Turning a described situation into an equation: the verbal model with units, and the three strategies the lesson names — use a formula, look for a pattern, and draw a diagram — plus the two-category problems that need only one letter.
Subject: Algebra 2 · 66 slides · symbolic lesson
Open the interactive version of this deck
Title
Algebra 2 · Lesson 1.5
Turning a paragraph of English into an equation worth solving
Objectives
Four lessons of this chapter have handed you an equation and asked you to solve it. From here on the equation is the thing you have to produce, out of a paragraph of ordinary English, and that turns out to be the harder half of the job.
The route from words to symbols has three stages, and the middle one is the one nearly everybody skips. Write the relationship in words with a unit on every quantity, draw or tabulate the situation, and only then choose letters and write the equation.
Every answer in this lesson gets checked against the original sentence, not just against the equation you wrote. That distinction matters: an equation can be solved perfectly and still answer the wrong question, and only the words can tell you so.
Units are the trap worth building a habit around. Most of the wrong answers in this lesson are not arithmetic slips; they are minutes fed into a formula that wanted hours, or gaps counted where objects were asked for.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 34 — Before, Now, Why and the Key Vocabulary
Warm-up
Start with a situation rather than an equation. The Acela train runs between Boston and Washington, a distance of 457 miles, and the trip takes 6.5 hours. You are asked for the average speed.
Resist doing the arithmetic for a moment. The question worth answering first is which relationship you are being asked about, because that decides the whole calculation.
Discussion prompt
Which of the formulas from Lesson 1.4 already describes this situation, and which of its three letters is the unknown here? Write both down before reading on.
That is the pattern for the whole lesson. Almost all of the thinking happens before the first equals sign, and almost all of the marks are lost there too.
Keep one more thing from this warm-up. The answer came out in miles per hour, which is exactly the unit a speed should have, and that agreement is not luck. It is a check you can run on every problem in this deck.
Section
Part 1
Concept
By now you can solve any linear equation you are handed. What remains difficult is producing the right one from a description, and the book gives that intermediate object a name.
verbal model — A word equation describing a real situation, written with a unit on every quantity, before any letters or numbers are put in.
A verbal model is not a rough draft to be thrown away. It is the only version of the problem you can read against the original sentence, so it is the version you check your answer with at the end.
Three strategies produce one. Use a formula you already have, look for a pattern in given values, or draw a diagram. The book names all three on page 34, and nearly every exercise in the section yields to one of them.
The three are not rivals. A single problem often wants a formula for its shape and a diagram to see what the letters stand for, and the last part of this lesson needs both at once.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 34 — the definition of a verbal model and the three strategies
Picture it
Here is the chain drawn out on the train problem. Three rows, saying the same thing three ways, and each row is easier to write because the one above it exists.
Figure (svg): Three stacked rows of boxes. The top row reads Distance equals Rate times Time in words, the middle row replaces each word with its unit, and the bottom row replaces each unit with the number or letter from the train problem. Arrows run downward from row to row.
The top row is a sentence you could say out loud. It commits you to a relationship, and to nothing else: no letters yet, no numbers, no decision about which quantity is unknown.
The middle row is the one to slow down on. Replacing each word with its unit turns the model into something you can test before you know a single value, because the units on the two sides must agree.
Only the bottom row can be solved, and only the middle row can be checked. Writing both is what makes an unfamiliar problem safe rather than a guess.
Notation
Take the verbal model apart before using it. Every one of these four observations gets used later in the lesson, and the last one is the one that saves you from the classic wrong answer.
Annotate
On: \( \text{Distance (mi)} = \text{Rate (mi/h)} \cdot \text{Time (h)} \)
The compound unit is doing the real work. Because a rate carries both of the other units, one on top and one underneath, it can be combined with either of them and always produce the third.
Say the model aloud once: miles equals miles per hour, times hours. Hearing the word hour twice, once underneath and once on its own, is what makes the cancellation obvious.
Every quantity in this lesson gets a unit written beside it, without exception. It costs a few seconds and it rules out an entire family of errors, which is the best trade available in this chapter.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 34 — the verbal model for Example 1
Intuition
Before any answer exists, you can already test your model. Run the units through it and see whether the two sides agree, and do it while the model is still in words.
Figure (svg): The product of 70.3 miles per hour, written as a fraction, and 6.5 hours, with the word hour struck through in both places, equalling 457 miles.
The struck-out words are the point. An hour underneath and an hour beside it divide out, exactly as a common factor would, and what is left is the unit the question asked for.
This is also how you decide between multiplying and dividing when you cannot remember which way round the formula goes. Only one of the two produces miles, so only one of the two can be right.
Turn it round and it settles the other questions too. Miles divided by miles per hour leaves hours, because dividing by a fraction multiplies by its reciprocal, so the hours come up from underneath.
The habit to build is small. Write the unit beside every number in your working, and when the final unit is not the one the question wanted, stop and look at the model rather than at the arithmetic.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 34 — the unit analysis check after Example 1
Sorting
Each of these claims to model a real situation. Ignore the numbers entirely and check only whether the unit on the left could possibly equal the unit on the right.
Sort into buckets
Sort each proposed model by whether its units balance.
The two failures are the same failure. A compound unit has something underneath it, and only division brings that thing up to cancel; multiplying leaves you with a squared unit that means nothing physical.
Look at what the second and third models have that the first does not: an addition. Adding is only legal between quantities of the same kind, so dollars may be added to dollars but never to months.
Notice how little you needed to know. No numbers appeared anywhere on this slide, and yet two models have already been eliminated, which is the cheapest progress you will make on any problem.
Worked example
The Acela travels between Boston and Washington, a distance of 457 miles, and the trip takes 6.5 hours. Find the average speed.
Choose the strategy: a formula already exists
Why: distance, rate and time is one of the standard formulas from Lesson 1.4, so there is nothing to invent here.
\[ d = rt \]
Because the formula is standard, the verbal model is just that formula with units attached. This is the easiest of the three strategies, and it is worth checking for first every single time.
Write the verbal model with units
Why: miles on the left, and miles per hour times hours on the right, so the hours cancel and both sides are miles.
\[ \text{Distance (mi)} = \text{Rate (mi/h)} \cdot \text{Time (h)} \]
Put the given values under their units
Why: 457 miles of distance, 6.5 hours of time, and the rate as the unknown.
\[ 457 = r \cdot 6.5 \]
Only now does a letter appear, and it appears in exactly one place. Everything before this line was about making sure it would appear in the right place.
Divide each side by 6.5
Why: because 6.5 multiplies the rate, and dividing undoes multiplying.
\[ r = \dfrac{457}{6.5} \approx 70.3 \]
Figure (svg): A long horizontal bar labelled 457 miles, divided into six full segments and one half segment, with each full segment labelled 70.3 and the half segment labelled 35.
The picture is the answer, drawn. Six full hours of 70.3 miles each account for 421.8 miles, and the last half hour adds about 35 more, which brings the total to 457.
Check against the original words, with units
Why: the book's own check: multiplying the speed back by the time must return the distance you were given, and the hours must cancel to leave miles.
\[ 70.3\,\dfrac{\text{mi}}{\text{h}} \cdot 6.5\text{ h} \approx 457\text{ mi} \]
That single line checks two things at once, the arithmetic and the unit, which is why the textbook offers it as the check for this example rather than simply restating the answer.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 34 — Example 1 and its CHECK
Estimation
A jet averages 540 miles per hour and flies from New York to Tokyo, a distance of 6760 miles. Before touching a calculator, decide roughly how long the flight lasts.
Estimate by rounding to numbers you can handle in your head. Five hundred miles an hour for ten hours would be five thousand miles, which is short, so the answer must be more than ten hours.
Predict first
About how long does the 6760 mile flight take at 540 miles per hour?
Correct: About 12.5 hours
Why: Five hundred miles an hour covers five thousand miles in ten hours and six thousand in twelve, so the answer sits a little above twelve. The 1.3 comes from dividing the wrong way round, and the 3.6 million comes from multiplying instead of dividing, which is the error the units already ruled out.
Having a rough answer in mind before you compute is worth more than it looks. It cannot tell you whether you are right, but it catches the large errors, and large errors are the ones that cost whole questions.
The estimate also tells you which operation you want. The time has to be a number a little over twelve, and only dividing the miles by the miles per hour produces anything of that size.
Check the estimate against what you know about the world too. A flight across the Pacific really does take something over twelve hours, which is a reassurance no amount of algebra can give you.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 34 — Guided Practice 1
Worked example
Now do it properly. A jet averaging 540 miles per hour flies the 6760 miles from New York to Tokyo, and you want the time in hours.
Use the same formula, with time as the unknown
Why: the formula does not change when the unknown moves; only which letter you end up dividing for changes.
\[ d = rt \]
Write the verbal model with units
Why: miles equals miles per hour times hours, and this time the hours are what you are missing.
\[ 6760\text{ mi} = 540\,\dfrac{\text{mi}}{\text{h}} \cdot t \]
Reading that line as units alone: miles equals miles per hour times hours. To get the hours out you divide the miles by the miles per hour, and the miles cancel, leaving hours underneath the fraction bar and therefore on top of the answer.
Divide each side by 540
Why: because 540 multiplies the time.
\[ t = \dfrac{6760}{540} \approx 12.52 \]
Figure (svg): A straight line rising from the origin showing distance flown against hours at 540 miles per hour, with dashed lines marking where the distance reaches 6760 miles.
The graph shows why the answer is a reading rather than a calculation. The line is every distance the jet could have flown; you entered it at 6760 on the vertical axis and came down to the time underneath.
The book rounds this to about 12.5 hours. Keeping the extra digit is harmless, and it explains the small gap in the check below.
Check against the original words
Why: multiply the speed back by the time and see whether Tokyo is where you land: 540 times 12.52 is 6760 miles, while the book's rounded 12.5 gives 6750, ten miles short purely from the rounding.
\[ 540(12.52) \approx 6760, \qquad 540(12.5) = 6750 \]
A gap of ten miles in 6760 is about one part in seven hundred, which is exactly what rounding to one decimal place should cost. A gap much larger than that would mean an error rather than rounding.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 34 — Guided Practice 1
Trap
The jet problem, worked in a hurry. Two numbers are given, so they get multiplied:
\[ t = 540 \cdot 6760 = 3\,650\,400 \]
Three and a half million of something. The number is enormous and nothing in the working says what it is, which is precisely why the error survives to the answer line.
This happens because the words were skimmed rather than modelled. Both numbers were treated as ingredients to be combined, without asking which relationship they sit in.
Put the units in and the wrong operation is visible in one line. Miles per hour times miles gives miles squared per hour, which is not a time and is not a thing.
\[ t = \dfrac{6760\text{ mi}}{540\,\text{mi}/\text{h}} \approx 12.52\text{ h} \]
Dividing cancels the miles and brings the hours up from underneath, so the answer comes out in hours, which is what the question asked for.
The general rule to take away: when you are unsure whether to multiply or divide, do not guess from the wording. Write the units and let them tell you, because only one of the two operations produces the unit the question wants.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 34 — the unit analysis check
Section
Part 2
Concept
The first strategy costs nothing to try, so try it first. Before building a model from scratch, ask whether the relationship in the problem is one of the standard ones you already met in Lesson 1.4.
| situation | formula | the compound unit in it |
|---|---|---|
| travel | d = rt | miles per hour, or kilometres per hour |
| fuel use | d = ef | miles per gallon |
| earnings | p = wh | dollars per hour |
| perimeter of a rectangle | P = 2l + 2w | none: all four terms are lengths |
| area of a rectangle | A = lw | none, but the answer is squared |
| circumference of a circle | C = πd | none: both sides are lengths |
Read the third column rather than the second. Three of these formulas contain a rate, and in every one of them the rate carries the unit of the answer on top and the unit of the thing you multiply by underneath.
That is why one habit handles all three. Whenever a problem mentions something per something, look for a formula of the shape total equals rate times amount, and you will almost always have found the model.
The last three rows have no rate at all. Every quantity in them is a length, which changes how the model is built: instead of multiplying a rate by an amount, you add lengths up, and that is what Part 4 is about.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 37 — Exercises 3 to 10, which practise both kinds
Matching
One formula, four questions. Decide for each which arithmetic the question wants, and notice that you can settle every one of them from the units without knowing any of the numbers.
Match the pairs
Why: A rate is always the answer unit divided by the other unit, so finding a rate means dividing a distance by a time. Finding a time means dividing a distance by a rate, and finding a distance means multiplying. The last one is the same as the first with one extra step in front of it, and that step is where it is usually lost.
Three of these are the distance formula solved for each of its three letters in turn, which is precisely the skill Lesson 1.4 built. Nothing new is being asked; only the words around it have changed.
The fourth is the one to watch, and it is a real exercise from this section. It asks for a rate in kilometres per hour while giving the time in minutes, so the conversion happens before the division, not after it.
If you paired them by looking at the unit of the answer rather than at the wording, you have the method. The unit you want tells you the operation, every time.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 38 — Exercises 24 and 25
Worked example
Dale Earnhardt Jr. completed the 500 mile Daytona race in 3.2 hours. Find his average racing speed. The distance is in the name of the race, which is the only thing unusual about this problem.
Identify the formula and the unknown
Why: a distance and a time are given, so the rate is what is missing, and the distance formula is the model.
\[ d = rt \]
Write the verbal model with units
Why: miles equals miles per hour times hours, so dividing the miles by the hours will leave miles per hour.
\[ 500\text{ mi} = r \cdot 3.2\text{ h} \]
Before dividing, estimate. Three hours at 150 miles an hour would be 450 miles, so the answer is somewhat above 150, which rules out a misplaced decimal point later.
Divide each side by 3.2
Why: because 3.2 multiplies the rate.
\[ r = \dfrac{500}{3.2} = 156.25 \]
An average of over 150 miles per hour sounds extreme and is entirely correct for this race. It is an average over the whole event, including the laps run behind a safety car, so the peak speeds are higher still.
Check against the original words
Why: run the speed forward for the stated time and see whether the race distance comes back, with the hours cancelling to leave miles.
\[ 156.25\,\dfrac{\text{mi}}{\text{h}} \cdot 3.2\text{ h} = 500\text{ mi} \]
This check is exact rather than approximate, because 500 divided by 3.2 happens to terminate. When a check comes out exactly right, you have not just confirmed the arithmetic; you have confirmed there was no rounding anywhere in it.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 38 — Exercise 24
Worked example
A magnetic levitation train covers the 30 kilometres from central Shanghai to Pudong airport in just 8 minutes. Find its average speed. Everything about this problem is easy except one step.
Identify the formula and the unknown
Why: a distance and a time again, so the rate is missing and the distance formula is still the model.
\[ d = rt \]
Now stop, because the trap is here rather than in the algebra. A speed in kilometres per hour needs a time measured in hours, and you have been handed minutes.
Figure (svg): Two parallel scales drawn to the same length. The top one runs from 0 to 60 minutes with 8 minutes marked near the left; the bottom one runs from 0 to 1 hour with 0.133 hours marked at the same place, joined by a dashed line.
Convert the 8 minutes into hours
Why: there are 60 minutes in an hour, so 8 minutes is eight sixtieths of an hour, which is two fifteenths.
\[ 8\text{ min} = \dfrac{8}{60}\text{ h} = \dfrac{2}{15}\text{ h} \approx 0.1333\text{ h} \]
The two marks in the picture sit directly above one another because they are the same instant written in two units. Feeding 8 into a formula that wanted 0.1333 would make the train sixty times slower than it is.
Divide the distance by the time
Why: dividing by a fraction multiplies by its reciprocal, so the two fifteenths turns into fifteen halves.
\[ r = \dfrac{30}{2/15} = 30 \cdot \dfrac{15}{2} = 225 \]
So the train averages 225 kilometres per hour, which is about 140 miles per hour, and the real thing reaches over 400 at its peak. The answer is large, and it should be.
Check against the original words, in the original units
Why: run the speed forward over two fifteenths of an hour and the 30 kilometres must come back; and 225 kilometres per hour is 3.75 kilometres per minute, which over 8 minutes is 30 kilometres again.
\[ 225 \cdot \dfrac{2}{15} = 30, \qquad \dfrac{225}{60} \cdot 8 = 3.75 \cdot 8 = 30 \]
The second version is worth noticing. Working entirely in kilometres per minute gives the same answer by a different route, which means the conversion was the only difficulty and it has now been checked twice.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 38 — Exercise 25
Fill the middle
A scuba diver is returning to the surface from a depth of 165 feet, and the safe ascent rate is 30 feet per minute. Find how many minutes the ascent takes.
Before filling anything in, decide the unit of the answer. The question asks for minutes, and the only way to get minutes out of feet and feet per minute is to divide, so the feet cancel.
Fill in the blanks
t = \dfrac5.5}___/\text___} = ___\text___
Why: One hundred and sixty five divided by thirty is five and a half, so the ascent takes five and a half minutes. Check it against the words: five minutes at thirty feet per minute is 150 feet, and the extra half minute adds 15 more, giving the 165 feet of depth the diver started at.
Notice that the rate here is a restriction rather than a measurement. A diver may ascend more slowly in perfect safety, so the answer is the shortest safe time rather than the time the ascent must take.
That is a useful reminder about models in general. The equation tells you what follows from the numbers; whether the situation allows it is a separate question that only the words can answer.
An answer of half a minute is also worth reading properly. Half of a minute is thirty seconds, so the honest way to report this is five minutes and thirty seconds, which is how a diver would actually plan it.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 38 — Exercise 26
Worked example
Here is a formula problem with no rate in it at all. A rectangular field is 20 metres longer than it is wide, and 220 metres of fencing goes all the way round it. Find both dimensions.
Two quantities are unknown, the length and the width, and you have only one equation available. The way out is to notice that the words tie the two together, so one letter can carry both.
Name the width, then write the length in terms of it
Why: the words say the length is 20 more than the width, so calling the width w forces the length to be w plus 20.
\[ w = \text{width}, \qquad l = w + 20 \]
Figure (svg): A rectangle whose two horizontal sides are drawn thick in orange and labelled as w plus 20, and whose two vertical sides are thick in blue and labelled w, with the total fence marked as 220 metres.
The drawing is where the choice becomes obvious. Put w on the short sides and w plus 20 on the long sides, and the whole rectangle is described by one letter, which is the only way a single equation can succeed.
Use the perimeter formula as the verbal model
Why: two lengths and two widths, all in metres, adding to the 220 metres of fencing.
\[ 2l + 2w = 220 \]
Substitute the expression for the length
Why: with brackets, because the whole of w plus 20 is doubled, not just the w.
\[ 2(w + 20) + 2w = 220 \]
Distribute the 2
Why: the bracket is multiplied through, so both the w and the 20 are doubled.
\[ 2w + 40 + 2w = 220 \]
Combine like terms
Why: the two w terms are the same kind of thing and add to four of them.
\[ 4w + 40 = 220 \]
Subtract 40, then divide by 4
Why: the 40 was added to the term carrying w, so it comes off first, and only then does the coefficient come off.
\[ 4w = 180 \;\Longrightarrow\; w = 45 \]
Answer the question that was asked
Why: the question wanted both dimensions, not just the width, so finish by using the relation you wrote at the start.
\[ l = 45 + 20 = 65 \]
Check against the original words
Why: a field 65 metres by 45 metres is 20 metres longer than it is wide, as the words demanded, and its perimeter is exactly the 220 metres of fencing given.
\[ 2(65) + 2(45) = 130 + 90 = 220 \]
Both halves of that check matter. Checking only the perimeter would pass a 110 by 0 field, and checking only the difference would pass a 45 by 25 one. The words made two claims, so the check has to test two things.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 37 — Exercises 7 to 10, the perimeter formula
Trap
The maglev train, done without converting. Thirty kilometres and eight minutes go straight into the formula:
\[ r = \dfrac{30}{8} = 3.75 \]
The arithmetic is perfect. The number is even meaningful, and that is what makes this the most dangerous kind of error in the lesson.
Written as an answer of 3.75 kilometres per hour, it claims a bullet train is slower than a bicycle, and nothing in the working says otherwise.
The number 3.75 is a real rate, but it is kilometres per minute, because minutes are what went into the formula. The unit follows the numbers you used, not the unit you hoped for.
\[ r = 3.75\;\text{km/min} \]
\[ = 3.75(60) = 225\;\text{km/h} \]
So the working was not wasted, and you have two routes to the answer: convert the time first and divide, or divide first and convert the rate. Both give 225.
The guard against this is to write the unit beside every number as you use it. An answer labelled kilometres per minute cannot quietly be read as kilometres per hour, and labelling it costs one word.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 38 — Exercise 25
Section
Part 3
Concept
Sometimes no formula is handed to you, only a table of measurements. The second strategy reads the relationship out of the table, and the one thing to look at is the differences between consecutive values.
| Time (min), t | 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Height (ft), h | 2000 | 1750 | 1500 | 1250 | 1000 |
Figure (svg): A row of five heights, 2000, 1750, 1500, 1250 and 1000, with curved arrows underneath joining each to the next, and every arrow labelled minus 250.
Every arrow in the picture is the same, a drop of 250 feet. That single fact is what licenses an equation: the paramotorist is descending at a steady 250 feet per minute rather than in some complicated way.
Two numbers come out of a table like this. The starting value is the height at time zero, read straight off the first column, and the rate is the repeated difference, with a sign for its direction.
Descending means the height is going down, so the rate is subtracted. If the values had been rising, the same reading would give an addition, and nothing else about the method would change.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 35 — the table and the pattern in Example 2
Notation
Here is the model the table produces, before the numbers go in. Four short observations, and the third one is where the sign lives.
Annotate
On: \( h = 2000 - 250t \)
Read the last note again, because it is the unit check doing its work in a new setting. The rate could not simply be subtracted from 2000; it had to be multiplied by a time first, and that multiplication is what turned a rate into a length.
The shape of this model is worth memorising, because it reappears in every subject that measures anything over time. A starting value, plus or minus a rate, times an elapsed time.
In Chapter 2 this same expression gets a second name. The starting value becomes the y-intercept and the rate becomes the slope, and the equation you are writing here is a line.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 35 — the verbal model for Example 2
Worked example
A paramotor is a parachute pushed along by a fan-like motor. The table gives the height h of a paramotorist t minutes into a descent, and you are asked for the height after 7 minutes, which is past the end of the table.
Subtract along the row of heights
Why: the differences are what tell you whether a single rate exists, so compute them before anything else.
\[ 1750 - 2000 = -250, \quad 1500 - 1750 = -250, \quad 1250 - 1500 = -250 \]
All four differences are the same, so a steady rate describes the whole descent. Had they differed, no equation of this shape would have been available and the problem would be a different one.
Write the verbal model with units
Why: feet on the left, and feet minus feet per minute times minutes on the right, so every term is a length.
\[ \begin{array}{rcl} \text{Height (ft)} &=& \text{Initial height (ft)} \\ && - \;\text{Rate (ft/min)} \cdot \text{Time (min)} \end{array} \]
Put the two numbers from the table into it
Why: 2000 feet at time zero, and a drop of 250 feet for each minute.
\[ h = 2000 - 250t \]
Figure (svg): A falling straight line for the paramotorist's height against time, with the five table points marked on it and the point at seven minutes, height 250 feet, marked further along in yellow.
The five table points lie on one straight line, which is the visible version of the differences all being equal. The answer at 7 minutes is read off the same line, a little past where the measurements stopped.
Substitute 7 for t
Why: the model is now a machine: put in a time and a height comes out, with no equation left to solve.
\[ h = 2000 - 250(7) = 2000 - 1750 = 250 \]
Check the model against a row of the table
Why: a model built from a table must reproduce that table, so test it at a time you already know: at 3 minutes it must give 1250 feet, and it does.
\[ 2000 - 250(3) = 2000 - 750 = 1250 \]
This is the right check for a pattern problem. There is no formula to substitute back into, so the thing your answer must agree with is the data the model came from, and agreeing at one interior point is strong evidence.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 35 — Example 2
Prediction
Stay with the same paramotorist and look further along the model. The height was 250 feet after 7 minutes, and it is falling by 250 feet every minute.
Before answering, notice what the question is really about: not arithmetic, but what the model says about the situation it describes.
Predict first
According to the model, what happens at 8 minutes?
Correct: The height is zero, so the paramotorist has landed
Why: Two thousand minus 250 times 8 is zero, and a height of zero means ground level, which is where the graph meets the horizontal axis. The model keeps producing negative numbers after that, and those are meaningless, which is the first sign that a model has a limited range of times it describes.
So this model has a natural end, and the graph shows it: the line reaches the axis at 8 minutes and any time beyond that is outside the situation the table described.
Notice how you found the end. You did not need a new idea, only the honesty to ask what the numbers mean rather than just what they are, and to notice that a negative height is not a height.
Nothing in the algebra warns you about this. The expression happily gives minus 500 feet at 10 minutes, and only the words, a parachute descending towards the ground, can tell you to stop.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 35 — the paramotoring table
Worked example
The book repeats the problem with new numbers to check that you read the rate off the table rather than remembering it. The heights are 2400, 2190, 1980, 1770 and 1560 feet at minutes 0 through 4, and you want the height after 8 minutes.
Subtract along the row of heights
Why: do not assume the rate is 250 again; the whole point of this checkpoint is that it is not.
\[ 2190 - 2400 = -210, \quad 1980 - 2190 = -210, \quad 1770 - 1980 = -210 \]
A drop of 210 feet per minute this time, and the same four-in-a-row agreement that licenses an equation. Reading it off rather than recalling it is the habit this checkpoint is training.
Write the model with the table's own two numbers
Why: 2400 feet at time zero, falling at 210 feet per minute.
\[ h = 2400 - 210t \]
Substitute 8 for t
Why: eight minutes of descent at 210 feet a minute is 1680 feet lost.
\[ h = 2400 - 210(8) = 2400 - 1680 = 720 \]
Before accepting 720 feet, sanity-check its size. The table had already fallen to 1560 feet by minute 4, so another four minutes at the same rate must remove roughly another 840, landing somewhere near 700.
Check the model against a row of the table
Why: at 4 minutes the model must reproduce the last value in the table, and 2400 minus 840 is 1560, which is exactly what the table says.
\[ 2400 - 210(4) = 2400 - 840 = 1560 \]
Notice that the check used the far end of the table rather than the near end. Checking at time zero would only confirm you copied the first value, whereas checking at minute 4 tests the rate as well.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 36 — Guided Practice 2
Error analysis
This is the book's own error-analysis exercise. A table gives y values of 75, 65, 55 and 45 at x equal to 0, 1, 2 and 3, and the proposed model is the line below. Find what is wrong before reading the notes.
Annotate
On: \( y = 75x - 10 \)
\[ y = 75 - 10x \]
The quickest way to catch this kind of slip is to test the proposed model at a value in the middle of the table. The two ends can agree by coincidence, as they nearly do here, but the middle almost never does.
There is a reading habit that prevents it entirely. The number at x equal to zero has to be the term with no x attached, because setting x to zero must kill every other term and leave it standing.
Ask of each number what unit it carries. Seventy-five is a plain height and ten is a height for each step, so only the ten can meet an x, since only the ten has a step underneath it waiting to cancel.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 38 — Exercise 19
Discrimination
The pattern strategy only works when the differences really are constant, and that is a fact about the table rather than an assumption you are allowed to make. Test each of these.
Sort into buckets
Sort each table by whether a single constant rate describes it. In every one, x runs 0, 1, 2, 3.
Four of the six come straight from the book's exercise set, and the models are worth writing out once: 11 plus 4x, 60 minus 15x, 46 minus 10x and 57 plus 50x. Each one is two numbers lifted off the table.
The two that fail are worth a moment as well. Their differences grow, which is the signature of the curved relationships later in the book, and no amount of forcing will make a straight-line model describe them.
Notice how little arithmetic this needed. Three subtractions per table and you know whether the whole strategy applies, which makes it the first thing to do whenever a table appears.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 37 — Exercises 11 to 14
Fill the middle
A table gives y values of 12, 19, 26 and 33 at x equal to 0, 1, 2 and 3, and asks which equation represents it. Read the two numbers off rather than testing the four options.
The starting value is whatever appears at x equal to zero, and the rate is the repeated difference. Fill both in, and keep in mind which of the two is allowed to meet the x.
Fill in the blanks
y = 7x + 12
Why: The differences are 19 minus 12, then 26 minus 19, then 33 minus 26, all of them 7, so the rate is 7 and it carries the x. The value at x equal to zero is 12 and it stands alone. Check in the middle of the table: at x equal to 2 the model gives 14 plus 12, which is 26, exactly as listed.
The distractors the book offers are instructive. One of them swaps the two numbers, giving 5x plus 7, and another attaches the x to the starting value, which is the same error as the previous slide.
Reading the numbers off is faster than testing options, and it is also safer, because testing only at x equal to zero would let two wrong options through.
One more thing to notice: the rate came out positive here, so the term is added. Nothing about the method changed, only the direction the values were moving.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 37 — Exercise 15
Error analysis
The second error-analysis exercise, and much more subtle than the first. The table gives y values of 7, 17, 27 and 37, but this time x runs 0, 5, 10, 15 rather than 0, 1, 2, 3.
Annotate
On: \( y = 7 + 10x \)
\[ y = 7 + 2x \]
Figure (svg): Four points at x equal to 0, 5, 10 and 15 with y values 7, 17, 27 and 37, the correct line through them drawn solid, and a much steeper wrong line shooting off the top of the frame.
The picture shows exactly how badly the wrong version fails. The dashed line has the right starting point and leaves the frame almost immediately, missing every point in the table except the first.
The reason this error is so easy to make is that the first table in the exercise set steps by one, and so does every worked example. Dividing by the step is invisible when the step is one, and then it is forgotten when it is not.
So make the division explicit even when it changes nothing. Writing the rate as a change in y over a change in x, every time, is what protects you the one time in ten when the step is five.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 38 — Exercise 20
Tweak it
The starting height and the rate are two separate dials in this kind of model, and it is worth seeing what each one controls. Fix the start at 2000 feet and move the rate.
Parameter explorer
Set the rate to 250 and read the height at 4 minutes off the curve. Then set it to 200 and say what happens to the time at which the height reaches zero.
\[ h = 2000 - {r}t \]
Every setting gives a straight line starting from the same place, which is what the shared starting height means. Only the steepness changes, and the steepness is the rate.
Watch where each line meets the horizontal axis. A faster descent lands sooner, and the landing time is always 2000 divided by the rate, which is the distance formula turning up again inside a pattern problem.
One thing the slider cannot show you is a rate of zero, which would be a paramotorist hovering forever. The model would still be perfectly valid algebra and would never reach the ground, which is worth remembering when a rate in a problem is suspiciously small.
Edge cases
Exercise 27 gives a table of bamboo heights during a period of fast growth: 15, 16.5, 18, 19.5 and 21 feet on days 0 through 4. It then asks a question the earlier exercises did not.
Figure (svg): A straight line for bamboo height against days, solid over the first four days where measurements exist and dashed far beyond them, reaching about seventy-five feet at day forty.
Discussion prompt
Write the model for the table, then decide whether it is reasonable to assume the pattern continues indefinitely. Give a specific consequence of assuming it does.
The solid stub in the picture is all the evidence there is. Everything dashed is the model being trusted where nobody measured anything, and the further right you read, the less the line is worth.
This is a good habit to carry out of the lesson. A model built from four days of data answers questions about those four days and the few around them, and a question about day four hundred is a question about the plant, not about the algebra.
Extending a model slightly past its data has a name, and so does extending it a long way; the first is usually safe and the second usually is not. The paramotorist at 7 minutes was the safe kind, one minute past the table.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 38 — Exercise 27
Section
Part 4
Concept
The third strategy is the one students trust least and need most. When the situation is spatial, objects along a wall, cuts in a board, posts in a fence, drawing it is not a nicety; it is how you find out what to add up.
The reason is specific. Spatial problems hide a counting question, and the words are bad at counting. Four banners on a wall involve five gaps, and no amount of re-reading the sentence makes that number appear.
Roughly to scale matters more than it sounds. If your gaps are drawn wider than your banners and the answer comes out at 6 feet against banners of 8, the drawing quietly confirms the answer is plausible.
The drawing is also the thing you check against at the end. Putting 6 feet back into the picture and seeing the pieces fill the wall exactly is a better check than re-solving the equation.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 35 — the diagram strategy in Example 3
Picture it
Before any specific problem, look at the counting fact that all of these questions turn on. Two arrangements, both perfectly ordinary, give two different relationships between objects and gaps.
Figure (svg): A straight line with four dots on it, labelled as objects, and the three spaces between them labelled as gaps, beside a second line where the objects are inside the ends so the gaps outnumber them.
On the top line the objects sit at the ends, so there is one more object than gap: four posts and three gaps between them. That is the arrangement in a fence.
On the bottom line the objects are held away from the ends by a gap on each side, so there is one more gap than object: three banners and four gaps. That is the arrangement in Example 3, except with four banners and therefore five gaps.
So the question to ask of any spacing problem is whether the ends are occupied or empty. Everything else follows from that one reading, and getting it from a drawing takes ten seconds while getting it from the words takes an argument.
A third arrangement turns up at the very end of this lesson, on a circular kiosk, where the line closes up into a loop. There the ends vanish altogether and the two counts finally agree.
Worked example
You are hanging four championship banners on a gym wall. The banners are 8 feet wide and the wall is 62 feet long. The space between the ends of the wall and the banners, and between each pair of banners, must all be equal. How far apart should the banners be placed?
Draw and label the wall
Why: the drawing is the strategy here; label the unknown equal spaces with one letter and the banners with their known width.
\[ x = \text{each equal space, in feet} \]
Figure (svg): A 62 foot wall drawn as an outlined rectangle with four 8 foot banners hanging inside it, separated by five equal gaps each labelled x, drawn to scale.
Now count off the picture. Four banners, and five spaces, because a space sits at each end of the wall as well as between each neighbouring pair. That five is the whole difficulty of the problem.
Add the pieces along the wall
Why: the drawing says space, banner, space, banner, space, banner, space, banner, space, and all of it fills 62 feet.
\[ x + 8 + x + 8 + x + 8 + x + 8 + x = 62 \]
Combine like terms
Why: five spaces and four banners of 8 feet each, which is 32 feet of banner.
\[ 5x + 32 = 62 \]
Notice how the equation reads as the picture. Five lots of the unknown, and 32 feet already spoken for, which leaves whatever is left to be shared equally among the five spaces.
Subtract 32 from each side
Why: the banners take up a fixed 32 feet whatever x turns out to be, so that part comes off first.
\[ 5x = 30 \]
Divide each side by 5
Why: because five equal spaces share the 30 feet that remain.
\[ x = 6 \]
Check against the original words and the drawing
Why: five spaces of 6 feet is 30 feet and four banners of 8 feet is 32 feet, which together fill the wall exactly; and the spaces really are all equal, including the two at the ends, which is what the words demanded.
\[ 5(6) + 4(8) = 30 + 32 = 62 \]
Check both claims, not just the total. An answer of 7.5 feet would fill the wall too if you allowed only four spaces, so the arithmetic alone cannot tell you that the ends were handled properly. Only the drawing can.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 35 — Example 3
Prediction
Guided Practice 3 changes one thing: the same 62 foot wall, the same 8 foot banners, but only three of them. Decide what happens to each space before computing anything.
Two things change together, and they pull in the same direction. There is less banner on the wall, so more space to share, and there is one fewer space to share it among.
Predict first
With three banners instead of four on the same 62 foot wall, each space becomes:
Correct: 9.5 feet
Why: Three banners take 24 feet, leaving 38 feet, and three banners on a wall make four spaces rather than five, so each space is 38 divided by 4, which is 9.5 feet. The 12.67 comes from using three spaces instead of four, which is the same miscount as before with one banner removed.
\[ 4x + 24 = 62 \;\Longrightarrow\; 4x = 38 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 9.5 \]
The spaces grew by more than half, from 6 feet to 9.5, from removing a single banner. Both effects helped: 8 more feet became free and one fewer space had to be filled.
The wrong option worth looking at is 12.67 feet, which is 38 divided by 3. It comes from counting spaces the way you count banners, and it is the same error the previous slide warned about, arriving in a new set of numbers.
Check the prediction against the drawing in your head. Spaces of 9.5 feet are wider than the 8 foot banners, so the wall should look mostly empty, and with only three banners on 62 feet it does.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 36 — Guided Practice 3
Worked example
Here is the other arrangement, and it is from your homework rather than the book's examples. A straight fence 96 feet long has a post every 8 feet, including one at each end. How many posts?
Draw the fence and decide what the 8 feet measures
Why: the 8 feet is the distance between neighbouring posts, so it measures a gap, not a post.
\[ 8 = \text{one gap, in feet} \]
Figure (svg): A ground line 96 feet long with thirteen vertical posts standing on it at eight foot intervals, the first and last numbered 1 and 13, and one interval marked 8 ft.
The drawing settles the question the words leave open. Posts stand at both ends, so the gaps sit strictly between posts, and there is one more post than gap.
Find the number of gaps first
Why: the gaps are what the 8 feet describes, so they are the quantity the arithmetic can reach.
\[ 8n = 96 \;\Longrightarrow\; n = 12 \]
Twelve is a correct and complete answer to a question nobody asked. The question was about posts, and 12 is the number of gaps, so one more step remains.
Convert gaps into posts using the drawing
Why: each gap has a post at its left end, and one extra post closes off the right end of the fence.
\[ \text{posts} = n + 1 = 13 \]
Check against the original words
Why: thirteen posts leave twelve gaps between them, and twelve gaps of 8 feet is exactly the 96 feet of fence, with a post at each end as the words required.
\[ 12(8) = 96, \qquad 13 = 12 + 1 \]
Test the reasoning on a tiny case if you doubt it. A fence 8 feet long with a post at each end has one gap and two posts, so posts really do exceed gaps by one, and the rule survives the smallest example there is.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 35 — the diagram strategy of Example 3
Trap
The fence problem, finished one step too early:
\[ \dfrac{96}{8} = 12 \text{ posts} \]
The division is right, the number is right, and the label on it is wrong. Twelve is how many gaps there are.
This is not a careless slip; it is what happens when the answer is taken from the arithmetic rather than from the drawing. Nothing in the division knows whether you wanted posts or gaps.
Go back to the picture and count what the division produced. Dividing the length by the gap length can only ever give a number of gaps, because that is the quantity the 8 feet measures.
\[ 13 \text{ posts}, \quad 12 \text{ gaps} \]
Then convert, using whichever end rule the drawing shows. Posts at both ends means one more post than gap; objects held away from both ends means one more gap than object.
The general guard is to name the unit of every number you produce. A 12 labelled gaps cannot quietly become an answer about posts, and labelling it costs one word.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 35 — the diagram strategy
Worked example
You have a piece of wood 72 inches long and cut it into three pieces. The second piece is 6 inches longer than the first, and the third is 6 inches longer than the second. Find all three lengths.
Name the shortest piece and build the others from it
Why: each piece is described relative to the one before, so naming the first forces the other two.
\[ x, \quad x + 6, \quad (x + 6) + 6 = x + 12 \]
Notice how the third piece was written. It is 6 more than the second, and the second was already 6 more than the first, so the third is 12 more than the first rather than 6.
Figure (svg): A 72 inch board drawn to scale and cut into three pieces of 18, 24 and 30 inches, each labelled with its expression in x and its length.
The drawing makes the two extra stubs visible. Three equal pieces would be 24 inches each; the real pieces are 18, 24 and 30, so one is 6 short and one is 6 long, and the middle one happens to be the average.
Add the three pieces to the whole board
Why: the three pieces together are the 72 inches you started with, with nothing lost.
\[ x + (x + 6) + (x + 12) = 72 \]
Combine like terms
Why: three x terms make 3x, and the two constants add to 18.
\[ 3x + 18 = 72 \]
Subtract 18, then divide by 3
Why: the 18 inches of extra length is fixed whatever x is, so it comes off first.
\[ 3x = 54 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 18 \]
Answer the question that was asked
Why: the question wanted the lengths of the three pieces, so substitute back into the expressions you named at the start.
\[ 18, \quad 24, \quad 30 \]
Check against the original words
Why: 24 is 6 more than 18 and 30 is 6 more than 24, as the words required, and the three pieces add to the 72 inches of board.
\[ 18 + 24 + 30 = 72 \]
Again the words made two claims and the check tests both. Pieces of 20, 24 and 28 would also total 72 but would differ by 4 rather than 6, so a total-only check would let them through.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 39 — Exercise 29
Fill the middle
The book's diagram exercise. A 12 foot wall carries three objects 3 feet wide, with four equal spaces of x: one at each end and one between each neighbouring pair. Write and solve the equation.
Count the pieces off the drawing in the book before filling anything in. Three objects at 3 feet each, and four spaces, because the objects are held away from both ends.
Fill in the blanks
4x + 3(3) = 12 \;\Longrightarrow\; 4x = 3 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 0.75
Why: Three objects of 3 feet use 9 of the 12 feet, leaving 3 feet to be shared by four spaces, so each space is three quarters of a foot, which is 9 inches. Check against the drawing: four spaces of 0.75 is 3 feet, plus 9 feet of object, giving the 12 feet of wall.
Spaces of nine inches beside objects of three feet is a crowded wall, and the drawing should look crowded. If your picture shows generous gaps, it is the picture that is wrong, not the answer.
The companion exercise beside it is worth doing in your head now: a 15 foot wall, three objects of 2 feet, four spaces. Six feet of object leaves 9 feet for four spaces, so each one is 2.25 feet.
Those two exercises look identical and give very different answers, which is the point of having both. The method never changes; only what the drawing tells you to count does.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 37 — Exercises 17 and 18
Worked example
You want to tape five posters on a 15 foot wall so that the spaces between posters are all equal, and the spaces at the left and right of the group are three times the space between two adjacent posters. The posters are 1.5 feet wide. Find how to position them.
Name the small space, then write the big ones in terms of it
Why: the words compare the end spaces to the inner ones, so naming the inner space makes the end space 3x.
\[ x = \text{one inner space}, \qquad 3x = \text{one end space} \]
Figure (svg): A 15 foot wall with five posters of 1.5 feet on it, four small equal gaps between them labelled x and two wide end gaps labelled 3x, drawn to scale.
Count off the drawing. Five posters, four inner spaces between them, and two end spaces, one at each side. That is eleven pieces along the wall, of three different kinds.
Add the pieces along the wall
Why: two end spaces of 3x, four inner spaces of x, and five posters of 1.5 feet, filling the 15 foot wall.
\[ 2(3x) + 4x + 5(1.5) = 15 \]
Simplify each group
Why: the two end spaces contribute 6x altogether, and the posters contribute 7.5 feet.
\[ 6x + 4x + 7.5 = 15 \]
Combine like terms
Why: the end spaces and inner spaces are all multiples of the same x, so they add to 10x.
\[ 10x + 7.5 = 15 \]
Ten lots of x is the surprise in this problem. There are only six spaces, but two of them count triple, so the equation behaves as though there were ten of the small ones.
Subtract 7.5, then divide by 10
Why: the posters use a fixed 7.5 feet, so that comes off first, leaving 7.5 feet of space to distribute.
\[ 10x = 7.5 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 0.75 \]
Answer in the form the question wants
Why: the question asked how to position the posters, so both sizes of space are part of the answer.
\[ x = 0.75\text{ ft}, \qquad 3x = 2.25\text{ ft} \]
Check against the original words and the drawing
Why: the two end spaces of 2.25 feet are exactly three times the inner spaces of 0.75 feet, as the words required, and everything adds to the 15 foot wall.
\[ 2(2.25) + 4(0.75) + 5(1.5) = 4.5 + 3 + 7.5 = 15 \]
Notice that three quarters of a foot is 9 inches and 2.25 feet is 2 feet 3 inches, which is how you would actually mark the wall. Converting the answer into the units a person would use is part of answering the question.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 39 — Exercise 30
Section
Part 5
Concept
The last kind of problem in this lesson has two unknown quantities and only one equation, which sounds impossible. It is not, because the two quantities are tied together by a total you were given.
Figure (svg): A bar representing fourteen gallons of fuel, split into a long left piece labelled g for the highway and a short right piece labelled 14 minus g for the city.
Look at the bar. Its whole length is fixed at 14 gallons, so choosing where to cut it fixes both pieces at once. Name the left piece g and the right piece has no freedom left: it is 14 minus g.
That is the entire trick, and it is worth saying as a sentence you can reuse. When two amounts add to a known total, name one of them and write the other as the total minus the first.
\[ g + (14 - g) = 14 \]
The line above is worth checking rather than trusting: the two expressions really do add to 14, whatever g is, so the pair is a genuine split of the total and not a guess.
In Chapter 3 you will keep two letters and write two equations instead of collapsing to one. Both methods work, and what you are doing here is the second equation being substituted in before it is ever written down.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 36 — the verbal model for Example 4
Notation
Here is the model for the fuel problem, and every piece of it is worth naming before you solve it. Four notes, and the third is the one the whole part turns on.
Annotate
On: \( 550 = 40g + 35(14 - g) \)
Check the units across the whole line once more. Two products, each a rate times an amount, both coming out in miles, added together and set equal to a distance in miles. Every term agrees.
The bracket is not optional. The whole of 14 minus g is multiplied by 35, because every one of those gallons delivers 35 miles, and dropping the bracket would multiply only the 14.
Notice which category the letter names. It names the highway gallons because the question asked for the highway gallons, and choosing the letter to be the thing you want saves a step at the end.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 36 — Example 4, Step 1
Step zero
A car used 14 gallons of gasoline and travelled 550 miles. Its fuel efficiency is 40 miles per gallon on the highway and 35 miles per gallon in the city. How many gallons were used on the highway?
Do not start solving. Answer three questions about the problem first, because the plan is where this kind of problem is won.
Discussion prompt
What exactly is the question asking for, what are the two quantities that add to a known total, and which single letter should you name? Write all three down before you read on.
The 14 and the 550 are doing completely different jobs, and confusing them is the commonest way this problem goes wrong. One is the total being split; the other is the total being added up to.
Tell them apart by their units. Gallons can only be split among gallons and miles can only be added to miles, so the unit of a number tells you which side of the equation it belongs on.
Having a plan also tells you when you are finished. You are looking for one number in gallons, on the highway, so an answer of 480 miles is not an answer to this question however correct it is.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 36 — Example 4
Worked example
The car from the previous slide: 14 gallons used, 550 miles travelled, 40 miles per gallon on the highway and 35 in the city. Find the highway gallons.
Name the letter and write the other category in terms of it
Why: the 14 gallons is the total being split, so naming the highway gallons forces the city gallons.
\[ g = \text{highway gallons}, \qquad 14 - g = \text{city gallons} \]
Write the verbal model with units
Why: total miles equals miles per gallon times gallons, for the highway, plus the same product for the city.
\[ \begin{array}{rcl} \text{Total (mi)} &=& \text{Highway (mi/gal)} \cdot \text{Gas (gal)} \\ && + \; \text{City (mi/gal)} \cdot \text{Gas (gal)} \end{array} \]
Put the numbers and the expression into it
Why: 40 miles per gallon for g gallons, and 35 miles per gallon for the rest.
\[ 550 = 40g + 35(14 - g) \]
Figure (svg): Two horizontal roads of different lengths, a long one for 480 highway miles and a short one for 70 city miles, and beneath them a single bar of 550 miles with a mark where the two meet.
The two roads are drawn at their true lengths using the answer you are about to get. Almost all of the 550 miles is highway, which is what you would expect when 12 of the 14 gallons went that way.
Distribute the 35
Why: every one of the remaining gallons delivers 35 miles, so the whole bracket is multiplied.
\[ 550 = 40g + 490 - 35g \]
Combine like terms
Why: 40g minus 35g is 5g, and the 490 is a plain number of miles.
\[ 550 = 5g + 490 \]
Look at what the 5 means before finishing. Moving one gallon from the city to the highway gains 5 extra miles, because the highway is 5 miles per gallon better, and that is the whole reason the equation can be solved.
Subtract 490 from each side
Why: 490 miles would be covered even if every gallon went in the city, so the extra 60 miles is what the highway gallons bought.
\[ 60 = 5g \]
Divide each side by 5
Why: each gallon shifted to the highway is worth 5 extra miles, so 60 extra miles means 12 gallons.
\[ 12 = g \]
Check against the original words
Why: the book's own check: 12 gallons on the highway and 2 in the city, which is 14 gallons in total as required, covering 480 plus 70 miles, which is the 550 given.
\[ 40(12) + 35(14 - 12) = 480 + 70 = 550 \]
The gallons check as well as the miles, and both matter. A pair like 13 and 2 would give 520 plus 70, which is not 550, and a pair like 12 and 3 would use 15 gallons rather than 14.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 36 — Example 4
Error analysis
Here is the same problem attempted with a letter for each category. Every line is legal, and yet the work cannot be finished. Find the reason before reading the notes.
Annotate
On: \( 550 = 40h + 35c, \quad h + c = 14 \)
\[ c = 14 - h \;\Longrightarrow\; 550 = 40h + 35(14 - h) \]
This is worth understanding rather than avoiding, because the two-letter version is where you are heading. In Chapter 3 you will keep both equations and solve them together, and this lesson is the special case where one of them is easy enough to substitute immediately.
The practical warning is about the moment you notice a second letter appearing. If a second letter arrives and you have only one equation, stop and ask what the total is that ties the two together.
The other common form of this error is subtler: writing 40g plus 35g and getting 75g. That treats every gallon as burned twice, once on each road, and it gives 550 divided by 75, which is not a whole number of gallons and should ring an alarm.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 36 — Example 4, Step 1
Worked example
A truck used 28 gallons of gasoline and travelled 428 miles. Its fuel efficiency is 16 miles per gallon on the highway and 12 in the city. How many gallons were used in the city?
This checkpoint changes the question as well as the numbers. It asks for the city gallons, so name the city gallons, and the highway gallons become the leftovers.
Name the letter to be the thing asked for
Why: the question wants city gallons, so let c be the city gallons and the highway gets what remains of the 28.
\[ c = \text{city gallons}, \qquad 28 - c = \text{highway gallons} \]
Write the model with each rate on its own gallons
Why: 16 miles per gallon on the highway gallons, 12 miles per gallon on the city gallons, adding to 428 miles.
\[ 428 = 16(28 - c) + 12c \]
Distribute the 16
Why: the whole bracket is multiplied, so both the 28 and the c.
\[ 428 = 448 - 16c + 12c \]
The 448 is worth reading. It is the distance the truck would have covered with all 28 gallons on the highway, and it is more than the 428 actually driven, which is how you know some city driving happened.
Combine like terms
Why: minus 16c plus 12c is minus 4c, because each gallon moved into the city costs 4 miles.
\[ 428 = 448 - 4c \]
Subtract 448 from each side
Why: this isolates the term carrying c, leaving a negative number on each side.
\[ -20 = -4c \]
Divide each side by negative 4
Why: a negative divided by a negative is positive, so c comes out positive as a number of gallons must.
\[ c = 5 \]
Check against the original words
Why: 5 gallons in the city and 23 on the highway is 28 gallons in total as required, and 368 plus 60 miles is the 428 the truck drove.
\[ 16(23) + 12(5) = 368 + 60 = 428 \]
The 20 mile shortfall is the quickest way to see the answer coming. Each city gallon costs 4 miles compared with a highway gallon, so 20 miles of shortfall means exactly 5 city gallons, and that reasoning agrees with the algebra.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 36 — Guided Practice 4
Tweak it
The equation in Example 4 has more than one number that could change. Hold the 14 gallons and the highway rate fixed, and see what the city rate does to the trip.
Parameter explorer
With the city rate at 35, read the total distance when 12 gallons go on the highway. Then drop the city rate to 25 and say why the curve tilts more steeply.
\[ d = 40g + {c}(14 - g) \]
Every setting gives a straight line, and the steepness of that line is the difference between the two rates. When the two rates are close, the line is nearly flat and the split barely matters.
Push the city rate all the way up to 40 and the line becomes horizontal at 560 miles. With both roads equally efficient there is nothing to solve, because every split gives the same distance, and the original problem would have no unique answer.
That is a useful thing to know about this whole family of problems. They are solvable precisely because the two categories differ, and the bigger the difference, the more sharply the total pins down the split.
Worked example
A moving company weighs 20 boxes you packed, each containing either books or clothes, and reports a total of 404 pounds. A box of books weighs 40 pounds and a box of clothes weighs 7. Find how many of each you packed.
Name one category and write the other as the remainder
Why: the 20 boxes is the total being split, so naming the book boxes forces the clothes boxes.
\[ b = \text{boxes of books}, \qquad 20 - b = \text{boxes of clothes} \]
Figure (svg): Twenty small squares in a row, the first eight shaded blue for boxes of books and the remaining twelve orange for boxes of clothes, with weights noted underneath.
The drawing is twenty squares with a colour change somewhere in it. Every position of that boundary gives a different total weight, and the problem is asking which position gives 404 pounds.
Write the verbal model with units
Why: pounds per box times boxes, for each kind, adding to the total weight in pounds.
\[ \begin{array}{rcl} \text{Total (lb)} &=& \text{Books (lb/box)} \cdot \text{Boxes} \\ && + \; \text{Clothes (lb/box)} \cdot \text{Boxes} \end{array} \]
Put the numbers and the expression into it
Why: 40 pounds each for b boxes, and 7 pounds each for the rest of the 20.
\[ 40b + 7(20 - b) = 404 \]
Distribute the 7
Why: every one of the remaining boxes weighs 7 pounds, so the whole bracket is multiplied.
\[ 40b + 140 - 7b = 404 \]
Combine like terms
Why: 40b minus 7b is 33b, because each box switched from clothes to books adds 33 pounds.
\[ 33b + 140 = 404 \]
The 140 is the weight if every box held clothes, and 33 is what each swap to books costs. Reading the equation that way, the answer is the number of swaps needed to climb from 140 pounds to 404.
Subtract 140, then divide by 33
Why: 264 extra pounds at 33 pounds per swap gives the number of book boxes.
\[ 33b = 264 \;\Longrightarrow\; b = 8 \]
Answer both parts of the question
Why: the question asked for both counts, so finish with the expression you named at the start.
\[ b = 8, \qquad 20 - b = 12 \]
Check against the original words
Why: 8 boxes of books and 12 of clothes is 20 boxes as the company weighed, and 320 plus 84 pounds is the 404 reported.
\[ 40(8) + 7(12) = 320 + 84 = 404 \]
Both counts came out as whole numbers, which they had to: you cannot pack two thirds of a box. When a problem of this shape gives a fractional answer, suspect the model before the arithmetic.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 39 — Exercise 31
Fill the middle
From the quiz at the end of the lesson. Calla lilies cost 3.50 each and peonies cost 5.50 each, and 12 flowers cost 52 in total. Find how many of each you bought.
Name the lilies and the peonies become the remainder of the 12. Before filling in, notice that all-peonies would cost 66 and all-lilies 42, so the answer sits between and closer to the peony end.
Fill in the blanks
3.5c + 5.5(12 - c) = 52 \;\Longrightarrow\; c = 7, \quad 12 - c = 5
Why: Distributing gives 3.5c plus 66 minus 5.5c, so 66 minus 2c is 52 and c is 7. That leaves 5 peonies. Check against the words: seven lilies at 3.50 is 24.50 and five peonies at 5.50 is 27.50, which add to 52 for 12 flowers.
The 2 in the middle of that working is the price difference between the two flowers. Every lily you swap for a peony adds 2 to the bill, which is why the equation can pin the split down at all.
The estimate at the top is the real skill here. Knowing in advance that the answer is a mixture leaning towards peonies means an answer of 11 lilies and 1 peony would have looked wrong before you checked it.
The companion quiz problem is worth doing the same way. A chess tutor charges 1.5 times as much for the first lesson as for later ones and 10 lessons cost 315, so the fee sits in 10.5 equal shares: 30 for a later lesson and 45 for the first.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 40 — Quiz for Lessons 1.3 to 1.5, Exercise 12
Worked example
A duathlon is a run, a bike ride, and a second run. One participant completed a 55 kilometre duathlon in 2 hours 35 minutes, running at 12 kilometres per hour and biking at 30. Find how much time was spent running and how much biking.
Convert the total time into hours
Why: the rates are per hour, so the time must be in hours before it can be split.
\[ 2\text{ h }35\text{ min} = 2 + \dfrac{35}{60} = \dfrac{31}{12} \approx 2.5833\text{ h} \]
This problem splits a total of time rather than a total of gallons or boxes, and everything else about the method is identical. That is worth noticing: the shape of the model does not care what is being split.
Name the running time and write the biking time as the remainder
Why: the two times add to the whole race, so naming one forces the other.
\[ r = \text{running hours}, \qquad \dfrac{31}{12} - r = \text{biking hours} \]
Figure (svg): A bar of 55 kilometres split into three legs: a short run, a long bike ride of 40 kilometres, and a second short run, with a dashed bracket joining the two runs.
The bracket in the drawing is the modelling decision. Two separate runs happen, but both are run at 12 kilometres per hour, so the model needs only their combined time.
Write the verbal model with units
Why: kilometres per hour times hours, for the running and for the biking, adding to the race distance in kilometres.
\[ \begin{array}{rcl} \text{Race (km)} &=& \text{Run rate (km/h)} \cdot \text{Run time (h)} \\ && + \; \text{Bike rate (km/h)} \cdot \text{Bike time (h)} \end{array} \]
Put the numbers and the expression into it
Why: 12 kilometres per hour for r hours of running, and 30 for whatever hours are left.
\[ 55 = 12r + 30\left(\dfrac{31}{12} - r\right) \]
Distribute the 30
Why: thirty times thirty-one twelfths is 77.5 kilometres, which is what biking the whole race would have covered.
\[ 55 = 12r + 77.5 - 30r \]
Combine like terms
Why: 12r minus 30r is minus 18r, because every hour moved from biking to running loses 18 kilometres.
\[ 55 = 77.5 - 18r \]
Subtract 77.5, then divide by negative 18
Why: the race fell 22.5 kilometres short of an all-biking race, and each running hour costs 18 kilometres.
\[ -22.5 = -18r \;\Longrightarrow\; r = 1.25 \]
Find the biking time from the total
Why: the remaining time is the race time minus the running time, which is one hour and twenty minutes.
\[ \dfrac{31}{12} - 1.25 = \dfrac{31}{12} - \dfrac{15}{12} = \dfrac{16}{12} = \dfrac43 \]
Check against the original words, distance by distance
Why: this is part d of the exercise: the running covers 12 times 1.25, the biking covers 30 times four thirds, and the two distances must add to the 55 kilometres of the race.
\[ 12(1.25) + 30\left(\dfrac43\right) = 15 + 40 = 55 \]
The times check too: 1.25 hours plus four thirds of an hour is one and a quarter plus one and a third, which is two hours and thirty-five minutes. Both totals agree with the words, which is what a full check of this problem requires.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 39 — Exercise 32
Section
Part 6
Pattern
Every problem in this lesson followed the same six steps, and the strategies only changed what step 2 looked like. Here is the loop, with the part people skip drawn as the arrow that closes it.
Figure (svg): A flow diagram of six boxes in two rows. The top row runs left to right from the words to the picture to the chosen letter; the bottom row runs right to left from the equation to solving it to checking against the words.
Steps 1 and 2 are the modelling, and they are where the marks are. Reading the words with units and getting the situation onto paper is what makes step 4 a transcription rather than a guess.
The last step is the one worth defending. Checking in your own equation confirms only your own arithmetic; checking against the sentence is the only test of whether you modelled the right situation.
Notice that the three strategies all live inside step 2. That is why they are not three different methods to memorise: they are three ways of doing one step, and you choose between them by looking at what the problem gives you.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 34 — the three strategies named on the opening page
Worked example
Your cell phone plan costs 40 per month plus 10 cents per text message, and the bill arrives at 53.80. The exercise asks you to estimate from a table first, then find the exact answer from a model, and then compare the two.
Build the table the exercise asks for
Why: the plan charges 40 whatever happens, plus a tenth of a dollar for each text, so 50 texts add 5 dollars.
\[ 40, \; 45, \; 50, \; 55, \; 60 \quad \text{at } 0, 50, 100, 150, 200 \text{ texts} \]
Read the estimate off that row before doing any algebra. The bill of 53.80 sits between the 50 at a hundred texts and the 55 at a hundred and fifty, and closer to the upper end, so expect something near 140.
Figure (svg): A gently rising line showing a monthly phone bill against the number of text messages sent, with the five table points marked and a dashed line at 53.80 dollars meeting the line at 138 texts.
Write the verbal model with units
Why: dollars equals a fixed monthly charge in dollars, plus dollars per text times texts.
\[ \text{Bill (dollars)} = \text{Fixed (dollars)} + \text{Rate (dollars/text)} \cdot \text{Texts} \]
Put the numbers in
Why: 40 dollars fixed, a tenth of a dollar per text, and a bill of 53.80.
\[ 40 + 0.10t = 53.80 \]
Subtract 40 from each side
Why: the fixed charge is there whether you text or not, so it comes off first and leaves the texting part alone.
\[ 0.10t = 13.80 \]
Divide each side by 0.10
Why: each text costs a tenth of a dollar, so dividing the texting charge by that gives the number of texts.
\[ t = \dfrac{13.80}{0.10} = 138 \]
Part c of the exercise asks whether the estimate and the exact answer agree. One hundred and thirty-eight does sit between 100 and 150, and nearer 150, which is what the table predicted.
Check against the original words
Why: a hundred and thirty-eight texts at ten cents each is 13.80 in messages, and adding the fixed 40 gives exactly the 53.80 on the bill.
\[ 40 + 0.10(138) = 40 + 13.80 = 53.80 \]
The table and the model are doing genuinely different jobs here. The table gives you a rough answer you cannot be badly wrong about, and the model gives you an exact one you could be badly wrong about, which is why the exercise asks for both.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 39 — Exercise 28
Real world
Exercise 33 is the challenge problem, and it is a spacing question on a shape that is not a straight line. You are hanging fliers round a cylindrical kiosk 5 feet across, and you want 15 fliers of 8.5 inches evenly spaced.
Figure (svg): A circle seen from above representing a kiosk five feet across, with fifteen short thick arcs round its edge standing for the fliers and fifteen equal gaps between them.
Look at the picture before reading the question again. Walking round the circle you pass a flier, a gap, a flier, a gap, and eventually arrive back at the first flier, with no gap left over.
Discussion prompt
Find the length of the edge you are hanging the fliers on, decide how many gaps there are, and work out how far apart the fliers should be placed.
Two unit conversions had to happen before any counting: feet into inches, and a diameter into a circumference. Both are the kind of step that never appears in the sentence and always appears in the answer.
The counting rule is the interesting part. On a straight wall the gaps and the objects differ by one in one direction or the other; on a closed loop they are equal, because the line has been joined up and the ends have gone.
Ask yourself which of the three arrangements you are in whenever a spacing problem appears, and get the answer from a drawing. It is the fastest decision in this lesson and the most expensive one to get wrong.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.5 Use Problem Solving Strategies and Models §1.5, p. 39 — Exercise 33
Comparison
Four situations, sorted by the clue in the words rather than by the subject. Fill in the missing cells, and notice that you can decide each row without doing any arithmetic.
Comparison matrix
| the situation | the clue in the words | the model's shape | letters named |
|---|---|---|---|
| 457 miles in 6.5 hours | a standard relationship | d = rt | 1 |
| heights 2400, 2190, 1980, 1770 | a table | start − rate × time | 1 |
| four banners on a 62 ft wall | a shape and equal spaces | a sum of lengths | 1 |
| 14 gallons split between two roads | a total and two categories | rate × g + rate × (14 − g) | 1 |
The last column is the punchline of the whole lesson. Every one of these problems is modelled with a single letter, however many unknown quantities the words seem to contain.
Read the second column on its own and it becomes a checklist for an unfamiliar problem. Is there a standard relationship, a table of values, a shape, or a total split into categories? One of the four is almost always there.
The third row is the odd one out in a useful way. Its model has no rate in it at all, only lengths added together, and that is why a drawing rather than a formula is what produces the equation.
If a problem shows two of these clues at once, take both. The kiosk problem needed a formula for the circumference and a drawing for the counting, and leaving either out would have sunk it.
Matching
Four fresh situations, and four model shapes. Decide by the clue in the words alone, and say to yourself which word settled each one before you pair it.
Match the pairs
Why: The first names a rate and asks for a time, which is the distance formula divided. The second is a table with equal differences of 4, so it is a starting value of 11 plus 4x. The third is spatial, so the pieces are named on a drawing and added. The fourth gives a total count and two categories, which is the one-letter split.
The word that settles each row is short. A rate points at a formula, a table points at differences, the word cut points at a drawing, and a total with two kinds in it points at the split.
The last row is worth setting up even though you are not solving it here. Twenty coins with n nickels means 20 minus n dimes, and the total is best written in cents so that no decimals appear at all.
If you paired these in under a minute, you have what this lesson was built to deliver. The algebra afterwards is all from Lesson 1.3, and the choice you just made is the part that is new.
Check
A balloon starts at 900 feet and descends 60 feet each minute, and you want its height after some number of minutes. Judge the four models by units alone, before any numbers go in.
Check your understanding
Which verbal model has units that balance?
Answer: A
Why: Feet per minute times minutes is feet, so the right-hand side of the first option is a length minus a length, which is a length, matching the left. That is the only one where both sides carry the same unit.
Every wrong option is a real mistake rather than a random wrong answer: one forgets to multiply the rate by a time, one confuses what is being asked for, and one multiplies by the time twice.
Notice that you never needed the 900 or the 60. The shape of the model is settled by units alone, and only then do the numbers go in, which is the order the whole lesson has been arguing for.
The correct model in symbols is a height of 900 minus 60 times the minutes, which is the same shape as the paramotorist's descent. Once you have met that shape, every falling-at-a-steady-rate problem is the same problem.
One last reading of option B, because it is the tempting one. It would say a balloon at 900 feet is at 840 feet forever, no matter how long it has been falling, which is what leaving out the time actually means.
Check
A shop sells 20 sandwiches in a morning, some at 4 dollars and some at 6, and takes 104 dollars. Let f be the number of the cheaper sandwiches. Choose the equation before solving anything.
Check your understanding
Which equation models the situation correctly?
Answer: B
Why: There are 20 sandwiches in total and f of them were the cheap ones, so 20 minus f were the dearer ones. Each group contributes its price times its count, and the two contributions add to the takings. Solving gives f equal to 8, so 8 cheap and 12 dear, and 32 plus 72 is 104.
The test that settles it in one glance is to add up the counts. Only the second option has counts that total 20, which is the one thing the words told you for certain.
Option C is the most common wrong answer in this family, because the subtraction feels symmetric when it is not. The total comes first and the named quantity is taken away from it, never the other way round.
Check the winner with numbers rather than with feeling. Eight sandwiches at 4 dollars is 32 and twelve at 6 is 72, which adds to the 104 taken, and eight plus twelve is the 20 sold.
Notice that the letter here names the group you were told about rather than the group you want, which is fine. You would just finish with a subtraction, exactly as the truck problem did.
Check
A straight garden path 45 metres long has a bench every 9 metres, including one at each end. Decide the count from a drawing rather than from the division.
Check your understanding
How many benches are there along the path?
Answer: C
Why: Dividing 45 by 9 gives 5, and that 5 is the number of gaps between benches. Benches stand at both ends, so there is one more bench than gap, giving 6 benches. Check it on a small case: a 9 metre path with a bench at each end has one gap and two benches.
This is the fence problem in different clothes, and the same single sentence decides it: the objects are at the ends, so the objects outnumber the gaps by one.
Option B is worth dwelling on because it is the answer the arithmetic hands you. The division is correct, the number is correct, and the label on it is wrong, which is the trap from Part 4 arriving in a check.
Draw it if you are unsure, even here. Six dots along a line with five spaces between them takes five seconds to sketch and removes all doubt.
The same question with the benches held away from both ends would have a different answer, and nothing about the numbers would change. Only the drawing tells the two apart.
Explain it to yourself
One idea has carried this whole lesson, and putting it into your own sentences is what makes it stick. Write your answer out before reading the one provided.
Discussion prompt
In three or four sentences, explain why the verbal model with units comes before the algebraic model, and give one specific error from this lesson that the units caught. Then say why the final check goes back to the words rather than to the equation you wrote.
If your explanation talked mostly about solving, try writing it again. The solving in this lesson was all from Lesson 1.3, and everything genuinely new happened before the first equals sign.
A good test of your own understanding: could you set up the paramotorist, the banners and the fuel problem without solving any of them? Setting up all three correctly is the whole skill this lesson delivers.
Try the second half of the question on something from your own week as well. Anything described in words and answered with a number, a journey time, a bill, a shopping split, has a verbal model behind it and is worth writing down once.
Exit ticket
One problem that uses all of it: a total split into two categories, a choice of unit that makes or breaks the arithmetic, and a check against the original sentence.
Twenty coins, all of them nickels or dimes, are worth 1.55 dollars in total. A nickel is 5 cents and a dime is 10 cents.
Discussion prompt
Model this with a single letter, solve it, and check your answer against both claims the words make. Say also why working in cents is easier than working in dollars here.
The choice of unit is the part to notice. In dollars the equation reads 0.05n plus 0.10 times the rest, and every line carries decimals that are easy to misplace; in cents the same equation has nothing but whole numbers in it.
Work through the model in the order the lesson taught. Find the total being split, name the letter as one category, write the other as the total minus it, and put a unit on every number before it goes in.
If the check occurred to you only when prompted, add it to your routine now. Two claims in the words means two things to test, and testing only the money would pass a pair like nine nickels and twelve dimes.
Recap
Four shapes of problem and one routine: say the relationship in words with units, get the situation onto paper, name one letter, write the equation, solve it, and check against the sentence you started from.
| the clue in the words | the strategy | the model's shape | from this lesson |
|---|---|---|---|
| a standard relationship | use a formula | d = rt, or P = 2l + 2w | the Acela, the maglev, the field |
| a table of values | look for a pattern | start plus or minus rate × time | the paramotorist, the bamboo |
| a shape with lengths along it | draw a diagram | lengths added along the drawing | the banners, the fence, the board |
| a total split into two kinds | one letter, total minus it | rate × g + rate × (total − g) | the fuel, the boxes, the duathlon |
\[ 550 = 40g + 35(14 - g) \]
That line is the shape to carry away from Part 5. One letter, one bracket holding the total minus it, and two products that both come out in the unit on the left.
Look back at the table and notice that the first three rows are really about producing an equation, and the fourth is about producing it with only one letter. All four then hand the work over to Lesson 1.3.
Two habits are worth keeping past this lesson. Put a unit on every quantity before it enters an equation, and finish by testing every claim the words made rather than only the total, because a model can satisfy one and fail the other.
Chapter 3 picks this up directly. There you will keep both letters and write both equations instead of substituting one into the other immediately, and the fuel problem is the example you will recognise when it arrives.
OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §2.3 Models and Applications §2.3 — the same verbal-model routine, called setting up a linear model
Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Algebra 2 — $55/session, free consultation.