The real number line and its subsets, ordering negatives, the five properties of addition and multiplication, subtraction and division as definitions, and unit analysis as a self-check.
Subject: Algebra 2 · 74 slides · symbolic lesson
Open the interactive version of this deck
Title
Algebra 2 · Chapter 1 — Equations and Inequalities
And there is a short list of moves you are allowed to make on it
Objectives
You have been using every rule in this lesson since middle school. You rearrange sums in your head, you pull a common factor out of a bracket, you turn a subtraction into an addition without thinking about it. What you have not done is name any of it.
From here on that changes. Algebra 2 asks you to justify a step, not just take it, and a step you cannot name is a step you cannot defend when an answer comes out wrong. Naming the moves is also how you find your own mistakes, because a wrong line always turns out to have used something that is not on the list.
The last one carries more weight than it looks. Half the sign errors people make in this course come from treating subtraction as a fifth operation with rules of its own, and the fix is one rewrite you can do on autopilot by the end of the hour.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, pp. 2-9 — the lesson these objectives follow
Warm-up
Start with something you can already do, because the point of this lesson is to name what you do rather than teach you a new skill. Try this before you read on, and pay attention to the moves rather than the answer.
Discussion prompt
Add 17 plus 48 plus 3 in your head. Almost everyone moves the 3 next to the 17 first. Write down the two separate things you just did to the sum, and whether you can name either one.
Notice that you did two different things, not one. Moving the 3 past the 48 is one kind of move, and choosing to add 17 and 3 as a pair before the 48 joins in is another. They feel like a single act of common sense, but they are separate permissions and they have separate names.
Keeping them separate matters more than it sounds. Later in the lesson you will meet a trap in which a reorder is labelled as a regroup, and the only defence is having noticed, here, at the start, that the two are different things.
Section
Part 1
Concept
Start with the object everything else sits on. Every real number is exactly one point on a line, and every point on that line is exactly one real number.
real number line — A line on which numbers increase from left to right, with one point for every real number and one real number for every point.
Figure (svg): A horizontal number line with integer ticks from minus six to six, an arrowhead at each end, a marked point at minus 3.5 and another at 2.5, and the words smaller on the left and larger on the right.
Notice how much the line stores for free. It holds the value of a number, and it also holds how that number compares with every other number at once, because comparing two numbers becomes looking at which one is further left. You get an ordering thrown in with the picture.
It also settles a question people find unsettling: are there gaps? No. Between any two points you can name, however close, there are infinitely many more real numbers. The line is solid, with no holes for a number to fall through, and that is why it can hold fractions and square roots and pi all at once.
Everything in this lesson, and a good deal of the rest of the course, is either a statement about where a number sits on this line or a statement about a move you are allowed to make without leaving it.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 2 — the real number line
Concept
The line splits in two, and one question does the splitting: can this number be written as one integer over another?
rational number — A real number that can be written as a quotient of two integers. As a decimal it either stops or repeats a block forever.
\[ \tfrac34 = 0.75, \qquad -\tfrac13 = -0.333\ldots, \qquad \tfrac{16}{5} = 3.2 \]
Look at what those three have in common. One stops after two digits, one repeats a single digit forever, one stops after one digit. Stopping and repeating are the two ways a rational decimal can behave, and there is no third way, which the next slide shows.
If the answer is no, the number is irrational, and its decimal never stops and never falls into a repeating block. That is a strong claim: it means no amount of computing will ever reveal a pattern, because there is none to find.
irrational number — A real number that cannot be written as a quotient of two integers, and whose decimal neither terminates nor repeats.
\[ \sqrt2 = 1.414213\ldots, \qquad -\sqrt{14} = -3.74165\ldots, \qquad \pi = 3.14159\ldots \]
The word irrational is unfortunate, because it has nothing to do with being unreasonable. It means not a ratio, and a ratio is exactly what a quotient of two integers is. Read the word that way and the definition remembers itself.
One warning for later in the lesson: a radical sign is not a mark of irrationality. The square root of 49 is 7, and 7 is as rational as a number can be. Work the root out first, then classify, and you will not fall for the trap that catches most people here.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 2 — Subsets of the Real Numbers
Intuition
That claim about decimals is not a coincidence, and you can see why with one long division. Divide 3 by 7 and watch the remainders.
\[ 3 \div 7: \quad r = 3, 2, 6, 4, 5, 1, 3, \ldots \]
Every remainder is a whole number from 0 to 6, because a remainder on division by 7 can never be 7 or more. So there are only seven possibilities, and you are generating remainders forever.
Keep dividing and you must eventually reach a remainder you have had before, and the moment you do, the digits that follow are the digits that followed last time. From there the block repeats forever, and it has to.
\[ \tfrac37 = 0.\overline{428571} \]
The block here is six digits long, which is no accident: with a denominator of 7 there are six possible nonzero remainders, so a repeating block can never be longer than six. That gives you a rough prediction of how ugly any fraction's decimal will be before you compute it.
A remainder of 0 is the other ending: the division stops dead and the decimal terminates. So a fraction has exactly two possible fates, and a decimal that does neither, like the digits of pi, cannot have come from a fraction at all. That is not an observation about pi; it is a proof that pi is irrational in outline.
Picture it
The book draws the four families as boxes inside boxes. That picture answers almost every classification question you will be asked, so it is worth more than the four definitions separately.
Figure (svg): Nested boxes: an outer box labelled real numbers holds two boxes side by side, rational numbers and irrational numbers. Inside the rational box sits a box of integers, and inside that a box of whole numbers. Example numbers sit in each region.
Read it inward and every claim holds: a whole number is an integer, an integer is rational, a rational is real. Read it outward and every claim fails: minus 4 is an integer but not a whole number, and three quarters is rational but not an integer.
Look at where the irrational box sits. It is inside the reals, but it does not overlap the rationals at all, because a number cannot be both a quotient of integers and not a quotient of integers. That is the no-third-option claim, drawn.
Two examples in the picture are worth stopping on. Sixteen over four is written as a fraction and yet it lives in the innermost box, because it equals 4. And every integer sits inside the rationals because you may always write it over one. Where a number lives is decided by what it equals, never by how it happens to be written.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 2 — the Subsets of the Real Numbers box
Notation
Written in symbols the whole picture collapses to one line. Take it apart before you use it.
Annotate
On: \( \mathbb{W} \subset \mathbb{Z} \subset \mathbb{Q} \subset \mathbb{R} \)
You will see these four letters on tests and in later chapters without explanation, so it is worth spending a minute on them now rather than guessing later.
The one thing to carry away is that the containment symbol is a one-way street. Reading a chain like this backwards is the single most common misuse of it: the line does not say that every rational is an integer, and it never will.
Worked example
Two numbers, one line. The first move is the one that matters, and it is the move most people skip.
\[ \text{Graph } -\tfrac54 \text{ and } \sqrt3 \text{ on a number line.} \]
Write the fraction as a decimal
Why: A fraction bar is a division sign. You cannot place a point you cannot say out loud as a decimal.
\[ -\tfrac54 = -1.25 \]
That first line is the move most people skip, and skipping it is why fractions get misplaced. You cannot look at five quarters and see where it goes; you can look at 1.25 and see it immediately.
Approximate the square root to the nearest tenth
Why: The square root of three is irrational, so there is no exact decimal to find. One decimal place is all you need to land between two ticks.
\[ \sqrt3 \approx 1.7 \]
Notice the word approximately here and the exact equals sign one line above. The fraction converted exactly; the root did not, and it never will. Writing an equals sign in the second line would be a small lie, and the book is careful about that distinction.
Place minus 1.25 between minus 2 and minus 1
Why: It is one and a quarter units left of zero, so a quarter of the way past the tick at minus one.
\[ -2 < -1.25 < -1 \]
Be careful with the direction here. One and a quarter units to the left of zero means past minus one, not short of it, and a surprising number of answers put minus 1.25 between zero and minus one by moving the wrong way.
Place 1.7 between 1 and 2
Why: Seven tenths of the way from the tick at one to the tick at two.
\[ 1 < 1.7 < 2 \]
Figure (svg): A number line from minus six to six with two marked points: minus 1.25, labelled minus five quarters, sitting between minus two and minus one, and 1.7, labelled the square root of three, sitting between one and two.
On the drawing, both points sit between ticks rather than on them, which is normal: most real numbers do. The ticks are there to measure against, not to land on.
Check by squaring the estimate
Why: Squaring is the way to test a square root without a calculator: 1.7 squared is 2.89, just under three, and 1.8 squared is 3.24, over it. So the root of three really does sit between 1.7 and 1.8, nearer 1.7.
\[ 1.7^2 = 2.89 < 3 < 3.24 = 1.8^2 \]
Get into the habit of that check. Squaring an estimate of a square root is quick, needs no calculator, and tells you not only that the estimate is in range but which end of the range it is nearer, because 2.89 is much closer to 3 than 3.24 is.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 2 — Example 1
Worked example
Convert, then sort, then plot. Doing it in that order means you plot left to right and never have to erase.
\[ \text{Graph } -0.2, \; \tfrac{7}{10}, \; -1, \; \sqrt2, \; -4. \]
Turn every entry into a decimal
Why: The mixed notation is the only thing making this list hard. Seven tenths is 0.7, and the square root of two is about 1.4.
\[ -0.2, \quad 0.7, \quad -1, \quad 1.4, \quad -4 \]
Once everything is a decimal the list is easy, and that is the whole trick. The difficulty in this question was never the placing; it was the five different notations sitting in one line.
Sort the decimals from least to greatest
Why: Sorting on paper is cheaper than sorting on the line, where a mistake costs an eraser.
\[ -4 < -1 < -0.2 < 0.7 < 1.4 \]
Plot the two integers first
Why: Minus four and minus one land exactly on ticks, so they anchor everything else.
\[ -4 \text{ and } -1 \text{ on ticks} \]
Anchoring is worth doing deliberately. Once two exact points are down, every remaining point is judged against something real rather than against your estimate of where the middle of the page is.
Fit the three non-integers between the ticks
Why: Minus 0.2 sits just left of zero, 0.7 most of the way to one, and 1.4 a little under one and a half.
\[ -1 < -0.2 < 0 < 0.7 < 1 < 1.4 < 2 \]
Figure (svg): A number line from minus five to three with five marked points: minus four and minus one on ticks, and minus 0.2, seven tenths and the square root of two between ticks.
Look at how little room minus 0.2 has. It is close enough to zero that a sloppy drawing would put it on the wrong side, and that is exactly the kind of small sign error that costs whole questions later on.
Check the root of two by squaring
Why: 1.4 squared is 1.96 and 1.5 squared is 2.25, so the root of two is between 1.4 and 1.5, and 1.4 is the right tenth. Reading the plotted line left to right gives back the sorted list.
\[ 1.4^2 = 1.96 < 2 < 2.25 = 1.5^2 \]
The second half of that check is the cheaper one and works on every graphing question: read your finished line from left to right and see whether it gives back the sorted list you wrote down. If it does not, one point is in the wrong place and you now know to look for it.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 3 — Guided Practice 1
Sorting
One question decides all ten of these, and it is not whether a radical sign is present. Work out what each number actually is first.
Sort into buckets
Drop each number into the column where it belongs.
Notice that every integer landed on the rational side. That is the nesting picture doing its work: you never have to ask separately whether an integer is rational, because the boxes already answered it.
Three of these are designed to catch you. The root of 49 is a whole number in disguise, 0.333 recurring is one third in disguise, and 22 over 7 is famous as an approximation of pi but is a fraction by construction. Approximating an irrational number does not make you irrational.
Trap
Asked which of these are irrational, a very common answer marks all three:
\[ \sqrt2 \]
\[ \sqrt{49} \]
\[ \sqrt{\tfrac19} \]
Two of the three are wrong, and the reason is that the radical sign was read as a label rather than as an instruction.
Work the root out before you classify it. A radical sign asks a question; it does not answer one.
\[ \sqrt{49} = 7 = \tfrac71 \]
\[ \sqrt{\tfrac19} = \tfrac13 \]
Only the first is irrational. Use the definition every time: can this number be written as one integer over another? The notation it arrived in is not evidence either way.
The same warning runs the other way too. A number written as a fraction is not automatically rational if what is inside is not an integer, so the root of two over two is irrational despite the fraction bar.
Prediction
Both of these numbers are close to minus 3.14, and one of them is rational. Commit to an answer before you look.
Predict first
Which number sits further left on the number line, negative 22 over 7, or negative pi?
Correct: negative 22 over 7
Why: As positives, 22 over 7 is 3.142857 and pi is 3.141592, so 22 over 7 is the larger. Taking opposites reverses the order, so negative 22 over 7 is the smaller and lands further left. They cannot be the same point either, because one is a quotient of integers and the other is not.
\[ \tfrac{22}{7} = 3.142857\ldots > 3.141592\ldots = \pi \;\Longrightarrow\; -\tfrac{22}{7} < -\pi \]
The two numbers agree to three decimal places, which is why 22 over 7 is such a popular approximation, and why the third option is tempting. But agreeing to three places is not being equal, and they cannot be equal for a reason that has nothing to do with digits: one is a quotient of integers and the other is not.
That order reversal in the last line is the whole subject of the next part, so hold on to it. Whenever you take opposites of both sides of an inequality, the inequality turns round, and that single fact explains every difficulty people have with negative numbers.
Section
Part 2
Concept
There is only one comparison rule in this course, and the line is it. Putting numbers in order means reading the line from left to right.
\[ a < b \iff a \text{ lies to the left of } b \]
So why do negatives feel hard? Because taking an opposite folds the line about zero, and folding swaps left and right.
Figure (svg): A number line from minus six to six with dots at minus five, minus two, two and five. Dashed arcs join each number to its opposite across a highlighted vertical line at zero.
On the right of zero, bigger digits mean a bigger number. On the left of zero, bigger digits mean a smaller number, because they mean further from zero in the direction that counts as less. Nothing has changed about the rule; only which way you are walking has changed.
It is worth saying what does not change. The distance from zero, which you will meet again as absolute value in Lesson 1.7, is the same for a number and its opposite. Minus five and five are both five units from zero. What differs is the direction, and direction is what ordering is about.
So when a list of negatives has to be ordered, you have a choice: place them all on a line and read left to right, or sort them by distance from zero and then reverse. The second is faster on paper, and it is the one the next example uses.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 2 — numbers increase from left to right
Worked example
Six states, six all-time record lows in degrees Fahrenheit. Put them in order from lowest to highest.
| state | record low |
|---|---|
| Alaska | −80 |
| Colorado | −61 |
| Florida | −2 |
| Montana | −70 |
| New York | −52 |
| Rhode Island | −23 |
Notice that all six are negative
Why: Every value is below zero, so the whole comparison happens on the left half of the line and every instinct about bigger digits is about to be reversed.
\[ -80, \; -61, \; -2, \; -70, \; -52, \; -23 \]
Order the digits from largest to smallest
Why: Ignore the signs for one line. The larger the digits, the further the number is from zero.
\[ 80 > 70 > 61 > 52 > 23 > 2 \]
Ignoring the signs is allowed here only because every single value is negative. If the list had mixed signs you would have to split it at zero first, which is what the next example does.
Put the minus signs back, which reverses that order
Why: Further from zero on the left means further left, and further left means less.
\[ -80 < -70 < -61 < -52 < -23 < -2 \]
That reversal is the only real content of this example. Compare the two lines: the greater-than signs became less-than signs and nothing else moved. Doing it in two deliberate lines like this, rather than in your head, is how you stop the reversal from being forgotten.
Figure (svg): A vertical number line of degrees Fahrenheit from minus ninety to ten, with six states marked: Alaska at minus eighty at the bottom, then Montana, Colorado, New York, Rhode Island and Florida at minus two nearest zero.
The picture makes the answer obvious in a way the list does not. Alaska's record low is the furthest from zero and sits at the bottom of the scale, and bottom is where lowest belongs.
Check against the picture
Why: Read the scale from the bottom up and you get Alaska, Montana, Colorado, New York, Rhode Island, Florida, the same order the algebra produced. Florida, at minus 2, is the mildest record low and sits nearest zero, which is the sanity check a human would make.
\[ \text{AK} < \text{MT} < \text{CO} < \text{NY} < \text{RI} < \text{FL} \]
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 3 — Example 2
Worked example
Now the list mixes negatives, a decimal, a fraction-free positive and an irrational number. Deal with the irrational one first, because it is the only entry you cannot read off directly.
\[ \text{Put in increasing order: } -0.5, \; 1.5, \; -2, \; -0.75, \; \sqrt7. \]
Trap the square root between two tenths
Why: Two point six squared is 6.76, under seven; two point seven squared is 7.29, over it.
\[ 2.6^2 = 6.76 < 7 < 7.29 = 2.7^2 \]
Squaring both candidates rather than reaching for a calculator is worth doing at least once, because it shows you where the estimate comes from. Seven sits between 6.76 and 7.29, so its root sits between 2.6 and 2.7.
Split the list at zero
Why: Every negative is left of every positive, so the two groups never interleave and you can order them separately.
\[ -0.5, \; -2, \; -0.75 \qquad \text{then} \qquad 1.5, \; \sqrt7 \]
This split is the step that makes mixed lists safe. Once the negatives are in one pile and the positives in another, you can apply the reversal rule to the first pile only, and the second pile behaves exactly as you expect.
Order the three negatives by distance from zero, furthest first
Why: Two is furthest from zero, then 0.75, then 0.5, and that order reverses when the signs go back on.
\[ 2 > 0.75 > 0.5 \;\Longrightarrow\; -2 < -0.75 < -0.5 \]
Order the two positives the ordinary way
Why: Nothing is reversed to the right of zero.
\[ 1.5 < \sqrt7 \]
Join the two runs
Why: Negatives in the order just found, then positives.
\[ -2 < -0.75 < -0.5 < 1.5 < \sqrt7 \]
Nothing has to be re-checked when you join them, because every negative was already known to be left of every positive. The two halves were independent, which is exactly why splitting at zero was worth doing.
Figure (svg): A number line from minus three to three with five marked points: minus two, minus 0.75, minus 0.5, 1.5 and the square root of seven at about 2.65.
Notice how close minus 0.75 and minus 0.5 sit on the drawing, a quarter of a unit apart, while the gap to minus 2 is more than a unit. Ordering is about which side, not about how far, but the picture is a reminder of how little room some of these decisions have.
Check by squaring the midpoint estimate
Why: 2.65 squared is 7.0225, a shade over seven, so the root of seven is a shade under 2.65 and comfortably above 1.5. Only one of the book's four lists has minus 2 leftmost and the root of seven rightmost, which is choice C.
\[ 2.65^2 = 7.0225 > 7 \;\Longrightarrow\; \sqrt7 < 2.65 \]
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 3 — Guided Practice 2
Ranking
These are the lowest points in five states, in feet relative to sea level. Two of them are below it, which is what makes this more than a digit sort.
Put in order
Order the five lowest elevations from least to greatest.
Why: The two negatives come first, and among them the one with the larger digits is the smaller number, so Death Valley at minus 282 is least and Louisiana at minus 8 is next. Then sea level at zero, then the two positives in the ordinary order. Sorting by digits alone would put minus 8 before minus 282, which is the usual mistake.
Figure (svg): A vertical elevation scale in feet from minus three hundred to three hundred with a dashed sea-level line at zero. Kentucky at 257 and Tennessee at 178 sit above it, Alabama sits on it, and Louisiana at minus eight and California at minus 282 sit below it.
Elevations are a good setting for this because the negatives mean something physical. Minus 282 feet is Death Valley, the lowest dry land in North America, and minus 8 feet is a stretch of Louisiana that sits below the sea it is next to.
Ask yourself which of the two you would be standing deeper in, and the ordering answers itself without any rule at all. That instinct is worth keeping, because it catches the digit-sorting error every time.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 6 — Exercise 10, the table of elevations
Trap
Asked for those six record lows from lowest to highest, this answer appears again and again:
\[ -2, \; -23, \; -52 \]
\[ -61, \; -70, \; -80 \]
It is the right list, read backwards.
The digits were sorted correctly and then the minus signs were ignored. Put two of them on a line and the mistake is impossible to keep:
\[ -80 < -2 \]
Eighty is bigger than two, and that is exactly why minus 80 is smaller. If you ever doubt it, ask which temperature you would rather stand in.
The reason this error is so persistent is that the wrong answer contains all the right work. The digits were sorted perfectly; only the last half-second of thought was missing.
So build the reversal into the method rather than relying on remembering it. Write the digit order on one line, then write the signed order underneath it, and let the two lines sit side by side where you can see them disagree.
Real world
Here is the same skill outside the textbook. These are average daytime surface temperatures in degrees Fahrenheit, and seven of the nine are negative.
| planet | temperature |
|---|---|
| Mercury | 725 |
| Venus | 865 |
| Earth | 68 |
| Mars | −24 |
| Jupiter | −160 |
| Saturn | −220 |
| Uranus | −320 |
| Neptune | −330 |
| Pluto | −370 |
Figure (svg): A number line of average daytime surface temperature in degrees Fahrenheit from minus four hundred to nine hundred, with the nine planets marked. Pluto, Neptune and Uranus crowd together at the cold end and Mercury and Venus sit far out at the hot end.
Look at how the picture bunches. Pluto, Neptune and Uranus sit almost on top of one another at the cold end, separated by fifty degrees out of a range of more than twelve hundred, while Mercury and Venus are flung far out to the right.
That bunching is why the numbers are easier to order than the picture: minus 370, minus 330 and minus 320 separate cleanly on paper even when the dots do not separate on a drawing. Use whichever representation makes the decision you actually have to make.
Discussion prompt
List the nine planets from least to greatest temperature, then say what the pattern is between temperature and distance from the sun, and name the one planet that breaks it.
This is the shape of most real data questions: the ordering is easy once you trust the rule, and the interesting part is the outlier. Venus is hotter than a planet closer to the sun, and that single broken pattern is what a scientist would go and investigate.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 8 — Exercise 59
Fill the middle
Two comparisons, both on the left of zero. Decide each by asking which number is further from zero, not which digits are larger.
Fill in the blanks
-4 \; < \; -0.2 \qquad\text<\qquad -\tfrac74 \; ___ \; -\tfrac32
Why: Both signs point the same way. Minus 4 is four units from zero and minus 0.2 is only two tenths, so minus 4 is further left and therefore less. Seven quarters is 1.75 and three halves is 1.5, so minus 1.75 is further from zero than minus 1.5 and is again the smaller.
\[ -\tfrac74 = -1.75, \qquad -\tfrac32 = -1.5 \]
Turning both fractions into decimals before comparing them is the same first move as Example 1. You cannot compare what you cannot place, and quarters against halves is exactly the sort of comparison people get backwards under time pressure.
There is a second route if you prefer fractions: rewrite three halves as six quarters, so the comparison becomes seven quarters against six quarters with a common denominator. Seven quarters is the bigger, so minus seven quarters is the smaller. Same answer, no decimals.
Either route beats guessing from the look of the numerators. Seven is bigger than three, and if you let that decide the question you will get the wrong sign both times.
Section
Part 3
Concept
Before the famous properties, one that is easy to read past. Add or multiply any two real numbers and the answer is another real number.
\[ a + b \in \mathbb{R}, \qquad ab \in \mathbb{R} \]
This is what lets you keep going. The output of one step is always a legal input to the next, so a chain of fifty steps never falls off the edge of the number system you started in.
It is not automatic, either. Stay inside the integers and division breaks it, because 3 divided by 4 is not an integer. That is one reason the rationals had to be invented, and it is the pattern behind every number system you have met.
The whole numbers are not closed under subtraction, since 3 minus 8 escapes them, so the integers were built. The integers are not closed under division, so the rationals were built. The rationals are not closed under taking square roots, since the root of two escapes them, so the reals were built.
You will see the pattern once more in Lesson 4.6, when the reals turn out not to be closed under taking square roots of negatives and the complex numbers arrive. Every new number system in school mathematics exists to close a hole exactly like this one.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 3 — the closure property
Intuition
There are five properties for addition, the same five for multiplication, and one that links them. That is the entire supply of legal rearrangements.
Because the list is short, every wrong answer in algebra can be traced. Somewhere in the chain a step used a move that is not on the list, and finding that step is a finite search.
So the names are not vocabulary for a test. They are the labels you hang on your own work so that you, and anyone marking it, can see that each line follows from the one above.
There is a second reason the list is worth knowing precisely, and it arrives in Chapter 3. Matrices can be multiplied, and matrix multiplication is associative but not commutative, so the order of two factors genuinely matters there.
If you have only ever thought of these rules as obvious facts about numbers, that comes as a shock. If you have thought of them as a list of permissions granted to a particular system, you simply check which permissions the new system grants and carry on.
Concept
The first move: you may swap two numbers past each other in a sum or a product.
\[ a + b = b + a, \qquad ab = ba \]
On the line it is two walks from zero that take the same two steps in a different order.
Figure (svg): Two number lines from zero to twelve. On the top line a hop of seven is followed by a hop of four; on the bottom line a hop of four is followed by a hop of seven. Both finish on eleven.
Both walks cover seven units and four units, so both cover eleven units altogether. The order you take the steps in cannot change how far you have gone, and that is the property in one sentence.
The word commutative comes from commute, to travel back and forth, which is a fair description of what the two numbers do when they swap places. Tying the name to the picture is easier than tying it to the formula.
One thing this property does not say: it never promises that subtraction behaves the same way. Seven minus four is 3 and four minus seven is minus 3, so subtraction is not commutative, and you will see shortly why that is not a gap in the list.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 3 — commutative property
Picture it
Multiplication needs a different picture, because a product is an array rather than a walk.
Figure (svg): Two dot arrays: three rows of five dots on the left and five rows of three dots on the right, with a curved arrow between them. Each array holds fifteen dots.
Three rows of five and five rows of three are the same fifteen dots with your head turned sideways. Nothing is added or removed by the turn, which is why a rectangle has one area however you name its sides, and why three fives must equal five threes.
This is the picture worth keeping, because the walking picture does not transfer. A product is not a journey; it is an array, and the reason the order does not matter is that a quarter turn moves no dots.
It also explains something you may have wondered about in your times tables. You only ever had to learn about half of the grid, because once you know seven eights you know eight sevens for free, and this property is the reason that shortcut is legitimate rather than lucky.
Concept
The second move, and the one most often confused with the first: you may change which pair is combined first.
\[ (a + b) + c = a + (b + c), \qquad (ab)c = a(bc) \]
Figure (svg): A number line from zero to eleven with three hops drawn above it, of lengths two, five and three, landing on ten. A bracket above groups the first two hops and a bracket below groups the last two hops.
Look carefully at what did not change. The three hops are still two, then five, then three, in that order. Only the pause moved. Associativity slides a bracket; it never moves a number past another one, and that distinction is the whole of the trap a few slides from now.
The practical payoff is that with three or more terms you are free to combine whichever pair is easiest first. That is exactly what you did in the warm-up when you reached for the 17 and the 3, and it is why nobody writes brackets in a long sum at all.
Here is the test to use when you cannot tell the two properties apart. Write both sides out and read the numbers left to right, ignoring brackets. If the reading is the same, the move was associative. If the reading changed, a number moved, and the move was commutative.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 3 — associative property
Picture it
Three factors make a box of dots, and a bracket decides which two you count first.
Figure (svg): Two copies of the same array of fifty-four dots, six rows by nine columns. On the left it is boxed into two slabs of three rows by nine columns; on the right it is boxed into nine columns of six dots.
Group the three and the nine first and you are counting two slabs of twenty-seven. Group the two and the three first and you are counting nine columns of six. The dots never moved, so the totals cannot differ.
This is the picture behind a habit you will lean on constantly: choosing the easy pairing. Twenty-seven doubled is easy, and so is nine sixes, but you would not want to be forced into one of them by a bracket somebody else wrote.
Try it with a product where one pairing is obviously kinder, such as twenty-five times thirteen times four. Pair the twenty-five with the four to make a hundred, then multiply by thirteen, and the whole thing is mental arithmetic. That choice is associativity and commutativity working together.
Concept
Each operation has one number that leaves everything alone. For addition it is zero; for multiplication it is one.
\[ a + 0 = a, \quad 0 + a = a, \qquad a \cdot 1 = a, \quad 1 \cdot a = a \]
Figure (svg): Top panel: a number line from minus one to eight with a dot at five and a small loop above it labelled add zero, staying at five. Bottom panel: two bars of the same length, the second labelled multiply by one.
Adding zero is a hop of no length, and multiplying by one is a stretch by no factor. These look too obvious to be worth a name, but they are exactly what you quote when a zero or a one appears in the middle of a chain and you want to delete it.
Notice that each property is written twice, once with the special number in front and once behind. That is not padding: it is saying that these two numbers commute with everything, which is a slightly stronger claim than simply defining them.
You will use the multiplicative identity in a disguised form all year. Multiplying by one is how you find a common denominator, how you rationalise a denominator, and, later in this very lesson, how every unit conversion works. Each conversion factor is just a complicated way of writing one.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 3 — identity property
Concept
Every number has a partner that cancels it, and the partner is different for each operation.
\[ a + (-a) = 0, \qquad a \cdot \frac1a = 1 \quad (a \ne 0) \]
opposite — The additive inverse of b, written minus b. If b is positive then minus b is negative, and if b is negative then minus b is positive.
Figure (svg): A number line from minus six to six with a dot at five, a dot at minus five and a dot at zero. An arrow runs from five leftward to zero, labelled add minus five.
The opposite of five is the hop that exactly undoes a hop of five, so the two together land you back on zero. Undoing is the whole idea: an inverse is whatever returns you to the identity.
Notice the one exception, written into the multiplication half as a condition. Zero has no reciprocal, because no number multiplied by zero can give one, and that single fact is the reason division by zero is undefined rather than merely awkward.
Keep that in view, because it is why every division rule you meet this year carries a condition attached. When a question says b is not zero, it is not being fussy; it is making sure the reciprocal you are about to use actually exists.
reciprocal — The multiplicative inverse of a nonzero number b, written one over b: the number that multiplies b to give one.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 3 — inverse property
Picture it
A reciprocal sounds abstract until you cut something up.
Figure (svg): A bar labelled one whole above a second bar of the same length cut into thirteen equal cells, the first cell labelled one thirteenth.
One thirteenth is the piece you need thirteen of. So thirteen of them rebuild the whole, and thirteen times one thirteenth is one, with no calculation needed. Every reciprocal works like this, which is why the definition is a fact about pieces rather than a rule to memorise.
The picture also makes the zero exception obvious. Ask how many pieces you get by cutting the bar into zero equal parts, and the question falls apart, which is exactly what happens to the arithmetic.
And it tells you what a reciprocal of a fraction has to be. If two thirds is two of the three pieces, the number that multiplies it to one must be three halves, because you need one and a half of them. Turning a fraction upside down is not a trick; it is what the picture forces.
Concept
Everything so far has kept addition and multiplication apart. One property joins them, and it is the one you will use most often for the rest of the course.
\[ a(b + c) = ab + ac \]
Figure (svg): A rectangle four units tall and eight units wide, ruled into unit squares and cut by a vertical line into a four by five piece of area twenty and a four by three piece of area twelve.
A rectangle four tall and eight wide has area 32. Cut it into a four by five piece and a four by three piece and the areas are 20 and 12, which still total 32. Nothing was added or removed; only the bookkeeping changed.
Read the line right to left and you have factoring: the same property, used to pull a common factor back out. Every factorisation you do in Chapter 4, and every time you collect like terms, is this one line read backwards.
It is also the property that fails most often when people rush. The factor outside has to reach every term inside, so 4 times the quantity 5 plus 3 is 20 plus 12, not 20 plus 3. Count the terms inside the bracket and make sure you have written that many products.
One more warning the picture makes clear. The property distributes multiplication over addition, and nothing else. There is no rule turning 4 times the quantity 5 times 3 into 20 times 12, and if you try it on the rectangle you will find you have no picture to draw.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 3 — distributive property
Notation
Four separate claims are packed into eight symbols. Work through them one at a time.
Annotate
On: \( a(b + c) = ab + ac \)
Work through the annotations in order and notice that only the first two are about reading the line. The third is about the order of operations, and the fourth is about which direction you are travelling in, which is the part that decides whether you call the move expanding or factoring.
If you only keep one of the four, keep the first. Not reaching the second term inside the bracket is the mistake that costs the most marks in this entire course, and it costs them quietly, because the answer still looks like an answer.
Worked example
Two statements. Say which property each one illustrates, and notice how you decide: by asking what changed between the two sides.
\[ \text{(a) } 7 + 4 = 4 + 7 \qquad \text{(b) } 13 \cdot \tfrac{1}{13} = 1 \]
Look at what changed in (a)
Why: The same two numbers, in the other order, with the operation unchanged. No bracket appears anywhere, so nothing was regrouped.
\[ 7 + 4 \;\longrightarrow\; 4 + 7 \]
Name it
Why: Order changed, under addition.
\[ \text{commutative property of addition} \]
Naming a property is a two-part job, and people usually do only the second part. First decide what changed, then decide which operation it changed under, because every property on the list comes in an addition version and a multiplication version.
Look at what appears in (b)
Why: A number multiplied by one over itself, and the answer is one, the multiplicative identity.
\[ 13 \cdot \tfrac{1}{13} = \tfrac{13}{13} = 1 \]
Part (b) is the one that catches people, because the answer is 1 and the identity property is the one with the 1 in it. But the identity property is about multiplying by one, and here one is the result, not the factor. Inverse produces the identity; it is not the identity.
Name it
Why: A number times its reciprocal gives one, which is the inverse property, not the identity property. The identity property would be 13 times 1.
\[ \text{inverse property of multiplication} \]
Check by trying the names the other way round
Why: Commutative applied to (b) would give one thirteenth times 13, a different statement; inverse applied to (a) would give 7 plus minus 7 equals 0, which is not what (a) says. Neither name fits the other statement, so the pairing is forced.
\[ \tfrac{1}{13}\cdot 13 = 1, \qquad 7 + (-7) = 0 \]
That is a check worth learning, because naming questions have no arithmetic to verify. Write down what the wrong name would have predicted, and see that it predicts a different line. If both names predict the same line, you have not understood the difference yet.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 4 — Example 3
Worked example
Four statements from the book. For each one, find the single thing that changed between the two sides, then read the name off.
\[ \text{(3) } (2\cdot 3)\cdot 9 = 2\cdot(3\cdot 9) \qquad \text{(4) } 15 + 0 = 15 \]
\[ \text{(5) } 4(5 + (-5)) = 4(5) + 4(-5) \qquad \text{(6) } 1 \cdot 500 = 500 \]
Item 3: the bracket moved, the order did not
Why: Same three factors, same left-to-right order, grouped differently.
\[ \text{associative property of multiplication} \]
Item 4: a zero was added and nothing changed
Why: Zero is the additive identity.
\[ \text{identity property of addition} \]
Item 3 is worth a second look. Both sides read two, three, nine from left to right, so no number moved; only the bracket did. That is the left-to-right reading test from the associative slide, applied in one glance.
Item 5: the outside factor reached both terms
Why: One factor multiplying a sum became two products added, which is the only property that mixes the operations.
\[ \text{distributive property} \]
Item 5 is the only one of the four that involves both addition and multiplication, and that alone identifies it. If a statement has a plus sign and a times sign in the same line, distributive is almost always the answer.
Item 6: a one was multiplied and nothing changed
Why: One is the multiplicative identity. Compare item 4 and see that the two identities are the same idea with different numbers.
\[ \text{identity property of multiplication} \]
Check item 5 by working out both sides
Why: The left side is 4 times 0, which is 0. The right side is 20 plus minus 20, which is also 0. Equal, exactly as the property promises, and a property that ever failed a numerical test would not be a property.
\[ 4(5 + (-5)) = 4(0) = 0, \qquad 4(5) + 4(-5) = 20 - 20 = 0 \]
Notice how odd that check looks: both sides came out as zero, so the statement is true but uninformative as a numerical test. The book chose 5 and minus 5 deliberately, to show the distributive property surviving a case where the bracket collapses.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 4 — Guided Practice 3 to 6
Matching
Five statements from the exercise set, five names. For each one ask what changed, and let the answer choose the name.
Match the pairs
Why: The first only moves a bracket, so it is associative. The second multiplies by one and changes nothing, so it is the multiplicative identity. The third swaps two factors, so it is commutative. The fourth adds an opposite and reaches zero, so it is the additive inverse. The fifth sends a factor into a bracket, which only the distributive property does.
Work through them by elimination rather than by recognition. Does the line mix addition and multiplication? Then it is distributive. Does it contain a zero or a one that is doing nothing? Then it is an identity. Does a pair collapse to zero or one? Then it is an inverse.
What is left after those three questions is either commutative or associative, and the bracket decides between them. Four quick questions settle every naming problem in the exercise set, and they settle it in the same order every time.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 6 — Exercises 11 to 16
Sorting
These two properties get mixed up more than any other pair. The test is mechanical: did a number move past another number, or did a bracket move?
Sort into buckets
Sort each statement by which of the two things changed.
If a statement has no brackets on either side, associativity cannot be the answer. That single observation settles half of these in one glance, before you have looked at the numbers at all.
The last two items use letters rather than numbers, and nothing about the decision changes. These properties hold for every real number, so they hold for x and y whatever those turn out to be, which is precisely what makes them useful in algebra rather than only in arithmetic.
Items b, d and f each commute more than one pair, so you would quote the commutative property twice in a written justification. There is no rule against using a property more than once; there is only a rule against using one you have not got.
Trap
A justification written on homework every week:
\[ a + [2 + (-a)] \]
\[ = a + [(-a) + 2] \]
labelled the associative property.
Nothing was regrouped. The bracket sits around the same two slots on both lines; what changed is which number is written first inside it.
\[ \text{a number moved: commutative} \]
\[ \text{a bracket moved: associative} \]
This exact step is line two of Example 4 later in this deck, and the book calls it commutative. Check the brackets before you write a name.
Read the two lines again and trace the bracket with a finger. It opens immediately after the first plus sign on both lines and closes at the end on both lines. It has not moved a millimetre.
What did move is the minus a, from the right of the 2 to the left of it. A number changed places, and a number changing places is commutative every time, whatever else is going on around it.
Counterexample
Exercise 51 asks whether subtraction is associative. It looks as if it should be, since it looks so much like addition.
Discussion prompt
Find one set of numbers showing that a minus b, all minus c, is not the same as a minus the quantity b minus c. Then say in one sentence what makes addition different.
Notice what kind of work a counterexample does. To prove a general statement you would have to argue about every possible a, b and c; to destroy one you need a single set of numbers, and you are finished in two lines.
So when a question asks whether something is always, sometimes or never true, try two or three sets of numbers first. If one of them breaks the claim you are done, and if none of them does you have at least learned what you are trying to prove.
Keep 10, 4 and 3 in your pocket. Small whole numbers with distinct values break most false claims, and using 1 or 0 often hides the failure because those numbers behave too well.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 7 — Exercise 51
Comparison
The five properties come in matched pairs, one for each operation. Filling this table is a faster way to remember them than learning ten separate sentences.
Comparison matrix
| question | for addition | for multiplication |
|---|---|---|
| Which number changes nothing? | 0 | 1 |
| What undoes 8? | -8 | 1/8 |
| Combining 8 with its undoer gives | 0 | 1 |
| The name for 8's undoer | opposite | reciprocal |
Read the table down each column and you have the identity and inverse properties for one operation. Read it across each row and you have the parallel between the two operations, which is the thing actually worth remembering.
The bottom row is worth reading twice, because those two words, opposite and reciprocal, are what the whole next part of the lesson is built from. Each one is simply the name for what undoes a number under its own operation.
If a row ever gives you trouble, rebuild it from the top. Ask what changes nothing, then ask what would have to combine with 8 to get back to that, and the rest of the column follows without being memorised.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 3 — Properties of Addition and Multiplication
Section
Part 4
Concept
Look back at the properties box and notice what is missing. It covers addition and multiplication and stops. That is not an oversight.
\[ a - b = a + (-b) \]
\[ a \div b = a \cdot \frac1b, \qquad b \ne 0 \]
Subtraction is not a third operation; it is addition of the opposite. Division is not a fourth; it is multiplication by the reciprocal. So the list of five properties really does cover everything, and the price you pay is one rewrite.
This matters because there is no commutative property of subtraction to quote. Trade the subtraction for an addition and you may quote the addition one, which is what every justified chain in this lesson does on its first line.
It also explains why the properties box looked incomplete. It is not describing four operations badly; it is describing two operations completely, and trusting you to translate the other two before you arrive.
There is a practical payoff beyond justification. Once every subtraction is an addition, a long expression becomes a sum of signed terms, and you may shuffle those terms into any order you like. That single habit removes most sign errors from Chapters 1 to 5.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 4 — Defining Subtraction and Division
Picture it
One arrow on the line, two ways to write it.
Figure (svg): A number line from minus five to ten with a dot at seven and a dot at three, and an arrow running four units left from seven to three.
Going four units left from seven is what the symbols seven minus four mean, and it is exactly what seven plus negative four means too. There is no second arrow hiding anywhere, so the rewrite costs you nothing and buys you the five addition properties.
Watch what the picture does to a hard case. Seven minus negative four asks you to add the opposite of minus four, and the opposite of minus four is four, so the arrow points right and you land on eleven. Subtracting a negative adds, and now you can see why rather than having to remember it.
The rule people memorise as two minuses make a plus is this and nothing more. It is not a fact about signs bumping into each other; it is the definition of subtraction plus the fact that the opposite of the opposite is the original number.
Picture it
The same trick for the other pair, drawn with squares instead of arrows.
Figure (svg): A row of twelve unit squares with brackets underneath marking three groups of four. The first group is highlighted and labelled one third of twelve.
Splitting twelve squares into three equal groups leaves four in each group. Taking one third of the twelve squares also leaves four. Those are two descriptions of one picture, so division can always be traded for a multiplication, which is what the reciprocal is for.
This picture is also where dividing by a fraction stops being mysterious. Dividing by one half means multiplying by two, and on the picture that is asking how many half-squares fit into twelve, which is twenty-four. Dividing by something smaller than one makes the answer bigger, and the squares show why.
Keep the phrase multiplying by the reciprocal rather than the rule about flipping and multiplying. They give the same answers, but only the first one tells you what you are allowed to do next, which is what a justification needs.
Notation
Two minus signs appear in this line and they are not the same kind of thing. Confusing them is the source of most sign errors in algebra.
Annotate
On: \( a - b = a + (-b) \)
Test yourself on a line with three of them: eight minus five minus two. The first two minus signs are operations and there is no unary one at all, so rewriting gives eight plus minus five plus minus two, which is one.
Once you can sort the operation signs from the number signs on sight, most of the sign trouble in this course disappears. Until you can, write the rewrite out in full every time, even when it feels like extra work, because it is the line that keeps the signs attached to the right numbers.
Worked example
This is the book's model answer, and the shape it wants from you: a name beside every single line. Notice that five different properties are needed for a statement that looks obvious.
\[ \text{Show that } a + (2 - a) = 2. \]
Rewrite the subtraction as an addition
Why: Definition of subtraction. This has to come first: until it is done, the expression contains an operation the properties do not mention.
\[ a + (2 - a) = a + [2 + (-a)] \]
Swap the two numbers inside the bracket
Why: Commutative property of addition. This is what brings minus a next to the a outside.
\[ = a + [(-a) + 2] \]
Those two middle steps are the ones that do the real work, and they have to happen in that order. Commuting brings the a and the minus a next to each other; regrouping is what lets them be added as a pair. Neither one alone would finish the job.
Move the bracket
Why: Associative property of addition. Nothing changes order here; only which pair is added first.
\[ = [a + (-a)] + 2 \]
Add a number to its opposite
Why: Inverse property of addition.
\[ = 0 + 2 \]
Notice that the a has now vanished, which is what the statement promised: whatever a was, the answer is 2. That is the point of proving it in general rather than testing it on a few numbers.
Drop the zero
Why: Identity property of addition, and the line is finished.
\[ = 2 \]
Look at the shape of the whole argument, because you will reproduce it many times. One definition to make the properties legal, then commute, then regroup, then cancel with an inverse, then delete with an identity. Five lines, five names, no arithmetic at all until the very end.
Check with two numbers
Why: A general proof is worth testing on a case. With a equal to 9 the left side is 9 plus the quantity 2 minus 9, which is 9 plus minus 7, so 2. With a equal to minus 3.5 it is minus 3.5 plus 5.5, which is 2 again. The answer does not depend on a, which is what the statement claims.
\[ a = 9: \; 9 + (-7) = 2, \qquad a = -3.5: \; -3.5 + 5.5 = 2 \]
If a chain like this ever stalls, the question to ask is which two things you are trying to get next to each other. Here it was a and its opposite. Once you know the target, commuting and regrouping are just the mechanics of getting there.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 4 — Example 4
Worked example
The same five-step shape, now on the multiplication side. Watch how each property has an exact mirror image in the version you just saw.
\[ \text{Show that } b \cdot (4 \div b) = 4 \text{ when } b \ne 0. \]
Rewrite the division as a multiplication
Why: Definition of division. The reciprocal of b exists precisely because the problem says b is not zero.
\[ b \cdot (4 \div b) = b \cdot \left(4 \cdot \tfrac1b\right) \]
Swap the two factors inside the bracket
Why: Commutative property of multiplication, to bring one over b next to the b outside.
\[ = b \cdot \left(\tfrac1b \cdot 4\right) \]
Put this chain beside Example 4 and read them together. Every line matches: definition, commutative, associative, inverse, identity. Only the operation changed, and with it the special numbers, from zero and opposites to one and reciprocals.
Move the bracket
Why: Associative property of multiplication.
\[ = \left(b \cdot \tfrac1b\right) \cdot 4 \]
Multiply b by its reciprocal
Why: Inverse property of multiplication.
\[ = 1 \cdot 4 \]
That pairing is why the properties are always stated twice. Learn one of these two chains properly and you have learned both, because you can translate line by line from one to the other.
Drop the one
Why: Identity property of multiplication.
\[ = 4 \]
The condition on b is not decoration. If b were zero the second line would contain one over zero, which is not a number, and the chain would collapse at the very first move rather than at the end where you might notice.
Check with two numbers, one of them negative
Why: With b equal to 5, four divided by five is 0.8 and five times 0.8 is 4. With b equal to minus 2, four divided by minus 2 is minus 2, and minus 2 times minus 2 is 4. Both give 4, and trying b equal to 0 would break the second step, which is why the condition is stated.
\[ 5(4 \div 5) = 5(0.8) = 4, \qquad -2(4 \div -2) = (-2)(-2) = 4 \]
Get into the habit of reading such a condition as an instruction about where your proof is valid. It tells you the statement is true for every real number except one, and the exception is exactly the one that breaks a step you actually used.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 4 — Guided Practice 7
Worked example
Here is the payoff. Collecting like terms is something you have done for years by instinct; these are the four properties that make it legal.
\[ \text{Show that } 3x + (6 + 4x) = 7x + 6. \]
Swap the two terms inside the bracket
Why: Commutative property of addition, to bring the two x terms together.
\[ 3x + (6 + 4x) = 3x + (4x + 6) \]
Move the bracket
Why: Associative property of addition, so that the two x terms are the pair added first.
\[ = (3x + 4x) + 6 \]
Pull the x out of the first two terms
Why: Distributive property, read right to left. This is the step that actually does the collecting.
\[ = (3 + 4)x + 6 \]
That is the line that answers a question you may have carried for years: why can you add 3x and 4x but not 3x and 6? Because the distributive property needs a common factor to pull out, and 3x and 6 have no x in common.
Add the coefficients
Why: Ordinary arithmetic, and the reason collecting like terms works at all.
\[ = 7x + 6 \]
Figure (svg): Two rows of algebra tiles. The top row shows three tall x tiles, then six unit squares, then four more x tiles, in the order written. The bottom row shows the same tiles regrouped as seven x tiles followed by six unit squares.
The tiles say it without any algebra. Seven tall tiles and six small squares cannot be merged into a single number, because a tall tile is a different shape from a small square and no rearranging will make them match.
Check with a number
Why: Put x equal to 2. The left side is 6 plus the quantity 6 plus 8, which is 20. The right side is 14 plus 6, which is also 20. The tiles say the same thing: seven x tiles and six unit tiles, however they were shuffled.
\[ x = 2: \; 6 + (6 + 8) = 20, \qquad 7(2) + 6 = 20 \]
Choosing x equal to 2 rather than 1 is deliberate. With x equal to 1 the expression 7x and the expression 7 plus x both come to 8, so a wrong answer would survive the test. Avoid 0 and 1 when you check algebra, for exactly that reason.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 4 — Guided Practice 8
Worked example
This is the exercise that shows why the definitions were worth the trouble. A subtraction sign sits right in the middle of an associativity move, and the counterexample slide already told you that subtraction is not associative.
\[ \text{Show that } (a + b) - c = a + (b - c). \]
Rewrite the subtraction as an addition
Why: Definition of subtraction. Now every operation in the line is an addition.
\[ (a + b) - c = (a + b) + (-c) \]
Move the bracket
Why: Associative property of addition, legal now that the expression is a pure sum.
\[ = a + (b + (-c)) \]
Compare this with the counterexample a few slides back and you can see the exact difference. There the bracket jumped across a subtraction sign that had never been rewritten; here the rewrite came first, so by the time the bracket moved there was nothing but addition for it to move across.
Rewrite the inner sum as a subtraction
Why: Definition of subtraction, read right to left, to get back to the form the question asked for.
\[ = a + (b - c) \]
Using a definition backwards is perfectly legal and worth being comfortable with. An equals sign works in both directions, so any definition you may read left to right you may also read right to left, which here is what returns the answer to the shape the question wanted.
Check with numbers, and against the counterexample
Why: Take a as 10, b as 4, c as 3: the left side is 14 minus 3, which is 11, and the right side is 10 plus 1, which is also 11. Compare the failed statement from earlier: the bracket there moved past a subtraction sign that was never rewritten, and that is the entire difference.
\[ (10 + 4) - 3 = 11, \qquad 10 + (4 - 3) = 11 \]
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 6 — Exercise 20
Error analysis
Here is a single step from a student's homework, labelled commutative property of addition. The label is wrong, and so is the line. Find both faults.
Annotate
On: \( 5 + (3 - 5) = 5 + (5 - 3) \)
\[ 5 + (3 - 5) = 3, \qquad 5 + (5 - 3) = 7 \]
Any step you can catch with a single number was never safe. Substituting one value costs ten seconds and would have stopped this line before it did any damage further down the page.
Notice the shape of the mistake, because it recurs. A property was quoted correctly by name and applied to an expression that did not have the form the property requires. The commutative property is about a sum of two things, and the writer did not check what those two things actually were.
So make a habit of naming the two objects before you swap them. Here they are 3 and minus 5, not 3 and 5, and saying that out loud is enough to make the correct swap obvious.
Fill the middle
This is Guided Practice 8 again with the names stripped out. Fill each one in from the list of six.
Fill in the blanks
Line 1 to line 2, from 3x + (6 + 4x) to 3x + (4x + 6): the commutative property of addition. Line 2 to line 3, to (3x + 4x) + 6: the associative property of addition. Line 3 to line 4, to (3 + 4)x + 6: the distributive property.
Why: The first move writes the same two numbers in the other order inside the bracket, so it is commutative. The second leaves the order alone and slides the bracket, so it is associative. The third pulls a common factor out of two terms, which only the distributive property does, read from right to left.
If you had to guess at the second one, check the brackets rather than the names. A bracket that moved is always associative, and a number that moved is always commutative, and no amount of staring at the names will tell you which happened.
The third blank is the one worth dwelling on, because the distributive property is being used backwards. Read left to right it would turn 7 times a bracket into two products; read right to left, as here, it turns two terms with a shared factor into one product.
Every chain you justify this year will be some arrangement of these three names plus the two definitions. There is no long list waiting for you later, which is why it pays to get these solid now rather than hoping to recognise them under exam pressure.
Step zero
Exercise 18 asks for a justified chain. Do not start naming properties yet.
\[ \text{Show that } 15 \cdot (3 \div b) = 45 \div b. \]
Discussion prompt
What is the one rewrite you must do before any property can be quoted, and why can you not simply start with the associative property instead?
Asking what has to happen before you can start is a habit worth building deliberately. In this lesson it is the rewrite; in later chapters it will be clearing a denominator, or getting an equation to equal zero, or writing a quadratic in standard form.
In every case the reason is the same. A theorem or property has a shape it applies to, and if your expression is not yet in that shape then no amount of correct quoting will help. Step zero is always getting into the shape.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 6 — Exercise 18
Explain it to yourself
Two rearrangements of the same expression. One is fine and one changes the answer, and the difference is entirely about where a minus sign lives.
\[ 7 - 4 = 7 + (-4) = (-4) + 7 = 3 \]
\[ 7 - 4 \;\longrightarrow\; 4 - 7 = -3 \]
Discussion prompt
Explain in two sentences why the first chain is legal and the second is not, using the word opposite.
Write your answer down before reading on, because the difference is easy to nod along to and hard to state precisely, and stating it precisely is the skill being built here.
The two results, 3 and minus 3, are opposites, which is not a coincidence. Reversing a subtraction always gives you the opposite of what you started with, and that is the closest thing subtraction has to a commutative rule.
But notice that it is a different rule with a different conclusion, which is exactly why subtraction is kept off the list of properties rather than given a weaker entry on it. One clean definition beats a pile of special cases.
Section
Part 5
Concept
The last idea in the lesson costs nothing and catches most arithmetic mistakes in word problems. Carry the units through the calculation as though they were algebraic factors.
\[ \frac{36 \text{ dollars}}{4 \text{ hours}} = 9 \frac{\text{dollars}}{\text{hour}} \]
unit analysis — Carrying the units through a calculation as if they were factors, so that cancelling them predicts the unit of the answer before the arithmetic is done.
The dollars stayed upstairs and the hours stayed downstairs, so the answer is dollars per hour. If the unit that survives is not the unit the question asked for, the calculation is wrong, and you know that without checking a single digit.
That is a genuinely unusual kind of check. Most checks tell you whether an answer is right after you have found it; this one tells you whether the plan is right before you have started, which is when the information is worth most.
It works because a unit behaves like a factor under the rules you have just learned. Units multiply, they cancel between top and bottom, and multiplying by a factor equal to one changes nothing. Everything in this part of the lesson is those three facts applied carefully.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 5 — Unit Analysis
Picture it
Long conversions are where this pays. Here is Example 5 part c set out as a product of four fractions.
Figure (svg): Four fractions multiplied in a row: forty-five miles over one hour, one hour over sixty minutes, one minute over sixty seconds, and 5280 feet over one mile. Miles, hours and minutes are struck through where they cancel, leaving feet over seconds.
Every conversion factor is a fraction equal to one, so multiplying by it cannot change the quantity, only the way it is spelled. Line them up so that each unwanted unit appears once above and once below, and it cancels.
Miles, hours and minutes all cancel in pairs here, and feet over seconds is the only thing left standing. That is the answer's unit, decided before any multiplication happens.
Look at why each factor equals one. Sixty minutes really is one hour, so the fraction one hour over sixty minutes is one hour divided by one hour written awkwardly. Multiplying by it is the identity property of multiplication in disguise, which is exactly why the quantity cannot change.
So you are not converting the number at all; you are respelling the same quantity until it is written in the units you were asked for. Forty-five miles per hour and sixty-six feet per second are one speed with two spellings, the way seven minus four and seven plus minus four were one arrow.
Worked example
Two one-step problems. In each, the units decide whether you divide or multiply, so you never have to guess.
\[ \text{(a) You work 4 hours and earn 36 dollars. What is your earning rate?} \]
Write the answer's unit as a fraction, then match it
Why: Dollars per hour means dollars upstairs and hours downstairs, which forces the calculation.
\[ \frac{36 \text{ dollars}}{4 \text{ hours}} \]
Divide the numbers
Why: Thirty-six divided by four.
\[ = 9 \frac{\text{dollars}}{\text{hour}} \]
Notice that you never had to decide whether to divide 36 by 4 or 4 by 36. Writing down the unit you want first made the decision for you, and it will keep doing so on every rate question you meet.
\[ \text{(b) You travel 2.5 hours at 50 miles per hour. How far do you go?} \]
Multiply, so that hours cancels
Why: Hours is upstairs in the time and downstairs in the rate, so it cancels and miles is what survives.
\[ (2.5 \text{ hours})\left(\frac{50 \text{ miles}}{1 \text{ hour}}\right) \]
Multiply the numbers
Why: Two and a half fifties.
\[ = 125 \text{ miles} \]
Both parts came out in one step, which is what makes them worth doing side by side. The same reasoning chose the operation each time, and you were never left guessing which way round the two numbers should go.
Check the surviving unit against the question
Why: Part (a) asked for dollars per hour and dollars per hour survived. Part (b) asked for a distance and miles survived. Had you divided in part (b) instead, the unit would have been hours squared per mile, which is not a distance at all, and the wrong answer would have announced itself.
\[ \frac{2.5 \text{ h}}{50 \text{ mi/h}} = 0.05 \frac{\text{h}^2}{\text{mi}} \]
So the two parts pull in opposite directions on purpose. One is a division and one is a multiplication, and if you tried to learn them as separate recipes you would have two things to remember. Learned through the units, they are one method used twice.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 5 — Example 5a and 5b
Worked example
Now four factors at once. Do not reach for a formula; build the chain by asking, for each unit, which level it needs to be on.
\[ \text{Convert 45 miles per hour into feet per second.} \]
List what must leave and what must arrive
Why: Miles has to go and feet has to arrive; hours has to go and seconds has to arrive. That is two conversions, and the book routes through minutes.
\[ \frac{\text{mi}}{\text{h}} \;\longrightarrow\; \frac{\text{ft}}{\text{s}} \]
Write each factor so the unwanted unit lands on the other level
Why: Hours is downstairs in the rate, so put hours upstairs in the next factor. Miles is upstairs, so put miles downstairs in the last one.
\[ \left(\frac{45\text{ mi}}{1\text{ h}}\right)\left(\frac{1\text{ h}}{60\text{ min}}\right)\left(\frac{1\text{ min}}{60\text{ s}}\right)\left(\frac{5280\text{ ft}}{1\text{ mi}}\right) \]
Build the chain one factor at a time and let each new factor be chosen by the unit you are currently stuck with. That way you never have to picture the whole calculation at once, which is what makes four-factor conversions feel impossible.
Cancel every unit that appears top and bottom
Why: Miles, hours and minutes each cancel once, and feet over seconds is left.
\[ = \frac{45 \cdot 5280}{60 \cdot 60}\cdot\frac{\text{ft}}{\text{s}} \]
The order of the four factors makes no difference at all, and that is the commutative and associative properties of multiplication at work. Write them in whatever order helps you see the cancellations; the product is the same.
Do the arithmetic
Why: Forty-five times 5280 is 237600, and 60 times 60 is 3600.
\[ \frac{237\,600}{3600} = 66 \]
State the answer with the unit that survived
Why: Feet per second, which is what was asked for.
\[ 45 \frac{\text{mi}}{\text{h}} = 66 \frac{\text{ft}}{\text{s}} \]
Sixty-six feet per second is worth a moment of judgement. Forty-five miles per hour is ordinary road speed, and sixty-six feet is about the length of two buses, covered every second. If the answer had come out as 6 or 600 you would have known at once that something was wrong.
Check by converting back
Why: Sixty-six feet per second times 3600 seconds per hour is 237600 feet in an hour, and dividing by 5280 feet per mile gives 45 miles per hour again. A conversion you can reverse is a conversion you got right.
\[ \frac{66 \cdot 3600}{5280} = 45 \]
Keep one of these conversions in your head as a benchmark. Sixty miles per hour is 88 feet per second, so any road speed in feet per second should be roughly one and a half times the number of miles per hour, which is a check you can do instantly.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 5 — Example 5c
Prediction
This is the only real decision in a conversion, and unit analysis makes it for you. Decide before reading on.
Predict first
You need to turn 253 kilometres into miles, and one mile is about 1.61 kilometres. Which factor do you multiply by?
Correct: 1 mile over 1.61 kilometres
Why: Kilometres starts upstairs, in the 253, so it has to appear downstairs in the factor if it is going to cancel, and that leaves miles upstairs. The first option would give kilometres squared over miles, which is not a distance. The last two state something false, since one mile is not 1.61 miles and one kilometre is not 1.61 miles.
\[ 253 \text{ km} \cdot \frac{1 \text{ mi}}{1.61 \text{ km}} \approx 157 \text{ mi} \]
There is a second check that needs no algebra: a mile is longer than a kilometre, so the number of miles must come out smaller. It did, from 253 down to 157.
Those two checks are worth having both, because they catch different errors. The unit check catches a factor written the wrong way up; the size check catches a factor that was the right way up but the wrong number, such as using 1.61 when you meant 0.62.
If you are ever unsure which way up a factor goes and cannot remember the size relationship either, write the conversion as a sentence first. One mile equals 1.61 kilometres becomes a fraction with those two quantities, and the only decision left is which of them goes on the bottom.
Worked example
Two legs of one road trip, quoted in two countries' units. The same conversion factor is used both ways up.
\[ \text{(a) 132 miles into kilometres} \qquad \text{(b) 253 kilometres into miles} \]
Choose the factor that cancels miles in part (a)
Why: Miles is upstairs in the 132, so miles goes downstairs in the factor.
\[ 132 \text{ mi} \cdot \frac{1.61 \text{ km}}{1 \text{ mi}} \]
Multiply
Why: 132 times 1.61 is 212.52, which the book rounds to 213.
\[ = 212.52 \approx 213 \text{ km} \]
Rounding 212.52 to 213 is the book's choice, and it is a reasonable one, because 1.61 is itself only an approximation of the real conversion factor. Carrying five decimal places forward from an approximate input would claim an accuracy the input never had.
Choose the factor that cancels kilometres in part (b)
Why: Now kilometres is upstairs, so this time kilometres goes downstairs and the same factor is turned over.
\[ 253 \text{ km} \cdot \frac{1 \text{ mi}}{1.61 \text{ km}} \]
Notice that the same physical fact produced two different-looking factors. There is only one conversion to know, and turning it over costs nothing, which is why you never have to memorise both directions.
Divide
Why: 253 divided by 1.61 is 157.14, which rounds to 157.
\[ = 157.14 \approx 157 \text{ mi} \]
Check that the two answers moved in opposite directions
Why: A kilometre is shorter than a mile, so any distance has more kilometres than miles: 132 miles grew to 213, and 253 kilometres shrank to 157. Converting 213 back gives 132.3 miles, the distance you started from.
\[ \frac{213}{1.61} = 132.3 \approx 132 \]
The round trip is the strongest check available on any conversion, and it costs one extra division. Converting 213 back gave 132.3 rather than exactly 132, and that small drift is the rounding you did on purpose, not an error.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 5 — Example 6
Error analysis
This is Exercise 39, an error-analysis question. The exchange rate quoted is 0.82 euro to the dollar, and you do not need to know whether that is right to see what went wrong.
Annotate
On: \( 25 \text{ dollars} \cdot \frac{1 \text{ dollar}}{0.82 \text{ euro}} \approx 30.5 \text{ euro} \)
\[ 25 \text{ dollars} \cdot \frac{0.82 \text{ euro}}{1 \text{ dollar}} = 20.5 \text{ euro} \]
Read the corrected line and the broken one side by side. The numbers 25 and 0.82 appear in both, and the only difference is which level the 0.82 sits on, yet one answer is money and the other is not a quantity at all.
That is why writing the units out in full is worth the extra seconds. Nobody spots an upside-down factor by looking at the digits, and everybody spots it by looking at whether the word dollars appears twice on the same level.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 7 — Exercise 39
Worked example
Four factors again, and an answer large enough that you will want the size check at the end.
\[ \text{Convert 16 years to seconds, using 365 days in a year.} \]
Chain the factors so each unit cancels once
Why: Years against years, days against days, hours against hours, minutes against minutes, and seconds is the survivor.
\[ 16\text{ y}\cdot\frac{365\text{ d}}{1\text{ y}}\cdot\frac{24\text{ h}}{1\text{ d}}\cdot\frac{60\text{ min}}{1\text{ h}}\cdot\frac{60\text{ s}}{1\text{ min}} \]
Multiply the years by the days
Why: Sixteen times 365.
\[ 16 \cdot 365 = 5840 \text{ days} \]
Write the whole chain down before multiplying anything. If you convert one step at a time you have to remember where you are, and it is easy to stop a factor early and hand in an answer in minutes.
Multiply by the hours in a day
Why: 5840 times 24.
\[ 5840 \cdot 24 = 140\,160 \text{ hours} \]
Multiply by the minutes in an hour
Why: 140160 times 60.
\[ 140\,160 \cdot 60 = 8\,409\,600 \text{ minutes} \]
Multiply by the seconds in a minute
Why: 8409600 times 60.
\[ 8\,409\,600 \cdot 60 = 504\,576\,000 \text{ seconds} \]
The question says to use 365 days, which quietly ignores leap years. Over sixteen years that is four extra days, about 345600 seconds, so the true figure is nearer 504.9 million. The instruction is there so that everyone gets the same answer, not because leap years do not exist.
Check the size of the answer
Why: One year is about 31.5 million seconds, a number worth remembering, so sixteen years should be about 500 million. Dividing the answer by 16 gives 31536000, which is that figure, so the answer is the right order of magnitude.
\[ \frac{504\,576\,000}{16} = 31\,536\,000 \]
Five hundred million is a number nobody has intuition about, which is why the size check at the end matters more here than on any other conversion in the lesson. Without it, an answer a hundred times too big would look exactly as plausible as the right one.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 5 — Guided Practice 14
Estimation
Estimating first is what stops a conversion error from getting past you. Commit to one of these before computing.
Predict first
A rocket sled covers 3 miles in 6 seconds. Roughly what is its average speed in miles per hour?
Correct: About 1800 miles per hour
Why: Half a mile every second, and an hour holds 3600 seconds, so an hour covers half of 3600, which is 1800 miles. The usual slip is to convert only once, by 60 instead of 3600, which gives 30 and then feels far too slow for a rocket sled.
\[ \frac{3 \text{ mi}}{6 \text{ s}} \cdot \frac{3600 \text{ s}}{1 \text{ h}} = 1800 \frac{\text{mi}}{\text{h}} \]
Seconds cancelled and miles per hour survived, and 1800 is about two and a half times the speed of sound, which is the right sort of number for this machine.
Estimating first is not a substitute for the calculation; it is a net underneath it. You are not trying to get 1800 in your head, only to know that the answer belongs in the thousands, so that a result of 30 would set off an alarm.
The wrong options here are all real errors rather than random numbers. About 180 is what you get by converting once too few, and about 18000 is what you get by converting once too many, which is exactly what happens when you chain factors without watching the units.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 7 — Exercise 47
Elimination
Three of these four are wrong, and in every case you can see it from the units alone.
Eliminate the wrong options
Which of these correctly converts 6 feet per second into miles per hour?
Survives elimination: A
Why: Feet must leave from upstairs and miles arrive there, so miles over feet is the right factor. Seconds must leave from downstairs and hours arrive there, so seconds over hours is the right factor. The result is 6 times 3600 over 5280, which is about 4.09 miles per hour, a brisk walking pace, and that is believable for 6 feet per second.
\[ \frac{6 \cdot 3600}{5280} \approx 4.09 \frac{\text{mi}}{\text{h}} \]
Work through the three wrong ones and name the fault rather than just rejecting them. Two put a unit on the wrong level, and one writes the original rate upside down, which is the fault that is hardest to see because it happens before any conversion starts.
Reading the rate correctly is genuinely a separate skill. Per means divided by, so feet per second is feet on top, and a rate you transcribe upside down will produce a beautifully cancelled chain leading to a completely wrong answer.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 7 — Exercise 42
Real world
The largest mammal and the smallest, quoted in units that cannot be compared as they stand. Unit analysis is what makes the comparison possible at all.
Discussion prompt
The blue whale averages 120 tons and the bumblebee bat averages 0.07 ounce. Convert both to pounds, then say roughly how many bats balance one whale. Then name a second method that never converts to pounds.
The reason a comparison needs a shared unit is the same reason you cannot add 3x and 6. Tons and ounces are different things, and dividing one by the other would leave a number carrying tons per ounce, which is not an answer to how many times as heavy.
Fifty-five million is a figure worth sitting with. If you lined the bats up nose to tail they would stretch most of the way round the world, and they would weigh what one whale weighs. That is what the range of mammal sizes actually looks like.
The last part of the question is the important one for your own work. Noticing that ounces would have done just as well as pounds is the difference between following a recipe and understanding why it works.
McDougal Littell Algebra 2 (Texas Edition), Ch. 1 Equations and Inequalities — Lesson 1.1 Apply Properties of Real Numbers §1.1, p. 8 — Exercise 60
Section
Part 6
Pattern
Every justified step answers one question: what changed between this line and the one above it? There are only five answers, so the search is short.
Figure (svg): A flow diagram. One box asks what changed between the two lines, and five arrows lead to five descriptions, each pointing to the property that licenses it: commutative, associative, distributive, identity and inverse.
Run the questions in that order and you will rarely be stuck for long. The first one is the one people skip, and skipping it is what produces justifications naming properties that do not apply to the line in front of them.
The diagram is worth redrawing from memory once. Five branches, five names, and a note at the bottom about the rewrite, which is small enough to hold in your head and complete enough to justify anything in this chapter.
Check
The first of three. Answer before revealing, and if two options look equally good, work out what each number actually equals before you decide anything about which box it lives in.
Check your understanding
Which of these numbers is an integer but not a whole number?
Answer: B
Why: Minus 27 is an integer, because the integers include the negatives, but it is not a whole number, because the whole numbers are zero and the counting numbers only. It is also rational and real, since the boxes nest.
Three of the four options are whole numbers, and two of them are disguised as something else. That is the point of the question: where a number lives is decided by its value, never by the notation it happened to arrive in.
If you find this kind of question slow, redraw the nested boxes on scrap paper and put each option into the innermost box it fits. The answer is then whichever one landed in the integers but not in the whole numbers.
Check
The second of three. Before looking at the options, say out loud what changed between the two expressions, and only then read the names.
Check your understanding
Which property justifies going from 3 plus the quantity 7 plus x, to the quantity 3 plus 7, plus x?
Answer: B
Why: The three terms are in exactly the same left-to-right order on both sides, 3 then 7 then x, and the only difference is where the bracket sits. A bracket that moved is always associative.
Apply the reading test rather than your memory of the names. Both sides read 3, then 7, then x, so nothing moved past anything, and a line where only the bracket shifted is associative every single time.
If you chose the first option, you are in good company, because commutative and associative are the pair that get confused. The habit that fixes it is checking the brackets before you check the names, and it fixes it permanently.
Check
The last of three. Decide the surviving unit first, then decide the arithmetic, exactly as in every conversion in Part 5.
Check your understanding
You drive 50 kilometres per hour. Which calculation gives your speed in miles per hour, given that one mile is about 1.61 kilometres?
Answer: B
Why: Kilometres has to cancel from upstairs, so the factor is one mile over 1.61 kilometres, and multiplying by that is dividing by 1.61. The answer is about 31.1 miles per hour, which must be smaller than 50 because a mile is longer than a kilometre.
Two separate checks both point at the same answer here. Kilometres must cancel from upstairs, which forces the factor one mile over 1.61 kilometres, and a mile is longer than a kilometre, which forces the answer to be smaller than 50.
Notice how little arithmetic the question needs. You are choosing a setup, not computing a result, and every wrong option can be eliminated by looking at the units or at the direction of the change.
Explain it to yourself
The properties box lists five properties for addition and five for multiplication, and says nothing at all about subtraction or division.
\[ a - b = a + (-b), \qquad a \div b = a \cdot \tfrac1b \]
Discussion prompt
Explain in three sentences why that is not a gap, and say what you have to do to an expression before those properties can be used on it.
Write the answer out in full sentences rather than thinking it through. Being able to say why the list is complete is a different skill from being able to use the list, and it is the one that survives the summer.
A good answer will mention the words opposite and reciprocal, because those two objects are what make the reduction possible. Without them there would be nothing for subtraction and division to be shorthand for.
If your answer instead says that subtraction has its own properties which nobody bothered to write down, go back to the counterexample slide. Subtraction is genuinely not associative and genuinely not commutative, so there would be very little to write.
Exit ticket
Three questions, one from each half of the lesson. Write the answers down before you check them.
\[ \text{(1) Order from least to greatest: } -1.8, \; \tfrac74, \; -\sqrt3, \; 0, \; \tfrac53. \]
\[ \text{(2) Justify every step of } 6 \cdot (a \div 3) = 2a. \]
\[ \text{(3) Convert 90 kilometres per hour into miles per hour.} \]
Discussion prompt
Do all three, then compare. For the second one, name every property you use; for the third one, say the surviving unit before you compute the number.
Give yourself no more than five minutes, and write all three answers down before checking any of them. Checking as you go lets you talk yourself into having known something you did not.
The first question hides its difficulty in the root of three, which sits between minus 1.8 and minus 1.7 and so is easy to put on the wrong side of minus 1.8. Turn everything into a decimal and the difficulty disappears.
The second question is the one to look at hardest if you got it wrong, because naming properties is the skill this lesson exists to build, and it is the one Lesson 1.2 assumes you have.
Recap
Two objects and one habit. The line holds every number, the list holds every legal move, and the units check your answer for free.
| when you are asked to | the move that starts it | the check that ends it |
|---|---|---|
| graph or order numbers | turn every entry into a decimal | read the line left to right |
| compare negatives | compare distances from zero, then reverse | ask which one you would rather have |
| justify a step | ask what changed: a number, a bracket, a factor, a 0 or 1 | substitute a number into both ends |
| handle a minus or a division sign | rewrite it as adding the opposite or multiplying by the reciprocal | the properties now apply by name |
| convert units | put each unwanted unit on the opposite level | the surviving unit is the one asked for |
\[ a - b = a + (-b), \qquad a \div b = a \cdot \tfrac1b \]
Read down the middle column and notice how many of the moves are the same move. Turning a fraction into a decimal, rewriting a subtraction as an addition, and writing a conversion factor the right way up are all the same instinct: get the expression into the shape the method needs before you start the method.
The right-hand column matters just as much. Every one of these five tasks has a check that costs almost nothing, and using them is the difference between hoping an answer is right and knowing it is.
Next, Lesson 1.2 evaluates and simplifies expressions with powers and variables in them. Every simplification you do there is one of the six moves from today, so if a step ever looks unfamiliar, name it and you will find it on this list.
OpenStax Algebra and Trigonometry 2e, §1.1 Real Numbers: Algebra Essentials §1.1 — the same material, with interval notation added
Want this taught 1-on-1? Alexander tutors Algebra 2 — $55/session, free consultation.