The substitution method and the elimination method for solving a linear system exactly, how to choose between them, what the no-solution and infinitely-many cases look like algebraically, and modelling with a system solved by algebra.
Subject: Algebra 2 · 69 slides · symbolic lesson
Open the interactive version of this deck
Title
Algebra 2 · Lesson 3.2
Two routes to the crossing point, and no graph paper needed
Objectives
Lesson 3.1 found the solution of a system by drawing both lines and looking at where they met. That works, it builds the right picture, and it has one hard limit: you can only read off a point your eye can resolve on a grid ruled in whole units.
This lesson replaces the eye with algebra. Two methods, both exact, both finishing with an ordered pair you can check. Neither one draws anything, and both of them will find a crossing point at negative four thirds without hesitating.
Keep the graph from Lesson 3.1 nearby as you go. Everything here is still about lines crossing, or failing to cross, and two or three times in this deck you will see the algebraic answer and the picture agree.
One habit runs through every slide: a pair of numbers is only a solution of the system if it satisfies both original equations. Every worked example in this deck ends by checking both, and so should yours.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 160 — Before, Now, Why and the Key Vocabulary
Warm-up
Before the new methods, look at what the old one left on the table. The graphing calculator activity at the end of Lesson 3.1 asked for the crossing point of this system, and reported an answer to two decimal places.
\[ \begin{cases} 6x - 9y = -20 \\ 2x + 4y = -52 \end{cases} \]
\[ \text{the calculator said about } (-13.05, -6.48) \]
Discussion prompt
Substitute the calculator's rounded pair into the first equation and work out what it actually gives. Then say what you would need in order to write the crossing point down exactly.
This is the whole argument for the lesson in one slide. Graphing is honest about roughly where the answer is, and silent about exactly what it is. Both methods you are about to learn are exact, and both end in numbers you can check.
Notice also how the check worked: you put the pair into the original equation and compared the two sides. That is the move the rest of this deck ends every worked example with, so it is worth getting comfortable with now.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.1, p. 159 — the graphing calculator activity that closes Lesson 3.1
Section
Part 1
Concept
A system is hard for exactly one reason: two letters. An equation in one letter you have solved since Lesson 1.3, and nothing in this chapter is harder than that. So both algebraic methods spend their first move getting rid of a letter.
Figure (svg): A flow diagram: one box reading two equations, two unknowns, splitting into a substitution box and an elimination box, which both lead down to a box reading one equation, one unknown.
Substitution removes a letter by replacing it. Solve one equation for one of its letters, then write that expression wherever the letter appears in the other equation, and the other equation now mentions only one letter.
substitution method — Solve one of the equations for one of its variables, substitute that expression into the other equation, and solve the single-variable equation that results.
Elimination removes a letter by cancelling it. Arrange for one letter to have coefficients that are the same size with opposite signs, then add the two equations, and that letter adds to nothing.
elimination method — Multiply one or both equations so that one variable's coefficients differ only in sign, then add the equations so that variable disappears.
Neither is more correct. Both give exact answers, both work on every system, and the choice between them is only ever about which one produces cleaner arithmetic on the system in front of you. Part 3 is about making that choice quickly.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, pp. 160-161 — the two Key Concept boxes
Intuition
Before any method, be precise about what you are hunting for. A solution of a system is a single pair of numbers that makes both equations true at the same time. One out of two is not a near miss; it is not a solution at all.
\[ \begin{cases} 2x + 5y = -5 \\ x + 3y = 3 \end{cases} \]
Take the pair with x equal to 5 and y equal to negative 3. Put it in the second equation and it works perfectly. Put it in the first and it does not.
| pair | first equation | second equation | solution? |
|---|---|---|---|
| (5, −3) | 10 − 15 = −5 ✓ | 5 − 9 = −4, not 3 | no |
| (−9, 4) | −18 + 20 = 2, not −5 | −9 + 12 = 3 ✓ | no |
| (−30, 11) | −60 + 55 = −5 ✓ | −30 + 33 = 3 ✓ | yes |
Read down the first two columns. Each of the first two rows satisfies one equation, which means each of them sits on one of the two lines. Only the third row sits on both lines at once, and that is what a crossing point is.
This is why every check in this deck substitutes into both originals. Checking one equation only tells you that you are somewhere on one line, which you already knew, because that is where your algebra started.
Notation
The brace at the left is doing real work, so take a moment over it. It says these two equations are to be treated as one demand, not as two separate problems that happen to be printed together.
Annotate
On: \( \begin{cases} 2x + 5y = -5 \\ x + 3y = 3 \end{cases} \)
The last note is the habit to build. A system's answer is a point, so it is written as an ordered pair, and the order is always x first. Reporting eleven and negative thirty would be the right numbers and the wrong answer.
The middle note is worth arguing with rather than accepting. Why should two equations pin down a point at all? Because each one, by itself, allows a whole line of pairs; asking for a pair on both lines at once usually leaves exactly one.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 160 — Example 1, the system as printed
Concept
The book gives substitution as three numbered steps, and the numbering matters, because step three is the one that gets left out. Here they are with the reason for each.
Figure (svg): Equation 2 rearranged as x equals negative three y plus three sits in a box; an arrow carries that expression into Equation 1, where the x is picked out in yellow and underlined, producing an equation in y alone.
The picture shows the second step happening. The highlighted x in the first equation is replaced, in brackets, by an expression that is worth exactly the same. Nothing about which pairs of numbers work has changed, and yet one letter has gone.
Brackets around the substituted expression are not decoration. The coefficient in front of the letter has to multiply the whole expression, and the commonest wrong line in this part of the lesson is a coefficient multiplying only the first term of it.
Step three is where half the marks live. Finding y is halfway: a system's answer is a point, and a point needs two coordinates, so the value you found has to go back in to produce the other one.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 160 — The Substitution Method key concept box
Worked example
This is the book's opening example. Read the four coefficients before doing anything: two, five, one and three. The one is in the second equation, in front of x, and that decides everything that follows.
\[ \begin{cases} 2x + 5y = -5 & \text{Equation 1} \\ x + 3y = 3 & \text{Equation 2} \end{cases} \]
Solve Equation 2 for x
Why: Its x carries a coefficient of 1, so a single subtraction frees it and no fractions appear anywhere.
\[ x = -3y + 3 \]
Keep this line. It is called the revised Equation 2 and step three needs it again, so writing it once and labelling it saves you re-deriving it later.
Substitute that expression into Equation 1
Why: Every x in the OTHER equation becomes the bracket, which leaves y as the only letter.
\[ 2(-3y + 3) + 5y = -5 \]
Expand the bracket
Why: The 2 multiplies both terms inside: twice negative three y is negative six y, and twice three is six.
\[ -6y + 6 + 5y = -5 \]
Collect the y terms
Why: Negative six y plus five y is negative one y, which is written as negative y.
\[ -y + 6 = -5 \]
Solve for y
Why: Subtract 6 from both sides, then multiply both sides by negative 1.
\[ -y = -11 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = 11 \]
Now step three, the one people forget. The value 11 goes back into the revised Equation 2, because that equation is already arranged to hand you x.
Substitute 11 for y in the revised Equation 2
Why: Negative three elevens is negative thirty-three, and three more than that is negative thirty.
\[ x = -3(11) + 3 = -33 + 3 = -30 \]
Check in BOTH original equations
Why: Substituting the pair into each row in turn: the first gives negative sixty plus fifty-five, and the second gives negative thirty plus thirty-three. Both rows hold, which is what makes this pair a solution of the system rather than of one equation.
\[ 2(-30) + 5(11) = -60 + 55 = -5 \quad \checkmark \]
\[ -30 + 3(11) = -30 + 33 = 3 \quad \checkmark \]
Notice how far from the origin the answer is. That is the first sign that graphing was never going to give you this point, and the next slide draws it.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 160 — Example 1
Picture it
Here is the same system as two lines, drawn on axes wide enough to contain the answer. Lesson 3.1 taught you to read the crossing point off a picture like this, so compare what the picture offers with what the algebra produced.
Figure (svg): Two lines drawn on axes crossing at the point with coordinates negative thirty and eleven, which is marked with a dot and labelled.
The two lines really do cross at negative thirty and eleven. The algebra was not doing something different from the graph; it was doing the same thing exactly, which is the claim worth taking away from this slide.
Now look at the scale. To draw this by hand you would need a grid running past negative thirty in one direction and past ten in the other, and you would still be reading a crossing point off a hand-ruled line. Five algebraic lines beat that comfortably.
There is a check hiding in the picture too. Both lines slope downwards and the second one is the shallower of the two, so they cross once, on the far left. A system whose answer came out positive would have contradicted the drawing.
Sorting
Substitution starts with a choice, and making it well costs two seconds. Scan the four coefficients of each system for a 1 or a negative 1, because isolating a letter with any other coefficient forces a fraction into every line that follows.
Sort into buckets
Sort each system by which variable is easiest to isolate.
The two systems in the last group are not harder, they are just a different job. Part 2 gives you elimination, which never needs a coefficient of 1 and would rather have coefficients that are multiples of each other.
One of the middle group is worth a second look: the one whose y carries a negative one. Isolating it works and costs one move, but every term you move across changes sign, so write that line out fully rather than doing it in your head.
Get into the habit of this scan before you write anything. Choosing the letter to isolate is the only real decision substitution asks of you, and it is made by looking, not by calculating.
Worked example
The first checkpoint after the two key concept boxes. Four coefficients again: four, three, one and five, so the plan is settled before any algebra happens.
\[ \begin{cases} 4x + 3y = -2 \\ x + 5y = -9 \end{cases} \]
Isolate x in the second equation
Why: It is the only coefficient of 1 in the system, so subtracting five y frees x with no fractions.
\[ x = -5y - 9 \]
Watch the signs on that line. Five y was added to x, so it leaves by subtraction, and negative nine stays where it was. Both terms on the right are negative, which is easy to get wrong when hurrying.
Substitute into the first equation
Why: The bracket goes in wherever x stood, and the 4 multiplies all of it.
\[ 4(-5y - 9) + 3y = -2 \]
Expand the bracket
Why: Four times negative five y is negative twenty y, and four times negative nine is negative thirty-six.
\[ -20y - 36 + 3y = -2 \]
Collect the y terms and solve
Why: Negative twenty y plus three y is negative seventeen y; adding thirty-six to both sides leaves negative seventeen y equal to thirty-four.
\[ -17y = 34 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = -2 \]
Back-substitute into the revised equation
Why: Negative five times negative two is positive ten, and nine less than that is one.
\[ x = -5(-2) - 9 = 10 - 9 = 1 \]
Check in both original equations
Why: Four plus negative six is negative two in the first row, and one plus negative ten is negative nine in the second. Both hold, so the pair really is the crossing point.
\[ 4(1) + 3(-2) = 4 - 6 = -2 \quad \checkmark \]
\[ 1 + 5(-2) = 1 - 10 = -9 \quad \checkmark \]
Every intermediate number here was a whole number, and that is the pay-off from choosing the coefficient of 1. Isolating y instead would have dragged thirds through four lines for the same answer.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 161 — Guided Practice 1 for Examples 1 and 2
Trap
Starting from the same system, you solve the second equation for x and then substitute into that same equation:
\[ x = -3y + 3 \]
\[ (-3y + 3) + 3y = 3 \]
Both sides collapse and the line reads three equals three, which is true and completely useless.
The natural conclusion is that something has gone wrong with the method, or that the system has infinitely many solutions. Neither is what happened.
Nothing went wrong except the target. The rearranged equation carries exactly the same information as the row it came from, so putting it back into that row can only confirm itself.
\[ 2(-3y + 3) + 5y = -5 \]
Substituting into the OTHER row is what brings in new information, and that is what forces y to be eleven.
A quick guard: after substituting, look at your new equation and count the letters. If it has one letter, you are on track. If it has none and reads as something obviously true, you substituted into the wrong row.
Part 4 meets a line like three equals three again, arrived at honestly, and there it really does mean infinitely many solutions. Knowing which of the two situations you are in is exactly why this trap is worth meeting now.
Fill the middle
The step that goes wrong most often is expanding the bracket, because the coefficient has to reach both terms inside it. Fill in the expansion, then the value it leads to.
Fill in the blanks
2(-3y + 3) + 5y = -5 \;\Longrightarrow\; -6y + 6 + 5y = -5 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = 11
Why: The 2 multiplies both terms in the bracket, giving negative six y plus six. Adding the five y outside leaves negative y plus six, so negative y is negative eleven and y is eleven. Multiplying only the first term would give negative six y plus three, and an answer of eight instead.
The wrong version of this line is worth seeing once. If the 2 reaches only the negative three y, you get negative six y plus three plus five y, which leads to y equal to eight, and then everything downstream is wrong while looking perfectly tidy.
There is a cheap way to catch it. Once you have expanded, put your value back into the unexpanded line: two times negative thirty-three plus three, plus fifty-five, is negative sixty plus fifty-five, which is negative five. It agrees, so the expansion was right.
Notice which letter survived the substitution and which one vanished. You replaced x, so the equation that came out mentions only y, and y is therefore the first coordinate you learn. The order in which the coordinates arrive depends on the letter you chose.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 160 — Example 1, Step 2
Worked example
A county fair sells two kinds of pass. An adult pass costs two dollars more than a children's pass. When 378 adult and 214 children's passes were sold, the takings were 2384 dollars, and the question asks for the cost of an adult pass.
Name the unknowns before writing anything: let a be the price of an adult pass and c the price of a children's pass, both in dollars. Two sentences in the question, so two equations.
\[ \begin{cases} a = c + 2 & \text{two dollars more} \\ 378a + 214c = 2384 & \text{the takings} \end{cases} \]
Notice that the first equation is already solved for a
Why: So no rearranging is needed at all, which is as strong a signal for substitution as a coefficient of 1.
\[ a = c + 2 \]
Substitute the expression for a into the second equation
Why: Every a becomes the bracket, and 378 multiplies all of it.
\[ 378(c + 2) + 214c = 2384 \]
Expand the bracket
Why: 378 times c is 378c, and 378 times 2 is 756.
\[ 378c + 756 + 214c = 2384 \]
Collect and solve for c
Why: 378c plus 214c is 592c; taking 756 off both sides leaves 1628.
\[ 592c = 1628 \;\Longrightarrow\; c = 2.75 \]
A price of 2.75 dollars is entirely reasonable for a children's pass, which is worth noticing before going on. An answer in the thousands, or a negative one, would have meant a mistake rather than an unusual fair.
Back-substitute to get the adult price
Why: Two dollars more than 2.75.
\[ a = 2.75 + 2 = 4.75 \]
Check both conditions against the situation
Why: The prices differ by exactly two dollars, and the takings work out: 378 adult passes bring in 1795.50 dollars and 214 children's passes bring in 588.50, which add to 2384.
\[ 378(4.75) + 214(2.75) = 1795.5 + 588.5 = 2384 \quad \checkmark \]
Read the question once more before writing your answer down. It asked for the adult pass, so the answer is 4.75 dollars; reporting 2.75 would be the right arithmetic answering the wrong question.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 165 — Exercise 56
Section
Part 2
Intuition
Adding two equations together looks like a liberty, so it is worth seeing why it is not. An equation is a statement that two quantities are the same size. If that is true of one pair, and true of a second pair, then adding is adding equal things to equal things.
\[ \begin{cases} 3x - 7y = 10 \\ 6x - 8y = \phantom{-}8 \end{cases} \]
Suppose some pair of numbers satisfies both rows. Then the left side of the first row really is ten, and the left side of the second really is eight. Adding the left sides must give eighteen, which is what adding the right sides gives.
\[ (3x - 7y) + (6x - 8y) = 10 + 8 \]
So every solution of the system is also a solution of the sum. That is the direction that matters: the new equation cannot lose a solution, so anything you find by solving it is still a candidate for the original system.
It can, in principle, gain solutions, which is exactly why the check at the end of each worked example is not a formality. Substituting your pair back into both original rows is what rules that out.
The same argument licenses multiplying a row by a constant first. Multiplying both sides of a true equation by negative two keeps it true, so the multiplied row has all the same solutions, and you are free to add that instead.
Concept
Adding is allowed, but adding at random gains you nothing: two messy equations usually add to a third messy equation. The trick is to arrange the addition so that one letter disappears in it, and that arrangement is the whole method.
Figure (svg): Equation 1 multiplied by negative two, written beside Equation 2, with an addition bar underneath and the resulting equation in y alone below it.
Follow the picture through. In the original system the x-coefficients are three and six, so multiplying the first row by negative two turns three x into negative six x, which is the same size as six x with the opposite sign.
Differ only in sign is the phrase to hold on to. Six and negative six qualify; six and negative three do not, and neither do six and six. Adding six x to six x gives twelve x and removes nothing at all.
Notice that only one equation needed multiplying here, because six is already a multiple of three. That is the tidiest case of elimination and the book points it out beside Example 2; when neither coefficient divides the other, both rows get multiplied.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 161 — The Elimination Method key concept box
Notation
The two lines you are about to add deserve a careful look, because everything that can go wrong in elimination has already happened by the time they are written down.
Annotate
On: \( \begin{array}{r} -6x + 14y = -20 \\ 6x - 8y = \phantom{-}8 \end{array} \)
The second note is the one that catches people out, and the book prints a warning about it beside Example 4. Multiplying an equation by a constant means multiplying every term of it, including the number on the right, which does not look like it is part of the work.
The third note is worth arguing with too. It is tempting to expect both letters to cancel, and alarming when only one does. One is all you want: if both cancelled you would have no equation left, which is the situation Part 4 is entirely about.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 163 — the Avoid Errors note on multiplying every term
Worked example
The book's elimination example. Look at the x-coefficients, three and six, and notice that six is exactly twice three. That is the signal that one multiplication will be enough.
\[ \begin{cases} 3x - 7y = 10 & \text{Equation 1} \\ 6x - 8y = 8 & \text{Equation 2} \end{cases} \]
Multiply Equation 1 by negative 2
Why: Choosing negative two rather than two is what makes the x-coefficients differ in sign; every term is multiplied, the ten included.
\[ -6x + 14y = -20 \]
Check that line before using it. Negative two times three x is negative six x, negative two times negative seven y is positive fourteen y, and negative two times ten is negative twenty. Three terms, three multiplications.
Add the revised equation to Equation 2
Why: Negative six x plus six x is zero, fourteen y minus eight y is six y, and negative twenty plus eight is negative twelve.
\[ (-6x + 14y) + (6x - 8y) = -20 + 8 \]
Read off the surviving equation and solve it
Why: The x-terms are gone, so this is an ordinary one-letter equation.
\[ 6y = -12 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = -2 \]
Substitute negative 2 for y in Equation 1
Why: Either original row would do; the first has smaller numbers. Negative seven times negative two is positive fourteen.
\[ 3x - 7(-2) = 10 \;\Longrightarrow\; 3x + 14 = 10 \]
Solve for x
Why: Subtracting fourteen from both sides leaves negative four, and dividing by three does not simplify, so the answer is a fraction.
\[ 3x = -4 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = -\tfrac{4}{3} \]
A fractional coordinate is not a sign of a mistake, and this is the example that proves the lesson's point. There is no honest way to read negative four thirds off a hand-drawn graph.
Check in both original equations
Why: The first row gives negative four plus fourteen, which is ten; the second gives negative eight plus sixteen, which is eight. The fraction survives both, so it is genuinely the crossing point.
\[ 3\left(-\tfrac{4}{3}\right) - 7(-2) = -4 + 14 = 10 \quad \checkmark \]
\[ 6\left(-\tfrac{4}{3}\right) - 8(-2) = -8 + 16 = 8 \quad \checkmark \]
Notice how the fraction cleared itself in both checks: three times negative four thirds is a whole negative four, and six times it is negative eight. Fractions in an answer often behave well in the check.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 161 — Example 2
Picture it
Here is Example 2 drawn. The two lines cross once, as the algebra said, and this is the picture the graphing method would have given you: a crossing that is plainly somewhere near negative one and a third, and plainly not on a grid line.
Figure (svg): Two lines crossing at the point with x equal to negative four thirds and y equal to negative two, marked with a dot and labelled.
Try to read the crossing off the drawing. The best you would honestly write is that x is between negative one and negative two, nearer to negative one, and that y looks like negative two. The book's own calculator screen reports negative 1.333333.
Compare that with the algebra, which produced negative four thirds exactly, in one division, with no reading of anything. This is the trade the lesson is built on: the picture tells you where to expect the answer and the algebra tells you what it is.
Use both. Before solving, a rough sketch tells you the signs of the answer, so a positive x here would have been caught immediately. After solving, the picture is a sanity check that the pair you found is where a crossing could plausibly be.
Discrimination
Elimination costs either one multiplication or two, and you can tell which before starting. Look at the two coefficients of a single letter: if one divides the other, one multiplication is enough, and if neither does, both rows must be multiplied.
Sort into buckets
Sort each system by how many equations you would have to multiply to eliminate a variable.
The group that needs no multiplying at all is the one to look for first. When a letter's coefficients are already equal, subtracting one equation from the other is the same trick with the multiplier hidden: subtracting is adding the row multiplied by negative one.
For the pairs that need two multiplications there is a reliable recipe. Multiply each row by the other row's coefficient of the letter you want gone, and put a minus sign on one of them. Example 3 later in this deck does exactly that with eight and eleven.
Notice that this scan never asks you to look at the letter you are keeping. Only the coefficients of the letter you intend to eliminate matter, so the decision stays small even when the numbers are large.
Worked example
This checkpoint is worth doing by elimination even though it has a three in front of both x-terms. Look at the y-coefficients, three and negative nine: nine is a multiple of three, so one multiplication clears the y-terms.
\[ \begin{cases} 3x + 3y = -15 \\ 5x - 9y = \phantom{-}3 \end{cases} \]
Multiply the first equation by 3
Why: Three times three y is nine y, which differs from negative nine y only in sign. The right-hand side is multiplied too.
\[ 9x + 9y = -45 \]
Add the revised equation to the second
Why: Nine y plus negative nine y is zero, nine x plus five x is fourteen x, and negative forty-five plus three is negative forty-two.
\[ (9x + 9y) + (5x - 9y) = -45 + 3 \]
Solve the surviving equation
Why: Fourteen x equals negative forty-two, and forty-two is three fourteens.
\[ 14x = -42 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = -3 \]
Here the letter that survived was x rather than y, simply because y was the one arranged to cancel. Which coordinate arrives first is decided by you, not by the system.
Substitute negative 3 for x in the first equation
Why: Three times negative three is negative nine, so three y has to make up the rest of negative fifteen.
\[ 3(-3) + 3y = -15 \;\Longrightarrow\; -9 + 3y = -15 \]
Solve for y
Why: Adding nine to both sides gives three y equal to negative six.
\[ 3y = -6 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = -2 \]
Check in both original equations
Why: The first row gives negative nine plus negative six, which is negative fifteen. The second gives negative fifteen plus eighteen, which is three, and that second row is the one the back-substitution never touched, so it is a genuine test.
\[ 3(-3) + 3(-2) = -9 - 6 = -15 \quad \checkmark \]
\[ 5(-3) - 9(-2) = -15 + 18 = 3 \quad \checkmark \]
Always check in the row you did not use for back-substitution as well. The row you substituted into will agree almost automatically; the other one is where an error would show up.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 161 — Guided Practice 2 for Examples 1 and 2
Error analysis
This is the book's own error-analysis exercise, and the mistake in it is the single most common elimination error there is. Work out what went wrong before reading the notes, because catching it yourself is what stops you repeating it.
\[ \begin{array}{l} \text{system: } 3x + 2y = 7 \text{ and } 5x + 4y = 15 \\ \text{student's work: } -6x - 4y = 7 \\ \phantom{\text{student's work: }} 5x + 4y = 15 \\ \phantom{\text{student's work: }} -x = 22 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = -22 \end{array} \]
Annotate
On: \( -6x - 4y = 7 \quad \text{(should be } -14\text{)} \)
\[ -6x - 4y = -14 \;\Longrightarrow\; -x = 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = -1, \; y = 5 \]
Confirm the repair in both rows. Three times negative one plus two fives is negative three plus ten, which is seven, and five times negative one plus four fives is negative five plus twenty, which is fifteen. Both hold, so the corrected pair is right.
Why does this slip happen so reliably? Because the terms with letters in them look like the work and the lonely number looks like a destination. Multiplying is done to a whole equation, never to the interesting part of one.
A cheap guard: after multiplying a row, count its terms and check that every one of them changed. Three terms in, three terms different, or you have missed one.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 164 — Exercise 27
Worked example
Now the case where neither coefficient divides the other. The x-coefficients are three and negative four, and neither is a multiple of the other, so both rows have to be multiplied.
\[ \begin{cases} 3x - 6y = \phantom{-}9 \\ -4x + 7y = -16 \end{cases} \]
Multiply the first equation by 4
Why: Four is the other row's x-coefficient, ignoring its sign; three x becomes twelve x.
\[ 12x - 24y = 36 \]
Multiply the second equation by 3
Why: Three is the first row's x-coefficient, so negative four x becomes negative twelve x, which now differs from twelve x only in sign.
\[ -12x + 21y = -48 \]
Twelve is the least common multiple of three and four, which is why those two multipliers were the ones to choose. Any common multiple would work, but the smallest keeps the numbers manageable.
Add the two revised equations
Why: Twelve x and negative twelve x cancel; negative twenty-four y plus twenty-one y is negative three y; thirty-six plus negative forty-eight is negative twelve.
\[ (12x - 24y) + (-12x + 21y) = 36 - 48 \]
Solve the surviving equation
Why: Negative three y equals negative twelve, so dividing by negative three gives a positive answer.
\[ -3y = -12 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = 4 \]
Substitute 4 for y in the first original equation
Why: Six times four is twenty-four, so three x has to make up nine after losing twenty-four.
\[ 3x - 6(4) = 9 \;\Longrightarrow\; 3x - 24 = 9 \]
Solve for x
Why: Adding twenty-four to both sides gives three x equal to thirty-three.
\[ 3x = 33 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 11 \]
Check in both original equations
Why: The first row gives thirty-three minus twenty-four, which is nine. The second gives negative forty-four plus twenty-eight, which is negative sixteen. Both original rows hold.
\[ 3(11) - 6(4) = 33 - 24 = 9 \quad \checkmark \]
\[ -4(11) + 7(4) = -44 + 28 = -16 \quad \checkmark \]
Both coordinates came out as whole numbers despite all the multiplying, which is usually a sign the multipliers were chosen well. Multiplying by seven and six instead would have reached the same pair through much larger numbers.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 161 — Guided Practice 3 for Examples 1 and 2
Trap
Solving the system three x minus seven y equals ten with six x minus eight y equals eight, it is easy to get this far and stop:
\[ 6y = -12 \]
\[ y = -2 \]
The answer is written down as negative two, and the work is put away.
It feels finished, because an equation was solved and a number came out of it.
A system in two letters has an answer in two numbers. Negative two is one coordinate of a point, and a point with one coordinate is not a location.
\[ x = -\tfrac{4}{3} \]
Putting negative two back into either original row is what produces the other coordinate, and only then is there an ordered pair to report.
There is a subtler version of this in the book's Example 3, where the question asks for the number of short sleeve shirts and the elimination naturally produces the number of long sleeve ones first. Solving for the wrong letter and stopping gives a real number and a wrong answer.
Make the habit mechanical: the last two things you write are the ordered pair and the two checks. If your work ends on a single number, it has ended early.
Ranking
Elimination has a fixed order, and getting it wrong wastes work rather than producing wrong answers. Decide the sequence for the system three x plus three y equals negative fifteen with five x minus nine y equals three before reading on.
Put in order
Order the moves that solve this system by elimination.
Why: Comparing coefficients comes first because it decides what to multiply by; multiplying comes before adding, since adding the untouched rows removes nothing. Solving the surviving equation gives one coordinate, back-substituting gives the other, and only a pair can be checked. Adding before multiplying is the wrong order that costs a whole page.
The first move is the one that looks like doing nothing, and it is the one that saves the most time. Comparing coefficients is how you learn that the multiplier is three and that the letter to lose is y rather than x.
Adding before multiplying is the failure this ordering prevents. Add these two rows as they stand and you get eight x minus six y equals negative twelve, which is a perfectly true equation in two letters and no progress whatsoever.
Notice that the last two moves are not optional extras tacked on. Back-substituting is what turns a number into a point, and checking is what turns a point into an answer you can defend.
Worked example
A plane flies 1000 miles in 5 hours with the wind behind it, and only 500 miles in 5 hours flying against it. Find the plane's own speed in still air, and the speed of the wind.
Turn the distances into speeds first, because speed is what adds. A thousand miles in five hours is 200 miles per hour over the ground, and five hundred miles in five hours is 100.
\[ \begin{cases} p + w = 200 & \text{with the wind} \\ p - w = 100 & \text{against the wind} \end{cases} \]
Figure (svg): Two rows of arrows. In the first the plane's arrow and the wind's arrow point the same way and add to two hundred; in the second the wind's arrow points backwards, leaving one hundred.
The picture is the reason elimination is the obvious method here. The wind arrow points forwards in one row and backwards in the other, so its coefficients are already one and negative one, which differ only in sign.
Add the two equations as they stand
Why: No multiplying is needed: w plus negative w is zero, p plus p is two p, and 200 plus 100 is 300.
\[ (p + w) + (p - w) = 200 + 100 \]
Solve for the plane's own speed
Why: Two p equals 300, so p is 150 miles per hour.
\[ 2p = 300 \;\Longrightarrow\; p = 150 \]
Substitute 150 into the first equation
Why: The plane contributes 150 of the 200 miles per hour it managed with the wind.
\[ 150 + w = 200 \;\Longrightarrow\; w = 50 \]
Stop and read that against the situation. A 50 mile per hour wind turns a 150 mile per hour plane into a 200 mile per hour one downwind and a 100 mile per hour one upwind, which is exactly the two figures you were given.
Check both flights, and the distances too
Why: Downwind the ground speed is 200, and five hours of that is 1000 miles. Upwind it is 100, and five hours of that is 500 miles. Both original statements hold.
\[ 5(150 + 50) = 1000 \quad \checkmark \]
\[ 5(150 - 50) = 500 \quad \checkmark \]
Notice that the check went back past the equations to the flights themselves. With a word problem that is the check worth making, because it tests the equations you wrote as well as the algebra you did.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 166 — Exercise 62
Fill the middle
Setting up an elimination is the part worth drilling, because once the revised rows are right the rest is addition. Complete the multiplication that clears the x-terms from this pair.
\[ \begin{cases} 2x + 5y = 14 \\ 3x - 2y = -36 \end{cases} \]
Fill in the blanks
2x + 5y = 14 \;\text3 42 \;\Longrightarrow\; 6x + 15y = ___
Why: Three is the other row's x-coefficient, so multiplying by it turns two x into six x. Every term is multiplied, so five y becomes fifteen y and fourteen becomes forty-two. The second row then gets multiplied by negative two, giving negative six x plus four y equals seventy-two, and the x-terms cancel on adding.
Finish the setup in your head: the second row needs multiplying by negative two, which gives negative six x plus four y equals seventy-two. Adding the two revised rows leaves nineteen y equal to one hundred and fourteen, so y is six and then x is negative eight.
The pattern is worth naming because it always works. To clear a letter whose coefficients are a and b, multiply one row by b and the other by negative a. The signs then oppose by construction rather than by luck.
Multiplying by three and negative two rather than by six and negative four is the small economy to make. Both line the coefficients up; the smaller pair keeps the numbers you carry through the addition down to two digits.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 164 — Exercise 21
Section
Part 3
Concept
Both methods work on every system, so this part is not about correctness. It is about the amount of arithmetic you sign up for, and that is decided by the coefficients before you write your first line.
Figure (svg): A decision diagram: a box asking whether any coefficient is one or negative one, with a yes branch leading to substitution and a no branch leading to elimination.
The book states the rule in one sentence. Substitution is convenient when one of the variables has a coefficient of 1 or negative 1, because isolating that letter costs one move and introduces no fractions. If no variable has such a coefficient, elimination is usually easier.
Think about why the rule falls out that way. Isolating a letter means dividing by its coefficient, so a coefficient of three turns every later line into thirds, while elimination never divides anything until the very last step.
There is a second reading of the diagram worth having. Substitution is the method that likes one small coefficient somewhere; elimination is the method that likes coefficients related to each other, whatever their size. Eight and eleven are terrible for substitution and perfectly fine for elimination.
If you genuinely cannot decide, pick either and start. The worst case is a slightly longer route to the same pair, and you can always check your answer with the other method, which is a habit the homework asks for.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 163 — Choosing a Method
Comparison
This table is the spine of the lesson. Read the left column as a description of a system you have just been handed, and the rest of the row as what you should do about it. Fill in the blanks from the rule on the last slide.
Comparison matrix
| what the system looks like | reach for | equations to multiply | example in this deck |
|---|---|---|---|
| an x or a y with coefficient 1 or −1 | substitution | none | Example 1 |
| one letter already solved for, as in a = c + 2 | substitution | none | Exercise 56 |
| coefficients of one letter already differ in sign | elimination | 0 | Exercise 62 |
| one coefficient is a multiple of its partner | elimination | 1 | Example 2 |
| no coefficient is 1, and neither divides the other | elimination | 2 | Example 3 |
| fractions or decimals in every coefficient | either | after clearing them | Exercises 44 and 47 |
Read down the middle column and you have the whole decision. Only the first two rows point at substitution, and both of them are about a letter that is already alone or nearly alone. Everything else is elimination country.
The last row is the one that trips people up, because a system full of fractions looks like the hardest kind and is really a disguise. Multiply each row through by a common denominator first, and what you are left with is one of the rows above it.
The final column is there so you can go back and look. Every description in the left column is a system you meet in this deck, so if a row feels abstract, the example beside it is the concrete version of it.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 163 — the Choosing a Method rule and Examples 1 to 3
Worked example
The claim that either method works deserves a demonstration rather than a promise. Here is Example 2's system solved by substitution, so you can compare the two routes line for line.
\[ \begin{cases} 3x - 7y = 10 \\ 6x - 8y = \phantom{-}8 \end{cases} \]
Solve the first equation for y
Why: No coefficient here is 1, so whichever letter you isolate brings a fraction. Isolating y means dividing by seven.
\[ y = \dfrac{3x - 10}{7} \]
That fraction is the price of using substitution on this system, and it is going to be carried through the next two lines. Elimination never produced anything like it.
Substitute the fraction into the second equation
Why: Every y in the other row becomes the fraction, and the 8 multiplies all of it.
\[ 6x - 8\left(\dfrac{3x - 10}{7}\right) = 8 \]
Multiply every term by 7 to clear the denominator
Why: Forty-two x, then negative eight times the bracket's numerator, then fifty-six on the right.
\[ 42x - 8(3x - 10) = 56 \]
Expand and collect
Why: Negative eight times three x is negative twenty-four x, and negative eight times negative ten is positive eighty.
\[ 42x - 24x + 80 = 56 \;\Longrightarrow\; 18x = -24 \]
Solve for x
Why: Eighteen and twenty-four share a factor of six, so the fraction reduces.
\[ x = -\dfrac{24}{18} = -\tfrac{4}{3} \]
That is the same x that elimination produced, reached in six lines instead of three, with a fraction in the middle of every one of them. The route was longer and the destination identical.
Check the pair in both original equations
Why: Back-substituting gives y equal to negative two, and the pair satisfies both rows: negative four plus fourteen is ten, and negative eight plus sixteen is eight.
\[ y = \dfrac{3\left(-\frac43\right) - 10}{7} = \dfrac{-14}{7} = -2 \]
\[ 3\left(-\tfrac43\right) - 7(-2) = 10 \quad \checkmark \qquad 6\left(-\tfrac43\right) - 8(-2) = 8 \quad \checkmark \]
So the two methods are two roads to one point, and the choice between them really is only about arithmetic. Nothing about the answer depends on which you took.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 163 — Choosing a Method, applied to Example 2
Matching
Four systems, four descriptions from the table. Decide by looking at the coefficients only, and then say to yourself which feature of each system settled it. No algebra is needed on this slide at all.
Match the pairs
Why: The first has an x with coefficient one, so substitution costs a single subtraction. The second already has w and negative w, so adding the rows removes the wind with no preparation. In the third, six is twice three, so one row gets multiplied. In the fourth, eight and eleven share no factor, so both rows do.
The two middle descriptions are the ones to separate carefully. Both are elimination, and the only difference is whether the coefficients already oppose or have to be made to. Checking that costs one glance at the signs.
Notice that the largest numbers, eight and eleven with totals in the thousands, belong to the case that needs the most preparation and is still the easy option. Size is not difficulty; relationship between the coefficients is.
If you found yourself half-solving each system to decide, that is normal at this stage. The aim is to reach the point where the shape of the coefficients is enough, and that comes after about a dozen systems.
Prediction
Commit to an answer before doing either. Look at the four coefficients, then think about what isolating a letter would cost compared with what lining the coefficients up would cost.
\[ \begin{cases} 8x + 9y = 15 \\ 5x - 2y = 17 \end{cases} \]
Predict first
Which method gets to the answer with less arithmetic on this system?
Correct: Elimination, multiplying the first row by 2 and the second by 9
Why: No coefficient here is 1 or negative 1, so every route through substitution divides by 8, 9, 5 or 2 and drags a fraction to the end. Elimination multiplies the first row by 2 and the second by 9 to get eighteen y and negative eighteen y, and then the addition gives sixty-one x equal to one hundred and eighty-three, so x is 3 and y is negative 1, both whole numbers throughout.
\[ 16x + 18y = 30 \qquad 45x - 18y = 153 \;\Longrightarrow\; 61x = 183 \]
Sixty-one is an awkward looking number, and yet one hundred and eighty-three is exactly three times it, so x is 3. Back-substituting into the first row gives twenty-four plus nine y equal to fifteen, so y is negative 1.
Check the pair in the row that was not used: five times three minus two times negative one is fifteen plus two, which is seventeen. Both rows hold, so the pair is confirmed.
The general lesson is about what large coefficients actually cost. They make the additions longer to write and they do not make the method harder, whereas a coefficient of nine in a substitution makes every line of the rest of the problem a ninth.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 163 — Guided Practice 9 for Example 4
Worked example
A system where every coefficient is a fraction. This looks like the hardest kind on the page and is really a disguise: one multiplication per row turns it into something you have already solved twice.
\[ \begin{cases} \dfrac{1}{2}x + \dfrac{2}{3}y = \dfrac{5}{6} \\[4pt] \dfrac{5}{12}x + \dfrac{7}{12}y = \dfrac{3}{4} \end{cases} \]
Multiply the first equation by 6
Why: Six is the least common denominator of halves, thirds and sixths, so every fraction in the row clears at once.
\[ 3x + 4y = 5 \]
Multiply the second equation by 12
Why: Twelve clears twelfths and quarters together, and the right-hand side becomes nine.
\[ 5x + 7y = 9 \]
Those two lines are a perfectly ordinary system of the kind Part 2 handles, and the fractions have gone for good. Clearing denominators first is almost always worth the two extra lines.
Choose the method by the new coefficients
Why: No coefficient is 1, and neither three nor five divides the other, so this is the two-multiplication case of elimination.
\[ \begin{cases} 3x + 4y = 5 \\ 5x + 7y = 9 \end{cases} \]
Multiply the first row by 5 and the second by negative 3
Why: Fifteen x and negative fifteen x differ only in sign.
\[ 15x + 20y = 25 \qquad -15x - 21y = -27 \]
Add them and solve
Why: Twenty y minus twenty-one y is negative y, and twenty-five minus twenty-seven is negative two.
\[ -y = -2 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = 2 \]
Back-substitute into three x plus four y equals five
Why: Four twos is eight, so three x has to be negative three.
\[ 3x + 8 = 5 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = -1 \]
Check in both ORIGINAL fractional equations
Why: Half of negative one is negative one half, and two thirds of two is four thirds; together they make five sixths. In the second row, negative five twelfths plus fourteen twelfths is nine twelfths, which is three quarters.
\[ -\tfrac12 + \tfrac43 = \tfrac{-3 + 8}{6} = \tfrac56 \quad \checkmark \]
\[ -\tfrac{5}{12} + \tfrac{14}{12} = \tfrac{9}{12} = \tfrac34 \quad \checkmark \]
Check in the fractional rows you were given, not in the cleared ones. The cleared rows are your own work, and checking in them would cheerfully confirm a slip you made while clearing.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 165 — Exercise 47
Fill the middle
Decimals are cleared exactly like fractions, by multiplying each row by a power of ten. Work out the multiplier that turns hundredths into whole numbers, then the value it leads to.
\[ \begin{cases} 0.02x - 0.05y = -0.38 \\ 0.03x + 0.04y = \phantom{-}1.04 \end{cases} \]
Fill in the blanks
\text100 16 \;\Longrightarrow\; 2x - 5y = -38, \;; 3x + 4y = 104, \;; x = ___
Why: The smallest place value in either row is hundredths, so one hundred clears every decimal at once. Eliminating x from the cleared rows, by multiplying the first by 3 and the second by negative 2, leaves negative twenty-three y equal to negative three hundred and twenty-two, so y is 14, and then two x minus seventy is negative thirty-eight, so x is 16.
Multiplying by ten would have been the mistake to make here. That leaves 0.2x minus 0.5y equal to negative 3.8, which still has decimals in it, so the whole point of the move is lost and you clear them twice.
Check the pair in the decimal rows you were given. Two hundredths of sixteen is 0.32, five hundredths of fourteen is 0.70, and 0.32 minus 0.70 is negative 0.38. In the second row, 0.48 plus 0.56 is 1.04, so both rows hold.
Fractions and decimals are the same obstacle wearing different clothes, and both are removed the same way: multiply each row by whatever makes its coefficients whole, and then use the table from earlier in this part.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 165 — Exercise 44
Trap
Faced with eight x plus ten y equals 3900 and eleven x plus sixteen y equals 5925, it is tempting to reach for substitution because it is the familiar method:
\[ x = \dfrac{3900 - 10y}{8} \]
The line is correct. It is also a fraction with eight underneath it, and it is about to be multiplied by eleven.
\[ 11\left(\dfrac{3900 - 10y}{8}\right) + 16y = 5925 \]
Four more lines of eighths follow, and every one of them is a chance to slip.
Elimination never divides until the final step, so nothing fractional appears in the middle of the work at all. Multiply the first row by negative eleven and the second by eight.
\[ 18y = 4500 \]
One addition, and the number that comes out is 4500 over 18, which is a clean 250. Then eight x plus 2500 equals 3900 gives x equal to 175.
The lesson is not that substitution fails here; it reaches the same pair. The lesson is that the method you like is not always the method the coefficients are asking for, and the cost of ignoring them is four extra lines of eighths.
Before choosing, run the scan from the table: is there a 1 or a negative 1 anywhere? Here the coefficients are 8, 10, 11 and 16, so the answer is no, and the decision is made for you.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 162 — Example 3, and the Choosing a Method rule on p. 163
Step zero
Both methods are now available, so the first thing you do with a new system is not algebra. It is a short inspection, and getting into the habit of it is worth more than any single technique in this lesson.
\[ \begin{cases} 6x - 3y = 15 \\ -2x + y = -5 \end{cases} \]
Discussion prompt
List, in order, the three things you would look at before making a single algebraic move on this system, then say which method they point to and what you expect to happen.
The third question is the one most people never ask, and it is the one that tells you in advance whether you are heading for an ordinary answer or for one of the two strange outcomes. Comparing both ratios costs a few seconds.
Notice how the inspection also decides which letter you will learn first. Isolating y here means the substituted equation will be in x, so x is the coordinate that arrives first, and y follows from the back-substitution.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 163 — Guided Practice 5 for Example 4
Section
Part 4
Concept
Sometimes you eliminate a letter and the other letter goes with it, leaving a line with no letters in it at all. That feels like the method breaking down, and it is the opposite: it is the system telling you how many solutions it has.
Figure (svg): A tree: one box asking what remains after eliminating a variable, branching into a value for one letter, a false statement, and an always-true statement, each with its meaning and picture underneath.
There are only three things that can be left. A value for one letter, which is the ordinary case and gives exactly one solution. A false statement such as zero equals five. Or a statement that is always true, such as zero equals zero.
A false statement means there is no pair of numbers that makes both rows true, because your algebra was a chain of legal moves and it ended somewhere impossible. No solution, and the lines are parallel.
An always-true statement means the opposite: every step was legal and nothing was pinned down, because the second row never asked for anything the first row had not already asked for. Infinitely many solutions, and the two equations describe one line.
Lesson 3.1 met these same two situations as pictures, parallel lines and coincident lines. This part is those pictures arriving as algebra instead, and the next four slides put each picture beside its line of algebra so the two stop feeling unrelated.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 163 — Example 4
Worked example
The book's first degenerate case. The coefficient of x in the first row is 1, so the inspection from Part 3 says substitution, and nothing about the strange ending changes that advice.
\[ \begin{cases} x - 2y = 4 \\ 3x - 6y = 8 \end{cases} \]
Solve the first equation for x
Why: Its coefficient is 1, so one addition frees it.
\[ x = 2y + 4 \]
Substitute into the second equation
Why: Every x becomes the bracket, and the 3 multiplies all of it.
\[ 3(2y + 4) - 6y = 8 \]
Expand the bracket
Why: Three times two y is six y, and three times four is twelve.
\[ 6y + 12 - 6y = 8 \]
Collect the y terms
Why: Six y minus six y is zero, so the y-terms cancel each other and no letter survives.
\[ 12 = 8 \]
Read the line rather than panicking at it. Twelve equals eight is false, and every move that produced it was legal, so the assumption you started from must be the thing that fails: there is no pair of numbers satisfying both rows.
Notice what cancelled and what did not. The y-terms cancelled because six y really is six y; the numbers did not, because twelve is not eight. Had the right-hand side been twelve, both sides would have matched and the answer would have been the opposite one.
Check that the conclusion is right by testing a candidate
Why: Take any point on the first line, say y equal to zero and x equal to four. It satisfies the first row exactly, and the second row gives twelve rather than eight, so it is not a solution of the system. The same gap of four appears whichever point of the first line you pick.
\[ x - 2y = 4 - 0 = 4 \quad \checkmark \qquad 3(4) - 6(0) = 12 \ne 8 \]
So the answer is that the system has no solution. That is a complete answer, not a failure to find one, and the next slide draws the reason.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 163 — Example 4, part (a)
Picture it
Here are Example 4(a)'s two equations drawn. Both have the same slope, one half, because the second row is almost the first row tripled. Almost, and that is the entire story.
Figure (svg): Two parallel lines of the same slope drawn on axes, with a short vertical marker between them showing the constant gap of two thirds.
Triple the first equation exactly and you get three x minus six y equals twelve. The second row says eight instead. So the two lines have identical directions and different positions, which is what parallel means.
The little marker in the picture measures the vertical gap between the lines, and it is two thirds wherever you put it. The gap never shrinks, so there is nowhere the lines could cross, and that permanent gap is what the algebra reported as twelve equals eight.
Put the two facts side by side and neither one is mysterious any more. The picture says the lines are parallel; the algebra says a number is not equal to a different number. They are the same observation in two languages, and the deck will use both from here on.
Vocabulary from Lesson 3.1 fits here too. A system with no solution is called inconsistent, and the twelve equals eight line is exactly what makes it deserve the name.
Worked example
The book's second degenerate case, and the numbers look far worse than 4(a). No coefficient is 1 or negative 1, so the inspection says elimination, and neither four nor fourteen divides the other, so both rows get multiplied.
\[ \begin{cases} 4x - 10y = \phantom{-}8 \\ -14x + 35y = -28 \end{cases} \]
Multiply the first equation by 7
Why: Seven times four x is twenty-eight x; every term is multiplied, so the eight becomes fifty-six.
\[ 28x - 70y = 56 \]
Multiply the second equation by 2
Why: Two times negative fourteen x is negative twenty-eight x, which differs from twenty-eight x only in sign.
\[ -28x + 70y = -56 \]
Look at those two lines before adding them. They are not merely arranged so that the x-terms cancel; every single term of one is the negative of the matching term of the other. That is a much stronger coincidence, and it is about to matter.
Add the revised equations
Why: The x-terms cancel, the y-terms cancel too because negative seventy y plus seventy y is zero, and fifty-six plus negative fifty-six is zero.
\[ 0 = 0 \]
Zero equals zero is true, and it is true no matter what x and y are. So the addition pinned nothing down, which means the second row was never asking for anything new: it is the first row in disguise.
Check the conclusion by testing two different points
Why: Take x equal to 2 and y equal to 0, which satisfies the first row. It satisfies the second too. Now take x equal to negative 2 and y equal to negative 1.6, which also satisfies the first row, and it satisfies the second as well. Two different points both work, so there cannot be just one solution.
\[ 4(2) - 10(0) = 8 \quad \checkmark \]
\[ -14(2) + 35(0) = -28 \quad \checkmark \]
\[ 4(-2) - 10(-1.6) = -8 + 16 = 8 \quad \checkmark \]
\[ -14(-2) + 35(-1.6) = 28 - 56 = -28 \quad \checkmark \]
So the answer is infinitely many solutions: every point of the line four x minus ten y equals eight. Writing one pair down and calling it the solution would be reporting one member of an infinite family.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 163 — Example 4, part (b)
Picture it
Example 4(b)'s two equations, plotted. The thick line is the first equation and the dashed line is the second, and the dashed one lands exactly on top of the other, which is why only one line is visible.
Figure (svg): A single line drawn twice, once solid and once dashed on top of it, with two points marked that satisfy both equations.
The reason is arithmetic you can check in your head. Multiply the first equation by negative seven halves and you get the second one exactly, term for term. Two equations that are multiples of each other describe the same set of points.
Both marked points satisfy both equations, and they were picked at random off the line. So would any other point on it, which is what infinitely many solutions means in practice: pick any x, and the line hands you the y that works in both rows.
Contrast this with the parallel picture two slides back. There, the second equation was almost a multiple of the first and the right-hand side spoiled it. Here nothing is spoiled, and that single difference is the difference between no solutions and all of them.
The vocabulary from Lesson 3.1 for this case is consistent and dependent: there are solutions, and the second equation depends on the first rather than adding anything to it.
Sorting
Six endings, taken from systems in this lesson and its exercise set. Sort each one by what it tells you about the system, and notice that only the shape of the line matters, never how you arrived at it.
Sort into buckets
Sort each leftover line by what it says about the system it came from.
The two true statements in the list are worth comparing. Zero equals zero and negative nine equals negative nine look different and say exactly the same thing: nothing was pinned down. Any true numerical statement means infinitely many solutions.
The line reading zero equals fifteen comes from Guided Practice 6, and it shows that the false statement need not involve small numbers or look dramatic. Zero equals fifteen, twelve equals eight and one equals two all deliver the same verdict.
Notice what none of these six lines contains: a letter equal to a letter. If you reach something like x equals y, you have not finished eliminating; go back and look for the step where a letter was cancelled that should not have been.
Worked example
This checkpoint follows Example 4 and hides its answer well. The second row has a y with coefficient 1, so substitution is the cheap route, and the inspection also notices that twelve is three times four.
\[ \begin{cases} 12x - 3y = -9 \\ -4x + y = \phantom{-}3 \end{cases} \]
Solve the second equation for y
Why: Its coefficient is 1, so adding four x to both sides frees it at once.
\[ y = 4x + 3 \]
Substitute into the first equation
Why: Every y becomes the bracket, and the negative three multiplies all of it.
\[ 12x - 3(4x + 3) = -9 \]
Expand the bracket carefully
Why: Negative three times four x is negative twelve x, and negative three times positive three is negative nine. Both signs matter here.
\[ 12x - 12x - 9 = -9 \]
Collect the x terms
Why: Twelve x minus twelve x is zero, so x has gone and only numbers remain.
\[ -9 = -9 \]
Negative nine equals negative nine is true, and true for every x, so the system has infinitely many solutions. The two equations are the same line: multiply the second row by negative three and you get the first row exactly.
If you expanded the bracket carelessly and wrote negative twelve x plus nine, you would have reached nine equals negative nine instead, and reported no solution. A single sign decides between the two opposite answers, which is why that step is worth writing out.
Check by testing two points of the line
Why: Take x equal to 0, so y is 3; and x equal to 1, so y is 7. Both pairs satisfy both rows, and two solutions already rule out the one-solution answer.
\[ 12(0) - 3(3) = -9 \quad \checkmark \qquad -4(0) + 3 = 3 \quad \checkmark \]
\[ 12(1) - 3(7) = 12 - 21 = -9 \quad \checkmark \qquad -4(1) + 7 = 3 \quad \checkmark \]
Report the answer as infinitely many solutions, and if you want to describe them, the line y equals four x plus three is the whole solution set.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 163 — Guided Practice 5 for Example 4
Counterexample
It is tempting to believe that two equations written with different numbers must describe different lines, and that different lines must cross. Both halves of that belief are wrong, and this checkpoint breaks the second half.
\[ \begin{cases} 6x + 15y = -12 \\ -2x - 5y = \phantom{-}9 \end{cases} \]
Discussion prompt
Eliminate x by multiplying the second equation by 3, then say what the leftover line means and how you could have predicted it from the coefficients alone.
That ratio test is worth keeping. When both letters' coefficients are in the same ratio, the lines are parallel or identical, and it is the right-hand sides that decide which. When the ratios differ, the lines cross exactly once.
So the appearance of a system tells you very little and the ratios tell you everything. Two equations can look wildly different and be the same line, or look almost identical and cross once.
Try the test on Example 4(b) as well: four over negative fourteen and negative ten over thirty-five are both negative two sevenths, and eight over negative twenty-eight is also negative two sevenths. All three ratios agree, which is why that system had infinitely many solutions rather than none.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 163 — Guided Practice 6 for Example 4
Matching
Three outcomes, and each one has an algebraic signature, a picture and a piece of vocabulary from Lesson 3.1. Tie them together now, because examinations ask for the name as often as for the answer.
Match the pairs
Why: A surviving letter with a value means one crossing point, so the system is consistent and independent. A false numerical statement means parallel lines and the system is inconsistent. A true numerical statement means the equations describe one line, so the system is consistent and dependent. Matching ratios all the way through, constants included, is the advance warning of that last case.
The word to be careful with is consistent, because it covers two of the three rows. Consistent only means there is at least one solution; independent and dependent then say whether there is exactly one or a whole line of them.
The last row is a prediction rather than an outcome, and it is the useful one in an examination. Comparing three ratios takes ten seconds and tells you what to expect before you commit to a method.
Try the prediction on a system you have already solved. In Example 1, two over one is two and five over three is not, so the ratios differ and the lines must cross exactly once, which is what the algebra found.
OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §11.1 Systems of Linear Equations: Two Variables §11.1 — the same three outcomes, with the same vocabulary
Tweak it
The difference between no solution and infinitely many is one number on one right-hand side, which is easier to believe once you have watched it happen. The first line here is fixed at x minus two y equals four, which is y equal to half of x, less two.
Parameter explorer
Slide the constant. Read the height at which the plotted line crosses the vertical axis, and find the value of the constant that makes it match negative two.
\[ 3x - 6y = {c} \]
Whatever you set the constant to, the slope of the plotted line stays at one half, because the constant never touches the x-term. Only the height moves, which is why the outcome is always either parallel or identical and never a single crossing.
Now connect the sliding to the algebra. Substituting x equal to two y plus four into three x minus six y equals c gives twelve equals c, so the elimination ends at a true statement exactly when the constant is twelve and at a false one every other time.
The book's Example 4(a) is the setting at eight, four units short of the value that would make the lines coincide, which is the same four that showed up in that example's check. One number, two completely different answers.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 163 — Example 4(a), with its constant made adjustable
Section
Part 5
Concept
Word problems in this lesson all have the same shape. There are two quantities you do not know and two separate facts about them, and each fact becomes an equation. Two equations in two letters is a system, and you now have two ways to solve one.
The book calls the middle step a verbal model: a sentence in words, with units, written above the equation it becomes. Cost per shirt times shirts, plus cost per shirt times shirts, equals total cost. Getting the units to agree is what tells you the equation is sensible.
The last step sounds trivial and is where marks go missing. Elimination hands you whichever letter you arranged to keep, and that is often not the letter the question asked about, so the final line of your work is a decision rather than a calculation.
One more habit for word problems: check your answer against the situation, not only against your equations. An answer of two and a half table tennis games satisfies the algebra and not the evening.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 162 — Example 3, Step 1
Worked example
A school buys short sleeve T-shirts for 8 dollars each and sells them for 11, and buys long sleeve ones for 10 dollars each and sells them for 16. It spends 3900 dollars altogether and takes 5925 dollars for all of them. How many short sleeve shirts were sold?
Name the unknowns: let x be the number of short sleeve shirts and y the number of long sleeve ones. Two facts here, one about money spent and one about money taken, so two equations.
\[ \begin{array}{lcl} \text{cost:} & 8x + 10y & = 3900 \\ \text{revenue:} & 11x + 16y & = 5925 \end{array} \]
Choose the method from the coefficients
Why: Eight, ten, eleven and sixteen: no coefficient is 1, and neither eight nor eleven divides the other, so this is elimination with both rows multiplied.
\[ \begin{cases} 8x + 10y = 3900 \\ 11x + 16y = 5925 \end{cases} \]
Multiply the cost equation by negative 11
Why: Every term: negative eighty-eight x, negative one hundred and ten y, and negative forty-two thousand nine hundred.
\[ -88x - 110y = -42\,900 \]
Multiply the revenue equation by 8
Why: Eighty-eight x now differs from negative eighty-eight x only in sign.
\[ 88x + 128y = 47\,400 \]
Add the revised equations
Why: The x-terms cancel; negative one hundred and ten y plus one hundred and twenty-eight y is eighteen y; and the money totals give four thousand five hundred.
\[ 18y = 4500 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = 250 \]
Here is the moment the book warns about. Two hundred and fifty is a perfectly good number and it counts long sleeve shirts, while the question asked about short sleeve ones. Stopping now gives a right number and a wrong answer.
Substitute 250 for y in the cost equation
Why: Ten times two hundred and fifty is two thousand five hundred, so the short sleeve shirts account for one thousand four hundred dollars of the spending.
\[ 8x + 10(250) = 3900 \;\Longrightarrow\; 8x = 1400 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 175 \]
Check both money totals
Why: Cost: 175 shirts at 8 dollars is 1400 and 250 at 10 dollars is 2500, which add to 3900. Revenue: 175 at 11 dollars is 1925 and 250 at 16 dollars is 4000, which add to 5925. Both facts hold.
\[ 8(175) + 10(250) = 1400 + 2500 = 3900 \quad \checkmark \]
\[ 11(175) + 16(250) = 1925 + 4000 = 5925 \quad \checkmark \]
So 175 short sleeve shirts were sold, along with 250 long sleeve ones. Both counts are whole numbers, which they had to be, and the profit works out at 2025 dollars if you are curious about how the fundraiser did.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 162 — Example 3
Picture it
The T-shirt problem drawn. The steeper falling line is every order of shirts that costs exactly 3900 dollars, and the other is every order that brings in exactly 5925. Each line on its own allows a great many orders.
Figure (svg): Two falling lines on axes, one for total cost and one for total revenue, crossing at the point one hundred and seventy-five, two hundred and fifty.
Read the cost line first. Buy no short sleeve shirts and you could afford 390 long sleeve ones; buy 400 short sleeve shirts and only 70 long sleeve ones fit in the budget. All of those orders spend the same 3900 dollars.
Now the revenue line does the same job for the takings. Only where the two lines cross does a single order hit both money totals at once, and that crossing is at 175 short sleeve and 250 long sleeve shirts, which is what the elimination produced.
The picture also shows why the answer had to be unique. The two lines have different slopes, because the cost and selling prices are in different ratios, so they cross exactly once. Had the mark-up been the same on both shirts, the lines would have been parallel and the story impossible.
Note the scale on both axes. These lines cross at a point with three-digit coordinates, far outside anything you would draw by hand, which is the Part 1 argument arriving in a real setting.
Real world
This is the exercise the lesson opener promised: a music store sold 9 guitars in a week for a total of 3611 dollars. Electric guitars sold for 479 dollars each and acoustic ones for 339. How many of each were sold?
\[ \begin{cases} x + y = 9 & \text{nine guitars} \\ 479x + 339y = 3611 & \text{the takings} \end{cases} \]
Figure (svg): Two lines on axes, a gently falling one for the nine guitars sold and a steeply falling one for the total of three thousand six hundred and eleven dollars, crossing at four and five.
Before solving, look at the coefficients and decide. The first row has two coefficients of 1, so substitution is as cheap as it ever gets, and elimination would mean multiplying by 479 or 339 for no reason at all.
Discussion prompt
Solve this system by substitution, then check your answer in both original equations and against the situation. Say also what a rough estimate would have told you before you started.
Notice how much work the coefficient of 1 saved. Isolating y in the first row cost one subtraction, and the only awkward arithmetic in the whole problem was four hundred and seventy-nine minus three hundred and thirty-nine.
The estimate at the end is worth making a habit. Working out the average price before solving tells you which way the answer must lean, so an answer of seven electrics and two acoustics would have been caught before you wrote it down.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 165 — Exercise 55
Worked example
Seventy-six people gathered to play table tennis, and 26 games were in progress at one time. A doubles game uses 4 players and a singles game uses 2, and everybody was playing. How many games of each kind were going on?
Let d be the number of doubles games and s the number of singles games. The two facts are the number of games and the number of people, and they are genuinely different facts, which is what makes the system solvable.
\[ \begin{cases} d + s = 26 & \text{games in progress} \\ 4d + 2s = 76 & \text{people playing} \end{cases} \]
Choose the method
Why: The first row has two coefficients of 1, so substitution is the obvious route; isolating s costs one subtraction.
\[ s = 26 - d \]
Substitute into the people equation
Why: Every s becomes the bracket, and the 2 multiplies all of it.
\[ 4d + 2(26 - d) = 76 \]
Expand and collect
Why: Two times twenty-six is fifty-two, and four d minus two d is two d.
\[ 4d + 52 - 2d = 76 \;\Longrightarrow\; 2d = 24 \]
Solve for the number of doubles games
Why: Twenty-four is two twelves.
\[ d = 12 \]
Back-substitute for the singles games
Why: Twelve doubles games out of twenty-six leaves fourteen singles games.
\[ s = 26 - 12 = 14 \]
Both answers are whole numbers, which they had to be, since half a game in progress is not a thing. An answer of twelve and a half would have meant an arithmetic slip or a misread number in the question.
Check both facts, and the situation
Why: Twelve plus fourteen is twenty-six games. Twelve doubles games use forty-eight players and fourteen singles games use twenty-eight, which is seventy-six people, so nobody is left standing about.
\[ 12 + 14 = 26 \quad \checkmark \]
\[ 4(12) + 2(14) = 48 + 28 = 76 \quad \checkmark \]
Notice that the two equations really did say different things. Had the second been eight d plus four s equals one hundred and fifty-two, it would have been the people fact doubled, the algebra would have ended at zero equals zero, and the evening would have been underdetermined.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 166 — Exercise 59
Estimation
A wholesaler mixes peanuts at 2.80 dollars a pound with cashews at 5.30 a pound, to make 100 pounds selling at 3.30 a pound. Commit to a rough answer before any algebra, because an estimate here is quick and catches a lot of mistakes.
\[ \text{2.80, } \; 5.30 \; \text{and a mix at } 3.30 \]
Predict first
Roughly how much of the 100 pound mix is peanuts?
Correct: About 80 pounds
Why: The mix price of 3.30 is only 0.50 above the peanut price and a full 2.00 below the cashew price, so the mix sits much closer to peanuts than to cashews and peanuts must dominate. The distances 0.50 and 2.00 are in the ratio one to four, which points straight at 80 pounds of peanuts and 20 of cashews, and the algebra on the next slide confirms it exactly.
The reasoning is worth naming. The mix price is a weighted average of the two nut prices, so it lands nearer the price of whichever nut there is more of. A mix at 3.30 is very near 2.80, so peanuts have to be doing most of the work.
You can even get the exact split from the estimate. The mix price sits 0.50 from peanuts and 2.00 from cashews, and the amounts come out in the opposite ratio, four to one, which is 80 pounds against 20.
Estimating first changes how you read your own answer. If the algebra had handed back 30 pounds of peanuts you would now know immediately that something was wrong, rather than writing it down and moving on.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 166 — Exercise 61
Worked example
Now the algebra behind the estimate. Let p be the pounds of peanuts and c the pounds of cashews. Two facts: the mix weighs 100 pounds, and the mix is worth 100 times 3.30, which is 330 dollars.
\[ \begin{cases} p + c = 100 & \text{pounds of mix} \\ 2.8p + 5.3c = 330 & \text{dollars of value} \end{cases} \]
Choose the method
Why: The first row has two coefficients of 1, so substitution again; isolating c costs one subtraction.
\[ c = 100 - p \]
Substitute into the value equation
Why: Every c becomes the bracket, and 5.3 multiplies all of it.
\[ 2.8p + 5.3(100 - p) = 330 \]
Expand the bracket
Why: 5.3 times 100 is 530, and 5.3 times negative p is negative 5.3p.
\[ 2.8p + 530 - 5.3p = 330 \]
Collect and solve
Why: 2.8p minus 5.3p is negative 2.5p, and taking 530 off both sides leaves negative 200.
\[ -2.5p = -200 \;\Longrightarrow\; p = 80 \]
Back-substitute for the cashews
Why: Eighty pounds of peanuts out of a hundred leaves twenty pounds of cashews.
\[ c = 100 - 80 = 20 \]
Figure (svg): A bar one hundred pounds long divided into a long peanut section of eighty pounds and a short cashew section of twenty pounds, with the money each section brings in written underneath.
The bar is drawn to scale, so you can see the estimate and the answer agreeing. Peanuts take four fifths of the length because the selling price sits four times closer to their price than to the cashew price.
Check both facts against the situation
Why: Eighty and twenty make a hundred pounds. Eighty pounds of peanuts is worth 224 dollars and twenty pounds of cashews is worth 106, and those add to 330, which is exactly a hundred pounds at 3.30.
\[ 2.8(80) + 5.3(20) = 224 + 106 = 330 \quad \checkmark \]
Notice that the estimate two slides ago got the answer right on its own. The algebra was needed to be sure, not to discover, and that is a comfortable position to solve from.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 166 — Exercise 61
Error analysis
Here is a fundraiser like Example 3 with different money in it. The school spends 4300 dollars on T-shirts at the same 8 and 10 dollars each, and takes 6475 dollars for them at 11 and 16 dollars each. A student starts like this.
\[ \begin{array}{l} 8x + 10y = 4300 \\ 8x = 4300 - 10y \;\Longrightarrow\; x = \dfrac{4300 - 10y}{8} \;\text{ ... and then stops} \end{array} \]
Annotate
On: \( x = \dfrac{4300 - 10y}{8} \)
\[ \begin{cases} 8x + 10y = 4300 \\ 11x + 16y = 6475 \end{cases} \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 225, \; y = 250 \]
Check both facts. Cost: 225 shirts at 8 dollars is 1800 and 250 at 10 dollars is 2500, which add to 4300. Revenue: 225 at 11 dollars is 2475 and 250 at 16 dollars is 4000, which add to 6475. Both totals hold, so the pair is right.
The general point is about counting. Two unknowns need two independent facts, and if your work only ever used one of the numbers you were given, you have a formula rather than an answer. Reread the question and find the fact you left out.
This worked example is mine rather than the book's. The printed What If exercise beside Example 3 gives money totals that cannot come from whole numbers of shirts at those prices, so the numbers above are clean ones of the same kind.
Worked example
A two day marathon walk. Martha starts walking at ten in the morning at 4 miles per hour. Carol starts two hours later and runs at 6 miles per hour to catch up. When does Carol catch Martha?
Let t be the hours since ten in the morning and d the distance walked in miles. Each walker gives one equation, and asking when Carol catches Martha is asking for the pair that satisfies both.
\[ \begin{cases} d = 4t & \text{Martha, from } t = 0 \\ d = 6(t - 2) & \text{Carol, from } t = 2 \end{cases} \]
The two in Carol's equation is the head start she is giving away, not a distance. At t equal to 3 she has been moving for one hour, so she has covered 6 miles, and the bracket is what arranges that.
Substitute Martha's distance into Carol's equation
Why: Both rows are already solved for d, so substitution is immediate: set the two expressions for the same distance equal.
\[ 4t = 6(t - 2) \]
Expand the bracket
Why: Six times t is six t, and six times negative two is negative twelve.
\[ 4t = 6t - 12 \]
Collect the t terms and solve
Why: Subtracting six t from both sides gives negative two t equal to negative twelve.
\[ -2t = -12 \;\Longrightarrow\; t = 6 \]
Find the distance as well
Why: Six hours of Martha's walking at 4 miles per hour.
\[ d = 4(6) = 24 \]
Figure (svg): Two rising lines on axes of time against distance: Martha's starts at the origin with the gentler slope, Carol's starts two hours later and is steeper, and they meet at six hours and twenty-four miles.
Carol's line starts two hours along the horizontal axis and climbs more steeply, so it begins behind and closes the gap. The crossing is the first moment the two have covered the same distance, and it is the only one.
Check both walkers, and the clock
Why: Martha: six hours at 4 miles per hour is 24 miles. Carol: she has been running for four hours at 6 miles per hour, which is also 24 miles. Six hours after ten in the morning is four in the afternoon, and 24 miles is inside the 26.2 mile course, so the story holds together.
\[ 4(6) = 24 \quad \checkmark \qquad 6(6 - 2) = 6(4) = 24 \quad \checkmark \]
The last part of the exercise asks how Carol could catch up an hour earlier. Starting at eleven instead of noon does it, and so does running at 8 miles per hour, since four hours of Martha's walking is 20 miles and Carol would need to cover that in her two and a half hours.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 166 — Exercise 60
Socratic
The hardest part of a word problem is usually not the algebra but the sentence that does not look like an equation. This challenge exercise has one of those, and it is worth arguing out before solving.
An electrician earned 50 dollars an hour and an apprentice earned 20. The electrician worked 4 hours more than the apprentice, and together they earned 550 dollars. How much did each person earn?
Discussion prompt
Name your two unknowns, turn each of the two facts into an equation, and solve. Say in particular how the phrase worked four hours more becomes an equation, and which quantity the question is actually asking for.
The phrase to slow down on is worked four hours more. It is tempting to write e plus four equals a, which says the apprentice worked longer. Test any such line with a number: if the apprentice worked 5 hours, the electrician worked 9, so 9 equals 5 plus 4.
The second thing this problem punishes is answering in the wrong units. The unknowns you chose were hours because hours are what the sentences talk about, and the question wanted dollars, so the final move is a multiplication rather than the end of the algebra.
Notice that the first equation was already solved for e, which is the cheapest possible invitation to substitute. Word problems containing a comparison usually hand you a row in that form, so watch for it.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 166 — Exercise 63
Section
Part 6
Pattern
Everything in this lesson fits in one procedure, and the order of it matters more than any individual technique. Run these five moves on any system and you will either produce a checked ordered pair or a statement about how many solutions exist.
Figure (svg): Five stacked boxes joined by downward arrows: look at the coefficients, pick the method, reduce to one equation, solve and back-substitute, and check in both original equations.
The first two moves are inspection rather than algebra, and they are what keep the middle of the work short. Choosing badly never gives a wrong answer, but it can turn three lines into eight.
The last line is the one that stops a degenerate system feeling like a disaster. When the letters all go, nothing has failed; the system has simply answered a different question than you expected, and the answer is in front of you.
Lesson 3.3 takes this procedure into inequalities, where two boundaries and a region replace two lines and a point, and Lesson 3.4 extends elimination to three equations in three letters. Both of them assume this procedure is automatic.
Check
An examination question of the kind that has appeared in this lesson. Look at the coefficients first, decide on a method, and only then start writing. Both coordinates matter, so do not stop at the first one.
Check your understanding
What is the solution of the system 3x + 2y = 4 and 6x - 3y = -27?
Answer: B
Why: Six is twice three, so multiply the first row by negative 2 to get negative six x minus four y equals negative eight, and add: negative seven y equals negative thirty-five, so y is 5. Then three x plus ten equals four, so x is negative 2. Both original rows hold: negative six plus ten is four, and negative twelve minus fifteen is negative twenty-seven.
The quickest way through four options like these is a single substitution. Put each pair into the first equation and three of them fail immediately, which takes far less time than solving from scratch under pressure.
Notice that the wrong options are the right numbers with wrong signs. That is deliberate on the examiner's part, because the commonest error in this elimination is multiplying by positive two instead of negative two and so failing to cancel.
If you did solve it properly, check which letter you eliminated. Eliminating y instead needs the first row times three and the second times two, giving twenty-one x equal to negative forty-two, and x is negative two as before.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 165 — Exercise 40
Check
This is the outcome that feels like an error and is not. Read the leftover line carefully, decide whether it is true or false, and then say what that tells you about the two lines.
Check your understanding
Eliminating a variable from a system leaves the line 0 = 7. What is the solution of the system?
Answer: C
Why: Zero is not seven, so the line is false, and every move that produced it was legal. That means no pair of numbers can satisfy both equations at once, so the system has no solution and the two lines are parallel. This is what Example 4(a) looks like when the numbers are different.
Keep the two verdicts apart by asking one question of the leftover line: is it true? A true statement with no letters means nothing was pinned down, so infinitely many solutions. A false one means the demand was impossible, so none.
The picture behind this answer is the parallel pair from Part 4. Same slope, different position, a constant gap, nowhere to cross, and the algebra reporting that gap as a number that does not equal zero.
The vocabulary is worth adding to your answer. A system with no solution is inconsistent, and saying so shows that you know the difference between this case and the dependent one.
Check
Elimination lives or dies in its setup, so this question stops before any adding happens. Look at the coefficients of the letter you want to remove and ask what would make them differ only in sign.
Check your understanding
To eliminate the y-terms from 4x - 3y = 10 and 3x + 5y = -7, which pair of multipliers works?
Answer: A
Why: The y-coefficients are negative 3 and 5, which already have opposite signs, so multiplying by 5 and 3 gives negative fifteen y and fifteen y and they cancel on adding. The result is twenty-nine x equal to twenty-nine, so x is 1 and then y is negative 2.
The habit being tested is reading the signs before choosing the numbers. When the two coefficients already have opposite signs, plain positive multipliers finish the job; when they have the same sign, one multiplier has to be negative.
Finish the problem to see the setup pay off. Twenty x minus fifteen y equals fifty and nine x plus fifteen y equals negative twenty-one, which add to twenty-nine x equal to twenty-nine, so x is 1, and then four minus three y equals ten gives y equal to negative 2.
Check in both original rows: four minus negative six is ten, and three plus negative ten is negative seven. Both hold, so the pair is confirmed and the setup was the only real decision in the problem.
Explain it to yourself
One idea has carried this lesson, and putting it in your own sentences is what makes it stick. Write your answer before reading the one below, because recognising a good explanation is much easier than producing one.
Discussion prompt
In three or four sentences, explain what substitution and elimination have in common, then say what you look at in a system to decide between them, and give one system of each kind from this lesson.
If your explanation used the word easier without saying what makes it easier, try again. Fractions are the currency here: the method that keeps whole numbers in the middle of the work is the method to pick.
A good test of your own understanding is whether you could explain the choice to somebody who knows how to solve a one-letter equation and nothing else. That is genuinely all either method assumes.
One more thing worth including: neither method cares whether the answer is a whole number, a fraction or nonexistent. That robustness is why algebra replaced graphing in this lesson rather than merely supplementing it.
Exit ticket
One problem that uses all of it: name the unknowns, turn two sentences into two equations, choose the method by the coefficients, and check your answer in both equations before you write it down.
Eleven gallons of regular gasoline and 16 gallons of premium together cost 58.55 dollars. Premium costs 20 cents more per gallon than regular. What is the cost of a gallon of premium?
Discussion prompt
Write the system, say which method the coefficients point to and why, solve it, and check the pair in both equations. Then say which of the two numbers the question actually asked for.
The detail that catches people here is the 20 cents. The other numbers in the problem are in dollars, so the comparison has to be written as 0.20 rather than 20, and mixing the units gives an answer about twenty dollars out.
Notice that this is the county fair problem from Part 1 wearing different clothes: two prices, one difference between them, and one total. Recognising a problem you have already solved is the most useful thing you can do under time pressure.
Finish by reading the question once more, as every word problem in this deck has. The algebra hands you both prices, and only one of them is the answer being asked for.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.2 Solve Linear Systems Algebraically §3.2, p. 166 — Exercise 58
Recap
Two methods, one decision, and one habit. The methods both reduce a system to a single equation in a single letter; the decision is made by looking at the coefficients; and the habit is checking the pair you found in both original equations.
| what you see | what you do | example in this lesson |
|---|---|---|
| a coefficient of 1 or −1 | substitution: isolate that letter | Example 1, (−30, 11) |
| a letter already alone, as in a = c + 2 | substitution, with no rearranging | Exercise 56, an adult pass at 4.75 |
| coefficients already opposite in sign | elimination, add straight away | Exercise 62, plane 150 and wind 50 |
| one coefficient a multiple of its partner | elimination, multiply one row | Example 2, (−4/3, −2) |
| nothing dividing anything | elimination, multiply both rows | Example 3, 175 short sleeve shirts |
| fractions or decimals | clear them, then choose again | Exercises 47 and 44 |
| every letter vanishes, statement false | no solution; the lines are parallel | Example 4(a), 12 = 8 |
| every letter vanishes, statement true | infinitely many; one line twice | Example 4(b), 0 = 0 |
Read the first six rows and notice that they are one row. Every one of them says the same thing: look at the coefficients, pick the cheaper route, and reduce to one letter. Only the cheapness changes from row to row.
The last two rows are the genuinely new idea of this lesson, and they are the ones to rehearse. A statement with no letters in it is an answer, and which answer it is depends only on whether the statement is true.
\[ \text{always finish with } \; 2(-30) + 5(11) = -5 \;\text{ and }\; -30 + 3(11) = 3 \]
That double check is the line to keep writing for the rest of the chapter. It costs two substitutions and it is the only part of the process that can catch a sign error, a dropped coefficient or an answer solved for the wrong letter.
Lesson 3.3 graphs systems of inequalities, where the crossing point becomes a corner of a region, and Lesson 3.4 runs elimination on three equations in three letters. Both build directly on the procedure you have just finished.
OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §11.1 Systems of Linear Equations: Two Variables §11.1 — the same two methods, with the three outcomes named
Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Algebra 2 — $55/session, free consultation.