Solving a formula or an equation for one of its variables: one-step and two-step rearrangements, rewriting a linear equation for y, and factoring out the target variable when it appears in more than one term.
Subject: Algebra 2 · 63 slides · symbolic lesson
Open the interactive version of this deck
Title
Algebra 2 · Lesson 1.4
Solving for a letter is solving an equation, with letters where the numbers were
Objectives
You have spent three lessons solving equations for x. Every one of them ended with a number. This lesson keeps all of those moves and changes one thing: the other quantities are letters, so the answer is a formula instead of a number.
That sounds like a small change, and it is. The difficulty people report here is almost never the algebra; it is the discomfort of an answer that still has letters in it. If that feeling turns up, remember that the letters are only numbers you have not been told yet.
The pay-off is worth naming now. Rearrange once and you can answer the same question for twenty different sets of numbers without ever solving again, which is exactly what the store owner in Example 5 and the track designer in Exercise 36 need.
Two habits will carry you through every slide here. Ask how the target letter is attached before you move anything, and finish by putting your numbers back into the equation you started from.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 26 — Before, Now, Why and the Key Vocabulary
Warm-up
Before any letters, warm up the moves on an equation whose answer is a number. Write your solution down before you read on; committing to paper first is what makes the comparison later worth anything.
\[ 2w + 24 = 41 \]
Discussion prompt
Solve for w, and write beside each line the reason for the move you made.
Notice what you did not have to think about: which move to make first. The 24 was added last when the expression was built, so it comes off first. That ordering is the whole of Part 3, arriving early.
Keep those two reasons in view for the rest of the lesson. Every rearrangement you are about to meet is one of them, or both, applied when 24 and 41 have been replaced by letters.
Check your answer the way you will be checking every answer from here on: put 8.5 back into the equation you started with. Two lots of 8.5 is 17, and 17 plus 24 is 41, so the value is right.
One last thing about this particular equation. It is the perimeter of a rectangle 12 metres long, written out with the numbers already in place, and you will meet it again in Part 3 with the numbers taken back out.
Section
Part 1
Concept
A formula is an equation relating two or more quantities, with a letter standing for each. You have met most of these already in geometry, which is exactly why they are useful here: the algebra is new, the formulas are not.
| quantity | formula | what the letters mean |
|---|---|---|
| distance | d = rt | d distance, r rate, t time |
| temperature | F = (9/5)C + 32 | F degrees Fahrenheit, C degrees Celsius |
| area of a triangle | A = bh/2 | b base, h height |
| area of a rectangle | A = lw | l length, w width |
| perimeter of a rectangle | P = 2l + 2w | l length, w width |
| area of a trapezoid | A = (b₁ + b₂)h/2 | b₁ and b₂ the two bases, h height |
| area of a circle | A = πr² | r radius |
| circumference of a circle | C = 2πr | r radius |
Read down the middle column and notice something about how each one is written. In every case a single letter sits alone on the left and the recipe for it sits on the right. The formula is written to hand you that one letter.
The circumference formula hands you C when you know r. Nothing in it is set up to hand you r when you know C, and yet that is the question a builder actually asks: I have measured round the tree, how thick is it? Closing that gap is what this lesson does.
Two of these will come back repeatedly, so look at them now. The distance formula and the temperature formula are the ones you are most likely to meet outside a maths lesson, and both get rearranged before the deck is over.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 26 — the table of common formulas
Picture it
Before rearranging anything, spend a moment matching each letter to something you could measure with a ruler. A formula you can picture is far harder to rearrange wrongly, because a silly answer looks silly.
Figure (svg): Four panels: a rectangle with sides labelled l and w, a triangle with base b and a dashed height h, a trapezoid with bases b sub one and b sub two and height h, and a circle with radius r. Each panel carries its formula underneath.
In the triangle and the trapezoid, h is the perpendicular distance between the parallel sides, drawn dashed here. It is not the slanted edge, and that single confusion accounts for a surprising number of wrong areas.
The circle panel carries two formulas because the radius controls both. Notice that the circumference uses r once and the area uses it twice; that difference decides whether solving for r is a division or, later in the year, a square root.
Keeping the picture in mind protects you at the end of a problem too. When a rearrangement produces a negative length or a width bigger than the whole rectangle, it is the picture, not the algebra, that tells you something went wrong.
Notation
This is the busiest formula in the table and the one whose rearrangement goes wrong most often. Take it apart before using it, so that when you rearrange it you are moving things you understand.
Annotate
On: \( A = \tfrac12 (b_1 + b_2)h \)
The order of those four notes is the order of the moves. Whatever wraps the target letter most loosely comes off first, so the half goes, then the height, and only then can you reach inside the bracket.
Subscripts trip people up because they look like exponents at a glance. A raised two would mean multiply by itself; a lowered two just means the second one. Nothing is ever multiplied by a subscript.
Why does the formula need two names for the bases at all? Because a trapezoid has two parallel sides of different lengths, and the area depends on both. A rectangle is the special case where the two names would hold the same number.
Read the formula aloud once before moving on: area is half of, bracket, base one plus base two, close bracket, times height. Saying a formula properly is a surprisingly good guard against rearranging it wrongly.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 26 — the Reading note on subscripts
Concept
The textbook's definition has two halves, and the second one is the half people forget. Read it slowly, because almost every error later in this lesson is this definition being half applied.
solve for a variable — Rewrite the equation as an equivalent equation in which the variable is alone on one side and does not appear on the other side.
Alone on one side is easy to check: glance at the left and see one letter with nothing attached. Absent from the other side is the condition that decides whether you can actually use what you have written.
\[ y = \dfrac{6}{2 + x} \qquad \text{solved for } y \]
\[ y = \dfrac{6 - 2y}{x} \qquad \text{not solved for } y \]
The second line is useless in practice. To work out the right-hand side you would already have to know y, which is the thing you were trying to find, so the line is true but circular.
The word equivalent matters too. Every move you make must keep exactly the same pairs of numbers working, which is why you only ever do the same thing to both sides. Rearranging never changes which values satisfy the equation, only how easy they are to read off.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 26 — the definition of solve for a variable
Sorting
Test the definition on six lines rather than trusting your memory of it. Ask of each one: is y alone on the left, and is the right-hand side free of y? Both answers must be yes.
Sort into buckets
Sort each line by whether it is solved for y.
The one to look at twice is the second, because it passes the easy test and fails the real one. A y on the left with a y on the right is the single most common half-finished answer in this whole lesson.
Notice also that three of the six are perfectly good equations; they are simply not solved for y yet. Being unsolved is not the same as being wrong, and the next parts of the lesson are about finishing the job.
Trap
Solving 2y plus xy equals 6 for y, here is a very common last line:
\[ y = \dfrac{6 - 2y}{x} \]
It looks finished. There is a single y on the left, nothing else beside it, and a tidy fraction on the right.
The move that produced it was legal too: subtract 2y from both sides, then divide by x. Every step is fine, and the destination is still wrong.
Read the right-hand side again. There is a y in it, so this is a rule for y in terms of y. Put any number in for x and you still cannot get an answer out.
\[ y = \dfrac{6}{2 + x} \]
This is the honest finish, and the route to it is different: collect both y terms and factor, rather than moving one of them across.
The lesson is that a legal move is not always a useful one. Before you move a term, check whether it carries the letter you are chasing. Part 5 turns that check into a method.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 28 — the Avoid Errors note beside Example 4
Socratic
Conditions in definitions are easy to nod along to and then ignore. This one earns its place, so argue it out rather than memorising it.
Discussion prompt
Suppose a classmate hands you the line y equals six minus two y, all over x, and says it is a formula for y. Describe what happens when you try to use it to find y for x equal to 4, and say in one sentence what the definition's second condition is protecting you from.
This is worth sitting with for a moment. The half-finished line is not false; it is just no easier to use than the equation you began with, so no work has actually been done.
A useful test to carry forward: could you hand this line to somebody with a calculator and no algebra? If they can produce a number from it, you have solved for the letter. If they would have to do algebra first, you have not.
There is a second thing hiding in the answer. Solving the half-finished line gave y equal to 1 when x was 4, and the properly solved formula gives six over six, which is also 1. The two agree, because rearranging never changes the truth of an equation, only its usefulness.
Keep that distinction clear in your head for the rest of the lesson. A wrong line and an unhelpful line are different faults, and almost every error ahead is the second kind.
Section
Part 2
Concept
Here are two problems side by side. On the left, everything except the unknown is a number. On the right, everything except the unknown is a letter. Read them a line at a time rather than as two separate calculations.
\[ \begin{array}{l|l} \textbf{numbers} & \textbf{letters} \\ \hline 6x = 24 & 2\pi r = C \\ x = \dfrac{24}{6} & r = \dfrac{C}{2\pi} \\ x = 4 & \text{(nothing left to simplify)} \end{array} \]
The move is identical in both columns: divide both sides by whatever multiplies the unknown. You have done the left column since primary school, and the right column asks nothing new of you.
The only difference appears on the last line. The left column can be simplified to a single number, and the right column cannot, because C is not a number yet. There is nothing left to do, so you stop.
So a rearranged formula is not a harder object than an answer. It is the same answer, stopped one step early, because the arithmetic is not available. If that feels unfinished, look at the left column and ask what the four actually told you that twenty-four over six did not.
One warning before you start. On the right, two pi is a single coefficient, not two things to deal with one at a time. Divide by the whole of it in one move.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 26 — Example 1, step 1
Worked example
The formula runs from the radius to the distance round the circle. You want it to run the other way: given the distance round, find the radius. That is the tape-measure-round-a-tree question.
\[ C = 2\pi r \]
Divide each side by 2 pi
Why: because 2 pi is the whole coefficient multiplying r, and dividing undoes multiplying.
\[ \dfrac{C}{2\pi} = r \]
Resist the urge to work out what two pi is. Leaving it exact keeps the formula usable for any circle and avoids a rounding error that would grow every time you used it.
Write r on the left
Why: so the formula reads as an instruction: take the circumference and divide it by two pi.
\[ r = \dfrac{C}{2\pi} \]
Figure (svg): A circle of radius r with an arrow marking the radius, and below it a straight segment exactly as long as the circle's edge, labelled 44 inches.
The picture is worth pausing on. The segment underneath is the circle's edge unrolled, and it is about six and a bit times the radius long. That is all two pi ever means.
A circle with a circumference of 44 inches is now a substitution, not a new problem. Nothing has to be solved again.
Substitute 44 for C
Why: the rearranged formula is ready for any circumference at all; this one happens to be 44 inches.
\[ r = \dfrac{44}{2\pi} \approx 7.00 \]
Check by going forward again
Why: multiplying the radius back up by two pi returns the circumference you were given, so the rearrangement is right. The book rounds this to about 7 inches.
\[ 2\pi(7.00) \approx 43.98 \approx 44 \]
Make that check a habit now, while the formulas are short. It is the only part of the process that can catch a sign error or a dropped coefficient.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 26 — Example 1
Fill the middle
Same rearranged formula, different circle. This is the first time you get to enjoy the saving: there is no algebra left to do, because Example 1 already did it.
Fill in the blanks
r = \dfrac3.98___ = \dfrac______ \approx ___
Why: Twenty-five divided by two pi is 3.9789, which rounds to 3.98 feet. Notice you did not rearrange anything this time: the formula from Example 1 did the work, and all that was left was arithmetic. That is exactly the saving rearranging buys.
Sanity-check the size of the answer before moving on. The circumference is a little over 6 times the radius, and 25 divided by 6 is about 4, so an answer near 4 feet is the right order of magnitude.
If you had been asked for ten circles instead of one, the saving would be ten-fold, and the algebra would still only have happened once. Keep that in mind when a question says, and then find the value for each of the following.
Round only at the very end. Dividing by two pi and then rounding gives 3.98; rounding two pi to 6 first and then dividing gives 4.17, which is wrong in the second digit. Keep the exact value in the calculation for as long as you can.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 27 — Guided Practice 1
Worked example
A rectangle covers 40 square metres and is 16 metres long. How wide is it? Before any algebra, notice that the question gives you the answer the formula was not written to give.
\[ A = lw \]
Divide each side by l
Why: because l multiplies w, and w is what you want alone. A rectangle has a length, so l is not zero and the division is safe.
\[ \dfrac{A}{l} = w \]
That little aside about l not being zero will become important in Part 5, where dividing by something that might be zero is exactly the danger. Here it costs nothing to say and builds the habit.
Write w on the left
Why: so the formula reads: divide the area by the length.
\[ w = \dfrac{A}{l} \]
Figure (svg): A rectangle 16 metres long and 2.5 metres wide, drawn to scale and cut into sixteen columns one metre wide, with the area marked as 40 square metres.
The picture is the rearrangement, drawn. Sixteen columns share the 40 square metres, so each column, one metre wide, holds 2.5 square metres, and that number is the width.
Substitute the numbers
Why: 40 square metres of area spread along a length of 16 metres.
\[ w = \dfrac{40}{16} = 2.5 \]
Check in the original formula
Why: length times width has to give the area back: sixteen times two and a half is forty.
\[ 16(2.5) = 40 \]
Units are a second check worth running. Square metres divided by metres leaves metres, which is what a width should be measured in.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 27 — Guided Practice 4
Worked example
A triangle has a base of 12 metres and an area of 84 square metres. Find its height. There are two things attached to h here, a base and a half, so expect two moves rather than one.
\[ A = \tfrac12 bh \]
Multiply each side by 2
Why: because the half multiplies everything on the right; doubling both sides clears it in one move.
\[ 2A = bh \]
Clearing a fraction first is a habit worth forming. Working with 2A and bh is easier and less error-prone than dragging a one half through the next two lines.
Divide each side by b
Why: so that h stands alone.
\[ \dfrac{2A}{b} = h \]
Figure (svg): A triangle with base b and dashed height h drawn inside a dashed rectangle of the same base and height; the rectangle's area is twice the triangle's.
Doubling the area is not an arbitrary trick. Twice the triangle is the surrounding rectangle, whose area is base times height, and that is exactly the equation you wrote on the previous line.
Substitute the numbers
Why: twice the area is 168 square metres, and the base is 12 metres.
\[ h = \dfrac{2(84)}{12} = \dfrac{168}{12} = 14 \]
Check in the original formula
Why: half of twelve times fourteen is eighty-four, the area you started from.
\[ \tfrac12(12)(14) = 84 \]
Notice the height came out larger than the base. Nothing is wrong: a tall narrow triangle is perfectly legal, and the picture shows one.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 27 — Guided Practice 5
Trap
Solving the triangle formula for h, one move short:
\[ A = \tfrac12 bh \]
\[ h = \dfrac{A}{b} \]
The base has been divided away, so h looks free, and the line even has the right shape for an answer.
The half never went anywhere. Both the half and the base multiply h, so both have to be undone before h is really alone.
\[ h = \dfrac{2A}{b} \]
Numbers catch this instantly. With a base of 12 and an area of 84, the wrong formula gives a height of 7, and a triangle 12 by 7 has area 42, only half of what you were given.
The general warning: count everything attached to the target letter before you start, and tick them off as you undo them. A fraction in front is easy to overlook precisely because it does not look like an operation.
Prediction
Exercise 18 is about the area of a flat circular ring of average radius r and width w. Look at how r sits in the formula and commit to a number of moves before you touch it.
\[ A = 2\pi r w \]
Predict first
How many moves does it take to solve this formula for r?
Correct: One division
Why: Everything on the right is multiplied together, so two pi w behaves as a single coefficient of r and one division frees it: r is A divided by two pi w. Counting moves by counting letters is what leads people to say two or three; count operations instead.
\[ r = \dfrac{A}{2\pi w} \]
The habit being built here is reading before writing. Three letters bunched together look like work, but they are joined only by multiplication, and multiplication comes apart in one division however many letters are involved.
With an area of 120 square feet and a width of 4 feet, that gives a radius of about 4.77 feet. Check it forward: two pi times 4.77 times 4 is 120, so the ring is right.
The formula itself is worth understanding rather than trusting. A thin ring is almost a rectangle: cut it and roll it out, and you have a strip of length two pi r and width w, whose area is the product of the two.
That also tells you when the formula stops being reliable. If the ring is wide rather than thin, the rolled-out strip is no longer a neat rectangle, and the area is only approximately two pi r w.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 31 — Exercise 18
Worked example
In a regular hexagon, a is the distance between opposite sides and d the distance between opposite vertices. The book gives d in terms of a and asks for the reverse.
\[ d = \dfrac{2a}{\sqrt3} \]
Multiply each side by the square root of 3
Why: because that root divides the right-hand side, and multiplying undoes dividing.
\[ d\sqrt3 = 2a \]
A root is no more frightening than a 2. It is one number, about 1.73, that happens to be written with a symbol instead of digits, and one move undoes it just the same.
Divide each side by 2
Why: so a stands alone.
\[ a = \dfrac{d\sqrt3}{2} \]
Figure (svg): A regular hexagon with a double arrow across it from vertex to opposite vertex, labelled d, and a shorter double arrow from one side to the opposite side, labelled a.
Check the answer against the picture before computing anything. The side-to-side distance a is visibly shorter than the vertex-to-vertex distance d, so your formula must produce something smaller than d, and multiplying by 1.73 then halving does exactly that.
Substitute 10 for d
Why: the hexagon whose opposite vertices are 10 centimetres apart.
\[ a = \dfrac{10\sqrt3}{2} = 5\sqrt3 \approx 8.66 \]
Check by going forward
Why: twice five root three, divided by root three, is ten: the distance you were given, and the roots cancel exactly.
\[ \dfrac{2(5\sqrt3)}{\sqrt3} = 10 \]
Leaving the answer as five root three is worth doing. It is exact, and a later calculation using it will not carry a rounding error picked up here.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 27 — Guided Practice 2
Tweak it
The rearranged formula for the width of a rectangle is a rule you can watch rather than just read. Fix the area, then ask what each possible length forces the width to be.
Parameter explorer
Slide the area. With an area of 40 and a length of 8, read the width off the curve. Then explain why doubling the length always halves the width.
\[ w = \dfrac{{A}}{l} \]
The shape of the curve is the formula's personality. It drops steeply at first and then flattens, which says that stretching a short rectangle costs a lot of width and stretching a long one costs very little.
Raising the area with the slider lifts the whole curve without changing that shape. The rule stays the same; only the amount of area being shared out changes.
This is something the unrearranged formula cannot show you. Written as area equals length times width, it states a fact; written as width equals area over length, it becomes a curve you can walk along.
Section
Part 3
Concept
When the target letter has something added to it as well as multiplied by it, the order of your moves starts to matter. The reliable way to choose is to look at how the formula was built, then unbuild it backwards.
Figure (svg): Two rows of boxes. The top row goes from w to 2w to P, with arrows labelled times 2 and add 2l. The bottom row runs the other way, from P to P minus 2l to w, with arrows labelled subtract 2l and divide by 2.
Reading the top row: start with w, multiply by 2, then add 2l, and you have P. That is the order the formula assembles things in, and you can read it straight off the expression.
Now read the bottom row. To get back to w you subtract 2l first and divide by 2 second, which is the top row walked backwards. Putting your shoes on over your socks means taking your shoes off first.
If you ever cannot see which operation went on last, ask what you would do to evaluate the expression for a given w. The last thing you would type into a calculator is the first thing to undo.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 27 — Example 2, step 1
Worked example
Here is the same rectangle problem twice. A rectangle has a length of 12 metres and a perimeter of 41 metres. On the left the numbers go in first; on the right they stay out until the very end.
\[ \begin{array}{l|l} \textbf{numbers first} & \textbf{letters first} \\ \hline 2(12) + 2w = 41 & 2l + 2w = P \end{array} \]
Read across each line rather than down each column. The claim being made here is that the two columns are the same piece of algebra, and the only way to believe it is to watch them move together.
Move the term without w across
Why: subtract the length part from each side. On the left that is a number, 24; on the right it is 2l. Identical move, identical reason.
\[ \begin{array}{l|l} 2w = 41 - 24 & 2w = P - 2l \end{array} \]
Simplify anything you can
Why: the left column collapses to 17. The right column cannot collapse, because P and l are unknown, and this is the only real difference between the columns.
\[ \begin{array}{l|l} 2w = 17 & 2w = P - 2l \end{array} \]
That is the whole of it. One column can do arithmetic and the other cannot, so one column is shorter. No extra rule, no new move, nothing that only works when letters are involved.
Divide each side by 2
Why: because 2 multiplies w, in both columns alike.
\[ \begin{array}{l|l} w = \dfrac{17}{2} = 8.5 & w = \dfrac{P - 2l}{2} \end{array} \]
Cover the left column with your hand and the right column still reads correctly, line for line. Cover the right and the left is the sum you would have written in Lesson 1.3.
Check that the letters contain the numbers
Why: put P equal to 41 and l equal to 12 into the right-hand answer and the left-hand answer comes back out. The letters version is the more useful one, because it answers every rectangle, not just this one.
\[ \dfrac{41 - 2(12)}{2} = \dfrac{17}{2} = 8.5 \]
If a formula ever looks alien, try this: write the numeric version of the same problem beside it and solve both together. The letters column will stop looking like a new subject.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 27 — Example 2, both routes
Worked example
Now the book's own version, written out cleanly on its own. Rearrange first, substitute second, which is the order you will use for the rest of the year.
\[ P = 2l + 2w \]
Subtract 2l from each side
Why: because 2l is added to the term carrying w, and subtracting undoes adding.
\[ P - 2l = 2w \]
Notice what the left side looks like now. It is a single quantity, the perimeter minus the two lengths, and it will stay glued together for the rest of the problem.
Divide each side by 2
Why: and divide the whole left-hand side, not just its first term. This is where the book puts an Avoid Errors warning.
\[ \dfrac{P - 2l}{2} = w \]
Writing the subtraction over a single fraction bar is what keeps you honest here. Half of P minus 2l is not half of P minus 2l written without the bar, and the bar is what says so.
Figure (svg): A rectangle 12 metres long, with its two length sides drawn thick in orange and its two width sides thick in blue, labelled with a perimeter of 41 metres.
The picture says what the algebra says. Twenty-four of the 41 metres is used by the two orange lengths, and whatever is left over has to be shared between the two blue widths.
Substitute 41 for P and 12 for l
Why: a length of 12 metres and a perimeter of 41 metres.
\[ w = \dfrac{41 - 2(12)}{2} = \dfrac{17}{2} = 8.5 \]
Check in the original formula
Why: two lengths of 12 and two widths of 8.5 use exactly 41 metres, the perimeter you were given.
\[ 2(12) + 2(8.5) = 24 + 17 = 41 \]
A perimeter that is an odd number of metres guarantees a decimal answer somewhere. That is a feature of the numbers, not a sign of an error.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 27 — Example 2
Fill the middle
This time the length is the target. A rectangle has a width of 7 inches and a perimeter of 30 inches, and the formula is the one you have just rearranged, pointed the other way.
Fill in the blanks
l = \dfrac2w}}8 = \dfrac______ = ___
Why: The perimeter formula is symmetric in l and w, so solving for l is the same two moves with the other letter: subtract 2w, then divide by 2. With a width of 7 the subtracted part is 14, leaving 16, and half of that is 8 inches. Check it forward: two eights and two sevens make 30.
The symmetry is worth noticing rather than just using. Length and width play identical roles in the perimeter formula, so anything true of one is true of the other with the letters swapped.
That is not true of every formula. In the trapezoid formula coming next, the height and the bases play very different roles, and solving for one is genuinely easier than solving for the other.
Check the answer against the shape before you accept it. A rectangle 8 inches long and 7 inches wide is nearly a square, which is exactly what a perimeter of 30 shared almost evenly between four sides should give you.
One more thing to notice about the middle step: the 14 came from doubling the width, not from the width itself. Every number that enters this formula has already been multiplied by 2, which is why the subtraction is 2w and not w.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 27 — Guided Practice 3
Ranking
You are about to solve the trapezoid area formula for one of its bases. Decide the order of the moves before doing any of them, because choosing the order is where this problem is won or lost.
\[ A = \tfrac12 (b_1 + b_2)h \]
Put in order
Put the moves in the order that isolates b sub two.
Why: Work from the outside in. The half and the h are multiplying the whole bracket, so they come off first, and only when the bracket stands alone can you subtract the other base out of it. Subtracting b sub one while it is still trapped inside a bracket that is multiplied by h is the error this ordering prevents.
The target letter here is buried two layers deep: inside a bracket, which is multiplied by h, which is halved. Peel the layers from the outside, exactly as you would unwrap a parcel.
The tempting wrong order is to attack the subtraction first, because the addition inside the bracket is the operation nearest the letter you want. Nearest is precisely what you cannot reach yet.
Think about how you would evaluate the formula if you knew both bases and the height. You would add the bases, multiply by the height, then halve. Undoing runs that list backwards, which is the order you have just chosen.
Getting the order right does more than save time. Subtracting a base while the bracket is still multiplied by h gives a line that is simply untrue, and every line after it inherits the error.
Worked example
A trapezoid has bases of 6 inches and 8 inches and an area of 70 square inches. Find its height. This is the easier of the two trapezoid targets, because the height is on the outside.
\[ A = \tfrac12 (b_1 + b_2)h \]
Multiply each side by 2
Why: clearing the half, exactly as in the triangle.
\[ 2A = (b_1 + b_2)h \]
Divide each side by the whole bracket
Why: because the bracket, once the two bases are added, is a single number multiplying h.
\[ \dfrac{2A}{b_1 + b_2} = h \]
Dividing by the whole bracket is the move to be careful with. It is not legal to cancel one base at a time out of that sum, and trying to is the most common wrong line here.
Figure (svg): A trapezoid with bases 6 and 8 and a dashed height, beside a second copy of it turned upside down so that together they form a parallelogram whose base is 14.
The doubling has a picture too. Two trapezoids turned against each other make a parallelogram whose base is the two bases added, which is exactly why those two letters never appear apart.
Substitute the numbers
Why: twice the area is 140 square inches, and the two bases add to 14 inches.
\[ h = \dfrac{2(70)}{6 + 8} = \dfrac{140}{14} = 10 \]
Check in the original formula
Why: half of fourteen times ten is seventy square inches.
\[ \tfrac12(6 + 8)(10) = 70 \]
Notice how little the individual bases mattered: only their sum, 14, ever entered the arithmetic. A trapezoid with bases 5 and 9 would have the same height.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 27 — Guided Practice 7
Worked example
Now the harder target, and the one the book turns into a multiple-choice question because so many plausible wrong answers exist. The base you want is inside the bracket, so it is the last thing you can reach.
\[ A = \tfrac12 (b_1 + b_2)h \]
Multiply each side by 2
Why: clear the half first, because it multiplies everything.
\[ 2A = (b_1 + b_2)h \]
Divide each side by h
Why: so the bracket is alone, and its contents finally become reachable.
\[ \dfrac{2A}{h} = b_1 + b_2 \]
Stop and read that line. It says something you could have guessed from the picture: twice the area divided by the height is the sum of the two bases, which is the base of the parallelogram from the last slide.
Subtract b sub two from each side
Why: the last operation to undo is the addition inside the bracket.
\[ b_1 = \dfrac{2A}{h} - b_2 \]
Note where the subtraction ended up: outside the fraction, not inside its denominator. The two bases were added together, so they come apart by subtraction, and nothing about that move touches the h.
Check on a trapezoid you can measure
Why: Exercise 5's trapezoid has bases 10 and 15 centimetres and area 75, so its height is 6. Feed an area of 75, a height of 6 and a second base of 15 into the new formula and the first base, 10, comes back.
\[ \dfrac{2(75)}{6} - 15 = 25 - 15 = 10 \]
Testing a new formula on a case you already know the answer to is the cheapest insurance in algebra, and it takes about twenty seconds.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 30 — Exercises 5 and 6
Elimination
These are the four options the book's multiple-choice exercise offers for the first base. Knock out the three that cannot be right, and say to yourself what went wrong in each before you eliminate it.
Eliminate the wrong options
Which line really is the trapezoid formula solved for b sub one?
Survives elimination: A
Why: Doubling the area and dividing by the height leaves the two bases added together, so the other base comes off by subtraction, outside the fraction. A number test settles it: with an area of 75, a height of 6 and a second base of 15, only the first option returns 10.
The last distractor is the interesting one, because it is the mistake a rushing student actually makes: seeing a subtraction and a fraction and putting them together in the nearest available place.
When options look this similar, stop comparing them with each other and test them with numbers instead. One trapezoid you know the answer for eliminates three of the four in under a minute.
The second option is worth a moment too. Dividing by 2 instead of multiplying is the classic reflex when a half is staring at you, and it produces a first term four times too small, which a quick number test exposes at once.
Multiple choice rewards this kind of thinking. You are not being asked to produce the answer from nothing; you are being asked to recognise three specific errors, all of which you have now met by name.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 30 — Exercise 6
Comparison
Before leaving the formulas, sort them by shape rather than by subject. Geometry names the formula, but how the target letter is attached is the only thing that decides your work.
Comparison matrix
| solve this | for | how the letter is attached | moves |
|---|---|---|---|
| A = lw | w | multiplied only | 1 |
| C = 2πr | r | multiplied only | 1 |
| A = bh/2 | h | multiplied only | 2 |
| P = 2l + 2w | w | multiplied, and something added | 2 |
| A = (b₁ + b₂)h/2 | b₁ | inside a bracket that is multiplied | 3 |
Reading down the last column: a pure product costs one division however many letters it contains, and each extra layer wrapped around the target costs one more move.
The third row is the one to argue with. The triangle formula is a pure product too, since the half is just another thing multiplying h, and yet it costs two moves because there are two multipliers to undo.
Getting into the habit of classifying before calculating is worth more than any individual answer on this slide. It is the same habit that will tell you, in Part 5, that no amount of moving terms will help.
Section
Part 4
Concept
The book now drops the geometry and keeps the method: the same approach works on any equation in two variables. The usual request is to make y the subject, and there is a good reason for that preference.
\[ 4x - 5y = 20 \qquad\Longrightarrow\qquad y = \tfrac45 x - 4 \]
Figure (svg): The line y equals four fifths x minus four, with the point where it crosses the vertical axis at minus four marked, and a dashed step of 5 across and 4 up drawn from it.
The two lines say the same thing about the same points, and every pair of numbers that works in one works in the other. Only the second one is ready to use, though: choose a value of x, do the arithmetic, and you have the matching y.
There is a bonus you will live off for the rest of the year. In the rewritten form, the number standing alone is where the line crosses the vertical axis, and the fraction in front of x is the step you take to walk along it.
The dashed staircase in the picture shows that step: go 5 across and the line climbs 4. Chapter 2 is built on reading those two numbers straight off a rewritten equation, so the rearranging you are practising here is its foundation.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 28 — the Rewriting Equations note
Worked example
Solve for y, then use the result to find y when x is negative 5. Watch the sign of the coefficient of y: it is negative, and that is where all the care is needed.
\[ 9x - 4y = 7 \]
Subtract 9x from each side
Why: because 9x is added to the term carrying y, so it goes first.
\[ -4y = 7 - 9x \]
Some people prefer to add 4y to both sides instead, to keep the y-term positive. That works too and avoids the sign trouble below; the book takes the direct route, so follow it carefully and notice where the risk sits.
Divide each side by negative 4
Why: and divide every term on the right: both the 7 and the minus 9x.
\[ y = \dfrac{7}{-4} - \dfrac{9x}{-4} \]
Writing the two fractions out with their negative denominators, before simplifying them, is worth the extra line. It leaves nothing to do in your head, which is where the sign errors happen.
Tidy the two signs
Why: a positive divided by a negative is negative, and a negative divided by a negative is positive, so the second sign flips as well.
\[ y = -\tfrac74 + \tfrac94 x \]
Figure (svg): The line nine x minus four y equals seven drawn on axes, with the point at x equals minus five and y equals minus thirteen marked on it.
The graph is the formula you just built. Walking along it to x equal to negative 5 lands you at the marked point, well below the axis, which is the answer the arithmetic is about to produce.
Substitute negative 5 for x
Why: with brackets, so the negative is multiplied as a whole.
\[ y = -\tfrac74 + \tfrac94(-5) = -\tfrac74 - \tfrac{45}{4} = -\tfrac{52}{4} = -13 \]
Check in the original equation
Why: this is the book's own check: nine times negative five, minus four times negative thirteen, is seven.
\[ 9(-5) - 4(-13) = -45 + 52 = 7 \]
Two negatives made a positive 52 in that check, which is the same sign behaviour that flipped the x-term earlier. Seeing it work twice in one problem is worth the extra line.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 28 — Example 3
Discrimination
Before doing any of these, decide one thing about each: when y is finally alone, will the x-term have changed sign along the way? The answer depends only on whether you end up dividing by a negative number.
Sort into buckets
Sort each equation by whether isolating y means dividing by a negative number.
The only thing you had to look at was the sign directly in front of the y-term. Everything else in the equation, including how ugly the numbers are, is irrelevant to this particular question.
Knowing the answer in advance changes how you work. If you are expecting the signs to flip, you will not be surprised into leaving one of them alone, which is exactly the trap two slides from now.
There is a way to avoid the negative divisor altogether. Instead of subtracting the x-term, add the y-term to the other side, so that the equation ends up with a positive multiple of y and nothing has to flip.
Both routes are correct, and you should be able to run either. The book takes the direct one, so the safest plan is to expect the sign change and write the division out in full rather than doing it in your head.
Worked example
A positive coefficient of y this time, for contrast, and numbers that share a factor at the end. Find y when x is 5.
\[ 8y - 14x = -22 \]
Add 14x to each side
Why: because 14x is subtracted, so adding undoes it and keeps the y-term positive.
\[ 8y = 14x - 22 \]
The y-term was already positive here, so nothing you do can flip a sign. Compare that with Example 3 at the same stage, where the left side read minus four y and the trouble was still ahead.
Divide each side by 8
Why: every term: the 14x and the 22 alike.
\[ y = \dfrac{14x - 22}{8} \]
Cancel the common factor 2
Why: 14, 22 and 8 are all even, so the fraction is not yet in lowest terms.
\[ y = \dfrac{7x - 11}{4} \]
Cancelling here is not just tidiness. The simpler fraction is the one you will substitute into, and smaller numbers mean fewer chances to slip when you evaluate it.
Substitute 5 for x
Why: into the tidied version, which is easier to evaluate.
\[ y = \dfrac{7(5) - 11}{4} = \dfrac{24}{4} = 6 \]
Check in the original equation
Why: eight sixes is forty-eight, fourteen fives is seventy, and forty-eight minus seventy is negative twenty-two.
\[ 8(6) - 14(5) = 48 - 70 = -22 \]
Always check in the original equation rather than in your rearranged one. Checking in your own rearrangement would happily confirm a mistake you made while producing it.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 30 — Exercise 13
Fill the middle
Rewrite this one for y and evaluate it at x equal to 2. The coefficient of y is positive, so this is the calmer kind; the only risk is the negative number on the right.
\[ 2x + 5y = -1 \]
Fill in the blanks
y = \dfrac2x}}-1, \qquad \text___ x = 2: \; y = ___
Why: Subtracting 2x from both sides leaves five y equal to negative one minus two x, and dividing by the positive 5 changes no signs. At x equal to 2 the numerator is negative five, so y is negative one. Check in the original: two twos plus five negative ones is negative one.
The numerator is a subtraction of two negatives-looking pieces, so write it out fully as negative one minus four before dividing. Rushing that step is how negative five becomes three.
It is a coincidence worth enjoying that x and y both come out as small whole numbers here. Textbook exercises are built that way on purpose, so an ugly answer is usually a signal to check your work.
Compare this with Example 3 for a moment. There the coefficient of y was negative and every sign on the right had to flip; here it is a positive 5, so the terms keep the signs they arrived with. Same two moves, different amount of care.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 28 — Guided Practice 11
Error analysis
This is the book's own error-analysis exercise. The first move is right and the second loses something. Work out what before you open the notes; catching it yourself is worth more than reading it.
Annotate
On: \( 5y = 7x + 2 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = \tfrac75 x + 2 \)
\[ y = \tfrac75 x + \tfrac25 \]
Why does this particular slip happen so often? Because the x-term looks like the real work and the lonely number looks like something already finished. Dividing is done to a side, never to a favourite term.
A quick guard: after dividing, count the terms on that side and check that every one of them changed. Two terms in, two terms altered, or you have missed one.
It helps to picture what dividing a side actually means. The side is one quantity, and you are shrinking the whole of it by a factor of five. Shrinking only part of it changes the quantity into something else entirely.
The book puts its warning in exactly these words: when dividing each side of an equation by the same number, remember to divide every term. It is on page 28, beside Example 3, and it is there because this error is that common.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 30 — Exercise 16
Trap
Solving four x minus five y equals 20 for y:
\[ -5y = 20 - 4x \]
\[ y = -4 - \tfrac45 x \]
The 20 became negative 4 correctly, and then the second term was left exactly as it was.
Dividing by negative 5 changes the sign of every term on that side, not just the first one you look at.
\[ y = \tfrac45 x - 4 \]
Test it with x equal to 5. The original says twenty minus five y equals 20, so y is 0, and the correct form gives 0. The wrong form gives negative 8.
Notice that the two versions differ in the sign of the slope, so they describe lines tilting opposite ways. A single missed sign is not a small error here; it draws a different line.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 30 — Exercise 15
Worked example
Find y when x is 2, two different ways, and then decide which way you would want if you had to do it for ten values of x. The book asks this deliberately, because the better route is not the faster one here.
\[ 15x - 9y = 27 \]
Route 1: move the x-term across
Why: subtract 15x from each side, leaving the y-term alone on the left.
\[ -9y = 27 - 15x \]
Route 1: divide by negative 9 and tidy
Why: every sign on the right changes, and 15, 27 and 9 all share a factor of 3.
\[ y = \dfrac{15x - 27}{9} = \tfrac53 x - 3 \]
Route 1: now substitute 2
Why: one multiplication and one subtraction, and no equation to solve.
\[ y = \tfrac53(2) - 3 = \tfrac{10}{3} - 3 = \tfrac13 \]
Now the other way round. Route 2 puts the number in before doing any algebra, which turns the problem into the kind of equation you met in Lesson 1.3.
Route 2: substitute first
Why: put 2 in place of x in the original equation and leave y as the only letter.
\[ 15(2) - 9y = 27 \]
Route 2: solve the numeric equation
Why: thirty minus nine y is twenty-seven, so nine y is three.
\[ 30 - 9y = 27 \;\Longrightarrow\; 9y = 3 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = \tfrac13 \]
Both routes give one third, as they must: rearranging never changes which pairs of numbers satisfy the equation, so no legal route can reach a different answer.
Check both answers agree, and count the cost
Why: for a single value of x, route 2 is slightly quicker. For several values of x, route 1 wins outright, because the formula is built once and then only evaluated, while route 2 solves a fresh equation every time.
\[ \tfrac13 = \tfrac13 \]
That trade-off is the reason this lesson exists. Rearranging is an investment: it costs a little now and pays back on every later use.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 31 — Exercise 27
Comparison
This is the pay-off route 1 promised. The formula is built, so the work left is arithmetic and nothing else. Fill in the missing values.
\[ y = \tfrac53 x - 3 \]
Comparison matrix
| x | y |
|---|---|
| 0 | -3 |
| 2 | 1/3 |
| 3 | 2 |
| 6 | 7 |
Four answers, and not one equation solved. Imagine doing this by route 2 instead: four separate equations, each with its own chance of a slip.
Look at the pattern down the column as well. Each step of 3 in x raises y by exactly 5, which is the fraction in front of x showing itself, and the value at x equal to 0 is the number standing alone.
Those two observations are the whole of the next chapter in miniature. A rearranged equation does not just compute faster; it tells you the shape of the line it describes.
Real world
Exercise 35 gives the everyday formula for turning Celsius into Fahrenheit and asks you to turn it round. This is rearranging you have probably wanted before, whenever a weather forecast used the wrong scale.
\[ F = \tfrac95 C + 32 \]
Figure (svg): Two vertical temperature scales side by side, Celsius from minus forty to one hundred and Fahrenheit from minus forty to two hundred and twelve, drawn to the same height, with dashed lines joining ten to fifty and minus forty to minus forty.
The two scales are drawn to the same height on purpose, so a horizontal dashed line joins temperatures that mean the same thing. Look at how much further the Fahrenheit scale travels over the same physical range.
Discussion prompt
Solve this formula for C and use it to convert 50 degrees Fahrenheit. Then find the single temperature at which the two scales show the same number, and say what in the picture told you such a temperature had to exist.
The order of the moves is the same as always: the 32 was added last, so it comes off first, and only then do you clear the fraction by multiplying by five ninths.
Because Fahrenheit climbs faster than Celsius but starts higher, the two readings have to cross somewhere, and only once. That is a conclusion about two straight lines, drawn from a rearrangement, and it is the sort of thing Chapter 3 will do systematically.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 32 — Exercise 35
Section
Part 5
Concept
Everything so far had the target letter in exactly one term. When it turns up in two, something genuinely new is needed, because no amount of moving terms across will isolate it.
\[ 2y + xy = 6 \]
Try it and see. Move the 2y across and there is a y on the right; move the xy across and there is a y on the right; divide by x and there is still a y on the right. Every legal move leaves the same problem.
Figure (svg): A rectangle of height c cut into two pieces of widths a and b, the left piece labelled ac and the right bc, with a brace underneath giving the whole width as a plus b.
The picture is the distributive property, which you have used from left to right for years: one height, two widths, two areas. Read it right to left instead and it becomes factoring.
\[ ac + bc = (a + b)c \]
Applied to the equation above, y is the common factor and the bracket collects what multiplies it. Two terms become one, the letter appears once, and a single division finishes the job.
This is the same skill Chapter 5 will use on quadratics, so it is worth building properly now. The only thing that changes there is which factor is common.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 28 — Example 4, step 1
Worked example
Find y in general, then find its value when x is negative 3. Watch how the first step is a decision rather than a move.
\[ 2y + xy = 6 \]
Notice that both terms on the left carry y
Why: so dividing by 2, or by x, would leave a y on the right and finish nothing.
\[ \underbrace{2y + xy}_{\text{both terms carry } y} = 6 \]
That observation is the whole difference between this example and everything before it. Spotting it costs one second and saves a page of legal but useless algebra.
Factor y out
Why: the distributive property, read backwards; the bracket holds what was multiplying y.
\[ (2 + x)y = 6 \]
Figure (svg): A strip of height y cut into two rectangles, one of width 2 with area 2y and one of width x with area xy, with the whole width marked 2 plus x and the whole area marked 6.
The strip in the picture has area 6, and its width is 2 plus x, so its height must be 6 divided by that width. That is the next line, before you write it.
Divide each side by the whole bracket
Why: once x is a number the bracket is a single number, so this is an ordinary one-step division. It is only legal when the bracket is not zero.
\[ y = \dfrac{6}{2 + x}, \quad x \ne -2 \]
The condition on the end is part of the answer, not a footnote. At x equal to negative 2 the strip would have no width at all, and no height could give it an area of 6.
Substitute negative 3 for x
Why: with brackets, so the negative is handled as a whole.
\[ y = \dfrac{6}{2 + (-3)} = \dfrac{6}{-1} = -6 \]
Check in the original equation
Why: two times negative six is negative twelve, and negative three times negative six is positive eighteen, and those make six.
\[ 2(-6) + (-3)(-6) = -12 + 18 = 6 \]
The answer came out negative, which the area picture cannot show, since areas are positive. The algebra happily goes where the picture cannot, and the check is what confirms it was allowed to.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 28 — Example 4
Error analysis
The book's second error-analysis exercise. Every line here is algebraically legal, and yet the work is not finished. Find the moment the plan went wrong rather than looking for an illegal step.
Annotate
On: \( 4y - xy = 9 \;\Longrightarrow\; 4y = 9 + xy \;\Longrightarrow\; y = \dfrac{9 + xy}{4} \)
\[ y = \dfrac{9}{4 - x}, \quad x \ne 4 \]
This is the same trap as the one in Part 1, arriving from the other direction. There the error was stopping too early; here it is moving the wrong term. Both end with a y stranded on the right.
The check that catches both is identical and takes two seconds: read your final line and hunt for the target letter anywhere except where it belongs.
Notice how reasonable the wrong first move looks. Moving a term across is the thing you have done in every lesson since Chapter 1 began, so the instinct is well trained; it is simply the wrong instinct for an equation whose target letter appears twice.
One way to head it off is to count before you move. Two terms carrying y means factor; one term carrying y means move things across. Deciding which case you are in takes a glance, and it saves the whole wrong route.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 30 — Exercise 17
Worked example
A subtraction between the two terms this time, which is where signs start to matter. Find y in general, then at x equal to 2.
\[ 4y - xy = 28 \]
Factor y out of both terms
Why: minus xy is y multiplied by minus x, so the bracket is 4 minus x. Watch that sign: it is the whole difficulty of this example.
\[ (4 - x)y = 28 \]
If you are unsure about the sign, expand your bracket again and see whether you get back what you started with. Four y minus x y: correct, so the bracket is right.
Divide each side by the bracket
Why: and record the value of x that would make the bracket zero, because dividing by zero is not allowed.
\[ y = \dfrac{28}{4 - x}, \quad x \ne 4 \]
Before substituting, look at the answer as a machine: feed it any x other than 4 and it returns a y. At x equal to 0 it gives 7, at x equal to 3 it gives 28, and the closer x creeps to 4 the larger the output grows.
Substitute 2 for x
Why: the bracket becomes 2.
\[ y = \dfrac{28}{4 - 2} = \dfrac{28}{2} = 14 \]
Check in the original equation
Why: four fourteens is fifty-six, two fourteens is twenty-eight, and the difference is twenty-eight.
\[ 4(14) - 2(14) = 56 - 28 = 28 \]
Notice that the check is easy precisely because you factored: both terms share the 14, so the arithmetic mirrors the algebra you just did.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 28 — Guided Practice 13
Edge cases
Every answer in this part came with a condition attached. Conditions like that are not decoration, and they are not the algebra being cautious: they are telling you something true about the original equation.
\[ y = \dfrac{28}{4 - x}, \quad x \ne 4 \]
Discussion prompt
Put x equal to 4 into the ORIGINAL equation, four y minus x y equals 28, and say what you find. Then explain in one sentence why the rearranged formula had to exclude that value.
This is worth taking seriously because of how it feels. It looks as though the formula has a flaw, when in fact the formula is the honest one and the original equation was hiding the problem.
Watch what happens to the answers as x creeps up towards 4: at 3 the answer is 28, at 3.9 it is 280, at 3.99 it is 2800. The values run away rather than settling, which is the behaviour Chapter 8 will name.
Worked example
Two wrinkles here. The equation is written backwards, with the number on the left, and the term you need to move carries an x but no y.
\[ 3 = 2xy - x \]
Do not let the layout bother you. An equation reads the same both ways, so you may either turn it round first or work with the letters on the right, whichever you find clearer.
Add x to each side
Why: the term with no y has to leave the side where y lives.
\[ 3 + x = 2xy \]
Divide each side by 2x
Why: because 2x, taken as one number, is what multiplies y. Note at once that x cannot be zero.
\[ y = \dfrac{3 + x}{2x}, \quad x \ne 0 \]
Only one term carried y here, so there was nothing to factor. Recognising that saves you from hunting for a bracket that does not exist, which is a real risk once factoring is fresh in your mind.
Substitute 2 for x
Why: top and bottom both change, so work them out separately before dividing.
\[ y = \dfrac{3 + 2}{2(2)} = \dfrac{5}{4} \]
Check in the original equation
Why: two times two times five quarters is five, and taking away the x, which is 2, leaves three.
\[ 2(2)\left(\tfrac54\right) - 2 = 5 - 2 = 3 \]
The exclusion here came from the coefficient rather than a bracket, which shows the condition is really about whatever you divided by, whatever shape it takes.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 28 — Guided Practice 12
Fill the middle
Here the coefficient of the first y is an invisible 1, and invisible things are the ones that get dropped. Fill in the factored line and the value at x equal to negative 1.
\[ y - 2xy = 15 \]
Fill in the blanks
(1 - 2x)y = 15 \;\Longrightarrow\; y = \dfrac5___, \qquad \text___ x = -1: \; y = ___
Why: A lone y is one times y, so factoring gives the bracket 1 minus 2x, not just minus 2x. At x equal to negative 1 the bracket is 3, so y is 5. Check in the original: 5 minus 2 times negative 1 times 5 is 5 plus 10, which is 15.
Forgetting the 1 is the single most common factoring error in this whole chapter. Whenever you pull a letter out of a term that was just that letter on its own, a 1 must be left behind in the bracket.
Substituting a negative value for x is the second risk here. Two times negative one is negative two, and one minus negative two is three, not minus one.
Say the factored line out loud as a sentence: one lot of y, take away two x lots of y, leaves one minus two x lots of y. Phrasing it that way makes the invisible 1 audible.
As a final check, expand your bracket. One minus two x, all times y, gives y minus two x y, which is exactly the left-hand side you began with, so the factoring was right.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 31 — Exercise 25
Counterexample
Shortcuts that work on one example and fail on the next are worth killing early, while you can still see what they really do. Here is one that sounds reasonable.
\[ 4y - xy = 28 \]
Discussion prompt
A classmate says: when the target letter appears twice, just divide both sides by the coefficient of the first term. So divide by 4 and be done. Carry that out, then use x equal to 2 to show that the result is not a formula for y.
That last point is the one to hold on to. A shortcut that produces the right number by making you do the original work again has not saved anything at all.
Factoring first is what turns the work into a formula you can simply evaluate, and it is no longer than the shortcut. One well-chosen move beats two legal ones.
There is a general lesson in the failure. Dividing by a number only helps when the letter you want appears once, because division cannot gather two scattered terms together. Gathering is what factoring is for.
Test any shortcut you are offered the same way: carry it out honestly, then look for the target letter on the wrong side. If it is still there, the shortcut has moved the work rather than removed it.
Worked example
This one has y on both sides to begin with, which looks worse than anything so far and is actually the same problem wearing a different coat: collect the y terms first, then factor.
\[ xy = x + y \]
Subtract y from each side
Why: so that every term carrying y is on the left and nothing else is.
\[ xy - y = x \]
That first move is the one Part 5 has been building towards. Gathering the target letter into one place is always the opening move; only once it is gathered can it be pulled out.
Factor y out
Why: the left side is y times x, minus y times one, so the bracket is x minus 1.
\[ (x - 1)y = x \]
There is the invisible 1 again. It comes from the lone y, and leaving it out would give a bracket of just x and a wrong answer.
Divide each side by the bracket
Why: and exclude the value that makes it zero.
\[ y = \dfrac{x}{x - 1}, \quad x \ne 1 \]
At x equal to 1 the original equation reads y equals 1 plus y, which nothing satisfies, so the exclusion is again reporting a fact rather than dodging one.
Check with a number
Why: take x equal to 3, so the formula gives y equal to three halves; then x times y is four and a half, and x plus y is also four and a half.
\[ x = 3: \; y = \tfrac32, \quad 3\left(\tfrac32\right) = \tfrac92 = 3 + \tfrac32 \]
An x on both the top and the bottom of the answer is perfectly acceptable. Solved for y means no y on the right, and it says nothing at all about how often x may appear.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 31 — Exercise 28
Section
Part 6
Worked example
A video store rents new movies for 5 dollars each and older movies for 3 dollars each. Revenue is what it takes in over the month, and the owner wants twelve thousand dollars of it.
This is the first problem where the formula does not come ready-made: you have to write it before you can rearrange it. The book calls that a verbal model, and it is simply a sentence turned into symbols.
\[ R = 5n_1 + 3n_2 \]
Read the model before moving anything
Why: n sub one counts new rentals at 5 dollars each and n sub two counts older rentals at 3 dollars each, so each product is money and the sum is the month's revenue.
\[ \underbrace{5n_1}_{\text{money from new}} + \underbrace{3n_2}_{\text{money from older}} = R \]
Checking that every piece of a model has the right units is time well spent. Dollars per movie times movies gives dollars, and dollars plus dollars gives dollars, so the equation is at least sensible.
Subtract the older-movie money from each side
Why: you want the number of NEW rentals, so everything else has to leave that side.
\[ R - 3n_2 = 5n_1 \]
Divide each side by 5
Why: because each new rental brings in 5 dollars.
\[ n_1 = \dfrac{R - 3n_2}{5} \]
Figure (svg): A falling straight line showing how many new movies must be rented for each number of older movies rented, if revenue is to be twelve thousand dollars, with the answers 2100 and 1800 marked.
One rearrangement, and every point on that line is now available to the owner. This is the saving from Exercise 27, in a setting where somebody is actually paying for the time it takes.
Put in twelve thousand dollars and 500 older rentals
Why: substitute R and n sub two, then simplify the top before dividing.
\[ n_1 = \dfrac{12\,000 - 3(500)}{5} = \dfrac{10\,500}{5} = 2100 \]
Do it again for 1000 older rentals
Why: only one number in the formula changes, which is exactly why the formula was worth building.
\[ n_1 = \dfrac{12\,000 - 3(1000)}{5} = \dfrac{9000}{5} = 1800 \]
Check the first answer in the original equation
Why: 2100 new rentals at 5 dollars is 10,500 dollars, and 500 older rentals at 3 dollars is 1500 dollars, which is exactly the twelve thousand asked for.
\[ 5(2100) + 3(500) = 10\,500 + 1500 = 12\,000 \]
Compare the two answers and read the trade: 500 more cheap rentals let the owner drop 300 expensive ones, which is the steepness of the line put into words.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 29 — Example 5
Real world
Exercise 36 puts a two-step rearrangement into a design question. The inside edge of the track is two straights and two semicircular ends, and one lap is a quarter of a mile, which is 440 yards.
\[ P = 2\pi r + 2x \]
Figure (svg): A running track drawn as two straight sides of length x joined by two semicircular ends of radius r, with the inside perimeter marked as 440 yards.
Before solving anything, satisfy yourself that the formula matches the drawing. The two straights contribute x each, and the two semicircular ends are half a circle each, so together they contribute one whole circumference, which is two pi r.
Discussion prompt
Solve the perimeter formula for r. Then find r when x is 75 yards and when x is 150 yards, and say what the greatest possible value of r would be for a 440 yard lap.
So the radius can be anything from just above zero up to about 70 yards, and a single rearranged formula makes that whole range readable at a glance. Reading it off the original would mean solving a fresh equation for every design.
Notice the shape of the answer as well: subtract the straights, then divide by two pi. It is Example 2 and Example 1 in the same problem, which is what the closing part of this lesson is about.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.4 Rewrite Formulas and Equations §1.4, p. 32 — Exercise 36
Pattern
Everything in this lesson is one of four routes, and you choose between them by looking at how the target letter sits in the equation, before you write a single line.
Figure (svg): A flow diagram with four rows. Each row names how the target letter sits in the equation on the left and the move that frees it on the right.
The diagram is worth reading right to left as well. If you know which move you are about to make, you should be able to say which feature of the equation made you choose it.
The last line is the one people skip, and it is the only one that can catch a mistake. A check takes one line and rescues an entire question.
Nothing here is special to y, or to geometry. The same five instructions solve a physics formula for time or a finance formula for an interest rate, which is where you will meet them next.
Matching
Four equations, four routes, and no algebra required yet. Decide by shape alone, then say to yourself which feature of the equation settled it.
Match the pairs
Why: The first is a pure product, so one division does it. The second adds something, so it needs two moves, with a positive divisor. The third also needs two moves, but the coefficient of y is negative, so every sign changes. The fourth has y in two terms, which no amount of moving terms can fix, so it must be factored.
The middle pair are the ones to separate carefully. They need the same two moves in the same order, and only the sign of the divisor tells them apart, which is exactly what the sorting slide in Part 4 trained you to spot.
If you can classify an equation this quickly, the algebra that follows is almost mechanical. Most marks lost in this topic are lost before the first line is written, by starting down the wrong route.
Notice that the first pair are geometry and the second pair are bare algebra, and that the distinction makes no difference at all to the routes. What the letters stand for never changes how they come apart.
If you found yourself half-solving each one in your head to decide, that is fine for now; the point is to reach the stage where a glance at the shape is enough, which comes with a dozen more examples.
Check
Back to the definition the whole lesson rests on. Apply both halves of it to each option: y alone on one side, and no y on the other.
Check your understanding
Which of these equations is solved for y?
Answer: B
Why: Solved for y means two things: y alone on one side, and no y anywhere on the other. Only the second line passes both tests, so only it can be evaluated by substituting a value of x.
Three of these four options are the same equation at different stages of being solved, which is why the eye is not enough. Glancing at the left-hand side alone would pass two wrong answers.
The fastest reliable test is the one from Part 1: could somebody with a calculator and no algebra get a number out of this line? Only one of the four survives that question.
It is also worth knowing that all four options come from the same equation, two y plus x y equals six. The winning line is where that equation ends up once you factor; the others are places people stop along the way.
Confirm the winner with a number. At x equal to 1 it gives y equal to two, and putting x equal to 1 and y equal to 2 into two y plus x y gives four plus two, which is six. The line survives the test that the others cannot even be given.
Check
This is the track formula from two slides ago. Ask first how r is attached: something is added to its term, and its coefficient is two pi taken together.
Check your understanding
The inside perimeter of a running track is P = 2πr + 2x. Which line gives r?
Answer: A
Why: Subtract the straights, 2x, from both sides, then divide the whole remaining side by the full coefficient of r, which is two pi. With P equal to 440 and x equal to 75 this gives about 46.15 yards.
Every wrong option here is a real mistake rather than a random wrong answer: one divides only part of a side, one loses half the coefficient, and one forgets that a track has two straights.
Numbers settle it faster than staring. Put P equal to 440 and x equal to 220 into each: the correct line gives a radius of zero, which is the track with no curved ends, and the others give nonsense.
The order of the two moves is worth restating, because it is the whole of Part 3. The straights are added to the curved part, so they come off by subtraction first, and only then does the coefficient of r come off by division.
If a question ever gives you a formula with pi in it, treat pi as an ordinary number that happens to have a name. It is about 3.14, it multiplies things, and it comes off by dividing, like any other factor.
Check
The Part 5 shape, with a subtraction in the middle. Before looking at the options, decide what the bracket must be when y is factored out.
Check your understanding
Solve 3y − xy = 12 for y.
Answer: B
Why: Both terms on the left carry y, so factor: y times the bracket 3 minus x equals 12, and dividing by the bracket gives 12 over 3 minus x, with x not equal to 3. At x equal to 1 this gives 6, and 3 times 6 minus 1 times 6 is indeed 12.
Two of the wrong options carry a y on the right, which the definition rules out immediately; the third differs from the answer by a single sign inside the bracket.
That sign is worth one last look. Expanding y times the bracket 3 minus x gives back three y minus x y, which is the equation you started with, so the bracket is right.
Add the exclusion to your answer even though no option shows one. At x equal to 3 the two terms on the left cancel and the equation claims that zero is twelve, so there is no y to find there.
If you got this one right without hesitating, you have the whole of Part 5: spot the letter in two terms, factor, divide by the bracket, and state what the bracket forbids.
Explain it to yourself
One idea has carried this whole lesson, and putting it into your own sentences is what makes it stick. Write your answer out before reading the one provided.
Discussion prompt
In two or three sentences, explain why solving P = 2l + 2w for w is the same skill as solving 2w + 24 = 41, and say what the one genuine difference is. Then describe when you would rather have the formula than the number.
If your explanation used the word letters more than the word moves, try writing it again. The moves are the content here; the letters are only what stops the arithmetic finishing.
A good test of your own understanding: could you teach the warm-up equation and Example 2 as a single lesson? If yes, you have the idea this deck was built to deliver.
Try the second half of the question on a case from your own life as well. Anything you would work out more than once, such as converting a price, a temperature or a speed, is a formula worth rearranging permanently.
Exit ticket
One question that uses all three habits: look at how the letter is attached, factor if it appears twice, and say what the answer forbids.
\[ 3 = 5y + xy \]
Discussion prompt
Solve for y, find y when x is 1, and name the value of x that the answer forbids, saying what the original equation does at that value.
The number on the left rather than the right is deliberate: an equation reads the same in both directions, and noticing that is half the battle with problems written this way.
Work through it in the order the lesson taught. Both terms on the right carry y, so gather them into one bracket first; only then is there a single letter to divide by, and the bracket you divide by is the thing to test for zero.
If the exclusion did not occur to you until you were prompted, add it to your checklist now. Whenever you divide by something containing a letter, ask what value would make it zero.
Finally, notice that the answer is a formula rather than a number, and that the number you were asked for came out of it in one line. That is the whole trade this lesson has been arguing for.
Recap
Four shapes of problem, one habit: look at how the target letter is attached, undo the outermost operation first, and finish by checking a pair of numbers in the equation you started from.
| how the letter sits | the move | example from this lesson |
|---|---|---|
| multiplied only | divide by the whole coefficient | C = 2πr solved for r |
| multiplied, with something added | subtract, then divide every term | P = 2l + 2w solved for w |
| with a negative coefficient | divide every term and flip every sign | 9x − 4y = 7 solved for y |
| in two terms at once | factor it out, divide by the bracket, state the exclusion | 2y + xy = 6 solved for y |
\[ y = \dfrac{6}{2 + x}, \quad x \ne -2 \]
The line above is the shape to remember from Part 5: a fraction, and a condition beside it. The condition is part of the answer, because it is the equation telling you where no answer exists.
Look back at the table and notice that the first three rows are really one row. Whether you divide once, twice, or twice with signs flipping, you are undoing multiplication and addition in the reverse order they were applied.
The fourth row is the only genuinely new idea in the lesson, and it is the one to rehearse. Two terms carrying the target letter means factor, always, and the bracket you divide by carries a condition with it.
Lesson 1.5 uses all of this immediately. Word problems are solved by writing a formula, rearranging it for the quantity you were asked about, and only then putting the numbers in, which is exactly the order Example 5 used.
OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §2.2 Linear Equations in One Variable §2.2 — the same rearranging, called solving a literal equation
Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Algebra 2 — $55/session, free consultation.