \]

Discussion prompt

The city wants to triple the area of the park by adding the same distance x to both the length and the width. Write the equation in standard form, solve it by factoring, reject the root the situation forbids, and give the new dimensions.

The only thing that changed from Example 4 is the number on the left-hand side, and that is worth noticing because it tells you the method is about the structure, not the numbers. Double, triple and halve all produce the same shape of equation.

Watch the word same in the phrase the same distance x. That is what puts x into both brackets and makes the equation quadratic. If the length and width were extended by different amounts there would be two unknowns and one equation, and no unique answer.

Estimating first is a good habit on problems like this. Tripling the area needs roughly to multiply both dimensions by about 1.7, so an x of around 40 to 70 feet is expected, and 50 lands comfortably in that range.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 257 — Exercise 65

51. Exercise 70: halving a deck, and the root that lies

Worked example

A recreation centre's deck is 21 feet long by 20 feet wide, and its area is to be halved by subtracting the same distance from both dimensions. The subtraction changes the signs, and it also produces a rejected root for a more interesting reason than usual.

\[ (21 - x)(20 - x) = \tfrac12 (21)(20) \]

Work out the target area and multiply the left-hand side out

Why: half of 420 is 210, and the product expands with a negative middle term because both brackets subtract x.

\[ 420 - 41x + x^2 = 210 \]

Write the equation in standard form

Why: subtract 210 from each side.

\[ x^2 - 41x + 210 = 0 \]

The constant is positive and the middle coefficient negative, so both numbers in the pair are negative. They multiply to 210 and add to negative 41, and since 210 is 6 times 35 the pair is negative 6 and negative 35.

Factor and split

Why: both brackets subtract, as the sign reasoning promised.

\[ (x - 6)(x - 35) = 0 \]

Solve, then test both roots against the situation

Why: x equal to 6 or x equal to 35; but taking 35 feet off a deck only 21 feet long would give a length of negative 14 feet, which is not a deck.

\[ x = 6 \quad \text{or} \quad x = 35 \]

Figure (svg): A rectangle 21 feet by 20 feet with a smaller rectangle 15 feet by 14 feet drawn inside its top left corner, the removed strips along the right-hand side and the bottom each marked with a width of x equal to 6 feet.

Shrinking uses the same picture read inwards. The rejected root is not just too big: at 35 feet both new sides would be negative lengths.

This rejection is worth dwelling on because it is not the usual one. The root 35 is positive, so it passes the naive test of being a sensible distance; it fails only when you put it back into the situation and find both new sides negative.

Check the surviving root

Why: taking 6 feet off each dimension leaves 15 feet by 14 feet, which is 210 square feet, exactly half the original 420. Notice that the rejected root also satisfies the equation, since negative 14 times negative 15 is also 210; the two negatives multiply to a positive area, which is why the algebra cannot tell that answer apart and you have to.

\[ (15)(14) = 210 = \tfrac12 (21)(20) \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 257 — Exercise 70

52. Exercise 71: when the doubling refuses to factor

Edge cases

One last area problem, and this one breaks. A square garden has sides 10 feet long, and a gardener wants to double its area by adding the same distance to both the length and the width.

\[ (10 + x)^2 = 2(10)(10) \]

Figure (svg): A square garden 10 feet on each side, drawn inside a larger square whose side is 10 plus x, where x is about 4.14 feet. The larger square's area is 200 square feet, twice the garden's 100.

The picture is perfectly reasonable and the answer certainly exists. It is factoring that fails here, which is the honest reason later lessons need another method.

Discussion prompt

Write the equation this x must satisfy in standard form. Then try to solve it by factoring, and explain exactly what goes wrong and what that tells you about the answer.

Look at how close the search came. The pair 4 and negative 25 sums to negative 21 and the pair 25 and negative 4 sums to 21, so a middle coefficient of 21 would have factored beautifully and 20 misses by one.

So factoring is a method with a domain, and this problem sits outside it. That is not a failure of the problem or of you, and it is exactly the gap Lesson 4.7 fills with completing the square and Lesson 4.8 fills with the quadratic formula.

Notice which feature of the situation caused it. The garden was square, so the equation was a squared bracket equal to a number, and the number 200 is not a perfect square. A rectangle 10 by 5 doubled would have factored; a square almost never does.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 258 — Exercise 71

53. Exercise 59: find the side of a rectangle of area 36

Worked example

A geometry problem rather than an expansion one. A rectangle has one side x and the other x plus 5, and its area is 36. Find x.

\[ x(x + 5) = 36 \]

Multiply out and write in standard form

Why: distribute the x, then subtract 36 from each side so the right-hand side is zero.

\[ x^2 + 5x - 36 = 0 \]

The constant is negative, so the two numbers have opposite signs, and the sum 5 makes the positive one larger by 5. Nine and negative 4 have product negative 36 and difference 5, so that is the pair.

Factor and split

Why: set each bracket to zero in turn.

\[ (x + 9)(x - 4) = 0 \]

Solve and reject the negative length

Why: x equal to negative 9 or x equal to 4; a side of a rectangle cannot be negative 9, so x is 4.

\[ x = -9 \quad \text{or} \quad x = 4 \]

Figure (svg): A rectangle nine units wide and four units tall, ruled into thirty-six unit squares, with its width labelled x plus 5 and its height labelled x, and its area marked 36.

Thirty-six unit squares fit exactly into a four by nine rectangle. The other root would ask for a side of negative nine, which no rectangle has.

The picture shows why 4 is right in a way the algebra does not. Thirty-six unit squares arrange into a rectangle four along one side and nine along the other, and nine is indeed four plus five.

Geometry problems like this always come with a hidden condition that the algebra knows nothing about: every length has to be positive. Writing that condition down beside the equation, before solving, turns rejecting a root from a piece of intuition into a step you can point at.

Check the answer against the geometry

Why: with x equal to 4 the sides are 4 and 9, and four nines are thirty-six, the area given. The rejected root would have made the sides negative 9 and negative 4, whose product is also 36, which is why the equation accepts it and the rectangle does not.

\[ 4(4 + 5) = 4(9) = 36 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 257 — Exercise 59

54. Exercise 42: write the equation, do not solve it

Step zero

Sometimes the whole difficulty is the setting up, so here is a problem where that is all you are asked for. A rectangular picnic site measures 24 feet by 10 feet, and you want to double its area by adding the same distance x to the length and the width.

Discussion prompt

Write down an equation you could solve to find x. Say in a sentence what each side of your equation represents, and do not solve it.

The habit being built is to name the unknown before writing anything else. Here x is a distance in feet, added to both dimensions, and saying that out loud prevents the commonest setup error, which is letting x stand for the new length instead.

Check the equation makes sense before solving it. At x equal to zero the left-hand side is 240 and the right is 480, so the left is too small, and it grows as x grows, which means a positive answer exists. That reasoning costs ten seconds and catches a mis-set-up equation.

One more reason to write the equation before touching it: the phrase double the area could be misread as double both dimensions, which would give a completely different and much larger answer. Putting the words into symbols is where that ambiguity gets settled.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 256 — Exercise 42

55. The zeros of a quadratic function

Section

Part 5

56. Three words for the same number

Concept

The last part of the lesson renames something you have already found. When a quadratic is written as a function rather than an equation, the values that make it zero get a new name.

zero of a function — A number k is a zero of the function y equals f of x if f of k equals zero. For a quadratic written in intercept form, the zeros are the two numbers being subtracted from x inside the brackets.

Figure (svg): The parabola y equals x squared minus 4x minus 12 with its two axis crossings marked, and three labels joined by arrows to the crossing at 6: zero of the function, x-intercept of the graph, and root of the equation.

One number, three jobs. Which word gets used depends only on whether you are talking about a function, a picture or an equation.

The picture has one number, 6, wearing three labels. It is a zero of the function because putting 6 in gives an output of zero. It is an x-intercept of the graph because the curve crosses the axis there. It is a root of the equation because setting the expression to zero and solving gives 6.

Which word you use depends only on what you are talking about: a function, a picture, or an equation. The book says this explicitly in a margin note, and it is worth taking seriously, because examination questions switch between the three words freely and expect you not to blink.

Lesson 4.2 gave you the shortcut for intercept form, where the crossings can be read straight out of the brackets. Factoring is what lets you get into that form in the first place, which is why the two lessons belong together.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 255 — the Understand Representations note on zeros, intercepts and roots

57. Example 5(a): find the zeros of y equals x squared minus x minus 12

Worked example

Find the zeros by rewriting the function in intercept form. The function is not an equation, so nothing gets moved across: you simply factor the right-hand side.

\[ y = x^2 - x - 12 \]

Factor the right-hand side

Why: the pair must multiply to negative 12 and add to negative 1, so one is negative and the larger in size: negative 4 and 3.

\[ y = (x + 3)(x - 4) \]

That is intercept form, the shape Lesson 4.2 taught you to read. The two numbers inside the brackets give the crossings with their signs flipped, so a bracket of x plus 3 means a crossing at negative 3.

Read the zeros off the brackets

Why: each bracket is zero at one value of x, and those two values are the zeros of the function.

\[ x + 3 = 0 \text{ or } x - 4 = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = -3 \text{ or } x = 4 \]

Figure (svg): The parabola y equals x squared minus x minus 12 crossing the horizontal axis at negative 3 and at 4, with both crossings marked and the lowest point below the axis between them.

The factored form names the two crossings and the graph confirms them. The vertex sits exactly halfway between the two zeros, which is the check worth making every time.

The book checks this with a graphing calculator and so does the picture: the curve passes through negative 3 and 4 on the axis. There is a second check worth making, which is that the vertex sits halfway between the two zeros, at x equal to one half.

Check both zeros by substituting into the function

Why: nine plus three minus twelve is zero, and sixteen minus four minus twelve is zero, so the function really does output zero at both values.

\[ (-3)^2 - (-3) - 12 = 0, \qquad 4^2 - 4 - 12 = 0 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 255 — Example 5(a)

58. Example 5(b): a function with only one zero

Worked example

The second half of the book's example, and it behaves differently. Factor it first and see what the difference is before reading on.

\[ y = x^2 + 12x + 36 \]

Factor the right-hand side

Why: the constant 36 is 6 squared and the middle term 12x is twice 6x, so this is the perfect square pattern from Part 2.

\[ y = (x + 6)(x + 6) \]

Both brackets are identical, which is the whole story of this example. Writing it as a square rather than a product makes the point clearer, and either form is correct.

\[ y = (x + 6)^2 \]

Read the zeros off the brackets

Why: both brackets vanish at the same value, so the two zeros coincide and there is only one distinct zero.

\[ x + 6 = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = -6 \]

Figure (svg): The parabola y equals x squared plus 12x plus 36 touching the horizontal axis at negative 6 without crossing it, its lowest point sitting on the axis.

Both brackets are the same, so both zeros fall at the same place and the curve bounces off the axis instead of passing through it.

The graph does not cross the axis at all: it comes down, touches at negative 6, and turns back up. That touching is what a repeated zero looks like, and it happens exactly when a quadratic is a perfect square.

Compare that with Example 5(a), where the curve cut cleanly through the axis in two places and dipped below it in between. Here there is no in between to dip into, because the two crossings have collapsed onto each other, and the lowest point of the curve is the crossing.

Check the single zero, and check a nearby value

Why: thirty-six minus seventy-two plus thirty-six is zero, so negative 6 is a zero; and at negative 5 the function gives 25 minus 60 plus 36, which is 1, a positive value. The function never goes below zero, which is why the curve only touches.

\[ (-6)^2 + 12(-6) + 36 = 0, \qquad (-5)^2 + 12(-5) + 36 = 1 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 255 — Example 5(b)

59. Match each function to its zeros

Matching

Four functions from the exercise set. Factor each one mentally, then flip the signs of the numbers in the brackets. The sign flip is the step this exercise is really testing.

Match the pairs

  • a. y = x² + 5x − 14
  • b. y = x² − 7x − 30
  • c. f(x) = x² − 10x + 25
  • d. y = x² − 12x − 45
  • w. −7 and 2
  • x. 10 and −3
  • y. 5, repeated
  • z. 15 and −3

Why: The first factors as x plus 7 times x minus 2, giving negative 7 and 2. The second factors as x minus 10 times x plus 3, giving 10 and negative 3. The third is x minus 5 all squared, a perfect square whose single zero is 5. The fourth factors as x minus 15 times x plus 3, giving 15 and negative 3. Two of these share a zero at negative 3, so read the other zero to tell them apart rather than matching on the first number you recognise.

Two of the four answers contain negative 3, which is deliberate. Matching on one number is not enough here, and the exercise punishes a quick glance in exactly the way a test question would.

The pair with a repeated zero is the one to notice: its constant is 25 and its middle coefficient is negative 10, so half the middle coefficient squared is exactly the constant, and both brackets come out the same. That fingerprint is quicker to spot than the pair search.

Check any one of them by adding the two zeros together. For a monic quadratic the two zeros always add to the negative of the middle coefficient, so 10 and negative 3 should add to 7, and they do.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 256 — Exercises 44 to 55

60. Slide the constant and watch the two zeros meet

Tweak it

The zeros are not fixed features of a shape: they move when the function does. Fix the middle term at 3x and slide the constant term, then watch what the two crossings do.

Parameter explorer

Start at the value negative 28, where the curve crosses at negative 7 and at 4. Raise the constant and watch the two crossings move towards each other. At which value of the constant do they meet, and what happens to the crossings above that value?

\[ y = x^2 + 3x + ({c}) \]

  • c — from -28 to 6: constant term

Notice that the curve never changes shape as you slide: it only moves up and down. The vertex stays at x equal to negative 1.5 throughout, which is halfway between the two zeros wherever they happen to be.

Three regimes appear as the constant rises: two crossings, then one, then none. Lesson 4.8 gives each of those a number, the discriminant, and the value 2.25 is exactly where that number reaches zero.

Try a few whole-number values and see how rarely the crossings land on whole numbers. Negative 28, negative 10 and negative 4 factor; most others do not, which is a fair picture of how often factoring is available in real problems.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 255 — Example 5, with the graphical check the book makes

61. Guided Practice 10 to 12: three functions, three sets of zeros

Fill the middle

The book's three checkpoints for Example 5, in one line each. Factor, then flip the signs to get the zeros.

Fill in the blanks

x^2 + 5x - 14 = (x + 7)(x - 2); \quad x^2 - 7x - 30 = (x - 10)(x + 3); \quad x^2 - 10x + 25 = (x - 5)^2

Why: For the first, the pair with product negative 14 and sum 5 is 7 and negative 2, so the zeros are negative 7 and 2. For the second, the pair with product negative 30 and sum negative 7 is negative 10 and 3, so the zeros are 10 and negative 3. The third is a perfect square: half of 10 is 5 and 5 squared is 25, so it is x minus 5 all squared and the single zero is 5.

Watch the third one in particular. The book writes it as a function called f of x rather than y, and nothing about the method changes: f of x is just another name for the output, and the zeros are the inputs that make it zero.

Check each answer by adding the two zeros. Negative 7 and 2 add to negative 5, which is the negative of the middle coefficient 5. Ten and negative 3 add to 7, the negative of negative 7. The repeated zero 5 counts twice, and 5 plus 5 is 10, the negative of negative 10.

That sum test is quick, and it catches the sign flip going the wrong way, which is by far the commonest error on these. If your zeros add to the middle coefficient rather than to its negative, you have copied the bracket numbers across without flipping them.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 255 — Guided Practice 10, 11 and 12

62. One number, three questions it answers

Comparison

Fill in the table to make the three vocabularies line up. Each row is one way of asking about the same number, and the last column is what you would actually write down.

Comparison matrix

you are giventhe questionthe name of the answerfor x² − 4x − 12
a function y = f(x)which inputs give an output of zero?zero−2 and 6
a graphwhere does the curve cross the horizontal axis?x-intercept-2 and 6
an equation ... = 0which values satisfy it?root−2 and 6
intercept formwhat is inside the brackets?the numbers to flip the sign of(x + 2)(x − 6)

The last column is the same pair of numbers four times over, which is the point of the table. Nothing about the answer changes when the question is rephrased, only the word used to describe it.

The bottom row is the one that does the work in practice. Intercept form holds the answer, but with the signs reversed, so a bracket of x plus 2 gives a zero of negative 2 and a bracket of x minus 6 gives a zero of 6.

Worth remembering for the rest of the chapter: whenever a question mentions x-intercepts, zeros or roots, the first thing to reach for is a factorisation. All three questions are answered by the same piece of work.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 255 — the three names in the margin note

63. Putting it together

Section

Part 6

64. The route, from a question to a checked answer

Pattern

Everything in this lesson is one route with a few branches. What follows is the order to work in, and the order matters: getting a zero on one side before you factor is what makes the rest legitimate.

  1. Is there a zero on one side? If not, move everything across until there is. A quadratic equal to 6, or to 54, is not ready for anything.
  2. Check the two patterns first. Two square terms with a minus between them factor instantly, and a trinomial whose middle term is twice the product of the two square roots is a bracket squared.
  3. Otherwise search. Find the pair whose product is the constant and whose sum is the middle coefficient, using the two signs to shorten the list before you list anything.
  4. Split with the zero product property, then solve the two one-step equations. The brackets and the roots always carry opposite signs.
  5. Reject what the situation forbids, then check every surviving answer in the original, by substitution for an equation and by measurement for a word problem.

The second step is where time is won or lost. Recognising a pattern turns a list of five factor pairs into one square root, and it costs a single glance at the two end terms to find out whether you are entitled to it.

The last step is the one people skip, and it is the only one that catches a mistake. A substitution takes one line and it tests the factoring, the splitting and the arithmetic all at once.

And when the search fails? Say so, and say why: no integer pair satisfies both conditions. That is a complete answer in this lesson, and in Lessons 4.7 and 4.8 it becomes the signal to use a different method rather than a dead end.

65. Exercise 57: build the equation from its roots

Worked example

The method run backwards, which is the best test of whether you understand it. Write a quadratic equation in the form x squared plus bx plus c equals zero whose roots are 8 and 11.

Start from the shape the answer must have. If the roots are 8 and 11, then the two brackets must vanish at 8 and at 11, so they are x minus 8 and x minus 11. Remember the sign flip: a root of 8 comes from a bracket that subtracts 8.

Write the product of the two brackets, set to zero

Why: each bracket is zero at one of the required roots, so the product is zero at both and nowhere else.

\[ (x - 8)(x - 11) = 0 \]

Multiply out to reach the requested form

Why: the two middle products are negative 11x and negative 8x, which combine to negative 19x, and negative 8 times negative 11 is positive 88.

\[ x^2 - 19x + 88 = 0 \]

Sanity-check the two coefficients against the two conditions you have used all lesson. The constant must be the product of the two bracket numbers, and 8 times 11 is 88. The middle coefficient must be their sum with the sign flipped, and 8 plus 11 is 19.

Check by solving your own equation

Why: factor it back and the two brackets return, giving exactly the roots you were asked for. Any multiple of this equation would also have those roots, so the requested leading coefficient of 1 is what makes the answer unique.

\[ x^2 - 19x + 88 = (x - 8)(x - 11) = 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 8 \text{ or } x = 11 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring §4.3, p. 256 — Exercise 57

66. Check: which factorisation is correct

Check

Back to the search, with the signs doing all the work. Read the constant's sign and the middle term's sign before you look at the options, and decide what shape the brackets must have.

Check your understanding

Factor x² − 4x − 12.

  • A. (x − 6)(x + 2) (correct)
  • B. (x − 2)(x + 6)
  • C. (x − 6)(x − 2)
  • D. (x + 6)(x + 2)

Answer: A

Why: The constant is negative, so the two numbers have opposite signs, and the middle coefficient is negative, so the negative one is the larger in size. Negative 6 and 2 multiply to negative 12 and add to negative 4. Multiplying back out gives x squared plus 2x minus 6x minus 12, which is x squared minus 4x minus 12.

Why B tempts people
These numbers have the right sizes but the minus is on the wrong one: 6 and negative 2 add to positive 4, so this expands with a middle term of plus 4x.
Why C tempts people
Two minuses give a positive constant, and this expands to x squared minus 8x plus 12, not a negative constant at all.
Why D tempts people
Two pluses give a positive constant and a positive middle term, and this expands to x squared plus 8x plus 12.

Notice that two of the wrong options can be eliminated by the sign of the constant alone, before any arithmetic. A negative constant needs one plus and one minus, so any option with two matching signs is out.

The remaining wrong option is the interesting one, because it has the right two numbers with the minus on the wrong member. The only way to separate it from the correct answer is to add the pair and compare with the middle coefficient.

If you want a check that takes five seconds, substitute a small number. At x equal to 1 the original gives 1 minus 4 minus 12, which is negative 15, and only one of the four options gives negative 15 at x equal to 1.

The habit worth taking from this question is reading the signs first. It converts a four-way guess into a two-way decision every single time the constant is negative.

67. Check: an equation that is not yet ready

Check

This one tests the first step of the route rather than the factoring. Ask what has to happen before the zero product property is allowed anywhere near it.

Check your understanding

What are the roots of (x − 2)(x − 3) = 6?

  • A. x = 8 or x = 9
  • B. x = 0 or x = 5 (correct)
  • C. x = 2 or x = 3
  • D. There are no roots

Answer: B

Why: The right-hand side is not zero, so the two brackets cannot be set to anything individually. Multiply out to get x squared minus 5x plus 6 equals 6, subtract 6 from both sides to get x squared minus 5x equals 0, factor as x times x minus 5, and read off the roots 0 and 5. Both check: at 0 the product is negative 2 times negative 3, which is 6, and at 5 it is 3 times 2, which is also 6.

Why A tempts people
This comes from setting each bracket equal to 6, which the zero product property does not permit. Testing it, at 8 the product is 6 times 5, which is 30, not 6.
Why C tempts people
These are the values that make each bracket zero, so they give a product of 0 rather than 6. At 2 the product is 0 times negative 1.
Why D tempts people
The equation certainly has solutions; the curve for the left-hand side reaches the height 6 in two places, and factoring after rearranging finds them both.

The choice offering 8 and 9 is the trap from Part 3 dressed as an answer, and it is chosen more often than any other. The guard against it is a question, not a rule: is there a zero on one side yet?

The choice offering 2 and 3 is worth understanding too. Those values do make the brackets vanish, so they solve a different equation, the one with zero on the right, and misreading which equation you are solving is its own kind of error.

Notice how little work the correct route needed once the 6 had been moved. The rearranged left-hand side had no constant term at all, so the common factor x came straight out and one of the roots was zero.

Keep the pair 0 and 5 in mind as a reminder that zero is a perfectly ordinary root. Nothing about a root of zero is degenerate; it just means the curve passes through the origin.

68. Check: the zeros of a function

Check

The last check joins the two halves of the lesson. Factor the function, then remember that the zeros are the bracket numbers with their signs reversed.

Check your understanding

What are the zeros of f(x) = x² + 6x − 55?

  • A. −11 and 5 (correct)
  • B. −11 and −5
  • C. −5 and 11
  • D. 5 and 11

Answer: A

Why: The pair with product negative 55 and sum 6 is 11 and negative 5, so the function factors as x plus 11 times x minus 5. Setting each bracket to zero gives x equal to negative 11 or x equal to 5. Substituting negative 11 gives 121 minus 66 minus 55, which is zero, and substituting 5 gives 25 plus 30 minus 55, which is also zero.

Why B tempts people
Two negative zeros would multiply to a positive constant, and the constant here is negative 55, so the two zeros must have opposite signs.
Why C tempts people
This is the correct pair with both signs flipped, which comes from copying the bracket numbers across without reversing them. Their sum would be 6 rather than negative 6.
Why D tempts people
Two positive zeros would again give a positive constant, and 5 times 11 is positive 55 rather than negative 55.

Two of the options fail on the sign of the constant alone. For a monic quadratic the two zeros multiply to give the constant, so a negative constant guarantees one positive and one negative zero.

The surviving wrong option is the sign flip done in the wrong direction, and it is the single commonest mistake in this part of the lesson. The zeros multiply to the constant and add to the negative of the middle coefficient: negative 11 plus 5 is negative 6, which matches.

This question is the book's own multiple choice from Exercise 56, and the four options are chosen to punish exactly that flip. Reading the brackets aloud helps: x plus 11 is zero when x is negative 11.

If you get this one right without hesitating, you have the whole of Part 5: factor, flip the signs, and check by substituting both values back into the function.

69. Say why the zero matters, in your own words

Explain it to yourself

One idea has carried this lesson, and putting it into your own sentences is what makes it stick. Write your answer out before reading the one provided.

Discussion prompt

In three or four sentences, explain why a quadratic equation is rearranged to have a zero on one side before it is factored, and what the factoring then buys you. Mention what goes wrong if the other side is 6 instead of 0.

If your explanation used the word factor more than the word zero, try writing it again. Factoring is the technique, but the zero is the reason the technique helps, and it is the part that transfers to cubics and beyond.

A good test of your own understanding: could you explain to somebody why the roots of a product equal to 6 have nothing to do with the number 6 appearing in either bracket? If yes, you have the idea the whole of Part 3 was built to deliver.

Try the same reasoning on a longer product. If three brackets multiply to zero then at least one of them is zero, and the argument is identical, which is why this one property serves every polynomial equation you will meet.

70. Exit ticket

Exit ticket

One question that uses every part of the lesson: a rearrangement, a search, a split, and a check.

\[ x^2 - 8x = -12 \]

Discussion prompt

Put this equation in standard form, solve it by factoring, and check both roots in the equation as it is given. Then say what the two roots are called when the same expression is written as a function instead.

Notice that the equation arrived with a negative number on the right, which is the version most likely to be mishandled. Adding 12 to both sides is what puts it in standard form, and the constant in the standard form is positive 12 rather than negative 12.

The sign reasoning saves real time here. A positive constant with a negative middle term means both numbers are negative, so you never have to consider the pairs 1 with 12, 2 with 6 or 3 with 4 in their positive versions at all.

If you found yourself factoring before rearranging, that is the habit to break tonight. The left-hand side as given, x squared minus 8x, does factor as x times x minus 8, and it buys you nothing because the right-hand side is not zero.

Finally, say the three names to yourself one more time. Two and 6 are the roots of the equation, the zeros of the function and the x-intercepts of the graph, and the work you did was the same for all three.

71. What you can do now

Recap

Two skills, joined by one property. Factoring turns a trinomial into a product, and the zero product property turns that product into two one-step equations. Neither is much use without the other.

what you havewhat to doexample from this lesson
a trinomial with a positive constantboth numbers agree in sign; the middle term says whichx² − 9x + 20 = (x − 4)(x − 5)
a trinomial with a negative constantone of each sign; the larger takes the middle term's signx² − 3x − 18 = (x + 3)(x − 6)
two squares with a minus betweenthe sum times the difference, no search neededx² − 49 = (x + 7)(x − 7)
square ends and a doubled middle termone bracket squared, with the middle term's signz² − 26z + 169 = (z − 13)²
a product equal to zeroset each factor to zero and solve both(x − 4)(x + 7) = 0 gives 4 and −7
a product equal to anything elsemultiply out, move it across, then factor(x − 2)(x − 3) = 6 gives 0 and 5

The last two rows are the ones to reread. They look almost identical and they are handled completely differently, and mixing them up is the error this lesson has warned about three times.

\[ x^2 + bx + c = (x + m)(x + n) \text{ where } mn = c \text{ and } m + n = b \]

That line is the whole of the search, and it is worth being able to derive rather than recall: multiply the two brackets out and the two conditions fall out of comparing coefficients. A rule you can rebuild is a rule you cannot forget.

Remember also what the lesson could not do. A trinomial that no integer pair fits, like the square garden's doubling, is not unsolvable; it is outside factoring's reach. Lesson 4.7 completes the square and Lesson 4.8 gives the quadratic formula, which works on every quadratic including the ones here.

Lesson 4.4 is the immediate sequel. It puts a number in front of the x squared term, so the two brackets no longer both start with a plain x, and the search grows to include that number's factors as well. Everything about signs and about the zero product property carries over unchanged.

OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §1.5 Factoring Polynomials §1.5 — the same pair search, called factoring a trinomial with leading coefficient 1

Sources

  1. McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 4 Quadratic Functions and Factoring — Lesson 4.3 Solve x^2 + bx + c = 0 by Factoring — Larson, Boswell, Kanold & Stiff, McDougal Littell / Houghton Mifflin, 2007, pp. 252-257
  2. OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §1.5 Factoring Polynomials
  3. OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §2.5 Quadratic Equations

Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Algebra 2 — $55/session, free consultation.

Book on Wyzant · Text (657) 465-8108