3.1 Solving Linear Systems by Graphing

Systems of two linear equations and what a solution means, solving by graphing and checking in both equations, systems with infinitely many solutions or none, the consistent and independent vocabulary, and modelling a comparison with a system.

Subject: Algebra 2 · 67 slides · symbolic lesson

Open the interactive version of this deck

What this lesson covers

The lesson, slide by slide

1. Solve Linear Systems by Graphing

Title

Algebra 2 · Lesson 3.1

A solution is one point that two lines share, so both lines have to agree about it

2. What this lesson gives you

Objectives

Up to now an equation with two letters in it has been a line, and you have been asked to draw it, read its slope, or find a point on it. Every one of those questions was about one line at a time.

This lesson puts two of them on the same grid at once and asks a new kind of question: is there a pair of numbers that both equations agree about? That pair, if it exists, is where the two lines cross.

One habit runs through the whole lesson and it is worth naming before you meet it. A pair of numbers that satisfies one of the two equations has done half of nothing; it is the pair that satisfies both that you are hunting for, and the only way to be sure is to substitute into both.

There is also an honest limitation here, and the lesson does not hide it. A crossing point read off a grid is only as accurate as the grid, which is exactly why Lesson 3.2 goes on to solve systems with algebra instead. Graphing is what makes the algebra make sense.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 153 — Before, Now, Why and the Key Vocabulary

3. First, one line and one point

Warm-up

Everything new today is built on two things you can already do: read a line off its equation, and test whether a given point lies on it. Warm both up before anything is added.

\[ y = 2x + 4 \qquad\text{and}\qquad y = -3x + 44 \]

Discussion prompt

Name the slope and the y-intercept of the first line. Then test the pair where x is 8 and y is 20 in the first equation, and test the same pair in the second equation. Write down what you find before reading on.

Notice what testing a point actually involved. You put the x value in, you worked out the right-hand side, and you compared it with the y value you were given. No graphing, no rearranging, no guessing.

Those two equations come from the calculator activity that opens this chapter in the textbook, where a table of values is scrolled until the two columns agree. They agree at x equal to 8, and the pair (8, 20) is the answer the activity is hunting for.

Keep the second test in mind as the lesson goes on. Most pairs of numbers pass one test and fail the other, and finding the rare pair that passes both is what the rest of these slides are about.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 152 — the Investigating Algebra activity

4. Solutions as crossing points

Section

Part 1

5. One equation already has endlessly many solutions

Concept

Start with a single equation in two letters and ask what solves it. The answer is not one pair of numbers; it is a whole line of them, and getting comfortable with that is what makes a system make sense.

\[ 4x + y = 8 \]

Choose any value of x you like and the equation tells you the matching y. Choose x equal to 0 and y must be 8; choose x equal to 3 and y must be negative 4. There is no shortage of solutions and no way to list them all.

Figure (svg): The line four x plus y equals eight, with the four ordered pairs (0, 8), (1, 4), (2, 0) and (3, minus 4) marked on it as dots.

One equation, endlessly many solutions: every dot on this line satisfies it, and so does every point between the dots.

Every dot drawn on that line is one solution, and so is every point in between, including all the ones with untidy coordinates. The line is not a decoration beside the equation: the line is the equation's solution set, drawn.

Hold that thought, because it is what makes the next step obvious rather than mysterious. If one equation is a line of solutions and a second equation is another line of solutions, then a pair solving both must lie on both lines at once.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 153 — a solution of a system satisfies each equation

6. Reading a linear system piece by piece

Notation

The textbook writes a system in a particular shape and labels the two rows. Take the notation apart now, so that the labels are information rather than clutter when a question uses them.

Annotate

On: \( \begin{cases} Ax + By = C & \text{Equation 1} \\ Dx + Ey = F & \text{Equation 2} \end{cases} \)

  • The brace is doing real work: it says these two equations are to be read together, as one problem, and that the x in the first line means the same number as the x in the second.
  • Names, not part of the maths. You will use them constantly when you check an answer, because you have to report that it worked in Equation 1 AND in Equation 2.
  • Ordinary numbers, fixed for the problem. This shape is called standard form, and both lines of a system are often written in it because it comes straight out of a word problem.
  • An ordered pair (x, y) that satisfies each equation. Substitute the x and the y, work out both sides of both equations, and both statements must come out true.

Nothing here says the two equations have to be in standard form. A system can mix forms freely, and the bus-fare problem later in this lesson has both of its equations written with y already alone.

The word ordered in ordered pair matters more than it looks. The pair (3, 8) and the pair (8, 3) are different points and different claims, and swapping the two numbers by accident is one of the quickest ways to fail a check that should have passed.

The last note is the definition you will be tested on, so read it once more. A solution of the system is a pair that satisfies each equation, and the word each is the part people lose.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 153 — the definition of a linear system and of a solution

7. Two conditions at once, and the point that meets both

Concept

Now put a second equation beside the first. Each equation is a condition on the pair of numbers, and a solution of the system is a pair that satisfies both conditions at the same time.

system of two linear equations — Two equations in the same two variables, to be satisfied together; also called a linear system.

solution of a system — An ordered pair (x, y) that satisfies each equation of the system. Solutions correspond to points where the graphs of the equations intersect.

Read the second definition's last sentence slowly. It is the bridge this whole lesson stands on: solutions of the system and crossing points of the graphs are the same thing, described in two languages.

Why must they be the same thing? Lying on the first line means satisfying the first equation, and lying on the second line means satisfying the second. A point that lies on both therefore satisfies both, and a pair that satisfies both must lie on both.

So the search for a solution becomes a search you can do with your eyes. Draw the two lines and look where they cross, which is the method this lesson is named after.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 153 — solutions correspond to points of intersection

8. Why two lines usually meet exactly once

Intuition

Before any example, get a feel for how often a crossing should be expected. Two lines with different steepnesses are closing on each other, or drawing apart, at a steady rate that never changes.

Figure (svg): Two lines, y equals minus three x plus two and y equals two x minus three, drawn on one grid and crossing at the single point (1, minus 1).

Two different steepnesses cannot stay apart forever and cannot touch twice, so they meet exactly once.

Because the gap between them changes steadily and never levels off, it must hit zero once, somewhere, and then keep going the other way. Once is the important word: having passed through zero, the gap moves away and cannot return.

So two lines of different slopes cross exactly once, no matter how nearly parallel they are. The crossing point of the two lines in this picture is the pair where x is 1 and y is negative 1, and there is no second pair anywhere.

That explains why the usual answer to a linear system is one single pair. The two other cases, which Parts 2 and 3 are about, both come from the one thing this argument assumed: that the steepnesses were different.

9. Two reliable ways to get a line onto the grid

Concept

You are about to draw a great many pairs of lines, so it is worth having two dependable routes from an equation to a line rather than plotting points at random and hoping.

\[ y = mx + b \]

The first route uses this form. Mark the point on the vertical axis at height b, then walk: across 1 and up m, or across the bottom number of the fraction and up the top one. Two points fix the line, but a third is a cheap insurance policy against a slip.

\[ 4x + y = 8: \quad x = 0 \Rightarrow y = 8, \qquad y = 0 \Rightarrow x = 2 \]

The second route suits an equation in standard form and skips the rearranging altogether. Put x equal to zero to find where the line crosses the vertical axis, put y equal to zero to find where it crosses the horizontal one, and join those two points.

the equation looks likequickest routewhat you plot
y is already alonestart at the intercept and stepthe point (0, b), then step by the slope
standard form, small numbersthe two interceptswhere each axis is crossed
standard form, awkward numbersrearrange, then stepthe point (0, b), then step by the slope

One accuracy habit matters more here than it did in Chapter 2. Plot your two points far apart, because a line drawn through two points that are close together can be a whole unit out by the time it reaches the crossing you are trying to read.

10. Example 1: graph the system, estimate, then check

Worked example

This is the lesson's first full example, and it sets the pattern for every graphing question you will meet. Read the instruction carefully: graph, estimate the solution, then check it algebraically.

\[ \begin{cases} 4x + y = 8 & \text{Equation 1} \\ 2x - 3y = 18 & \text{Equation 2} \end{cases} \]

Rewrite Equation 1 with y alone

Why: standard form is awkward to plot; with y by itself you can read a starting height and a step.

\[ 4x + y = 8 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = -4x + 8 \]

Rewrite Equation 2 with y alone

Why: the same move: subtract the x term, then divide every term by the coefficient of y.

\[ 2x - 3y = 18 \;\Longrightarrow\; -3y = -2x + 18 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = \tfrac{2}{3}x - 6 \]

The two slopes are different, negative 4 against two thirds, so from the previous slide you already know what to expect: one crossing, somewhere. The graph only has to tell you where.

Figure (svg): The lines four x plus y equals eight and two x minus three y equals eighteen drawn on one grid, crossing at the marked point (3, minus 4).

Both lines pass through the marked point and through nothing else in common. That single pair is what solving the system means.

Read the crossing off the grid

Why: the lines appear to meet where x is 3 and y is negative 4; both coordinates land on grid lines, which is what makes this estimate trustworthy.

\[ (x, y) \approx (3, -4) \]

The word appear is the book's own, and it is honest. Until the pair has been substituted back, what you have is a reading off a picture, not a verified answer.

Check the pair in both original equations

Why: substitute 3 for x and negative 4 for y in Equation 1, then do the same in Equation 2. Both statements come out true, so the pair solves the system, and the solution is the pair where x is 3 and y is negative 4.

\[ \begin{array}{ll} 4(3) + (-4) = 12 - 4 = 8 \;\checkmark & 2(3) - 3(-4) = 6 + 12 = 18 \;\checkmark \end{array} \]

Notice that the check went back to the original equations, not to the rearranged ones. A slip made while rewriting would survive a check against your own rewriting, and this is how you catch it.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 153 — Example 1

11. The check that has to happen twice

Picture it

The check you just did has a shape worth drawing, because a great many marks are lost by doing half of it. The pair comes in at the top and has to come out true at the bottom of both branches.

Figure (svg): A flow diagram: the pair (3, minus 4) at the top splits into two branches, one into equation one and one into equation two, each branch ending in the arithmetic and the word true.

One tick is not a check. The pair has to survive both original equations before you may call it the solution.

The left branch and the right branch are independent tests. Passing the left one tells you the point is on the first line, which is genuine information, but on its own it says nothing about the second line at all.

Think about how many pairs pass the left test: every pair on the whole first line, which is endlessly many. The right test is what cuts that crowd down to one.

The textbook prints this warning in the margin beside Example 1 rather than in the exercises, which tells you how often it needs to be said. Check the graphical solution in both equations before concluding that it is a solution of the system.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 153 — the Avoid Errors note beside Example 1

12. Which equation does each pair satisfy?

Sorting

Six pairs of numbers, and the system from Example 1. Test each pair in the first equation and then in the second, and sort by what you find rather than by what looks plausible.

\[ \begin{cases} 4x + y = 8 & \text{Equation 1} \\ 2x - 3y = 18 & \text{Equation 2} \end{cases} \]

Sort into buckets

Sort each ordered pair by which of the two equations it satisfies.

Equation 1 only
(2, 0); (0, 8)
Equation 2 only
(9, 0); (0, −6)
Both, so it solves the system
(3, −4)
Neither equation
(1, 1)
one
These pairs make four x plus y come to 8, so they sit on the first line, but in the second equation they give 4 and negative 24 instead of 18.
two
These pairs make two x minus three y come to 18, so they sit on the second line, but in the first equation they give 36 and negative 6 instead of 8.
both
Twelve minus four is 8 and six plus twelve is 18, so this pair passes both tests, which is exactly what solving the system asks for.
none
Four plus one is 5 and two minus three is negative 1, so this pair misses both targets; most pairs of numbers do.

Count the buckets as you finish: four of the six pairs satisfy exactly one equation. Those are the pairs that fool a student who checks only once, and there are far more of them than there are solutions.

The pair where x is 1 and y is 1 earns its place too. It reminds you that a pair being wrong is the normal state of affairs, and that lying on neither line is not some special failure.

If you want a faster way to run these tests, substitute into the standard forms rather than the rearranged ones. Working out four times x plus y is quicker than working out negative four x plus eight and comparing.

13. Trap: the pair that passes one test

Trap

The trap

Here is a student's whole answer to a checking question, on the system three x minus two y equals 2 and x plus two y equals 6.

\[ (0, -1) \]

\[ 3(0) - 2(-1) = 2 \]

Two equals two, so the pair is reported as a solution of the system. The arithmetic on that line is completely correct.

This is the book's own error-analysis exercise, and it is not an unusual mistake. One equation was checked, it worked, and the work stopped there.

The fix

The second equation was never tested. Put the same pair into it and the claim falls apart at once.

\[ 0 + 2(-1) = -2 \ne 6 \]

So the pair lies on the first line and nowhere near the second. It solves one equation, which is not what the system asked.

\[ (2, 2) \]

The pair where x is 2 and y is 2 is the real solution: three times two minus two times two is 2, and two plus two times two is 6. Both true, so this one survives the double test.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 156 — Exercise 16, error analysis

14. Guided Practice 1: complete the double check

Fill the middle

Here is the first Guided Practice system with its crossing point already read off the graph. Your job is the part that turns a reading into an answer: finish both substitutions.

\[ \begin{cases} 3x + 2y = -4 \\ x + 3y = 1 \end{cases} \qquad (x, y) = (-2, 1) \]

Fill in the blanks

3(-2) + 2(1) = -4 \qquad\text1\qquad (-2) + 3(1) = ___

Why: Negative six plus two is negative four, which is what the first equation demands, and negative two plus three is 1, which is what the second demands. Both statements are true, so this pair is the solution of the system. Had only the first come out right, you would know nothing yet.

Watch the signs rather than the arithmetic here. Three times negative two is negative six, and it is the pair of brackets around the negative two that keeps you from writing 3 minus 2 by accident.

Notice also that each substitution used the equation as it was printed. You are testing whether the pair satisfies the system you were given, so the system you were given is what the pair has to be tested against.

One more thing worth saying now. If a check fails, do not assume the arithmetic is wrong. A failed check usually means the crossing was misread off the graph, and the fix is to look at the picture again, not to try the substitution once more.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 153 — Guided Practice 1

15. Guided Practice 1: three x plus two y equals negative four

Worked example

The same system as the last slide, done properly from the beginning. Graph it, estimate, and check, in that order, so that you see where the pair came from.

\[ \begin{cases} 3x + 2y = -4 & \text{Equation 1} \\ x + 3y = 1 & \text{Equation 2} \end{cases} \]

Solve Equation 1 for y

Why: halving is the last move, so every term on the right gets halved.

\[ 2y = -3x - 4 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = -\tfrac{3}{2}x - 2 \]

Solve Equation 2 for y

Why: subtract x from both sides, then divide every term by 3.

\[ 3y = -x + 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = -\tfrac{1}{3}x + \tfrac{1}{3} \]

Both slopes are negative, so both lines fall as you read left to right. They fall at different rates, though, and that difference is what guarantees a crossing.

Figure (svg): The lines three x plus two y equals minus four and x plus three y equals one crossing at the marked point (minus 2, 1).

The crossing sits on a grid corner, so reading it off is safe here. The check still has to be done.

Read off the crossing

Why: the lines meet on a corner of the grid, one where x is negative 2 and y is 1.

\[ (x, y) = (-2, 1) \]

A crossing that lands exactly on a grid corner is the friendly case. When it lands between corners, as it will on a later slide, the reading becomes an estimate and has to be treated as one.

Check the pair in both original equations

Why: substitute negative 2 for x and 1 for y in each equation as printed. Negative six plus two is negative four, and negative two plus three is one, so both statements are true and the pair where x is negative 2 and y is 1 is the solution.

\[ \begin{array}{ll} 3(-2) + 2(1) = -4 \;\checkmark & (-2) + 3(1) = 1 \;\checkmark \end{array} \]

It is worth noticing how cheap that check was: two substitutions and four small multiplications. The habit costs almost nothing and catches almost everything.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 153 — Guided Practice 1

16. Guided Practice 3: a crossing on the vertical axis

Worked example

This third checkpoint has a crossing in an unusual place, which makes it a good test of whether you are reading the picture or guessing at it.

\[ \begin{cases} 8x - y = 8 & \text{Equation 1} \\ 3x + 2y = -16 & \text{Equation 2} \end{cases} \]

Solve Equation 1 for y

Why: the coefficient of y is negative 1, so dividing by it flips the sign of every term.

\[ -y = -8x + 8 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = 8x - 8 \]

Solve Equation 2 for y

Why: subtract the x term first, then halve everything.

\[ 2y = -3x - 16 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = -\tfrac{3}{2}x - 8 \]

Look at the two rearranged equations before drawing anything. Both of them have the same number standing alone, negative 8, which means both lines cross the vertical axis at the same height. That height is the crossing point.

Figure (svg): The lines eight x minus y equals eight and three x plus two y equals minus sixteen crossing on the vertical axis at the point (0, minus 8).

A crossing on the vertical axis means x is zero, which makes the check unusually easy to do in your head.

Read off the crossing

Why: both lines pass through the point on the vertical axis at height negative 8, so that is where x is 0 and y is negative 8.

\[ (x, y) = (0, -8) \]

Reading a crossing that sits on an axis is a small mercy worth noticing, because one of the two coordinates is zero and there is nothing to misjudge about it. The other coordinate is then just the height at which both lines leave the axis.

Check the pair in both original equations

Why: with x equal to 0 the x terms vanish, which makes this the easiest check in the lesson: the first equation becomes the negative of negative 8, and the second becomes twice negative 8.

\[ \begin{array}{ll} 8(0) - (-8) = 8 \;\checkmark & 3(0) + 2(-8) = -16 \;\checkmark \end{array} \]

That the slopes differ, 8 against negative three halves, is what tells you this is the only crossing. Sharing a y-intercept means the lines meet there, and differing in slope means they meet nowhere else.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 153 — Guided Practice 3

17. How much can a reading off a grid be trusted?

Estimation

Every crossing so far landed on a corner of the grid. That was the textbook being kind. Before you meet a crossing that does not, commit to an opinion about how much a graphical answer is worth.

\[ \begin{cases} 6x - 9y = -20 \\ 2x + 4y = -52 \end{cases} \]

Predict first

Graphed on a grid ruled in units, this system looks as though it crosses near the point where x is negative 13 and y is negative 6.5. What is that reading worth?

  • It is exact, because the lines really do cross where they look as though they cross
  • It is an estimate, and only substituting into both equations can tell you how good an estimate it is
  • It is worthless, because a graph can never say anything true about a system
  • It must be wrong, because a solution has to have whole number coordinates

Correct: It is an estimate, and only substituting into both equations can tell you how good an estimate it is

Why: A graph can only report what its rulings can resolve, so a crossing between rulings has to be read as an estimate. The substitution is what turns the estimate into information: if both equations come out true, the reading was exact; if one of them misses, you know by how much and in which direction. Nothing about a solution requires whole numbers, and a graph that gets you within half a unit has told you a great deal.

The answer that calls graphing worthless is tempting once you have been burned by an inexact reading, but it goes much too far. A graph tells you how many solutions there are, roughly where the solution sits, and whether an algebraic answer you get later is plausible.

The answer about whole numbers is worth killing outright. Nothing in the definition of a solution mentions whole numbers, and the very next slide has a solution whose coordinates are fractions with 21 underneath.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 159 — the graphing calculator activity after Lesson 3.1

18. A crossing that misses every grid corner

Worked example

This is the system the textbook hands to a graphing calculator rather than to graph paper, and it is the honest limit of the method you have just learned.

\[ \begin{cases} 6x - 9y = -20 & \text{Equation 1} \\ 2x + 4y = -52 & \text{Equation 2} \end{cases} \]

Solve both equations for y

Why: the same two moves as always, done to both rows at once so the two lines can be drawn.

\[ y = \tfrac{2}{3}x + \tfrac{20}{9} \qquad y = -\tfrac{1}{2}x - 13 \]

Read the crossing off the coarse grid

Why: the lines meet somewhere to the left of negative 13 and a little below negative 6, which is as much as a grid ruled in units can tell you.

\[ (x, y) \approx (-13, -6.5) \]

Figure (svg): Two panels of the same system. On the left, a grid ruled in fives with the crossing point falling between the rulings; on the right, the same crossing magnified until the coordinates minus 13.05 and minus 6.48 can be read.

Nothing is wrong with the graph; it simply cannot report more precision than its rulings have. Chapter 3.2 exists for exactly this crossing.

The magnified panel shows what the coarse one was hiding. The crossing is at a point whose coordinates are not simple decimals at all, and no amount of squinting at the left panel would have produced them.

Test the estimate in both original equations

Why: this is the step that reveals the problem, and notice which equation it is that complains.

\[ \begin{array}{ll} 6(-13) - 9(-6.5) = -78 + 58.5 = -19.5 & \text{but } -20 \text{ was wanted} \\ 2(-13) + 4(-6.5) = -26 - 26 = -52 & \checkmark \end{array} \]

Read that pair of lines again, because it makes the trap from earlier concrete. The estimate passes the second equation exactly and misses the first by half a unit, so a student who checked only the second would have reported a wrong answer with complete confidence.

Verify the exact solution instead

Why: the true crossing has coordinates with 21 underneath; substitute those fractions and both equations come out true exactly, which is what the estimate could not manage.

\[ x = -\tfrac{274}{21}, \; y = -\tfrac{136}{21}: \quad 6\left(-\tfrac{274}{21}\right) - 9\left(-\tfrac{136}{21}\right) = \tfrac{-1644 + 1224}{21} = -20 \;\checkmark \]

In decimals those are about negative 13.05 and negative 6.48, which is exactly what the calculator reports. The graph found the neighbourhood and the algebra of Lesson 3.2 will find the address.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 159 — the graphing calculator activity, solved by the intersect feature

19. The same crossing found in a table

Comparison

Graphing is not the only way to hunt for a pair that satisfies both equations. The activity that opens the chapter builds a table of values for each equation and scrolls down it until the two columns agree.

\[ \begin{cases} y = 2x + 4 \\ y = -3x + 44 \end{cases} \]

Comparison matrix

x2x + 4−3x + 44
0444
41232
61626
82020

Fill in the four missing values and then look down the last two columns together. They start 40 apart, close steadily, and meet at one row: the row where x is 8 and both columns read 20.

That row is the solution, and it is the same pair you tested in the warm-up. The table is the graph with the picture taken away, which is why the crossing shows up in it as two equal numbers rather than as two lines touching.

A table has one clear advantage over graph paper: nothing is estimated. If the agreement happens at a whole number value of x, a table finds it exactly. Its weakness is the flip side of that, since a crossing at x equal to 8.4 would slip between the rows and never appear at all.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 152 — Explore: solve a system using a table

20. Say why a crossing point is a solution

Explain it to yourself

This is the one idea Part 1 exists to deliver, and saying it in your own words is what fixes it. Write your sentences down before you read the ones provided.

Discussion prompt

In two or three sentences, explain why a point where the two graphs cross must be a solution of the system, and why a point on just one of the lines cannot be. Use the words satisfies and lies on.

If your explanation leaned on the word crossing without mentioning what a line is made of, try it again. The reason the method works is that a line is the set of pairs satisfying its equation, and everything else follows from that.

There is a useful consequence hiding in your own answer. If a system has no crossing, it has no solution, and if the two graphs are the same line, then every point of that line is a solution. Parts 2 and 3 are those two sentences, worked out.

21. When the lines coincide

Section

Part 2

22. Two equations that draw the same line

Concept

The argument for one crossing assumed the two lines were genuinely different lines. Here is the first system where that assumption fails, and the failure is not a mistake in the problem.

\[ \begin{cases} 4x - 3y = 8 & \text{Equation 1} \\ 8x - 6y = 16 & \text{Equation 2} \end{cases} \]

Look along the second equation, term by term, against the first. Eight is twice four, negative six is twice negative three, and sixteen is twice eight. Every part of Equation 1 has simply been doubled.

Doubling both sides of a true equation keeps it true, and halving it again gets you back, so the two equations make exactly the same demand on x and y in two different sets of numbers.

\[ y = \tfrac{4}{3}x - \tfrac{8}{3} \qquad\text{from either equation} \]

Rearranged, the two rows collapse into one and the same rule. Same slope, same starting height, so the same line gets drawn twice, and the second drawing lands precisely on top of the first.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 154 — the Check Solution note beside Example 2

23. Example 2: an equation doubled, and what it costs

Worked example

Solve the system and classify it. The instruction has two halves, and the graph answers both.

\[ \begin{cases} 4x - 3y = 8 & \text{Equation 1} \\ 8x - 6y = 16 & \text{Equation 2} \end{cases} \]

Rewrite Equation 1 with y alone

Why: subtract the x term, then divide every term by negative 3, which flips each sign.

\[ -3y = -4x + 8 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = \tfrac{4}{3}x - \tfrac{8}{3} \]

Rewrite Equation 2 with y alone

Why: the same two moves, now with the doubled numbers; the fractions reduce back to the ones above.

\[ -6y = -8x + 16 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = \tfrac{8}{6}x - \tfrac{16}{6} = \tfrac{4}{3}x - \tfrac{8}{3} \]

The two right-hand sides are identical, so there is nothing left to graph twice. Whatever line the first equation draws, the second draws again in the same place.

Figure (svg): One line drawn twice: a solid line labelled four x minus three y equals eight with a dashed line labelled eight x minus six y equals sixteen lying exactly on top of it.

The orange dashes never leave the blue line. Two equations, one set of points, so every point of the line solves both.

Read the graph for the number of solutions

Why: the graphs are the same line, so every point on it lies on both graphs and satisfies both equations; there are infinitely many solutions rather than one.

\[ \text{solutions} = \{(x, y) : 4x - 3y = 8\} \]

Say what that means in ordinary words before moving on. Asking which point the two lines share is a fair question with an awkward answer here: they share all of them.

Notice that the answer is not nothing and it is not everything either. The solutions are still restricted, since a pair off that line, such as the one where x is 0 and y is 0, satisfies neither equation. What the system failed to do was narrow the line down any further.

Check three of the infinitely many solutions

Why: take the pairs where x is 2, 5 and negative 1, read the matching y off the line, and test each in both equations; a single point cannot settle the claim, so test several.

\[ \begin{array}{lll} (2, 0): & 4(2) - 3(0) = 8 \;\checkmark & 8(2) - 6(0) = 16 \;\checkmark \\ (5, 4): & 4(5) - 3(4) = 8 \;\checkmark & 8(5) - 6(4) = 16 \;\checkmark \\ (-1, -4): & 4(-1) - 3(-4) = 8 \;\checkmark & 8(-1) - 6(-4) = 16 \;\checkmark \end{array} \]

Because each point on the line is a solution, this system is called consistent and dependent, the vocabulary Part 4 sets out properly. For now the picture is the thing to remember.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 154 — Example 2

24. Naming a few of the infinitely many

Intuition

Infinitely many solutions can sound like no answer at all, so make it concrete. Pick any x you like, read the matching y off the line, and you are holding a solution.

Figure (svg): The single line of the coincident system with three of its points marked and named: (minus 1, minus 4), (2, 0) and (5, 4).

Three solutions picked at random off the line, and there is no end to them. Each one satisfies both equations of the system.

Three are marked here and none of them is special. Choose x equal to 8 and the line gives y equal to 8, and that pair satisfies both equations too; choose x equal to 0 and you get negative eight thirds, which is a perfectly good solution with an untidy look.

So the honest answer to this system is not a point but a rule: the solutions are every pair satisfying four x minus three y equals 8. The second equation adds no new information at all, which is what the word dependent will mean in Part 4.

It is worth noticing what a graph is doing for you here that arithmetic on its own would not. Two equations that look different gave one line, and you saw that at a glance rather than deducing it from the numbers.

25. Is one equation just the other one rescaled?

Discrimination

Six pairs of equations. For each pair, try multiplying one equation by a number to turn it into the other, and sort by how far that attempt gets you. Rearranging into slope-intercept form is a second way to decide.

Sort into buckets

Sort each pair by the relationship between the two equations.

Every term scales by the same factor: one line
4x − 3y = 8 and 8x − 6y = 16; 2x + 5y = 6 and 4x + 10y = 12; −20x + 12y = −24 and 5x − 3y = 6
The x and y parts scale but the constant does not: parallel lines
3x − 2y = 10 and 3x − 2y = 2; −2x + y = 5 and y = 2x + 2
No factor works at all: the lines cross
2x − y = 4 and x − 2y = −1
same
Multiply the first equation of each pair by 2, by 2 again, and by negative 4 and you land exactly on the second, constant included, so each pair draws one line and has infinitely many solutions.
par
In the first of these the x and y parts already agree but the constants are 10 and 2; in the second both lines climb 2 for every 1 across but start at heights 5 and 2. Same direction, different place, so no crossing.
cross
No single factor turns two x minus y into x minus two y, so these lines have different slopes and meet at exactly one point, the pair where x is 3 and y is 2.

The pair with negative twenty and twelve in it is the one that catches people, because the factor is negative four rather than a friendly two. Check all three numbers before deciding: negative four times 5 is negative 20, negative four times negative 3 is 12, and negative four times 6 is negative 24.

The pair whose two equations look completely different, one in standard form and one with y alone, is a reminder that form tells you nothing. Rearrange both and the comparison becomes easy.

This sort is the whole of Parts 2 and 3 in one exercise. If you can place a system in the right bucket without drawing anything, you can classify it, which is what Part 4 will ask you to do on purpose.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 156 — Exercises 17 to 28, solve and classify

26. Exercise 12: a multiple hiding behind a rearrangement

Worked example

This system looks nothing like Example 2, because one equation has already been solved for y and the other has not. Graphing it is still the way to see what is going on.

\[ \begin{cases} y = 4x + 3 & \text{Equation 1} \\ 20x - 5y = -15 & \text{Equation 2} \end{cases} \]

Rewrite Equation 2 with y alone

Why: subtract the x term, then divide every term by negative 5; watch all three signs change.

\[ -5y = -20x - 15 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = 4x + 3 \]

There is the punchline, and no graph was needed to reach it. Equation 2 rearranges into Equation 1 exactly, so the two rows are the same line written in two forms.

Going the other way round is worth seeing too. Multiply Equation 1 by negative 5 to get negative five y equals negative twenty x minus fifteen, then move the x term across, and you have Equation 2. The factor between the two equations is negative 5.

State the number of solutions

Why: one line, drawn twice, so every point of it satisfies both equations: infinitely many solutions, and the system is consistent and dependent.

\[ y = 4x + 3 \quad\text{for every } x \]

Check two points in both original equations

Why: take x equal to 1 and x equal to 0, read y off the rule, and test each pair in both equations as printed.

\[ \begin{array}{lll} (1, 7): & 7 = 4(1) + 3 \;\checkmark & 20(1) - 5(7) = -15 \;\checkmark \\ (0, 3): & 3 = 4(0) + 3 \;\checkmark & 20(0) - 5(3) = -15 \;\checkmark \end{array} \]

Notice how the check changes character in this case. With one solution you verify a single pair; with infinitely many you cannot verify them all, so you verify the rule and spot-check a couple of pairs to be sure you rearranged correctly.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 156 — Exercise 12

27. What would the algebra say about this system?

Prediction

Lesson 3.2 will solve systems by substitution instead of by graphing. It is worth predicting now what that algebra will do when the two equations describe the same line, because the answer looks alarming the first time you meet it.

\[ \begin{cases} y = 4x + 3 \\ 20x - 5y = -15 \end{cases} \]

Predict first

Substitute the first equation into the second and simplify as far as it goes. What kind of statement do you end up with?

  • A statement like 0 = 0, which is true whatever x happens to be
  • A statement like 0 = 3, which nothing can make true
  • A single value of x, and then a single value of y
  • Two different values of x

Correct: A statement like 0 = 0, which is true whatever x happens to be

Why: Putting four x plus three in place of y gives twenty x minus five times the bracket, which is twenty x minus twenty x minus fifteen, so the x terms cancel and the line reads negative fifteen equals negative fifteen. Every x survives that test, which is the algebra reporting that every point of the line is a solution. It is not a dead end and not an error: it is what infinitely many solutions looks like when you do the arithmetic instead of the drawing.

\[ 20x - 5(4x + 3) = 20x - 20x - 15 = -15 \;\Longrightarrow\; -15 = -15 \]

The two letters both vanished, which is the signal to watch for. When x disappears and leaves a statement that is true, every value of x works; when it disappears and leaves a statement that is false, no value does.

Meeting that now saves an unpleasant surprise later. A line that reads 0 equals 0 is not a sign you have gone wrong; it is the answer, and the answer is infinitely many solutions.

28. Break it: different equations, different graphs?

Counterexample

Here is a claim that sounds unarguable and is false. Take it apart with an example rather than with an argument, since one example is all it takes.

Discussion prompt

A classmate says: two equations that are written differently must have different graphs, so a system of two different-looking equations can never have more than one solution. Produce a system that breaks this, and say in one sentence what the claim confused.

The general lesson is worth more than the example. An equation is a condition, and many different-looking equations can impose exactly the same condition, which is why rearranging to a common form is such a reliable first move.

You can manufacture a counterexample to this claim whenever you like. Write any equation, multiply it through by 7, and you have a pair that looks unrelated and draws one line.

It also explains why textbook answers can differ from yours and both be right. Your line and the printed line may be the same line, wearing different numbers.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 156 — Exercises 21 and 24, systems in disguise

29. When the lines are parallel

Section

Part 3

30. The same step, from a different height

Concept

The other way the one-crossing argument can fail is for the two lines to be different but never to approach each other. That happens when they take exactly the same step.

\[ \begin{cases} 2x + y = 4 & \text{Equation 1} \\ 2x + y = 1 & \text{Equation 2} \end{cases} \]

These two equations have identical left-hand sides and different right-hand sides, which is a combination worth pausing on. They are asking the same expression to be two different numbers at once.

\[ y = -2x + 4 \qquad y = -2x + 1 \]

Figure (svg): The parallel lines two x plus y equals four and two x plus y equals one, each carrying an identical step of one across and two down drawn as dashed construction lines.

Both lines take the identical step, one across and two down. Starting three apart and stepping alike, they stay three apart.

Rearranged, both lines fall two for every one across, so the dashed steps drawn on them are identical. Only the starting heights differ, 4 on one line and 1 on the other.

Two lines that step alike keep whatever separation they began with. There is nowhere for them to meet, so there is no pair of numbers that satisfies both equations, and the system has no solution.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 154 — Example 3 and its Check Solution note

31. The gap that never closes

Intuition

It is worth making the no in no solution physical rather than verbal. Measure the vertical distance between the two lines at any x you like.

Figure (svg): The same two parallel lines with three vertical double arrows drawn between them, at x equal to minus one, one and three, each labelled with a gap of three.

Measure the vertical distance anywhere you like and it is three. A crossing would need that distance to reach zero somewhere.

Three measurements are drawn, at x equal to negative 1, 1 and 3, and every one of them is 3. That is not a coincidence of the picture: subtract the two rules and the x terms cancel, leaving the constant difference 3.

\[ (-2x + 4) - (-2x + 1) = 3 \quad\text{for every } x \]

A crossing would be a place where that gap is zero. The gap is 3 everywhere and never changes, so there is no such place, anywhere on the infinite length of either line.

Compare that with the crossing lines from Part 1, where the gap shrank steadily to nothing and then grew again on the other side. Whether the gap depends on x at all is the whole difference between one solution and none.

32. Example 3: two x plus y equals 4, and also equals 1

Worked example

Solve the system and classify it. The two equations are so similar that the answer can be argued in words, but graph it anyway, because the picture is the evidence.

\[ \begin{cases} 2x + y = 4 & \text{Equation 1} \\ 2x + y = 1 & \text{Equation 2} \end{cases} \]

Rewrite each equation with y alone

Why: one subtraction in each row, and nothing else is needed.

\[ y = -2x + 4 \qquad y = -2x + 1 \]

Compare the slopes and the intercepts

Why: the slopes are equal, both negative 2, and the intercepts differ, 4 against 1: same direction, different starting height.

\[ m_1 = m_2 = -2, \quad b_1 = 4 \ne 1 = b_2 \]

That comparison has already answered the question. Equal slopes mean the lines never turn towards each other, and different intercepts mean they were never in the same place to begin with.

Read the graph for the number of solutions

Why: the graphs are two parallel lines with no point of intersection, so no pair of numbers satisfies both equations: the system has no solution and is called inconsistent.

\[ \text{no } (x, y) \text{ satisfies both} \]

There is a direct way to see the contradiction without any graph at all, and it is the argument the book expects you to be able to give.

Verify that no solution can exist

Why: suppose a pair satisfied both equations; then the expression two x plus y would equal 4 and also equal 1, so 4 would equal 1, which is false. No such pair exists, which confirms the reading of the graph.

\[ 2x + y = 4 \;\text{and}\; 2x + y = 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; 4 = 1 \;\text{(false)} \]

Notice what kind of answer that is. Nothing was solved and no numbers were found, and yet the question is completely answered: there is no solution, and here is the proof.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 154 — Example 3

33. Guided Practice 5: complete the comparison

Fill the middle

This checkpoint looks exactly like Example 3 in disguise, with a subtraction between the terms instead of an addition. Do the comparison rather than the graph.

\[ \begin{cases} 3x - 2y = 10 \\ 3x - 2y = 2 \end{cases} \]

Fill in the blanks

y = \tfrac51x - ___ \qquad\text___\qquad y = \tfrac______x - ___

Why: Dividing negative two y equals negative three x plus 10 by negative 2 gives y equal to three halves x minus 5, and the same move on the second equation gives three halves x minus 1. The slopes match and the intercepts do not, so the lines are parallel, the system is inconsistent, and there is no solution to find.

Take care with the signs in that division. Every term is divided by negative 2, so negative three x becomes positive three halves x and positive 10 becomes negative 5.

Once both lines are written this way the verdict takes a second. Equal slopes, different intercepts, parallel, no solution, inconsistent, and not one point had to be plotted.

You can also argue it the way Example 3 ended. If a pair made three x minus two y equal 10 and also equal 2, then 10 would equal 2, so no pair does.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 155 — Guided Practice 5

34. Guided Practice 6: a parallel pair in two costumes

Worked example

Here the two equations are written in different forms, which hides the relationship completely until you rearrange. This is the checkpoint that separates people who compare forms from people who compare lines.

\[ \begin{cases} -2x + y = 5 & \text{Equation 1} \\ y = 2x + 2 & \text{Equation 2} \end{cases} \]

Rewrite Equation 1 with y alone

Why: add two x to both sides; Equation 2 is already in that form and needs nothing.

\[ -2x + y = 5 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = 2x + 5 \]

Now the two rows can be compared honestly. Both climb 2 for every 1 across, and their starting heights are 5 and 2, which is the parallel pattern from Example 3 in slightly better clothes.

Figure (svg): The lines minus two x plus y equals five and y equals two x plus two drawn on one grid, parallel and three apart, with no crossing anywhere.

One equation is dressed as a standard form and the other as a slope-intercept form, but both climb two for every one across.

Compare the slopes and intercepts

Why: equal slopes with unequal intercepts is exactly the parallel case, so the lines never meet.

\[ m_1 = m_2 = 2, \quad b_1 = 5 \ne 2 = b_2 \]

State the verdict

Why: parallel graphs share no point, so no pair satisfies both equations and the system is inconsistent.

\[ \text{no solution} \]

Before verifying that, notice how easily this system could have been misread. The first equation has a minus sign in front of its x term and the second has a plus, which looks like a difference between the two lines until you move the x term across and find the same slope of 2 on both.

Verify by trying to force a crossing

Why: set the two right-hand sides equal, as a crossing would require, and see what the algebra reports: the x terms cancel and leave a false statement, so no x can work.

\[ 2x + 5 = 2x + 2 \;\Longrightarrow\; 5 = 2 \;\text{(false)} \]

Compare this with the coincident case in Part 2, where the same move left 0 equals 0 and every x survived. One vanishing act says everything works; the other says nothing does.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 155 — Guided Practice 6

35. What does the algebra say when the lines are parallel?

Prediction

Pair this with the prediction you made in Part 2, because the two answers are the two halves of one idea and they are easy to swap by accident.

\[ \begin{cases} 3x - 2y = 10 \\ 3x - 2y = 2 \end{cases} \]

Predict first

Subtract the second equation from the first, term by term. What statement are you left with, and what does it tell you?

  • A statement like 0 = 8, which nothing can make true, so there is no solution
  • A statement like 0 = 0, which is always true, so there are infinitely many solutions
  • A single value of x, which gives the one solution
  • A statement with x still in it, so more work is needed

Correct: A statement like 0 = 8, which nothing can make true, so there is no solution

Why: Three x minus three x is zero, negative two y plus two y is zero, and 10 minus 2 is 8, so subtracting leaves zero equals 8. No pair of numbers can make that true, so no pair satisfies both equations, and the system is inconsistent. The vanishing of both letters is the signal; whether what is left is true or false is what separates infinitely many solutions from none.

\[ (3x - 2y) - (3x - 2y) = 10 - 2 \;\Longrightarrow\; 0 = 8 \]

Write the two outcomes side by side in your notes now. Both letters vanish and a true statement remains, so every pair on the line works; both letters vanish and a false statement remains, so nothing works.

Notice that the false statement is not a failure of your algebra. It is the system telling you honestly that the demand it makes cannot be met, which is a complete and correct answer to the question.

The graph says the same thing in its own language. Subtracting one equation from the other is the algebra of measuring the gap between the two lines, and a gap of 8 that does not depend on x is the picture from the last slide: two lines that keep their distance for ever.

36. Trap: equal slopes, so the same line

Trap

The trap

Asked to classify the system three x minus two y equals 10 with three x minus two y equals 2, a student writes this.

\[ y = \tfrac{3}{2}x - 5 \]

\[ y = \tfrac{3}{2}x - 1 \]

Then: the slopes are equal, so the lines are the same line, so there are infinitely many solutions.

The first half of that reasoning is correct, and the rearranging is correct too. Only the conclusion is wrong.

The fix

Equal slopes make the lines parallel. Being the same line needs equal slopes and the same intercept, and here the intercepts are negative 5 and negative 1.

\[ b_1 = -5 \ne -1 = b_2 \]

So the lines run alongside each other four apart and never meet. The system has no solution and is inconsistent, which is the opposite verdict to the one written.

The test has two parts, always. Ask about the slope, and then ask about the intercept, because the slope alone cannot tell the two parallel cases apart.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 155 — Guided Practice 5

37. Classifying a system

Section

Part 4

38. The three pictures, side by side

Picture it

Everything in the first three parts is in this one figure. Two straight lines drawn in the same plane have exactly three options, and each option answers the question how many solutions.

Figure (svg): Three small grids side by side. The first shows two lines crossing once, the second two parallel lines, the third one line with a dashed line lying on top of it.

Two straight lines in one plane can only do these three things, which is why a linear system has one solution, none, or endlessly many.

Look at the middle and right panels together, since those are the two people confuse. In the middle the lines are two, and they miss; on the right the lines are one, drawn twice, and everything about them matches.

The vocabulary underneath each panel is what the rest of this part unpacks. For now, notice that the words are attached to pictures, and that reading the picture is what tells you which words to use.

It is worth knowing that this is the complete list. There is no fourth arrangement of two straight lines, so a linear system has one solution, no solution, or infinitely many, and never, say, exactly two.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 154 — the Key Concept box on the number of solutions

39. Each equation is one piece of information

Intuition

Here is another way to see why exactly three things can happen, and it is the way that makes the three cases feel inevitable rather than memorised. Count what each equation tells you.

Before any equation is given, the pair of numbers you are looking for could be anywhere in the plane: two whole dimensions of possibilities. One equation cuts that down to a line, which is still endlessly many pairs but a much smaller collection.

\[ \text{plane} \;\xrightarrow{\;\text{first equation}\;}\; \text{line} \]

A second equation cuts the collection down again, and how far depends entirely on whether it says something new. If it does, the line is cut down to a single point, and that point is the solution.

\[ \text{line} \;\xrightarrow{\;\text{second equation}\;}\; \text{point, nothing, or the same line} \]

If the second equation says exactly what the first said, it cuts nothing away and the whole line survives: infinitely many solutions. If it contradicts the first, nothing at all survives: no solution.

So the three cases are new information, no new information, and contradictory information. Every system you meet for the rest of this chapter, including the three-variable systems of Lesson 3.4, falls into one of those three.

40. Two questions, four words

Concept

The textbook's vocabulary sounds heavier than it is, because it is really two yes-or-no questions asked in order. Ask the two questions in that order and the words fall out.

consistent — A system that has at least one solution. Its graphs meet somewhere.

inconsistent — A system that has no solution. Its graphs are parallel and never meet.

independent — A consistent system with exactly one solution. Its graphs cross at one point.

dependent — A consistent system with infinitely many solutions. Its graphs are the same line.

The first question is whether there is any solution at all: yes makes the system consistent, no makes it inconsistent, and an inconsistent system needs no second word.

The second question is asked only of a consistent system: exactly one solution makes it independent, and infinitely many make it dependent. So the three verdicts are consistent and independent, consistent and dependent, or inconsistent.

The word dependent is chosen well. When the second equation is a multiple of the first it depends on it entirely and adds no new information, which is precisely why the solutions do not narrow down to a point.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 154 — classifying systems

41. Reading the slope-intercept test

Notation

Once both equations are written with y alone, the classification is a comparison of four numbers and nothing more. Decode that comparison carefully, because it is the fastest tool in the lesson.

Annotate

On: \( y = m_1x + b_1 \qquad y = m_2x + b_2 \)

  • The two slopes. The subscripts are labels, not multipliers: m sub 1 means the slope of the first line. Comparing these two numbers is the first question you ask.
  • The lines tilt differently, so they close on each other and cross exactly once. One solution, consistent and independent, whatever the intercepts happen to be.
  • The lines tilt alike but start at different heights, so the gap between them is constant and never zero. No solution, inconsistent.
  • The two equations are the same rule, so one line is drawn twice and every point of it is a solution. Infinitely many solutions, consistent and dependent.

Notice that the second question is never worth asking until the first is answered. If the slopes already differ, the intercepts cannot change the verdict, and comparing them is wasted effort.

This test is exactly the challenge exercise at the end of the section, which asks for the conditions on the four constants in y equals a x plus b and y equals c x plus d. The answer is the three notes above with different letters.

One warning about using it. The test compares lines, not the equations you were handed, so both equations have to be rearranged first. Two rows that look unlike each other can still pass through the same points.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 157 — Exercise 34, the challenge on a, b, c and d

42. Complete the three-case table

Comparison

Put the three cases into one table so that the picture, the numbers and the words all sit in the same row. Fill in the missing column as you read across.

Comparison matrix

what the graphs doslopes and interceptshow many solutionsclassification
cross at one pointslopes differoneconsistent, independent
run parallelslopes equal, intercepts differnoneinconsistent
lie on top of each otherslopes equal, intercepts equalinfinitely manyconsistent, dependent

Read the middle column down and notice how little it takes to move between rows. Change one intercept in the third row and you are in the second; tilt one line slightly and you are in the first.

The last column has the only piece of pure vocabulary in the lesson. Everything else in the table is something you can see, which is why the picture is worth carrying around in your head as the name for each row.

Reading the rows the other way is also useful. Given the words consistent and dependent, you should be able to say at once that the graphs are one line and that there are infinitely many solutions.

OpenStax College Algebra 2e, §7.1 Systems of Linear Equations: Two Variables §7.1 — the same three cases, called independent, inconsistent and dependent

43. Classify three systems without drawing any of them

Worked example

Three systems from the exercise set, to be classified by comparing slopes and intercepts. The graph is not forbidden, it is simply no longer necessary.

\[ \begin{cases} y = 3x + 2 \\ y = 3x - 2 \end{cases} \qquad \begin{cases} -20x + 12y = -24 \\ 5x - 3y = 6 \end{cases} \qquad \begin{cases} 4x - 5y = 0 \\ 3x - 5y = -5 \end{cases} \]

Compare the first system

Why: both equations are already in slope-intercept form: equal slopes of 3, and intercepts 2 and negative 2, so the lines are parallel.

\[ m_1 = m_2 = 3, \quad b_1 = 2 \ne -2 = b_2 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{inconsistent} \]

Rewrite the second system

Why: divide the first equation by negative 4, or multiply the second by negative 4; either way the two rows become one equation.

\[ -20x + 12y = -24 \;\Longrightarrow\; 5x - 3y = 6 \]

Because the two equations are identical once scaled, the second system draws one line twice. Every point of that line is a solution, so it is consistent and dependent.

Rewrite the third system

Why: solve each equation for y and compare the coefficients of x.

\[ y = \tfrac{4}{5}x \qquad y = \tfrac{3}{5}x + 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; \tfrac{4}{5} \ne \tfrac{3}{5} \]

Different slopes, so the third system crosses exactly once and is consistent and independent. That verdict promises a solution, so it is fair to ask what the solution actually is.

Check the crossing of the third system in both equations

Why: subtracting the two original equations gives x equal to 5, and then four times 5 minus five y equals 0 gives y equal to 4; test the pair in both rows as printed.

\[ \begin{array}{ll} 4(5) - 5(4) = 20 - 20 = 0 \;\checkmark & 3(5) - 5(4) = 15 - 20 = -5 \;\checkmark \end{array} \]

Three systems, three verdicts, and only one of them needed a pair of numbers found. Knowing how many solutions there are is a real answer in its own right.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 156 — Exercises 19, 21 and 22

44. Match each system to its verdict

Matching

Four systems and four verdicts. Rearrange each system in your head, compare the slopes first and the intercepts second, then commit.

Match the pairs

  • a. y = 3x + 2 and y = 3x − 2
  • b. y = 3x + 2 and y = −3x + 2
  • c. 2x + 5y = 6 and 4x + 10y = 12
  • d. y = −1 and 3x + y = 5
  • w. inconsistent: no solution
  • x. consistent and dependent: infinitely many
  • y. consistent and independent, crossing at (0, 2)
  • z. consistent and independent, crossing at (2, −1)

Why: The pair with two slopes of 3 and different intercepts is parallel, so it has no solution. The pair with slopes 3 and negative 3 shares the intercept 2, so the lines cross on the vertical axis where x is 0 and y is 2. The pair in standard form is one equation doubled, so it draws one line and has infinitely many solutions. The system with a horizontal line forces y to be negative 1, and then three x minus 1 equals 5 gives x equal to 2.

The two systems built from slopes of 3 are worth comparing directly. Same slope with different intercepts gives no solution; different slopes with the same intercept gives one solution, at the shared intercept.

The horizontal line is easier than it looks. The equation y equals negative 1 is a perfectly good line, a flat one, and substituting its height into the other equation finds the crossing in a single step.

Check the two crossings if you have any doubt, because the classification is only half the claim. Three times 0 plus 2 is not 5, so the pair (0, 2) belongs to the other system, not to this one.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 156 — Exercises 17 to 24

45. Find the error: dependent reported as inconsistent

Error analysis

Below is a student's classification of a system, written out line by line. Both equations were rearranged and then the verdict inconsistent was written underneath. Every arithmetic step in it is correct, and the verdict is still wrong. Find the moment the reasoning slipped.

Annotate

On: \( \begin{array}{l} 2x + 5y = 6 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = -\tfrac{2}{5}x + \tfrac{6}{5} \\ 4x + 10y = 12 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = -\tfrac{2}{5}x + \tfrac{6}{5} \end{array} \)

  • Both equations were rearranged correctly. Dividing the first by 5 and the second by 10 really does give these two right-hand sides.
  • The two slopes are equal, both negative two fifths, and that was read straight off as parallel. Equal slopes are only half of the parallel test.
  • The intercepts are equal as well, both six fifths. Same slope and same intercept means one line, not two, so the graphs coincide.
  • Infinitely many solutions, and the system is consistent and dependent. Parallel would have needed equal slopes with different intercepts, and there is no difference here to find.

\[ y = -\tfrac{2}{5}x + \tfrac{6}{5} \quad\text{twice: one line} \]

This is the trap from Part 3 arriving from the other side. There a parallel pair was called one line; here one line is called a parallel pair, and both errors come from stopping after the slope.

The cure is a habit rather than a rule. Write both rearranged equations one above the other and compare them as whole expressions, not slope first and then maybe the rest.

A quick sanity test also catches it. Pick any x, say x equal to 3, and work out y from each equation: both give zero, so the lines have a point in common and cannot be parallel.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 156 — Exercise 24

46. Slide the second line and watch the verdict change

Tweak it

Here is the whole classification in one moving picture. The first line is fixed as y equals two x plus 1, and the slider controls the slope and the intercept of the second.

What is plotted is the difference between the two lines, that is, the second line's height minus the first line's height. Where that difference crosses zero, the two lines are at the same height, which is a crossing of the system.

Parameter explorer

Set the slope to 4 and find where the difference crosses zero. Then set the slope to 2 with the intercept at 4, and say what happened to the crossing. Finally set the slope to 2 and the intercept to 1.

\[ y = ({m} - 2)x + ({b} - 1) \]

  • m — from -2 to 6: slope of the second line
  • b — from -4 to 6: intercept of the second line

Watch what the slope slider does to the shape of the difference. Any slope other than 2 leaves a tilted line, and a tilted line crosses zero exactly once, which is the one-solution case however extreme the tilt.

Setting the slope to 2 flattens the difference completely, and from then on the intercept decides everything. A flat difference above or below zero is a gap that never closes, and a difference flat on zero is the same line twice.

This is worth remembering as a picture of why there are exactly three cases. A line either tilts or it does not, and a flat line either sits on zero or it does not.

47. Which claim about systems survives?

Two truths and a lie

Four claims, three of which are false in a way that gets written down in real work. Rule out the three and keep the one that holds up.

Eliminate the wrong options

Three of these claims are false. Which one is true of every linear system?

  • a. Two lines with the same slope have no point in common.
  • b. A pair that satisfies one equation of a system satisfies the system.
  • c. A system whose graphs are the same line has infinitely many solutions.
  • d. Every system of two linear equations has exactly one solution.

Survives elimination: c

Why: If the two graphs are the same line, then every point of that line lies on both graphs and so satisfies both equations, which is infinitely many solutions. The three false claims are the three standard slips: treating equal slopes as proof of no crossing, treating one satisfied equation as enough, and assuming a system always has a single answer.

The claim about equal slopes is the one to sit with, because it is nearly true and its exception is a whole case of the classification. Equal slopes and different intercepts give no common point; equal slopes and equal intercepts give all of them.

The claim about satisfying one equation is the trap from Part 1 in a single sentence. If you can explain why it is false by counting how many pairs lie on one line, the idea has landed.

The last claim is the honest instinct of anyone who has only seen crossing lines, and the figure with three panels is its refutation. Two of the three panels have no single crossing point at all.

48. Modelling with a system

Section

Part 5

49. Two plans, two equations, one crossing

Concept

Systems earn their keep on comparisons. Whenever two options charge differently for the same thing, each option is an equation and the crossing point is where they cost the same.

The pattern is always the same three sentences. Say what x counts and what y measures, write one equation per option, then find where the two lines meet.

\[ y = (\text{rate})x + (\text{fixed fee}) \]

The fixed fee is where the line starts and the rate is how steeply it climbs. An option with a high fee and a low rate starts above a cheap-to-join option and rises more slowly, which is exactly the arrangement that produces a crossing.

Interpreting that crossing is the part worth practising. It is not the answer to which plan is better, it is the boundary between two answers, with one plan cheaper on the left of it and the other cheaper on the right.

One detail of graphing changes in these problems. Negative numbers of rides and negative costs mean nothing, so only the first quadrant is drawn, and both lines are cut off where the meaning stops.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 155 — Example 4 and its verbal model

50. Example 4: the monthly pass or pay per ride

Worked example

You ride an express bus home. Option A is a monthly pass costing 25 dollars plus 75 cents a ride. Option B is 2 dollars a ride and nothing up front. After how many rides do the two options cost the same?

Name the letters and write Option A

Why: let x be the number of rides and y the total cost in dollars; the cost per ride multiplies x, and the monthly fee is added once.

\[ y = 0.75x + 25 \]

Write Option B

Why: no fee, so the total is just the per-ride cost times the number of rides.

\[ y = 2x \]

Check the two equations against the story before going on. At zero rides Option A already costs 25 dollars and Option B costs nothing, which is right, and Option B climbs faster, at 2 dollars a ride against 75 cents.

Figure (svg): A first-quadrant graph of total cost against number of rides, showing the pass line starting at twenty-five dollars and the pay-per-ride line through the origin, crossing at twenty rides and forty dollars.

Cost in dollars up the side, rides along the bottom. The pass starts higher and climbs more slowly, so the lines have to meet.

Read the crossing off the graph

Why: the lines meet where x is 20 and y is 40, and only the first quadrant was drawn because a negative number of rides has no meaning.

\[ (x, y) = (20, 40) \]

Check the pair in both equations

Why: twenty rides on the pass costs 15 dollars of fares plus the 25 dollar fee, and twenty rides at 2 dollars each is also 40 dollars, so both equations are satisfied and the total costs are equal after 20 rides.

\[ \begin{array}{ll} 0.75(20) + 25 = 15 + 25 = 40 \;\checkmark & 2(20) = 40 \;\checkmark \end{array} \]

The book asks this as a multiple-choice question with 10, 20, 24 and 28 rides offered. Testing your own answer in both equations is better than testing all four offers, and it is the same work you would do anyway.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 155 — Example 4

51. Which option wins, on each side of the crossing

Intuition

The crossing answers the question the book asked, but not the question a passenger actually has. Nobody wants to know when the options tie; they want to know which one to buy.

Figure (svg): The same two cost lines with the region between them shaded: orange to the left of twenty rides where paying per ride is cheaper, green to the right where the pass is cheaper.

The crossing is not the answer to a money question on its own; it is the boundary between two answers.

The shading splits the picture at 20 rides. To the left the pay-per-ride line is lower, so paying each time is cheaper; to the right the pass line is lower, and the pass is cheaper.

So the practical answer is a rule, not a number. Ride fewer than 20 times a month and pay per ride; ride more than 20 times and buy the pass; ride exactly 20 and it makes no difference to your money.

This is why a crossing point is worth so much more than the arithmetic that found it. One point on a graph has divided every possible month into two kinds, and told you what to do in each.

52. Guided Practice 7: the pass rises to 36 dollars

Worked example

Same two options, one number changed: the monthly pass now costs 36 dollars instead of 25. The checkpoint asks how that affects the answer, and the interesting part is that the answer stops being a whole number.

\[ \begin{cases} y = 0.75x + 36 & \text{the new pass} \\ y = 2x & \text{pay per ride} \end{cases} \]

Set the two costs equal

Why: the crossing is where the two expressions for y agree, so putting them equal finds its x.

\[ 2x = 0.75x + 36 \]

Collect the x terms

Why: subtract three quarters of x from both sides; two minus nought point seven five is one and a quarter.

\[ 1.25x = 36 \]

Divide by 1.25

Why: this is the number of rides at which the two plans cost the same.

\[ x = \dfrac{36}{1.25} = 28.8 \]

Figure (svg): The same comparison with the monthly pass raised to thirty-six dollars, so the two lines now cross at twenty-eight point eight rides.

Raising the fee lifts the pass line without tilting it, so the crossing slides to the right: you need more rides to break even.

Notice what raising the fee did to the picture. The pass line lifted without tilting, so the crossing slid to the right: a dearer pass takes more rides to pay for itself.

It is worth doing this one algebraically rather than by reading the graph, and the reason is Part 1's honesty point. The crossing is at 28.8 rides, which no grid ruled in whole rides could report, so the picture would have told you between 28 and 29 and nothing more exact.

Check the crossing and then interpret it

Why: at 28.8 rides both plans cost 57.60 dollars, so the arithmetic is right; but you cannot take 28.8 rides, so read the rule instead. Up to 28 rides paying per ride is cheaper, and from 29 rides on the pass wins.

\[ \begin{array}{ll} 0.75(28.8) + 36 = 21.6 + 36 = 57.6 \;\checkmark & 2(28.8) = 57.6 \;\checkmark \end{array} \]

Compare that with the 20 rides of Example 4 and you have the effect of the fee in one sentence: eleven dollars more up front costs you nearly nine more rides before the pass starts saving you money.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 155 — Guided Practice 7

53. Exercise 37: the gym membership plans

Real world

Now build the system yourself. A gym offers two plans: Option A charges a 121 dollar joining fee and 1 dollar a day, and Option B charges nothing to join and 12 dollars a day.

Discussion prompt

Write an equation for the total cost of each plan, find the number of days at which the two costs are equal, and check your answer in both equations. Then say how the answer would change if Option B's daily charge rose, and why.

The check is the step to insist on here, even though the numbers are easy. Both plans have to reach 132 dollars at 11 days, and seeing that they do is what confirms you solved the right system.

The follow-up question about a steeper Option B is the interesting half. A rate change tilts a line, while a fee change lifts it, and the two have different effects on where the crossing lands.

Notice how similar this is to the bus problem with completely different numbers. One plan with a fee and a small rate, one with no fee and a large rate, and a crossing that tells you which to pick.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 157 — Exercise 37

54. Before you graph a word problem

Step zero

Word problems go wrong before any line is drawn, in the decisions you make while setting up. Slow down and take them deliberately.

Discussion prompt

You worked 14 hours last week at two jobs and earned 96 dollars in total. Lifeguarding pays 8 dollars an hour and the cashier job pays 6 dollars an hour. Before solving anything, write down what each letter stands for, what each equation is counting, and what part of the plane you should draw.

The habit to take from this is the units check. Eight dollars an hour times x hours gives dollars, which can be added to six dollars an hour times y hours, and 96 dollars is the same kind of thing; an equation mixing hours and dollars would be wrong before you started.

Naming the letters in writing matters more than it seems. Half the wrong answers to this problem are right answers to the same question with x and y swapped, and a written definition is what protects you from that.

Deciding on the quadrant early also saves work. Both hours are between 0 and 14, so you need a small piece of the first quadrant, and the scale can be chosen once rather than adjusted three times.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 157 — Exercise 35

55. Exercise 35: fourteen hours and ninety-six dollars

Worked example

Now solve the system you set up. Two jobs, 14 hours in total, 96 dollars earned, at 8 dollars and 6 dollars an hour. How many hours went to each job?

\[ \begin{cases} x + y = 14 & \text{hours} \\ 8x + 6y = 96 & \text{dollars} \end{cases} \]

Solve the hours equation for y

Why: with y alone it can be graphed, and it says what every possible split of 14 hours looks like.

\[ y = -x + 14 \]

Solve the money equation for y

Why: subtract the x term, then divide every term by 6 and reduce the fraction.

\[ 6y = -8x + 96 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = -\tfrac{4}{3}x + 16 \]

The two slopes are negative 1 and negative four thirds, so the lines fall at different rates and must cross once. That crossing is the only split of the 14 hours that also earns exactly 96 dollars.

Figure (svg): Two lines on a first-quadrant grid of cashier hours against lifeguard hours: the total hours line and the total pay line, crossing at six lifeguard hours and eight cashier hours.

One line holds every way to work fourteen hours, the other every way to earn ninety-six dollars. Only their crossing does both.

Read the crossing off the graph

Why: the lines meet where x is 6 and y is 8, so 6 hours lifeguarding and 8 hours at the till.

\[ (x, y) = (6, 8) \]

Read the units back into the answer at once, because a bare pair of numbers is not an answer to the question that was asked. Six is a number of lifeguarding hours and eight is a number of cashier hours, and saying which is which is the difference between a right answer and a reversed one.

Check the pair in both original equations

Why: six hours plus eight hours is the 14 hours worked, and 48 dollars plus 48 dollars is the 96 dollars earned, so both equations are satisfied.

\[ \begin{array}{ll} 6 + 8 = 14 \;\checkmark & 8(6) + 6(8) = 48 + 48 = 96 \;\checkmark \end{array} \]

Sanity-check the answer against the story as well. Fourteen hours all at the lower rate would pay 84 dollars and all at the higher rate 112, so 96 has to come from a mixture, which is what the crossing found.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 157 — Exercise 35

56. Exercise 38: the refrigerator that never pays back

Worked example

Two refrigerators. Model A costs 600 dollars and 50 dollars a year to run; model B costs 1200 dollars and 40 dollars a year. After how many years do they cost the same to own, and is that answer any use?

Write the total cost of each model

Why: the purchase price is paid once and the running cost is paid every year, so each total is a fee plus a rate times the number of years.

\[ y = 600 + 50x \qquad y = 1200 + 40x \]

Set the two totals equal

Why: the costs are the same where the two lines meet, so put the expressions equal and collect.

\[ 600 + 50x = 1200 + 40x \;\Longrightarrow\; 10x = 600 \]

Divide by 10

Why: this is the number of years at which the two totals agree.

\[ x = 60 \]

Figure (svg): Two rising cost lines against years of ownership: the cheaper refrigerator starting at six hundred dollars and climbing faster, the dearer one starting at twelve hundred, crossing at sixty years.

The crossing is real arithmetic and useless advice: no refrigerator runs for sixty years, so the cheaper one wins in practice.

The graph shows how slowly this crossing arrives. The cheaper fridge stays ahead for decades, and the two lines close on each other at only 10 dollars a year.

Check the crossing, then judge whether it means anything

Why: at 60 years both models have cost 3600 dollars, so the arithmetic is right; but no refrigerator lasts 60 years, so within any realistic lifetime the cheaper model wins and the crossing never happens.

\[ \begin{array}{l} 600 + 50(60) = 600 + 3000 = 3600 \;\checkmark \\ 1200 + 40(60) = 1200 + 2400 = 3600 \;\checkmark \end{array} \]

This is the most valuable answer in Part 5. A model can be solved perfectly and still give advice you should refuse, and noticing that is part of the mathematics rather than an afterthought. Ten years in, the cheaper model has cost 1100 dollars and the dearer one 1600, and that gap of 500 dollars has only narrowed to 350 dollars by twenty-five years.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 157 — Exercise 38, checking reasonableness

57. When can two plans never cost the same?

Edge cases

Every comparison so far had a crossing. Push on the setting until the crossing disappears, because the case with no solution has a plain meaning in money.

Discussion prompt

Two phone plans charge a monthly fee plus a fixed price per gigabyte. Describe the one arrangement of fees and rates for which the two plans never cost the same, and then describe the arrangement in which they always cost the same. Say what each one looks like on the graph.

So the inconsistent case is not an oddity of textbook algebra. It is the everyday situation of one plan simply being a fixed amount dearer than another, with nothing you can do to catch up.

And notice what has to be true for a crossing to exist at all: the two rates must differ. Whichever plan charges less per gigabyte will eventually be cheaper, however large its fee, because a steeper line always catches a flatter one in the end.

That last sentence is Part 1's one-crossing argument in the language of money. Different slopes cross exactly once, so a cheaper rate always wins eventually, and the crossing is where eventually begins.

58. Exercise 39: will the women's times catch the men's?

Real world

Here is a system that comes from measurements rather than from prices. The table gives the winning Olympic 100 metre freestyle times from 1972 to 2000, in seconds, with x counting years since 1972.

years since 19720481216202428
men's time51.250.050.449.848.649.048.748.3
women's time58.655.754.855.954.954.654.453.8

A line of best fit through each set of points gives a system of two equations. Both lines fall, because both sets of times are improving, and the women's line falls faster.

\[ m \approx -0.0958x + 50.84 \qquad w \approx -0.1241x + 57.08 \]

Figure (svg): Two panels of Olympic hundred metre freestyle times. On the left the eight men's and eight women's data points with a fitted line through each; on the right the same two lines extended for two hundred and fifty years until they finally cross.

Two lines with different slopes must cross somewhere. Whether the crossing means anything is a separate question, and here it does not.

Discussion prompt

The two fitted lines have different slopes, so they must cross. Find roughly when, and then say whether the prediction is worth believing. Give a reason that comes from the graph rather than from the arithmetic.

This is a system with a genuine solution and no meaning, which is a different fault from the refrigerator. There the crossing was real but unreachable; here the lines themselves stop describing anything long before they meet.

It is still a fair question and the graph still earns its place. What the left panel really shows is that the gap has narrowed, and that is a claim the data does support.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 158 — Exercise 39, the Olympic freestyle data

59. Putting it together

Section

Part 6

60. The procedure, in order

Pattern

Everything in this lesson is one routine with one decision inside it. The decision is what the two rearranged equations have in common, and the routine is what you do before and after deciding.

Figure (svg): A decision tree. From a box saying write both equations with y alone, one branch asks whether the slopes are equal; the no branch ends in one solution, and the yes branch asks about the intercepts, ending in infinitely many or none.

Three questions, three verdicts, and no graph paper required. The graph is still what makes each verdict make sense.

The tree only asks two questions, and the second one is asked only when the first answer is yes. If the slopes already differ you are finished deciding, and the work left is finding and checking the crossing.

  1. Rewrite both equations with y alone. Standard form hides the comparison; slope-intercept form shows it.
  2. Compare the slopes. Different slopes mean one crossing, so go and find it.
  3. If the slopes match, compare the intercepts. Different intercepts mean parallel lines and no solution; identical intercepts mean one line and infinitely many.
  4. Graph both lines and read the crossing, remembering that a reading between grid lines is an estimate.
  5. Substitute the pair into BOTH original equations. One tick is not a check, and the original equations are what the pair has to satisfy.
  6. In a word problem, interpret the crossing, in the units of the story, and ask whether the answer is reasonable.

The fifth line is the one this lesson has argued for hardest, and it is the one most often skipped. It costs two substitutions and it is the only step that can catch a misread graph.

The sixth line is what turns an answer into an answer to the question asked. Twenty is a number; twenty rides, after which the pass becomes the cheaper option, is a result.

61. Put the five moves in order

Ranking

The order of these moves matters, because each one needs the last one's output. Arrange them as you would actually carry them out on a fresh system.

Put in order

Put these five moves into the order you would carry them out.

  1. Rewrite both equations with y by itself
  2. Compare the slopes, and the intercepts if the slopes match
  3. Draw both lines on one grid
  4. Read the coordinates of the crossing point
  5. Substitute the pair into both original equations

Why: Rearranging comes first, because nothing can be compared or plotted until y is alone. Comparing the slopes and intercepts comes next, since it tells you whether there is a crossing to look for at all. Then you draw, then you read off the crossing, and the substitution into both original equations comes last, because it is the only step that can confirm what the reading claimed.

The comparison step is the one people leave out, and leaving it out costs time rather than marks. A minute spent comparing slopes can tell you there is no crossing before you carefully draw two lines looking for one.

Notice that substituting is last for a reason. It tests a specific pair of numbers, so it cannot happen until you have a pair, and it tests them against the equations as printed rather than against your own rearranging.

Two of these five moves can be skipped in the right circumstances, and it is worth knowing which. If the comparison tells you the lines are parallel or the same, there is no crossing to draw or read, so the drawing and the reading fall away and the comparison has answered the whole question by itself.

62. Check: which pair solves both equations

Check

Four pairs and one system. Do not try to solve it: test the pairs, and remember that a pair has to pass both equations rather than one.

Check your understanding

What is the solution of the system −4x − y = 2 and 7x + 2y = −5?

  • A. (2, −6)
  • B. (−1, 6)
  • C. (1, −6) (correct)
  • D. (−3, 8)

Answer: C

Why: For the pair where x is 1 and y is negative 6: negative four minus negative six is 2, so the first equation holds, and 7 minus 12 is negative 5, so the second holds too. That is the only pair that passes both tests, so it is the solution of the system.

Why A tempts people
Negative eight plus six is negative 2, not 2, so this pair fails the first equation immediately and there is no need to try the second.
Why B tempts people
Four minus six is negative 2 rather than 2, so the first equation fails; the y value is right in size but wrong in sign.
Why D tempts people
Twelve minus eight is 4, not 2, so this pair lies on neither line and fails both equations.

Three of the four pairs fail the very first equation, which makes the arithmetic short. Test the simpler equation first and most wrong options fall out in one line.

The pair with the right numbers and the wrong signs is the one to look at twice, since swapping a sign is the commonest slip in this kind of test. Work out negative four times x and then subtract y, carefully, rather than guessing at the combination.

Notice that the question could also be answered by solving the system, and that testing is much faster. When a question hands you candidate answers, substituting is usually the quickest honest route.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 156 — Exercise 15

63. Check: classify this system from the equations alone

Check

No graph and no solution needed here, just the two questions from the tree: are the slopes equal, and if so, are the intercepts equal too?

Check your understanding

Classify the system 3x − 2y = 10 and 3x − 2y = 2.

  • A. consistent and independent
  • B. consistent and dependent
  • C. inconsistent (correct)
  • D. none of these

Answer: C

Why: Rearranged, the two equations are y equal to three halves x minus 5 and y equal to three halves x minus 1. The slopes are equal and the intercepts are not, so the lines are parallel, no pair satisfies both equations, and a system with no solution is called inconsistent.

Why A tempts people
Consistent and independent means the lines cross at exactly one point, which needs different slopes. Both of these lines have slope three halves.
Why B tempts people
Consistent and dependent means the two equations describe the same line, which would need the intercepts to match as well. Here they are negative 5 and negative 1.
Why D tempts people
One of the three standard verdicts does apply. Two lines in a plane cross once, run parallel, or coincide, and parallel is the case here.

The quickest argument is the one that does not rearrange at all. The expression three x minus two y cannot equal 10 and 2 at the same time, so no pair of numbers can satisfy both rows.

Keep the difference between the two consistent verdicts sharp, because the wrong one of them is the likelier mistake. Dependent needs the whole equation to be a multiple of the other, constant and all.

It is worth noticing what you were not asked for. Nobody wanted a solution, and there is none to give; how many solutions there are is a complete answer in itself.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 156 — Exercises 17 to 28

64. Check: reading a crossing in context

Check

A modelling question, so there are two steps: write the two equations, then find and interpret the crossing. Watch which number is the fee and which is the rate.

Check your understanding

A climbing gym charges 30 dollars a month plus 2 dollars a visit. A second gym charges nothing monthly and 5 dollars a visit. After how many visits in a month do the two cost the same?

  • A. 6 visits
  • B. 10 visits (correct)
  • C. 15 visits
  • D. 30 visits

Answer: B

Why: The two costs are 30 plus 2 times the visits, and 5 times the visits. Setting them equal gives 3 times the visits equal to 30, so the number of visits is 10, and both plans then cost 50 dollars. Below 10 visits the pay-per-visit gym is cheaper, and above 10 the monthly fee has paid for itself.

Why A tempts people
This divides the 30 dollar fee by the 5 dollar rate, which ignores the 2 dollars a visit the first gym also charges, so it crosses too early.
Why C tempts people
This divides the fee by the 2 dollar rate and forgets the second gym entirely; at 15 visits the plans cost 60 and 75 dollars, which are not equal.
Why D tempts people
This is the monthly fee read as a number of visits. At 30 visits the plans cost 90 and 150 dollars, which is nowhere near equal.

The two wrong answers built by dividing 30 by one of the rates are worth examining, because each uses one real number from the problem and ignores another. A crossing depends on both rates, never on one of them.

Check the winner in both equations the way Part 5 insisted. Thirty plus two times ten is 50, and five times ten is 50, so the two plans really do agree at ten visits.

Then say what the number means. Ten visits is the break-even point, so a month with fewer visits is cheaper at the second gym, and a busier month is cheaper on the monthly plan.

65. Explain all three outcomes in your own words

Explain it to yourself

One last piece of writing, and it is the one that shows whether the lesson has landed. Do it before reading the answer, and do it in sentences rather than in labels.

Discussion prompt

Explain, without naming any of the four classification words, why a system of two linear equations can have exactly one solution, no solution, or infinitely many, and why no other number of solutions is possible. Then say how you would tell the three cases apart from the equations alone.

If your explanation used the word parallel without saying what parallel does to the gap between the lines, add that sentence. The gap that never closes is the reason, and parallel is only its name.

The remark about two points is worth keeping. It is the reason the list of cases is complete rather than merely long, and it is a fact about straight lines that you will use again in geometry.

Try the last part of your answer on a system you have not seen: four x minus y equals 1 together with eight x minus two y equals 3. Rearranged they are y equal to four x minus 1 and y equal to four x minus three halves, so the numbers in front of x agree and the constants do not, and your own rule reports no solution.

66. Exit ticket

Exit ticket

One system, and three things to do with it: solve it, classify it, and check it. Use the order from the pattern slide.

\[ \begin{cases} 4x + 5y = 3 \\ 6x + 9y = 9 \end{cases} \]

Discussion prompt

Decide how many solutions this system has by comparing slopes, then find the solution if there is one, check it in both original equations, and classify the system.

Compare the slopes before you hunt for the crossing, even when you are confident there is one. It takes one line of work and it tells you whether the hunt is worth starting.

If you read this crossing off a graph, notice that both coordinates are whole numbers, which is the friendly case from Part 1. A grid ruled in units can be trusted to find it exactly.

Then do both substitutions. Negative twelve plus fifteen is 3 and negative eighteen plus twenty-seven is 9, and it is those two lines, not the graph, that let you say you have the solution.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing §3.1, p. 156 — Exercise 24

67. What you can do now

Recap

A system asks two questions of one pair of numbers, and its graph turns that into a question about two lines. Everything in this lesson came from taking that picture seriously.

what the graphs dohow many solutionsthe two wordsexample from this lesson
cross at one pointexactly oneconsistent, independent4x + y = 8 with 2x − 3y = 18
lie on top of each otherinfinitely manyconsistent, dependent4x − 3y = 8 with 8x − 6y = 16
run parallelnoneinconsistent2x + y = 4 with 2x + y = 1

To decide which row you are in, write both equations with y alone and compare. Different slopes put you in the first row; equal slopes send you to the intercepts, which separate the other two.

\[ \begin{cases} 4x + y = 8 \\ 2x - 3y = 18 \end{cases} \;\Longrightarrow\; (3, -4): \; 4(3) + (-4) = 8, \; 2(3) - 3(-4) = 18 \]

The line above is the habit to keep: a pair, and both substitutions done. Checking in one equation tells you the point is on one line, which every point of that line already manages.

Keep the honest limitation in view as well. A crossing read off a grid is only as exact as the grid, and the system whose solution had 21 underneath could not be read off graph paper at all.

That is exactly what Lesson 3.2 is for. Substitution and elimination find the crossing with algebra instead of eyesight, and you will recognise their answers of 0 equals 0 and 0 equals 3 as the coincident and parallel cases you met here.

OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §11.1 Systems of Linear Equations: Two Variables §11.1 — the same three cases, with the crossing found algebraically

Sources

  1. McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 3 Linear Systems and Matrices — Lesson 3.1 Solve Linear Systems by Graphing — Larson, Boswell, Kanold & Stiff, McDougal Littell / Houghton Mifflin, 2007, pp. 153-159
  2. OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §11.1 Systems of Linear Equations: Two Variables
  3. OpenStax College Algebra 2e, §7.1 Systems of Linear Equations: Two Variables

Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Algebra 2 — $55/session, free consultation.

Book on Wyzant · Text (657) 465-8108