1.3 Solving Linear Equations

Equations, solutions and equivalent equations; the four properties of equality; isolating a variable on one side and then on both; clearing brackets and fractions; and writing an equation from a verbal model.

Subject: Algebra 2 · 71 slides · symbolic lesson

Open the interactive version of this deck

What this lesson covers

The lesson, slide by slide

1. Solve Linear Equations

Title

Algebra 2 · Lesson 1.3

Every move on its own line, every answer substituted back

2. What this lesson gives you

Objectives

Lesson 1.2 rewrote expressions. An expression has no answer to find: you feed it a number and it hands one back, and a different number gives a different result. Nothing about it is ever true or false.

An equation is a different kind of object. It makes a claim, and your job is to find every number that makes the claim true. Some equations have exactly one such number, some have none at all, and a few are true for every number you could try.

The last two are what make this an Algebra 2 lesson rather than a repeat of Algebra 1. You have solved equations before, and the mechanics will feel familiar for the first half of the lesson.

What is new is that you will be asked which of three possible answers an equation has, rather than being promised that one number exists; and you will be handed a paragraph of English and asked to produce the equation yourself, which is the harder half of every word problem.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 18 — Before / Now / Why and Key Vocabulary

3. Before anything new: what is an equation for?

Warm-up

Start by finding out what you already believe. This takes a minute and it is worth the minute, because the answer you write now is the thing the rest of the lesson has to correct or confirm.

Discussion prompt

You have simplified expressions all through Lesson 1.2. Write down, in one sentence and without looking back, what is different about an equation, and what it would mean to solve one.

Keep that distinction close for the next hour. Almost every mistake in this lesson comes from treating one side of an equation like an expression you are allowed to tidy on its own, and the next few slides are about why that is not allowed.

One more thing worth noticing now. Simplifying an expression changes how it looks and never changes what it equals, so there is nothing to check at the end. Solving an equation produces a claim about a number, and a claim can be tested.

That is why every worked example in this deck ends with a substitution. It is not a formality tacked on the end; it is the only step in the whole solution that is capable of telling you whether the rest of it was right.

4. What counts as a legal move

Section

Part 1

5. Equation, solution, equivalent equations

Concept

Four words carry this whole lesson, and three of them you already half know. Read each definition and then look at the symbols under it, because the symbols are where the meaning actually lives.

equation — A statement that two expressions are equal.

linear equation in one variable — An equation that can be written in the form below, with a and b constants and a not zero.

\[ ax + b = 0, \qquad a \ne 0 \]

Linear means the variable appears to the first power only: never squared, never under a root, never in a denominator. That single restriction is what makes the rest of this lesson a procedure you can follow rather than a puzzle you have to be clever about.

solution — A number that makes the statement true when it is substituted for the variable.

equivalent equations — Two equations with exactly the same solutions.

Keep hold of that last word. Solving is not one clever step that reveals the answer. It is a chain of equations, each one equivalent to the one before it, ending at something so simple that you can read the answer straight off.

Every rule in the rest of Part 1 exists to protect that chain. If one link produces an equation with different solutions from the one above it, everything below the break is about a different problem, and no amount of careful arithmetic afterwards can rescue it.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 18 — the definitions above Example 1

6. The scale that never lies

Picture it

Before any algebra, get the picture in your head. Each box holds the same unknown weight, each small disc weighs exactly one unit, and the beam being level is the equals sign.

Figure (svg): A pan balance in equilibrium. The left pan holds two boxes marked x and three weights marked 1; the right pan holds eleven weights marked 1.

The boxes all weigh the same unknown amount. The beam is level, so the two pans weigh the same.

Count what is on each pan. Two boxes and three discs on the left, eleven discs on the right, and the beam is not moving, so those two collections weigh the same. That sentence, written in symbols, is the equation below.

\[ 2x + 3 = 11 \]

Now ask yourself what you are allowed to do to that balance. Anything at all, as long as the beam stays level, because the moment it tips you are no longer making a true statement about the same unknown.

Hold on to this picture. It will not survive into Chapter 5, where the numbers stop being weights, but for the whole of this lesson every legal move is something you could physically do to these two pans, and every illegal one is something that would tip them.

7. Checking a proposed solution: is 4 a solution?

Worked example

Someone hands you an answer. Before you believe it, put it back into the original equation and see whether the claim comes out true. Work the two sides separately and compare only at the very end, because that is what keeps the check honest.

\[ 3x + 8 = 9x - 16, \qquad \text{try } x = 4 \]

Substitute 4 for x on the left side

Why: Every x in the left expression becomes a 4.

\[ 3(4) + 8 = 12 + 8 = 20 \]

Substitute 4 for x on the right side

Why: Do the same to the right expression, on its own, without looking at what the left side gave.

\[ 9(4) - 16 = 36 - 16 = 20 \]

Compare the two numbers

Why: Both sides came out 20, so the claim is true and 4 is a solution.

\[ 20 = 20 \;\checkmark \]

Notice what a check is not. It is not re-reading your working to see whether it looks right; you would make the same mistake twice. It is an independent test that only needs the original equation and the number you are testing.

It is worth seeing what a failed check looks like, so that you recognise one when it happens to you rather than assuming you have miscopied something.

Check that 3 is not a solution

Why: Substituting 3 gives 17 on the left and 11 on the right, a false statement, so 3 is not a solution and the 4 was not luck.

\[ 3(3) + 8 = 17, \quad 9(3) - 16 = 11, \quad 17 \ne 11 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 25 — the calculator activity, where a table finds the same solution

8. Four properties of equality, all of them two-sided

Concept

The book lists exactly four transformations that turn an equation into an equivalent one. Every legal line you write in this lesson is one of these four, so they are worth knowing by name and not only by feel.

propertywhat you doin symbols
Additionadd the same number to each sideif a = b, then a + c = b + c
Subtractionsubtract the same number from each sideif a = b, then a − c = b − c
Multiplicationmultiply each side by the same nonzero numberif a = b and c ≠ 0, then a · c = b · c
Divisiondivide each side by the same nonzero numberif a = b and c ≠ 0, then a ÷ c = b ÷ c

Read the middle column again and notice that every single entry says each side. Nothing in the list gives you permission to touch one side alone, and there is no fifth property hiding somewhere that does.

Notice also that the properties are named after what you do, not after what the equation looks like. Undoing a subtraction uses the addition property, and undoing a division uses the multiplication property. That is the single most common naming mistake on a test, and it costs marks on questions you have otherwise solved perfectly.

The two columns that mention c being nonzero are flagged for a reason, and the next two slides are about what goes wrong if you ignore that condition. For now, just register that adding and subtracting come with no conditions at all, while multiplying and dividing do.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 18 — KEY CONCEPT: Transformations That Produce Equivalent Equations

9. Reading the multiplication property piece by piece

Notation

Take the third property apart symbol by symbol. Each piece is doing a job, and the condition on c is the one almost everybody reads past without stopping.

Annotate

On: \( a = b \;\text{ and }\; c \ne 0 \;\Longrightarrow\; a \cdot c = b \cdot c \)

  • The hypothesis: you already have a true equation. Every property starts from one you have and hands you a new one.
  • Multiplying by zero turns any equation into 0 = 0, true for every x. The solutions would be lost, so the new equation would not be equivalent.
  • The SAME c on both sides. A different multiplier on each side is not this property, and it is not a legal move.
  • It points one way here, but each property is undone by its partner, which is why you can walk a solution backwards to check it.

The last annotation is quietly important. Because every move can be undone, the chain of equations runs in both directions, and that is exactly why the answer at the bottom really is a solution of the equation at the top rather than just something that came out of it.

The letters a, b and c here are standing in for whole expressions, not only for plain numbers. That is why you will be allowed to subtract two x from each side later on: the property never said c had to be a number you could count.

10. Why the multiplier must not be zero

Intuition

That condition is not decoration, and the quickest way to believe it is to break it deliberately on an equation whose answer you already know.

\[ 2x = 6 \quad\xrightarrow{\;\times 0\;} \quad 0 = 0 \]

The second line is true for every number you could put in for x. The first is true only for 3. They do not have the same solutions, so they are not equivalent, and everything you write after that line is about a different problem from the one you were set.

Think of it on the balance. Multiplying both pans by zero empties both of them, and two empty pans balance no matter what was in them a moment ago. You have destroyed the information rather than rearranged it.

Dividing by zero is worse still: it is not defined at all, so the line you would write does not even mean anything. This is exactly why the two multiplying properties carry a condition and the two adding ones do not, and it is why one of the sorting items a few slides from now is a trap.

11. Take three from each pan

Picture it

Here is the subtraction property performed rather than stated. Compare this picture with the one two slides back and find what has changed.

Figure (svg): The same balance with three weights on each pan drawn as dashed outlines, meaning removed. Two boxes remain on the left and eight solid weights on the right, and the beam is still level.

Dashed weights are the ones taken away. Three off each pan leaves the beam level: that is the subtraction property of equality.

The dashed discs are the ones taken away. Three left the left pan and three left the right pan, so both pans lost exactly the same weight and the beam has not moved a millimetre.

\[ 2x + 3 - 3 = 11 - 3 \;\Longrightarrow\; 2x = 8 \]

On paper that is one line. In the picture it is one action performed twice, once on each pan, and those two descriptions are the same thing. When you write the line, say to yourself what you took off and from where.

Notice which three discs were chosen. The three on the left were the ones standing between you and the boxes, so removing them is progress. Removing three from the right pan alone would have been legal-looking nonsense, and removing four from each would have been legal but pointless.

12. Reading the balance as algebra: solving 2x + 3 = 11

Worked example

This equation is mine, not the book's, chosen so that the picture and the paper can sit side by side for one last time. Name the property on every line as you go; that habit is exactly what the homework will ask for.

\[ 2x + 3 = 11 \]

Subtract 3 from each side

Why: Subtraction property of equality: the three loose discs come off both pans.

\[ 2x + 3 - 3 = 11 - 3 \]

Simplify each side

Why: Adding 3 and then subtracting it leaves the left side alone, and 11 minus 3 is 8.

\[ 2x = 8 \]

Two lines for one move looks slow, and in your own work you will soon merge them. Write them separately while you are learning, because the merged version is where people lose a sign.

Figure (svg): The balance again, now with one box marked x on the left pan and four weights marked 1 on the right pan, still level.

Two boxes balanced eight weights, so half of each pan still balances. One box weighs four.

Divide each side by 2

Why: Division property of equality: keep half of each pan.

\[ \frac{2x}{2} = \frac{8}{2} \]

Simplify

Why: Two boxes weighing 8 between them means one box weighs 4.

\[ x = 4 \]

Check in the original equation

Why: Substituting 4 gives 8 plus 3, which is 11, so the claim is true and 4 is the solution.

\[ 2(4) + 3 = 8 + 3 = 11 \;\checkmark \]

Four lines of algebra, and every one of them is a picture you could have drawn. Later equations in this lesson get considerably longer, but not one of them will use a move that is not somewhere on that balance.

13. Trap: changing one side only

Trap

The trap

A line that appears in almost every first set of homework:

\[ 2x + 3 = 11 \]

\[ 2x = 11 \]

The 3 was dropped from the left and nothing was done on the right.

\[ x = \tfrac{11}{2} \;\text{?} \]

The fix

This one is tempting because the 3 really does need to go, and the person writing it has correctly identified the obstacle. What is missing is the second half of the move: it has to go from the right as well.

Figure (svg): The same balance with the three weights removed from the left pan only. Two boxes are on the left, eleven weights on the right, and the beam has tipped down on the right.

Nothing came off the right pan, so the beam tips. The new line is no longer an equation about the same x.

The picture is unambiguous. Nothing came off the right pan, so the beam tips, and a tipped beam is not an equation.

Test the two equations against each other rather than trusting your eye. The first is true when x is 4; the second is not, so they are not equivalent and the answer has already been thrown away by line two.

\[ 2(4) = 8 \ne 11 \]

14. Which property took this line to the next?

Matching

Decide each one by asking what you did, not by looking at what is in the equation. That is precisely where the two possible answers come apart, and getting it right here is worth marks later.

Match the pairs

  • a. x − 7 = 12 becomes x = 19
  • b. x + 5 = 2 becomes x = −3
  • c. 6x = 42 becomes x = 7
  • d. x ÷ 3 = 5 becomes x = 15
  • w. Addition property of equality
  • x. Subtraction property of equality
  • y. Multiplication property of equality
  • z. Division property of equality

Why: A subtraction inside the equation is undone by adding, and a division inside it is undone by multiplying, so the first and last pairs use the opposite-sounding property from the one you can see. Name the move you made, never the operation you were looking at.

If you matched the first one to subtraction, you were reading the equation rather than the move. The equation contains a subtraction; what you did to it was add 7 to each side. Both things are true, and only the second one is the name of the property.

A good habit for the homework: write the property beside every line as you go, in the margin. It takes three seconds, it forces you to notice what you actually did, and it is what the exercise set asks for anyway.

15. Legal move, or not?

Sorting

Three of these are straight out of the table of four properties. Three are not, and one of the three looks perfectly reasonable right up until you ask what happens when the thing you divided by turns out to be zero.

Sort into buckets

Each move is applied to a linear equation. Which ones are guaranteed to produce an equivalent equation?

Equivalent equation
Add 7 to each side; Subtract 2x from each side; Divide each side by 3
Not guaranteed
Multiply each side by 0; Add 4 to the left side only; Divide each side by x
ok
Adding 7, subtracting 2x and dividing by 3 are the addition, subtraction and division properties applied to both sides with a nonzero divisor. Subtracting 2x is allowed because the properties never said c had to be a plain number.
no
Multiplying by 0 destroys the equation. Adding to one side only breaks the balance. Dividing by x divides by something that might be zero, and it can delete a solution: from x times x = 3x you would get x = 3 and lose x = 0.

The third item is the one worth pausing on. Subtracting two x from each side is legal, and you will do it constantly from Part 3 onwards, because the c in the properties stands for any expression and not only for a number you could count out in discs.

The last item is the reverse case. Dividing by x looks like the same kind of move, but x is an unknown, and an unknown is allowed to be zero. You will meet this again in Chapter 5 with rational equations, where it becomes a genuine source of lost solutions.

16. Variable on one side

Section

Part 2

17. Undo in the reverse order

Intuition

Before you solve anything, look at what was done to x, in order. In the expression below, x was first multiplied by four fifths, and then 8 was added on the end.

\[ x \;\xrightarrow{\;\times \frac45\;}\; \tfrac45 x \;\xrightarrow{\;+8\;}\; \tfrac45x + 8 \]

To take it apart you walk the arrows backwards. The last thing done is the first thing undone, so the 8 comes off before the four fifths does.

\[ \tfrac45x + 8 \;\xrightarrow{\;-8\;}\; \tfrac45x \;\xrightarrow{\;\times \frac54\;}\; x \]

This is the order of operations run in reverse, and it is the reason the plus or minus almost always comes off before the coefficient. It is the same logic as taking off your shoes before your socks.

Whenever you are unsure which move comes first, draw these two arrows in the margin. It takes ten seconds and it turns a decision into a reading, which is far less error-prone when the numbers get ugly.

18. Example 1: a fractional coefficient

Worked example

Solve the equation, naming the property on each line. The fraction looks like the hard part and your instinct will be to deal with it first, but the arrows on the last slide say it is the last thing to touch.

\[ \tfrac45 x + 8 = 20 \]

Subtract 8 from each side

Why: Subtraction property: 8 was the last thing added, so it is the first thing undone.

\[ \tfrac45 x + 8 - 8 = 20 - 8 \]

Simplify

Why: The left side loses the 8 and the right side becomes 12.

\[ \tfrac45 x = 12 \]

Multiply each side by five fourths

Why: Multiplication property, using the reciprocal of four fifths, because a number times its reciprocal is 1.

\[ \tfrac54 \cdot \tfrac45 x = \tfrac54 (12) \]

Simplify

Why: On the left the fractions cancel to 1. On the right, 12 divided by 4 is 3, and 3 times 5 is 15.

\[ x = 15 \]

Multiplying by the reciprocal is the move to take away from this example. Dividing by four fifths would give the same answer, but dividing by a fraction is itself multiplying by the reciprocal, so you may as well do it in one honest step and write the reason down.

Check the arithmetic on the right-hand side rather than trusting it. Five fourths of 12 is easier as 12 divided by 4, then times 5, than as 60 divided by 4, though both give 15.

Check in the original equation

Why: Four fifths of 15 is 12, and 12 plus 8 is 20, which matches the right side exactly.

\[ \tfrac45(15) + 8 = 12 + 8 = 20 \;\checkmark \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 18 — Example 1

19. Example 1 again, the book's other way

Worked example

The margin note beside Example 1 offers a completely different opening move: get rid of the fraction before anything else. If both routes really are chains of equivalent equations, then both have to reach the same answer.

Watching that happen is worth the extra minute, because it is the first piece of evidence you have that the properties do what they claim rather than just being rules to obey.

\[ \tfrac45 x + 8 = 20 \]

Multiply each side by 5

Why: Multiplication property. Five is the denominator, so multiplying by it clears the fraction.

\[ 5\left(\tfrac45 x + 8\right) = 5(20) \]

Distribute the 5 across both terms inside the brackets

Why: The 5 multiplies the whole left side, which means every term of it, not only the fraction.

\[ 4x + 40 = 100 \]

That second line is where this route can go wrong. The 8 has to be multiplied too, and forgetting it is the same error you will meet again in Exercise 42 near the end of Part 4.

Weigh the two routes against each other. This one has four steps instead of three, but every number in it is a whole number, and most people find 4x equals 60 friendlier than four fifths x equals 12.

Subtract 40 from each side

Why: Subtraction property.

\[ 4x = 60 \]

Divide each side by 4

Why: Division property.

\[ x = 15 \]

Check that both routes agree

Why: The same 15 came out of a different chain of equations, and it still satisfies the original equation.

\[ \tfrac45(15) + 8 = 20 \;\checkmark \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 18 — ANOTHER WAY margin note

20. Supply the missing lines

Fill the middle

Guided Practice 1. The first and last lines are given and the middle has been taken out. Work out what has to sit between them, and say the property to yourself as you fill each box.

Fill in the blanks

4x + 9 = 21 \;\Longrightarrow\; 4x = 12 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 3

Why: Subtract 9 from each side first: 21 minus 9 is 12, so the middle line is 4x = 12. Then divide each side by 4 to get x = 3. Checking: 4 times 3 is 12, and 12 plus 9 is 21.

Reading a solution backwards like this is a genuinely different skill from writing one forwards, and it is the skill you use when you check a friend's work or your own from last week.

If you found yourself guessing rather than deducing, solve the equation properly on paper first and then compare. The point of the exercise is to notice that only one middle line can possibly connect those two ends.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 19 — Guided Practice 1

21. Guided Practice 3: a negative fractional coefficient

Worked example

A minus sign in front of the fraction changes nothing about the method. Keep it attached to the three fifths and treat the whole thing, sign included, as one coefficient.

\[ -\tfrac35 x + 1 = 4 \]

Subtract 1 from each side

Why: Subtraction property: undo the addition first, as always.

\[ -\tfrac35 x = 3 \]

Multiply each side by minus five thirds

Why: Multiplication property, using the reciprocal of minus three fifths, which is minus five thirds.

\[ -\tfrac53 \cdot \left(-\tfrac35 x\right) = -\tfrac53 (3) \]

Simplify each side

Why: Two negatives multiply to a positive on the left. On the right, 3 divided by 3 is 1, times 5 is 5, and the sign stays negative.

\[ x = -5 \]

The reciprocal of a negative fraction is negative. If you multiply by positive five thirds instead, the left side becomes minus x rather than x, and you have one more step to do and one more sign to get wrong.

If a negative answer makes you uneasy, that is exactly what the check is for. A negative solution is as ordinary as a positive one, and the substitution settles the question in ten seconds without any appeal to how it feels.

There is a second route here that is worth knowing. Multiplying each side by minus 1 first turns the equation into three fifths x minus 1 equals minus 4, with a positive coefficient, and some people find that easier to look at.

Both routes are chains of equivalent equations, so both give minus 5. Choose whichever leaves you with fewer minus signs to keep track of, and write the property name either way.

Check in the original equation

Why: Minus three fifths of minus 5 is 3, and 3 plus 1 is 4, which is the right side.

\[ -\tfrac35(-5) + 1 = 3 + 1 = 4 \;\checkmark \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 19 — Guided Practice 3

22. Find the error: a reciprocal that became a subtraction

Error analysis

Exercise 41 from the section. The first move is right, so look further down the page than you expect to. Decide which line is the first wrong one before you read the notes.

Annotate

On: \( \tfrac37 x = 15 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 15 - \tfrac37 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 14\tfrac47 \)

  • Correct. Subtracting 2 from each side of (3/7)x + 2 = 17 does give (3/7)x = 15, by the subtraction property.
  • Here is the break. The three sevenths is MULTIPLYING x, not added to it, so it comes off by multiplying, never by subtracting.
  • Multiply each side by the reciprocal, seven thirds: x = 15 · 7/3 = 35.
  • Their answer gives (3/7)(14 4/7) + 2 ≈ 8.24, not 17. The correct one gives (3/7)(35) + 2 = 15 + 2 = 17. One substitution would have found this.

What makes this error interesting is that it is not carelessness. The person knew that something had to be removed from the left and reached for the only removal move they could think of. The fix is not to concentrate harder; it is to ask what the three sevenths is doing to the x.

Every wrong answer in this lesson can be caught by the same last step. If you check, you never hand in one of these, whatever went wrong in the middle.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 22 — Exercise 41, ERROR ANALYSIS

23. Put the moves in order

Ranking

\[ 3 + \tfrac87 d = -1 \]

Nothing in this equation is difficult, and the order is the whole question. Think of the two arrows from the reverse-order slide before you drag anything.

Put in order

Order the steps of a complete solution to the equation above.

  1. Write down the original equation
  2. Subtract 3 from each side
  3. Multiply each side by seven eighths
  4. Simplify to leave d on its own
  5. Substitute the value back into the original equation

Why: Undo the addition before the coefficient, because the coefficient was applied first and reverse order takes it off last. Subtracting 3 leaves eight sevenths d equal to minus 4, and multiplying by seven eighths gives d equal to minus seven halves. Checking: eight sevenths of minus 3.5 is minus 4, and 3 plus minus 4 is minus 1.

The first and last items are the ones people leave out of their written work, and they are the two that examiners look for. Writing the original equation down is what you are checking against, and the substitution is what turns a guess into an answer.

Notice that the coefficient here is a fraction bigger than one, so the reciprocal is smaller than one and the answer shrinks. If your answer had grown, that would be a signal to go back and look at which way up the reciprocal went.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 21 — Exercise 18

24. Which move comes first?

Prediction

\[ 7 - \tfrac53 c = 22 \]

Commit to one answer before you look at the rest. Two of these four options are moves you are genuinely allowed to make; only one of them takes you towards the answer, and telling those apart is the skill here.

Predict first

What is the correct first move here?

  • Subtract 7 from each side
  • Multiply each side by three fifths
  • Add five thirds c to each side
  • Divide each side by 7

Correct: Subtract 7 from each side

Why: The 7 is added to the term holding c, so it comes off first and leaves minus five thirds c equal to 15. Then multiply by minus three fifths to get c equal to minus 9. Dividing by 7 is legal but useless: it would have to divide every term, including the 22, and leaves the fraction in a worse state than before.

Dividing each side by 7 is the interesting distractor. It is perfectly legal and it produces a perfectly true equation; it just produces one that is harder to solve than the one you started with, because the 22 and the fraction both get divided too. Legal and useful are two different tests, and a move has to pass both.

Adding five thirds c to each side is the move you would reach for if the c appeared somewhere else as well. Keep it in mind rather than dismissing it, because in Part 3 that becomes the standard opening move.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 21 — Exercise 17

25. Variable on both sides

Section

Part 3

26. The same box on both pans

Picture it

Everything so far had the unknown in one place, which meant you could work steadily towards it. Now it appears twice, and the balance shows you why that costs only one extra move rather than a new method.

Figure (svg): Two balances side by side. The left one has three boxes marked x and two weights on its left pan and one box and eight weights on its right pan. The right one shows the same balance after one box has been taken off each pan: two boxes and two weights against eight weights.

A box on each pan is weight the two sides share, so it can come off both at once.

Look at the left balance. Three boxes and two discs against one box and eight discs, and the beam is level. The single box on the right pan is weight the two sides have in common.

\[ 3x + 2 = x + 8 \;\Longrightarrow\; 2x + 2 = 8 \]

Lift one box off each pan at the same moment and the beam stays level, because both pans lost the same weight. That is the subtraction property again, used on a variable term instead of on a number.

The right-hand balance is what you are left with, and it is an equation of exactly the kind you solved in Part 2. Two more moves, a check, and it is done.

27. Collect the variables on one side, the numbers on the other

Concept

An equation with x in two places is not harder than one with x in a single place. It just needs one new kind of opening move: subtract a variable term from each side, so that all the x ends up together.

\[ \underbrace{4p + 15}_{\text{has } p} = \underbrace{7p - 3}_{\text{has } p} \;\Longrightarrow\; 15 = 3p - 3 \]

Look hard at what the equation became. The variable is now in one place only, so the rest of the work is Part 2 material, and nothing after the first line is new to you.

The general plan for the rest of this lesson is two sorting moves and then a division: get every variable term on one side, get every plain number on the other, then divide by whatever coefficient is left.

Which variable term you subtract is entirely up to you, and the next few slides are about making that choice deliberately rather than at random. Both choices are correct; one of them is usually less painful.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 19 — Example 3

28. Example 3: 4p + 15 = 7p − 3

Worked example

The book sets this as a multiple-choice question, and you could answer it by substituting the four options until one works. That would get the mark and teach you nothing, and it collapses completely on a question with no options, so solve it properly.

\[ 4p + 15 = 7p - 3 \]

Subtract 4p from each side

Why: Subtraction property. Taking the smaller variable term off both sides leaves a positive coefficient on the right.

\[ 4p + 15 - 4p = 7p - 3 - 4p \]

Simplify each side

Why: On the left the p terms cancel; on the right 7p minus 4p is 3p.

\[ 15 = 3p - 3 \]

Do not be put off by the variable ending up on the right-hand side. An equation reads the same in both directions, and there is no rule anywhere that puts the unknown on the left.

Add 3 to each side

Why: Addition property, to clear the number away from the p term.

\[ 18 = 3p \]

Divide each side by 3

Why: Division property.

\[ 6 = p \]

Write the answer the way round that the question asked for it if you like, but do not waste a line flipping it. Six equals p and p equals six are the same statement.

Check in the original equation

Why: Left side: 4 times 6 plus 15 is 24 plus 15, which is 39. Right side: 7 times 6 minus 3 is 42 minus 3, which is also 39.

\[ 4(6) + 15 = 39, \quad 7(6) - 3 = 39 \;\checkmark \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 19 — Example 3, TAKS practice

29. Guided Practice 5: collecting the other way on purpose

Worked example

Here the two variable terms have opposite signs, so there is no smaller one to subtract in the usual sense. Watch what adding, rather than subtracting, does to the signs.

\[ -2x + 9 = 2x - 7 \]

Add 2x to each side

Why: Addition property. Adding the opposite of the left variable term is what clears it away.

\[ -2x + 9 + 2x = 2x - 7 + 2x \]

Simplify each side

Why: On the left minus 2x plus 2x is zero; on the right 2x plus 2x is 4x.

\[ 9 = 4x - 7 \]

Notice that the coefficient on the right grew from 2 to 4 rather than shrinking. That is what always happens when the two variable terms have opposite signs, and it is worth expecting so that it does not look like a mistake.

Add 7 to each side

Why: Addition property.

\[ 16 = 4x \]

Divide each side by 4

Why: Division property.

\[ 4 = x \]

You could have gone the other way and subtracted 2x from each side, which would have left minus 4x on the left and a negative coefficient to divide by. Same answer, one more chance to lose a sign.

The rule of thumb still applies here, it just needs restating for opposite signs: collect on the side whose coefficient is already positive, and add rather than subtract to clear the other one.

Check in the original equation

Why: Left side: minus 2 times 4 plus 9 is minus 8 plus 9, which is 1. Right side: 2 times 4 minus 7 is 8 minus 7, which is also 1.

\[ -2(4) + 9 = 1, \quad 2(4) - 7 = 1 \;\checkmark \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 21 — Guided Practice 5

30. Complete the both-sides solution

Faded example

Guided Practice 6. The variable terms are minus x on the left and minus 6x on the right, so adding 6x to each side is the move that leaves a positive coefficient behind.

Fill in the blanks

10 - x = -6x + 15 \;\Longrightarrow\; 10 + 5x = 15 \;\Longrightarrow\; 5x = 5 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 1

Why: Add 6x to each side: minus x plus 6x is 5x, so the left becomes 10 plus 5x and the right becomes 15. Subtract 10 from each side to get 5x = 5, then divide by 5 to get x = 1. Check: 10 minus 1 is 9, and minus 6 times 1 plus 15 is also 9.

The first blank is the one that decides the rest. Minus one x plus six x is five x, and if you wrote seven there you have added the two coefficients without their signs, which is the most common arithmetic slip in this part of the lesson.

Once the middle is right the ending is forced, which is the useful thing about writing a solution as a chain: a mistake shows up as a line that cannot be reached from the one above it.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 21 — Guided Practice 6

31. Where the two sides agree

Picture it

Here is another way to see what a both-sides equation is actually asking. Draw each side as its own line and the question turns into one about heights.

Figure (svg): Two straight lines on axes. The line y equals 3x plus 8 rises gently and the line y equals 9x minus 16 rises steeply; they cross at the point 4 comma 20, which is marked with a dot.

Each side of the equation is its own line. The solution is the one x where the two heights agree.

The gentle line is the left side and the steep one is the right side. They climb at different rates, so they cross exactly once, and the x at the crossing is the solution of the equation.

You can read the check off the picture too. At x equal to 4 both lines are at height 20, which is precisely the pair of twenties you computed by substituting back on the very first worked example of this deck.

The calculator activity at the end of the section finds the same answer a third way, by printing both sides in a table and scrolling until the two columns agree. Three routes, one number, and that agreement is not a coincidence.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 25 — Graphing Calculator Activity: Use Tables to Solve Equations

32. Which side should the variable terms go?

Discrimination

Both sides always work, so this is not a question about right and wrong. It is a question about which route saves you a division by a negative number at the very end, where tired people make sign errors.

The test is quick: compare the two coefficients, including their signs, and collect on the side that holds the larger one.

Sort into buckets

Collect the variable terms on the side that leaves a positive coefficient. Which side is that for each equation?

Collect on the left
3a + 4 = 2a + 15; 5w + 2 = 2w + 5; p + 5 = 25 − 4p
Collect on the right
2z − 3 = 6z + 25; 17 − 6r = 25 − 3r; 6 − 5q = q + 9
left
In 3a + 4 = 2a + 15, 5w + 2 = 2w + 5 and p + 5 = 25 − 4p the left coefficient is the larger one (3 against 2, 5 against 2, 1 against −4), so subtracting the right-hand variable term leaves a positive coefficient: a, 3w and 5p.
right
In 2z − 3 = 6z + 25, 17 − 6r = 25 − 3r and 6 − 5q = q + 9 the right coefficient is the larger one (6 against 2, −3 against −6, 1 against −5), so collecting there leaves 4z, 3r and 6q, all positive.

The fourth item is the one that catches people. Both coefficients are negative, and minus three is larger than minus six even though the digit is smaller, so the variable terms go to the right, where they leave a positive three behind.

The fifth and sixth items have an invisible coefficient of one, on the p and on the q. Writing that one in, faintly, is a good habit while you are learning, because a bare letter is easy to read as having no coefficient at all.

Remember that nothing here is about correctness. Every one of these six can be collected on either side and solved, and you would get the same answer both ways; you are choosing the route with fewer negative numbers in it.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 21 — Exercises 20 to 31

33. Both routes, side by side

Comparison

Fill in the coefficient each route leaves behind. Work each one out by subtracting the other side's variable term, and watch for the pattern that emerges down the two columns.

Comparison matrix

equationcollect on the left givescollect on the right gives
3a + 4 = 2a + 151−1
2z − 3 = 6z + 25−44
5w + 2 = 2w + 53-3
17 − 6r = 25 − 3r-33

The pattern is that the two columns are always negatives of one another, and that is not an accident. Collecting on the left computes the left coefficient minus the right one; collecting on the right computes the right minus the left, which is the same subtraction the other way round.

So the choice never changes the size of the number you divide by, only its sign. That is exactly why it is a comfort decision rather than a correctness one, and why the rule of thumb is simply to avoid the minus.

34. Collecting is a choice, not a rule

Intuition

Nothing in the four properties says the variable has to end up on the left. Here is one equation solved both ways, so you can see what the choice actually costs.

\[ 3a + 4 = 2a + 15 \;\Longrightarrow\; a + 4 = 15 \;\Longrightarrow\; a = 11 \]

\[ 3a + 4 = 2a + 15 \;\Longrightarrow\; 4 = -a + 15 \;\Longrightarrow\; -11 = -a \;\Longrightarrow\; 11 = a \]

Both are chains of equivalent equations, so both are correct and both reach 11. The second one takes an extra line and asks you to divide by minus one at the end, which is precisely where sign errors live.

So choose the side that leaves the coefficient positive. You are not obeying a rule when you do that; you are buying yourself a smaller chance of a slip, which is a completely different kind of reason and a better one.

This is worth saying aloud because a lot of algebra is taught as if there were one permitted route. There is not. There are usually several, they all work, and part of getting good at this is developing a taste for the one with the fewest places to go wrong.

35. Brackets and fractions come off first

Section

Part 4

36. The distributive property, drawn

Concept

Brackets have to go before anything can be collected, because terms locked inside them cannot be combined with terms outside. The picture below is why the rule for removing them says what it says.

Figure (svg): A rectangle three units tall and x plus 2 units wide, cut by a vertical line into a piece of area 3x and a piece of area 6.

The height 3 multiplies the whole width, so it multiplies each piece of the width.

\[ a(b + c) = ab + ac \]

The multiplier outside the brackets multiplies the whole width of the rectangle, and the width is made of two pieces, so it multiplies each of them. The area of the whole is the area of the parts.

Miss the second piece and the area you write down is smaller than the rectangle you drew. That is not a rule you are breaking; it is a quantity you are getting wrong, and the check will find it.

The same picture works when the pieces are subtracted, with the second rectangle cut off the end rather than added on. It also works when the multiplier is negative, though then you have to think of it as reversing rather than as area, which is why the next example is the one to slow down on.

37. Guided Practice 7: brackets on both sides

Worked example

Distribute on both sides first, treating each side as its own small job. Once the brackets are gone this is an ordinary both-sides problem of exactly the kind you solved in Part 3.

\[ 3(x + 2) = 5(x + 4) \]

Distribute the 3 and the 5

Why: Distributive property, on each side separately. Each multiplier reaches both terms in its own brackets.

\[ 3x + 6 = 5x + 20 \]

Count the terms before and after. Two brackets became four terms, and if your line has fewer terms than that, something has been left behind inside a bracket.

Subtract 3x from each side

Why: Subtraction property, collecting on the right where the coefficient is larger.

\[ 6 = 2x + 20 \]

Subtract 20 from each side

Why: Subtraction property, clearing the number away from the variable term.

\[ -14 = 2x \]

Divide each side by 2

Why: Division property.

\[ -7 = x \]

A negative answer here is expected rather than alarming. The right side starts higher, at 20 against 6, and it also grows faster, so the two sides can only agree somewhere to the left of zero.

Getting into the habit of predicting the sign before you finish is cheap and it catches a whole class of mistakes. If your answer here had come out positive, you would know to look again without being told.

Notice also how little of this problem was new. Two distributions, then three moves you have been making since Part 2, which is what it means to say that clearing brackets reduces a hard equation to an easy one.

Check in the original equation

Why: Left side: 3 times minus 5, which is minus 15. Right side: 5 times minus 3, which is also minus 15.

\[ 3(-7 + 2) = -15, \quad 5(-7 + 4) = -15 \;\checkmark \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 21 — Guided Practice 7

38. Example 4: brackets, negatives and like terms

Worked example

The hardest equation in the section, and the place to slow down rather than speed up. Every individual step here is one you have already done; there are simply more of them and two of them involve negative multipliers.

\[ 3(5x - 8) = -2(-x + 7) - 12x \]

Distribute on each side

Why: Distributive property. On the right, minus 2 times minus x is plus 2x, and minus 2 times 7 is minus 14.

\[ 15x - 24 = 2x - 14 - 12x \]

That sign change on the right is where most of the marks in this exercise set are lost. Two negatives multiplied give a positive, every time, and the safest habit is to write the multiplication out before you write its answer.

Combine like terms on the right

Why: 2x minus 12x is minus 10x. The left side has nothing to combine.

\[ 15x - 24 = -10x - 14 \]

Combining like terms is a separate move from distributing, and it deserves its own line. Trying to do both at once is how a term goes missing.

Add 10x to each side

Why: Addition property, collecting on the left where the coefficient will stay positive.

\[ 25x - 24 = -14 \]

Add 24 to each side

Why: Addition property.

\[ 25x = 10 \]

Divide each side by 25 and simplify

Why: Division property; 10 over 25 reduces by 5 to 2 over 5.

\[ x = \tfrac25 \]

Leave the answer as a fraction in lowest terms rather than as a decimal. Two fifths is exact, 0.4 happens to be exact here as well, but the habit of keeping fractions will matter enormously in Chapter 4.

Check in the original equation

Why: Left side: 5 times two fifths is 2, minus 8 is minus 6, times 3 is minus 18. Right side: minus 2 times the bracket gives four fifths minus 14, and 12 times two fifths is twenty-four fifths, so the right side is 0.8 minus 14 minus 4.8, which is also minus 18.

\[ 3(2 - 8) = -18, \quad \tfrac45 - 14 - \tfrac{24}{5} = -18 \;\checkmark \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 20 — Example 4

39. Guided Practice 8: negatives outside both brackets

Worked example

Two negative multipliers this time, one on each side. Write the distribution out in full rather than doing it in your head; the extra line costs you nothing and saves the sign.

\[ -4(2x + 5) = 2(-x - 9) - 4x \]

Distribute on each side

Why: Minus 4 times 2x is minus 8x and minus 4 times 5 is minus 20; on the right, 2 times minus x is minus 2x and 2 times minus 9 is minus 18.

\[ -8x - 20 = -2x - 18 - 4x \]

Combine like terms on the right

Why: Minus 2x minus 4x is minus 6x.

\[ -8x - 20 = -6x - 18 \]

Both coefficients are now negative, so the discrimination rule from Part 3 applies with care: minus 6 is the larger of the two, so collecting on the right is what turns the coefficient positive.

Add 8x to each side

Why: Addition property, collecting on the right for exactly that reason.

\[ -20 = 2x - 18 \]

Add 18 to each side

Why: Addition property; minus 20 plus 18 is minus 2.

\[ -2 = 2x \]

Divide each side by 2

Why: Division property.

\[ -1 = x \]

Two negative numbers in the last two lines and the answer is still a clean minus one. If yours came out as a fraction, look back at the combining step, because that is where an eight and a six most often get swapped.

Check in the original equation

Why: Left side: 2 times minus 1 plus 5 is 3, times minus 4 is minus 12. Right side: minus 1 becomes 1 inside the bracket, so 2 times minus 8 is minus 16, and minus 4 times minus 1 adds 4, giving minus 12.

\[ -4(3) = -12, \quad 2(-8) + 4 = -12 \;\checkmark \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 21 — Guided Practice 8

40. Trap: the multiplier reaches only the first term

Trap

The trap

The commonest wrong line in this whole lesson:

\[ 3(x + 2) = 5(x + 4) \]

\[ 3x + 2 = 5x + 4 \]

The brackets were dropped, not distributed.

\[ -2 = 2x \;\Longrightarrow\; x = -1 \;\text{?} \]

The fix

This happens when you read brackets as punctuation rather than as multiplication. They are multiplication, and the number outside is multiplying everything inside, not just the first thing it meets.

\[ 3(-1 + 2) = 3, \quad 5(-1 + 4) = 15 \]

One substitution ends the argument: the two sides come out 3 and 15, which are not equal, so minus one is not a solution of anything here.

The correct distribution gives minus 7, and the area picture says why. The 3 covers the whole width of the rectangle, so it has to multiply both pieces of that width.

A quick guard while you work: count terms. Two brackets should become four terms, and this wrong line has only four symbols where it should have four terms.

41. One multiplication kills every fraction

Concept

A denominator is only a division waiting to happen, and you do not have to work around it. Multiply each side by a number that all the denominators divide into and every fraction disappears in a single line.

Figure (svg): A bar 24 minutes long shown twice. Above, it is cut into three blocks of 8 minutes labelled one car each. Below, it is cut into four blocks of 6 minutes. Three cars plus four cars is seven cars.

Multiplying by 24 picks the stretch of time that both rates cut into whole blocks. That is all clearing denominators does.

The picture shows why the number works. Twenty-four minutes is a stretch of time that both an eight-minute job and a six-minute job cut into whole blocks, so counting in twenty-fourths makes both rates whole.

\[ \tfrac18 t + \tfrac16 t = 7 \;\xrightarrow{\;\times 24\;}\; 3t + 4t = 168 \]

The number to use is the least common denominator. Any common multiple works, so 48 would clear the fractions just as well; the least one simply keeps the numbers small, and small numbers mean fewer mistakes.

Two things to watch. Every term on both sides gets multiplied, including terms that had no fraction in them, and a term with no denominator is not exempt. Both of those are the subject of the error-analysis slide in a moment.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 20 — Example 5, the LCD step

42. Example 5: two people washing seven cars

Worked example

You wash a car in 8 minutes, a friend washes one in 6 minutes. How long do the two of you take to wash 7 cars working together? The rates are fractions of a car per minute, which is what puts the denominators into the equation.

\[ \underbrace{\tfrac{1}{8}}_{\text{your rate}}t + \underbrace{\tfrac{1}{6}}_{\text{friend's rate}}t = \underbrace{7}_{\text{cars}} \]

Check the units before you solve. A car per minute times minutes gives cars, and cars plus cars gives cars, which matches the 7 on the right. If that had not matched, the equation would be wrong and the algebra would be wasted.

Multiply each side by the least common denominator, 24

Why: Multiplication property. Both 8 and 6 divide into 24, and the WHOLE side is multiplied, not just the fractions.

\[ 24\left(\tfrac18 t + \tfrac16 t\right) = 24(7) \]

Distribute the 24 across both terms

Why: Distributive property: 24 over 8 is 3, and 24 over 6 is 4.

\[ 3t + 4t = 168 \]

Combine like terms

Why: 3t plus 4t is 7t.

\[ 7t = 168 \]

Divide each side by 7

Why: Division property.

\[ t = 24 \]

Twenty-four minutes is less than either person would take alone, which is the sanity check you should run on every work-rate problem. If your answer is longer than one person working by themselves, something has been added that should have been divided.

Check against the situation, not just the equation

Why: In 24 minutes you wash 24 divided by 8, which is 3 cars, and your friend washes 24 divided by 6, which is 4 cars. Three and four make the seven that were asked for.

\[ \tfrac{24}{8} + \tfrac{24}{6} = 3 + 4 = 7 \;\checkmark \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 20 — Example 5

43. Find the error: only one side was multiplied

Error analysis

Exercise 42. The idea behind the first move is exactly right and the choice of multiplier is exactly right, and then a whole side of the equation goes missing. Find the line where it happens before reading on.

Annotate

On: \( \tfrac15 x + \tfrac12 = 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; 10\left(\tfrac15 x + \tfrac12\right) = 1 \;\Longrightarrow\; 2x + 5 = 1 \)

  • 10 is a fine choice: it is the least common denominator of 5 and 2.
  • Here is the error. The left side was multiplied by 10 and the right side was left as 1. This is the AVOID ERRORS note in the margin of Example 5, exactly.
  • Multiply the right side too: 10(1) = 10, so the line reads 2x + 5 = 10, giving 2x = 5 and x = 5/2.
  • Their x = −2 gives (1/5)(−2) + 1/2 = 0.1, nowhere near 1. The correct x = 5/2 gives 1/2 + 1/2 = 1.

Multiplying by the least common denominator feels like tidying up rather than like a move, and that is precisely why the other side gets forgotten. It is a move. It is the multiplication property, and the property says each side.

There is a useful tell in the wrong line: the left side changed and the right side did not. Whenever one side of your working is identical to the line above and the other is not, stop and ask what you did to only one of them.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 22 — Exercise 42, ERROR ANALYSIS

44. Guided Practice 10: fractions on both sides

Worked example

Fractions and a variable on both sides at once, which is every skill in Parts 2 to 4 in one question. Clear the fractions first and the rest of it is Part 3 all over again.

\[ \tfrac23 x + \tfrac56 = x - \tfrac12 \]

Multiply each side by 6

Why: Multiplication property; 6 is the least common denominator of 3, 6 and 2.

\[ 6\left(\tfrac23 x + \tfrac56\right) = 6\left(x - \tfrac12\right) \]

Distribute the 6 on each side

Why: Every term gets multiplied: 6 times two thirds is 4, 6 times five sixths is 5, 6 times x is 6x, and 6 times one half is 3.

\[ 4x + 5 = 6x - 3 \]

Notice that the x on the right had no denominator at all and still had to be multiplied. Every term on a side is part of that side, and the multiplier does not get to choose which terms it likes.

Subtract 4x from each side

Why: Subtraction property, collecting on the right where the coefficient is larger.

\[ 5 = 2x - 3 \]

Add 3 to each side

Why: Addition property.

\[ 8 = 2x \]

Divide each side by 2

Why: Division property.

\[ 4 = x \]

The check on this one is worth doing carefully, because it is the first time you have had to add fractions to verify an answer rather than just multiply them.

Eight thirds plus five sixths needs a common denominator of six: sixteen sixths plus five sixths is twenty-one sixths, which is seven halves. Do that on paper rather than in your head, and the check is as trustworthy as the solution.

Check in the original equation

Why: Left side: two thirds of 4 is eight thirds, plus five sixths is seven halves. Right side: 4 minus one half is also seven halves.

\[ \tfrac83 + \tfrac56 = \tfrac72, \quad 4 - \tfrac12 = \tfrac72 \;\checkmark \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 21 — Guided Practice 10

45. Supply the clearing step

Fill the middle

Guided Practice 9. The denominators are 4 and 5, so the least common denominator is 20. Work out what each term becomes when you multiply the whole equation by it.

Fill in the blanks

\tfrac14 x + \tfrac25 x = 39 \;\Longrightarrow\; 5x + 8x = 780 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 60

Why: Multiply each side by 20: 20 over 4 is 5, and 20 times two fifths is 8, and 20 times 39 is 780. So 13x = 780 and x = 60. Check: a quarter of 60 is 15, two fifths of 60 is 24, and 15 plus 24 is 39.

The second blank catches people. Twenty times two fifths is not 10; divide by the denominator first to get 4, then multiply by the numerator to get 8. Doing it in that order keeps you in whole numbers throughout.

The 780 on the right is given to you deliberately, because it is the piece most often left as 39. If your two coefficients are right but your answer is twenty times too big, that is the term you forgot to multiply.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 21 — Guided Practice 9

46. Before you compute: what does each one want first?

Step zero

Planning the first move is a skill of its own, and it is quick. Look at all three of these, decide what you would do first for each, and only then read the answer.

Discussion prompt

Do not solve these. For each one, name the single first move and say why it is first.

Part (c) is included to make a point about decimals. You could multiply through by 10 to clear them, and that is a perfectly good move, but decimals are not fractions and they do not have to be cleared. Collecting works on them directly.

Getting into the habit of a ten-second plan is worth more than it sounds. Most long solutions that go wrong go wrong in the first two lines, and those are the lines you write before you have warmed up.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 22 — Exercises 37, 47 and 58

47. None, one, or all of them

Section

Part 5

48. When the variable disappears

Concept

Every equation so far has ended with the variable alone on one side. Sometimes it never gets there: the variable terms cancel each other completely and you are left with a statement about numbers only.

That is not a mistake and it is not a dead end. It is the answer, in a form you have not been taught to read yet, and this is the part of the lesson that Algebra 1 never reached.

\[ 5x - 20 = 5x + 12 \;\Longrightarrow\; -20 = 12 \]

Read the leftover statement as what it is. Minus 20 is not 12, so the statement is false, and there is no x anywhere in it that could be chosen to make it true. No number can satisfy the original equation, and you write no solution.

\[ 3x + 15 = 3x + 15 \;\Longrightarrow\; 15 = 15 \]

Here the leftover statement is true, and it stays true whatever x was, because x has dropped out of it entirely. Every number is therefore a solution, and you write all real numbers.

The two cases look almost identical on the page, and the only difference is whether the surviving number statement is true or false. That is the whole test, and it takes one glance once you know to look for it.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 23 — SPECIAL EQUATIONS, Exercises 63 to 66

49. Exercise 63: an equation with no solution

Worked example

Nothing about the opening of this problem announces that it is special. You start it exactly as you started every equation in Part 4, and the surprise arrives on line three.

\[ 5(x - 4) = 5x + 12 \]

Distribute the 5

Why: Distributive property: 5 times x is 5x and 5 times minus 4 is minus 20.

\[ 5x - 20 = 5x + 12 \]

Subtract 5x from each side

Why: Subtraction property. This is the usual collecting move, and here it removes the variable entirely.

\[ -20 = 12 \]

Do not panic at this line and do not scratch it out. Almost everybody's first instinct is to assume they have gone wrong and start again, and they get the same line the second time.

Read the leftover statement

Why: Minus 20 is not 12. The statement is false, and no choice of x appears in it to change that.

\[ -20 \ne 12 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{no solution} \]

Figure (svg): Two parallel straight lines with the same slope, one 32 units above the other, drawn on axes; they never meet.

Both sides climb at the same rate, so the gap of 32 never closes and no x makes them agree.

The picture explains it. Both sides climb at the same rate of five, so they stay a constant 32 apart forever, and two lines that never meet describe two heights that never agree.

You could have seen this coming after line one. Both sides had exactly 5x in them, and once the variable terms match, the constants decide everything: different constants mean the gap never closes.

Write the answer as the words no solution, and keep the false line above it as your evidence. A marker wants to see that you reached minus 20 equals 12 and understood it, not that you gave up.

Check by trying any number at all

Why: With x equal to 0 the sides are minus 20 and 12; with x equal to 100 they are 480 and 512. The gap of 32 never closes, which is exactly what the two parallel lines show.

\[ x = 100: \; 5(96) = 480, \quad 5(100) + 12 = 512 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 23 — Exercise 63

50. Exercise 64: an equation true for every number

Worked example

This one opens the same way and lands in the opposite place. Watch the two sides become identical rather than merely similar.

\[ 3(x + 5) = 3x + 15 \]

Distribute the 3

Why: Distributive property: 3 times x is 3x and 3 times 5 is 15.

\[ 3x + 15 = 3x + 15 \]

Subtract 3x from each side

Why: Subtraction property. Again the variable cancels, and again that cancelling is information rather than failure.

\[ 15 = 15 \]

Read the leftover statement

Why: This one is true, and it stays true no matter what x was, so every real number is a solution.

\[ 15 = 15 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{all real numbers} \]

Figure (svg): One straight line drawn solid with a thinner dashed line lying exactly on top of it, and five dots marked along it where sample values of x have been checked.

These are not two lines. They are one line written two ways, so every dot on it is a solution.

An equation like this has a name: it is called an identity. The two sides were never two different expressions in the first place; they were one expression written two ways, and the distribution simply revealed that.

On the graph there is only one line, with the second drawn dashed on top of it. Every dot marked along it is a value of x where the two sides agree, and there are infinitely many more between the dots.

Compare this with the previous slide. Same opening move, same cancelling of the variable, and the only difference in the whole problem is that here the two constants happened to match as well.

Identities are worth recognising because they turn up as claims rather than as questions later on. Every formula you will be asked to prove in trigonometry is an identity, and proving one means showing the two sides are the same expression written differently.

Check with two very different numbers

Why: With x equal to minus 7 both sides come out minus 6; with x equal to 1 both sides come out 18.

\[ 3(-2) = -6 = 3(-7) + 15, \quad 3(6) = 18 = 3(1) + 15 \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 23 — Exercise 64

51. The three possible answers

Picture it

Put the three outcomes side by side as solution sets, drawn on number lines. The picture is what you are really being asked for when a question says solve.

Figure (svg): Three number lines. The top one has a single filled dot at 4. The middle one is bare, with no points marked. The bottom one is highlighted along its whole length with an arrowhead at each end.

Every linear equation in one variable lands in one of these three pictures, and never anywhere else.

The top line has a single filled dot, the usual case. The middle line has nothing marked at all, which is what no solution looks like: an empty set, not a small one. The bottom line is shaded end to end, arrows included.

A linear equation in one variable ends in one of these three pictures and nowhere else. It can never have exactly two solutions, and it can never have exactly seventeen.

Hold on to that until Chapter 4. Quadratics arrive there, the left side gets a squared term, and two solutions become the normal case rather than an impossible one. The reason is worth understanding now so that the change feels like a development rather than a contradiction.

52. Which case you are in, settled in advance

Concept

Exercise 67 asks you to solve the general linear equation, with letters standing where the numbers usually are. It looks forbidding and it is actually the clearest slide in this part, because its answer explains all three cases at once.

\[ ax + b = cx + d \]

Subtract cx and b from each side

Why: Subtraction property twice: variable terms to the left, numbers to the right.

\[ ax - cx = d - b \]

Factor x out of the left side

Why: Distributive property, read backwards.

\[ (a - c)x = d - b \]

Everything from here depends on the number in front of x, and you cannot divide by it until you know whether it is zero. That single question splits the problem into the three cases in the table.

casewhat the last line becomesanswer
a ≠ cdivide by a − cone solution, x = (d − b)/(a − c)
a = c and b ≠ d0 = d − b, a false statementno solution
a = c and b = d0 = 0, a true statementall real numbers

Read the middle row against Exercise 63. There a and c were both 5 and the constants were different, so it landed in the no-solution row exactly as the table predicts.

The top row is the one you have been living in for the whole lesson. Every equation in Parts 2 to 4 had different coefficients on the two sides, which is why every one of them had exactly one answer.

Solving with letters instead of numbers is uncomfortable the first time and it is worth the discomfort, because one general result has just replaced the need to discover the three cases separately by trial.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 23 — Exercise 67, CHALLENGE

53. Why there can never be exactly two solutions

Intuition

Look again at the line the general equation collapsed to. Everything that can possibly happen to a linear equation is visible in it, which is why it is worth one more slide.

\[ (a - c)x = d - b \]

If the number in front of x is not zero, you divide by it and get one answer, because a number divided by a number is one number. There is no way for that division to produce two results, however hard you look at it.

If it is zero, the left side is zero no matter which x you choose, so x has stopped mattering entirely. The equation is then either always true or never true, depending only on the right side, and nothing in between is available.

\[ 0 \cdot x = 0 \quad \text{for every } x \]

Chapter 4 breaks this open. A squared term gives the left side a second way to hit a target, since two different numbers can square to the same thing, and that is the whole reason quadratics have two solutions where linear equations have one.

54. One, none, or all?

Sorting

Decide each one by collecting the variable terms and reading what is left behind. You do not need to finish any of them; the coefficients tell you the case and then the constants settle it.

Sort into buckets

Decide each one by collecting the variable terms and reading what is left behind.

Exactly one solution
4x + 1 = 5x + 1; 3(x − 1) = x − 1
No solution
4x + 1 = 4x + 2; 3(x − 1) = 3x − 1
All real numbers
4x + 1 = 4x + 1; 2(x + 3) = 2x + 6
one
In 4x + 1 = 5x + 1 the coefficients 4 and 5 differ, leaving x = 0. In 3(x − 1) = x − 1 they are 3 and 1, leaving 2x = 2 and x = 1.
none
In 4x + 1 = 4x + 2 and 3(x − 1) = 3x − 1 the coefficients match but the constants do not, so the variable cancels and leaves 1 = 2 and −3 = −1, both false.
all
In 4x + 1 = 4x + 1 and 2(x + 3) = 2x + 6 the two sides are the same expression once the brackets are gone, so every number works.

Two of these need the brackets removed before you can compare anything, which is a reminder that the case test comes after the tidying and not before it. Judging the last two by eye without distributing gets both of them wrong.

The third item is the one with a solution of zero, and it is included deliberately. Zero is an ordinary answer, and confusing it with no solution is exactly the trap on the next slide.

55. Trap: reading no solution as the solution zero

Trap

The trap

After the variable cancels:

\[ -20 = 12 \]

A common write-up:

\[ x = 0 \;\text{?} \]

Or, just as common, leaving the page blank.

The fix

Zero is tempting because nothing is left on the page where an x should be, and nothing feels like it ought to be zero. But zero is a number like any other, and here no number works at all.

\[ 5(0 - 4) = -20 \ne 12 = 5(0) + 12 \]

Substituting zero gives minus 20 on the left and 12 on the right, so zero fails exactly the way every other number fails. It is not a special case; it is just the first number people reach for.

No solution means the solution set is empty, and the answer is those two words. Write them, and if you have room, write the false statement that proves it beside them.

The blank page is the other half of this trap. A blank scores nothing; a false leftover statement plus the words no solution scores everything, and you already did all the work.

56. Building the equation yourself

Section

Part 6

57. A verbal model is the equation before the symbols

Concept

Most of the time nobody hands you an equation. You are given a paragraph of English and the equation is the thing you have to produce, which is the genuinely hard half of every word problem.

The book's method has three stages, and the middle one is the one people skip because it feels like writing rather than maths.

Figure (svg): Four labelled boxes in a row reading Income, Wages, Percent for tips and Food bills, joined by an equals sign, a plus sign and a times sign, with arrows running down to a second row holding 105, 30, 0.15 and x.

Write the sentence in boxes first, with a unit on every box. The symbols underneath are a translation, not an invention.

Write the relationship in words first, with a unit on every box. Then put a number or a letter under each box. Only then write the equation out on one line.

The units are your check on the model. If the boxes read dollars equals dollars plus dollars, the model is sound before you have chosen a single symbol, and if they do not, no amount of correct algebra afterwards will fix it.

The other reason to write the words first is that it decides what your letter means. Half the wrong answers to word problems are correct answers to a slightly different question, because the letter quietly changed meaning halfway through.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 19 — Example 2, the verbal model

58. Reading the waiter's equation piece by piece

Notation

Here is the equation that those boxes produce. Before solving it, make sure you can point at each piece and say out loud what it is and what units it carries.

Annotate

On: \( 105 = 30 + 0.15x \)

  • What the waiter actually took home, in dollars. It is a total, which is why it sits alone on one side.
  • The wages, in dollars. A fixed amount that arrives whether anybody eats anything or not, so it is added, not multiplied.
  • Fifteen percent written as a decimal. It has no units: it is dollars of tip per dollar of food bill, so the dollars cancel.
  • The unknown you were asked for: the food bills in dollars. Multiplying it by 0.15 turns food bills into tips, and that product is dollars again.

Every term on the right is in dollars, and so is the left. If a term ever fails that test, the model is wrong and you should go back to the boxes rather than pressing on.

The 30 and the 0.15 look alike on the page and behave completely differently. One is a quantity that is added; the other is a rate that multiplies. Telling those two roles apart is most of what makes a word problem readable.

59. Example 2: the waiter's food bills

Worked example

A waiter earns wages of 30 dollars in a shift plus 15 percent of the customers' food bills in tips, and takes home 105 dollars in total. What did the food bills come to?

Name the unknown with its unit

Why: Choose the quantity the question actually asks for, not an intermediate one like the tips.

\[ x = \text{total food bills, in dollars} \]

Write the verbal model as an equation

Why: Income equals wages plus the tip rate times the food bills; 15 percent is written as the decimal 0.15.

\[ 105 = 30 + 0.15x \]

Turning the percent into a decimal is the step that quietly goes wrong. Fifteen percent is 0.15, not 15 and not 1.5, and each of those mistakes moves your answer by a factor of ten.

Subtract 30 from each side

Why: Subtraction property, clearing the wages away from the tip term.

\[ 75 = 0.15x \]

Divide each side by 0.15

Why: Division property, with a nonzero divisor.

\[ 500 = x \]

Dividing by a decimal smaller than one makes the answer bigger, which is worth expecting. Seventy-five dollars of tips at fifteen cents in the dollar must come from a great deal more than seventy-five dollars of food.

If dividing by 0.15 makes you uncomfortable, multiply the whole equation by 100 first. That turns it into 10500 equals 3000 plus 15x, which is the same clearing move you used on fractions, applied to decimals instead.

Check in the situation, not only in the equation

Why: Fifteen percent of 500 dollars is 75 dollars in tips, and 75 plus the 30 dollars of wages is the 105 dollars the waiter took home.

\[ 30 + 0.15(500) = 30 + 75 = 105 \;\checkmark \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 19 — Example 2

60. Estimate before you solve: the estate agent

Estimation

An estate agent has a base salary of 22 thousand dollars a year and earns 4 percent commission on total sales, and wants to earn 60 thousand dollars in the year.

Guess the size of the answer before you compute it. Estimating first is not a shortcut; it is what catches a decimal point that has moved, which is the characteristic error of percent problems.

Predict first

Roughly how much must the agent sell?

  • About 100 thousand dollars
  • About 400 thousand dollars
  • About 950 thousand dollars
  • About 4 million dollars

Correct: About 950 thousand dollars

Why: The commission has to cover 60 thousand minus 22 thousand, which is 38 thousand. At 4 percent every 100 dollars of sales earns 4 dollars, so the sales must be 25 times the commission, and 25 times 38 thousand is 950 thousand. A rough answer first is exactly what tells you a decimal has slipped.

\[ 60000 = 22000 + 0.04x \;\Longrightarrow\; 38000 = 0.04x \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 950000 \]

The useful move in the estimate is turning 4 percent into a multiplier of 25. Dividing by four hundredths is the same as multiplying by twenty-five, and once you see that, the whole calculation can be done in your head.

Look at the structure of the equation as well as the answer. It is the waiter's equation with different numbers: a fixed amount, plus a rate times an unknown, equalling a total. Recognising a model you have already solved is most of the work.

The largest option is there to punish the commonest slip, which is subtracting the base salary after dividing instead of before. Doing the operations in the wrong order here changes the answer by a factor of more than four.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 19 — Guided Practice 4

61. Exercise 72: ten discs for 199 dollars

Worked example

A friend bought 10 items in all, some compact discs at 15 dollars each and some video discs at 22 dollars each, and spent 199 dollars. How many of each? There are two unknown counts here and you are allowed only one letter.

Name one unknown and write the other in terms of it

Why: The two counts add to 10, so once you know one of them you know the other without a second letter.

\[ c = \text{compact discs}, \quad 10 - c = \text{video discs} \]

That second line is the whole trick of this problem. Whenever two quantities have a known total, name one and subtract to get the other, and the second unknown disappears before it causes trouble.

Write the cost model

Why: Cost equals the price of each kind times how many of that kind, added together.

\[ 15c + 22(10 - c) = 199 \]

Distribute the 22

Why: Distributive property: 22 times 10 is 220 and 22 times minus c is minus 22c.

\[ 15c + 220 - 22c = 199 \]

Combine like terms

Why: 15c minus 22c is minus 7c.

\[ -7c + 220 = 199 \]

Subtract 220 from each side, then divide by minus 7

Why: Subtraction property, then division property.

\[ -7c = -21 \;\Longrightarrow\; c = 3 \]

Answer the question that was asked. Three is the number of compact discs, and the video discs are the other seven, so both numbers belong in your final sentence.

A count has to be a whole number, which gives you a free check on this kind of problem. If c had come out as three and a half, the model or the arithmetic would be wrong, because nobody buys half a disc.

Check against the total, and answer the follow-up

Why: Three compact discs at 15 dollars is 45, seven video discs at 22 dollars is 154, and 45 plus 154 is 199. If the total had been 185 the same equation gives minus 7c equal to minus 35, so 5 of each.

\[ 3(15) + 7(22) = 45 + 154 = 199 \;\checkmark \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 23 — Exercise 72

62. Exercise 51: a perimeter that is an equation

Worked example

Figure (svg): A rectangle with its bottom side labelled 2x plus 3 and its right side labelled x plus 2, with a note that the perimeter is 46.

The picture is what turns a perimeter into an equation: two long sides and two short ones, all four added.

Find x, then the length of each side. The picture is what turns the word perimeter into something you can write down, so read the diagram before you write anything.

Write what perimeter means for this rectangle

Why: Two long sides and two short ones, all added; opposite sides are equal, so each expression is used twice.

\[ 2(2x + 3) + 2(x + 2) = 46 \]

Distribute both multipliers

Why: Distributive property on each bracket.

\[ 4x + 6 + 2x + 4 = 46 \]

Combine like terms

Why: 4x plus 2x is 6x, and 6 plus 4 is 10.

\[ 6x + 10 = 46 \]

Subtract 10 from each side, then divide by 6

Why: Subtraction property, then division property.

\[ 6x = 36 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = 6 \]

Stop and re-read the question here, because this is where marks are lost. It asked for the lengths of the sides, and x is not a side; it is a number that appears inside two expressions for sides.

Turn x back into lengths

Why: Substitute 6 into each expression written on the diagram.

\[ 2x + 3 = 15, \qquad x + 2 = 8 \]

Now sanity-check the shape as well as the arithmetic. Both sides came out positive, which a rectangle requires, and the long side really is longer than the short one, which is how the diagram was drawn.

A geometry problem always gives you this second kind of check for free, and it catches things the algebra cannot. A negative length or a short side longer than the long one means the equation was built wrong, however cleanly it solved.

Check the perimeter

Why: Two sides of 15 and two of 8 give 30 plus 16, which is the 46 the problem stated.

\[ 2(15) + 2(8) = 30 + 16 = 46 \;\checkmark \]

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, p. 22 — Exercise 51, GEOMETRY

63. Two taxi firms, one break-even distance

Real world

This is a both-sides equation in disguise, and spotting the disguise is the point. Each side is one firm's total cost, and solving asks the distance at which the two agree.

Discussion prompt

One firm charges a 5 dollar pickup fee plus 2 dollars a mile. The other charges 3 dollars a mile and no pickup fee. Write and solve the equation for the distance at which the two cost the same, then say in one sentence which firm is cheaper on a short trip and why.

The structure is worth naming because it recurs constantly: a fixed cost plus a rate, against a different fixed cost plus a different rate. Phone plans, gym memberships and printing quotes are all this equation with different numbers.

Notice also what the answer is for. The break-even distance does not tell you which firm to use; it tells you where the answer changes, and you still have to test one side of it to know which way round the comparison goes.

64. Putting it together

Section

Part 7

65. The procedure, in order

Pattern

Here is the whole lesson as one procedure. Work down this list and you never have to decide what to try next, which is the real benefit of having an order rather than a collection of tricks.

Figure (svg): A flow diagram: clear brackets, clear fractions, collect like terms, then a branch. If the variable terms survive, divide and check. If they cancel, read the leftover statement: false gives no solution, true gives all real numbers.

Four moves in this order, and one branch. The branch is the only part that is new in Algebra 2.
  1. Brackets first. Distribute every multiplier across every term inside.
  2. Then fractions or decimals. Multiply each side, all of it, by the least common denominator.
  3. Combine like terms on each side separately.
  4. Collect the variable terms on the side that leaves a positive coefficient, and the numbers on the other.
  5. Divide by the coefficient, then substitute the answer into the ORIGINAL equation.
  6. If the variable cancels, read the leftover number statement: false means no solution, true means all real numbers.

Skipping a step is how most wrong answers begin. Collecting before the brackets are gone leaves terms stranded inside them, and dividing before collecting means dividing a term you are about to move.

The last line is the only part of this that is new to you this year, and it is the one that will appear on a test dressed up as an ordinary question. Expect it rather than being surprised by it.

Steps one and two can be swapped when the fractions are outside the brackets, but brackets first is the safer default, because distributing a fraction over a bracket often creates denominators that the clearing step then has to handle anyway.

Nothing on this list is a trick and none of it needs to be memorised as a sequence of words. Every line is a property of equality plus a reason for doing it now rather than later.

66. Check: naming the property

Check

Name the move, not the operation you can see in the equation. Work out what was added or subtracted to get from one line to the next before you look at the options.

Check your understanding

An equation goes from 15 = 3p − 3 to 18 = 3p. Which property justifies that line?

  • A. Addition property of equality (correct)
  • B. Subtraction property of equality
  • C. Multiplication property of equality
  • D. Distributive property

Answer: A

Why: Three was added to each side: the left went from 15 to 18 and the right lost its minus 3. The property is named after what you did to both sides, which was adding, even though it removed a subtraction from the equation.

Why B tempts people
Subtracting 3 would have given 12 on the left and 3p minus 6 on the right, which is not the line shown.
Why C tempts people
Nothing was multiplied here; both sides changed by 3, not by a factor of 3.
Why D tempts people
The distributive property is about multiplying across brackets, and there are no brackets in either line.

If you chose subtraction, you read the minus 3 in the equation rather than the plus 3 that you did to it. That is the single most common slip in this topic, and the fix is to describe the move out loud before naming it.

A reliable script: say what changed on the left, then say what changed on the right, then name the operation that did both. Here the left gained 3 and the right lost its minus 3, and the one operation that explains both is adding 3.

The distributive property is on the list because the word property makes people reach for whichever one they remember best. It is not a property of equality at all; it is a rule about multiplying over an addition, and it can never justify a line that has no brackets in it.

67. Check: brackets on both sides

Check

Distribute on both sides first and only then collect. One of the wrong options is exactly what you get by dropping the brackets instead, so solve it properly rather than recognising a number.

Check your understanding

What is the solution of 3(x + 2) = 5(x + 4)?

  • A. x = −7 (correct)
  • B. x = −1
  • C. x = 7
  • D. x = 11

Answer: A

Why: Distributing gives 3x + 6 = 5x + 20. Subtract 3x to get 6 = 2x + 20, subtract 20 to get minus 14 = 2x, and divide by 2 to get x = minus 7. Substituting back: 3 times minus 5 is minus 15, and 5 times minus 3 is minus 15.

Why B tempts people
Minus 1 is what you get by dropping the brackets instead of distributing: 3x + 2 = 5x + 4. Substituting it gives 3 on the left and 15 on the right.
Why C tempts people
The sign is wrong. Substituting 7 gives 27 on the left and 55 on the right.
Why D tempts people
This is the answer to 3a + 4 = 2a + 15 from an earlier slide, not to this equation.

Every one of the three wrong answers can be eliminated in ten seconds by substituting it, which is worth remembering in an exam when you are not certain of your working. Substituting is slower than solving on an open question and faster than solving on a multiple-choice one.

The answer minus 1 is the important distractor here, because it is not a random wrong number. It is what a real and specific mistake produces: dropping the brackets rather than distributing through them, which is the trap from Part 4.

The answer 11 is a number lifted from an earlier slide in this deck, where it solved a completely different equation. Recognising a number you have seen before is not the same as having solved the problem, and questions are often built to punish exactly that.

68. Check: the variable cancelled

Check

This is the new case from Part 5. Read the leftover statement and decide whether it is true or false, because that is the only thing that matters here.

Check your understanding

Solving an equation leads to the line 8 = 8. What is the solution?

  • A. x = 8
  • B. x = 0
  • C. No solution
  • D. All real numbers (correct)

Answer: D

Why: The variable has cancelled and the statement left behind is true. It stays true whatever x was, so every real number satisfies the original equation, and the two sides were the same expression written two ways.

Why A tempts people
The 8 is a leftover number statement, not a value for x; no x appears in that line at all.
Why B tempts people
Zero is one solution among all of them here, but it is not the answer, because every other number works too.
Why C tempts people
No solution is what a FALSE leftover statement means, such as 8 = 9. This one is true.

The two answers that hand back a value for x are the two ways people try to turn a number statement into a solution. Neither works, because x has genuinely gone from the line, and the question is now how many numbers work rather than which particular one does.

No solution is the wrong answer worth understanding rather than just rejecting. It and all real numbers arrive by the identical route, and the only thing that separates them is whether the number statement you are left holding is true or false.

So build the reflex now: when the variable cancels, do not look for a value, look at the statement. Eight equals eight is true, so every number works; eight equals nine would be false, so none do.

69. Why substitute into the original?

Explain it to yourself

This is the habit that will save you the most marks over the year, so it is worth being able to justify rather than just perform.

Discussion prompt

You have just solved an equation and want to check it. Explain in two sentences why the answer must go into the ORIGINAL equation and not into the line just above your answer.

There is a second reason worth knowing. Checking against the original also catches copying errors, which are surprisingly common and completely invisible to any amount of re-reading your own working. A digit written down wrong on line two looks perfectly correct on line five.

The habit costs about twenty seconds per question and it converts almost every arithmetic slip from a lost mark into a caught one. On a test with ten equations on it, that is the difference between a grade and the grade above it.

Write the check down rather than doing it in your head. Examiners give credit for it, and more importantly, a written check is one you actually finish instead of abandoning halfway when the numbers get awkward.

70. Exit ticket

Exit ticket

Two equations, one of each kind. The first is ordinary and the second is one of the special cases from Part 5, and part of the question is noticing which is which.

\[ \text{(a)}\; 2(b + 3) = 4b - 2 \qquad \text{(b)}\; -2(4 - 3x) + 7 = 6(x + 1) \]

Discussion prompt

Solve (a) line by line, naming the property each time, and check it. Then decide (b) and say which of the three cases it falls into.

If you can do both of these without looking back at the deck, you have the lesson. If (b) made you hesitate, reread the concept slide at the start of Part 5 rather than doing more equations like (a); more practice on the case you already understand will not help.

Write out the property names in (a) even though it slows you down. That is what the homework asks for, and the naming is the part that gets rusty first, because the moves themselves quickly become automatic.

One habit to carry out of here: in (b), the moment both sides showed a coefficient of 6 in front of x, the outcome was decided. Looking at the two coefficients before you finish collecting will often tell you which of the three answers is coming.

McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations §1.3, pp. 22-23 — Exercises 33 and 66

71. What you can do now

Recap

One table for the whole lesson. The middle column is what you do first, and the right column is how you know it worked, which is the half people forget to build a habit around.

situationfirst movewhat tells you it worked
variable on one sideundo the addition, then the coefficientsubstituting gives a true statement
variable on both sidessubtract the smaller variable term from each sidethe coefficient left behind is positive
bracketsdistribute to every term insidethe term count goes up, not down
fractions or decimalsmultiply each side by the least common denominatorno denominators remain anywhere
the variable cancelsread the leftover number statementfalse means none, true means all real numbers

\[ ax + b = cx + d \;\Longrightarrow\; (a - c)x = d - b \]

That single line is the lesson compressed. Whether the coefficient on the left is zero decides which of the three answers you are going to write, and everything else is arithmetic.

Lesson 1.4 keeps every one of these moves and changes only the goal. Instead of a number you will solve for one letter in a formula full of letters, which is the same chain of equivalent equations with nothing left to compute at the end.

OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §2.2 Linear Equations in One Variable §2.2 — the same material in OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry

Sources

  1. McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.3 Solve Linear Equations — Larson, Boswell, Kanold & Stiff, McDougal Littell / Houghton Mifflin, 2007, pp. 18-25
  2. OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §2.2 Linear Equations in One Variable

Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Algebra 2 — $55/session, free consultation.

Book on Wyzant · Text (657) 465-8108