Simple and compound inequalities, their graphs with open and solid endpoints, the transformations that preserve them, the rule that reverses the symbol when you multiply or divide by a negative, and modelling a range of acceptable values.
Subject: Algebra 2 · 75 slides · symbolic lesson
Open the interactive version of this deck
Title
Algebra 2 · Lesson 1.6
One symbol changes, and the answer stops being a number and becomes a stretch of the number line
Objectives
You have spent five lessons solving equations, and every one of them ended with a single number. Change the equals sign to a less-than sign and almost nothing about the method changes, but the answer does: instead of one value, you get every value in a whole stretch of the number line.
That is why this lesson comes with a picture attached to every answer. A solution set is too big to write out, so you draw it, and the drawing has to say exactly where the stretch begins and whether the number at that edge is in or out.
One rule in this lesson has no counterpart in equation solving, and it is the one that costs marks: multiply or divide by a negative number and the symbol turns round. Part 3 spends four slides showing you why that happens rather than asking you to memorise it.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 41 — Before, Now, Why and the Key Vocabulary
Warm-up
Start with an equation you can already solve, then change one character in it. Write both answers down before reading on, because the comparison is only worth something if you have committed to it.
\[ 2x + 7 = 19 \qquad \text{and} \qquad 2x + 7 < 19 \]
Discussion prompt
Solve each one, and describe the difference between the two answers in a sentence.
Notice what you did not have to change. Subtracting the same number from both sides and dividing both sides by the same positive number are legal on an inequality for the same reason they are legal on an equation: they do not disturb which values make the statement true.
The one thing you now owe the reader is a way of presenting an answer with infinitely many values in it. Writing it as a formula, less than 6, is one way; drawing it is the other, and Part 1 is about drawing it properly.
Hold on to the number 6 for a moment. In the equation it was the answer. In the inequality it is not an answer at all, since two sixes plus seven is nineteen, not less than nineteen. The boundary value and the solutions are different things.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 42 — the transformations that produce equivalent inequalities
Concept
An equation asks which value makes two expressions equal. An inequality asks which values make one expression smaller, or larger, than another, and there are usually far too many of them to name one at a time.
solution of an inequality — A value that makes the inequality a true statement when it is substituted for the variable. The graph of the inequality is every point on the number line that represents a solution.
Read that definition twice, because it hands you a test you can run on any number at any moment. Put the number in. If what comes out is true, the number belongs to the answer; if it comes out false, it does not. No judgement, no guessing.
\[ \text{Is } 4 \text{ a solution of } 2x + 7 < 19? \quad 2(4) + 7 = 15 < 19 \;\checkmark \]
That test is the safety net for this entire lesson. Whenever an answer looks doubtful, or a symbol may have turned round when it should not have, pick one number from inside your answer and one from outside, and let the arithmetic settle it.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 41 — the definitions of solution and graph
Section
Part 1
Notation
The book opens by naming the family you are working in. It is worth reading slowly, because the conditions in it explain why every answer in this lesson is one stretch of the line rather than something more complicated.
Annotate
On: \( ax + b < 0, \quad ax + b > 0, \quad ax + b \le 0, \quad ax + b \ge 0 \)
You will rarely be handed an inequality already arranged in one of those four shapes, and you do not need to be. Every inequality you meet here can be pushed into one of them by the same collecting and simplifying you did in Lesson 1.3.
The word strict is worth adopting now. A strict symbol excludes the boundary, an inclusive one includes it, and almost every mistake in Part 1 is an inclusive answer drawn with a strict dot or the other way round.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 41 — the definition of a linear inequality in one variable
Concept
Here is the entire notation for graphing a simple inequality. An arrow shows the direction that is shaded, and a dot at the boundary shows whether that one number joins the party.
Figure (svg): Two number lines. The left one is shaded to the left of 2 with a hollow dot at 2; the right one is shaded to the right of minus one with a solid dot at minus one.
On the left, every number below 2 is a solution and 2 itself is not, so the dot is drawn hollow: the shading arrives at 2 and stops just short of it. On the right, minus one is a solution, so the dot is filled in and the shading starts there.
The arrowhead at the end of each shaded part is not decoration. It says that the shading carries on forever in that direction, past the edge of the paper, which is the honest way to draw a set with no far end.
That last line is worth saying because of a habit people bring from reading the symbol as an arrowhead. The direction of the shading comes from testing a number, not from which way the symbol appears to point.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 41 — Example 1 and its two graphs
Worked example
Both parts of the book's first example are answered by the same two decisions: which side of the boundary gets shaded, and which dot goes on the boundary. Take them in that order every time.
\[ \text{(a)}\; x < 2 \qquad \text{(b)}\; x \ge -1 \]
Mark the boundary of part (a)
Why: the only number mentioned is 2, so that is where the shading has to change.
\[ \text{boundary at } x = 2 \]
Decide the direction by testing a number
Why: zero is easy to test and lies to the left, and it works, so the left side is shaded.
\[ 0 < 2 \;\checkmark \qquad 3 < 2 \;\times \]
Testing beats remembering. One easy number on each side of the boundary tells you which way to shade without any reliance on how the symbol looks.
Choose the dot for part (a)
Why: the symbol is strict, so 2 is not a solution and the dot is left open.
\[ 2 < 2 \text{ is false} \]
Do the same for part (b)
Why: the boundary is minus one, the symbol is inclusive, and testing zero shows the shading runs to the right.
\[ -1 \ge -1 \;\checkmark \qquad 0 \ge -1 \;\checkmark \]
Check both graphs against the definition
Why: a graph is every point representing a solution: minus one belongs to part (b) and is drawn solid, while 2 does not belong to part (a) and is drawn hollow. Compare your two drawings with the ones on the previous slide.
\[ \text{(a) hollow at } 2, \qquad \text{(b) solid at } -1 \]
Say each graph aloud as a sentence before you move on. All the real numbers less than 2, and all the real numbers greater than or equal to minus one: if the words match the picture, the picture is right.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 41 — Example 1
Concept
These two inequalities have the same boundary and shade the same direction. Everything that distinguishes them happens at one single point, which is why that point deserves a careful decision rather than a quick one.
Figure (svg): Two number lines with the same endpoint 3. The upper one has a hollow dot at 3, the lower a solid dot, and each carries the result of putting 3 into its own inequality.
The test is mechanical. Substitute the boundary value into the inequality exactly as written. Three is not less than three, so the upper graph loses its endpoint; three is less than or equal to three, so the lower graph keeps it.
It is worth noticing how little separates the two answers in size. They differ by exactly one number out of infinitely many, and yet a question about a minimum charge, a legal speed limit or a passing grade can turn entirely on whether that one number is included.
If you are ever unsure in the middle of a problem, do not guess from the shape of the symbol. Put the boundary number in and read what comes out, which takes about three seconds and is never ambiguous.
Sorting
Run the endpoint test on six inequalities in a row. For each one ask the same question: if you put the boundary number in for x, do you get a true statement or a false one?
Sort into buckets
Sort each inequality by the dot its graph needs at the boundary.
Two of the six are written back to front, with the number on the left. That changes nothing about the dot, because the dot depends only on whether the symbol is strict, and it is the same symbol whichever way round you read it.
It does change the direction of the shading, though, and that is worth being careful about. Six is greater than or equal to x says the same thing as x is at most 6, so the shading runs to the left, not the right.
If a back-to-front inequality makes you hesitate, rewrite it with the variable on the left before drawing anything. Turning it round costs one line and removes the commonest source of a graph shaded the wrong way.
Concept
Two of the inequalities you just sorted were written with the number on the left. That arrangement is common in textbooks and in the middle of a solution, and it is worth handling deliberately rather than hoping.
\[ 6 \ge x \qquad \text{means} \qquad x \le 6 \]
An inequality can be read from either end, as long as the symbol is read in the direction you are travelling. Left to right, the first line says six is greater than or equal to x. Right to left, it says x is at most 6, and those are the same claim about the same numbers.
The dot does not care which way round you write it. Six is still included, because the symbol is still inclusive, and turning a statement round never changes a strict symbol into an inclusive one or the other way about.
What does change is what your eye expects. People draw the shading in the direction the symbol seems to point, and on a back-to-front inequality that instinct shades the wrong half of the line.
\[ -2 < x \qquad \text{means} \qquad x > -2 \]
So make it a habit: before drawing anything, rewrite the inequality with the variable on the left. It costs one line, and it removes the single most common cause of a graph shaded the wrong way.
This matters more than it looks, because solving frequently produces a back-to-front line. Guided Practice 7 in Part 3 ends with minus seven at most x, and that is exactly the moment to turn it round.
Worked example
These are the book's first two checkpoints. Work each one with the same two decisions, and notice that one of the boundaries is negative, which changes nothing about the method but does change where on the line you draw.
\[ \text{(1)}\; x > -5 \qquad \text{(2)}\; x \le 3 \]
Test the boundary of the first
Why: minus five is not greater than minus five, so the endpoint is excluded and the dot is open.
\[ -5 > -5 \text{ is false} \]
Test a number to find the direction
Why: zero lies to the right of minus five and satisfies the inequality, so the shading runs right.
\[ 0 > -5 \;\checkmark \]
Negative boundaries trip people up for a reason worth naming: minus five sits to the LEFT of zero, so the numbers greater than it are the ones between it and zero and everything beyond. Larger still means further right, even among negatives.
Test the boundary of the second
Why: three is less than or equal to three, so the endpoint is included and the dot is solid.
\[ 3 \le 3 \;\checkmark \]
Test a number for the direction
Why: zero satisfies it and lies to the left of 3, so that side is shaded.
\[ 0 \le 3 \;\checkmark \]
Figure (svg): Two number lines. The left is shaded to the right of minus five with a hollow dot there; the right is shaded to the left of 3 with a solid dot at 3.
Check each graph with a number from outside
Why: minus six fails the first, and four fails the second, so neither shaded region has been drawn too far. Both endpoints match the symbols they came from.
\[ -6 > -5 \;\times \qquad 4 \le 3 \;\times \]
One value inside and one outside is the complete check for a graph. The inside value proves you shaded the right way, and the outside value proves you did not shade too much.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 41 — Guided Practice 1 and 2
Matching
Four symbols, four English phrasings, and the dot each one produces. Match them without drawing anything, because being able to move between the three representations quickly is what makes the word problems in Part 5 readable.
Match the pairs
Why: The symbol gives the direction and the dot together. Fewer than and more than are strict, so those two get hollow dots; at least and at most include the boundary, so those two get solid dots. The words at most and at least are the ones worth memorising, because they are how real problems phrase an inclusive limit.
The two phrases doing the most work here are at most and at least. A shop that sells at most twenty tickets can sell exactly twenty, and a ride requiring at least a metre of height admits somebody exactly a metre tall, so both of those are solid dots.
Fewer than and more than behave the opposite way. A rule saying fewer than twenty people may enter excludes the twentieth person, and that exclusion is the hollow dot in the picture.
Keep this triangle of representations in mind for the rest of the lesson: the symbols, the English, and the picture. Every question in Part 5 arrives as English and has to leave as at least two of the other three.
Translation
Exercises 11 to 14 run the process backwards. A graph is put in front of you and you write the compound inequality it represents, which means reading the dots and the arrows rather than drawing them.
Figure (svg): Four small number lines. The first is shaded between minus three and 1 with solid dots; the second shades left of 1 and right of 3; the third shades outside minus two and 4; the fourth shades between minus three and 9.
Match the pairs
Why: Read each graph in two steps. First, is the shading one band or two separate pieces? A band is an and-inequality written in three parts; two pieces is an or. Second, take each endpoint on its own: a solid dot gives an inclusive symbol and a hollow dot a strict one. Graph 1 and graph 4 are bands; graph 2 and graph 3 are pairs of pieces, and graph 2 is the one whose two dots differ.
The hardest of the four is the one with a solid dot at one end and a hollow dot at the other. There is no rule that says both ends must match, and the two ends of a real range very often do not.
Notice also that the tick spacing changes from graph to graph. Two of these count in ones and two do not, so read the numbers printed under the line rather than counting tick marks.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 45 — Exercises 11 to 14
Trap
Asked to graph x less than 4, a very common drawing:
\[ x < 4 \]
A filled dot at 4, with the shading running left from it. The direction is right and the shape is right, so at a glance the picture looks finished.
The reasoning behind it is usually this: 4 is the number in the question, so 4 must be part of the answer. The number in the question is the boundary, though, which is a different job.
Substitute the boundary into the inequality as written and the drawing corrects itself.
\[ 4 < 4 \text{ is false} \]
Four is not less than four, so 4 is not a solution, so it cannot be part of the graph. The dot has to be hollow, and the shading arrives at 4 without reaching it.
The same slip in reverse costs just as much. Drawing x at most 4 with a hollow dot throws away the one value the word most was there to include, and in a problem about a budget or a speed limit that value is often the whole question.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 41 — the note beside Example 1 on open and solid dots
Socratic
Graphing can feel like decoration when the symbolic answer is already written down. It is not, and arguing the case for yourself is worth more than being told.
Discussion prompt
You have solved an inequality and written x is less than 6. Give two things the drawn graph tells a reader that the written answer does not make obvious, and say why that matters when the answer is a range of prices or temperatures.
There is a practical reason too. Part 2 asks you to combine two inequalities, and combining them is far easier to do correctly on a picture, where overlapping is something you can see, than in symbols, where it is something you have to imagine.
So treat the graph as part of the answer rather than an illustration of it. Every solved inequality in this deck is drawn, and every drawing is checked with one number from inside it.
Section
Part 2
Concept
Most real conditions have two edges rather than one. A temperature is comfortable between two values; a delivery van is too light or too heavy; a sale price lies inside a band. The book gives one name to all of these.
compound inequality — Two simple inequalities joined by the word and or the word or.
The joining word is not a detail. It decides whether you keep the numbers that satisfy both parts or the numbers that satisfy at least one of them, and those two sets can look nothing like each other.
\[ -1 < x < 2 \qquad \text{and} \qquad x \le -2 \;\text{ or }\; x > 1 \]
The first of those is written in a compressed three-part form that only works for and. Reading it aloud as x is greater than minus one AND x is less than 2 is the book's own advice, and it is the reading to use every time until it becomes automatic.
The second cannot be compressed, and Part 2 will show you what goes wrong when people try. An or-condition describes two separate stretches of the line, and no three-part expression can describe two separate stretches.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 41 — the definition of a compound inequality
Picture it
Build an and-inequality out of its two halves rather than treating it as a single new object. Draw each half on its own line, then keep only the numbers that both lines had shaded.
Figure (svg): Three stacked number lines. The first is shaded right of minus one, the second left of 2, and the third shows only the stretch between them, where both shadings overlap.
Look at the two dashed verticals. To the left of the first one only the orange line is shaded, to the right of the second only the blue one is, and between them both are shaded, which is why the bottom line carries shading only there.
The result is one unbroken band with two ends. That shape is the signature of an and-inequality, and it is why the compressed three-part notation exists: a band has exactly two numbers worth naming, so you write one at each side of the x.
Each end keeps the dot it arrived with. Here both halves were strict, so both ends of the band are hollow, but a band with a solid end at one side and a hollow end at the other is perfectly normal and will turn up in Example 5.
Worked example
The book's first compound graph. Treat it as two graphs drawn on top of each other, then keep what they share, exactly as the previous slide did.
\[ -1 < x < 2 \]
Split the three-part form into its two halves
Why: the middle term belongs to both statements, so x appears in each of them.
\[ x > -1 \quad \text{and} \quad x < 2 \]
Reading the left-hand piece takes care. The printed statement is minus one is less than x, and turning it round gives x is greater than minus one, which is the form that is easy to draw.
Graph each half separately
Why: one hollow dot at minus one shading right, one hollow dot at 2 shading left.
\[ \text{both symbols are strict} \]
Keep only what both halves shade
Why: a number must clear both tests to be a solution, so the answer is the stretch between the two boundaries.
\[ -1 < x < 2 \]
Check three values, one inside and one on each side
Why: zero passes both halves; minus two fails the first; 3 fails the second. So the band is in the right place and neither end is included.
\[ 0: \; -1 < 0 < 2 \;\checkmark \qquad -2: \; -1 < -2 \;\times \qquad 3: \; 3 < 2 \;\times \]
Testing a value from each side as well as from the middle is what proves a band rather than a ray. A ray would have passed one of those outside tests.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 41 — Example 2a
Notation
This compressed notation saves a great deal of writing later, so decode it once, carefully, rather than pattern-matching on it.
Annotate
On: \( -1 < x < 2 \)
That last note is a real error, not a hypothetical one. A three-part inequality whose outer numbers are in the wrong order describes an empty set, and the usual cause is copying the two numbers down in the order they appeared in the question.
One habit protects you completely: after writing a three-part inequality, glance at the two outer numbers and check that the left one is the smaller. If it is not, the statement is either empty or was meant to be an or.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 41 — the Read Inequalities note
Picture it
Now the other joining word, built the same way. Draw the two halves, then keep every number that at least one of them shaded.
Figure (svg): Three stacked number lines. The first is shaded left of minus two with a solid dot, the second right of 1 with a hollow dot, and the third carries both shadings at once with a gap between them.
Nothing is discarded here. The bottom line carries the left-hand shading and the right-hand shading together, so the answer is two separate pieces with a stretch of unshaded line between them.
That gap is the part worth staring at. A number sitting in the gap, such as zero, satisfies neither half: it is not at most minus two and it is not greater than 1, so it is in neither piece of the answer.
Because the answer has two pieces, it needs two separate statements to describe it, joined by the word or. There is no way to squeeze it into the three-part form, and the next trap slide shows what happens when somebody tries.
Worked example
The book's or-example. Solve nothing; simply draw each half and keep both, watching the two dots, which are not the same as each other.
\[ x \le -2 \;\text{ or }\; x > 1 \]
Graph the first half
Why: at most minus two is inclusive, so the dot at minus two is solid and the shading runs left.
\[ -2 \le -2 \;\checkmark \]
Graph the second half
Why: greater than 1 is strict, so the dot at 1 is hollow and the shading runs right.
\[ 1 > 1 \text{ is false} \]
Two different symbols in one compound inequality is normal. Each half brings its own dot, and there is no rule that makes them agree.
Keep both pieces on one line
Why: a solution of an or-inequality needs to satisfy only one of the halves, so both shadings survive onto the final graph.
\[ x \le -2 \;\text{ or }\; x > 1 \]
Check one value in each piece and one in the gap
Why: minus three satisfies the first half, 2 satisfies the second, and zero satisfies neither, so the gap really is empty.
\[ -3 \le -2 \;\checkmark \qquad 2 > 1 \;\checkmark \qquad 0: \text{ neither} \;\times \]
The value in the gap is the one that earns its keep. It proves the answer is two pieces rather than one band, which a value from inside either piece could never show.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 41 — Example 2b
Discrimination
Six compound inequalities, three possible shapes. Decide each one from the joining word and the position of the two boundaries, before drawing anything.
Sort into buckets
Sort each compound inequality by the shape of its graph.
The last item is the interesting one. Asking for a number at least 3 and at most 3 leaves exactly one number, so the band has collapsed to a single point, which is still an answer and still gets drawn, as one solid dot.
The empty case is worth being comfortable with too. An inequality with no solutions is not a mistake in the question; it is a genuine answer, and Part 4 will produce a few of them algebraically.
Notice that you sorted all six without drawing a single number line. Comparing the two boundaries and reading the joining word is enough, which is the speed you want by the end of the lesson.
Prediction
This is Exercise 15, a multiple-choice question that turns entirely on reading two dots correctly. Look at the picture first and write your own answer before reading the options.
Figure (svg): A number line shaded to the left of minus one with a hollow dot there, and shaded to the right of 3 with a solid dot there.
Predict first
Which compound inequality is graphed here?
Correct: x < −1 or x ≥ 3
Why: The two arrows point away from each other, so the graph is two pieces and the joining word is or, which rules out the band. The dot at minus one is hollow, so that half is strict; the dot at 3 is solid, so that half is inclusive. Only one option gets both dots right. The option offering a band is tempting only if you read the arrows without looking at where they point, and the last option, which shades everything, is what you get by pairing both symbols the wrong way round.
The option that shades the whole line deserves a second look, because it shows how a plausible-looking or-statement can say nothing at all. Every number is either greater than minus one or at most 3, so that statement is true of every number and its graph would be entirely shaded.
The band option fails on shape before you even reach the dots. A band is shaded between its two endpoints, and this graph is shaded outside them, which is the opposite picture.
So the reading order that works is: arrows first for the shape, dots second for the symbols. Get the shape wrong and no amount of care over the dots will rescue the answer.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 45 — Exercise 15
Trap
Asked to write the two pieces from Example 2(b) compactly, a tempting line:
\[ -2 \ge x > 1 \]
It has both boundaries, both symbols and the variable in the middle, so it looks like the compact notation used for bands.
Read it as the notation actually means, though, and it says x is at most minus two AND x is greater than 1, which no number manages.
The three-part form always means and. Since the two halves here have no overlap, that statement has no solutions, while the answer you wanted had infinitely many.
\[ x \le -2 \;\text{ or }\; x > 1 \]
An or-answer stays as two statements with the word between them. That is not a clumsier notation; it is the only honest one, because the answer genuinely is two separate stretches.
A quick guard before you write any three-part inequality: check that the left-hand number is smaller than the right-hand one. Here minus two is not greater than 1, and that mismatch is the warning that the compact form is the wrong tool.
Counterexample
Claims about always and never are worth attacking directly. Here is one that sounds safe enough to nod at, which is exactly why it deserves a counterexample.
Figure (svg): Three stacked number lines. The first is shaded right of 4, the second left of 2, and the third is completely unshaded because the first two never overlap.
Discussion prompt
A classmate says: an and-inequality describes the band between its two numbers, so it always has solutions. Produce a compound inequality that breaks the claim, explain what its graph looks like, and say what has to be true of the two boundaries for a band to exist at all.
The same two boundaries joined by or behave completely differently. Numbers above 4 or below 2 is almost the whole line, missing only the stretch from 2 to 4, so one joining word gives nothing and the other gives nearly everything.
That contrast is the reason the joining word is worth reading before anything else. It is a single short English word carrying the entire difference between an empty answer and an enormous one.
Step zero
Guided Practice 3 and 4 both ask for a graph. Decide the shape of each answer before touching a pencil, because the shape is where a compound graph goes wrong, not the arithmetic.
\[ \text{(3)}\; -3 \le x < 1 \qquad \text{(4)}\; x < 1 \;\text{ or }\; x \ge 2 \]
Discussion prompt
For each one, say whether the graph will be a single band or two separate pieces, and say which endpoints will be solid and which hollow, with a reason for each dot.
Figure (svg): Two number lines. The left is shaded from a solid dot at minus three to a hollow dot at 1; the right is shaded left of a hollow dot at 1 and right of a solid dot at 2.
Compare your predictions with the two drawings. If your shapes were right, the dots are a matter of one substitution each, and the whole exercise takes half a minute.
It is worth noticing that the two graphs mention the same number, 1, and that in both of them it is hollow, but for the same reason in each case: the symbol beside it is strict. The reason for a dot never depends on the rest of the inequality.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 41 — Guided Practice 3 and 4
Section
Part 3
Concept
Solving an inequality means replacing it with simpler inequalities that have exactly the same solutions. The book calls those equivalent inequalities, and it lists the moves that produce them.
equivalent inequalities — Inequalities that have the same solutions as the original one. You solve by isolating the variable through a chain of them.
| move | example | becomes |
|---|---|---|
| add the same number to each side | x − 7 < 4 | x < 11 |
| subtract the same number from each side | x + 3 ≥ −1 | x ≥ −4 |
| multiply each side by the same positive number | (1/2)x > 10 | x > 20 |
| divide each side by the same positive number | 5x ≤ 15 | x ≤ 3 |
| multiply by a negative and reverse the symbol | −x < 17 | x > −17 |
| divide by a negative and reverse the symbol | −9x ≥ 45 | x ≤ −5 |
The first four rows are the moves you already use on equations, unchanged and without conditions. Adding, subtracting, multiplying by something positive and dividing by something positive all leave the symbol exactly as it was.
The last two rows are the new material in this lesson, and they are the only rows where anything happens to the symbol. Check the final one with a number: minus nine times minus five is 45, which is at least 45, while minus nine times minus four is 36, which is not.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 42 — the Key Concept table of transformations
Concept
Look again at why the first four moves in that table are safe and the last two are not. The difference is what each kind of move does to the number line as a whole.
Adding the same number to both sides slides every number along by the same amount, in the same direction. Two numbers that were four apart are still four apart, and the one that was further left is still further left, so the comparison between them is untouched.
\[ 3 < 7 \;\Longrightarrow\; 3 + 5 < 7 + 5 \;\text{ that is }\; 8 < 12 \]
Multiplying by a positive number stretches or squeezes the line about zero. Distances change, but nothing crosses over zero to the other side, so again the number that was further left stays further left.
\[ 3 < 7 \;\Longrightarrow\; 2 \cdot 3 < 2 \cdot 7 \;\text{ that is }\; 6 < 14 \]
Multiplying by a negative number does something these two cannot: it flips the line over. That is the one move that changes which of two numbers is further left, and it is exactly the move that forces the symbol to be rewritten.
So the rule is not an extra fact bolted on to inequality solving. It is the one consequence of the only move that reverses the order of the number line, and the next three slides make it visible.
Worked example
Fifty dollars, twenty of it spent on admission, and a game costing one dollar fifty a go. The question asks for the possible numbers of games, which is a range rather than a single number, so it is an inequality problem from the start.
Write the verbal model first
Why: the admission fee plus the cost of the games has to come to no more than the money you have.
\[ \text{admission} + \text{cost per game} \cdot \text{games} \le \text{money} \]
Turn the model into symbols
Why: with g standing for the number of games, the cost of the games is one and a half g dollars.
\[ 20 + 1.5g \le 50 \]
The words that chose the symbol were can spend. Spending exactly fifty dollars is allowed, so the limit is included and the symbol is inclusive rather than strict.
Subtract 20 from each side
Why: the admission is already gone, so this removes a fixed cost. Subtracting does not touch the symbol.
\[ 1.5g \le 30 \]
Divide each side by 1.5
Why: one and a half is positive, so again the symbol stays exactly as it is.
\[ g \le 20 \]
Figure (svg): A number line from 0 to 24 with solid dots on every whole number from 0 to 20 and hollow red dots on 21 to 24, above a shaded stretch ending at 20.
The picture adds something the algebra cannot. You cannot play two thirds of a game, so only the whole-number dots are genuinely available, and the answer in practice is the whole numbers from 0 to 20.
Check the boundary and one step past it
Why: twenty games costs thirty dollars and brings the total to exactly fifty, which is allowed; twenty-one games costs thirty-one fifty and brings the total to fifty-one fifty, which is not.
\[ 20 + 1.5(20) = 50 \;\checkmark \qquad 20 + 1.5(21) = 51.5 \;\times \]
Checking the boundary and the next value along is the right check for a money problem, because the interesting question is always exactly where the budget runs out.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 42 — Example 3
Fill the middle
A straightforward one to fix the routine: subtract, then divide by something positive, and watch the symbol stay put through both moves.
Fill in the blanks
4x + 9 < 25 \;\Longrightarrow\; 4x < 16 \;\Longrightarrow\; x < 4
Why: Subtracting 9 from each side leaves four x less than 16, and dividing each side by the positive number 4 leaves x less than 4. Neither move was a multiplication or division by a negative number, so the symbol never moves. Check it with a number from each side: four threes plus nine is 21, which is less than 25, and four fives plus nine is 29, which is not.
Draw the answer before you leave it. A hollow dot at 4 with the shading running left, because 4 itself gives exactly 25 and 25 is not less than 25.
It is worth being explicit about why nothing turned round here. Both moves were of the ordinary kind, and the rule about reversing applies only to multiplying or dividing by a negative number, never to adding or subtracting one.
That distinction is the subject of the trap two slides after the next worked example, where somebody reverses a symbol because a negative number appeared somewhere in the working rather than because they divided by one.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 43 — Guided Practice 5
Intuition
The rule is not a convention and it is not arbitrary. Multiplying by a negative number reflects the whole number line in zero, and a reflection swaps left and right, which is the same as swapping smaller and larger.
Figure (svg): Two number lines drawn one above the other. On the upper one, 3 sits to the left of 5. Arrows cross downward to the lower line, where minus three sits to the right of minus five.
Follow the two arrows. Three sits to the left of 5, so 3 is the smaller. After multiplying both by minus one, minus three sits to the RIGHT of minus five, so minus three is now the larger of the two.
Nothing about the pair changed except their position. Their distance apart is still 2, and they are still the same two numbers doubled back on the other side of zero, but which one counts as bigger has swapped over.
\[ 3 < 5 \qquad \Longrightarrow \qquad -3 > -5 \]
So when a whole inequality is multiplied or divided by a negative number, every solution reflects to the other side of zero, and the symbol has to reverse to describe the same set of numbers in its new position.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 43 — the Avoid Errors note beside Example 4
Concept
Having seen the reflection, write the rule down in a form you can quote. It is a statement about any two numbers, not about any particular ones.
\[ \text{If } a < b \text{ and } c < 0, \text{ then } ac > bc \]
Read it slowly. If a is smaller than b, then multiplying both by the same negative number makes the first result the LARGER one, which is why the symbol between them has to be written the other way round.
\[ 2 < 6 \;\Longrightarrow\; -2 > -6 \qquad -4 < 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; 12 > -3 \]
The second of those is worth checking carefully, because both signs changed. Minus four times minus three is 12 and one times minus three is minus three, and 12 really is greater than minus three, so the reversed symbol is correct.
Dividing is the same rule, since dividing by a negative number is multiplying by its negative reciprocal. There is no separate rule to learn for division, only the same one wearing a different coat.
One last warning about scope. The rule is about multiplying or dividing, and it applies to the whole inequality at once. A negative number appearing inside your working is not, on its own, a reason for anything to move.
Tweak it
Watch the rule happen rather than take it on trust. The curve here is a times x minus 6, so the inequality a times x is greater than 6 is asking where the curve sits above the horizontal axis.
Parameter explorer
Start with a positive and find the values of x where the line is above the axis. Now drag a down through zero and watch that region jump to the other side of the crossing. Say what happens at the moment a is zero.
\[ y = {a}x - 6 \]
The crossing point moves as you drag, but that is not the interesting part. The interesting part is that the shaded side flips from right to left at exactly the moment the coefficient passes through zero.
This is the reversal rule with the mystery taken out of it. Dividing by a negative number is what turns a rising line into a falling one, and a falling line meets a level from the other side.
Try a equal to zero deliberately once. The line becomes flat and the inequality becomes a claim about numbers alone, which is the case the definition ruled out by insisting that a is not zero.
Picture it
Here is one fixed instance of what the slider showed, drawn carefully so you can read the answer off it.
Figure (svg): The falling line y equals minus two x crossing the horizontal line y equals minus six at x equal to 3, with the region to the left of 3 shaded because the falling line is above the level there.
The inequality minus two x is greater than minus six asks where the falling blue line sits above the orange level. Because the line falls, that happens to the LEFT of where they cross, and the crossing is at 3.
So the answer is x less than 3, which is exactly what the rule produces: divide both sides by minus two and turn the symbol round. The graph and the rule agree, and the graph explains the rule.
Keep this picture in mind whenever a reversal feels wrong. Falling lines are above a level on the left, rising lines are above it on the right, and the sign of the coefficient is what decides which kind of line you have.
Worked example
The first solution where the reversal actually happens. Notice in advance that x is multiplied by minus three, so the last move will be a division by a negative number.
\[ 1 - 3x \ge -14 \]
Subtract 1 from each side
Why: an ordinary move, so the symbol does not change.
\[ -3x \ge -15 \]
Divide each side by minus three, and reverse the symbol
Why: this is the move the rule is about: the divisor is negative, so at least becomes at most.
\[ x \le 5 \]
Write the reversal on the same line as the division, as a single action. People who do the division first and promise to fix the symbol afterwards are the people who forget.
Figure (svg): A number line shaded to the left of a solid dot at 5, with a note that 5 itself makes the original inequality true.
Check the boundary
Why: five makes the two sides exactly equal, and equality is allowed by an at-least symbol, so the endpoint is included and the dot is solid.
\[ 1 - 3(5) = -14 \;\checkmark \]
Check one value on each side
Why: four is inside the answer and works; six is outside and fails, which confirms the symbol was turned the right way.
\[ 1 - 3(4) = -11 \ge -14 \;\checkmark \qquad 1 - 3(6) = -17 \ge -14 \;\times \]
If you had forgotten to reverse, your answer would have been everything above 5, and the value 6 would have passed instead of failing. That one test catches the commonest error in the lesson.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 43 — Guided Practice 6
Worked example
The book's fourth example, with x on the left and on the right. Collect the variable first, exactly as you would in an equation, and see what coefficient you are left with.
\[ 5x + 2 > 7x - 4 \]
Subtract seven x from each side
Why: this gathers the variable on the left, and subtracting changes nothing about the symbol.
\[ -2x + 2 > -4 \]
Subtract 2 from each side
Why: another ordinary move, and the symbol still stands as it was.
\[ -2x > -6 \]
Figure (svg): Two rising lines on the same axes, five x plus two and seven x minus four, crossing at the point 3 comma 17, with the region left of the crossing shaded where the first line is higher.
The picture says what is about to happen. The left-hand side is the higher of the two lines only until they cross at 3, so the answer must be everything to the left of 3, and the algebra now has to produce that.
Divide each side by minus two, and reverse the symbol
Why: the coefficient of x is negative, so greater than becomes less than.
\[ x < 3 \]
Figure (svg): A number line shaded to the left of a hollow dot at 3, with a green mark at 0 labelled true and a red mark at 4 labelled false.
Check one value inside and one outside
Why: zero is a solution of the original, and 4 is not, which is exactly what a graph shaded to the left of 3 claims.
\[ 0: \; 2 > -4 \;\checkmark \qquad 4: \; 22 > 24 \;\times \]
Had the symbol not been turned round the answer would have been everything above 3, and the value 4 would have had to work. It does not, so the reversal was needed.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 43 — Example 4
Discrimination
Six inequalities. Decide for each one whether isolating x will end in a division by a negative number, which is the only thing that moves a symbol. Do no arithmetic beyond finding the coefficient of x.
Sort into buckets
Sort each inequality by whether solving it requires the symbol to reverse.
The fourth item is the one that rewards a moment's thought. Subtracting five x from both sides leaves minus seven at most x, with a positive coefficient, so no reversal is needed even though a negative number is on show.
That is the general escape route. If you would rather never divide by a negative number, collect the variable on whichever side leaves its coefficient positive, and the reversal simply never arises.
Deciding this in advance is worth the ten seconds. Knowing a reversal is coming makes it very hard to forget, and knowing none is coming makes it very hard to add one by accident.
Error analysis
This is the book's own error-analysis exercise. Every line here is arithmetically correct, and the final answer is still wrong. Find the moment before you read the notes.
Annotate
On: \( 2x + 8 \le 6x - 4 \;\Longrightarrow\; -4x \le -12 \;\Longrightarrow\; x \le 3 \)
\[ x \ge 3 \]
Notice how the error survives every check that does not involve a number. The arithmetic is right, the layout is tidy, and the answer has the right boundary; only the direction of the shading is wrong, and only a substitution reveals it.
That is exactly why this deck ends every solution with a test value. One number from inside the claimed answer costs a few seconds and catches this error every single time.
There is a second habit that prevents it. When a line has a negative coefficient of x, write the reversal into the same step as the division rather than planning to remember it afterwards.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 45 — Exercise 34
Trap
The book's other error-analysis exercise. Solving ten plus three x is greater than five x:
\[ 10 + 3x > 5x \]
\[ 10 < 2x \]
Three x has been subtracted from each side, leaving ten and two x, and the symbol has been turned round at the same time, giving the answer that 5 is less than x.
The thinking is understandable. A rule about reversing exists, a subtraction has just happened, and the reversal has been applied to be safe.
Subtracting never reverses anything. The rule applies only when you multiply or divide by a negative number, and neither of those happened here.
\[ 10 > 2x \;\Longrightarrow\; 5 > x \]
So the answer is that x is less than 5, which is the opposite of what was written. Test zero in the original: ten plus nothing is greater than nothing, so zero is a solution, and the wrong answer excludes it.
Put the two error-analysis exercises side by side and the lesson is symmetrical. One forgot a reversal that was needed, the other added a reversal that was not, and a single test value would have caught either one.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 45 — Exercise 35
Worked example
Here is the escape route in action. The variable appears on both sides, and you get to choose which side to collect it on, so choose the side that leaves its coefficient positive.
\[ 5x - 7 \le 6x \]
Subtract five x from each side
Why: collecting on the right rather than the left leaves a positive coefficient, so no reversal will be needed later.
\[ -7 \le x \]
That single move has finished the algebra. There was only one x on the right to begin with, so once the five x has gone there is nothing left to divide by.
Turn the statement round to read it
Why: minus seven is at most x says the same thing as x is at least minus seven, and the second is easier to draw.
\[ x \ge -7 \]
Figure (svg): A number line from minus nine to minus one, shaded to the right of a solid dot at minus seven.
Check the boundary and a value on each side
Why: minus seven makes both sides equal to minus forty-two, which an at-most symbol allows; zero works and minus eight does not.
\[ 5(-7) - 7 = -42 \le -42 \;\checkmark \qquad 5(-8) - 7 = -47 \le -48 \;\times \]
Compare this with Example 4, where collecting on the left forced a reversal. Same kind of problem, different choice of side, and one of the two routes never meets the rule at all.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 43 — Guided Practice 7
Comparison
Take one inequality and solve it both ways: collect the variable on the left and accept a reversal, or collect it on the right and avoid one. Fill in what each route produces.
\[ 3 - x > x - 9 \]
Comparison matrix
| step | collect on the left | collect on the right |
|---|---|---|
| move the variable | −2x > −12 | 12 > 2x |
| divide | divide by −2 | divide by 2 |
| does the symbol move? | yes, it reverses | no |
| answer | x < 6 | x < 6 |
Both routes land on exactly the same answer, as they must: rearranging never changes which numbers satisfy an inequality, only how much care the rearranging takes.
The right-hand column is shorter on rules and longer on discipline, because you have to remember to read the final statement backwards. The left-hand column is the opposite: nothing to turn round at the end, but a reversal in the middle.
Use whichever you find more reliable, but be able to follow both. Examination mark schemes and worked solutions use the left-hand route, so you need to be able to read it even if you prefer the other.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 43 — Guided Practice 8
Worked example
One more of the same kind, with a bracket in front to expand. The bracket changes nothing about the method; it only adds a first move.
\[ 2(x - 4) > 4x + 6 \]
Expand the bracket
Why: two lots of x minus four is two x minus eight, and both terms get multiplied.
\[ 2x - 8 > 4x + 6 \]
Subtract four x from each side
Why: collecting the variable on the left leaves a negative coefficient, which tells you a reversal is coming.
\[ -2x - 8 > 6 \]
Add 8 to each side
Why: an ordinary move, so the symbol stays as it is.
\[ -2x > 14 \]
Divide each side by minus two, and reverse the symbol
Why: the divisor is negative, so greater than becomes less than.
\[ x < -7 \]
An answer made entirely of negative numbers is easy to distrust, and the way to settle the doubt is not to stare at it but to test it.
Figure (svg): A number line from minus twelve to minus four, shaded to the left of a hollow dot at minus seven.
Check one value inside and one outside
Why: minus ten is a solution of the original and minus seven is not, so the boundary and the direction are both right.
\[ -10: \; -28 > -34 \;\checkmark \qquad -7: \; -22 > -22 \;\times \]
Notice that minus seven makes the two sides exactly equal. That is the signature of a correct boundary, and the strict symbol is why the dot beside it is hollow.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 45 — Exercise 33
Section
Part 4
Concept
A three-part inequality is two statements sharing a middle. If you want to keep both statements true, anything you do has to be done to both of them, which means doing it to all three parts at once.
\[ -4 < 6x - 10 \le 14 \]
Think of what that line is really saying. The quantity six x minus ten is above minus four, and the same quantity is at most 14. Adding ten to the middle without adding ten to the outside would change the quantity and leave the comparisons talking about something else.
\[ -4 + 10 < 6x - 10 + 10 \le 14 + 10 \]
So every step is written across the whole line, all three parts getting the same treatment on the same row. It takes a little more writing and removes the commonest error in this part of the lesson.
The reversal rule still applies, and it now applies to both symbols at once. Multiply or divide a three-part inequality by a negative number and the two symbols both turn round, which has the effect of swapping the two ends of the band.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 43 — Example 5
Worked example
The book's and-example. Keep the variable in the middle and work outwards, so that the answer arrives already in the compact form.
\[ -4 < 6x - 10 \le 14 \]
Add 10 to each of the three parts
Why: ten is subtracted in the middle, so adding it back frees the variable term; the outside parts must move too.
\[ -4 + 10 < 6x - 10 + 10 \le 14 + 10 \]
Simplify each part
Why: the middle is now six x alone, and the two edges have become 6 and 24.
\[ 6 < 6x \le 24 \]
Divide each of the three parts by 6
Why: six is positive, so neither symbol moves.
\[ 1 < x \le 4 \]
Read the answer as a sentence before drawing it: all the real numbers greater than 1 and less than or equal to 4. The two ends carry different symbols, so they will carry different dots.
Figure (svg): A number line shaded from a hollow dot at 1 to a solid dot at 4, with the left end labelled out and the right end labelled in.
Check both ends and one value inside
Why: putting 1 in gives exactly minus four, which a strict symbol excludes; putting 4 in gives exactly 14, which an inclusive symbol allows; and 2 sits comfortably inside.
\[ 6(1) - 10 = -4 \;\times \qquad 6(4) - 10 = 14 \;\checkmark \qquad 6(2) - 10 = 2 \;\checkmark \]
Testing both ends is what proves the dots. Each end reproduces one of the original outer numbers exactly, and the symbol beside that number decides whether the end is in or out.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 43 — Example 5
Ranking
Guided Practice 9 gives another three-part inequality. Decide the order of the moves before making any of them, using the same reasoning you used for equations: undo the outermost operation first.
\[ -1 < 2x + 7 < 19 \]
Put in order
Order the moves that isolate x.
Why: Seven is added to the variable term last, so it comes off first, and it comes off all three parts. Simplifying then turns the outer parts into minus eight and 12. Only when the middle is a bare multiple of x can you divide, and dividing by the positive 2 leaves the symbols alone. The answer is that x lies between minus four and 6, with both ends excluded. Dividing before subtracting would work too, but it turns every part into a fraction for no benefit.
The middle is where the variable lives, so read it to decide the move: seven is added to two x, so subtract seven; two multiplies x, so divide by two. The outer parts never choose the move, they only come along with it.
Simplifying is listed as its own step on purpose. Writing minus one minus seven and nineteen minus seven out before collapsing them to minus eight and 12 is where the arithmetic errors get caught.
Check the finished band the way you always do. Zero lies inside it, and putting zero in gives seven, which is indeed between minus one and nineteen.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 44 — Guided Practice 9
Worked example
This one carries a negative coefficient inside a three-part inequality, so both symbols will turn round at once. Watch what that does to the two ends.
\[ -8 \le -x - 5 \le 6 \]
Add 5 to all three parts
Why: five is subtracted in the middle, so adding it back leaves minus x alone there.
\[ -3 \le -x \le 11 \]
Stop and read that line as it stands. It says the NEGATIVE of x lies between minus three and eleven, which is not yet an answer, because the question was about x.
Multiply all three parts by minus one, and reverse both symbols
Why: the multiplier is negative, so each comparison turns round; the middle becomes x and the two edges become 3 and minus eleven.
\[ 3 \ge x \ge -11 \]
Figure (svg): Two number lines. The upper shows a band from minus three to eleven for minus x; arrows cross downward to the lower line, where the band runs from minus eleven to 3 for x.
Rewrite with the smaller number on the left
Why: a band is conventionally written from its lower end to its upper end, so turn the whole statement round.
\[ -11 \le x \le 3 \]
The two ends have traded places, which is exactly what the reflection picture predicted. Nothing has been lost: the band is still fourteen units wide, and it has simply been turned about zero.
Check both ends and one value inside
Why: minus eleven gives exactly six and 3 gives exactly minus eight, the two original outer numbers, and both symbols were inclusive so both ends belong; zero sits inside and gives minus five.
\[ -(-11) - 5 = 6 \;\checkmark \qquad -(3) - 5 = -8 \;\checkmark \qquad -(0) - 5 = -5 \;\checkmark \]
Had you forgotten to turn the symbols round you would have written that x lies between 3 and minus eleven, which is empty. An impossible-looking band is a reliable sign that a reversal was missed.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 44 — Guided Practice 10
Error analysis
A three-part inequality solved with one move applied in one place. The line looks reasonable, which is what makes this error so durable.
Annotate
On: \( -1 < 2x + 7 < 19 \;\Longrightarrow\; -1 < 2x < 12 \;\Longrightarrow\; -1 < x < 6 \)
\[ -4 < x < 6 \]
A number test exposes it immediately. Minus two lies inside the correct band but outside the faulty one, and putting minus two in gives three, which is genuinely between minus one and nineteen.
The habit that prevents this is mechanical: write every step as a full three-part line, with all three parts on the row, rather than editing the middle in place and copying the edges down unchanged.
It is also worth noticing which edge survived. People rarely forget both; they forget the one they look at second, which is usually the left one, because the eye starts at the variable in the middle.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 44 — Guided Practice 9
Concept
An or-inequality cannot be written in three parts, so it cannot be solved in three parts either. Instead you solve two separate inequalities and keep both answers, joined by the same word that joined the question.
\[ 3x + 5 \le 11 \;\text{ or }\; 5x - 7 \ge 23 \]
Each half is an ordinary linear inequality of the kind Part 3 dealt with, and each is solved without any reference to the other. Set them out side by side so nothing leaks from one to the other.
The only thing the two halves share is the final word. A solution of the compound inequality is a solution of either half, so you keep everything both halves produced, and the graph has two pieces.
The same applies to a reversal: it belongs to whichever half produced it. One half may need the symbol turned round while the other does not, and that is perfectly normal.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 43 — Example 6
Worked example
The book's or-example, worked as two columns. Neither half knows about the other until the final line.
\[ 3x + 5 \le 11 \;\text{ or }\; 5x - 7 \ge 23 \]
Deal with the first half: subtract 5
Why: five is added to the variable term, so it comes off first.
\[ 3x \le 6 \]
Divide the first half by 3
Why: three is positive, so the symbol stays.
\[ x \le 2 \]
Now the second half: add 7
Why: seven is subtracted there, so add it to both sides of that inequality.
\[ 5x \ge 30 \]
Divide the second half by 5
Why: again a positive divisor, so again nothing moves.
\[ x \ge 6 \]
Put the two answers together with the word that joined the question. Everything at most 2, together with everything at least 6, and nothing in between belongs to either.
Figure (svg): A number line shaded to the left of a solid dot at 2 and to the right of a solid dot at 6, with the stretch between them left blank.
Check one value in each piece and one in the gap
Why: zero satisfies the first half, seven satisfies the second, and 4 satisfies neither, which is what the gap in the graph claims.
\[ 0: \; 5 \le 11 \;\checkmark \qquad 7: \; 28 \ge 23 \;\checkmark \qquad 4: \; 17 \le 11 \;\times, \; 13 \ge 23 \;\times \]
The value from the gap is the one that proves the answer is two pieces. Both halves have to fail it, and here they do.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 43 — Example 6
Fill the middle
Another or-inequality, and this time one half produces a boundary of zero, which is easy to mishandle. Solve each half on its own and fill in what each one gives.
Fill in the blanks
3x - 1 < -1 \;\Longrightarrow\; x < 0 \qquad \text3 \qquad 2x + 5 \ge 11 \;\Longrightarrow\; x \ge ___
Why: Adding 1 to the first half gives three x less than zero, and dividing by the positive 3 leaves x less than zero. Adding 7 is not needed in the second half; subtracting 5 gives two x at least 6, so x is at least 3. The graph has a hollow dot at zero shading left and a solid dot at 3 shading right, with the stretch from zero to 3 belonging to neither piece. Check the gap with 1: three minus one is 2, which is not less than minus one, and two plus five is 7, which is not at least 11.
Zero as a boundary is worth a second look. Dividing zero by three is still zero, and a boundary of zero behaves exactly like any other boundary, with a hollow dot because the symbol is strict.
Notice that the two halves needed different amounts of work, which is normal. There is no requirement for the two sides of an or-inequality to be similar, only for each of them to be solved correctly.
Finish as always by drawing it and testing a value from the gap. If a number from between the two boundaries passes one of the halves, one of the halves has been solved the wrong way round.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 44 — Guided Practice 12
Comparison
Everything in this part reduces to one decision made at the start. Fill in the blanks to state the difference in full.
Comparison matrix
| question | joined by and | joined by or |
|---|---|---|
| how many inequalities to solve | one, in three parts | two |
| what a solution must satisfy | both halves | either half |
| shape of the graph | one band | two pieces |
| can it be written in three parts? | yes | no |
| can it be empty? | yes | only if both halves are |
The last row is the one people find surprising. An and-inequality is easy to make empty, because two conditions can simply miss each other, while an or-inequality keeps everything either half produced and so is almost never empty.
The third row is the one to carry into an examination. If your and-answer came out as two pieces, or your or-answer as a single band, something has gone wrong before the arithmetic, and it is quicker to reread the joining word than to check every line.
And notice that the middle column is a single object throughout. That is the whole reason for the three-part notation: one inequality, one chain of moves, one band at the end.
Edge cases
The book's challenge exercises break the pattern deliberately. In each of them the variable disappears, and what is left is a statement about numbers that is either always true or never true.
Figure (svg): Two parallel rising lines, two x minus eight and two x plus one, with a vertical arrow between them showing that the gap of nine never closes.
Discussion prompt
Solve two x minus eight, all greater than two x plus one, and then solve four x minus five at most four times the bracket x plus two. Say what happens to the variable in each, and what the answer is in each case.
The picture explains the first one. Both sides are lines of the same steepness, so they are parallel and one stays nine below the other forever; asking for the lower one to be the higher one asks for something that never happens.
The second case is the same picture with the question asked the other way round. The lower line is always below the other, so the at-most condition holds everywhere and nothing narrows the answer down.
Recognise the signal rather than the specific numbers. If the variable vanishes from both sides, stop solving and read the statement that is left: true means all real numbers, false means no solution.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 45 — Exercises 49 and 50
Section
Part 5
Concept
Outside a textbook, inequalities almost never arrive as symbols. They arrive as English: a budget, a speed limit, a safe operating temperature, an entry requirement. Translating the English correctly is most of the work.
| the words | the symbol | the dot |
|---|---|---|
| fewer than, under, below, less than | strict, less than | open |
| at most, no more than, up to, maximum | inclusive, at most | solid |
| more than, over, above, greater than | strict, greater than | open |
| at least, no fewer than, minimum | inclusive, at least | solid |
| between a and b | a band, usually strict at both ends | two open |
| from a to b | a band, usually inclusive at both ends | two solid |
The rows worth memorising are the second and the fourth. At most and at least are the standard English for an inclusive limit, and they are the phrases that legal and financial rules actually use, which is why they turn up in almost every word problem.
The last two rows come with a caution. Between and from are used loosely in ordinary speech, so a careful question will say what it means, as Exercise 54 does when it states that each range includes the lower temperature but not the higher one.
When a question does not say, decide from the situation and write down the decision you made. A temperature range for a living animal usually includes its endpoints; a bracket of prices where the next bracket starts at the same number usually does not.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 44 — Example 7 and the range of temperatures
Worked example
A monitor lizard's body temperature runs from 18 to 34 degrees Celsius. Write that as a compound inequality, then rewrite the same range in degrees Fahrenheit.
Write the range as a compound inequality
Why: from 18 to 34 includes both ends, so both symbols are inclusive and C sits in the middle.
\[ 18 \le C \le 34 \]
Substitute the conversion formula for C
Why: the temperature formula gives Celsius in terms of Fahrenheit, so putting it in the middle turns the statement into one about F.
\[ 18 \le \tfrac{5}{9}(F - 32) \le 34 \]
Notice which direction of the formula you need. You want to end up with F alone in the middle, so you start by writing C as an expression in F rather than the other way round.
Multiply all three parts by nine fifths
Why: nine fifths is the reciprocal of five ninths, and it is positive, so neither symbol moves.
\[ 18 \cdot \tfrac95 \le F - 32 \le 34 \cdot \tfrac95 \]
Simplify the two outer parts
Why: eighteen times nine fifths is 32.4, and thirty-four times nine fifths is 61.2.
\[ 32.4 \le F - 32 \le 61.2 \]
Add 32 to all three parts
Why: the last operation attached to F, and it goes on every part.
\[ 64.4 \le F \le 93.2 \]
Figure (svg): Two vertical temperature scales side by side, Celsius and Fahrenheit, drawn so equal heights mean equal temperatures, with the lizard's range marked as a thick band on each and dashed lines joining the two bands.
Check both ends in the conversion formula
Why: putting F equal to 64.4 into five ninths of F minus thirty-two gives exactly 18, and 93.2 gives exactly 34, the two Celsius temperatures you started from.
\[ \tfrac59(64.4 - 32) = 18 \;\checkmark \qquad \tfrac59(93.2 - 32) = 34 \;\checkmark \]
Both ends stayed inclusive all the way through, because every move was a multiplication or addition by a positive number. A conversion involving a negative factor would have turned the band round.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 44 — Example 7
Fill the middle
Same animal, narrower range: from 15 to 30 degrees Celsius. The route is identical, so this is a chance to run it without help.
Fill in the blanks
15 \le C \le 30 \;\Longrightarrow\; 27 \le F - 32 \le 54 \;\Longrightarrow\; 59 \le F \le 86
Why: Multiplying all three parts by nine fifths turns 15 into 27 and 30 into 54. Adding 32 to all three parts then gives 59 at one end and 86 at the other. Check both ends the other way: five ninths of 59 minus 32 is 15, and five ninths of 86 minus 32 is 30, so the band really does describe the same temperatures.
Compare the two answers. A Celsius band fifteen degrees wide became a Fahrenheit band twenty-seven degrees wide, because a Fahrenheit degree is a smaller step than a Celsius one. The band did not change temperature, only its description.
It is worth keeping the exact decimals rather than rounding as you go. Rounding 27 or 54 early would move the endpoints, and in a question about a safe operating range the endpoints are the whole point.
Both ends stayed inclusive again, for the same reason as before. Every move was a multiplication or an addition by a positive number, and only a negative one would have disturbed the symbols.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 44 — Guided Practice 13
Real world
Exercise 57 gives a manufacturer's claim: the laptop operates within a temperature range of 50 to 95 degrees Fahrenheit. This time the conversion runs the other way.
\[ 50 \le F \le 95 \]
Discussion prompt
Rewrite this range in degrees Celsius, using the conversion that Celsius is five ninths of the quantity F minus thirty-two. Then say why a manufacturer would choose inclusive symbols here rather than strict ones.
The moves are the same two as in Example 7, run in the opposite order: subtract the 32 first, because here it is attached to the quantity you already have, then multiply by five ninths.
Check the answer by converting back. Ten degrees Celsius is nine fifths of ten plus thirty-two, which is 50, and thirty-five is nine fifths of thirty-five plus thirty-two, which is 95, so the two bands describe the same temperatures.
This is worth doing once with numbers you can sanity-check against experience. Ten degrees is a cold room and thirty-five is a very hot day, which is a believable operating range for a piece of electronics.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 47 — Exercise 57
Comparison
Exercise 54 gives a table of gear against air temperature and asks for an inequality on each row. The question states that each range includes its lower temperature but not its higher one, which settles every dot for you.
Comparison matrix
| temperature | gear | inequality |
|---|---|---|
| 60 to 65 | full wetsuit | 60 ≤ T < 65 |
| 65 to 72 | full leg wetsuit | 65 ≤ T < 72 |
| 72 to 80 | wetsuit trunks | 72 ≤ T < 80 |
| 80 or warmer | no special gear | T ≥ 80 |
Look at what happens where two rows meet. Sixty-five is the upper end of one range and the lower end of the next, and the rule about including the lower but not the higher is what stops it belonging to both.
That is why a well-written set of brackets never uses the same kind of dot at a shared boundary. If both rows included 65, somebody at exactly 65 degrees would be told to wear two different things.
The final row is not a band at all. Eighty or warmer has a lower end and no upper end, so it is a simple inequality with one solid dot and an arrow running off to the right.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 46 — Exercise 54
Worked example
Olympic National Park's plant zones are stacked by elevation: lowland from 0 to 500 metres, montane from 500 to 1400, subalpine from 1400 to 2000, and alpine from 2000 to 2429. Each range includes its lower elevation and not its higher one.
Figure (svg): A vertical elevation scale in metres with four stacked zone boxes beside it: lowland, montane, subalpine and alpine. Two thick marks to the right pick out the lowland zone and the two highest zones together.
Write the lowland zone
Why: it starts at sea level, includes 0, and stops just below 500.
\[ 0 \le e < 500 \]
Write the alpine and subalpine zones combined
Why: they are neighbours, so together they run from the bottom of the subalpine zone to the top of the park.
\[ 1400 \le e \le 2429 \]
Combining two touching ranges into one band is only legal because they touch. Had there been a gap between them the answer would have needed the word or, which is exactly what the next part produces.
Write the elevations that are not montane
Why: the montane zone is cut out of the middle, which leaves what is below it and what is above it.
\[ 0 \le e < 500 \;\text{ or }\; 1400 \le e \le 2429 \]
Notice how the dots turned round when the zone was negated. The montane zone included 500 and excluded 1400, so its complement excludes 500 and includes 1400, and each boundary swaps its dot.
Check three elevations, one in each region
Why: two hundred metres is lowland and passes, one thousand metres is montane and fails, and 1500 metres is subalpine and passes.
\[ 200 \;\checkmark \qquad 1000 \;\times \qquad 1500 \;\checkmark \]
Testing one value from each named region is the right check for a banded problem, because it exercises every boundary you wrote.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 46 — Exercise 55
Estimation
Exercise 53: two hundred and fifty dollars raised, thirty-five of it needed for videotapes, and the camera costs forty-five dollars a day. Estimate the answer before solving, then check whether your estimate survives the whole-number constraint.
\[ 35 + 45d \le 250 \]
Predict first
For how many whole days can the camera be hired?
Correct: 4 days
Why: Subtracting 35 leaves forty-five d at most 215, and dividing by the positive 45 gives d at most 4.78 or so. Days are whole, so the answer is 4, which costs 35 plus 180, that is 215 dollars, leaving 35 dollars unspent. Five days would cost 260 dollars, which is more than was raised. The tempting wrong answer is 5, from rounding 4.78 up in the usual way; here rounding up breaks the budget, so a limit of this kind always rounds down.
Rounding is the whole lesson in this problem. The algebra allows any number up to about 4.78, and reality allows only whole days, so you take the largest whole number inside the range rather than the nearest one.
Compare it with Example 3, where the division came out exactly 20 and no rounding question arose. A ragged answer like 4.78 is the normal case, and an exact one is the exception.
Check it in the original words rather than in your rearranged inequality. Thirty-five dollars of tape plus four days at forty-five is two hundred and fifteen, which is within the two hundred and fifty raised, and a fifth day would push it over.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 46 — Exercise 53
Worked example
The chapter's challenge exercise. Daylight cameras cost two dollars seventy-five, flash cameras four dollars twenty-five, you must buy exactly twenty, and you want to spend between sixty-five and seventy-five dollars inclusive.
Name one unknown and write the other in terms of it
Why: with d daylight cameras, the rest of the twenty are flash cameras.
\[ d + f = 20 \;\Longrightarrow\; f = 20 - d \]
Write the total cost
Why: each kind costs its own price times its own count.
\[ \text{cost} = 2.75d + 4.25(20 - d) \]
Simplify the cost
Why: eighty-five dollars for twenty flash cameras, less a dollar fifty for every one you swap for a daylight camera.
\[ \text{cost} = 85 - 1.5d \]
That simplified form is worth reading before going on. It says the bill starts at eighty-five and falls by one dollar fifty for each cheap camera you swap in, which is the whole behaviour of the problem in one line.
Write the budget as a three-part inequality
Why: between sixty-five and seventy-five inclusive means both ends belong.
\[ 65 \le 85 - 1.5d \le 75 \]
Subtract 85 from all three parts
Why: an ordinary move, so neither symbol changes.
\[ -20 \le -1.5d \le -10 \]
Divide all three parts by minus one and a half, and reverse both symbols
Why: the divisor is negative, so the band turns round and its ends trade places.
\[ 13.33 \ge d \ge 6.67 \]
Figure (svg): A falling line showing the total cost of twenty cameras against the number of cheap ones, with a shaded horizontal band between 65 and 75 dollars and dots on the whole numbers from 7 to 13 that land inside it.
Check the whole numbers at each end of the band
Why: the counts must be whole, so d runs from 7 to 13; seven daylight cameras cost 74.50 dollars and thirteen cost 65.50, both inside the budget, while six would cost 76 dollars and fourteen would cost 64.
\[ d = 7: \; 74.50 \;\checkmark \qquad d = 13: \; 65.50 \;\checkmark \qquad d = 6: \; 76 \;\times \]
This is the reversal rule, the three-part form and a whole-number constraint in one problem, and the graph shows all three at once: a falling line, a band of acceptable cost, and dots only where the count is whole.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 47 — Exercise 60
Real world
Exercise 59 gives a grading rule: sixty-five per cent of the homework score, fifteen per cent of the quiz score and twenty per cent of the final exam score, all out of one hundred. The question is which students can still reach 85 overall.
\[ 0.65H + 0.15Q + 0.20E \ge 85 \]
Discussion prompt
Amy has 84 for homework and 80 for quizzes; Clara has 75 and 95. Write and solve the inequality for each of them, and say which of the two can still reach a grade of 85 or better.
The interesting part of this question is not the algebra but the last step of the reading. An inequality can produce a perfectly correct answer that lies outside the range the quantity is allowed to take, and then the honest conclusion is that there is no solution in context.
It is the same idea as the whole-number constraint in the camera problem, from the other direction. Algebra answers the question you wrote down; you still have to ask whether every value it offers is actually available.
Notice too how little the exam is worth. It carries only twenty per cent, so each point of exam score moves the final grade by a fifth of a point, which is why the required scores climb so steeply when the other marks are low.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 47 — Exercise 59
Section
Part 6
Pattern
Every question in this lesson is answered by the same short routine. Decide what you are looking at, solve, draw, and test, in that order.
Figure (svg): A flow diagram of four rows. Each row names the shape of the inequality on the left and the move that solves it on the right.
The diagram sorts the four shapes by the only feature that changes your work: whether the final division is by a negative number, and whether the two halves are joined by and or by or.
The last two lines are the ones that get skipped and the ones that pay. Drawing the answer exposes an impossible band immediately, and a single test value exposes a symbol pointing the wrong way.
Notice that nothing in the routine is specific to this chapter. The same six lines will solve the absolute value inequalities of Lesson 1.7, where the only new work is turning one absolute value statement into a compound inequality first.
Elimination
Exercise 56: a canoe costs eighteen dollars for the first two hours and three dollars an hour after that. You want to canoe for more than two hours and can spend no more than thirty dollars, with t the total number of hours.
Eliminate the wrong options
Which inequality represents the situation?
Survives elimination: A
Why: The eighteen dollars covers the first two hours, so only the hours beyond the second are charged at three dollars, and there are t minus 2 of those. Spending no more than thirty dollars makes the symbol inclusive. Solving it gives three lots of t minus two at most twelve, so t is at most 6, and together with the condition that t is more than 2 the answer is a band from 2 to 6.
The wrong options are all the same kind of error: a fixed charge treated as if it bought nothing. Whenever a price has a flat part and a rate part, ask what the flat part has already paid for before you multiply anything.
A number test separates them in seconds. At three hours the real cost is eighteen plus three, that is twenty-one dollars, and only one of the four expressions produces 21.
Notice also that the question quietly contains a second condition. More than two hours is an inequality in its own right, so the full answer is a compound one: t greater than 2 and t at most 6.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 46 — Exercise 56
Check
One inequality, one reversal. Find the coefficient of x before you start, and decide there and then whether the symbol is going to move.
Check your understanding
Solve 15 − 3x > 3.
Answer: A
Why: Subtracting 15 from each side leaves minus three x greater than minus twelve. The coefficient is negative, so dividing by minus three turns the symbol round and gives x less than 4. Test it: at zero the left side is 15, which is greater than 3, and at 5 it is zero, which is not.
The value 5 is the one that settles it. Fifteen minus fifteen is zero, which is not greater than 3, so 5 cannot be a solution, and any answer that includes it is wrong.
If you prefer never to divide by a negative number, add three x to both sides instead. That gives 15 greater than three x plus three, then 12 greater than three x, then 4 greater than x, which says the same thing with no reversal anywhere.
Whichever route you take, finish by drawing it: a hollow dot at 4 with the shading running left, because 15 minus three fours is exactly 3 and 3 is not greater than 3.
Check
Back to the reading skill from Part 1, now with both kinds of dot on one graph. Take the shape first and the dots second.
Check your understanding
A number line is shaded to the left of a hollow dot at 2, and also to the right of a solid dot at 5. Which compound inequality is it?
Answer: A
Why: Two arrows pointing away from each other make two separate pieces, so the joining word is or. The hollow dot at 2 makes that half strict and the solid dot at 5 makes that half inclusive, which fixes both symbols.
The quickest way to reject the band is to test a number from the middle. Three is in the unshaded gap on the described graph, so any answer that includes 3 is describing the wrong set.
The option with the dots swapped is the one to be careful about, because it is right about everything except the two things this question is testing. Read each dot on its own and give it its own symbol.
As a habit, write the shape down before the symbols. Two pieces means or, one band means and, and that decision alone removes half the options in almost every question of this type.
Check
The hardest shape in the lesson: a band, a negative coefficient, and therefore two symbols turning round at once.
Check your understanding
Solve −3 < 4 − x ≤ 3.
Answer: A
Why: Subtracting 4 from all three parts gives minus seven less than minus x, at most minus one. Multiplying all three parts by minus one reverses both symbols and swaps the ends, giving 7 greater than x, at least 1, which is written as the band from 1 up to but not including 7.
The two ends are where the marks are. Putting 1 in gives 3, which the inclusive symbol accepts, and putting 7 in gives minus three, which the strict symbol rejects, so 1 is in and 7 is out.
If you want to avoid the reversal altogether, add x to all three parts first. That gives x minus three less than 4, at most x plus three, which is messier here, so on this shape the reversal is usually the cleaner route.
Draw it to finish: a solid dot at 1, a hollow dot at 7, and the band shaded between them, which is a picture you can check against the two substitutions above.
Explain it to yourself
One idea in this lesson was genuinely new, and explaining it in your own sentences is what turns it from a rule you obey into a fact you know. Write your answer before reading the one below.
Discussion prompt
In two or three sentences, explain why multiplying or dividing an inequality by a negative number reverses the symbol, and why adding or subtracting a negative number does not. Use the words left and right somewhere in your explanation.
If your explanation used the word rule more than the word reflect, try writing it again. The reflection is the reason, and the rule is only its summary.
A good test of whether it has landed: could you predict, without solving, that dividing a three-part inequality by a negative number will make its two ends trade places? That prediction follows from the reflection and nothing else.
Keep the sliding-versus-reflecting distinction in mind for Lesson 1.7. Absolute value measures distance from zero, and distance is exactly the thing a reflection leaves alone, which is why absolute value inequalities split into two cases.
Exit ticket
One question using everything: an or-inequality whose two halves each need a reversal, followed by a graph and a check.
\[ -x - 4 \ge 1 \;\text{ or }\; 2 - 5x \le -8 \]
Discussion prompt
Solve each half, describe the graph you would draw including both dots, and test one value in each piece and one from the gap.
Both dots came out solid here, which is worth noticing rather than assuming. Reversing a symbol turns greater than into less than, but it never turns a strict symbol into an inclusive one.
The value from the gap is the part of the check most people leave out. Zero has to fail both halves, and it does, which is what proves the answer really is two pieces rather than the whole line.
If you found yourself reversing only one of the two halves, that is the signal to slow down on or-inequalities. Each half is a separate problem with its own coefficient and its own decision about the symbol.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.6 Solve Linear Inequalities §1.6, p. 45 — Exercise 48
Recap
Four shapes of question, one routine: read the joining word, solve the way you solve an equation, turn the symbol round only when you multiply or divide by a negative number, draw the answer, and test a value from inside it.
| what you are given | what you do | what the answer looks like |
|---|---|---|
| a simple inequality | solve as an equation | one ray, with an open or solid dot |
| a negative coefficient of x | solve, reversing at the division | a ray pointing the other way |
| a three-part inequality | one move to all three parts | a band with two ends |
| two parts joined by or | solve each part separately | two pieces with a gap |
| a range in words | translate, then convert | a band in the new units |
\[ -4 < 6x - 10 \le 14 \;\Longrightarrow\; 1 < x \le 4 \]
The line above is the shape to remember from Part 4. Each end of the answer kept the symbol that its own end of the question carried, which is why one dot is hollow and the other is solid.
The single thing most likely to cost you a mark is the reversal, in either direction: forgetting it when you divide by a negative number, or applying it when you have merely subtracted one. The test value at the end of every question is what catches both.
Lesson 1.7 takes all of this and adds one idea. An absolute value measures distance from zero, so a statement about an absolute value being small becomes an and-band, and a statement about it being large becomes an or-pair of pieces, which are exactly the two shapes you have spent this lesson drawing.
OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §2.7 Linear Inequalities and Absolute Value Inequalities §2.7 — the same rules again, with interval notation for the answers
Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Algebra 2 — $55/session, free consultation.