2.8 Linear Inequalities in Two Variables

Solutions of a linear inequality in two variables, boundary lines and half-planes, dashed against solid boundaries, the two-step graphing procedure with a test point, one-variable inequalities graphed in the plane, and modelling a real constraint as a shaded region.

Subject: Algebra 2 · 71 slides · symbolic lesson

Open the interactive version of this deck

What this lesson covers

The lesson, slide by slide

1. Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables

Title

Algebra 2 · Lesson 2.8

One line, two halves, and one substitution that decides which half you want

2. What this lesson gives you

Objectives

Lesson 1.6 solved inequalities in one variable and shaded a ray on a number line. This lesson keeps every one of those ideas and hands you a second variable, which turns the ray into half of the plane.

The answer to an inequality in two variables is not a point and not a line: it is an area, containing infinitely many pairs of numbers. Your job is to draw the edge of that area and then decide which side of the edge you want.

Two decisions appear on every single graph in this lesson, and they are independent of each other. The symbol decides whether the edge is dashed or solid. One substitution decides which side gets shaded. Keep them separate and nothing here is hard.

The second decision is where almost all the marks go missing, because there is a tempting shortcut that works often enough to feel like a rule and then fails. You will meet it, watch it fail, and get a method that never does.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 132 — Before, Now, Why and the Key Vocabulary

3. What you already have from Lesson 1.6

Warm-up

Start with something you can already do. In one variable, the solutions of an inequality were a stretch of the number line, with an open circle where the endpoint was excluded and a filled one where it was included.

\[ x < 2 \]

Discussion prompt

On a number line, this shaded everything to the left of an open circle at 2. Now suppose y is allowed to vary as well. Which points of the coordinate plane satisfy it? Describe the shape, and say what happened to the open circle.

Figure (svg): Two panels. On the left a number line from minus one to five with everything left of an open circle at two drawn thick. On the right a coordinate plane with a dashed vertical line at x equals two and the whole strip to its left shaded.

The same inequality, read first in one dimension and then in two. Adding a second variable turns the ray into a strip: y may be anything at all.

Compare the two panels carefully. The inequality did not change at all; only the number of variables in play did. The endpoint became an edge, and the ray became a region.

That is the whole lesson in one picture, and everything that follows is about drawing the edge correctly and choosing the right side of it. The arithmetic you use to choose the side is arithmetic you already own.

One more thing to notice before moving on: the shaded strip has no top and no bottom. Regions in this lesson are almost always infinite, so you can never check them by listing their points.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §1.6 — the one-variable inequalities this builds on

4. Testing an ordered pair

Section

Part 1

5. Four forms, and one definition of a solution

Concept

A linear inequality in two variables looks exactly like a linear equation with the equals sign swapped for one of four symbols. Nothing about the left-hand side changes, which is why everything you know about lines still applies.

\[ Ax + By < C, \qquad Ax + By \le C, \qquad Ax + By > C, \qquad Ax + By \ge C \]

solution of a linear inequality — An ordered pair (x, y) that makes the inequality true when its two values are substituted for x and y.

Read that definition again and notice how little it asks. There is no graphing in it, no rearranging and no shading. You substitute two numbers, work out one value, and compare it with C. The statement is either true or false, and that is the verdict.

\[ 2x + 5y > 9 \quad \text{at } (-2, 3): \; 2(-2) + 5(3) = 11 > 9 \]

So eleven is greater than nine, the statement is true, and the pair is a solution. Testing a pair is the cheapest thing in this lesson, and it is worth doing whenever you are unsure of anything later on.

Because there is no rearranging in the definition, it does not matter what shape the inequality is written in. The four forms above, and anything that can be rearranged into them, are all tested the same way.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 132 — the four forms and the definition of a solution

6. An answer you cannot write out as a list

Intuition

One thing about this lesson is genuinely new, and it is worth naming before the method starts. The answer to an inequality in two variables is not a number, not a pair of numbers, and not something you could finish writing down.

\[ 2x + 5y > 9 \]

Try to list its solutions. The pair minus two and three works. So does the pair minus two and three point one, and the pair minus two and three point zero one, and every pair between them. One value of x already brings infinitely many partners with it.

That is why the answer has to be a picture. A shaded region is not a rough summary of the solution set: it is the only practical way to write down infinitely many pairs at once, and every point of the shading is a genuine solution.

It also explains the shape of the work ahead. You can never check an answer by listing it, so you check it by testing a point or two, which is exactly what the procedure will be built out of.

Keep one habit from Lesson 2.3 as you go. A line was also infinitely many pairs, and you drew it from two points and a rule rather than from a list. A region works the same way: an edge, and a decision about which side.

7. Reading the general form piece by piece

Notation

Before using the general form, take it apart. The letters divide into two quite different jobs, and confusing them is what makes a student substitute into the wrong place.

Annotate

On: \( Ax + By \le C \)

  • The two variables. These are the things you substitute numbers into, and a solution is a pair of values for them, always written x first.
  • Fixed coefficients, already known. They never change while you work on one inequality, so they are just numbers wearing letters.
  • The number the left-hand side is being compared with. Work out the left side, then look at C and ask whether the comparison holds.
  • Here it allows equality, so a pair that makes the two sides exactly equal is a solution. That single fact is what will be drawn as a solid rather than a dashed edge.

The order of work follows the order of those notes. Put your two numbers in for x and y, let the coefficients do their multiplying, add, and only then compare with C.

Notice that the symbol comes last in the reading and last in the work. Many wrong answers come from looking at the symbol first, forming an expectation about the picture, and then bending the arithmetic to fit it.

One practical point about the general form: it does not have y by itself, and it does not need to. You will spend most of this lesson leaving inequalities exactly as the question wrote them.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 132 — the general forms of a linear inequality

8. Example 1: which of four pairs satisfies 2x plus 5y greater than 9

Worked example

This is a multiple-choice question from the book, and the fastest route through it is not a graph. Test the candidates one at a time and stop worrying about what the region looks like.

\[ 2x + 5y > 9 \]

Test the first pair

Why: substitute minus four for x and minus one for y; two lots of minus four is minus eight, and five lots of minus one is minus five.

\[ 2(-4) + 5(-1) = -8 - 5 = -13 \]

Minus thirteen is nowhere near greater than nine, so that pair fails. Notice that both coordinates were negative and both terms came out negative, which is worth a glance before you compute anything.

Test the second pair

Why: substitute minus two and three; minus four plus fifteen leaves eleven.

\[ 2(-2) + 5(3) = -4 + 15 = 11 > 9 \]

Eleven is greater than nine, so this pair is a solution. In a multiple-choice question you could stop here, but test the rest anyway: it costs two lines and it confirms you have not misread a sign.

Test the third pair

Why: substitute two and minus four; four minus twenty is minus sixteen.

\[ 2(2) + 5(-4) = 4 - 20 = -16 \]

Test the fourth pair

Why: substitute six and minus one; twelve minus five is seven.

\[ 2(6) + 5(-1) = 12 - 5 = 7 \]

Seven is the interesting failure. It is close to nine, but close does not count: the pair sits just on the wrong side of the edge, and the arithmetic says so without any drawing.

Figure (svg): The line two x plus five y equals nine drawn dashed, with the region above it shaded, and the four candidate points plotted: three below the line marked no and one above it marked yes.

Only one of the four candidates sits in the shaded region, and the arithmetic said so before the graph was drawn. The picture is a check, not the method.

Check the answer against the picture

Why: the winning pair is the only one of the four in the shaded region, and the near miss at six and minus one sits just below the boundary, exactly as its value of seven predicted.

\[ (-2, 3) \text{ is the solution} \]

The graph is drawn here to confirm the arithmetic, not to replace it. When a question gives you candidate pairs, substituting is always quicker and always safer than sketching.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 132 — Example 1

9. Guided Practice 1 to 4: sort the pairs

Sorting

Now test four pairs against one inequality, and add the origin as a fifth. Work each one out on paper before you place it, because the whole point is that substitution is quick enough to do every time.

Sort into buckets

Sort each ordered pair by whether it satisfies 5x − 2y ≤ 6.

A solution
(2, 2); (−3, 8); (0, 0)
Not a solution
(0, −4); (−1, −7)
yes
The middle pair gives exactly 6, which is allowed because the symbol includes equality; the pair with 8 in it gives −31, and the origin gives 0, both comfortably under 6.
no
The pair with minus four gives 8, and the pair of negatives gives 9. Subtracting a negative y adds, so both of these came out larger than you might expect.

Two of these deserve a second look. Wherever y is negative, the term with minus two in front of it turns positive and pushes the value up, which is how a pair of small negative numbers produced nine.

The origin is in the list for a reason that will matter for the rest of the lesson. It is the easiest substitution in mathematics, because every term vanishes and you are left comparing zero with C.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 132 — Guided Practice 1 to 4

10. Guided Practice 2: the pair that lands exactly on the edge

Worked example

One of those five pairs is worth a full worked example, because it sits precisely on the boundary and that is where the lesson's first trap lives.

\[ 5x - 2y \le 6 \quad \text{at } (2, 2) \]

Substitute both coordinates

Why: five lots of two is ten, and two lots of two is four, which is being subtracted.

\[ 5(2) - 2(2) = 10 - 4 = 6 \]

Compare the result with 6

Why: the symbol allows equality, so a result of exactly six satisfies the inequality.

\[ 6 \le 6 \quad \text{true} \]

So this pair is a solution, and it is a solution by the narrowest possible margin. Any pair that gives exactly C is on the edge of the region rather than inside it.

Now change one character and watch the answer flip. If the symbol had been strictly less than, six would not be less than six, and this same pair would fail.

\[ 5x - 2y < 6 \quad \text{at } (2, 2): \; 6 < 6 \quad \text{false} \]

Check what this means for the drawing

Why: a pair that gives exactly C lies on the boundary line, so whether such pairs count is precisely the question a dashed or solid edge answers.

\[ 5x - 2y = 6 \quad \text{at } (2, 2): \; 6 = 6 \]

Hold on to that connection. The dash you are about to meet is not a decoration: it is the graph's way of recording whether pairs like this one are in or out.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 132 — Guided Practice 2

11. Trap: substituting only one coordinate

Trap

The trap

Testing whether the pair with minus one and minus seven satisfies the inequality, here is a very common first line:

\[ 5(-1) \le 6 \]

Minus five is at most six, so the verdict comes out yes.

The y-coordinate was never used. An ordered pair carries two numbers and the inequality has two variables, so leaving one out answers a different question entirely.

The fix

Put both numbers in. The second term subtracts two lots of minus seven, and subtracting a negative adds.

\[ 5(-1) - 2(-7) \]

\[ = -5 + 14 = 9 \]

Nine is not at most six, so the pair fails. The one-coordinate version got the opposite answer, which is worse than getting no answer at all.

The habit that prevents this: write out the substitution with both brackets in place before you work anything out. A bracket with nothing in it is easy to spot; a missing term is not.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 132 — Guided Practice 4

12. Is the origin a solution?

Prediction

Before doing any arithmetic, commit to an answer. The point of this slide is that the origin is special, and it is special in a way that makes it worth reaching for first every time.

Predict first

Is the origin a solution of the inequality two x plus five y is greater than nine?

  • Yes, because the origin satisfies most inequalities
  • No, because substituting gives 0, which is not greater than 9
  • It cannot be decided without drawing the graph
  • It depends which side of the line you shade

Correct: No, because substituting gives 0, which is not greater than 9

Why: Substituting zero for x and zero for y kills both terms, leaving zero on the left. Zero is not greater than nine, so the origin fails. Notice how little work that was: whenever the origin is available, it is the cheapest test point there is, because every term vanishes and you are left comparing zero with the number on the right.

\[ 2(0) + 5(0) = 0 \quad \text{and } 0 \not> 9 \]

The last two options are worth naming as wrong, because both of them get the logic backwards. Nothing about a graph is needed to test a point, and the shading is decided by the test rather than the other way round.

Remember the result as well as the method. The origin is not in this region, which means the region is the half-plane on the far side of the line from the origin, which is exactly what the picture in Example 1 showed.

From here on, reach for the origin first whenever you need a test point. You will see the one situation where it is unavailable soon enough, and it is easy to spot in advance.

13. Exercise 31: a test with decimals in it

Fill the middle

Decimal coefficients change nothing about the method, which is exactly why the exercise set includes them. Substitute, multiply, add, compare.

Fill in the blanks

0.2(-3) + 0.7(-1.5) = -1.65 \quad \text< -1.65 \;___\; -1

Why: Zero point two times minus three is minus zero point six, and zero point seven times minus one point five is minus one point zero five. Together they make minus one point six five, which is less than minus one, so the inequality asking for more than minus one is false and the pair is not a solution. Careful with the comparison: minus one point six five is further left on the number line than minus one, so it is the smaller of the two.

The pair fails, then. If that surprised you, the likely cause is the comparison rather than the multiplication: with negative numbers, bigger digits mean a smaller value.

The same exercise offers a second pair, zero point five and minus one, which gives minus zero point six. That is greater than minus one, so that pair is a solution and the two pairs sit on opposite sides of the boundary.

A habit worth borrowing for decimals: sketch a tiny number line in the margin and mark the two numbers on it. It takes three seconds and it settles every comparison of negatives you will ever meet.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 136 — Exercise 31

14. Why one test point can speak for a whole region

Intuition

Everything in this lesson rests on a fact that deserves an argument rather than an announcement: all the points on one side of the boundary give the same verdict. Here is why, in the case the book draws.

\[ 3x - 2y \quad \text{along the vertical line } x = 2 \]

y3x − 2y at x = 2greater than 2?
06 − 0 = 6yes
16 − 2 = 4yes
26 − 4 = 2no, it is equal
36 − 6 = 0no
46 − 8 = −2no

Read the middle column downwards. Every step up in y subtracts another two, so the value falls steadily: six, four, two, zero, minus two. It never wanders back up.

Figure (svg): The line three x minus two y equals two with the vertical line x equals two drawn, and five points marked up that vertical line labelled with the values six, four, two, zero and minus two.

Climb the dashed vertical line and the value of 3x − 2y drops steadily: 6, 4, 2, 0, −2. It passes 2 exactly once, and that crossing is the boundary.

A quantity that only ever decreases can cross the number two once and once only. Above the crossing every verdict is no, below it every verdict is yes, and the crossing itself is the boundary point on this vertical line.

The same argument works on every vertical line in the plane, because the coefficient of y is what makes the value fall and that coefficient is the same everywhere. Stack up all those vertical lines and you have two solid half-planes.

That is the licence for the whole method. One substitution tells you the verdict for one point, and the geometry tells you every other point on that side agrees with it.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 132 — the boundary line divides the plane into two half-planes

15. Say the licence in your own words

Explain it to yourself

Put the previous slide into your own sentences before you rely on it. An idea you can only recognise is not yet an idea you can use under pressure.

Discussion prompt

Explain in two or three sentences why substituting a single point is enough to decide the shading for infinitely many points. Then say what would go wrong with the method if the two sides of the line could each contain a mixture of solutions and non-solutions.

Figure (svg): The line y equals x minus one drawn dashed, with three points above it labelled yes and three points below it labelled no.

Six points, six substitutions, and the verdicts come out in two solid blocks. That is the fact that makes one test point enough for a whole half-plane.

The picture is the claim tested six times rather than argued. Three points above the line and three below, and the verdicts arrive in two blocks with no mixing anywhere.

Notice which fact is doing the work here. It is not that the boundary is straight: it is that the left-hand side changes in one direction as you cross it. Part 5 exploits exactly that, with a boundary that bends.

If your explanation mentioned the word shading more than the word substitute, write it again. The substitution is the reason; the shading is only the record of it.

16. Boundary lines and half-planes

Section

Part 2

17. Where the edge comes from

Concept

The graph of a linear inequality is the set of all points in the plane that represent solutions. To draw it you need its edge, and the edge comes from the inequality by a single change: replace the symbol with an equals sign.

\[ 3x - 2y > 2 \quad \longrightarrow \quad 3x - 2y = 2 \]

boundary line — The line you get by replacing the inequality symbol with an equals sign. It divides the plane into two half-planes, one of which is the graph of the inequality.

That line is the set of pairs giving exactly the number on the right, which is why it is the dividing line between giving more and giving less. Everything you know about graphing a line from Lessons 2.3 and 2.4 applies to it unchanged.

Figure (svg): The line three x minus two y equals two drawn dashed on axes, with the half-plane below it shaded and two test points marked, one in the shaded side and one outside it.

Substituting the lower point gives 6, which is greater than 2; the upper one gives −4, which is not. Every point on the shaded side behaves like the first.

half-plane — One of the two regions a line divides a coordinate plane into. The graph of a linear inequality in two variables is a half-plane, with or without its boundary.

Look at the two marked points. The lower one gives six, which is more than two, and it sits in the shaded half. The upper one gives minus four, which is not, and it sits outside. One of the two halves is the answer and the other is not, always.

So the work splits cleanly in two. Draw the line, which is old skill, and then decide which half, which is the new skill. Nothing else is involved.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 132 — the graph of a linear inequality and the half-plane figure

18. Dashed or solid: what the stroke records

Picture it

Once the line is drawn, one question remains about it: do the points on the line itself belong to the solution set? The inequality symbol answers that, and the stroke of the line records the answer.

Figure (svg): Two copies of the line x minus y equals one. On the left the line is dashed and a point on it is drawn as an open circle; on the right the line is solid and the same point is filled in.

The shading is the same on both sides of this picture. The only question the dash answers is whether the points on the edge itself count.

On the left the symbol is strict, so a pair giving exactly one fails and the whole line is excluded: the line is drawn dashed, and the point marked on it is hollow to show it is out.

On the right the symbol allows equality, so a pair giving exactly one succeeds and the line is part of the graph: the line is solid and the same point is filled in.

Notice what the stroke does not tell you. Both panels shade the same side, so the dash carries no information at all about direction. Students who expect it to are the ones who shade the wrong half.

This is the same convention as the open and filled circles from Lesson 1.6, stretched from a point to a line. Nothing new has been invented; a one-dimensional marker has simply grown a dimension.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 132 — the Interpret Graphs note on dashed and solid boundaries

19. A boundary that is drawn but not included

Concept

It is worth being precise about the odd status of a dashed line, because it looks like a contradiction: why draw a line whose points are not solutions?

Because the line is not the answer, it is the edge of the answer. You draw it for the same reason a map draws a coastline: to show where one region stops, not to claim the coastline is the sea.

\[ y > x - 1 \quad \text{at } (2, 1): \; 1 > 1 \quad \text{false} \]

That pair sits exactly on the line and fails by the narrowest margin possible. Move up by any amount at all, however tiny, and the statement becomes true, which is why the region has no first point.

\[ y > x - 1 \quad \text{at } (2, 1.001): \; 1.001 > 1 \quad \text{true} \]

So a strict inequality in two variables describes an open region: it comes arbitrarily close to its edge without reaching it. In one variable you met the same thing as an open circle on a number line.

One practical consequence. If a question asks for a solution of a strict inequality and you hand back a point on the boundary, the answer is wrong, however close it looks on a sketch. Pick a point visibly inside.

20. What a finished graph is claiming

Concept

A shaded graph is a strong statement, and it is worth spelling out what it says, because that is what makes it checkable.

Those three sentences are testable, which is the useful part. Pick a point that looks well inside your shading and substitute it, then pick one well outside and substitute that. Two lines of arithmetic, and the whole graph is confirmed.

\[ 3x - 2y > 2 \quad \text{at } (4, 1): \; 12 - 2 = 10 > 2 \quad \text{true} \]

\[ 3x - 2y > 2 \quad \text{at } (-2, 1): \; -6 - 2 = -8 \not> 2 \quad \text{false} \]

The first point is inside the shading and the second is outside it, and the verdicts match. If they had come out the other way round you would know instantly that you had shaded the wrong half, without anybody telling you.

Make those two substitutions your finishing move on every graph you draw. They take less time than the shading did, and they catch the one error that this topic produces most often.

21. Dashed or solid?

Sorting

Six inequalities, and only the symbol matters here. Do not rearrange anything and do not think about sides; just read the symbol and sort.

Sort into buckets

Sort each inequality by the kind of boundary line its graph needs.

Dashed boundary
3x − 2y > 2; y > −2x; x < 2
Solid boundary
5x − 2y ≤ −4; y ≤ −3; 2x + 5y ≥ 9
dash
Strictly greater than and strictly less than exclude equality, so no point of the boundary is a solution and the line is drawn dashed.
solid
At most and at least both allow the two sides to be equal, so every point of the boundary is a solution and the line is drawn solid.

Three of each, and you could have sorted them without knowing what any of the letters meant. That is the point: this decision is made by looking at one character.

The one that occasionally causes hesitation is the one with a negative on the right. The sign of the number has nothing to do with the stroke of the line; only the symbol does.

Keep this decision separate from the shading decision in your head and on paper. Draw the line with the right stroke first, then put the pencil down and do the substitution.

22. Match each inequality to its boundary equation

Matching

Finding the boundary equation is mechanical, but it is worth one deliberate pass, because a wrongly copied boundary makes everything afterwards wrong in a way that is hard to spot.

Match the pairs

  • a. 5x − 2y ≤ −4
  • b. y > −2x
  • c. x + 3y < 9
  • d. −2y ≤ 8
  • w. y = −2x, through the origin
  • x. 5x − 2y = −4, through (0, 2)
  • y. y = −4, a horizontal line
  • z. x + 3y = 9, through (9, 0) and (0, 3)

Why: In every case you replace the symbol with an equals sign and change nothing else. The last one needs one extra move: dividing both sides of the equation by minus two gives y equal to minus four, a horizontal line. Notice that dividing an equation by a negative number does nothing to an equals sign, which is why the boundary can be tidied up safely even though the inequality itself could not be.

The boundary through the origin is the one to remember. When the boundary passes through the origin, the origin is on the line, and a point on the line can never be used as a test point.

Two of these boundaries are easiest to draw from their intercepts. Put x equal to zero to find where the line crosses the vertical axis, then y equal to zero for the horizontal axis, and join them.

The horizontal one is a reminder that a boundary need not be slanted. A one-variable inequality still has a boundary line in the plane, and Part 4 is entirely about that case.

23. Trap: a solid boundary for a strict inequality

Trap

The trap

Graphing the strict inequality below, here is the first line of a common wrong answer:

\[ y > -2x \]

Draw the line y equals minus two x as a solid line, then shade above it.

The shading is right. The stroke is not, and the finished graph now claims something the inequality never said.

The fix

Test a point on the line itself and see what the graph is claiming. Take the point where x is one and y is minus two.

\[ -2 > -2(1) \]

\[ -2 > -2 \quad \text{false} \]

The pair fails, so that point is not a solution, yet a solid line has just drawn it as one. Draw the boundary dashed and the graph tells the truth again.

A useful habit for marking your own work: pick any point on your boundary and substitute it. If it satisfies the inequality the line should be solid, and if it does not the line should be dashed.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 133 — Example 3(a), where the boundary is dashed

24. Reading an inequality off a finished graph

Worked example

Exercise 41 turns the lesson round: here is the region, what was the inequality? Work through the three features of the picture in order, because each one recovers a different part of the answer. This example is mine, built in the style of that exercise.

Figure (svg): A solid line through zero comma two and four comma zero, with everything below and left of it shaded, and the origin marked inside the shading.

Two intercepts fix the boundary, the solid stroke fixes the symbol, and the shaded side containing the origin fixes the direction.

Read the boundary from its two intercepts

Why: the line crosses the vertical axis at 2 and the horizontal axis at 4, so it falls one unit for every two across and its equation can be written from the intercepts.

\[ \frac{x}{4} + \frac{y}{2} = 1 \quad \longrightarrow \quad x + 2y = 4 \]

Multiplying through by four cleared the fractions and left a tidy standard form. Any equation of that line will do, but the standard form makes the next two steps easiest to state.

Read the symbol from the stroke

Why: the line is drawn solid, so points on it are solutions and the symbol must allow equality.

\[ x + 2y \;\square\; 4 \quad \text{with equality allowed} \]

Read the direction from the shaded side

Why: the origin lies in the shaded region, so the origin must satisfy the inequality; substituting gives zero, and zero is at most four.

\[ x + 2y \le 4 \quad \text{at } (0,0): \; 0 \le 4 \]

So all three features are used, and none of them was guesswork. The intercepts gave the left-hand side, the stroke gave the symbol, and the origin gave the direction.

Check with a second point

Why: take the point four units up on the vertical axis, which is clearly outside the shading: substituting gives eight, and eight is not at most four, so that point is correctly excluded.

\[ (0, 4): \; 0 + 2(4) = 8 \not\le 4 \]

Testing one point inside and one point outside is the standard way to confirm an inequality you have read off a graph. If both come out as the picture shows, your answer describes that picture.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 136 — Exercise 41, write an inequality for the graph shown

25. Is the origin always a legal test point?

Counterexample

The book calls the origin convenient, and it is: every term vanishes and the arithmetic is instant. But convenient is not the same as always available, and there is exactly one situation that rules it out.

\[ y > -2x \quad \text{at } (0, 0): \; 0 > 0 \quad \text{false} \]

Discussion prompt

Substituting the origin into this inequality gives a false statement. Explain why that does not mean the origin's side is unshaded, and say what it is about this particular inequality that makes the origin useless here. Then name a point you could use instead.

So the rule is narrow and easy to check. Look at the right-hand side: if it is zero, the boundary runs through the origin and you need a different test point. Otherwise the origin is the best one available.

When you do need another point, pick one whose arithmetic is almost as easy. A point with a zero in it, or a pair of small whole numbers well clear of the line, keeps the substitution short.

Avoid picking a point that merely looks off the line on your sketch. Substitute it and confirm it does not give exactly the number on the right, because a point near the line is no use if it is actually on it.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 133 — the Avoid Errors note on choosing a test point

26. The two-step graphing procedure

Section

Part 3

27. The whole method, in two steps

Concept

Here is the book's Key Concept box, and it really is the whole method. Two steps, one of which is a drawing and the other a substitution, with a branch at the end that the arithmetic decides for you.

  1. Step 1. Graph the boundary line, using a dashed line for less than or greater than and a solid line for at most or at least.
  2. Step 2. Test a point not on the boundary line. If it is a solution, shade the half-plane containing it. If it is not, shade the other half-plane.

Figure (svg): A flow diagram: draw the boundary, choose its style from the symbol, pick a test point off the line, substitute, and then branch to shading the point's side if the result is true or the other side if it is false.

Step one is a drawing decision made from the symbol. Step two is an arithmetic decision made from one substitution. Nothing in the procedure asks you to guess a side.

Notice how the two steps use different information. Step one uses only the symbol, and step two uses only the arithmetic of one substitution. Neither step needs the other's information, so there is nothing to get tangled.

The branch at the end is the part worth memorising as a sentence: a true verdict shades the point's own side, and a false verdict shades the opposite side. A false verdict is not a dead end, it is an answer.

Reach for the origin in step two whenever the boundary misses it, which you check by looking for a non-zero number on the right. If the boundary goes through the origin, pick any nearby point with easy arithmetic instead.

There is no third step. In particular there is no step where you look at the symbol again and decide to shade upwards, and the next few slides are about why adding that step is dangerous.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 133 — the Key Concept box, Graphing a Linear Inequality

28. Put the procedure back in order

Ranking

Five actions, one correct order. Before you drag anything, ask yourself which action cannot be done until another one is finished, because that is what fixes the sequence.

Put in order

Order these five actions into the procedure for graphing a linear inequality in two variables.

  1. Replace the inequality symbol with an equals sign
  2. Draw that line, dashed or solid according to the symbol
  3. Pick a point that is not on the line
  4. Substitute the point's coordinates into the inequality
  5. Shade the point's own side if the statement is true, the other side if it is false

Why: You cannot draw the boundary before you have its equation, and you cannot pick a point off the line before the line exists. The substitution has to happen before the shading, because its verdict is the only thing that decides which side to fill. Notice that the symbol is used twice, once for the stroke of the line and once inside the substitution, and that these are two different jobs.

The step people try to skip is picking a point. It feels like an unnecessary formality when the picture already looks obvious, and it is exactly the step that protects you when the picture is misleading.

The step people try to move is the substitution. Doing it before the line is drawn is harmless, but doing it after the shading is not: at that stage it is a check, and a check you might be tempted to ignore.

Rehearse the sequence on a problem you have already done. Running a known problem through a new order of steps is a cheap way to make the order feel automatic.

29. Example 3(a): graph y greater than minus two x

Worked example

A boundary through the origin, and a strict symbol. That combination forces both of the interesting decisions in this lesson, so it is a good first full graph.

\[ y > -2x \]

Write the boundary equation

Why: replace the symbol with an equals sign and change nothing else.

\[ y = -2x \]

Decide the stroke

Why: the symbol is strictly greater than, so points on the line are not solutions and the line is dashed.

\[ \text{dashed, slope } -2, \text{ through } (0,0) \]

Draw that line through the origin going down two for every one across. Because it passes through the origin, the origin is unavailable as a test point, and you can tell that from the zero on the right-hand side before drawing anything.

Test the point where x and y are both 1

Why: it is well clear of the line, and the arithmetic is as short as the origin's would have been.

\[ 1 > -2(1) \quad \longrightarrow \quad 1 > -2 \quad \text{true} \]

True, so the shading goes on that point's side of the line, which is the upper left region. The book chooses this same point, and any point off the line would have given the same answer.

Figure (svg): The line y equals minus two x drawn dashed through the origin, with the half-plane above it shaded and the test point one comma one marked inside the shading.

The boundary runs through the origin, so the origin cannot be the test point. The hollow circle marks the point you are not allowed to use.

Check with a point on the other side

Why: take the point where x is 1 and y is minus 3, which lies below the line: substituting gives minus three, which is not greater than minus two, so that side is correctly left unshaded.

\[ -3 > -2(1) \quad \longrightarrow \quad -3 > -2 \quad \text{false} \]

Testing a second point on the far side is the cheapest possible confirmation, and it catches the single most common error in this topic, which is shading the wrong half.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 133 — Example 3(a)

30. Example 3(b): graph 5x minus 2y at most minus 4

Worked example

Now a boundary that misses the origin, and an inclusive symbol. Watch for the shading, because this is the example where the tempting shortcut gives the wrong answer.

\[ 5x - 2y \le -4 \]

Write the boundary equation

Why: replace the symbol with an equals sign.

\[ 5x - 2y = -4 \]

Find two points on it

Why: put x equal to zero to get the vertical intercept, then y equal to zero for the horizontal one.

\[ (0, 2) \quad \text{and} \quad (-0.8, 0) \]

Those two points are enough to draw the line. The horizontal intercept is not a whole number, so plot the vertical intercept and use the slope of two and a half to reach a second lattice point.

Decide the stroke

Why: the symbol allows equality, so the boundary belongs to the graph and the line is solid.

\[ \text{solid, through } (0, 2) \]

Test the origin

Why: the right-hand side is not zero, so the boundary misses the origin and the easiest point in the plane is available.

\[ 5(0) - 2(0) = 0 \quad \text{and } 0 \not\le -4 \quad \text{false} \]

The origin is not a solution, so the shading goes on the other side of the line. Since the origin is below and right of the boundary, the region you shade is the one above and left of it.

Figure (svg): The line five x minus two y equals minus four drawn solid, with the half-plane above and left of it shaded, and the origin marked outside the shading.

The origin gives 0, which is not at most −4, so the shading goes on the other side. The boundary is solid because the symbol allows equality.

Check with a point in the shaded region

Why: take the pair minus two and two, which is clearly inside: five lots of minus two is minus ten, minus two lots of two is minus four, and minus fourteen is comfortably at most minus four.

\[ 5(-2) - 2(2) = -10 - 4 = -14 \le -4 \quad \text{true} \]

Now look back at the symbol. It says at most, and yet the region is above the line. That is not a mistake in the working, and the next slide is about why it happens.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 133 — Example 3(b)

31. Trap: shading from the symbol instead of a test point

Trap

The trap

The shortcut sounds so reasonable that most students invent it for themselves. Greater than means above, less than means below.

\[ 5x - 2y \le -4 \]

The symbol says at most, so shade below the line.

That answer is the wrong half of the plane, and every point in it fails the inequality.

The fix

The shortcut reads a symbol that is not talking about height. The inequality compares the number 5x minus 2y with minus four; it says nothing directly about y.

\[ (0,0): \; 0 \not\le -4 \]

The origin fails, so the far side is shaded: above the line, not below it.

Figure (svg): Two copies of the line five x minus two y equals minus four. The left panel shades below the line and is marked wrong; the right panel shades above it and is marked right. The origin is marked in both.

Reading the symbol off the original inequality shades the red side. Substituting one point shades the green side. Only the substitution can be trusted.

The reason is the minus sign. Rearranging for y divides by minus two, which reverses the symbol, so at most in the original becomes at least in the y-form and the direction turns over.

\[ y \ge \frac{5x + 4}{2} \]

So the shortcut works only when the coefficient of y is positive, and it fails silently whenever it is negative. A test point does not care either way, which is why it is the method and the shortcut is not.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 133 — Example 3(b), where the shading is above a line with an at-most symbol

32. Exercise 17: graph 3x minus y at least 1

Worked example

Here is the same trap the other way round, so that you can see it is not a one-off. The symbol says at least, and the shaded region will be below the line.

\[ 3x - y \ge 1 \]

Write the boundary and find two points

Why: replace the symbol with an equals sign, then take the two intercepts.

\[ 3x - y = 1 \quad \longrightarrow \quad (0, -1), \; \left(\tfrac13, 0\right) \]

Decide the stroke

Why: the symbol allows equality, so the line is solid.

\[ \text{solid, slope } 3, \text{ through } (0, -1) \]

Test the origin

Why: there is a 1 on the right, so the boundary misses the origin and it is available.

\[ 3(0) - 0 = 0 \quad \text{and } 0 \not\ge 1 \quad \text{false} \]

False, so shade the side away from the origin. The origin sits above this line, so the region you shade is the one below and to the right of it.

Figure (svg): The line y equals three x minus one drawn solid, with the region below and right of it shaded, and the origin marked just above the line outside the shading.

The symbol is at least, and yet the shading is below the line. The test point is the only thing that could have told you that.

Confirm it against the rearranged form if you like. Subtracting three x and then dividing by minus one turns the symbol round twice over, leaving y at most three x minus one, which is indeed the region below the line.

\[ 3x - y \ge 1 \quad \longrightarrow \quad y \le 3x - 1 \]

Check with a point in the shaded region

Why: take the pair two and zero, which lies below the line: six minus zero is six, and six is at least one.

\[ 3(2) - 0 = 6 \ge 1 \quad \text{true} \]

Two examples, two different symbols, and in both of them the shortcut based on the symbol gave the wrong half. Whenever the y term carries a minus sign, expect the direction to be the opposite of your first instinct.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 135 — Exercise 17

33. When the y-form is safe, and what it costs

Concept

There is nothing wrong with rearranging an inequality so that y stands alone. It is a perfectly good route, and after it the symbol really does tell you the direction. The cost is one extra chance to make a mistake.

\[ 5x - 2y \le -4 \]

\[ -2y \le -5x - 4 \]

\[ y \ge \frac{5x + 4}{2} \]

The middle line is where the danger is. Dividing both sides by minus two reverses the symbol, exactly as it did in Lesson 1.6 with one variable, and forgetting that reversal is the single most common slip in this whole chapter.

Once the rearranging is done correctly, reading the region is genuinely easy: at least means the region above the line, at most means below, and the symbol is now talking about height because y is on its own.

So you have two methods. Rearrange and read the symbol, or leave the inequality alone and test a point. The second involves no sign manipulation at all, which is why the book teaches it and why it is the one to use under exam pressure.

Best of all, use one as a check on the other. If your test point and your rearranged form disagree about the shading, you have found a mistake without needing anybody to mark it.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §1.6 — reversing the symbol when you divide by a negative number

34. Guided Practice 9: complete the test for x plus 3y less than 9

Fill the middle

Your turn to run step two. The boundary is already drawn below, crossing the axes at nine and at three, and the only thing left is to decide which side of it to fill.

Fill in the blanks

(0) + 3(0) = 0 \quad \text< \quad 0 ___ 9

Why: Both terms vanish at the origin, leaving zero, and zero really is less than nine, so the statement is true. A true verdict shades the half-plane containing the test point, which here is the region below and left of the dashed line. The boundary is dashed because the symbol is strict, so the two intercepts are drawn hollow: they are on the edge and therefore not solutions.

Figure (svg): The line x plus three y equals nine drawn dashed through nine comma zero and zero comma three, with the region below it shaded and the origin inside the shading.

Both intercepts are hollow because the boundary is excluded. The origin gives 0, comfortably under 9, so the shading is on its side.

Notice how little arithmetic step two needed. Whenever the origin is available it turns the substitution into reading off the number on the right, which is why it is worth checking for first every time.

Guided Practice 10 asks for the graph of two x minus six y greater than twelve, and it is a useful contrast. The origin gives zero again, but this time zero is not greater than twelve, so the shading goes on the far side.

Try that one on paper now, with the boundary through six and zero and through zero and minus two. Two problems whose first line is identical and whose answers are opposite halves is the best possible practice for this step.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 134 — Guided Practice 9 and 10

35. Turn the boundary and watch the region follow

Tweak it

A slider makes the relationship between the boundary and the region something you can watch rather than something you take on trust. Turn the line and ask, at each setting, whether a fixed point has changed sides.

Parameter explorer

Slide the coefficient. The inequality is y greater than the coefficient times x, so the shaded region is always above the line drawn. For which settings is the point where x and y are both one a solution, and what happens at the setting where the line passes through that point?

\[ y > {m}x \]

  • m — from -3 to 3: coefficient of x

Two features never change as you slide. The line always passes through the origin, because the right-hand side is zero at every setting, and the shaded region is always the one above the line, because y stands alone with a positive coefficient.

What does change is which points are in that region. Watch the point where x and y are both one: for shallow and negative settings it is comfortably inside, and as the line steepens past it, it falls out.

The setting where the line goes exactly through the point is the important one. There the point gives equality, the statement is false because the symbol is strict, and the point is useless as a test point because it is on the boundary.

That is the whole reason for the rule about test points, seen as a motion rather than a warning. A point is only informative while it is off the line.

36. Two decisions, side by side

Comparison

Fill in the gaps and the table becomes a summary of the whole procedure. Every row is one inequality run through both decisions, and the two decisions use different columns of information.

Comparison matrix

inequalitystroketest at the originwhich side
2x + 5y ≥ 9solid0 ≥ 9 is falsethe far side
x + 3y < 9dashedtruethe origin's side
5x − 2y ≤ −4solid0 ≤ −4 is falsefar
y > −2xdashedunusable: the line goes through ittest (1, 1) instead

Read the second column down and notice that it depends on nothing but the symbol. Read the fourth column down and notice that it depends on nothing but the verdict in the third. The columns never talk to each other.

The last row is the exception that proves the rule. Its third column has no verdict at all, because the origin is on the line, so the fourth column has to name a different point before the procedure can finish.

If you filled the third column of the middle row by looking at the symbol rather than doing the substitution, you got lucky this time. The row below it is the one where that habit gives the wrong answer.

37. Which test point can you actually use?

Discrimination

Sort five candidate test points by whether they can be used for the inequality named beside them. The question in every case is the same: is the point off the boundary line?

Sort into buckets

For each inequality, sort the suggested test point by whether it is usable.

Usable
y > −2x, test (1, 1); 5x − 2y ≤ −4, test (0, 0)
On the boundary, so useless
y > −2x, test (0, 0); 3x − 2y > 2, test (2, 2); x + 3y < 9, test (0, 3)
ok
In these the substitution gives a value different from the number on the right, so the point is genuinely off the line and its verdict speaks for its whole side.
no
In these the substitution gives exactly the number on the right, so the point lies on the boundary. A point on the edge belongs to neither side and can decide nothing.

The test that settles every one of them is to substitute and look for equality. Getting exactly the number on the right is the signature of a point on the boundary, whatever the picture seems to show.

Two of the useless ones are not obviously on the line at a glance. The pair two and two gives six minus four, which is two, and the pair zero and three gives nine, so both land precisely on their boundaries.

This is why a sketch is not enough for choosing a test point. Substitute first, and if you get equality, move your point somewhere clearly inside one of the halves and substitute again.

38. One-variable inequalities in the plane

Section

Part 4

39. A missing variable is an unrestricted variable

Concept

Some inequalities mention only one of the two variables. They are still inequalities in two variables, because you are still being asked which points of the plane satisfy them, and the answer is still a half-plane.

\[ y \le -3 \qquad \text{and} \qquad x < 2 \]

The key idea is that a variable which does not appear is a variable under no restriction at all. The first inequality says nothing whatever about x, so every value of x is allowed, and the region runs off both sides of the page.

Write the missing variable in with a coefficient of zero if it helps you see it. Zero times x plus y is at most minus three is the same statement, and now it plainly has two variables in it.

\[ 0 \cdot x + y \le -3 \]

The boundary of such an inequality is a horizontal or a vertical line, and those are the two easiest lines in the plane to draw. Everything else about the procedure is unchanged: choose the stroke from the symbol, then test a point.

In Lesson 1.6 the same inequality described a ray on a number line. In the plane it describes a half of the whole plane, because each of the infinitely many heights is now a separate point.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 133 — Example 2, graph linear inequalities with one variable

40. Example 2(a): graph y at most minus 3

Worked example

Read the inequality as a restriction on height only. Any point whose height is minus three or lower qualifies, no matter how far left or right it sits.

\[ y \le -3 \]

Write the boundary equation

Why: replace the symbol with an equals sign; the result is a horizontal line.

\[ y = -3 \]

Decide the stroke

Why: the symbol allows equality, so every point at height exactly minus three is a solution and the line is solid.

\[ \text{solid horizontal line through } (0, -3) \]

Draw it three units below the horizontal axis and take it right across the frame. There is no slope to work out here, because the height never changes.

Test the origin

Why: the boundary is nowhere near the origin, so the easiest point in the plane is available.

\[ 0 \not\le -3 \quad \text{false} \]

The origin fails, so shade the half-plane that does not contain it. The origin is above the line, so the region is everything below the line.

Figure (svg): A solid horizontal line at y equals minus three with everything below it shaded, and the origin marked well above the line outside the shading.

Nothing restricts x, so the region runs off both sides of the frame. The whole graph is the answer to a question about y alone.

Check with a point in the shaded region

Why: take the pair four and minus five, well inside the shading: its height is minus five, and minus five is at most minus three.

\[ (4, -5): \; -5 \le -3 \quad \text{true} \]

Notice that the x-coordinate of that check played no part at all. It could have been four hundred and the verdict would be the same, which is exactly what an unrestricted variable means.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 133 — Example 2(a)

41. Example 2(b): graph x less than 2

Worked example

Now the restriction is on horizontal position instead of height, and the symbol is strict. This is the inequality from the warm-up, finished properly.

\[ x < 2 \]

Write the boundary equation

Why: replace the symbol with an equals sign; the result is a vertical line.

\[ x = 2 \]

Decide the stroke

Why: the symbol is strict, so points with x exactly 2 are not solutions and the line is dashed.

\[ \text{dashed vertical line through } (2, 0) \]

A vertical line has no slope and cannot be written in the y-form at all, which is a useful reminder that the y-form is a convenience rather than a requirement.

Test the origin

Why: the origin is not on the line, so use it.

\[ 0 < 2 \quad \text{true} \]

True, so shade the half-plane containing the origin, which is everything to the left of the dashed line. The strip has no top and no bottom, because y is unrestricted.

Figure (svg): A dashed vertical line at x equals two with the whole strip to its left shaded, the origin marked inside the shading, and the point three comma zero marked outside it.

Every point left of the dashed line has an x-coordinate below 2, whatever its height. The dash keeps the line itself out of the solution set.

Check a point on each side

Why: the pair three and two lies to the right and gives 3, which is not less than 2, so it is correctly outside; the pair minus one and five gives minus one, which is less than 2, so it is correctly inside.

\[ (3, 2): \; 3 \not< 2 \qquad (-1, 5): \; -1 < 2 \]

Both checks ignored the second coordinate entirely. When only one variable appears, only one coordinate of your test point does any work, and the other is there purely to make it a point.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 133 — Example 2(b)

42. Guided Practice 5 and 6: the two kinds of edge

Picture it

Two checkpoint exercises from the book, drawn side by side, because the pair makes the distinction obvious in a way either one alone does not.

Figure (svg): Two panels. On the left a dashed horizontal line at minus one with everything above it shaded; on the right a solid vertical line at minus four with everything to its right shaded.

The variable named in the inequality decides which way the boundary runs, and the symbol decides whether that boundary belongs to the region.

On the left, y is the restricted variable, so the boundary is horizontal and the region is a top or a bottom. The symbol is strict, so the edge is dashed and its points are excluded.

On the right, x is the restricted variable, so the boundary is vertical and the region is a left or a right. The symbol allows equality, so the edge is solid and its points are included.

Both were settled by the same two questions you now ask of everything. Which variable does the inequality restrict, and does the symbol let the boundary in? Neither question needs any algebra.

The origin does the shading in both cases. Zero is greater than minus one, and zero is at least minus four, so both regions contain the origin, which is why one shades upwards and the other rightwards.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 134 — Guided Practice 5 and 6

43. Find the error: a ray where a region belongs

Error analysis

A classmate hands you this to mark. The instruction was to graph the inequality in a coordinate plane, and what has been drawn would have been right one chapter ago.

Annotate

On: \( x < 2 \quad \text{drawn as a thick ray on the } x\text{-axis} \)

  • The boundary value of 2 is correct, and drawing it as an open endpoint rather than a filled one correctly records that 2 itself is excluded.
  • The answer has been drawn only along the horizontal axis, so it claims that the solutions all have a y-coordinate of zero. The pair with x equal to one and y equal to five is a solution and is nowhere on that ray.
  • The inequality looks exactly like the one-variable inequalities of Lesson 1.6, and the habit of shading a number line is strong. Nothing in the symbols reminds you that the question has moved into the plane.
  • Stretch the endpoint into a whole vertical line and the shading into the whole strip left of it. An excluded endpoint becomes a dashed line, and an included one becomes a solid line.

The instructive part is how much of the work was right. The value and the exclusion were both correct, and the only failure was about which space the answer lives in.

A quick way to catch this in your own work: pick any solution with a non-zero second coordinate and see whether your drawing contains it. If it does not, your answer is too small.

The reverse mistake also happens, when a genuinely one-variable question is answered with a shaded region. Read the instruction: in a coordinate plane means a region, and on a number line means a ray.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 136 — Exercises 19 and 20, describe and correct the error

44. Exercise 10: graph minus 2y at most 8

Worked example

This one carries a sting from Lesson 1.6. The variable has a negative coefficient, so tidying the inequality up means dividing by a negative number, and that reverses the symbol.

\[ -2y \le 8 \]

Divide both sides by minus 2 and reverse the symbol

Why: dividing an inequality by a negative number turns it round, exactly as in one variable.

\[ y \ge -4 \]

If you are ever unsure whether the reversal was needed, test one number. Minus two lots of zero is zero, which is at most eight, so zero must satisfy the tidied version, and zero is indeed at least minus four.

Write the boundary equation

Why: either form gives the same line, because dividing an equation by a negative number changes nothing.

\[ -2y = 8 \quad \longrightarrow \quad y = -4 \]

Decide the stroke

Why: the symbol allows equality in both forms, so the line is solid.

\[ \text{solid horizontal line through } (0, -4) \]

Test the origin in the original inequality

Why: using the original avoids relying on the reversal being right.

\[ -2(0) = 0 \le 8 \quad \text{true} \]

True, so shade the side containing the origin, which is everything above the line. The tidied form agrees: at least minus four means heights of minus four and upwards.

Figure (svg): A solid horizontal line at y equals minus four with everything above it shaded, the origin inside the shading, and the point at minus four below the line marked out.

Dividing by minus two turned the symbol round, and the test point agrees: the origin satisfies the original inequality, so the shading contains it.

Check a point below the line

Why: the pair minus two and minus six has height minus six: minus two lots of minus six is twelve, and twelve is not at most eight, so that point is correctly outside.

\[ -2(-6) = 12 \not\le 8 \quad \text{false} \]

That check is the one to run whenever a negative coefficient is involved. Had you forgotten the reversal and shaded downwards, this single substitution would have caught it.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 135 — Exercise 10

45. Which description is the graph of x at least minus 4?

Elimination

Four descriptions of a graph, three of which go wrong in a way somebody really does go wrong. Rule them out one at a time and say what each one has confused.

Eliminate the wrong options

Which of these describes the graph of the inequality x is at least minus four, drawn in a coordinate plane?

  • a. A solid vertical line at −4, with everything to its right shaded
  • b. A dashed vertical line at −4, with everything to its right shaded
  • c. A solid horizontal line at −4, with everything above it shaded
  • d. A thick ray on the horizontal axis from −4 rightwards

Survives elimination: a

Why: The inequality restricts x and says nothing about y, so the boundary is the vertical line where x is minus four and the region runs off the top and bottom of the page. The symbol allows equality, so the line is solid, and testing the origin gives zero, which is at least minus four, so the shading contains the origin and lies to the right.

The one that only differs by a stroke is the most dangerous, because the region is perfectly right and the error is a single pen stroke. Graders notice it every time.

The horizontal option is the classic slip of confusing which variable is restricted. Keep hold of the picture: x measures how far across, so a restriction on x cuts the plane with a vertical line.

The ray is the previous slide's error in another costume. It answers the Lesson 1.6 version of the question rather than this one.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 135 — Exercise 8

46. Why a strip and not a ray?

Socratic

This question is worth arguing out rather than accepting, because the answer is the reason the whole lesson exists.

Discussion prompt

A classmate says that x at least minus four should be a ray, because the inequality only mentions one variable and a ray is what Lesson 1.6 drew. Give the shortest possible argument that settles it, using one specific point.

Notice the shape of the argument. To show that a proposed answer is too small, you only have to produce one solution it leaves out, and that is usually the fastest way to settle a disagreement about a region.

The deeper point is that the number of variables is set by the question, not by the number of letters that happen to appear. Graph in a coordinate plane means that pairs are the objects being tested.

It also explains the strip's shape. The restriction on x gives the strip its left and right edges, and the absence of any restriction on y is why it has no top and no bottom.

47. When the boundary bends

Section

Part 5

48. The method never mentioned straightness

Concept

Go back and read step two of the procedure. It says to test a point not on the boundary, and it says nothing at all about the boundary being a line. That is not an accident: the method works for any boundary that separates the plane into two pieces.

\[ y > -2\left|x - 3\right| + 4 \]

An absolute value graph is the V shape from Lesson 2.7, and it divides the plane into two regions just as cleanly as a line does: the part inside the V and the part outside it. So the same two steps apply.

Step one becomes: graph the absolute value equation, dashed or solid according to the symbol. Step two is completely unchanged. Substitute one point, and shade its region if the statement is true.

What you lose is the y-form shortcut, and that is no loss at all, since you were advised not to rely on it. What you keep is the substitution, which never depended on the shape of anything.

Lesson 2.7 gave you the tools for step one: the vertex sits where the expression inside the bars is zero, the number outside the bars stretches the V, and a negative in front turns it upside down.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 135 — Absolute Value Inequalities

49. Decoding the absolute value boundary

Notation

Step one of the procedure now asks you to graph an absolute value equation, so take the general form apart before using it. Three numbers control the V, and each one controls a different feature.

Annotate

On: \( y = a\left|x - h\right| + k \)

  • Shifts the V sideways. The vertex sits where the expression inside the bars is zero, which is at x equal to h. Watch the sign: bars around x minus 3 put the vertex at positive 3.
  • Shifts the V up or down. Once the bars give zero, the height left over is k, so the vertex is the point with coordinates h and k.
  • Stretches the arms and can flip the V. Its size is how steeply each arm rises, and a negative value turns the V upside down so the vertex is a peak rather than a valley.
  • Make the inside positive before anything else happens, which is what produces two arms instead of one line. Everything outside the bars acts on that positive result.

In Example 5 the three numbers are minus two, three and four, so the vertex is at three and four and the arms fall two units for every one across. That is enough to draw the boundary without plotting a table of values.

The order to read them in is h, then k, then a. Place the vertex first, because it is the one point you know exactly, and then draw the arms outwards from it at the slope the first number sets.

None of this is new: it is Lesson 2.7 on absolute value functions, borrowed for one step of the procedure. The inequality has not changed anything about how the graph is drawn.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 135 — the absolute value boundary of Example 5

50. Why the argument survives a bend

Intuition

Part 1 justified the test point with an argument about walking up a vertical line. It is worth checking that the argument still holds when the boundary bends, rather than assuming it.

\[ y > \left|x - 1\right| \quad \longrightarrow \quad y - \left|x - 1\right| > 0 \]

Written that way, the question is whether one quantity is positive. Now fix x at some value, say 3, and walk upwards. The second part of the expression is frozen at 2, because it depends only on x, and the first part grows steadily with y.

y at x = 3y − |x − 1|positive?
00 − 2 = −2no
11 − 2 = −1no
22 − 2 = 0no, it is zero
33 − 2 = 1yes
44 − 2 = 2yes

The value climbs by one for every step up, so it passes zero exactly once, and above that crossing every verdict is yes. The crossing point is where the vertical line meets the V.

Nothing in that reasoning cared about the shape of the boundary. All it needed was that the boundary gives one height for each x, and that the left-hand side changes steadily as you rise, so the V is handled by the same argument as a line.

What would break it is a boundary that doubles back, giving two heights at the same x, such as a circle. Then a vertical line crosses twice and the plane is cut into more than two pieces, which is why this lesson stops at graphs like these.

51. Example 5: graph y greater than minus 2 times the absolute value of x minus 3, plus 4

Worked example

Build the boundary first, using what Lesson 2.7 gave you about absolute value graphs, and then run step two exactly as before.

\[ y > -2\left|x - 3\right| + 4 \]

Write the boundary equation

Why: replace the symbol with an equals sign.

\[ y = -2\left|x - 3\right| + 4 \]

Locate the vertex

Why: the expression inside the bars is zero when x is 3, and then y is 4.

\[ \text{vertex } (3, 4) \]

The minus two in front does two things at once. Its size stretches the V so that it rises or falls two units for every one across, and its sign turns the V upside down, so the vertex is a peak rather than a valley.

Find where the boundary crosses the horizontal axis

Why: set y to zero: two times the absolute value must equal four, so the distance from 3 is 2.

\[ \left|x - 3\right| = 2 \quad \longrightarrow \quad x = 1 \text{ or } x = 5 \]

Decide the stroke

Why: the symbol is strictly greater than, so the boundary is dashed.

\[ \text{dashed V, peak at } (3, 4), \text{ through } (1,0) \text{ and } (5,0) \]

Test the origin

Why: the origin is well clear of the V, so it is available; the bars make the inside positive before the minus two multiplies it.

\[ -2\left|0 - 3\right| + 4 = -2(3) + 4 = -2 \]

So the boundary is two units below the axis at that x, and the origin is above it. The statement asks whether zero is greater than minus two, and it is, so the origin is a solution.

Figure (svg): A dashed inverted V with its peak at three comma four, with the whole region above the V shaded, and the origin marked inside the shaded part.

The boundary bends, but the shading is decided exactly as before: the origin makes the inequality true, so the origin's side is the answer.

Check a point inside the V

Why: take the pair three and zero, directly below the peak: the boundary there is at height 4, and zero is not greater than 4, so that point is correctly left unshaded.

\[ (3, 0): \; 0 \not> -2\left|3 - 3\right| + 4 = 4 \]

The book describes the shaded part as the portion outside the absolute value graph, and with an upside-down V the outside is the region above it. Your two substitutions have proved that without needing the word outside at all.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 135 — Example 5

52. Exercise 22: graph y greater than the absolute value of x minus 1

Worked example

The same shape the right way up, and this time the origin fails. Watch how little the working changes and how much the picture does.

\[ y > \left|x - 1\right| \]

Write the boundary and find its vertex

Why: replace the symbol with an equals sign; the expression inside the bars is zero when x is 1, and then y is 0.

\[ y = \left|x - 1\right|, \quad \text{vertex } (1, 0) \]

Decide the stroke

Why: the symbol is strict, so the V is dashed and the vertex is not a solution.

\[ \text{dashed V, vertex } (1, 0), \text{ slopes } 1 \text{ and } -1 \]

With no number in front of the bars, the V rises one unit for every one across, so it makes a right angle at the vertex. Nothing is turned upside down here, so the vertex is the lowest point.

Test the origin

Why: the bars turn minus one into one, which is the whole of the right-hand side.

\[ \left|0 - 1\right| = 1 \quad \text{and } 0 \not> 1 \quad \text{false} \]

The origin fails, so shade the other region. The origin sits just below the left arm of the V, so the region to shade is the one the V opens into, above and between its arms.

Figure (svg): A dashed V with its lowest point at one comma zero, with the region inside and above the V shaded, and the origin marked just outside the shading.

The origin gives 0 on the left and 1 on the right, so it is not a solution: the shading is the region the V opens into, not the region below it.

Check a point high inside the V

Why: take the pair one and four, directly above the vertex: the right-hand side is zero there, and four is greater than zero.

\[ (1, 4): \; 4 > \left|1 - 1\right| = 0 \quad \text{true} \]

Compare the two absolute value examples. One shaded above an upside-down V and one shaded above an upright V, and in both cases the word that decided it was true or false, never inside or outside.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 136 — Exercise 22

53. Exercise 23: predict the region before you draw it

Prediction

One more absolute value inequality, and this time commit to the region before doing anything. The point of predicting first is that a wrong prediction is the most informative thing that can happen to you.

\[ y < \left|x\right| + 5 \]

Predict first

The boundary is an upright V with its vertex five units up the vertical axis. Which region does the inequality describe?

  • The region below the V, which contains the origin
  • The region above the V, which does not contain the origin
  • Only the V itself, drawn solid
  • Nothing at all, because the right-hand side is never negative

Correct: The region below the V, which contains the origin

Why: Substituting the origin gives zero on the left and five on the right, and zero is less than five, so the origin is a solution and its region is shaded. That region is everything below the V, and the V is dashed because the symbol is strict. The answer has nothing to do with the right-hand side being positive: an inequality with a strictly positive right-hand side still has a perfectly ordinary region of solutions.

\[ (0,0): \; 0 < \left|0\right| + 5 = 5 \quad \text{true} \]

Notice how the prediction was settled by one substitution rather than by imagining the shape. The V could have been stretched, squashed or shifted and the origin would still have decided the region.

The region below an upright V is the one most students find hardest to picture, because it wraps around underneath both arms and is not the tidy wedge the V seems to suggest. Trust the substitution over the picture.

If you predicted the region above the V, the likely cause is the habit of reading less than as below without checking which side of the boundary the origin is on. Here the two agree, and in the earlier examples they did not.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 136 — Exercise 23

54. Modelling a real constraint

Section

Part 6

55. A limit in words becomes a region on paper

Concept

Outside a textbook, inequalities in two variables almost always arrive as limits. You have a fixed amount of something, two ways of spending it, and a question about which combinations are possible.

The book calls the intermediate step a verbal model: a sentence in words, with the units written in, that you then translate one phrase at a time into symbols. Writing it slows you down by thirty seconds and saves whole questions.

\[ \text{rate} \cdot \text{time} + \text{rate} \cdot \text{time} \le \text{total} \]

Every product in a model like this has to come out in the units of the total. Megabytes per second times seconds gives megabytes, and megabytes plus megabytes gives megabytes, so the model is at least sensible before any numbers go in.

The other half of the modelling is knowing which points of the plane are physically real. Negative seconds and negative pizzas do not exist, so the region you draw is usually cut down to the first quadrant.

Once it is drawn, the region is a menu. Every point in it is a plan you could actually carry out, and the boundary is the set of plans that use up the resource exactly.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 134 — Example 4, the verbal model

56. Example 4: write and graph the video-space constraint

Worked example

A film class is burning a DVD of student films, and each group gets up to 300 megabytes. Normal scenes encode at 0.4 megabytes per second and complex scenes at 1.2, and the question is which combinations of the two fit.

Name the two unknowns

Why: x is the number of seconds of standard video and y the number of seconds of high-quality video; those are the two quantities you are free to choose.

\[ x = \text{standard seconds}, \quad y = \text{high-quality seconds} \]

Write the verbal model as symbols

Why: each rate multiplies its own time to give megabytes, the two amounts add, and the total may be up to 300.

\[ 0.4x + 1.2y \le 300 \]

The phrase up to is what produces the at-most symbol. It allows the group to fill the space exactly, so equality is permitted and the boundary will be solid.

Find the boundary's intercepts

Why: put y equal to zero for all-standard video, then x equal to zero for all high-quality video.

\[ \frac{300}{0.4} = 750 \quad \text{and} \quad \frac{300}{1.2} = 250 \]

Those two numbers are worth reading as sentences. With nothing but normal scenes you get 750 seconds of video; with nothing but complex scenes you get 250. The high-quality rate is three times as expensive, so it buys a third as much time.

Test the origin

Why: the right-hand side is not zero, so the origin is off the boundary and available.

\[ 0.4(0) + 1.2(0) = 0 \le 300 \quad \text{true} \]

True, so shade the origin's side of the line, which is the side below it. Then cut the region down to the first quadrant, because neither x nor y can be negative.

Figure (svg): A first-quadrant graph with a solid line falling from two hundred and fifty on the vertical axis to seven hundred and fifty on the horizontal axis, the triangle below it shaded, and three solution points marked.

The line is every plan that fills the disc exactly; the shaded triangle is every plan that fits. Only the first quadrant is drawn, because negative seconds mean nothing.

Check a point on the boundary

Why: the pair 150 and 200 should use the space exactly: 0.4 times 150 is 60 megabytes, 1.2 times 200 is 240 megabytes, and together they make exactly 300.

\[ 0.4(150) + 1.2(200) = 60 + 240 = 300 \]

Because that point gives exactly 300 it lies on the boundary, and because the boundary is solid it is a legitimate plan. A group choosing it fills the disc to the last megabyte.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 134 — Example 4, Steps 1 and 2

57. Example 4 continued: three plans the group could choose

Worked example

Step three of the example asks for three solutions, which now costs nothing: any point of the shaded region will do, and checking one is a single line of arithmetic.

\[ 0.4x + 1.2y \le 300 \]

Take the plan on the boundary first

Why: 150 seconds of standard and 200 of high quality gives exactly the full 300 megabytes.

\[ 0.4(150) + 1.2(200) = 300 \le 300 \]

Take a plan with more standard video

Why: 300 seconds of standard and 120 of high quality: 120 megabytes plus 144 megabytes.

\[ 0.4(300) + 1.2(120) = 120 + 144 = 264 \le 300 \]

That plan leaves 36 megabytes unused, which is why it sits strictly inside the region rather than on its edge. Interior points are plans with room to spare.

Take a plan with much more standard video

Why: 600 seconds of standard and 25 of high quality: 240 megabytes plus 30 megabytes.

\[ 0.4(600) + 1.2(25) = 240 + 30 = 270 \le 300 \]

Notice what the three plans have in common and how they differ. All three fit, but only the first uses the disc fully, and the book makes exactly that observation about its own three answers.

This is the pay-off of drawing a region rather than solving an equation. An equation would have given you the plans that fill the disc exactly; the region gives you every plan that fits, which is the question that was actually asked.

Check that a plan just outside really fails

Why: try 600 seconds of standard and 60 of high quality: 240 megabytes plus 72 megabytes is 312, which exceeds the 300 available.

\[ 0.4(600) + 1.2(60) = 312 \not\le 300 \]

So the shading is doing real work: it is separating the plans that can be burned to the disc from the plans that cannot, and the boundary is exactly where that changes.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 134 — Example 4, Step 3

58. The region as a menu: read it one slice at a time

Picture it

A shaded region can feel like a vague answer. It becomes a very precise one the moment you fix one of the two quantities, because then it hands you a range for the other.

Figure (svg): The video-space region again, with a vertical line at three hundred seconds of standard video and the allowed heights along it drawn as a thick segment from zero up to a hundred and fifty.

Fix the standard video at 300 seconds and the region hands back a range: any amount of high-quality video from 0 up to 150 seconds, and no more.

Suppose the group commits to 300 seconds of normal footage. That uses 120 of the 300 megabytes, leaving 180, and at 1.2 megabytes a second that buys at most 150 seconds of complex footage.

\[ 0.4(300) = 120, \quad 300 - 120 = 180, \quad \frac{180}{1.2} = 150 \]

The thick segment is that answer drawn: every height from 0 up to 150 is available, and the point where it stops is on the boundary, where the disc is exactly full. The book's plan of 120 seconds sits inside the segment with space to spare.

So the region is not one answer but a whole family of them, indexed by whichever quantity you decide first. That is why a constraint is drawn rather than solved: you are being shown every option at once.

Slicing the other way works identically. Fix the high-quality footage at 200 seconds and the same arithmetic gives at most 150 seconds of standard footage, which is the horizontal slice through the same region.

59. Wording to symbol

Matching

Modelling goes wrong at the translation far more often than at the algebra, and usually on one phrase. Match each English phrase to the symbol it produces, and say the phrase to yourself as you decide.

Match the pairs

  • a. up to 300 megabytes
  • b. more than 1800 dollars in sales
  • c. at least 200 dollars earned
  • d. fewer than 20 hours worked
  • w. ≤ 300
  • x. > 1800
  • y. ≥ 200
  • z. < 20

Why: Up to and at most both include the stated value, so they allow equality and give a solid boundary. More than and fewer than exclude it, so they are strict and give a dashed boundary. At least is the inclusive version of more than, which is why earning exactly two hundred dollars counts as success but selling exactly eighteen hundred dollars worth does not exceed eighteen hundred.

The pair to be careful with is more than against at least. They point the same way but differ on the boundary itself, and that difference is the whole dashed-or-solid decision in your final graph.

A phrase worth watching for is no more than, which means the same as at most despite containing the word more. Read the whole phrase rather than reacting to one word in it.

When a question uses a phrase you are unsure of, test the boundary value in the sentence. Ask whether spending exactly three hundred megabytes is allowed, and the symbol follows immediately.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 137 — Exercises 43 to 47, where each constraint arrives as a phrase

60. Guided Practice 11: the same class, more space

Real world

The book's checkpoint changes one number and asks for the whole problem again. That is the ideal way to find out whether you own the method or only remember the answer.

Discussion prompt

Repeat Example 4 for a group allotted up to 420 megabytes instead of 300. Write the inequality, give both intercepts of the boundary, say whether it is dashed or solid and which side is shaded, and give one plan that uses the space exactly.

The shape of the region is identical to Example 4's; only its size changed. That is worth noticing, because it means the trade-off between the two kinds of video is a property of the rates rather than of the disc.

The trade-off is readable straight off the slope. One second of complex video costs three times what a second of normal video costs, so giving up three seconds of standard buys you one more second of high quality.

Try the same trick on the original example with 600 megabytes and check your intercepts double. A model you can rescale without redoing the thinking is a model you understand.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 135 — Guided Practice 11

61. Exercise 44: 4800 ounces of pizza dough

Worked example

A pizza shop has 300 pounds of dough, which is 4800 ounces. A small pizza uses 12 ounces and a large one uses 18, and the question is which combinations can be made.

Name the two unknowns

Why: x is the number of small pizzas and y the number of large ones, and both are whole numbers that cannot be negative.

\[ x = \text{small pizzas}, \quad y = \text{large pizzas} \]

Write the model

Why: each pizza uses its own weight of dough, the two amounts add, and the total cannot exceed the 4800 ounces available.

\[ 12x + 18y \le 4800 \]

Find the intercepts

Why: all small pizzas uses 4800 divided by 12, and all large uses 4800 divided by 18.

\[ \frac{4800}{12} = 400 \quad \text{and} \quad \frac{4800}{18} = 266\tfrac23 \]

The second intercept is not a whole number, which tells you something real: 266 large pizzas use 4788 ounces and leave 12 ounces, exactly enough for one small pizza and not enough for another large one.

Decide the stroke and test the origin

Why: cannot exceed allows equality, so the boundary is solid; the origin gives zero ounces of dough used, which is at most 4800.

\[ 12(0) + 18(0) = 0 \le 4800 \quad \text{true} \]

So shade the origin's side, below the line, and keep only the first quadrant. Making no pizzas at all is a legal use of the dough, if a poor business decision.

Figure (svg): A first-quadrant graph with a solid line from about two hundred and sixty-seven large pizzas down to four hundred small pizzas, the region below it shaded, and three points marked on and under the line.

Everything under the line is a batch the shop can actually make; the line itself uses every ounce of the dough. The corner uses it all on small pizzas.

Check three plans, one of them on the boundary

Why: a hundred of each uses 1200 plus 1800 ounces; two hundred small and a hundred large uses 2400 plus 1800; and four hundred small with no large uses every ounce.

\[ 3000 \le 4800, \quad 4200 \le 4800, \quad 12(400) = 4800 \]

The first two plans leave dough over and sit strictly inside the region, and the third sits exactly on the boundary. All three are solutions, which is precisely what a solid boundary records.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 137 — Exercise 44

62. How many large pizzas, if a hundred small ones are promised?

Estimation

Estimate before you calculate. A hundred small pizzas are already promised, so some of the dough is spoken for and the question is what the rest will buy.

Predict first

With 4800 ounces of dough and 100 small pizzas already promised, what is the greatest number of large pizzas the shop can still make?

  • 100 large pizzas
  • 200 large pizzas
  • 266 large pizzas
  • 300 large pizzas

Correct: 200 large pizzas

Why: A hundred small pizzas use 1200 ounces, leaving 3600 ounces. Each large pizza takes 18 ounces, and 3600 divided by 18 is exactly 200, so two hundred large pizzas use the remaining dough precisely. The figure of 266 is what all the dough would buy if no small pizzas were made at all, which is the vertical intercept rather than the answer to this question.

\[ 12(100) = 1200, \quad 4800 - 1200 = 3600, \quad \frac{3600}{18} = 200 \]

Geometrically you have just walked along a vertical line. Fixing the number of small pizzas at a hundred picks out one vertical slice of the region, and the answer is where that slice meets the boundary.

That is a useful way to use any region like this. Fix one quantity, read the slice, and the boundary hands you the largest value the other quantity may take.

The wrong answer worth understanding is the one that uses the whole 4800 ounces. It ignores the hundred small pizzas entirely, and it is the answer to the question with nothing promised.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 137 — Exercise 44

63. Two constraints at once, and the region that satisfies both

Worked example

Real problems rarely arrive one constraint at a time. Suppose one job pays 12 dollars an hour and another pays 15, you may work at most 20 hours in a week, and you need to earn at least 200 dollars. This example is mine, and it is where Lesson 3.3 begins.

Write the earnings constraint

Why: twelve dollars for each hour at the first job plus fifteen for each hour at the second must reach at least 200.

\[ 12x + 15y \ge 200 \]

Write the time constraint

Why: the two numbers of hours together may be at most 20.

\[ x + y \le 20 \]

Graph the first boundary and test the origin

Why: its intercepts are 200 over 12, which is about 16.7, and 200 over 15, which is about 13.3; the origin earns nothing, which is not at least 200.

\[ 12(0) + 15(0) = 0 \not\ge 200 \quad \text{false} \]

False, so that region is shaded away from the origin: you must work enough hours to clear 200 dollars, and the origin is the plan of working none at all.

Graph the second boundary and test the origin

Why: its intercepts are both 20, and the origin uses no hours at all, which is certainly at most 20.

\[ 0 + 0 = 0 \le 20 \quad \text{true} \]

True, so the time region is shaded on the origin's side. The two shadings now point in opposite directions, and only where they overlap does a week satisfy both demands.

Figure (svg): A first-quadrant graph with two lines: one falling from thirteen and a third on the vertical axis and one falling from twenty. The region above the first and below the second is shaded twice over, and an interior point is marked.

The blue region earns enough; the orange region fits in the week. The bright overlap is the set of weeks that manage both, and its corners are the extreme plans.

The overlap is the bright quadrilateral, and its corners are the extreme plans: the shortest week that still earns enough, the longest week allowed, and the two plans that use a single job only.

Check a point in the overlap

Why: take ten hours at the first job and eight at the second: twelve tens plus fifteen eights is 240 dollars, which is at least 200, and ten plus eight is 18 hours, which is at most 20.

\[ 12(10) + 15(8) = 240 \ge 200, \quad 10 + 8 = 18 \le 20 \]

Both statements come out true, which is what belonging to an overlap means. A point outside it fails at least one of them, and Lesson 3.3 is about finding such overlaps deliberately.

OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §11.3 Systems of Nonlinear Equations and Inequalities: Two Variables §11.3 — systems of inequalities in two variables, where overlapping regions are the subject

64. Putting it together

Section

Part 7

65. The procedure, and the two decisions inside it

Pattern

Every graph in this lesson came out of the same two decisions, taken in the same order, and neither of them is a judgement call. Here they are as one picture and one checklist.

Figure (svg): A decision tree starting from the inequality, branching left for a strict symbol to a dashed boundary and right for an inclusive symbol to a solid boundary, both feeding into a single test-point box that branches into two shadings.

The symbol decides only the stroke of the boundary. Once the line is drawn, the symbol has nothing left to say and the test point takes over.
  1. Replace the symbol with an equals sign and graph that boundary. Intercepts are usually the quickest route, and a vertex if the boundary bends.
  2. Choose the stroke from the symbol: dashed for less than and greater than, solid for at most and at least. This is the only job the symbol has.
  3. Pick a point that is not on the boundary. Use the origin unless the right-hand side is zero, which is exactly when the boundary runs through it.
  4. Substitute and read the verdict. True shades the point's own side; false shades the other. Never shade from the symbol.
  5. Cut the region down if the context demands it, to the first quadrant when negative values are meaningless, and check one point inside and one outside.

The fourth line is the one that saves marks. Twice in this lesson the symbol pointed one way and the truth lay the other way, in both cases because the coefficient of y was negative.

The last line is what separates a correct graph from a correct answer. A region that includes negative numbers of pizzas is not wrong algebraically and is useless practically, and a question about a real limit expects the sensible part.

Nothing in the checklist mentions straight lines, which is why it survived Part 5 unchanged. Any boundary that separates the plane into two pieces can be handled by the same five instructions.

66. Check: which pair is not a solution?

Check

Read the question carefully, because it asks which pair fails rather than which succeeds. Test all four and keep the one that produces a false statement.

Check your understanding

Which ordered pair is not a solution of 3x − 5y < 30?

  • A. (0, 0)
  • B. (−1, 7)
  • C. (1, −7) (correct)
  • D. (−5, −5)

Answer: C

Why: The pair with a positive x and a negative y gives 3 plus 35, which is 38, and 38 is not less than 30. The others give 0, minus 38 and 10, all comfortably under 30. Notice that subtracting a negative y adds, which is why a negative second coordinate is the one that pushes this expression up.

Why A tempts people
The origin makes both terms vanish, leaving 0, which is less than 30, so it is a solution.
Why B tempts people
Minus 3 minus 35 is minus 38, which is far less than 30, so this pair is a solution.
Why D tempts people
Minus 15 plus 25 is 10, which is less than 30, so this pair is a solution too.

The trap in a not-a-solution question is answering the question you expected. Three of these are solutions, so if you stop at the first pair that works you will give a wrong answer with full confidence.

The arithmetic worth being careful with is the term with the minus five in front. Wherever y is negative that term becomes positive and the total grows, which is how the failing pair reached 38.

Geometrically the failing pair is the only one on the far side of the boundary line, and the other three all sit on the origin's side of it. One substitution each, four verdicts, no drawing needed.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 136 — Exercise 21

67. Check: the boundary and the side

Check

This one asks for both decisions at once. Work out the stroke from the symbol, then test the origin, and only then look at the options.

Check your understanding

What does the graph of 2x + 5y ≤ −10 look like?

  • A. A solid boundary, shaded on the side away from the origin (correct)
  • B. A dashed boundary, shaded on the side away from the origin
  • C. A solid boundary, shaded on the side containing the origin
  • D. A dashed boundary, shaded on the side containing the origin

Answer: A

Why: The symbol allows equality, so the boundary is solid. Substituting the origin gives 0, and 0 is not at most minus 10, so the origin is not a solution and the shading goes on the other side. The boundary passes through minus 5 on the horizontal axis and minus 2 on the vertical axis, so the shaded region is the one below and left of it.

Why B tempts people
The stroke is wrong: at most allows equality, so the points of the boundary are solutions and the line must be solid.
Why C tempts people
The side is wrong: the origin gives 0, which is not at most minus 10, so the origin's side is the unshaded one.
Why D tempts people
Both decisions are wrong here, and each one is wrong for its own reason: the symbol allows equality, and the origin fails the test.

If you chose an option shading the origin's side, check the substitution again rather than the picture. Zero is greater than minus ten, so the origin cannot satisfy an inequality demanding at most minus ten.

Notice that the two decisions really are independent. Getting the stroke right tells you nothing about the side, and getting the side right tells you nothing about the stroke, which is why four options exist at all.

A sketch confirms it in seconds. Both intercepts are negative, so the whole boundary sits down and to the left of the origin, and the region below it is the one that misses the origin.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 135 — Exercise 18

68. Check: turning a limit into an inequality

Check

Back to modelling, where the most common error is a wrong symbol rather than wrong arithmetic. Read the sentence and ask what may be spent and what may not.

Check your understanding

A pizza shop has 4800 ounces of dough. A small pizza uses 12 ounces and a large one uses 18. Which inequality describes the possible numbers of small pizzas x and large pizzas y?

  • A. 12x + 18y ≤ 4800 (correct)
  • B. 12x + 18y ≥ 4800
  • C. 18x + 12y ≤ 4800
  • D. 12x + 18y = 4800

Answer: A

Why: Each small pizza consumes 12 ounces and each large one 18, so the dough used is 12x plus 18y, and the shop cannot use more than it has. The total may equal 4800, when every ounce is used, so the symbol allows equality and the boundary is solid.

Why B tempts people
This demands at least 4800 ounces be used, which is more dough than the shop owns; it describes the impossible plans rather than the possible ones.
Why C tempts people
The two weights have been swapped, so this charges 18 ounces for a small pizza and 12 for a large one.
Why D tempts people
An equation allows only the plans that use every single ounce, and leaves out every plan with dough left over.

The swapped-weights option is worth a moment. It is the mistake you make when you write the numbers down in the order they appear in the sentence rather than attaching each one to its own variable.

The equation option is the most interesting wrong answer, because it is not false, merely too narrow. It describes the boundary alone, and the question asked for the whole region.

Guard against both by naming your variables in writing before you write the model, then reading your model back as an English sentence and comparing it with the question.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 137 — Exercise 44

69. Explain the two decisions in your own words

Explain it to yourself

One paragraph, in your own sentences, and written before you read the answer. If you can produce it from memory tomorrow, you own this lesson.

Discussion prompt

Explain to somebody a year behind you how to graph a linear inequality in two variables. Name the two decisions, say which piece of information settles each, and explain why shading above for a greater-than symbol is not safe advice.

If your explanation ran to more than about a hundred words, look for the sentence where you started describing a particular example. The procedure itself is short, and its shortness is the thing worth teaching.

If you wrote that the symbol decides the shading, reread Example 3(b). That deck slide exists because the belief is so natural and so wrong, and the graph there has an at-most symbol with a region above the line.

Try explaining it once with no pictures and once with a sketch beside you. The version you find easier tells you which half of your understanding needs the most work.

70. Exit ticket

Exit ticket

One problem that uses every part of the lesson: a model, a boundary, a stroke, a test point, a sensible region, and some solutions.

\[ 2x + 3y \le 20 \]

Discussion prompt

A mini-car raceway gift pass carries 20 credits. The Rally track costs 2 credits a race and the Grand Prix track costs 3. Say what x and y stand for, confirm the inequality above, state the boundary equation and its stroke, give your test point and its verdict, and finish with three possible solutions, one of which uses every credit.

Work it in the order the lesson taught, and write each decision down rather than holding it in your head. The stroke comes from the symbol, the side comes from the origin, and the first quadrant comes from the context.

The vertical intercept is not a whole number, which is a real feature of the problem rather than a mistake. Six Grand Prix races use eighteen credits and leave two, which is exactly one Rally race.

If you gave three solutions and none of them used every credit, go back and look for the boundary. Solutions on a solid boundary are the ones that spend the resource exactly, and questions very often ask for one.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables §2.8, p. 138 — the Lesson 2.7 to 2.8 Quiz, question 10

71. What you can do now

Recap

An inequality in two variables has a region for its answer, and you can now produce that region for any linear inequality, and for an absolute value one as well, by taking two decisions in order.

the questionwhat settles itthe record on the graph
Is this pair a solution?substitute both coordinatesthe point is inside or outside the shading
Where is the edge?replace the symbol with =the boundary line, drawn from its intercepts
Do the edge's points count?the symbol: strict or inclusivea dashed line, or a solid one
Which half is the answer?one test point, substitutedthe shading, on that point's side or the other
Is the whole half sensible?the context and its unitsthe region cut down, often to the first quadrant

\[ \text{test } (0,0) \text{ unless the right-hand side is } 0 \]

That one line is the most useful thing to memorise. The origin is available exactly when the number on the right is not zero, and when it is unavailable, any point clearly off the boundary will do instead.

The habit to carry forward is distrust of the symbol as a guide to direction. It tells you the stroke of the line and nothing else, and the two examples where it appeared to promise a side were both cases where it lied.

Lesson 3.3 takes the next step. Several inequalities at once, all of their regions on one set of axes, and the answer being the overlap, exactly as in the two-job example. The corners of that overlap turn out to matter more than its interior, which is where linear programming starts.

OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §11.3 Systems of Nonlinear Equations and Inequalities: Two Variables §11.3 — the same regions and their overlaps, treated as systems of inequalities

Sources

  1. McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 2 Linear Equations and Functions — Lesson 2.8 Graph Linear Inequalities in Two Variables — Larson, Boswell, Kanold & Stiff, McDougal Littell / Houghton Mifflin, 2007, pp. 132-137
  2. OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §11.3 Systems of Nonlinear Equations and Inequalities: Two Variables
  3. OpenStax College Algebra 2e, §7.3 Systems of Nonlinear Equations and Inequalities: Two Variables

Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Algebra 2 — $55/session, free consultation.

Book on Wyzant · Text (657) 465-8108